Juno News - December 14, 2023


Jordan Peterson offers to take over as Harvard president

Topics
Mentioned
Canada endorses UN pledge to phase out oil and gas Is Justin Trudeau compromised by the CCP? | Investigative journalist Sam Cooper

Episode Stats


Length

39 minutes

Words per minute

176.33

Word count

6,946

Sentence count

235

Harmful content

Misogyny

2

sentences flagged

Toxicity

2

sentences flagged

Hate speech

3

sentences flagged


Summary

Summaries generated with gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ .

As we close out another week in irreverence, host Andrew Lawton is joined by Jordan Peterson and Professor Tom Flanagan to discuss a variety of topics, including Jordan Peterson's new book, "Grave Error" and Harvard University President, Claudine Gay, who has been accused of anti-Semitism.

Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Topics generated with Qwen2.5-3B-Instruct.
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 Transcription by CastingWords
00:00:30 Thank you.
00:01:00 welcome to canada's most irreverent talk show this is the andrew lawton show brought to you by true
00:01:20 north hello and welcome to you all canada's most irreverent talk show here thursday december 14
00:01:31 2023 as we close out another week in irreverence that is the goal to which we strive every now and
00:01:38 then someone will come up and say i am insufficiently irreverent to claim the title
00:01:43 of canada's most irreverent talk show but there are two answers to that number one irreverence
00:01:47 is in the eye of the beholder. And number two, I have yet to encounter anyone else who has made
00:01:52 a claim to be Canada's most irreverent talk show. So I am self-identifying like all those guys that
00:01:58 want to use tampons in the men's washroom at the parliament buildings, which is apparently this
00:02:05 great public service that we were in need of and didn't even know it. So I am self-identifying as
00:02:10 irreverent unless someone wants to come along and challenge me for the title. We can have a
00:02:14 a Hamiltonian-Burian duel on some battlefield if we need to sort things out there.
00:02:21 Nevertheless, it is wonderful to have you aboard the show.
00:02:23 We're going to be talking a little bit later on about online pornography,
00:02:26 which will either tantalize you or turn you away in disgust.
00:02:30 We are not going to be showing any of it, which will either disappoint you or delight you.
00:02:34 So I'll let you decide for yourself on that one.
00:02:37 Also going to be speaking later on with Professor Tom Flanagan about his new book, Grave Error,
00:02:43 which is a phenomenally I would say controversial book and and subversive book on an issue that I
00:02:50 know True North folks in True North Nation out there have been paying attention to but much of
00:02:55 the mainstream media has not at least not in this way so that we'll chat about with Dr. Flanagan
00:03:00 later on in the program but I want to begin by kind of exploding something that was meant as a
00:03:06 bit of a joke but might actually have merit here Jordan Peterson who you may have heard of he's
00:03:12 made a couple of headlines in the last couple of years he i interviewed i haven't had him on this
00:03:16 show but i i had him on my former show for like a whole hour and we talked about anything and
00:03:21 everything under the sun and i've met him a number of times he's always been a big supporter of true
00:03:26 north and the work that we do here he's got some best-selling authors he has just announced that in
00:03:31 february march and into april he's like touring basically every major and mid-level city in the
00:03:38 united states jordan peterson is doing and if his previous tours are any indication these will all
00:03:43 sell out but he is willing to give it all up jordan peterson is willing to give up the touring
00:03:50 give up the aggressive media schedule maybe give up the podcast even to take one particular job
00:03:56 that admittedly has not yet been offered to him but maybe we can start a bit of a campaign
00:04:01 to draft jordan peterson that job is president of harvard university now harvard is the
00:04:08 A school in the Ivy League that is synonymous with excellence to a lot of people, but has, as of late, become synonymous with anti-Semitism.
00:04:17 And the thing that's interesting about this is that so far there's no vacancy.
00:04:21 The president is not resigning, and that's Claudine Gay, that's her name, and so far the school is not prepared to get rid of her.
00:04:29 Now, she's had a bit of a one-two punch of controversies as of late.
00:04:33 First, there was her unwillingness to condemn in unequivocal terms that genocide and calls for genocide violate Harvard's anti-bullying policy.
00:04:45 There was this rather awkward exchange between her and Republican Congresswoman Elise Stefanik you may have caught last week in the House of Representatives and one of its committees.
00:04:55 Take a look.
00:04:56 Dr. Gay, at Harvard, does calling for
00:05:00 the genocide of Jews violate Harvard's rules of bullying and harassment, yes or no? 0.95
00:05:06 It can be, depending on the context.
00:05:09 What's the context?
00:05:11 Targeted as an individual, targeted at an individual.
