Juno News - February 21, 2024


Justin Trudeau's "hate speech" ban is coming

Mentioned
Trudeau could balance the budget – so why doesn’t he? Independent MP considering run for Tories

Episode Stats


Length

44 minutes

Words per minute

166.98

Word count

7,409

Sentence count

242

Harmful content

Misogyny

6

sentences flagged

Toxicity

2

sentences flagged

Hate speech

9

sentences flagged


Summary

Summaries generated with gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ .

In this episode of The Andrew Lawton Show, host Andrew Lawton talks about the importance of resisting the Liberal government's proposed ban on online hate speech, and why he thinks the government should be allowed to protect free speech.

Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 Transcription by CastingWords
00:00:30 Thank you.
00:01:00 welcome to canada's most irreverent talk show this is the andrew lawton show brought to you by true
00:01:20 north hello and welcome to you all canada's most irreverent talk show here the andrew lawton show
00:01:30 on true north midway through the week although it's like the first day of the week i've been
00:01:35 doing a show so uh you'll understand why tomorrow yesterday we were it was a combination of things
00:01:41 but i was recording an interview which we're using for the show tomorrow and we just weren't
00:01:47 able to make it work with being able to be in a studio in one place and one time and we were
00:01:51 coming off a long weekend and I'm making excuses here but we'll try to make up for it in what time
00:01:56 we have left in the abbreviated post family day week I hope you had a good long weekend
00:02:02 I had a busy morning I was in Kitchener Ontario for a press conference that conservative leader
00:02:08 Pierre Polyev was holding and man oh man did a lot of well personal person you can't say man oh
00:02:15 man anymore it's a hate crime uh personal person did a lot of news come out of this press conference
00:02:20 we got uh pierre polyev saying that we need to protect women's only spaces we had pierre polyev
00:02:26 saying we need to mandate age for people viewing online porn we had pierre polyev talking about
00:02:32 what i am going to be spending the first bit of the show talking about which is the importance
00:02:36 of resisting the liberal government's uh incoming ban on online so-called hate speech now you'll
00:02:44 know why I do the air quotes there because oftentimes when you talk about this topic you'll
00:02:48 say you'll hear people say well hate speech isn't free speech and I'd say well free speech is free
00:02:52 speech and the issue is always in how you define these things because what the liberals often want
00:02:59 to call hate speech is speech that may be unpleasant or unkind but is still part of what
00:03:05 you should be allowed to say and think in a free society but the liberals don't believe that they
00:03:10 are not actually minded to embrace a free society, certainly when you're discussing the idea of
00:03:16 speech and of controversial or contentious opinions, which is why they've been so eager,
00:03:22 enthusiastic to regulate what you can say online. This has always been for me the hill to die on.
00:03:29 It has to be. Free speech is so important. It is the speech that you need to defend and uphold and
00:03:35 protect all other rights and freedoms. That is what free speech is. And the thing about it is
00:03:40 that the Liberals tried this in 2021. They introduced a bill that would have regulated and
00:03:45 banned so-called online hate speech. It would have lowered the threshold that exists under the
00:03:49 current criminal law for hate speech, which has a very, very high bar and needs to have a high bar.
00:03:55 And they have promised this omnibus online harms bill. This bill is going to do a number of things.
00:04:01 The bill is going to talk about pornography, it's going to talk about terrorism content,
00:04:06 it's going to talk about hate speech, and they do this all in one place.
00:04:10 So that if you criticize the bill because you don't like the implications on censorship,
00:04:15 they can turn around and say, you must be comfortable with terrorist content,
00:04:19 or you must be comfortable with child porn.
00:04:21 This is what they do.
00:04:22 So I think we need to unpack this bill when we see it.
00:04:25 It's going to be coming in the next few weeks, but there were some media reports,
00:04:29 some leaks from the Liberals that share some details that are likely to be in that bill and
00:04:34 there has been all but confirmation on this that the bill is going to go after that online hate
00:04:39 speech issue now to give you a brief history on this there used to be in the Canadian Human Rights
00:04:45 Code or the Canadian Human Rights Act rather a prohibition on communicating hate speech online
00:04:52 it was called section 13 of the Canadian Human Rights Act it was used to prosecute
00:04:56 Under the human rights regime, bloggers, people like my late friend Kathy Shadle,
00:05:01 faced complaints under this, and it had very direct implications on free speech
00:05:06 because it was a bill that licensed government censorship.
00:05:08 It licensed sanctioned by the state if you say unpopular or unkind things online.
00:05:14 So the liberals in their previous attempts to bring this back had a supercharged version of this
00:05:20 where not only did they reinstate Section 13 and have this ban on online, again, hate speech,
00:05:26 but they also included mechanisms to force social media companies to take action against this. So
00:05:33 all of a sudden, the government is deputizing Facebook and Twitter to be the censors of what
