Juno News - November 25, 2022


Justin Trudeau Testifies | Emergencies Act Inquiry

Topics
Mentioned
Chrystia Freeland Testifies | Emergencies Act Inquiry The winners and losers of the pandemic

Episode Stats


Length

6 hours

Words per minute

128.58

Word count

46,357

Sentence count

962

Harmful content

Misogyny

4

sentences flagged

Toxicity

3

sentences flagged

Hate speech

2

sentences flagged


Summary

Summaries generated with gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ .

Our next witness, Prime Minister Justin Trudeau, takes the stand before the Public Order Emergency Commission on February 14th, 2019. He is the final witness to be interviewed by Commission Council, and his testimony will be heard in two parts. The first part will cover the chronology of events leading up to the declaration of a public order emergency, and the second part will focus on his perspective on the events of that day.

Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Topics generated with Qwen2.5-3B-Instruct.
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 Thank you.
00:00:30 Thank you.
00:01:00 Thank you.
00:01:30 Thank you.
00:02:00 Thank you.
00:02:30 Thank you.
00:03:00 Thank you.
00:03:30 Thank you.
00:04:00 Thank you.
00:04:30 Thank you.
00:05:00 Thank you.
00:05:30 Thank you.
00:06:00 Thank you.
00:06:30 Thank you.
00:07:00 Thank you.
00:07:30 Thank you.
00:08:00 Thank you.
00:08:30 Thank you.
00:09:00 Thank you.
00:09:30 Thank you.
00:10:00 Thank you.
00:10:30 Thank you.
00:10:59 lot order a lot the Public Order Emergency Commission is now in session
00:11:12 that comes on so they thought they just say man over okay good morning so we're
00:11:19 at the last day of the public hearings on the facts there will be of course the
00:11:26 public hearings on policy matters so I think we're ready for the next witness
00:11:46 Commission Council for the Commission our next and final witnesses Prime
00:11:51 Mr. Justin Trudeau.
00:11:52 Wow
00:12:06 Um, maybe we'll take a few minutes, uh, I'm not sure where, what process is, a bit anti-climactic.
00:12:31 uh so should we take five minutes i think we'll take five minutes then and see and you can come
00:12:41 and get me when it uh it is thank you the commission is in recent for five minutes
00:12:46 the commission go ahead it's a it's just a bit of a false start nothing to do with
00:13:00 your appearance i could you're welcome uh to come in obviously we're happy to get started
00:13:08 i can wait this piece more and we're affirmed mr prime minister will you swear on a religious
00:13:12 document or do you wish to affirm j'aimerais le faire sur la bible s'il vous plaît
00:13:32 pour la fin de procès verbal s'il vous plaît veuille indiquer et ensuite
00:13:36 and then repeat your name in the entire way.
00:13:40 Yes, I affirm.
00:13:44 Justin Trudeau, J-U-S-T-I-N-T-R-U-D-E-A-U.
00:13:48 Jerez-vous que le témoignage que vous allez rendre
00:13:52 devant la Commission sur la vérité, toute la vérité et rien que la vérité que je vous mets en aide?
00:13:56 Je l'affirme. Merci.
00:14:00 Merci.
00:14:04 just uh uh before we get started there as i understand it as you heard there will probably
00:14:15 be some testimony in english and some in french so please if you need uh uh translation equipment
00:14:24 you should have it in hand
00:14:26 good morning prime minister morning thank you for being here uh so we'll start with the routine
00:14:37 housekeeping uh you recall being interviewed by commission council on september 9th of this year
00:14:42 yes okay and after that interview commission council prepared a summary of your interview
00:14:47 yes um for the record we don't need to call it up mr clerk but it's wts.5084
00:14:54 and prime minister uh you reviewed that summary and and you can confirm that it's accurate to
00:14:59 the best of your knowledge yes okay and i'll add there that of course it's a summary it's
00:15:04 not an exact transcript of your words but it's a prepared summary and we're all aware of that
00:15:09 so prime minister as you know you are the final witness to testify before the commission so at
00:15:14 this point the commission has heard a lot of evidence about uh the events of january and
00:15:19 February, leading up to your government's decision to declare a public order emergency
00:15:25 on February 14th. But what we haven't heard yet is your perspective. So your own perspective,
00:15:31 your viewpoint, both as the Prime Minister leading the country through these events and
00:15:36 the decision maker in the government's ultimate decision to invoke the Emergencies Act for
00:15:40 the first time in that act's history. So we have two hours together this morning, and
00:15:46 I anticipate that the examination is gonna proceed
00:15:49 in two parts.
00:15:49 The first part will consist of fairly specific questions
00:15:53 taking you through the chronology of events,
00:15:56 often with reference to documents
00:15:58 that have been adduced before the commission,
00:16:00 readouts of your own calls.
00:16:02 And the second part will consist
00:16:04 of some bigger picture questions.
00:16:06 So addressing some of the key themes
00:16:09 that have arisen out of these events
00:16:10 and the government's response to it.
00:16:16 So let's start with the chronology of events, and I'll warn you, we're going to fly through
00:16:24 this pretty quickly. Two hours is not a lot of time to fly through everything that happened
00:16:28 between these days, but if ever you feel like you need to add in some narrative or explanation,
00:16:35 please feel free to do so. So we'll start with just the pre-arrival days, so before the convoy
00:16:40 arrived in Ottawa. We know that you learned the convoy was on its way a few days before,
00:16:45 maybe around january 24th and you were briefed on it by both officials from pco and your own staff
00:16:52 from pmo can you recall what your expectation was at that point so you've been briefed the
00:16:59 convoi is on its way what did you anticipate was going to happen on a view pendant
00:17:06 During the months that have been preceded, there was a level of frustration and dissatisfaction
00:17:15 with the government policies regarding the mandate, regarding the vaccination.
00:17:20 And we had heard a lot of rhetoric from several people across the country.
00:17:29 It was also a reflection of what we had seen during the electoral campaign, which was passed
00:17:34 six months ago.
00:17:35 Alors, de voir que ces groupes allaient venir manifester à Ottawa, on s'attendait un petit peu au genre de rhétorique et à l'intensité qu'on avait vue, mais on a régulièrement des manifestations à travers le pays.
00:17:59 On est vigilant, on est attentif, mais on se prépare dans la mesure du possible.
00:18:06 Vous avez parlé de la campagne électorale. Pouvez-vous dire un peu plus sur ce sujet?
00:18:12 Bien, la campagne électorale avait été un moment où on a pu consulter les Canadiens directement sur les mesures qu'on voulait amener pour protéger la santé publique,
00:18:28 c'est-à-dire spécifiquement des exigences de vaccination pour quiconque voulait embarquer dans un train ou dans un avion,
00:18:36 ou bien travailler pour la fonction publique fédérale.
00:18:41 Et c'était des gros enjeux, une grosse décision de limiter l'accès au transport fédéral comme ça.
00:18:50 Donc, pour moi, c'était important que les Canadiens puissent se prononcer sur cet enjeu-là.
00:18:55 C'est sûr qu'on le faisait ancré dans les recommandations de santé publique, dans le désir de garder les gens en santé, en sécurité.
00:19:05 Mais je pense que c'était tout à fait approprié qu'on ait des débats robustes à travers le pays sur ces enjeux-là.
00:19:13 Et c'est exactement ce qu'on a eu pendant les élections. Il y avait plusieurs partis qui étaient en faveur de ce que nous, on proposait.
00:19:20 Il y en avait d'autres qui étaient farouchement opposés.
00:19:23 Et les Canadiens, pendant cette campagne électorale, ont pu se prononcer.
00:19:28 Mais ce qu'on a aussi vu, et ce que moi et mon équipe et mes candidats ont vu en particulier,
00:19:34 c'est un niveau de manifestation, de frustration et d'agression,
00:19:49 ou au moins d'intensité d'émotion par rapport à cette campagne-là, par rapport à ce que nous proposions,
00:19:58 qui était pire et plus intense que tout ce qu'on avait vécu dans d'autres campagnes électorales ou dans d'autres événements politiques.
00:20:07 Donc, on voyait qu'il y avait une intensité potentielle qui était là pendant la campagne électorale,
00:20:16 qu'on a vu à quelques reprises dans les mois qui ont suivi et qu'on soupçonnait s'en venait peut-être à Ottawa pour ce qu'on voit.
00:20:24 Okay, so just to sum that up, I'll switch back to English.
00:20:28 I think we'll probably be switching back and forth a few times.
00:20:33 You saw the protest coming and you've been briefed on it.
00:20:36 And as you said, Ottawa is used to dealing with big protests,
00:20:40 but there was maybe a hint that something could be a little bit different here.
00:20:44 So there was a hint of worry there.
00:20:45 And then, of course, we know that the convoy arrived on, started arriving on the 28th and then went into full swing on the 29th.
00:20:55 What was that first weekend like when the convoy arrived from your point of view?
00:20:59 Well, first of all, one of the things that we noted in the run-up to the arrival was a bit of a disconnect between what the sort of political arms of my office were seeing and expecting from what we'd seen on social media,
00:21:22 colored by our experiences from the campaign uh that was only a few months before contrasted with
00:21:31 the assurances by um whether it was ottawa police services or even the public service
00:21:38 that this was just a normal quote unquote style of protest that we see on the hill fairly regularly
00:21:49 And there was already a little bit of worry that this might be a different brand of event than Canadians were used to seeing.
00:22:00 And we certainly saw during the first weekend that the expectations that the police had said that they would simply go home, the ability to keep it under control was not exactly there.
00:22:19 okay and i think starting on that sunday um you made a few calls to various mps in your
00:22:25 ottawa caucus sort of checking in and seeing how people were doing because there was a level of
00:22:30 concern there so um on that note i'll ask mr clerk to please pull up ssm.can.nsc402813
00:22:43 while that's being pulled up it's a it's a readout of a call that you had on sunday january 30th
00:22:48 with yasser nakfi just for the benefit of everyone in the room can you tell us who
00:22:53 gastronomy is yes sir is the member of parliament for uh ontario for ottawa center okay perfect
00:23:00 so if we can just scroll down to the text here mr there we go um so hey astor how are you pm
00:23:08 how are you doing and how are folks in the community and mr nakfi says very dire community
00:23:15 feels under siege you can imagine number of trucks rigs honking for them it's a party but
00:23:21 they forget it's also a neighborhood especially low-income families i've been getting a lot of
00:23:26 feedback also been in touch with marco that's mr manichino bill i assume minister blair and
00:23:32 local officials finding ways to make sure these folks are not part of residential streets tonight
00:23:37 will be challenging and you say i feel so gutted for so many people who are just in such a difficult
00:23:43 situation it's not just disruption but there's a lot of hateful rhetoric going on are you seeing
00:23:48 some of that and mr nazi says it's unbelievable the images that we see are hard to believe
00:23:54 saw a life-size poster on a truck of hitler and your name underneath this is the kind of grossness
00:24:00 our country is subject to i have constituents being yelled at for wearing masks while out doing
00:24:06 normal chores there are all kinds of issues people are facing in the neighborhood i don't know if
00:24:11 they can sleep at night um and you then reply there doesn't seem like much clarity on how long
00:24:16 this will last and then you refer to something an incident at the shepherd of good uh of good hope
00:24:23 and then finally your last comment here is i'm so sorry my friend this is just horrible
00:24:28 the rcmp is concerned everyone's on eggshells having this going on in our nation's capital
00:24:33 is just totally irresponsible so i just to some extent that's self-explanatory um but i'm wondering
00:24:39 if you can help us a little bit in in explaining the context of that call and what mr knockview was
00:24:45 referring to and what you'd observed yourself well i i dare say that citizens of ottawa are
00:24:51 used to political activity and protests on on the hill on a range of things but this was
00:24:59 present and in their daily lives and disrupting their weekend in a way that wasn't a usual
00:25:09 political protest um from from the intimidation and harassment of people for wearing masks
00:25:16 uh to uh a very concerning story about uh folks um disrupting the the nearby homeless shelter and
00:25:26 soup kitchen um there are there were indications that there was a level of um
00:25:35 disregard for others that unfortunately we had seen examples of uh during the election campaign
00:25:43 uh and it it emphasized for me that this was the same kind of thing uh that we had seen the
00:25:50 the intensity the anger um the hateful rhetoric okay moving on then mr clerk to the next document
00:25:58 ssm.can.nsc402812 so prime minister this is moving on to the next day so that
00:26:08 that'll be monday 31st um i think at some point there was uh some hope or expectation that the
00:26:13 convoy might disperse by monday but it didn't and at that point you have a call with mayor jim
00:26:19 watson of ottawa we'll just look at a a couple of things here uh the initial reference is to a press
00:26:26 conference you've done and he tells you you hit it at the park hit all the right notes uh and then
00:26:32 says these people had their time and need to move on so he's very and he's trying to get this across
00:26:37 to the chief of police uh be chief slowly so um mayor watson was obviously very focused on on
00:26:43 putting an end to the protest if he can uh scrolling down then that last bit jw that's
00:26:50 mayor watson chief of police said it's so volatile but kept under control so far trucks are starting 0.64
00:26:58 to leave but the diehards chained themselves for this to this it's unfortunate for people living
00:27:03 in the neighborhood um chief of police spoke to chief lucky and we need more a few more sources
00:27:09 i think that probably means resources and you say that's for sure and then it goes on we uh sorry he
00:27:15 says a little more we have to do this with a sense of balance these guys are just looking for a fight
00:27:21 and your comment back to on that just down a bit mr clerk is the remainders will have no choice
00:27:28 but to incite as a counterbalance so we all have to be careful can you explain those last few
00:27:34 comments and that the balance and counterbalance you were you were referring to there can you scroll
00:27:38 back up to the the okay no just keep both that Jim's line and mine on the on the screen there we
00:27:44 go um yeah I mean these calls were very much about me understanding uh what's happening from
00:27:58 a local a local sense and you know there was expression in the in this uh that there were
00:28:04 some people who are more intense in the protests than others some were just along to be part of
00:28:09 something that they agreed with others were really shaping it and driving driving it uh and i think
00:28:15 um i believe i'm not entirely sure what i was saying there i'm not sure the transcript is
00:28:22 exactly right either but it it's enough this sense that we didn't want to further provoke
00:28:29 uh but we need to be firm and standing up for people uh we need to encourage people to leave
00:28:34 but if they see their um that the numbers are starting to dwindle the ones who remain
00:28:40 will be more intense so there's a sense already that as we as we manage this we have to be
00:28:47 careful we want to make sure that we support and protect people living in the city that we're
00:28:52 We're allowing for life to get to normal despite this protest
00:28:59 without inciting any reactions that amplify the thing further.
00:29:09 Okay. That's helpful. Thank you.
00:29:12 The next one, Mr. Clerk, is ssm.can.nsc402814.
00:29:20 So now we're at Wednesday, February 2nd, and this is a call that you have with Anita Vandenbald.
00:29:29 So again, can you tell us, Prime Minister, who Anita Vandenbald is?
00:29:32 Anita is a Member of Parliament for Ottawa-Nepean East, or I believe that's it. 0.74
00:29:40 Anyway, she's just to the west of downtown.
00:29:46 count. She's a longtime MP and a very strong community member of Parliament. And she was 0.74
00:29:58 expressing here just how the tone of and the tenor of this, what was going on in the neighborhoods
00:30:11 and around people was worse and more hateful and different from anything she had seen before
00:30:18 in a number of years as an MP, but a long time involved in political engagement.
00:30:25 So you remember this call?
00:30:26 Yes, I do, very much.
00:30:28 Okay, so we'll just read through a little bit of what Ms. Vandebelt said.
00:30:33 Starting there, you say, I wanted to check in, how are you doing?
00:30:36 She says, I really appreciate it.
00:30:38 i'm torn i'm scared but i get really mad that i'm scared kids with autism the noise it's one of
00:30:45 those things you feel like it's okay well it's awful i'm not a stranger to volatile environments
00:30:50 but it's different because i know the sentiment is directed towards us you particularly there's
00:30:56 this hate for liberals and then after that i do think it may deter some young women looking into
00:31:01 politics um i see i don't want anything to happen to one of us god forbid you before we start 0.86
00:31:08 thinking about all of this and then she speaks about constituents calling about what the pm is
00:31:13 going to do about it it's hard and she says it's hard because i know it's not within your purview
00:31:18 people are frustrated and they just want somebody to do something to get the city back
00:31:23 and then she speaks about some some other hateful messages that she's uh she's observed and you say
00:31:29 it's about how you balance it again being responsible and reasonable so the part of
00:31:33 this that i'd like you to speak to prime minister is where she says a lot of constituents are
00:31:39 calling me about what the pm what the prime minister is going to do about this and she said
00:31:43 she then says it's hard because i know it's not within your purview so what does that refer to
00:31:49 that as she refers to one of the one of the challenges and and things that we were struggling
00:31:55 with from the early days of the pandemic of the of the convoy occupation which is that
00:32:02 because they were very visibly most motivated to protest the federal government and federal
00:32:10 government policies even though many of the mandates they were actually vocally concerned
00:32:15 about were provincial measures but it was very clear that they had targeted ottawa and the seat
00:32:21 of our federal government deliberately that it was a federal protest in a city that houses the
00:32:28 capital there is an impression and an expectation that therefore it's ottawa or sorry it's the
00:32:36 federal government's responsibility uh to deal with it to uh make sure that it goes away to stop
00:32:42 it it's there is a a general expectation even by people who are long-time residents of ottawa
00:32:48 that this is somehow like Washington, D.C.,
00:32:53 that is a separate enclave where the RCMP can give out traffic tickets,
00:32:58 which they don't.
00:32:59 But there is a blending of orders of government
00:33:03 in protection of Parliament Hill and the precinct
00:33:06 that led a lot of people to say,
00:33:08 well, they're here, they're angry at the Prime Minister,
00:33:11 they're disrupting my neighbourhood.
00:33:13 Federal government should really do something
00:33:15 to get rid of these protesters or or move them along or have them leave where we were continually
00:33:24 explaining as anita said it's not in our purview the management of wellington street of neighborhoods
00:33:32 around was the jurisdiction of the ottawa police services and if they needed support the opp
00:33:39 and then the rcmp could be providing extra supports but it was their jurisdiction
00:33:44 but of course anyone who's involved in politics you can be a a federal mp walking through your
00:33:49 your riding and someone complains about garbage pickup uh they don't want you hear you say oh no
00:33:54 that's not a federal issue that's municipal they say um thank you i'll i'll make sure we pass that
00:34:00 message along we'll try and see sure that that gets fixed um the idea that i was saying um this is not
00:34:06 a federal policing issue this is not a federal issue this this occupation this is something that
00:34:13 ottawa police jurisdiction need to need to take care of um for a lot of people sort of say well
00:34:18 let's see them they're here because of the federal government and the federal government is refusing
00:34:22 to do anything about it uh was the kind of blending of narratives that that we had to be really
00:34:29 careful about all right i think we're going to come back to that when i start asking about
00:34:34 ontario's initial response to all of this but we're not quite there yet so i'll take you a few
00:34:39 few more things and then i'll ask you to pick up where you left off there um so so far we've been
00:34:44 looking at some calls you've had with your your own mps mps from your caucus the next one uh mr
00:34:50 clerk you can pull up it's ssn.can407738 is a call that you had with excuse me on february 3rd
00:34:59 candace bergen who i believe had just become leader of the opposition in the house i confess
00:35:04 i was yesterday years old when i learned that but uh i now know um okay so this is a call you then
00:35:11 have on wednesday february 3rd uh with ms bergen and and do you recall this do you remember this
00:35:16 call prime minister yes i do and can you tell us what inspired that call or it was mostly a
00:35:21 congratulatory call when uh someone becomes uh leader of a political party that's opposite us
00:35:28 in the house i i tend to reach out and have a bit of a personal conversation i usually ask after
00:35:35 family see how how they're adjusting to it to maybe give some recommendations about trying to
00:35:40 get enough sleep uh but i try and keep it a human introductory call even though i had engaged with
00:35:46 her many times uh in the house over the over the years as an mp um when she became leader i wanted
00:35:53 to reach out and establish that personal contact of course it was all happening in the context of
00:35:59 this uh this uh occupation uh going on so that was part of the discussion but primarily it was
00:36:06 a congratulatory call okay got enough sleep is always good advice um mr click can we scroll down
00:36:11 a little bit here we see there we go okay so this is the part of the conversation that um
00:36:19 you start talking about the the security situation in Ottawa you say uh the second
00:36:24 set of briefing would be security situation in Ottawa right now obviously a real concern
00:36:30 and we have lots of disagreement on causes and path forward I would certainly like to make sure
00:36:34 you you're getting briefings on safety and the situation and have you at least fully informed
00:36:40 hopefully we're we're all going to be able to make sure Canada's democracy continues to run
00:36:46 and our institutions remain strong and quite frankly the citizens of ottawa get back to the
00:36:50 regular lives scroll down again please to the next page mr clerk so miss bergen says absolutely i
00:36:56 agree i'm sure you weren't following question period today but that's what i'd like to see
00:37:01 some resolution you're right we disagree on some things but i would agree with you the goal is let's
00:37:07 find a way for people to head back home and clear things up in ottawa we do want the same things if
00:37:13 you have some ideas or some things you think could be done extending an olive branch is one way of
00:37:19 putting it we'd love to be able to work together to make that happen all of us and you say in reply
00:37:25 all of us need to focus on getting the temp down the temperature down and getting people back to
00:37:30 normal lives let's ensure there are discussions on that and there may be opportunities to work
00:37:36 together some of them i think you're referring to the protesters there have jammed themselves into
00:37:41 a counter in a corner and they're asked for non-starters we have our democracy and our
00:37:47 institutions that is well worth defending there are ways we can get beyond this i'm worried about
00:37:52 setting a precedent where if anyone wants something they can set up a blockade on wellington street
00:37:58 people need to be heard and that's part of our democracy and getting that balance right
00:38:02 miss bergen says she agrees with everything you said i think that you do have to be cautious
00:38:08 and as pm you don't want to set a bad precedent i'm sure you're talking and come up coming up
00:38:13 with some ideas and then she offers to help um so the part of that that i'd like to i'd like you to
00:38:18 elaborate on is it appears there that you're talking and i take it the olive branch is a
00:38:23 suggestion of some of some engagement with the protesters some talking to in in whatever capacity
00:38:29 that would end up being um so what comes out of this conversation that you have in this bergen
00:38:35 with miss bergen and what was in your mind at the time um i i say you know we have um
00:38:44 ensure there are discussions on that let's ensure there are discussions on that was very much
00:38:48 uh let's make sure as political parties we keep talking about it keeping up figuring out how
00:38:54 we can work together um and then you know some of their asks are non-starters like
00:39:00 overturning the results of the election that we just had but in terms of responding to their
00:39:09 demands or or legitimizing them by engaging I'm highlighting that I'm worried about setting a
00:39:15 precedent that a blockade on Wellington Street can can lead to changing public policy people
00:39:21 need to be heard but we need to get that balance right and then she agreed that I need to be
00:39:27 cautious and i don't want to set any bad precedents okay so fairly self-explanatory
00:39:33 a willingness to to discuss but you you were concerned about setting a precedent where
00:39:39 uh a blockade could equal a a change in public policy is that fair yeah i think we we have
00:39:48 a robust functioning democracy and uh protests public protests are an important part of making
00:39:56 sure we're getting messages out there and canadians are getting messages out there and
00:39:59 highlighting how they feel about various issues uh but using protests to demand uh changes to
00:40:09 public policy um is something that that i think is is is worrisome okay um so thank you mr although
00:40:18 sorry to a certain no no please go on yeah protest if you're out protesting that the government is
00:40:22 you know shutting down a safe injection site or something you are asking for changes in public
00:40:27 policy but there is a difference between uh occupations uh and and you know saying we're not
00:40:37 going until this has changed uh in a way that is massively disruptive uh and potentially dangerous
00:40:44 uh versus just saying yeah we're protesting because we want uh we want public policy to
00:40:49 change and we're trying to convince people to get enough of them that politicians will listen to
00:40:54 enough people saying okay i'm going to lose votes if i don't change this that's the usual way uh
00:41:01 protests uh can be effective in in our democracies okay that's a fair point of distinction thank you
00:41:07 um mr clerk the next document is ssm.can.nsc402819 so prime minister we're now heading into the the
00:41:18 second weekend of the protest so saturday february 3rd um and our understanding is that the protest
00:41:24 intensified again um with more more trucks coming into ottawa uh and on that day on the saturday you
00:41:31 have a call with the governor general mary simon do you recall do you remember that call yes i do
00:41:35 okay so here is the the readout of it and we'll just go through some of quite a bit of actually
00:41:41 what was said on that call um so again there's the introduction and um you say it's been stressful
00:41:49 not so much for me personally the governor general says yes they seem reluctant to give it up also
00:41:56 makes it challenging and you say yep people blame the feds but many of the mandates not us
00:42:04 and for the police well we don't direct them trying to get resolved as peacefully as possible
00:42:10 want them to find a way to save face but they can't shut down our democracy sorry they're
00:42:15 trying to pull you into this also they just don't understand the institutions uh and then the
00:42:20 governor general asked to go further on that actually i'll stop there do you remember what
00:42:25 you're referring to in that paragraph there uh yeah that was the uh i believe it was a a memorandum
00:42:32 of understanding that uh some groups within or some group within the protesters uh had
00:42:40 declared that what they wanted was to empower the senate to work with the governor general to
00:42:46 create a provisional government or uh and or chain take take a point a government committee
00:42:53 uh that would change public policy um and displayed a lack of understanding of of uh of
00:43:00 how our democracy and our institutions actually work okay um but i mean it also meant she was
00:43:07 getting bombarded uh the rito hall uh which is filled with good people giving out medals to
00:43:13 worthy canadians uh were bombarded constantly uh by uh um by demands that she fire the prime minister
00:43:22 uh and and in a very very aggressive way and that's that's what i was referring to as tough
00:43:28 for her and tough for her team understood and is that what prompted this call um could have been
00:43:35 part of it but i also speak regularly with the with the governor general just to check in and
00:43:39 obviously this was something that was worthwhile checking in on but yes that was probably the
00:43:44 reason fair enough um okay so then she asked if there's any sense on how it will be resolved and
00:43:50 you say something and then uh now they're starting to do that bill blair has handled a lot in the
00:43:56 past and we know uh we've heard a lot from bill blair at the commission as well um this is not
00:44:01 a protest more an occupation hard to diffuse it will take time being very careful to not try to
00:44:08 fix something we don't have the tools for and then there's some discussion with the funding
00:44:12 can you scroll down a bit mr clerk um onto the next page please and then she's the governor
00:44:21 general says yeah there's some some of the senior staff getting a lot of hateful emails asking for
00:44:28 the governor general to fire the prime minister and to create these crazy things it's difficult
00:44:33 to receive these things they made a website in my name saying stuff i have to let it slide off
00:44:38 our backs and then you discuss the security situation so is that where you were just
00:44:42 referring to prime minister and sort of bombardment okay um so just generally speaking before we move
00:44:51 on what was your sense of of where things were at on that second weekend um
00:44:58 the first weekend it caught everyone by surprise uh through the second weekend i think i mentioned
00:45:05 it in in referring to bill blair um talking with the local police with his his own expertise and
00:45:12 and background um talking about things that can be done uh to try to de-escalate to start putting
00:45:19 an end to this understanding that it can't happen overnight but that there are things that should be
00:45:24 done there was an expectation or a hope that on that second weekend we would see um a decrease
00:45:33 in activity uh and a dwindling uh instead we saw a surge on that second weekend and things that we
00:45:42 had heard that you know the police were going to start doing this or doing that and we're going to
00:45:48 be able to respond didn't seem to be materializing there was a sense that that the
00:45:59 occupation was just continuing uh full swing without uh without any real
00:46:07 control or or even plan to end it and i know from conversations with mps and others
00:46:16 that the citizens of Ottawa were quite frantic about having to go through a second weekend of
00:46:23 horns and disruptions and being yelled at for wearing masks and not being able to
00:46:30 go to their neighbourhood stores and seeing the Rideau Centre shut down and all these different
00:46:34 things that were really problematic. And people were starting to get pretty upset that this was
00:46:40 you know, two full weekends that they were being massively disrupted by.
00:46:46 Okay. Thank you, Mr. Clerk. Take that one down. So speaking of getting a little upset,
00:46:52 the next topic I want to address with you is Ontario's initial response to the protest in
00:46:58 those early weeks. So one theme that's emerged from the evidence we've heard, and we've seen
00:47:03 this several references to it in the documents, is your government's frustration and your own
00:47:09 frustration with um what might be characterized as a certain reluctance on the part of ontario to
00:47:15 to engage especially in the tripartite tables that um minister blair i think had put together so
00:47:21 uh mr clerk can you pull up ssm.can.nsc402837
00:47:30 this is uh the readout from a call that you had prime minister with mayor jim watson on february
00:47:35 okay so just keep scrolling a bit mr clerk uh past the key takeaways on to page two
00:47:50 um so just to stop there give a bit of situation so mr mayor watson here brings up the expression
00:47:57 whack-a-mole which we've heard several times in the commission um fighting a losing battle
00:48:03 we don't have enough police um and and you reply that well that's entirely right i don't i know
00:48:10 we're looking carefully at that we're looking at the resourcing and then you say on the ottawa
00:48:15 policing side you've seen as i have some concerns on how things were handled from the beginning and