00:05:14 It's targeted at Jewish students, Jewish individuals.
00:05:18 Do you understand your testimony is dehumanizing them?
00:05:21 Do you understand that dehumanization is part of anti-Semitism?
00:05:27 I will ask you one more time.
00:05:30 Does calling for the genocide of Jews
00:05:32 violate Harvard's rules of bullying and harassment?
00:05:35 Yes or no?
00:05:38 Anti-Semitic rhetoric when it crosses into conduct
00:05:41 anti-Semitic rhetoric when it crosses into conduct
00:05:45 that amounts to bullying, harassment, intimidation,
00:05:49 that is actionable conduct.
00:05:51 we do take action so the answer is yes that calling for the genocide of jews violates harvard
00:05:58 code of conduct correct again it depends on the context it does not depend on the context
00:06:06 the answer is yes and this is why you should resign these are unacceptable answers across the board
00:06:14 i must say i don't love the showmanship of american congressional committees i think
00:06:18 think it's oftentimes more powerful to let people sink themselves with their own words than to do
00:06:23 this feigned outrage like congresswoman Stefanik was ask a question you don't need to cut her off 0.98
00:06:28 and ask again because you know her answer is going to be more damning than your question is going to
00:06:32 be in this case but what type of conduct is it that has become the norm at Harvard well here's
00:06:38 us one example we plucked out for you. I forgot how short that clip was. I was looking at the
00:06:55 other monitor. No word on if that violates Harvard's anti-bullying policy, but that was
00:07:00 just the one of the one-two punch. A few days ago, some independent journalists, Christopher Rufo and
00:07:05 And Chris Brunette found out that there are very serious plagiarism challenges that can
00:07:10 be leveled against Claudine Gay's doctoral work, her dissertation, which eventually gave
00:07:15 her a PhD, which eventually propelled her into her career in academia that led to her
00:07:19 being the president of Harvard.
00:07:21 And they found that she has lifted a number of passages without attribution, which in
00:07:26 a couple of cases, the authors of the plagiarized work have said, yeah, this pretty much looks
00:07:31 like garden variety plagiarism.
00:07:33 But even so, she has not announced she's going to step down.
00:07:37 Now, this is where Jordan Peterson comes in.
00:07:39 Jordan Peterson had this rather cheeky post on X this morning.
00:07:45 Excuse me, Harvard, if you're looking for a new candidate for president with a proven academic track record,
00:07:52 a now international reputation, and the ability to stand up to the bloody narcissist of the woke mob,
00:07:58 I know someone who might be interested just saying and then to punctuate it he put a colon
00:08:05 and a clothing parentheses which I believe is a smiley face emoticon as the kids say it's not an
00:08:12 emoji this is a very important distinction an emoticon is like the original the emoji
00:08:16 is the colorized versions of it so there's your history and the development of online
00:08:21 shorthands for your emotions which maybe I should do a dissertation in that I can be like Claudine
00:08:26 Gay, and I can just copy and paste it from other folks. But Jordan Peterson's having a bit of a
00:08:31 lark here. I don't think he's pursuing this, although he has tried to, in the past, launch
00:08:35 things like the Peterson Academy. And for a time, there was a Jordan Peterson-inspired MBA program
00:08:41 at, I believe, the University of Austin. It was a university in Texas. But nevertheless,
00:08:47 what's interesting here is that Jordan Peterson is exposing in his little joke that Harvard is
00:08:54 not interested in pushing back against the mob. And this is the serious point underlying Harvard's
00:09:00 defense of anti-Semitism on its campus, is that they're saying, well, yes, we have academic freedom,
00:09:05 we have free speech, this is all important. And I say, absolutely, yes, I support their right to be
00:09:10 like that. But Harvard is very inconsistent about this, as are most universities. If you want to go
00:09:16 on campus and say, I believe that a male can be a female, they're going to say, well, I don't know
00:09:22 if you have academic freedom to say that, but if you want to get up there and talk about genocide
00:09:26 in this context, they want to shroud themselves in freedom. And I think this is where it gets
00:09:32 to be very important about applying these rules consistently. So whether or not he is actually
00:09:38 auditioning for the job, I don't know, but I thought it was a nice cheeky way to raise attention
00:09:43 to the fact that currently the status quo there is not working. I wanted to pivot back into Canadian
00:09:49 politics for a few moments here. There was this bill that was advanced by the House of Commons
00:09:55 and sent off to committee yesterday that has not gotten a huge amount of coverage. And part of the
00:10:01 reason is that this is a Senate private members bill. Now, these are not often pieces of legislation
00:10:06 that get passed. But in this particular case, we see enough support in the House of Commons to at
00:10:11 least move it so far. It's already passed the Senate, which is why it's in the House. If you
