Juno News - April 24, 2024


Justin Trudeau thinks Canadians need more of him

Topics
Mentioned
Blaine Higgs on parental rights, gender identity, and being labelled “far right” How technology is shaping the future of Canadian oil and gas

Episode Stats


Length

46 minutes

Words per minute

177.61

Word count

8,253

Sentence count

289

Harmful content

Misogyny

1

sentences flagged

Toxicity

9

sentences flagged

Hate speech

5

sentences flagged


Summary

Summaries generated with gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ .

In this episode of The Andrew Lawton Show, host Andrew Lawton talks about Justin Trudeau's recent interview with Vox's Alex Blumbergen in the U.S. and why he thinks Justin Trudeau is the best PM Canada has ever had.

Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Topics generated with Qwen2.5-3B-Instruct.
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 Transcription by CastingWords
00:00:30 Thank you.
00:01:00 welcome to canada's most irreverent talk show this is the andrew lawton show brought to you by true
00:01:19 north hello and welcome to you all happy hump day it is wednesday midway through the week it is
00:01:30 april 24 2024 uh what is that oh four 24 24 i don't know if there's any significance to that
00:01:36 but it seemed as i said it like it might be worth pointing out anyway better than 420 we don't uh
00:01:42 we don't do any of that funny 420 funny 420 business on the andrew lawton show although my
00:01:47 inability to say funny 420 business may lead you to suspect otherwise. But nevertheless,
00:01:52 we had a bit of a special delivery to the studio a few moments ago. I won't lift the whole box
00:01:59 because I will embarrass myself. But it was a box full of these bad boys that just showed up.
00:02:05 This is my new, well, you're getting the reflection of the light there. There we go.
00:02:09 This is my new book, forthcoming biography. Well, is it still forthcoming if I'm holding it in my
00:02:14 hands. I don't know. For the rest of you, it's forthcoming. The release date is May 28th and it
00:02:21 is called Pierre Polyev, A Political Life. It is a full-length bio. You don't need to put the cover
00:02:27 up when I'm holding it, Sean. That was just until we had this thing, although that actually looks
00:02:32 like a nicer image, but there you go. It's Pierre Polyev, A Political Life. A lot of fun, actually,
00:02:38 and people, when I wrote my book about the Freedom Convoy, complained that there weren't pictures in
00:02:43 it. So on this one, we have a photo. I shouldn't show you the photos because I can't give it away,
00:02:50 but I'll show you one photo. This is on the inside cover. We got some old
00:02:54 Polyev family photos there that are in the mix. So this is a book that I was really excited to
00:03:00 write and I hope you are excited to read if you're interested in it and have tolerated this
00:03:05 never-ending promo of it. I was very excited to get those a few moments ago. You can pre-order
00:03:10 it for yourself at Amazon, at Indigo, or through the publisher, which is Sutherland House. And
00:03:16 they're at SutherlandHouseBooks.com. But nevertheless, I'm sure there will be more
00:03:20 about that as the release date nears. I wanted to first and foremost talk about, actually,
00:03:25 Pierre Polyev factors into this story a little bit, because you may recall not that long ago,
00:03:31 Pierre Polyev launched an ad campaign in which he uttered the phrase that I don't think most
00:03:35 Canadians really disagreed with that Canada is broken and you see this on the micro level when
00:03:41 you have Canadians who at the time were unable to get passports because the passport offices were in
00:03:47 such disarray and then you also had the idea that we also see increasingly an economy that is pricing
00:03:55 out young people from the housing market where people are not able to get jobs you have everyone
00:04:01 relying on the gig economy, and so on and so forth. And Pierre Polyev made the comment that I
00:04:07 think in large ways explains why he has become such a popular vehicle in polling numbers, which
00:04:14 is that people are not satisfied with the status quo. Justin Trudeau is the status quo. Pierre
00:04:19 Polyev is the change candidate right now. And Justin Trudeau got so indignant about this. You
00:04:25 may recall this speech that he gave at the Liberal Party convention just a couple of months after
00:04:30 Pierre Polyev was named conservative leader.
00:05:00 I think Canada better is always possible, but I don't accept Canadians and politicians 1.00
00:05:14 that talk down our country.
00:05:17 Let me be very clear.
00:05:22 Let me be very clear for the record.
00:05:27 Canada is not broken.
00:05:32 Very offended at the assertion that anyone could say Canada is broken.
00:05:37 Yeah, we can always do better, but the country is not broken.
00:05:41 The country is not broken.
00:05:42 Canada's working.
00:05:43 Everything's hunky-dory.
00:05:44 We've been doing a fantastic job at it.
00:05:46 Well, don't I listen to, because I do this stuff so you don't have to,
00:05:50 a 30-minute podcast interview that Justin Trudeau did this week with Vox in the U.S.
00:05:56 And obviously, it was a fairly left-leaning interviewer, someone who was born in Canada
00:06:02 but now lives in the United States.
00:06:04 And most of the questions to Justin Trudeau were basically like that old Simpsons question
00:06:09 that Lisa asked Mr. Burns, which was, your campaign has all the momentum of a runaway
00:06:13 freight train.
00:06:14 Why are you so popular?
00:06:15 So there wasn't really anything challenging, but you still get some revealing insights
00:06:20 from justin trudeau's answers and in particular i enjoyed him talking about the trials of being
00:06:26 a young canadian this is in audio form only but take a listen people are facing an anxiety that
00:06:34 the economy doesn't work for them anymore that the principles that held true for us xers for boomers
00:06:40 of getting a good job being able to save up for why you rent to buy a house eventually and then
00:06:46 you get a Morgan, you build things forward like that.
00:06:48 That just doesn't work anymore,
00:06:50 that the deck is stacked against young people