00:48:21 then you ask about uh mayor watson's relationship with the police chief and and how they're working
00:48:26 together and you observe that there are moments where mayor watson is saying one thing and the
00:48:32 chief is saying another and ask if if there's anything you can do about that so just briefly
00:48:36 before we go on can you comment on that a little bit and and the ottawa policing situation to the
00:48:41 extent that you were briefed on and aware of it one of the things we'd said from the very beginning
00:48:48 uh to the rcmp uh and to the commission the rcmp and and to um government in general uh that if
00:48:57 there was anything we could do to support the ottawa police services in their in what they
00:49:02 were doing if we had resources or abilities because you know there is a federal presence in
00:49:08 in this capital city um we should do it that we were there to be helpful i instructed brenda to
00:49:15 try and do whatever whatever she could to send support to uh to uh to the city of ottawa what
00:49:22 we got back or what we had heard as i recall were different numbers from what the mayor said
00:49:30 ottawa needed to what the police chief was saying they needed and the one thing that
00:49:38 the commissioner made clear to me was they needed to know that if they were deploying
00:49:45 resources that they were going to be appropriately used that there was a plan
00:49:49 for that and you know we see it sometimes in requests for assistance across the country
00:49:55 uh where someone will say we need 20 000 police officers or from or we need we need the military
00:50:01 to come in with a thousand troops or we need this or that in in rfas uh and part of our due diligence
00:50:08 is okay what do you need them for what are you going to be doing for because for example if
00:50:13 if you're sending in military as we did in in hurricane fiona uh to help clear power lines
00:50:21 as was necessary in atlantic canada in no situation do military members engage in policing
00:50:31 activity and there was a sense that maybe they could be directing traffic and we have to make
00:50:35 sure no they're not police military isn't there to play police roles and that that's why we always
00:50:41 have questions that okay we're going to send resources but we need to know how how they're
00:50:46 going to be deployed and there wasn't always that clarity around what the plan was how many they
00:50:51 actually needed uh how they were being used and how they were uh you know how where they were
00:50:57 going to be best deployed okay um just keep scrolling down please mr clerk i'll tell you
00:51:04 want to stop uh keep going please oh no i'm sorry i missed it there we go uh so mayor watson says
00:51:12 i'm gonna ask after this phone call whether the federal government will live up to its commitment
00:51:17 we need boots on the ground very shortly it's not dying down took over metcalf street blocked all of
00:51:22 it and you reply listen yes yes you can say the federal government will be here there with more
00:51:28 resources but again the thing that frustrates me and everyone is conflated but doug ford has been
00:51:34 hiding from his responsibility on it for political reasons as you highlighted and important i suppose
00:51:41 it's important that we don't let them get away from that we intend to support you on that and
00:51:46 mayor watson replies if they keep dragging their feet i'm happy to call them out on it it would
00:51:50 be nice if we got something firmed up with the federal government to shame them ford didn't even
00:51:55 make an effort to come and see what's going on so can i just ask you prime minister to comment a bit
00:52:00 on on the politics that are going on there um well first of all when i say every everyone is
00:52:06 i believe is conflating it was conflating you know a federal protest of federal issues with
00:52:11 a federal responsibility to do the policing that would dissipate that that protest so that was
00:52:16 Sorry, a little bit of an interplay that there was a sense that in the initial phases of the protest, the Ontario government was happy for the perception to be out there that this was a city of Ottawa issue and a federal government issue.
00:52:40 and that as a province, they really didn't have a responsibility or a jurisdiction to play in there.
00:52:48 It was an unpleasant situation. There were bad headlines.
00:52:52 I was getting grumbled at by citizens of Ottawa every day because the federal government wasn't dealing with it.
00:53:00 I can understand that provincial politicians who were being overlooked in the complaints everyone had
00:53:06 about why this wasn't getting resolved would say you know what let's let's not poke our noses into
00:53:12 this and and uh you know people will continue criticizing those people that help i'm fairly
00:53:17 certain that behind the scenes um the opp was engaged with ottawa police services and was
00:53:24 providing supports as as we as we were as a federal government but i think at the political level
00:53:29 there was probably a decision to continue to stay back a little bit and let us wear it a little bit.
00:53:37 What we had seen during the pandemic and during other crises
00:53:42 is when the three orders of government are able to work seamlessly together,
00:53:48 not only does it deliver better results and better coordination,
00:53:53 But it actually reassures citizens to see that people who are not always politically aligned at the highest levels can roll up their sleeves and work for the benefit of citizens.
00:54:08 And that's certainly something that I've always tried to do and I've been able to do with Premier Ford on many, many issues.
00:54:14 But at this point in the evolution of the occupation, that wasn't something that we were able to do.
00:54:21 And so, yes, there was a bit of frustration.
00:54:23 Okay, well, and we'll see that the very next day you had a call with Premier Ford.
00:54:28 And just in the narrative, what was going on at this point, in addition to Ottawa,
00:54:33 and there were a few things, as we know, going on across the country,
00:54:36 but by this time, this 7th, 8th, 9th, the Ambassador Bridge blockade had really heated up and was in full swing.
00:54:43 And that seemed to be a turning point in several ways, but certainly for Ontario's participation in all of this.
00:54:51 So, Mr. Clerk, if you can take that document down, please, and bring up SSM.CAN.NSC402845.
00:55:12 point for advocacy to to make a long story short this is a call where it seems that you and premier
00:55:17 ford are engaging and deciding to work together to solve this problem at this point um you can
00:55:23 skip over the first oh here we go the the last part of that first paragraph so pdf premier doug
00:55:29 ford uh he says what we can recommend and what we can work together on is i've asked our ag
00:55:36 our attorney general to look at legal ways to give police more tools and exhaust legal remedies
00:55:42 because the police are a little shy and i can't direct them so that's one area we can focus on
00:55:47 we can't take their polar licenses um we check that we we can shut down their fuel consumption
00:55:53 and cordon off highways that's where we're at might be operator licenses yeah probably not polar
00:55:59 but um operator licenses let's go with that um so then you reply first of all
00:56:07 they're not a legal protest they're occupying a municipal street and are not legally parked
00:56:12 you shouldn't need more tools legal tools they're barricading the ontario economy and doing millions
00:56:17 of dollars of damage a day and harming people's lives at a time we're trying to draw in investments
00:56:24 a whole bunch of people are looking at this and saying we can't even clear up a protest on a bridge
00:56:29 so just stopping there prime minister do you remember what you were referring to
00:56:32 when you start talking about you shouldn't need more tools um
00:56:41 i mean that whole question around legality or illegality of the protest um they didn't have
00:56:48 a permit to protest um they not not certainly as long as they had um they were illegally parked
00:56:56 uh they were um engaged in disruptive activities there are any number of municipal and provincial
00:57:06 bylaw infractions and legal infractions that they were engaged in by just being there
00:57:11 and there is a sense that you know and this was based on an earlier conversation i had with bill
00:57:18 Blair about how one proceeds in this uh is you know you you can enforce small things as a way
00:57:27 of keeping the situation under control and creating boundaries and balances and moving towards uh
00:57:33 towards it it's a it's a it's an approach um the issue here uh was that there were things that they
00:57:41 could do and things that i know were tried that they realized were unsafe for them to do there
00:57:50 are stories of police officers getting swarmed there uh when they tried to arrest someone with
00:57:55 a jerry can filled with gasoline uh there was a sense that you know giving out simple tickets
00:58:02 wasn't really having much of an impact as they did that and taking stronger measures
00:58:10 was going to be resisted and met with significant resistance.
00:58:17 But these are things that if they feel they didn't have the resources to enforce a prohibition
00:58:27 on bringing in jerry cans or a prohibition of parking on the approach to the uh ambassador
00:58:33 bridge well let us give you more resources to do that between the opp and the rcmp um you know we
00:58:40 should be able to get the numbers up in a way that could lead for an ability to use those existing
00:58:47 tools on the books that was very much where our thinking was at that point how how many more
00:58:54 police officers how much more resources do you need to get a plan and if there was a concern
00:59:00 around um well we can't get those police allocated to us from other jurisdictions
00:59:07 unless there is a clear plan well we'll we'll send you planners we'll help get those um those people
00:59:16 there so you can establish a plan that will allow itself to be deployed there was really a sense
00:59:21 that there was more things that could be done and he seemed to be a greeting okay and that's
00:59:27 actually what you end up saying in the part you can't see right now of that uh the next page the
00:59:32 paragraph i'm at least consistent uh so nobody say the bridges and tunnels act meet the federal
00:59:39 government has something i can't read that anymore but federal government has responsibility over the
00:59:44 bridge and border so there's a role for us to play we're happy to play it but nobody can get on the
00:59:49 bridge because they're on municipal land being blocked so we'll give you whatever resources
00:59:53 you you're in you need the police of jurisdiction need to do their job if they're saying they can't
00:59:58 do it because they don't have enough offices or equipment we need to remove that excuse as
01:00:04 soon as possible so they can do their work and we can prevent ontario become becoming a laughing
01:00:10 stock um mr clerk just scroll down to the last page please we'll skip over there's some
01:00:15 jurisdictional discussions going on there um and then just to the top of that page please mr glick
01:00:23 so this is the sort of the conclusion of the conversation uh you say what are the next steps
01:00:28 you've said the open p you're going in are they keeping you apprised and do they understand the
01:00:33 urgency they can't talk this out for three weeks they need to act immediately and i'm assuming
01:00:39 there the concern of acting immediately is brought about by the situation on ambassador bridge which
01:00:45 we heard a lot about from the deputy prime minister yesterday premier ford replies they'll act but
01:00:52 without directing them it's hard to describe their game plan they'll have a plan unlike ottawa where
01:00:57 they didn't have a plan i'll get briefed more from the solicitor general would keep you updated 0.97
01:01:03 this is critical i hear you i'll be up their ass with a wire brush um then the next yeah you say 0.55
01:01:11 if that's one of the quote quotable quotes of the commission there have been a few that's one 0.95
01:01:15 um the next your reply there uh is well we're there with resources bill bear bill blair will
01:01:22 coordinate on our side you can reach out to the law minister of larmy you and i need to work
01:01:27 together on this people will be reassured by the two of us working together we need to demonstrate
01:01:32 this is not a place of lawlessness okay we can take that down thank you i will say though that
01:01:36 you know they can't talk this out for three weeks they need to act immediately i wasn't just talking
01:01:40 about the ambassador bridge i was talking about ottawa as well i was talking about the fact that
01:01:45 that that this simply can't continue to be stretched out this way but when i say they
01:01:51 need to act immediately obviously um i'm not directing uh the premier to direct police we
01:01:57 know all the limitations that we have but there was an expectation that this was a situation that was
01:02:03 going on for too long and as as doug pointed out a couple paragraphs later you know there is a sense
01:02:10 that people that the police of jurisdiction had lost control and wasn't able to control the
01:02:15 situation okay that's various i took the document down before we got to audible that's right thank
01:02:20 Thank you, Mr. Park. That won't come down now. So, shifting gears away from Ontario,
01:02:29 we understand that there's a lot of concern coming at the federal government from the United States
01:02:34 as well. And again, the Deputy Prime Minister yesterday spoke about the many conversations
01:02:39 she was having with stakeholders in the U.S., U.S. officials, Brian Deese in particular.
01:02:44 and we understand that on, I believe, February 11th,
01:02:49 you ended up having a phone call with President Biden.
01:02:53 Mr. Clerk, we'll just pull up the readout of that call.
01:02:56 It's pb.can6057.
01:03:10 Okay, scroll down to the next page, please.
01:03:12 so maybe that's there it's it's got to be somewhere
01:03:19 keep scrolling until you see your readout but in the mean oh no there it is i think um
01:03:23 in any event prime minister can you tell us just the readout doesn't actually say that much so can
01:03:27 you tell us about your recollection of that call um there was sort of two um two goals i had in
01:03:35 that call uh the first one uh was to reassure him uh that just right despite the disruptions to to
01:03:43 trade uh and to and real impacts on both sides of the border which were economic yes but were also
01:03:49 people to people we know we knew from the pandemic that you know thousands of healthcare workers
01:03:54 cross the ambassador bridge every day from uh from canada to go uh work in uh in detroit to
01:04:00 in their hospitals uh there is there are real meaningful connections across that crossing uh
01:04:06 that were being disrupted in meaningful ways and i wanted to reassure uh president biden that
01:04:11 canada was going to um going to be able to solve for this and that we were going to continue to be
01:04:19 a reliable partner for trade and for people-to-people ties and a safe neighbor um that was
01:04:28 sort of in response to his concerns around disruptions to activities on both sides of
01:04:35 the border because of the blockage. But the second thing I wanted to talk about was just
01:04:39 sort of the general context, the fact that the 911 centre being overwhelmed in Ottawa
01:04:47 a couple of days before happened from American calls, that there was a significant amount of
01:04:55 amplification from certain sectors of the American political sphere and there
01:05:05 was also a significant amount of money flowing and support for these occupation
01:05:15 activities in Canada that were coming from people in the United States
01:05:19 sympathetic to that cause and opposed to both he and I in our public health
01:05:28 policies but also in our general policies would you say that President
01:05:33 Biden shared your level of concern about the situation um no I think I was much
01:05:41 more concerned about the the blockage to the lives and the disruption and the
01:05:48 potential security concerns. I think he was very concerned. But I don't think anyone was more
01:05:53 concerned than me. Okay, fair enough. It was happening on your side of the border. So that
01:05:58 makes sense. Thank you, Mr. Clerk. That's it for that one. So this sort of brings us to a pretty
01:06:06 critical time in the narrative of what happened in February. So we're building to a bit of a
01:06:12 crescendo around that time, the 10th, the 11th. And we've heard from the Clerk of the Privy Council
01:06:18 that on February 9th, she advised you to convene the Incident Response Group.
01:06:24 And the first meeting of the Incident Response Group was then on February 10th.
01:06:28 So we have heard quite a bit about different cabinet committees and what the IRG is.
01:06:33 But I'm wondering if you can tell us from your perspective,
01:06:36 sitting as Prime Minister and Chair of these committees,
01:06:39 what it means to convene an IRG and how it differs and what it gives you,
01:06:45 what advantage it has versus other other structures um regular cabinet committees uh are chaired by
01:06:55 members of cabinet and feature various cabinet members sitting around the table assisted by
01:07:03 their um their directors their deputy ministers uh but it they are discussions amongst cabinet
01:07:11 ministers on a particular issue that will then go to full cabinet that's what most committees are
01:07:17 the irg is a special committee special in that it is chaired by me it doesn't have a permanent
01:07:23 membership because we deal with incidents that require or are important for the federal government
01:07:31 to respond to these could be floods or hurricanes uh the most recent irgs i've had were have been on
01:07:38 um on the situation in haiti uh and how canada can can respond and support uh you know they
01:07:45 they we had them uh around uh you know have them around all sorts of different things
01:07:49 uh depending on and depending on what they are needed for uh we pick the areas of expertise we
01:07:58 want around the table but differently from most committees this is a these are meetings in which
01:08:06 the officials sit around the table and are not just expected to participate they actually lead
01:08:13 uh the discussions um whether it's deputy ministers or or heads of agencies the commissioner of the
01:08:20 rcmp the director ceases what have you um they are giving direct reports ministers are usually if not
01:08:28 always there as well but if they speak at all it's at the very end to add a little bit of color or
01:08:35 further further input irgs are all about making sure that the government as a whole is hearing
01:08:44 directly that i am hearing directly from all these different agencies and all these different
01:08:50 inputs into whatever incident we're looking at uh and and then we um and then we establish a plan
01:08:59 or or we move forward uh on that it's actually a decision-making body we can make determinations
01:09:05 about what we do next but that frame is uh fairly unique amongst those uh amongst our committee
01:09:12 structure so that kind of get it collapses that layer between the officials and the ministers a
01:09:17 bit so gives yeah directly from from the ministers which is sometimes something that that uh cabinet
01:09:25 ministers who are used to getting briefed by their officials and then briefing their colleagues
01:09:30 takes a little bit of getting used to when we have a different irg on a different subject with
01:09:35 new ministers who aren't usually at irgs it always is a little adjustment for them that no no no we're
01:09:40 hearing from their deputy minister not from them um it's about informing us but it's also about
01:09:46 making sure that everyone is on the same page one of the challenges in any government uh is
01:09:54 the siloing that happens something that happens in in public safety doesn't necessarily get
01:10:00 connected to transport doesn't necessarily get connected as organically as we'd like to
01:10:05 immigration and you know various things like that so making sure that everyone's around the table
01:10:11 getting on the same page in terms of what's happening with this incident that we're looking
01:10:17 at and what we're going to do about it and there's usually okay let's hear the taskings we're going
01:10:23 do uh and uh let's check back in in a few days and see see how see how we've done and see where we
01:10:30 are again uh irgs rarely happen on a sort of a one-off there's usually a series of them until
01:10:36 the incident is is over or has been moved to a different body to uh to weigh in on okay thank
01:10:43 you that's helpful and understanding um so we know that the irg that that you convened to deal with
01:10:51 this particular problem met first of all three times before invocation and then i think it met
01:10:56 daily after that but we're going to focus on that first part on on the 10th the 12th and the 13th
01:11:02 and um i'll just fill in a little bit of the narrative so so you don't have to here but we
01:11:06 understand that on the 10th what was discussed was two tracks for a potential federal response so at
01:11:12 this point i i won't say it had been decided but it was certainly under serious consideration that
01:11:18 the federal government might have to act in some way shape or form here and track one was um what
01:11:25 can the federal government do under its existing authorities track two was what could we potentially
01:11:30 do under any new authorities including the emergencies act and i just want to pause here
01:11:37 and ask you one thing which is um in the documents that's sort of maybe not the first but it's
01:11:44 certainly the first sort of confirmation official confirmation that the emergencies act was under
01:11:50 discussion but we have seen references to the emergencies act here and there in various phone
01:11:55 calls or emails or discussions etc and i'm wondering if you can describe if someone asked you
01:12:01 um when did the emergencies act come into play as a possibility uh how would you answer that
01:12:07 as as an idea um it would have been from the very beginning in the back of our minds as you see a
01:12:16 situation that is an emergency is out of control is has a potential for real impact on citizens
01:12:25 potential for violence uh real concerns about what's going on not just in ottawa but right
01:12:31 across the country at the coots blockade that started up on the same first weekend uh that the
01:12:38 ottawa uh occupation did these are the things that um you say okay as we look at a whole range of
01:12:50 potential outcomes in this there might be a moment where we have to invoke the emergencies act
01:12:55 um it wasn't seriously thought of because i will say certainly in in my thinking right now it was
01:13:02 a fairly binary reflection it was oh we might have to invoke the emergencies act there was no
01:13:07 reflection of what we would have to invoke the emergencies act to do it was just understanding
01:13:13 that if this situation continues and is unable to get under control by anything else the federal
01:13:20 government might have to give the provinces more powers give police more powers do something to put
01:13:26 an end to this so whenever we said yeah we're looking at all options it would have been in the
01:13:31 back of our minds particularly because um i think we're probably the first government that had ever
01:13:39 actually leaned in carefully to maybe using the emergencies act as we did in the beginning of the
01:13:45 pandemic uh we dusted it off and you know had presentations at cabinet around what the
01:13:52 emergencies act was and how it was an update from the previous legislation that existed before and
01:13:59 how it was charter compliant and yeah because post 1982 a lot of things needed to change
01:14:04 if for the better in our in our country uh with the charter of rights and freedoms so
01:14:09 So we got a crash course in the Emergencies Act and the consultations required and all
01:14:17 the various steps of it two years before around the pandemic.
01:14:22 As I had said during the consultations at that time with the Premiers, I didn't think
01:14:28 we needed to use it.
01:14:29 I didn't think it was appropriate for us to declare a public welfare emergency, I believe
01:14:34 the section is within the Emergencies Act that we would have invoked around the pandemic.
01:14:39 there were a lot of people calling for us to do it because it was obviously a national emergency
01:14:43 this pandemic particularly in the early days of spring 2020 so we were somewhat versed in
01:14:50 this legislation that had never been used seeing this particular um public order situation uh it was
01:15:02 a reflection in the back of our minds or my mind anyway i can't speak for everyone that
01:15:07 maybe it would end up at this but for the same reason we um were loath to call an irg too soon
01:15:17 in the process we knew that it wasn't ours to solve at this point that there were still lots
01:15:24 of things that the jurisdiction the police of jurisdiction and various orders could and should
01:15:28 be orders of government should could and should be doing to put an end to this so it wasn't until
01:15:33 as you say uh the irg of february 10th thursday that we uh said okay um track one you know what
01:15:42 more can we do to empower police and and public safety officials to put an end uh to these illegal
01:15:51 occupations what more resources can we spend with existing authorities and track two was
01:15:57 what could we do that we would have to create new authorities for whether it was through regulation
01:16:05 whether it was through passing emergency measures through the house or whether it was using
01:16:10 something like the emergency measures act and the key for me in that conversation
01:16:17 was it was a shift from that sort of binary frame of
01:16:21 no emergencies act or emergencies act because if you think about it the emergencies act itself
01:16:31 doesn't do anything except declare an emergency it's it's that it enables government to bring in
01:16:39 special temporary measures to deal with the situation so the useful conversations around
01:16:46 the emergencies act started on february 10th when i asked the question okay what are the extra tools
01:16:57 that we would need to bring in either through legislation or through regulation or in various
01:17:03 ways or through the emergencies act that we don't actually have now or what would we do
01:17:10 with the emergencies act if we brought it in that we can't otherwise do and that reflection on
01:17:16 well what would be the tools actually clarified and and and got the work going perfect example was
01:17:24 we had heard consistently throughout that commercial tow truck drivers were not willing
01:17:29 uh to come in and remove trucks well the emergencies act perhaps could compel uh truck
01:17:36 drivers uh tow truck drivers to uh come and actually fulfill their contracts that are they
01:17:42 signed with cities uh to keep the streets clear of of illegally parked cars so that reflection
01:17:50 was really the one that started then and the tasking that i gave on that thursday
01:17:55 that we would check in again on the saturday uh at the next irg was okay come up with
01:18:02 those tools that we could get at that would solve this and then we'll look at whether we
01:18:07 need the emergencies act to bring in these tools or can we do it through another way or can we
01:18:12 convince the province to do it are there other ways of doing it but let's figure out what are
01:18:16 the things that would allow us to get this situation which was out of control back under
01:18:24 control okay so that was that was essentially the discussion around the table on the 12th i believe
01:18:29 And then the 13th was the big day in terms of deciding as a government whether you were going to take that first step and seriously consider invoking the Emergencies Act.
01:18:42 Can you take us through, from your point of view, the chronology essentially of the 13th?
01:18:48 We know there was an IRG meeting in the afternoon, I think it was 4.30,
01:18:52 and the decision coming out of the IRG was to have a cabinet meeting in the evening
01:18:57 to discuss the potential invocation of the Act.
01:19:00 So, how did those meetings play out?
01:19:06 Pendant le groupe de réponse d'incident de ce dimanche,
01:19:11 on a regardé attentivement les mesures proposées,
01:19:16 La liste d'outils dont on pourrait se doter pour aider la police, les provinces à non seulement remettre les situations sous contrôle, mais aussi empêcher les situations de revenir.
01:19:36 Parce que, si vous avez parlé de cette expression du whack-a-mole, on a vu que les manifestants étaient très habiles à se déplacer, à faire une présence ici, puis ensuite se déplacer pour l'autre,
01:20:00 pour réduire leur présence dans une place, pour donner beaucoup de défis aux policiers de pouvoir répondre.
01:20:06 Et l'inquiétude, ce n'était pas qu'en mettant toutes nos ressources dans une place,
01:20:12 on ne pourrait pas remettre l'ordre dans une situation.
01:20:17 C'est qu'en faisant ça, on laissait vulnérable une autre place où ils allaient pouvoir le faire,
01:20:23 où une fois qu'on l'a réglé, deux jours plus tard, ils allaient revenir.
01:20:25 Donc, il y avait plus une question de, oui, de mettre fin aux occupations illégales, mais aussi de comprendre qu'il fallait les garder clairées jusqu'à ce que la situation se calme réellement à travers le pays.
01:20:42 Et donc, pendant cette rencontre du dimanche, on a regardé les différentes propositions,
01:20:49 que ce soit les propositions par rapport aux conducteurs de remorques,
01:20:53 que ce soit les dispositions pour des zones d'interdiction où tu n'avais pas le droit d'y aller,
01:21:00 tu n'avais pas le droit d'y aller pour les besoins de manifester,
01:21:03 tu n'avais pas le droit d'amener des enfants, tu n'avais pas le droit de traverser la frontière canado-américaine
01:21:10 avec un but de te joindre. Il y avait des mesures que les banques allaient pouvoir geler les comptes de banque des manifestants
01:21:20 pendant qu'ils étaient sur le terrain en train de barricader pour les inciter de rentrer chez eux.
01:21:30 On a discuté de toutes ces mesures-là. On a regardé, OK, c'est quoi nos options pour amener ces outils-là à être une réalité.
01:21:40 Est-ce qu'on peut passer de la législation à la Chambre des communes? Est-ce qu'on peut l'accélérer et demander le consentement unanime ou accélérer le débat pour amener ça rapidement? Est-ce qu'on pourrait le faire en encourageant les provinces d'utiliser plus d'outils?
01:21:58 And at that moment, it started to be quite clear that the situation had been so urgent,
01:22:10 there was a concern that it could be empiric and gringolier even more elsewhere,
01:22:18 that there was an urgency to act and that the tools that we had to quickly bring these specific tools
01:22:28 C'était la loi sur les mesures d'urgence.
01:22:58 And I'll give you a little framing of it, which is, of course, we know that the declaration of a public order emergency is premised on the existence of a threat to the security of Canada, as defined in the CSIS Act.
01:23:15 And we know that CSIS, in the process of assessing the protests, assessed that there was no, the protests did not meet that threshold.
01:23:26 They did not constitute a threat to the security of Canada as defined in the CSIS Act.
01:23:31 So this is one of...
01:23:32 As defined for the CSIS Act.
01:23:36 Okay, please.
01:23:38 Over to you.
01:23:39 The legislation in the 80s that was built brought in a definition of a national, sorry, a threat to national security, imported the words of the CSIS definition.
01:23:58 That was a handy definition that was already existing and there, that's how we can define what a national threats to the security of Canadians.
01:24:09 uh would be those words in the cesus act are used for the purpose of
01:24:20 cesus determining that they have authority to act against an individual a group or a specific plot
01:24:30 with for example a wiretap that in order for them to take action in a particular situation
01:24:36 that threshold needs to be met of threats to national security and actually be useful if we
01:24:44 could pull up uh part c of uh sure sure um you know what we have that one second i will get you
01:24:52 a document number but okay sure go ahead do you want or do you not yes i do sorry okay
01:24:58 com com dot five zeros nine five four please
01:25:03 so here i think this pastes together the the three things so national emergency public order
01:25:15 emergency scrolling down you'll see the reference to csesac and there keep scrolling mr clerk just
01:25:22 keep going yep there we go good um so in order for CSIS to be able to do a
01:25:35 particular operation it has to make meet this matter of threats to the security
01:25:40 of Canada and then they can go and do that wiretap this definition within
01:25:51 a declaration of public order emergency under the Emergencies Act is about the
01:25:59 governor and council finding reasonable grounds that there are threats to the
01:26:05 security of Canada sufficient to invoke the the Emergency Measures Act so both
01:26:16 the context and the purpose is very different. The people doing the deciding, in the case
01:26:23 of the CSIS Act, if this is met as a definition, it's CSIS itself that decides that this is
01:26:30 met. There's checks and balances afterwards. But for the purpose of declaration of a public
01:26:36 order emergency, it's the governor and council, cabinet and the prime minister making that
01:26:41 determination so the context within which we look at this definition is very different from the
01:26:50 deliberately narrow frame that cesis is allowed to look at what inputs it can take in what proofs
01:26:56 it needs to establish this are very well prescribed so that cesis can be you know
01:27:03 so that cesis is responsible in what it does whereas the declaration of public order emergency
01:27:09 is open to inputs, sure, from CSIS, but also from the RCMP, also from transport, from immigration,
01:27:19 from the whole of government, from the clerk, from the National Security Intelligence Advisor.
01:27:23 So within threats to the security of Canada, what we had to determine was,
01:27:31 does the situation going on across the country constitute a threat to the security of Canada?
