Juno News - November 25, 2022


Katie Telford and Senior PMO Officials Testify | Emergencies Act Inquiry

Topics
Mentioned
Chrystia Freeland Testifies | Emergencies Act Inquiry The winners and losers of the pandemic

Episode Stats


Length

4 hours and 15 minutes

Words per minute

135.79

Word count

34,709

Sentence count

748

Harmful content

Misogyny

1

sentences flagged

Hate speech

3

sentences flagged


Summary

Summaries generated with gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ .

In this episode, the Prime Minister's Office interviews three witnesses from the PM's Office about their work in relation to the investigation into the handling of a religious document and a religious communication. The witnesses are: John Broadhead, Katie Telford and Brian Clow.

Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Topics generated with Qwen2.5-3B-Instruct.
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 Thank you.
00:00:30 Thank you.
00:01:00 Thank you.
00:01:30 Thank you.
00:02:00 I overdone that.
00:02:23 Order alert?
00:02:28 the commissioners we can win the commissary plan
00:02:49 okay good afternoon mr commissioner shantona showed you for the record
00:02:53 our next witnesses are from the prime minister's office
00:02:56 mr john broadhead miss katie telford mr brian clow
00:03:03 mr clow will you swear on a religious document or do you wish to affirm
00:03:08 i will affirm for the record please state your full name and spell it out
00:03:13 first name brian b-r-i-a-n last name clow c-l-o-w do you solemnly affirm that the evidence to be
00:03:21 given by you to this commission shall be the truth the whole truth and nothing but the truth i do
00:03:26 Thank you. Ms. Telford, will you swear on a religious document or do you wish to affirm?
00:03:32 A religious document.
00:03:33 We have the Bible, the Koran, or the Torah available? 0.53
00:03:35 Bible. 0.91
00:03:44 Stand.
00:03:46 Does it stand?
00:03:52 For the record, please state your full name and spell it out.
00:03:54 katherine telford k-a-t-h-e-r-i-n-e telford t-e-l-f-o-r-d do you swear that the evidence
00:04:03 to be given by you to this commission shall be the truth the whole truth and nothing but
00:04:07 the truth so help you god i do thank you mr broadhead will you swear on a religious document
00:04:14 or do you wish to affirm affirm please for the record please state your full name and spell it
00:04:19 out john broadhead j-o-h-n-b-r-o-d-h-e-a-d do you solemnly affirm that the evidence to be given
00:04:26 by you to this commission shall be the truth the whole truth and nothing but the truth i do thank
00:04:31 you
00:04:44 good afternoon thank you for being here um we're just going to start with a couple of routine
00:04:48 housekeeping items uh the first of which is introducing your interview summary so you'll
00:04:53 recall having sat for an interview with commission council on october 11th of this year and following
00:04:58 that interview commission council prepared a summary of the interview have you all three
00:05:03 reviewed that summary yes sorry just for the record i know it's a bit difficult with the three
00:05:08 of you but uh someone answer yes please yes okay and uh also present at that interview was your
00:05:14 colleague mr jeremy broadhurst yes can you confirm that mr broadhurst as well as reviewed that the
00:05:20 the summary of the interview yes and that it is accurate according to all all four of you
00:05:25 yes perfect um so mr clerk for the record that's wts6083 no need to call it up
00:05:34 and then the second small order of business is the pmo institutional report so the prime minister's
00:05:40 office prepared an institutional report for these proceedings um that the doc id number of that is
00:05:46 doj ir six zeros uh 14 and i just like you to confirm again that that report was prepared by
00:05:53 pco and that you have reviewed it and that is it is accurate to the best of your knowledge and belief
00:05:59 yes thank you okay um so the first thing i'll say is this is one of the the examinations that we're
00:06:05 doing as a panel there are three of you and some of my questions will be directed at one of you
00:06:10 specifically because it's something that's within your personal knowledge or a document or a
00:06:15 communication that you were involved in and some of them i will throw out more generally and the
00:06:20 person best place can answer and you can also feel free if it's appropriate and you have knowledge
00:06:26 to add to someone's someone else's answer you're you're free to do that um so the first question i
00:06:32 I think I'll address to Ms. Telford, which is just can you explain the mandate and the
00:06:37 structure at a very sort of general level of the Prime Minister's office?
00:06:41 What does the Prime Minister's office do?
00:06:44 The Prime Minister's office, we serve at the pleasure of the Prime Minister, which is different
00:06:50 than our public service colleagues in the sense that job security is a little different.
00:06:57 work between between elections as well and many of us though not all of us do take leaves during
00:07:04 election campaigns to work on election campaigns um but in between elections and working in
00:07:10 government our role is to facilitate information to the prime minister to facilitate his ability
00:07:17 to make the best decisions he can to advance the agenda that he was elected on by the canadians
00:07:24 So that includes everything from very operational work. So we have teams of tour advanced people,
00:07:31 as we call them. We have regional desks who coordinate with stakeholders, including different
00:07:36 levels of government in different parts of the country. I'm sure my colleagues can speak to
00:07:42 John is our director of policy and can speak to the policy team. Brian Clow is one of two
00:07:49 deputy chiefs of staff in the prime minister's office. The other deputy chief of staff is
00:07:53 marjorie michelle and um the other chief of staff uh since she's not here is primarily responsible
00:08:00 for a lot of the operational elements of the office ranging from human resources because we
00:08:04 are an office of uh roughly a hundred and um so the human resources side the public appointments
00:08:11 as well there's hundreds and thousands of public appointments that go through government and so
00:08:15 we act as a coordinating body in many ways on the political side between ministers offices as well
00:08:22 and but our primary job is getting the prime minister the information that he needs getting
00:08:27 him the best advice from all parts of government but also from outside of government that he needs
00:08:32 to be able to accomplish what he committed to canadians he would do if he were elected
00:08:39 and just building on that i'll ask you to explain this telford your specific role as chief of staff
00:08:43 and then i'll ask each of your colleagues to do the same so i view my role um in two ways
00:08:50 there's the day-to-day management role um so i manage uh the the um the prime minister's office
00:08:57 and uh of ex of an extraordinary group of people who work day and night particularly during this
00:09:02 time period they did and um so it's all these sort of operational scheduling um and day-to-day
00:09:11 management you can imagine of running an office of that size as well as coordinating between
00:09:16 other ministers offices as well so we have a weekly chief of staff meeting that involves the
00:09:21 chiefs of staff from all of the ministers offices across government as a way of touching base and
00:09:26 and sharing information sometimes best practices and then the other the other hat i wear at the
00:09:32 same time is being a senior advisor to the prime minister and in terms of bringing him the best
00:09:38 advice i can from everywhere i can but also facilitating other people being able to get
00:09:44 in front of him and provide him with all the advice and the inputs that he needs to make the
00:09:48 best decisions he can for canadians thank you and mr broadhead can you explain your role please
00:09:54 sure so as as director of policy um one of the the key pieces of my role is is to kind of work with
00:10:01 peace the privy council office very closely to coordinate the cabinet agenda so as you've heard
00:10:05 through these proceedings there's that we have many cabinet committees um and so we work with pco
00:10:11 to make sure um items are ready to go forward and there's agendas um any any kind of um remaining
00:10:20 issues to be sorted out between ministers or departments uh so that's that's one uh we have
00:10:26 a team of uh of 14 uh policy advisors so they cover um the all all the departments so they each
00:10:34 have policy files so they become um you know the links to the minister's offices as well as to the
00:10:39 content experts at pco and other departments and i think in that role we we provide advice
00:10:46 to the prime minister on on policy items so whether it's items going to cabinet uh other
00:10:52 items such as the budget um our team will often prepare memos along those lines and advise the
00:10:59 prime minister on the policy side of these things okay and we're going to come back in a minute to
00:11:04 you mentioned pco and we've heard from a few witnesses uh last week from pco um so we're
00:11:09 going to come back to the interplay a little bit between your office and pco but first i'll just
00:11:13 ask mr cloud to introduce himself and describe his role so i am one of two deputy chiefs of staff as
00:11:18 katie laid out and i oversee five teams in the office one is the policy team which john described
00:11:25 second is communications team it's it's the largest of the five they do exactly what what
00:11:30 their name says press releases all government communications media relations for sure
00:11:36 quite a range of activities in that department there's third is the issues management and
00:11:41 parliamentary affairs team that's one unit so everything that goes through parliament whether
00:11:45 it's legislation votes in the house debates in the house the the pmo parliamentary affairs team
00:11:51 engages in that space but they they also focus on issues management which i like to think of it as
00:11:58 the government has its proactive agenda which is largely driven out of the policy team
00:12:03 and then the issues management team days deals with day-to-day developments what whatever comes
00:12:08 at us and so certainly the issues management team was involved in in what's being studied
00:12:12 here quite early on and then there are two more units that i oversee their smaller units one is
00:12:17 a global affairs team they focus on all any number of international files and finally there's a unit
00:12:23 that was created a couple of years ago to deal with the response to the COVID-19 pandemic.
00:12:30 Thank you. And I should mention that the reason you've all been selected to be here today is
00:12:35 you were all involved in some way in assisting the Prime Minister in responding to the events
00:12:41 of late January and February that are before the Commission. Certainly not just you, but certainly
00:12:46 all of you. So just going back to that question of the interplay between PCO and PMO, I'm not
00:12:53 sure who's best place to speak to that between the three of you um but mr broadhead you brought
00:12:58 it up so maybe we'll start with you so what specifically what is of interest the general
00:13:05 relationship so that the lines of communication and the interaction between the public service
00:13:10 and the political side and advising the prime minister sure so i'll speak to my experience
00:13:15 because i i obviously cover one one part of that uh dynamic and um i interact with primarily two
00:13:22 parts of privy council office one is um the kind of uh priorities and planning uh group which is
00:13:28 michael vandergrift's group and then the other one is the operations team which is now run by
00:13:33 kaylee lebeck plans and priorities is really the the cabinet side and operations is more the the
00:13:40 execution and uh of of that so there is i would say a constant um flow of information back and
00:13:47 forth um they they provide us advice they convene meetings of departments across the government
00:13:55 um they um they really kind of hold the institutional knowledge on many of these
00:14:01 files and so we kind of work very closely together to to ensure we're aligned on the on the policy
00:14:07 agenda um that things are rolling out um they also have great experience in terms of execution of
00:14:13 policy so it's are things getting done are things happening that we brought into play are they still
00:14:19 going is it still moving uh so it's a it's a very constant uh and a very important relationship for
00:14:25 us mr alford do you have anything to add to that in terms of the lines of communication and in
00:14:30 providing advice to the prime minister i would just add that um and i'm sure you heard this from
00:14:35 the clerk uh who is who i have primarily the most contact with is with the clerk and the national
00:14:40 security and intelligence advisor and to only a slightly lesser degree the deputy clerk and
00:14:45 they're also the ones who have the most contact um with the prime minister and so the clerk meets
00:14:52 with the prime minister on a very regular basis um often meets with the prime minister and deputy
00:14:56 prime minister together and i will attend the majority of those meetings as well um and there
00:15:02 is and then and then she and i will talk regularly in between those meetings as well in terms of
00:15:07 planning out you know what needs to get covered and what's going on and prioritizing who else we
00:15:13 might need in those meetings and so as john said it's a it's a very um regular flow of information
00:15:19 back and forth but and that's true for the entire prime minister's office everybody has counterparts
00:15:23 of one kind or another on the public service side and um the flow of information is uh is
00:15:31 significant um though we do have clearly different roles um in terms of uh what our
00:15:37 responsibilities are to the prime minister and uh and of course as i said earlier how we're how
00:15:42 we're employed thank you okay um that introduction uh out of the way we'll turn to the the matters
00:15:49 before the commission um and starting with the very early days of the convoy can you describe to
00:15:57 to us when pmo first became aware that the convoy was a thing that was possibly rolling into ottawa
00:16:04 what your initial uh impressions of it were what your sources of information were and the sort of
00:16:10 pre-arrival early days so the week of january 17th there were a few interactions um on monday january
00:16:19 17th there was a report sent from pco to pmo i think one or two people in in the prime minister's
00:16:26 office it might have actually come from a minister's office as a flag that there was some
00:16:30 slow roll activity in emerson manitoba at that point though that information was not shared
00:16:36 beyond that it was just one of any number of of issues as the week went on though we started to
00:16:41 hear more and see more reports of the convoy protest on thursday january 20th there was an
00:16:49 email that came from pco to a number of people in pmo that laid out it was an update on the convoy
00:16:55 protest i think it was focused on it named three places specifically coots north portal saskatchewan
00:17:02 and ottawa and the update also included a press release from the canadian trucking alliance which
00:17:09 condemned the convoy activity um specifically proposed unlawful activity which even at that
00:17:15 point there what was coming out of the a number of the speakers was proposed unlawful activity
00:17:22 and road blockages specifically so it was that week january 17th when we started to hear about
00:17:28 this that weekend uh i'd say 22nd 23rd by then it was on everybody's radar the week of the 24th is
00:17:39 when the prime minister started to get updated daily on it okay um and that takes us mr clare
00:17:45 can you please bring up ssm.can.nsc402578 so mr clove if i take this correctly you were speaking
00:17:54 at that point of of pmos sort of monitoring of what was going on and i believe the 25th was the
00:18:00 first time uh you got a briefing from the pco so that the in addition to i'll look at this email
00:18:08 so there was email traffic and there there would have been phone calls the week of the 17th
00:18:18 between pco and pmo but tuesday the 25th i do believe was the first meeting scheduled
00:18:25 with pco and pmo staff to to go through all of the elements as were known at that point
00:18:30 okay so we're just going to look at what the content of that meeting was mr clerk if you can
00:18:35 scroll down keep scrolling okay there we go so this is mike mcdonald and we know can you actually
00:18:42 just refresh our memories as to who mike mcdonald is so he works in pco and he's part of the national
00:18:49 national security team that's right intelligence secretariat okay so mike mcdonald is explaining
00:18:54 and and briefing essentially on what the the state of knowledge there is at the time so he says uh
00:19:00 latest lay of the land security coordination national security apparatus what do we know
00:19:06 law enforcement across the country is learning more about the convoy and its organizers as they
00:19:12 interact with them and then there's some description of where it's coming from
00:19:17 the next bullet down says actively monitoring one thing they're picking up on is chatter on social
00:19:22 media so far rcmp telling us that the convoy itself is peaceful not causing problems along the
00:19:29 way their goal is to get to ottawa not have infractions along the way and then very small
00:19:35 online chatter that's where people are using disturbing language mr clerk if you can just
00:19:41 keep scrolling to the next page please there we go um following january 6 events last year which is
00:19:49 a reference to january 6 in capitol hill in the united states nsia worked with pps rcmp and
00:19:56 sergeant at arms for a scenario planning for regular protests push boundaries and plan out
00:20:02 for things like an insurrection this has been done then uh ottawa police and pps have an mou
00:20:10 have done exercises for these types of protests on the federal side we have governance in place
00:20:16 that is up and running adm national security operations center meeting every day to ensure
00:20:21 parts of the federal family are coordinated in efforts and can feed information through so
00:20:28 does that represent essentially first of all that the content of that briefing as as you were aware
00:20:33 of it that day so i wasn't a part of this specific brief but received this email and so i have no
00:20:40 reason to believe it doesn't represent what was discussed there but i would say it it's only a
00:20:45 piece of the picture of what we were watching at that time there's a reference in there to social
00:20:50 media chatter and disturbing comments and by this point it was a very significant issue and getting
00:20:57 a lot of coverage in media some of those comments this this email was sent on january 25th which is
00:21:02 the same day it was reported in media that some individuals who were planning to participate in
00:21:07 the demonstration were saying they wanted this to be there january 6th that's why you see i suspect
00:21:13 you see this in this email summary because there were individuals explicitly referencing january
00:21:20 6th and at this point as well it was known in public that some people planning to participate
00:21:25 in the demonstration had a proposal to replace the government by going to the governor general
00:21:31 and the senate and it was it's otherwise known as the mou okay um so just scrolling down a bit
00:21:37 again mr clerk there's a comment at the end there so you'll see at the end it says questions question
00:21:42 mark zed and i believe that's a reference to zeta astrovis phil blair's chief of staff yes mr blair
00:21:48 chief of staff um so she says curious to know how feed into political level from our perspective
00:21:54 feel assured having worked in the space of all work being done but ministers feeling on need
00:22:00 uneasy and keen on details i'm wondering if you can help us understand what is meant there by
00:22:06 sense of unease at the political level
00:22:12 i think there at that point there was a lot of conversation going on about what we were seeing
00:22:19 and what we thought this was going to be and there were a number of updates coming through
00:22:25 like the one you see here but we were also seeing a lot in open source and through the media which
00:22:31 was very concerning already mentioned the reference to january 6th so that's what i think this speaks
00:22:37 to okay so it is it fair to say then then in in mike mcdonald's email that we just read through
00:22:43 the message coming through is essentially well we've planned for this we did some planning after
00:22:48 january 6th and things are sort of under control and the machine is operating as it should but then
00:22:54 misastrovis raises a concern saying the ministers are actually pretty worried about this so is it
00:22:59 fair to say that there was some unease at the ministerial or the political level that that
00:23:04 maybe isn't reflected in the briefing yes okay um
00:23:14 so then just moving thank you mr clerk you can take that document down
00:23:21 so that's the sort of pre-arrival state um is there unless there's anything else you'd like to
00:23:25 add about what was going on pre-arrival but then the chronologically the next thing that happens is
00:23:31 the convoy arrives and doesn't leave when everyone expected it to do and then we head into
00:23:36 the first week of the protests if we can call it that um so i'd like you to pull up now mr
00:23:42 clerk ssm.nsc.can402941 and as that's being done maybe i can ask you to just describe to us from
00:23:56 your point of view what that first week was like and what was going on from your perspective in
00:24:01 in attempting to respond and the notes i'm pulling up here mr clow's notes from a february 3rd meeting
00:24:08 which i think can fairly be described as a brainstorming ideas kind of meeting but before
00:24:12 we get into the specifics of the notes um can you fill in a bit of the narrative of what was
00:24:18 happening when you're thinking and in your office at the time so we watched the convoy arrive not
00:24:29 only in ottawa but there was activity in coots very serious activity that first weekend emerson
00:24:35 we're starting to see some blockages there it was down to one lane would open up again
00:24:40 some trucks would move but there was activity in emerson so this was already a national issue in
00:24:45 in the first week and we were we continued to see very concerning statements from some
00:24:51 demonstrators including um from demonstrators and organizers that they were not going to leave
00:24:57 until the government changed this policy but in that first weekend law enforcement was
00:25:04 was responsible local law enforcement i should say and by the end of the weekend it was clear
00:25:09 they weren't leaving so i would say concern had increased at the end of the weekend
00:25:13 so we in the prime minister's office with pco with minister's offices with caucus with others
00:25:19 we were hearing a lot of concern and we were discussing internally and getting updates and
00:25:24 sharing information with each other as best we could before this meeting on the third which was
00:25:30 well into the second week there there had been a briefing of the prime minister by the national
00:25:35 security advisor and the clerk so there were discussions happening what what happened on
00:25:40 February 3rd and what these notes reflect is this was a Thursday the second weekend what was
00:25:47 approaching and law enforcement had not been able to contain the various protests and in fact in my
00:25:54 view they were getting worse so we assembled and basically covered the waterfront what's going on
00:26:01 who's talking to who what can we be doing more of what are different provinces and municipalities
00:26:07 asking are different provinces and municipalities asking questions that if they aren't asking for
00:26:13 support if they aren't can we have a conversation with them to see if they should be asking for
00:26:18 support so in these notes you'll see us cover quite a few different ideas thank you and you'll
00:26:24 appreciate we have an hour and a half so i'm skipping i know i'm skipping through weeks in
00:26:28 chronology very quickly but it's necessary and thank you for filling that in um so here we go
00:26:34 February 3rd. There's just a few points that I want to pick out here. So the first notation says
00:26:38 JB, that's John Broadhead, Mr. Broadhead? That was Jeremy Broadhurst. Oh, that's Jeremy
00:26:44 Broadhurst. Okay, this may get confusing. Jeremy Broadhurst, looks like OPS won't move,
00:26:50 weeks, not days, weird reinforcements problem or something reinforcements problem. Weekend
00:26:55 reinforcement problem. That makes more sense. Behind scenes, too deferential, need bad cop,
00:27:02 You've got to use tools you have.
00:27:04 Whether to change public message is different. 0.98
00:27:06 And then KT, that's Ms. Talford?
00:27:11 Yes.
00:27:11 I can't read the first part.
00:27:13 The second part says, what, if anything, can we do?
00:27:16 What are options?
00:27:16 So that's introducing this as a sort of a brainstorming of ideas.
00:27:20 And then we'll see a variety of ideas expressed here.
00:27:24 Mr. Clerk, can you just scroll down?
