Juno News - May 19, 2022


Jason Kenney is resigning. What does it mean for Canadian conservatism?

Topics
Guests
Mentioned
Should you invest in Bitcoin? Andrew Lawton is heading to the WEF Annual Meeting

Episode Stats


Length

49 minutes

Words per minute

191.51

Word count

9,449

Sentence count

441

Harmful content

Misogyny

1

sentences flagged

Toxicity

1

sentences flagged


Summary

Summaries generated with gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ .

In this episode of The Andrew Lawton Show, host Andrew Lawton is joined by Conservative Party of Canada's Jim Carajalios and Ontario Party Leader Derek Sloan to discuss the state of conservative politics in Canada.

Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Topics generated with Qwen2.5-3B-Instruct.
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 lair
00:00:04 the
00:00:10 soon
00:00:19 in
00:00:23 We'll be right back.
00:00:53 reverent talk show this is the andrew lawton show brought to you by true north
00:01:03 hello and welcome to you all this is the andrew lawton show here on true north and i believe i'm
00:01:08 hiding behind an email right now this is uh this is like the technical brilliance you can come to
00:01:14 expect from the andrew lawton show it looks like unless my uh my end is uh is all messed up here
00:01:19 But in any case, which is entirely possible, if you are seeing me, then I don't mind that at all.
00:01:23 I'm just getting a look at a different view than you are, possibly because one second ago, just before I got into my studio in the bunker here,
00:01:33 I like slipped down the stairs and I was holding my laptop in one hand and I managed to avoid breaking my laptop or my head,
00:01:39 one of which produces constructive things and it's not my head.
00:01:42 But I made it in here sitting down and ready to do this.
00:01:46 It is a big day and a big week for conservative politics in this country.
00:01:50 We're going to be speaking later on in the show about Jason Kenney and his resignation
00:01:56 as the, or forthcoming resignation, I should say, as the leader of the UCP and of the Premier
00:02:02 of Alberta.
00:02:04 And there are still some questions lingering about that.
00:02:07 Danielle Smith, who's already lined up to say that she is seeking the leadership of
00:02:11 the UCP and ultimately the premiership of Alberta is saying that this is a grassroots resolution.
00:02:16 People saying that they do not have confidence in the numbers you need to stay as the leader
00:02:22 in Jason Kenney's leadership. So that's actually something we'll be talking about at great length
00:02:27 later on. And we're covering different provinces today. I want to start with Ontario politics,
00:02:31 because this is, if you're in Ontario, you may or may not know, we're in the midst of an election
00:02:35 right now coming up in just a couple of weeks. It hasn't been the most riveting of elections.
00:02:40 admittedly it's been a bit sleepy and certainly for me because four years ago i was actually a
00:02:45 candidate in the ontario election so i'm glad to be sitting this one from the sidelines in media
00:02:51 but one of the unique attributes of this election is that you have some upstart conservative parties
00:02:56 that are positioning themselves to really be alternatives to doug ford's government one of
00:03:01 them is the new blue party which was founded by jim carahalios and has belinda carahalios who is
00:03:08 elected as a PCMPP, as an elected representative up until the writs were issued. And then you also
00:03:14 have the Ontario Party, another new party by someone who's been on this show before, Derek
00:03:19 Sloan, formerly a Conservative Party of Canada, leadership candidate and member of Parliament,
00:03:24 now leader of the provincial Ontario Party. And I thought it would be a great idea to actually get
00:03:29 Jim and Derek together on this show to talk about what it is that their parties are doing
00:03:34 in the landscape of Ontario politics and how they differ from each other. Because this is something
00:03:39 I've been getting emails from Ontarians saying, like, I don't know which of these is supposed to
00:03:44 be the party that I vote for. So I thought it'd be good to have a friendly collegial debate between
00:03:49 the two. Derek Sloan of the Ontario party accepted rather quickly. Jim Carajalios declined to
00:03:55 participate because he said that basically the spokesperson from his campaign said that the
00:04:00 Ontario party was not a real contender in their view. So instead, we have Derek Sloan on for a
00:04:06 one-on-one interview, but I wanted it noted that Jim Carajalios was invited to make this a broader
00:04:11 discussion and was not interested in doing it. But I do want to welcome Derek to the show. Derek,
00:04:16 it's good to talk to you again. Thanks for coming on today. Yeah, glad to be here. Thanks, Andrew.
00:04:21 So I touched on it a little bit in the intro here, but I think it is an important discussion
00:04:25 to be had because we talk all the time about the strategic aspects of this, you know, vote splitting
00:04:30 and strategic voting.
00:04:31 And there's also the more fundamental philosophical idea,
00:04:34 which is that conservatives oftentimes,
00:04:37 I think independence is the greatest frustration
00:04:40 they have to deal with
00:04:41 because you have a lot of groups
00:04:42 that are sometimes very difficult to rally together.
00:04:44 So why do we have, if we include the PC party here,
00:04:48 why do we have three parties
00:04:50 that are really going after, I would say,
00:04:52 and you can correct me if I'm wrong,
00:04:54 the same voters in a lot of ways?
00:04:57 Yeah, well, I would say that,
00:04:59 you know, I think that there is more room than just sort of poaching off the Conservatives for
00:05:04 votes. And I'll go into that a little bit later. But I think what we're seeing now is just
00:05:09 dissatisfaction with Doug Ford. There are many Conservatives, many people who voted for Doug
00:05:15 Ford, who are frankly appalled at what we've seen the last couple of years, and they want new
00:05:20 options. And the Ontario Party is one of them. In terms of, you know, succeeding as a new party,
00:05:25 I think that your goal, of course, has to be more than just taking votes from the Conservatives.
00:05:30 You have to be able to take votes from everybody.
00:05:34 We also live in a country where, you know, roughly half of the people vote, sometimes a little more, sometimes a little less.
00:05:40 There's a lot of people who don't trust anybody, who don't like anybody.
00:05:44 And I think we can reach those people, too.
00:05:47 So what is it that the Ontario Party is really trying to do?
00:05:51 It's not a party that has a conventional name that Canadians are used to that defines it, the Liberals, the Conservatives.
00:05:57 So what is the space that you think the Ontario Party occupies?
00:06:01 Well, you know, I think Ontarians and Canadians generally are looking for parties that they can trust.
00:06:07 And our party is a party that's based on, you know, truth, integrity, transparency.