01:27:39 Yes or no? And then we looked at particularly C. Are there activities within Canada directed towards or in support of the threat or use of acts of serious violence against persons or property for the purpose of achieving a political or ideological objective?
01:28:09 That was what we were looking at. Is that threshold met? Are there activities supporting the threats or acts of serious violence, a threat of serious violence for political or ideological goals?
01:28:26 If that threshold was met in our reasoned opinion, then that part of invoking a public order emergency was met.
01:28:37 The other part of it is, does it constitute a national emergency?
01:28:41 And there's elements on that that I won't get into unless you ask me about.
01:28:43 But I was very much focused on was this bar hit, yes or no, for the purposes of invoking the Emergencies Act.
01:28:57 There has been a bit of back and forth at this commission on whether these words are different or can be read differently or broader when they're used in a public order emergency than they're used for the CSIS.
01:29:19 It's not the words that are different.
01:29:20 The words are exactly the same in both cases.
01:29:23 The question is, who's doing the interpretation?
01:29:27 what inputs come in and what is the purpose of it and the purpose of it for
01:29:32 this point was to be able to give us in special temporary measures as defined in
01:29:41 the Public Order Emergency Act that would put an end to this national
01:29:46 emergency okay so so essentially you're saying that around the table that day
01:29:55 Yes.
01:29:56 You were looking at the inputs that were given to you by officials and by the ministers
01:30:02 and concluded that there was activities within Canada.
01:30:08 Threats of serious violence was the key ones.
01:30:11 And can you elaborate on what those threats were?
01:30:15 What led to that conclusion?
01:30:18 And again, we went around the table with officials from all different agencies and heads of departments
01:30:25 uh to talk about this there was uh the um militarization of vehicles for example we'd seen
01:30:33 uh sorry weaponization of of vehicles we'd seen uh you know cars ramming into police officers
01:30:39 or other cars at coots uh we saw an incident like that in um in uh surrey i believe uh we saw
01:30:49 trucks uh used as as uh potential weapons certainly in um uh in ottawa with their their
01:30:57 presence and unknown uh interiors there was the use of uh children as human shields uh deliberately
01:31:05 uh which was a real concern both at the ambassador bridge and the fact that there were kids on
01:31:11 wellington street that people didn't know what was in the uh in the trucks whether it was kids
01:31:17 whether it was weapons whether it was both police had no way of knowing uh those there was presence
01:31:24 of weapons uh at coots as we saw there was a concern around weapons being stolen uh in peterborough
01:31:31 uh that we didn't know about 2 000 guns that we didn't know where they had gone at that point
01:31:35 uh we later found out that they didn't go there but there was that was a real concern
01:31:39 that we had about what was happening to them um there were a number of others as well there was
01:31:45 the fact that um police trying to invoice enforce uh laws were met with uh active resistance and put
01:31:56 uh a group of 30 police officers trying to uh interdict someone or arrest someone who was
01:32:01 carrying a jerry can uh into uh into the site in ottawa uh got swarmed by a hundred people and they
01:32:08 had to leave uh because there were threats to their safety and they weren't able to arrest that
01:32:12 individual there were layers of danger that ceases kept uh bringing up to us that the presence of
01:32:21 people promoting um ideologically motivated violence violent extremism in uh the convoys
01:32:29 uh had a danger of triggering not necessarily them to act but lone wolf actors or people who
01:32:38 could be radicalized to take actions that were violent we saw increasingly counter protests of
01:32:47 people who were trying to take back their city uh who were for example we all saw images of of
01:32:53 grandmothers standing uh in residential streets against uh you know massive trucks heading their
01:32:59 ways to try and you know prevent them from coming to join the convoy there were all these things that
01:33:06 positioned or present presented real threats of serious violence and every input we were getting
01:33:15 on that weekend at the irg was that things were not getting better things were getting worse
01:33:24 even as it looked like there was a plan for the ambassador bridge to move forward it looked like
01:33:29 there was going to be a plan for coots moving forward it wasn't a sense there wasn't a sense
01:33:36 that things were dissipating on the contrary we were hearing about fort erie we were hearing
01:33:42 about the blue water bridge in sarnia we were hearing about potential blockades in uh in new
01:33:46 brunswick we were hearing about uh potentials at lacol we were hearing more convoys and more
01:33:53 supporters heading to different places to take action there were things going on in bc and surrey
01:33:58 Like, there was a sense that this was a broadly spread thing,
01:34:03 and the fact that there was not yet any serious violence that had been noted
01:34:10 was obviously a good thing, but we could not say that there was no potential
01:34:18 for threats of serious violence, for serious violence to happen over the coming days.
01:34:22 We were seeing things escalate, not things get under control.
01:34:27 Okay. You mentioned there that the Ambassador Bridge was on its way to resolution in a sense, and Cootes was on its way to resolution. One of the things that's come up in the evidence is that at this juncture, Ottawa could also perhaps have been said to be on its way, perhaps in an earlier stage, to resolution in the sense that a plan, an integrated plan for policing was coming together at that point.
01:34:56 And that may not have been something that was clearly expressed on the 13th to the IRG and or cabinet.
01:35:05 So first, I wanted to ask you what your understanding of that situation was at the time.
01:35:11 First of all, from the beginning, from the approach of the very first weekend, we heard from various authorities and police of jurisdiction, don't worry, we got this.
01:35:24 There's a plan.
01:35:24 there's a plan and for the second weekend there was a plan and we have a plan for this and it's
01:35:29 not going to happen and we've got this we're getting we're getting more resources nope there's
01:35:32 a plan we kept hearing there was a plan um and even i mean we heard in in testimony here that
01:35:39 there was uh a plan on the 13th that the ottawa police services pulled together um i would
01:35:46 recommend people take a look at that actual plan um which wasn't a plan at all it was a talk
01:35:54 about using liaison officers to try and shrink the perimeter a little bit but as you look at the
01:36:01 annex for you know how the troops are deployed how the police officers are deployed what resources
01:36:05 are going to be need every annex is uh to be determined later to be determined later it was
01:36:11 not even in the most generous of characterizations a plan for how they were going to end the
01:36:17 occupation in ottawa um when the plan did come together and if someone wants to compare
01:36:23 the supposed plan on the 13th with the actual plan on the 17th that uh ottawa police services
01:36:29 pulled together um you see the crisp difference between these are the types of units we need
01:36:34 these are the resources we need this is how we're going to do it this is all the stages of it
01:36:38 on the 17th it was not there on the 13th but even beyond that because i'm not
01:36:44 fully aware how much of this is hindsight and how much of this was that general sense we got
01:36:49 that people continued to say oh no we're going to be able to get this under control i think and we're
01:36:54 jumping ahead but you know jason kenny was saying on on uh on the monday morning in our in our first
01:37:00 minister's meeting yeah coots is well on its way to being under control we had heard that before
01:37:06 and there were fluctuations going on in the various uh in the various sites across the country um
01:37:13 it was not enough just to have a plan to clear a couple of lanes it was getting the situation
01:37:25 under control so as to prevent a recurrence or a restaging of a protest elsewhere and that was what
01:37:34 was very clear from all the all the perspectives around the table that there was not confidence
01:37:42 that we were on a track to getting the national emergency under control in the coming days
01:37:50 that it was continuing to um to be a situation that was not um being controlled by police by
01:38:01 officials okay so uh we will get to the first minister's meeting but let's just finish off
01:38:07 on this point with the 13th um in a lot of the evidence that has come out before the commission
01:38:14 we see hesitancy and reluctance to invoke the emergencies act so officials advising that this
01:38:20 this may make things worse this may inflame tension this may embolden protesters etc um
01:38:26 and we also obviously heard from from mr vigno saying and the thesis assessment that there was
01:38:32 no threat to the security of canada under the cesus act uh and then we heard mr vigno say but
01:38:38 i still thought that the the act was necessary and i conveyed that to the prime minister
01:38:43 so can you tell us uh was there consensus on the use of the act did what did what did you hear
01:38:51 about whether or not people agreed with this interpretation whether you should vote the act
01:38:57 yes there was consensus around the irg table uh on sunday the 13th there is no question about it and
01:39:03 and uh director vigno's um answer on that is absolutely consistent uh cesus for example
01:39:13 wouldn't feel that they had the capacity to bring in a wiretap against one of the convoy
01:39:20 organizers under the CSIS Act because that the tools that they have and the threshold they have
01:39:27 to meet for what is a threat to the security of Canada um according to CSIS's evaluation
01:39:35 was not was not met and that that was something we heard from the very beginning CSIS uh continued
01:39:41 to say from the beginning of the protest we haven't yet under the CSIS Act uh reached a level of
01:39:47 threats to canada but the director of cesus is also one of the national security advisors to me
01:39:55 and in looking at the frame and scope of the situation we were in uh was very comfortable
01:40:03 in saying yeah for the purposes of the cesus act this is not met but for the surf for purposes of
01:40:09 the public order emergencies uh act that the governor and council has to make a reasonable
01:40:15 decision about we feel that it is met and that was the consensus from officials around the table and
01:40:22 again it was about um not even just sort of that binary okay do we declare the emergency you're on
01:40:31 it's do we declare a public order emergency so that we can bring in these specific measures
01:40:38 and as we went around the table on that and my expectation is and that was a virtual table i
01:40:43 believe but my expectation is always if you have significant disagreements this is the time to speak
01:40:50 up there was no voice saying hold it we don't think you should do this or i don't think you
01:40:57 should do this which does happen from time to time in cabinet meetings and in irgs and
01:41:04 And if someone had come up and said, okay, we don't think, us at Transport Canada, we don't think that we should invoke a public order emergency, I would have said, thank you.
01:41:18 I would have taken that into account, but I didn't need unanimity or full consensus in order to make the determination in governor of council according to that that we were moving forward.
01:41:32 obviously it helped uh and in this case there was consensus around that table that invoking
01:41:39 the emergencies act was what we needed to do and when you say that are you speaking of the
01:41:45 irg in the afternoon or the eventual cabinet meeting in the in the evening i'm speaking of
01:41:50 the irg right now with where we went around the table with officials but we did a similar thing
01:41:55 that afternoon uh sorry that evening with the cabinet meeting but i can talk about that a few
01:41:59 Yeah, that's the segue. So please, please do. Tell us about the cabinet meeting.
01:42:29 on l'espérait, mettre fin à cette situation. Six éléments qu'on n'allait pas pouvoir amener ou invoquer par d'autres processus que l'appel à la loi sur les mesures d'urgence.
01:42:50 Il y a eu une bonne discussion autour de la table. Tous les ministres qui voulaient parler ont pu parler et sans partager les délibérations, je peux dire qu'on est sortis avec un consensus clair, que je devais procéder aux prochaines étapes de consultation avec les premiers ministres, avec la possibilité d'invoquer la loi sur les mesures d'urgence.
01:43:19 Then, but I could hear the reactions, just as I did before, on the same day with the IRG meeting, that people felt comfortable enough and together enough on this issue.
01:43:45 yes we could move on towards the possibility of invoking the act the next day part of the
01:43:56 discussion at the cabinet table as well okay yes you made the same consensus then yes what we can
01:44:10 loosely called decision day um february 14th and i'm just gonna try and lay out the chronology of
01:44:17 that day and then ask you first of all whether that is the that is the correct chronology of
01:44:22 the day and then ask you to speak to various parts of it so um the first minister's the decision
01:44:28 coming out of cabinet the evening before was to convene a first minister's meeting to have the
01:44:34 obligatory consultation under section 25 of the emergencies act before it could be invoked and we
01:44:39 know that late that night an invitation was sent out to the premiers to that meeting that invitation
01:44:45 did not include the subject of of the meeting and we've heard some some of uh your ministers
01:44:51 and officials speak to to why um but in any event so the first minister's meeting was held i believe
01:44:58 at 10 15 the following morning on the 14th following that meeting you had a call with
01:45:05 opposition leaders i believe and and a call with your own caucus no no um the uh caucus call was
01:45:12 before the first minister's meeting thank you okay i wanted to make sure that we shared with
01:45:18 our members of caucus who were going to be um involved in very much a part of a government that
01:45:27 has uh would invoke the emergency measures act i wanted to let them know before um premiers
01:45:35 were consulted uh i wanted to let them know that i was about to consult the premiers but the sense
01:45:40 was that uh caucus um would should hear it before the premiers uh heard about that that makes sense
01:45:48 okay so caucus call first then first ministers meeting then i think you spoke to opposition
01:45:53 leaders uh then around 3 41 pm i said around but we actually know the minute 3 41 pm you receive
01:46:00 advice from the clerk and that advice as we know is that they recommend that the clerk recommends
01:46:06 that you invoke the emergencies act and shortly thereafter there's a public announcement of it so
01:46:11 just unpacking that starting with the caucus call briefly but the focus of this will obviously be
01:46:16 the first minister's meeting take us through that day um the caucus call uh was informing them that
01:46:23 i was about to go into a first minister's meeting in which i was going to um present them uh with
01:46:31 the fact that we were thinking about invoking the emergencies act uh and i shared with them
01:46:37 that these were the kinds of things we would be giving police and various new authority various
01:46:50 officials and authorities to which tools would be able to move forward with that so I presented it
01:46:55 it wasn't a big discussion I wasn't looking for consensus there wasn't a lot of feedback it was
01:47:02 just informing them that we were taking this seriously and moving forward and i i dare say
01:47:10 the response was uh was very positive uh from uh from our our caucus um then uh the first ministers
01:47:18 meeting as i'd mentioned uh earlier uh this was not the first time i talked about the emergencies
01:47:24 act with the premiers uh i guess miss telford and i had talked about yesterday i have had many many
01:47:32 many uh first ministers meetings uh over the course of the past two years to deal with the
01:47:37 pandemic emergency and we have always worked very constructively together and for me
01:47:45 being able to sit down with them and highlight that we were seriously considering invoking the
01:47:53 emergencies act in order to do the following things uh and i wanted to hear from them and then
01:48:01 i went around the around the table across the country uh to hear from each of them on their
01:48:08 reflections their inputs their concerns their support their disagreements in some cases
01:48:20 but really wanted to hear what it was that they were going to be
01:48:23 um what their thinking was on this situation that would uh by definition affect all of them
01:48:31 on a situation that was uh to a certain extent affecting all of them um at the end of that
01:48:38 meeting i uh reached out to the um opposition leaders uh had conversations with them about
01:48:47 what i was reflecting on doing and asked for their support and then
01:48:57 started preparing for a potential announcement that afternoon as the note from the clerk came in
01:49:09 making the official recommendation to the government that we invoke the emergencies act
01:49:15 okay so let me let me start with an initial question taking you back to first thing in
01:49:19 the morning had you made up your mind already no um i certainly i was a long way down the road
01:49:30 of um realizing that it was um it was probably uh the path we needed to take
01:49:38 but I did not make up my mind until the note from the clerk was in front of me and it was in black
01:49:46 and white that the public service made a formal recommendation that I invoke the emergencies act
01:49:53 if I'd gotten to that point and they had said no we still don't think the threshold is met
01:49:58 it is possible that we wouldn't be here today and I would not have invoked it
01:50:07 But I don't know.
01:50:09 But the fact that when that note came in,
01:50:13 I made that final decision with all the conversations,
01:50:17 all the inputs and all the feedback that I'd gotten from caucus,
01:50:21 from sort of cabinet and from first ministers and opposition leaders
01:50:25 and all the officials I'd talked to.
01:50:29 That was when I made the decision.
01:50:31 So going back to the first minister's meeting then,
01:50:34 we understand it lasted about an hour and and all of the premiers had a chance to voice their
01:50:40 opinions and their concerns but is there anything they could have said or done at that point to
01:50:45 change your mind absolutely um if uh someone had said um listen i hear those six things
01:50:56 you're planning on doing you don't need them because these are the tools we're going to use
01:51:03 instead we have the power we're going to be able to in ontario do this and we're confident that
01:51:09 that will end the situation in ottawa and end the situation at potential blockades for on and keep
01:51:16 us safe uh this these you don't need to bring in compelling of tow truck drivers because we've we've
01:51:23 figured out how to do it for good we have a plan to put an end to this in a concrete and compelling
01:51:29 because I'd heard a lot of plans up until that point.
01:51:32 But if I had been convinced that other orders of government
01:51:44 or any other law in Canada was sufficient to deal with this emergency,
01:51:53 then we wouldn't have met the threshold.
01:51:57 because part of the threshold for the Emergencies Act is and is unable to be dealt with under any other measures or laws in Canada.
01:52:05 And if they had said convincingly or enough of them had said, no, no, you don't need it because we have it under control,
01:52:11 which is to a certain extent what they all said to me when I had this conversation with them around the pandemic.
01:52:18 I said, listen, there's a lot of pressure for us to look at the Emergencies Act.
01:52:22 Do we need to bring in the Emergencies Act?
01:52:24 And they all said, no, don't bring in the Emergencies Act.
01:52:27 We've got it under control. We're able to do this in our own jurisdictions, in our healthcare systems. We don't need to do it. Public order emergency is different than public welfare emergency, but that principle was there, and we didn't invoke the Act back in the spring of 2020.
01:52:42 So, yes, they could have said things that prevented me, that would have said, okay, let's give it a few more days, or let's not do this at all.
01:52:57 They said lots of things, but that threshold that I had personally wasn't met.
01:53:02 Okay. And you mentioned, I mean, some of them did express opinions around the lines
01:53:08 of, well, we kind of got it under control here. This problem isn't really cropping up
01:53:13 here, or it's cropping up here in a way that our law enforcement can deal with. So are
01:53:18 you drawing a distinction there between, okay, the premiers may say it's under control here,
01:53:24 but that doesn't mean it's under control everywhere. So they would have had to come to you with
01:53:28 something that would have solved the big problem as you saw it is that um i think there just would
01:53:34 have been a sense that that the measures i was proposing weren't going to be useful or effective
01:53:46 and what i heard on the contrary uh was uh concerns that we'd shared that this might
01:53:54 inflame the protesters to declare a public order emergency and bring in martial law um which was
01:54:02 one of the concerns or that they would interpret it as that of course it wasn't martial law and
01:54:06 it did not suspend people's fundamental rights and freedoms um but it it at the same time um
01:54:15 they expressed these concerns which we had shared but i was balancing off against okay um
01:54:21 There is a danger of further inflaming the situation, but the situation was already pretty inflamed,
01:54:29 and my concern was if we continue to not do anything, are enough citizens going to start counter-protesting
01:54:36 and taking things into their own hands at various places across the country
01:54:40 that we do get into dangerous, violent situations?
01:54:44 Even Premier Moe, I believe, we could pull it up, but I think people have seen it a few times, highlighted that he didn't have any real, that the six elements we had seemed reasonable enough, but he was in disagreement with the invocation of the Emergencies Act, that those six elements we should maybe move forward with in some way, but without doing the Emergencies Act.
01:55:09 That was something that we'd looked at trying to do as well.
01:55:12 But it was clear that in order to do those, bring in those tools,
01:55:17 the Emergencies Act was the vehicle that was created for that purpose
01:55:22 so that we could respond to a national emergency.
01:55:25 Jason Kenney, I believe, said,
01:55:27 I'm not going to quibble with the use of the Act,
01:55:29 but we don't need it here in Alberta.
01:55:32 And that was something that came out a number of times,
01:55:36 even by those who were supporting it, said,
01:55:39 yeah you do what you need to do don't think we need it here but i know this is a um this is a
01:55:44 situation where you should probably do it or can you not do it uh in my jurisdiction and just do
01:55:51 it for ontario and that was certainly something that that i uh i had reflected on and certainly
01:55:58 reflected on further through that conversation but the reality is there were um pop-ups and
01:56:06 and troubling reports right across the country that we were getting from all of our various inputs
01:56:14 there was a financing of these convoys that was coming from every corner of the country and
01:56:20 internationally these were things that were generalized across the country and and therefore
01:56:28 required a use of the Emergencies Act.
01:56:31 Par exemple, le Premier ministre Legault
01:56:34 a exprimé...
01:56:35 Premier Legault expressed some concern.
01:56:40 He didn't want to have the RCMP suddenly
01:56:44 take over all the police interventions
01:56:50 and operations in Quebec
01:56:51 when he thought he didn't need that
01:56:54 and I was able to reassure him.
01:56:56 And it's something that I actually
01:56:57 incorporated in my my communication subsequently that it was there to be
01:57:07 used if necessary but if for instance there was a blockade at lacol and the
01:57:14 SQ is perfectly able to deal with it like they they responded very well at
01:57:21 the second weekend at an attempted convoy in Quebec City.
01:57:29 The RCP was only there to be a support if necessary, and that was the framework.
01:57:40 So it was a very useful conversation, and I heard a lot of points of view.
01:57:50 It was a good thing for me to be able to hear them, even with different opinions, and just to reassure what I was doing.
01:58:04 This entire part is the last question I want to ask you about that day, Prime Minister.
01:58:09 So at 3.41, you received the decision note from the clerk.
01:58:13 We call it the invocation memo.
01:58:15 Technically, it's a decision note.
01:58:18 Presumably, you read it.
01:58:19 Yes.
01:58:20 Okay. And was there anything in it that surprised you? Was that the advice you were expecting to get from the clerk or was it?
01:58:28 it was the advice that was consistent with the consensus around the table the day before
01:58:35 at the irg you know the clerk and the national security and intelligence advisor and the
01:58:42 deputy clerk and all the heads of departments and agencies had had a chance to weigh in
01:58:49 on on the various measures and on the invocation and there was a clear consensus coming out of
01:58:57 there that this is what we should do but it was a big thing not a small thing to have the head of
01:59:06 the public service formally recommend the invocation of the emergencies act and the
01:59:13 declaration of a public order emergency um it's not something that had ever been done in canada before
01:59:21 it was certainly not something that we undertook to do lightly
01:59:24 And as a Prime Minister, I get to sign off and agree with these notes, or in some cases disagree with them.
01:59:41 And that was a moment that I took with the weight of the decision I was about to take.
01:59:47 And I reflected briefly on, first of all, the reassurance that it gave me that the entire system, all the inputs in the system had come up to the clerk of the Privy Council, the top public servant in Canada, impartial, professional public service, making the recommendation to move forward on this was essential to me.
02:00:13 but I also reflected on okay what if I don't sign it what if I say okay we now
02:00:24 have advice from the professional public service to invoke a public order
02:00:28 emergency and I decide you know what let's give it a few days where the
02:00:39 The professional public service had made a determination that the thresholds were met, that the use of it was appropriate and, you know, responsible, and the measures were the right ones that we were going to put in it.
02:00:54 And I said, no, you know what, let's wait and see another few days, another week to see if we really need to do it.
02:01:03 First of all, what if the worst had happened?
02:01:09 those following days what if um someone had gotten hurt what if a police officer had been
02:01:15 put in a hospital what if uh when i had an opportunity to do something
02:01:22 i had waited and we had unthinkable happen over the coming days even though there was all this
02:01:29 warning that it was possibly coming um i would have worn that in a way that we would certainly
02:01:35 be talking about in a forum such as this but more than that
02:01:44 the responsibility of a prime minister is to make the tough calls and keep people safe
02:01:52 and this was a moment where the collective advice of cabinet of the public service
02:02:02 and my own inclination was that this was a moment to do something that we needed to do to keep
02:02:13 Canadians safe. And knowing full well that this was an inevitable consequence of me signing,
02:02:22 I agree, on this note, I was very comfortable that we were at a moment where this was the
02:02:30 right thing to do. And we did it. And it is a certain amount of comfort that, first of
02:02:45 all, the system is working as it should, that people who are defending civil liberties are
02:02:50 able to say, you really should be careful about doing this, maybe you shouldn't have
02:02:53 done it, that we have a system pushing back on this, because it's a big thing, not a small
02:02:57 thing to do this but that also we were able to solve the situation with it that there was no loss
02:03:08 of life there was no uh you know serious violence that we were able to get neighborhoods back under
02:03:17 control border border services opened and um there haven't been a recurrence of these kinds
02:03:26 of illegal occupations uh since then i'm not going to pretend that it's the only thing that could
02:03:32 have done it but it did do it and that colors the conversations we're having now uh with the fact
02:03:41 that these could be very different conversations and i am absolutely absolutely serene and confident
02:03:50 that i made the right choice in agreeing with the invocation mr commissioner definitely good
02:03:56 time for a break okay so we'll take the uh morning break we'll take uh 15 minutes please
02:04:03 the commission is in recess for 15 minutes
02:04:11 Thank you.
02:04:41 Thank you.
02:05:11 Thank you.
02:05:41 Thank you.
02:06:11 Thank you.
02:06:41 Thank you.
02:07:11 Thank you.
02:07:41 Thank you.
02:08:11 Thank you.
02:08:41 Thank you.
02:09:11 Thank you.
02:09:41 Thank you.
02:10:11 Thank you.
02:10:41 Thank you.
02:11:11 Thank you.
02:11:41 Thank you.
02:12:11 Thank you.
02:12:41 Thank you.
02:13:11 Thank you.
02:13:41 Thank you.
02:14:11 Thank you.
02:14:41 Thank you.
02:15:11 Thank you.
02:15:41 Thank you.
02:16:11 Thank you.
02:16:41 Thank you.
02:17:11 Thank you.
02:17:41 Thank you.
02:18:11 Thank you.
02:18:41 Thank you.
02:19:11 Thank you.
02:19:41 Thank you.
02:20:11 Order votre.
02:20:41 The Commission has reconvened that Commissioner.
02:20:48 I mentioned before the break that you thought it was a good thing that commissions like
02:20:59 this one are here to challenge your decision to invoke the Emergencies Act. I'm about
02:21:06 put that to the test because as you can imagine uh that decision has come under a lot of criticism
02:21:13 and we've heard a lot of that criticism over the last six weeks of these hearings so i'm going to
02:21:18 put to you some of the criticisms that we've heard and i'd like to hear your answers on them
02:21:23 um the first one is well actually the first one was that the threshold wasn't met but i think
02:21:28 we've covered that we don't need to go over that one again um the second one is that invoking the
02:21:35 emergency emergencies act was executive overreach it's an anti-democratic act um
02:21:48 it exists because it was debated and voted on in parliament many years ago but
02:21:58 but duly written into the books and the laws of Canada
02:22:02 as a tool available for a situation around emergencies like this.
02:22:13 It requires...
02:22:15 They're written for situations where the emergency or the urgency
02:22:21 requires a government to have tools to put into place
02:22:24 in unforeseen circumstances that can't be anticipated years or decades in advance.
02:22:35 But that's why it was an important debate when it was brought in.
02:22:39 And that's why there are mechanisms afterwards to ensure that it was not used erroneously or lightly.
02:22:52 first mechanisms votes a vote in the house next one a parliamentary committee a design to look
02:22:59 into it the third one and most importantly this process itself which um is a really important one
02:23:06 that i knew from the moment i invoked that we were going to end up in a room such as this doing this
02:23:14 work and i would have to explain and we as a government would have to explain and justify
02:23:21 this decision to canadians because the use of special temporary emergency powers is something
02:23:32 that canadians need to be reassured is within the rules and the principles of our democracy and
02:23:42 that's exactly what this is do you think the accountability mechanisms work is this
02:23:49 is this a proper check on that power in your view sitting in your chair right now um sitting in this
02:23:56 chair and having watched uh the questions posed of officials and ministers and now me i can say
02:24:06 that it's not something that any any government would undertake likely this is a serious process
02:24:14 where there is a serious challenge function being exercised as it should be
02:24:21 as to whether it's the best way of doing things this law was brought in almost 30 years ago
02:24:31 there's always ways of reflecting on doing it differently or better
02:24:34 but that'll be the will of the house and that'll be based on perhaps recommendations by the
02:24:39 commission but um i think this process works okay um the second or another criticism that's been
02:24:49 leveled or challenge that's been made is that it wasn't really necessary the situation would have
02:24:55 resolved itself and in the end the way things played out the declaration was made the 14th
02:25:01 the orders came in the 15th and then by the 23rd it was it was revoked and everything was solved
02:25:07 and many of the measures put in were never even used so how do you respond to that you didn't
02:25:12 actually have to do it it wasn't a necessary measure at the time um it's hard to prove a
02:25:19 hypothetical uh that if we hadn't done it um things could have been resolved uh perhaps
02:25:27 perhaps they would have gotten much worse my role was to make what was the responsible call
02:25:40 in keeping Canadians safe the act was used in many different ways and far from being as you
02:25:50 perhaps suggest a proof point that it wasn't needed that it was only in place for such a
02:25:56 period of time I think that goes to the fact that it was needed and it was
02:26:03 effective in actually doing with as light a touch as we thought we could