00:05:39 it believes is, again, so-called hate speech. So with this news that came out this morning,
00:05:45 I asked Conservative leader Pierre Pauliev at the press conference if the Conservatives
00:05:50 would stand opposed to this ban when it comes in.
00:05:54 And he gave a long, long answer, which is good
00:05:58 because I think it had a lot of material in there
00:05:59 that we can work with.
00:06:01 But I just wanted to warn you in advance,
00:06:02 this is like a three and a half minute clip
00:06:04 because once you've asked the question,
00:06:05 he basically can do what he wants.
00:06:07 But this was what Pierre Polyev said.
00:06:09 Well, I think you get to hear my question as well.
00:06:11 But this was my question
00:06:12 and Pierre Polyev's response from this morning.
00:06:15 Morning, Mr. Polyev, Andrew Lawton, True North.
00:06:18 The federal government has said that its online harms bill is imminent.
00:06:23 They've said this bill will include, among other things, a ban on so-called online hate speech.
00:06:28 As you know, the Conservatives a decade ago repealed Section 13 of the Canadian Human Rights Act,
00:06:33 which the Liberals have talked about reintroducing and tried in the last parliamentary term.
00:06:38 Will the Conservatives oppose the reintroduction of these provisions
00:06:42 and the Liberals' approach to so-called online hate speech?
00:06:46 Yes.
00:06:48 We will oppose Justin Trudeau's latest attack on freedom of expression.
00:06:54 And I want to ask, what does Justin Trudeau mean when he says the word hate speech?
00:07:04 He means speech he hates.
00:07:08 So, for example, let's go through some of the things he said is hate speech. 0.54
00:07:12 Jerry Butts, the PMO puppet master, said that it was hate speech to criticize Trudeau for using the ridiculous term people kind, right?
00:07:25 Justin Trudeau said anyone who criticized him during the pandemic was engaging in hate speech.
00:07:33 Basically, anybody who disagrees with his radical agenda when it comes to kids, he says it's hate speech.
00:07:42 He attacked Muslim parents who were protesting against his agenda.
00:07:46 Is he going to criminalize those Muslim parents for protecting their children in schools?
00:07:53 Go down the list of things that Justin Trudeau disapproves of,
00:07:58 and you can imagine all of the things that will be criminalized.
00:08:03 Then there becomes the question of who is going to be in charge of determining what is hate speech.
00:08:09 recently a school board in Ontario banned Anne Frank's books okay so would that be considered
00:08:18 hate speech under Justin Trudeau's woke authoritarian agenda I think it would
00:08:24 so anyone who thinks that speech they don't like is going to be criminalized and therefore
00:08:32 the bill should be supported go through that those people should go through the list of their
00:08:37 own thoughts that Justin Trudeau considers to be unacceptable views, and you can assume that he
00:08:44 will ban all of that as well. And finally, I point out the irony that someone who spent the first
00:08:53 half of his adult life as a practicing racist who dressed up in hideous racist costumes so many
00:09:02 times he says he can't remember them all should then be the arbiter on what constitutes hate
00:09:09 why doesn't he what he should actually do is look into his own heart and ask himself why he was such
00:09:17 a hateful racist for despite his enormous personal privileges of a multi-million dollar trust fund
00:09:24 being the son of a prime minister growing up in mansions traveling the world why he had so much 0.96
00:09:29 hate in his art that he was such an awful racist and what he should do is actually explain where
00:09:36 that ugliness came from and maybe in that way rather than through coercion he could help us
00:09:44 all in the fight against real hate thank you man where where do you even start on an answer like
00:09:52 that he talks about justin trudeau being a racist he says justin trudeau is a woke authoritarian he
00:09:58 says Justin Trudeau cannot be the arbiter of what you can say or do online. We even got a Jerry
00:10:04 Butts reference there because Jerry Butts likes to take aim at opinions and expressions he doesn't
00:10:09 like online. So there was a lot there. I mean, the core policy was an unequivocal one that the
00:10:13 Conservatives will oppose this bill. The Conservatives will oppose the reinstitution
00:10:19 of Section 13 of the Canadian Human Rights Act and in general, the Liberal government's efforts
00:10:24 to rein in online speech. Now, this is crucial. I mentioned at the outset of this show, and I've
00:10:31 mentioned time and time again, that free speech is my hill to die on. And, you know, it's been said,
00:10:37 and it's not an original thought on my part, that the reason free speech is so important is because
00:10:41 if every other freedom were stripped away and you were left with only that one, you could then use
00:10:47 that freedom to argue and fight for your other freedoms. It's the one that if you don't have,
00:10:51 you have nothing. What is democratic freedom if you don't have the right to speak
00:10:55 about politics and about the political process? What right is, I mean, basically, what good are
00:11:01 a lot of the rights and freedoms if you don't have the right to have your own expressions and
00:11:06 by extension, your own thoughts? Because when you regulate speech, you are regulating thinking.
00:11:11 And again, you have to pull yourself out of the mindset here of, well, I don't like hate speech.
00:11:17 No one likes hate speech. No one likes the idea of it. But I bet if I were to grab five of you
