Juno News - September 12, 2025


Is there a double standard for hate speech in Canada?

Mentioned
Kirk’s influence on the next generation of activists Conservative MPs react to Ottawa targeting Juno News

Episode Stats


Length

24 minutes

Words per minute

167.09

Word count

4,079

Sentence count

201

Harmful content

Misogyny

2

sentences flagged

Hate speech

7

sentences flagged


Summary

Summaries generated with gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ .

A man in his late 20s was convicted of hate speech and terrorism-related offenses for his connection to Atomwaffen Division, a neo-Nazi group. While the terrorism charges were justified, the implication is that people can get sent to prison for a significant amount of time based on their speech. Who decides what "hate speech" means and how far the chill on speech has spread in Canada? In this episode, we talk to Josh DeHaas from the Centre for Constitutional Freedoms and the co-host of the Not Reserving Judgement podcast, Melanie Bennett.

Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 Earlier this year, a man from Ottawa was convicted of hate speech and terrorism-related offenses
00:00:05 for his connection to Atomwaffen Division, a quite vile neo-Nazi group. While the terrorism
00:00:13 charges were justified, the implication is also that people can get sent to prison for a significant
00:00:19 amount of time based on their speech. I'm definitely not defending this man, but the
00:00:26 trend towards criminalizing speech should concern us all. Politicians and bureaucrats are using what
00:00:32 they understand as hate as a pretext to expand the state's power over legitimate expression,
00:00:38 and often, not always, if it's conservative or right-wing coded expression. Joining me to break
00:00:45 it down is Josh DeHaas from the Centre for Constitutional Freedoms and the co-host of the
00:00:50 Not Reserving Judgment podcast. Let's talk about the state of civil liberties in Canada. Who decides
00:00:55 what extreme means and how far the chill on speech has spread? I'm Melanie Bennett. This is Disrupted.
00:01:12 Josh, thank you so much for joining me.
00:01:14 Thanks for the invitation.
00:01:16 I want to talk to you about something curious. It's not something I talk about very often,
00:01:22 but let's talk about Nazis and terrorism. Let's just go through a little bit of what I know,
00:01:28 and I'd love to hear your opinion about it. So we've just found out that a man in his late 20s,
00:01:35 Patrick Gordon McDonald, or earlier this year, was charged with promoting hate speech, participating
00:01:41 in activities of a terror group, and facilitating terrorist activities. And during the trial, so basically,
00:01:50 this guy was called Dark Foreigner, and it was this whole Atomwaffen group, and it was this neo-Nazi
00:01:56 group, and all this evidence was gathered, and he was charged and convicted, I believe,
00:02:00 and sentenced to 10 years for hate speech for this neo-Nazi group. And you probably know a lot more
00:02:08 about this than I do, and I'm dead curious. So what do you know about this case?
00:02:13 Well, the sentencing just came down, and it's a 10-year sentence for all three of the convictions
00:02:20 that you just mentioned. So two, promotion and contributing to terrorism charges, which is
00:02:27 Section 83 of the Criminal Code, and then also a conviction on willful promotion of hatred against
00:02:35 an identifiable group, in this case, Jewish people, which is one of the main hate speech provisions.
00:02:42 It's one of the ones that's quite controversial in Canada, but that's been upheld by the Supreme Court.
00:02:50 And a 10-year sentence is pretty unusual, and even to have hate speech charges like this made,
00:02:58 never mind have a person conviction, is not very common in Canada. So this case is kind of a big deal.
00:03:05 It tells us a lot about when you can charge people who are making videos, as this person
00:03:11 has been convicted of doing, that promote terrorism, in this case through recruitment,
00:03:18 or that are racist Nazi videos, and in this case led to a conviction for hate speech.
00:03:27 So it was on the basis of the videos that he was convicted? Is that right?
00:03:32 Right. So what happened is he was, this is according to the court decision, was part of this
00:03:38 Atomwaffen group, which has become a listed terrorist group that happened in 2021. But when
00:03:46 these videos were made, which are essentially recruitment videos, these are videos where you have
00:03:53 guys in, you know, dressed up in dark clothing with Nazi symbols and carrying, you know, machine guns,
00:04:02 that sort of thing, encouraging people to take down the global cabal of, you know, you know,
00:04:08 who that supposedly runs the, the country, just the typical, you know, stereotypes that we always hear.
00:04:15 So they were making these recruitment videos, and that was enough to convict of the terrorism
00:04:24 charges. So, you know, the, the contributing to a terrorist group and the videos, some of the
00:04:32 statements made in the videos were what was decided to be the willful promotion of hatred. And what makes