02:26:11 have a resolution to this to this ongoing situation and emergency okay
02:26:21 And there's also an argument made that this invocation, you were dealing with an act that has never been invoked before, and now it has been.
02:26:31 And there's a possibility that this invocation of the act will then open the floodgates, in a sense, to the act being used again and again and again,
02:26:40 in particular because and we have your point on this but you invoked it in a circumstance where
02:26:48 the threat to the security of canada had not been found by cesus so does this in effect open the
02:26:54 floodgates to the emergencies act being used by a decision by the executive in all kinds of
02:27:02 circumstances but cesus isn't the decision maker in a matter of public order emergencies
02:27:10 the use of the definition in the cesus act as i said before has two very different contexts from
02:27:22 the use of it by cesus and the use of it in invocation of a public order emergency context
02:27:28 is different the purpose is different the decision maker uh is different um the the the
02:27:36 requirements around it the inputs are different um and the fact that the director of cesus
02:27:43 while consistently saying it doesn't yet meet the cesus threshold for cesus to act
02:27:50 in wiretapping people or whatever it is it is still something that is necessary
02:27:56 for a public order emergency but do you worry about the floodgates aspect of this but having
02:28:01 done this you've now maybe unleashed the kraken um i think first of all the excellent work
02:28:15 this commission and all the across the examiners have been doing over the past number of weeks
02:28:22 uh highlights that it's not something to be undertaken lately um and i didn't need to have
02:28:27 seen this commission to consider this very much to be a a measure of last resort um this wasn't
02:28:34 something we were eager to do um and i dare say that future governments um are likely to
02:28:46 look at this experience and say yeah no it's not really not something we want to go through
02:28:50 lightly but the law is on the books to assist in dealing with national
02:29:01 emergencies and the determination was made by the governor and council by the
02:29:10 professional public service that the thresholds were met and that this was
02:29:16 necessary and regardless of any setting of precedence um i think it would be the worst
02:29:25 thing for me to say even though the thresholds have been met even though it is needed and necessary
02:29:33 we're not going to do it because someone might abuse it or overuse it in the years to come
02:29:40 when there's a national emergency and serious threats of violence to canadians and you have
02:29:45 a tool that you should use how would i explain it to the family of a police officer who was killed
02:29:51 or a a grandmother who got run over stopping trying to stop a truck or or a protester who was
02:29:58 killed uh if i hadn't used the tools if uh one of the protesters uh one of the occupiers had been
02:30:06 uh had been killed uh in a violent clash with someone else um getting this situation under
02:30:13 control and protecting the safety of all canadians is a priority on the same theme but slightly
02:30:22 different um the act was invoked here in response to to a protest and protest is a very important
02:30:30 part of of uh functioning democracy and you touched on this on one of your answers before
02:30:36 the break but does this open the door then to to the emergencies act being regularly used as
02:30:42 as a tool to quell protest because protest is not necessarily clean it's it's protest can be messy
02:30:48 and it can be problematic and it can interfere at times with critical infrastructure we think
02:30:53 of indigenous protests environmental protest so what stops this from being used against that
02:31:02 um again the checks and balances we have and the need to demonstrate
02:31:09 and meet a high threshold. But also from experience over the past seven years, we've seen many
02:31:17 protests and disruptions across this country, including protests of, as you say, critical
02:31:25 infrastructure and economic – of economic importance. And it never occurred to me or to
02:31:33 the government to invoke the Emergencies Act around any of those. Now, your point around
02:31:39 And maybe future governments will run to it as a tool now that the seal has been broken.
02:31:47 But I have greater faith in Canadians and in our institutions than the fact that we
02:31:57 might sort of shrug as our fundamental rights are casually brushed aside in the name of
02:32:06 political expediency or a national emergency that actually wouldn't be one.
02:32:16 Another criticism that has leveled is that while the protests may have gotten, can we
02:32:22 say, out of hand or snowballed and been extremely disruptive, they weren't the actions of the
02:32:28 small minority, but a real expression of frustration, of legitimate frustration on behalf of a significant
02:32:35 number of Canadians who had been through, either suffered from or felt aggrieved by
02:32:42 years of public health measures. And in response to that, they wanted to engage, and they wanted
02:32:53 you to speak to them, and they wanted to hear directly from their federal government, and
02:32:57 that did not happen. So do you have an answer to that?
02:33:00 I think, first of all, we heard them. We knew exactly what they were asking for.
02:33:11 They were very, very clear that they wanted an end to mandates.
02:33:16 The convoy protesters were expressing their disagreement with very specific public policies,
02:33:25 that they were very vocal, both in mainstream communications
02:33:32 and through social media on what they wanted,
02:33:36 and they were very much heard.
02:33:38 They had political parties in the previous election
02:33:42 very much carrying those messages and presenting them to Canadians
02:33:48 as part of the options that Canadians had to choose in that previous election.
02:33:52 So people were well aware of the opinions and concerns and perspective of those individuals.
02:34:05 But it was clear that it wasn't that they just wanted to be heard.
02:34:12 They wanted to be obeyed.
02:34:14 They wanted us to change public policy, public health policy designed to help Canadians
02:34:20 and were going to occupy locations across this country
02:34:25 and interfere with the lives of Canadians
02:34:27 until such a decision was taken.
02:34:30 And I can't help but have noticed
02:34:35 that when Premier Kenney in Alberta
02:34:39 did during the course of these convoy occupations
02:34:46 remove a number of mandates instead of decreasing the amount of concern.
02:34:55 The convoy at Coutts, the occupation at Coutts, seemed to be emboldened and say,
02:35:01 look, it's starting to work, let's keep going, instead of actually de-escalating.
02:35:06 So I am very aware that expressing concern and disagreement around positions of public policy
02:35:15 is the right and is to be encouraged by any Canadian who wants to.
02:35:23 But the occupation and destabilization of and disruption of the lives of so many Canadians
02:35:35 and refusal to maintain a lawful protest
02:35:45 is not all right um one thing we haven't talked about yet is it i assume you're familiar with the
02:35:53 section 58 report to parliament explaining the the reasons for for invoking the emergencies act
02:36:00 if we look at that report much of it focuses on the economic consequences of the protests and the
02:36:06 economic disruptions and the economic the threats to economic security um and we've you've spoken
02:36:12 this morning about how the threshold for invoking the emergencies was met because there were threats
02:36:17 of serious violence but we haven't really addressed where economic security fits into
02:36:22 this picture so i'd like to hear you on that i think it's a piece of it obviously uh if people
02:36:29 are facing losses of income, if we're seeing massive disruption in a country's economy,
02:36:37 that will have and that could have real impacts on the stability and security of individuals
02:36:43 within that country. But it was an additional concern on the situation. It wasn't the primary
02:36:53 or the foundational one. Our job in here was to make sure we were keeping Canadians safe
02:36:58 and countering the threats of serious violence
02:37:00 that the occupations represented.
02:37:03 And that's what we focused on.
02:37:05 The last question I want to ask you, Prime Minister,
02:37:07 is on the question of trust in public institutions.
02:37:12 We know you've said that part of your rationale
02:37:14 for invoking the Emergencies Act
02:37:17 and for reacting to what you were seeing around you
02:37:19 was you were seeing a loss of confidence
02:37:22 or a loss of faith in Canada's public institutions.
02:37:26 that factored into your thinking against that is put that this action has destroyed a lot of
02:37:33 people's faith in their public institutions because it was seen as an executive overreach
02:37:38 so what is your response to that how do you see this having affected one way or the other
02:37:44 um i think we saw during the past couple of years and beyond that in the times we're living in
02:37:52 that people's faith in their institutions and in their democracy is really really important
02:37:59 in during the pandemic one of the things we knew that was really important was if we wanted people
02:38:05 to follow public health advice if we wanted them to stay safe during the pandemic and stay home
02:38:12 during those first weeks of of pan-canadian lockdown um we needed to be delivering income
02:38:20 supports supports for small businesses support so people could hang on and know that as they did the
02:38:27 things that kept themselves and their families safe their institutions were there to support them
02:38:33 and building up that confidence in institutions is really important and when people across this
02:38:40 country we're noting uh that our police can't even um maintain order in our capital city uh
02:38:53 that we cannot maintain the flow of essential goods and services over our most important border
02:39:00 crossing that armed protesters at coots in alberta were able to defy the police for so long um
02:39:16 people's faith in our country's institutions able to do the basic things around keeping them safe
02:39:25 gets eroded, and that is something that one has to take very seriously, that I took very, very seriously.
02:39:33 Mr. Commissioner, those are my questions.
02:39:37 Okay, thank you very much. We're going to now move into the cross-examinations.
02:39:47 So I'd like to call on first the CCLA, please.
02:39:55 Good afternoon, Prime Minister. My name is Eva Krajewska, and I'm councillor for the
02:40:10 Canadian Civil Liberties Association. Prime Minister, I wanted to start off with a quick
02:40:17 chronology leading up to the invocation of the emergencies act um on february 13th you meet with
02:40:25 the irg around 4 p.m correct yes and then you meet with cabinet the evening of the 13th correct
02:40:32 yes and at that time cabinet cabinet delegates to you the ultimate decision to invoke the
02:40:39 emergencies act and clerk charrette characterized this as lefted at referendum to the prime minister
02:40:46 correct yes and you consult with your caucus the morning of the 14th correct yes and then with the
02:40:52 first ministers the morning sorry it was more of an informing caucus than consulting with them but
02:40:58 yes okay that's fine and then you consult with the first ministers also the morning of the 14th
02:41:05 you speak to mr jagmeet singh and uh the leader of the opposition miss bergen that same day
02:41:12 and you announced the invocation of the EA at a 4.30 press conference that afternoon, correct?
02:41:20 Yes.
02:41:20 Right. And so the Emergencies Act is invoked on February 14th,
02:41:26 and then the measures that are put in place under the Emergencies Act are enacted on February 15th, correct?
02:41:33 Yes.
02:41:34 And those, if I can put them as two buckets, the two buckets of measures that are invoked on the 15th,
02:41:41 The first are, there is now a prohibition on public assembly that may lead to a breach of the peace, correct?
02:41:49 And the second are various economic measures that include the freezing of accounts of anyone who is involved in that public assembly that may lead to a breach of the peace, correct?
02:42:00 Yes.
02:42:01 Right.
02:42:02 And now, going back a little bit, you spoke briefly about Windsor.
02:42:07 the blockade at the Ambassador Bridge, that was a significant event that was one of the events that
02:42:16 led to the invocation of the Emergencies Act, correct? It was one of many, but yes. It was one
02:42:22 of many. And you understand that the police, both the Windsor Police Service and the OPP,
02:42:28 started to clear that block starting on February 12th? Yes. And that continued on February 13th?
02:42:36 Yes.
02:42:37 And I believe WPS, Windsor Police Service,
02:42:41 tweeted that the Windsor Ambassador Bridge
02:42:45 was cleared at 01200 on February 14th.
02:42:50 That sounds right.
02:42:51 Now, with respect to Coutts,
02:42:53 that was another blockade of a border
02:42:56 that was causing you and the government
02:42:59 a significant concern, correct?
02:43:01 Yes.
02:43:01 And you were informed by Premier Kenney
02:43:04 on February 14th in the morning,
02:43:06 that the RCMP had started to make arrests
02:43:09 the night before, correct?
02:43:11 Yes.
02:43:11 And that, in his words,
02:43:13 the situation has been secured
02:43:16 and they will now proceed with broader arrests
02:43:18 and secure the border.
02:43:19 You remember that?
02:43:20 Yes.
02:43:21 And in Alberta,
02:43:23 Alberta is one of the provinces that had in place
02:43:26 or has in place a critical infrastructure legislation
02:43:30 that protects critical infrastructure
02:43:32 from blockades, including highways.
02:43:34 correct yes now ottawa ottawa the ottawa demonstrations in the blockade they don't
02:43:40 get removed until later in the week of february 15th correct correct and for the purpose of that
02:43:47 operation the rcmp the opp and the ops they form a joint command yes and prime minister you agree
02:43:57 that the emergencies act and the orders enacted under the emergencies act there was nothing in
02:44:04 in those order that created the joint command no right yes i agree that that the emergencies act
02:44:14 did not address creation of joint commands although it did allow for the easy deputization
02:44:22 of rcmp officers to enforce municipal bylaws and municipal rules without having to go through
02:44:32 the usual processes that are required if they want to do that, which allowed for a greater
02:44:40 integration. Correct. It did away with the administrative process that was taking some
02:44:47 time of having the RCMP enforce local bylaws. So it did facilitate the coming together of those
02:44:53 three forces. But the joint command in and of itself, that was something that the police
02:44:58 could have created and could have done
02:44:59 without the invocation of the Emergencies Act.
02:45:02 Yes.
02:45:02 Right.
02:45:03 And we heard evidence from Commissioner Lucky of the RCMP
02:45:08 that she had signed off on a plan to enforce
02:45:13 and remove the protesters in Ottawa on February 13th
02:45:18 that she had confidence in,
02:45:19 that she, the OPP, and the OPS had confidence in.
02:45:23 Did you hear that testimony?
02:45:25 No, I disagree with that.
02:45:28 Okay, you disagree with that?
02:45:29 Yes, I do not believe that the plan that was either signed off on supposedly by the RCMP
02:45:36 or presented by the Ottawa Police Services on the 13th was, in any real regards,
02:45:44 an actual plan for clearing the protests.
02:45:48 And is this a plan that you saw or that you were just spoken to about?
02:45:52 I was spoken to about. I did not see it myself.
02:45:54 Okay. And were you spoken to about it by Commissioner Luckey or by Minister Mendocino?
02:45:58 I don't remember.
02:45:59 You don't remember.
02:46:00 But as of February 13th, your impression was that the plan that was in place at that time was not one that you or the RCMP had confidence in?
02:46:11 It was not one that we had confidence in, no.
02:46:14 Okay. All right. I will leave it there because I think there are other parties here that understand that better than I do.
02:46:23 okay so in terms of the legal tools that were available in ottawa uh we heard evidence from
02:46:30 superintendent burnier who was the event commander for the ottawa police services you're familiar
02:46:37 with that yes okay he testified that he did not communicate to anyone that he needed or the ops
02:46:44 needed additional tools in order to implement their plan did you hear that evidence uh in in
02:46:50 hindsight yes during this process during this process but at the time you did not hear from
02:46:56 ops or superintendent bernie that the ops required additional legal tools or legal resources
02:47:04 um what we saw consistently was uh the
02:47:09 the occupation was continuing and the the ability of the police to resolve it was not was not there
02:47:25 right and you spoke about that earlier with miss chowdhury that both you
02:47:29 the government and i think both uh clerk charrette and deputy clerk juan all expressed the view that
02:47:36 the view or even frustration that the police had not been using the legal tools available
02:47:43 to them to remove the demonstration or had not been able to use or had not been able to use those
02:47:49 tools yes okay and uh prime minister brenda lucky the commissioner of the rcmp also on the on the
02:47:57 13th she was of the view that existing legal tools had not been exhausted and she communicated this
02:48:04 to the chief of staff of minister to minister mendoza i was not aware of that at the time uh
02:48:11 as we went around the virtual table at the irg that day um the consensus from everyone including
02:48:20 the uh commissioner of the rcmp uh was clear that there that we were advancing uh on these uh extra
02:48:28 tools um and i as i said i don't disagree with that assessment that not all tools had been used
02:48:38 that was part of the problem that not all tools were being used uh to uh end uh this occupation
02:48:45 right and uh prime minister we talked about the threshold for invoking a national emergency you
02:48:51 spoke about that briefly in um your examination in chief and you understand that the other than
02:48:58 the cease then the threshold in the ceases act part of the test is whether the the matter exceeds
02:49:05 both the capacity and the authority of a province to deal with the matter you understand that yes
02:49:12 and deputy clerk drawing said that authority refers to legal authority and capacity refers to
02:49:19 operational capacity and you would agree with that okay yes and when you i'm taking you back
02:49:27 now to your press conference at 4 30 on the 14th at that press conference you specifically referred
02:49:36 to the fact that there were serious challenges to law enforcement's ability to effectively enforce
02:49:43 the law you remember that yes and that the emergencies act will be used to strengthen
02:49:48 and support law enforcement agencies at all levels of the country you remember saying that yes and
02:49:54 that the police will be given more tools to restore order in places where public assemblies can
02:49:59 constitute illegal and dangerous activities yes and so at that time that was one or one of the
02:50:06 main justifications that you stated publicly for the invocation of the emergencies act yes
02:50:12 and that was again because many of your ministers and many of the people in the public service had
02:50:21 expressed frustration with the police inability to exercise those legal tools no it wasn't just
02:50:30 because people had expressed frustration um it was real concern as you mentioned that a number
02:50:38 of places were moving in the right direction in terms of resolving the situation at Coutts,
02:50:45 resolving the situation at the Ambassador Bridge.
02:50:48 There was a very real and present concern that it is one thing to clear a lane or two,
02:50:55 it is another thing to keep a border location or otherwise open.
02:51:02 And what we had seen was intentions for the convoy to pop up again at the Blue Water Bridge
02:51:07 and sarnia at fort erie there was discussion of the call there were more activities starting in
02:51:13 surrey and bc at other border crossings there was a ongoing concern that it wasn't just about
02:51:20 ending the places that were there it was ensuring that they simply didn't shift to another locale
02:51:26 because many of these uh convoy uh participants had come a long way across the country and were
02:51:35 mobile enough to go to another nearby location and so you're you're you're in a sense making sure
02:51:41 it was almost preventative preventative in terms of we've removed them and we want to prevent them
02:51:46 from relocating and restaging at another location would that be fair yes that was a concern but at
02:51:52 the same time there was very much a concern that it be temporary that we brought in that we not
02:51:58 keep the emergencies act in place for a minute longer than necessary and when the uh rcmp suggested
02:52:05 that they wanted it in place for three weeks or they would need it in place for up to three weeks
02:52:09 uh you know we we took that very seriously as a request but we ended up saying no uh we're going
02:52:15 to end it as quickly as we can and we did prime minister you spoke about how you are advised that
02:52:21 it would be impermissible for the government to direct the police and that was a line that you
02:52:25 and your staff and your ministers understood very clearly correct yes we were very careful about that
02:52:30 you're very careful about that but you'd agree that when you invoke the emergencies act and you
02:52:35 very publicly say to the police these are tools that you now have that you are publicly signaling
02:52:42 this is the road we want you to walk down now and and use these tools in order to deal with
02:52:47 of these demonstrators. Do you agree with that? We were very clearly saying that we need to restore
02:52:55 enforcement of the law and we need to restore public order. But as I said clearly a little
02:53:01 earlier, in the situation of a theoretical blockade at Lacalle, I was very clear with
02:53:07 the Premier of Quebec and indeed in communications that if the public order emergency tools weren't
02:53:14 necessary they didn't need to use them and and quebec did not invoke their own emergencies act
02:53:20 correct they did not uh i'm not sure but i i'll thank your word for it but i don't think quebec
02:53:25 invoked their emergencies act for the purpose of the thing uh for the convoy now my last area of
02:53:30 question uh prime minister is with respect to the cesus act and its integration into the
02:53:36 uh emergencies act i under so you you've stated under the cesus act when cesus determines that
02:53:44 they are going to use surveillance on a person they need to meet the left sec the threshold at
02:53:51 section two correct yes and that's because the surveillance of one person without other legal
02:53:57 authority is something that is very serious and that requires a high legal threshold correct
02:54:02 Now, I understand your evidence that for the purpose of the Emergencies Act, we are dealing with a different context, yes, a different purpose, and we're dealing with a different decision maker, correct?
02:54:15 But I would put to you that when invoking the Emergencies Act, that threshold, the level of threshold of the security threat that must be met, cannot be any lower than it is when CSIS is proposing to surveil one person.
02:54:35 That the threshold is no different. Do you agree with that?
02:54:39 Yes, I do.
02:54:40 Thank you, Prime Minister. Those are my questions.
02:54:45 Okay, next is the Canadian Constitution Foundation.
02:54:55 Commissioner, my friend has asked to switch spots.
02:55:00 I see that.
02:55:01 We've advised the parties. Yes, I am not Mr. Kittredge, and no parties have objected.
02:55:08 Okay, well, in the spirit of cooperation, that's fine with me.
02:55:13 Thank you, sir.
02:55:14 And have you given up your time on the Canadian Constitution?
02:55:17 Oh, no, not at all.
02:55:20 Just want to be clear.
02:55:22 I hope spring's eternal, but I'm afraid not.
02:55:25 Okay.
02:55:27 All right.
02:55:28 Well, good morning, Mr. Prime Minister.
02:55:31 I'd like to quickly circle back.
02:55:33 Could you introduce me?
02:55:34 Oh, I'm sorry.
02:55:35 Particularly given my mistake.
02:55:38 I'm Rob Kittredge for the Justice Centre for Constitutional Freedoms,
02:55:42 and we share standing at these hearings with the Democracy Fund and Citizens for Freedom.
02:55:48 I'd like to circle back to a bit of a constitutional conversation I had the other day.
02:55:56 Cabinet confidentiality, the principle that members of Cabinet are free to express their opinions on issues before Cabinet,
02:56:03 fully in private meetings and discussions with you and their Cabinet colleagues.
02:56:07 Are you familiar with that principle?
02:56:10 Yes, I am.
02:56:10 and the principle of uh cabinet solidarity uh where once decisions are presented to the public
02:56:17 or to parliament they are collective decisions of cabinet and can't be repudiated or criticized by
02:56:23 your ministers and if they were to do that they would have to resign their post that is the
02:56:29 principle yes all right um tow trucks have come a lot come up a lot at this commission
02:56:37 and my friends and the Commissioner know me by now as a bit of a towing aficionado.
02:56:42 It's been a while since I've brought up the subject, but I thought maybe you and I could
02:56:46 have a little talk about it. As you know, in order to legitimately and legally declare a public order
02:56:51 emergency pursuant to the Emergencies Act, the purported emergency cannot be effectively dealt
02:56:57 with under any other law of Canada. You're taking the position that the emergency declaration was
02:57:02 justified in part because towing services were required and could not be procured is that accurate
02:57:09 um that's a bit of a leap um we say that the emergencies act was required uh because the
02:57:19 situation as a whole could not be resolved uh by with under existing authorities and was not being
02:57:26 resolved under existing authorities right but uh towing service procurement was part of that
02:57:31 total picture that you're talking about wasn't it um one of the barriers that we heard regularly
02:57:37 from uh police of jurisdiction to removing uh the uh trucks occupying various locations was
02:57:46 the difficulty in securing towing services yes that was one of the barriers they were facing in
02:57:52 being able to restore public order right so uh one of the measures that you act that you put in
02:57:57 place through the Emergency Measures Regulations was an ability to compel tow truck drivers
02:58:02 to provide towing services, wasn't it?
02:58:04 Yes, it was.
02:58:05 So I'd say that would be a fairly significant part of the reason why you would have had
02:58:09 to invoke the Emergencies Act, wouldn't you agree with that?
02:58:12 It was an element of the solutions to the situation that we were dealing with, yes.
02:58:18 It was one of a handful of powers that you created using the Emergency Measures Regulations,
02:58:25 is that right?
02:58:26 Yes.
02:58:27 say it's relatively important would you agree with that it was important in in yes solving solving the
02:58:35 emergency situation yes certainly relevant to the invocation of the emergencies act
02:58:43 the invocation of the emergencies act wasn't because people couldn't find tow trucks the
02:58:50 invocation was because there was a public order emergency that posed serious threats to canadians
02:58:57 And the inability to solve this public order emergency that posed a serious threat to the safety of Canadians was compounded by the inability to actually move those trucks, for example.
02:59:15 And that would be one of the ways that the emergency couldn't have been effectively dealt with under any other law of Canada, wouldn't you say?
02:59:27 municipalities and provinces have contracts with tow truck companies to
02:59:35 keep the highways clear to keep the roads clear and tow parked cars that are
02:59:39 illegally parked all the time so they had theoretically the authority to
02:59:46 compel people under breach of contract to actually tow vehicles that they that
02:59:53 that were illegally parked um for various reasons they were unable or unwilling to use the civil
03:00:02 powers they have under contract or perhaps it would just take too long for them to be able to
03:00:06 do it but in feedback with everyone from alberta to ontario to elsewhere uh was that they needed
03:00:13 to be able to compel uh those tow trucks to actually do uh the job of clearing the streets
03:00:19 and you in fact put that power into the emergency measures right yes we did and so a discussion of
03:00:24 that of tow trucks is relevant to this discussion we're having right now yes um and uh we talked
03:00:31 about cabinet uh solidarity earlier there's been a waiver of cabinet confidence the related
03:00:36 partial waiver i should say of cabinet consonant confidence the related principle that would have
03:00:41 allowed you to withhold documents from this commission uh you've disclosed quite a few and
03:00:45 would you say you've been pretty transparent with the commission um there have been hundreds of uh
03:00:52 public uh inquiries over the course of of our country's history and uh only four times were
03:00:59 there waivers of cabinet confidence for this situation it was extremely important to me
03:01:05 that all the inputs or as many inputs as possible uh that cabinet received in
03:01:11 making the determinations uh that we did uh were are visible to canadians so yes we've waived
03:01:19 cabinet confidence in terms of the inputs that cabinet heard to make the decision but the actual
03:01:25 deliberations as you point out uh remain secret great um so you you wanted to make sure that uh
03:01:31 the relevant uh matters were visible to canadians uh can i pull up poe jcf2 please
03:01:37 So this is a document as it's coming up. We've been having a bit of an argument over the last
03:01:43 little while about some redactions that were made in the documents disclosed by my friends for Canada.
03:01:50 And there were some disputes about parliamentary privilege and irrelevance. But in this particular
03:01:58 document, I'd like you to take a look at this. This first document was what was originally
03:02:02 disclosed and this document the second one uh had some redactions removed that uh that and those
03:02:09 documents were ordered disclosed last night um and uh were uh canada took the position last night
03:02:18 that there were uh there was reason to insist on uh this that this uh redaction or that this document
03:02:26 be produced not be produced unredacted um but i wonder if maybe you could uh and at the end of
03:02:32 the day this was produced at 10 26 a.m this morning so i'm a little more unprepared for this
03:02:37 cross than i normally am um but uh i wonder if you could look at that first redaction on the uh
03:02:43 on the original disclosure and see if you can see the reason for the redaction that's
03:02:48 highlighted in the black box there um it appears to say parliament uh irrelevant
03:02:55 and parliamentary privilege right so i'm looking at the irrelevant one uh could you identify on
03:03:01 the other side what uh information was blacked out as irrelevant by your government um americans
03:03:09 offer offering tow trucks yeah and uh wouldn't you say that uh discussion of tow trucks was relevant
03:03:16 to the discussion we're having here today uh i'm not the one who made these redactions
03:03:22 uh it's the professional public service that made those redactions so you'd have to ask them
03:03:26 right well i think we will be but um uh in any event uh i would put it to you that tow trucks
03:03:32 weren't in fact required uh that the power to compel tow trucks was not used for anything
03:03:38 other than convenience and uh that tow trucks had been secured at all important locations prior to
03:03:44 the invocation of the emergencies act and i i gotta say it's uh it's interesting to close on
03:03:50 this tow truck point i hadn't expected that to happen but uh would you agree with me that tow
03:03:54 trucks weren't in fact needed at the time of the invocation of the act mr commissioner brian gover
03:03:59 for the government of canada and uh if my friend is going to put that to the witness he ought to
03:04:05 put the proposition correctly i remind my friend that uh the evidence of commissioner karik of the
03:04:14 Ontario Provincial Police was that the powers under the Emergency Measures Regulation in
03:04:19 relation to tow trucks were used. I refer specifically to his February 22nd, 2022 report
03:04:27 to Deputy Solicitor General Di Tomasso which shows that clearly those powers were used. Thank you.
03:04:35 Right, well I would respond by saying that the evidence so far has shown that
03:04:39 uh that that that while the while strictly speaking there was an indication of or there
03:04:45 was a use of that power under the act uh by the opp it was basically used as a method to ensure
03:04:51 that the payment was made it's it's supposed to come to me and i think those happen to be areas
03:04:56 that i'm going to have to deal with what is in fact the case but you can pose your question in
03:05:03 a different way if you wish but i think whether or not they were used whether or not it was required
03:05:09 is something i will i think i think we're burying the lead a little bit here and uh i'll ask you
03:05:14 again uh you would agree that a discussion of tow trucks and information about tow trucks is relevant
03:05:20 to the duck to the work of the commission and the uh discussion that we're having here today
03:05:24 wouldn't you i know there was a lot of time spent on tow trucks during the past six weeks right well
03:05:29 thank you very much okay thank you next is now the canadian constitution foundation or have i
03:05:36 it is okay thank you i don't want to get it wrong again
03:05:44 it's been a long six weeks commissioner uh good morning prime minister my name is sujit chowdhury
03:05:48 i'm counsel for the ccf um a prime minister i'd like to uh shift gears a bit and uh ask you some
03:05:56 questions about your role as chair of the cabinet and so it is it's true would you agree that one
