Juno News - January 24, 2024


It's official: Trudeau broke the law

Topics
Mentioned
Federal Court declares use of Emergencies Act UNCONSTITUTIONAL Tucker Carlson takes on Justin Trudeau and Chrystia Freeland in Alberta

Episode Stats


Length

54 minutes

Words per minute

171.88

Word count

9,343

Sentence count

435

Harmful content

Misogyny

1

sentences flagged

Hate speech

3

sentences flagged


Summary

Summaries generated with gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ .

On this episode of The Andrew Lawton Show, host Andrew Lawton talks about the landmark Supreme Court of Canada ruling on the use of the Emergency Management Act by the federal government in order to detain and prevent protesters from demonstrating in the streets.

Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Topics generated with Qwen2.5-3B-Instruct.
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 Transcription by CastingWords
00:00:30 Thank you.
00:01:00 welcome to canada's most irreverent talk show this is the andrew lawton show brought to you by true
00:01:20 north canada's most irreverent talk show here on true north on this wednesday january 24 2023
00:01:33 the freedom convoy two years ago today was just passing through alberta i believe picking up steam
00:01:40 on its way to ottawa so that's something to keep in mind there uh we have i believe i'm just looking
00:01:47 at our little show production chat channel thing, whatever we call it here. And one of my colleagues
00:01:52 has a new profile picture. Send that over to Sean, Artem. I want to put that up on the screen for
00:01:58 people. I kind of like that. So I'm very easily distracted, but you'll understand why in a few
00:02:04 moments when we put this up on the screen. But you may have heard yesterday, if you've been sleeping
00:02:08 and in a coma for the last day and a half, perhaps you haven't. But yesterday, we had the big ruling
00:02:14 from the federal court and specifically justice richard mosley finding that the invocation of
00:02:21 the emergencies act was unjustified it was not keeping with the parameters and the legal tests
00:02:27 set out in the emergencies act itself and more crucially the measures that the federal government
00:02:33 brought into effect under the emergencies act like the freezing of bank accounts the conscription of
00:02:39 tow truck drivers this whole suite of things violated the constitution it was unconstitutional
00:02:44 it violated a couple of provisions of the Charter of Rights and Freedom.
00:02:49 So we are going to chat about that in a little bit more depth today
00:02:53 now that myself and other guests here have had the chance
00:02:57 to go through the 190-page ruling.
00:02:59 I was very grateful yesterday that Christine Van Gein
00:03:02 from the Canadian Constitution Foundation
00:03:04 had just like sped red for half an hour before coming on air
00:03:08 and made far more sense than most Canadian politicians ever would.
00:03:12 But we have her on now with the benefit of having been able to take a deeper dive into this.
00:03:17 Christine Van Gein, it is good to talk to you here.
00:03:20 Thank you so much for coming back on.
00:03:22 So now that you've had the chance to look through this, I'm curious what your takeaway is.
00:03:27 Because obviously you agree with the outcome, as do I.
00:03:31 But the reasoning behind it, do you find it sound?
00:03:34 And is it based on what you would have hoped as a lawyer it was going to be based on?
00:03:38 Yeah, so these are very detailed reasons where Justice Mosley goes through not just some of the preliminary matters like standing and mootness, but really dives into the crux of invocation.
00:03:54 So he gets, he spends a lot of time dealing with whether or not the threshold to invoke
00:04:01 the Emergencies Act was met, and then he looks at, once finding that it was not met, then he goes
00:04:06 through the measures enacted under the Emergencies Act, that was the freezing of bank accounts and
00:04:12 the prohibition on gatherings, and found that those were unconstitutional. So we can talk about
00:04:18 any of those. He also gave a shout out to counsel. He said that, one of my favorite quotes was at the
00:04:24 end of the decision and he said that the advocacy was wonderful. And he said in kind of radical
00:04:31 transparency, he said, when this case started, I was leaning the other way. But for the advocacy
00:04:37 of groups like the Canadian Constitution Foundation and the Canadian Civil Liberties
00:04:41 Association, this case could have very well turned out differently. So to receive that type of
00:04:47 sort of shout out from the bench, it's a wonderful, wonderful feeling.
00:04:53 I wanted to ask about that, actually, because I've not read as many of these things as you have.
00:04:57 I've read probably more than it is healthy for a normal person, but I've not really come across
00:05:03 a judge being that transparent about their own evolution on a case like this, whereas he was
00:05:07 basically saying, look, at the beginning, I was leaning this way. Is that as rare as it seems on
00:05:12 the service it is so judges will uh will sometimes if counsel is particularly good or particularly
00:05:18 bad uh either give a a nice or a mean shout out to the lawyer and say that this counsel
00:05:25 was was exceptional or this counsel was bad uh you don't want to be the on the bad end because
00:05:32 well there was one of those in this case too i i saw it was one of the groups canada frontline
00:05:37 nurses just got a rather scathing rebuke by the judge yeah i i i was there in the courtroom uh so
00:05:44 i saw what the lead up to this was and i frankly it was pretty well deserved i wasn't surprised
00:05:50 that there was a some criticism from the bench of that one particular lawyer because he i mean
00:05:55 his argument started with a discussion about the prime minister wearing blackface which of course
00:06:00 he did but it's not really there's not really a legal argument uh in that it's more of a just by
00:06:05 the way yeah anyway yeah it is rare to receive a kudos like that from the bench so we were very
00:06:12 thrilled to get that i wanted to ask you because one of the things you and i spoke about when your
00:06:18 a book came out pandemic panic not that long ago was that freedom of assembly is a very
00:06:23 underdeveloped area of law and i was curious what your take was on on if that's a bit more
00:06:28 developed now or if that really weighed in in this decision in a meaningful way so justice
00:06:34 Mosley wrote that there was no breach of the right to freedom of assembly because he said
00:06:41 the right to freedom of assembly comes with a caveat, which is freedom of peaceful assembly.
00:06:46 So he was not concerned with the gathering limits breaching that right because he said
00:06:51 the gathering limits prohibited participating in a gathering that may lead to the, that could
00:06:59 reasonably lead to a breach of the peace. So he said those gatherings are protected anyway.
