Juno News - January 02, 2024


Justin Trudeau says he's not going anywhere this year

Topics
Mentioned
Students taught “safe crack smoking” Saskatchewan drops carbon tax on home heating

Episode Stats


Length

46 minutes

Words per minute

183.13

Word count

8,587

Sentence count

311

Harmful content

Misogyny

4

sentences flagged

Toxicity

2

sentences flagged

Hate speech

5

sentences flagged


Summary

Summaries generated with gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ .

It's a new year, which means we celebrate the arbitrary passage of time from one day to the next, and pretend that from December 31st to January 1st, a year has elapsed. This week, Andrew Lawton talks about his trip to Egypt.

Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Topics generated with Qwen2.5-3B-Instruct.
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 Transcription by CastingWords
00:00:30 Thank you.
00:01:00 Welcome to Canada's Most Irreverent Talk Show.
00:01:16 This is the Andrew Lawton Show, brought to you by True North.
00:01:25 Hello and welcome to you all, Canada's Most Irreverent Talk Show.
00:01:29 this is the Andrew Lawton Show on True North, the first program of 2024. Yes, it is January 2nd.
00:01:39 We are two ways into a new year, which means we celebrate the arbitrary passage of time
00:01:44 from one day to the next and pretend that from December 31st to January 1st, a year has elapsed.
00:01:50 It's a bit of a weird thing that we do on New Year's. I've never really been a fan of it.
00:01:54 I used to just be the Grinch of New Year's and hate the whole thing.
00:01:59 And then one year, I don't know, maybe it was three years ago or so,
00:02:02 I just had like a weird bit of New Year's spirit.
00:02:04 And I went to a New Year's party and, you know,
00:02:06 convinced myself to stay up until, I don't know, like 12.02 a.m.
00:02:10 And this time I was actually, I was out at a New Year's dinner for New Year's,
00:02:16 which was like a big deal for me.
00:02:18 And yes, I had to have a nap to make it to that point.
00:02:21 But you know what?
00:02:21 I did it and it was delightful.
00:02:23 So hope you all had a wonderful holiday season.
00:02:26 We are right back into the thick of it here.
00:02:29 As many of you may have seen, if you follow me on, I was going to say Twitter, but it's called X now.
00:02:34 If you follow me on X, I was not in Canada over the holidays.
00:02:39 I actually have always been, I was in Quebec one year for Christmas.
00:02:43 I don't know if that counts as being in Canada or not, but I've always spent Christmas with my family.
00:02:49 this year, though, my wife and I got out of Dodge and we were actually in Egypt, which has been like
00:02:53 a lifelong ambition for both of us. And it was the only week we could find time to go. And I,
00:02:59 so actually I have a picture of it here. We have evidence that I was in fact in Egypt as I, there
00:03:05 we go. That's me. And on top of me is a, oh no, sorry. I'm the one on top there. The camel's on
00:03:11 bottom. And in the background, the great pyramids of Giza, not Gaza. They don't really have pyramids
00:03:18 there Hamas blew them up uh that was a lot of fun uh poor camel but he uh dutifully carried me along 0.99
00:03:23 and at the end of it his handler uh was very very nice man he he came up to me and he said
00:03:29 I've taken care of you and I said well yes you have he's like good now you must take care of
00:03:34 me and my family and he put his hand out and I was wondering how much he was trying to shake
00:03:38 me down for it ended up being like five dollars or something so it was absolutely well worth it
00:03:44 Also took in some of the other great majestic sites of Egypt.
00:03:49 I paid a visit to this guy.
00:03:52 This is not for the faint of heart, this picture.
00:03:54 Now, I know that looks like the remains of King Tut in King Tut's tomb,
00:04:00 but that's actually Justin Trudeau's polling numbers right there, believe it or not.
00:04:05 They've been lying dead for about 4,000 years just sitting there,
00:04:09 and even a light gust of wind would just obliterate them into dust.
00:04:14 So that's not King Tut.
00:04:15 That is the Liberals' latest polling data right there in real time for you.
00:04:20 But it was a lot of fun.
00:04:21 And one of the things that was so fascinating before we get into the main show here,
00:04:26 I had never been to Egypt before, so it was a very new experience.
00:04:30 The police there are incredibly, incredibly corrupt.
00:04:35 And I don't like stereotypes.
00:04:37 I like I don't like I just don't I don't like generalization I don't like stereotypes
00:04:42 and so we had one day my wife and I we had a guide and the guide was with the driver and we
00:04:49 were traveling and there was this brand new bridge so the Egyptian president Abdel el-Sisi has been
00:04:56 like huge on public works he's building roads and bridges every which way and there was this one new
00:05:02 bridge that uh everyone was excited about the bridge didn't officially open until january 1st
00:05:09 but it was completed and it was open because people could drive on it and the police officer
00:05:15 that we encountered standing at the on-ramp uh was just there to like get everyone who wanted
00:05:22 to go on the bridge to bribe him which we learned was the only way you'd get on the bridge and i was
00:05:28 like okay well that's a little bit of an oddity and then you know maybe all the police aren't
00:05:31 that bad we but we we go to this old temple my wife and i beautiful old uh building well not
00:05:36 really a building but a site thousands of years old and there is this police officer there with
00:05:42 his uh submachine gun and he sees us taking pictures and he he you know gestures for us to
00:05:48 come over and he starts showing us all of these different places there he opens this one gate
00:05:53 and lets us walk through he points us here it was a couple of minutes and at the end of it i'm
00:05:58 I'm thinking, oh, wow, what a wonderful police officer. That's so nice. He's bringing us behind
00:06:02 these closed doors. And then we're in this tiny little dark tomb. And in one hand, he has his
00:06:08 submachine gun. And in the other hand, he's just staring at me with his hand out, waiting for me to