00:06:12 And we walk the talk.
00:06:15 We have policies that really want to put freedom and choice back into the hands of Ontarians.
00:06:20 and we have a party structure that is based on free votes and openness and transparency
00:06:26 that the mainstream parties just don't have.
00:06:29 Let's talk a little bit about that gap that we touched on a few moments ago
00:06:34 between the New Blue Party led by Jim Carajalios and the Ontario Party
00:06:38 because the New Blue Party, to its credit, was the first party to really form
00:06:44 in the wake of this dissatisfaction with Doug Ford and the PCs.
00:06:48 And Jim Carajalio is a longtime activist in Ontario politics, going back to when Patrick Brown was the leader.
00:06:54 He was the first to carve this out.
00:06:56 He's made a big point about how he's running a full slate of candidates for his party.
00:07:01 So the first there, why was an alternative needed?
00:07:04 Why did someone else need to come along?
00:07:07 Yeah, that's a good question.
00:07:09 You know, the Ontario Party actually existed before the new Blue Party.
00:07:13 They were founded in 2018.
00:07:14 They ran candidates actually in the 2018 election.
00:07:17 But you are correct in the sense that the New Blue, you know, sort of became the first popular party to sort of counter Doug Ford in the minds of many people.
00:07:30 What happened in behind the scenes is that there was a variety of people who were trying to bring unity to the freedom movement here in Ontario.
00:07:37 So there was Randy Hillier who wanted to have a party.
00:07:41 There was other people who wanted to run a party.
00:07:43 Roman Babber, for a time, I know, was thinking of starting his own provincial party.
00:07:48 That's right.
00:07:49 So there was a group of people that wanted to bring some unity to this.
00:07:52 And to sort of go back even further, the Carajalos team there has persistently sort of avoided attempts at unity.
00:08:03 So there was a chance early on to work with Randy Hillier and others in the spring of 2020.
00:08:10 and both Belinda or Jim basically said if I can't run this thing I don't want any part of it
00:08:16 and so that sort of turned Hillier and some other people off the the expectation that Randy Hillier
00:08:23 had was that there was going to be a party that they were going to to run together and to my
00:08:28 knowledge and Randy would have to confirm this but from what I understand Randy was blindsided
00:08:32 by the announcement of New Blue so there's been sort of a persistent you know going ahead that's
00:08:37 left other people behind in the starting of parties. I can tell you that personally, in my
00:08:42 experience with all this, I was involved with a group of people that was trying to bring
00:08:47 New Blue and Randy Hillier together. And those efforts failed in large part because of the
00:08:52 attacks that were made by New Blue against Randy Hillier. So at that point, many people decided
00:08:59 that there needs to be another option that can maybe bring these folks together. That's at the
00:09:04 time that I decided to take over leadership of the new blue or sorry, leadership of the Ontario
00:09:08 party at the beginning of, go ahead. So at the beginning of taking over the leadership of the
00:09:15 Ontario party, we worked immediately to try and unite factions here in Ontario. So we spent several
00:09:21 weeks speaking to Randy Hillier and his team, and we were at the table together. There was other
00:09:27 people involved, Bruce Party, David Haskell, other people that have had long experience in Ontario
00:09:32 politics, trying to create alternatives to the mainstream parties. Jim was invited to those
00:09:38 meetings. He declined to come. After Randy's movement sort of fizzled in the early weeks of
00:09:44 this year, January, and then the trucker convoy started and Randy turned his attention to the
00:09:49 convoy, we then began to reach out to New Blue directly. We tried multiple different angles,
00:09:55 obviously reaching out to them directly. Rick Nichols reached out to them directly. We even had
00:10:00 a party or a riding president in Durham by the name of Jack, who's a new blue riding president.
00:10:07 He met me at the trucker convoy and he said, hey, you're always talking about working together with
00:10:12 Jim. Would you actually meet? I said, I'd be happy to meet with Jim and his team, Jack and some of
00:10:18 his friends started trying to arrange a meeting between Jim and our team. So we actually had a
00:10:23 date scheduled. That date was Monday, March the 7th. And we were expecting to meet with Jim there.
00:10:31 We had a couple of our team members. We drove all the way into Port Perry from where I live.
00:10:36 And the night before the meeting, Jim sent an email to the people that were organizing it,
00:10:43 saying that he would not be attending because, and he listed a variety of reasons that were
00:10:47 frankly outrageous one reason was that he said that that i did not have authority to meet that
00:10:53 i didn't want to meet with him anyhow that i was uh you know under the control of um uh tanya
00:11:00 granick allen that i had a a secret deal with o'toole just a long list of outrageous accusations
00:11:06 but it was very clear to the tool just to interrupt there derrick o'toole being the
00:11:10 guy who kicked you out of caucus that's correct so he claimed that i had a secret deal with the
00:11:14 the person who you know threw me out of the party um all of this was uh you know thinly veiled
00:11:21 a letter to say i don't want to meet basically that's that's how everybody interpreted you know
00:11:25 i don't want to meet i have no interest in meeting meaning jim had no interest in meeting
00:11:30 so we showed up at this meeting and our team was there we had a great conversation with the other
00:11:33 new blue supporters but jim and belinda did not want to come the very morning the very morning
00:11:40 that we went early that morning we sent over the proposal that we were going to present to them so
00:11:46 we we had gotten whiff of the fact that they weren't going to be coming and so we said you
00:11:50 know what let's send the proposal that we were going to discuss so in that particular proposal
00:11:55 we outlined a way that we could work together um obviously a merger of the parties you know a
00:12:00 couple of months before an election would probably be challenging but we said listen let's try and
00:12:04 and work together as best as we can. So at the very least, we should have a non-compete clause
00:12:10 where we don't run candidates against leaders and prominent members of the party. So we committed to
00:12:16 not run a candidate against Belinda, for example, and we're sticking to that commitment. So we do
00:12:23 not currently have a candidate against Belinda. We said that we should continue that strategy as
00:12:28 wide as possible. So maybe it wouldn't be 100% possible to work together in
00:12:34 every riding but but at least many ridings we could so this was a proposal that we sent out
