Juno News - September 10, 2021


Leaders Debate 2021 - True North Exclusive Coverage

Topics
Mentioned
Trudeau goes off the rails against independent media The case of Dr. Julie Ponesse: ethics professor placed on leave for not getting the vaccine

Episode Stats


Length

4 hours and 23 minutes

Words per minute

171.15

Word count

45,158

Sentence count

3,074

Harmful content

Misogyny

17

sentences flagged

Toxicity

9

sentences flagged

Hate speech

42

sentences flagged


Summary

Summaries generated with gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ .

Tonight's election night special is a special election night edition of the True North Politics podcast. Hosted by Sarah Abdurrahman, Andrew Lawton, and Sue Ann Levy, we're here to talk all things election, politics, and all things federal politics.

Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Topics generated with Qwen2.5-3B-Instruct.
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 Thank you.
00:00:30 Thank you.
00:01:00 We'll be right back.
00:01:30 We'll be right back.
00:02:00 We'll be right back.
00:02:30 We'll be right back.
00:03:00 We'll be right back.
00:03:30 We'll be right back.
00:04:00 We'll be right back.
00:04:30 Thank you.
00:05:00 We'll be right back.
00:05:30 Thank you.
00:06:00 We'll be right back.
00:06:30 Hi, we're live downtown Toronto, sorry there's a little bit of a technical glitch there,
00:06:56 But tonight is the election night special here at True North.
00:06:59 We're so excited for all the programming that we have here tonight.
00:07:02 I'm joined in studio by a group of my friends.
00:07:05 I'm really excited to have Sue Ann Levy, a True North contributor here.
00:07:09 We have Anthony Fury, the editor over at the Toronto Sun,
00:07:12 and Hamish Marshall, True North's in-house pollster for the election.
00:07:15 We have a lot to talk about.
00:07:16 We're going to talk about all things politics, all things federal election.
00:07:20 But first, we're going to go over to Andrew Lawton,
00:07:22 who is live with us in Gatineau, outside of the federal leaders' debate.
00:07:27 Andrew, what's going on over there at the leaders' debate?
00:07:32 Well, of course, at the exact moment you asked that question,
00:07:35 a bunch of protesters start shouting.
00:07:37 There are a lot of PPC protesters here, actually.
00:07:40 Maxime Bernier and the People's Party upset about not being included in the official debate,
00:07:45 so they decided to have a rally outside the Canadian Museum of History here in Gatineau.
00:07:50 It's been very peaceful, no issues in the time that I've been out here.
00:07:54 As of right now, I'm actually in the secure part of the debate venue, outside, as we await the arrival of the leaders.
00:08:00 So far, just Annamie Paul has arrived, which means there are four leaders left to go for the five who will be debating tonight for the first and only time in English.
00:08:11 Interesting. And so what are you expecting for the debate? Are the leaders there yet? Has anyone arrived?
00:08:18 so just anime paul has arrived right now the the others will be on route very shortly because this
00:08:24 is kicking off in about an hour's time one of the interesting things that that i think uh from the
00:08:29 last debate which is the french language debate last night that will be a bit different is that
00:08:34 this one's a lot more widely viewed this is the one that's more likely to get clipped and picked
00:08:38 up by the media so if there were leaders that were holding something back in the tank if you will
00:08:43 I think we can expect to see that come out tonight.
00:08:48 Is the format going to be the same?
00:08:50 I mean, I tuned into the French debate last night.
00:08:52 I don't think there are many people, other people,
00:08:54 they're just judging by the numbers on YouTube and the live streams.
00:08:57 But can we expect a similar format?
00:09:00 Last night, there was, you know, it was very scripted.
00:09:03 There wasn't really a lot of back and forth,
00:09:04 not a lot of opportunities to get into real debates.
00:09:08 And they covered a lot of grounds.
00:09:09 But the issues that they covered were, in my mind,
00:09:12 not the most relevant issues in the country.
00:09:14 Do you know if it's the same format tonight as it was last night, Andrew?
00:09:18 It's very similar. There are some minor differences.
00:09:21 Of course, the moderators are a bit different.
00:09:23 But they're sticking to that idea of having five core themes.
00:09:26 And what's interesting, and what's been one of the bigger criticisms
00:09:29 put towards the debate since they announced the themes,
00:09:32 is that there is not going to be a foreign policy section at all.
00:09:36 There's going to be talk about leadership and accountability,
00:09:38 some COVID recovery, reconciliation,
00:09:40 but no talk of foreign policy and a lot of people feel like well we have a crisis with Afghanistan
00:09:46 a growing conflict with China like we're missing out on a very key part of the campaign here