00:06:52 in a way that is different from previous generations.
00:06:56 And that's a problem because it leads to a sense of uncertainty
00:07:00 about the future and a sense of,
00:07:02 okay, the institutions and society and government can't actually help.
00:07:06 And that sort of feeds into populism.
00:07:08 The challenge that we have is,
00:07:10 okay, what are the biggest challenges out there in Canada?
00:07:14 Housing.
00:07:14 People can't imagine working as a nurse or a carpenter or an electrician or a police officer and living in the city that they serve.
00:07:23 Well, that's something that we should be able to fix, and we're working on fixing that.
00:07:28 We need to make sure things like people who are paying $2,000 a month on rent, besides someone else who's paying $2,000 a month for a mortgage,
00:07:37 well, that rent should be counted towards their credit score so they can eventually get a mortgage.
00:07:42 That's something that nobody thought of before because rent was never such a huge part of people's expenditures.
00:07:49 Making that change gives people hope, again, that you can see a better future in which you're going to be able to succeed.
00:07:57 So on one hand, he's saying that in his old speech that, oh, it's terribly offensive.
00:08:04 You can't look down on Canadians by saying Canada's broken.
00:08:06 And now in this interview, he's literally saying that the economy doesn't work for young Canadians,
00:08:11 that institutions aren't serving them, that the deck is stacked against them, and that things
00:08:17 aren't working for them. Now, I am no linguist, but I would say that things are not working
00:08:23 and things are broken are pretty semantically similar. I don't think you can be all offended
00:08:31 and high and mighty and get on your tall, high hybrid horse because, well, the horse has been
00:08:39 phased out with the carbon tax. You can't get on your high horse and be so offended and mortified
00:08:43 that someone says Canada is broken while turning around and saying, well, you know what, things
00:08:46 aren't broken. So for starters, there is some brazen hypocrisy here that Justin Trudeau is 0.91
00:08:51 exhibiting when he makes on one hand the comment that the brokenness of Canada is non-existent,
00:08:57 and on the other hand concedes that. And then there's the other side of this, which is how on
00:09:01 earth he can convincingly say that he has the answers when he has been the guy on whose watch
00:09:07 things have gotten exactly where they have gotten for the last eight years, pushing 10 by the time
00:09:13 the next election is likely to roll around. So all of a sudden, Justin Trudeau, just as we heard
00:09:18 from his government on immigration, they've just been this hapless bystander. Well, everything in
00:09:23 Canada has happened and it doesn't matter that it's been on their watch. It's somehow not their
00:09:28 fault. It's Stephen Harper's fault. In this Vox interview that he did, which I won't share the
00:09:33 whole half hour of with you. He was asked about populism. And, you know, Pierre Paliyev is the
00:09:38 angry, meanie populist. And Justin Trudeau, he's got the guy. He's the guy with all the answers.
00:09:43 But what's fascinating here is that Trudeau has said, oh, well, I mean, it's global. And there's
00:09:50 none of this stuff is just in Canada. This is happening everywhere. So he is basically trying
00:09:54 to make it out to be that anything bad in the country is not his fault. Anything good was his
00:10:00 doing and we're all supposed to just not see the glaring inconsistencies in that so you've either 0.99
00:10:06 been the most inept incompetent prime minister or you have been just an incredibly malicious force 0.96
00:10:11 and malignant force in canada those are the two options none of this oh well it's a global trend 0.97
00:10:17 and we've just been i mean his defense is basically that we've done nothing and we couldn't stop it
00:10:22 but trust us because we're going to stop it moving forward that has been justin trudeau's line on
00:10:27 this now that interview he did with vox i don't know how many votes it's going to get him in
00:10:31 canada but it's part of a new fandangled strategy the liberals are rolling out which i saw in a
00:10:38 toronto star piece written by susan delacorte now susan delacorte is an absolutely lovely woman
00:10:43 uh she's always been very good to me and has never been as rude as many of the others in
00:10:48 legacy media towards independent media but she's also not a particularly critical voice when it
00:10:53 comes to Justin Trudeau. And that's, you know, perhaps why she has a home in the Toronto Star
00:10:58 there. But she says, you're about to hear, this is the headline, you're about to hear Justin Trudeau
00:11:03 on a lot more popular podcast. Here's what's behind it. And this is apparently part of a
00:11:09 strategy where Justin Trudeau thinks that people need to hear more from him. So all of these
00:11:14 terrible liberal polling numbers that put, you know, the desirability of him as Canada's prime
00:11:19 Minister at like 18% among Canadians who have been surveyed. All of that is just because they 1.00
00:11:24 haven't heard enough from him. No, no, no. Over the last eight years, Canada and Canadians have
00:11:30 not heard enough from Justin Trudeau. And if only they knew the guy more, if only they heard from
00:11:35 him more, then they would be more inclined to support the Liberals. Maybe they're just not that
00:11:41 into you, Prime Minister. Maybe Canadians know full well who you are and what you're about. And
00:11:45 they know full well that you're the guy who's been at the helm for the last eight years. And
00:11:49 that is precisely why they are turning at you and turning on you and your government in such
00:11:55 a dramatic way. Now, I talked a bit, this was going back like 24 days ago now, when this big
00:12:02 giant carbon tax protest started up. And again, for a lot of people, it was just a protest on
00:12:07 April 1st against the carbon tax. For some people, specifically in Alberta and also in
00:12:12 Atlantic Canada, as I just learned, the carbon tax protest has continued. People have continued