00:06:14 pay him off for the service I didn't know I was getting. Now, again, fortunately, this scam was
00:06:21 basically all about like getting seven or eight dollars from me as well. So the poor Egyptian 1.00
00:06:26 currency at least means that when you're getting hosed, because everyone in the country is trying 0.86
00:06:31 to screw you. So when you're getting hosed, at least it's for a small amount of money. But
00:06:34 whatever you did, enough about me. I hope you had a wonderful, wonderful holiday here.
00:06:39 I wanted to talk on this show about one of the things that does not change. I mentioned glibly
00:06:44 Justin Trudeau's poll numbers. They have been in the gutter for months now. Pierre Polyev and
00:06:50 the Conservatives have been riding high. You see some fluctuations here and there. But
00:06:55 But Justin Trudeau would have, I saw one poll recently, a 3% chance of forming government if the election were held on the day that the polling was done, whatever that was.
00:07:07 It was early December. 3% chance, which means that out of 100 scenarios, 97 of them would lead to Pierre Polieva, the Conservatives, winning.
00:07:17 Three percent, one of them might be, I don't know, nuclear catastrophe of the Conservative campaign bus, would lead to Justin Trudeau winning.
00:07:26 So it's odd that he has been, as he does the round robin of interviews for the end of the year, so brazen in claiming that everything is fine.
00:07:36 This was one of his interviews with Mercedes Stevenson.
00:07:39 Historically, Canadian prime ministers don't get elected four times in a row, and people
00:07:45 are being very clear that they don't like you in these polls.
00:07:50 People are frustrated right now.
00:07:52 But on a personal level, I made a commitment in 2015 to a whole bunch of young people who
00:08:00 came out to vote for the very, very first time that we were going to be doing the right
00:08:05 kinds of things to secure the promise of this country in a way that people were worried
00:08:10 about.
00:08:12 And years later, even with everything we've done on the environment, on inclusion, on
00:08:17 gender equality, on growing the economy, on reconciliation, those young people eight years
00:08:24 later are having trouble paying their rent, worried about their future in ways that are
00:08:29 just as tangible, if not more, because of the global context we're in.
00:08:34 And I didn't make a promise that I was going to make things better for them and then walk
00:08:37 away after four years or even after eight years.
00:08:40 I said I'd be there to fight for them every single day.
00:08:44 Even if they don't want you there.
00:08:46 Listen, there'll be an election eventually in which people get to make that choice.
00:08:51 But I am not giving up on them.
00:08:53 I'm not giving up on Canada.
00:08:55 I'm not giving up on the progressive vision of progress that we've been fighting for every
00:09:02 single day over the past years that's very much like you can't fire me i quit he you know her
00:09:10 point in the question was a very valid one which is uh canadians don't want you anymore they don't
00:09:15 like you they don't want you around and he said well i made a commitment to them they're not
00:09:19 getting rid of me that easily it's like no no they're forgiving you for the commitment they
00:09:24 want you to walk away you you don't owe it to them you in fact you owe it to them to walk away
00:09:29 We are coming up, I believe it's in March, I can't recall exactly the date, I have it written down
00:09:35 somewhere, but we are coming up on the 40-year anniversary of Pierre Elliott Trudeau's famous
00:09:42 walk in the snow, which was that little late night walk he took through, was it the grass or the sand?
00:09:48 No, sorry, the snow. When he took that little walk and decided that he was going to be stepping down,
00:09:53 that he had taken things as far as he could take them. Now, Pierre Elliott Trudeau gets,
00:09:59 i think a lot of credit for being self-aware but the reality is he had already had his moment uh
00:10:06 and he had already lost and it was only coming back and arguably he had his most uh substantive
00:10:11 term when he returned but he had at that point nowhere else to go but down so he he left and the
00:10:18 the so-called walk in the snow has now entered canadian parlance so will justin trudeau take
00:10:22 a walk in the snow i mean every indication he's given in every interview that one with mercedes
00:10:27 Stevenson being the most recent example here, is that you are going to have to drag him out the
00:10:33 door kicking and screaming if you want him to go anywhere. There is no shame. There is no self
00:10:40 awareness. There is no introspection. When you look at polling numbers, which obviously you have
00:10:45 to take with a grain of salt, he says, well, it's all these external things. I mean, it's not really
00:10:50 about me. It's about all of these other factors. That's basically what he's saying here. So when
00:10:56 he says we made a commitment to young people in 2015 yeah you were going to legalize pot and you
00:11:02 were going to change the voting system and you did just one of those because that one was the one
00:11:06 that benefited you uh the reality is justin trudeau made a commitment to young people young
00:11:11 people in some cases are happy with them in some cases they're not but this idea that he has to
00:11:16 stay there until the end of time or he's voted out whichever comes first is a very weird way i mean
00:11:23 I'm a big believer in quit before you fail, which is when you get to the point where you cannot do
00:11:29 anything more, you should go out where people still believe that you had something to offer
00:11:36 and that you did something. Sean in my messaging here says, Gretzky is a great example of that.
00:11:43 I'm assuming he's not referring to the Ontario member of the legislature, Lisa Gretzky. So
00:11:49 So I'm left to believe this must be a sports reference.
00:11:52 But Wayne Gretzky did something that apparently proves my point.
00:11:55 So thank you very much for that, Sean.
00:11:56 Very helpful.
00:11:57 I'm sure the audience understands what you're talking about if I don't.
00:12:01 But Seinfeld, I can use Seinfeld references.
00:12:05 Seinfeld knows this full well.
00:12:08 Because when the series Seinfeld ended, it was at the absolute apex.
