Juno News - December 12, 2023


Jagmeet Singh claims victory over dental care plan

Topics
Mentioned
'Frozen Communist s***hole': Joe Rogan blasts Trudeau’s Canada Canada endorses UN pledge to phase out oil and gas

Episode Stats


Length

38 minutes

Words per minute

173.24

Word count

6,727

Sentence count

305

Harmful content

Misogyny

3

sentences flagged

Toxicity

1

sentences flagged

Hate speech

19

sentences flagged


Summary

Summaries generated with gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ .

Jagmeet Singh is the most ineffectual leader the NDP has ever had, and yet he's also the greatest thing the party has ever done. Andrew Lawton explains why, and why only Jagmeet Singh can do it.

Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Topics generated with Qwen2.5-3B-Instruct.
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 Hello and welcome to you all Canada's most irreverent talk show here the Andrew Lawton
00:00:05 show on True North on this Tuesday December 12th. I hope you are having a wonderful afternoon as
00:00:12 always I have to well not as always but just as occasionally in the last couple of weeks of the
00:00:18 year I have to remind you the imminence of Christmas. Now originally this was just meant
00:00:24 to be like a warning so that if you haven't done your Christmas shopping yet you can go out and
00:00:27 get started. We're 13 days away, but now it's like a hate crime to mention Christmas. The only thing
00:00:33 more offensive now is to mention Hanukkah. So I will happily say to all of you, Merry Christmas,
00:00:38 Happy Hanukkah. I hope you are, whichever you're celebrating or not at all, I hope you have a good
00:00:43 one or both of those. But one thing I wanted to bring up here just before we get into it,
00:00:50 there has been this rather interesting trend that has taken place over the last 23 hours.
00:00:56 yesterday at the end of the show, I said to send me your questions because I'm going to do like a
00:01:01 mailbag type episode next week and field some of your questions. I said they could be about anything
00:01:06 and everything. Andrew at truenorthcanada.com is my email address, andrew at truenorthcanada.com.
00:01:13 And oh boy, did some of you take that literally. I have had some just bizarre, bizarre questions
00:01:19 that have come in to such a point where I was wondering if there was some like elaborate
00:01:23 campaign just to throw me off guard. So I don't know, again, I don't know if I'll do all the
00:01:27 questions, but I'll try not to filter. I'll give you some of the weird ones because now that I've
00:01:32 told you, surely this is piquing your interest. So thanks to those who have sent the questions,
00:01:36 except for the one that had a weird one about my socks. And we will get to, maybe I'll do that one.
00:01:41 I don't know. Now that I'm thinking of it, that person might've been a bit weird, but anyway,
00:01:46 we'll get to the real stuff on the show now. Fear not. This is a bit of an interesting trend
00:01:52 we see in Canadian politics, where Jagmeet Singh, the NDP leader, manages to be the most ineffectual
00:01:58 leader of the NDP that the party has ever had, which is really an accomplishment for the new
00:02:04 Democratic Party. To be less ineffectual, or I guess less effectual, to be more ineffectual
00:02:09 as a party is tremendous. I mean, that's the only thing Jagmeet Singh is succeeding at,
00:02:14 is being a failure, because he has managed to get no concessions on any of the issues that
00:02:20 matter to the NDP, which is, again, particularly exceptional when that party literally holds the
00:02:26 balance of power in Canadian politics right now. They could single-handedly take down the
00:02:32 Liberal government because the Bloc Québécois is fed up with them, the Conservatives are fed up
00:02:37 with them. It is only Jagmeet Singh that is the one who really cares about this. So why it's so
00:02:43 interesting is that this is like the dream scenario for Canadian socialists. They're never
00:02:49 going to be in government in Canada at a national level, but they have governmental power. And
00:02:54 instead they just want to tweet about or post on X about, oh, well, the liberals are failing and
00:03:00 grocery store CEOs are bad and oh, billionaires are evil without doing anything. I said a few
00:03:06 weeks back when I was in Ottawa, I saw Jagmeet Singh riding away from Parliament Hill on his
00:03:12 bicycle. And I was, as I said at the time, so impressed that it was possible to pedal without
00:03:18 a spine. But nevertheless Jagmeet Singh has not proved me wrong in the last few days. The big
00:03:24 announcement from the Liberals this week, I talked about it a little bit yesterday, is that the
00:03:29 Liberals are coming out with a big giant national dental program. Okay what does this mean? Well
00:03:35 the Liberals are going to give 9 million Canadians, oh let me look at the fine print, up to 9 million
00:03:43 canadians dental insurance now this is going to uh basically mean that low-income uninsured
00:03:49 canadians will have access the government says to dental care by virtue of the government giving