00:09:52 remember for the first week Justin Trudeau couldn't have an event without being asked about
00:09:56 what was happening in Afghanistan and Canada's response or lack thereof so the fact that that
00:10:01 isn't going to be brought up here officially is a big frustration for people now in response to
00:10:07 this what some people have said is, well, there's no reason a leader couldn't bring it up in some
00:10:12 other form, you know, maybe bring it up in the accountability section. But that's going to be
00:10:16 one of the big things that I think a lot of people are going to see is missing from tonight's debate.
00:10:21 Kind of sad, isn't it, Andrew? I remember back when the media used to organize these debates
00:10:25 before it was a government commission that did it, and that was a new thing under Trudeau.
00:10:30 We'd have lots of debates. We had, I remember, McLean's hosted an entirely foreign policy
00:10:35 debate back when Harper was the prime minister in 2015.
00:10:39 And, you know, it seems that the government's taking control of these debates, but they
00:10:43 haven't really done a very good job.
00:10:44 It seems bizarre, just given, you know, Canada's place in the world, doing Trudeau's whole
00:10:48 thing before was Canada's back and look at us in the world stage.
00:10:52 And here we are in 2021.
00:10:54 You know, we've lived through a global pandemic. 1.00
00:10:56 We have China on the rise.
00:10:57 We have Afghanistan falling to the Taliban.
00:11:00 And yet nothing on foreign affairs, foreign debate.
00:11:03 It's really, really sad.
00:11:06 Yeah, and I'm sure Hamish can tell you when you get to discussing things later on that foreign policy does not traditionally move votes, but that doesn't make it less important.
00:11:15 And the whole reason for the government takeover of the debates, the formation of this Leaders Debates Commission, was to supposedly create a debate that wasn't beholden to the interests of private media companies that would serve a public interest.
00:11:27 So you have to look at and say whose interests are being served when some pretty key issues that matter to the country are being left out of the discussion.
00:11:35 So I think that's a big, a big issue here.
00:11:38 And again, you know, there are other opportunities that leaders can still bring up whatever issues they want in the scrums, depending on what they're asked and throughout the course of the campaign.
00:11:46 But that's going to be one of the noteworthy aspects of this.
00:11:48 And just looking at kind of the analysis from last night's debate, the French debate, a lot of the times what is discussed matters a lot more than what's said in response to it.
00:11:59 One notable example of this is a question on climate change from an 11-year-old.
00:12:03 And the entire premise of the question was based on gloom and doom.
00:12:07 The question used the term climate catastrophe.
00:12:10 The 11-year-old was saying he's worried about his future kids.
00:12:13 And so it becomes very difficult for any leader to really have a discussion about this when it's already been framed in a particular way.
00:12:20 So format matters.
00:12:22 It's so sad. Honestly, everything that's wrong with the country and the way that we, even the way that we introduce these topics to kids,
00:12:28 we're giving these little kids anxiety, giving them fear about a politicized concept.
00:12:33 I was really bothered, Andrew, last night when they had that 11-year-old.
00:12:37 And look, he did a great job.
00:12:38 but honestly like the idea that he was asking about what his kids like 11 year old saying what
00:12:44 will my kids future look like I don't know an 11 year old that thinks that way I have a hard time
00:12:49 believing that he came up with that question on his own it was actually it was almost like a lost
00:12:53 in translation moment like did I hear that correctly this little 11 year old just asking
00:12:57 about his own kids that to me that was just pure political uh propaganda and it was really
00:13:02 disappointing to see. Andrew, quickly, just one more question. What can we expect format-wise?
00:13:08 So we have a two-hour debate, and then let us know a little bit about what to expect after that.
00:13:15 So it's going to be just the debate itself for a moment. It's going to be broken up into five
00:13:19 themes. So roughly, that will work out to be the two hours divided evenly among those themes.
00:13:25 And interestingly enough, I think what we're likely to see is a fair bit of crossover there.
00:13:30 So I do think that some of the discussions won't be as easily confined to their section just because of the format.
00:13:36 And then after the debate, all the leaders, all five who are participating, will come and do a 10-minute scrum each for reporters.
00:13:43 And this was something, if anyone did watch the French-language debate last night, you'll know I was able to get a couple of questions in.
00:13:49 One to Prime Minister Justin Trudeau and another to NDP leader Jagmeet Singh.