00:11:23 and say, what is hate speech? You're going to have wildly different beliefs on what it is.
00:11:29 I'll give you an example. Twitter, before Elon Musk purchased it, used to say that dead naming
00:11:36 someone fell under its hate speech policy, which is to say that if I one day say I'm actually
00:11:42 transgender, you must call me Andrea Lawton. Don't picture it. It's not going to be pretty. 1.00
00:11:46 If you call me Andrew, that could be under Twitter's terms of service as hate speech.
00:11:52 Now, that was not the law.
00:11:53 Twitter can decide for itself how it wants to govern its affairs.
00:11:56 But at the time, that was one interpretation of what hate speech was.
00:12:00 Using someone's former name, the name by which you may have known them for many, many years,
00:12:04 that would be a form of hate speech.
00:12:07 The Ontario Human Rights Act says that misgendering someone is a violation of your Ontario human
00:12:16 right to gender identity.
00:12:19 So it stands to reason that if the Ontario Human Rights Code had a hate speech provision
00:12:23 like Section 13 of the Canadian Human Rights Act, if that's brought back, their view would
00:12:28 be that misgendering someone was hate speech.
00:12:31 They already view it as being discrimination.
00:12:33 If you are misgendered in the waiting room of your doctor's office, that could be a legal 1.00
00:12:38 discrimination claim that you have against your family physician's kind receptionist.
00:12:44 So for starters, we have a major problem here of who gets to decide.
00:12:50 The other aspect is who is responsible for enforcing.
00:12:55 Because we have a body, the Canadian Human Rights Commission, which would be the one
00:12:58 that had to adjudicate if you had a complaint under the Human Rights Act.
00:13:02 Now, when you talk about social media companies, now all of a sudden the government is looking to Facebook and Twitter and YouTube and saying, you guys are the ones, sorry, you people, you people out there, you people kinders, you are the ones that have to enforce this edict.
00:13:18 So all of a sudden, Facebook is going to be on the hook for some bajillion dollar fine if Facebook is found to have not sufficiently acted to take your hate speech off the internet.
00:13:29 Now Facebook, as we've learned, doesn't really want to deal with the pesky regulatory environment of the Canadian government
00:13:37 It's a lot easier for Facebook just to say, you know what, we're pulling out of Canada
00:13:40 Or, you know, it might be more expedient for Facebook to say, fine
00:13:43 We don't want to just argue with Canadian speech bureaucrats
00:13:46 We'll just take the content down because that's so much easier
00:13:49 Now if Facebook makes a decision to do that, who is your complaint with?
00:13:53 Is your complaint against Facebook, a private company that has no real standing before the Human Rights Commission, or is your complaint against the government who can turn around and say, well, we didn't censor you, Facebook did. We didn't punish you for what you said, the social media company did.
00:14:08 so right here you have just off the top of my head a couple of the big problems with the scheme
00:14:15 that the government has proposed in the past and is likely to propose under this bill to regulate
00:14:20 speech and then you have the fundamental free speech aspect which is that the government is
00:14:24 going after speech it's drawing a line for what is legal and illegal speech that is lower than
00:14:29 the very high criminal threshold that already exists and as Bruce Party who's a phenomenal
00:14:34 lawyer and law professor has said time and time again, if something is illegal offline, it's
00:14:39 illegal online, which means we already have hate speech in the criminal code. So why do you need
00:14:44 a new law? If you cannot legally say something on the street, you can't legally say it on Facebook
00:14:49 or Twitter. The only reason the government has to put a new definition here is because they are
00:14:55 putting a sub-criminal threshold in. They're lowering the bar, which means more things are
00:15:00 going to be caught by what hate speech is. And as the government has said, they've taken
00:15:04 their inspiration for defining hate speech from a former Supreme Court decision, which is called
00:15:10 the Watcott decision, which has a number of very concerning things in it. Number one, something
00:15:15 was something could be true and still hateful. So that decision actually says, if you read it,
00:15:21 truth is no defense. So how are we supposed to believe that this is not going to be abused
00:15:27 if and when this becomes law.
00:15:30 I want to welcome into the show Josh DeHaz,
00:15:31 who is a lawyer with the Canadian Constitution Foundation,
00:15:34 where he is also a preeminent podcast host, a competitor,
00:15:37 but he does great work over there alongside Christine Van Gein and Joanna Barron.
00:15:42 Josh, good to have you back on the show. Thanks for coming on.
00:15:45 Good to be here.
00:15:46 So I want to talk about this free speech fight in Prince Edward Island in a few moments,
00:15:50 but just on the online harm stuff,
00:15:52 obviously we have to wait for the text of the bill to come out,
00:15:55 But we know from the first version of it and what the government has said in public messaging, what it's likely to look like here.
00:16:02 This is going to be just a feeding frenzy for civil liberties lawyers based on like any interpretation of what they're coming out with.
00:16:10 Right. Yeah.
00:16:11 Well, if if they come if they come out with a bill that brings back something like Section 13, you know, if anything that looks like what they proposed under Bill C-36,