00:12:19 to protest the carbon tax. They've continued to log their discontent about what's been happening
00:12:26 in this world with the Spike the Hike campaign from Pierre Polyev, the tax campaign, and all
00:12:32 of that. But what's been interesting here is that Pierre Polyev was doing a little swing through
00:12:37 Atlantic Canada. I don't know what day it was exactly. It was probably on the weekend, but
00:12:41 I'm not sure. And he decided to stop. He saw some of these carbon tax protesters near the
00:12:47 New Brunswick-Nova Scotia border. He decided to pull over and have a little chat with them. Now,
00:12:54 what was interesting about this little chat is that they were, of course, filming and streaming,
00:13:00 as you do when you get a heavyweight VIP that drops by your protest site. I was going to share
00:13:05 some of the clips, but the volume is really, really low, so it would have been difficult.
00:13:08 But you can hear him say at one point that everything that Justin Trudeau says is BS.
00:13:14 At another point, you can see him walking by their F. Trudeau flag, which they have on the back of one of their trucks.
00:13:21 And then he tours this little camper trailer type thing that they have set up.
00:13:25 And one of the things on that, like if you really, really zoom in and zoom in and zoom in on that trailer, there's what's called the Diagalon flag.
00:13:34 And I thought I could have gone through the rest of my life without ever having to mention Diagalon, but here we are.
00:13:40 It was a group that, like Marco Mendicino, basically held up as being some, you know, terror group when the Emergencies Act was coming in.
00:13:47 It started off as this weird internet subculture meme and joke and has since ballooned into a larger community.
00:13:54 I don't believe Diagalon is an organized group in any meaningful way.
00:13:59 I also will fully say that many of the people associated with Diagalon, including its founder, Jeremy McKenzie, have said some absolutely vile things.
00:14:08 These are the folks who were sitting around on a webcast joking about Anna Polyev, Pierre Polyev's wife, being raped.
00:14:15 So I've got no time for them.
00:14:17 But I also would fairly confidently say that there are probably some people out there that just thought it was a funny joke and aren't part of any of that.
00:14:24 But nevertheless, there was a Diagalon flag on the side of this camper.
00:14:28 And then the media lost their minds on this, and it set up Justin Trudeau to smack down Pierre Polyev's comments about him as a peddler of BS at a press conference this morning.
00:14:40 Hi, I'm Michelle Song with CBC News.
00:14:42 Your opponent was photographed posing with anti-carbon tax protesters flying F. Trudeau flags. 1.00
00:14:49 In the video, Pierre Polyev is heard saying that you are a liar and everything you say is, quote, bullshit. 0.99
00:14:55 Can we get your response, please? 0.99
00:14:59 Every politician has to make choices about what kind of leader they want to be.
00:15:06 Are they the kind of leader that is going to exacerbate divisions, fears and polarization
00:15:14 in our country, make personal attacks and welcome the support of conspiracy theorists
00:15:23 and extremists because that's exactly what Pierre Polyev continues to do not just when he you see
00:15:30 him engaging with members of Diagalon but also when he refuses to condemn and reject the endorsement
00:15:42 of Alex Jones. Alex Jones is a proven liar and conspiracy theorist who you know had to pay has to 0.90
00:15:52 pay millions, hundreds of millions of dollars, because he lied about the Sandy Hook killing 0.98
00:16:00 that killed 20 little kids.
00:16:04 This is the kind of man who's saying, Pierre Polyev has the right ideas to bring the country
00:16:11 towards the right, towards conspiracy theories, towards extremism, towards polarization, towards
00:16:18 kind of lies that Alex Jones is peddling still. So the fact that Pierre Poliev hasn't stood
00:16:28 up to condemn that endorsement, the fact that he continues to encourage the kind of divisive
00:16:36 approaches to Canada that I don't think Canadians want to see really shows that he will do anything
00:16:44 to win anything to torque up negativity and fear and it only emphasizes that he has
00:16:54 nothing to say to actually solve the problems that he's busy amplifying
00:16:59 it's a bit of a good omen well not good omen but it's a bit of a an illustrative omen about what
00:17:06 the next federal election is going to look like the liberals are trailing in the polls
00:17:11 Canadians have grown increasingly frustrated with the carbon tax,
00:17:14 so much so that they've been protesting for literally 24 days straight,
00:17:19 more than three weeks, longer than the Freedom Convoy,
00:17:21 protesting the carbon tax and the subsequent increases to the carbon tax.
00:17:26 The leader of His Majesty's loyal opposition is driving through town,
00:17:30 decides to pull over and say hello,
00:17:32 and Justin Trudeau focuses on this little tiny little itsy-bitsy flag on a trailer
00:17:36 and then pivots to Alex Jones and the far right.
00:17:39 This was a tweet from the Liberals a couple of days ago.
00:17:42 They've been doing this like every other day.
00:17:45 Friendly reminder that Pierre Paulyev still has not denounced his endorsement
00:17:49 from far-right American conspiracy theorist Alex Jones.
00:17:53 So in the election, when the conservative candidates are going to people's doors and saying,
00:17:58 well, you know what, we're going to axe the tax and get rid of Justin Trudeau,
00:18:01 and the Liberals are going to be going to the door saying,
00:18:04 yeah, I know everything's gotten worse for you in the last eight years,
00:18:06 but did you see that Alex Jones tweet?
00:18:08 and that's going to be the election.
00:18:11 So it's funny that Justin Trudeau
00:18:12 likes to go on American podcasts
00:18:14 and rail against the angry solution-free populism
00:18:19 that he puts at conservative leader Pierre Paulyev's feet
00:18:22 while he's the one that is blathering on about Alex Jones
00:18:25 when his opponent dares to meet with a couple of people
00:18:29 that are fed up with the federal carbon tax.
00:18:31 Quite revealing, you might say.
00:18:33 Well, let's pivot to this.