00:13:53 And it's kind of a bit of a luck of the draw as to which leader you get to ask a question to.
00:13:57 But obviously, you know, the reason I'm here is because that opportunity to put questions to leaders who might not otherwise take questions from reporters or take questions from us allows us to ask things that do matter to a lot of people but haven't really been front and center in much of the campaign coverage.
00:14:13 So, you know, it may just be, you know, a 50-minute period after a debate, but it's a very important 50-minute period because that's where you get an opportunity to sometimes go beyond the talking points or at least beyond the issues that have been taking up a lot of the oxygen of the campaign.
00:14:27 Right, and I mean, it's the closest that we at True North come to being able to ask Justin Trudeau questions and hold him accountable.
00:14:33 It's great that you got that question into him last night, Andrew.
00:14:36 And unfortunately, you know, Justin Trudeau's never answered a question, I don't think, in his life.
00:14:39 He talked, you know, you asked a question and then he talked for a minute, but he didn't really address your question or answer it in any way.
00:14:47 But still, you know, you've got to take your chance and put questions in.
00:14:50 Well, we really look forward to it.
00:14:52 To me, you know, that's the most exciting part of the night is those scrums afterwards.
00:14:55 but obviously we've got a big night planned and lots of exciting things so
00:15:00 Andrew thank you so much for joining us from Gatineau and we look forward to
00:15:05 seeing you later on in the show. Well I think I saw some bourbon there so save
00:15:09 me some when I get for when I get back to Ottawa.
00:15:12 Alright so I feel like there's a lot to talk about and you know what what Andrew
00:15:18 and I just got into a little bit was that the fact that there are protests
00:15:22 outside of this event. We've seen protests throughout the entire campaign and I feel
00:15:25 like that is the theme of this campaign is Justin Trudeau's unpopularity. He
00:15:30 obviously called this election because he believed that he was going to get a
00:15:34 majority. He thought that, you know, the polls, I believe at the time, were telling us that he was
00:15:38 going to win a majority. Is that right? Absolutely, yeah. If you look at the polls
00:15:41 week before the election was called, the majority was the most, by far, the most
00:15:45 likely outcome. His personal popularity numbers were not, they weren't
00:15:50 spectacularly good but they were better than they were two years ago when he went
00:15:53 into the 2019 election they were looking decent and really the big story of this
00:15:56 campaign has been his personal numbers have just tracked down our own poll
00:16:00 showed he's certainly dropped over the last three and a bit weeks and you know I
00:16:06 think this debate's maybe a good part of that whether he can try to try to recreate
00:16:09 some of that old magic but what we thought what I've certainly found in
00:16:12 research with with about Dustin Trudeau in the past is he's unusual politician
00:16:17 and then once people decide they don't like him for whatever reason we
00:16:19 does something whether it's you know blackface or the trip to India or any
00:16:25 number of a hundred other gaffes is once they stop liking them they'll just sort
00:16:29 of start liking a little bit or disliking a little bit more you just
00:16:32 really dislike them. A lot of people really like them but really dislike them and he really
00:16:36 polarizes people so his ability to get people back or charm them again is very
00:16:41 very limited and that's why I think the selection is very tight. What do you think?
00:16:45 What is it about Dustin Trudeau that you either love him or you hate Anthony?
00:16:48 Well, you know, it's a phrase that they apply to Greek tragedy, hubris.
00:16:52 And that's what we've seen here in all of this.
00:16:55 As Hamish says, things were looking good for him.
00:16:58 He says, well, maybe they can look better.
00:17:00 Maybe I can go.
00:17:02 And at this moment where lots of divided opinions on the pandemic, stuff was going to happen in Afghanistan.
00:17:09 I know he didn't think it would be the exact day he went to the governor general.
00:17:11 But perhaps if he had his eye on the ball a bit more and been talking to the commanders on the ground,
00:17:15 then he would have foresaw, okay, this is the situation that's going to happen right when I call for this election.
00:17:21 So I think hubris thought the better of him.
00:17:23 And that may be the story of his whole political career.
00:17:26 Well, I mean, in some ways it served him well.
00:17:29 I was thinking back to Justin Trudeau in 2015, and, you know, there was something exciting about him.
00:17:34 I was never a Trudeau fan or anything like that.
00:17:37 But, you know, he was on the cover of the Rolling Stone magazine.
00:17:40 He was sort of young and a little bit famous.
00:17:42 and people there was there was sort of excitement around him and trudeau mania like i don't i don't