00:03:56 them a dental insurance plan now this sounds big it sounds transformative well it's not the
00:04:01 universal dental care plan that the ndp has always wanted nowhere near that it's not even a new
00:04:07 program this is just an expansion of an existing program that already existed that the liberals
00:04:13 wanted that dealt with youth, that dealt with minors and children. And now we're just talking
00:04:20 about expanding this ever so slightly. And if you were to talk to the NDP right now,
00:04:26 they think that they've pulled off the greatest coup, the greatest achievement, the greatest win
00:04:31 in Canadian politics. I'll show two clips. This is Jagmeet Singh talking about this
00:04:36 phenomenal NDP victory. Friends, the day has finally arrived. The NDP dental care program
00:04:43 has finally been announced and that means the rollout is going to start very soon. So I want
00:04:49 you to make full use of this program. I've spoken to people who were able to access the under 12
00:04:54 program and it changed the lives of so many kids in our country. I want to make sure you and your
00:05:00 family can access this program. So now that it's been announced, the best way for you to get all
00:05:05 the details for us to get those details to you about how to enroll how to access a program is
00:05:10 just to text us text us hashtag NDP dental and we will give you all the details about how to enroll
00:05:17 how to access program as soon as we get those details so again I'm so excited this is great
00:05:23 news and now we want to make sure you can access it so definitely text us and we will give you all
00:05:28 the information i haven't yet texted jagmeet singh i i maybe well maybe i will later maybe i'll send
00:05:36 him a text later on we'll all well you can ask him about his socks uh but that is uh one of the
00:05:41 things he's asking people to do you hear the branding there the ndp dental program the ndp
00:05:45 dental program it was the ndp dental program announced by the uh wait wait for it oh the
00:05:51 liberals sorry okay it was the liberal dental program but you know the ndp is getting a little
00:05:56 bit excited no one has been as excited about this as ndp member of parliament don davies though
00:06:03 take a look at don in the house of commons this week thanks to new democrats nine million
00:06:09 canadians will have access to the dental care they deserve seniors children people with disabilities
00:06:15 will soon be able to go to the dentist without worrying about the cost because of the ndp
00:06:19 families will save thousands of dollars during an affordability crisis this is the biggest
00:06:24 expansion of public health care in half a century.
00:06:27 Shamefully, last week the Conservatives again voted no to dental care and putting money
00:06:32 back in people's pockets.
00:06:34 Can the Minister explain the impact of the NDP dental plan on Canadians?
00:06:41 The Honourable Minister of Health.
00:06:44 In a time of great global difficulty, in a time where people all over the world are
00:06:49 finding things hard, there are those that stand up and provide solutions.
00:06:53 and talk about how we make things better.
00:06:56 And I want to recognize the NDP in stepping forward
00:06:59 and talking about solutions, about talking about answers.
00:07:02 When we saw the Conservatives voting against dental care,
00:07:05 voting against support for seniors,
00:07:07 voting against support for patients with disability,
00:07:10 voting against our children who need dental support.
00:07:13 Shame on them, Mr. Speaker.
00:07:14 And congratulations to any party that stands up for ideas
00:07:18 and getting things done in this country.
00:07:23 I love just the juxtaposition.
00:07:26 I mean, they're talking as though they're on the same team there.
00:07:29 But the NDP is like, will the liberal minister talk about how great the NDP is?
00:07:33 The liberal minister gets up.
00:07:34 He's like, yeah, we're happy with any party that wants to help us do this.
00:07:38 Sean says it reminds him of Howard.
00:07:41 That is a deep cut.
00:07:42 How old were you during that campaign?
00:07:44 Yeah, Howard Dean, the former governor of Vermont, who when he ran for president was
00:07:49 like listing all the Sean says he was four.
00:07:51 Well, you were a very astute, politically aware four-year-old at the time.
00:07:55 Yeah, he like yelped and screamed as he was reading all the states that he was campaigning in.
00:08:02 And that basically cost him the election because everyone looked at Howard Dean and in America was like, oh, I don't want that.
00:08:07 I don't want a guy that like shrieks like a little girl to be the president of the United States. 1.00
00:08:11 So that was the thing. So I was and I was not getting a Howard Dean vibe from Mark Holland.
00:08:16 I was getting a Dwight Schrute blood alone moves the wheels of history vibe with a bit of a smile.
00:08:21 that was more the vibe i was getting there but just on the merits alone the ndp is saying this
00:08:28 is an ndp plan and the liberals are like yeah it's a liberal plan but you guys helped out and
