Juno News - April 14, 2023


Katie Telford testified for over two hours yet said nothing

Topics
Mentioned
It looks like GAME OVER for Justin Trudeau Can civilization be saved?

Episode Stats


Length

49 minutes

Words per minute

165.1

Word count

8,164

Sentence count

329

Harmful content

Misogyny

4

sentences flagged

Hate speech

2

sentences flagged


Summary

Summaries generated with gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ .

Katie Telford testified before the House of Commons committee investigating the Trudeau campaign s alleged involvement with Chinese nationals in the 2016 election campaign. She was grilled by MPs about what she knew, when she knew it, and what she didn't know. And what did she tell them?

Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Topics generated with Qwen2.5-3B-Instruct.
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 Welcome to Canada's Most Irreverent Talk Show.
00:00:05 This is the Andrew Lawton Show, brought to you by TrueNord.
00:00:15 Oh, I'm sorry, I dozed off there.
00:00:19 I was watching Katie Telford's two and a half hour testimony
00:00:23 before a House of Commons committee.
00:00:26 I think I made my way through the first two hours, and then I just passed out.
00:00:32 I didn't even know I was on air right now.
00:00:34 What time is it?
00:00:35 Three, three?
00:00:35 Okay, so I've been out for a little over an hour.
00:00:37 Has anything happened?
00:00:38 No?
00:00:38 I didn't miss anything?
00:00:40 No?
00:00:40 She said nothing?
00:00:41 Oh, who could have seen that coming?
00:00:44 Well, if you would like that question answered, please check out today's daily brief in which
00:00:49 I said, you know, I bet Katie Telford is not going to say a darn thing.
00:00:53 Welcome, my friends, to Canada's most irreverent talk show, The Andrew Lawton Show here on True
00:00:58 North, closing out the week on this Friday, April 14th, 2023. And the aforementioned testimony by
00:01:07 Katie Telford, I don't even, like I shouldn't have even budgeted time in the show to talk about it
00:01:12 because there's nothing to talk about. She sat there and MPs asked her questions. She gave what
00:01:19 were theoretically in the broadest sense of the phrase characterized as answers although I think
00:01:26 responses is probably more actually I think even that's a bit generous and at the end of it I don't
00:01:32 think we know anything more about China's interference in Canadian elections or the
00:01:37 government's response or lack of response than we did a couple of hours ago so I think that the
00:01:43 conservatives made a bit of a tactical error in putting so much emphasis on getting Katie
00:01:50 Telford to testify, the chief of staff to Justin Trudeau, taking questions from parliamentarians.
00:01:57 They're all going to get to the bottom of it. They're asking what she knew, when she knew it,
00:02:00 what she was briefed on, when she was briefed, how much she told Justin Trudeau, how much was
00:02:05 passed along to the liberal campaign and all of that. And look, the questions are fair. The issue
00:02:10 is a reasonable one, but it's not something that the Liberals have any interest in being
00:02:16 transparent about. So I don't know why anyone thought that putting Katie Telford in the hot
00:02:22 seat on committee was going to reveal anything whatsoever. So I'm not exaggerating here. Believe
00:02:28 me when I say I have nothing to report to you from what happened. I can talk about what didn't
00:02:35 happen. And I can certainly talk about how she went around talking, but there's literally no
00:02:40 new information that came out of this. So what happened first and foremost was everything was
00:02:47 concealed by national security, anything that would have been substantive. It's like, well,
00:02:52 I can't talk about that. That's national security. Well, I can't talk about that. I had to undertake
00:02:57 to not disclose this, so I can't talk about it. And there are obviously very real things that are
00:03:03 protected under national security grounds. But here we're talking about an inquiry that is
00:03:08 supposed to be led by the people representing the Canadian people, representing those of us in the
00:03:14 country to whom the government is supposed to be accountable, not the other way around.
00:03:19 And when it came to things that Katie Telford would be legally authorized to say,
00:03:24 curiously, she didn't have any of the answers. Anytime she was asked a question that was even
00:03:28 potentially interesting, she would say, well, you know, I didn't, I wasn't in that meeting.
00:03:32 I don't know about a meeting like that.
00:03:34 Oh, you'd have to talk to so-and-so.
00:03:36 Oh, you'd have to talk to them.
00:03:37 Oh, that was on the campaign.
00:03:39 I mean, she couldn't even answer the one question that I thought was probably the easiest question.
00:03:44 A conservative MP, Michael Barrett, said to Katie Telfer,
00:03:48 I don't have a clip of it handy, but this is legitimately the question.
00:03:52 What role did you have on the campaign?
00:03:56 And her answer was, I was on the bus.
00:03:59 Like, were you driving the bus?
00:04:01 Were you catering on the bus? Were you doing push-ups on the bus?
00:04:05 Were you holding the camera for Justin Trudeau to do his video takes?
00:04:10 Like, what were you doing on the bus?
00:04:11 Were you advising? Were you consulting?
00:04:13 Were you just, like, sleeping like I was at the beginning of the show?
00:04:16 So who knows what she was doing? She was on the bus.
00:04:19 And conveniently, when anything came up of substance that had to do with, oh, I don't know,
00:04:23 Handong, the then-liberal candidate that it sounded like was getting a little bit of a push
00:04:28 from the Chinese Politburo.
00:04:30 She said, well, I wasn't in any conversation.
00:04:32 So did any conversations take place?
00:04:34 I don't know.
00:04:35 Maybe I wasn't in any conversations.
00:04:38 You'll have to talk to so-and-so.
00:04:39 So apparently, we're going to hear from someone on this committee
00:04:44 that's connected to the liberal campaign
00:04:46 at a meeting that will be scheduled in April.