00:12:12 It was the top.
00:12:14 It was like in the ratings.
00:12:15 People were offering them more and more and more money just to keep it going.
00:12:19 And Seinfeld and the cast said, listen, you were at the top.
00:12:23 There is only one way to go, and that is down.
00:12:25 So they canceled the show.
00:12:27 They left people wanting more.
00:12:30 They left people wanting more.
00:12:31 Now, in the case of Justin Trudeau, he knows that people don't want anymore.
00:12:35 He's already passed that point.
00:12:38 You know, maybe the 2021 election was the logical point at which he could have made his exit.
00:12:42 Probably about a year after that.
00:12:44 I mean, it would have looked bad if he had just said when Pierre Polyev became the leader in 2022.
00:12:49 all right I'm out I you know I've done it he can have a shot now but he is not liked and he is not
00:12:56 wanted and he is the only single person who doesn't seem to realize that now in his year-end interviews
00:13:02 he did the usual suspects he did CBC, CTV, Global News well Pierre Polyev did a very different
00:13:09 approach Pierre Polyev sat down with True North he sat down with Rex Murphy he sat down with Brian
00:13:16 Lilly. He talked to all of these other folks. And what was interesting is the media then
00:13:20 pounced on Pierre Polyev for not talking to the right kinds of journalists because only the
00:13:26 official Parliament Hill journalists are the real journalists. That was the approach that they
00:13:31 tended to take about that. But it was fascinating to me. I mean, I actually got a lot more out of
00:13:36 some of these Pierre Polyev interviews than I probably would have gotten if he was just being
00:13:39 beaten over the head with Rosie Barton's questions about tone and civility or whatever she would 1.00
00:13:45 have asked him about had he sat down with her. But what's fascinating here is that Justin Trudeau
00:13:50 doesn't seem to realize the why for the polling number. He did mention in a bit of self-awareness
00:13:57 that Pierre Polyev has captured an anxiety and an angst in the Canadian population very well,
00:14:04 but he still doesn't realize why things aren't working. This is a clip that I think really shows
00:14:10 that. Where do you find optimism right now? Because I think that's something Canadians 1.00
00:14:14 are struggling with right i think there is a frustration anger and patience all those things
00:14:19 and i wonder where where you find that and where you would tell them to find it two things first
00:14:25 of all a lot of the things that we're putting into place now are going to be delivering in the coming
00:14:33 years as we're seeing inflation getting under control as we see interest rates hopefully coming
00:14:38 down in sometime in 2024 that's going to take pressure off as we see ten dollar a day child
00:14:43 care become a reality across the country but the building blocks are there but even that's not even
00:14:50 where i draw most of my inspiration from it's our fellow canadians we saw it during the worst forest
00:14:56 fire season on his in history over the summer the way people stepped up for each other the way people
00:15:02 were there for each other the way people are there now with food banks with supports the way
00:15:07 communities are coming together yeah they're united and all being mad at the federal government
00:15:11 and the government's right now because there's something to be mad about there but at the same
00:15:16 time those people who throw up their hands and say oh Canada's just broken couldn't be wronger
00:15:21 because Canadians are not broken they're facing really tough times but we're doing what we always
00:15:27 do as Canadians we roll up our sleeves we're there for our neighbors we lean in to the headwinds
00:15:32 and we succeed some people don't buy that though I understand how tough it is right now
00:15:39 but what people need to be looking for is who is actually looking to solve the challenges we're
00:15:45 facing and who's just looking to exploit them or amplify them and that is going to be the choice
00:15:51 that will shape the next two years in politics
00:15:56 so basically he's saying canada is not broken because canadians are great and okay that's a
00:16:02 you know a nice little heartwarming message but when someone gets up and says canada is
00:16:07 broken which is a line Pierre Polyev has used and that's obviously where Justin Trudeau is
00:16:13 going with that when he says that he's not saying there's a problem with Canadian people he's saying
00:16:18 that the institutions in this country are not working and are not serving Canadians that there
00:16:25 is something very different from saying Canada is broken than Canadians are broken and Justin
00:16:31 Trudeau is the one trying to conflate these two, I would say quite wrongly. But there's also
00:16:37 something, and this is a criticism you could make of Stephen Harper's government. It's a criticism
00:16:42 you could make of the former Ontario government under Kathleen Wynne. But we'll talk about it in
00:16:47 the context of Justin Trudeau right now. He has been elected three times. He had a majority
00:16:53 government in 2015. He had a minority government in 2019. He has a de facto majority government
00:16:59 now because the NDP is propping his government up. Now, the reason that's an important point is
00:17:06 because if you look at from 2015 to now, Justin Trudeau has had an eight-year period. By this
00:17:12 fall, it'll be a nine-year period with which he can do effectively whatever he wants.
00:17:19 So when he talks about, well, we're putting in things now that are going to start yielding
00:17:24 benefits and reaping benefits years down the road, you're like, well, hang on, you've had
00:17:30 almost a decade. Why didn't you do these? Okay, maybe you didn't get time to do everything in
00:17:34 your first term, but certainly your second, why didn't you do them? What was holding you back?
00:17:40 And Stephen Harper, it was the same sort of thing. You could make the claim that in 2011 or 2015,
00:17:45 by which point the conservatives have won three elections already, anything in their platform,
00:17:51 you are right to question why do you even need this platform you've been in government for so
00:17:57 long why have you not done everything you you've needed to do i mean the best thing you could do