00:27:26 We see, sorry, just above there.
00:27:28 Anyway, we can get Bergen's help.
00:27:30 that's a reference to kansas bergen i believe she had just become leader that day okay um and then
00:27:38 we have ms astrovis saying blair doesn't want to call slowly but he's open to calling watson
00:27:45 and then rfa is a reference to a request for assistance and we're going to come back to these
00:27:49 in a moment but ontario could only ask if they have exhausted resources scrolling down again
00:27:55 please mr clerk until you get to the bottom of the page so here we have an intervention uh many
00:28:02 of the ideas that are expressed here we've already heard about so i'm skipping through them quickly
00:28:06 but at the bottom of the page here this is a yasser i believe so that was separate from the
00:28:11 meeting we just covered that was a phone call from uh ottawa center mps or nakvi he called me and i
00:28:17 wrote down what he told me okay that same day on february same day okay so and what he told you was
00:28:22 clearly ottawa police and city are unable to deal with this reinforcements coming this weekend it's
00:28:30 going to really embolden these folks my constituents near breaking point worried
00:28:36 people will take things into his own hands into their own hands i'm sorry so does that reflect
00:28:41 mr cloud what what mr nagfi was expressing to you absolutely and and this was on february 3rd
00:28:48 so by this point the ottawa convoy had been here for a full week a full seven days and ottawa
00:28:54 residents had experienced a lot and i think you see that reflected in mr knack these comments
00:29:00 okay um mr hook we just scroll down to the top of the next page
00:29:11 yeah there we go uh so i think this is a continuation of the phone call with mr knack
00:29:17 what i heard from slowly plea for help it's a plea for something something political
00:29:22 do you recall that reference mr cloud i believe that was a reference to
00:29:27 either the day before or earlier that week chief slowly said there was no policing solution
00:29:35 that's correct it was it was the day before and what i'm wondering is is can you what was
00:29:38 the reaction with within pmo to that statement here we have mr mr knock fees i think
00:29:45 interpretation of it which is it's a plea for something and then he says it's a plea for
00:29:50 something political does that reflect or was there any thinking among the three of you or
00:29:54 among your office within your office about what what chief slowly may have been expressing there
00:29:59 it definitely added to the concern of what we were seeing and to hear ottawa police say that
00:30:06 this was not a policing solution was very concerning and it told us that this was not
00:30:10 going to end anytime soon okay i think we can leave those notes for now thank you mr clark
00:30:17 um the next ones we'll pull up
00:30:22 well it's actually the same note sorry mr clark
00:30:31 keep scrolling down until you see february 6th
00:30:34 yeah there we go so fed says p.m february 6 6 to 8 p.m so i i assume this is a meeting that was
00:30:47 with the prime minister attended by as it says here the clerk the nsia and then john janice jody
00:30:54 sam that would be john broadhead mr broadhead janice is the clerk jody jomas the nsia
00:31:02 sam who's who's sam sam cleel is the director of issues management okay and there were probably
00:31:08 a few other people on that call not many more i'm confident katie was on that call
00:31:14 okay so if we just scroll down then uh until we see ops trying to reduce violence or taking some
00:31:21 steps um and then below that coots persists but traffic is moving a b this is alberta asked for
00:31:29 rfa we don't see caf uh canadian armed forces being able to help with that do you remember who
00:31:36 was making that statement there is this the the nsia's update there mr claire so one to situate
00:31:43 this conversation this was sunday february 6th in the evening so the end of the second weekend
00:31:47 prime minister was updated just as he was updated the previous sunday because a second weekend had
00:31:53 passed and ottawa had worsened and other situations were were becoming more difficult as well and i
00:32:01 note the nsa reported that 11 bc community communities have protests 35 across the country
00:32:08 so i i can't tell from the notes if that comment was jody thomas's comment of the one you asked
00:32:15 about but it looks like it was part of a list of updates from jody thomas were these briefings
00:32:21 happening daily there were multiple conversations happening daily at this point
00:32:29 and there were interactions with the prime minister every day at this point in some way or another
00:32:34 but this specific construct of a meeting with the clerk national security intelligence advisor and
00:32:39 staff didn't happen every day but it happened with increasing frequency okay um so the next point
00:32:45 that we want to look at here is is right at the bottom of the page here on that's a reference to
00:32:51 ontario pushed back and then uh the notation is pm established list of mandates i can't read the
00:33:00 next word something vaccines jim's vaccines all provincial okay and then under that it says dm
00:33:08 for solgen so that would be deputy minister deputy solicitor general pushed back um and that takes
00:33:14 us to an issue that we canvassed a bit here in the commission so far and i'd like to get your
00:33:20 perspective on this afternoon which is what was going on in those early days of the protest the
00:33:26 first week and first week and a half in terms of interaction between various levels of government
00:33:32 and the federal and provincial aspects and especially uh ontario's response or or perhaps
00:33:38 lack of response if we can characterize it that way mr broadhead i believe this is probably best
00:33:43 put to you within your purview sure i can start and then um folks can add in um so i would i would
00:33:51 say there was uh lots of conversations happening at this point with various governments at the
00:33:59 officials level at the political level across the country as as we tried to make sure we were
00:34:06 hearing from them on what was happening on the ground uh and making sure we had those that that
00:34:12 intelligence um i think with respect to ontario specifically i think there there was at the uh
00:34:19 outset um a different approach to uh to this uh um to the strategy uh and i i think as we get to
00:34:31 we were quite keen on this idea of a tripartite table that minister blair had um had been working
00:34:37 on and uh we thought that was a good way of getting everybody at the table making sure
00:34:42 resources were aligned making sure everyone uh looked each other in the eyes and uh and work
00:34:48 together and at that time ontario um was not as keen on that approach i don't really want to
00:34:55 you know speculate for what the solicitor general or deputy minister solicitor general uh
00:35:00 at this point wasn't um but from my conversations with them they did want to have ottawa the city
00:35:05 of ottawa and and the ottawa police service kind of play the lead role and and we're not as um
00:35:11 interested at that time in the the collaborative tripartite approach that that we were interested
00:35:18 in okay um uh mr clerk can you take those notes down for a second and pull up ssm.nsc.can403015
00:35:27 please. So Mr. Broadhead, I think this is a text that goes to the point you were just elucidating.
00:35:50 So we don't have a confirmed date for this one, but it must be February 8th. Thank you.
00:35:57 um and this is a text between you and ms astrovis a text exchange and uh she says to you like she's
00:36:03 in the blue here marco that's a reference to minister mendicino hasn't heard back from sylvia
00:36:09 jones that's a reference to uh the solicitor general of ontario on the meeting with the
00:36:13 three orders of government reference to the tripartite and you say yeah because they don't
00:36:18 want to be a part of it and she says oh i know and you say so anything i should do
00:36:24 we should just go ahead without them and then it goes on so can you contextual contextualize that
00:36:30 for us a little bit yeah as they were getting kind of pushed back and or just not support uh
00:36:38 from their counterparts the solicitor general particular they had asked me to connect with
00:36:43 my contact in the premier's office and to just check and see if if was this something that
00:36:49 the entire government or this minister just to kind of ascertain some of those
00:36:53 kind of contextual details so i did uh i chatted with with uh jamie wallace and it was clear that
00:37:00 that they were kind of they had a different approach and strategy um and the tripartite
00:37:06 table was not a priority for them at that time sorry who is jamie wallace sorry jamie wallace
00:37:10 is the chief of staff to premier ford okay so you had a conversation with mr wallace chief
00:37:15 of staff to premier ford and the message coming back to you was uh was this was not a strategy
00:37:21 they wanted to pursue at this time was there any reason given for that um it was i um you know i
00:37:29 think you know my recollection of that conversation was it was really they they wanted ottawa to be
00:37:37 the main uh driver of this and and did not want a kind of multi-governmental approach to this at
00:37:43 that time that that was the impression i got from that phone call okay
00:37:50 were you having interactions during this time with counterparts in other provinces as well
00:37:55 yeah so so previously previous to being a director of policy which i started in january um i was
00:38:02 senior advisor with a focus on intergovernmental affairs and so through that i got to work closely
00:38:09 with with a number of the provinces um the three i was having most contact with one was
00:38:15 yeah was british columbia because they were chair of the council of federation at the time so that
00:38:19 was an ongoing active discussion generally and i want to be clear not just about this for example
00:38:27 mr wallace and i were working on child care very actively at this time as well and other other
00:38:31 issues uh were very uh would come up so um and then other provinces as well but the other part
00:38:39 of our our pmo which is important in this is the regional desks uh who don't report to me they're
00:38:45 part of the operations team they have g they have geographical areas of responsibility so they're
00:38:52 often in touch with provinces and cities and we have kind of information sharing between us
00:38:57 So I'm in touch with them a lot there. They let me know when things are happening. I do, I do as well. So I know that from in those times, there was a lot of informal contact, as well as obviously from ministers and officials.
00:39:11 Okay, and we may come back to some of those interactions. But we'll stick to Ontario for now. Mr. Clerk, can you pull up SSM.nsc.can402935?
00:39:27 So, Ms. Talford, this is a text exchange between you and Minister Dominique Leblanc, who we
00:39:50 know is the Minister of Intergovernmental Affairs.
00:39:53 And he writes to you and says, just got this from Vandergriff. So that's a reference to his deputy minister, Michael Vandergriff. Minister, want to let you know that the Ontario Solicitor General has again declined the invitation to attend the tripartite meeting today on the Ottawa occupation. And you say, I think we need to shine a light on that. He says, we'll say it.
00:40:15 Can you explain to us what was going on in this text message and what you meant by, I think we need to shine a light on that?
00:40:23 so i think this was a continuation of what john was just talking about this was um obviously a
00:40:29 further attempt at a meeting with the three levels of government and ontario was continuing to decline
00:40:35 um i don't recall when he says we'll say it um where that meant uh but it it putting myself back
00:40:45 in that time i think when i'm saying we should shine a light on it it's bringing some attention
00:40:50 to the fact that uh ontario wasn't at the table and we really did believe it would be a more
00:40:55 efficient and effective way to work would it be fair to say that there was some frustration
00:41:01 um with ontario's response at this point there was definitely some frustration because we believed
00:41:07 it could be easier than it was all things being very relative at that time but um but there was
00:41:12 ongoing communication with ontario bilaterally throughout it just meant that the conversations
00:41:17 were happening between ottawa and the federal government the federal government in ontario
00:41:22 ontario and so there were just numerous bilateral conversations that we just thought could have been
00:41:27 um better handled and more efficient if we could have all just come together because as i know has
00:41:33 come up uh throughout the inquiry there was a fair bit of confusion around numbers and requests and
00:41:39 the rfas the way they work the request for um assistance they do need to go through the
00:41:44 provincial level of government and so not having them as part of the conversation made things
00:41:49 that bit more complicated that's fair um mr clerk can you please pull up ont50159
00:42:02 so i'm going to ask you here about a meeting that was held on on february 6th uh that was
00:42:08 a sort of tripartite but not quite uh between the city of ottawa federal government and provincial
00:42:14 government and the exchange i'm going to take you to we've seen this document several times in the
00:42:18 commission so i'm not going to go through the whole thing but at the end of the the document
00:42:22 there's an exchange between the national security advisor and the deputy solicitor general of ontario
00:42:27 that i'd like to get your take on so it's february 6 and 11 o'clock meeting attended by officials from
00:42:35 three levels of government so mr clerk if you can scroll down to the very bottom of the document
00:42:44 You'll see it says there, Jody Thomas, National Security Advisor, noted that it was a positive
00:42:51 meeting and regrets to end on this following point.
00:42:55 Would the province be looking to the federal government if this protest was happening outside
00:43:00 the city of Ottawa, e.g. happening in other places like Kingston?
00:43:04 And the response from Mr. Di Tommaso was, this is a protest, an encampment moving against
00:43:09 federal mandate on trucks they came across they came to ottawa from across the country for that
00:43:15 purpose now mr g tomaso testified at the commission approximately two weeks ago and uh he expressed
00:43:23 that in his view ms thomas's he he interpreted ms thomas's comment as i'll quote the words here
00:43:30 the federal government wanting to wash its hands of the entire matter um and so i'd just like to
00:43:36 get your reaction in in terms of whether you think that was a fair assessment of what was going on
00:43:41 uh whether you think that that was what what was being expressed there and um what ms thomas was
00:43:48 trying to express when she said would this be would the province be looking to the federal
00:43:52 government if this was somewhere other than ottawa i might um start like i don't i'm not putting too
00:44:02 much weight into this like as i read it and i wasn't there but this strikes me as frustration
00:44:09 and a bit of a back and forth and that frustration happening and and and both sides kind of
00:44:14 articulating some of that frustration i think um we were trying to look for ways to work together
00:44:21 there were three levels of government and it was um it was a challenge to get these these these
00:44:29 machines um working in the right direction i think this is a this back and forth is a
00:44:35 would be my guess would be this is an outcrop of just a frustration around those those levels
00:44:41 of government and the and the two different approaches that i've outlined before fair enough
00:44:45 and you can appreciate that one of the issues that the commission is is looking into is is
00:44:50 the interaction between governments and and which is not always an easy thing but um how it all
00:44:55 played out here okay um so eventually um around this time around the time of february 7th 8th 9th
00:45:04 ontario became more engaged when the ambassador bridge blockade became entrenched and
00:45:10 And so we know that that has happened and I'll take you with that point too.
00:45:17 um
00:45:39 the witness summary i'm sorry mr clerk it's uh
00:45:43 wts six zeros 14 page 11.
00:46:02 oh i'm sorry 83 i'm sorry i got the wrong number 83. 14 is the ir
00:46:13 So if we scroll down to page 11, please, Mr. Clerk.
00:46:29 Keep scrolling, keep scrolling, okay, scroll up a bit, please.
00:46:41 i'm looking for is the panel was asked what in their view could be that i have the wrong page
00:46:47 number while they're looking for the reference mr broadhead what i what i want to ask you about is
00:47:01 what in in your view you were asked this during the interview and i'd like you to elaborate on it
00:47:07 what inspired the shift from ontario why did it happen then and um and how did that occur
00:47:13 and i'll preface my answer by saying this is me not in the government of ontario which i
00:47:22 i did spend a long time in the government ontario but i was not there at this point
00:47:25 um i i think it uh in a in a sense um it started to become absolutely clear that we had to work
00:47:36 together so it was almost the the increase of of things happening so you add the ambassador bridge
00:47:42 to the ottawa situation you have other things starting to happen around the province um
00:47:48 in new windsor sarnia cornwall and in all i i think it became clear and i'm hypothesizing here
00:47:54 that um but we did see an evolution of their strategy at that time in terms of at the political
00:48:01 level collaboration i think there's lots going on in other places that i don't want to comment to
00:48:05 but just that's what i i can specifically comment to okay and we know that there were several
00:48:11 important phone calls that happened around that time um certainly between the prime minister and
00:48:17 and premier ford which we'll talk about tomorrow when the prime minister is here
00:48:21 uh between minister leblanc we talked about when minister leblanc was here um
00:48:28 leaving ontario for a moment and talking about engagement with other provinces
00:48:32 um i do want to ask you some questions about another topic that's come up several times here
00:48:36 which is alberta's request for assistance so i'm going to put to you a few facts that that we know
00:48:44 and that have come out already at the at the commission and that are also brought out in the
00:48:48 pmo institutional report um so there's a notation in the in your ir that pmo staff engaged with
00:48:56 pam livingston so mr mr broadhead maybe you can tell us who pam livingstone is
00:49:01 pam livingston at the time was chief of staff to the premier kenny okay and there were two
00:49:06 interactions apparently between pmo and ms livingston about the alberta request for assistance
00:49:13 and that request for assistance we've seen several times before so no need to pull it up
00:49:18 but was for essentially assistance in in tow trucks and removing vehicles from the coots blockade
00:49:25 There's also a notation that the Prime Minister had a formal call on February 6th with Minister Blair
00:49:32 to discuss Alberta's request for assistance and the ongoing situation.
00:49:37 And then I'm going to ask the Clerk to pull up Mr. Cloud's notes again,
00:49:41 ssm.nsc.can402941.
00:49:54 So this is the notation I said we'd come back to. This is the meeting that you're having with the Prime Minister on February 6th. And the notation. There it is. Thank you. Coutts persists, but traffic is moving. Alberta asked for RFA. We don't see CAF being able to help with that.
00:50:19 So at that point, it's apparently been concluded or decided in some form that the Canadian Armed Forces is unable to assist. Is that correct, Mr. Klaff?
00:50:28 So the RFA came in the day before that, and it immediately spurred a number of conversations with different offices.
00:50:34 Ministers were consulted, and the Prime Minister was consulted on a few different occasions about this.
00:50:40 And yes, there was a general sense that CAF should be a last resort.
00:50:45 But also in this specific case, I think you've heard from other witnesses as well, but at the time, the discussion was that this was not an appropriate or even useful response to what the problem was.
00:51:02 And what I mean by that was, were these trucks actually going to be able to do the job?
00:51:06 That was all part of the discussion that ensued after the request came in on the 5th.
00:51:11 What I'm really wondering about all of these exchanges, and there was a further meeting apparently on the 9th where, again, this time it was Ms. Telford, Ms. Charette, the Prime Minister, and Ministers Leblanc, Mancino, and Blair all discussing the RFA during one of the meetings that was held.
00:51:31 Why was this RFA treated quite differently than most are?
00:51:35 This was elevated to the level of the PMO and the prime minister,
00:51:40 which most requests for assistance are not.
00:51:42 Can you explain or elaborate on that?
00:51:46 Just, and you might want to add to this,
00:51:48 but we are usually made aware of requests for assistance
00:51:52 wherever they're going in government.
00:51:57 And in this case, we were obviously following everything
00:52:00 to do with the blockades and the occupation very very closely and in this case because the the
00:52:06 feedback from departments was coming that there wasn't a way to help and our in our what we were
00:52:12 trying to do was support anybody who needed assistance on the ground um and so if alberta
00:52:18 was asking for help we wanted to be able to support them so it just led to a lot of conversations it
00:52:24 kind of comes to the role that our office often plays of coordination and facilitation because
00:52:28 we then started reaching out and asking questions of other departments saying does anyone else have
00:52:33 the equipment that they might be looking for it may not be appropriate for calf and they may not
00:52:37 have the equipment um but uh but is there that equipment somewhere else that could be found so
00:52:43 i think as is in the interview summary you know we even went so far as to say does parks canada
00:52:47 have this kind of thing um because the goal was to be able to assist if we could maybe if i can
00:52:54 just add i think you know we also looked at can we reimburse if they find them privately can can
00:53:01 should we reimburse that so it was it was it and and i kind of pushed back a little bit on that
00:53:07 this rarely happens like in in a case where the process comes through and it goes to the minister
00:53:15 and it's it's a i've known of other cases where it was like no we can't assist um the minister's
00:53:25 office will often flag it to us and we'll ask questions about well if we explored this and i
00:53:31 can i can remember other instances where where that was a case where we just pushed more to find
00:53:37 other solutions that in the in the kind of narrow band of the rfa process they may not have thought
00:53:42 okay that's fair it's a the request for assistance that we're dealing within the commission it's the
00:53:47 only one that we've seen this pattern in but that's fair explanation okay um i'm gonna want
00:53:52 to shift gears now and talk about uh what you were hearing during this process with various
00:53:59 uh stakeholders and interlocutors both nationally and internationally um so mr clow i'll start with
00:54:06 you um we know you had a few conversations with uh a man named juan gonzalez who's the special
00:54:13 advisor to president biden can you tell us about those conversations and what you were hearing
00:54:17 from him yes so i heard from juan gonzalez he is part of the national security team in the white
00:54:23 house and we'd interacted on a few files um before the convoy protests and he reached out i believe
00:54:31 on wednesday february 9th at that point it was a request to connect national security intelligence
00:54:39 advisor jody thomas with the white house homeland security advisor to urgently discuss the windsor
00:54:47 blockade but also other border blockades that were in effect at that time so juan and i had a bit of
00:54:52 back and forth about that that then led to a number of conversations some of which you heard
00:54:58 about this morning from the deputy prime minister um but there were there were various interactions
00:55:04 between the prime minister's office pco several ministers offices and their counterparts in the
00:55:09 united states in the white house and different departments in the united states because they
00:55:14 became seized with the border blockades that were impacting them quite significantly so you mentioned
00:55:19 that we heard this morning from the deputy prime minister that she was hearing a lot of concern
00:55:23 from officials in the United States about what was going on
00:55:27 and some encouragement, if we can put it that way,
00:55:30 to bring a swift end, given the impact this was going to have
00:55:33 on Canada-US relations and trade.
00:55:36 Were you hearing similar concerns from the people you were talking to
00:55:41 in the United States and or in other countries?
00:55:44 Absolutely.
00:55:45 And the concern was not only about trade, economics, dollars and cents.
00:55:50 It was for sure.