00:07:03 I mean, I do quibble with this because I don't want to say too much because it may be involved in the appeal, but I understand the position that he took because it does have that caveat in the right, but I don't agree with the conclusion that that right was not violated.
00:07:23 But the important thing to know about the right to freedom of assembly is that it is an underdeveloped right in our Charter.
00:07:30 There's not very much jurisprudence on the right to freedom of assembly.
00:07:33 And we wrote in our book that the pandemic presented a number of opportunities to develop a legal test of what constitutes an assembly.
00:07:41 In this case, there clearly was an assembly.
00:07:45 The question on whether or not something is an assembly more is geared to whether, you know, private gatherings like a Thanksgiving dinner would constitute an assembly under the charter.
00:07:56 I think that it would, given that the text of the charter doesn't delineate what the purpose of the gathering needs to be.
00:08:03 But anyway, that's sort of not what this case was about.
00:08:07 He found there was no breach of the right to freedom of assembly.
00:08:11 the breaches were the right to freedom of expression because a protest is an expressive
00:08:16 event. And he found there was a breach to privacy rights that the disclosure of information from
00:08:24 bank accounts was an unreasonable search and seizure that was unjustified.
00:08:28 I wanted to ask about something that follows up on a discussion we started yesterday,
00:08:33 which was the distinction between this and the Public Order Emergency Commission. And just to
00:08:38 bring people up to speed here, the Public Order Emergency Commission was a creature of statute.
00:08:42 It's mandated in the Emergencies Act itself that there must be this review. And at the end of that
00:08:47 rather exhaustive set of hearings, the commissioner, Paul Rouleau, found that the government was
00:08:53 justified, that it basically complied with the tests set out in the Emergencies Act. Now,
00:08:58 the federal court has found the opposite is true, that it was not justified. And I'm curious now
00:09:03 that you've dug into the decision, where that divergence took place and where, if there was
00:09:09 like a pivotal point, Justice Mosley disagreed with basically Commissioner Rouleau? So he doesn't
00:09:18 say that. I mean, it's obvious that he is disagreeing. But I think from what seems like
00:09:25 one of the key areas of disagreement is on the threshold of threats to the security of Canada.
00:09:32 And that is not what this case actually turned on. This case turned first on whether or not a national emergency existed, and Justice Mosley found that it did not.
00:09:45 But the real question for lawyers who are interested in the Emergencies Act is this issue of what is a threat to the security of Canada.
00:09:55 And in the legislation, the Emergencies Act, that is a term that the legislation says has the same
00:10:04 definition as given to the term in the CSIS Act, another piece of legislation. And the CSIS Act
00:10:12 requires there to be a threat or actual serious violence for a ideological or religious or
00:10:21 political cause. And Justice Mosley disagreed with Justice Rouleau about the flexibility of
00:10:32 that definition. And Justice Mosley found that that term, because it's defined in the statute
00:10:39 as having the same meaning as another statute, there can be only one reasonable interpretation.
00:10:45 It cannot have the myriad of possible interpretations that the federal government has tried to give it, which includes things like economic harm because there were border blockades.
00:10:59 Justice Mosley found that economic harm is not a threat to the security of Canada under the CESES Act.
00:11:05 And so it is not a threat to the security of Canada under the Emergencies Act.
00:11:10 And he said, perhaps it should be.
00:11:12 I don't know.
00:11:13 perhaps the legislature could amend it. If they want that to be the interpretation,
00:11:19 they should amend the legislation. But it is not the role of the court to do that,
00:11:25 to amend the legislation. But Justice Rouleau did accept the government's interpretation that
00:11:32 threat to the security of Canada had a sort of different meaning under the Emergencies Act than
00:11:39 it does under the CSIS Act. And the government has continued in the announcement of their appeal
00:11:45 to make that case that it has this broader definition that actually includes economic harm.
00:11:51 One of the things that I think is probably and will remain in the history books as the most
00:11:57 heavy handed aspect of this is the freezing of bank accounts. I mean, after you and I spoke
00:12:00 yesterday, I had Tom Marazzo on and also Eddie Cornell, two people whose bank accounts were
00:12:05 frozen. Cornell was actually one of the applicants in this case. And this remains incredibly
00:12:12 overbroad. There were, you know, the government sort of held as its defense to this, well, we only
00:12:17 froze this small handful of accounts, but the way the emergency orders were written,
00:12:22 they could have frozen many, many more. I mean, anyone who had donated a dime to the truckers
00:12:26 would have been fair game as I read this and as most people would. So I'm curious how the judge
00:12:32 really took that because I did see one section in particular that stood out in which Justice
00:12:37 Mosley talked about the indiscriminate nature of it, that the government really didn't do anything
00:12:41 to prevent spouses from being affected who had nothing to do with the convoy. So, okay, a few
00:12:47 things. So the bank account freezing, Justice Mosley found was a violation of the charter's
00:12:53 section eight guarantee to be free from an unreasonable search and seizure. Now in court,
00:12:58 the government had argued that this was not even a search which is frankly preposterous and justice
00:13:04 mostly in the hearing basically told them to stop wasting their time and get to section one whether
00:13:10 or not it was a justified search because he's like i don't know i i forget his exact words but
00:13:15 in the hearing itself he was not buying this argument that this was not a search so we know
00:13:22 that the examination of financial records is a search. Like there is a lot of case law that says
00:13:30 that. Financial records are part of what we call the biographical core of personal information.
00:13:37 It can reveal all kinds of personal details about a person. So, you know, like what your
00:13:43 socioeconomic status is, what your lifestyle choices are. I mean, frankly, I don't want my
00:13:50 husband looking at my credit card bills, let alone Justin Trudeau. So clearly this is a search.
00:13:59 The orders required financial institutions to give this information to the government,
00:14:05 to police, to CSIS, and to the RCMP. So the other thing, Justin Mosley said, this is a search.
00:14:14 The other thing he found was he had to look at whether or not the search was minimally impairing.
00:14:20 whether it was a justified limit under section one of the charter. One of those criteria is that it