03:06:03 of your chief responsibilities as prime minister is to share the cabinet yes and it's a serious
03:06:09 responsibility yes and so yesterday uh there was a panel uh testifying from the prime minister's
03:06:17 office i i'm sure you're aware and uh your chief of staff uh katie telford uh answered questions
03:06:24 about your role as chair of the cabinet are you aware of her testimony yes and so she uh under
03:06:32 cross-examination uh she testified that you are the ultimate decision maker for determining
03:06:39 the information and documentation shared at cabinet meetings um is there do you have any
03:06:44 reason to disagree with what she said um yeah that was in a a series of questions uh you know
03:06:52 linked to you know who ultimately decides who's in the room or not uh the reality is the authority
03:06:57 rests with me. If I, in seeing what the public service has prepared for me as a list of subjects
03:07:08 in Cabinet or attendees at Cabinet or documents to be provided at Cabinet, if I have significant
03:07:16 issue with any one of them, I can say, no, we're not going to present that to Cabinet,
03:07:20 and it won't go to cabinet but as par for the course um i do not spend um time
03:07:28 going over in advance every possible document going to cabinet to say yes this can go this
03:07:35 can go this shouldn't go this can't go it's an exceptional circumstance so there's advice
03:07:39 provided to you by the privy council office is that what you're saying on what documentation
03:07:43 and information goes to cabinet it's presented to you for review and then you sign off on it yes or
03:07:49 now um no for example um if we're dealing in cabinet with a particular uh mc from our particular
03:08:01 proposal from a given department uh they will put forward that document that proposal
03:08:10 i will as par for the course as all cabinet members do read through that documentation as
03:08:15 as part of our deliberations that we're about to have but for me i have the power to say
03:08:24 no you know what we're not going to discuss this today or this document's not going to go in
03:08:29 uh which i do from time to time if we decide no it's not ready to go forward we're not going to
03:08:34 do that uh but i guess i'm not entirely sure what what power you're trying to get get me to admit
03:08:40 to having or not sure so well why don't we talk about the february 13th cabinet meeting
03:08:44 uh so the questions are about that and so you you'd agree sir that that was uh an extraordinarily
03:08:50 important cabinet meeting yes a historic meeting even yes uh and though uh even though it was
03:08:57 happening uh at a time of great um pressure of great urgency uh you would have taken care to
03:09:05 determine uh in your capacity as chair of cabinet that cabinet had all the relevant information
03:09:13 documentation before it um the way cabinet works is we do an awful lot of work in cabinet committees
03:09:22 we do not uh as a par for a course dig into every item that comes forward in a fulsome way
03:09:30 because we have subgroups of cabinet that dig into that so there will have been before any
03:09:36 cabinet meeting including that one subgroupings meeting to debate to discuss things that then
03:09:43 get reported back to cabineters so but you would agree that under the emergencies act as you as you
03:09:50 as you stated this morning in testimony the power to declare a public order emergency
03:09:54 rests with what you called the cabinet and prime minister which is the governor governor
03:09:59 which is the full cabinet not a cabinet subcommittee no that's right okay subcommittees
03:10:03 deliberate but as a as a matter of uh generality they don't make final determination and you agree
03:10:10 there's no way you could have gone to that you could have declared a public
03:10:13 order emergency without having a full cabinet meeting um
03:10:21 in this case it was something very important to me i could imagine
03:10:27 catastrophic scenarios in which a government might have to declare a public order emergency
03:10:33 without a meeting of full cabinet either because of urgency or because of circumstance that prevents
03:10:41 cabinet from gathering so but in this case there was such a meeting yes and so i chose to have a
03:10:46 meeting so i'd like to ask you some questions of what you've termed as the inputs to that meeting
03:10:51 and just to be abundantly clear to my friend from the attorney general of canada i'm not going to
03:10:55 ask you about the content of any of those inputs that might be protected by confidence i just
03:11:00 simply want to ask you of certain documents where inputs are not to the cabinet meeting if i may
03:11:06 so the first uh is that we've heard in testimony that there was a legal opinion
03:11:11 that explained the diff the difference in the definition of threats to the security of canada
03:11:16 in the cses act and the emergencies act and you've testified to that this morning
03:11:20 do you know sir if that illegal opinion was provided to the full cabinet at its meeting of
03:11:25 february 13th in matters of legal opinion in many situations most situations we hear from
03:11:36 the attorney general and justice minister who reports to cabinet on uh this or that uh legal
03:11:44 opinion so was that written opinion provided to the cabinet sir uh i believe it was a report from
03:11:50 uh a verbal report from the minister of justice i'd like to ask you about another document uh
03:11:56 which is that we've heard about a threat assessment prepared by cesus and you're familiar with that as
03:12:00 well and director vigno testified uh that he'd concluded or cesus had concluded that there
03:12:07 wasn't a threat to national security under 2c of the cesus act he also testified that that threat
03:12:13 assessment was provided to the irg on february 13th so my question is was this threat assessment
03:12:19 provided to the full cabinet on the evening of february 13th uh in our reporting to cabinet
03:12:27 there was a reporting on the consensus reached by the irg including the director of cses who
03:12:39 recommended uh and agreed with the invocation of a public order emergency we were not at cabinet
03:12:45 dealing with whether or not CSIS had the authority to move forward with a wiretap on one person or
03:12:51 another it was a discussion on the invocation of a public order emergency which requires reasonable
03:12:58 grounds for the governor and council to make a determination so sir you'd agree that that
03:13:03 document was not provided to the full cabinet on the feb on february 13th you said which document
03:13:10 is that? The CSIS threat assessment. And if I could rephrase what you said, you just said
03:13:14 the IRG considered that report. It discussed it. No, no. Throughout the IRGs, CSIS, as
03:13:23 a par for a course, would mention that the threshold had not been met for CSIS operations
03:13:32 within this of a particular type, according to their context and their mandate.
03:13:39 But we were not looking as an IRG or a cabinet as to whether or not CSIS would be allowed to do this or that thing.
03:13:49 We were looking at, certainly by this end, whether or not we had a threshold met for the invocation of a public order emergency.
03:13:59 So, Prime Minister, Director Vigneault testified that a written threat assessment was prepared by CSIS, and he testified that he provided that to the IRG.
03:14:10 Yes.
03:14:10 Are you saying that that document was not provided to the IRG?
03:14:14 No, that would have been provided to the IRG.
03:14:16 But would you agree that it wasn't provided to the full cabinet?
03:14:19 Yes, I agree that it was, that the report was given that the narrow CSIS threshold was not met for a CSIS operation, but because that was not the issue at play in this cabinet discussion.
03:14:41 The issue was, was the threat of serious violence threshold met in the context of a public order emergency?
03:14:51 Was the discussion at play?
03:14:52 And, Prime Minister, this morning in your testimony, you addressed the policing plan that was prepared by the OPS.
03:14:59 And I believe you stated, we should read it, we should look at it, because it wasn't much of a plan.
03:15:07 Is that fair?
03:15:08 That is my understanding of it.
03:15:09 So sir, I'd like to pull the plan up on the screen, please.
03:15:13 It's, and Mr. Registrar, it's PB NSC CAN 407734.
03:15:19 four zeros seven seven three four
03:15:39 thank you mr registrar uh prime minister is this the document or is this the plan you're referring
03:15:43 to i have not uh i have heard about this i haven't ever actually seen it so so sir what i'd like to
03:15:50 do so you've not read this no i have not okay so i certainly have not read it on the 13th okay and
03:15:55 so i i'd like to just um mr registrar i'd just like to walk the prime minister through the pages
03:16:01 not so he could read it because we don't have time but just to point out that this is a heavily
03:16:04 redacted document so page one is the cover page page two is a is this signature page if we could
03:16:13 go down page three is a description of the situation and the mission and then mr registrar
03:16:18 if you could please please scroll down uh the rest of this document has been redacted so that's page
03:16:23 four page five page six uh page seven page eight so prime minister you said we should read this
03:16:31 plan we can't uh it's your it's within your legal authority to instruct your council to remove these
03:16:37 redactions for the sake of the of the transparency of this commission sir would you would consider
03:16:42 that request i object to that on behalf of the government of canada it's brian gover once again
03:16:48 this is putting the prime minister in an odious position uh we had no notice that they would
03:16:55 attempt this uh in cross-examination these things require careful consideration do not lend themselves
03:17:03 to decisions in the moment and we maintain our objection commissioner sorry sir this was in our
03:17:15 document list um that we circulated within time uh to council for the attorney general they had
03:17:21 noticed that we would be putting this document and the question is a fair one in response to
03:17:26 to the prime minister's testimony this morning that he said you should read it i think it it
03:17:32 is fair in a sense but i think what's being raised is it's a little more complicated than
03:17:38 the federal government or the prime minister releasing these this is a police operational
03:17:44 plan of the ops involving officers from the ops and from opp involving strategy etc and i would
03:17:53 be very surprised if the federal government would order its release without consulting
03:17:59 with the various police services and i i i think that's the unfairness that's being referred to and
03:18:05 quite fair frankly i agree now it's having said that he made reference to the plan and
03:18:12 there is an issue about reading it for sure but i think the context is is important here so
03:18:18 commissioner with that with with your ruling there and i thank mr governor for his point
03:18:22 Prime Minister, can I put it to you this way?
03:18:23 You said we should read the plan, but I think to a degree we can't.
03:18:28 Indeed.
03:18:30 As I said, I haven't read the plan, but we're in a situation where, as can be imagined,
03:18:36 I have access to unredacted information.
03:18:42 And what I know and my understanding of this plan was, and I'm happy to testify to that,
03:18:48 that it was not a complete plan of engagement.
03:18:51 And, Prime Minister, and again, I think I would like to raise this, again, I'm looking to Mr. Gover in anticipation of his reaction.
03:19:02 As you know, there's a legal opinion that over which solicitor client privilege has been asserted.
03:19:08 We asked Minister Lamedi to release that opinion, and in a public statement this week, he said he couldn't because he lacked the authority to.
03:19:16 That would be up to his client, and he then clarified that his client is a governor and counsel.
03:19:21 so again for the record sir and this has been an issue for all week not just this morning
03:19:27 would you advise that that opinion be released in the interest of transparency
03:19:33 mr commissioner it's brian gover once again for the government of canada
03:19:38 solicitor client privilege of course is a very substantial right in our legal system it's one
03:19:44 that the supreme court of canada is recognized as a constitutional dimension
03:19:49 i remind my friends that in this case as the prime minister has said cabinet confidence has been
03:19:56 waived for the fourth time in 155 years to provide evidence of inputs we know that the decision note
03:20:05 that was referred to in testimony by the clerk of the privy council referred to the advice of the
03:20:11 public service that that it was appropriate to invoke the emergencies act in my submission
03:20:19 we need not go further with the inquiry and pierce the veil of solicitor client privilege
03:20:26 setting but in my submission could be a dangerous precedent going forward and one this is certainly
03:20:32 an issue that requires careful consideration and not one to require a prime minister to respond to
03:20:39 in the spur of the moment thank you
03:20:44 okay well i think uh you have a refusal uh essentially uh by uh council so i think you're
03:20:51 gonna have to move on okay thank you commissioner and and and so i have one final question sir so
03:20:57 uh there has been a lot of discussion this week about legal thresholds and how they differ um
03:21:04 under the emergencies act on your on your government submission than they do under the
03:21:08 cesus act and you testified about this this morning i i just want to ask you one question
03:21:14 the the emergency was revoked on february 23rd correct um yes we can take we can take my word
03:21:22 for it and and and prior to that revocation uh there was a great deal of public debate
03:21:29 and public discussion um about um the about the case for the emergency made by the government is
03:21:36 that right yes and sir i i'd put it to you that not until this commission has the government of
03:21:42 canada ever publicly communicated that the threshold for declaring a determining a threat
03:21:48 to national security is different under the emergencies act than under the cease effect not
03:21:53 once why is that sir it's in the first line of the public order emergency
03:22:02 section of the emergencies act that the governor and council can on reasonable
03:22:12 grounds declare a public order emergency if in their reasonable opinion
03:22:19 I'm paraphrasing obviously, there are threats to the security of Canada and it is a national emergency.
03:22:30 That doesn't mention CSIS threshold anywhere.
03:22:35 Commissioner, I think those conclude my questions. Thank you.
03:22:39 Okay, thank you. Just before I go to the next cross-examiner,
03:22:44 There seems to be some reactions in the crowd that, in my view, are inappropriate.
03:22:53 This is, I think, a very important process and very serious.
03:23:00 There are a lot of people outside, as I understand it, who would like to come in.
03:23:04 I would ask you to please refrain from comments or laughing or whatever.
03:23:14 uh and try and keep it serious uh that would be appreciated and not only appreciated i if
03:23:21 necessary it will be enforced so could i ask that it you continue to be attentive and
03:23:32 pay the attention that is required for what's going on
03:23:36 so with that brief comment uh call on the ottawa police service please
03:23:43 Good afternoon, Prime Minister. My name is Jessica Barrow, and I am counsel for the Ottawa
03:23:56 Police Service. Prime Minister, we've heard evidence from you about your understanding
03:24:02 of intelligence information as well as operational planning at various points throughout the
03:24:08 events in ottawa and i just want to clarify your role as it relates to that information and i take
03:24:14 it it's not your role as prime minister to collect intelligence information is that correct no it's
03:24:19 not similarly it's not your role to review the details of an operational plan no it's certainly
03:24:24 not and that's because you rely on highly trained police officers to perform the work that they're
03:24:30 best at which is performing those functions and then it gets briefed up to you is that fair yes
03:24:35 And I assume that you regularly rely in particular on the intelligence and operational planning expertise of the RCMP as they are the National Police Service, correct?
03:24:46 Yes.
03:24:47 And of course, you trust them to perform those functions effectively.
03:24:50 Okay. So we've heard considerable evidence to date from the Commission that an integrated planning cell arrived in Ottawa on February 8th. Were you aware of that?
03:25:01 That sounds right.
03:25:03 And we also heard that Superintendent Bernier from Ottawa Police Service took over as event commander on February 10th and established what he referred to as an integrated command structure, which we heard described from him as including experts from subject matter areas such as negotiations, public order, intelligence, etc.
03:25:23 Were you aware of that?
03:25:25 That sounds reasonable, yes.
03:25:27 Okay. And the experts involved in both the integrated planning cell and the ultimate integrated
03:25:34 command structure included senior and specially trained officers from OPS, RCMP, OPP and other
03:25:40 municipal police services. Would you agree with that? Yes, I was aware of that.
03:25:45 And as you indicated, you would have, of course, leave it up to those experts to draft,
03:25:50 review and approve operational plans. Is that fair? Yes. Okay. And you certainly wouldn't have
03:25:55 had the capacity in your role to engage in any kind of line-by-line review or assessment
03:26:01 of the viability of those operational plans no okay and so i want to focus because we've
03:26:07 heard a fair bit of evidence about this this morning uh in relation to the time frame of
03:26:12 february 12th onwards and the operational plans that existed at that time you participated in
03:26:18 an irg meeting on february 12th is that correct yes uh yes and so i'd like to pull up the minutes
03:26:25 from that meeting if we can it's ssm nsc can 214 please
03:26:37 and in particular i'm looking for page six mr clerk
03:26:55 And so we see in the second paragraph that this is an update from the Minister of Public Safety and we see the last sentence of that.
03:27:06 During the discussion, confirmation was obtained that the OPS Chief of Police accepted the plan and the Commissioner of the RCMP agreed to be able to provide additional details of that plan at the next call.
03:27:18 Do you recall that?
03:27:21 i'm looking at the sentence before where it says there appears to be a lack of a plan in ottawa
03:27:26 with the chief of ottawa police services having yet to approve the plan developed with the rcmp
03:27:31 and opp right and then subsequent to that we see that in the middle of the meeting there's
03:27:35 confirmation uh that the ops chief has agreed to the plan and that commissioner lucky agrees
03:27:42 to provide additional details to this group subsequently in relation to the details is that
03:27:47 fair fair okay and so this was put to commissioner lucky in her testimony and my understanding of her
03:27:54 evidence is that she never did subsequently provide the details of that plan to this group
03:28:00 on the 13th or otherwise would you disagree with that evidence um no i agree because uh what we
03:28:07 heard was the plans uh were not adequate they were um not uh operational plans at that point
03:28:15 okay but you didn't ever hear the details of the plan and she certainly doesn't say in this meeting
03:28:20 that from her perspective it was not an adequate plan she's just saying i'll provide you an update
03:28:24 later i can't speak to what she was knowing or not but i can say that when we were briefed on the
03:28:33 13th as to the operational plan or readiness of
03:28:41 enforcement in in ottawa we were understanding that there was not a full operational plan at that
03:28:50 point okay so your understanding of what occurred on the 13th was that you were provided some level
03:28:55 of information that led you to believe that there was no complete operational plan is that fair
03:28:59 That was consistent with everything we heard throughout the course of the three weeks, that there were not yet concrete plans to be able to actually do the work that Canadians were hoping to see.
03:29:17 Right. So I understand that there are various planning timeframes, but I'm specifically talking about the 13th and whether you were provided details of a complete operational plan to end the protests in Ottawa.
03:29:32 My understanding was there was not a complete operational plan to end protests in Ottawa as of the 13th.
03:29:39 Okay. I'd like to bring up OPP 1851, please.
03:29:47 Okay, so let's just start with the title page.
03:30:01 This is called Integrated Mobilization Operational Plan, and if we could scroll down to page
03:30:07 two, you can see at the top that the plan was written by the integrated planning cell
03:30:13 that has multiple services listed there.
03:30:17 dated the 13th and we see that there's sign off here from superintendent phil lew of the rcmp
03:30:24 uh chief superintendent carson party of the opp and acting superintendent rob bernier
03:30:30 of the ottawa police service you see that okay and so i just want to if you look at the bottom
03:30:35 of this uh the screenshot here you can see that this is a 73 page document you see that
03:30:41 okay okay and so obviously we don't have time unfortunately to fully digest this entire document
03:30:49 um but is it fair to say that um prior to the police operation on february 18th to 20th as
03:30:57 well as prior to the invocation of the emergencies act you had never seen this document no okay
03:31:05 no it is it yes it is fair to say that no i had never seen it thank you for that clarification
03:31:09 um and so you suggested multiple times in your evidence this morning uh that to your knowledge
03:31:16 the operational plan that existed at the time of the of february 13th was by no means an actual
03:31:22 plan to actually end the protests in ottawa is that a fair representation of your evidence that
03:31:26 was my understanding yes okay and you also testified that it was not a plan that you or
03:31:31 the rcmp had confidence in is that correct at least that was your understanding if there
03:31:39 wasn't a plan, then we probably didn't have confidence in it.
03:31:45 Fair enough.
03:31:45 But as you can see here, there is a 73-page document dated February 13th that a senior
03:31:50 member of the RCMP has signed off on.
03:31:54 Yes.
03:31:54 Okay.
03:31:55 So if we just scroll down, as I said, we don't have time to review the entire document,
03:31:59 but we do have a table of contents here.
03:32:01 And so I just want to go through a few components of the parts or component parts of the overall
03:32:05 plan so that you understand kind of the general scope of it.
03:32:09 and so if we scroll down a little bit we see there's a deployment plan right a
03:32:17 reference to a deployment plan sorry the entire deployment plan is on page 13 yes
03:32:23 so I'm just I'm just trying to understand the scope of the plan since I
03:32:26 only have 10 minutes we can't actually digest the entirety of the plan so you
03:32:30 can see that there's some content in relation to deployment plan so is this
03:32:36 table of contents yes so the entire deployment plan fits onto one page description of the
03:32:43 deployment plan is okay and then we see a reference to investigative plan
03:32:52 correct i i i can't speak to whether this is a good plan or a complete plan or not i haven't
03:32:58 read this obviously right and so you hadn't read it obviously no then i rely on the inputs of uh
03:33:05 the experts around me to reassure me or not that there is a capacity to move forward okay so let's
03:33:13 turn to page eight and we see the objectives listed if you could scroll down and it says to
03:33:21 facilitate a resolution through de-escalation graduated measurable and multi-phased response
03:33:27 while ensuring the safety of participants citizen and members of participating agencies and return
03:33:31 the city of ottawa to a state of normality and so you referenced earlier in relation to the planet
03:33:37 from your understanding all it was was to continue the negotiations essentially that were already
03:33:42 taking place correct listen i am i am hesitant to speak to fragments but i don't know that that
03:33:55 objective one looks like the enforcement action that actually happened later that week okay well
03:34:05 if they talk about a de-escalation uh graduated measurable and multi-phased response um sounds
03:34:17 like something that would take longer than the 24 to 48 hours that the enforcement action actually
03:34:23 took on uh friday and saturday but i'm no expert on this so my lawyers are probably glaring at me
03:34:28 for uh opining on this too much fair enough well i can tell you that the experts on the plan
03:34:34 have testified and they have testified that this was the plan that they were acting on
03:34:39 on the weekend of february at 18th when they completed the pou operation would you have any
03:34:44 reason to disagree with that uh i think evaluating various testimonies is the job of the commissioner
03:34:50 fair enough okay um and i just want to pull up you're pretty close well not pretty close
03:34:55 you're over the end so if you can try and wrap it up please thank you
03:35:03 and so to circle back to the comments you provided in relation to the readiness of police plans as
03:35:08 of the 13th um i take it you would agree with me that perhaps there was a little bit more substance
03:35:13 to the plan than you were aware of on the 13th i am unable to speak to that okay and we've heard
03:35:21 evidence that the ottawa police were required to acquire approximately 2200 additional police
03:35:27 officers from across the country to support this plan and to successfully complete the pou operation
03:35:33 that occurred on the weekend of february 18th would you have any reason to disagree with that
03:35:38 um i wasn't aware of i wasn't following at that presentation of evidence so i can't comment on
03:35:44 that fair enough and uh you may have heard or not uh that this was the largest pou operation
03:35:49 in canadian history that i was aware of okay thank you very much for your time those are my questions
03:35:56 okay well thank you um this is a little early two minutes early we don't normally give an
03:36:01 hour and two minutes for lunch but i think uh today we will uh as a special occasion thank
03:36:08 you for your generosity so we'll come back at two o'clock the commission is in recess until two o'clock
03:36:31 Thank you.
03:37:01 Thank you.
03:37:31 Thank you.
03:38:01 Thank you.
03:38:31 Thank you.
03:39:01 Thank you.
03:39:31 Thank you.
03:40:01 The act was invoked here in response to a protest, and protest is a very important part of a functioning democracy, and you touched on this in one of your answers before the break,
03:40:26 But does this open the door then to the Emergencies Act being regularly used as a tool to quell protest?
03:40:34 Because protest is not necessarily clean.
03:40:37 Protests can be messy and can be problematic, and it can interfere at times with critical infrastructure.
03:40:43 We think of Indigenous protest, environmental protest.
03:40:46 So what stops this from being used against that?
03:40:51 Again, the checks and balances we have and the need to demonstrate and meet a high threshold.
03:41:04 But also from experience, over the past seven years we've seen many protests and disruptions across this country,
03:41:12 including protests of, as you say, critical infrastructure and of economic importance.
03:41:18 And it never occurred to me or to the government to invoke the Emergencies Act around any of those.
03:41:27 Now, your point around maybe future governments will run to it as a tool now that the seal has been broken.
03:41:37 But I have greater faith in Canadians and in our institutions than the fact that we might sort of
03:41:48 shrug as our fundamental rights are casually brushed aside in the name of political expediency
03:41:57 or a national emergency that actually wouldn't be one.
03:42:02 Another criticism that has levelled is that while the protests may have gotten, can we say, out of hand or snowballed and been extremely disruptive, they weren't the actions of a small minority, but a real expression of frustration, of legitimate frustration on behalf of a significant number of Canadians who had been through, either suffered from or felt aggrieved by years of
03:42:32 of public health measures and um in response to that they wanted to engage and they wanted you
03:42:43 to speak to them and they wanted to hear directly from their federal government and that did not
03:42:47 happen so do you have an answer to that um i think first of all
03:42:52 we heard them. We knew exactly what they were asking for. They were very, very clear that they
03:43:02 wanted an end to mandates. The convoy protesters were expressing their disagreement with very
03:43:12 specific public policies that they were very vocal, both in mainstream communications and
03:43:22 through social media on what they wanted, and they were very much heard. They had political
03:43:29 parties in the previous election very much carrying those messages and presenting them
03:43:37 to Canadians as part of the options that Canadians had to choose in that previous
03:43:41 election so people were well aware of the opinions and concerns and perspective of those individuals
03:43:55 but it was clear that it wasn't that they just wanted to be heard they wanted to be obeyed
03:44:04 they wanted us to change public policy public health policy designed to help canadians and
03:44:10 were going to occupy locations across this country
03:44:15 and interfere with the lives of Canadians
03:44:17 until such a decision was taken.
03:44:20 And I can't help but have noticed
03:44:24 that when Premier Kenney in Alberta
03:44:29 did, during the course of these convoy occupations,
03:44:36 remove a number of mandates instead of decreasing the amount of concern.
03:44:44 The convoy at Coutts, the occupation at Coutts, seemed to be emboldened,
03:44:51 saying, look, it's starting to work, let's keep going, instead of actually de-escalating.
03:44:56 So I am very aware that expressing concern and disagreement
03:45:02 around positions of public policy is the right
03:45:06 and is to be encouraged by any Canadian who wants to.
03:45:12 But the occupation and destabilization
03:45:19 and disruption of the lives of so many Canadians
03:45:23 and refusal to maintain a lawful protest
03:45:31 lawful protest is not all right.
03:46:01 Thank you.
03:46:31 Thank you.
03:47:01 Thank you.
03:47:31 In order for CSIS to be able to do a particular operation, it has to meet this matter of threats
03:47:44 to the security of Canada.
03:47:46 And you touched on this in one of your answers before the break, but does this open the door
03:47:51 then to the Emergencies Act being regularly used as a tool to quell protests?
03:47:57 Because a declaration of public order emergency under the Emergencies Act is about the governor
03:48:04 and council finding reasonable grounds that there are threats to the security of Canada
03:48:11 sufficient to invoke the Checks and Balances we have and the need to demonstrate and the
03:48:22 purpose is very different. The people doing the deciding in the case of the CSIS Act,
03:48:29 if this is met as a definition, it's CSIS itself that decides that this is met and there's
03:48:35 checks and balances afterwards. But for the purpose of declaration of a public order emergency,
03:48:42 it's the Governor and Council. So the context within now which we look at this
03:48:51 And this definition is very different from the deliberately narrow frame that CSIS is allowed to look at, what inputs it can take in, what proofs it needs to establish this are very well prescribed so that CSIS can be in our institutions than the fact that we might sort of shrug.
03:49:11 Whereas the Declaration of Public Order Emergency
03:49:14 casually is open to inputs, sure, from CSIS,
03:49:19 but also from the RCMP, also from transport, from immigration,
03:49:24 from the whole of government, from the clerk,
03:49:26 from the National Security Intelligence Advisor.
03:49:28 So within Threats of Security of Canada,
03:49:32 what we had to determine was, does the situation going on
03:49:40 But a real expression of frustration, a legitimate frustration on behalf of a significant number of Canadians who had been through activities within Canada directed towards or in support of the threat or use of acts of serious violence against persons or property for the purpose of achieving a political or
03:50:10 ideological objective um first of all that was what we were looking at is that threshold are
03:50:20 there activities they were asking supporting they were very very clear that they wanted serious
03:50:26 violence uh serious violence uh the four political ideological goals were were expressing their
03:50:34 If that threshold was met in our reasoned policies, that part of invoking a public order emergency was met.
03:50:42 The other part of it is communication and social media on what they wanted, and they were very much heard.
03:50:50 I was very much focused on, was this bar hit, yes or no, for the purposes of invoking the emergency options that Canadians had to choose
03:51:03 in that previous election.
03:51:04 So there has been a bit of back and forth at this commission
03:51:09 on whether opinions and concerns, words are of different
03:51:15 or can be read differently or broader when they're used
03:51:20 in a public order emergency than they're used for the CSIS.
03:51:24 It's not the words that are different.
03:51:25 The words are exactly the same in both cases.
03:51:28 The question is, who is doing the interpretation
03:51:31 to help Canadians come in and what is the purpose of locations across this country
03:51:37 and interfere with the lives of Canadians
03:51:39 was to be able to give us in special, temporary measures
03:51:45 as defined in the public order that would put an end to this.
03:51:51 Threats of serious violence was the key ones.
03:51:55 And can you elaborate on what those threats were?
03:51:59 What led to that conclusion?
03:52:01 And again, we went around the table with officials from all different agencies and heads of departments to talk about this.