00:55:51 But there was also a discussion in many of these conversations, including between the Prime Minister and the President, that both countries were facing similar forces in certain ways.
00:56:02 For example, the United States also saw some convoy activity.
00:56:07 I think it was dealt with quite quickly by the Americans, but they saw a trucker protest heading to the Super Bowl.
00:56:14 There was one that was trying to be assembled to head to Washington, D.C.
00:56:17 So these were a part of the conversations as well.
00:56:19 It was viewed as a shared problem.
00:56:22 But for sure, the immediate issue was the blockades at various border crossings, especially Windsor, and how do we sort these out quickly.
00:56:30 And we understand you also had some conversations with Ambassador Hillman, Ambassador to the United States.
00:56:35 Can you tell us about those conversations?
00:56:37 Well, she was one of the key principals having interactions with the White House and various departments in the United States.
00:56:44 and the substance you know one example of substance within those conversations was how
00:56:51 can we introduce measures to end the blockades or or at least dissuade them from growing and
00:56:59 from new ones from popping up for example there was discussion of potential immigration measures
00:57:04 or penalties placed on people who conducted unlawful activity at these border blockades
00:57:09 there was definitely discussion of whether the united states could provide tow trucks to help
00:57:14 given it was virtually impossible to get tow trucks on the Canadian side of the border.
00:57:19 So that's the kind of thing that was discussed.
00:57:20 Did that ever end up happening?
00:57:25 I don't know.
00:57:26 So the immigration measures, I don't believe the United States implemented any measures.
00:57:30 We did in the Emergencies Act.
00:57:34 In terms of tow trucks being provided by the United States,
00:57:37 there might have been some in Detroit, Windsor, provided by Detroit or the government of Michigan.
00:57:42 I'm not sure about that.
00:57:44 Mr. Broadhead, Ms. Telford, were either of you having conversations with international counterparts? No?
00:57:52 Not during the occupation or when the blockades were on.
00:57:56 For months afterwards, I can say, including up until recent summits, though, this is a topic that continues to come up with counterparts from various countries.
00:58:07 And the prime minister also had calls during the occupation with other world leaders where this was a topic that was coming up because they were they were watching what was happening in Canada and concerned that they were starting to see the same thing in some of their countries and they were concerned about copycat situations.
00:58:23 So this has been an ongoing conversation with international leaders.
00:58:27 I would just add as well, another feature of all of the conversations between the Americans and us, including the call between the Prime Minister and the President, was the fact that a lot of the support for the unlawful activity here in Canada was coming from the United States in terms of money, in terms of people, and in terms of political support from some of the most prominent U.S. political figures.
00:58:49 millions of dollars came in from the united states according to published reports chief slowly
00:58:55 announced that there were american citizens who had traveled to join the occupation in ottawa
00:59:01 so that was also a feature of the discussions here the flooding of 911 phone lines here in ottawa
00:59:06 came largely from americans as as announced by chief slowly and the ottawa police so
00:59:12 this was very much a shared problem and we were talking about it in that sense we've heard about
00:59:18 some of that already at the commission um you speak of the foreign funding and we explored that
00:59:23 a bit this morning with the deputy prime minister and it was it was found in the end that there were
00:59:28 millions of dollars coming from um from the united states from private donors so there was no foreign
00:59:35 state funding coming in would you agree with that yes okay um and we've also established that there
00:59:42 there was little information available to the government at the time of the convoy
00:59:48 of how much money was coming in from the United States.
00:59:51 That wasn't really information that was available to the government at the time.
00:59:55 Would you agree with that?
00:59:56 It definitely became more apparent as time passed, and I totally agree with you.
01:00:00 It is cloudy and unclear, and it's concerning that it happened.
01:00:07 But one example I would give, I mean, we felt quite strongly at the time that it was happening.
01:00:13 And proof of that, I would say, is when GoFundMe paused the account, you saw some of the most prominent American political figures attack GoFundMe.
01:00:24 And they didn't do that for no reason.
01:00:27 They did it because it was clear to them and it was clear to us that a lot of the funding was coming from Americans.
01:00:34 Okay. So you've taken me to what I actually wanted to ask you about, which is one thing we haven't heard much about so far is political commentary coming from the United States. So you mentioned prominent political figures who are weighing in on all of this. Can you tell us about some of that, some of what you were hearing or observing on that front?
01:00:53 the issue there there were there were a number of examples from senators from governors from
01:01:00 the former president and the issue there is not that individuals and politicians aren't allowed
01:01:06 to comment on politics and policies in other other countries it happens all the time but the
01:01:12 concern for us was it was direct encouragement for unlawful activity that was hugely damaging
01:01:18 to the country including the border blockades so that's that's why i raise it here and that's why
01:01:22 the president the prime minister spoke about it it was the support for unlawful activity okay um
01:01:30 mr clerk can can you please pull up mr clow's notes again so that's ssm.nsc.can402941
01:01:38 Remarkably effective note taker.
01:01:53 Now it's going to be a little challenging to find the page here because we don't have
01:01:57 a date for it, so just keep scrolling down until you see talked about the Emergencies
01:02:07 Act.
01:02:08 So scroll down again, please scroll down.
01:02:23 Keep scrolling.
01:02:29 Keep scrolling.
01:02:37 Keep going. I think it's just after this. Keep going, please.
01:02:56 There's a lot of blackout in this, so it's a little challenging.
01:03:00 Oh, we're at the FMM already. So it must be before that.
01:03:07 I think I saw it.
01:03:10 Did you?
01:03:11 A few pages up. Yeah.
01:03:12 Can you zoom out a little bit, please, Mr. Quirk, so we can see?
01:03:16 Thanks.
01:03:17 Keep going up a little bit.
01:03:27 so a little bit further up a little bit further so i think you see yeah there we go okay so first
01:03:36 question we don't have a date on this because it's sort of there's some blackout before that but
01:03:40 do you remember the date of this mr claude i believe it was february 9th okay so it's a meeting
01:03:45 on february 9th and um this is various things happening over the course of the day why don't
01:03:49 you tell us one meeting why don't you tell us what was happening so february 9th was there were
01:03:56 a few conversations going on. I don't specifically remember what meetings at what times, but
01:04:02 I did write down and it was reported to us that Minister Blair had spoken to the clerk
01:04:08 about the Emergencies Act. And that was in the lead up, I think just one day before the
01:04:15 incident response group meeting where the Emergencies Act was discussed in some detail
01:04:19 in addition to other things. So this was just a report to us that that conversation had happened
01:04:24 between the minister and the clerk okay so around february 9th we're getting to the point as we know
01:04:28 where the federal government um felt a need to perhaps intervene in the situation and and uh
01:04:35 and bring this to a close in some way so as you say uh blair spoke to the clerk and talked about
01:04:41 the emergencies act on the options can you just read read your handwriting there didn't commit on
01:04:47 the options emergency could be peace if that sounds like we have authority then a reference
01:04:53 to natalie the deputy clerk and i see this as discussions are happening about how we can help
01:05:03 what more we can be doing and the emergency that could be a piece of that okay and we know that
01:05:12 the following day the prime minister convened the first incident response group meeting yes so i'd
01:05:18 like to tell us a bit about that meeting the decision to convene the irg and what that meant
01:05:23 um in the prime minister's eyes in your eyes and what an irg really is
01:05:31 um i think as the clerk may have spoken to already and i think as these notes show too
01:05:37 the meetings were becoming increasingly frequent with added ministers and different departments
01:05:44 getting involved because of the request for assistance um amongst a growing number of
01:05:51 blockades now as well as protests in different parts of the country and the occupation of course
01:05:57 is now really entrenched in ottawa um and so as we were having these meetings the clerk i believe
01:06:04 advised the prime minister though it made it made good sense to the group of us at the time as well
01:06:09 that it was time to formalize our structure moving forward and that we were at a point
01:06:14 of national crisis. And that's what the incident response group is put together for. It was
01:06:18 a group that was it was a cabinet committee that was created, I believe, in the first
01:06:24 mandate of the government midway through. And it is chaired by the prime minister. It
01:06:31 does not have a set permanent membership. It is it is convened with the ministers appropriate
01:06:37 to whatever the incident is um that is being discussed and the thing that makes it very
01:06:42 different from other cabinet committees is where in another cabinet committee uh that it tends to
01:06:48 be policy focused in a little longer term this is obviously dealing with something um in real time
01:06:54 and something that's a crisis like in nature um but the the structural difference too is that
01:07:01 officials lead, in many ways, the conversations within the IRG meetings space, and they are
01:07:08 right at the table. So whereas at a cabinet committee meeting, the ministers would be
01:07:12 sitting around the cabinet table and the officials might be sitting to the side, they may very
01:07:17 well be making presentations, and then the ministers would be discussing those presentations
01:07:21 or they might speak up to make clarification when their ministers call on them for that
01:07:26 clarification. At an IRG meeting, the principal presenters are officials. And so whether it's the
01:07:33 NSIA, whether it's the commissioner of the RCMP, whether it was the head of CSIS, depending on the
01:07:39 incident in past, it might be the CAF and the chief of defense staff. And then the ministers
01:07:45 are called on by the prime minister to add anything that they might see as not having been
01:07:50 covered, to add any thoughts they have on the basis of the information that's been presented.
01:07:56 but they are all sitting around the same table which makes it quite a different meeting than
01:08:00 than really any other and what's the purpose of that why is an irg structured like that
01:08:05 with direct input from officials i think um for a number of reasons it's their expertise um and
01:08:13 getting it in real time to the prime minister and uh and to the to the ministers and things are
01:08:18 moving very quickly um and it's uh so it's an efficiency and an effective kind of tool to bring
01:08:26 everybody to that same table and convene the leadership of the different security agencies
01:08:31 for whatever the security incident is and to hear from people directly okay so essentially you remove
01:08:38 the sort of the layering up and instead the prime minister has direct access to all of the inputs
01:08:43 that uh that you may want or need as do all of the other ministers because they then get to hear
01:08:49 from directly from the heads of the different agencies or law enforcement uh heads okay fair
01:08:55 enough um so we've been through the content of many of the irgs one theme i want to pick up with
01:09:05 you is something that was eventually brought to the irg on february 12th but um uh has been a
01:09:12 discussion at the commission throughout which was the idea of whether the the prime minister or
01:09:18 anyone from the federal government should engage with the protesters and attempt to bring this to
01:09:24 a close through either some sort of negotiation some engagement some speaking um so the first
01:09:31 thing i'll bring up on that point is mr clerk it's pb dot can dot four zeros 1184.
01:10:01 It might be 1844, sorry.
01:10:18 Ms. Dulford, this is a text exchange on February 6th between you and Minister Manichino.
01:10:24 so it's it's early days because as i said this theme of of interaction negotiation
01:10:30 is uh something that came up okay can we scroll down please mr clerk
01:10:41 going keep going
01:10:47 going
01:10:54 Page eight, please.
01:10:58 Okay, here we go.
01:11:00 So if we can blow that up, it's really hard to read,
01:11:03 but you'll see a notation here,
01:11:05 lawyer, arbitrator, mediator, author,
01:11:08 suggested by Anne McClellan as a possible interlocutor.
01:11:12 Again, I think it's a long shot
01:11:13 for the reasons we discussed.
01:11:15 Also, I noticed after we hung up
01:11:17 that we didn't even spend a moment on politics and readiness.
01:11:20 Okay, so that part of it
01:11:23 not be all that relevant but can you do you remember this tax exchange miss dalford
01:11:28 now that i see it okay and you remember the idea of discussing a possible interlocutor
01:11:34 at that point and what was going on can you fill that in for us please look i think over the course
01:11:41 of right from the beginning of the occupation um when it became an occupation uh there were
01:11:47 numerous people who were trying to suggest anything they could to try to find a way to assist and i
01:11:54 think that's what ann was doing here um and uh i've received and i believe it's it's part of
01:12:01 the documents as well that you've you've received i received suggestions from numerous other people
01:12:06 as well uh mps were raising names with us uh there were suggested names of mps from other parties who
01:12:13 who were coming forward wondering if they could help there was there was a lot of people that
01:12:18 were trying to find a way um to figure out if an engagement could work and no one was able to take
01:12:26 it past that first thought and so um no one could figure out who they should talk to there was no
01:12:34 clear leadership on the other side there was no clear understanding of what they would even be
01:12:38 talking about uh the police were already as we were being informed through the incident response
01:12:45 groups they were already engaging at a at a certain level and so it wasn't clear what this
01:12:51 engagement strategy would be um let alone if it could have any effect and you know i think there's
01:12:57 a difference too between engagement um and negotiation and the prime minister and the
01:13:04 cabinet the government wasn't prepared to negotiate public health measures that were rooted in science
01:13:10 um i'm not i also am not sure and i think a lot of people weren't sure at the time that really
01:13:18 that that's what this was all about and so figuring out what the topic of the conversation
01:13:22 could be let alone who it could be with that could have any effect on changing the circumstances
01:13:28 when no one could answer that question really these conversations couldn't didn't move past
01:13:34 the initial suggestion of i wonder if okay so at this point this is part of the conversation
01:13:39 we're still in sort of early days of the protest and i think you're what you're taking us to now
01:13:43 is um what what's come to be known as the engagement proposal and we've heard some
01:13:47 evidence on that and mr clerk you can take that one down please and pull up following
01:13:53 SSM.nsc.can402958. So, Ms. Telford, I think what you've just been referencing has been
01:14:04 canvassed before the commission a bit, and it's Mr. Deputy Minister Stewart's engagement
01:14:10 proposal that he prepared with the assistance of Marcel Bowden from the OPP PLT. And this
01:14:19 is now we're the evening of february 11th it's a text that mr minister mendicino sent to you
01:14:26 saying hey there we got some very last minute and thin paper tonight on an engagement strategy
01:14:31 uh from my deputy minister apparently socialized it with several people including the ontario
01:14:37 government not me and we'll just scroll down and see the rest of the text please
01:14:43 um he says it's unclear whether pco or cmp or ontario supports this but he's flagging this as
01:14:50 a concern uh about information flow and then he says at the bottom sorry but had to let you know
01:14:56 um marco um so can you tell us a bit from your perspective we've heard mr minister mendicino's
01:15:03 perspective on it but what was your perspective receiving this text and do you know why mr
01:15:09 minister medicina was essentially apologizing saying sorry i'm just letting you know about this
01:15:16 when the irgs began convening um just the day before i believe um one of the things
01:15:24 that was stressed at the first irg or in and around the irg really was just the need for
01:15:30 appropriate information flow and for regular and constant and information flow and so i believe
01:15:38 that's what he's he's saying sorry for there is he's he's letting me know that there's this
01:15:43 information that is now floating around that has already gone to some people and it had not kind
01:15:48 of followed the usual channels um and i think he was sorry that it was the hour that it was that
01:15:54 we were all trying to grapple with what to do here um but uh i had also just received the paper
01:15:59 previously from the clerk i think about an hour before by the looks of this um and so
01:16:08 i would i wouldn't read too much into the story and we were much more focused on the uh on the
01:16:13 draft and ultimately what was decided later that night um after i talked with the clerk and i then
01:16:21 called the prime minister and the prime minister agreed to put it on um with the suggestion that
01:16:26 was coming from the clerk he agreed to put it on the agenda for the irg the next day for discussion
01:16:31 and we've seen that it ended up on the agenda and i think you just started to tell us a little bit
01:16:35 but maybe you can finish that answer um why ultimately it was decided not to pursue that
01:16:40 that engagement strategy in in some ways it's it's what i already touched on uh which is this
01:16:47 was one more proposal that was not yet at the place that one could act on there were too many
01:16:53 unanswered questions uh there was no clarity in terms of who the discussion would be with
01:16:59 um on either side of the discussion and what the discussion would be about and what it might result
01:17:04 in and so you know while while everyone including the prime minister was encouraging everyone to
01:17:10 put every option on the table and it's why this was was put on the agenda ultimately uh there
01:17:16 wasn't anything further to pursue on this at that time okay um thank you mr clerk you can take that
01:17:22 one down um so we're going to skip a little ahead in the chronology again the following day february
01:17:33 13th is obviously key there's the the incident response group meeting in the afternoon followed
01:17:38 by the cabinet meeting in the evening the decision coming out of the irg is to have the cabinet
01:17:44 meeting and then the decision coming out of the cabinet meeting is to have a first minister's
01:17:48 meeting to consult on whether or not to invoke the Emergencies Act. Mr. Clerk, can you pull up
01:17:55 ssm.nsc.can402941? It's Mr. Clow's notes again, this time at page 22.
01:18:06 So when Minister LeBlanc testified a few days ago, we went through some of the comments that
01:18:11 with the record of the readout of the first minister's meeting and some of what was expressed
01:18:16 by the provinces there and these i believe are mr clow's notes of that same meeting um and i'm
01:18:22 wondering whether we can go through a bit of these and mr broadhead maybe this is best directed at
01:18:27 you but whether you can fill in about a bit of the context about what was what was being expressed
01:18:33 during the first ministers meeting by these various premiers and um whether or not in your
01:18:39 view it coincided with uh what you've been hearing up to then about uh solving the problem of the
01:18:45 convoy sure i'll start and then um my colleagues can uh can add um i you know i think it was uh
01:18:54 quite consistent with what we had heard before but i think it was a very robust conversation
01:19:00 um you know we had the ministers minister lametti and i believe minister mendicino or leblanc
01:19:07 uh and the prime minister speak then we went uh the prime minister went across the country
01:19:13 um in terms of making sure he heard from each of the provinces and territorial premiers um
01:19:20 i think you know we had we had known on on where you know not that specifically on the emergencies
01:19:25 act um but we had known from conversations with ontario uh what they were kind of feeling
01:19:32 generally we had heard from a lot of the provinces so um i think it was it was quite an interesting
01:19:37 conversation i think um we did learn a lot and just to use you know a couple quick examples
01:19:44 you know some of the some of the issues around supply chain that that newfoundland and and
01:19:49 nunavut brought up and concern from the premier in the northwest territories about a blockade
01:19:55 um concerns from premier horgan about rcmp being stretched too thin um as they were a contingent
01:20:03 had been sent to to support another part of the country and it really kind of showed that the
01:20:09 national nature of it and and the kind of variety of issues folks were facing um and and even the
01:20:16 folks who were i would say um more concerned um such as the the premier of alberta or the premier
01:20:23 saskatchewan you know even they had said things like well i won't quibble with the use of the 0.99
01:20:28 the emergencies act but i'm worried about inflaming folks which was something we were concerned about
01:20:34 had talked about at irgs was a real cause um of discussion um and and same with with with premier
01:20:41 mo who said you know the the six things you've mentioned sound reasonable but i'm worried about
01:20:47 inflaming so um you know and and even even you know premier will go talking about um you know
01:20:54 the certez de quebec and um you know and the dynamic between the the certez and and the rcmp
01:21:01 um and us having to kind of you know discuss where those boundaries were with them uh in calls mr
01:21:08 leblanc mentioned after with uh with minister labelle i believe it was um uh really showed
01:21:13 like it was a very meaty conversation i found and um but not a not a not one where i think we were
01:21:21 um shocked by by what we were hearing because of the outreach that had happened in advance
01:21:28 mr alford i would just add that this was um i'm not sure there's a prime minister
01:21:32 in canadian history that has had as many first ministers meetings as this prime minister has
01:21:37 because of the pandemic and uh so they were such a regular occurrence and this group of premiers
01:21:43 know each other quite well because of that and while you know there are perhaps sometimes
01:21:49 more pointed and more partisan statements made in public facing environments in these meetings
01:21:57 that they have and I think you can see that in the notes and in the descriptions of it
01:22:01 they really they are thoughtful conversations and they do come at things differently there's no
01:22:08 doubt they have different you know regional needs and we're facing different things in different
01:22:14 parts of the country but as as premier king i can still remember saying you know toward the
01:22:20 end he was one of the later speakers as per the notes and him saying to the prime minister i know
01:22:25 you don't take this lightly and this was a thoughtful conversation and because they they
01:22:30 really were grappling with you know even those who were concerned about the potential for
01:22:36 inflammation if the emergencies act were invoked even those who were concerned about it in their
01:22:41 specific regions understood there was a broader national um potential national need here and that
01:22:48 the prime minister had uh the authority ultimately and potentially and the need to do this and so
01:22:55 even those who were showing some reluctance um from their kind of premier perspective of their
01:23:02 particular province were showing an openness or a recognition as premier kenny did and sort of
01:23:08 saying i won't quibble with you um on whatever you have to do with the emergencies act ultimately
01:23:13 and i think that speaks to they'd had an fmm just a couple of weeks prior to this um that was solely
01:23:19 focused on before all of this had started um as part of par for the course now during the pandemic
01:23:25 because we need to remember the time we were in which was the height of omicron and so they'd
