Juno News - September 18, 2019


Justin Trudeau’s assault on Canadian border security

Mentioned
Trudeau is the radical when it comes to immigration Trudeau, blackface, and political hypocrisy

Episode Stats


Length

20 minutes

Words per minute

208.36

Word count

4,265

Sentence count

212

Harmful content

Misogyny

1

sentences flagged

Toxicity

2

sentences flagged

Hate speech

17

sentences flagged


Summary

Summaries generated with gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ .

Candice Malcom joins me to talk about her new book, No Border: Justin Trudeau's Assault on Canadian Border Security, and why it's so important to remember that immigration is a political issue in the election.

Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 We're going very meta today. The True North Senior Fellow and Founder Candice Malcom joins
00:00:14 me on True North to talk about her new book, No Border, Justin Trudeau's Assault on Canadian
00:00:20 Border Security. Candice Malcom, my friend and colleague, joins me. Candice, thanks for coming
00:00:25 on and congrats on the new book. Thank you so much, Andrew. It's great. I don't think we've
00:00:29 done one of these videos in a while, so it's good to catch up and chat a little bit here.
00:00:33 For sure. And obviously, the timing of this is not coincidental with the election coming
00:00:38 up in just a few short weeks, I'd presume, which really lends me to ask you here, what
00:00:43 is the real point of this book? Is it to say that immigration is an issue and this is why
00:00:49 it's important? Or is it really trying to make immigration a political issue for the election?
00:00:54 Well, Andrew, I think immigration is already one of the top issues of this election. I
00:00:59 think that you can't deny, after having four years of Trudeau's disastrous policies, seeing
00:01:04 50,000 people illegally come into our country every year to claim asylum and clog up our refugee 1.00
00:01:10 system, Trudeau's handling of immigration has just been awful since day one. So my last book
00:01:16 called Losing True North, I wrote it almost immediately after Justin Trudeau got elected. He got elected in the fall of
00:01:23 2015, really on the back of a pledge that he made that was in relation to the Syrian refugee
00:01:29 crisis that was spilling into Europe. He kind of captured that moment, appeared to be the most
00:01:33 sympathetic, the most, you know, big hearted when it came to welcoming Syrian refugees. He made the 0.89
00:01:38 biggest pledge. And, you know, it didn't really matter what the facts were on the ground. It didn't
00:01:43 matter that Canada had no capacity to welcome the number of people that he wanted to welcome. It
00:01:48 didn't matter that Trudeau himself had a very naive view when it came to the threat of ISIS and
00:01:52 Islamist terrorism and how that was welcomed into Europe alongside the Syrian mass immigration. So 0.81
00:01:59 Trudeau made this big promise. He captured the hearts and imagination of so many Canadians. I think
00:02:03 that was really an important aspect of why he got elected in the first place. And then one of the
00:02:07 government's very first moves once they became government was a bill called Bill C6, which
00:02:12 drastically changed the way that someone becomes a Canadian citizenship. So they made it a lot easier.
00:02:18 They scrapped the language requirement for anyone over the age of 54. They made it so that you could
00:02:22 become a citizen in just three years of only living in Canada part-time. And then, of course,
00:02:28 they made it so that convicted ISIS and Islamist terrorists, convicted al-Qaeda terrorists could
00:02:33 become Canadian citizens. Because as Trudeau famously said, he said, a Canadian is a Canadian is a Canadian,
00:02:37 you know, even if you're a convicted ISIS terrorist who hates Canada, essentially. So Trudeau
00:02:43 dismantled our citizenship program. And I put that book out in early 2016. It was really successful.
00:02:49 I think Canadians really cared about what was happening to our country, to our immigration
00:02:53 system. And so, you know, that book came out. And I really just felt that over the last three years,
00:02:58 the things that Trudeau did in his first couple of months was just the tip of the iceberg. There
00:03:03 was so much more. There's so much more happening. And it has happened over the last few years. So I felt
00:03:07 like it was really important to do a recap and to go through some of those disastrous policies,
00:03:11 which we can get to one by one if you want here. But just to kind of do an overview and to say,
00:03:17 hey, this is what Trudeau has done over the last four years to remind Canadians that the stakes are
00:03:21 really high, that when you're the prime minister of this country, you have the huge ability to remake
00:03:25 the country, to change the country. And immigration is one of the ways you can do that, one of the most 0.99
00:03:29 dangerous ways that an irresponsible government can destroy a country. You and I, I remember,
00:03:35 talked on my old radio show when that previous book came out. And I recall, I mean, first off,
00:03:41 it was a great book, but it had a lot of predictions in it. And looking back on it,