00:08:32 thanks and and shame on those evil nasty conservatives that uh you know wanted kids to 1.00
00:08:36 have cavities or whatever the point was that mark holland was attempting to make there but 0.78
00:08:41 this is the ndp doing a victory lap and it's not even the biggest thing they wanted it's not even
00:08:46 new so let's go back to the supply and confidence agreement which is the coalition excuse me sorry
00:08:53 coalition the uh costly coalition as the conservatives call it between the liberals
00:08:59 and the ndp that came in the wake of the 2021 election the agreement if you look at the bullet
00:09:05 points there what they've all said they're going to launch a new dental care program for low-income
00:09:11 canadians it's going to start with 12 year olds in 2022 then it's going to expand and in 2023 it's
00:09:17 going to be there for seniors and persons with disabilities with full implementation by 2025.
00:09:23 so this was already what they had agreed to and the thing is it was already something the liberals
00:09:29 wanted it was something the liberals campaigned on now you look at other things that have been
00:09:33 proposed there they are nowhere to be found for example the ndb's pursuit of a universal national
00:09:41 PharmaCare program, which was supposed to come by the end of 2023. Now, by my count, that is,
00:09:48 what, 19 days away is my math right there? 19 days. They have to come up with this National
00:09:55 PharmaCare program, which just is not happening right now. Now, to be clear, I am not advocating
00:10:02 for these policies. I'm not saying I want these things. I'm not saying that Canadians should have 1.00
00:10:06 to pay for them. What I am pointing out is that the NDP and the Liberals have always been singing
00:10:12 from the same songbook on this, and even then the Liberals are not doing what the NDP wanted.
00:10:18 The NDP could literally hold this government to account in a real way by saying, you do this by
00:10:24 December 31st, or we pull your support, we go to an election, and Justin Trudeau is going to be
00:10:29 surfing full-time on the beaches of Tofino. But that's not what the NDP is doing, because to do
00:10:34 that, you require a spine. To do that, you require a backbone. And now we have in Canada, this
00:10:43 government that effectively operates with a majority mandate because the NDP is not wanting
00:10:49 to do its role of being an opposition party. Now I've played these clips on the show and I
00:10:56 partially I'm doing it just because it's fun. I don't want to pretend that there's like a really
00:10:59 serious point, but I'll try and make a serious point out of this. The NDP has in the past tried 0.61
00:11:05 to position losses as victories. Do you remember Jagmeet Singh's dance moves after the 2019 election?
00:11:12 Pepperidge Farm remembers.
00:11:29 yeah that was i love the song by the way i don't know the song i don't know what the words are the
00:11:44 words could be uh we're going to be a failure as a party and not do anything in punjabi but
00:11:48 uh nevertheless he's dancing he's got good beats and good grooving and all of that i'm not arguing
00:11:53 with the dance moves but this is a guy who won 24 seats going into the election he had 39 seats
00:12:04 he comes out with a 15 seat loss gets 15.98 percent of the vote and he's dancing as though
00:12:13 he won now this surely was a one-off right well let's go to the 2021 election in this election
00:12:19 Jagmeet Singh had started with 24 he went up a little bit he went to 25 seats this election 17
00:12:27 of the vote a slight improvement but do the dance moves fit the achievement let's take
00:12:41 uh that was a bit more of an austere dance move i mean on that election he had actually gone up
00:12:45 uh at least a seat so you think he'd be able to be a little bit more forceful but he'd used up
00:12:49 up all the good moves in 2019. Jagmeet Singh, you could be the most powerful and influential player
00:12:56 in Canadian politics. It pains me to say that and the fact that you don't realize it or don't use
00:13:01 that power is why you are never going to be the Prime Minister. That's not an endorsement or an
00:13:07 anti-endorsement. I'm simply stating an observational fact there. Moving on from this for just a few
00:13:14 moments here, I wanted to talk about this somewhat breaking story that came out today where Canada
00:13:19 has, alongside several other countries, effectively started calling for a ceasefire in Israel. This is
00:13:27 a joint statement by the prime ministers of Australia, Canada, and New Zealand. They say
00:13:33 in this statement, I won't read the whole thing, that we want to see this pause resumed. They had
00:13:38 Israel and Hamas, a humanitarian pause, and support urgent international efforts towards a sustainable
00:13:45 ceasefire. This cannot be one-sided. Hamas must release all hostages, stop using Palestinian 1.00
00:13:52 civilians as human shields, and lay down its arms. There is no role for Hamas in the future 0.66
00:13:57 governance of Gaza. So there is still criticism and condemnation for Hamas, but effectively this