00:04:48 And maybe when we hear from the campaign source,
00:04:51 we'll get a bit more information about what could have happened,
00:04:55 what might have happened, what didn't happen.
00:04:57 But I'm not optimistic, and here's why I go back to comments I made several weeks ago about why I'm not holding my breath that a public inquiry, even if we were to have one, would actually reveal as much as people think.
00:05:13 Because the government has all of these different tricks up its sleeve, all of these tools at its disposal to not give up information.
00:05:20 I mean, you look at the Freedom Convoy and then the resulting Public Order Emergency Commission,
00:05:25 the government made a point of saying it was the most transparent exercise in the history of governments anywhere or whatever it was.
00:05:32 You know, we've waived cabinet confidence, we've waived this, we've waived that.
00:05:36 And even with all of those waivers, there was information that the government wouldn't give.
00:05:42 The government wouldn't give, for example, information that it said was protected under solicitor-client privilege,
00:05:47 which ended up being a pretty critical piece of evidence in this whole discussion.
00:05:52 So you take a public inquiry that talks about something
00:05:55 that is directly related to national security,
00:05:57 and you know that there's not going to be transparency.
00:06:00 So instead, we're to be satisfied that David Johnston,
00:06:04 the uber-eminent special rapporteur on China's interference in Canada's elections,
00:06:10 a guy who takes these, like, you know, he goes on parades with Xi Jinping,
00:06:14 he buddy-buddies with Xi Jinping,
00:06:15 he made one comment i the exact quote i can't remember but i remember the critical word
00:06:20 which was that he was in china and said he felt at home there well i mean increasingly in justin
00:06:27 trudeau's canada it's probably not all that uncharacteristic to feel at home in china so
00:06:31 that's more of a reflection of justin trudeau's canada than of david johnson i guess but
00:06:36 here's a guy who doesn't actually engage with people that aren't like him he is uber eminent
00:06:43 He plays by different rules.
00:06:44 It doesn't matter that he goes on ski trips with the Trudeau family.
00:06:47 He is eminent enough to be his royal eminent eminence
00:06:51 and then be special enough to be the rapporteur,
00:06:55 irrespective of these connections.
00:06:56 So he may come out with a finding that suggests there should be a public inquiry,
00:07:01 which would be probably David Johnston's greatest ability to save face and say,
00:07:06 yeah, you know what?
00:07:07 I want to just say that I realize this is bigger than me.
00:07:10 I'm not going to sweep it under the rug.
00:07:11 Y'all have to have an inquiry.
00:07:13 because David Johnson will definitely use the word y'all you can mark my words but all of that
00:07:18 is besides the point in that I'm not saying we should ignore this thing because this is important
00:07:25 and where there's smoke there's fire and I don't actually agree fundamentally with what my colleague
00:07:31 Andrew Kirsch said on the show last week the former CSIS intelligence officer who basically
00:07:36 took the position that well we shouldn't be celebrating leaks I think at the same time
00:07:40 time, whether we could hand-ring about what should have happened, we do have this information now.
00:07:46 We know there was Chinese interference in Canada's elections. We know it was to benefit 0.78
00:07:51 the Liberals, and we know that Justin Trudeau's story of this has changed more times than I can
00:07:56 count. Remember when it was, well, I was never briefed on funding, and then it was, oh yes,
00:08:01 I was briefed, but I didn't know the extent of it, and then it was, yes, I've received many
00:08:05 briefings and then just this week he had like changed tack again and was talking about how
00:08:11 many times he was briefed on this and how seriously he took it and how they were working
00:08:15 around the clock to solve it so so which is it is that it was no big deal or is it that this was
00:08:21 something that you were actively engaged in and you were staying on top of and it's a learning
00:08:25 opportunity for us all and all that because uh the liberals now have been proven to be trying to get
00:08:32 very cute with their excuses. Even when Justin Trudeau said that he was never briefed, he didn't
00:08:38 say technically he was never briefed on Chinese interference. He said he was never briefed on
00:08:43 China funding candidates. And in the context, he was trying to get people off his back. He was
00:08:50 trying to make it sound like, oh, this is the first I'm learning of it when the media is bringing it
00:08:54 up. But what he was actually admitting to is that he did have conversations about the broader issue
00:09:01 of interference, but he wasn't going to cop to that one specific part of it. So maybe that part
00:09:06 wasn't brought up in a briefing at that time or something like that, or maybe it was. I mean,
00:09:11 one of the documents that we've seen in the last couple of days shows just the extent to which
00:09:17 there were meetings between the CSIS director and the National Security Advisor and the government.
00:09:24 I'm looking right now at a document, and I just want to get the name of the committee right here.
00:09:30 This is a document that was published in the committee's digital binder.
00:09:35 So these are documents that were provided to committee, and they show a list of meetings,
00:09:40 a list of meetings that are specifically about briefings on foreign election interference.
00:09:46 October 22nd, 2018, the National Security Advisor met with Justin Trudeau.
00:09:52 February 9th, 2021, the Director of CSIS briefed Justin Trudeau.
00:09:57 June 14th, 2022, the National Security Advisor briefed Justin Trudeau.
00:10:03 October of 2022, the CSIS Director did.
00:10:06 November 30th, the NSIA, the National Security Advisor did.
00:10:11 And on March 20th, just, what, three weeks ago,
00:10:14 the National Security Advisor and the CSIS Director both briefed Justin Trudeau on this.