03:52:10 There was the militarization of vehicles, for example.
03:52:16 We'd seen, sorry, weaponization of vehicles.
03:52:20 We'd seen, you know, cars ramming into police officers or other cars at coots.
03:52:25 We saw an incident like that in Surrey, I believe.
03:52:32 We saw trucks used as potential weapons, certainly in Ottawa with their presence and unknown interiors.
03:52:44 There was the use of children as human shields, deliberately.
03:52:49 In the interiors, there was the use of children as human shields deliberately, which was a real concern both at the Ambassador Bridge and the fact that there were kids on Wellington Street, that people didn't know what was in the trucks, whether it was kids, whether it was weapons, whether it was both.
03:53:10 police had no way of knowing those. There was presence of weapons at Coutts, as we saw. There
03:53:18 was a concern around weapons being stolen in Peterborough that we didn't know, but 2,000 guns
03:53:24 that we didn't know where they had gone at that point. We later found out that they didn't go
03:53:28 there, but there was, that was a real concern that we had about what was happening to them.
03:53:34 There were a number of others as well. There was the fact that police trying to invoice
03:53:40 in force laws were met with active resistance and a group of 30 police officers trying to
03:53:50 interdict someone or arrest someone who was carrying a jerry can into the site in Ottawa
03:53:56 got swarmed by 100 people and they had to leave because there were threats to their safety and
03:54:02 they weren't able to arrest that individual. There were layers of danger that CSIS kept
03:54:08 Bringing up to us that the presence of people promoting ideologically motivated violent extremism in the convoys had a danger of triggering not necessarily them to act but lone wolf actors or people who could be radicalized to take actions that were violent.
03:54:39 Threats of serious violence was the key ones.
03:54:43 And can you elaborate on what those threats were?
03:54:47 What led to that conclusion?
03:54:49 And again, we went around the table with officials
03:54:53 from all different agencies and heads of departments.
03:55:08 Thank you.
03:55:38 Thank you.
03:56:08 We heard evidence from Commissioner Lucky of the RCMP that she had signed off on a plan
03:56:23 to enforce and remove the protesters in Ottawa on February 13th that she had confidence in,
03:56:30 that she, the OPP, and the OPS had confidence in.
03:56:34 Did you hear that testimony?
03:56:36 No, I disagree with that.
03:56:38 Okay, you disagree with that?
03:56:40 Yes.
03:56:41 I do not believe that the plan that was either signed off on,
03:56:45 supposedly by the RCMP, or presented by the Ottawa Police
03:56:50 Services on the 13th, was, in any real regards,
03:56:55 an actual plan for clearing the protests.
03:56:58 And is this a plan that you saw or that you were just spoken to about?
03:57:03 I was spoken to about. I did not see it myself.
03:57:05 And were you spoken to about it by Commissioner Luckey
03:57:07 or by Minister Mendocino?
03:57:09 I don't remember.
03:57:10 You don't remember.
03:57:11 But as of February 13th, your impression was that the plan
03:57:15 that was in place at that time was not one that you
03:57:20 or the RCMP had confidence in.
03:57:22 It was not one that we had confidence in, no.
03:57:25 Okay.
03:57:35 Threats of serious violence was the key ones.
03:57:40 And can you elaborate on what those threats were?
03:57:44 What led to that conclusion?
03:57:46 And again, we went around the table with officials
03:57:50 from all different agencies and heads of departments
03:57:54 to talk about this.
03:57:55 There was the militarization of vehicles, for example.
03:58:01 example. We'd seen, sorry, weaponization of vehicles. We'd seen, you know, cars ramming
03:58:07 into police officers or other cars at coots. We saw an incident like that in Surrey, I believe.
03:58:17 We saw trucks used as potential weapons, certainly in Ottawa with their presence and
03:58:27 unknown interiors. There was the use of children as human shields deliberately, which was a real
03:58:37 concern, both at the Ambassador Bridge and the fact that there were kids on Wellington Street,
03:58:42 that people didn't know what was in the trucks, whether it was kids, whether it was weapons,
03:58:48 whether it was both. Police had no way of knowing those. There was presence of weapons at Coutts,
03:58:55 as we saw. There was a concern around weapons being stolen in Peterborough that we didn't know,
03:59:01 but 2,000 guns that we didn't know where they had gone at that point. We later found out that
03:59:06 they didn't go there, but that was a real concern that we had about what was happening to them.
03:59:12 There were a number of others as well. There was the fact that police trying to enforce
03:59:19 laws were met with active resistance and a group of 30 police officers trying to
03:59:28 interdict someone or arrest someone who was carrying a jerry can into the site in Ottawa
03:59:34 got swarmed by 100 people and they had to leave because there were threats to their safety and
03:59:40 they weren't able to arrest that individual. There were layers of danger that CSIS kept
03:59:46 uh bringing up to us that the presence of people promoting um ideologically motivated violence
03:59:54 violent extremism in uh the convoys uh had a danger of triggering not necessarily them to act
04:00:05 but lone wolf actors or people who could be radicalized to take actions that were violent
04:00:12 are you drawing a distinction there between okay the premiers may say it's under control here but
04:00:20 that doesn't mean it's under control everywhere so they would have had to come to you with
04:00:24 something that would have solved the big problem as you saw it is that um i think there just would
04:00:30 have been a sense that that the measures i was proposing weren't going to be useful or effective
04:00:40 and what i heard on the contrary uh was uh concerns that we'd shared that this might
04:00:50 inflame the protesters to declare a public order emergency
04:00:54 but we'd shared that this might inflame the protesters to declare a public order emergency
04:01:01 and bring in martial law um which was one of the concerns or that they would interpret it as that
04:01:09 Of course, it wasn't martial law, and it did not suspend people's fundamental rights and freedoms.
04:01:14 But at the same time, they expressed these concerns, which we had shared, but I was balancing off against, okay, there is a danger of further inflaming the situation.
04:01:30 but the situation was already pretty inflamed and my concern was if we continue to not do anything
04:01:36 are enough citizens going to start counter-protesting and taking things into their
04:01:41 own hands at various places across the country um and we also obviously heard from from mr vigno
04:01:51 saying and the thesis assessment that there was no threat to the security of canada under the
04:01:56 CESIS Act. And then we heard Mr. Vigneault say, but I still thought that there was no threat to
04:02:02 the security of Canada under the CESIS Act. And then we heard Mr. Vigneault say, but I still
04:02:09 thought that the act was necessary, and I conveyed that to the Prime Minister. So can you tell us,
04:02:16 was there consensus on the use of the act? What did you hear about whether or not
04:02:23 people agreed with this interpretation whether you should vote the act yes there was consensus
04:02:28 around the irg table on sunday the 13th there is no question about it and and uh director vigno's
04:02:36 um answer on that is absolutely consistent uh cesus for example wouldn't feel that they had
04:02:45 the capacity to bring in a wiretap against one of the convoy organizers under the CSIS Act,
04:02:53 because the tools that they have and the threshold they have to meet for what is a threat to the
04:03:00 security of Canada, according to CSIS's evaluation, was not met. And that was something we heard from
04:03:08 the very beginning. CSIS continued to say from the beginning of the protest, we haven't yet,
04:03:14 under the CSIS Act reached a level of threats to Canada. But the director of CSIS is also one of
04:03:22 the national security advisors to me. And in looking at the frame and scope of the situation
04:03:30 we were in, was very comfortable in saying, yeah, for the purposes of the CSIS Act, this is not met.
04:03:37 But for the purposes of the Public Order Emergencies Act that the governor and council has to make a reasonable decision about, we feel that it is met.
04:03:47 And that was the consensus from officials around the table.
04:03:52 And again, it was about not even just sort of that binary, okay, do we declare the emergency or not?
04:04:01 It's do we declare a public order emergency so that we can bring in these specific measures?
04:04:08 And as we went around the table on that, and my expectation is, and that was a virtual table, I believe,
04:04:14 but my expectation is always if you have significant disagreements, this is the time to speak up.
04:04:20 There was no voice saying, hold it, we don't think you should do this, or I don't think you should do this.
04:04:30 In order for CSIS to be able to do a particular operation, it has to meet this matter of threats to the security of Canada.
04:04:43 And then they can go and do that wiretap.
04:04:45 This definition within a declaration of public order emergency under the Emergencies Act is about the governor and council finding reasonable grounds that there are threats to the security of Canada sufficient to invoke the Emergency Measures Act.
04:05:13 So both the context and the purpose is very different.
04:05:18 The people doing the deciding, in the case of the CSIS Act,
04:05:22 if this is met as a definition, it's CSIS itself that decides that this is met.
04:05:28 There's checks and balances afterwards.
04:05:31 But for the purpose of declaration of a public order emergency,
04:05:35 it's the governor and council cabinet and the prime minister making that determination.
04:05:39 So the context within which we look at this definition is very different from the deliberately narrow frame that CSIS is allowed to look at, what inputs it can take in, what proofs it needs to establish this are very well prescribed so that CSIS can be, so that CSIS is responsible in what it does.
04:06:04 Whereas the declaration of public order emergency is open to inputs, sure, from CSIS, but also from the RCMP, also some from transport, from immigration, from the whole of government, from the clerk, from the national security intelligence advisor.
04:06:21 So within threats to the security of Canada, what we had to determine was, does the situation going on across the country constitute a threat to the security of Canada?
04:06:37 Yes or no? And then we looked at particularly C. Are there activities within Canada directed towards or in support of the threat or use of acts of serious violence against persons or property for the purpose of achieving a political or ideological objective?
04:07:07 that was what we were looking at.
04:07:11 Is that threshold met?
04:07:13 Are there activities supporting the threats or acts of serious violence,
04:07:19 a threat of serious violence for political or ideological goals?
04:07:26 If that threshold was met in our reasoned opinion,
04:07:31 then that part of invoking a public order emergency was met.
04:07:35 The other part of it is, does it constitute a national emergency?
04:07:38 And there's elements on that that I won't get into unless you ask me about.
04:07:42 But I was very much focused on, was this bar hit, yes or no,
04:07:50 for the purposes of invoking the Emergencies Act?
04:07:58 There has been a bit of back and forth at this commission
04:08:02 on whether these words are different
04:08:08 or can be read differently
04:08:11 or are broader when they're used in a public order emergency
04:08:14 than they're used for the CSIS.
04:08:17 It's not the words that are different.
04:08:18 The words are exactly the same in both cases.
04:08:21 The question is, who's doing the interpretation?
04:08:25 What inputs come in?
04:08:26 And what is the purpose of it?
04:08:28 And the purpose of it for this point
04:08:31 was to be able to give us in special temporary measures
04:08:38 as defined in the Public Order Emergency Act
04:08:40 that would put an end to this national emergency.
04:08:48 So you've stated under the CSIS Act,
04:08:52 when CSIS determines that they are...
04:08:54 So you've stated under the CSIS Act,
04:08:58 when CSIS determines that they are going to use surveillance on a person, they need to meet the
04:09:04 threshold at section two, correct? Yes. And that's because the surveillance of one person
04:09:11 without other legal authority is something that is very serious and that requires a high legal
04:09:16 threshold, correct? Now, I understand your evidence that for the purpose of the Emergencies Act,
04:09:23 we are dealing with a different context yes yes a different purpose yes and we're dealing with a
04:09:30 different decision maker correct but i would put to you that when invoking the emergencies act
04:09:35 that threshold the level of threshold of the seer of the security threat that must be bet
04:09:42 cannot be any lower than it is when cses is proposing to surveil one person that the
04:09:51 threshold is no different do you agree with that yes i do thank you prime minister those are my
04:09:57 questions the responsibility of a prime minister is to make the tough calls and keep people safe
04:10:07 and this was a moment where the collective advice of cabinet of the public service
04:10:19 and my own inclination was that this was a moment to do something
04:10:27 that we needed to do to keep Canadians safe.
04:10:32 And knowing full well that this was an inevitable consequence
04:10:37 of me signing, I agree, on this note,
04:10:41 I was very comfortable that we were at a moment
04:10:44 where this was the right thing to do.
04:10:47 and
04:10:48 we did it
04:10:54 and it is a certain amount of
04:10:56 comfort
04:10:58 that first of all the system is working as it should
04:11:03 that people who are defending civil liberties are able to say
04:11:07 you really should be careful about doing this maybe you shouldn't have done it
04:11:10 we have a system pushing back on this because it's a big thing not a small thing
04:11:13 to do this
04:11:14 But that also we were able to solve the situation with it, that there was no loss of life, there was no serious violence, that we were able to get neighborhoods back under control, border services opened,
04:11:37 And there haven't been a recurrence of these kinds of illegal occupations since then.
04:11:46 I'm not going to pretend that it's the only thing that could have done it, but it did do it.
04:11:52 And that colors the conversations we're having now with the fact that these could be very different conversations.
04:11:59 and I am absolutely, absolutely serene and confident
04:12:06 that I made the right choice in agreeing with the invocation.
04:12:13 The act was invoked here in response to a protest,
04:12:17 and protest is a very important part of a functioning democracy,
04:12:22 and you touched on this in one of your answers before the break,
04:12:25 But does this open the door then to the Emergencies Act being regularly used as a tool to quell protest?
04:12:33 Because protest is not necessarily clean.
04:12:36 Protests can be messy and can be problematic, and it can interfere at times with critical infrastructure.
04:12:42 We think of Indigenous protest, environmental protest.
04:12:45 So what stops this from being used against that?
04:12:50 Again, the checks and balances we have and the need to demonstrate and meet a high threshold,
04:13:01 but also from experience over the past seven years, we've seen many protests and disruptions
04:13:09 across this country, including protests of, as you say, critical infrastructure and of
04:13:16 economic importance. And it never occurred to me or to the government to invoke the Emergencies
04:13:23 Act around any of those. Now, your point around maybe future governments will run to it as
04:13:31 a tool now that the seal has been broken. But I have greater faith in Canadians and in our
04:13:42 institutions than the fact that we might sort of shrug as our fundamental rights are casually
04:13:51 brushed aside in the name of political expediency or a national emergency that actually wouldn't be
04:14:01 one. Another criticism that is leveled is that while the protests may have gotten, can we say,
04:14:11 out of hand or snowballed and been extremely disruptive.
04:14:15 They weren't the actions of a small minority,
04:14:17 but a real expression of frustration,
04:14:20 of legitimate frustration on behalf
04:14:23 of a significant number of Canadians
04:14:25 who had been through, either suffered from
04:14:29 or felt aggrieved by years of public health measures.
04:14:34 And in response to that, they wanted to engage.
04:14:39 they wanted to engage and they wanted you to speak to them
04:14:43 and they wanted to hear directly from their federal government
04:14:45 and that did not happen.
04:14:46 So do you have an answer to that?
04:14:50 First of all, we heard them.
04:14:57 We knew exactly what they were asking for.
04:14:59 They were very, very clear that they wanted an end to mandates.
04:15:04 The convoy protesters were expressing their disagreement with very specific public policies, that they were very vocal, both in mainstream communications and through social media, on what they wanted.
04:15:24 and they were very much heard.
04:15:27 They had political parties in the previous election
04:15:30 very much carrying those messages
04:15:33 and presenting them to Canadians
04:15:37 as part of the options that Canadians had to choose
04:15:39 in that previous election.
04:15:41 So people were well aware of the opinions and concerns
04:15:48 and perspective of those individuals.
04:15:52 but it was clear that it wasn't that they just wanted to be heard they wanted to be obeyed
04:16:02 they wanted us to change public policy public health policy designed to help canadians and
04:16:09 we're going to occupy locations across this country and interfere with the lives of canadians
04:16:16 until such a decision was taken.
04:16:19 And I can't help but have noticed that when Premier Kenney in Alberta
04:16:28 did, during the course of these convoy occupations,
04:16:36 remove a number of mandates, instead of decreasing the amount of concern,
04:16:43 The convoy at Coutts, the occupation at Coutts, seemed to be emboldened and say, look, it's starting to work, let's keep going, instead of actually de-escalating.
04:16:55 So I am very aware that expressing concern and disagreement around positions of public policy is the right and is to be encouraged by any Canadian who wants to.
04:17:10 But the occupation and destabilization of and disruption of the lives of so many Canadians
04:17:24 and refusal to maintain a lawful protest is not all right.
04:17:40 so sir what I'd like to do so you've not read this no I have not okay so I certainly had not
04:17:46 read it on the 13th okay and so I'd like to just um Mr. Registrar I'd just like to walk the prime
04:17:52 minister through the pages not so he could read it because we don't have time but just to point
04:17:56 out that this is a heavily redacted document so page one is the cover page page two is a is this
04:18:03 signature page if we could go down page three is a description of the situation and the mission
04:18:09 And then, Mr. Registrar, if you could please scroll down, the rest of this document has been redacted.
04:18:15 So that's page 4, page 5, page 6, page 7, page 8.
04:18:21 So, Prime Minister, you said we should read this plan. We can't.
04:18:25 It's within your legal authority to instruct your council to remove these redactions.
04:18:31 For the sake of the transparency of this commission, sir, would you consider that request?
04:18:35 I object to that. On behalf of the Government of Canada, it's Brian Gover once again.
04:18:40 This is putting the Prime Minister in an odious position.
04:18:45 We had no notice that they would attempt this in cross-examination.
04:18:51 These things require careful consideration, do not lend themselves to decisions in the moment, and we maintain our objection.
04:19:03 uh commissioner sorry sir uh this was in our document list um that we circulated within time
04:19:12 uh to counsel for the attorney general they had noticed that we would be putting this document
04:19:16 and the question is a fair one in response to the prime minister's testimony this morning that he
04:19:20 said you should read it i think it it is fair in a sense but i think what's being raised is
04:19:28 it's a little more complicated than the federal government or the prime minister releasing these
04:19:33 this is a police operational plan of the ops involving officers from the ops and from opp
04:19:43 involving strategy etc and i would be very surprised if the federal government would order
04:19:49 its release without consulting with the various police services and i i think that's the unfairness
04:19:56 that's being referred to, and quite frankly, I agree.
04:20:00 Now, having said that, he made reference to the plan,
04:20:04 and there is an issue about reading it, for sure,
04:20:07 but I think the context is important here.
04:20:10 So, Commissioner, with your ruling there,
04:20:13 and I thank Mr. Gover for his point,
04:20:14 Prime Minister, can I put it to you this way?
04:20:16 You said we should read the plan,
04:20:17 but I think you would agree we can't.
04:20:20 Indeed.
04:20:22 As I said, I haven't read the plan,
04:20:24 But we're in a situation where, as can be imagined, I have access to unredacted information.
04:20:34 And what I know and my understanding of this plan was, and I'm happy to testify to that, that it was not a complete plan of engagement.
04:20:43 And Prime Minister, and again, I think I would like to raise this again.
04:20:50 I'm looking to Mr. Gover in anticipation of his reaction.
04:20:54 As you know, there's a legal opinion over which solicitor-client privilege has been asserted.
04:21:00 We asked Minister Lamedi to release that opinion, and in a public statement this week, he said he couldn't because he lacked the authority to.
04:21:08 That would be up to his client, and he then clarified that his client is his governor and counsel.
04:21:13 So again, for the record, sir, and this has been an issue for all week, not just this morning,
04:21:19 would you advise that that opinion be released in the interest of transparency?
04:21:25 Mr. Commissioner, it's Brian Gover once again for the Government of Canada.
04:21:31 Solicitor-client privilege, of course, is a very substantial right in our legal system.
04:21:36 It's one that the Supreme Court of Canada has recognized as a constitutional dimension.
04:21:41 I remind my friends that in this case, as the Prime Minister has said,
04:21:47 Cabinet confidence has been waived for the fourth time in 155 years to provide evidence of inputs.
04:21:54 We know that the decision note that was referred to in testimony by the Clerk of the Privy Council
04:22:01 referred to the advice of the public service that it was appropriate to invoke the Emergencies Act.
04:22:10 In my submission, we need not go further with the inquiry and pierce the veil of solicitor-client privilege, setting what, in my submission, could be a dangerous precedent going forward.
04:22:24 This is certainly an issue that requires careful consideration and not one to require a Prime Minister to respond to in the spur of the moment.
04:22:33 Thank you.
04:22:34 i'm wondering if you can describe if someone asked you um when did the emergencies act come
04:22:44 into play as a possibility uh how would you answer that well as as an idea um it would have been from
04:22:53 the very beginning in the back of our minds is you see a situation that um is an emergency is
04:23:01 out of control, has a potential for real impact on citizens, potential for violence,
04:23:08 real concerns about what's going on, not just in Ottawa, but right across the country.
04:23:13 The Coutts blockade that started up on the same first weekend that the Ottawa occupation did.
04:23:21 These are the things that you say, okay, as we look at a whole range of potential
04:23:31 outcomes in this there might be a moment where we have to invoke the emergencies act um it wasn't
04:23:38 seriously thought of because i will say certainly in my thinking right now it was a fairly binary
04:23:44 reflection it was oh we might have to invoke the emergencies act there was no reflection of
04:23:49 what we would have to invoke the emergencies act to do it was just understanding that if this
04:23:55 situation continues and is unable to get under control by anything else the federal government
04:24:01 It might have to give the provinces more powers, give police more powers, do something to put an end to this.
04:24:07 So whenever we said, yeah, we're looking at all options, it would have been in the back of our minds.
04:24:18 I'm wondering if you could describe.
04:24:20 There's a willingness to discuss, but you were concerned about setting a precedent where a blockade could equal a change.
04:24:31 in public policy. Is that fair?
04:24:33 Yeah, I think we have a robust functioning democracy
04:24:39 and protests, public protests are an important part
04:24:43 of making sure we're getting messages out there
04:24:46 and Canadians are getting messages out there
04:24:48 and highlighting how they feel about various issues.
04:24:50 But using protests to demand changes to public policy
04:24:58 is something that I think is worrisome.
04:25:02 Okay.
04:25:04 So, thank you, Mr.
04:25:05 Although, sorry, to a certain extent.
04:25:06 No, no, please go on.
04:25:07 Yeah, protests.
04:25:08 If you're out protesting that the government is, you know,
04:25:10 shutting down a safe injection site or something,
04:25:13 you are asking for changes in public policy.
04:25:15 But there is a difference between occupations
04:25:19 and, you know, saying we're not going until this has changed
04:25:26 in a way that is massively disruptive and potentially dangerous
04:25:32 versus just saying, yeah, we're protesting because we want public policy to change
04:25:38 and we're trying to convince people to get enough of them,
04:25:40 that politicians will listen to enough people saying,
04:25:43 okay, I'm going to lose votes if I don't change this.
04:25:45 That's the usual way protests can be effective in our democracies.
04:25:53 So just stopping there, Prime Minister,
04:25:55 do you remember what you were referring to when you start talking about you shouldn't need more
04:26:00 tools? I mean, that whole question around. So just stopping there, Prime Minister,
04:26:10 do you remember what you were referring to when you start talking about you shouldn't need more
04:26:14 tools um i mean that whole question around legality or illegality of the protest um they didn't have
04:26:28 a permit to protest um they not not certainly as long as they had um they were illegally parked
04:26:35 They were engaged in disruptive activities.
04:26:40 There are any number of municipal and provincial by-law infractions
04:26:46 and legal infractions that they were engaged in by just being there.
04:26:50 And there is a sense that, you know, and this was based on an earlier conversation
04:26:56 I had with Bill Blair about how one proceeds in this,
04:26:59 in this, is, you know, you can enforce small things as a way of keeping the situation under
04:27:08 control and creating boundaries and balances and moving towards it.
04:27:13 It's an approach.
04:27:16 The issue here was that there were things that they could do and things that I know
04:27:22 were tried that they realized were unsafe for them to do.
04:27:30 There are stories of police officers getting swarmed
04:27:32 when they tried to arrest someone with a jerry can filled with gasoline.
04:27:37 There was a sense that giving out simple tickets
04:27:42 wasn't really having much of an impact as they did that,
04:27:48 and taking stronger measures was going to be resisted
04:27:52 and met with significant resistance.
04:27:57 But these are things that if they feel they didn't have the resources
04:28:03 to enforce a prohibition on bringing in jerrycans
04:28:07 or a prohibition of parking on the approach to the Ambassador Bridge,
04:28:13 well, let us give you more resources to do that.
04:28:17 Between the OPP and the RCMP,
04:28:19 we should be able to get the numbers up.
04:28:22 in a way that could lead for an ability to use those existing tools on the books.
04:28:30 Prime Minister, can you tell us, just the readout doesn't actually say that much,
04:28:33 so can you tell us about your recollection of that call?
04:28:39 There were sort of two goals I had in that call.
04:28:45 The first one was to reassure him that despite the disruptions to trade and real impacts on both sides of the border, which were economic, yes, but were also people to people.
04:28:59 We knew from the pandemic that thousands of health care workers crossed the Ambassador Bridge every day from Canada to go work in Detroit in their hospitals.
04:29:11 There are real meaningful connections across that crossing that were being disrupted in meaningful ways.
04:29:17 And I wanted to reassure President Biden that Canada was going to be able to solve for this
04:29:25 and that we were going to continue to be a reliable partner for trade and for people-to-people ties and a safe neighbour.
04:29:35 that was sort of in response to his concerns around disruptions to activities on both sides
04:29:44 of the border because of the blockage. But the second thing I wanted to talk about was just
04:29:48 sort of the general context, the fact that the 911 centre being overwhelmed in Ottawa
04:29:56 a couple of days before happened from American calls, that there was a significant amount of
04:30:04 amplification from certain sectors of the American political sphere. And there was also
04:30:15 a significant amount of money flowing and support for these occupation activities in Canada that
04:30:25 were coming from people in the United States sympathetic to that cause and opposed to both
04:30:33 he and I in our public health policies, but also in our general policies.
04:30:39 Okay. Would you say that President Biden shared your level of concern about the situation?
04:30:48 No. I think I was much more concerned about the blockage to the lives and the disruption and the
04:30:57 potential security concerns. I think he was very concerned, but I don't think anyone was more
04:31:03 concerned than me. We heard evidence from Commissioner Lucky of the RCMP that she had
04:31:11 signed off on a plan to enforce and remove the protesters in Ottawa on February 13th that she
04:31:20 had confidence in, that she, the OPP, and the OPS had confidence in. Did you hear that testimony?
04:31:26 um no I disagree with that okay you disagree with that yes I I do not
04:31:33 believe that the plan that was either signed off on supposedly by the RCMP or
04:31:39 presented by the Ottawa Police Services on the 13th was in any real regards an
04:31:46 actual plan for clearing the protests and is this a plan that you you saw or
04:31:52 that what you were just spoken to about I was spoken to about I did not see it
04:31:55 Okay, and were you spoken to about it by Commissioner Lucky or by Minister Mendocino?
04:31:59 I don't remember.
04:32:00 You don't remember.
04:32:01 But as of February 13th, your impression was that the plan that was in place at that time
04:32:08 was not one that you or the RCMP had confidence in?
04:32:12 It was not one that we had confidence in, no.
04:32:15 Okay.
04:32:25 Are you drawing a distinction there between, okay, the premiers may say it's under control here, but that doesn't mean it's under control everywhere.
04:32:34 So they would have had to come to you with something that would have solved the big problem as you saw it?
04:32:39 I think there just would have been a sense that the measures I was proposing weren't going to be useful or effective.
04:32:52 of. And what I heard on the contrary was concerns that we'd shared that this might inflame the
04:33:03 protesters to declare a public order emergency and bring in martial law, which was one of the
04:33:11 concerns or that they would interpret it as that. Of course, it wasn't martial law and it did not
04:33:15 suspend people's fundamental rights and freedoms um but it it at the same time um they expressed
04:33:24 these concerns which we had shared uh but i was balancing off against okay um there is a danger of
04:33:31 of further uh inflaming the situation but the situation was already pretty inflamed and my
04:33:38 concern was if we continue to not do anything uh are enough citizens going to start counter
04:33:44 protesting and taking things into their own hands at various places across the country
04:33:48 threats of serious violence was the key ones and can you can you elaborate on on what those
04:33:57 threats were what led to that conclusion um and again we went around the table with officials
04:34:03 uh from all different agencies and heads of departments uh to talk about this there was
04:34:10 uh the um militarization of vehicles for example we'd seen uh sorry weaponization of vehicles we'd
04:34:18 seen uh you know cars ramming into police officers or other cars at coots uh we saw an incident like
04:34:26 that in um in uh surrey i believe uh we saw trucks uh used as as uh potential weapons certainly in
04:34:36 in Ottawa with their their presence and unknown interiors there was a use of children as human
04:34:46 shields deliberately which was a real concern both at the Ambassador Bridge and the fact that there
04:34:52 were kids on Wellington Street that people didn't know what was in the in the trucks whether it was
04:35:00 kids whether it was weapons whether it was both police had no way of knowing those there was
04:35:05 presence of weapons uh at coots as we saw there was a concern around weapons being stolen uh in
04:35:12 peterborough uh that we didn't know about 2 000 guns that we didn't know where they had gone at
04:35:17 that point uh we later found out they didn't go there but there was that was a real concern
04:35:22 that we had about what was happening to them um there were a number of others as well there was
04:35:27 The fact that police trying to enforce laws were met with active resistance and a group of 30 police officers trying to interdict someone or arrest someone who was carrying a jerry can into the site in Ottawa got swarmed by 100 people and they had to leave because there were threats to their safety and they weren't able to arrest that individual.