00:16:21 They're going to have all kinds of challenges because, you know, it's just would not be constitutional to do something that extreme to have, you know, $20,000 fines for things that you say on the Internet that somebody finds offensive.
00:16:36 And so we really hope that that's not what they come up with.
00:16:41 But I guess we'll have to wait and see for the details in terms of this idea of an ombudsman or I think we're supposed to say ombudsperson.
00:16:48 ombudsperson. Yeah, it's actually hate speech if you say ombudsman. It could be under this new
00:16:54 bill. So I'll just go with the ombudsperson to be careful here. That raises all kinds of other
00:17:00 potential free speech issues here. If they go with 24-hour takedowns, that is just going to lead
00:17:07 Facebook and other internet service providers to take down anything that could put them at risk
00:17:15 or make them liable so that would be a huge free speech issue too that we would have to to try and
00:17:21 attack yeah and i and i maybe i'm again i'm not a lawyer i i play one on tv sometimes but the the
00:17:27 one thing that comes out here is that under c18 the liberal government put this uh regulation risk
00:17:33 requirement on on companies like facebook and google and said you guys have to pay news companies
00:17:38 if you're going to have news on your platform so facebook says all right it's not worth the
00:17:41 the hassle. We're just going to ban news. We looked into it. We got a legal opinion because
00:17:46 we were wondering if we could sue the government. And every lawyer we talked to said, well, no,
00:17:50 because Facebook made the decision. I mean, they may have done it in response to legislation,
00:17:54 but your issues with Facebook, which has, I would concede, no legal obligation to allow anyone to
00:17:59 use its platform. You apply that here. And I worry that the same thing applies where Facebook
00:18:05 will just develop a broad terms of service to encompass the law. But if Facebook's zapping
00:18:11 your content where's your recourse if you've been censored do you even have any yeah that would be
00:18:17 that that's that's the issue here so i think you could still mount some sort of challenge but it
00:18:22 would be very difficult to do if facebook itself wasn't uh getting involved in in that sort of
00:18:28 charter challenge um the other the other concern i would have is that companies like facebook might
00:18:34 just leave canada and you know people laugh at that but right now you have similar sorts of
00:18:39 legislation in the european union and uh they're they're they're telling twitter all the time look
00:18:45 if you don't comply with the with our uh requirements and uh you know get rid of more
00:18:51 of what we consider misinformation then we might kick twitter out of europe and it canada's a lot
00:18:58 smaller twitter probably cares a lot less about us but there's a possibility that if twitter is
00:19:03 faced with some sort of legislation that says they have a duty of care to take down information that
00:19:08 is so-called you know misinformation or discriminatory that they might just pull out at some point
00:19:15 let me ask you about that that arbitrator aspect here because a lot's changed in the internet in
00:19:22 the time that section 13 was there originally it was repealed in 2013 to now social media companies
00:19:28 are much more powerful we also have a government that i think has been much more emboldened on
00:19:33 on this idea of reining in online hate,
00:19:36 whereas Section 13 was really created
00:19:38 in response to fax machines,
00:19:40 if you go back to the origin of it.
00:19:43 So this idea of supercharging it,
00:19:45 by putting all these requirements on tech companies,
00:19:47 I see as being quite problematic,
00:19:49 but they also seem to think that they had kind of
00:19:51 charter-proofed the language with Bill C-36
00:19:55 by drawing from the Watcott decision.
00:19:57 I was wondering if you could just give a brief primer
00:19:59 on how that decision framed what free speech
00:20:03 and hate speech in this context are.
00:20:06 Yeah, so Watkot attempted to say that there is a line
00:20:11 over which you cannot cross between speech that's acceptable
00:20:15 and speech that is hateful
00:20:17 and can be constitutionally limited by the criminal laws.
00:20:21 And what ends up happening when you try to draw those lines
00:20:25 is you just end up using a lot of synonyms.
00:20:28 so walk lot says you know basically if your speech is inciting you know detestation against a group
00:20:35 that's illegal but if you're just offending a group or uh being hurtful towards a group that's
00:20:41 not okay so i i don't know how any reasonable person can tell the difference between words
00:20:46 like you know detestation or you know extreme dislike which is another one that's apparently
00:20:52 okay. And so all that Walcott really clarifies is that there is some line and it's really hard to
00:20:58 know where that is. It's going to be like the old I know it when I see it interpretation on
00:21:04 pornography, right? Right, right, exactly. And if there's that much subjectivity involved,
00:21:11 then you're really at the mercy of whoever the decision maker is. And let's say there's some
00:21:16 know digital safety czar or ombudsperson as i guess they're now called in the legislation it's
00:21:22 going to be up to you know their their tastes and their view about what is um what is hateful and
00:21:28 what isn't that's where the problem comes in because these are you know government appointees
00:21:33 and uh what they're offended by might be perfectly legitimate speech yeah and obviously you know