00:10:20 You then take another look at this and talk about briefings to ministers.
00:10:25 And oh my goodness, we have here, I'm looking at the list, August 15th, 2018, October 5th, 2018, November 26th of that year, January of 2019, April 2019, May 2019, June, July, August, August.
00:10:41 We had monthly meetings in August of 2019, an election year by the way, two back-to-back briefings for the Minister of Democratic Institutions by the CSIS Director, by the Chief of CSE, the Communications Security Establishment, and on and on these went into 2020, 2021, 2022, and 2023.
00:11:06 So the government was painfully aware,
00:11:10 vividly so, that election interference was an issue.
00:11:14 They were getting ongoing briefings.
00:11:16 So if they were not briefed to the full extent of this,
00:11:20 that is an example of all of these briefers
00:11:23 being colossally bad at their job,
00:11:25 that they don't even bring up the details
00:11:27 on which they're supposed to be briefing.
00:11:29 But I actually suspect that wasn't the case.
00:11:31 And by the way, Katie Telford was briefed
00:11:34 as a representative of the office.
00:11:36 There were other briefings here
00:11:37 that weren't with Justin Trudeau,
00:11:39 but were with the prime minister's office
00:11:42 when that didn't happen,
00:11:43 as Katie Telford said today.
00:11:44 So she didn't say one thing.
00:11:46 It would generally be with her.
00:11:49 And then when you look at the list
00:11:50 of briefings that took place
00:11:52 with political party representatives,
00:11:54 so people that signed an agreement
00:11:56 to not talk about it,
00:11:57 they were being told these things as well.
00:11:59 And included in that would be liberal aides,
00:12:02 liberal campaign officials
00:12:03 that presumably were being told,
00:12:05 hey, we've got some concerns with some of your candidates
00:12:08 and their relationship with China, here you go.
00:12:12 So you'd think at some point there would have been a conversation,
00:12:15 to take Handong's name, because he's been accused and he's been named,
00:12:19 so he has a right to defend himself.
00:12:22 He has said that this is not an accurate allegation,
00:12:25 but he has been accused of being the beneficiary of Chinese interference in these documents.
00:12:31 So presumably there would have been a conversation at some point
00:12:34 among some pretty chief liberals. 0.51
00:12:35 Hey, do we cut this hand-on guy loose or do we keep him around?
00:12:41 Even if they sided with keeping him, which they did,
00:12:44 you'd think there would have at least been a conversation.
00:12:48 But Katie Telfer had no idea.
00:12:49 She says, well, I wasn't a part of that.
00:12:51 So what were you doing?
00:12:52 I know you were on the bus, but what were you doing if you were not there?
00:12:55 Because if you were on the bus with Justin Trudeau,
00:12:58 presumably you would have been around Justin Trudeau
00:13:00 if he were having this conversation.
00:13:02 So either we have these things
00:13:03 that have just not been taken seriously
00:13:05 by the liberals,
00:13:07 which is entirely possible,
00:13:08 or we have all of these people
00:13:10 just being blatantly and brazenly dishonest,
00:13:13 which I actually think
00:13:14 the truth might be somewhere
00:13:16 in the middle of here.
00:13:18 We are going to talk about this further
00:13:20 in the future,
00:13:21 because as I said,
00:13:22 I can't really base a show off of
00:13:23 comments that weren't made.
00:13:25 And even the questions,
00:13:27 I don't think were all that great
00:13:28 that Katie Telford was getting.
00:13:30 But if you really want to laugh,
00:13:32 look at the questions that were being asked of her
00:13:34 by Liberal MPs,
00:13:35 because they're all on the committee, 1.00
00:13:36 so the Liberals get to lob their softballs at her. 0.99
00:13:39 And they're basically like the equivalent
00:13:41 of if you're Simpsons fans,
00:13:43 of Lisa Simpson's interview with Mr. Burns.
00:13:46 And she says, you know,
00:13:47 your campaign has all the momentum
00:13:48 of a runaway freight train.
00:13:49 Why are you so popular?
00:13:51 It was basically that.
00:13:52 Like Jennifer O'Connell asked like some eight-minute question
00:13:56 about how terrible Pierre Polyev was.
00:13:57 And I'm like, well, Pierre Polyev wasn't the guy that Justin Trudeau,
00:14:01 or wasn't the guy, oh, there's a Freudian slip.
00:14:03 Pierre Polyev wasn't the guy that Xi Jinping wanted the candidates to win of.
00:14:07 So take from that what you will.
00:14:09 I do want to carry on with a bit of a sidestep
00:14:13 from the usual daily grind of politics, though.
00:14:16 Earlier today, I caught up with an author
00:14:19 whose book I think touches on a lot of the big themes of the era.
00:14:22 That's coming right up.
00:14:27 You're tuned in to The Andrew Lawton Show.
00:14:34 Welcome back to The Andrew Lawton Show.
00:14:37 I have become a bit of a history nerd in recent years.
00:14:40 I never went to set out to study that in the first place,
00:14:44 but I've just become more and more enamored with history.
00:14:47 Frankly, the more people in this day and age try to take aim at history
00:14:51 or oftentimes just ignore it altogether.
00:14:54 so I was very very pleased when I saw a book that says the past is not something that we should run
00:15:00 from but arguably run towards Michael Bonner who I've met a couple of occasions and he's been a
00:15:07 quite a prolific figure for reasons that will become apparent very soon but he's written a
00:15:11 fantastic book in defense of civilization how our past can renew our present and he joins me now
00:15:19 Michael Bonner it's good to talk to you thanks for coming on today and congratulations on the book
00:15:23 Thanks for having me, Andrew.
00:15:25 Now, I know you've obviously gone through academia.
00:15:28 You have a PhD.
00:15:29 You're tremendously accomplished.
00:15:30 This is not written just for the academic in mind.
00:15:34 I mean, this was a very readable read, as they say.
00:15:37 Yeah, I mean, I didn't want to get into academic fights or controversies or anything like that.