00:10:16 are trying to keep track at home of the numbers. It is a bill. Oh, now I forget the bill. It's a
00:10:20 Senate bill S210, I want to say. But basically what this bill does is strive to restrict access
00:10:28 to minors, to young people, to online pornography. Now, let me first and foremost say I wholeheartedly
00:10:37 agree with what the bill is trying to accomplish. I think that online porn is tremendously harmful
00:10:43 when you're talking about the implications on young people.
00:10:45 I know it's very accessible.
00:10:47 And there have been studies after studies after studies
00:10:50 that have shown that young people, children,
00:10:52 I mean, in some cases as young as like six, seven years old,
00:10:55 are accessing just absolutely horrendous and vicious things
00:11:00 that become part of their perception
00:11:04 and conceptualization of what sex and sexual expression are.
00:11:08 I'm talking about violence.
00:11:09 I'm talking about sex acts that most adults
00:11:12 who have been engaged in sex for much of their lives
00:11:16 would not even know exist.
00:11:18 And this is something that we see happening.
00:11:20 So the idea of preventing children from accessing that,
00:11:24 I agree with wholeheartedly.
00:11:26 The question becomes, how do you do it?
00:11:29 Now, what this bill would do if passed
00:11:31 is create a regulatory environment
00:11:34 where you need to provide proof of your age
00:11:37 if you want to get on a website
00:11:39 that is offering sexually explicit material.
00:11:42 proof of age. Now, does that mean like when you want to go to a website, oh, I just have to say
00:11:47 my birth date is, you know, January 1st, 1901 and click okay. And that's that. Or does it mean
00:11:52 something that is more comprehensive? They want something more comprehensive, like for example,
00:11:57 uploading your identification. Now, this to me is where you get into the very glaring issue here
00:12:05 with this. Now the conservatives, the NDP, the Bloc Québécois, they were all supporting this.
00:12:09 It was most liberals that said no, and then the conservatives kind of just started being
00:12:13 very outraged about, oh, how dare the liberals vote against this?
00:12:16 Now, why the liberals vote against it, I don't know.
00:12:19 But suffice it to say, I do not believe their approach is from the same place that mine
00:12:24 is, which is that I concede there is a harm.
00:12:26 I agree that harm needs to be dealt with, but I don't believe that this is going to
00:12:31 create the solution that people think.
00:12:36 So why this is so very important is because right now we have two aims that are kind of
00:12:41 working against each other. One is that we should not have excessive government regulation on the
00:12:46 internet. The other is that we should actually try to protect children from the harm of pornography.
00:12:50 Now, listen, I'm not making a judgment of people's personal tastes here. I think that
00:12:56 people as adults can do what they want. This is where my inner libertarian comes out
00:13:00 from a legal perspective. And if we want to pass all these moral judgments, that's something we
00:13:04 get to do as individuals and as a society. Not that I'm encouraging being judgmental, but
00:13:09 we can typify what is right and what is wrong on our own without government being the one to make
00:13:16 that call. Now, why I think this is so important for us to understand here is that if the government
00:13:24 is going to do this, force these companies, one of the biggest porn companies in the world is a
00:13:29 Canadian company, MindGeek, which owns Pornhub and some related sites, one of the things that
00:13:34 government will be doing is forcing them to do this age verification process. So on the surface,
00:13:41 there are going to be people that say, well, hang on, I don't want to have to upload my driver's
00:13:44 license to this, you know, porn company here and all the privacy implications that come along with
00:13:51 that. Well, some folks in the computer science space say you can deal with this without having
00:13:56 those privacy issues so i wanted to delve into that a little bit joining me on the line now is
00:14:02 as far adib who is a doctoral candidate in electrical and computer engineering at concordia
00:14:08 university uh it's good to have you as far thank you for joining me
00:14:14 thank you so much andrew for the invitation it's great to be here so the obvious issue here is that
00:14:20 people i think have a right to protect their privacy and if if you want to engage as an adult
00:14:25 watching online pornography the idea of having to provide identification of having to prove who you
00:14:31 are kind of erodes that fundamental relationship people think they have with the internet so
00:14:36 how can this be done in a way that protects individual privacy if it can yeah that's a great
00:14:44 question so right now what we usually do we use our id documents to verify our age for example
00:14:51 here in Canada we have our driving license our passport or maybe our health card so the current
00:14:58 way is if we need to prove that we are adults then we have to take a picture of the ID or we
00:15:05 have to scan it and there are some third-party softwares which do the verification and then