00:14:26 be a minimally impaired, minimal impairment of the right. And he found that the suspension
00:14:33 of bank accounts and credit cards affected joint account holders and joint credit cards.
00:14:40 So people who had absolutely nothing to do with the protest, if they were at home in
00:14:46 Toronto or Alberta or British Columbia or some other part of the country having nothing to do
00:14:51 with the protest. They might not be able to use their credit card or get into their bank account
00:14:56 to buy groceries or to buy medication. And that happened to one of the applicants in this case,
00:15:03 that happened to him. These family members had absolutely nothing to do with the protest,
00:15:09 yet their accounts were frozen. That's not minimally impairing. And Justice Mosley found
00:15:15 that the government took absolutely this to use his words. He said that he found there appears
00:15:21 to have been no effort to find a solution to that problem. Another thing that Justice Mosley found
00:15:28 on the credit card and bank freezing was that there was no clear standard that applied to
00:15:36 determine whether someone would be a designated person and have their account frozen. So the
00:15:42 The police say we only froze the accounts of people who were heavily involved in the protest.
00:15:48 But the regulations don't actually say that.
00:15:52 So as you pointed out, someone who had simply donated to or supported the convoy might be subject to being targeted.
00:16:01 There was no clear standard.
00:16:03 And Justice Mosley described the process for freezing the accounts.
00:16:07 To quote him, he said, the police just making it up as they went along.
00:16:12 And then he also found once your account was frozen, there was no process to question the
00:16:19 determination of why your account was frozen or how to get it unfrozen. So a lot going on there
00:16:25 that clearly a breach of Section 8 of your right to be free from an unreasonable search.
00:16:31 And Justice Mosley found that that breach was not a justified limit on your charter rights.
00:16:37 Were there any of the emergency measures that he defended that he said, you know,
00:16:40 actually that wasn't unconstitutional? So he said that there was no engagement of
00:16:47 the Bill of Rights. There was some argument on Bill of Rights. He was not interested in the
00:16:52 arguments on international law. He found there was no breach of Section 7, which is the right
00:16:57 to life, liberty and security of person, because he said, well, some people were detained when
00:17:04 they were arrested. I believe he said they were arrested under the ordinary criminal code and
00:17:10 their detention was uh was brief so because one because one aspect i was interested in was i mean
00:17:18 partially for selfish reasons was the way that journalists were uh excluded from even reporting
00:17:24 on this i mean there were some very i mean this would be something that would probably have to
00:17:27 come up in a separate case but there were excluded or pepper sprayed andrew well both i mean in my
00:17:33 in my case pepper spray but but even excluded and you had on the ground some very inconsistent
00:17:37 decisions, like police saying that you don't have a right to walk down a sidewalk because they've
00:17:43 decided that this is now an area that they're clearing out. And in my case, I had a couple of
00:17:49 points where I was threatened with arrest, even though this is the day after the protests had
00:17:53 been dismantled. But I'm wondering when you look at this from your perspective, and I don't want
00:17:58 you to give the government ideas here, but the government had committed to appealing this
00:18:02 basically before the ink was dry and before they had had a chance probably to-
00:18:07 Well, fair enough. But I'm curious where you think they'll try to dig in on this and where
00:18:12 you think they'll try to base their appeal. So they can only appeal what are referred to as
00:18:19 mistakes of law. I mean, you can also appeal what are called mistakes of fact, but that's a lot
00:18:27 harder. It needs to be what's called a palpable and overriding error. And so there were a number
00:18:31 of findings of fact in this decision that will be a difficult hurdle to overcome. So on this
00:18:39 question of threat to the security of Canada, one of the things Justice Mosley found was that the
00:18:46 only evidence of any threat of serious violence, which is part of the threshold, was in Coutts,
00:18:52 in Coutts, Alberta, where a number of people were arrested and had firearms. And Justice Mosley
00:18:58 wrote that while obviously concerning, and of course it is concerning, those individuals were
00:19:06 arrested before, I believe, before the, they were arrested under the ordinary criminal code. So
00:19:15 part of the threshold is the requirement that no other law can be used to deal with the situation.
00:19:20 And clearly these individuals were arrested under the existing criminal code. So the fact that
00:19:27 Justice Mosley kind of found that the evidence showed there was only one threat of serious
00:19:34 violence and it was addressed using the criminal law, I mean, that is a finding of fact. The
00:19:43 government can't now bring new evidence to show there were other hardened terror cells around
00:19:50 Canada that were a huge threat, they're stuck with that finding. And that can't really be
00:19:57 overcome, at least not very easily. I think on errors, what they have to focus on is what we
00:20:03 call as lawyers, errors in the law. And I mean, I don't think there are errors in law in this
00:20:09 decision. I agree with this decision completely. But based on what Chrystia Freeland said in her
00:20:16 press conference yesterday. It seems like the government continues to emphasize this notion
00:20:23 of threat to the security of Canada and the standard including economic harm. So they seem
00:20:31 set on that argument. But I will say before they can even get to that, Justice Mosley had already
00:20:38 found that the use of the law was unjustified because he found that there was not a national
00:20:43 emergency. And that alone was enough to find that the invocation was unreasonable.
00:20:49 Yeah. And the government's insistence that economic harm even qualifies as all of these
00:20:54 things under the Emergencies Act, I think is very, very questionable in a lot of ways. I just,
00:21:00 I wanted to, just before we go here, draw attention to, if you're following along at home,
00:21:04 everyone, para 308 and 309 of the, I see Christine's following along. She's, I see her
00:21:10 looking for the monitors there. Basically, what he's saying here is that there was no real
00:21:14 distinction between people that had a truck that were blocking a border effectively or blocking
00:21:20 Wellington Street and people that just wanted to stand on Parliament Hill with a Canadian flag and
00:21:24 stand up for freedom, as is always legal, is a legitimate form of protest. And that was something