00:04:39 the latter part really interesting to me is these are online videos. And when you think of hate speech
00:04:45 nowadays, we think about it all occurring online, but of course, when it first started, when these laws
00:04:52 were first invented, they're, they've been around since 1970 in Canada, there was no internet. So
00:04:58 there's a part of it that says private communications don't count. So if, if you're talking
00:05:04 privately, that's not going to be hate speech, but that left a question about whether speech on the
00:05:10 internet is private communications or whether that's public and courts in Quebec have in the
00:05:16 past found that, you know, posting hateful speech on Facebook, for example, counts as criminal hate
00:05:25 speech that can land you in jail, but it's really not that common outside of Quebec to be charged for
00:05:30 online hate speech. And here, not only was he charged, but he was convicted. So that's part
00:05:35 of what makes this so interesting in 2025. Yeah. Small detail from the decision. I noted that this
00:05:43 man in his late twenties, the, the evidence was obtained from his bedroom in his parents' basement,
00:05:50 which I felt, I don't know, just had to live up to a stereotype in this particular case. But it also
00:05:55 says in the global mail that the RCMP called, called this particular case, the first case in Canada
00:06:00 involving both terrorism and hate propaganda offenses laid against someone for promoting
00:06:06 violent far right ideology. Now, we're not a fan of Nazis. So a lot of people may go, okay,
00:06:12 this is a great idea. We don't want the global elite conspiracy to be propagating. And so maybe
00:06:19 this is a good decision. But you were telling me before that you had some concerns about free speech
00:06:25 in this particular case. And I thought maybe you could explain a little bit what your position is
00:06:30 on that. Yeah. So I think my concerns related to speech are, you know, not particularly necessarily
00:06:37 related to this person or his, his speech. But the idea is that when you're talking about putting
00:06:43 somebody in jail for, at the end of the day, what are essentially words, that is a scary proposition
00:06:50 because it's so subjective to try and define what words would count as hatred and what words
00:06:57 are not going to be considered hatred and land you in prison for, for years.
00:07:03 This is a problem that courts have struggled with from the beginning of these hate speech laws being
00:07:08 on the books in the first place, because, you know, lots of things that people say are controversial
00:07:15 and other people will say, well, that's, that's hateful. You know, if you criticize women for 0.96
00:07:21 wearing hijabs, some women will say that's anti-Islamic hate. Other people will say, well, 0.75
00:07:28 you know, encouraging women to wear hijabs is anti-female hate or misogyny. It's just,
00:07:34 it's really hard to know what is going to be considered hateful or not. And the court has said in
00:07:39 the past, well, we can, we can define it as the manifestations of the most extreme, sorry,
00:07:47 the most extreme forms of the emotion represented by the words detestation and vilification.
00:07:57 And then it's really hard to know what that means. So that's later gets to gets redefined and
00:08:03 you're told to look for the hallmarks of hatred, which can include things like, you know, there's a
00:08:09 global conspiracy by a group to take over the world. But, you know, in this case, some of the
00:08:15 evidence for what was considered hate speech, in my opinion, was pretty weak, like burning Israeli, 0.99
00:08:22 American and EU flags. I'm not sure how you can hate the EU, but apparently burning those flags was
00:08:29 part of what pointed to hate speech. Well, flying the St. George cross in the UK right now is starting
00:08:35 to be considered a hate symbol as well. So that's not really that surprising.
00:08:40 Right. And that's a perfect example of just how subjective this is. You know, people say,
00:08:46 well, the context of putting up the English flag is that you're a racist. And other people say,
00:08:52 no, I'm a patriot. And that's my only message here. Right. So once you start criminalizing people
00:08:58 for their words, as opposed to their actual actions, like, you know, threatening to actually
00:09:04 do some sort of terrorism, which is perfectly justifiable to imprison somebody for, we get
00:09:10 into this really difficult, slippery slope that creates a lot of free speech chill, because people
00:09:15 just don't know where the line is. They just don't know what they can or can't say.
00:09:20 Yeah, I don't know the exact date. But I'm aware that in America, free speech advocates,
00:09:25 I can't remember their name exactly. Sorry, it's gone over my head right this second. But on the same
00:09:31 basis of what you were talking about, I know that they defended these marches of, I guess,
00:09:37 white supremacists in Jewish areas in the United States on the basis of you needed to protect