00:14:03 is a statement that is endorsing the idea that it is incumbent on Israel to lay down its arms and
00:14:10 stop fighting against the brutal terrorist group that killed more than 1400 israelis and has
00:14:17 continued to wage war on israel and has called for the annihilation of israel and the jewish state
00:14:22 israel is not supposed to fight back against those people now if you don't follow this issue or you
00:14:28 don't follow geopolitics which i would forgive you for not doing you may not understand what's at
00:14:33 stake here the word cease fire sounds nice who doesn't like cease fire it's the same as peace
00:14:38 Peace is great. Everyone loves peace. Give peace a chance, right? But the problem with a ceasefire
00:14:43 is that it's rooted in a fundamental idea that Israel does not have the right to defend itself.
00:14:49 And I am fully sympathetic to the realist position here that Canada and the U.S. and the U.K. should
00:14:55 not be involved in a foreign war. But supporting Israel is not about involving yourself in a war.
00:15:00 It's about just looking at a situation and realizing what the right thing to do is. And
00:15:05 This idea of whether supporting Israel is meddling or whether it is something that is in a country's national interest has become an interesting discussion.
00:15:13 And it's one that I wanted to take up with Brian Lee Crowley, who is the managing director of the McDonnell-Laurier Institute.
00:15:20 I ran into him when I was in Alberta a couple of weeks back filming some interviews with other folks.
00:15:25 And I said, Brian, I got to get you on this.
00:15:26 And it has made it well, it's really made itself out to be a timely and prescient interview.
00:15:31 Take a look.
00:15:33 I'm joined by the Managing Director of the Macdonald Laurier Institute,
00:15:37 which is, well, I don't want to say very quickly because you've been putting the effort in,
00:15:40 but has very notably been becoming just an absolute powerhouse on so many discussions
00:15:45 on domestic policy and foreign policy in this country, Brian Lee Crowley.
00:15:50 Always a pleasure. Good to see you, Brian.
00:15:51 Hendrick, I can't tell you how much I like being on the show with you.
00:15:54 Oh, well, thank you.
00:15:55 I'm glad to do it in person.
00:15:57 Yeah, yeah.
00:15:57 Actually, I don't know if we've heard of it with you on the show in person.
00:16:00 I know we've done panels together.
00:16:01 Well, look, foreign policy is often one of these issues that you get people in politics that occasionally like to geek out on and people, the conventional political wisdom dictates are not really motivated by it.
00:16:14 Voters don't really care about it.
00:16:15 But this has been a year in which I'd say it has been on the agenda, both with China notably and now really notably the Middle East and Israel.
00:16:24 And let's just start there, because Stephen Harper, when he was in power, had a very markedly
00:16:31 strong position on Israel.
00:16:33 He was very well liked there, very well regarded there.
00:16:36 Donald Trump in the U.S. did something very similar.
00:16:39 He moved the embassy to Jerusalem, which was supposedly going to open Pandora's box and
00:16:45 really hasn't.
00:16:46 Now you fast forward to today, we have Justin Trudeau, who's the prime minister in Canada,
00:16:52 and I think has kept the Canadian position of support for Israel,
00:16:56 but a lot more modestly.
00:17:01 Where would you say, well, I don't think I'll be appointed ambassador anytime soon,
00:17:06 but why does that relationship matter for Canada?
00:17:10 Oh boy, that's such a great question, Andrew.
00:17:13 I think because the Middle East is one of the most important
00:17:18 and most volatile places in the world.
00:17:21 And because Israel is an island of liberal democratic values in a sea of instability, autocratic regimes, dangerous behavior by Iran, Syria basically engaged in a killing spree of its own citizens.
00:17:42 I mean, in every part of the Middle East, danger signals fly.
00:17:48 And, you know, we as a liberal democratic world, not just Canada and the United States, but our NATO allies, all of whom rely, for example, on energy that comes from the Middle East.
00:18:00 What happens in the Middle East matters enormously to us.
00:18:03 And in a sense, I think Israel is the canary in the coal mine. 0.96
00:18:09 As long as Israel survives and thrives in the Middle East, 1.00
00:18:15 I believe that we in the liberal democratic world
00:18:18 can continue to defend our interests in that region.
00:18:21 And if ever Israel was to falter and fail,
00:18:24 I think it would be disastrous for all of us.
00:18:26 So it's not just that I think that this is important for Israel.
00:18:31 Obviously it is.
00:18:33 What's going on is an existential threat to Israel. 0.74
00:18:36 But it's also terribly important to us. We have huge interests at stake in the Middle East. And the only people who see the world in the way that we do, from a liberal democratic perspective, the only people are the Israelis. 0.90
00:18:52 one of the challenges we've seen on the domestic front on this is that there's been a an increase