00:17:49 know what the first trudeau mania was but there was definitely that excitement i it was unlike
00:17:54 previous politicians the thing i like about canadian politicians is they're usually pretty
00:17:58 boring and unassuming and justin trudeau was a little bit different and i think that's what you
00:18:02 either love or hate and you know by the time 2019 rolled around he couldn't really do that anymore
00:18:08 like you know the blackface thing that came out in the middle of the campaign that that that really 0.81
00:18:13 hurt his street creds with the left wing kind of like avant-garde people that just weren't gonna
00:18:18 you know he's not really broke he's fake world right and so he really that campaign was like he
00:18:24 had to demonize the conservatives and he sort of like set it up like he's the anti-trump he's not
00:18:28 trump he's trudeau he's the nice progressive guy and i feel like this time around he doesn't really
00:18:33 have that contrast and he's having a really hard time creating a blue man to contrast himself with
00:18:38 and that's part of the disease. What do you think? I think also that population has woken up 1.00
00:18:43 as opposed to being woken up during COVID and people have suffered a lot. They lost people,
00:18:51 they lost their jobs, they lost their businesses and I think aside from the full vaccine
00:18:59 issue and his failure to bring the vaccine to Canada in a timely manner, I think people were
00:19:06 were really suffering, and he underestimated that, and the people that are protesting,
00:19:13 I believe, are not anti-vaxxers, they're people who are just fed up with Trudeau, and fed
00:19:19 up with what happened during COVID, and the failure of the government to realize that
00:19:24 these people are suffering and to connect with people.
00:19:27 Well, it's interesting.
00:19:28 Well, we must just sit in a poll for Trudeau, and we're talking about this on our show today,
00:19:33 So we asked, can we try to explain the question about whether COVID changed people's executive
00:19:40 government?
00:19:41 Sure, yeah.
00:19:42 So we asked people basically lockdowns made you more concerned about the government's
00:19:46 amount of power the government has or lockdowns made you more grateful the government has
00:19:53 the power to take actions to look to keep you safe.
00:19:56 And 35% of people say lockdowns made you more concerned about government power.
00:20:02 35% say they're more grateful for the government's power, but 35%, you know, in our conversation
00:20:09 with us, Candice, you know, like 35% in Canada, that's actually a good number and a good start.
00:20:14 And interestingly enough, when you think of these poor deaths we've been seeing, especially
00:20:17 in Quebec, that number is highest in Quebec.
00:20:20 I think it's 47 or 48% are more concerned about the growth of governor power in Quebec,
00:20:27 which I think is very interesting and could certainly lead to all sorts of interesting things over there.
00:20:33 Well, 35%, I mean, it seems bad because obviously the overwhelming majority of Canadians just feel good about having Big Brother taking care of them.
00:20:41 But, you know, 35%, if that's like the upward ability of Maxine Bernier to win,
00:20:47 I mean, that would be a total game-changer in Canadian politics if he could manage to kind of recruit all those people.
00:20:52 But I think that, Sue, and you're right, that the sort of anger people have,
00:20:56 it's not just at being anti-vaccine and this is something that really bothers me the way that
00:21:02 Justin Trudeau tries to sort of own science like it's like whatever his opinion is is the science
00:21:07 like capital T capital S and he uses it all the time even you know last night at the debate he
00:21:11 took a shot at the rebel and he said you know it's because of you that people don't trust the
00:21:15 science and it's like I overhear people's conversation even today I was at the hairdresser
00:21:20 getting my hair cut and the guy next to me was complaining about people who don't get vaccinated
00:21:24 saying that because of them his kids still have to wear masks at school and he's just fed up
00:21:28 and he wants like you know he's just ranting this guy right and i'm kind of thinking like
00:21:33 just because you're vaccinated doesn't mean that covid goes away right like like just anecdotally
00:21:38 i know somebody who's fully vaccinated they had been on a business trip to dallas came back and
00:21:43 had covid right there's a big outbreak happening in texas right now so just because you're fully
00:21:47 vaccinated doesn't make covid go away but people have this perception and trudeau's the one that's
00:21:52 pushing it that as soon as we get to this level where everyone's vaccinated we can just go back
00:21:56 to normal it's like is that even true like like where are we where are we headed because people
00:22:02 can still get it i mean if we're talking about back to normal justin trudeau's double vaccinated