00:21:30 that it came up slightly in the Public Order Emergency Commission, where Commissioner Rouleau
00:21:34 asked at a couple of points if there was ever an alternative representative. You can continue your
00:21:39 protest, but here's how. And I appreciated that Justice Mosley did dig in on that, where he said,
00:21:45 hang on, someone who wanted to stand there as an individual and not block a street was treated the
00:21:49 same way as someone that parked a semi in front of Parliament Hill. Yeah, so this is in the part
00:21:54 of the decision that's dealing with charter infringement. So the way the Emergencies Act
00:22:01 was invoked, the government created regulations, and one of them was a restriction on participating
00:22:07 in a gathering that could reasonably lead to a breach of the peace or materially supporting
00:22:12 the gathering or traveling to that gathering. And insofar as the prohibition would stop you from
00:22:24 sitting in a semi-truck on Wellington blasting your horn, perhaps that might have been okay.
00:22:31 But this prohibition was not minimally impairing, which is what is required for it to be
00:22:37 constitutional. It did not, it captured too many people. So yes, it captured the person who had
00:22:44 been spent three weeks on Wellington Street, which is not, you can't blockade infrastructure
00:22:51 indefinitely. That we are a rule of law country. You cannot do that. That is not protected
00:22:55 expression, but it captured that person. But it also captured a person who had a poster that they
00:23:03 wanted to walk with to Capitol Hill or Parliament Hill and stand on the grass, which is completely
00:23:08 protected expression. So it captured too many people. It was not minimally impairing, which is
00:23:15 one of the requirements of a law if it's going to infringe on a right, which this did.
00:23:20 Well, I'll give you again the congratulations well-earned that I gave you yesterday on the show.
00:23:26 And now the judge himself has also lauded you for your work, which I hadn't seen yesterday.
00:23:31 So well done all around on this, Christine.
00:23:33 I look forward to having you back on as this case proceeds.
00:23:36 I mean, the best case scenario at this point would be for the court of appeal or the federal court of appeal to say there's no appeal here, right?
00:23:43 I'm not sure if they get leave to appeal as of right or not.
00:23:47 but I think certainly if leave is the permission of the court to appeal, I think that they would
00:23:53 get it. I think an interesting question is if whatever the outcome is at the court of appeal,
00:24:02 I mean, the timeline that we're looking at is probably six months from now, an appeal could
00:24:06 be heard. And then six months from now, we might get a decision. So a year until there's a federal
00:24:12 Court of Appeal decision you're thinking? I think at a minimum. And then when we talk about any
00:24:17 possible, if there's any possible delays, how close are we pushing it to an election? Because
00:24:22 I do think if there's a change of government, the desire to appeal this decision will perhaps be
00:24:30 lacking. Yeah, fair enough. But assuming just that it goes through the normal channels here,
00:24:35 you've got a hearing under the Federal Court of Appeal, Federal Court of Appeal decision,
00:24:39 and then potentially beyond that Supreme Court of Canada,
00:24:42 how long would that add to the timeline?
00:24:44 Another six months for the appeal
00:24:47 and then six months for the decision.
00:24:49 Yeah, and you're right.
00:24:50 So we're well into, I mean,
00:24:51 a year into the next government's term possibly,
00:24:54 whether there's a change or not.
00:24:55 So ideally here, there would be a bit of contrition
00:24:58 from the federal government,
00:24:59 but right now we're not seeing that.
00:25:01 I think that they'll probably rush it
00:25:03 because I think they can read polls as well.
00:25:06 Yeah, fair enough.
00:25:07 All right, well, we'll get the political analysis
00:25:09 us next time. Christine Van Gein, Litigation Director for the Canadian Constitution Foundation.
00:25:13 Well done on this, and thanks so much for coming on again. Thank you. All right, if I keep having
00:25:18 her on, eventually she's just going to take over the show, because she has such an incredible way 1.00
00:25:22 of distilling down these things into understandable terms. But I wanted to switch to the political
00:25:28 side of this for a moment here, because one of the things that's easy to forget for a lot of people
00:25:33 is how much of a tectonic shift in politics there was at the time of the Freedom Convoy.
00:25:40 And we had Aaron O'Toole, who was the leader of the Conservative, well, leader is questionable,
00:25:45 but who nominally led the Conservative Party of Canada at the time, who was very weak on the Freedom Convoy,
00:25:53 would not say whether he was going to meet with the truckers, wouldn't say if he was supporting it,
00:25:57 would say that we need to get more truckers vaccinated and that's how we're going to solve the trucker vaccine mandate.
00:26:03 And his lack of support for the Freedom Convoy was a big reason that Aaron O'Toole was ousted.
00:26:07 And the rapid pace at which things then evolved with his replacement with Candace Bergen,
00:26:14 who was the interim leader, had been O'Toole's deputy leader,
00:26:17 but broke ranks with him to support the Freedom Convoy in a statement that was published.
00:26:22 I can't remember the exact night.
00:26:24 I believe it was on the eve of the convoy's arrival in Ottawa, if memory serves.
00:26:28 and then Pierre Paulyev who famously turned around on the steps on the way into that one
00:26:33 fateful caucus meeting and said that well in his own way that he was supportive of the convoy and
00:26:39 wasn't going to let the media malign those who were individual bad actors because he said in
00:26:44 aggregate this is a peaceful protest. Well Candace Bergen who is now retired from politics had a
00:26:51 line on X formerly Twitter that was actually somewhat moving. She says I recall vividly and
00:26:57 with pride when our Conservative caucus made the collective decision to oppose the Emergencies Act
00:27:03 being used against peace-loving Canadians protesting liberal overreach. We decided in
00:27:08 that moment that we wanted to be on the right side of history, and that we are. Candice Bergen,
00:27:14 I have plucked her out of political retirement for the next 10 minutes or so. She joins me on
00:27:19 the line now. Candice, wonderful to talk to you. Thanks so much for coming on today.
00:27:23 Great to see you again. Thanks for asking me.
00:27:26 You had, I'll say it was actually quite a moving post you made to social media yesterday,
00:27:31 where you talked about how proud you were when the Conservative caucus banded together
00:27:36 and decided to oppose the Emergencies Act.
00:27:39 And I've made the point in the past that this is not, you could oppose the convoy and also
00:27:43 oppose the Emergencies Act, although I know many of the people in your party and yourself