00:12:39 the email that they sent privately to uh the the to the group there that wanted to meet
00:12:47 basically said that they didn't even believe that we wanted to meet and that if we did really want
00:12:52 to meet we should send a proposal from our official email so we did in fact do that and
00:12:57 the proposal that you just showed on screen is that particular proposal um later publicly we
00:13:03 released that proposal and said, listen, guys, you've been asking us to work together. We've
00:13:07 been trying. And it was challenging, of course, because publicly, Jim and Belinda would say,
00:13:11 oh, yeah, we do want to work together. But then privately, they would be shutting down the
00:13:14 meetings we were trying to create. So we did, in fact, send the proposal publicly. And then
00:13:20 their public response basically said, no, this is a backroom deal. You know, we don't want to meet,
00:13:26 blah, blah, blah. And, you know, again, for anybody who's watching this, it's frustrating
00:13:31 because, you know, how do you meet with someone other than asking them to meet? I mean, it wasn't
00:13:35 a secret meeting. It was leader to leader. We could have publicized it. We weren't trying to
00:13:41 hide it. We just didn't want to, you know, preemptively publish anything that they didn't
00:13:47 want us to publish. But we would have been happy to meet with them publicly or privately. We still
00:13:52 would be. But unfortunately, not only did they decline the offer to meet, they began to up the
00:13:57 rhetoric of defamatory attacks. And they sent out a very outrageous publication that basically
00:14:06 slandered multiple people in the freedom movement. It slandered Tanya Granik-Allen. It slandered
00:14:11 myself. Of course, they've slandered Randy Hillier and others in the past. They've attacked
00:14:16 Rick Nichols, Tom Morazzo, many important people in the freedom movement. So it was very clear to
00:14:23 us that they had no interest in meeting. They've had multiple opportunities to do that, and they've
00:14:28 basically just responded with smears and attacks. On our part, the Ontario Party believes that
00:14:36 there's been enough destruction in the last two years to last us for a lifetime. So you're not
00:14:41 going to see us throwing mud at anybody. I don't think Jim and Belinda are part of some giant
00:14:47 conspiracy or something like that. But the fact is, is they certainly have been very challenging
00:14:52 to work with and I think there's a track record and a pattern of that and you know here in the
00:14:57 freedom movement we have to operate in good faith we have to operate uh in in ways that that unite
00:15:02 the movement and unfortunately I've seen the opposite from them um and they've and they've
00:15:08 made a lot of very uh you know aggressive allegations about myself that that frankly have
00:15:13 have zero basis in fact uh you know think everything from you know the generic sort of
00:15:19 i'm in a conspiracy with doug ford to specific things like um you know i've i've never registered
00:15:26 a federal party which is which is false you can go on the elections canada website the party is
00:15:31 there my name is attached to it you know they claim that i was raising all kinds of money in
00:15:35 alberta and then bringing it over here to to found the ontario party that's illegal that's that's
00:15:41 election fraud uh there's there's that would be a crime to do that of course that was never done
00:15:46 all of our uh uh you know elections returns were filed publicly you can't you know andrew you have
00:15:53 a a decent understanding of how political parties work you can't just put a hundred thousand dollars
00:15:58 into a political bank account you need that you need to know exactly no it frustrates candidates
00:16:03 immensely you've got to raise it you know individual amounts at a time no and and i just
00:16:07 just to interrupt here right because this has gone on a bit long and there's a lot of detail here and
00:16:11 And this is why I wanted to have both you and Jim on the show to talk about this, because I think this is an important issue.
00:16:17 And I think for a lot of people who are not as as ingratiated in the conservative movement, they're just wondering, who do I vote for?
00:16:25 It makes everyone look quite bad.
00:16:27 So I want to just I'm going to invite just for those watching, I'm going to invite Jim on to the show next week to to address some of this and other things as well.
00:16:36 Like I said, I wanted to do a debate.
00:16:38 They didn't want to do that.
00:16:39 That's their prerogative.
00:16:40 But let me ask specifically here about where the Ontario Party sits, because one thing I've noted is that you, both you and Jim, actually, were at the Freedom Convoy in Ottawa.
00:16:51 You have a couple of people that were very involved in the convoy that are running as candidates.
00:16:55 Tom Marazzo, who's been on this show, Bridget Belton, who was, you know, ultimately the one whose idea that the convoy was.
00:17:02 Is there enough support for the convoy, in your view, to build a party that you want to really make a dent in provincial politics?
00:17:10 Well, I certainly think that the Freedom Convoy was a monumental and important event. And many of the people, as you said, that, you know, pretty much all of the major players that are involved in politics now have chosen the Ontario Party. And I think for good reason. But, you know, we have to go broader than that. I think that we have to, you know, reach people on various issues. And I think the Trucker Convoy is one of them. But we have to be broader and bigger than just the Trucker Convoy as an issue.
00:17:39 let's talk about you because obviously you were and we spoke i think for the first time when you
00:17:44 were seeking the leadership of the conservative party of canada in 2020 uh you carried on as a
00:17:49 conservative mp were expelled from from caucus and in a way that i i think was very very
00:17:54 reprehensible and we i said as much on the show uh but then you went out to alberta and you were
00:17:59 founding a federal party and then you were seeking a seat as an independent in alberta and you were
00:18:04 talking to people there saying no you're an albertan now then that election's gone you're
00:18:08 You're back to Ontario running a provincial party.
00:18:10 So, I mean, how do you square the questions that voters are asking about where your loyalties lie?
00:18:15 Because a lot of it looks, frankly, very opportunistic.
00:18:18 Well, I'll tell you that when it comes to being an independent politician or, you know, somebody in a non-mainstream party, there's no glamour and there's no opportunity. 0.95
00:18:28 Frankly, it's from conventional standards, it's a fool's errand.
00:18:34 You know, parties like our, you know, independents in Ontario, I think two independents have
00:18:38 gotten elected in the last 70 years or something like that.
00:18:42 It's very challenging and it's been very, you know, challenging on my family, but it's
00:18:46 been also rewarding as well in the sense that we get to meet amazing people and fight for