00:15:43 I wanted just to tell the story or to make the argument.
00:15:49 And, you know, I'm very relieved that you think I succeeded.
00:15:54 Well, let me hear in your words what you think that argument is.
00:15:59 What is it that you set out to do with this?
00:16:01 Well, I mean, I can sum it up with, you know,
00:16:05 there are a couple of quotations that I include at the end of the book.
00:16:09 You know, there's that saying from, you know, T.S. Eliot.
00:16:14 He says, history is now, which is seemingly a paradox.
00:16:18 history is now. And then there's the other one, history is ourselves, from Kenneth Clark. And
00:16:24 the point is that we need to find meaning and purpose, every generation needs to find meaning
00:16:32 and purpose in the past. And that doesn't mean that the past is, you know, uniformly to be,
00:16:39 you know, we shouldn't, we shouldn't be uncritical, we shouldn't be, you know, partisan or blind to
00:16:46 our past failures, but we have to come to terms with it, wrestle with it, make sense of it,
00:16:53 and find meaning and purpose in it. One of the challenges politically, and I know this book is
00:17:01 not an artifact of the culture war, I think you take a much more nuanced and much bigger picture
00:17:06 view of things, but I'd say one of the challenges that we do see today is that there are a lot of
00:17:11 people who view the past as irreconcilable with the president. They think, as I alluded to a
00:17:16 moment ago, that it's something we should run away from, that we should denounce, that we should
00:17:20 condemn. And I'd say often that's coming from people that have not undertaken to understand
00:17:25 the past entirely. But what is it precisely that you think makes it so that these things are not
00:17:30 just reconcilable, but actually that we need to look to the past as we move forward? Well,
00:17:34 Well, I mean, the fundamental problem is that there is no break in history, there is no break with the past, it's impossible. And attempts have been made, notably in the 20th century, but it doesn't work.
00:17:52 And sort of disconnecting people from the past is extraordinarily disruptive.
00:18:02 You can find examples of this from this sort of accidental in the form of the Industrial Revolution,
00:18:12 people being herded into factories instead of working on their farms and so forth.
00:18:17 extraordinarily disruptive um or much more sinister in the case of the soviet and nazi
00:18:25 tyrannies sort of insisting that you know everything that came before is sort of to
00:18:30 be repudiated and looking far into the future uh toward a sort of utopia um
00:18:38 it look basically making trying to make that break has not had a good track record and you
00:18:43 know we we shouldn't try we should try to find as i say meaning we should try to make our peace
00:18:50 uh with the the evils or the failures of the past rather than trying to um obliterate them
00:18:59 does the view that western nations have the western world has to civilization align in your
00:19:06 view with how other cultures are dealing with this and other cultures are doing this because
00:19:11 I mean, even if you take a strictly Canadian context on this, whatever people think of Quebec politics, Quebec as a society is much more emphatic about protecting its culture and asserting its culture.
00:19:22 And I think in a lot of the Western world, we see really this idea that we're not allowed to have a culture.
00:19:27 We're not allowed to celebrate our civilization.
00:19:29 I know you've studied Iran extensively.
00:19:32 I know you talk about China extensively in the book.
00:19:34 And it strikes me that a lot of these other parts of the world, for whatever their faults politically, have actually done a better job of trying to preserve their civilization.
00:19:45 Yeah, I mean, I think that what I would say is that the Western view of history as a story of progress, that is extremely unusual.
00:19:58 And I don't think that it's correct.
00:20:00 um first of all that that's that's simply an assumption it seems to be borne out by you know
00:20:09 the facts of the sort of mid 20th century onward if you lived in most of North America life looked
00:20:16 like it was getting better and better and better and that it you know you might have concluded
00:20:22 that nothing would get in the way of continuous improvement um but that that's a very unusual
00:20:30 view historically and i think now we're beginning to understand or realize that that is not um
00:20:39 correct uh it can't be taken for granted you know the the um continuous evolution of technology is
00:20:48 not um a reliable measure of you know uh of a civilization or of this the success of a of a
00:20:58 culture and um an older view which i think is borne out by um human experience is something
00:21:07 more like a cycle of of um uh the the rise and then the eventual uh collapse of societies or
00:21:17 or of civilizations and um we should take this to heart um i think no no civilization is immune
00:21:27 from collapse however long a view you take you know it's sometimes tempting to think of like
00:21:32 like constant evolution and change and so forth.
00:21:34 But the longer a view you take,
00:21:36 the more you are forced to admit that eventually,
00:21:39 you know, human societies do die out.
00:21:42 Where do you think we are at in that cycle now?
00:21:45 Well, I can't say for sure.
00:21:47 I mean, this is, I mean, it depends who you ask.
00:21:53 I mean, there are people who might say
00:21:54 that with the Continental Reformation,
00:21:56 everything went to pot in, you know, 1517,
00:21:59 and it's been, you know...
00:22:01 It's all been downhill since then.
00:22:03 Yeah, well, I mean, from one perspective, that would be true.
00:22:07 From the perspective of the sort of closely knit, tightly integrated society of the Western European Middle Ages, that society is no more.
00:22:22 It's gone.
00:22:24 I mean, you might find sort of relics of it in sort of agricultural areas of Europe.
00:22:30 but that's sort of that's sort of mostly uh mostly gone um and you know if you think of
00:22:38 if you think of how much has um how should i put this you think of as useful as the internet is