00:03:45 did you really, when writing this one, go back and remind yourself of, yep, that happened,
00:03:50 that happened, that happened? Because I found myself doing that when I was reading this book
00:03:56 that's just come out, looking back, and a lot of the things that you warned of have come to pass or
00:04:01 are in development right now. Yeah, I mean, one of the things that I do, Andrew,
00:04:05 just on a regular basis is go through polling data. And it's really interesting,
00:04:09 because in the 90s and the early 2000s, Canada was different from other kind of Western countries,
00:04:14 different from the United States, Australia, the UK, in that most Canadians accept immigration,
00:04:19 there hadn't really been kind of a movement in Canadian society of kind of anti-immigration or
00:04:26 anti-migration, people that were really skeptical. Overwhelming majorities, like 60,
00:04:30 65, 70% of Canadians welcomed immigration and thought that immigration was good for the country.
00:04:35 And in time, you can compare that to, you know, the United States that had a much,
00:04:38 much lower consensus, like 30% of people thought that immigration was good. In Australia and the UK,
00:04:43 it was like 50%. And you can see polling over time has just completely flipped. And now Canada is in
00:04:48 the exact same situation as these other Western countries, in that Canadians, by and large,
00:04:53 don't really want more immigration. And, you know, what has changed, what has happened, is that Canadians 1.00
00:04:59 trust immigration, they know that, you know, we're a small population country, we're kind of off in a 0.99
00:05:03 corner away from a lot of the rest of the world. And, you know, we need people, we need people to
00:05:08 come and help grow our economy, to help populate some of our northern cities, and to continue the
00:05:13 kind of growth that we have. But Canadians only support immigration when it's done legally, when
00:05:18 it's done in accordance with the rule of law, when people come in good faith, and when people really
00:05:22 want to make a change in their life, they don't just want to come to Canada to live off the system,
00:05:26 to enjoy a free ride, to, you know, get some of the benefits. If you want to come and become Canadian,
00:05:32 you have to work hard, you have to come by the rules, come by the book, do it legally, and then
00:05:36 join the Canadian family, learn English, commit yourself to becoming Canadian, and really, you
00:05:41 know, getting that Canadian identity. And a lot of the newcomers that are coming today, they just,
00:05:46 they're not interested in that. They're kind of Canadians of convenience, they come because of
00:05:50 the passport. We've seen a huge rise in things like birth tourism, where people just show up in
00:05:56 Canada when they're like seven and a half or eight months pregnant, they have a baby, and then they
00:06:00 leave. There was one hospital in Richmond, British Columbia that said about a fifth of all babies
00:06:04 were born to foreigners who had no connection, no ties to Canada. So this is kind of like a 0.90
00:06:09 microcosm of what is happening. And Canadians are very skeptical of that. We want people to come to
00:06:14 our country that love Canada, that want to contribute and add to the Canadian story. And, you know, it's not
00:06:21 that Canadians are closed minded, or they're not open to having people from different cultures, and,
00:06:25 you know, that look different or whatever. Canadians are open to that. They just don't like it when
00:06:31 people do things that are illegal, that don't actually contribute to Canadian society. And I
00:06:36 think Trudeau is kind of ignorant of that. He's, he's playing with fire. He loves the idea of being 0.99
00:06:42 this open, welcoming, loving guy who shows up at the airport to welcome people. But he's not as concerned
00:06:47 with the day to day nitty gritty of what it's like, it's really hard to move to a new country and to adapt to a new
00:06:53 society. And, you know, you need to provide the support, you need to make sure that you're not
00:06:59 letting in so many people that they don't have a chance to adapt. Because if given the choice,
00:07:03 they can just find a little enclave where, you know, they can be around people who look and speak
00:07:08 exactly like them, that's going to be a lot easier than getting dropped into, you know, like the middle
00:07:13 of Saskatchewan and no one understands your culture, no one speaks your language. And that's going to be a lot
00:07:18 harder in the long run. It's better for everyone if you do adapt to the Canadian society. But in the
00:07:23 short run, and you know, what's easier is people just finding their own ethnic community and staying 0.89
00:07:28 isolated. And I think that's what Trudeau fundamentally doesn't understand. And that's why so many of my
00:07:34 predictions from my first book are coming true, Andrew, is because, you know, the writing is on
00:07:38 the wall. And when you have this ignorant approach that just says, hey, everyone should come to Canada
00:07:42 and, you know, everything will work out. It's like, no, no, it's not going to work out. You have to 0.73
00:07:47 actually do the hard work, put in the hard work, both on the government side and, you know, on behalf of