00:18:50 values that we all hold.
00:18:53 With respect to, you know, with respect to going to Alberta and then coming back here,
00:18:58 Of course, I never, you know, never used the words I'm an Albertan now, you know, things like that. But I certainly the reason that we went out there is because we were in the midst of touring across the country to promote, you know, ending the lockdowns and the freedom issues.
00:19:16 And as you've stated, I did register a federal party.
00:19:19 The party was, in fact, approved a couple of months ago.
00:19:22 But it took Elections Canada months and months to approve it.
00:19:25 And, of course, it was not approved in time for the election.
00:19:30 Our original intention, having that party, was to run candidates in both the West and the East.
00:19:35 We wanted to have strong candidates in the West, strong candidates in the East.
00:19:40 And, you know, looking back, it's easy to see when the election was called, but nobody really knew exactly when it was going to be called.
00:19:46 There was rumors, but there's always rumors.
00:19:49 You know, the last two years, there's always rumors there's going to be an election.
00:19:52 So we were in the middle of a tour in Alberta when the election was called.
00:19:56 And we decided to be able to run some candidates in the East and the West.
00:20:02 Ultimately, my wife actually ran in the riding that I held.
00:20:05 And I ran in a Banff Airdrie in Alberta, which in fact was held by the conservative whip. And I was making a double point, one, you know, to kind of target the conservatives in their homeland, but also to make the point that, you know, that particular whip of the party was the person who was enforcing discipline and keeping so many conservative MPs quiet during one of the biggest crises we've ever had in this country.
00:20:29 But then why not continue building a federal party?
00:20:33 Why, when that didn't work out, do you jump into another party?
00:20:36 Yes, that's a very good question.
00:20:38 So after the election, our party had still not been approved.
00:20:41 So our party was only approved in February.
00:20:44 And I've always made the commitment to Canadians and the pledge to fight for freedom wherever I possibly can.
00:20:53 We all admit, or anybody who's in the freedom sphere admits, that we need to revitalize politics municipally, provincially, and federally.
00:21:01 So the Ontario election was the next election on the docket, so to speak.
00:21:06 You know, it's June 2nd, so only a couple of weeks away.
00:21:10 Initially, I had planned to basically support behind the scenes, you know, whatever party was available in Ontario.
00:21:17 So there was the New Blue Party.
00:21:19 Randy Hillier was talking about forming something.
00:21:21 so I had the intention of helping out one of those two parties and so I spoke a little bit
00:21:27 with Jim I spoke a little bit with Randy Hillier and I was involved with a group of people that
00:21:33 was trying to bring both of those two movements together and so multiple meetings were set up to
00:21:40 try and do so and you know frankly both both of those people but particularly Jim you know
00:21:46 sewered those meetings by going haywire against Randy Hillier. And he put out a litany of tweets
00:21:51 accusing Randy of, you know, some very horrible things, you know, basically being a fake and a
00:21:55 fraud. And that's, you know, that's not a nice thing to say. That's the worst thing you could
00:21:59 say about somebody in the freedom movement. So those meetings failed. And at that point,
00:22:06 the group of people that was trying to bring that together said, listen, they didn't expect
00:22:12 that randy would be able to get something off the ground in time for the election and that they were
00:22:17 correct in that and they also felt that that jim's behavior was was divisive and was creating
00:22:22 problems within the freedom movement so they thought by creating a new option or bringing a
00:22:27 new option to the table it might provide a way to bring people together and so that's what we
00:22:31 basically have attempted to do from the beginning of that so you know in terms of um in terms of my
00:22:38 you know uh career so to speak in politics i'm hoping to be effective wherever i can
00:22:43 and i and i felt that at this time in ontario i could provide a positive option for ontarians and
00:22:48 best case scenario bring some people together or work together or heal some rifts in the movement
00:22:53 and you know in some go on that derek do you have a plan then beyond this one election to
00:22:58 lead the ontario party so i don't believe in leader-centric parties i believe that parties
00:23:05 need to be able to outlive their leaders and not just be focused on a cult of personality.
00:23:10 I have, you know, I'm obviously planning on leading the party through this election,
00:23:16 but I don't plan on leading the party forever. And that's not saying that I'm, you know,
00:23:20 have a date that I'm going to step down or anything like that. But what we're trying to
00:23:23 do is build a movement that's not just based on a Jim or a Derek or whatever, but is an open party
00:23:29 that has democratic principles that can thrive and prosper. So that's what I'm going to be creating
00:23:35 here with the Ontario party. And that will outlive my tenure as leader. But I'm afraid that some of
00:23:42 the other- You're not ruling out. I mean, if there is an opening to lead an Alberta-focused
00:23:46 freedom party or go back into federal politics, that's not something that you're ruling out in
00:23:51 the next few years. Yeah. So all of those things are possible. I'm not saying that I have a
00:23:56 definitive plan to do those. I only, you know, whatever I choose to do, I do it with all my
00:24:01 heart. And right now I'm leading the Ontario party and I'm going to continue doing that with
00:24:05 all my heart until I feel that I will be better, of better use somewhere else. But no, I don't
00:24:12 think we should wed ourselves to any particular, you know, party for the rest of our lives. And
00:24:18 some of my concerns with some of the other freedom parties just generally in this country
00:24:22 is that they're doing a lot of good things, but they're really focused on kind of the leader and
00:24:27 a cult of personality. And we have to move beyond that. You mentioned earlier, I think quite
00:24:32 unfortunately accurately, that the non-establishment parties and candidates have a very rough go in
00:24:38 Canada and in Ontario specifically. What do you consider for an upstart party that doesn't have
00:24:43 any representation in the legislature that's been elected to the legislature? I know Rick Nichols
00:24:48 did join the Ontario party.
00:24:49 What do you consider a win
00:24:51 in this election on June 2nd?
00:24:54 Well, I think it would be very ideal
00:24:56 for us to win a bunch of seats.
00:24:59 And even though that would be challenging,
00:25:01 we're hoping that that could be a possibility.