00:21:40 people when they have this debate i mean the big problem we run up against is that people have
00:21:45 trouble separating their emotional valuation of a particular expression from whether it has merit
00:21:51 as a legal form of expression and again we do not have a right to be comfortable we do not have a
00:21:57 right to not be offended or bothered or perturbed now i'm the one using all the synonyms and i think
00:22:01 this case in pei is a great example of this you have a counselor there in in murray harbor a very
00:22:07 very small community i don't even think it's at town level i think it's an even lower threshold
00:22:12 than town. And my colleague, Lindsay Shepard, wrote about John Robertson a while ago. He put
00:22:17 up a sign on his own property. And the sign, we have a picture there, truth, mass grave hoax,
00:22:24 reconciliation, redeem Sir John A's integrity. I think it's pretty clear what he's referring to
00:22:30 on both counts. And you may drive by that and say, I agree, I disagree, doesn't really matter.
00:22:35 He's now facing potential removal as a councillor over this. Explain what's going on here.
00:22:42 Yeah, so John put up this sign back in September. And this is a sign, it's one of those signs where you can, you know, change the plastic letters, I think you just showed it, that you see outside of, you know, churches or sometimes, you know, town halls. And he uses this just to spread his messages. Often it's things like, you know, happy, congratulations to the newlywed couple or, you know, there's some festival coming up and he wants to advertise it.
00:23:09 But occasionally he uses it for more political speech.
00:23:13 And in this case, he put up this sign because he's angry about the idea that in 2021, everybody was sort of led to believe that these mass graves had been located at Indian residential schools when, in fact, what was most likely found were cemeteries with unmarked graves.
00:23:33 Obviously very sad what happened at residential schools.
00:23:36 but he he's he's he's annoyed that this narrative sort of persists so um obviously this is his
00:23:44 private speech on his private property but his fellow village councillors didn't like this
00:23:48 message so they went after him using their code of conduct bylaw and you know municipalities across
00:23:56 canada have these codes of conduct they're they're they're meant to you know prevent city councillors
00:24:01 town counselors from doing things like harassing staff members or embezzling money or you know
00:24:08 having things that look like conflicts of interest but in recent years we've seen them start going
00:24:14 after fellow counselors for their political speech and that's what happened to john here
00:24:19 you know they did a big investigation they found that he breached sections of the code of conduct
00:24:25 related to ethical behavior that related to you know discrimination and harassment and arranging
00:24:31 your private affairs in a way that inspires public trust all of which is irrelevant to the sign
00:24:38 because it was not nothing to do with his actual job as a village counselor it was just a sign on
00:24:44 his property and it's political speech which is the most protected type of speech so you would
00:24:49 think that they would not be able to sanction him for for his sign and were pretty confident
00:24:55 that they violated the the constitutional guarantee for free speech by by uh sanctioning
00:25:00 for him they gave him a 500 fine uh suspended him for six months and demanded this forced apology
00:25:07 to to them and to the indigenous peoples and uh he refused to do that so now the minister
00:25:13 has launched an inquiry where one of the possibilities at the end of that is his removal.
00:25:20 So just, you know, an official on town council being removed for his political speech.
00:25:28 And they haven't really flinched or blinked in this since he's, you know,
00:25:33 secured legal representation through you in the CCF?
00:25:36 So we haven't heard anything from the town. They haven't flinched. What I can say is,
00:25:42 uh well the town very very obviously messed up this investigation and this whole process in many ways
00:25:50 but the minister uh in in a sense may have flinched because he issued an order in december that said
00:25:58 you know you have two days to accept these sanctions including the apology or resign
00:26:04 and uh john robertson he didn't he didn't do that at the time you know he was sort of looking for
00:26:09 legal counsel and he was uh on vacation so he he but he didn't do that at the time in any event
00:26:16 and the minister i think subsequently realized that um there may have been some problems with
00:26:21 this investigation and the the sanctions uh the way that things went about so he rescinded that
00:26:27 order and he uh issued a new order for an inquiry so now he's going to sort of redo all of the
00:26:33 this investigation about whether john's sign somehow breaches this code of conduct which i
00:26:39 i think it pretty clearly does not the thing that i find so incredibly incredibly concerning about
00:26:46 that i found a lot of it concerning but he's expressing a political opinion he is an elected
00:26:50 politician now in this particular case i don't think it's a position that murray harbor pei
00:26:55 necessarily has to deal with at the local level it may conceivably i again i don't know if it's near
00:27:01 any indigenous communities but the fact of the matter is that when you have a colleagues that
00:27:06 are weaponizing this code of conduct process for people expressing political opinions they're
00:27:11 effectively overriding the democratic process they're overriding the fact that constituents