04:35:55 There were layers of danger that CSIS kept bringing up to us that the presence of people promoting ideologically motivated violent extremism in the convoys had a danger of triggering, not necessarily them to act, but lone wolf actors or people who could be radicalized to take actions that were violent.
04:36:25 the responsibility of a prime minister is to make the tough calls and keep people safe
04:36:36 and this was a moment where the collective advice of cabinet of the public service
04:36:48 and my own inclination was that this was a moment to do something
04:36:56 that we needed to do to keep Canadians safe.
04:37:01 And knowing full well that this was an inevitable consequence
04:37:06 of me signing, I agree, on this note,
04:37:10 I was very comfortable that we were at a moment
04:37:13 where this was the right thing to do.
04:37:16 and
04:37:17 we did it
04:37:23 and it is a certain amount of
04:37:25 comfort
04:37:27 that first of all the system is working
04:37:32 as it should
04:37:32 that people who are defending civil liberties are able to say
04:37:36 you really should be careful about doing this
04:37:38 maybe you shouldn't have done it
04:37:39 we have a system pushing back on this
04:37:40 because it's a big thing not a small thing to do this
04:37:43 but
04:37:44 But that also we were able to solve the situation with it, that there was no loss of life, there
04:37:55 was no serious violence, that we were able to get neighborhoods back under control, border
04:38:05 services opened, and there haven't been a recurrence of these kinds of illegal occupations
04:38:14 that i'm not going to pretend that it's the only thing that could have done it but it did do it
04:38:21 and that colors the conversations we're having now uh with the fact that these could be very
04:38:27 different conversations and i am absolutely absolutely serene and confident um that i
04:38:36 made the right choice in agreeing with the invocation
04:38:39 i'm wondering if you can describe if someone asked you um when did the emergencies act come
04:38:48 into play as a possibility uh how would you answer that as as an idea um it would have been from the
04:38:57 very beginning in the back of our minds as you see a situation that um is an emergency is out of
04:39:06 control is has a potential for real impact on citizens potential for violence uh real concerns
04:39:13 about what's going on not just in ottawa but right across the country uh the coots blockade that
04:39:19 started up on the same first weekend uh that the ottawa uh occupation did these are the things that
04:39:27 um you say okay as we look at a whole range of potential outcomes in this there might be a
04:39:37 moment where we have to invoke the emergencies act um it wasn't seriously thought of because
04:39:44 i will say certainly in my thinking right now it was a fairly binary reflection it was oh we might
04:39:50 have to invoke the emergencies act there was no reflection of what we would have to invoke the
04:39:55 Emergencies Act to do. It was just understanding that if this situation continues and is unable to
04:40:02 get under control by anything else, the federal government might have to give the provinces more
04:40:07 powers, give police more powers, do something to put an end to this. So whenever we said,
04:40:13 yeah, we're looking at all options, it would have been in the back of our minds.
04:40:17 the act was invoked here in response to to a protest and protest is a very important part of
04:40:28 are we ready perfect
04:40:41 the next group the government of alberta please
04:40:47 good afternoon prime minister my name is stephanie bose i'm counsel for the province of alberta
04:40:58 you were asked this morning if any of the first ministers could have said or done
04:41:04 anything to change your mind about the emergencies act and i understood your evidence to be yes if
04:41:11 one of them had said they had alternate tools and they thought it would end the situation
04:41:15 if they had figured out how to obtain towing services and if they had convinced you that
04:41:21 the laws in Canada were sufficient to deal with the protests is that a correct understanding
04:41:25 uh it would have had to been more of them one of them but yes this was a national emergency
04:41:30 we were facing but if there was uh if there was compelling reasons why the emergencies act
04:41:36 wasn't necessary it certainly would have given me pause thank you you would agree that this is the
04:41:43 very reason why proper and adequate consultation is so important and in fact required under the
04:41:50 emergencies act yes that makes sense okay don't you agree then that giving the first minister's
04:41:56 advance notice and time to prepare would have allowed the first ministers to share with you
04:42:01 the details and the input that you indicated to the commission would be important to your
04:42:06 decision-making um throughout the two weeks three weekends leading up to those conversations we had
04:42:16 many engagements with the provinces the officials ministers and indeed there was a letter from the
04:42:24 province of Alberta asking for exactly that help with a tow truck resources so they felt very
04:42:30 strongly that the federal government needed to step up with extra tools and extra support so
04:42:38 that they could get those vehicles towed from coots so there was engagement with the provinces
04:42:45 throughout and they were certainly we were certainly all talking about what would be
04:42:49 needed to put an end to these these occupations and blockades and certainly there's been a lot
04:42:54 of evidence before this commission about how alberta solved the tow truck problem so i won't
04:42:58 get into that but you would agree that none of the engagement you had with the provinces
04:43:03 discussed at all the use of the emergencies act and whether it was necessary in the provinces
04:43:10 the consultation on the use of the emergencies act needed to center around what we'd actually do
04:43:20 with the act if i had consulted uh with the premiers early on without saying these are the
04:43:28 six things we would do with the emergencies act their first question would be okay you might want
04:43:34 to do this emergencies act but what are you going to do with it what powers will you be giving
04:43:40 yourself or the federal government or our our officials and police services so there
04:43:48 There was ongoing conversations about tools and the consultation on the Emergencies Act was done when we had a very clear list of the things we would actually be bringing in with the Emergencies Act.
04:44:01 I will put to you that the way the First Minister's meeting was arranged, which was a short notice invitation with no indication of the topic of discussion,
04:44:10 meant that the discussions you did have with the First Ministers
04:44:14 could not possibly provide you with the details that you needed to consider.
04:44:20 I disagree.
04:44:22 In your evidence today, you said that at the First Ministers' meeting,
04:44:27 you heard Premier Kenney say there was a plan for Coutts,
04:44:30 but that you had heard that before and you were not convinced that morning
04:44:34 that it would be put to use. Is that correct?
04:44:36 um no i had no reason to doubt premier kenny's um goodwill and uh hopes that uh coots would be
04:44:49 resolved uh soon but i also knew that coots had been in place for at that point three weeks
04:44:56 there had been an ebb and a flow there were moments where traffic was let through moments
04:45:01 where people showed up more intensely and it goes to the preoccupation we had that even if
04:45:11 as he indicated there were good chances that it would be cleared in the coming moments there was
04:45:18 going to be a continued challenge to hold open that area given the current current context
04:45:25 minister mendicino said at the irg the afternoon previous which you were present at that there was
04:45:34 going to be enforcement action at coops correct uh yes it was something that we had been monitoring
04:45:40 for a while uh it would turn out that the rcmp who had intended to do enforcement action as the
04:45:50 provincial police force uh many days if not a week before had to suspend it because of uh genuine
04:45:57 concerns around officer safety and the presence of significant uh numbers of weapons and uh
04:46:05 problematic individuals in that so it was something we were anticipating and hoping
04:46:10 was going to happen certainly hoping was going to happen peacefully but it was something that
04:46:15 we had been hoping would happen for a while yes certainly because what we saw was that
04:46:22 the actions at coots changed from public order policing activity into a criminal investigation
04:46:30 and around 8 pm on the night of the 13th commissioner lucky emailed minister mendicino
04:46:35 and jody thomas and advised them that the rcmp had an enforcement plan ready for execution
04:46:41 and that they were indeed on the cusp of enforcement in coots and that proved to be true
04:46:47 correct yes it did it was that was good news that it was true yes so then why were you doubtful when
04:46:54 premier kenny told you that he believed the situation had been secured and the rcmp would
04:47:00 now proceed with broader arrests and secure the porter when exactly what you had been told the
04:47:05 night before about rcmp enforcement did in fact happen we had been told throughout the process
04:47:13 uh throughout these weeks that things were about to happen sometimes they happened sometimes they
04:47:17 didn't and not just at coots but elsewhere so there was an understanding that inevitably things
04:47:23 were more difficult than uh then well reality is always more difficult than plans uh it was good
04:47:30 news uh that the province was able to clear but i will also say or that the the situation was able
04:47:36 to be cleared in the province at that point i will also say that it was done in part with resources
04:47:42 drawn from british columbia and one of the things uh that premier horgan uh attested to or said in
04:47:49 that meeting was um he understands it's a national emergency he understands and agreed with our use
04:47:55 of things but he was very concerned that even as he was worried about what was happening at
04:48:00 the surrey border crossings as he was worried about uh convoy activity uh in the interior
04:48:06 in other parts of bc uh he had had to give up a number of police officers to help with enforcement
04:48:13 in in alberta and while yes it was good news that alberta looked like it was going to be resolved
04:48:21 there was a constant challenge that uh the whack-a-mole challenge that was uh brought up
04:48:26 in other contexts uh that things kept coming back and we had a level of concern uh that even if one
04:48:35 place was resolved the threat environment the concerns we had uh were going to replicate
04:48:42 themselves elsewhere and you understood that the police um the extra rcmp officers that were brought
04:48:49 into alberta were of course brought in under the provincial police service agreement not under any
04:48:54 powers created under the emergencies act no because they were brought in well before well
04:48:58 before the uh the emergencies act but it did go to the challenge facing being a national emergency
04:49:07 uh when we see police well when we saw the police action uh in ottawa at the end of that week
04:49:13 it drew on police uh members uh from uh from forces spread across ontario and beyond
04:49:22 the emergencies act didn't change that though it facilitated that it didn't create police
04:49:28 it didn't create police officers no but it highlighted that uh you couldn't just look at
04:49:34 one place and say oh we have enough resources to fix in this one place it was a broad challenge
04:49:41 across the country at the same time so alberta being on a hopeful track at that moment was
04:49:48 obviously good news but it wasn't sufficient to say oh great there's no more national emergency
04:49:55 all right i'm going to put to you the fact that you did have evidence that the laws in the
04:50:01 provinces were sufficient to handle the blockades and i'll give you two examples one is that the
04:50:06 windsor police along with the opp cleared the blockade and the ambassador bridge was reopened
04:50:13 before you made your decision correct um yes with the caveat that they a lot of the people who were
04:50:23 leaving uh the ambassador bridge were purportedly headed towards uh the sarnia crossing or the fort
04:50:30 erie crossing uh meaning that there were there were still real concerns that even as we settled
04:50:36 things in one place uh the rhetoric across the country and the online activity indicated that
04:50:43 people were not going home but they were looking for the next thing they could engage with right
04:50:50 so the police powers were able to deal with the problem correct in they were able to clear
04:50:58 the blockade they were able to clear the clear lanes at that moment yes in that spot okay but
04:51:06 there was a real concern there would be more right or the other example of the other example is coots
04:51:12 where where the rcmp were able to safely conduct a criminal investigation execute search warrants
04:51:18 and make arrests correct yes and that protesters in coots indicated to rcmp that they wanted to
04:51:26 leave the protest because they didn't want to be associated with the criminal elements uncovered
04:51:30 correct uh i i can't speak to what their intent was okay we've heard evidence in this commission
04:51:38 so the commission knows um what uh one of the protesters did indicate the intent was
04:51:43 now these are in fact the type of decreases in troublesome protest activity that you had been
04:51:49 hoping to see in the weeks prior weren't they yes and um definitely examples of how existing
04:51:58 legal tools and police powers were effective at dealing with the legal portions of protests
04:52:03 correct yes all right you're pretty well out of your time so and that's okay i think i think i
04:52:14 will end there thank you very much prime minister for answering my questions today thank you thank
04:52:19 you next uh is uh the convoy organizers please
04:52:35 the lawyers representing freedom corp and the protesters were who were here in ottawa in january
04:52:51 and february of 2022 i want to first talk to you about the events that led up to the invocation of
04:52:58 the emergencies act you would agree with me that the emergencies act was invoked on valentine's day
04:53:05 monday february 14th correct yes and you are aware that this commission has received evidence from
04:53:12 the police and other witnesses that on monday february 14th the ambassador bridge was reopened
04:53:19 as was coots all the borders were reopened correct uh yes and there was concern that more
04:53:27 uh locations were going to be uh closed acutes didn't open till tuesday
04:53:35 okay well we'll review the record for that on the sunday night february 13th there was an irg
04:53:41 meeting and you were there and in fact you were the chair of that meeting is that correct yes
04:53:46 and at the irg meeting you were advised that there were breakthrough there was a breakthrough
04:53:51 agreement between the mayor of ottawa and the convoy organizers to move trucks out of the
04:53:56 downtown residential areas isn't that correct uh that is not how i remember it no okay well
04:54:02 i can advise you that at the inquiry it was confirmed by the documents your officials filed
04:54:09 here and by witnesses namely jody thomas she confirmed that at that irg meeting you were
04:54:16 briefed that there was an agreement with the mayor does that do you recall that with whom
04:54:22 but with the mayor and who some of the convoy organizers which ones well tamara leach who's
04:54:29 present here in this room signed a letter it was made publicly available on the news
04:54:36 on sunday february 13th and you were advised of that agreement at the irg meeting and we were
04:54:44 also advised uh that that agreement wasn't holding and that many of the convoy had decried it as
04:54:53 fake news and not actually an agreement that they would abide by and you learned that on twitter
04:54:58 is that correct no we learned that at the at the irg by whom by our collected officials thanks
04:55:05 and now you should be aware that this commission has also received evidence from city officials
04:55:15 and others that the next day on monday the 14th over 100 protest vehicles had moved out of the
04:55:21 downtown residential areas under the mayor's agreement prior to your 4 30 pm announcement
04:55:29 invoking the emergencies act is that right uh i can't speak to that but i'm sure others have or
04:55:35 will they have and you are aware of the evidence before this commission from police officials and
04:55:42 others who testified that the efforts by the truckers to further vacate the downtown residential
04:55:49 areas under the mayor's deal were blocked by the police on both tuesday and wednesday february 15th
04:55:56 and 16th are you aware of that no i am not my understanding was the police were allowing anyone
04:56:03 who wanted to leave to leave okay would you agree with me that it would have been a far better
04:56:10 outcome if you and your colleagues would have allowed the de-escalation agreement
04:56:15 with the mayor to be completed and there would have been no need to invoke the extraordinary
04:56:20 powers of the emergencies act including the significant and violent police actions and
04:56:27 freezing canadians bank accounts if i could interrupt uh commissioner it's brian gover
04:56:33 on behalf of the government of canada the agreement was to move the protesters to wellington
04:56:39 my friend is misstating the evidence in my submission i could provide some clarity okay go
04:56:47 ahead um it's very well known in the agreement with the mayor that it was to remove vehicles
04:56:57 from the downtown residential areas and yes mr gover thank you to move to wellington
04:57:05 but out of residential areas apart from wellington so thank you
04:57:14 can you now are you able to answer the question
04:57:17 uh i believe the answer was no but you can repeat the question if you like sure
04:57:25 if you had allowed the de-escalation agreement in other words moving trucks outside and other
04:57:32 protest vehicles outside of the downtown area there would be no need to invoke the emergency
04:57:39 act mr commissioner i i object again because characterizing this as a de-escalation agreement
04:57:46 in my submission is a misnomer.
04:57:49 This was an agreement that didn't hold,
04:57:52 but it was to move vehicles from residential areas to Wellington Street.
04:57:58 Well, I'll let the question stand.
04:58:00 I think it's a question of interpretation.
04:58:03 Go ahead.
04:58:04 So, no, I don't agree.
04:58:06 Thank you.
04:58:11 Your officials have testified that they were following the convoy
04:58:15 as it began moving from regions of Canada towards Ottawa.
04:58:19 And you are aware that thousands of Canadians lined the highways
04:58:22 and overpasses to cheer the truckers.
04:58:24 Is that right?
04:58:26 I can't speak to the number, but yes.
04:58:29 There were many supporters, yes.
04:58:33 Mr. Prime Minister, I would like to read to you an excerpt
04:58:36 from three of the many statements that Canadians prepared for this commission,
04:58:40 Canadians who supported the convoy and explained why.
04:58:42 and i would like i would ask the registrar to bring up document id hrf four zeros one six six zero
04:58:54 if you could turn to page 274 please
04:59:04 and while that comes up i'll just start reading the statement
04:59:06 274. Elizabeth Klapik provided a statement about how the government's COVID mandates and lockdowns 0.96
04:59:18 disrupted her life. Starting at paragraph three, she said, the truckers and the Canadians who
04:59:25 lined the roads, overpasses and highways restored the hope that I had almost lost.
04:59:31 These patriotic Canadians told me that I am not alone, that I matter.
04:59:36 I will never forget the hope and pride I felt watching these amazing truckers
04:59:41 driving along Canadian highways, crowded with patriotic Canadians flying their flags
04:59:52 and holding their signs of support.
04:59:58 I will never forget the tears I shed as I regained that almost lost hope, that love for my home and native land, that love for my fellow Canadians.
05:00:10 At page 235, Ottawa resident Karen Hanna, who obtained a sociology degree from Ottawa University, starting at paragraph 5, stated,
05:00:23 for months. The leader of our country publicly shamed people like me and my husband. Our own
05:00:33 family members turned on us, blamed us, and some even told us we don't deserve health care.
05:00:41 Paragraph 17. One of my most emotional moments was dancing on Rideau Street beside a local man.
05:00:47 He had tears streaming down his face.
05:00:49 All he wanted was a hug.
05:00:51 It was very overpowering for him.
05:00:54 I met a girl, 22 years old, who just hopped in her car from Winnipeg and just kept driving.
05:01:00 She stayed the entire time.
05:01:02 I met people who were like family to me.
05:01:05 People who gave up everything to come to Ottawa for justice and an explanation.
05:01:10 At page 116, here is one of many, many concerned parents and spouses.
05:01:20 Sam Crozier, at paragraph 8, says,
05:01:23 I am not asking for help. I am begging you to please listen, hear my heart, feel my pain, and help work towards the true North strong and free that we were promised.
05:01:38 my husband an army veteran who now has ptsd and not from anything he has seen or done in the
05:01:44 forces but from what our own government has done our government has destroyed my life i a once
05:01:51 optimistic full of life person find myself struggling to stay above water now i struggle
05:01:57 to find joy in anything and daily fear a new announcement being made that will further punish
05:02:03 us i have written the same email to every member of parliament daily and been ignored by a large
05:02:13 collection of the people meant to be our leaders meant to be listening to us mr prime minister
05:02:19 you have now heard the statements from some of the many concerned canadians who felt compelled
05:02:26 to support the protesters do you now understand the reason so many canadians came to ottawa
05:02:34 with such resolve in the midst of a harsh cold canadian winter
05:02:41 because of the harms caused by your government coveted mandates and they wanted to be heard
05:02:46 I am moved, and I was moved as I heard these testimonies, as I saw the depth of
05:03:00 hurt and anxiety about the present and the future expressed by so many people.
05:03:08 that COVID pandemic was unbelievably difficult on all Canadians. And my job throughout this pandemic
05:03:19 was to keep Canadians safe. And the way that I chose to do that was to lean on
05:03:25 public health officials, lean on experts and science on the best way to keep Canadians safe.
05:03:33 and because Canadians got vaccinated to over 80 percent we had fewer deaths in Canada than places
05:03:43 that didn't reach that and every heartbreaking story I hear of a family who sat beside the bed
05:03:50 of a loved one dying because they had believed that the vaccines were more dangerous than the
05:03:59 disease i take personally because i wish i could have done more and i don't convince people to
05:04:09 get vaccinated but i only have 10 minutes so thank you that was helpful uh mr prime just just to
05:04:16 interrupt you you're gonna have to shorten it because you're you're uh already over your time
05:04:21 okay thank you a number of people have testified in this inquiry referencing your widely published
05:04:28 comments and calling the unvaccinated racists and misogynists and we have heard testimony in this
05:04:35 inquiry about how some of your officials wanted to label protesters as terrorists would you agree
05:04:41 with me that one of the most important roles of a prime minister is to unite canadians and
05:04:45 not divide them by engaging in name calling uh i did not call people who were unvaccinated
05:04:53 names i highlighted there's a difference between people who are hesitant to get vaccinated for
05:05:04 any range of reasons and people who deliberately spread misinformation that puts at risk
05:05:12 that life and health of their fellow canadians and my focus every step of the way and the primary
05:05:21 responsibility of a prime minister is to keep canadians safe and alive right so in terms of
05:05:28 safety uh you when you met with our refrain minister blair public safety minister minister
05:05:38 mendicino national security intelligence advisor jody thomas and rcmp commissioner brenda lucky
05:05:44 and today you testified that the federal government was committed to exhausting all alternatives to
05:05:50 a resolution prior to making a decision to invoke the extraordinary powers of the emergencies act
05:05:57 do you agree that that accurately describes your government's position that the invocation of the
05:06:02 emergencies act was a measure of last resort was not something to be taken lightly thank you
05:06:07 and something to do when when other options were not effective and you are aware that the opp along
05:06:15 with others developed an engagement proposal and you were advised of that proposal at the irg
05:06:21 meeting on february 12th correct um it was a proposal but we had and it was presented to us
05:06:29 we had more questions uh about uh how it would actually work uh there it was not a complete
05:06:35 proposal my last question mr prime minister when did you and your government start to become so
05:06:41 afraid of your own citizens that's a very unfair and we are not those are my questions
05:06:52 thank you uh if there's any more trouble that side of the room is going to be expelled is that clear
05:07:01 clear enough. Next I'll call on the City of Ottawa please.
05:07:26 Good afternoon Prime Minister. My name is Alyssa Tompkins. I'm counsel for the City
05:07:30 of Ottawa. I just wanted to take you to a couple of statements on your witness summary
05:07:36 to start. So if we could bring that up, it's WTS 6084, please, Mr. Clerk. And we'll be
05:07:46 going to page four. And just if we can scroll down to where we're talking about challenges
05:07:56 in ottawa so the first point uh you make is that uh the lesson learned was not to let the trucks
05:08:05 park because that makes it more difficult to remove them and you noted the decision makers
05:08:10 in toronto and quebec city heeded this lesson prime minister are you aware that since that time
05:08:16 uh the city of ottawa in preparation for two events has indeed closed roads so the cities
05:08:21 learn that lesson as well you'll agree excellent okay um the second um about their resources
05:08:30 uh you state that there appeared to be a breakdown of communication between ops and the city and you
05:08:37 state it was unclear for instance whether the mayor's request for additional police officers
05:08:42 was made with the support of the ops or the ottawa police services board now are you talking about
05:08:48 the letter that you received from mayor watson um i'm talking about the the fact that we were
05:08:54 regularly briefed throughout uh that there were different requests coming from uh the police
05:09:02 then from the mayor then from other elements within the ottawa's orbit okay well i'm a bit
05:09:10 short on time but i'll put to you that the letter you received from the mayor was co-signed by the
05:09:16 chair of the ottawa police services board so by the time the letter came it was clear it was from
05:09:21 the opsb as well correct perhaps i can bring it up um okay i i don't know that it serves us um
05:09:29 i'll i'll put to the record and given my short time we'll we'll deal with it after and in terms
05:09:34 of ops also by by that point um well why don't we go to the readout of the call so the letter came
05:09:42 just to situate you the letter came um february 7th and the next day on february 8th you had a
05:09:48 call with mayor watts and do you remember that yes i do but we'll bring up the readout so it's uh
05:09:53 ssm.can.nsc.00002837
05:10:07 okay and um so there there's nothing in here let's scroll down uh to page two but if we go through
05:10:29 it there's no there's no concern expressed by you during this call that that there's any uncertainty
05:10:34 about whether ops or the opsb are aware of the resource request so by this point is that clear
05:10:41 in your mind i'm sorry uh would that it is clear that that mayor watson is asking for 1800 officers
05:10:55 yes yes i mayor watson was regularly clear in wanting um many more officers it wasn't
05:11:04 always clear what the plan for those officers would be those we turn to the ops for that and
05:11:10 the ops uh tended to give us different numbers than the city of ottawa was giving us that was
05:11:16 how i was briefed through it okay no and well i will i there was other evidence on that i'm not
05:11:21 going to take you to it but i think you're saying that uh you were briefed on that but we can rely
05:11:27 on the evidence of those individuals here okay but in a contemporary way as i was watching things
05:11:34 unfolded the briefings i received and what was consistent was there was confusion or misalignment
05:11:42 between different sectors of the city of ottawa and the ottawa police forces in terms of what
05:11:49 they needed how they needed how they were being delivered uh and that was that was one of the
05:11:54 realities we were dealing with okay but um that concern was not expressed in this call to mr
05:12:00 watts and you'll agree um sorry scroll down a bit further uh
05:12:13 oh yeah there are moments where you are saying one thing and he is saying another is there anywhere
05:12:18 we can help around that i think that was me expressing uh that there were different messages
05:12:23 coming out of the policing side versus the mayor's side yeah and he responds about the police solution
05:12:32 issue so just to your to your suggestion that we didn't talk about the differences between those
05:12:39 i actually did talk about the differences between what different uh groups were saying
05:12:45 okay well we can debate the particularities of that um point this is the day after you received
05:12:50 the letter co-signed by the opsb and there's nothing on this call saying that there's concern
05:12:57 that the ops didn't provide that number there are moments where you are saying one thing and
05:13:04 the police are saying another is there any way we can help around that right and we'll see the mayor
05:13:10 responds one thing was when he said it's not a police solution but it is a police police solution
05:13:17 so that's what the mayor understood you to be expressing a concern about and if we stroll down
05:13:22 uh then we get to a discussion about um mr ford and that that's actually where i i wanted to get
05:13:31 to you took a lot of time you're out of time so please uh get to the point quickly yep so if we
05:13:39 keep going and um oh there we are so you express um that the federal government will be there with
05:13:47 the resources and uh there's something about conflating um and i think you testified earlier
05:13:55 about it's the source of the mandates but uh you say doug ford has been hiding from his responsibility
05:13:59 on it for political reasons as you highlighted and important that we don't let them get away
05:14:04 from that and we intend to support you on that and the mayor says if they keep dragging their feet
05:14:08 I'm happy to call them out. It would be nice if we have something firmed up from the federal
05:14:12 government to shame them. Ford didn't even make an effort to come and see what's going on. So
05:14:17 part of the reason that you'll agree, the part of the reason the mayor was reaching out to the
05:14:21 federal government directly was to give him additional ammunition to put pressure on the
05:14:26 province, correct? I can't speak to the mayor's intentions in reaching out to me. I know that I
05:14:34 reached out to the mayor to talk about the situation in Ottawa and to express that I had
05:14:39 expressed to Commissioner of the RCMP and others that we should be providing whatever resources
05:14:45 can help the City of Ottawa. And all I'm saying is that when the mayor went to both the province
05:14:51 and the feds, he's explaining to you here that one of the reasons he's doing that, because he's also
05:14:56 reached out to Ford, is that he's hoping you'll give him something so that he can also push on
05:15:00 for so he he knows he has to go to the province too yeah but we don't um we don't provide uh police
05:15:08 officers in order to uh shame or make political points we're providing police officers to be
05:15:15 useful on the ground and to be able to deliver things so uh maybe there are political points
05:15:21 to be to be scored or made but our focus every step was what can we do to help deliver the
05:15:27 resources uh that ottawa obviously needed uh in order to move forward on dealing with this
05:15:35 occupation but you'll agree that the mayor was frustrated as were you that the province was not
05:15:40 providing the resources they read it they needed on an expedited as i believe i testified my
05:15:46 understanding was that the opp was engaged but it was at the political level uh that there wasn't
05:15:52 as much engagement at that particular point as we know uh as time went by uh the province got
05:15:58 very much activated and engaged and indeed i i had a call with premier ford the very next day
05:16:04 in which he showed his engagement all right thank you very much prime minister i appreciate
05:16:09 you answering my questions okay next is the ottawa coalition please
05:16:28 good afternoon mr prime minister my name is christine johnson i'm counsel for the ottawa
05:16:33 coalition of residents and businesses i want to use my time with you today prime minister
05:16:39 to unpack the evidence that you've provided that in your mind this demonstration in ottawa was not
05:16:46 a peaceful protest so you've already told us um i believe um in response to some questions from my
05:16:54 friend with the commission and my friend with the ccla that you obviously believe that protest
05:16:59 is a very important part of a functioning democracy you also acknowledged and i think
05:17:04 most people in Ottawa would agree that peaceful protests may sometimes cause inconvenience for
05:17:10 people and may also sometimes cause temporary uh interference with critical infrastructure even