00:22:46 and so forth you think how how um different life is uh you know people are somewhat less likely to
00:22:55 gather in the so-called third place or the you know there's the famous there's the famous study
00:23:01 uh called bowling alone the study of sort of um fraternal and volunteer organizations in america
00:23:08 you know that that sort of lifestyle where you know a whole sort of town gets together to you
00:23:17 know join in a musical performance or you know there are various sort of layers of clubs and
00:23:23 church organizations or volunteer groups you know that has some it's not totally gone but
00:23:29 it has somewhat faded away and i think that the the spread of um you know internet technology
00:23:35 and so forth has somewhat accelerated that um depending on who you ask you know i'm i'm i think
00:23:43 i'm more on the side of that represents a decline rather than an evolution but the the point for me
00:23:52 is not necessarily to pinpoint exactly where we might be on some sort of trajectory but rather
00:23:58 to remind people that what i'm calling civilization is fragile that it needs to be protected and
00:24:06 nurtured and that we do that or historically we have always done that as a species by looking
00:24:13 to the past finding meaning there and and imitating what uh what worked uh before
00:24:23 one of the things that you touch on in the book that i i find very interesting is how contentment
00:24:30 or satisfaction do not correlate with what a lot of people characterize as progress i mean we have
00:24:36 as you've noted in our discussion now and in the book we have technological innovations that you
00:24:41 You know, we're just completely unimaginable.
00:24:44 Even a generation ago, let alone countless generations ago, you have medical innovations, you have longer lifespans.
00:24:51 Now, that is a little bit more dubious now, but all of this has, for a lot of people, not made the world a better place and it's not made their life better.
00:25:02 And I'm curious where you think that comes from.
00:25:05 Is it a decline in faith?
00:25:07 Is it a decline in moral grounding or is it something else entirely?
00:25:10 Well, yeah, that's a very important question. I think that the first thing we should observe, I mean, I'm not a Luddite, I'm not opposed to technologies.
00:25:21 No, you don't view modernity as the enemy as exclusively as some of your contemporaries might.
00:25:26 Yeah, and of course, again, there's no break in history going either forward or back, right? So, you know, we are where we are, and we're not going to change that.
00:25:40 But the fundamental point is that I think in a society in which you would not have had the comforts that you describe or the benefits of science and especially medicine and so forth, that it would have been easier to maintain a view whereby the world requires much more
00:26:10 input from you, much more work from, you know, you and your family to sort of hold it together to keep the forces of chaos at bay or to sort of, you know, reverse decline and so forth.
00:26:24 Now it's easier to coast. And I think that a better approach would be to say, well, let's keep our technology, let's improve it, but let's use it to connect ourselves better, to provide more leisure for ourselves, to work at our culture, to form societies, to form families,
00:26:54 to, you know, ensure that the conditions under which we ourselves grew up and flourished are still there for, you know, for our children and that sort of thing. And I think, I think we've lost sight of that. I think that there was a sense at the end of the 20th century that sort of, you know, triumphant Western liberal order had no enemies left.
00:27:21 left and it was just time to you know relax and take it easy and so on you know a sort of
00:27:28 caricature of the of the of the Fukuyama end of history sort of thing but I think we now realize
00:27:35 that that was mistaken and that you know our institutions and our our civilization need
00:27:42 significantly more work than we've put into them well one of the challenges too is that we often
00:27:50 pretend that some things are a lot more enduring than they are and I mean I know you've worked in
00:27:55 politics I've been immersed in that world unfortunately as well and the reality is
00:28:01 people put so much emphasis on things that will not last and we know will not last and
00:28:05 you see that in manufacturing we build things that do not last and there is this I don't know
00:28:13 if it's an indifference to history or if it's just not understanding what will withstand the test of
00:28:19 time i'm curious your take on that yeah well i mean i i do think that you're right but what has
00:28:25 stood the test of time i think is actually so obvious that it's easy to miss i mean if you think
00:28:32 about it um like civilization or you know what i'm calling civilization is only really about
00:28:41 um 5 000 years old if you if you consider the the say the old kingdom egypt or you know mesopotamia
00:28:53 it's it's about that it has it has some earlier origins which i talk about um in the book but you
00:28:59 know it's fully formed about 5 000 years ago that is a blip in the history of the human species
00:29:07 that's like a nanosecond in our full existence right and if you think about how many of these
00:29:15 societies and empires and you know city-states whatever that have come and gone over time some
00:29:23 of them we didn't even know about until they were dug out of the ground and in the in the 19th
00:29:28 century that's how um thorough the uh collapse and obliteration uh can be and for all we know i mean
00:29:38 it's it's it's not impossible but uh i don't know how likely it is but it's it's possible that um
00:29:47 you know the the very very sort of earliest stirrings of settled life and so forth that they
00:29:54 they represent um the rebirth from a time when there had already been a decline that's possible
00:30:01 you know i don't know for sure but what has worked in the past i think is is is very is
00:30:08 very obvious i mean the earliest states for example or the the earliest societies they