00:25:03 It would be great to have a high vote percentage as well.
00:25:08 Already in some of the polls,
00:25:10 our party is basically in spitting distance
00:25:13 of the Green Party.
00:25:14 I'd love to blow right past the Green Party 0.82
00:25:16 and win a couple of seats.
00:25:18 Of course, we're not just fighting to win one seat, we're fighting to win the whole thing.
00:25:22 But as you and I both know, that would certainly be challenging.
00:25:27 Derek Sloan, leader of the Ontario Party.
00:25:29 Good to talk to you, Derek.
00:25:29 Thanks for coming on today.
00:25:31 Really glad to be here.
00:25:32 Thank you.
00:25:33 Thank you.
00:25:34 And again, like I said at the beginning, I'm going to, right after the show's done, send an email to The New Blue and invite Jim Carajalios to come on the show next week.
00:25:41 The reason I'm speaking to Derek now is because I invited the two of them, trying to have a debate between the two.
00:25:47 It wouldn't have been a formal, I wouldn't have been asking them about their Netflix preferences.
00:25:51 It wouldn't have been an Edmonton Conservative Party of Canada debate.
00:25:54 But I was going to have a discussion between the two, but New Blue declined.
00:25:57 So it just ended up being Derek that joined.
00:26:00 But I'm very glad he did.
00:26:02 And like I said, I mean, there's a lot happening in Conservative politics in general this week.
00:26:06 What happened last night in Alberta is quite significant, not just in the development and
00:26:11 landscape of Alberta politics, but also in, I think, the conservative movement, the lower case
00:26:17 C conservative movement more broadly. Just to bring you up to speed, here is the clip of Jason
00:26:22 Kenney announcing his forthcoming resignation. Friends, tonight the members of our party
00:26:29 completed a democratic exercise in accountability. The result is not what I hoped for or frankly
00:26:36 what I expected. But I've been clear from day one that I will respect the decision of the members
00:26:42 in this leadership review. And I expect all members of our party to do just that.
00:26:55 Friends, while 51 percent of the vote passes the constitutional threshold of a majority,
00:27:07 it clearly is not adequate support to continue on as leader.
00:27:11 And that is why tonight I have informed the president of the party of my intention to
00:27:16 step down as leader of the United Conservative Party.
00:27:21 I'm sorry, but friends, I truly believe that we need to move forward united.
00:27:26 We need to put the past behind us.
00:27:28 And our members, a large number of our members, have asked for an opportunity to clear the air through a leadership election.
00:27:35 And I recommended, therefore, that the provincial board schedule a leadership election in a timely fashion.
00:27:42 So as you heard there, the room itself seemed to be very pro-Kenny and very surprised that he was considering and contemplating stepping down.
00:27:51 And the reason I think in part, and I don't have the clip handy, but Jason Kenney, when he was on
00:27:55 this show, what was it, two or three weeks ago, said that he considered 50% plus one a win. He
00:28:01 said if he got that narrow, narrow, narrow margin of victory, just over 50%, he would consider that
00:28:07 the threshold at which he was able to remain the leader. And I said on the show then, and I've said
00:28:12 since that functionally, you do not get to do that without severely, severely, severely alienating
00:28:19 your party, because it means that some of those are not even that enthusiastic. They were just
00:28:23 like, yeah, I guess I'll vote for him. So if you have 50% plus one, or I think as he got 51.4%,
00:28:29 it really isn't a significant mandate to lead. And I think he understood that very quickly.
00:28:35 And I want to speak about Jason Kenney, because I know when I've had him on,
00:28:41 especially in the COVID era, I've had a lot of people reach out quite angry at me for not being
00:28:46 angry at him. They look at the lockdowns that he said would never happen, the vaccine passports he
00:28:51 said would never happen, the jailed pastors, and a litany of other things, which I am on side with
00:28:56 you in hating and condemning. And they want me to hate Jason Kenney. They want me to yell at Jason
00:29:02 Kenney. They want me to scream at him. And anything short of yelling at him is not good enough for
00:29:07 people. And I know that. And I probably have gotten more nasty emails about my interviews
00:29:13 with Jason Kenney than about anything else I've done in quite a while. And I understand
00:29:18 the frustration and I have put it to him. I mean, I'm not an angry person.
00:29:23 My goal in an interview, as I've always said, is I want to get an answer. Once I get an answer,
00:29:27 I'm not trying to convince the person I have on the line. I'm not trying to berate them or
00:29:31 punish them. I'm trying to put to them so people can hear the question, hear the answer and decide
00:29:36 for themselves. And I've always, always going back years in politics, had an appreciation
00:29:42 for Jason Kenney.
00:29:43 He's always been a principled conservative.
00:29:46 He's always been a tremendously hard worker,
00:29:48 a consummate professional.
00:29:50 And he's always made the time to come on this show.
00:29:52 I cannot tell you the last time.
00:29:54 In fact, I don't think it's ever happened
00:29:56 where I've requested an interview with Premier Kenney
00:29:59 and it has not happened at some point
00:30:01 within the next couple of months.
00:30:02 Now, I haven't abused that
00:30:03 and I haven't invited him on for a weekly segment
00:30:05 or a morning call every day or something like that.
00:30:08 But I've always asked
00:30:09 and sometimes it takes a little while to schedule,
00:30:11 but they've always said yes. That interview I did with him last week at the Canada Strong and
00:30:16 Free Networking Conference, that was set up on about 30 minutes notice just by reaching out.
00:30:21 I said, he's here. Will he do a sit down? And for all the frustrations I have about political
00:30:28 candidates, specifically conservatives who talk a big game about being annoyed with the mainstream
00:30:32 media, but don't actually make the time for independent media, Jason Kenney has never been
00:30:37 like that. Even when he knows that he is unpopular with the very people who watch this show,
00:30:43 he has taken the time to speak to the audience of this program. Now, has it won him any support?
00:30:49 Has it earned me any affection? I don't know. But he's done that. And I think it takes a tremendous
00:30:55 amount of self-confidence to do that. Maybe hubris to some people, but I think self-confidence
00:31:01 and self-assuredness. And the one thing I've never doubted about Jason Kenney is that he's
00:31:06 principled. And I think that he has served this country and I think he served his province
00:31:11 in a tremendously good way. Now, does this mean he has not done things that I find abhorrent and
00:31:18 his government has not done things that I find abhorrent? Absolutely not. And I'm a firm believer