00:27:16 have the opportunity to vote politicians in or out based in part on their political beliefs
00:27:21 yeah that's that's exactly right so uh it's it's it's very crazy here that the minister could
00:27:28 remove this person for for his speech i mean that's up to the voters and you know there's
00:27:33 there's this idea that uh his speech was very controversial and unpopular and that seems to
00:27:40 be the case in public you know that the town did get a lot of emails and things like that that's
00:27:45 were from people that said he's a residential school denialist which is absolutely not the case
00:27:50 um or that he's he's uh you know harming reconciliation but there is also a silent
00:27:56 majority out there that thinks you know what we were misled by the media in uh 2021 or at least
00:28:03 by by some parts of the media and uh they might they're they're on john's team you know they're
00:28:10 sending donations to the ccf they're signing the petition on our website and they're emailing john
00:28:15 to say you know we're with you just because you don't hear them publicly all that much doesn't
00:28:19 mean that they're not out there so um we we should at the end of the day we need to wait till
00:28:25 the next election and then it will be up to the voters if john runs whether to re-elect him
00:28:31 All right.
00:28:32 Well, and he has to watch
00:28:33 if he promotes himself on his sign.
00:28:35 He may get slapped down again there.
00:28:37 Josh, to has with the Canadian Constitution Foundation,
00:28:39 also one of the hosts of Not Reserving Judgment.
00:28:42 I think you have a new episode today, right?
00:28:43 It's Wednesdays?
00:28:45 We do.
00:28:46 We do.
00:28:46 And we're talking about this online harm stuff.
00:28:48 So you can hear more of what we have to think about that
00:28:50 and some of the rumors we've heard.
00:28:52 So all right.
00:28:53 Perfect.
00:28:55 Lawyers peddling in rumors.
00:28:56 That's very edgy in your world.
00:28:58 All right, Josh, thanks very much.
00:28:59 really good to talk to you again great thanks andrew all right we're doing all the hot button
00:29:04 issues today we're doing free speech we're doing hate speech and we will also do assisted dying 0.55
00:29:09 maid assisted suicide it goes by a number of names but none of which mask what is actually
00:29:14 at stake which some people try to obscure let me share this clip of an exchange between conservative
00:29:20 mp garnett jenis and a liberal parliamentary secretary on what made really is questions
00:29:28 ...and comments of the Honourable Member for Sherwood Park for Saskatchewan.
00:29:32 Thank you, Mr. Speaker.
00:29:33 I have a question for the government about their so-called MAID policy. 0.95
00:29:37 Now, they've said repeatedly that especially as it relates to mental health challenges,
00:29:42 their MAID policy would aim to exclude those who are suicidal.
00:29:48 But I want to understand from the government,
00:29:50 isn't any person who requests MAID suicidal simply by definition,
00:29:55 since they're requesting MAID?
00:29:57 I think it's irresponsible and untrue, honestly, to claim that MAID has anything
00:30:08 to do with suicide.
00:30:10 The Government of Canada recognizes the importance of all Canadians to have access to critical
00:30:15 mental health resources and suicide prevention services.
00:30:19 I am a member of the special MAID committee and not one witness that I heard when I was
00:30:26 there said that this is suicidal. So assisted suicide has nothing to do with what's that
00:30:36 suicide okay a little bit of wordplay going on from the Liberal government a Liberal government
00:30:42 that has committed to a massive expansion of medically assisted dying including to people
00:30:49 who are grappling only with mental illness. I've shared on a number of occasions my own
00:30:53 struggles with depression, my past attempt at suicide, attempts at suicide, in fact,
00:30:59 one of which was very, very successful almost and nearly ended my life. I'd say it was truly
00:31:05 successful that I failed. But at the time, my endeavor was to end my life and had MAID been
00:31:12 available to me as someone with mental illness, I very likely would have tried to go that road.
00:31:17 Now, MAID is increasingly used by people who have run out of options because of the healthcare
00:31:22 system, not because they are dealing with a terminal and irremediable condition, as the
00:31:27 legislation is supposed to restrict it to, but because they have run out of options, they have
00:31:31 had troubles accessing adequate care. And for all that we hear talk about healthcare equity and
00:31:37 people who are unable to access healthcare for a number of reasons, why are we seeing such an
00:31:43 expansion of MAID? This is something that was put in a very, very important piece in the
00:31:49 McDonnell Laurier Institute by a doctor in my neck of the woods in London, Dr. Ramona Coelho.
00:31:55 Barriers to care persist, but access to MAID keeps expanding. She joins me now. It's been many
00:32:00 years since we've spoken, Dr. Coelho, but it's good to speak to you again. Thanks for coming on today.
00:32:05 My pleasure.
00:32:06 So explain to me, first off, this apparent double standard here. On one hand, we hear people say
00:32:11 that there are these health equity challenges. People in marginalized communities, people with
00:32:16 disabilities, they all have issues navigating the system, but many of those people are the ones that 1.00
00:32:20 are being directed by practitioners at many points towards MAID. Yeah, it's very disturbing. Right now