00:15:11 then they say this okay this guy is above 18 or maybe they are not so which is something that's
00:15:16 being used all over the world now privacy concern is when we are sharing our it document we are
00:15:22 sharing a lot of information about us so that's a big privacy concern so that's why we are proposing
00:15:28 some alternatives which we call biometrics that means something from our body which tells our age
00:15:34 for example uh some social media they have tested instagram uh i mean the egg checking on instagram
00:15:41 using facial image so you just sit in front of a webcam you let them take a picture of yours
00:15:47 and using artificial intelligence they can tell whether you're an adult or not so this is considered
00:15:53 more privacy assuring because we don't need to share our id documents and consequently uh like
00:15:58 i am doing my phd research at concorde in montreal we are working with hard signals which can tell
00:16:03 our edge and also there are some other technologies so in summary id document is an option the other
00:16:09 option is using biometrics which comes from our body and which is our page i i think this raises
00:16:15 though another issue i i don't not to be too graphic here but someone who's about to access
00:16:19 a pornography site i don't think the thing they want is for that website to be taking a picture 0.61
00:16:24 of them in that moment yeah it is this is really a hard call so it's up to the user they have to
00:16:31 decide do they want to share their id or they do do they want to allow to take their image in either
00:16:37 way they have to tell something about themselves and that's why we know there are other opinions
00:16:43 about this bill but as you rightly said andrew this bill is very important to protect our kids
00:16:49 because in last 10 years child sexual abuse have increased over 800 percent here in canada
00:16:55 and we still see this stories just two weeks ago we saw a story of a boy of 12 years committed
00:17:00 suicide because he was a victim of sextortion we know about amanda 13 bc who took her life 10 years
00:17:06 back and she was a victim of sextortion as well so we need to put it our case and that's why we
00:17:11 have to make some compromise so we are working with different technological options and it's
00:17:16 up to us whichever we take now i know there are options here i mean as it's worded now in this
00:17:21 bill that's making its way through parliament government could force websites to do this now
00:17:26 would the expectation be that each website has its own way of doing this or would there be a natural
00:17:33 third party that would emerge that websites would use that kind of does this that people may
00:17:38 trust like for example paypal is a an example where you know if you're a website instead of
00:17:43 just taking the credit cards yourself you could just say well you know paypal you trust paypal
00:17:47 you can use them and they'll pay us yeah exactly so ideally this is done by a third party there
00:17:54 are different companies who offer this service we can have a look at what uk are doing uk has
00:18:00 doing done a very good job in terms of online protection just recently they had their online
00:18:04 safety bill so they have their own regulator who is looking after these things so similarly here
00:18:10 in canada we need someone it can be crt someone else to take up that responsibility to make a
00:18:15 common platform where this edge verification will take place and as you rightly said andrew
00:18:21 whatever technology we bring people will be concerned about their data and we need to assure
00:18:26 them that this data remain protected it is not being used for any other purpose that's why we
00:18:31 need a centralized server which takes the data which ensures that this data is not used by anyone
00:18:37 else except for edge verification and we can integrate some third-party software to do the job
00:18:42 for us now so that obviously people the best systems out there are vulnerable i mean just
00:18:50 today in my city for example the the library's website has been subject to a massive cyber
00:18:55 attack and is inaccessible so one idea that you mentioned in an op-ed i read from you is that
00:19:00 there's a system in which the data can never be saved at all like it could basically be assessed
00:19:06 and deleted immediately but is that as as transparent as it sounds or does it live in
00:19:13 some way in a way that theoretically some hacker could access yeah ijd the law requires you to just
00:19:21 to check the age and maybe keep the data for a certain time it can be for one minute or two minutes
00:19:26 and then the data has to be deleted that's what the law requires but as you again rightly said
00:19:32 uh yes there are always duples in the technology and there are ways to bridge the data so we need
00:19:38 to give our best try so i was again i can mention about the uk example or about the european example
00:19:44 they have the gpdr there which is the privacy protection law which is pretty strong and
00:19:49 whenever there is a breach the consequences are very harsh so we have to work in both ways in
00:19:54 technically we have to make sure that yes we have this technology which can do the verification and