00:31:24 in never defining people by their worst traits and their worst characteristics and their worst
00:31:29 decisions. I think people need to be decided on balance. I'm not an Albertan. It's not for me to
00:31:33 say whether he should stay or go. And I don't know for sure if he is going. One of the interesting
00:31:38 things I would point out here about Jason Kenney is that he hasn't actually said when he's going
00:31:44 to step down. There's some speculation. And I don't know, I've been on air for the last half
00:31:48 hour. I don't know if it's changed then. Some speculation he could run for the leadership
00:31:52 of the UCP. He could actually end up replacing himself, depending on what happens in the next
00:31:57 few weeks and months. The party has about a year until the next election. I think it's like May
00:32:02 well it's may something in in 2023 so there's about a year to go until albertans are going
00:32:08 back to the polls who knows stranger things have happened jason kenny could be on the ballot
00:32:12 then but whatever issues i've had with him and i i've called a spade a spade when they have arisen
00:32:19 i i think he is a very decent person and a very good leader and unfortunately that good leadership
00:32:26 didn't manage to hold in his own caucus.
00:32:30 And that was a big thing.
00:32:32 I think that one of his great failings,
00:32:34 just as an outsider looking in,
00:32:36 was his inability to manage his caucus.
00:32:39 And I don't mean manage in the sense of control.
00:32:42 I mean, manage in the sense of make sure
00:32:43 that people in his caucus feel included
00:32:46 and feel heard and feel listened to.
00:32:48 I mean, the UCP allows more dissent in caucus
00:32:51 than a lot of other parties do generally.
00:32:53 I mean, Doug Ford, he was kicking out people.
00:32:55 I think on average, he kicked out like one and a half MPPs a year from the PC caucus.
00:32:59 If you take a look at all the independents that were stepping aside just before this
00:33:04 election compared to people that were in the PC caucus after the last election, whereas
00:33:08 Jason Kenney, he had people in his caucus that were tweeting for him to resign and they
00:33:12 still remained in his caucus.
00:33:13 So I mean, part of that is that he didn't want to take a heavy handed approach to these
00:33:17 people and then have more pop up in their place.
00:33:20 But the reason I'm bringing all of this up is just to say, do not let your hatred, do
00:33:27 not let your hatred cloud what is a very distinguished career that has lasted many years.
00:33:33 And yeah, I'm going to say to Jason Kenney, thank you for your service.
00:33:38 Whatever happened in the last few years, however it ended, thank you for your service.
00:33:41 I don't think people should be defined by their worst traits and their worst characteristics.
00:33:45 But I do think, looking at the bigger picture here, we are in the midst of a tremendous reckoning in the conservative movement right now.
00:33:52 You look at Pierre Paliève, who is, I think, very much reshaping the traditional conservative coalition.
00:33:59 He's trying to do what Maxime Bernier and the PPC did in the last election, which is appeal to people who genuinely feel left behind by the establishment, left behind by Canadian politics.
00:34:10 And I hate Trump comparisons because I find them so lazy, but it is similar, I guess I'm doing this, but it's not lazy now. It's similar to Trump in that Trump did not win because he had conventional Republican support. He won because he moved the base and he changed the rules of the game and he changed the playing field entirely to something else.
00:34:31 Pierre Polyev is doing that in his rallies.
00:34:33 Now, Jean Charest, to his credit, is doing something in the opposite way.
00:34:38 He's still trying to reshape the boundaries, but he's also trying to avoid the conservative
00:34:44 base in a way that Pierre Polyev is not.
00:34:46 Pierre is leaning into the conservative base.
00:34:48 Jean Charest is trying to talk to all these other people saying, listen, the only way
00:34:51 we're going to win is if you have a guy like me in the running, if you have a guy like
00:34:54 me leading the party.
00:34:55 But we time and time again go back to this question of what conservative politics is supposed to be and what the conservative movement is supposed to be.
00:35:06 And I want to play a couple of clips for you here.
00:35:08 These are just impromptu interviews I did when I was in Edmonton last week covering the conservative leadership race.
00:35:14 The first is with Drew Barnes.
00:35:16 Now, Drew is one of those MLAs who was kicked out of the UCP caucus by Jason Kenney.
00:35:22 And Drew was a very outspoken advocate for independence in Alberta, an advocate speaking out against lockdown and evidently had a little bit too much independence for Jason Kenney's liking.
00:35:33 Here's my chat with Drew.
00:35:36 Let's start with the elephant in the room here. You were kicked out of the United Conservative Party caucus.
00:35:41 Here you are at a Conservative Party of Canada leadership debate.
00:35:44 Do I take from that that you haven't thrown in the towel on the established Conservative parties in this country?
00:35:48 Well, the UCP, of course, the big data in the UCP is May 18th, the vote on Jason Kenney's failed leadership.
00:35:55 We all saw how he twisted and turned and took away members in Albertans' chance to vote.
00:36:00 So the UCP, that's a big separate problem.
00:36:03 But the Conservative Party of Canada, of course, is the closest opportunity we have here in Alberta, in Cyprus Medicine Hat,
00:36:10 to having meaningful power and meaningful legislation to get some economic freedom and some individual opportunity.
00:36:16 So I'm grateful that these people, again, are going across Canada and expressing their ideas.
00:36:23 I'm hoping tonight, though, to hear what's in it for Alberta.
00:36:27 Who's going to break that sacred cow of equalization?
00:36:30 Who is going to give us fairness when it comes to the Supreme Court of Canada,
00:36:35 representation in the House of Commons, and the Senate?
00:36:38 I want to hear some talk about that and some meaningful action.
00:36:40 So, and yeah, I mean, my constituents, I was grateful to be on the Fair Deal panel two years ago.
00:36:47 It's 80% of Albertans that are demanding from Ottawa a fair deal, one shape or another.
00:36:52 And I hope I'll hear some of that tonight.
00:36:55 Obviously, candidates have generally come out in favour of oil, in favour of pipelines, against Justin Trudeau's handling of it.
00:37:01 I think a lot of times people mistake having a solid energy policy with having a solid Western Canada policy when the two aren't synonymous.
00:37:08 There are other concerns in the West.
00:37:10 I haven't heard them brought up in the leadership race so far,
00:37:13 and we don't have any candidates that are from the West.
00:37:15 I know Pierre Polyev was born out here, but doesn't represent here.