00:30:13 were not states they were basically agglomerations of households um the earliest states were sort of
00:30:20 households scaled up. The household seems to scale well. What does not scale up well,
00:30:28 in my opinion, is the contemporary emphasis on the sort of radical and extreme individualism.
00:30:39 Obviously, in Western society, there's always been a kind of trend, or some people claim to
00:30:47 to have discerned this sort of like inevitable trend toward the growth of individualism and
00:30:54 so forth. And for all the good that that has done, it can be pushed to an extreme. And I think in
00:30:59 contemporary society, it has been. That is an innovation. That is a new thing that I think
00:31:04 has not worked well for us. Looking back to the past, we can find things that have worked simply
00:31:16 because they have been passed down and imitated. And that would be, you know, my recommendation
00:31:23 would be that's where we should start. Someone recently reviewed the book and she said, well,
00:31:29 you know, if I understand it right, what we should do is, you know, we should read our
00:31:34 grandmother's recipes and bake cakes with our children. And I think, yeah, that's great.
00:31:42 that's where let's let's start there one of the big challenges in being canadian is how distorted
00:31:50 your view of time can be and of history can be i mean you mentioned 5 000 years being a blip in
00:31:57 canada if you know an outhouse was constructed in 1920 municipalities will declare it a heritage
00:32:03 landmark and not allow anything to develop it and you go to you know even the united states which
00:32:08 has about a century head start on canada and there is this one on the freedom trail in boston i
00:32:13 remember there's this old 1700s building that was a quintessential part of the american revolution
00:32:17 and it's now a chipotle um and then you go to europe i remember being in malta and i went to
00:32:23 this little museum that was in a church and they had something that was uh 3 000 years old and the
00:32:29 museum director was like here touch it uh here hold it like and i was like i'm terrified of this
00:32:34 And there is something to this that oftentimes we sort of view through our own society's lens where history begins.
00:32:43 And in Canada, whether it's, you know, 1867 or whether you go back to 1763 or 1534, wherever it is, we're still talking about such a narrow, narrow slice of what has been in the world.
00:32:55 And you translate that to architecture to talk about heritage landmarks, and buildings have become, I think, such an interesting case study in how people view history and how people view the past and how people view what is or isn't fashionable.
00:33:11 And I know you talk about architecture significantly in the book, and I was wondering if you'd explain why you believe buildings are so important in this discussion.
00:33:18 Ah, okay, yes, I'll get to the buildings in a second, but I just, I cannot resist taking over one.
00:33:23 So the part of the problem, and, you know, I love history the same way you do, and I think that Canadian history also should be taught and so forth.
00:33:33 But I think that we have to be wary of this idea that you can hive off something called Canadian history from some other kind of human history.
00:33:44 Because if you do that, then you're left with an ever-diminishing amount of time that sort of very quickly becomes current events or some form of journalism, potentially.
00:34:00 Well, and history is a measure of time and also space. You're quite right.
00:34:04 time and space and that's that's the architectural connection too but i mean people have lived in
00:34:10 canada or what we call canada you know um for what is it like 40 000 years i mean
00:34:20 there is there is a history of settlement here which we should not ignore right and obviously
00:34:25 this is a fraught you know this is a politically fraught question which is very sad to me i don't
00:34:32 i wish it were not but um all of human history is our collective patrimony and that there we should
00:34:43 be very wary of sort of hiving it all off into these different things as though there's no
00:34:48 there's no continuity i mean i'm very big on on continuity obviously there are moments where
00:34:53 continuity is broken, but the whole point of the civilized attitude is to try to maintain
00:35:03 that continuity, which means that I'm very, very opposed, or I guess I dislike the sort
00:35:16 of capital L liberal approach to Canadian history whereby there's this sort of break
00:35:22 with the past in in in 1867 and then there's another one in 1982 with pierre trudeau and so
00:35:28 you know i i you know let's just let's just look where you know let's look as far back into the
00:35:36 past as we possibly can to you know um the ancestors of everybody who's here um to our
00:35:44 you know our uh our aboriginal past and let's bring it all together into into the most expansive
00:35:52 and capacious story that we can i mean that's that's my view as for our no it's very well said
00:35:58 and i i know you do have to go but i i do want to get in a question about buildings here because i
00:36:03 did tease it and i'm personally interested in it so explain why that's so central well buildings
00:36:08 Buildings fundamentally symbolize, I argue, what I call the civilized attitude, that you have a place in space and time.
00:36:21 It is symbolized by building a building, by putting up a structure that is an extension of your, you know, it's basically an extension of your own body, which protects you from the elements and marks out a particular space as a significant one, either because you live there or you work there or it's some kind of official building or it's a monument or something like that.
00:36:50 The so-called, the anthropology of architecture, I think, is an extremely important notion. Architecture, if it is to be civilized, it should be built on a human scale.
00:37:02 I don't like the gigantism of modern skyscrapers, which can only be appreciated from a huge distance away, or the sort of distortions of modernist or postmodernist architecture where you don't know where the door is or you can't get in.