01:23:29 actually had an fmm just i think it was january 10th where they were talking about the new mandates
01:23:35 that the provinces were having to put into place and we were looking to support them on that front
01:23:39 so this is a group that has navigated crises for a couple of years together and in many if not most
01:23:44 of their cases that's helpful context in understanding comments like you just brought
01:23:49 up i don't miss premier kenny saying i don't quibble with the use of the act mr cloud do
01:23:53 you have anything to add on that on this front i think it's been well covered i would just
01:23:58 emphasize i know it's been addressed here and elsewhere in the past couple weeks
01:24:02 but premier kenny's comment on this phone call that there was a potentially violent hardcore
01:24:10 group of individuals at the center of the coots blockade who were ready to die for a cause and
01:24:16 we had heard that through other reports and from our own officials but it was a recognition that's
01:24:22 just one example of the very serious potential for violence that was posed by many of these
01:24:27 demonstrations thank you mr clerk you can you take that one down so we know that what happened after
01:24:36 the first minister's meeting which lasted about an hour um there was then i believe a call with
01:24:41 opposition leaders and uh then some point that afternoon the prime minister received a decision
01:24:48 note from the clerk and fairly shortly thereafter took the decision to invoke the emergencies act
01:24:54 one thing i wanted to ask from your perspective was any consideration given in in any of this
01:25:00 to holding a debate before parliament uh not to decide of course but to to engage in a debate
01:25:08 over whether the emergencies act should be invoked so there was an emergency debate about the convoy
01:25:14 and the demonstrations about a week about i think exactly a week before the invocation of the
01:25:19 emergencies act um the emergencies act itself contains parliamentary process and provisions
01:25:25 that debate and the vote in the house did happen um but the decision to invoke on february 14th
01:25:32 was made after a series of discussions and inputs the fmm that morning being a critical one the
01:25:39 opposition leader called being a critical one the view was time was up and it needed to be enacted
01:25:44 right away and recognizing that the parliamentary process is built into the act and was to come in
01:25:49 the days ahead we we thought that that was robust so did so essentially that conversation didn't
01:25:56 happen because it didn't have to there was already a parliamentary process built in yes is that fair
01:26:01 okay um and i just want to turn briefly now to the the the topic of revocation of the act which
01:26:08 which I know is skipping ahead again.
01:26:16 Mr. Clerk, if you can pull up Mr. Clough's notes again.
01:26:18 I don't know what we do without Mr. Clough's notes here.
01:26:21 SSM.nsc.can402941, page 28.
01:26:34 The only thing missing from the notes is clear page numbers.
01:26:37 always number the pages so this is february 19th uh it's a staff call and right at the bottom there
01:26:45 you say parliament's job is to confirm or confirm or revoke doesn't impact changes i believe after
01:26:53 revocation what happens to frozen accounts so that's a topic we've explored a bit with um
01:26:58 finance at what point do we withdraw based on what inputs um so is it fair to say at this point this
01:27:06 is a discussion of almost first principles um we we don't really know what the criteria are to
01:27:11 revoke we need to figure out what those criteria are was that an accurate reflection
01:27:18 it's hard to say for sure what that specific note refers to but
01:27:23 there was progress by that point the february 19th we were far from out of it there were still a lot
01:27:30 of situations there were still many threats and if i remember correctly ottawa was there may have
01:27:35 been the beginning of action but it wasn't done um so definitely at the irgs and on staff calls
01:27:42 and in other conversations we were beginning to ask ourselves okay what how long is this needed
01:27:49 and it was always understood and it was made clear by the prime minister
01:27:52 this should only be in place as long as it's needed so we were constantly asking ourselves
01:27:57 that very question what are what do we need to assess and what will feed into the decision
01:28:04 to revoke okay and there was no what i think what i was saying was there's no playbook for it so it
01:28:09 was essentially a discussion from first principles of trying to figure out what these criteria should
01:28:13 be we could scroll down a bit please mr clerk to the following day you'll see irg um not that one
01:28:20 on February 20th, so keep going.
01:28:33 So the first notation there says IRG February 20th,
01:28:37 RCMP slash officials public brief
01:28:41 on how long emergency act is needed.
01:28:43 Now we're gonna take this down
01:28:45 and bring up a different document, Mr. Clerk,
01:28:47 which is ssm.can.nsc402910.
01:28:54 This isn't something that's recorded in your notes, Mr. Clow.
01:28:57 What I'm gonna bring up is Commissioner Luckey's
01:29:01 key messages from that date.
01:29:02 So it's an RCMP document and I'm gonna take you through
01:29:06 and ask you whether your recollection
01:29:08 is that that was expressed during the IRG.
01:29:16 So there we go.
01:29:17 So the key messages are, as I said yesterday, the situation across the country remains concerning, volatile, and unpredictable.
01:29:25 We are continuing to see a range of protest events and solidarity actions across the country with Port Sventry and legislatures the key targets.
01:29:34 I want to underscore two key bottom lines off the top.
01:29:37 First, as it relates to Ottawa and Ontario, there is an operational need to maintain access to these powers to ensure that we can finish what we started and prevent any retrenchment, even for the next two to three weeks.
01:29:52 And then after that, it is important that we retain the ability to maintain the perimeter, restrict travel, and ensure we can continue to choke off financial support and other assistance to the protesters in Ottawa.
01:30:06 And then it goes on. Do you recall this having been expressed at the IRG that the emergencies act should stay in place by the RCMP, by Commissioner Lucky for another two or three weeks?
01:30:17 my colleagues may have stuff to add but I don't know if it was conveyed on the
01:30:23 20th but that was definitely a message right up to the revocation that the
01:30:27 RCMP believed that the powers were critical and they argued that they
01:30:32 should stay in place for a period longer in order to prevent additional
01:30:40 blockades from starting or from people from returning to the ones that existed
01:30:43 Okay. Ms. Telford, Mr. Broadhead, do you have anything to add to that?
01:30:48 No, that's...
01:30:48 I agree.
01:30:49 Okay. And as we know that that's not what happened in the end, the act was revoked three days later.
01:30:55 So is it fair to say that that input was received but not followed by, in the end, the government?
01:31:02 Important to point out is that both for the invocation and the revocation, the RCMP was one of many inputs.
01:31:09 So, for sure, this view would have been considered and was considered, but ultimately, the Prime Minister and the IRG decided to revoke when they decided to revoke, based on many different inputs.
01:31:22 Okay. One thing I wanted to ask you while about the revocation decision is there have been some suggestions that the motion to confirm the declaration of emergency had been passed through the House of Commons but was up for a vote in the Senate.
01:31:37 And that part of the timing of revocation may have been due to some perhaps lack of confidence around whether the Senate would confirm the declaration. Can you speak to that?
01:31:50 so quite the opposite actually and and yes i am aware of that suggestion that perhaps there's an
01:31:57 attempt to revoke before the senate got to its vote we actually wanted the senate to move as
01:32:04 quickly as possible and i think it did too but it was as it was reported to us the senate was delayed
01:32:10 in convening partly because of the ottawa very significant continuing ottawa demonstrations
01:32:15 that were happening right on the senate's doorstep they did begin their debate at a certain point
01:32:21 but that was not considered when it came to revocation the decisions around revocation
01:32:27 was what's the situation is this act still needed are these powers still needed um we would have
01:32:34 liked the senate to have its vote but i will also say i know of no reason to believe that the senate
01:32:38 would not have endorsed it and i i do believe that um i'm not sure about this but i do believe that
01:32:45 this commission has seen evidence that the chief of staff to senator gold the govern the the
01:32:52 government leader in the senate was doing vote counting and they were quite comfortable that
01:32:57 they were in a good place anything to add on that point just offered mr brada no i i completely agree
01:33:04 with what brian was just saying and i would just add that it was extraordinarily important to the
01:33:10 prime minister that it be that he'd be true to what he said out in the beginning when he invoked
01:33:15 the act and that it wasn't going to last one minute longer than absolutely necessary and so
01:33:20 that was the entire motivation behind when the revocation happened and the same way you know
01:33:26 safety and security was at the core of every meeting he was having throughout the politics
01:33:30 and parliamentary issues we're on a completely separate track from that decision making okay
01:33:37 um those are actually all the questions i have for you since given that the prime minister will
01:33:42 be here tomorrow and your boss will be speaking for himself um those are the questions that i
01:33:46 have for you this afternoon but before i sit down is there anything that we haven't covered here
01:33:50 today that you would like to say now that you have the opportunity i think we're good nope pretty
01:33:59 okay thank you commissioner those are my questions okay thank you very much um i think probably this
01:34:08 is a good time to take a 15 minute break and let everyone get up and stretch and so we'll come back
01:34:17 in 15 minutes thank you the Commission is in recess for 15 minutes
01:34:47 Thank you.
01:35:17 Thank you.
01:35:47 Thank you.
01:36:17 Thank you.
01:36:47 Thank you.
01:37:17 Thank you.
01:37:47 Thank you.
01:38:17 Thank you.
01:38:47 Thank you.
01:39:17 Thank you.
01:39:47 Thank you.
01:40:17 Thank you.
01:40:47 Thank you.
01:41:17 Thank you.
01:41:47 Thank you.
01:42:17 Thank you.
01:42:47 Thank you.
01:43:17 Thank you.
01:43:47 Thank you.
01:44:17 Thank you.
01:44:47 Thank you.
01:45:17 Thank you.
01:45:47 Thank you.
01:46:17 Thank you.
01:46:47 Thank you.
01:47:17 Thank you.
01:47:47 Thank you.
01:48:17 Thank you.
01:48:47 Thank you.
01:49:17 Thank you.
01:49:47 Thank you.
01:50:17 Thank you.
01:50:47 Thank you.
01:51:17 Thank you.
01:51:47 Thank you.
01:52:17 Thank you.
01:52:47 Thank you.
01:53:17 Thank you.
01:53:47 Order alert.
01:54:07 The Commission has reconvened.
01:54:08 The Commission of Plans.
01:54:11 Okay.
01:54:14 Now the next stage.
01:54:17 i'd like to call on a government of alberta please
01:54:23 good evening um to this panel my name is stephanie bows i am counsel for the province of alberta
01:54:30 um i just want to start with um the statement in the pmo institutional report which indicates that
01:54:37 pmo staff engaged with premier kenny's chief of staff miss livingstone on february 5th and 12th
01:54:44 i just want to confirm that during that time the pmo did not discuss the possible use of the
01:54:49 emergencies act during those engagements is that correct that it was not me having that
01:54:55 those conversations but that is my understanding yes okay thank you and with respect to the first
01:55:01 ministers meeting mr broadhead you were asked about your understanding of the various positions
01:55:07 of premiers at that meeting i'd like the clerk to pull up ssm.nsc.can 50625
01:55:21 and these are some expanded notes prepared and produced by the government of canada describing
01:55:26 that meeting once we have them up i'll ask the clerk to please scroll down to page three
01:55:31 okay so we can see here that there's some some further notes about the comments of premier
01:55:41 kenny at this meeting and i'll just walk through some of these right now um he starts by describing
01:55:46 the situation in coots and how it went from a thousand trucks on a rolling protest to 900 going
01:55:53 home with 100 staying behind and then down to a group of 40 which he described as a core group
01:55:59 then you'll see him describe the arrests at the border and indicate we believe the situation has
01:56:05 been secured and further down there have procured on market for equipment and have drivers in place
01:56:13 unless an unexpected surprise should open codes border crossing today a little farther down again
01:56:21 would be problematic to declare emergency today to take momentum of arrest last night
01:56:27 declaration risks further radicalizing thousands of sympathizers in alberta know you have a lot
01:56:34 of serious issues to balance off including in ottawa but i am suggesting this could create
01:56:40 a net negative for alberta if we need to seize or compel people we are prepared to use our own
01:56:47 emergencies act so you would agree that it's fair to say that the premier's position
01:56:52 at this first minister's meeting was that invoking the federal emergencies act was
01:56:57 neither wanted nor needed in alberta correct
01:57:01 yeah i would i would say he he was um definitely clear that he did not believe it was needed in
01:57:10 alberta at that time okay thank you and i'd like to um switch tracks with you and ask about what
01:57:18 was done to prepare the prime minister for the february 13th cabinet meeting and specifically
01:57:25 where his inputs of information came from so i'm going to ask you you can answer yes or no
01:57:30 whether the pmo was responsible for providing the prime minister with the following information
01:57:39 and that's about the status of the rcmp operation in coups was it the print the pmo that was
01:57:47 responsible for providing that information to the Prime Minister? No. How about the status
01:57:53 of Alberta's acquisition of tow trucks from the private market? The Privy Council leads these
01:58:02 briefings that you're referring to. Okay, so I'll just name off a few more, and maybe then you can
01:58:08 tell me if there was anything in my list that the PMO was responsible for providing the information
01:58:14 to the prime minister and those are the status of the protests in windsor at the ambassador bridge
01:58:19 the status of opening of the ambassador bridge the status of the ops operational plan with respect to
01:58:26 the protests in ottawa or that the commissioner commissioner lucky was of the view that not all
01:58:31 tools available through existing legislation had yet been exhausted we may have added information
01:58:39 if we'd heard it through minister's offices or um through open source information but the briefing
01:58:45 on all the matters you would have been led by the clerk of the privy council the deputy clerk of the
01:58:50 nsia okay thank you i would just add that we heard at various points in the weeks leading up to
01:58:58 invocation of the act that action was about to be taken in some of the places that you mentioned
01:59:03 and on the point about rcmp stating that not all tools have been exhausted that was obvious to
01:59:10 everyone in various locations law enforcement had tools that they weren't able to enforce
01:59:15 because there were other more serious issues preventing that and that's partly why decision
01:59:21 was making to made to invoke the act the next day okay and so you would agree that the prime
01:59:27 minister had that information as well that there were tools available but that they weren't being
01:59:31 used as i said that was obvious to everyone who was watching what was going on the ground
01:59:36 okay thank you um i would like the clerk to please pull up ssm dot nsc dot can four zeros
01:59:45 two nine four one and this is a record that um commission council has taken you through
01:59:51 in some detail already there's just a few places where i was hoping you could help me
01:59:55 me read some of the writing. So, Mr. Clerk, if you could please scroll down to page 12.
02:00:14 Actually, this is not something that I need clarification on the writing on,
02:00:17 but something I do have a question on. Let me just make sure I'm in the right place here.
02:00:25 So if you see on the right-hand side, there's a note beside Brenda, and I'm assuming this is Commissioner Luckey, is that correct?
02:00:33 Yes.
02:00:34 Okay. And she indicates with respect to Coutts, they were almost gone, but a pastor incited them to stay, was 250 vehicles, now down to 40, and weapons are in the protest, need to go slow here.
02:00:51 Was the Prime Minister part of this conversation?
02:00:54 Yes, he was.
02:00:54 This was the February 10th incident response group meeting.
02:00:57 Okay, good.
02:00:58 Thank you.
02:01:02 And then if we go to page 23, here's where I'll need your help interpreting the writing.
02:01:10 Thank you.
02:01:11 So we can see about a quarter of the way down the page.
02:01:14 There's an arrow and it says specific.
02:01:17 And what's the next word after that?
02:01:23 to be honest i can't read it either the quality of the photocopy is not it's not strong okay
02:01:34 so specific something draft list using the money as uh and then what's that next word there as a
02:01:42 hook for the national stuff so this was a reference to there we knew and we heard on the fmm call
02:01:49 that some premiers and some people felt that the act should not be provided applied nationally
02:01:56 and this comment referred to needing to underscore in the communications that part of the reason the
02:02:02 act needed to apply nationally was so that it would apply to financial transactions across
02:02:07 the country given many of the demonstrators were from across the country and do yeah i think you
02:02:14 just said that this was about needing to refer in the communications what communications are you
02:02:18 talking about so this was february 14th 12 30 pm after the fmm as preparations were underway for a
02:02:27 potential prime ministerial announcement later that afternoon prime minister took the decision
02:02:33 to invoke the act later that afternoon and he went out and announced it okay now i'd like to talk a
02:02:40 little bit about that announcement if we can go to um ssm.can402665
02:03:03 and if we go to the very last email in this record
02:03:11 there's a discussion of a press conference that was at that time scheduled for noon on february
02:03:17 14th and we'll see the time of this email is listed as february 13th 8 pm now i'm not sure
02:03:23 if this is one of the emails that's caught with the time difference related to greenwich mean
02:03:29 time but it's either 3 pm or 8 pm on the 13th in either event that's before the cabinet meeting
02:03:37 correct i can't i can't confirm the timing of the email but it could be okay and it indicates that
02:03:50 there was going to be a press conference the next day with the prime minister the deputy
02:03:55 prime minister minister blair minister mendicino and minister limetti there's a bit more discussion
02:04:03 in other emails, including that Minister Lemony is there just to answer questions, and that only
02:04:08 the Prime Minister and the Deputy Prime Minister will provide comments. Is this because that was
02:04:14 the press conference that was intended to announce the invocation of the Emergencies Act?
02:04:21 So what I would say is, at this point, there were numerous statements being made by the Prime
02:04:26 Minister and other ministers to media, sometimes in the form of a press conference. My recollection
02:04:32 was this was planning for a statement of some sort and yes given the emergencies act was under
02:04:38 consideration it was a scenario at that time that they could be making announcements about
02:04:44 the emergencies act the next day but the decision had not been taken at that point so you'll see
02:04:49 that it says as you know the presser is to provide an update on the federal government response to
02:04:53 the blockades as well as the ukraine and i'll take it from your answer that there was some anticipation
02:04:58 that maybe it might be about the emergencies act but what other announcement was going to be made
02:05:03 about the blockades the next day there could have been any number of of measures taken and
02:05:11 that's that was the examination going on exactly at that time what tools could exist
02:05:19 is it going to be enough decision was emergencies act had the tools required
02:05:23 and that's why the decision was taken the next day
02:05:25 and i understand that part of the dmo's role is to prepare speeches for the prime minister is that
02:05:33 correct the dpmo no the prime minister's office and pco prepare speeches for the prime minister
02:05:43 sorry i thought in the institutional report that there was mention of drafting speeches by the
02:05:50 prime minister's oh did i'm sorry by the prime minister's office yes absolutely okay i'm sorry
02:05:55 I misspoke there. Did the Prime Minister's office… Just to let you know, I think you're
02:06:01 over your time, so you're going to have to wrap up pretty soon. Okay, I'll just finish this area.
02:06:07 Did the Deputy Prime Minister's office draft a speech for the Prime Minister for the press
02:06:11 conference on February 14th? I'm not aware. You're not aware, okay. Thank you,
02:06:16 those are all my questions tonight. Okay, thank you. Next call on the convoy organizers, please.
02:06:25 Sir, before I begin, I have an issue that I need to address.
02:06:39 As you know, and I've made applications several times, the disclosure in the record is entirely
02:06:46 deficient.
02:06:47 We've been trying to deal with these redactions.
02:06:51 There's still redactions for parliamentary privilege which the government has not removed.
02:06:56 There's no legal basis for, as you've already ruled, to redact any document on the basis
02:07:02 of parliamentary privilege.
02:07:04 There's also the issue, as I've re-raised by email as well, the issue with the notes
02:07:11 of this witness, the process that was used in dealing with that needs to be reassessed.
02:07:19 These are important witnesses.
02:07:20 I need rulings and so does everyone here.
02:07:25 The rulings on the redactions are so important and, for example, Ms. Jodie Thomas testified
02:07:34 and said that she supported the invocation of the Emergencies Act but there's a note
02:07:42 that we got after we fought for the one redaction we got that said Jodie Thomas did not.
02:07:50 it was put up on the screen it was notes taken it had one section 39 redaction on it so if that's
02:07:56 a cabinet document we can assume cabinet knew about it and it states that section 2 no violence
02:08:03 and they're trying to come up with a way how to make this work anyway that would have been very
02:08:09 helpful to have when she was on the stand under oath this is happening constantly there is thousands
02:08:19 of documents if you can i'm not looking for a speech i understand there has been have been
02:08:26 issues about uh redactions i believe that one is one i already disclosed and i believe you
02:08:32 questioned somebody about it as recently as yesterday or the day before um i am not sure
02:08:41 about the redactions certainly for just to qualify the redactions with respect to parliamentary
02:08:46 privilege i didn't say it doesn't exist i said i said it was novel and that the arguments presented
02:08:55 were insufficient and i ordered the three redactions disclosed we received something i
02:09:01 i think it's yesterday or maybe it was even today and i apologize i haven't yet ruled on it that's
02:09:07 true but i do my very best to make decisions i try my very best to make them intelligent and
02:09:16 thoughtful and that sometimes is not done immediately so that's that's sort of how i
02:09:23 can respond to those points sir i can make it very easy and we've written your council uh for
02:09:30 a set of them so the law is such that where a redaction is sought on the basis of irrelevance
02:09:37 it is not the onus of the person seeking to have it redacted on the basis of irrelevance it's the
02:09:44 onus on the person seeking for it to be redacted and the purpose for that is is that all of the
02:09:49 documents given to us are subject to the implied undertaking rule so they're they don't become
02:09:53 public until a ruling on their relevance is made okay well i i'm not in a position to rule on
02:10:02 that i i suspect that's the mode the the request you made either yesterday or today i don't know
02:10:07 which and i'm sorry i'm not in a position to rule on it right now sir but so what i'd like you is
02:10:13 if you could proceed with your examination or that would be i think ideal at this stage and
02:10:20 and I'll do my best to deal with the motion
02:10:23 of the redaction issues as soon as possible.
02:10:27 Okay, but I just wanna put on the record
02:10:29 that throughout this entire proceeding,
02:10:32 all council here, and we're on national television,
02:10:35 this is supposed to be completely transparent.
02:10:37 This is the purpose of this.
02:10:39 I'm doing my very best.
02:10:40 It's not your fault, it's just the fault