00:27:48 were supportive of this protest and large parts of it.
00:27:51 But why were you and your caucus so firmly against the Emergencies Act when this first came up?
00:27:58 Well, Andrew, you have to remember the context of the moments that we were in.
00:28:03 And you're right. Many of us supported the reasons that the convoy were there, that the people were there.
00:28:09 Many of those people were our constituents.
00:28:10 But we also knew that they needed to head off the streets.
00:28:14 They needed to go home. That was our wish.
00:28:17 But we wanted the Prime Minister to listen to them.
00:28:20 That did not seem to be happening. So when the Emergencies Act was invoked, we had to make a decision. And there was a lot of pressure. You'll remember the media, the mainstream media, not all media, but most of the media was saying this was the right thing to do. And we had to support it. And so we came together as a caucus, which is what I find these MPs that I've been so privileged to have worked with, we do so well.
00:28:44 We came together. We had a really good conversation in our caucus, heard all sides, and we heard, should we support it? Should we be fully against it? Should we ask for an amendment? And, you know, without breaking any kind of cabinet or caucus confidentiality, I can just tell you what an incredible conversation and discussion we had as a caucus back in February 2022, talking about freedom, talking about our constituents,
00:29:13 and what we needed to do as parliamentarians.
00:29:17 And we talked about history and where we wanted to be
00:29:19 when all of this was said and done in five years, 10 years, 50 years.
00:29:24 And we decided overwhelmingly and we were very proud
00:29:29 and very strongly supporting working and fighting
00:29:32 and speaking against the Emergencies Act.
00:29:36 That history aspect is incredibly important.
00:29:39 I made the point a while back on my show that, you know,
00:29:41 at one point, William Lyon McKenzie was a traitor who was in exile. And then you fast forward a
00:29:46 decade and he's a member of parliament. I mean, things can change. And with the benefit of
00:29:50 hindsight, even the judge said this in the ruling yesterday, you can get a more full picture of
00:29:54 things. And that seems to be happening here as well. We're in the moment you had a lot of anger,
00:30:00 of course, in many directions. But the further away we get from this, that there's this surreal
00:30:04 aspect when you think, wait, did the government actually freeze people's bank accounts? And that
00:30:10 was the emergencies act that's what was what they did here so when you talk about being on the right
00:30:14 side of history I know it's thankless being in politics and you had to bear a lot of the
00:30:19 criticism from the media and the left for this but I do think you're going to get that in the end
00:30:24 well you know and that's gratifying absolutely but what I'm thinking about today and my heart
00:30:29 just goes out to the people the people who are still suffering because they were part of that
00:30:34 convoy they supported supported the convoy the fact is that the government's position on the
00:30:39 protesters, most of the media's false portrayal of what happened in Ottawa, have really set a lot
00:30:48 of Canadians who were not in Ottawa against the protesters. And, you know, I know even when I
00:30:54 would go home and talk to people and I would say, listen, yes, they need to leave the streets of 1.00
00:30:58 Ottawa, but these people are happy. They are peaceful. You know, you look at the protests
00:31:03 that are going on right now supporting Hamas and how different those protests are being portrayed.
00:31:09 trade. And yet people throughout the country were being told that these were violent, hateful
00:31:15 protests and that the Emergencies Act had to be invoked because they were so dangerous.
00:31:21 These are the people, my heart goes out to the people who have been lied to by their own
00:31:26 government and the media, and then the people who are so falsely maligned. So, I mean, I'm really,
00:31:32 really proud and glad our caucus took the stand that we did. But, you know, we need to learn from
00:31:38 this, Andrew, and if we don't learn from this, I'm afraid that the whole agenda of wedge,
00:31:45 stigmatize, and divide Canadians will be won by Trudeau. If we don't learn from this, which
00:31:52 thankfully I believe that we are, I see what our leader Pierre Polyev is doing and caucus is doing,
00:31:59 but I do worry about our country as far as the media. You know, I honestly, Andrew, I'm glad
00:32:04 that you've had me on, I would love to ask some members of the media, you know, I was grilled by
00:32:09 Evan Solomon. I was absolutely grilled. How dare you not support the Emergencies Act? And how dare
00:32:15 you support these people? You know, what does he have to say for himself now? You know, how about
00:32:21 some of the writers in the Globe and Mail, for example, where's their accountability? And I feel
00:32:26 that unless there is some real reckoning, government will be held to account, Andrew,
00:32:30 this government will be held in terms of the vote they will be held to account uh at some point
00:32:37 but there are many people elites academics you know the ottawa bubble we know the ottawa bubble
00:32:44 so i'm really happy proud that we were on the right side i'm so proud of the caucus that i
00:32:49 served with incredible members of parliament but we better learn from this you are right i mean the
00:32:55 media malfeasance throughout the entire protest and i i mean i'd say the entire covet era what
00:33:00 was quite something. I mean, there was one Globe and Mail reporter that posted online that there
00:33:04 was a wrecking ball outside Trudeau's office, but it was actually the weight holding the Canadian
00:33:09 flag there that was, you know, like the size of, you know, my fist or something. And then you also
00:33:13 had CBC musing that this was all some foreign Russian financed operation. And there hasn't
00:33:20 really been ever a reckoning, let alone an apology from these people. And I think a lot of folks have
00:33:25 really expected this could all just be kept in the past well and i guess in what in a sense
00:33:33 their reckoning has come and that most of the media in canada has lost all credibility especially
00:33:39 with i would say 40 and under uh they have no credibility and uh and so 40 and under are using
00:33:47 their dollars to show where where they want to get their news from and it's not the cbc's uh it's
00:33:53 frankly not the CTVs, probably not the, not none of the mainstream. So I guess there is that
00:33:58 reckoning. But, you know, I do, I do remain hopeful, Andrew, as much as I'm, I'm frustrated
00:34:03 as I look back. And I think that there still is a false malignment of actually peace loving
00:34:10 Canadians who came to Ottawa, asking, just asking for their prime minister to say, I hear you. And
00:34:18 yes, we are not going to continue with these mandates. There will be an end. And this is all