00:32:28 in Canada, the laws for medical assistance in dying are so permissive, aiming and considering
00:32:36 only the narrow lens of accessibility when we are in fact talking about suicide. And so actually we
00:32:44 need to protect Canadians by having many safeguards and we need to have strict eligibility 1.00
00:32:51 criteria, which we do not have. And so although MAID is supposed to be a compassionate service,
00:33:00 apparently for people who have nothing, we have nothing left to offer, it can easily be offered
00:33:06 or be used when people have no other options. I was recently interviewed for an Al Jazeera
00:33:13 documentary on the life of Rosina Camas and you can see she had her own recordings and writings
00:33:20 near the end of her life you can even see part of her maid assessments and and how callous that whole 0.97
00:33:28 experience was you know the maid assessor offering to kill her on the weekend if she had time 1.00
00:33:34 and the real poverty and loneliness that she experienced that led to her desperation
00:33:41 So the potential for abuse of people being taken advantage of by a government system is real.
00:33:53 As the stats currently stand, you know, you have main assessors and providers that are speaking out in Health Canada saying that,
00:34:02 no, this is actually mostly like wealthy, privileged people who are choosing this.
00:34:06 don't have to worry. Most of our cases are for people who are near death. My article talks about
00:34:13 how the Canadian Association of Maid Assessors and Providers actually has created policies to
00:34:22 seemingly circumvent those safeguards so that even if you have just a disability, you're not dying,
00:34:28 if you state your intention to refuse care, they can treat you as if you have a terminal
00:34:34 illness and end your life immediately. And so you have even less time to recover, even less time for
00:34:39 sober second thought. And really that changes how we can interpret the Health Canada reports and
00:34:45 stats, because people with disabilities who are marginalized can be hidden under track one as if
00:34:50 they had a terminal illness just because they were refusing to eat and drink. I mean, a lot of
00:34:55 Canadians have heard, if not, they certainly should, that the famous case of the woman who
00:34:59 needed a chairlift in her home and was offered assisted suicide instead but there are a number
00:35:05 of examples of this and you allude to this in your piece where people in the disability community
00:35:09 are sounding the alarm about this and the tragic reality is when you have made being pushed on
00:35:15 people that have disabilities that aren't in a terminal illness it's because their life is being 1.00
00:35:20 valued at less than that of someone without the disability by many of these practitioners is it
00:35:27 night absolutely um so basically you're making my my friend and excellent author gabrielle peters
00:35:35 always talks about how our government has created a killable class a class of people that are seen
00:35:42 as having lives less worthy um maybe not even less worthy but that is merciful to help them end
00:35:48 their lives and really that's based on bias and stigma the ideas the false ideas that somehow
00:35:56 they don't, first of all, they don't enjoy their lives. Most studies show that
00:36:00 our society and physicians rate people's quality of lives with disabilities as quite low when they
00:36:06 do not. And also so that you have this kind of idea that we're offering them a mercy and a way
00:36:14 out because really, wouldn't they rather just be dead, which couldn't be farther from the truth.
00:36:19 But when you have a program that targets people like that, basically when they're suicidal,
00:36:24 like andrew you shared that you were suicidal at some point in your life i have also been but if
00:36:29 we appear able-bodied then all of a sudden we develop we deserve suicide prevention services
00:36:35 although it looks like made will potentially expand even for people like us but for now if
00:36:40 you have a physical disability if you are suicidal and it's a little bit more long-standing
00:36:45 you might get made one thing that i i've always struggled with on this is that it seems like a lot
00:36:51 of maid providers are already operating well outside the legislation as it's spelled out i
00:36:58 i mean we we've heard number a number of cases about this and i'm i'm wondering how that was
00:37:03 allowed to happen is is this coming from regulators that aren't really caring or checking up or is it
00:37:09 just uh you know like these these maid assessors and maid providers are just knowing that no one
00:37:14 is going to prosecute them because i i've personally been aware of cases where someone
00:37:18 who would not have been eligible in one province was eligible in another and this is not supposed
00:37:25 to be the case because it's a federal law so i'm wondering what's gone so wrong here already even
00:37:29 before this liberal government expansion kicks in i have like 10 answers to that but uh just
00:37:37 i'll say like first of all very concerning there is geographic variation across canada which shows
00:37:43 that there are different cultural practices quebec has the highest rate in the whole world 0.99
00:37:47 right now um as they mentioned in the article bc i think also uh certain areas of bc and even
00:37:54 certain areas of ontario so the the geographic changes should alarm us it means that there's a
00:38:01 lack of standardization two the legislation is meant to protect protect mate assessors and
00:38:08 providers it hasn't thought enough about patient protection like i said they've talked about