00:18:03 as a government if you're running for a fourth term in office is say uh you know our platform
00:18:07 is one page and it's basically just maintaining all of these things we've already done that's
00:18:13 effectively it because by that point anything you haven't done is because you didn't come up
00:18:16 with the ideas or you were just holding back your best material uh just waiting for people to give
00:18:21 you an encore but sometimes i just want to see the best material in the main set now the problem
00:18:26 with that i was once at a journey concert and journey made the fatal mistake of doing all their
00:18:31 hits in the main set so everyone left before the encore but you know what no one was left wanting
00:18:37 more so journey understood that part at least i'm throwing again i can't do the sports references
00:18:42 but if you want me to do journey references in Seinfeld, I've got you covered. Just none of this
00:18:47 Gretzky stuff that people are talking about, you kids these days. One of the things that has
00:18:52 changed this year is Saskatchewan has made good on its promise to not collect the carbon tax.
00:18:59 They are no longer collecting a carbon tax on fuel and heating. Their rationale is that the
00:19:05 federal government gave this selective carve-out for home heating oil, which disproportionately
00:19:10 benefited atlantic canada so saskatchewan is saying to the federal government well you know
00:19:15 what tough luck we are not going to charge the carbon tax to our people now is this constitutional
00:19:21 or not i'm certain there's going to be a court battle about it but it means that the provinces
00:19:26 are not messing around when it comes to this standoff with the federal government over it
00:19:32 one of the things that i think will come up here is obviously where the feds go from here because
00:19:37 no prime minister wants to be the one that ushered in a federalism crisis. And I would
00:19:42 say that federal provincial relations have been pretty strained right now, worse than I've ever
00:19:48 seen in, well, worse than I can recall in my life, not worse than they've ever been.
00:19:53 But this is a big problem. So in the case of Saskatchewan, they're looking at the federal
00:19:58 government and saying, you know what, if you guys are going to do this to us, we're going to do this
00:20:01 to you. We've had the Sovereignty Act, the Saskatchewan First Act, we've had the notwithstanding
00:20:07 clause. All of these different provincial governments right now, from New Brunswick to
00:20:11 Ontario, Saskatchewan, Alberta, Manitoba, they've all been saying with alarming regularity now to
00:20:18 the federal government, we are not going to play your game. So I think if I were to make a prediction
00:20:25 for the year ahead, we will probably see more of this on different policies. Remember, Saskatchewan
00:20:31 used the notwithstanding clause on a parental rights bill. It wasn't on the Sovereignty Act,
00:20:36 it wasn't on an energy thing they use notwithstanding clause to get around a provincial
00:20:41 rights bill that a court had found unconstitutional we've had alberta that's talking about using this
00:20:46 in many different contexts ontario has used the notwithstanding clause which is that section of
00:20:51 the constitution that effectively lets uh provinces preemptively say uh we are going to do this in
00:20:58 spite of what the charter of rights and freedom says so if we see federal provincial relationships
00:21:04 like this is that the best way of doing things you know one thing that i will just to geek out
00:21:12 on political science for a moment here the federal government kind of views itself as being
00:21:17 the overarching power under which provinces lie but if you read the constitution the federal
00:21:23 provincial relationship is actually envisioned as more of a partnership in some jurisdiction
00:21:29 in some contexts a federal government has sole jurisdiction in others provinces have
00:21:34 sole jurisdiction and in a few areas federal governments and provincial governments have to
00:21:39 share jurisdiction and i mean really if you're talking about let's say a health care or energy
00:21:46 these are supposed to be matters of provincial jurisdiction they do not work for the federal
00:21:52 government they are not subordinate to the federal government so it is in some ways supposed to be a
00:21:58 an equal relationship or uh to use the old line first among equals to describe the prime minister
00:22:04 well you could also use that to describe the federal government so i but again at the same
00:22:10 time no one wants this really antagonistic relationship between the two and i think that's
00:22:16 going to be what we're seeing more of but you know the charitable defense of what saskatchewan
00:22:20 and alberta and the like are doing here is that they wouldn't need to do this if the federal 0.89
00:22:26 government weren't trying to encroach into provincial jurisdiction time and time again so
00:22:32 we'll talk about what saskatchewan is doing here i also want to talk about the fuel tax issue in
00:22:37 alberta chris sims is our regular monday correspondent but obviously we don't have a
00:22:41 monday show this week but it had been too long since we had heard from her so we wanted to bring
00:22:45 her on for a rare tuesday appearance the alberta director for the canadian taxpayers federation
00:22:51 uh chris always a pleasure thanks for coming on and happy new year happy new year thanks for
00:22:55 having us again so let's talk here about what saskatchewan is doing i i just laid the groundwork
00:23:01 here but effectively are they in legally iffy territory here or are they pretty soundly
00:23:07 protected that's a great question i think we're in kind of newer territory we've got an actual
00:23:13 you know we often hear people of the taxpayers federation email us and say something like i'm
00:23:17 not going to pay my taxes this year damn this government which you know we appreciate that
00:23:22 passion you got my email good yeah thanks so much for responding to our survey so so what we find 0.95
00:23:28 interesting here is that we've got the premier saying it so now there's a heck of a lot more on
00:23:35 the table and what's really neat to see is that uh premier scott moe has really kind of got this