00:19:59 delete the data in one or two minutes or in a very new time frame and on the legal side if there is
00:20:04 any kind of breach we need to make sure that the companies are accountable it might be a hard call
00:20:10 because not everything is hosted here in canada obviously we have the big social media companies
00:20:15 a lot of websites who are not legally accountable here but still we have to put our best try to make
00:20:20 them accountable so that's what we need to keep trying well it's certainly an interesting topic
00:20:25 and i i think there are there are a lot of questions that people can have and should have
00:20:29 about uh the regulatory side about privacy rights but understanding the technology i think is crucial
00:20:35 to that so your uh insights have been very helpful on this as far adib from concordia university
00:20:40 Thank you very much. And I hope you'll be able to testify before a committee when this gets
00:20:44 further through. Yeah, I hope, son. Thank you so much for having me. Have a very good day.
00:20:48 All right. Thank you very much, Asfar. And look, I mean, I think his points there that he's raised
00:20:53 are useful. And I know that some of the words will trip the radars of the privacy minded when
00:20:59 he talks about central server and biometrics and all of that. But I think that's important,
00:21:03 because if you are supporting this legislation, I think you need to realize what it is that is
00:21:09 involved in this process. And look, I'm so sympathetic to the problem. And I cannot stress
00:21:16 that enough. I'm so sympathetic to wanting to keep children, vulnerable people away from materials
00:21:22 that they are not supposed to be accessing. But again, I also am very aware of the fact that
00:21:29 conservatives have spent the last few years railing against the CRTC expanding its regulatory control
00:21:35 over the internet so to all of a sudden wake up and say well we want the CRTC to regulate online
00:21:41 porn not just for Canadian content which we know is going to be coming so people are going to be
00:21:46 doing unspeakable things to their poutine once C11 is implemented on these websites but not just
00:21:52 regulating Canadian content but regulating access and making these websites collect information
00:21:59 about users, not just minors, but information about people who are, you know, 30, 40, 50,
00:22:06 that for whatever reason, they want to kick back and enjoy the latest. And the thing that I find
00:22:11 so fascinating about this conversation is that we're assuming that kids who are seeking this
00:22:17 out will not find ways around it. And this is, I think, where we go to any parent who's tried to
00:22:24 set up some you know parental controls on their internet surely has a false sense of security
00:22:29 about that kids are smart kids outsmart technology kids will find ways to work around it they'll go
00:22:34 to websites that are unregulated they'll uh send stuff around in whatsapp groups i mean it'll be
00:22:39 like the equivalent of i guess passing around that same magazine that you know your older brother
00:22:43 picked up or something like that in school but they will find a way to do it now does that result
00:22:48 in a net benefit if it's still harder to come across. Maybe, maybe it does. But I think the
00:22:54 problem that we run into here is that we are looking to government to be the answer. Whereas
00:23:00 on this issue and so many others, I want to look at parents and say parents should be very forthright
00:23:08 in having conversations with their children. Parents should be very aware of what their
00:23:13 children are doing. We should be focusing on the education here. And I don't trust right now the
00:23:18 public schools to, uh, do this. I don't trust the public schools for reasons we've talked about in
00:23:23 the last few months. Uh, one person in, in the chat says that biometrics is more invasive than
00:23:29 ID. Yeah. I mean, that was the thing. Like originally when age verification came up,
00:23:33 I'm thinking of like some poor guy that has to lay, or, or woman, you know, it's an equal
00:23:37 opportunity that has to go and like scan their driver's license and, you know, upload it to
00:23:41 Pornhub. And, uh, all of a sudden there's now some database of, Oh, uh, you know, John Smith
00:23:46 of 123 Maple Street loves, well, use your imagination of what John Smith of 123 Maple
00:23:52 Street loves, but that's the thing. And then, yeah, biometrics is even worse. So now John Smith
00:23:57 just has to like stare at his webcam while he's waiting for the video to load. And this is exactly,
00:24:03 I mean, if it's an awkward, uncomfortable topic, it should be. We're talking about people's very
00:24:07 intimate desires and practices and habits here and government trying to regulate those and force
00:24:13 companies that, let's be real, I do not trust. I do not trust your average purveyor of pornography
00:24:20 online to be the diligent protectors of your privacy, because these are companies that have
00:24:26 turned a blind eye to the sharing of non-consensual sexual images. These are companies that have
00:24:31 turned a blind eye to child pornography on their platforms, companies that have no sense of the
00:24:38 harm they are causing to society and childhood development. So no, I do not look at them and