00:09:42 distasteful, maybe even hateful speech to actually have freedom of expression because it was speech.
00:09:48 And so it's interesting in Canada that this is happening for this particular, in this particular
00:09:53 case. But I'm also curious, is it relevant? Or do you think it's relevant that this, the RCMP says
00:10:00 this is the first case like this, and it happens to be for right wing extremism? And in Canada,
00:10:08 we're seeing a lot of this extremism, actually on the left, and that gets ignored a lot. So I was
00:10:14 wondering if you, if you saw that as an important, an important detail in this at all.
00:10:20 I certainly thought about that, because, you know, court cases take a long time to get through
00:10:25 the courts. So this is about events that happened years ago, right? So we're only just getting to the
00:10:30 conviction and sentencing this year. But what we've seen in the past two years is a lot of people
00:10:37 speaking out against Israel in particular. And I think all of that speech ought to be protected.
00:10:46 I think any speech that is, you know, not going to cause immediate physical consequences, like
00:10:52 inciting a riot or inciting violence against people, or is not, you know, in some physically harmful
00:10:58 form, all speech should essentially be allowed no matter how odious it is. But when you see what
00:11:05 happened in this case, the, these were recruitment videos, so they were pretty clear terrorist activity,
00:11:11 but so much of what's going on with people supporting Hamas or supporting Hezbollah gets
00:11:19 pretty close to these lines also of, you know, aiding terrorist flags, right? We're not talking
00:11:26 about the St. George Cross or the European Union flag or things like that. We're talking about
00:11:29 the flags that represent actual terrorist groups, whether it's Hezbollah or Hamas, and we're not seeing any
00:11:35 action on that. The question is, are you, if you're flying the flag, are you recruiting someone just
00:11:40 like this person was convicted of, of recruiting people through his videos? And it's a fine line,
00:11:47 right? You know, you can say on the one hand, that's that speech and all speech should be allowed,
00:11:52 but that's not the law in Canada. I mean, those are my personal beliefs, but that's not the law.
00:11:57 Um, so are we going to start seeing charges for, uh, Hamas and Hezbollah supporters who are,
00:12:03 I think exist in Canada in pretty large numbers. I think it's clear because we do see the flags,
00:12:08 you know, there's a, a bumper sticker on a car driving around in suburban Toronto that is the
00:12:15 face of Yaya Sinwar, who is the, the leader of Hamas, um, now deceased, thankfully, but is that
00:12:22 promotion of, of terrorism? And the question, the, the answer is, we don't know. We, we just don't
00:12:28 know what a court would do, but if you're going to, um, if you're going to prosecute people for
00:12:34 right-wing extremism, it needs to be equally meted out, um, when it comes to left-wing extremism or,
00:12:41 uh, you know, Hamas or Hezbollah, I don't know if you would label that left-wing, but I think you know
00:12:46 what I mean, it has to be, it has to be equal. It's not, but it has been adopted by people who would
00:12:52 often consider themselves to be progressive or leftist. And so that's why I kind of put it into
00:12:57 that category because there seems to be this alliance going on, uh, between these particular
00:13:02 groups for that particular matter. But going back to the focus on speech and, uh, criminalizing
00:13:09 speech when it comes to political views, uh, I, I'm going to change the subject just slightly
00:13:15 because you've, uh, mentioned, uh, uh, Sean Foyt and the situation with Sean Foyt and how
00:13:20 he's being targeted. Um, admittedly, this is not somebody who's been a criminally charged or
00:13:27 anything like that, but you sort of see the same dichotomy with the Sean Foyt situation where this
00:13:32 preacher, this American preacher supported the American president, came to do shows. He'd been to
00:13:37 Canada many times before. He did this tour this summer and the media just absolutely had a field
00:13:43 day on. I mean, it got canceled all over the place. And this was happening at the same time
00:13:48 as another preacher, an Islamic preacher who has been linked to curious things, uh, that I reported
00:13:55 on and not a peep about any of that whatsoever. And so you, you do see it. I find it concerning that
00:14:02 you see an attack on speech for a particular worldview, but not others. Do you want to talk a
00:14:08 little bit about Sean Foyt? I, yeah. So I think that's a really astute point. This is the problem
00:14:14 is when you start, uh, letting the government and the courts decide what words you can and cannot say,
00:14:19 which people are allowed to speak or not speak, then these are the things that happen, you know,
00:14:25 certain viewpoints. And it's usually the minority viewpoint, uh, gets completely silenced and, um,
00:14:32 other viewpoints are allowed to go ahead. So, you know, Sean Foyt, I'm sure your listeners know,