00:23:41 confidence about him now and i like to think that it's often due to the fact that we have
00:23:47 have Danielle Smith as the Alberta Premier right next door. And so the two of them, I think, are
00:23:52 kind of in a bit of competition with each other on who can stand up to the Trudeau government
00:23:57 faster and more. And so what's interesting with Saskatchewan is that they have a crown corp when
00:24:03 it comes to their power regulation and power delivery. Now, quite often, we don't like crown
00:24:09 corporations because they can wind up being monopolistic. You don't have any competition
00:24:13 and it can go sideways. But with the fight with Ottawa, it's been very useful for him to be able
00:24:20 to do that. So much so that we've got Daniel Smith kind of going, hmm, maybe we should create
00:24:26 a temporary form of an Alberta Crown Corporation just as a mechanism to fight Trudeau's attack
00:24:32 on our energy sector. And so I think we're in pretty new territory here. I'd have to think long
00:24:38 and hard about when the last time was that a provincial leader stood up with this kind of force
00:24:44 saying, I'm refusing to collect your federal tax within my jurisdiction. We know that Quebec must 1.00
00:24:51 have said something like this sometime in the past, but this is definitely something big and
00:24:56 bold coming from the West. Yeah, I would agree. And I think that in the context of what Saskatchewan
00:25:03 is doing here, they're really doing an end run and a very creative end run around the federal
00:25:07 government. I'd say something analogous would be when Alberta said, we are not going to devote
00:25:12 police resources to enforcing the gun grab. It was really a move the federal government hadn't
00:25:17 anticipated and kind of was a bit checkmated on this. I'll ask you then in the context of how this
00:25:24 competition benefits people, because I agree. I mean, this one-upsmanship between Alberta and
00:25:28 Saskatchewan is great. I was in, I want to say it was Pigeon Forge or Gatlinburg. It was one of
00:25:33 these like tourist trap towns in Tennessee once, and they had a dollar store. And then you got
00:25:38 drive a little bit down the street and there was a 99 cent store. And across from that, there was a
00:25:42 98 cent store. And I was like, this is fantastic. I mean, they're probably all owned by the same
00:25:47 company, but like, I was like, this is great. I mean, what, what better way to, to be a consumer
00:25:50 than be in the midst of three businesses that are all vying for your consumerism here. And if you're
00:25:57 I think you and I were joking in the past, if you live in Lloydminster, which is that city that
00:26:02 straddles Saskatchewan and Alberta. You're getting the best of both worlds here. But
00:26:05 Canadians benefit when you have provinces that are wanting to really provide a better value for
00:26:12 their residents and for citizens here. But the flip side of this is that Alberta is not doing
00:26:18 everything perfect. The Alberta government this year reinstated as of yesterday the fuel tax. And
00:26:24 I know you were really just desperately hoping and pleading with the government on my show a couple
00:26:30 of weeks ago that they would walk this back. They didn't. So first off, how much is this for
00:26:35 Albertans? Yeah, this is really frustrating. And so just to focus on the positive again for a
00:26:41 second, it's the reason why we're really happy that Premier Daniel Smith and Premier Scott Mo
00:26:47 are standing up to Trudeau is because it usually saves people money and it provides more
00:26:52 accountability because typically the more local smaller government is going to be more accountable
00:26:58 and usually cheaper to operate than this big conglomerate amorphous thing that is called
00:27:05 Ottawa. And so that is why we're cheering them on when it comes to that sort of thing.
00:27:10 Unfortunately, you're right. It's a big head scratcher. So one year ago, Premier Daniel
00:27:16 Smith did the right thing. She fully suspended the Alberta fuel tax, which saved us 13 cents
00:27:22 per liter of gasoline and diesel. And it was big savings. It was like $10 a minivan, $15
00:27:28 a pickup truck, about $130 for a trucker to fill up his big rigs. When you add it all up province
00:27:33 wide, it was saving around $100 million a month. So big time savings. Now, technically, yes, it was
00:27:42 tied to the price of a barrel of oil. And when they announced the fuel tax suspension, they said,
00:27:48 hey, if the price of oil drops below a certain threshold, we're going to partially reimpose
00:27:54 this tax. So that's the math part. But the politics part a year ago is when the premier
00:28:00 announced why she was doing this. And the why matters here. She said she was doing this because
00:28:05 people were struggling to afford the basics, because inflation was still a huge problem,
00:28:10 and because Prime Minister Trudeau is obsessed with increasing his federal carbon tax. So she
00:28:15 saw this as kind of a shield against Ottawa. None of that stuff has changed. In fact, it's getting
00:28:22 worse. Trudeau is going to jack up the carbon tax in just a few weeks' time. But inexplicably,
00:28:28 the Treasury bureaucrats in Edmonton have gotten a hold of Nate Horner, the finance minister,
00:28:34 and whispered something into his ear, and they've now increased it. It's up to nine cents per litre.
00:28:41 So for the first time in a year, Albertans are not paying the lowest fuel taxes in all of Canada.
00:28:47 that title is actually now in manitoba with the ndp premier wab canoe
00:28:52 yeah and look i i think what you're saying there is valid and it's why temporary in terms of the
00:29:00 government lexicon is never something anyone should take to the bank but i'll ask you about
00:29:05 the why here because this would be an easy win for taxpayers to make this permanent is it just
00:29:11 that the government in alberta can't afford it is that their only rationale have they really defended
00:29:16 allowing this to go back on? That's what they're trying to say. But the problem here is that the
00:29:22 math is staring at us in the face. So great question. If they were teetering on the brink
00:29:29 of a deficit of not balancing the budget, the Taxpayers Federation and people like us would not