00:34:23 we were asking from him, and I know this is what these Canadians were asking for, they were falsely 1.00
00:34:27 maligned. So although I feel a real sense of injustice was done for them, I am hopeful for
00:34:34 our country. You know, when you speak to people one-on-one, people are good. People in Canada,
00:34:41 I believe, are genuinely good people. And what they're looking for is leadership. And that's
00:34:47 what I think we're all hoping is going to happen after the next election. We're going to have
00:34:51 leadership that will make decisions in the best interest of the entire country, not just to wedge,
00:34:59 stigmatize, and divide for his own or their own political game. Were you surprised that the NDP
00:35:05 went the way they did on this? You know, the party of Tommy Douglas, the party that has
00:35:09 put itself in protests more times than anyone could count. Were you surprised that they ended
00:35:15 up, I mean, Jagmeet Singh has tried to do a bit of revisionism here and said it was only reluctantly,
00:35:19 But they were quite supportive of this at the time. And I'm curious if that, when you were in the thick of it there as leader of the opposition, if that shocked you in any way.
00:35:28 Well, we'd seen Jagmeet and the NDP just placate the Liberals and basically follow along for so long. You know, Andrew, the irony is the Liberal Party has strayed so far from what it was. It is not the party of Jean Chrétien, you know, even Paul Martin, John Manley. It is not the party that most traditional Liberals knew. And I would say the NDP have very much strayed from what they were as well.
00:35:55 they are not the party of Tommy Douglas. And, you know, maybe that's a good thing. Maybe
00:36:00 times are changing and we're all changing and adjusting. But the center seems to have moved.
00:36:07 And the people who thought we were in the center now see that many who were left liberals,
00:36:14 but more in the center have moved far, far to the left. And then the NDP are, we don't even
00:36:20 know where they are actually they're they're not they're left but they're not left in terms of
00:36:25 supporting workers or protesters unless the protesters are protesters that they support
00:36:31 you know they haven't and I mean that's the other thing we haven't even really talked about
00:36:35 when you compare the protesters that were in Ottawa in early 2022 versus the protests the
00:36:42 anti-semitic protests and the hateful protests we have seen gone going on across the country
00:36:49 in support of the terrorist hamas organization you look at the comparative of the two and the
00:36:57 media coverage and the government response to the to the two different types of protest
00:37:02 so what what does that tell you yeah i know that's very well said and this court ruling is i think
00:37:08 vindication for a lot of people yourself included but it's not the end of the story certainly when
00:37:13 you talk about the media and the fact that the government has still been unrepentant about this
00:37:17 So we'll hopefully see a similar reaction to the Court of Appeal and all the way to the Supreme Court.
00:37:22 But I realize I've plucked you back into the political world here, and I'm so grateful you did it, Candice Bergen.
00:37:28 We always get people saying how much they miss you in politics, but I hope you're doing well.
00:37:32 And I thank you so much for joining me today.
00:37:34 Thanks so much, Andrew. Great to be on. Happy to do it any time.
00:37:39 That was Candice Bergen, the former leader of the Conservative Party of Canada.
00:37:45 up. Now, one thing I want to make a point of here, and I asked Candace near the end about Jagmeet
00:37:50 Singh's role in all of this. The NDP has been incredibly weak. No, that was the sentence.
00:37:55 They've just been incredibly weak. But on this in particular, and that revisionism from Jagmeet
00:37:59 Singh is kind of fascinating. Here's him saying yesterday that it was only reluctantly that he
00:38:05 backed the use of the Emergencies Act. From the beginning, we've said we said and we maintain
00:38:11 that the reason we were in that crisis was a direct failure of justin trudeau's leadership
00:38:16 and also other levels of government that failed to act to take the the challenge presented seriously
00:38:22 their inaction resulted in a serious crisis where we reluctantly supported the indication of the
00:38:28 emergencies uh measures we said that that was uh something that we reluctantly supported
00:38:34 uh and then uh we also were very open to the ruleau commission and the work and the
00:38:39 accountability measures to assess whether it was the right decision and what needs to be done
00:38:43 differently in the future the ruling has been passed down i understand there will be an appeal
00:38:47 of that ruling and we will follow closely to see the outcome of that appeal reluctantly okay uh
00:38:54 here's jagmeet singh two years ago when he was announcing his support for the use of the
00:38:59 emergencies act with the war measures act uh you know then ndp leader tommy douglas said it was
00:39:07 like using a sledgehammer to create to crack a peanut now of course today in ottawa i mean the
00:39:13 we we have seen a bunch of aggressions of all sorts but no one has been kidnapped no one has
00:39:19 died up to now so i guess my question is how will history uh you know remember you as ndp leader
00:39:27 with this emergencies act um and all the uh entrenches to uh civil liberties right now
00:39:33 I think it's really important to reflect on the War Measures Act for just a moment.
00:39:38 The War Measures Act was a sledgehammer, and that's why there were serious problems of its application,
00:39:45 because it was a very broad and overly powerful piece of legislation.
00:39:50 That's why it was repealed and a new legislation was brought forward.
00:39:55 The Emergencies Act is nothing like the sledgehammer of the War Measures Act.
00:39:59 It's not at all the same.
00:40:00 It doesn't even include the powers for the military.
00:40:02 it doesn't include military at all it's a very different piece of legislation and it is much
00:40:07 more targeted and specific and so it's a very different time oh it's different it's no big
00:40:14 deal it's not like it's the war measures act i'm not hearing that reluctance that mr singh speaks
00:40:20 so fondly of yesterday about the emergencies act and let's go back to 2021 now this is a visual
00:40:27 a visual display here. I have written to Justin Trudeau asking him to consider using the Federal
00:40:34 Emergencies Act to help Ontario. This could help make sure vaccines are getting to people who need
00:40:39 them and help sick workers get paid when they stay home. We must do everything possible to keep
00:40:45 people safe. And then there is a letter there. I'm not going to read the letter because I understand
00:40:50 some people listen to the show when they're driving and I don't want you to veer into the
00:40:53 ditch because you've fallen asleep by me reading the dulcet tones of Jagmeet Singh to you.