00:18:35 I mentioned the Freedom Convoy.
00:18:36 this is a relic in some ways of an era that many people would rather move on from an era in which
00:18:42 Canadians were segregated along the lines of their vaccine status. And we saw people that
00:18:47 were forced out of jobs they had had for years, careers they had for years, and people who bravely
00:18:53 put on a uniform for this country that were told they were no longer fit to serve Canada in the
00:18:58 Canadian Armed Forces because they would not get vaccinated against COVID-19. Well, a story from
00:19:04 the Epoch Times this week says that at least some Canadian Armed Forces members have been given
00:19:09 waivers that allow them to serve once again if they were previously sanctioned for not getting
00:19:15 the COVID vaccine. I wanted to talk about this with Catherine Christensen, a lawyer
00:19:19 with Valor Law. Good to talk to you again, Catherine. Thanks so much for coming on today.
00:19:24 Good afternoon, Andreas. Good to be back. So let's first off start with what's actually
00:19:30 changed here? What has the Canadian Armed Forces done? Well, first of all, the mandate still exists
00:19:35 for Canadian Armed Forces members. Certainly anyone who isn't vaccinated, isn't getting deployed,
00:19:42 isn't eligible for promotion. Although I can tell you that some of the people who stood up
00:19:48 and managed to stay serving have been promoted, have been on deployments without vaccination.
00:19:53 So there's some confusion there.
00:19:55 But apparently last fall, they quietly brought in a policy that anyone who would receive a 5F, which is unfit for service release category, strictly because of the COVID mandate, would be allowed to re-enroll and that their applications were welcome.
00:20:17 and with the caveat that all 5F reapplications have to be approved by the chief of defense staff.
00:20:24 So if you get past the recruiting application piece, the chief of defense staff has final say.
00:20:30 Now, I have had clients of mine who were 5F'd approach recruiting centers, certainly since
00:20:36 last fall, even as early as last month here in March, and the recruiting centers won't
00:20:41 even take their application. But then I got news directly from a recruiting source that indeed this
00:20:51 policy is now back, that they are allowed to apply. Now in Noah Chartier's article, he points out that
00:21:00 they say they've only had one person apply under this relaxed policy. I'm going to question that
00:21:08 because I know that for sure that there has been a lot more than one person try to apply and been
00:21:13 turned down at the recruiting centers. Well and I would also point out here I mean while this might
00:21:19 be on the surface something that looks quite positive it doesn't really get to the crux of
00:21:24 the issue here which is that they still have as you note the mandate they've never really apologized
00:21:29 for it they've never done anything to say hey we want you back it seems like they're just dealing
00:21:35 with the fact that uh very few people are wanting to go into the canadian armed forces right now
00:21:39 they've got a recruitment crisis and i think they're trying a little they're trying to really
00:21:42 dance around the the real root of the issue here yeah well the real root of the issue is two years
00:21:48 ago these same people were told they were unfit for service that the they were not uh any type
00:21:55 of person that the canadian armed forces wanted and now uh all of a sudden they're quietly saying
00:22:00 oh no come back but come back without return necessarily return to your same trade what
00:22:08 about compensation for the time you were off if you were that qualified that they want you back
00:22:16 i'm thinking that there's a bit of a conundrum they've got because if they allow them back 1.00
00:22:22 they're defeating their own defense because we've got lawsuits against them in the courts right now
00:22:28 I'm being able to stand up and say to the court, well, these people were supposedly unfit for
00:22:36 service and needed to be permanently released, but now they're okay to come back. That's a bit
00:22:42 of a dilemma. And the mandate itself is particularly absurd now because if you had
00:22:48 had two doses of the COVID vaccine in 2021, your protection is zero at this point. You have no
00:22:57 benefit over someone who did not get vaccinated at this point. I mean, so let's even assume there
00:23:03 was a benefit in 2021. There isn't now. So the idea of clinging to this mandate just defies
00:23:08 any sense of science. And really, I had spoken to one veteran about this a couple of years ago,
00:23:14 And he had said that basically it was a compliance issue more than it was a medicine issue.
00:23:19 They wanted to weed out the type of person that didn't want it more than there was any, you know, strategic or operational reason that it needed to be there.
00:23:28 Exactly. Because let's face it, going into this mandate of General Ayers, they'd already gone through working in the nursing homes.
00:23:38 So ground zero, where a lot of the deaths took place, we had armed force members there, and not one of them died of COVID from that exposure. So that's pre-vaccine. So then they bring in this vaccination and decimated the Canadian Armed Forces because they've lost so many people over it, as well as the woke agenda is also to blame.
00:24:01 But they lost a lot of very capable people with exemplary military records just because of the people standing up and saying, no, I'm not going to take it, whether it's against my religion, whether I don't have informed consent, or I want my bodily autonomy, or I have medical reasons that I can't take it.
00:24:21 And now that they're desperate, they seem to want them back.
00:24:26 We had you on the show back in June when you had launched, I think it was like a $500 million lawsuit representing hundreds of soldiers at the time about this.
00:24:36 And I just wanted to ask, I know these things can take years, but what's the status on that one now?
00:24:42 Well, it's been interesting because we ended up launching a second mass tort after the first one came out and people approached our office.
00:24:49 So we're up to about 458, and the two lawsuits, they were only a few months apart from filing,