00:07:52 newcomers who are coming to our country. One thing that has really become apparent to me, 1.00
00:07:57 and I'm sure you've seen this as well, is that the more significant of an issue immigration has
00:08:02 gotten in Canada, it's similarly become more and more difficult to have an honest discussion. And
00:08:07 certainly the media is shying away from it. And I wanted to have you expand on that thought if you
00:08:13 could, because one of the big problems, and we've seen this from, you know, the immigration minister
00:08:17 calling people that criticize the government's immigration record on Canadian. We've seen it from 1.00
00:08:22 the prime minister insulting some woman in Quebec who asked a question about immigration. And this is
00:08:28 something that's happening with more and more frequency. How do you think we can break through
00:08:33 that? Because we've been given more and more examples of why it's important to talk about this,
00:08:37 but there seems to be more and more of a resistance to talking about it.
00:08:41 Yeah, it's almost becoming like a joke, like a farce. Like, you know, if someone disagrees with
00:08:47 you, you just call them racist. And that's like, that's how a liberal thinks they win an argument.
00:08:51 I mean, the idea, again, is that this is the reason why Canadians are becoming more and more 0.99
00:08:56 skeptical, is the approach of people mostly on the political left. It's that if you question this
00:09:01 idea, if you are critical, you know, not of the fact that there are different people from
00:09:06 different ethnic backgrounds coming to Canada. I don't think that that's the problem that a lot of
00:09:10 Canadians have. I think the problem a lot of Canadians have is the cultural fit, whether
00:09:14 people are actually going to follow our rule of law. And, you know, I think that the Trudeau
00:09:19 government was faced with a dilemma. They realized that Canadians were very unhappy. The majority of
00:09:24 Canadians were calling the illegal border crisis a crisis, whereas the immigration minister and the
00:09:29 prime minister were denying that it was a crisis and basically saying anyone who was talking about it
00:09:33 was just irresponsible and they were fear mongering. So you have a crisis of illegal immigration.
00:09:38 You can either deal with that, deal with the policy and go and kind of like lay down the
00:09:42 law and be tough. But that would threaten Trudeau's whole image. So instead of actually addressing
00:09:48 the crisis, they tried to address the public relations, the perception of a crisis. And they
00:09:53 did that by basically promoting that anyone who talks about this is just a hateful, bigoted person
00:09:59 who hates immigration and they are not welcome in the public sphere. They're not welcome to be part of 0.99
00:10:04 the conversation. And fortunately for the Trudeau liberals, the media were all too happy to comply
00:10:10 with this. It's really interesting, Andrew, as part of my research in my book, I was going back and
00:10:14 looking at immigration data all the way back. I was also looking at immigration news coverage dating
00:10:19 back decades. And, you know, there was a consensus among journalists. They would call what was happening
00:10:25 illegal immigration. I have a story from 2005 open on my laptop from the Toronto Star that they were
00:10:31 talking about how there were 45,000 illegal immigrants who had just disappeared into Canadian
00:10:36 society. And they were writing about the phenomenon. You know, you would never see a story like that
00:10:40 in the Toronto Star today because they no longer, first of all, they no longer use the term illegal
00:10:44 immigration. As soon as the Trudeau government started using the term irregular immigration, which
00:10:48 has never been used in the past in Canadian language, the way that Canadians talked about immigration,
00:10:54 as soon as they changed to irregular immigration, all the news media fell in line and started doing the exact
00:10:59 same thing. The news media started to basically tell every story as if the people who were coming
00:11:05 were sympathetic and that Canada had to help them, even if they were bad people, even if they were,
00:11:10 you know, drug dealers or gang members. The news media would still paint them as if they were the
00:11:14 victim and somehow it was Canada's responsibility to help these people. And, you know, Trudeau really
00:11:19 just put pressure on media and made Canadians feel like they really couldn't have this conversation.
00:11:25 Because the worst thing that you can be called in our society today is racist. No one wants to be called
00:11:30 racist. And most of the people who are worried about Canadian border security are not racist people,
00:11:35 but they would shy away from the conversation just because they don't want to be labeled with that
00:11:39 really, really disgusting term that, you know, makes you feel like you have no place in the conversation.
00:11:46 To that point, people on the right tend to have, in a lot of ways, internalized this. And one example
00:11:52 you mentioned earlier, birth tourism, when the Conservative Party of Canada's members
00:11:56 at their convention, I think it was last summer, almost a year ago, were discussing a motion on