00:22:06 and he still walks around with a mask half the time he's like why are you wearing a mask if you're
00:22:10 double vaccinated a couple of them have added as well so sophie rivar trudeau had it so they've
00:22:18 they've had two doses of vaccine they've had the virus itself some of them not all of them
00:22:23 but but i think you know to your point about trudeau stressing these points so hard i mean
00:22:27 that still gives the government the end to say we have the magic silver bullet solution and you just
00:22:33 have to come to us and we will solve this for you i remember well over a year ago they said all you
00:22:37 got to do is download our contact tracing app and they were really pushing that said this will end
00:22:41 the pandemic subsequent things have come along usually provincial issues and i can hammer
00:22:45 different premiers on that that all we mean is this that or the other vaccine passports is the
00:22:49 newest thing if only we bring in the vaccine passports it's all done uh right away but after
00:22:54 doug ford cave and said he'd bring one in in ontario just three hours later the ontario science
00:22:59 table i came over the report saying well we still might need to have a fall lockdown so you're like
00:23:04 clearly there is no magic silver bullet solution but i know the politicians would like to dangle
00:23:10 that idea uh in front of us and to your point about the anecdote of the hairdresser i mean
00:23:14 No, I think a lot of people are buying it, sure.
00:23:17 Well, if any thinking person would see that the goalposts keep changing.
00:23:21 So if you want to travel, if I were to jump on a plane tomorrow,
00:23:25 I'm double vaccinated, have been since April.
00:23:29 I still have to get a COVID test before I leave, show it, show proof.
00:23:35 I'm going to a Broadway show in a couple of weeks.
00:23:37 They've sent me a whole thing telling me what I have to do.
00:23:40 Wait, you didn't mix vaccines, did you?
00:23:42 No.
00:23:42 There's a whole story about if you got AstraZeneca and you got something else, you couldn't be a broad way to use.
00:23:46 I got, yeah, I got Moderna.
00:23:48 But, I mean, there's a whole protocol you still have to follow.
00:23:51 So, you know, vaccines are not going to be the panacea.
00:23:55 And talk about boosters, if you look in Israel, they're already talking about third and fourth shots.
00:24:01 Well, and they're also having a huge spike in cases.
00:24:04 Yes, yes.
00:24:05 So, yeah, I feel like politicians just sort of, exactly, they said they've removed the
00:24:08 bullpen, so they're hanging these carrots for us, to make us believe that if we just
00:24:12 jump through this next group, it's like, at some point, people have a breaking point.
00:24:16 And I think that's what we're seeing with a lot of the protests.
00:24:19 People are just absolutely fed up.
00:24:21 They've had enough.
00:24:21 And this is an interesting point I raised in my show the other day.
00:24:24 So when there were large-scale protests, like three years ago, led by Greta, the teenage
00:24:30 environmentalist, you know, all these kids were out there, and they were angry.
00:24:34 and that was that was wonderful that you know that was passionate kids looking
00:24:38 out for their future and then the same thing with the Black Lives Matter protests
00:24:42 you know we had angry people there was a lot of violence a lot of looting the
00:24:46 whole movement for defunding the police you know it's a left-wing social movement
00:24:50 and it got huge coverage and huge credibility in mainstream culture even
00:24:53 this past summer when the reconciliation issue came up and the residential
00:24:58 schools and the unmarked graves it's like there's a lot of anger a lot of
00:25:02 a lot of vandalism, a lot of violence, and we just heard constant excuses for this behavior.
00:25:07 And now we see, you know, large, huge protests like the one in Montreal.
00:25:12 I've never really seen something that big.
00:25:14 I was surprised when I was looking at it when there was Montreal.
00:25:17 You know, you'd assume they wanted to go to Calgary or something,
00:25:20 but no, freedom-loving people in Montreal.
00:25:23 And the way that the media just either ignores them or completely demonizes them,
00:25:27 or the prime minister of the country completely demonizes them,
00:25:29 These people are racist, these people are misogynistic, these people are angry, and they have no credibility whatsoever.
00:25:35 Their political issues and their anger translates to them being bad people, 0.62
00:25:40 whereas on the left, these same people's anger, it's passion and it's social movements.
00:25:47 It's the same double standard. It drives me crazy because I've seen legacy media
00:25:55 characterized, that is, for example, rabid right-wing, PPC followers, anti-vaxxers, you know, crazies, and everybody follows in long step.
00:26:09 Trudeau says it, and everybody else in the media portrays the same way.
00:26:15 These are just people who are fed up, as you said. Average people.