00:18:58 in especially on the political right i'd say and in isolationism and i'm sympathetic to a lot of
00:19:04 that i'm sympathetic to the idea that so we need to be more independent and protective of our
00:19:09 sovereignty and i i'm very sympathetic to the argument that getting involved in conflicts that
00:19:14 don't affect us is not advisable and that you can be trapped in foreign wars certainly in american
00:19:20 context. But why is that? I mean, that attitude, I'd say, has reared its head in very ugly ways
00:19:27 on Israel, when you get people that say, it's not our problem, I don't care. What's your thought
00:19:32 on that? Because I know you've seen that similar to me, and certainly on Ukraine and Russia,
00:19:36 we've seen that attitude. Yes, and you know, it's quite astonishing to me that people in Canada
00:19:42 might not get the idea that as a medium power in the world,
00:19:49 an important medium power, you know,
00:19:51 we're one of the 10 largest economies in the world,
00:19:54 we have some weight in the world.
00:19:56 But that Canada, somehow people seem to think we can make it alone,
00:20:05 you know, that we don't need to rely on other people
00:20:07 who see the world we do in the way we do,
00:20:10 and that we promised to support them
00:20:12 and they promised to support us
00:20:14 when push comes to shove.
00:20:17 I mean, this is why we were one of the founders of NATO.
00:20:19 The whole idea of the United States,
00:20:21 the fundamental motivating idea
00:20:25 behind the creation of NATO
00:20:26 was that other than the United States,
00:20:29 none of us could stand alone
00:20:30 in the face of an existential threat.
00:20:33 We rely on each other.
00:20:35 We have promised each other
00:20:36 if someone attacks one of us,
00:20:39 they attack all of them.
00:20:40 This idea of mutual defense and, you know, the idea that we can afford to be indifferent to the fate, especially of other countries, you know, that subscribe to liberal democratic values, that we could stand aside from those things.
00:21:01 And, you know, as the old saying goes, you know, we keep feeding the tiger and the oath that he'll eat us last.
00:21:09 You know, we're in Ukraine and we're supportive of Israel because the things that they represent, as far as I'm concerned, are things that Canada wants to defend in the world and we can't do it alone.
00:21:23 and so we must be prepared to step up when those values are challenged anywhere in the world
00:21:29 because you know if we don't the next place they'll be challenged is a lot closer to home
00:21:33 well i think on israel we certainly see that i mean you talk about israel as being a canary in
00:21:39 the coal mine and i think the anti-semitism that we've seen shockingly brazen displays of
00:21:45 in the last two months in canada are a tremendous example of this and i think you could point to a
00:21:51 number of factors here. I think you can point to immigration, you can point to education, you can
00:21:55 point to, you know, perhaps some of the media playing a role in this and academia playing a
00:22:00 role in this. But all of this is to say, if we allow those ideas to exist unchallenged and
00:22:07 uncriticized, there is no Israel. And that's, I think, a tremendous, tremendous display. And I 0.79
00:22:13 think that's where the story is very much a domestic one, as much as it is a global one.
00:22:19 Yes, I have to say, Andrew, I've been deeply disturbed by what I've seen in Canada over the last couple of months.
00:22:27 I have had Jewish friends come to me and say, you know, Brian, I never thought I'd say this, but if it comes to that, will you hide me?
00:22:38 Well, will you hide me?
00:22:40 I never thought that I would see circumstances in Canada in which our Jewish citizens would be frightened that there was no longer a place for them and that they might actually physically be threatened.
00:22:53 And now, of course, we see, you know, university professors arrested and charged with vandalism against a business in Toronto.
00:23:03 What was the what was the reason for the vandalism?
00:23:05 It was owned by a Jew, owned by a Jew. 0.91
00:23:08 And so these are...
00:23:09 Oh, it's a crystal note.
00:23:10 I mean, that's the thing.
00:23:11 People overuse Nazi and Holocaust comparisons,
00:23:14 but this is literally what happened in 1930s here.
00:23:18 And, you know, my Jewish friends say to me,
00:23:22 look, you know, people say that they're sympathetic and so on,
00:23:26 but people are not speaking up.
00:23:29 And, you know, I think that the idea that what's going on,
00:23:36 for example, between Israel and Hamas is about foreign policy and not about the nature of Canada
00:23:45 is completely wrong. I think what the conflict between Hamas and Israel is bringing to the
00:23:51 surface conflicts that we didn't really think existed in Canada, we're discovering otherwise.
00:23:58 Well, and that's, I think, one of the big challenges of multiculturalism. Now, let me say, 1.00
00:24:04 I believe that I wouldn't go so far as to say the diversity is our strength in the Tridopia way. 0.99