00:29:35 be clamoring for them to extend this fuel tax relief. We don't want to see deficits. We want
00:29:41 to see them running surpluses so they can pay down the debt, okay? Because the debt is a major
00:29:45 problem. We're spending billions of dollars on interest payments per year. That isn't the case
00:29:50 in Alberta. We have a $5.5 billion surplus right now on the books. They have a $5.5 billion surplus
00:30:00 after a year of not collecting this tax. So mathematically, it's a big head scratcher as well.
00:30:08 So even if, and they should, even if they kept their promise to put 50% of their cash surplus down on the debt, which they've agreed to do, fine. Andrew, they could still extend this by another six months and still have a more than a billion dollar surplus at budget time.
00:30:27 So this is again, like politically, mathematically, we don't get it.
00:30:32 This doesn't make any sense.
00:30:33 My only, my, my spidey sense is telling me that I think in Edmonton, I call it auto-wash
00:30:39 at the federal level.
00:30:41 I think in Alberta, you did, you do a lot of talk radio here.
00:30:44 Do they call it dome disease up in Edmonton?
00:30:46 Yeah, I think so.
00:30:47 They get under this dome and these bureaucrats at treasury start, these are the same people,
00:30:52 by the way, who want a PST.
00:30:54 Like they are not our friends.
00:30:56 you should not be listening to these people um my hunch is uh that the politicians the premier
00:31:02 the minister are catching a bit of dome disease and they're listening to the bureaucrats at treasury
00:31:07 and who love higher taxes well maybe we're overdue for another red lobster accord which uh if you
00:31:13 don't get the inside joke i'll explain it again later i have explained we have explained it in
00:31:17 the past i don't know if we've shown the uh the famous picture but uh the invitation we need
00:31:21 another conference yeah we have the red lobster accord uh all right chris timms we will talk to
00:31:26 you next monday thank you so much as always for your time happy new year all right thank you and
00:31:31 happy new year to you as well uh since we're uh keeping on a little bit of a provincial bent today
00:31:37 i wanted to turn from uh one area of provincial jurisdiction to another which is health care
00:31:43 uh not to say the provinces are always managing this issue as well as they need to be this is
00:31:49 probably no more acutely available and accessible to us than it is with wait times. Now, wait times
00:31:56 are not as much an issue as they are, or let me back up. We don't hear the discussion of it as
00:32:03 much as we did a few years ago even. There was a real pinch point where there was a crisis,
00:32:08 especially in Ontario, of people being treated in hallways. You had hospitals that had to develop
00:32:12 hallway medicine protocols but when we talk about access to health care especially to
00:32:18 surgeries which are very much important for people they're still in terrible terrible places we know
00:32:25 there are a number of studies that have pointed to how many canadians are just taking themselves
00:32:29 off the waitlist and going and paying out of pocket in the united states or elsewhere in the
00:32:34 world our friends over at secondstreet.org have been tracking this issue relentlessly and they
00:32:39 found that waitlists have increased by five percent with over 140 000 more canadians waiting
00:32:47 for surgery diagnostic scans or specialist appointments joining me is the president of
00:32:52 secondstreet.org colin craig colin always a pleasure thanks for coming on today well thanks
00:32:58 for the chat today and i appreciate it so obviously uh this is an issue that canadians if they don't
00:33:04 know about it's because they're fortunate enough to be not on the wait list any canadian who ever
00:33:08 tried to navigate the system is well aware of this here and uh we're not talking about examples of
00:33:14 people that are you know being turned away at emergency rooms because they had a heart attack
00:33:18 and they're not being treated but uh that is also not to say that these are not very crucial things
00:33:24 that people in canada are not able to readily access well that's right i mean this these numbers
00:33:30 that we've dug up we asked every province in the country a pretty straightforward question how many
00:33:35 people in your province are waiting for surgery a diagnostic scan or to see a specialist and
00:33:41 there are actually only three provincial governments that could tell us all three of those numbers
00:33:47 nova scotia quebec and alberta and the other provinces gave us either one of the numbers or
00:33:54 two of the numbers so there's a lot of holes in it we're looking at 3.1 million people waiting
00:33:59 for those important health care services and you alluded to it in many cases sadly those are a lot
00:34:06 of people that are suffering and we tried to be cautious and try to fill in some of those blanks
00:34:13 if you go to our website you've got this big grid with all the numbers the governments gave us
00:34:17 with a lot of holes and if you fill in the holes to try to look at what that big picture looks like
00:34:22 it's probably about 5.1 million Canadians that are waiting or to put this in plain English about one
00:34:28 in eight Canadians are on a wait list right now for health care services just
00:34:33 to just to jump on that point the issues that you had from the provincial
00:34:36 government is that a data collection issue or is it a transparency issue and
00:34:40 by that I mean do they have the numbers and they're not sharing them or are they
00:34:43 just not making it a point of finding these in front this data I think it's a
00:34:48 partially a data collection problem and to be blunt and incompetence problem if
00:34:54 you have a problem the first thing you need to do is understand how big it is
00:34:58 and understand how you're going to get rid of it or attack it, fight it, whatever you want to call it.
00:35:04 So if you're going to measure progress against how many people are waiting to see a specialist,
00:35:09 well, the first thing you got to do is figure out, okay, well, how many people are waiting right now
00:35:12 to see a specialist and how do we get that number down? And if you can't produce that number as a