00:26:20 I've been canvassing the last couple of days in Midtown Toronto, and I'm telling you, it's a very liberal riding.
00:26:27 But you go knocking on the doors and people are so angry with Prime Minister Trudeau.
00:26:33 It's over and over again.
00:26:35 They'd rather vote MVP or Green.
00:26:37 I'm hearing that over and over and over again.
00:26:40 Interesting.
00:26:40 No, it's really interesting to see Trudeau.
00:26:42 It's just a total fall from grace.
00:26:44 We've got Andrew out in Gatineau, and we're going to go back to him.
00:26:48 So Andrew, tell us a little bit about, we're talking to Andrew Lawton, True North contributor, True North senior fellow.
00:26:54 Tell us what the scene is over there in Gatineau outside of the federal leaders' debate.
00:27:00 Yeah, thanks. It has been a bit interesting.
00:27:03 So the noises that you might hear from time to time tend to time with whenever a politician's motorcade or vehicle is coming into the area.
00:27:11 and people are not quite pleased with it.
00:27:13 These are overwhelmingly People's Party of Canada protesters
00:27:16 who were gathered with a very simple message at first,
00:27:19 let Max speak.
00:27:20 But interestingly enough,
00:27:21 and kind of tying into the discussion you were just having,
00:27:24 a lot of the frustration that is driving their protests
00:27:28 seems to be what we see driving a lot of the protests
00:27:31 that have dogged Justin Trudeau
00:27:32 for the entirety of the campaign.
00:27:34 And that is frustration with vaccine passports,
00:27:36 frustration with this sort of permanent suspension of normalcy.
00:27:41 And that's, I think, quite interesting.
00:27:43 And just to go back to some of the themes that I think are likely to emerge tonight,
00:27:47 one thing that I'm going to be listening for is any sort of discussion about that idea of returning to normal.
00:27:54 What does normal look like?
00:27:55 What are the benchmarks that we are using to get it there?
00:27:58 And interestingly enough, last night, all of the talk was really about, when it came to COVID anyway,
00:28:03 about how much aid was given, what that aid was being used for.
00:28:07 There was some discussion about CERB and CRB and the longevity of some of these programs, the labour shortage that we're seeing all over the country.
00:28:15 These were some of the ideas that came up.
00:28:17 But none were really getting to the crux of the matter, which is we've got travel restrictions, we've got vaccine passports, we've got further encroachments on what we can do in our individual lives in most provinces in Canada.
00:28:29 What is your plan to get us out of that?
00:28:31 And that was not something that we heard at all.
00:28:33 So that's going to be something I'm listening for in tonight's debate.
00:28:36 And not to tip my hand too, too much, but something that I might actually ask about in the scrums after.
00:28:41 So that's going to be one of the big things that I'm keeping an ear out for and keeping an eye out for in the debate.
00:28:47 And just to give you a sense of where things stand now, as far as the arrival of leaders,
00:28:51 we're only waiting on, I think, one or two more.
00:28:53 Justin Trudeau just arrived a couple of moments ago, so things should be getting started up.
00:28:58 And this is, for those who are just tuning in, the English language leaders debate starting at 9 p.m.
00:29:04 But it's going to be certainly an interesting night anyway.
00:29:06 That report, Andrew Lawton on the ground in Gatineau, which is just right outside of Ottawa.
00:29:12 We're really excited, and thank you for giving us that update.
00:29:16 Yeah, you can see Ottawa in the background, so we're close there.
00:29:19 There it is. Oh, yeah. Oh, is that Parliament right behind you?
00:29:23 Yes, yes.
00:29:24 Nice. Awesome. All right, thank you so much, Andrew, right back in the studio here with Sue Ann Levy.
00:29:30 I'm Candice Malcolm. We've got Anthony Fearing and Hamish Marshall.
00:29:33 Thank you so much for tuning in to the show.
00:29:36 And if you like Tremor, if you appreciate the work that we do and our investigative journalism, our independence,
00:29:42 I really encourage you to help us out, make a donation.
00:29:44 Anything that you can give is really helpful to our operation.
00:29:48 We're funded entirely by generous Canadians and their donations.
00:29:52 We don't take bailouts from the media.
00:29:55 And it's so disheartening as a journalist to see so many media outlets,
00:29:59 so many journalists across the country increasingly taking more and more money it's like every year
00:30:04 there's another story of another media bailout or another fund that the trudeau government has
00:30:09 created to support local journalism or to support certain types of journalism it's like they're
00:30:14 creeping their hands into every corner of the industry and it's really hard to trust a journalist
00:30:19 that is getting paid for by a bailout from the trudeau government whether it be the state