00:24:55 but they've caught up to each other because it's the same Crown lawyer, and they've been playing
00:25:00 some games. We sent them our affidavit of documents, which is basically a list of our
00:25:07 evidence, and they didn't reply back. So I went into the court to force them to give me a list
00:25:14 their evidence. We've now ended up in case management and we are before the case management
00:25:19 justice next week and I'm looking forward to hearing the Crown lawyer defend why he can't
00:25:27 give me a list of his evidence to defend because at this point they've got no evidence and the
00:25:32 longer they delay the better it is for me because now we're well over 300,000 pages of evidence of
00:25:39 wrongdoing in the Canadian armed forces. So they keep delaying, it's just going to get worse.
00:25:46 I seem to recall, and I might be mixing up the case, but when there was the lawsuit against the
00:25:51 federal air travel vaccine mandate, I think the applicants had a similar issue in that it was like
00:25:57 pulling teeth to get the government to provide the evidentiary basis it had for this policy, which,
00:26:03 I mean, maybe in politics you can get away with fudging on the evidence, but in a court there is
00:26:07 still a process and if you don't provide evidence for your side of it you don't actually have a
00:26:11 case do you right yeah so this is exactly what my motion in january when i filed it was saying well
00:26:17 if they don't want to provide me with any evidence to defend then i want uh leave of the court to
00:26:24 bring a summary judgment give us what we ask for because you can't defend against what we've claimed
00:26:28 um they're in a bit of a situation here because uh cap is well known for blocking any access
00:26:37 information requests but we spent two years very quietly asking for information through access to
00:26:44 information requests and we collected hundreds of thousands of pages of evidence before they
00:26:50 even knew we were bringing a lawsuit because not one of those requests came out of my office they
00:26:54 were all done by private individuals um so we've kind of gone around done an end run around them
00:27:01 and we have a lot more evidence i think than they realized that we have we would have going
00:27:05 into the lawsuit. In my opinion, I think they're also trying to delay moving into depositions
00:27:17 where I'm going to be calling General Eyre, General Cadu, General Fortan, Admiral McDonald,
00:27:25 all of those are going to be called to testify under oath. And when General Whalen's court
00:27:31 marshal was coming along the day before they wanted to have air testify at that they dropped
00:27:38 the charges to keep him from having to testify under oath so interesting well they're terrible
00:27:43 they're terrible with access to information requests i filed one in january about tampons
00:27:49 in washrooms on army bases because you know there was they were they were all getting removed by
00:27:54 soldiers that thought it was nonsense when there's a tampon dispenser in the men's washroom and that's
00:27:58 still taken over three months and i don't have the records yet so i feel like i have to buckle
00:28:02 in for a long wait i'm i'm amazed you got all you did in two years given how dnd has been on these
00:28:07 requests in the past well the information commissioner has actually been very helpful
00:28:12 she has actually brought lawsuits against the calf to get documents that we have asked for 0.80
00:28:16 um the longest uh access to information requests i thought uh it was a long time but there's some
00:28:23 that have been years and years and years and they still don't have that information uh even though
00:28:29 they're entitled to it so uh we we did it we kind of outmaneuvered the system which is what my
00:28:37 clients hired me to do because after we tried the injunction i said okay we're gonna go deep we're
00:28:42 gonna go dark and i've got all military people who are really good at keeping secrets if they have to
00:28:48 and very smart and very motivated and they did fantastic work for me yeah it shows what happens
00:28:54 when you alienate a very skilled dedicated group of people and they have an axe to grind time on
00:29:00 their hands and those skills that were previously being deployed for the country and now are being
00:29:04 deployed against the bureaucrats in the department keep in mind that these are people who know that
00:29:10 the documents exist because they wrote the documents yeah so they know what to ask for
00:29:15 which is so key it's not just a fishing expedition right yeah yeah they're like well here's my chain
00:29:20 of command and i know i had emails with all of these people and in some cases they still had the
00:29:26 email they they you know they brought it with them so we knew to send in the action uh information
00:29:32 requests to get it legitimately through the process and then they'd say well though that
00:29:36 that doesn't exist and we'd go yes it does well good stuff we'll uh wish you well on this catherine
00:29:44 please do keep us posted as you work your way through the system here i sure will and we're
00:29:48 also bringing a vaccine injury one we've got lots of members of the canadian forces who were injured
00:29:55 from the moderna vaccine so that's coming up too all right well appreciate that very much
00:30:00 katherine christensen from valor law out in alberta thank you so much katherine take care andrew all
00:30:05 right well one issue that we have been covering all week has been the united nations ongoing
00:30:11 efforts to push a plastics treaty we have the big confab in ottawa this week thousands of delegates
00:30:17 from around the world we had the federal government on monday announce the formation of a plastics
00:30:23 registry which will be coming around 2025 i believe and we've talked about some of the details on
00:30:29 that but i think at its core we have to really go back to first principles here because what
00:30:33 the federal government has done is really designated plastic as a toxin and once you've
00:30:39 done that once you say plastic is toxic you're actually able to justify a lot which was why the