00:37:22 And when you find it, you don't know if it's a push or a pull.
00:37:24 Yeah, I mean, there's all that kind of stuff, too. But I mean, fundamentally, ancient people had what I would consider to be a different attitude, which is that you've marked out a place where, you know, some particular activity, business occurs, and that it is structured in a way to meet your needs, not to challenge them.
00:37:44 And I think that that has been, I think that's been lost from urban planning, although there are some, there are some signs that it might be changing. The new king, former Prince Charles, is a big architecture buff. He's written a lot of books that people used to laugh at. But I think that, I think that his position on these things is fundamentally sound, and we might, we might see some change there. We'll see.
00:38:12 Well, it might be a little bit of a low reach for you, 0.63
00:38:14 but I think we should get you on some zoning boards.
00:38:16 I would love to see what you came up with there.
00:38:18 Michael Bonner, the book is In Defense of Civilization,
00:38:22 How Our Past Can Renew Our Present.
00:38:24 And I don't recommend books often
00:38:27 just because I don't read as many books as I'd like.
00:38:30 There are far more out there than I have time to read.
00:38:31 But this one definitely grabbed me
00:38:33 and I think you would enjoy it as well.
00:38:35 Michael, thank you so much for coming on
00:38:37 and for writing this.
00:38:37 It was great talking to you.
00:38:38 Pleasure. Thank you for having me.
00:38:41 you're tuned in to the andrew lawton show
00:38:45 that was michael bonner and that book is uh in defense of civilization the uh that was
00:38:56 pre-recorded uh thankfully uh we were able to turn it around pretty quickly the reason it was
00:39:01 pre-recorded was because of katie telford's extended uh testimony and we had a set time but in any case
00:39:11 We'll have to delve down into the nitty-gritty and talk about the really uber-specific stories.
00:39:23 One in particular jumps out from Vancouver.
00:39:26 We've talked about housing, which is a very big issue.
00:39:29 It is rising in cost.
00:39:31 It is forcing people out of the market entirely.
00:39:34 And in Vancouver, things are so bad that you might find yourself not able to afford a home,
00:39:42 not able to afford perhaps a condo, not able to afford an apartment,
00:39:46 not even able to afford a room in an apartment.
00:39:49 But how about a bed in a room in an apartment?
00:39:52 A Vancouver rental ad was offering a lower bunk for $620, a lower bunk.
00:40:02 Now, this was an ad put on Craigslist, and in the advertisement, it is someone who says they are a University of British Columbia alumni.
00:40:12 Now, I believe it should be alumnus or alumna, but I won't get too particular on the Latin plurals.
00:40:19 They say they're offering this a secure and family-oriented home to live in, and you can go.
00:40:28 I don't know Vancouver very well.
00:40:29 It's actually in a house.
00:40:31 The house features 10 bedrooms and nine bathrooms, and they're just like cramming students into this, I guess, to such an extent that you can, for $600 in this house, get the lower bunk.
00:40:42 Now, so each of the rooms is $1,101 plus utilities and internet, and for two people, there's a $350 charge, and this leads us to the one shared room that is like the hostel equivalent of housing.
00:40:58 Now, I don't want to begrudge people that need to make tough calls, but I think when we are renting out lower bunks and people think this is an acceptable housing option, perhaps we are not exactly looking at the right way of doing things in society.
00:41:13 Now, the ad ended up being removed, as I understand it. So I don't know if this is because someone snatched it up or maybe because it got a little bit of negative attention. It got pulled for that reason. But the bizarre thing is, if you look at that, the house is actually lovely.
00:41:27 I mean, the house actually looks like a lot of fun.
00:41:29 The kitchen is nice and spacious, has a beautiful island.
00:41:32 They've even got a French press on the kitchen counter in the listing.
00:41:36 So clearly some classy coffee taste.
00:41:38 But when you are cramming so many people into the house, I don't know, maybe that's a way to make your university experience sore.
00:41:45 But I think it is an example of perhaps a less than adequate situation here.
00:41:50 Other weird news today that I have to point out.
00:41:54 This one brought me back because years ago in Ontario, when the Liberal government was in power,
00:41:59 I remember there was this big controversy.
00:42:01 It was all the rage and talk radio in the columns of government subsidizing a giant duck.
00:42:08 Now, this was a real story.
00:42:11 There was a giant duck.
00:42:12 It was supposed to be the world's largest duck.
00:42:14 You can see it for yourself on the screen right now.
00:42:17 The world's largest duck was to be a magnificent display,
00:42:21 so much so that the Ontario government was subsidizing this.
00:42:27 And, you know, oddly, as far as things that the Kathleen Wynne government in Ontario spent money on,
00:42:31 the duck wasn't even the worst.
00:42:33 But this rubber duck is coming back.
00:42:35 It has now been six years since Ontarians were first graced with its presence, 0.91
00:42:40 and now the Toronto Waterfront Festival is returning,
00:42:43 and the duck will be coming back in September.
00:42:46 So if you missed your shot at looking at this giant floating bath toy in 2017,
00:42:52 you can come back and I may actually take a quack at doing a segment about it in September.
00:43:00 Never mind. I won't do that anymore.
00:43:03 I apologize. That was not fair for you to have to listen to that.
00:43:09 What else do we have going on here?
00:43:11 You think inflation is bad?
00:43:12 Even the price of Girl Guide cookies is going up.
00:43:16 I got a bulletin, a business bulletin this morning.
00:43:19 I'm not going to make a pun on this one.
00:43:21 So if you're all nervous now and you're ready to get pun triggered, that won't happen.
00:43:27 But the Girl Guides have raised their cookie prices for the first time in a decade by 20%.