00:30:24 broadcaster in the cbc or more and more newspapers that are going to the government hat in hand
00:30:29 to get a bailout and it's interesting just as a journalist to watch the landscape change over the
00:30:34 last decade or so um you know the the old guard is really kind of clutching they don't want to let go
00:30:40 of their hold over the country over the control that they have or they perceive that they have
00:30:45 um in in sort of having the establishment views and and the in the old uh distribution chains
00:30:51 and and it's kind of fun to see disruptors out there and different outlets younger people not
00:30:56 even getting their news at all from newspapers or or television people going entirely into social
00:31:01 media so it's fun to be a part of that and i'm really excited about the work that we do at
00:31:05 true dork about lots of programming lots of content investigative journalism written reports
00:31:09 every day at tnc.news we do podcasts live shows events like like this here and so we really have
00:31:15 a lot going on and if you if you like your journalism and you want to support independent
00:31:18 journalism in canada i encourage you to head on over to tnc.news slash donate i want to talk a
00:31:24 little bit about the um debate format i touched it a little bit in the intro when i was talking
00:31:29 to andrew but basically the idea that the government is now the one that controls how
00:31:34 these debates are run in the in the federal government i um our friends over at the rebel
00:31:39 had to sue and do an emergency injunction once again this year in order to get into the into
00:31:45 the debate and i watched the hearing that they did and it was interesting to hear the government
00:31:49 lawyer explain why the debates commission exists because they really think that they have a noble
00:31:55 role it's like oh the debates uh there was like public trust was was was waning and we need to
00:32:01 re-establish public trust in this debate process of the election and yet i can't imagine um how
00:32:09 any of the debates commission that they the work that they do how that would regain the trust of
00:32:14 canadians i mean just this election alone we have what three well two two official french
00:32:20 debates and then they got the french um profiles of each leader and now we finally have an english
00:32:24 debate and it's in quebec right it's like why can't they do a debate in alberta why can't they
00:32:29 do a debate in vancouver it's it's really it really doesn't feel like they're representative
00:32:34 of the country in any way well the the funny thing actually is that all their arguments about how the
00:32:39 The old system of consoria, journalists getting together and creating debates didn't work.
00:32:46 They don't apply that to Quebec because there actually are only two government debates.
00:32:51 There's the French debate last night, the English debate tonight.
00:32:54 But last week, Té Véa, which is the biggest private TV channel in Quebec, had their own debates.
00:33:00 And Té Véa just said, we're having a debate.
00:33:02 We're inviting these candidates, these four candidates.
00:33:07 And if you don't come, you don't care.
00:33:08 but we're going to do it anyway.
00:33:10 McTavia has such a big audience,
00:33:11 the power of the market means that everybody comes.
00:33:14 And the difference is, it would be like,
00:33:16 there isn't really an equivalent in English Canada
00:33:18 that has a big enough market share in order to do that.
00:33:21 If you remember in the last election, actually,
00:33:23 and you might not even remember this
00:33:24 because it didn't really work,
00:33:26 is City TV tried to do a national debate
00:33:28 in the first week of the campaign.
00:33:30 And there was Elizabeth May and Andrew Scheer
00:33:33 and Jameet Singh, but Mr. Trudeau did not come.
00:33:38 And they did the debate, and because the prime minister
00:33:40 wasn't there, the ratings were terrible,
00:33:43 and it wasn't a big success for City TV.
00:33:47 And actually, McLean's co-hosted it with them.
00:33:50 And then on top of that, they sure
00:33:54 didn't pay a big price because City TV doesn't have the ratings
00:33:57 or the reach across the country to really make them pay
00:34:00 a price for skipping that debate.
00:34:02 So I find it very odd that we're in this world
00:34:05 where they have all these arguments about how this
00:34:07 about establishing public trust and everything,
00:34:09 except it doesn't apply to Quebec, where they just do it anyway.
00:34:11 And the funny thing is, the debate last
00:34:13 week, the private debate last week, is the real debate
00:34:15 in Quebec. The debate last night, I'm sure when
00:34:17 the TV viewing numbers come out, and you said
00:34:19 the livestream numbers were bad,
00:34:21 in the last election,
00:34:23 my recollection is it was five
00:34:25 or six more times we would watch the
00:34:27 TVI debate than watch the official
00:34:29 debate. The debate last night was just
00:34:31 sort of a government box-checking exercise.