00:24:44 trust them to make these decisions. So we'll follow this as it proceeds. This is where the
00:24:50 libertarian in me and the social conservative in me kind of have a fight about this. I'm hoping to
00:24:54 get my friend Jonathan Van Maron, with whom I have had many fights about this subject and related
00:24:59 ones on in the future, although he wasn't available today. We're going to be talking in a few moments
00:25:04 time with Dr. Tom Flanagan. But before we get there, I learned recently, and by recently I mean
00:25:11 like two and a half hours ago, it was like vaguely in my subconscious, so maybe I like saw it at one
00:25:17 point before, that they're making a Law & Order Toronto. Like this is not a joke. They're making,
00:25:24 put up the poster there. It's going to be coming to City TV in 2024. There we go. Law & Order
00:25:29 Toronto criminal intent. And what kind of refreshed this was I saw this morning, a friend of mine in
00:25:36 Toronto had stumbled upon a set where they were filming Law and Order Toronto. And it was, you
00:25:40 know, we're filming here, everyone be quiet, yada, yada, yada. And I was just thinking of what that
00:25:45 would look like. And I realized just how it would be such a horrendously boring show, because someone
00:25:49 would get stabbed on the subway in the first scene. And then for the rest of the episode, people would
00:25:54 just be waiting for police to show up and they never do. And then at the end, it would just be
00:25:58 to be continued. And the episode is just, you know, will the police come or are they going to
00:26:02 be too busy doing other things? And then I was sort of thinking about Law and Order Toronto a
00:26:06 little bit more and what that would look like. And I realized that we could do this as the most
00:26:12 inexpensive production possible, because in Canada, you don't actually need to cast multiple
00:26:17 actors to be different criminals. You could run the whole series on just one criminal who commits
00:26:23 a crime and then is released on bail at the end of the episode. And then he commits another crime
00:26:27 at the beginning of the next episode and is released on bail.
00:26:29 So you can actually just get by with just having one single offender
00:26:33 and that would make it more like a documentary than a scripted drama.
00:26:37 So I don't know if that's what the producers are doing,
00:26:39 but that would be my recommendation on this.
00:26:42 I had one person who had replied and said,
00:26:45 no, no, no, you're all wrong, Andrew.
00:26:46 The show is just going to be about police going around
00:26:49 banging on people's doors because their tweet was a little bit racist.
00:26:52 So as soon as I heard that, I felt like, oh my goodness,
00:26:55 that's probably going to be the more accurate account of what's been happening here. So let
00:27:00 me know what you think Law & Order Toronto is going to... Oh no, I did the Toronto. You're
00:27:07 supposed to say Toronto. I never pronounced the second T. I apologize to the people of Toronto
00:27:12 for mispronouncing your name. Although lately, now they've changed Dundas. So Dundas, who is this
00:27:22 a very positive figure in history that you may be familiar with he's the the guy i mean there's
00:27:26 a town in ontario named dundas we have uh dundas young dundas square we have the dundas subway
00:27:32 station there the city of toronto did this massive inquiry over like the last three years
00:27:38 to effectively rename anything with dundas in it and they realized it was going to cost a
00:27:43 bajillion dollars and be so disruptive and all of that and now what they've done
00:27:48 is they've decided to okay we won't change everything we'll just change some of the main
00:27:55 things so what they what they're agreeing on now is that they're going to change young dundas square
00:27:59 and they're going to change any ttc station that has dundas in it which i think is like two or
00:28:05 three of them uh they're renaming uh young dundas square sankofa sankofa square now the hilarious
00:28:14 thing is, this is a word, I don't know the language of Ghana. I don't know if it's Ghanese
00:28:19 or Ghanaian. I apologize for not being an expert on African linguistics, but it's apparently a word
00:28:25 that originates in Ghana. And what the word means is the act of reflecting on and reclaiming
00:28:33 teachings from the past, which enable us to move forward together. So they're saying that this word
00:28:40 is about reclaiming teachings from the past while purging the name of this historic figure,
00:28:47 who, by the way, has not even done the things that he's been accused of, of just being some, 0.86
00:28:51 you know, racist, Haiti, Haiti, hate monger. But they're trying to like put a heritage spin on
00:28:56 this. And it's like, if you've ever been to Edmonton, Edmonton used to have municipal ward
00:28:59 councils that were numbered one, two, three, four, five, six, and all that, like in every other city.
00:29:05 and a couple of years back they changed all the municipal wards to indigenous words and you'd look
00:29:13 at them now and you have people that are being elected in wards that they cannot pronounce like