02:10:43 that nobody's ordering DOJ to actually produce
02:10:46 what they're obliged to do.
02:10:48 Well, that's something you can deal with in another forum.
02:10:52 I'm doing the best I can here.
02:10:53 I think we've gotten a lot of disclosure.
02:10:57 There are issues, and we're dealing with those issues that are raised as they are raised.
02:11:01 We dealt with the ones you raised, I believe, at the end of last week,
02:11:06 made some orders, confirmed some of the redactions,
02:11:10 and we'll deal with your most current application.
02:11:14 But could you just not order that the redactions for parliamentary privilege, because I can tell you, I've studied that area in and out.
02:11:27 And the reason no one could provide you an authority for the purpose of a redaction on the basis of parliamentary privilege is it doesn't exist.
02:11:35 And parliamentary privilege is, of course, an ancient doctrine.
02:11:38 And if you would just order the production of the records without those redactions, it would remove a whole bunch.
02:11:46 Then if you would order the production of all relevant records with respect where relevant is claimed, those records are then subject to the implied undertaking rule.
02:11:58 And there's no national security issue with those.
02:12:00 If they were, Section 38 would be claimed.
02:12:03 There's no Cabinet confidence because Section 39 is not claimed.
02:12:06 and that's it that has been the law it's time immemorial how can you contest if something's
02:12:12 relevant if you don't know what it says and my problem is is that this witness is now on the
02:12:21 stand one of the documents is key in my submission it is the notes of miss jackson which is the office
02:12:29 assistant to this witness there are redactions therein on the basis of irrelevance and there
02:12:36 There are redactions therein, also I believe on one of the other grounds that I've sent
02:12:42 a written motion, if you will, email to your council.
02:12:46 We've been asking for these things and asking for proper production throughout this proceeding.
02:12:51 All council are in agreement that we don't have proper production, sir.
02:12:55 Okay, well, I'm not sure you can speak for all council and I'm sure they can speak for
02:12:58 themselves as to whether or not you've been asking for this a long time.
02:13:03 i'm not aware that you asked about those redactions so uh but but maybe i don't have the
02:13:10 records but anyways we're gonna have to stop this and and despite your belief that the law is always
02:13:17 very clear my experience of 20 years is there's that's why judges have are around and so if you
02:13:23 could proceed otherwise you know we're not going to get anywhere so so if i could bring up uh the
02:13:30 notes of miss jackson which are at
02:13:50 uh sm.can.7719
02:14:00 Okay. So, Ms. Telford, Sarah Jackson, she's your office manager, is this correct?
02:14:09 Yes.
02:14:11 All right. And so, obviously, she's a scribe and does scribing for you when you're in meetings?
02:14:18 No.
02:14:19 All right. So, the notes that she takes, she has, if we can scroll down.
02:14:25 and down
02:14:30 right so that says kt call and i take it that's you
02:14:36 kt usually does refer to me right so she's taking notes of a phone call she has with you
02:14:42 i don't know you don't know so that's on february 4th do you remember february 4th
02:14:50 yes okay so what happened on February 4th um well no I don't remember in that level of detail
02:15:02 okay is there something you're looking for in particular well I'm trying to find out
02:15:06 because I have to build a record for this do you have any idea why
02:15:11 anything in your conversation on February 4th in that note would be irrelevant
02:15:16 i don't know and i take it when you spoke to miss telford or sorry to
02:15:23 uh this uh individual at the time there was no lawyer present was there i don't know what this
02:15:31 call is okay so can we scroll down then so you see there the government has claimed solicitor
02:15:37 client privilege okay and you don't remember speaking with a lawyer on february 4th do you
02:15:43 as i said i don't know what this call is right so how would the government know
02:15:50 if you don't know that this is solicitor client privileged
02:15:55 they couldn't could they so it's redacted and this is the problem sir uh you have irrelevant
02:16:04 irrelevant is there a question yes and so if we can scroll down
02:16:08 okay and in that note on february 4th i know you don't have a good memory but in your conversation
02:16:16 that's that's it no i know good memory of february 4th i know she doesn't have a good
02:16:21 memory of it but it wasn't an insult uh blair's current strategy emergencies act right
02:16:27 so i take it you're understanding she's writing down what you're saying and you told her that
02:16:35 blair's current strategy is the emergencies act so it was ministers blair's strategy to invoke
02:16:43 the emergencies act on february 4th that's your understanding isn't it no that's not my
02:16:48 understanding so what was blair's current strategy emergencies act on february 20 or february 4th
02:16:54 2022 i can't speak to what's written here you don't remember no if you wanted to
02:17:05 pull up notes of mine from february 4th that might be helpful but i can't speak to these do you have
02:17:10 notes from february 4th notes from a lot of days that have been provided you've been provided okay
02:17:17 have you provided all of them to the department of justice okay and would you say that you provided
02:17:23 notes from each and every single day from any day i have notes on okay and with respect to this
02:17:32 meeting do you remember what you and uh miss jackson were talking about
02:17:38 i unfortunately don't know what meeting she's taking notes from here without more context
02:17:43 it may or may not even be a meeting i was in but obviously you were discussing the emergencies act
02:17:52 the emergencies act came up at numerous occasions as we've said earlier in
02:17:55 okay earlier today do you think it would assist the tribunal in this inquiry if miss jackson
02:18:01 testifies no i think i can answer any questions you might have but you can answer what that note
02:18:07 says is there something you're curious about that note in particular well on february 4th of 2022
02:18:15 miss jackson in a conversation with you writes down blair's current strategy emergency sack
02:18:21 right and we you hadn't even had an irg at that point i believe you've had an opportunity to speak
02:18:29 with minister blair yeah and i put this to him and he said that it wasn't true
02:18:33 so wouldn't it be helpful if you can't remember i'm not sure that was correct
02:18:39 that he said he said that he never had i put the note to him and he said that
02:18:44 that's not wasn't a strategy that that's incorrect that doesn't mean it isn't true i mean all this
02:18:51 note says is blair's current strategy and emergency act underneath it so on february 4th
02:18:59 When was the first time that the government came out and spoke that they were considering invoking the Emergencies Act? Do you remember?
02:19:08 Publicly?
02:19:09 Yeah.
02:19:11 I mean, there were questions from the media where ministers were speaking about the Emergencies Act long before it was invoked.
02:19:19 Yeah. And Minister Blair, I discussed this with him, on February 13th, for the first time he went on a show and he talked about that it was under consideration from the outset.
02:19:34 But then when he testified here, he said it wasn't.
02:19:39 So was the invocation of the Emergencies Act under consideration from the beginning of the protest in Ottawa?
02:19:46 the emergencies act was something that was discussed at the beginning of the pandemic
02:19:52 and it was a public conversation at that time as well as a private conversation there were
02:19:57 calls for the prime minister if we can put the document back up please
02:20:00 perhaps it's brian gover for the government of canada perhaps the witness could complete
02:20:06 her answer to the question without interruption oh no i've just the document went down i'm not done
02:20:11 i apologize so thank you so and i understand that there was a consideration of a public welfare
02:20:21 emergency right that's very different than a public order emergency you know that there
02:20:26 doesn't have to be a section two security threat right and are you talking about i'm not sure when
02:20:33 you're talking about we're talking about from covid because you said it was under consideration then
02:20:37 They did look at the Emergencies Act at that time, and there was a public call for that at the time, and it was determined because the Prime Minister was very reluctant, as he was during the occupation this past February, to invoke it.
02:20:51 And so there's been conversations on various occasions about the Emergencies Act over time.
02:20:56 So when that note's taken on February 4th, 2022, are you saying that you're talking about it in relation to COVID?
02:21:04 i genuinely don't know what this note is as i've already said to you a few times
02:21:10 okay so if i can scroll up or down or up please or down but we'll go down down's fine
02:21:18 okay so that says flag 2kt february 10th and it's written in there that this is irrelevant
02:21:29 what does that mean why is it irrelevant do you know because i don't know specifically
02:21:36 i don't know either i could surmise that flag to katie means it's probably a bit of a to-do
02:21:42 list of things she wanted to flag to me that were obviously deemed irrelevant to what we
02:21:47 are talking about today okay and could we scroll down again and this one where it says staff
02:21:53 blockade right and then it has section 39 invoked do you know what that means i don't know why they
02:22:02 invoked it there right and so i take it when you were having this phone call there was no one else
02:22:09 present on the phone other than you and miss jackson was there i don't believe that this is
02:22:13 a phone call any longer well if we scroll back up this is the second page it's the way it's
02:22:17 said flag to Katie at the top. Flag to Katie okay and so on February 10th do you remember if Ms.
02:22:25 Jackson was in a meeting with cabinet? She is not normally in meetings with cabinet. So how could
02:22:32 section 39's cabinet confidence so how can so it this is the problem those are my questions.
02:22:41 Thank you. If we could now call on the Ottawa Police Service, please.
02:23:01 Good evening. My name is David Michikowska. I'm a lawyer for Ottawa Police Service.
02:23:05 um miss telford my questions at least initially will be directed to you
02:23:13 i understand that the pmo relies on the rcmp
02:23:18 generally but what do you mean uh well you really i i guess pmo relies on the rcmp to protect the
02:23:25 prime minister and others yes and you trust the rcmp you do um the rcmp has kept the prime minister
02:23:33 and his family safe? They have. And the RCMP takes security very seriously? They do. And one of the
02:23:45 documents, I won't take you to it, but I believe the Commission took you to it, one of the documents
02:23:53 that you were taken to reference the intersect group. You're familiar with the intersect group?
02:23:58 can you remind me sure um it was described in that document as a group that gets uh stood up
02:24:08 and is um composed of the ops the rcmp pps opp you're familiar with that yes and all of them
02:24:18 are involved in decisions and discussions about these types of protest events and security concerns
02:24:25 correct that sounds right and in fact in that chain of the emails that you were
02:24:33 taken to there's reference and it was on January 25th miss powers indicates that
02:24:40 the key will be tomorrow's intersect meeting and how law enforcement will
02:24:45 pre-mobilize so you're obviously aware that the RCMP whom you have a lot of
02:24:52 confidence in is monitoring the protest as it's approaching ottawa correct yes and on um january
02:25:03 27th um and i i won't pull it up but i'll give the reference for the record it's pb dot can four zeros
02:25:13 one eight four four um there's a series of um text messages uh i believe between minister
02:25:22 mendocino and yourself and you indicate that the rcmp or he indicates to you that the rcmp on
02:25:30 january 27th says that the current estimate is about 2700 trucks but the numbers could fluctuate
02:25:37 do you recall that that sounds right and uh there's another um document um from the pmo i
02:25:47 believe it's from ms power um she's the issues advisor she's one of several issues advisor but
02:25:54 she holds the file for public safety and so there's an email from her on january 28th
02:26:01 um again uh the reference number is ssm.can.nsc402795 and she gives some more uh data as to what the
02:26:14 status is one of the things that she references in that uh report on the latest numbers is um
02:26:22 Project Hendon and we've heard a lot about Project Hendon uh was that something that you were familiar
02:26:28 with as well? Not at the time. I'm sorry? Not at the time. Okay. Subsequently, you did hear about
02:26:35 Project Hendon. Is that right? During the inquiry, I've heard a fair bit. Right. And so she's
02:26:40 referring to, so obviously, the RCMP, I'm assuming, has access to the same Hendon data as the other
02:26:48 security services. Fair assumption? I couldn't speak to what information they had access to.
02:26:55 okay um and so what we see when we look at all of these um documents that i'm referring to is
02:27:02 the numbers of vehicles of trucks in the convoy in the last couple days before it arrives is a
02:27:11 constantly fluctuating number nobody seems to be able to get a full grasp on is that fair it certainly
02:27:18 felt that way and certainly nobody uh even the rcmp up until that day the friday were saying that
02:27:27 this protest was going to become an occupation correct i will say in those in those updates
02:27:34 that were coming from mary liz power and they were more than once daily by the end of the week
02:27:41 there were some references and i do believe this commission has seen in those emails and i think it
02:27:45 was attributed to op intersect that this could be a prolonged demonstration but you are right there
02:27:53 was a lot of uncertainty about what was coming and so you understood that even the law enforcement
02:28:01 community couldn't predict exactly what occurred and what did in fact occur fair
02:28:09 i agree this was a challenging situation for everyone and you wouldn't fault the rcmp for that
02:28:14 would you? No. You've talked about what you saw on social media in the days leading up to it,
02:28:25 and CSIS has told us that analyzing social media is rather complex and requires more than simply
02:28:34 scrolling through social media. You wouldn't have any reason to disagree with that, would you?
02:28:38 I think it's a fair statement, but there are some things said on social media that represent clearly the views of the person expressing it.
02:28:53 And in this case, in this demonstration, there were statements made on social media about threats of violence, threats to individuals, and aims and motives that they had.
02:29:03 I'm sorry, I don't mean to cut you off, but I have a very limited amount of time.
02:29:07 My question was more related to the numbers of people that are coming on social media, because what Mr. Vigneault said is it is difficult to tell.
02:29:18 It's a challenge, I think he said, to know when someone moves from the online space to physical space and the social media is full of misinformation.
02:29:29 Ms. Telford, you wouldn't disagree with that, would you?
02:29:31 I think it was challenging for everyone. And that's why it was important to bring everyone together at various points. But I do think there was, I think, you know, I think the number of people, including Mr. Vigneault, have spoken about how figuring out the social media space is something that needs to be done coming out of this.
02:29:51 right um and you recognize um just moving on to another area you recognize that police and we've
02:29:58 heard from a number of ministers that police need to have operational independence from governments
02:30:05 absolutely and that police have to make operational decisions in real time for reasons that may not
02:30:15 be evident to the government and or to the public fair of course and that's something we took very
02:30:21 very seriously and uh again you respected that operational independence you wouldn't want the
02:30:27 police whether it's the ottawa or opp or the rcmp to take action without considering what impact
02:30:35 that action would have on officer safety or crowd safety or children in the crowd of course
02:30:43 and in fact one of the lessons of ipriwash that we've heard is that governments should not be
02:30:48 allowed to influence specific law enforcement operational decisions you'd agree with that
02:30:55 fair it was actually something i asked after and we got a verbal brief on very early on i think it
02:31:02 was actually even before uh it all got uh before it became even an occupation um because it was
02:31:08 something we were very preoccupied about respecting and that did and it's because decisions those type
02:31:15 of operational decisions belong to the police based on their expertise and their discretion
02:31:21 correct yes and there's nothing to suggest that the ottawa police service did not exercise their
02:31:29 discretion legitimately and in good faith in this case is that fair fair um the situation we've heard
02:31:39 in ottawa was i'm going to use a word that we've all heard a lot in this was a volatile one um you
02:31:47 wouldn't disagree with that it was extremely volatile and ultimately that situation was
02:31:53 diffused uh but you'd agree with me that diffusing a situation like this one uh is something that
02:32:01 takes time in fact the prime minister in a conversation with the governor general on
02:32:07 February 5th specifically made that point when he said it's going to take time to defuse this.
02:32:15 You wouldn't disagree with that, would you? I believe that conversation was a ways into
02:32:19 the occupation already. So I don't think I can agree or disagree with whether or not
02:32:27 these things always take time. And ultimately in addition to time,
02:32:31 it took a massive amount of additional resources as well, correct?
02:32:37 It certainly did in this instance.
02:32:39 And those, let me just finish off my remaining minute or two.
02:32:47 Negotiations, you understand that before police execute a tactical operation,
02:32:53 they will try and diffuse the situation and try to negotiate, right?
02:32:59 These were things we were briefed on, yes.
02:33:01 And in fact, you'll recall that the Prime Minister and Minister Blair met with opposition leaders
02:33:07 leaders and provided a briefing on february 10th and if that briefing the national security and
02:33:13 intelligence advisor specifically said law enforcement activities are in line with
02:33:20 negotiations with organizers to ensure there's no violence that makes sense to you doesn't it yes
02:33:28 and she also uh indicated that minister uh blair um talked about the importance of negotiation by
02:33:36 the police and you wouldn't disagree with what minister blair said no i believe and i believe
02:33:42 this was the first call with the opposition leaders that was earlier on in the occupation
02:33:46 is that right uh i'm not sure if it was the first or the second i'm pretty sure it was the first
02:33:52 um now we we talked about the um engagement proposal that was prepared as a framework for
02:33:58 negotiation and i understand that deputy minister stewart on february 11th advised that that
02:34:06 engagement proposal had been prepared and validated with the opp expert marcel bodin
02:34:13 do you recall that i know he worked with somebody in the opp and in fact chief slowly had earlier on
02:34:20 also requested an interlocutor uh be used uh as a method of achieving a breakthrough you're aware
02:34:27 that? I'm not sure. And one of the rationales, and I'll just finish off this point if I may,
02:34:37 Commissioner, one of the rationales that you mentioned in your witness statement for why the
02:34:44 engagement proposal went nowhere was the what happened in Windsor. And when I looked at the
02:34:54 record there's an indication um in a document that we'd seen previously it's pbnsc.can402963
02:35:08 deputy minister stewart said that the reason the letter from ontario minister jones didn't have
02:35:14 much effect was owing to the late hour of the day in which it was given out and the enforcement
02:35:21 starting the next morning you wouldn't have any reason to disagree with that would you
02:35:27 i i do believe that's what deputy the deputy minister said right and after the engagement
02:35:33 proposal was um discarded as an idea nobody went back to the police and said or marcel
02:35:41 bodin and said hey what else should we do is that fair it wasn't discarded as an idea
02:35:48 there was nothing to act on i do think those are different things okay thank you very much
02:35:54 uh those are my questions thank you if i could uh now ask for the ccla please
02:36:18 Good afternoon. My name is Kara Zwiebel. I'm counsel for the Canadian Civil Liberties
02:36:25 Association. Mr. Commissioner, my friend Mr. Honor from the Democracy Fund has given
02:36:30 me five of his minutes, and he's going to limit his questioning to five minutes, so
02:36:34 I have 15 now on my count.
02:36:37 Okay.
02:36:38 So, I want to ask you about a theme that my friend Mr. Michikowski was just asking
02:36:45 you about um around sort of this this question about um uh the proper relationship between
02:36:52 police and government um and i would imagine that as um both you know employees in the prime
02:36:58 minister's office and obviously residents of ottawa um it might be difficult to sort of
02:37:04 separate the fact that you're looking at at what's going on both from a policy perspective but also
02:37:10 living through it um on right you live here i don't oh you don't live i live in toronto oh okay
02:37:16 um so so some of you live here um um now i i know you have access to uh to briefings from the rcmp
02:37:27 um i'm not sure if you get if you get uh briefings or sit in on briefings from any of the intelligence
02:37:34 uh bodies um but i i think we've seen some documents um that also sort of show you doing a
02:37:42 bit a bit of your own you know getting information as we all do from media sources from uh social
02:37:48 media um so for example can we can we pull up ssm nsc can four zeros two nine four zero
02:37:57 And I think, Ms. Telford, this is a text message between you and the Prime Minister.
02:38:09 I think it's a tweet from a reporter.
02:38:15 An admission police can, this is February 2nd, an admission police cannot control the situation.
02:38:21 This is a complete mess and textbook mismanagement.
02:38:23 they allowed the truckers to set up shop next to the pmo and west block and where tens of thousands
02:38:28 of people live and now realize the problem they helped create unbelievable and i i think this is
02:38:33 the prime minister writing to you the pps i think that's parliamentary protective service
02:38:39 rcmp guy and caucus said as much he said he didn't want to let them onto wellington
02:38:43 but it wasn't his call um so so are you sharing this with the prime minister as just sort of
02:38:50 here's what's happening on the ground, here's what people are talking about,
02:38:54 here's what's in the zeitgeist?
02:38:57 In a manner of speaking, you'll find through a lot of the texts that I submitted
02:39:02 a lot of different tweets, as well as information from the Prime Minister's
02:39:10 executive assistant who lived right in Centre Town and was keeping him posted
02:39:15 on what it was like on the ground.
02:39:17 Okay. And then can we also pull up SSM CAN 407729?
02:39:41 I forget that they're also here, but I can't really see them.
02:39:44 so um so over here uh again i think can we just scroll down just a little bit so this is evan
02:39:50 solomon just walked through the protest on parliament hill tonight and i spoke to two
02:39:54 guys carrying fuel containers past police the police chief said protesters would not be allowed
02:40:00 to bring fuel to i think that's trucks but these two said police aren't bothering them at all no
02:40:05 enforcement um and i i think this is you uh sorry can we scroll up was this one of your texts no
02:40:11 it's not actually so what you can't see there is that also in this chat is um is the prime minister's
02:40:18 uh executive assistant or was executive assistant at that time okay and so that's an example of what
02:40:23 i was just describing okay um and can we scroll down um so saw this type of thing happen when i
02:40:29 left hill gas coming in and cops were just standing looking at them walk by and we've heard evidence
02:40:35 in the commission that um at some point protesters started filling jerry cans with water um as a bit
02:40:41 of a tactic so that it looked like the police weren't doing anything about gas being brought
02:40:46 in but in fact it was it was water is that something that you were aware of or have you
02:40:50 have you heard about that uh during the course of the commission i've heard a number of things to do
02:40:57 with the jury cans over the course of the commission okay um is it fair to say that what you were
02:41:04 seeing both on social media and in the media and on the ground here in ottawa as as residents um or
02:41:11 part-time residents maybe um weren't sort of matching what you were hearing from from the