00:30:44 federal government was slapped down in the way that it was when it had that single-use plastics
00:30:49 ban the conservative party of canada now has decided to launch a campaign to bring back the
00:30:54 plastic straws which uh you know isn't we don't have the photo handy but that's an issue near and
00:30:59 dear to my heart the the plastic straw crusade by the government but let's actually talk about
00:31:03 the science here we have always been told we have to follow the science what does the science say
00:31:09 on plastics. I wanted to bring into the show Dr. Chris D'Armond. He's the president of Phantom
00:31:14 Plastics. Now, he actually is an expert on this. He's not just a guy who is in the industry and
00:31:20 represents a commercial interest. He actually knows the science in and out on this and has
00:31:25 spoken about it around the world. Chris, it's good to talk to you. Thanks so much for coming
00:31:28 on the show today. Yeah, thank you for having me on the show. I appreciate it.
00:31:31 so let's talk first and foremost about that idea of plastic being a toxin what's the argument that
00:31:39 they advanced to justify this and and why would you say they're getting it wrong or what are they
00:31:43 missing yeah that's a great point so you can't just make up things and say this is that or that's
00:31:48 the other i mean there are scientific ways of telling what's toxic and what isn't toxic
00:31:52 so when that was that accusation was made i went and looked up the science and that's the problem
00:31:57 in general people say um you know this person's for plastic against plastic we shouldn't be for
00:32:02 or against anything we should be for finding what's true right and then once we found the
00:32:07 evidence once we found what's true then we move on from there and make sensible choices and people
00:32:11 have forgotten that they're so busy taking sides no one's checking the facts so i'm looking at a
00:32:15 table right here which i've posted online which is you know the epa's definition of what's toxic
00:32:20 and what's less toxic and if we look at um plastics we like polyethylene polypropylene pet
00:32:27 and so forth we find that they're the safest things so there are four categories of toxicity
00:32:31 they're in the safest category that there is so they're as safe as things we have on our table
00:32:37 they're they're safer than table salt for example um and i'm looking at a list of there are safest
00:32:42 alcohol which we drink every day that's the category that these plastics are in they're
00:32:46 literally so safe you could eat them every day and nothing would happen to you so it's whereas
00:32:50 if you look at things like copper metal which drinking water pipes are made of they're in the
00:32:54 most toxic category so there are ways of telling what's toxic what isn't toxic there are literally
00:32:59 numbers that define how much of this you can ingest and have a problem or not have a problem
00:33:04 and plastics are simply non-toxic so for somebody to just make up in his bathtub one day this is
00:33:10 toxic and i decree it so he's not julius caesar right i mean there are actual ways and scientists
00:33:15 have been studying this for 50 years right this and it's it's all documented and available to the
00:33:19 public so it's um beyond absurd that somebody should make such a proper proclamation well and
00:33:24 i find that in this argument and certainly when you look at the policy response to it they conflate
00:33:29 two issues because you could say plastic is non-toxic but there is a pollution issue and
00:33:33 you could say we don't like plastic that's being dumped in the oceans and parts of the world but
00:33:38 but you're right that when they use the toxic label to justify policy which is what the federal
00:33:44 government in canada did it just doesn't have a basis at all so how do they argue that it is
00:33:49 when the evidence is so clear on this that it isn't that's strange i haven't looked into their
00:33:53 argument actually i haven't so i'm a scientist i said i don't think there's much there they just
00:33:57 made it up i i do know that i looked the same guy and it's so funny that they call him right
00:34:01 honorable because it appears to be any anything but honorable as far as i can tell because whenever
00:34:05 i compare what he says to what science says they're the exact opposite he tried to ban a
00:34:10 flame retardant called dbdpe and i wrote a report i was so outraged that i wrote a report and read 0.90
00:34:15 all the science on that he proposed banning one of the safest flame retardants that prevents 0.98
00:34:20 canadians from dying in their bed in flames uh based on zero evidence he had not one piece of
00:34:26 experimental evidence upon which to declare this stuff is dangerous and there is science on that
00:34:31 substance it's been thoroughly tested for years and years and years and found to be completely
00:34:35 safe it's so safe that if you eat it like not a molecule of it dissolves because it's completely
00:34:39 insoluble so they say that they're banning this flame retardant on the precautionary principle
00:34:45 which means better safe than sorry. Whereas what they're actually doing is the opposite. It's
00:34:48 better sorry than safe. You're saying, okay, I'd rather that hundreds of Canadians potentially die
00:34:52 in flames on the one hand versus zero evidence of toxicity on the other. And that's what happens
00:34:57 when you let ideology get out of control and forget to check the data. Just as a complete
00:35:03 non-scientist here, I'll ask you, are all plastics, when it comes to the toxicity question,
00:35:08 are all plastics created equally? Or is there a distinction between the plastic that's in a
00:35:12 plastic straw and the plastic that's in an industrial PVC pipe? Yeah, well, in general,
00:35:17 plastics are made of really big molecules. And so the FDA has declared them basically safe. So
00:35:22 plastics are assumed to be safe because they don't migrate around. The molecules can't move.
00:35:26 They can't go through your skin, for example. The molecules can't go through your skin. They're so
00:35:30 large. So they're considered, due to their very nature, safer than almost all chemicals. Is there