00:12:02 birthright citizenship and whether to put an end to it. This is something that was not a radical
00:12:08 concept. Canada is one of just a small handful of developed countries that has birthright citizenship,
00:12:13 but even that was really kiboshed by the Conservative leadership. And do you think that this is
00:12:19 something that the right needs to do a better job at pushing back on? Or do you think it is about
00:12:26 choosing your battles because of that media climate we've just been talking about?
00:12:29 Well, look, I think that when you're talking about these issues, you do have to be careful,
00:12:33 you have to be sensitive. And a lot of people will interpret what you're saying as being kind of
00:12:38 like hateful or exclusive of other people. So you have to be careful in your language. I don't think,
00:12:45 I think that there's a lot of examples of people just kind of being brash or mean-spirited or rude
00:12:50 in the way they talk about immigration. And you have to be careful for sure. But that said,
00:12:54 I think in so many cases, the Conservative Party of Canada, the like conservative establishment,
00:13:01 is afraid of their own shadow. They don't want to rock the boat. They saw how Kelly Leach was treated.
00:13:05 You remember Kelly Leach ran for leader of the Conservative Party. She had a couple of ideas that were
00:13:10 pretty strong. Maybe she didn't communicate them in the best way. But the media just completely
00:13:15 demonized her. They turned her into like a Trump figure. And they pretty much ruined her career 0.99
00:13:20 in politics. And I think that a lot of Conservatives saw that and just didn't want anything to do with
00:13:25 it. They didn't want to touch any of those issues. You saw, you know, just on this campaign trail,
00:13:31 Andrew Scheer was asked about a values test for immigrants. And he really quickly shied away from
00:13:35 the Liberal government and said that he wouldn't do that. But that, you know, he thinks that integration
00:13:39 is important. So I think that, you know, in so many ways, the Liberal government has been successful
00:13:45 in creating this climate of like fear around immigration. But what hasn't changed is the fact
00:13:50 that most Canadians still don't want more and more immigration. Only 6% of Canadians, according to a poll
00:13:55 last summer, wanted more immigration. And then at the same time, the trio government was rapidly increasing
00:14:02 the immigration numbers, annual immigration intake to the highest levels in recent history. So,
00:14:08 you know, in some ways, it's like the Liberals are successful in creating this climate where you
00:14:12 can't talk about it. And then the Conservatives just don't really know what to do. They don't want
00:14:16 to be seen as being racist or offensive. But then at the same time, they haven't really created a
00:14:21 different approach or a different vision of Canada from the Liberals. So we're kind of stuck
00:14:26 without a lot of leadership. I guess that's why you have Maxine Bernier and his party that is willing to
00:14:31 talk about this. And as you see, they're written off and most of the media absolutely despise them
00:14:37 or think that they are actually just a bunch of bigots. And, you know, that's what that's what
00:14:41 you get for talking about immigration. So again, I think that's why elections are really important.
00:14:46 And the more that we have Liberals have found, the more that we have these people that
00:14:50 a take it take Canadian advantages for granted. And that's why they are willing to, you know, slash our
00:14:56 immigration citizenship requirements and then also open the border and not do anything to defend the
00:15:00 border and to defend our legal immigration system and the integrity of it. But then at the same time,
00:15:05 really create this climate of fear where you can't talk about these issues, you can't criticize them,
00:15:09 or you'll be disregarded and successful. And that's why it's so dangerous, Andrew.
00:15:15 When you talk about prescriptions that you'd like to see adopted, when we look at what Trudeau is doing,
00:15:22 I think we all can agree much of it needs to stop the Safe Third Country Act, Roxham Road, all of these issues.
00:15:27 But what's worse is that the government has continuously said it's fixing these issues.
00:15:32 And you talk about this in your book specifically with Ahmed Hassen going over to, I think it was Nigeria,
00:15:38 and not really coming back with any sort of clear record of what he did over there that was supposed
00:15:43 to help with the illegal border crossings, or Emmanuel Dubourg speaking to the Haitian community,
00:15:48 same sort of thing. So the government has said that it's dealt with this. Are the data showing that?
00:15:53 No, I mean, that's the interesting thing is that the number of illegal border crossings has stayed the
00:15:59 same. Canada is on track in 2019 to have more asylum seekers than any of the previous year. You know,
00:16:05 2017 broke the record and doubled the previous year for a number of asylum seekers. And then 2018 was
00:16:11 even higher, so a new record. And now 2019 is on track to set a new record once again. So the numbers