02:41:17 police from uh briefings from the rcmp i think especially in the early days there were a lot
02:41:26 of different numbers uh coming from what we were seeing on social media what we were seeing reported
02:41:31 from mainstream media who were you know walking around and and doing their own counts um as well
02:41:38 as what was coming in from different law enforcement agencies okay um can we go to um
02:41:45 mr clow's notes ssm nsc can four zeros two nine four one it's page 11 of the pdf
02:41:53 And if you can make it just a bit bigger. So I think I don't think we have a date on
02:42:11 this, although I think based on where it's placed in the
02:42:17 document, we're maybe I think it's after the note that you
02:42:24 identified Mr. Clow as being on February 9. And it's February
02:42:27 10. Okay. So February 10. So this is I think that is this the
02:42:32 three of you? Or is this the other JB? The other JB? Okay,
02:42:36 the other JB and the Prime Minister. Katie will call
02:42:40 clerk next you're not being briefed by intel officials someone on us side who can give best
02:42:47 advice um surely someone in system someone played out plan uh and i'm not sure what rcmp intel lucky
02:42:59 anyone else to report on this so what is this can you tell me what this note means not being briefed
02:43:04 by intel officials yes so that morning so this was february 10th there were a series of meetings that
02:43:09 led up to the incident response group that happened later that day so right before this
02:43:14 note a meeting a discussion happened between the prime minister and several ministers including
02:43:20 minister medicino minister blair where he was updated and went around the table full discussion
02:43:27 of the current situation this discussion was a debrief of the prime minister and a few of us
02:43:33 staff members coming out of that meeting so you see some next steps and i believe the comment
02:43:39 about intel was a reflection that we were absolutely getting a lot of information
02:43:43 particularly from the national security intelligence advisor but there was an interest in
02:43:48 more of it and there was still an incomplete picture when you looked at the various
02:43:55 blockades and demonstrations across the country and what was behind it and what was going into
02:44:00 it and where was it going okay so so not a lack of intelligence but not as much as you wanted
02:44:07 is that fair right okay um in your witness um summary and i can bring it up if you'd like but
02:44:14 there's the lessons learned sort of section or a place where you're you're pointing out some um
02:44:21 you know areas that you hoped the commission could comment on and one of the things you say there um
02:44:27 The panel suggested that the Commission provide further guidance on the independence of police
02:44:33 operations. Mr. Broadhurst, so that's the other one who's not here, sorry, underscored that the
02:44:40 government understands the importance of not dictating police operations, and at times it was
02:44:45 difficult to know whether the police and the government shared the same ultimate goal. The
02:44:50 government should be able to discuss a desired outcome, for example, to clear the occupation and
02:44:55 blockades and share concerns about the consequences that the country would face if that does not
02:44:59 happen. Did you, during the time that the blockades and occupation were happening, did you have
02:45:07 doubts about whether the police planned to clear them? I don't think it's a question of whether
02:45:16 they planned to clear them, but that there were on multiple occasions where we were being briefed
02:45:21 that things were going to happen that then didn't happen.
02:45:25 So we found ourselves three weeks in with with things continuing to escalate.
02:45:34 OK, but you would say that you you did believe that you that police
02:45:37 and government had the same ultimate goal.
02:45:40 There were frustrations and maybe mismatches in terms of timing.
02:45:44 But was there a doubt in your mind that the did like I know it sounds silly,
02:45:50 but did you think that the police's plan was to was to just allow this to continue no the concern
02:45:55 was do they have the tools or is there more that could be done by the federal government provinces
02:46:02 municipalities could we support them more that was the discussion and concern okay um and once
02:46:08 the emergencies act what was invoked um i've talked to this about some other witnesses and
02:46:13 and i think they've agreed that um although government can't direct police one of the things
02:46:18 that a public order emergency does is communicate very clearly to police that there are certain
02:46:24 things that the government wants to happen and they're giving them the tools to make those
02:46:29 things happen do you agree with that so in this case the government wants uh the flow of funds
02:46:39 to stop going to people that are funding the blockades right and it's giving the rcmp
02:46:45 and financial institutions the tools to make that happen the government the cabinet the
02:46:51 prime minister wanted the unlawful activity and the threats to stop and the emergencies act and
02:46:57 the measures in it was the best assessment of what could be provided as additional tools
02:47:04 to help the unlawful activities stop okay um and once the emergencies act was in place and
02:47:11 the orders were in place um i know the irg continued to meet um and there was some tracking
02:47:18 of of the measures of how the measures were working right there was an attempt to collect
02:47:23 that information so that you could see um what impact the orders were having is that fair
02:47:30 yes okay thank you um one other area i want to talk about i i understood your evidence on the
02:47:36 the engagement proposal and why that didn't go further because there wasn't sort of a
02:47:41 tangible plan there i just wanted to ask you about a different aspect of this and if if we can pull up
02:47:48 um uh sorry it's i hope i have it here yeah ssm nsc can five zeros 292
02:47:59 This is one of the, I think it's an SSE meeting notes. Sorry, let's just take a look. Yes,
02:48:12 SSE, and it's from February 3rd. And if we can scroll, it would be probably, I think it's page
02:48:20 eight. And Mr. Clerk, you might need to, oh, you don't have to rotate it. But if you can just move
02:48:27 it over yeah so i just want to ask about these creative some of these creative alternatives on
02:48:32 this side of the screen um one is um le grand debat modeling after 2019 yellow jackets protest in
02:48:40 france the country launched a national listening listening exercise cross-country meetings french
02:48:46 president attended some did that suggestion make it to the irg or to cabinet was that something that
02:48:54 that was explored um beyond i guess beyond this sheet of paper and sorry what date was this from
02:49:02 uh february 3rd i believe february 3rd so that was the first meeting of that cabinet committee
02:49:09 my assessment of this document is that it's a public service document which is
02:49:14 fairly normal for these discussions to fuel a discussion i would say on that i can't speak to
02:49:20 what was discussed or whether that was addressed in the meeting but i would say in february there
02:49:26 was a very specific urgent need and my view is that that would not have been appropriate to
02:49:33 address that urgent national challenge that we were facing right in that moment okay and just
02:49:38 um if we can scroll down just a little bit the last item there communications shift encourage
02:49:43 shift in communication we hear you we understand go home question does this legitimize protest
02:49:51 um what about that discussion was there a discussion about um and i know we saw a text um
02:49:57 a message that was communicated i think through minister leblah from jason kenney um saying
02:50:04 you know something about calling them all nazis didn't help um i think here what what someone's
02:50:09 getting it is maybe we should tone down the rhetoric and and try to um even if we're not
02:50:14 going to meet with them try to in a communications way tone it down um was that something that was
02:50:21 discussed um or or considered there were constantly discussions like that is there something we could
02:50:28 say something we could do just like there were lots of discussions about the engagement proposals
02:50:33 but the wall we would always hit is the assessment was given the demands of the convoy which was to
02:50:42 drop all the mandates we weren't going to get very far with this kind of uh this kind of suggestion
02:50:48 okay um last thing i'm going to ask um i know i'm almost out of time i just want to ask about
02:50:54 um and if we could pull up um sorry mr clow's notes one last time uh i think the clerk probably
02:51:03 knows that um and here it's page 23. it's not almost by the way oh okay may i get one last one
02:51:13 in thank you um so uh so we're at uh february 14th and um maybe we can make it just a little
02:51:23 a little bigger thank you um so february 14th 12 30 um pm i'm gonna look on my paper here um
02:51:35 p.m taking i think that's maybe time taking time now then it says he'll depart from the hill
02:51:42 to head to west block okay and then jagmeet singh opposition leader uh can do it whenever
02:51:48 the part that i'm interested in is um this discussion about quebec um and you know i
02:51:54 gather that i'm not sure this is i guess this is after the first minister's meeting so um we know
02:51:59 that quebec is a bit concerned about the application of the emergencies act in the province um and it
02:52:05 says um without sending without saying we're sending rcmp to quebec pm call ago no intention
02:52:15 to do anything in quebec other than ottawa uh pablo i assume that's minister rodriguez called
02:52:21 to lego military isn't a part of this not looking to take over won't go to quebec border um
02:52:29 um so it it it seemed if you don't need it then we're not going there so this was a staff debrief
02:52:39 following the fmm on that day ahead of the prime minister's conversations with the opposition
02:52:44 leaders so at this time the consideration was considering continuing around the emergencies act
02:52:51 so this was a quick discussion of staff of things we should be considering or doing coming out of
02:52:57 fmm given the premier of quebec communicated so clearly that he didn't want the act applied in
02:53:05 quebec that's what that discussion reflects it was a very brief staff discussion okay it wasn't
02:53:11 ever communicated to the premier of quebec that the act wouldn't apply there or that the police
02:53:16 wouldn't take action there because that's not something that would have been possible given
02:53:20 what the orders said right the act did apply there okay thank you thank you for answering
02:53:24 Thank you for hearing my questions.
02:53:25 Thank you, Mr. Commissioner.
02:53:26 Mayor Paterson- Okay, thank you.
02:53:27 The Democracy Fund, JCCF, please.
02:53:39 Good evening.
02:53:40 My name's Alan Hawner.
02:53:41 I'm a lawyer from the Democracy Fund.
02:53:43 I just have a few questions for you,
02:53:44 and they're directed to anyone at the panel.
02:53:49 You were asked about political commentary
02:53:51 from the United States.
02:53:53 If I recall correctly, that was something that President Biden and Prime Minister Trudeau
02:53:59 spoke about.
02:54:00 Yes.
02:54:01 Okay.
02:54:02 And I just want to ask you about some of the political commentary which happened after
02:54:06 the invocation of the Emergencies Act, which, and after the meeting with President Biden,
02:54:10 which I understand to be February the 11th.
02:54:13 The phone call was February 11th, yes.
02:54:15 Pardon me?
02:54:16 The phone call was February 11th.
02:54:18 Yes, thank you.
02:54:19 Can we pull up pb.can6069 underscore REL.0001?
02:54:35 This is a letter from Premier Kenney, Premier Moe,
02:54:38 and 16 governors from the United States of America,
02:54:42 and I believe it's dated February the 16th.
02:54:47 And my friends, and correct me if I misconstrue this letter, but the signatories here are
02:54:54 expressing concern over vaccine requirements and the impacts of those requirements on the
02:54:59 North American supply chain, the cost of living, and the availability of essential products
02:55:05 for people from both countries.
02:55:09 My question for you is, how does a letter like this get before the Prime Minister?
02:55:13 Could I see the signatories?
02:55:15 Yes, of course.
02:55:16 so in general when correspondence comes in especially at this moment
02:55:25 on this issue given the emergency act was in place february 6 february 16th letters get to him
02:55:33 sometimes through a normal course that may take some time other times letters are elevated more
02:55:39 urgently and this letter here i i assume it's important because we got 16 governors from united
02:55:46 States. It's our biggest trading partner, our best ally. Notably, it's signed by the
02:55:51 governor of Montana. Of course, Montana is right across from Coutts, Alberta. Did this
02:55:58 letter get to the prime minister? Do you know?
02:56:01 So I can't recall if this got to the prime minister, but I would say the views expressed
02:56:04 are matched the views that we heard from a lot of people, but the government did not
02:56:11 agree with that. Okay, thank you. Can we pull up pb.can.401045 underscore REL dot 0001?
02:56:25 And the document we're going to see here, it's not dated, but the top words are congressional
02:56:32 reaction and it contains a number of tweets including a tweet from Matt Rosendale. He's
02:56:38 a member of the U.S. House of Representatives from Montana and it's supposed to be after the
02:56:46 invocation of the Emergencies Act and he says that he led 63 Republican colleagues in support
02:56:52 of the truckers protesting COVID-19 mandates and urging President Joe Biden to work with Canada
02:56:59 to lift the mandates on essential travel at the border. Do you know if this was ever brought to
02:57:04 to the prime minister's attention. This specifically, I can't speak to that. I
02:57:10 don't know if it was brought to his attention. Okay. One more document, ssm.nsc.can50172.
02:57:23 And this is when it comes up, so I got the number right.
02:57:38 So this is an email from Deputy Jack Adam to Deputy Minister Jack Adam to Deputy Minister
02:57:45 David Morrison.
02:57:46 I'm not sure if they're both from Global Affairs Canada, but the email sets out U.S. political
02:57:51 reactions to Canadian measures. It's dated February the 16th. And if we can just look
02:57:57 at item number two here. We see that there are different comments. One of the comments
02:58:03 here is Canadian truckers being fired and now targeted as terrorist by your woke government.
02:58:10 And it is attributed to a US House of Representatives member. And there are other remarks from other
02:58:18 politicians which are somewhat uncomplimentary towards our country do you know if this document
02:58:26 was ever brought to the prime minister's attention i don't believe this document would this looks
02:58:31 like an internal document at the department of trade but prime minister we were all well aware
02:58:37 that these views were being expressed by a certain segment in u.s politics okay thank you very much
02:58:44 those are my questions thank you and next the canadian constitution foundation please
02:58:55 yes thank you my name is jenny shen mcgonathan and i am counsel for the canadian constitution
02:59:02 foundation and my questions are for mistelford so we know that there were three irg meetings
02:59:09 that took place on february the 10th the 12th and the 13th and while cabinet ministers were present
02:59:16 at this meeting at these meetings it's not a meeting of the entire cabinet right correct
02:59:24 and we do know that there was a meeting with the entire cabinet that took place the evening of
02:59:30 february the 13th right that's right and the following morning on february the 14th there
02:59:37 was a meeting with the first ministers and then later that day on february the 14th or at some
02:59:43 point that day there was a decision made to declare the public order emergency later that day that's
02:59:50 right thank you and so i just have a few questions about cabinet meetings does the prime minister's
02:59:58 office advise the prime minister on the agendas for cabinet meetings usually the um privy council
03:00:07 office led by the clerk puts forward an agenda for a cabinet meeting and actually usually
03:00:15 john's team here will go back and forth with them a bit on it in case there's any insight
03:00:21 into particularly into time management of the meeting but they will present that to the prime
03:00:27 minister okay so it's fair to say though that you have some input the prime minister's office has
03:00:34 some input into the agenda input would be fair yes all right and who ultimately decides the
03:00:43 agenda at cabinet meetings like who has the final say the prime minister and does the prime minister's
03:00:51 office advise the prime minister on which non-cabinet officials attend cabinet meetings
03:00:57 no not really i mean the the the clerk of the privy council uh would be the person who would
03:01:05 advise and um advise on officials uh in terms of who should attend and uh and then there's usually
03:01:14 a few from the prime minister's office who attend and the prime minister agrees with who those are
03:01:19 okay so does the prime minister's office offer any input in terms of suggestions of who could
03:01:26 or who should attend these meetings that are non-cabinet members only of our own team
03:01:33 okay and who ultimately decides which non-cabinet officials attend these cabinet meetings
03:01:42 i think i just said that but i'll try again um is so the clerk in terms of officials on
03:01:47 the public service side um and ultimately it's the prime minister who decides who
03:01:52 who he welcomes in the cabinet room uh but the clerk will advise and uh and sign off on a on
03:01:59 a list from from an official's perspective and then there's usually some representatives from
03:02:03 the prime minister's office okay but the prime minister i take it has the final say of who
03:02:08 attends of course all right and um does the prime minister's office advise the prime minister on
03:02:15 what information should be shared at these cabinet meetings again the privy council office
03:02:23 um and so it's the clerk who will and her teams uh who will put together the information
03:02:30 and we may have some supplemental or additional information from a political perspective that we
03:02:35 may provide in a in a pre in a briefing ahead of cabinet but the documents come from the public
03:02:43 service side okay so leaving aside the physical documents that are coming in it's fair to say
03:02:49 though that the prime minister's office has some input into the kinds of documents that
03:02:53 are provided at the cabinet meetings uh yes i mean we will provide feedback uh sometimes
03:03:02 they'll ask us from the public service side what our thoughts are around especially as it relates
03:03:06 to meeting flow and what might be most useful that kind of thing for the ministers okay and
03:03:11 i take it it's fair to say that it's again the prime minister who's got the ultimate say
03:03:16 of the information that's provided at these cabinet meetings yes and in terms of documents
03:03:23 at the cabinet meetings i take it you also have the prime minister's office also provides some
03:03:27 input into the kinds of documents i think we've already touched on this the documents as well
03:03:32 yes okay and so in terms of the february 13th meeting the evening meeting with the full cabinet
03:03:43 who sort of set the agenda for the cabinet meeting
03:03:48 same process as i just described okay and did the prime minister's office
03:03:53 offer any input for the agenda for that february 13th evening cabinet meeting
03:03:59 So things were moving very quickly that day, and we were on the brief ahead of the Cabinet meeting,
03:04:07 and so I imagine we probably added some thoughts in terms of how the meeting might flow,
03:04:13 but that would have been the extent of it that day.
03:04:16 Okay, and what about the information that was provided at that February 13th evening Cabinet meeting?
03:04:25 did the prime minister's office offer any input on the information that would be provided
03:04:30 i'm not even sure if we would have i don't recall doing that no
03:04:34 okay what about the documents at that february 13th evening meeting did the prime minister's
03:04:40 office offer any input sorry i'm not sure i know the difference between the last one and this one
03:04:46 i thought we were just answering about documents so same same answer so information it could be
03:04:53 things that are said vocally out loud to the cabinet members versus physical documents that
03:04:58 are provided to the cabinet members so as i said a couple of times in in the briefing ahead of
03:05:04 cabinet we will provide our our insight our advice our best advice and feedback in terms of how the
03:05:12 flow might work and um and just ways of approaching different things um but that's really the extent
03:05:21 of our involvement and in preparation for the meeting whether it be documents or information
03:05:27 and again i guess it's fair to say for that february 13th evening meeting it's the prime minister
03:05:32 who had the ultimate say over the agenda the information that was provided in the documents
03:05:38 that were shared is that fair yes and just my last few questions i have um we've heard about
03:05:45 this assessment from CSIS, an assessment that ultimately concluded that the situation did not
03:05:54 amount to threats to the security of Canada as set out in the CSIS Act. Was this a threat assessment
03:06:02 provided to the cabinet members at the February 13th evening meeting with the full cabinet?
03:06:08 i am not sure whether i think the deputy clerk and clerk and it's like i i think their testimony
03:06:18 was on this on this they they led that process so i would refer to their testimony i don't recall
03:06:23 anything more than that but none of you know okay what about an alternative threat assessment
03:06:31 you know a threat assessment that's different from the cesus threat assessment was that provided
03:06:37 was any such assessment provided to the cabinet members at that evening February 13th meeting with the entire cabinet?
03:06:46 So all of these assessments were provided to the incident report, the IRG, earlier that day.
03:06:53 And then that was really rolled up and reported out to cabinet in the evening.
03:06:58 Okay, so, but the members of the IRG meeting, you know, it's not the entire cabinet, right?
03:07:08 correct and so i'm just asking about the actual was there a document with a threat assessment
03:07:15 that's different from the cc threat assessment was there a document that was shared at that
03:07:20 february 13th evening meeting i can speak to that and can either the other two refer back to
03:07:28 the deputy clerk's testimony okay and we've heard about this legal opinion that was created that
03:07:36 talked about how the definition of threats to the security of Canada in the CSIS Act
03:07:42 has a different interpretation when applied to the Emergencies Act. I'm not asking about
03:07:47 the content of that opinion. I just want to know, do you know if that legal opinion
03:07:52 had been provided at that february 13th evening meeting with the entire cabinet
03:08:08 i'm not sure what we can say i'm not sure what we can say on that i think there's that's
03:08:12 there's some cabinet confidence issues there so i don't see anyone objecting and i think
03:08:19 someone can correct me if i'm wrong but the input that's provided to cabinet in terms of
03:08:24 what information was provided is not covered by cabinet privilege i'm not asking about what was
03:08:29 discussed or the deliberations i just want to know if that legal opinion had been provided
03:08:35 at that february 13th evening meeting with the entire cabinet commissioner it's brian gover on
03:08:41 behalf of the government of canada the government of canada maintains the objection that you heard
03:08:45 yesterday from government counsel then about solicitor client privilege pertaining to the
03:08:54 information provided by attorney general minister of justice lametti
03:09:02 okay so i think we're stuck on that
03:09:07 and just so i'm clear that objection means i can't ask whether that opinion had been provided during
03:09:14 that meeting sorry I can't see anyone yeah I'm just waiting for an answer
03:09:23 Brian go over you may not consistent with maintaining the objection inquire
03:09:30 into the content of any advice given by the Minister of Justice and Attorney
03:09:35 General and the question is does that include the fact of or of the opinion or
03:09:43 not my friend may inquire as to whether an opinion was expressed the fact of the opinion not the
03:09:54 content so to be clear i was never asking about the content of the opinion was the fact of this
03:10:01 you know was this legal opinion the fact that this legal opinion existed and whatever its content may
03:10:07 have been, shared at that February 13th evening meeting with the full cabinet?
03:10:15 I'm not sure. From a document perspective, there were certainly discussions around it.
03:10:22 Okay. And the final question I have is, there was this Ottawa Police Service POU plan.
03:10:30 Was that plan shared to the cabinet members at that February 13th evening meeting with the entire cabinet?