00:35:35 a plastic that's toxic? I don't know of one. I've looked at all the major thermoplastics and I don't
00:35:40 think um i can think of a toxic plastic right now that's toxic and if another question that
00:35:47 people ask is okay well maybe the plastic's not toxic but what about the additives in them
00:35:50 and that tape table i just mentioned i looked up the toxicity of the standard additives in
00:35:54 these plastics like polyethylene polypropylene and don't forget these are things fda approved
00:35:59 that you can put them in your mouth and store food in them so they've already been tested and
00:36:02 found to be safe we know what migrates out of them the additives if they come out and how much
00:36:07 but these even the additives themselves when you check their toxicity they're the same as plastics
00:36:11 they're so safe you can eat teaspoons of them and nothing happens to you might not be delicious
00:36:16 though that uh but flavor flavor is not the uh the metric here so so let's take a look at what's
00:36:22 happening in in ottawa this week we have uh the world leaders on this trying to convene to create
00:36:27 a plastic treaty and you have the federal government in canada saying we need a plastic
00:36:32 registry companies need to account for all that they're doing and creating i know you've actually
00:36:37 consulted with a lot of these companies in the past. And as I've understood it, a lot of them
00:36:41 are well aware of what they're producing and where it's going. I mean, this is just a basic part of
00:36:46 what they're doing from an industrial perspective. And I don't see why the hand of government is
00:36:50 what's needed here. Yeah. So let me give some perspective on that. My job is to be a plastic
00:36:56 scientist, and I've done it for decades, right? The thing that I'm discussing with you today is
00:37:00 not what I get paid to do. I'm not paid to be a plastic environmentalist. The reason I got into
00:37:04 this is that my own daughters were taught lies at school and that made me angry so as a hobby i read
00:37:08 four thousand scientific studies and i found that nobody's checking the facts the media aren't
00:37:13 checking the facts apart from people like you who crusade for truth like i do and the green groups
00:37:17 are making hundreds of millions of dollars from telling lies because every time you compare what
00:37:21 they say to the facts you find that they're the exact opposite as i mentioned so have you ever
00:37:26 heard that um we eat a credit card of plastics a week for example the latest scientific peer-reviewed
00:37:31 study said it would take 20 000 years to eat a credit card of plastic but guess what these green
00:37:36 groups have got that up on their websites right next to a big juicy donate now button right and
00:37:40 if you want to understand something follow the money so i'm not here to defend plastics i'm not
00:37:45 here to do anything other than take the evidence which was really tedious i didn't have these
00:37:49 reading glasses before i started reading these thousands of studies so i take the evidence and
00:37:53 present it fairly so if you look on my website or in my free book you'll see that everything
00:37:57 that i quote is cited verbatim where i literally copy and paste from the study with zero spin
00:38:01 and cite the study so you can click a link and go and check it yourself and that's where we should
00:38:05 start let's not start with pro-plastic or against plastic let's start with what's true and what
00:38:10 isn't true and um to your point probably the single most disappointing thing for me is that
00:38:17 this thing with plastics is a big distraction if you look at what's actually harming the environment
00:38:21 plastic is half a percent of the materials we use so in our obsession to talk about plastic
00:38:26 all day and all night which is half a percent of the materials we use it's the greenest option
00:38:31 in 90 percent of cases according to life cycle studies so we're obsessing over half a percent
00:38:36 of all of our materials that's almost always the least harmful option and completely ignoring the
00:38:41 99 of material which is almost always the the most harmful option so the issue isn't that
00:38:46 plastics have an impact they certainly do and there is litter but it's not just plastic that's
00:38:50 litter and it litter isn't caused by materials either it's caused by people so pretty much
00:38:55 everything is off track here we're not making any impact and we're in fact doomed to failure if we
00:39:00 keep obsessing over plastic and not talking about the 99 of problematic materials well and also a
00:39:06 lot of these objectives from the green industry tend to butt up against each other i was skimming
00:39:11 through your book uh the plastics paradox and one of the headlines you you cite is about coca-cola
00:39:17 in that coca-cola was so committed to reducing its carbon footprint they uh got rid of aluminum
00:39:23 and switch to plastic bottle collection so here you have again a company saying oh wow we have
00:39:27 to do the right thing for the environment plastic is the environmental the environmentally superior
00:39:32 alternative yes the only way to know what's more harmful and less harmful is something called a
00:39:37 life cycle analysis and that's accepted by governments and ngos and companies all around
00:39:41 the world and it's scientifically proven for 50 years and homes to become better and better
00:39:45 and it's peer-reviewed so it's hard to cheat right there are five such studies on drink containers
00:39:50 that you just mentioned and they all say that the plastic bottle causes least harm so why would you
00:39:55 ever go to metal or glass which is scientifically proven to cause vastly more harm and i'm not just
00:40:00 talking about co2 vastly more fossil fuel burned because you need a lot of energy to make to melt
00:40:05 glass and metal and more of the other things as well like eutrophication and acid rain and so
00:40:10 forth it's when you switch to an alternative you end up with more waste more and more harm in almost
00:40:15 every parameter you can measure. Yeah. And the thing is that we have to look at what we are