00:37:18 So do you think it is possible to have a really Western Canadian-focused platform
00:37:23 from any of these candidates and then from the party moving forward?
00:37:26 Well, I'd say it's to their detriment, and it's at their risk if they don't.
00:37:30 We saw PPC do fairly well last time.
00:37:33 Maverick Party didn't do as well, but had a lot of good candidates.
00:37:36 so there's a lot of there's a lot of good solid Albertans and Westerners that
00:37:41 are stepping up to demand fairness to demand a greater voice in our country
00:37:44 or or other consequences of course in my fair deal panel dissenting report one
00:37:50 of the things I said is we should have a independence referendum down the road
00:37:54 give Ottawa two or three years to give us a fair deal and then let Albertans
00:37:57 hold Ottawa accountable to whether or not they've done that so my being here
00:38:01 tonight is part of that to see what's in it in it in it for Alberta the oil and
00:38:06 gas thing is amazing. You know, we see that even though it wasn't a great huge amount in terms of
00:38:11 the world, 100 million barrels of oil used per day, the fact that Canada was buying some oil
00:38:16 from Russia, the fact that America was buying, I think it was almost a million barrels a day from
00:38:20 Russia, and the fact that, you know, the governor of Michigan almost ended energy security for Canada,
00:38:26 and the fact that we all know the hypocrisy. If we could get a northern gateway or the
00:38:32 Trans Mountain Pipeline twinned the getting more of our good oil and gas to to Asia would be the
00:38:38 best thing to improve air quality in the world and and how that hypocrisy continues is beyond me
00:38:43 so uh yeah let's uh you know let's see some some real action hey maybe tonight they'll talk about
00:38:48 Trudeau saying he's going to appeal the uh appeal court of Alberta's decision that that constitutional
00:38:53 overreach on the no more pipelines uh the the uh Emissions Accountability Act uh yeah let's let's
00:38:59 stay focused on a strong Canada but that comes from a strong Alberta. And just lastly if Jason
00:39:05 Kenney is not successful in his leadership review and that party goes through a reckoning would you
00:39:10 want to be welcomed back into the UCP? I'm certainly going to weigh all my options. I've
00:39:15 been talking to a lot of my UCP colleagues, past colleagues this week. We've gone for a lot of
00:39:20 walks, lunches and coffees and yeah there's a lot of similar values there. There's a lot of people
00:39:25 that share the same frustrations as I do,
00:39:27 even though they weren't ejected from caucus.
00:39:30 But Andrew, let's be clear.
00:39:31 If Jason Kenney isn't gone on the 18th,
00:39:34 the chances of it being Premier Rachel Notley next time are so high,
00:39:37 and the chances of devastation for Alberta and our next generation
00:39:41 is very, very high.
00:39:43 Everywhere I go, Premier Kenney,
00:39:45 people tell me it's time for Premier Kenney to go.
00:39:47 He got 55% of Albertans voting for him last time.
00:39:51 Now he's unlikely to get 55% of his own club,
00:39:53 his own members voting for him.
00:39:55 It is so time for him to do the right thing and get out of the way and give other Albertans a chance to make Alberta the freest and most prosperous place in Canada.
00:40:03 Thank you.
00:40:04 Now, that was recorded a week and one day ago, and it ended up proving rather prescient from MLA Drew Barnes,
00:40:11 although he was tight-lipped on whether he would be the one who would jump up and actually seek the leadership himself or try to rejoin the party.
00:40:20 This morning, Danielle Smith had a press conference in which she spoke about her bid to replace Jason Kenney as UCP leader.
00:40:26 You also have Brian Jean.
00:40:28 And again, like I said earlier, you have the federal conservative leadership race going on as well.
00:40:32 Also at that debate in Edmonton, I ran into Andrew Scheer, who is a former leader of the Conservative Party of Canada himself.
00:40:39 Now, he's backing, I should say, Pierre Polyev here.
00:40:42 So he's not a neutral arbiter in this race.
00:40:45 But we did speak a little bit about the importance of conservatism in conservative politics,
00:40:51 which shouldn't sound like a radical concept, but I think it's one that needs restating every now and then.
00:41:00 Andrew, you've done this before, the leadership debate.
00:41:03 Now, you had, I think, a lot harder because you were up against like 12 other candidates when you ran in 2017.
00:41:09 But realistically, when you are in a leadership race and you're appealing to Conservative members,
00:41:15 not necessarily Canadians as a whole, how do you approach this without alienating yourselves
00:41:19 from the Canadians whose votes you're going to be seeking later on?
00:41:22 Well, you know, the key is to be who you are and be authentic.
00:41:26 And that's what I did when I was leader.
00:41:27 And I was very pleased to see Pierre do that tonight.
00:41:31 And one of the great things about Pierre is he's been saying the same things his entire life.
00:41:35 You know, when he was a university student, he was writing essays about making Canada the freest country in the world.
00:41:42 And he was doing that his entire career as a member of Parliament.
00:41:45 And that's what we heard again tonight.
00:41:47 So it's important in a leadership race that you are honest, you're up front,
00:41:51 and that people believe that you're going to do what you say you will.
00:41:55 And that's something that is incredibly important when Conservative members are thinking about who to cast their ballot for,
00:42:01 who will actually do the things that they're saying they will do during this race.
00:42:05 and Pierre has that advantage over the other candidates.
00:42:09 You and I spoke when you were about to depart
00:42:11 as leader of the Conservative Party of Canada
00:42:13 and you had said something that stuck with me
00:42:15 about how you wished you had pulled some more punches
00:42:18 or not pulled punches, I guess, and been a bit more yourself.
00:42:21 What's your advice to whoever is the next leader
00:42:23 on how they can stay grounded
00:42:25 when you have all of the consultants and campaigners
00:42:27 and polling data and all of that in your ear
00:42:29 that is kind of trying to push you in a different direction?
00:42:32 Well, you know, at the end of the day,
00:42:35 Advice is good to listen to, to consider,
00:42:37 but you can't find yourself in a position where you're just in a,
00:42:41 you're completely a fabrication of something, you know,
00:42:44 and a lot of people give advice, you know, don't pick a fight on this,
00:42:48 don't pick a fight on that, but Canadians want to see contrast.
00:42:51 Our members want to see contrast.
00:42:53 Our members want to see how you're going to be able to handle yourself
00:42:55 in a general election campaign.
00:42:57 You know, there's some people complaining about some of the exchanges
00:43:00 in this leadership race.
00:43:01 Believe me, this is tame compared to what the liberal war machine is going to do to the next leader.