00:43:33 So the classic chocolate and vanilla sandwich cookies, which are not as good as the mint ones, by the way.
00:43:38 And where do the mint ones go?
00:43:41 Because it seems like anytime they're selling cookies,
00:43:43 it's these like weird vanilla chocolate ones.
00:43:45 Anyway, they're going up from $5 to $6 a box
00:43:49 due to increased costs of baking and shipping.
00:43:52 So first it's the eggs and then it's the Girl Guide cookies.
00:43:56 And now you have to choose between the lower bunk in a Vancouver apartment
00:44:00 or the extra box of Girl Guide cookies.
00:44:03 These are the tough choices that people need to make now.
00:44:05 It is Friday, so keeping with the True North tradition, we like to end things on a bit of a lighter note.
00:44:12 And I'm trying to like wash the taste of the, you know, take a quack at it pun out of your ears because tastes are in your ears now.
00:44:19 It's a very, we're going very postmodern on the show today.
00:44:22 But let's have a little round of Fake News Friday.
00:44:25 yes fake news friday scouring every corner of the globe finding our way through the
00:44:40 blizzard of lies the depths of deception the caves of confabulations i don't know
00:44:47 fabrications we'll uh we'll come up with some new alliteration there uh but this one actually
00:44:51 we have to give honourable mention to Conservative leader Pierre Polyev for trying to push back
00:44:57 against this in real time when faced with a question in Edmonton from a Canadian press
00:45:03 reporter. Take a look. When it comes to defunding the CBC, you've signaled the intention to maintain
00:45:11 a level of support for Radio Canada and French language programming. To do that, the corporation
00:45:16 says the Broadcasting Act would need to be amended. So are you prepared to change the law and create
00:45:21 public broadcaster that only serves one group in canada are you you work for cp yes i do so
00:45:28 your biggest client is cbc right yes but yes that's right i just don't want i just want to
00:45:34 be careful that we don't get you into a conflict of interest here have you checked with the ethics
00:45:38 commissioner on whether you're in a conflict of interest in asking about cbc funding given that
00:45:42 it's the principal source of money for cp uh i would check that with my editors but again are
00:45:48 Are you still prepared to change the law and create a public broadcaster that only serves one language in Canada?
00:45:53 The CBC, frankly, is a biased propaganda arm of the Liberal Party and, frankly, negatively affects all media.
00:46:05 For example, CP is negatively affected by the fact that you have to report favorably on the CBC
00:46:12 if you want to keep your number one taxpayer-funded client happy.
00:46:15 we need a neutral and free media but not a propaganda arm for the liberal party and when
00:46:23 i'm prime minister we're going to have a free press where everyday canadians decide what they
00:46:28 think rather than having liberal propaganda jammed down their throats next question thank you
00:46:34 well that was uh i think quite the display and look i think that in some cases uh it is fair to
00:46:50 say that we don't want to see a totally antagonistic relationship between politicians
00:46:54 and the media but i think both of them have a job to do and i think it's fine to fight fire with
00:46:59 fire. And in that case, if you have Pierre Polyev getting needled with questions about CBC defunding
00:47:04 and he wants to point out that, hey, you guys are cashing big checks from CBC, that's a fair
00:47:10 question to put to journalists. And one thing I'll say about the media in general is that oftentimes
00:47:16 journalists try to sort of hide behind objectivity and in the sense that they don't believe that they
00:47:23 are agents of the stories they cover and the issues they cover and all of that. And I don't
00:47:28 know the reporter who asked the question. This isn't a slight of them by any stretch, but I'm
00:47:32 saying in general, the I'm just asking questions defense doesn't really fly when you're going after
00:47:38 one particular party or one particular candidate in a different way than you go after others. So
00:47:43 I think in this particular case, yes, it's fair to talk to Pierre Polyev about CBC funding,
00:47:48 given that is a campaign issue that he's chosen to take up. Completely fair. I also think it's
00:47:55 fair for the media to have to play defense every now and then because we know the other way hasn't
00:47:59 exactly worked well for conservatives of just groveling and hoping that eventually you'll make
00:48:04 them like you so that hasn't worked so try the Ron DeSantis approach as I've said in the past
00:48:10 that does it for us for today I want to just give you a huge thank you for tuning in to this show
00:48:16 as you've noted we've only added the Friday show relatively recently so we're playing around with
00:48:21 it. Last time I just did like, you know, a round of standup comedy. This time you got the crappy
00:48:27 duck joke. So not always am I going to land it, but we are going to have a lot of fun sometimes
00:48:32 when we can, because it's the only way to suffer through the aforementioned decline of civilization
00:48:37 to at least laugh on the way out. So I always try to take somewhat of a cheery disposition on these
00:48:43 things, not because I don't realize how serious things are, but because if we're crying and
00:48:48 screaming we are not going to get through it the way we can if we can find something to laugh at
00:48:52 and we get lots of material for that so that's my little plug for a bit of joy as you head into the
00:48:58 weekend hopefully the weather is nice where you are and if you are inclined to support independent
00:49:04 media you can head over to donate.tnc.news and we thank you so much for your support that does
00:49:10 it for us back next week with more of Canada's most irreverent talk show thank you god bless
00:49:14 and good day to you all
00:49:18 Thanks for listening to The Andrew Lawton Show.
00:49:21 Support the program by donating to True North at www.tnc.news.