00:35:16 provincial government, I think that's a problem. So yeah, I think it's a problem in terms of the
00:35:22 fact that they don't seem to collect the data centrally in some cases, and in other cases,
00:35:28 maybe just not even asking the question to find out well and to be more cynical on this not that
00:35:33 i try to be a cheery optimist sometimes but why would you want to collect the data if you know
00:35:38 what it will show and i think that's probably where we're seeing a little bit of this here
00:35:43 there's no motivation to go in and do an intensive deep dive into figures that are going to show
00:35:47 provinces are are not delivering the service they're supposed to yeah no that could be part
00:35:53 it i mean we've got to remember too that they can often give us some data but not others so they can
00:35:58 tell us right across the country pretty much with the exception of prince edward island how many
00:36:03 people are waiting for surgery um but we got to remember that quite often with healthcare issues
00:36:09 you don't always need surgery sometimes you need some kind of other intervention
00:36:13 medication or some kind of other change physiotherapy whatever it is it's often cases
00:36:19 where you don't need surgery and so you've got to meet with a specialist to find out what that
00:36:23 course of action is maybe need a diagnostic scan and so forth so uh it's troubling that you can't
00:36:29 get those numbers but like i said the numbers don't seem to be good there were some bright spots
00:36:33 though we saw some positive improvement over the past year in saskatchewan and manitoba and
00:36:39 quebec were a couple of the ones that we highlighted where we've seen some good progress
00:36:43 in terms of a number of people waiting i know that the third rail in canadian politics has
00:36:48 always been health care. I mean, any discussion about the system yields just this knee-jerk,
00:36:54 visceral, emotional reaction from people. We've had mixed court rulings on what you're able to do
00:37:00 as far as fee-based services and care. But one thing we know in the case of Quebec is that you
00:37:07 have the option to oftentimes go and get a service out of your own pocket. Now, that's not to say that
00:37:13 when you're paying as much in taxes as you are for provincial health care, that's just. But
00:37:18 if you're kind of just looking in self-preservation mode I get why people do that so for people outside
00:37:24 of Quebec though they don't have that opportunity available so they're either forced to just deal
00:37:28 with it or to leave the country are they not yeah that's basically it it's a real messy situation
00:37:35 it makes no sense whatsoever so you're right if you're living in Montreal and let's say you need
00:37:41 to get your hip done you have a few choices one of which is you could wait for the government to
00:37:45 provide you that hip operation and you get it done,
00:37:49 you walk out, you don't face a bill,
00:37:50 it's paid for through tax dollars.
00:37:53 You also have the option of going to a local clinic
00:37:57 in Montreal and get your hip done
00:37:59 or maybe in Quebec City or somewhere else.
00:38:01 You can pay for that privately and get it done fast
00:38:05 and you have that option, public system or private option.
00:38:08 Then obviously you have a third option,
00:38:09 which is to leave the province altogether,
00:38:13 to go to another country or other province whatever so quebec is unique uh the supreme
00:38:18 court of canada has given quebec uh this unique right the rest of the country you don't really
00:38:24 have that option there's a whole bunch of government regulations and barriers that mean
00:38:28 that you can't pay for example in vancouver to get your uh your hip operation and you have to
00:38:34 travel somewhere else so quite often you see people from vancouver fly to calgary and you
00:38:40 And you often see Calgarians do the same thing, they'll fly to Vancouver and pay for it.
00:38:44 There's some interesting things that are happening there where in Calgary is actually a clinic
00:38:50 that is enabled, it's a bit wonky, but they've been able to hire surgeons that are not part
00:38:56 of the public system whatsoever and you can actually now pay in Calgary for some private
00:39:02 surgery locally.
00:39:04 It's weird, it doesn't make any sense.
00:39:06 The problem is all these government regulations are gumming up the health care system.
00:39:11 They're leading to more people depending on the public system rather than some of those people deciding to pay privately.
00:39:17 And when that happens, you take pressure off of the public system and you reduce wait times in the public system.
00:39:23 And that's why no other developed nation on the country with universal health care does what Canada does.
00:39:28 They make it easy for patients to have that choice because it's better overall for results.
00:39:33 Yeah. And I want to talk about one of those ideas in a moment.
00:39:35 But just on the weird sort of situation you described there in Alberta, one of the things I find so obnoxious about this debate is that we don't really have the system that the universal health care activists think we do and kind of pretend we do, where it's not this truly 100% public system with nothing private whatsoever, because there are these weird loopholes and exceptions.
00:39:59 I mean, on one end, you have just people that have a friend of a friend who's a doctor that
00:40:05 can jump the line that way. But in other cases, you have a lot of clinics that operate in a very
00:40:10 weird legal gray area. I've talked to some people. In fact, I did a discussion on this very show,
00:40:16 and there was a private healthcare clinic in my city that does a combination of private and public
00:40:22 healthcare. And I had a lawyer on the same show who was saying, well, I'm not convinced that what
00:40:26 they're doing is legal and and the owner of the clinic said well yeah we are and here's why but
00:40:30 but people can't even quite agree with what the law says in some cases on on this stuff and then
00:40:35 you you further add to this patients just want a solution i like patients don't care where it comes
00:40:41 from and uh one of the points your colleague dom lucick wrote an op-ed for true north about this