00:24:08 But I do think one of the things that makes Canada so unique is that it has this this cross section.
00:24:13 But the challenge there is that we've seen an importation of conflict.
00:24:16 Yeah. You know, Calistan is a notable example of this.
00:24:19 And as we're seeing in the last couple of months, Israel.
00:24:22 And can you put the genie back in the bottle on it?
00:24:25 Well, you see, I think that one of the things that we don't really understand very well as Canadians about immigration is that people don't come here, by and large, to live as they lived in the country that they came from.
00:24:45 It's expensive and disruptive to immigrate.
00:24:48 You don't come so that you can do exactly the same thing here that you were doing back home.
00:24:52 People don't come here to change Canada.
00:24:55 People come here to be changed by Canada, to become Canadian. 0.84
00:24:59 And I think it's terribly important that we understand as Canadians what it is that is great about Canada
00:25:08 and that we are completely entitled to demand that newcomers to Canada respect and understand.
00:25:15 And I think this idea that, well, you know, look, I'm the great-great-grandson of immigrants from Ireland, and you know that the Irish imported some conflicts between North and South, between Irish and English and all.
00:25:38 Eventually, we were able to get rid of those, that transplanting of... 0.95
00:25:43 I was going to say, they haven't necessarily there, but certainly here they have.
00:25:47 We managed to get that under control.
00:25:50 So, you know, my family has some experience of this.
00:25:55 You know, the first major political assassination in Canada, Darcy McGee,
00:26:02 was killed by, you know, an Irishman bringing that conflict to Canada. 0.96
00:26:07 um so we have a stake uh as a society that is dependent on immigration and that appreciates 0.99
00:26:17 immigration and wants immigration but we have a responsibility to make sure that we make clear
00:26:23 to newcomers to this country you can't do certain things here with you because it conflicts with 0.83
00:26:29 what makes Canada great it conflicts with the rule of law it conflicts with the respect we have to
00:26:33 have for each other the the different backgrounds and ethnic origins and so on that we have
00:26:39 and there is no place in my view for you know immigrants to Canada to congregate in their
00:26:51 tens of thousands in major cities in Canada and call for the death of other members of the
00:26:58 canadian community this is not polarity in a society like canada and i think we're we're too
00:27:05 afraid to defend the values which actually make canada a place worth coming to uh and i think
00:27:13 the conflict uh with israel uh between israel and hamas uh is giving us a great object lesson
00:27:22 and how important it is to be clear
00:27:24 about what it means to come to Canada
00:27:26 and the behaviours that Canadians will accept.
00:27:31 Brian Lee Crowley.
00:27:32 Thank you.
00:27:33 Bye, Mary.
00:27:35 That was my interview with Brian Lee Crowley
00:27:38 of the Macdonald-Laurier Institute.
00:27:40 It was recorded a couple of weeks ago.
00:27:42 I always like to give that context.
00:27:44 But in that case, there really wasn't anything
00:27:46 that has become outdated.
00:27:47 And I'd say, if anything,
00:27:49 it's probably become even more accurate
00:27:51 and more truthful as time has gone on and we've gotten a bit more of a sense of how things are
00:27:58 shaking out. One issue I wanted to bring up that's completely unrelated to this. Yesterday I had like
00:28:03 a great segue from one topic to the other. Today I don't have that so we just have to do the back
00:28:08 when I worked in talk radio like commercial breaks were great because you could just like go to
00:28:11 commercial and not have to worry about awkward transitions or anything like that but nevertheless
00:28:16 wanted to talk about generosity it's a season of giving of course although not as much in Canada
00:28:22 this year a new report from the Fraser Institute finds that generosity is at a profound low there's
00:28:30 been a steep decline and Canadians are no longer giving now is this because Canadians are greedy 1.00
00:28:36 and miserly or is it because they are simply so cash strapped from all of these other circumstances
00:28:42 they can't afford to be giving with as much generosity as they have previously.
00:28:48 Jake Fuss is the Director of Fiscal Studies with the Fraser Institute and joins me on
00:28:53 the show.
00:28:53 It's always good to talk to Jake.
00:28:54 Jake, good to see you again.
00:28:55 Thanks for coming on today.
00:28:57 Good to see you.
00:28:57 Thanks for having me on.
00:28:58 So we'll get into the why in a moment, but let's just first identify what the trend you're
00:29:03 seeing here is.
00:29:05 Yeah, well, every holiday season, we track the generosity of Canadians looking at donations
00:29:08 claimed on your tax returns.
00:29:10 And what we found is that in 2021, we saw that the lowest percentage of tax filers were making donations since the year 2001.