00:29:17 i you know i could run in dene because i can say dene but you've got others that are like
00:29:21 i i'll get canceled if i try to pronounce them but i look at them and it's like you know 17
00:29:26 letters and no vowels in it and i'm all for people you know being able to pronounce foreign
00:29:31 languages and learn foreign languages and all of that. But this is when we just take the
00:29:36 reconciliation narrative a little bit too far that it starts getting in the way of practicality. And
00:29:42 that's effectively where we have gone to with this. And I think it's why the discussion about
00:29:48 the residential schools narrative is such an important one, because this is an issue in which
00:29:54 the, it all started with to Kamloops First Nation in British Columbia, they come out
00:29:59 with a very damning allegation, the discovery of unmarked graves of hundreds of children on
00:30:06 the site of the former residential school. Now, you compound this with a media that loves the
00:30:11 spicy narrative, with a country that generally speaking does not know its own history all that
00:30:17 well, and you had this narrative that took hold that was pushed by the New York Times, by CBC,
00:30:21 by CTV, that there had been mass graves discovered, that hundreds and hundreds of children
00:30:26 had been murdered at residential schools.
00:30:29 And look, I participated on a radio panel
00:30:31 where the host who clearly was not familiar
00:30:33 with the story and what was even being alleged
00:30:37 made this claim when that was never even
00:30:40 what the people of De Kamloops were saying.
00:30:42 But it started a bit of a trend
00:30:44 and other First Nations started to announce
00:30:46 these discoveries themselves.
00:30:48 We heard things that were being discussed
00:30:49 that no one really knew like ground penetrating radar,
00:30:52 which sounds like it's very precise,
00:30:54 but in reality just detects abnormalities in the ground that could be remains of a human that could
00:31:00 be nothing of the sort there have been excavations that have been done at some of these schools
00:31:06 and they have not turned up anything resembling bodies where there was a site that did have
00:31:11 bodies it was an established graveyard that was used to bury both indigenous and non-indigenous
00:31:17 people so this is not to say that nothing bad has happened at residential schools is to say
00:31:22 that we need to have a level of historic context and understanding when we engage in a very hot
00:31:28 button issue but this became an incredibly potent one politically it's why the flag of canada the
00:31:35 national flag was at half mast on public buildings for i think it was well over six months and it
00:31:39 became literally a news story midway through the campaign when conservative leader erin o'toole in
00:31:46 in 2021 says, yes, we should fly the Canadian flag at full mass. And that, I mean, again,
00:31:52 the idea that someone wanting to be prime minister says, yes, we should fly the Canadian flag and not
00:31:56 keep it at half mass indefinitely. That doesn't sound like it's supposed to be newsworthy,
00:32:01 but it was because that was the context in 2020 and 2021 that Justin Trudeau had set up,
00:32:08 that Canada was a country we should be ashamed of, not proud of, that Canada's history was something
00:32:13 we should run away from and condemn
00:32:15 instead of celebrating and building upon.
00:32:19 And that I think is why as a country,
00:32:22 understanding history is so important.
00:32:24 I don't know if I have the book in my stack back there.
00:32:27 I probably do, but I don't want you to like
00:32:28 have to just look at my back for some prolonged time
00:32:31 while I try to find it.
00:32:32 But Mark Milkey's book, The 1867 Project,
00:32:35 which was published by the Aristotle Foundation,
00:32:37 did a great job at bringing in a range of people,
00:32:40 including some from the political left,
00:32:42 to talk about Canada and its history.
00:32:45 And we had new Canadians, lifelong Canadians,
00:32:48 lefties, right-wingers that were all saying,
00:32:51 yeah, there's something about this country
00:32:52 that we need to celebrate and honor and respect.
00:32:57 And that to me is what we should be striving towards.
00:33:01 And we're waiting for Tom Flanagan,
00:33:02 who's been a very big purveyor
00:33:04 of historic understanding for years,
00:33:06 but he's also the co-editor alongside CP Champion
00:33:09 of a new book, which True North actually co-published
00:33:13 along with the Dorchester Review called Grave Error.
00:33:16 And it's a collection of essays
00:33:18 that does some of these very things that we're discussing.
00:33:21 I should share the subtitle too,
00:33:22 Grave Error, How the Medium Has Led Us 0.95
00:33:24 and the Truth About Residential Schools.
00:33:27 And there's a forward in there by Conrad Black,
00:33:29 who, by the way, if you have not read Conrad's book,
00:33:33 The Canadian Manifesto, I would encourage you to do it.
00:33:37 It was a very short read.
00:33:38 And it was not particularly expensive.
00:33:39 But it was a book that gave just this condensed and really accurate and compelling account of Canadian history.
00:33:49 And it was published by my publisher, Sutherland House, and it came out a couple of years ago.