05:17:18 but during the convoy demonstrations in Ottawa you'd agree that we weren't seeing near acts
05:17:23 of civil disobedience or temporary interference with critical infrastructure we were seeing
05:17:29 unlawful conduct that significantly interfered with the community's ability to live and exist
05:17:36 yes thank you and it's your view that as early as the first weekend of the demonstration in ottawa
05:17:43 some convoy participants were engaged in serious illegal activity by blocking and occupying city
05:17:49 streets defacing public property and harassing residents yes as was evidenced by my call with
05:17:55 yasser nakvi who highlighted a number of those things and a few more and from that first weekend
05:18:01 onwards this became even worse and more concerning to you yes reports of people being harassed for
05:18:07 wearing masks the constant noise the people not feeling safe in their own streets there
05:18:13 were many examples of that and you mentioned to us this morning that you grew concerned
05:18:18 in particular over counter protests rising up um were you aware in particular of uh the
05:18:25 counter protest that has now been coined as the battle of billings bridge on february 13th
05:18:31 that was i believe remind me i believe that was where a number of residents prevented trucks from
05:18:36 getting to the downtown car that's correct and is it fair to say that this counter protest was
05:18:42 actually quite successful in getting some trucks to leave very peacefully uh it's possible that it
05:18:48 achieved those but um having civilians uh having to do things that would be more appropriate for
05:18:58 trained police officers to be doing i think we can both agree is not an ideal situation
05:19:04 right and so was the government worried that uh given the success even of this counter protest
05:19:10 they might become more frequent if there was no government action and you were worried that
05:19:14 that that was what might ultimately lead to a violent conflict yes when i talked about threats
05:19:20 of serious violence the increase of counter protests and citizens taking issues into their
05:19:30 own hands increases the possibility of conflict and and violence right and we've seen one document
05:19:40 that i want to ask you but i won't pull it up but um a cesis report that we've been taken to
05:19:45 a number of times in this inquiry um that described the situation in downtown ottawa
05:19:51 and cesis communicated downtown ottawa mood was actually quite festive not threatening to passers
05:19:58 by i take it this was not your assessment based on what you were seeing and hearing for yourself
05:20:03 i think there were moments of uh festiveness and and collegiality amongst people who were there
05:20:14 at the same time cesus also reported to uh to me uh and to cabinet uh that there were uh imve
05:20:24 um purveyors of extremist ideology within the protest and one of the concerns was
05:20:33 people could be inspired or convinced or amplified in their behaviors to actually
05:20:42 lash out and take actions in ways that were threats to to public safety and in addition
05:20:48 to that you were hearing in fact uh that many ottawa residents business owners and workers
05:20:52 didn't find did in fact find the convoy quite threatening so to those passers by at least
05:20:57 there there was threatening behavior yes um and you in your witness statement uh you also suggest
05:21:03 that in your mind this was not a peaceful protest because of the threat of violence that existed
05:21:08 towards law enforcement when they were trying to manage the demonstration i think a uh protest
05:21:17 in which law enforcement are prevented
05:21:21 from being able to do their jobs
05:21:26 because of threats of violence to themselves
05:21:30 ceases to be a legal or peaceful protest.
05:21:36 And my last question for you following from that
05:21:38 is that when the government was ultimately considering
05:21:42 the invocation of the Emergencies Act,
05:21:44 CESA's advised Cabinet that invoking the Act could further inflame extreme anti-government rhetoric and even incite violence.
05:21:52 To your mind, hearing that assessment, does that not in and of itself confirm to you the threat of serious violence that was ever-present amongst these demonstrations?
05:22:01 Yeah. If someone's telling me, oh, you know, you should be careful about actually enforcing the law because that might make people more violent,
05:22:11 that's not necessarily a good argument as to why we should sort of let it slide or not intervene.
05:22:19 When people are emboldened or digging in to their illegal behaviors
05:22:28 and that enforcement of public order is actually a threat,
05:22:36 and this is actually something that Jason Kenney brought up at the FMM,
05:22:40 highlighting that these are not rational actors.
05:22:43 These are conspiracy theories, and he was concerned, as we were,
05:22:47 that the invocation of the Emergencies Act could have people who are irrational overreact.
05:22:54 But at the same time, we had to balance that risk against the risk
05:22:59 that people who were already starting to get fed up and engage in counter-protests
05:23:07 uh would start taking more and more into their own hands which was a greater risk i think thank you
05:23:14 very much prime minister those are all my questions for you thank you next i'd like to call on the
05:23:19 ontario provincial police please good afternoon mr prime minister chris diana council for the opp
05:23:34 just bear with me for a moment while i set my timer
05:23:41 all right perhaps mr clerk if we can start by bringing up document ssm.nsc.can50625
05:23:51 and while this document is coming up uh prime minister it's the transcript of your call with
05:23:57 the premiers to situate you in time and place which i believe was february 14th in the morning
05:24:01 is that correct yes all right if we can turn to page six please
05:24:11 scroll down a little bit all right where it says pm on the second line down i'm just going to read
05:24:17 let's read it out it says on a personal note everything i've heard about rcmp and opp have
05:24:21 been excellent opp commissioner regarded very highly by federal officials windsor operation
05:24:27 was outstanding we'll continue to collaborate so i take it that that's what you were hearing from
05:24:33 your senior officials that you'll be had been very effective to date uh yes and i would have
05:24:38 mentioned i you're always looking for positive things to say uh in these fmms uh where sometimes
05:24:44 there are contentious issues but that would have been the the understanding i had of the past
05:24:48 previous uh previous days it may not have held from the very beginning of the protest i won't
05:24:53 speak to that but at the at that moment yes that was what i was hearing from officials and that
05:24:57 And that would have been in accordance with your own personal views
05:24:58 over what you had seen in recent days happening in Ontario in any event, right?
05:25:05 Yes, that there was progress, yes.
05:25:10 I take it that your government had full confidence in the OPP
05:25:12 to discharge its policing responsibilities within the province of Ontario?
05:25:18 It is not up to the federal government to determine who is policing.
05:25:24 policing so it's not it's not up to us to have a confidence in the opp to execute provincial
05:25:30 responsibilities no but my point is you and this is not a call where the media was on this was you
05:25:35 were talking to the premiers and you without prompting brought up the opp and the opp commissioner
05:25:40 so i take it that your government was satisfied with what it had seen at the time of that call
05:25:44 with the opp i i was prompted because the premier was talking about uh about the opp before so it
05:25:50 wasn't entirely unprompted but i was happy to say yes i'm not trying to argue about it yes
05:25:55 things seem to be working well at that point right and because by that point and we've established
05:25:59 early in your evidence that the ambassador bridge had been fully open to traffic correct uh yes and
05:26:05 that wasn't an obp led enforcement uh if you say so and we also know at that point i think you
05:26:12 testified that you were aware that the obp had sent subject matter experts to lead the integrated
05:26:18 planning team in ottawa yes i knew that they had sent experts to support in ottawa right and they
05:26:23 were working with other police services but you may have heard some of the evidence of carson party
05:26:27 who was leading the exercise from the opp correct uh i hadn't but i i'm sure that's true and you
05:26:34 also mentioned some other areas of difficulty in ontario mentioned the blue water bridge
05:26:40 you mentioned fort erie those are the other areas the opp was actively engaged in correct
05:26:45 i i assume yes and to your knowledge there were never there was never a an occupation or a blocking
05:26:54 of either of those crossings i believe there were slow rolls headed towards uh one or both of them
05:27:00 at one point uh there was chatter about people moving from the ambassador bridge to one or two
05:27:07 of the others uh but i don't believe those i'm quite sure that those blockades never actually
05:27:12 fully materialized right and the opp were actively engaged in those movements correct uh yes both
05:27:18 before and after the invocation of the emergencies act right now in that context where the opp is
05:27:23 active across the province of ontario you would agree that opp commissioner kareek
05:27:28 could have provided valuable input on what tools might be useful under the emergencies act
05:27:33 um i'm fairly certain that the opp did provide inputs we as a federal cabinet got our inputs
05:27:47 through the rcmp but part of the rcmp's role was to inform us on suggestions and requirements by
05:27:58 all other police organizations as well no and fair enough and you may not have heard the evidence
05:28:03 both deputy minister stewart and commissioner lucky thought that the opp had been consulted but
05:28:08 in fact they had not been and i guess what i'm putting to you is the notion that if we're dealing
05:28:13 with the question of either necessary or useful tools if if the protest is happening in ontario
05:28:20 it would be a good idea to seek some input from the opp correct um it would not be up to me to
05:28:27 call the opp it would not be up to the uh necessarily even the federal minister to do it
05:28:33 our expectation my expectation certainly would have been uh that it would be for the rcmp to work
05:28:39 with uh their fellow police organizations on coordination and i would have assumed that that
05:28:45 was done and that could be done quickly through from commissioner to commissioner correct yes
05:28:51 and for purses of transparency and commissioner i understand i've hit my five minute mark and
05:28:55 for my last question for purposes of transparency we know that there is a consultation record as
05:29:01 we've seen here when you talk with the premiers that there should also be a written record of
05:29:07 consultation with law enforcement so that for accountability purposes when we go back and take
05:29:11 a look at the circumstances in terms of the tools that there's no ambiguity about what was needed or
05:29:17 what tools might be useful would you agree with that suggestion um i i know the commission will
05:29:22 be uh reflecting on suggestions on how to uh how to move uh move forward in future emergencies
05:29:28 so you would agree with my suggestion then correct uh it's not up to me to to agree with what needs
05:29:34 to happen in the future okay but you wouldn't disagree then i think more consultation is is
05:29:39 good but understanding that uh in an emergency one needs to move quickly all right thank you mr
05:29:44 prime minister okay thank you the uh next is uh former chief former chief slowly's council please
05:30:00 mr prime minister i'm rebecca jones council for former chief slowly
05:30:06 and you've testified today about the situation facing the country and the city of ottawa in
05:30:12 particular when the emergencies act was invoked right and this included threats of violence at
05:30:20 trucks with weapons in coots um trucks with unknown contents in ottawa and children in ottawa at the
05:30:28 site of the occupation right yes and she slowly described the situation uh in ottawa as a tinder
05:30:35 box and i take it you'd agree with that yes that was one of our concerns that it could get worse
05:30:41 very quickly right there was always a risk of escalation yes and you testify that it is the
05:30:47 responsibility of the prime minister to make tough calls and keep people safe right uh yes
05:30:55 and others as well but yes that is one of the roles it's not your only responsibility
05:31:00 um i take it that is also the role of a police chief yes and the prime minister and a police
05:31:06 chief don't take steps just because people are demanding them right um we certainly need to take
05:31:15 into account uh the perspective and concerns and um expectations of citizens uh that's an important
05:31:26 input into leadership but ultimately we have to getting the decision right is more important than
05:31:33 making the popular decision right and you testified that as of the date of the emergencies act the
05:31:40 fact that there had not yet been any serious violence was obviously a good thing but that
05:31:45 you couldn't say there there was no threat of that right indeed and i'm going to suggest that
05:31:52 the fact that there had been no serious violence was not only a good thing but it was a credit
05:31:57 to municipal police forces all police forces chief slowly and all of his policing partners
05:32:06 um yes and a credit to uh residents and a credit to people who were there on the ground um there
05:32:18 was no violence it would have taken one person on any side to create situations of violence so
05:32:24 uh we are it is fortunate that that there was no violence uh no significant violence uh at that
05:32:30 point right at any point and it is to the credit of the police among others that there was no
05:32:36 serious violence right i i'm not positioned to evaluate how much what the police did or didn't
05:32:44 do in ottawa uh was directly responsible for the lack of violence okay now in uh 2021 uh
05:32:53 then chief slowly was invited to the prime minister's uh listening circle to speak about
05:32:57 policing reforms you remember that i do and uh mr prime minister you thanked him for his
05:33:02 presentation and you thanked him for his leadership in leading police reform in canada right yes
05:33:09 and um i take it you agree that it's important to have voices
05:33:13 like peter slowly's at the table in canadian policing
05:33:17 you mean uh diverse canadians in positions of power yes yes okay and the convoy related events
05:33:31 across canada in late january and february of this year i take you'll agree with me they
05:33:38 were a trauma for the nation um there were certainly a very challenging time and many
05:33:45 Canadians experienced them as trauma yes right and this trauma landed more heavily on the shoulders
05:33:52 of certain individuals uh like Chief Soleil and his family than on others is that fair
05:34:01 um I think there
05:34:08 there's a lot of trauma to go around on all sides
05:34:11 okay now i want to return in the time i have left to the issue of the readiness of the operational
05:34:19 plan as of february 13th and you've been at candidate acknowledging that you didn't read
05:34:25 the operational plan on february 13th which of course makes sense that i wasn't given the
05:34:30 operational plan and nor would you expect to be that's right okay and you can't comment
05:34:36 on whether or not it was a good or complete plan you testified i i can't comment from personal
05:34:43 knowledge but my understanding both at the time and subsequently from people who are aware of
05:34:51 the plan was that it was not a complete plan okay so we're gonna have to put aside subsequently
05:34:58 um it was the plan that cleared the occupation in ottawa uh is the evidence here but at the time
05:35:03 sorry that was that was a plan of the 17th that cleared cleared the occupation it's not the plan
05:35:08 of the 13th well we will put that aside um we we will disagree on that issue mr prime minister but
05:35:16 um what i believe you're saying is that at the time on february 13th or as of february 13th
05:35:24 um that was your view based on what you were being told i take it um by the commissioner of the rcmp
05:35:33 sorry what was my view that the plan was the plan wasn't ready yes okay that was my view and um
05:35:42 i just want to take you please to trn 23 page 69 please
05:35:53 and mr prime minister this is the testimony of commissioner lucky before uh this inquiry
05:36:03 I believe it may be page 69 in the pdf.
05:36:22 There we are.
05:36:24 And so if you start scrolling down, you'll see that Commission Council is asking about
05:36:30 status of the plan and please of course take your time to read it as of february 13th
05:36:41 and you will see that commissioner lucky confirms yes that was when it was completed
05:36:47 and that would be on february 13th and then commission council says and we've heard some
05:36:52 evidence about this from other police agencies but essentially uh that it was a team effort the rcmp
05:36:58 was there the opp and the ops correct and and commissioner lucky says yes and commission council
05:37:06 says and i understand it you in particular commissioner lucky and perhaps the rest of
05:37:11 your team who looked at it were generally satisfied with the plan as an operational
05:37:16 plan to deal with the situation in ottawa and commissioner lucky says yes both myself and
05:37:22 commissioner karik were briefed on the plan the friday before that like i think it was around
05:37:27 february 11th we got the actual briefing from the planners on the plan and yeah yes we were
05:37:33 satisfied with the plan okay so i i put that to you mr prime minister to suggest that what happened
05:37:41 here was that you were not briefed by commissioner lucky on the 13th as to her satisfaction and the
05:37:48 rcmp satisfaction on the integrated plan to clear ottawa um i can only speak to what i both
05:38:00 knew then and what i know now what i knew then was uh what i was uh what my understanding was
05:38:08 then was that uh there was not a complete plan uh or a workable or operational plan to
05:38:17 clear ottawa at that point and i now know uh that indeed there was not uh a plan uh on that weekend
05:38:27 it's important that we that we stick with what you understood on february 13th yes so i understood
05:38:33 then was that there there was not an adequate and i i i hear you on that what i'm suggesting to you
05:38:38 based on what you've seen was commissioner lucky's evidence that there's a disconnect here and
05:38:44 perhaps what happened and i'm going to suggest what happened is that commissioner lucky didn't
05:38:48 brief you and your cabinet on the fact that there was a complete plan on the 13th
05:38:56 i can't comment on that okay thank you thank you next call on the city of windsor please
05:39:12 Good afternoon, Mr. Prime Minister. My name is Jennifer King, and I am legal counsel to the City of Windsor.
05:39:19 Mr. Prime Minister, I would like to start by taking you to one document, SSM CAN NSC 402698.
05:39:28 This is a readout of a call that you had with Mayor Dilkens of Windsor on February the 10th.
05:39:33 Do you recall that conversation?
05:39:36 Yes.
05:39:37 On the first page, there are some takeaways. I just wanted to read out the first one.
05:39:42 The mayor appeared confident that a plan and resources are in place.
05:39:46 He only needed the injunction to operationalize the plan by Saturday.
05:39:51 PM provided reassurance that the federal government is there.
05:39:55 If you could scroll to page two towards the bottom of the page, Mr. Clerk.
05:40:00 And you'll see here, Mr. Prime Minister, that it indicates that you said,
05:40:06 as I was speaking with police officers and various folks,
05:40:09 no question on the ground operationally who has jurisdictions.
05:40:12 I can assure you that the RCMP is working closely with the OPP.
05:40:16 Because this is our problem, and I want you to be reassured that we are out there and operationally totally linked.
05:40:23 So I just wanted to stop there.
05:40:24 What did you mean, Mr. Prime Minister, when you said this is our problem?
05:40:28 It is our problem together.
05:40:31 It is our as in different orders of government together, as I assume what I meant on this one,
05:40:37 because the rest of the sentence is really showing that I knew
05:40:41 and had been apprised that in regards to what was happening in Windsor,
05:40:48 the OPP and the RCMP were working well together.
05:40:52 And hopefully it continues on, and hopefully the politics will recede a little
05:40:55 because some of that stuff coming out of QP is a little inconsistent.
05:40:59 What does QP mean here?
05:41:02 Probably question period on the federal side,
05:41:04 because I think he was talking about the challenges he was facing in council chambers as well
05:41:10 and some of the debates that were happening at the municipal level.
05:41:13 Right. Okay. You can take that down, Mr. Kirk. Thank you.
05:41:16 You testified this morning, Mr. Prime Minister, about jurisdictional issues that arose
05:41:20 related to the governmental response to the blockades and occupations in January and February.
05:41:25 In Windsor, there's a provincial highway connected to an international border crossing
05:41:30 by a municipal road through a community, right?
05:41:33 Yeah.
05:41:33 Would you agree that the response to the blockade required communication and collaboration between all three levels of government?
05:41:41 Yes.
05:41:42 Certainly this morning you testified that when three orders of government are able to work seamlessly together, you get better results, right?
05:41:48 Yes.
05:41:49 You would agree with me that there was not a pre-existing plan or framework establishing the jurisdictional responsibilities of each of the three levels of government when responding to the unprecedented circumstances of these blockades of critical infrastructure?
05:42:04 uh i can't speak to the existence or not of that but it it is uh clear that uh that if there was
05:42:11 it wasn't as uh effective as it could have been and if there wasn't perhaps there should have been
05:42:16 okay and you testified this morning about the two tracks of work coming out of the irg meeting on
05:42:21 february 10th the clerk of the privy council told this commission that track one was to determine
05:42:27 everything that could be done within the existing set of powers duties and functions under the law
05:42:32 right yes so there was no pre-existing plan or framework setting out the various authorities
05:42:37 available to all three levels of government to respond to these blockades sorry i don't i
05:42:44 understand what you're asking so it wasn't predetermined it wasn't pre-collected the
05:42:48 different authorities that were available to the different levels of government but that sounds
05:42:53 like uh operational police coordination and that's not something that as prime minister i would be
05:43:00 particularly closely involved in well certainly the three levels of government were considering
05:43:05 and and the irg was considering the different authorities and powers available to them to assist
05:43:12 yes the the the irg and the federal government was looking to offer resources to police of
05:43:19 jurisdiction in helping out yes okay so the commission has heard during this hearing several
05:43:24 times the winds are started reaching out to the province and to the federal government
05:43:28 shortly after the blockade was cleared asking for the three levels of government to sit down
05:43:33 debrief and work together to develop a plan to protect these international border crossings
05:43:39 minister blair just give you a heads up testified that he did not recall this request but said it
05:43:45 struck him as a reasonable request do you agree yes and minister mendicino testified that a planning
05:43:50 process to protect border crossings must include every level of government of course the city of
05:43:55 Windsor and other border communities as well. Do you agree? That makes sense, yes. And so you'll
05:44:00 agree that all three levels of government must collaboratively develop a framework to protect
05:44:04 the critical infrastructure in Canada? Yes. Mr. Prime Minister, you said in your remarks
05:44:10 on the revocation of the Emergencies Act on February 23rd that even as this emergency is over,
05:44:16 we need to make sure our institutions are prepared and ready for the future.
05:44:20 this issue won't just go away and in fact um mr prime minister the next threat may be different
05:44:26 than the blockades that we experienced earlier this year what are you doing mr prime minister
05:44:31 to ensure that such a plan is developed on an urgent basis um i have made it clear to
05:44:39 the appropriate ministers that working in particularly mr minister blair minister of
05:44:44 emergency preparedness that preparing for emergencies of all types must be a priority
05:44:50 for this government and must involve working with partners at all orders of government thank you
05:44:58 next i'd like to call on the windsor police service please
05:45:06 sir patterson i'm counsel to the windsor police service
05:45:09 um minister blair testified earlier this week and he agreed that the windsor enforcement operation
05:45:16 on february 12th and 13th was a success with no loss of life or serious injury to public
05:45:23 protesters or police uh would you agree with minister blair's assessment i have no reason
05:45:29 to disagree yeah no okay and you're aware the ambassador bridge was reopened by police in the
05:45:35 early hours morning sorry early hours of the morning of february 14th correct yes okay my
05:45:42 friend for the opp took you to the first minister's conference call on february 14th 2022 at ssm nsc can
05:45:52 625 please and i'll just put your comments back up it's the same paragraph we're going to look at
05:46:00 again on page six my focus obviously will be a little bit different than the opps
05:46:14 um and in that paragraph uh for the comments attributed to you you say um the windsor operation
05:46:20 was outstanding and would that accurately reflect your comments that you gave to the
05:46:24 the first ministers that day uh yes those seem to be my comments okay great thank you those are my
05:46:32 questions okay with that pat on the back we'll go to uh the government of saskatchewan please
05:46:46 good afternoon sir i'm mitch mccadam one of the lawyers for the government of saskatchewan
05:46:51 and I want to ask you a few questions about COVID-19 and the Emergencies Act.
05:46:58 I would ask the clerk to please bring up poe.sas.701.
05:47:07 sir this is a letter that you sent to premier mo of saskatchewan on april 8 2022 2020 pardon me
05:47:25 about covid19 in the emergencies act and i think you talked this morning a little bit about
05:47:31 considering and invoking the Emergencies Act
05:47:35 to deal with the pandemic back in March and April of 2020, didn't you?
05:47:38 Yes.
05:47:40 And I take it that similar letters would have been sent to all the premiers?
05:47:45 Yes.
05:47:47 And if we can go to the top of page two of this letter,
05:47:51 at the end of the first paragraph,
05:47:54 it refers to the fact that you are formally initiating a consultation process
05:47:59 under the Emergencies Act. That's correct, isn't it?
05:48:03 Yes.
05:48:03 It was a formal process.
05:48:05 Yes.
05:48:07 And, Clerk, if we could go back to the first page
05:48:10 and the bottom of the letter.
05:48:15 It indicates that you had already discussed the Emergencies Act
05:48:19 with the Premiers during at least two telephone conferences,
05:48:22 one on March 23rd and one on April 2nd.
05:48:25 That's correct, isn't it?
05:48:27 Yes.
05:48:29 and also in that same paragraph it refers to the fact that ministers from at least four different
05:48:37 departments have spoken to their provincial counterparts about whether measures under the
05:48:42 emergencies act could assist in the collective efforts to deal with the pandemic that's correct
05:48:47 too isn't it yes and if we can go back to page two please
05:48:56 in the fourth paragraph on that page it refers to you asking the minister of public safety
05:49:07 and the deputy prime minister to also reach out to their provincial counterparts
05:49:11 to discuss this that's correct as well yes so i i take it that back in 2020 there was an effort
05:49:19 involving a number of different federal departments to reach out to their provincial counterparts to
05:49:24 discuss the emergencies act in this context yes and if we look at the end of
05:49:34 that paragraph I take it that there was a plan that you are going to convene
05:49:39 another telephone conference with the premiers to discuss this topic further
05:49:42 correct I had a lot of telephone conferences with the premiers around
05:49:46 then yes okay thank you clerk if I could next ask you to pull up another document
05:49:53 It's SAS.702, please.
05:50:10 We'll just wait for a moment while the letter gets pulled up.
05:50:17 Prime Minister, you'll see that this is a letter from Scott Moe,
05:50:21 sent as chair of the council of the federation to you about covid 19 and the emergencies act
05:50:27 on april 14th do you recall this letter yes
05:50:33 and if we look at the end of the first paragraph in this letter it refers to another conference
05:50:38 call with the premiers about this matter on april 9th that's true right yes
05:50:45 and in premier mo's letter he shared with you the opinion of the premiers
05:50:49 that it was neither necessary nor advisable to invoke the emergencies act at this time
05:50:54 that's correct isn't it yep and that's what you heard at the conference call on april 9th correct
05:51:00 yes and as a result the emergencies act was not ever invoked by your government to deal
05:51:06 with the covet 19 pandemic was it that is correct except in so much as the most recent use of the
05:51:15 emergencies act was linked to the covet pandemic at least indirectly okay understood
05:51:23 and sir would you agree with me that the provinces had the capacity and the authority
05:51:27 or the tools to deal with the pandemic back in 2020 2020 yes and the provinces
05:51:36 and the provinces were dealing with it i think your words this morning were they had it under
05:51:40 control uh they certainly had more appropriate tools and experience to deal with the public
05:51:47 health emergency than uh the federal government did to to do that to take over the public health
05:51:54 side of the public health emergency yes okay healthcare delivery is the provinces in this
05:51:59 country so that's the point understood and where federal assistance was required it could be
05:52:06 provided without invoking the emergencies act correct yes now prime minister we've all already
05:52:13 heard today a lot about the consultation with the provinces in february of this year in particular
05:52:19 on the morning of february 14th so i won't go that through that with you again but i just ask
05:52:25 you if you will agree with me that the consultation process that was followed in february of this year
05:52:31 was very different from the process that was followed back in the spring of 2020 yes it was
05:52:37 thank you sir those are all of my questions if i can allow to elaborate as to why they were
05:52:44 different absolutely prime minister um the emergencies act isn't a monolithic act it
05:52:52 actually has many different categories and types of emergencies within it um in the spring of 2020
05:52:58 what we were talking about was a public welfare, a public health emergency.
05:53:05 I don't have the exact categorization, but one can imagine that a public health emergency like a pandemic
05:53:11 would require a different set of tools than or a different perspective
05:53:17 and certainly a longer-term opportunity with more opportunities to write letters back and forth
05:53:25 and consult with the whole council of the federation and draw paperwork in response to
05:53:31 the consultation and we certainly took advantage of that because in the section of public order
05:53:38 emerge sorry of the emergencies act that refers to public health emergency and invocation of the
05:53:44 emergencies act it says clearly you have to have that consultation done before in the section on
05:53:53 a public order emergency the requirements for consultation uh is i believe laid out that if
05:54:03 there is no time for consultation that consultation can actually happen afterwards uh after the
05:54:09 invocation uh it certainly highlights that it wouldn't be ideal uh but it recognizes that a
05:54:15 public order emergency might require a much more rapid reaction time than a public health emergency
05:54:25 and the fact that we were looking at two different parts of the same emergencies act
05:54:29 i think goes a long way towards explaining why we were able uh to do an extensive consultation
05:54:37 even though as i'd said from the outcome outset it wasn't i wasn't leaning towards
05:54:43 it wasn't our intention to invoke a emergencies act around the public health but we wanted to
05:54:49 do the consultation because people were concerned that that we look at all tools to deal with this
05:54:54 pandemic and we did but when it came to the exigency and the urgency of the public health
05:55:04 sorry the public uh order emergency we went from a saturday a sunday establishing the uh six or so
05:55:16 different tools that we would bring in to consulting the very next morning with the
05:55:22 premiers that with this freshly established list of tools and then invoking just hours later and
05:55:29 And those compressed timelines made it a very different context
05:55:33 from one type of invocation of the Emergencies Act to another.
05:55:39 Prime Minister, you'll understand that we as lawyers
05:55:42 are always looking for precedents,
05:55:44 and this is the only other precedent
05:55:46 where your government has considered invoking the Emergencies Act.
05:55:50 Isn't that true?
05:55:51 Yes.
05:55:53 Thank you. Those are all of my questions.
05:55:55 Thank you. Next, I'd like to call...
05:55:59 Thank you.
05:56:29 Thank you.
05:56:59 Thank you.
05:57:29 Thank you.
05:57:59 Thank you.
05:58:29 Thank you.
05:58:59 Thank you.
05:59:29 Thank you.
05:59:59 Thank you.
06:00:29 You