00:38:13 accessibility and protecting the meat assessors and providers, but not enough thought has been
00:38:18 given about patient protections. Three, you have a government that has allowed Health Canada
00:38:24 to kind of use our most ideologically, I would say, out there leaders on this issue to
00:38:35 guide our policy. That's not usually how we develop policy. We usually try to find a balance.
00:38:41 But you have people like Jocelyn Downey, Mona Gupta, people who have basically expressed that
00:38:47 they want the kind of widest open maid regime who are leading our Canadian policies, which is 1.00
00:38:52 dangerous for everybody. And then fourth, I would say that, you know, a lot of maid assessors and 0.99
00:38:58 providers that I know are actually very concerned about maid outside the end of life context,
00:39:02 and they do refuse cases. But all you need to have is a few people who are willing to kill
00:39:09 or end the lives of many people,
00:39:12 and you have a big problem
00:39:14 given the way our system is set up.
00:39:16 That is itself jarring
00:39:18 because I think that for the current time anyway,
00:39:21 and I fear that this could be under threat
00:39:23 with a different government,
00:39:24 physicians have the right to object.
00:39:26 And you talk about this in your piece,
00:39:28 they're conscientious objectors,
00:39:29 but even that you have an issue with
00:39:31 and how that's applied.
00:39:33 I was wondering if you could elaborate on that.
00:39:35 Yeah, I have a big issue with,
00:39:37 And actually, this is what you interviewed with me for a few years ago, is that initially in Ontario, the CPSO came up with this wacky policy, and I'll call it that, called effective referral, where a physician needs to, again, considering accessibility and timeliness, needs to make an effective referral to another provider who will do the service.
00:40:02 um and and that basically puts patients on a very dangerous path if everyone has to
00:40:08 funnel people onto a death regime pathway you that partly i think explains why we have
00:40:15 such high numbers in canada 16 000 estimated for 2023 13 000 this is the problem of having
00:40:22 only a few people to do it right because now if everyone has to everyone has to direct them to
00:40:27 those people so even actually if you're a maid provider who is not comfortable with the case
00:40:34 and that's what i highlight in my policy uh piece for mcdonald laureate so even if you're a maid
00:40:39 provider who is uncomfortable so one of the people the trainee said they were uncomfortable with made
00:40:44 for poverty and the experts said well okay fine your conscience says you can't do this but you
00:40:49 need to make a referral and hopefully hopefully someone else will do it so if you keep putting
00:40:54 someone on a pathway, they're going to find a maid provider who, if they continue on that 1.00
00:41:01 path, which technically, if every physician keeps putting them on that path, they're going
00:41:04 to find somebody who will eventually do it. And there was a story, I think it came out
00:41:08 in the Ottawa Citizen, but an Ottawa paper about a woman who basically was referred on
00:41:13 six or seven times until she finally found someone in Brampton who would complete her
00:41:18 maid case. And they were talking about how sad it was that she had to go through seven
00:41:23 seven providers and I guess the real question is like why were those six providers who are okay
00:41:29 with MAID not okay with giving her MAID like could it be that this should have been stopped
00:41:34 yeah that's tragic if at first you don't succeed try try again at its at its macabre end Dr. Ramona
00:41:42 Coelho fantastic piece very grim but I think important in the McDonnell Laurier Institute
00:41:47 barriers to care persist but access to MAID keeps expanding thank you so much for coming on today
00:41:53 Thank you for having me.
00:41:54 Have a great day.
00:41:55 All right, yourself as well.
00:41:57 It's always difficult getting family physicians on
00:41:59 because they are just like worked morning tonight.
00:42:01 So we're so glad she could fit us in on short notice.
00:42:05 We are out of time for today,
00:42:07 but I wanted to give you a bit of a heads up
00:42:08 on what's coming on the show tomorrow.
00:42:11 I sat down yesterday with Kevin Vong,
00:42:14 who is an independent Liberal member of Parliament,
00:42:17 elected as a, that's me on the left there.
00:42:20 No, sorry, I'm on the right.
00:42:21 Kevin Vong's on the left.
00:42:22 I got us mixed up.
00:42:24 No, I was actually, my screen was reversed.
00:42:26 But this is going to be a fascinating interview.
00:42:29 It's about what you can do, or in some cases, what you can't do as an independent Member
00:42:34 of Parliament.
00:42:35 And that is coming out tomorrow.
00:42:37 We'll have a full, I think, 45 minute or so wide ranging chat and a very interesting
00:42:42 news story that I think is going to emerge from that interview.
00:42:46 So keep an eye out.
00:42:48 That's going to be tomorrow at the usual time, 1 o'clock Eastern, 11 a.m.
00:42:51 Mountain.
00:42:52 I am off next week, so you will be able to keep up to date on the regular old True North content.
00:42:57 But on Thursday, I will be on off the record once again.
00:43:00 So we'll hopefully have enough to keep you tied it over until I return in a week and a half's time.
00:43:06 Canada's most reverent talk show, The Andrew Lawton Show, True North.
00:43:09 Thank you, God bless, and good day to you all.
00:43:13 Thanks for listening to The Andrew Lawton Show.
00:43:15 Support the program by donating to True North at www.tnc.news.
00:43:22 We'll be right back.
00:43:52 We'll be right back.