00:40:46 and he said in the european union you can go to another eu country pay out of pocket and then be
00:40:51 reimbursed. Now, I'm never a big fan of government spending a lot of money. But my approach to this
00:40:57 would be if the government has said that you had a right to this, and they were going to pay for it
00:41:02 anyway, it shouldn't matter where you got it from. But that is a no go in Canada.
00:41:07 Yeah, you're right. I mean, it's sort of like taking the horse blinders off for governments,
00:41:11 right? We have this approach in this nation, largely where provincial governments think,
00:41:16 okay, this is how we're going to provide healthcare to Canadians. And they're thinking
00:41:20 within their own jurisdiction. Whereas what they do in the EU is they take the horse blinders off
00:41:25 and they say, well, wait, we can allow patients access to the entirety of Europe and allow them
00:41:31 if they want to go to another European country, they can go there, pay for surgery and then get
00:41:36 reimbursed by their home government. And it's not whatever they want to spend. It's up to what that
00:41:41 government would have spent locally. So if we give an example in Canada, let's say in Ontario there,
00:41:47 Andrew, that you need your hip operation. And let's say that the government's going to tell
00:41:52 you, well, they'll get to you next year. So in the meantime, you're in chronic pain, you're off work,
00:41:58 you're not making any money, you're dependent on the social assistance, whatever. It's a bad
00:42:04 situation all around. But if they said to you, Andrew, okay, if we give you this surgery next
00:42:09 year, it's going to cost $30,000 for us as a government to give it to you. We're going to
00:42:14 you the option of going somewhere else and you'll have access to thirty thousand dollars in
00:42:20 reimbursement well you might decide well look you know i've got a cousin in lithuania i'd love to
00:42:26 see that cousin i'm going to go over there see that cousin and at the same time i'll get my hip 0.99
00:42:31 operation because i can get it done for maybe 25 000 canadian and uh you know i'll actually save
00:42:37 the government some money well you'd have that option you could recover your cousin's place
00:42:42 whatever or maybe you go to tennessee or wherever you would have that option suddenly as a patient
00:42:46 you'd have access to thousands and thousands of places to get that surgery done around the world
00:42:53 and for the government it's it's positive because they can get you back to work faster you can start
00:42:59 working again paying taxes and so forth they're paying the money say this year instead of next
00:43:05 year in that example of lithuania you know they'd actually save a bit of money maybe if you went to
00:43:10 Tennessee it was 30,000 or maybe 35,000 it was 35,000 well then you're paying
00:43:15 that difference between the 30 and 35,000 but it's good for the government
00:43:20 because it helps helps them get you the care you need faster like so you get
00:43:25 back to work for other patients who decide not to go abroad for surgery well
00:43:29 they benefit too because now Andrew Lawton's not ahead of me in line he's
00:43:33 gone on to somewhere else I don't want to travel I want to get my surgery in
00:43:36 Ontario well it's still good for me because now I get to move up a spot in
00:43:39 line. So it's good for patients too. It's not a magical solution, but it can help in a time of
00:43:45 crisis. We're in a time of crisis. So it's an idea that we think that governments should give a look
00:43:50 at here in Canada. We've actually seen some governments kind of do this in Manitoba. They've
00:43:55 been sending patients all over the world to Ohio and California, British Columbia, and I believe
00:44:01 Alberta as well, sending them to private facilities where they can get their hips and their knees done 1.00
00:44:07 and whatever. That was one thing that they did to try and get their backlog down. And they've had
00:44:11 some positive results in Manitoba. The numbers are down about 21% for the surgeries that they
00:44:17 provided data for. So I think it's an option that could help. Yeah, very well said. You can read all
00:44:24 of this and more over at secondstreet.org. The president, Colin Craig, always good to talk to
00:44:28 you, sir. Thanks for coming on today. Thanks for having me, Andrew. Thank you very much. I will say
00:44:33 on the note of fee-based service, I wasn't going to tell this story because, well, it wasn't mine
00:44:38 to tell, but I think, I don't think she'd mind. My wife, when we were over in Egypt, which I
00:44:43 mentioned at the beginning, got quite sick. And we were at this one hotel. This is just before we
00:44:48 came back and we were kind of in the middle of nowhere. Like we were, there was nowhere to go
00:44:52 and no good way to get around. And she was sick, like not like critically ill, but like just needed
00:44:58 some drugs from a pharmacy. And I was like, I don't, didn't know where the pharmacy was,
00:45:03 how to go to the pharmacy. Uh, so the front desk was very helpful. They said, well, there's a
00:45:06 pharmacy, uh, not far from here. They'll deliver it for you tonight. And he gave me the number and
00:45:12 you know, I called up the guy and it was like, you know, she needed a couple of, uh, it was like
00:45:16 cough syrup and ibuprofen basically. And, uh, they said, we'll deliver it in 20 minutes and it's
00:45:23 going to cost you 180. And I was like, Ooh, that's a bit steep, but you know what? For like
00:45:28 delivery that seems, you know, whatever. And we were a bit desperate and they meant 180 Egyptian 1.00
00:45:33 pounds, which was $5 for the drugs and the delivery fee. So, uh, sometime, not, not that
00:45:39 Egypt's healthcare. I don't, I don't know if it's good or bad, but, uh, sometimes you can get things
00:45:43 for a bit cheaper than you think, uh, elsewhere. So, uh, welcome to you all. If you're coming in
00:45:48 and happy new year, we will talk to you in just 23 hours and 15 minutes with more of the Andrew
00:45:53 Lawton Show on True North. Thank you. God bless and good day to you all. Thanks for listening to
00:45:59 the Andrew Lawton Show. Support the program by donating to True North at www.tnc.news.
00:46:23 We'll be right back.