00:40:57 But here we have him saying it's a national emergency that warrants the Emergencies Act
00:41:02 because the federal government isn't getting enough vaccines to Ontario.
00:41:07 And he wants us to believe that it was only reluctantly that the NDP
00:41:11 backed the use of the Emergencies Act two years ago.
00:41:14 So Jagmeet Singh has once again shown that he has no spine.
00:41:19 As I joked when I saw him riding his bike,
00:41:21 it was a feat of physical brilliance that I still don't quite understand.
00:41:24 how the kinetic movements were even possible without so much as a backbone
00:41:29 to allow him to steer that bicycle down Wellington Street.
00:41:33 But Singh says, oh, no, no, no, I only kind of sort of iffy-ish sort of went along with it.
00:41:38 But the record shows something else there.
00:41:41 I played a Chrystia Freeland clip yesterday.
00:41:44 I had two more of them today, but again, I'll spare the audience and won't do it here.
00:41:48 But I did mention at the beginning of this program, something had made me chuckle.
00:41:52 This was a graphic that apparently was made by one of the members of our team here.
00:41:57 This is now, this is now, it's actually a hate symbol.
00:42:00 Yeah, the show is going to get canceled by the CRTC podcast registry before long.
00:42:04 That is like a new Canadian flag.
00:42:06 If you're listening to the podcast, it's got a bouncy castle in place of the maple leaf.
00:42:11 So the Canadian flag was already enough of a hate symbol.
00:42:14 This one is even more so.
00:42:16 So be careful where you fly that thing.
00:42:18 You never know what might happen to you.
00:42:19 But what's fascinating here is that we have a government that has been so utterly unrepentant
00:42:27 about this. A finding from the federal court that the constitutional rights of Canadians
00:42:32 were not respected. Now, it's interesting to square that with a comment Justin Trudeau made
00:42:38 on Valentine's Day 2022. Take a look. We're not using the Emergencies Act to call in the military.
00:42:47 We're not suspending fundamental rights or overriding the Charter of Rights and Freedoms.
00:42:53 We are not limiting people's freedom of speech. We are not limiting freedom
00:42:58 of peaceful assembly. We are not preventing people from exercising their right to protest legally.
00:43:08 Okay, we're not ignoring your charter rights. Do I have that right? I'm just looking at the
00:43:15 Yeah, no, he said that.
00:43:16 Okay, so here we have a leader doing what I had at the time remarked as being a little
00:43:22 bit odd.
00:43:22 And I said, if a government has to like pinky swear and promise to you that it's not trampling
00:43:26 on your constitutional rights, there's a good chance it is trampling all over your constitutional
00:43:32 rights.
00:43:32 And now a judge has at long last agreed.
00:43:36 So we're going to continue to follow this along.
00:43:38 As Christine Van Gein said, it's likely to be six months until there's even a hearing
00:43:42 on this, and then another six months to get a decision, and then you may have beyond that a
00:43:46 Supreme Court. Here's a question that I want to put to Conservative leader Pierre Paulyev next time
00:43:51 I speak to him. If you form government and this appeal is underway, will you commit to dropping
00:43:58 the appeal? That's a question that I have for the Conservative leader, and I would love to hear an
00:44:02 answer. So if you run into him at one of those photo lines he does, please ask and report back
00:44:07 if you get an answer. I'll send an email off to his office once I get off air as well. I just
00:44:11 thought of that question but it seems like a good one. I wanted to shift from one trampling of your
00:44:17 rights to another here. We have on an ongoing basis here the federal government going after the rights
00:44:23 of law-abiding gun owners in this country. We have a so-called buyback plan in which the government
00:44:29 is going to buy things back that it never once owed in the first place. They're still trying to
00:44:33 find a vendor to manage this buyback program. This was announced, just to put this into perspective
00:44:39 here just shy of four years ago. And still, there is no program in existence yet. And the fact that
00:44:49 they haven't found a vendor yet, normally I would accuse governments of dragging their heels and
00:44:54 slowing things down. In this case, I'm going to say go as slow as you want to, guys. I am in no
00:44:58 rush to have my property confiscated. Rod Giltaka is the executive director of the Canadian Coalition
00:45:04 for Firearm Rights. It's always good to talk to him. And he joins us now. Rod, welcome back, sir.
00:45:10 Your video looks better than mine. You've got that good podcast set up there. Welcome.
00:45:14 Well, thank you for having me, Andrew.
00:45:16 So again, I mean, normally I never want government to be mired in bureaucracy. In this case,
00:45:23 I'll kind of make an exception for it here. But legitimately, what is the holdup here? Because
00:45:27 originally, this was supposed to not just be in motion, but done by 2022. By May of 2022,
00:45:34 there was supposed to be every one of these guns picked back up by the government. We're now
00:45:38 two years beyond that, and not a single gun has been confiscated.
00:45:43 Well, the holdup is that the challenge to doing a national buyback in a country like Canada,
00:45:48 unlike, let's say, New Zealand, Canada is 10 million square kilometers. So there's a lot of
00:45:53 challenges there. The government has tried a lot of different things, ended up being headed off at
00:45:59 the pass, a lot of dead ends, right? First, they wanted Canada Post to do it. Well, first,
00:46:04 they want the RCMP to do it. And they're like, ah, no thanks. Uh, we have to, this other thing
00:46:07 that we're doing called policing. Uh, then they want a Canada post to do it. And they're like,
00:46:11 you want people in, in, in Canada post outlets to be sitting on hundreds of apparently assault
00:46:18 style firearms and our employees are the only thing thing between these firearms and the criminal
00:46:23 element. Um, and now they're asking gun stores to do it, which gets really, really tricky.
00:46:28 yeah and i mean you obviously have i mean gun stores as you and i have spoken about it as i've
00:46:34 spoken about on the show have been among those most directly harmed by this because they've been
00:46:39 saddled with inventory that they've been able to do nothing with very little communication from the
00:46:43 government very little confiscation or well consultation there's a freudian slip but the
00:46:48 one point that i would stress there is that they're also generally opposed to this so they
00:46:52 don't want to be agents of this confiscation regime. Well, it puts them in a really, really
00:46:59 terrible position. If you think, you know, they can't sell handguns anymore. Handguns and handgun
00:47:03 ammunition was, was big business for a lot of gun stores. They can't sell a wide variety of,
00:47:09 of semi-autos that they used to. So their, their, their inventory, their possible inventory or the