00:14:36 is, uh, a Christian singer. He's associated with, uh, the MAGA movement. Um, and he had,
00:14:44 I believe it was nine shows either have his permits revoked or, uh, not granted in the first place in
00:14:51 different cities and, uh, parts of Canada. And this was because people didn't like things he had said
00:14:58 online. Uh, most of them were about LGBTQ issues. Um, but none of them, in my opinion,
00:15:06 came close to hate speech, except perhaps one comment, um, which was about, uh, what basically,
00:15:13 look, basically what happened was, uh, somebody posted a video of a protest against a hospital
00:15:18 in New York that had stopped, uh, giving gender, uh, reassignment surgeries to minors. At least 0.87
00:15:26 that's how Foyt described it. And he said that the Bible has something to say about this,
00:15:30 the word millstones. And he quoted a Bible passage. So on our very unclear free speech law in Canada,
00:15:37 it's possible. You could argue that that's hateful and discriminatory. I don't think that would get
00:15:42 very far in court at all. And certainly you can't, you know, preemptively cancel people's concerts
00:15:49 because you think they might do a hate speech in the future, which is essentially what happened here.
00:15:54 So I think this is one of the most egregious periods for free speech in Canada this past summer,
00:16:00 just seeing cancellation after cancellation and very few people standing up and saying,
00:16:05 wait a minute, this is wrong. You know, if you can cancel Sean Foyt, because he's said some things
00:16:10 on Twitter that, um, progressives don't like, you know, progressives should, should realize that this
00:16:16 will come back and bite them too, because, you know, we could have a pretty far right government in
00:16:21 the future that says, uh, drag queen story hours should not happen in public spaces or, you know,
00:16:28 controversial rappers shouldn't be allowed to perform or, um, the imam case is a great one because 0.88
00:16:36 as much as we might not like what, uh, he has to say, as much as we might find that homophobic,
00:16:41 um, he should be allowed to, to speak, uh, speech itself should never be a crime.
00:16:48 Yeah. And that's, I, I often wonder how I feel about that too, because when it's something that
00:16:55 you feel strongly about, then maybe you think, yes, that person should be stopped from saying
00:16:58 those things. And so it's, it can be difficult to, uh, extend the same courtesies to others when
00:17:04 you have very strong views about those particular things. So now we've talked about the diagnosis
00:17:09 of the issue, obviously there's a speech issue, but what's the prognosis in terms of, uh, the,
00:17:15 the legal, the legal system in Canada, where are we going? Um, it's really hard to say. So legally,
00:17:22 the, uh, bad free speech jurisprudence really started in the 1980s, um, and Keekstra. So this is
00:17:30 the case of, uh, an Alberta teacher who was, um, also an antisemite, um, a theme of in today's show
00:17:37 had been teaching his kids, you know, antisemitic tropes and, um, obviously he should have been 1.00
00:17:42 fired. But the question was whether his free speech could prevent him from actually going
00:17:47 to jail for, um, at the end of the day, what were just, just words as awful as they were. Um,
00:17:54 in that decision, the Supreme court upheld the government's free speech or sorry, the government's
00:18:00 hate speech law, the same one that, um, we were just talking about earlier with this, uh,
00:18:05 new person convicted. And so we know in Canada that these, these, these laws will be upheld now
00:18:11 over the past couple of decades, there have been some improvements in the law. For example,
00:18:17 the Mike Ward case, the case of a comedian who was, um, forced to pay money originally to
00:18:25 the mother of a boy and a boy with a disability for making fun of them. This is a, you know,
00:18:31 a famous, uh, boy just, just making fun of them in a comedy routine. He was supposed to pay them
00:18:36 $42,000. And the Supreme court said, actually, no, you can't find people that much money for,
00:18:43 uh, for jokes. You know, people can handle a joke. Yeah. Very slim margin. So, you know,
00:18:51 the Supreme court has changed since then. That was a five, four decision. It could easily go the other
00:18:56 way five, four in the next free speech case. And it could be the end of, of free speech. So, um,
00:19:02 things are, are not looking great in the courts. Um, it's also worth noting that, you know, the,
00:19:08 the person who appointed most judges in Canada over the past decade was Justin Trudeau. And he was not
00:19:14 well known for, um, preserving free, free speech. He introduced several laws that implicated free speech,
00:19:23 some in quite serious ways. And they didn't all pass, but they could come back now that we have,
00:19:28 uh, another new liberal government that may or may not make shutting down, uh, what they see as
00:19:35 discriminatory speech online, a priority. So, uh, not looking good in the courts and also not looking