00:33:54 And it was definitely one that I would encourage you to take a look at.
00:33:57 So if you're looking for a last minute stalking stuffer for someone who hates Canada, you can give them both Grave Error and Canadian Manifesto and hopefully bring them back on board here.
00:34:06 But why I think this is an interesting story is because it's not just a story of a country that does not know or care about or like its history, but it's also about a media that has that same approach and that same attitude, but also a bit more of an arrogance in how it tells these stories.
00:34:24 And I mean, there were a lot of journalists that I think were very afraid because of the political sensibilities around this to ask any questions.
00:34:32 And, you know, there were some very awkward encounters between some journalists and some indigenous people that were involved in making these announcements.
00:34:40 And you'd see it. And journalists were very, very nervous and very apprehensive about getting involved because they didn't want to be seen as racist.
00:34:50 They didn't want to be seen as not respecting their truth because we live in an era now in
00:34:55 which truth is subjective. And I've grappled with the residential school issue because you can't
00:35:02 have a nuanced conversation about it. I will not defend the residential schools program. I think
00:35:07 it's a tremendous shame that we forced assimilation on people that did not want it. But that's also
00:35:13 a small subset of the complexities around this issue. One is that the attitudes of time periods
00:35:21 evolve and change. There are many things we do even, I mean, look, I'm convinced that in five
00:35:25 years we'll be in a country in which people will look at vaccine mandates differently than they did
00:35:29 in 2021. We, with history, evolve and grow and we realize, okay, maybe we were well-intentioned at
00:35:35 the time, but didn't do the thing that we should have. But the other part that people often forget
00:35:41 is how many indigenous families saw this as being a positive for their children. Yes, there were 0.99
00:35:47 children that were snatched away from their families, but there were also families that
00:35:51 very much wanted their children to have a British education, to be steeped in the religious values
00:35:56 of the day, the English language and all of that. And the other part that's often very confused is
00:36:02 that the residential schools of the 19th century were not the same as the residential schools of
00:36:08 the 1990s. These things evolved as schools did in general. So when people say, and these residential
00:36:13 schools were around until 1990, yes, they were. But we're not talking about the same dynamics that
00:36:19 were happening and the same trends that were happening in the 19th century, the very heinous
00:36:24 aspects of this that carried through up until just effectively 30 some odd years ago. And it was
00:36:30 interesting. I was reading back on a bit of more recent political history on this because you
00:36:34 recall in 2008, Stephen Harper gave his very infamous apology in the House of Commons to
00:36:41 victims and survivors of residential schools. And one of the things that came about through this
00:36:47 was that there was also a payout program. It was called the Common Experience Payout. And it was
00:36:53 a program that had been agreed to by the Liberal government previously, and the Conservatives
00:36:58 decided not to rock the boat on, which gave every single victim and survivor of the residential 0.91
00:37:06 schools a payout for having gone through that, irrespective of what their experience was. And it
00:37:12 was deemed simpler to do that than to adjudicate. Now, there were additions where if you had
00:37:18 been sexually abused, you'd get more money. And if you'd been physically abused, you'd get more.
00:37:22 But there was basically a baseline there where everyone was getting access to this. And
00:37:27 it was very contentious. And even among conservative members of parliament, there were
00:37:31 some that are saying, well, hang on, I don't want to accept this premise here that everything was
00:37:36 this one way. Anytime a conservative politician has spoken up about this, like that Senator Lynn
00:37:42 Bayak, for example, it has proven to be very controversial. She was kicked out of caucus
00:37:48 with that. So I think we might be having some technical issues with Tom Flanagan. So we'll
00:37:54 have to reschedule that. But it is a book that has been very well reviewed so far. And I think
00:37:59 you can still get it on Amazon in time for Christmas. It's called Grave Error. So hopefully
00:38:04 you'll be able to take a look at that, how the media misled us and the truth about residential
00:38:09 schools. Thankfully, I had like a ready-made rant on this subject anyway. So it wasn't hopefully
00:38:13 too, too bad to, to fill the time there, but that does it for me for today. We will be back
00:38:18 next week with more of Canada's most irreverent talk show as the countdown to Christmas continues
00:38:23 here on true north thank you god bless and good day to you all thanks for listening to
00:38:28 the andrew lawton show support the program by donating to true north at www.tnc.news
00:38:53 We'll be right back.