00:47:15 products that they can carry has been drastically, dramatically reduced. And then the government
00:47:20 says, hey, you know, here's a revenue stream for you in helping us helping people comply with the
00:47:25 law. So I think that on one hand, you have a lot of gun store owners going, you know, I could really
00:47:31 use the business. On the other hand, it's like, well, do I want to destroy my business by giving
00:47:35 in and being an agent of confiscation on behalf of the liberals against the people who I want to
00:47:40 be my customers? I'm glad I'm not in that position, but I would not be surprised if the overwhelming
00:47:46 majority of gun store owners decide they want nothing to do with this. Yeah. And I think one
00:47:51 thing that was really, really encouraging to see is Alberta and Saskatchewan take the stand they did
00:47:56 and say, you know what, you may control the criminal law, but we control how police resources
00:48:01 in our province are deployed. And we are not going to allow police to engage in this function.
00:48:06 I was hoping, you know, just magically cause this national ripple effect and every province was
00:48:11 going to do it that hasn't happened though so right now if the liberals had their way we would
00:48:17 still in the majority of the country see this brought to fruition whenever this program comes
00:48:22 with you know legal appeals notwithstanding well yeah um if the liberals had their way i mean
00:48:28 but i think they're handling it like they handle most things right they'll come out with a big
00:48:31 press release full court press this is what we're doing and this is exactly what we said we were
00:48:36 going to do and that's exactly what we're doing and we're keeping canadians safe and doing all
00:48:40 this garbage that they've done for eight and a half years. And then when reality shows up,
00:48:45 they completely fold like a cheap suit. Like that, that is, that is, that is exactly what
00:48:50 the liberals have done, I guess, other than pot. But if you think of it, only the liberal government,
00:48:56 the liberal party of Canada can lose money, money selling weed. But it's, it's all been about press
00:49:01 releases. And, you know, I, I don't know, gaslighting, I guess you could say. But this
00:49:07 time, it's different because this time the challenge is so great that it would take a
00:49:12 highly competent group of people to make this happen. And lucky, I guess, for gun owners for 0.79
00:49:16 now, that doesn't exist in the Liberal government. So I guess we're going to have to see where it
00:49:21 goes from here. I just wanted to get you to give an update if you could on where the legal side of
00:49:26 this is, because I know there were a couple of challenges going on. I know you've had some
00:49:29 unsuccessful rulings, but is there still a glimmer of hope on that path? Well, we are appealing and
00:49:35 And I can't claim to say I'm not envious of what happened yesterday, but I think if anything,
00:49:44 what an interesting time in Canadian history to even just be monitoring the judiciary.
00:49:50 On one hand, the government comes in because of an unrelated event, which was the impetus
00:49:58 for the assault style weapons ban, which was Nova Scotia, where this perpetrator had smuggled
00:50:05 all of his firearms that were used in those shootings from the United States illegally.
00:50:09 And then Trudeau's like, we need to ban guns in Canada. And then you have a court saying, well,
00:50:15 you have no property rights. You have no rights of self-defense. That's another charter question
00:50:19 that we asked. And we had a question that was very clear, and we still believe we clearly should
00:50:24 have won on that, which is the government, it was the OIC, the Ordering Council was ultra varies.
00:50:31 It's very similar to the ruling that came out yesterday. The government didn't have that
00:50:34 authority. So they slap us all down on, on all counts with a very scant decision. And then a
00:50:41 month later, a federal court decides that it is unreasonable to unconstitutional for the government
00:50:46 to ban plastic shopping bags and plastic straws. I mean, that was a line too far. And then we've,
00:50:52 we have this ruling, you know, yesterday, right? So it's the judiciary is all over the place.
00:50:58 the the moral compass in this country in so many corners is spinning can't find you know north
00:51:04 anywhere apparently so um i hope that we'll be successful on appeal because um again property
00:51:10 rights self-defense issues and the role of government in our society all at stake in that
00:51:15 case well and the one point that i i think has always remained important here is that a political
00:51:20 solution is always available it's always possible for the government to one day snap its fingers
00:51:25 and say we're no longer proceeding with this.
00:51:27 Now, that's unlikely under this government,
00:51:29 but if this process is delayed and delayed and delayed
00:51:32 until past the next election,
00:51:34 another government, I mean, let's be real,
00:51:36 the Conservatives are the ones most likely
00:51:38 at this point to form government,
00:51:39 could still say this is not happening
00:51:42 and put it dead in its tracks, could it not?
00:51:44 Well, it's going to take legislation on some,
00:51:46 it's really complicated how the Liberals have done
00:51:49 their OIC and Bill C-21 and C-71 before that.
00:51:54 The order in council, that could be struck down.
00:51:57 But anyway, it gets quite complicated.
00:51:59 So it may require legislation, which will require a conservative majority government.
00:52:04 But yeah, in Canada, as I've said ad nauseum, in Canada, using the British parliamentary
00:52:10 system, our government can do pretty much whatever it wants to anybody it wants.
00:52:15 The courts are, I'm not going to say powerless, but they have a lot less power than they have,
00:52:22 say, in the United States.
00:52:24 then of course they're influenced i think we can all agree on that at some level um but the yeah
00:52:29 the whole system gets gets gets pretty complex but what one government does another government
00:52:37 can undo is really the rule of thumb in our system even though those powers are pretty dramatic but
00:52:42 that's a political solution is uh one easy the easiest way the easiest path i guess you could say
00:52:48 to canadian gun owners just being left alone and getting their property back
00:52:52 Rod Giltak, head of the Canadian Coalition for Firearm Rights.
00:52:55 Always a pleasure, sir.
00:52:56 Thanks for coming on today.
00:52:58 Thanks, Andrew.
00:52:59 All right, that does it for us for today.
00:53:01 We will be back tomorrow to close out the week here on Canada's Most Irreverent Talk Show.
00:53:05 Thank you, God bless, and good day to you all.
00:53:08 Thanks for listening to The Andrew Lawton Show.
00:53:11 Support the program by donating to True North at www.tnc.news.
00:53:21 We'll be right back.
00:53:51 We'll be right back.