03:10:44 We had heard at various points in the lead up to the invocation that there were plans or action was about to be taken in various situations, including Ottawa.
03:10:55 absolutely that was part of the discussion and consideration the fact that action had not been
03:11:04 taken up until that point and the assessment was that was because law enforcement did not
03:11:09 have the tools they needed okay but was that plan the document the plan you know there's a there's
03:11:16 a document that's called the op spou was that document shared with the february 13th cabinet
03:11:24 members it's hard to comment because we don't have the document we don't i don't know i'm not sure
03:11:27 what document that is sure um i'm not sure how much time i have left commissioner below i can
03:11:32 just bring up the document just to ask them if this was something that was shared during that
03:11:36 meeting you're over time so if you want to put up the document that'll be yeah that's fine i'm just
03:11:42 i'm not sure they understand what it is a pou plan is a public order unit which is are the police
03:11:50 officers who go in on a police uh uh public order uh process or
03:12:01 so i can't speak to that specific but cabinet was definitely aware that on february 13th when they
03:12:06 were discussing the situation in ottawa was worse than it had been at any point and the threats of
03:12:12 violence the actual violence was terrifying that's what was discussed at cabinet okay but you can't
03:12:19 say whether that document had been shared during that meeting and i just want to be fair to the
03:12:24 witness sorry oh sorry it's pbnsc can uh four zeros seven seven three four that's the document
03:12:37 and i'll just ask them if this is something they've recognized and whether they know if it was shared
03:12:49 just on that page so i take it from shaking your head now we need an audible answer that's not
03:13:02 familiar to me i've never seen this one okay thank you very much those are all my questions
03:13:07 Okay, next is the City of Ottawa, please.
03:13:26 Good evening, my name is Alyssa Tompkins, I am a Council for the City of Ottawa.
03:13:32 I just want to ask you a couple questions about some comments in the witness summary.
03:13:37 So, Mr. Clerk, if we could bring up the witness summary, it's WTS, however many zeros, 83.
03:14:02 And if we could go down to page four, bottom of page four.
03:14:13 So I'll start by directing my questions to Mr. Clough because these comments are attributed
03:14:18 to him, but obviously the others can add in.
03:14:22 So there's a comment here at Mr. Clough noted that the city was clearly struggling to manage
03:14:27 the occupation and that this was reflected in most conversations and media reporting
03:14:32 and reaction from residents so mr cloud did you understand that the response to the protest was
03:14:38 a police-led operation absolutely i understand that okay so you understand that the city
03:14:46 cannot direct law enforcement as to operational matters when i said city there
03:14:52 i believe i would have meant the city holistically so all of it the sum of its parts clearly the
03:15:00 situation in ottawa was out of control and that's what i was referring to okay so in terms though
03:15:06 of it it you understand it was managed by the police though which reports into the city of
03:15:12 ottawa i mean all of this is is the different levels are relevant here okay so the police
03:15:19 you understand there's a police services board that is independent from the city so i've answered
03:15:25 the question my comment was that the city of ottawa was out of control in especially in the
03:15:32 downtown okay okay i just wanted to be sure that that you weren't suggesting the city itself could
03:15:39 be doing more i'm not speaking to i wasn't here or am i now speaking to specifics of the arrangement
03:15:45 within the city of ottawa okay and if we could just go to the next page please
03:15:53 and uh again it's it's you mr clow uh referring to a meeting you had um and i think if we were to
03:16:03 actually look at the footnote i won't take you to it but i think it's a february 3rd
03:16:07 and it's noted that one issue identified in the notes of this meeting was the fact that the
03:16:12 request from ottawa did not come from ontario and it was unclear whether provincial resources
03:16:17 had first been exhausted so this is prior to the letter from the mayor so we're in the first week
03:16:24 and i i just um commissioner lucky and minister blair have both testified that it's in fact very
03:16:30 common for the city of for ops to reach out to the rcmp directly because of ottawa's status as
03:16:36 the national capital and I just want to make sure you don't have any evidence to contradict them
03:16:42 that this was actually a quite a normal process at this point. I don't have any evidence of that
03:16:49 effect and I stand by what's what appears here. Okay thank you those are my questions. Okay thank
03:16:54 Thank you. Next is the Ottawa Coalition, please.
03:17:12 Good evening. My name is Christine Johnson.
03:17:14 I'm counsel for the Ottawa Coalition of Residents and Businesses.
03:17:18 I want to ask you a few questions this evening about your experiences
03:17:22 in Ottawa and also some of the experiences you were hearing of staff members that you work with
03:17:30 in Ottawa. And I understand, Mr. Broadhead, that you live in Toronto and we're not here for the
03:17:34 Ottawa protests. So I will direct my questions. Okay, so I will direct these questions to Ms.
03:17:41 Telford and to Mr. Clough. So you were both here living in Ottawa during the demonstrations?
03:17:47 Yes. And in the witness statement, and to save time, I don't think we need to pull it up unless I hear otherwise from you, but your colleague, Mr. Broadhurst, noted that at least some protesters engaged immediately in illegal activity by blocking and occupying city streets, defacing public property, harassing residents.
03:18:12 Was this also your observation, that this kind of illegal activity was occurring as early as the first weekend in Ottawa?
03:18:20 Yes.
03:18:21 Yes.
03:18:22 And Mr. Clerk, I will ask for you to pull up a document, SSM.CAN.00007737.
03:18:35 And as this is coming up, I can advise that this is a set of text messages that we see at the top.
03:18:46 It says Katie and JT.
03:18:48 I presume this is text between you, Ms. Tilford, and our Prime Minister.
03:18:54 And I believe it doesn't show at the top of this document,
03:18:57 but the way this document's labeled in our disclosure, our discovery database,
03:19:01 it also says it involved um phil prue who i believe is the executive assistant or was the
03:19:06 executive assistant that's right and you've testified here tonight that mr prue lives in
03:19:12 center town yes yes um and we see here uh you can see faintly at the top these are uh texts shared
03:19:22 on february 2nd um and it looks like miss telford you share a tweet um from city councillor katherine
03:19:30 mckinney describing the situation in center town and then we see this blue box below and i'm not
03:19:38 sure do you recall if this was from mr prue or was this from our prime minister that would be
03:19:42 phil prue okay and he says yep the honking wheel spinning went on late again last night it was all
03:19:49 day yesterday again i put earplugs in at times during the day yesterday to make it less aggressive
03:19:55 It has already started again this morning.
03:19:59 They have some periods of calm now, but then start nonstop for a period of time.
03:20:03 It is enough to absolutely drive you absolutely nuts.
03:20:07 The truck horns especially, they sound like they are right in the middle of your home.
03:20:12 So would you agree that this statement seems to convey that for residents living in the heart of Centretown,
03:20:19 the honking could be heard very loudly inside homes and not just on the street?
03:20:23 that's certainly what he was conveying and did you hear about this experience from other residents
03:20:29 as well through your conversations with um city councilor citizens groups yes uh we were hearing
03:20:36 it from local members of parliament um and and they were hearing it from many other constituents
03:20:42 we were hearing it from staff we were hearing it from members of parliament who were in town
03:20:46 um it was uh and and everyone was from a staff perspective was having to work from
03:20:53 home during this period or almost everyone was there were a few essential staff able to go in
03:20:58 um but both because we couldn't access our offices because of the occupation
03:21:04 um as well as omicron we we were working virtually during this whole period
03:21:10 right and on that point i i think i saw in the witness statement that there was actually a
03:21:14 direction at some point that staff should work from home for their safety and it was mentioned
03:21:19 that this was uh never done before it was never communicated that staff should work from home for
03:21:23 their safety before that was unusual and significant that's right for a demonstration
03:21:29 staff had been advised to work from home during covet pandemic at different periods but for a
03:21:33 demonstration as far as we can recall we've never had to send a notice like that saying stay away
03:21:38 And in terms of safety concerns regarding staff, we saw in your witness statement, there was mention of a particular incident where a convoy participant threw coffee at a pregnant staff member. Do you recall that incident?
03:21:54 That's right.
03:21:55 And do you know if this incident was reported to police at all?
03:21:58 I'm not sure.
03:21:59 Are you aware that there were incidents of threatening and assaultive nature going on that were not, in fact, always reported to police at this time and where they were, residents were not always receiving feedback that these complaints were being followed up on?
03:22:19 Yes.
03:22:20 Okay, those are all my questions for you this evening.
03:22:22 Thank you very much.
03:22:23 Thank you.
03:22:25 Next is the Ontario Provincial Police.
03:22:29 good evening it's chris diana council to the opp and commissioner i can advise that i've been
03:22:43 gifted five additional minutes from the windsor police service for which i'm very grateful
03:22:47 i may not need that time but i appreciate the gift and if i need it i will use it
03:22:52 yeah and if you don't use it they don't get it back
03:22:54 won't be my concern at that point i wanted to ask about nipper wash you mentioned nipper wash
03:23:02 in your witness summary and as far as who answers this it doesn't really matter whoever has knowledge
03:23:06 i was going to bring up your witness summary but i don't think that's necessary
03:23:10 you referenced that there was a verbal briefing you said that in your evidence-in-chief
03:23:14 and i wanted to ask you about that verbal briefing what did that come out of
03:23:19 why was there a purple what do you mean yes um so as i think i mentioned earlier
03:23:27 today i um it was actually something that i raised very early on in all of this um perhaps
03:23:36 because i i worked at queen's park uh once upon a time uh but it was something i was just very
03:23:41 conscious of and wanted to make sure we knew where all the lines exactly were and um the deputy clerk
03:23:47 who's a former deputy minister of justice made sure to get us information on that right and the
03:23:53 reason i wanted to ask was because i mean that's very preemptive of you but were there any concerns
03:23:59 that you had about comments that had been made by anybody at that time no it was literally day one
03:24:03 that i asked these questions and when you say day one like the first day the day of the arrival of
03:24:07 the protesters approximately i might have even been just before it was it was the very first
03:24:15 meeting i was in talking about these kinds of things and hearing about potential how the police
03:24:20 were going to be handling things were any members of cabinet asking you kind of how far can we go
03:24:24 as far as police because understandably there was some frustration that we've heard about
03:24:28 police enforcement uh no if anything it was uh everyone was extraordinarily cautious on that
03:24:38 All right, Mr. Clerk, if you can bring up pb.can.1870 and Mr. Cloud, these are some text messages I believe that you were involved with, so I'd like to ask you because I think you may have some specific knowledge.
03:24:56 all right and it's not entirely clear from the text themselves although the description of the
03:25:05 text in the database suggests that this may have been a text exchange with chief of staff
03:25:10 mike jones who i believe with the chief of staff for the minister mendicino yes that's from mike
03:25:16 jones to me okay and so i wanted to ask and that's what i thought based on the content so this is an
03:25:22 email exchange you had sorry a text exchange with mike jones on february 6 240. do you remember this
03:25:30 exchange i do yes all right and so mike jones writes he expressed some concern about ops
03:25:38 enforcement and concern for the safety of the pm i assume he's referencing the prime minister there
03:25:45 yes and he says he wants to go out and say that ops needs to get control over the situation
03:25:51 and if they need more from opp they should make that clear but they should get working on removals
03:25:57 within the next 24 hours now i take it that when he says he wants to go out he's referring to
03:26:02 minister mendicino is that correct i would assume so do you know if that if mr minister mendicino
03:26:10 or anybody else actually went to ops with that kind of direction to try to remove people within
03:26:15 the next 24 hours so first thing i'll say is these updates came in there was a lot happening there
03:26:21 were a lot of conversations going on so i you'll note i didn't even have a chance to reply to this
03:26:26 or i didn't reply to it but i would have received the update my recollection is that did not happen
03:26:32 what is proposed here um and i don't want to read too much into the specifics of what is written
03:26:39 here but absolutely as katie said we were always incredibly careful and aware that politicians
03:26:48 don't direct the police right and when you say we were aware you're talking about the prime
03:26:53 minister's office or are you talking about all of cabinet both these this was discussed and mentioned
03:26:59 on various occasions throughout the convoy and is it because people were expressing concerns
03:27:04 about police enforcement it was because this clearly policing was a central part of this
03:27:12 and a lot of us are aware of issues from the past everyone here is aware of it for wash
03:27:18 for example so we were highly sensitive right out of the gate that politicians do not instruct the
03:27:26 police yes and i would have asked to be clear i would have asked minister mendicino but we didn't
03:27:30 get this in time for me to do that which is why i'm trying to understand from you whether or not
03:27:35 minister mendicino or anybody else actually contacted anyone from ottawa police service
03:27:40 or even the rcmp to say we want people gone we want them gone quickly i have no knowledge of
03:27:47 that okay but you would agree i don't believe that happened no certainly and it sounds like
03:27:51 the prime minister's office was very aware of upper wash which is great and i'm sure you would
03:27:55 agree that if that had been communicated to the police service that would have been inappropriate
03:28:00 correct if what is written here is a faithful and accurate description of of what it appears
03:28:09 we were in here i do agree direction should not be given to the police by politicians right and you
03:28:15 would have no reason stout that you know what his chief of staff was saying you wouldn't have a
03:28:20 reason to believe that wasn't what he was hearing from his own minister correct i have no reason
03:28:24 to believe that but i i can't and shouldn't speak to that um i do actually believe this text message
03:28:29 was put to minister mendicino this week but that really would be a question for for him
03:28:34 do you know when you talked about the briefing that was done on ipra wash
03:28:39 were the ministers involved in that briefing i mean it sounds like there were a number of
03:28:45 discussions but miss telford you mentioned there was one briefing in particular at the beginning
03:28:49 was that a a cabinet briefing no that was that was something we received um on our request but
03:28:56 um but it was something reinforced on numerous occasions throughout the process and again when
03:29:02 say we i just want to make sure i drill down on who who who are we are they the the politicians
03:29:08 their staff members kind of who is we uh so we within prime minister's office who are here we
03:29:14 were briefed early on on our request but then the the um the principles were repeated on numerous
03:29:23 occasions uh certainly through irgs and through other discussions throughout i don't think there
03:29:30 there was anyone that I worked with who was not conscious of of the need to be
03:29:34 cautious correct thank you and just to confirm the record it was put to
03:29:41 Minister Mendocino okay we all make mistakes and so council for former chief
03:29:57 Chief Sloley, please.
03:30:06 Thank you, Commissioner.
03:30:08 Panel, Tom Curry for the former Chief of the Ottawa Police Service, Chief Sloley.
03:30:14 Just a few questions, if I can, please.
03:30:18 These events have been described by probably everyone who has appeared here as unprecedented.
03:30:23 And certainly in your collective tenure in the Prime Minister's office, that would be true.
03:30:29 Yes.
03:30:30 And the circumstances were also, I think she slowly described the volatile nature of the events here in Ottawa, and you share that view.
03:30:42 Yes.
03:30:42 I think he may have described or others have described a tinderbox risk of violence, present always, it seemed, and growing.
03:30:54 Yes, and we saw it ourselves as well as had it reported to us, the threat of violence both to people and property.
03:31:02 It was significant throughout and escalating.
03:31:04 And although it may not have been clear at the outset of the demonstration and the protest,
03:31:13 but as it evolved, did you come to understand that there were significant limitations
03:31:18 on the ability of the Ottawa Police Service to manage it with its own resources?
03:31:24 It certainly seemed that way.
03:31:27 And were the briefings that you received always through RCMP officials, briefings on police operations or updates, did they come from Commissioner Luckey?
03:31:41 Yes, though also the Deputy Minister of Public Safety, the NSIA, would have different parts to the briefs as well.
03:31:48 Understood. So just a couple of things, if I can get, and I think they're Mr. Clow's notes.
03:31:52 So could we please just get your help with a couple of things?
03:31:55 This is for our registrar, SSM NSCCAN 2941, please.
03:32:07 If that, yeah, thank you.
03:32:09 Just a little larger, thank you.
03:32:14 So this is just to situate you.
03:32:16 Do you see February 3rd, 1115?
03:32:18 Yes.
03:32:20 And you've looked at some of these notes previously.
03:32:23 that says it looks like ops won't move weeks not days um weekend reinforcements problem
03:32:34 behind the scenes two deferential need i think you just i want to just confirm this says need bad cop
03:32:42 you've got to you've got to use the tools you have whether to change public message is different
03:32:50 Those are references. Do you know what those are references to? Is that reference to the idea that that at that time, at least someone was expressing the view that police were taking a standoffish position with the demonstrators?
03:33:06 I think that's a fair assessment of that comment.
03:33:08 And then just in the second one, it looks, the second set of comments, just as to this, RCMP, does it say through OPS under bus at caucus?
03:33:24 Yes.
03:33:24 Yes, it does.
03:33:25 How do we get right people on the path to driving somewhere?
03:33:31 Any way to get, well, and you talked about that earlier.
03:33:34 Is that, to the extent that you can recall this, does, is that an indication that the RCMP was, was pointing to OPS as the police of jurisdiction responsible for doing this and that they weren't taking sufficient action at that time? Or can you help us?
03:33:51 It was, that's me recounting from a national caucus meeting that, I believe that morning, where there was a presentation given to caucus members.
03:34:05 The large part of the discussion was actually around personal security and security of the building.
03:34:11 There were significant concerns for members of parliament being able to get from the airport to downtown, let alone from downtown up on the hill.
03:34:17 And actually getting off the hill was a bigger problem than even getting on it.
03:34:21 But also as part of that, it was discussed or it was caucus were told that if it had been up to anyone other than the OPS,
03:34:32 that they would not have allowed the trucks onto Wellington and that they had given that advice and it wasn't taken.
03:34:39 Right, all right. Did you learn at that time from anyone in that briefing from RCMP that some RCMP officials had seen and reviewed and approved the OPS plan in advance of the protest?
03:34:54 They did not get into that level of detail with caucus.
03:34:56 Okay. Could I ask you just to look, please, at page seven of this record, Mr. Registrar, just for a couple of other things.
03:35:03 Now, of course, I've got to pick it out where it was.
03:35:16 Ah, about the middle of the page, you see there's a reference to,
03:35:22 this is obviously a cabinet, it looks like it might be a cabinet committee briefing,
03:35:26 but it it says too high about the middle 250 rcmp assisting some holding back for surge
03:35:33 and there's reference to the ambassador bridge up above did you did you come to realize as this
03:35:38 evolved that there was some misunderstanding about how many rcmp officers were made available
03:35:46 to ops at any given time matter of shift counting and the like did you learn that
03:35:50 there definitely appeared to be some confusion over several days about the numbers right i think
03:35:59 the mayor of city of ottawa had said that what was represented as the number that had been deployed
03:36:05 to ottawa was was smaller than the number that had been represented in to pub the public and so on
03:36:13 and then just a couple of other lines if i may ops trying to reduce violence are taking some steps
03:36:20 um and then there's a likening to ottawa's strategy to to d-day that is that a reference
03:36:29 to the idea that there was a plan in place to try to dismantle the occupation but that it was going
03:36:35 to require significant additional resources it could be but i don't know that um this was an
03:36:42 update from the nsia to the prime minister that sunday evening on february 6th right and then
03:36:49 And Mr. Commissioner, your indulgence for one more question with Mr. Clow's benefit, page 12, if you don't mind.
03:36:58 Of course, you were following this as this page is coming up.
03:37:02 You were following this across the country.
03:37:04 These, as you've described, Ambassador Bridge and the like.
03:37:09 If you look at, if you scroll down a little bit, Mr. Registrar, there we go.
03:37:15 I just want your help with this.
03:37:16 Brenda, of course, you've described as Commissioner Lucky.
03:37:19 um certain references to rcmp ottawa team headed to windsor york waterloo opp plan is to remove by
03:37:29 morning because auto workers uh counter protest we've heard some evidence about that mayor wanted
03:37:39 to remove chief so then chief sent letters is that a reference to letters that were received
03:37:45 by I think either the Prime Minister or Minister Blair requesting resources from RCMP you recall
03:37:54 that I'm not sure what that final line refers to but this looks like a discussion of an update we
03:38:00 received this was February 10th at the IRG that Windsor action was anticipated the very next day
03:38:06 thank you and then the last very last thing on February 5th Chief slowly noted at a Police
03:38:13 services board meeting that quote something has changed in our democratic fabric and we do not
03:38:18 have the legislation or the resources to manage such situations we do not have the justice system
03:38:24 framework or the needed coordination between all levels of government to predictably manage
03:38:29 these demonstrations going forward you described a threat to national security do you share those
03:38:34 Can any of those views?
03:38:35 Mayor Mrakas- Largely yes.
03:38:40 Mayor Mrakas- Thank you.
03:38:41 No other questions for you.
03:38:42 Thank you.
03:38:44 Mayor Mrakas- Okay, next is the city of Windsor.
03:38:48 Mayor Mrakas- Good evening Graham, reader for the City of Windsor.
03:38:51 We have no questions, we ceded our time to the Government of Canada.
03:38:55 Mayor Mrakas- Okay.
03:38:56 Government of Saskatchewan, please.
03:38:58 please uh good evening panel my name is mike morris and i'm counsel for the government of
03:39:05 saskatchewan uh mr broadhead just at the outset i want to make something clear at the first
03:39:12 minister's meeting premier mo expressed the view that the emergencies act was not wanted
03:39:18 and not needed in saskatchewan correct i i believe he also said these the six items
03:39:26 sounded reasonable uh might maybe sounded reasonable but wouldn't be perceived that way
03:39:33 is that fair i think that's fair yes and and certainly did not want the act to apply to