00:29:18 So less than one in five Canadians on their tax receipts were making those donations.
00:29:23 It was about 17.7% of Canadians.
00:29:26 That compares to 2001, where it was about 25.2% of tax filers making those donations.
00:29:32 So we've really seen a steep decline, not only nationally, but just in every province across Canada.
00:29:37 It's not unique to Ontario. It's not unique to Alberta.
00:29:39 it's really occurring across all of the provinces in canada and it's a trend that we've been seeing
00:29:44 consistently over the last two decades now one of the challenges of course here is that you're
00:29:50 you're a couple years behind on on the data you have available 2021 uh we have of course inflation
00:29:57 cost of living issues you also have lingering effects of lockdowns you have some of these
00:30:02 covet issues how much do you think those are weighing on this versus some of the broader
00:30:07 economic trends and the climate that we're still seeing in 2023? Yeah, I mean, those could
00:30:13 certainly be a factor. But I mean, what we see is that this has been a trend before COVID, during
00:30:17 COVID, and then it's likely going to be a continuing trend coming out of COVID as well when we get the
00:30:21 data for 2022 and 2023 from the Canada Revenue Agency on those tax slips. So ultimately, you
00:30:28 know, it's really been a sign of broader economic concerns over the last number of years and the
00:30:33 last number of decades, too. We've really seen that consistent decline in all provinces in Canada,
00:30:39 both in the share of income that's being donated to these charitable organizations,
00:30:43 and also then the percentage of taxpayers making those donations. So it's really been this
00:30:48 consistent concerning trend. And it hasn't really, you know, had too much of an effect with COVID or
00:30:53 before or after, you know, likely moving forward with cost of living and housing remaining
00:30:58 consistent issues to, we could possibly see even further declines in the years ahead.
00:31:05 I know the data do not tell you the why. They just tell you the what. And you can see that
00:31:10 pretty clear. But is there any other, I know Cardus has done some work on this in the past.
00:31:15 Are there any good compelling explanations for what is driving this trend? Because as you mentioned,
00:31:20 and when you look at the chart, it's a pretty straight line. I mean, you get a few blips here
00:31:24 and there. But generally speaking, it's a pretty clear decline. Do we know why that is or have
00:31:28 suspicions of why that is? Yeah. So even though we don't track the exact reasons why this occurs
00:31:34 in our study, we do know possible reasons why people choose to give to charities through economic
00:31:40 research. And what it generally points to is generosity is often sensitive to how much after
00:31:45 tax income people have available to them. So if your income levels are not increasing or your tax
00:31:50 bill is going up, for instance, then you have less money available to you to make those charitable
00:31:55 donations. Other things that can also play a factor in why people choose not to give or choose
00:32:00 to give would be, you know, things like religious affiliation, the age of the population, generally
00:32:06 the older you are, the more likely you are to donate. Also education levels. These are all
00:32:11 things that can play a determining role in whether or not people could choose to give to charitable
00:32:16 organizations. But ultimately, I think, you know, one of the big factors here is possibly after tax
00:32:22 income, because that is one of the sensitive factors to charitable giving in general.
00:32:28 I'm speculating here, but when you mention after tax income, I think there are two aspects. One is
00:32:33 just how many dollars do you have to give? How much discretionary income do you have? And the
00:32:37 other, I think, is the one, and this will be a bit harder to quantify, but what message is the
00:32:42 government sending when they're taxing you? They're basically saying, we're taking care of people you
00:32:46 don't need to. And I think that must be factoring in to some extent where you get people that are in
00:32:51 a situation where they assume that, well, if I'm being taxed, you know, this much, maybe I don't
00:32:55 need to donate to charity to solve these problems. I'm sure government's looking after it.
00:33:00 Well, one of the things that we've seen really recently is the tax bill is rising much faster
00:33:04 than the costs of basic necessities like food, shelter and clothing even. So even though those
00:33:10 costs are going up, tax bill is going up even faster. So that obviously leaves less money
00:33:15 available for not only basic necessities, but other things as well, whether that's entertainment
00:33:19 or remaining expenses to give to charitable organizations too. So currently in Canada,
00:33:24 about 45% of the average family's income is going towards their tax bill. And that's more than what's
00:33:30 going towards basic necessities. So about 36% of your income is going to housing, food and clothing