00:16:17 are continuing to grow. The Trudeau government like to create the appearance that they're doing something,
00:16:21 but the numbers show something totally different. And you wouldn't really know it as a Canadian unless
00:16:26 you were, you know, someone who was really, really interested in this and spending time
00:16:30 on the immigration and, you know, data websites and pulling up all the statistics because you don't
00:16:36 see it reflected in the media. They stopped talking about it. So you would assume the problem has been
00:16:40 solved, but it hasn't. There's just so many, you know, people from around the world that are still
00:16:45 hearing about this idea that you can go to Canada, you can just walk across the border, or you can
00:16:51 come up with some kind of a scheme to get to a Canadian airport using false documentation,
00:16:55 claim that you're a refugee, just stick your hands in the air, say refugee, and you're guaranteed all 0.95
00:16:59 the same legal protections as a Canadian, even if you have no claim, even if your claim is completely
00:17:03 bogus, you can do that. And you're guaranteed right now the wait time to see an immigration 0.95
00:17:07 judge is about five years. It's about five years. So you get five years where you get, you know,
00:17:12 unlimited handouts, benefits, the exact same stuff as a Canadian who is on welfare, 0.82
00:17:17 plus even more because there's other programs like the interim federal health program, which gives
00:17:22 these people, these migrants, free dental care and different kind of drug plans that Canadians 0.99
00:17:28 don't even get or have to pay out of pocket. It really is, I mean, for someone coming from a poor
00:17:33 country, that's like a huge boost in their standard of living, even if you're eventually found not to be
00:17:39 a real refugee. Canada is basically non-existent at this point. So you have tens of thousands of
00:17:48 people who have been rejected or their claim is a bit abandoned, and they're still living in Canada
00:17:52 and, you know, not there legally, they're there illegally. But this is able to carry on. And
00:17:58 Andrew, it's not like the solution would be that big. You know, we have laws on the books that could
00:18:02 deal with this stuff. We have lots of laws on the books. It's just that Trudeau is choosing not to
00:18:07 follow those rules. He's really ignoring them. And the protections that we have that are built into the
00:18:12 system, he's kind of quietly undoing them, and making it even easier for people to take advantage of
00:18:17 our generosity. Do you think it would be enough to just return to that Harper and Kenny era of
00:18:24 immigration? Or do you think that the challenges have gotten to a point where we really need a
00:18:28 a new or at the very least renewed approach to immigration? Well, I think that Harper and Kenny
00:18:34 inherited like a real mess in immigration. They spent years trying to fix it. I was there for a short period
00:18:40 working for Kenny in the immigration department. I was there for about a year and a half,
00:18:44 and I saw kind of the mess that we had. And there's just so many people that take advantage of
00:18:48 Canada's generosity. And the Canadian government knows it. The bureaucrats working in the immigration
00:18:52 department, you know, they're not naive. A lot of them have worked overseas in consulate offices,
00:18:56 and they understand, you know, just how valuable a Canadian passport can be and how many people
00:19:01 are willing to kind of cheat and steal to get one. But the problem I see now is that we just had so
00:19:07 many years of mass sustained immigration where people are coming into Canada and they're not really
00:19:12 integrating. You know, a lot of people are integrating, a lot of people are not. And so I
00:19:16 think it's actually time that we take a pause where we just sort of, you know, slow down the immigration 1.00
00:19:22 intake, maybe keep it to like essential economic immigrants, people coming specifically with a job
00:19:28 at a visa. And then, you know, slow down for a year or two, don't take as many people and make sure,
00:19:33 focus on the people who are already in our country, on the people who are already Canadians,
00:19:37 make sure that they are welcomed and that they are, you know, learning English and integrating
00:19:42 and joining the Canadian family. And then, you know, maybe in a couple of years, we can open the
00:19:45 borders back up and allow more people to come in legally with a focus on the legal side of it.
00:19:51 But, you know, I think that we've had so many years now of just kind of mass migration, open borders,
00:19:56 no regard for integration whatsoever, that there's a lot of people in our country that we should be
00:20:01 concerned about. And we should make sure that they are part of the Canadian family before we focus on,
00:20:06 hey, let's let another million people in, or let's let another two million people in,
00:20:09 which is the current plan. The book is No Border, Justin Trudeau's Assault on Canadian Border Security.
00:20:16 The author, True North founder and fellow Candice Malcolm. Candice, thanks for the time. And again,
00:20:21 congrats on the new book. All right. Thank you so much, Andrew.