03:39:40 saskatchewan correct i think that was clear from the premier yes okay thank you i'd like us to take
03:39:47 a look at a document so i'm going to ask the clerk to pull up ssm can four zeros six nine two zero
03:40:00 and while we're waiting i'll let you know that this is an email from ms charette clerk of the
03:40:05 privy council to actually everyone on this panel at 8 24 a.m on february 14th
03:40:19 so we can see there 8 24 a.m uh from ms charette good morning all there's something that's
03:40:25 privileged but then she is detailing uh work that seems to be going on other products in train
03:40:32 fmm script with q's and a's comms news release and bg which i expect means background decision
03:40:40 note for pm uh then at the end she says others still in the machine uh mr broadhead when she
03:40:47 says others still in the machine can we take that as they were being worked on at that time
03:40:54 i don't it's not a very common phrase like i don't totally know what she was referring to here
03:40:59 um well she says only one i have seen is fmm script and then she says others still in the
03:41:07 machine so i i take it that means those are in progress would that be fair
03:41:11 i don't really want to speculate on what the clerk of the privy council was thinking with that
03:41:17 okay um if we could go on to a different document then uh well before we do does anyone else have
03:41:26 view on that that they're able to express are you specifically asking others still in the machine
03:41:32 or just yes the whole statement absolutely it could mean a number of things i i don't think
03:41:39 we can speculate okay i'm going to ask the clerk to pull up the email that was referred to by
03:41:46 council for alberta before it's ssm can four zeros two six six five and this is the email thread that
03:41:58 was entitled presser tomorrow and i'd like us to go down to the bottom of the second page of the pdf
03:42:12 right there is good uh we can see an email from a person named vanessa at the pmo
03:42:22 to a number of other people including others at the pmo indicating presser tracking for 4pm
03:42:29 this is not to be shared publicly until fmm over and pm updated itinerary is available or is out
03:42:37 please and uh her her email there of course is is at 1105 i believe if we just go up
03:42:48 11.05 a.m so my understanding is the first minister's meeting would have been going on at
03:42:53 that point um miss telford was the purpose in delaying the announcement of the press conference
03:43:00 so that the premiers would not be offended no the um there was a lot of work happening
03:43:08 concurrently at the time and uh to be ready for whatever scenarios and whatever decision ultimately
03:43:14 the prime minister came to and so vanessa um who you named there who's our excellent deputy
03:43:20 director of communications was making sure that all those tracks were were heading in the right
03:43:26 direction um at any point things could have been stopped and uh and things could have changed just
03:43:32 as they were okay i'd like us to go to the middle of the first page of this pdf and it'll be an
03:43:39 email at 1 43 p.m there it is from vanessa again uh to uh david taylor and and others stating we
03:43:48 just finished speech prep with pm alex is editing his remarks and we'll be able to share with this
03:43:55 group as soon as he is done so i i gather at this point in time 1 43 p.m on the 14th
03:44:04 the prime minister has already rehearsed his speech that he's going to be giving at 4 30 p.m
03:44:10 is that fair speech prep speech prep is our shorthand uh for going through his remarks uh
03:44:19 which we would have definitely returned to again uh that afternoon and so that means they would
03:44:25 have done a once through with him on what things could look like okay um he wasn't rehearsing two
03:44:33 versions of a speech was he one where he was announcing the the invocation of the emergency
03:44:39 act and another where he wasn't was he to be clear i wouldn't call it rehearsing um the words speech
03:44:47 prep literally mean preparing a speech and so they would have been discussing what what would have
03:44:53 been going into the content in it whether he was comfortable with where the drafts were at at this
03:44:57 point okay um we heard evidence from the clerk of the privy council some time ago and her evidence
03:45:08 was that the decision note was sent from the pco to the pmo at 3 41 pm on february 14th
03:45:21 we can pull up a document if you need me to or i can just ask you to take my word for it
03:45:26 and if if that's the case um are you familiar with the decision note i i gather you've likely
03:45:35 seen it before is that fair we're familiar with the decision though okay a fairly lengthy document
03:45:42 with a number of appendices correct yes and if it was received at 3 41 pm do we know at what time
03:45:52 uh it would have been returned with the prime minister's initials to the pco
03:45:58 it was at some point between receipt and when the prime minister made the announcement
03:46:07 okay so it's obviously sometime before 4 30 in the afternoon then correct
03:46:14 um that would not have given the prime minister much if any time to have read all of that
03:46:19 material would you agree with me well a couple comments one he did read the note
03:46:25 to the start time in the press conference it may be a bit absurd to dig in on the minutes but the
03:46:31 minutes are important here i don't know that it started precisely at 4 30 i think there might have
03:46:36 been some delay there but after it was received the prime minister did review the note signed the
03:46:41 note made the announcement and that signing of the note um was came after the fmm came after the
03:46:48 opposition leader consultation and that was the prime minister making the decision there before
03:46:55 he announced it. Okay I'm going to ask each of you a very similar question. Ms. Telford what I'd
03:47:01 like to know is when you found out that the prime minister would be announcing the invocation of
03:47:06 the emergencies act at the 4 30 p.m press conference. He and I would have been discussing
03:47:15 the possibility throughout the day until he signed the decision note uh there was there was nothing
03:47:23 confirmed um okay do we know when the announcement went out to the press gallery that the conference
03:47:32 was going to be held at 4 30 p.m i don't know what time that went out mr clow i believe went
03:47:39 out earlier that afternoon around around or shortly after one o'clock and the decision
03:47:46 at that point to issue the itinerary was to notify media the prime minister would have
03:47:50 something to say and it is absolutely possible that the prime minister could have decided
03:47:57 not to proceed down this path before he addressed the media that afternoon and it happens not
03:48:03 infrequently on an issue that scenarios are planned a track may be on a certain track but a decision
03:48:13 a different decision is taken at a certain point even at the last minute so no the decision was
03:48:19 not taken until shortly before it was announced to media okay i'll explore that just briefly if
03:48:24 i can let's call the emergencies act track one and let's call whatever the other decision could
03:48:31 have been track two was there material prepared for a track two presentation at 4 30 pm
03:48:39 if the decision was taken not to invoke the emergency act on that day the remarks
03:48:44 and announcement would have been changed
03:48:48 they would have time you're well over your time so you're gonna have to wrap up
03:48:52 um last question but was there any draft material prepared uh in the event that the decision was to
03:49:02 not invoke the emergencies act i'm not sure if there was you would be familiar if there was
03:49:09 though wouldn't you but my point is even if there wasn't a draft this can be done quite quickly if
03:49:15 in order to redraft materials um and it has happened before in different issues we got very
03:49:21 nimble during the pandemic where we were putting out advisories for things where we weren't sure
03:49:27 what the content was going to be a couple of hours later and that's what you need to do in
03:49:31 times of crisis yeah i appreciate uh the entire panel answering my questions thank you very much
03:49:37 Okay, now we go to the Government of Canada, please.
03:49:44 Thank you, Commissioner, and my name is Brian Gover.
03:49:55 I'm one of the lawyers for the Government of Canada.
03:49:58 And good evening, Ms. Telford, Mr. Clough, and Mr. Broadhead.
03:50:05 Go ahead. By my count, Commissioner, I believe I have 20 minutes with the kind donation from the City of Windsor. I hope to be substantially less than that.
03:50:15 That'll probably be a happy event for a lot of people, but don't feel on my account.
03:50:22 Well, let's see how we do.
03:50:27 First of all, the Order in Council sets out terms of reference directing the Commissioner
03:50:34 to examine the, to the extent relevant, the impact, role and sources of misinformation
03:50:41 and disinformation, including the use of social media.
03:50:46 And by misinformation, we understand that to mean unknowingly or unintentionally spreading
03:50:52 false inaccurate or misleading information we understand disinformation to be deliberately and
03:50:58 intentionally spreading false inaccurate or misleading information ms telford at any point
03:51:06 during the convoy occupations and blockades did you become aware of any misinformation or
03:51:13 disinformation that was affecting the situation um there was i became aware of a lot of of both
03:51:21 misinformation and disinformation over the course of the um the occupation and the blockades um
03:51:29 to name just just a few examples even even leading into the first weekend um one was
03:51:36 that this was even solely a trucker um protest and let alone the fact that it was solely about
03:51:46 uh federal vaccine mandates it was quite clear from very early on and even leading into the first
03:51:52 weekend we knew from the canadian truckers alliance as was mentioned earlier and also
03:51:58 from data that we had that over 90 of truckers were vaccinated we also knew that a lot of the
03:52:07 mandates that were being talked about were ones that were actually responsibilities and put in
03:52:12 place or imposed by provincial level governments or or even other levels of governments or
03:52:17 jurisdictions whether they be school boards or cities and uh and then of course there's a lot
03:52:22 of misinformation disinformation around vaccines themselves and then personally in terms of our
03:52:27 office we dealt with a number of different instances um our official photographer was drawn
03:52:33 into a conspiracy theory uh unfortunately where he was being alleged to be out taking a picture
03:52:40 of some um hate film flags and uh he at the time was actually in isolation with covid himself
03:52:49 there was no chance he was doing that we began trying to correct that he began receiving death
03:52:54 threats during that period um there was also a fake letter distributed amongst um people within
03:53:02 the occupation that was signed allegedly it was not signed by us but it was it was signed using
03:53:09 my name and the prime minister's name uh and uh suggesting ways in which we might agree to
03:53:16 some kind of i i don't even know what but this fake letter was corrected um and actually made
03:53:23 international news it was corrected on cnn at the time and then i personally was actually asked to
03:53:28 stay away for quite some time um from the downtown core because there was a it started on telegram
03:53:36 and then moved on to other social media channels a story that was created uh that i was going to
03:53:42 create a false flag operation and have a horse killed um and then blame it on the occupiers
03:53:47 so there were concerns for my security during that period as well and i understand uh commissioner
03:53:53 that the the fake letter that has been alluded to by ms telford can be found at pb dot can dot
03:54:01 four zeros one eight two one and the the false flag regarding Ms. Telford and the horse
03:54:10 is in evidence as pb.can.00001822. Ms. Telford how was misinformation and disinformation
03:54:23 conveyed or distributed in the course of the weeks that we're concerned with here?
03:54:28 we saw it being conveyed and distributed in multiple different ways the letter for example
03:54:34 was you know both screenshots of it floating around on social media but it was actually
03:54:38 being distributed in hard copy um and uh the other things as i mentioned were moving from
03:54:44 different social media platforms from one to the other uh but it was also we were seeing people
03:54:49 doing podcasts and youtube videos and different things where they were disseminating this
03:54:54 information as well moving to my second area mr cloud you've testified in response to a question
03:55:02 from commission council about communications with juan gonzalez whom you described as a member of
03:55:09 president biden's national security team on february 9th and commissioner we have in evidence
03:55:17 and I won't take the witness to it, the text message at SSM.CAN.407744.
03:55:31 And Mr. Clough, in addition to the text exchange,
03:55:34 did you have a telephone call with Mr. Gonzalez that you recall?
03:55:38 I believe we did speak at one point.
03:55:41 And when was that in relation to February 9th?
03:55:44 I can't remember the precise date, but the first exchange, there was an email exchange, a text exchange with him on the 9th,
03:55:56 and the interactions continued until about the 15th or 16th.
03:56:01 Thank you.
03:56:02 The third area relates to federal-provincial-territorial consultations and the first minister's meeting,
03:56:10 And we have the readout at ssm.nsc.can50625, and perhaps I'll ask our registrar to display that, please.
03:56:23 and perhaps i'll ask if we could go to the second page and
03:56:40 you'll recall that my friend for the province of alberta said that premier kenny was clear that
03:56:50 the Emergencies Act was not required in Alberta and referred to the situation in Coutts having
03:56:56 been addressed. Can anyone on the panel assist me with this question? Do you know where the
03:57:03 additional RCMP resources came from to address the situation in Coutts, which we've heard was
03:57:11 the subject of a police operation in the early morning hours of February 14th? Mr. Broadhead.
03:57:17 My understanding is that there was a contingent sent from British Columbia to assist at COOTS.
03:57:23 And in fact, at the second page, we have Premier Horgan from British Columbia indicating that his only concern is that the measures would be implemented by RCMP and BC, which are already fully taxed.
03:57:37 Not sure where you're going to find the people. We've already sent an RCMP contingent east.
03:57:43 Is that what you're referring to in that respect?
03:57:45 yeah and i would just add what what this illustrates is an example of something we heard
03:57:50 from officials um in the lead up to february 14th and the invocation which was yes there was some
03:57:56 progress in certain places and certain blockades but the progress was done with the help of
03:58:04 additional resources in in certain cases so in bc for example it was definitely concerning that
03:58:12 Alberta was cleared with BC not concerning it's good that Alberta progress was made with additional
03:58:17 resources but BC was facing its own problems there were arrests at the Pacific Highway there
03:58:23 was there was a military style vehicle there when convoy activity happened in BC so part of the
03:58:29 concern across the country was was there enough resources across the board to handle all of the
03:58:37 pop-ups that were happening and we were seeing in increasing numbers that weekend and Mr. Clough in
03:58:41 course of your evidence already you've referred to this phenomenon of stretching police resources
03:58:47 is that correct yes and this was in the context this conversation of declaring a public order
03:58:53 emergency which itself involves a national emergency is that right yes now you were taken
03:59:01 by the way to page three and what premier kenny said and if my friend from alberta said this i
03:59:09 didn't hear it but she referred to uh if we look down page three would be problematic to declare
03:59:20 emergency today uh and referred to what we see following the the next point starting with
03:59:29 invoking what they see as martial law what we didn't hear was what's in between two sentences
03:59:38 folks at the core of this movement are not rational they are prone to conspiracy theories
03:59:45 have i read that correctly yes and was that to the best of your recollection a feature of what
03:59:53 premier kenny said during the first minister's meeting yes can i can i add to that just the
04:00:00 other one that i think uh struck me in his comments was this line at the bottom of the page that
04:00:07 i don't quibble using the emergencies act which is particularly interesting considering his
04:00:14 previous roles with the with the federal government in uh in that kind of national and i think
04:00:20 there you know i i i certainly interpreted that uh as an important distinction between
04:00:27 what he felt was needed in alberta versus what uh we knew we were looking at from a national
04:00:33 perspective and having to take into consideration the stretch resources the diff the movement the
04:00:39 differing um situations across the country and and mr broadhead to elaborate if you would
04:00:45 when you refer to premier kenny's previous roles with the federal government to what are you
04:00:50 referring i believe he was minister national defense uh in particular so that was the
04:00:56 one i was thinking of right uh the uh and we're moving right along to the fourth area
04:01:02 could we take that down mr registrar and could we go to and display ssm.can.407721
04:01:15 and i come to this panel because i believe this was alluded to by my friend mr miller on behalf
04:01:24 of the convoy organizers and i really seek your assistance in interpreting what i understand to
04:01:32 be a note written by alex jerek first of all i've probably mispronounced his name but did you know
04:01:41 who that is yes he's uh part of the issues management parliamentary affairs team with a
04:01:46 focus on parliament and so a member of the pmo yes and if we look at this maybe we could scroll
04:01:58 down just a couple of lines perfect thank you uh and we see uh something attributed to someone named
04:02:05 rayal do you see that mr clow yes that's rayal lewis he's the chief of staff to the government
04:02:11 house leader and uh this says uh confident will win those votes need to do more in senate to win
04:02:21 that vote have i read that correctly that looks correct and uh how does that accord with your
04:02:27 recollection of the discussion surrounding the pending senate vote around the time when revocation
04:02:35 of the declaration i'm gonna object he's misrepresenting the document that document is
04:02:39 in fact prior to the uh invocation though doesn't have a date on it and it talks about the announcement
04:02:46 on the monday and it's quite clear that that record uh is in fact from prior to invocation
04:02:52 and it actually says in it that there's no violence under the cesus act i'm not sure what
04:03:00 the date is is there a date on the document no the doj never provided a date unfortunately
04:03:06 i'm not yeah well i i'm just looking at it so it's unclear what the date is i guess is what
04:03:12 you're saying it does say that it's uh before a monday where there's an announcement and of course
04:03:17 that the announcement of the emergencies act was on monday the 14th on valentine's day
04:03:24 uh if i may continue commissioner what i'm endeavoring to do is to ask for the
04:03:30 panel's interpretation of this so that we clarify these areas okay thank you thank you very much
04:03:36 and uh this continues and this is a part that i believe mr miller had referred to in his
04:03:44 cross-examination uh earlier or his commentary earlier nes spoke with nsia and jody thomas and
04:03:52 then there's an arrow s2 of cesus act colon violence not met new arrow wonder if need full
04:04:01 30 days if Ottawa cleared, then speech Monday morning. Are you able to help us, Mr. Clough,
04:04:09 understand the context of this? First of all, what does NES stand for?
04:04:14 So this whole page, reviewing it, this does look like it's well after. It could be a full
04:04:19 week after the invocation of the Act. Clearly, they're talking about the parliamentary process.
04:04:23 So the first part, Raelle Lewis saying he's confident when the votes need to do more in
04:04:27 senate so i addressed that in an earlier question that i know of no reason to believe the senate was
04:04:34 not going to endorse that and as i said earlier the chief of staff to the government leader in
04:04:38 the senate was doing vote counting and i believe that evidence was presented here and they were
04:04:43 quite confident they would win that vote the rest of the page looks like more parliamentary process
04:04:50 and an individual caucus member who is that individual caucus caucus member nader skin smith
04:04:56 and whose view did you understand to be that uh section two of the CSIS Act uh had not been met
04:05:04 it's hard to say I don't know what this refers to but there there was a public discussion going on
04:05:11 about this very fact as there is in this commission but I don't know specifically what
04:05:16 this refers to in this note right all right well we've done our best to interpret that and thank
04:05:21 you for that sir sir sorry i'm giving the dates well i understand but we don't have a date for
04:05:27 that document yeah and he gave his best evidence and there's not much we can do so please let let
04:05:34 the let uh council proceed thank you the the second to last uh area has to do with the process
04:05:44 that the three of you observed surrounding the decision to invoke the Emergencies Act
04:05:53 and how would you describe the process surrounding the invocation of the Emergencies Act, the
04:06:03 evolution of the thinking of the Government of Canada on that issue? Perhaps I'll ask you first,
04:06:10 Ms. Telford. I think the process was it was we tried to be methodical about it. It was very
04:06:19 step by step and it was seeking advice every step of the way from multiple parts of government.
04:06:26 It was taking in a lot of different inputs and it was doing a lot of consultation throughout.
04:06:32 And so actually even in processes that that are that often go on much longer than this one
04:06:38 could afford to. I would say this is actually one of the more robust processes I've seen.
04:06:44 Thank you. Mr. Clow, same question for you. Your description of the process.
04:06:49 I would absolutely agree with that. I don't know that I have much to add other than as has been
04:06:52 covered at some length here today and at this commission, especially in those days leading up
04:06:58 to the invocation from the IRG and even before that, the steps that were taken were careful,
04:07:05 considered and there were a number of conversations involving a number of senior officials and
04:07:11 ministers ultimately leading to the cabinet meeting on the sunday night um so it to me it was very
04:07:18 methodical thank you and mr broadhead the only thing i would add to what i obviously agree with
04:07:25 uh my two colleagues i think um watching the incident response the incident response group
04:07:31 And I say this as a policy wonk and somebody who spends a lot of time with cabinet committees and these processes, it really helped facilitate the type of discussion.
04:07:42 Having the experts, the civil servants, the key folks at the table, all the ministers there, that type of open discussion, it just meant we could move at a speed that the other institutions, the other parts of our apparatus don't allow.
04:08:00 and so i think that the combination of that and um and all the external advice we were getting
04:08:06 i think it was agree that it was a very kind of methodical process and i think that i think the
04:08:11 prime minister um was very clear about how methodical it needed to be um both in the
04:08:21 both before and and uh and after so i'll leave there and finally our last question is to you
04:08:28 miss telford if anyone were to suggest that the decision to invoke the emergencies act was
04:08:35 politically motivated what would you say to that it was absolutely not uh it was um it was driven
04:08:45 at its core in every meeting the prime minister began and ended and it was discussed throughout
04:08:52 how do we ensure the safety and security of canadians and there wasn't time space or desire
04:08:58 to talk about anything else thank you very much those are my questions okay thank you um any uh
04:09:08 re-examination no re-examination commissioner okay well thank you uh very much for uh sharing uh
04:09:17 for not sharing your thoughts responding to questions and uh coming to testify much
04:09:23 appreciated and it's appreciated that you accommodated the late hour i'm sure it's not
04:09:28 your first late nights but it is uh appreciated so uh i think we'll take a short break uh to move
04:09:36 We'll move to the next witness and we'll take to reorganize and so on.
04:09:45 So we'll take five or ten minutes for a break.
04:09:55 The Commission is in results.
04:09:56 The Commission is in a way.
04:10:06 Thank you.
04:10:36 Thank you.
04:11:06 Thank you.
04:11:36 Thank you.
04:12:06 Thank you.
04:12:36 Thank you.
04:13:06 Thank you.
04:13:36 Thank you.
04:14:06 Thank you.
04:14:36 Thank you.
04:15:06 Thank you.