00:33:36 combined. So this is a really concerning trend that we've seen now for consistently really over
00:33:41 last decade or two in Canada and it's probably going to continue for the foreseeable future.
00:33:47 And I know this goes outside of this particular study but you've done some work in the past I
00:33:51 think it was earlier in the fall where you looked at just rising federal spending and there was no
00:33:56 real tax relief that was being put to Canadians or is being put to Canadians by the government is
00:34:01 there? Nothing really tangible at the moment right now I mean and we're really in need of some tax
00:34:06 reform in Canada because you know we have this waning productivity challenge we have collapsing
00:34:11 business investment in Canada. We also have concerns with living standards as our real GDP
00:34:16 per capita, which is basically a broad measure of living standards in Canada, has either been
00:34:20 declining or stagnant for quite some time. So even though our economy is growing overall,
00:34:25 our income levels on a per person or per household basis are not really increasing over time.
00:34:30 So there's a lot of concerns here with the tax system in Canada. And even though we have this
00:34:35 massive kind of increase in government spending over the last eight years or so, we haven't really
00:34:40 seen the results from an economic growth standpoint. So we've seen debt increase quite
00:34:46 massively. We've also seen that spending increase by about 25% since the beginning of COVID as well.
00:34:52 And we have this bigger size of government, but we don't really have much to show for it.
00:34:56 So ultimately, we need to pursue policies that actually boost that economic growth,
00:35:00 actually improve the living standards for Canadians, because right now we're not seeing
00:35:04 those results. Well, it's a bit of a far-fetched Christmas wish, but I think definitely a worthwhile
00:35:09 one. Jake Fuss, Director of Fiscal Studies for the Fraser Institute. Thanks for coming on, Jake.
00:35:14 Thanks very much for having me on. Yeah, look, I mean, Cardis has done some very useful work on
00:35:20 this. The Fraser Institute annually does work on this that's very solid, and they look right at
00:35:24 the data. I mean, it's a pretty unavoidable reality. These are the things. I mean, theoretically,
00:35:29 people could be donating to non-registered charities or not claiming their charitable
00:35:33 contributions on their taxes. By the way, if you are donating to charity and not claiming your tax
00:35:38 receipt on your taxes, you are giving Justin Trudeau more money and you should be ashamed
00:35:41 of yourself. Same as in Ontario, we have this line item on our tax returns called the Ontario
00:35:47 Opportunities Fund. Now, what you might ask is the Ontario Opportunities Fund. It is a voluntary
00:35:54 payment to pay down the provincial debt that you can do. So I could like willingly say,
00:36:00 you know what, I'd like to donate my tax refund to cover the terrible, horrendous spending
00:36:06 decisions by this government. Anyone who pays the Ontario Opportunity Fund should also be ashamed
00:36:11 of themselves. This is like, it's an early festivus here. I've got a lot of problems with
00:36:15 you people, as Frank Costanza would say. Well, we are coming out of time today, but I mentioned
00:36:21 earlier on this comparison that Sean raised between Don Davies and Howard Dean. And instead
00:36:27 of just paying attention to the show, Sean has apparently just put this clip together that I'm
00:36:32 to show for you now last week the conservatives again voted no to dental care and putting money
00:36:38 back in people's pockets can the minister explain the impact of the NDP dental plan on Canadian
00:36:44 all right well so you're forgiven for like not paying attention to the Brian Lee Crowley
00:36:52 interview Sean that was uh 13 seconds well worth the wait there uh that does it for me we will be
00:36:58 back tomorrow with more of Canada's Most Irreverent Talk Show. We got a special interview with Mark
00:37:02 Marano, fresh off his trip to Dubai for COP28. Always a good time. I don't know if he rode the
00:37:08 camel in like he did to Sharm el-Sheikh at COP27 in Egypt. I don't know. Surely there are some 1.00
00:37:14 camels in Dubai. I mean, they're probably like Maserati camels or Lamborghini camels, like
00:37:18 only the high-end designer import camels, but I'm sure they exist there. So we'll check in with
00:37:24 mark morano on tomorrow's show also speaking of ontario uh no don't tune out if you're from
00:37:29 alberta uh we're going to be chatting about this phenomenal new book about mike harris and his
00:37:34 legacy which is a story about conservatism as much as it's a story about ontario politics that's also
00:37:39 on the show tomorrow and lots of other stuff coming up in the remaining week here so do tune
00:37:44 in we will talk to you tomorrow thank you god bless and good day to you all thanks for listening
00:37:49 to the Andrew Lawton Show.
00:37:51 Support the program by donating to True North
00:37:53 at www.tnc.news.
00:38:19 We'll be right back.