00:19:42 great, uh, from a political democratic point of view. Well, while I've got you here, I want to ask
00:19:47 your opinion on a relevant, but slightly adjacent issue. And that's the Quebec prayer ban that's
00:19:56 being proposed because there's a lot of opinions going around about that. A lot of people are very
00:20:00 supportive of this because basically what's happened is you have these, uh, groups of Muslims praying in
00:20:05 front of, uh, various places, but also in Toronto, it's on the streets, but the ban is in Quebec. And,
00:20:11 um, I, I know what my feelings are about this, but what, what's your opinion on the prayer ban?
00:20:19 Well, you were talking earlier about how it can be really hard to be principled on these things
00:20:23 because, you know, when there's somebody that you see as hateful, uh, or harmful, you want to shut
00:20:30 down your instinct is to try and shut down their speech as well. And I don't think there's anything
00:20:34 wrong with that. As long as it's not the government doing it, as long as it's, you know, social
00:20:39 approbation that's causing the speech to be shut down. Stigmatizing. Yeah. Social stigma. Like we
00:20:45 don't need the government to do this. And when the government decides it's a problem, but when we
00:20:49 decide as, as individuals or society, it's, that's how it's supposed to work. Um, in terms of the
00:20:55 prayer ban. So, uh, in some cases, mass prayers have been held in the middle of streets, blocking
00:21:01 traffic, and that is already illegal. That is. Right. And if it's on private property,
00:21:09 that's also illegal, that's trespassing. And these are the things that a lot of people fail
00:21:13 to understand is that, you know, your right to freedom of expression is, is not limitless.
00:21:19 And if you look at the rule I was talking about earlier, um, you can never, you should never be
00:21:24 able to limit ideas in a free society, but if the form is harmful, like trespass or blockading,
00:21:30 that's perfectly legitimate to limit. So is that included?
00:21:35 Nuisance noise. That's another one. If you're using your loudspeaker to do your call to prayer,
00:21:40 I think that is something that can be ticketed. If your noise is, uh, you know, a nuisance to other
00:21:46 people and we're not seeing tickets handed out for that much to my dismay, but in terms of banning
00:21:52 prayer, like if it's in public spaces, even if it's out outside Notre Dame, which is the big cathedral
00:21:59 where this has caused a lot of, um, consternation, even if you think that's a sacred place and that
00:22:06 there shouldn't be, uh, Muslims praying there because it's somehow, um, an assault on, uh, 1.00
00:22:13 Canadian society or Christian society. Even if you hold those views, um, I don't think that you,
00:22:18 you can constitutionally ban that because it's a content-based restriction. It's, it's about the idea
00:22:24 and we all have a right to gather in public spaces. We all have a right to express ourselves in public
00:22:30 spaces. So if that's what Quebec goes ahead and does and says, you can't pray anywhere in public
00:22:36 spaces, that is clearly unconstitutional. And as much as, you know, some people might think, well,
00:22:43 these people who are praying, they support Hamas. I'm not saying they necessarily do, but this is the 0.84
00:22:49 thinking people have, or these people are anti-Canada somehow, even if you think that, you
00:22:55 know, their rights are equal to yours and what makes Canada better than a lot of places, um, like Gaza, 0.80
00:23:02 for instance, is that we have these liberal values where we, where everybody's speech is supposed to
00:23:08 be treated equally. Um, it isn't always in practice, but we should try and stick to that principle. And
00:23:14 the better solution here in Quebec is just, you know, enforce the laws that actually exist. Right. Right.
00:23:21 Yeah. That concerns me. I'll just, I mean, I'll share my own opinion on this is it does concern me
00:23:26 that we have, we have laws that we can enforce. And instead it's worrying to me to see so many people
00:23:32 willing to go for a blunt, uh, a, a blunt weapon, like trying to criminalize people's speech when you can
00:23:40 actually apply all these other laws, but apply them equally, not just apply them. Right.
00:23:44 To some people and not to others based on their intersectional status and how many oppression
00:23:49 points that they have and so on and so forth. Um, so I guess I'm quite, quite similar to you in that,
00:23:55 in that regard for that particular topic, but, um, this has been a great conversation. Thank you so
00:23:59 much for joining me today. I've often asked myself whether I would defend this, the expression or
00:24:03 speech of people that I find despicable. And I understand the instinct of wanting to ban things
00:24:09 that we hate altogether, but it does worry me that more and more people appear to be championing
00:24:16 censorship rather than questioning what's going on. I'd love to know what you think in the comments,
00:24:21 especially. I'm Melanie Bennett. Thanks for watching.