Juno News - January 26, 2019


John McCallum has gone and blown it

Mentioned
The True North Report: Alleged human smuggler charged by border officials Justin Trudeau's carbon tax goes on trial this year

Episode Stats


Length

3 minutes

Words per minute

187.56

Word count

577

Sentence count

55


Summary

Summaries generated with gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ .

John McCallum's explanation for why he misspoke about Meng Wanzhou's case in a press conference, and why it matters to the Prime Minister, and the Chinese government's response to it, raises the question of whether he was actually doing the PM's bidding, or was he going rogue?

Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 Hey guys, is anybody out there buying John McCallum's explanation, his walk back, whatever
00:00:10 he wants to call it, where he says he misspoke the other day in that press conference?
00:00:14 This was not a misspeak.
00:00:16 A misspeak is what you do when you, oh I don't know, you just say the wrong word or so forth,
00:00:20 you say an off-the-cuff remark, you put out a tweet without really thinking about it.
00:00:24 This was a press conference, a prearranged one, where they invited Chinese language media
00:00:29 only in Markham, the city north of GTA.
00:00:32 They did not invite English language media.
00:00:34 English language media were floored by it, CBC, CTV, everyone else waking up in the morning
00:00:38 saying, what on earth just happened?
00:00:40 And he sits down and he gives a long speech, he gives a long statement where he adds three
00:00:46 arguments for why he thinks Meng Wanzhou has a good case to fight the extradition.
00:00:52 You misspoke.
00:00:53 You had to plan this.
00:00:55 You had to sit down.
00:00:56 You had to say, well what are my arguments going to be?
00:00:58 How am I going to articulate them?
00:01:00 You write them down.
00:01:01 You send out the invitation.
00:01:03 Give us a break.
00:01:04 So we got a problem here because Prime Minister Justin Trudeau said two things.
00:01:07 He's been asked, do you agree with this?
00:01:09 And Christy Freeland was asked as well.
00:01:11 And they just turn around and they say, well rule of law matters and will prevail in Canada.
00:01:15 Yeah, that's not what you were asked.
00:01:16 They dodged the question.
00:01:18 Then they were asked, will you fire John McCallum?
00:01:20 He said, no, not going to happen.
00:01:22 Let's not get distracted by this.
00:01:23 This is not a distraction.
00:01:26 John McCallum, who was an MP and was a cabinet minister, is now a diplomat.
00:01:30 He is a public servant.
00:01:32 He serves the Prime Minister.
00:01:34 Diplomats do not create public policy.
00:01:36 So the whole question becomes, was he in fact doing the Prime Minister's bidding?
00:01:41 And we don't know because the Prime Minister has not denied it.
00:01:43 He hasn't confirmed it, but he hasn't denied it.
00:01:46 Or was he going rogue?
00:01:48 And if he was going rogue, why do you keep him on?
00:01:51 Why don't you fire him, given the message this has sent?
00:01:55 More likely, Trudeau likes that there are two messages sent out there.
00:01:59 One where they're saying, don't worry, United States, our largest trading partner.
00:02:03 We got your back.
00:02:04 We're doing the extradition.
00:02:05 And the other, to the Chinese language media, to the guys in Beijing, oh, don't worry.
00:02:10 This is just a minor thing.
00:02:11 It more involves the US than us.
00:02:12 We'll work it through.
00:02:14 And then, as John McCallum said in that press conference, this is just a minor obstacle
00:02:19 that we will get over and then we will work towards a closer relationship in the future.
00:02:24 Time out.
00:02:25 People don't want a closer relationship with China right now.
00:02:28 Yes, we've got to do some degree of trade.
00:02:30 Yes, we've got to do some diplomacy with them.
00:02:32 But this is a reset right now.
00:02:34 A lot of people are opening their eyes to how the Chinese government operates.
00:02:39 Does Justin Trudeau see it that way?
00:02:41 Is he also welcoming of a reset?
00:02:43 And if he's not welcoming of a reset, what does he want with our China policy?
00:02:48 And that is what Canadians need to be told.
00:02:50 Of course, did you need to be told?