00:43:07 It's tame compared to what the corporate media is going to do.
00:43:11 You know, all the media outlets that are subsidized by Justin Trudeau are going to be a lot tougher on the next conservative leader than the people up on stage here tonight.
00:43:20 So I think it's important for Keynes and our members to see who can handle themselves under pressure with that kind of sparring back and forth.
00:43:28 And I actually enjoy that contrast.
00:43:30 Elections are about contrast, about differences.
00:43:33 We've got leaders who are advocating for some policies,
00:43:36 and we've got others advocating.
00:43:38 That's the nature of a debate.
00:43:39 So I'm glad to see some of that coming out in this leadership campaign.
00:43:43 You know the story better than anyone else.
00:43:46 The media tends to go to the same old bag of tricks.
00:43:48 Even when you have candidates that are very much pro-choice,
00:43:51 they're still asking about abortion and stuff like that.
00:43:53 So how do you keep the big tent together?
00:43:55 And I know you're supporting Pierre Polyev,
00:43:57 so let's say that your candidate wins.
00:43:58 How does Pierre Polyev keep the so-called Big Blue Ten together, keep the social conservatives happy, keep the red Tories, the libertarians, keep all of that together,
00:44:06 while also making it so that people feel like they have a place and they're getting some policies on offer?
00:44:11 Yeah, well, this is a critical component to it.
00:44:14 Party unity doesn't happen just because the leader runs around yelling at people to stay united.
00:44:20 We've seen that with other conservative leaders at different times at different levels.
00:44:24 And the key is to engage with all the different types of conservatives in our coalition and find that common ground.
00:44:31 And one of the reasons why I decided to endorse Pierre was because of his message about uniting around freedom.
00:44:38 I think that's very important.
00:44:39 I know that's very important, that you can have a difference of opinion.
00:44:42 You know, I might think one thing, you might think another.
00:44:44 But if we have a government that's going to give us the freedom to disagree and live our own lives
00:44:49 and make our own decisions with ourselves or our family, then we can agree on that.
00:44:53 And we can both live out our life the way we want to.
00:44:56 And so that's the way to do it, is to find that area of common ground
00:45:00 and treat all those people with respect.
00:45:03 And that's something that I know many people in our party are looking for
00:45:06 in the next leader to say, okay, I just want to make sure my voice is heard,
00:45:09 that when I get up at a convention, when my member of parliament speaks
00:45:13 in the House of Commons, that they're not going to be punished
00:45:15 because they have a different view than the leader may have.
00:45:19 Thank you.
00:45:19 Thank you very much.
00:45:20 that was former Conservative Party of Canada leader Andrew Scheer caught up with him in
00:45:26 Edmonton as well I believe he's on the debate prep team for Pierre Polyev if memory serves I
00:45:31 couldn't actually tell you where I learned that from but I'm pretty sure someone told me maybe
00:45:34 it was Andrew maybe it was someone else who knows I don't think I made it up I try not to do that
00:45:39 on the show but nevertheless thanks very much to all of you for tuning in that does it for today
00:45:43 but just one plug before we go if you missed yesterday's program I'll tell you again I am
00:45:48 off on actually today's thursday so tomorrow tomorrow i am off to davos switzerland for the
00:45:54 world economic forum's annual meeting i am going to be there to cover it no don't worry i'm not
00:46:00 selling out i'm not joining uh klaus schwab's global anti-capitalist organization i'm going
00:46:05 because i want to separate conspiracy theory and all of the people that dismiss it all as conspiracy
00:46:11 theory from the reality in their own words in their own thoughts in their own programming and
00:46:16 planning, their own agenda, what it is they seek to do globally and in a number of countries like
00:46:22 Canada, whose Deputy Prime Minister, Chrystia Freeland, sits on the advisory board. And that's
00:46:27 the whole point here. This is not about capitulating to conspiracy theory. It's about
00:46:31 shining a light on an organization that if you take it at its word, take it at face value,
00:46:37 wants to do drastic and in some cases, draconian things to free market economics and to capitalism
00:46:44 and basically to the global order as we know it.
00:46:49 And this is not about one guy
00:46:51 sitting in the Swiss mountains pulling the strings.
00:46:53 It's about bringing all of these leaders together
00:46:56 who seem to be buying into a lot of these things.
00:46:59 I mean, the book that I'm reading right now by Klaus Schwab
00:47:01 is his latest work called The Great Narrative.
00:47:04 And I'll have more on this next week
00:47:05 as we see the conference shape up.
00:47:07 But I've had a lot of people that have reached out to me
00:47:09 since I announced on the previous show that I was going
00:47:12 that have said, you know, we'll be praying for you,
00:47:14 best of luck. I'm really pulling for you. So thank you for that. It is truly important. And
00:47:18 I think it's important to be there and cover this because I can't tell, I could not tell you the
00:47:22 last time, if ever, an independent journalist has gone into the lion's den like this to report on
00:47:28 what's happening there. And like I've said, I don't even know what my coverage is going to look
00:47:31 like yet. I know they don't want me there. I know I'm a little bit crafty though. I'm not going to
00:47:35 break any laws, but I am going to try to ask some people some questions and really figure out what's
00:47:40 going on there and I still have not been able to learn who the Canadian delegation is going to be
00:47:44 so if the government won't give me the list I might have to just walk around and look for
00:47:48 you look Canadian you look Canadian you yeah okay yeah you look Canadian all right who are you and
00:47:52 what are you doing here so that'll be coming up next week so do stay tuned on that and truly if
00:47:56 you want to pitch in and support our coverage you can do that by going to donate.tnc.news
00:48:03 donate.tnc.news and you can jip in a few bucks as you're able to and we will absolutely
00:48:09 absolutely be so appreciative of that. I know I will as we head out on this. It'll be a bit of
00:48:14 an adventure, but I'm looking forward to it. So with that, we will talk to you soon. I'm going
00:48:17 to have another show tomorrow. I'm trying to pack them in this week before I head away,
00:48:21 so don't miss that, but we'll talk to you soon. Thank you, God bless, and good day to you all.
00:48:28 Thanks for listening to The Andrew Lawton Show.
00:48:30 Support the program by donating to True North at www.tnc.news.
00:48:39 We'll be right back.
00:49:09 We'll be right back.