00:40:21 creating plastic to replace and what those alternatives are. I mean, people would love
00:40:26 to say, all right, let's take the plastic bottle away. And sure, you know, maybe we could all use
00:40:30 a reusable water bottle that somehow is better than a plastic water bottle. But for the most
00:40:36 part, I don't think it works out. And anyone who's ever had reusable grocery bags knows you
00:40:40 basically buy as many of them as you would use plastic bags because you forget them at home.
00:40:44 And I somehow I feel that it's more intensive here. But plastic is replacing something. And, you know, I'll read the list that you have here. Paper, cotton, glass and metal.
00:40:55 You have to pick one material of those. And plastic is generally the best of them.
00:41:01 If you look at 100 lifecycle studies, plastic beats those materials in every study I've seen. The only things that are consistently greener than plastic are wood and wool.
00:41:09 and unfortunately we can't run the internet based on you know based on a knitted computer and a
00:41:14 and a wooden wooden wire is coming to our house and my wool straw hasn't taken off yet i need to
00:41:20 go back and rework the prototype so yeah there are things that are greener than plastic in
00:41:25 certain applications and i say that in my book because i am genuinely just trying to be honest
00:41:29 here and show show people the facts so they can make smart choices so what we have is a bunch of
00:41:33 green groups who as dr patrick moore said and i have his book in front of me here's two of his
00:41:37 books this is a guy who was the president of greenpeace and he left in disgust and said they
00:41:41 just make up lies for donations they abandoned the environment decades ago according to him
00:41:46 and the other big green groups did the same thing they're making hundreds of millions from just
00:41:50 saying things that aren't true when you check the science and that's the problem because government's
00:41:53 listening to these people i was just in ottawa with a bunch of these people all around telling
00:41:58 you know just telling whoppers all day long and whereas the plastics people are in there
00:42:02 spending hundreds of millions of their own money losing money sometimes doing things which are the
00:42:06 right thing to do, even though they might not be profitable. It's exactly the wrong way around.
00:42:10 When we're kids, we're taught that it's the big bad industry. And then there are these crusaders
00:42:14 for truth. But this has been distorted and turned the other way around where the people that we
00:42:18 think crusade for truth are just telling us lies all the time. So let me ask you, and I fear I know
00:42:24 the answer to this, but perhaps you can set me at ease. Do governments call you up? Do politicians
00:42:29 call you up when they're putting these policies in place? Or is it done completely in the absence
00:42:34 of all this evidence you've collected over the years?
00:42:37 Yeah, so as I said, this is a hobby.
00:42:38 And for the first three years,
00:42:39 so I've done it all unpaid, not a single penny, right?
00:42:42 And in the beginning,
00:42:43 people were really like shocked at the message
00:42:45 because they had never heard,
00:42:46 they'd never seen the truth before.
00:42:47 So they were rightfully amazed.
00:42:48 And I said, well, please look,
00:42:49 because there are two sides
00:42:50 and one side has the evidence on it.
00:42:52 So now we're a few years later
00:42:53 and I'm being asked to give speeches
00:42:55 and governments are asking me.
00:42:57 So the Canadian shadow government
00:42:58 has asked me to testify and show the facts.
00:43:01 And the United Arab Emirates said,
00:43:02 hey, we don't want to make the same mistakes
00:43:03 that they made in europe and in america and canada we want to start afresh look at the evidence and
00:43:08 then make policies because you mentioned bags a second ago there was a bag ban in new jersey and
00:43:13 they looked afterwards to see what happened and what happened after the ban was just what you said
00:43:17 would happen they had vastly higher sales of plastic because these very thin plastic bags
00:43:22 had to be replaced with much thicker bags so you go and buy an actual garbage can liner which is
00:43:27 five times thicker than a transparent polyethylene grocery bag and they had what they said was
00:43:32 exponentially more greenhouse gas. And that's exactly what we would have predicted by the 30
00:43:37 studies which are published that said that that would happen. And instead, they just implement
00:43:41 these policies. And it literally takes you 10 seconds to do a Google search. You can go into
00:43:45 Google now and type in LCABAG, and you will find peer-reviewed lifecycle studies. Why has no
00:43:51 politician ever done that? Why hasn't Greenpeace or the World Wildlife Fund or Ellen MacArthur
00:43:55 Foundation in the last years and years and years ever occurred to them to do a Google search on
00:44:00 the very topic that they claim to care about. That is shocking. And that really shows what
00:44:04 their true motives are. Well, I'm glad you've made your book available for free. They have
00:44:08 no excuse to not read it. The Plastics Paradox. I dug into it this week and I hope to finish it
00:44:15 on the weekend. But Dr. Chris de Armit, thank you so much, sir. Really great to talk to you.
00:44:20 Thanks for caring about evidence. I really respect that. Cheers. Thanks. All right. I appreciate
00:44:23 your appreciation of it. Thank you, Chris. Well, since we're plugging books here, let me do this
00:44:28 one again. Pierre Polyev, A Political Life, hot off the press. It's available for pre-order at
00:44:33 Amazon, Indigo, and Sutherland House. That's it for me for today. We will be back tomorrow with
00:44:38 more of Canada's Most Irreverent Talk Show here on True North. Thank you, God bless, and good day to
00:44:43 you all. Thanks for listening to The Andrew Lawton Show. Support the program by donating to True North
00:44:49 at www.tnc.news.
00:44:58 Music
00:45:02 Music
00:45:10 Music
00:45:14 Music
00:45:20 Music
00:45:24 Music
00:45:26 Music
00:45:27 Music
00:45:28 We'll be right back.
00:45:58 We'll be right back.