00:34:34 The thing that was interesting
00:34:35 happened last week that's so interesting well i i'm kind of curious about how tonight is going to
00:34:40 unfold i don't really know if canadians are tuning in i was listening to the radio
00:34:44 driving uh down here and you know all they were talking was attendance in the u.s open and everything
00:34:49 like that and like you know there's a canadian i think the semi-finals now it's like that's exciting
00:34:55 and that's not the same time as the debate you know if i wasn't getting here doing this job i
00:34:59 might be at home watching tennis right now yeah you know it's interesting because this idea that
00:35:04 the debates commission would solve everything everything would be perfect first of all
00:35:08 how is it broken in the first place and i mean you referenced how there were foreign policy
00:35:12 debates in the past and i think that the monk center the monk debates put forward their own
00:35:16 debate uh back in 2015 it was very successful and now people are complaining about various
00:35:21 particulars of the debates commission so clearly this hasn't solved anything and i think there's
00:35:27 an old saying that the response to any sort of freedom of the press free speech issue is more
00:35:32 free speech, more freedom of the press. So Rebel News or any other outlets is knocking on the door
00:35:38 saying, I want to participate. Okay, well, let them participate and let more participate. And then
00:35:42 they just, you know, the more voices are the merrier for all of that. That should be the
00:35:48 operating principles. And then if you want to have other debates, and to Hamish's point, if a large
00:35:52 enough entity comes forward and says, well, we're hosting a debate, we don't care about this debates
00:35:55 commission formal quasi-government thing, then it's going to happen. So it's just very odd,
00:36:00 this debate commission thing.
00:36:02 It is not a good solution
00:36:04 to a problem that never existed in the first place.
00:36:06 Right, it's a such and such a problem.
00:36:08 I think it's one more example of Trudeau's
00:36:10 touch or control
00:36:12 over speech,
00:36:14 free speech, lack thereof.
00:36:17 And, you know,
00:36:17 to me, it was a fait accompli
00:36:21 that rebel would be banned
00:36:22 and that they'd have to fight to get in
00:36:24 because
00:36:25 they are his Achilles' heel.
00:36:28 hopefully us as well. And, you know, he didn't want them coming and doing whatever they do.
00:36:37 I mean, it was silly because it just made him look bad. And today, you know, he gave
00:36:42 Rebel a platform to, you know, grandstand even more. And, you know, we won, we won.
00:36:49 But a debates commission, to me, is just evidence of the total control, I think, including bailing out media and giving them handouts that has occurred during Justin Trudeau's reign.
00:37:07 Well, I mean, there's a couple interesting things.
00:37:10 It's like, okay, they didn't learn anything the first time around by banning...
00:37:13 So in 2019, people aren't aware of what we're talking about.
00:37:16 Both True North and The Rebel were banned.
00:37:19 The Debates Commission said that we were not media companies,
00:37:22 and they let us know at the very last minute.
00:37:24 That was the worst part.
00:37:25 They didn't post any public rules or criteria about what you required to be in order to get accredited.
00:37:31 They let us know on Friday afternoon, and the debate was on Monday.
00:37:34 So we hired a lawyer and worked all weekend when Ezra heard that we were doing it.
00:37:38 He did the same thing, and the judge heard our two cases together
00:37:42 just because we're fighting the same thing and at that point it became pretty evident to me that
00:37:47 the judge was on the judge was on our side i mean it was like you know why did you why did you ban
00:37:52 them why didn't you give your criteria all the stuff that i was wondering it's like okay i'm
00:37:56 getting vindicated by this federal judge and i'm so grateful that he ruined our favor you know it
00:38:01 happened again and this time the judge issued you know or sorry the debates commission wrote like a
00:38:07 20-page report as to why the rebel was being banned because they thought, okay, we'll just
00:38:11 take what we didn't do right last time and we'll cover our tracks. I was glad that True
00:38:16 North got accepted this time. And the rebel didn't, but the federal judge had the same
00:38:21 opinion. I watched that case as well, and she was really skeptical of the idea that the
00:38:25 Trudeau government or the debates commission would exclude rebel who has been accredited
00:38:30 in all these other situations. I think, you know, they've been accredited at the United
00:38:33 nations and all these other places um not letting them in but then letting like the vietnamese state
00:38:39 broadcaster who doesn't even have any presence in canada like it's such a joke why would you
00:38:43 why would they get a credit one and not the other and why put the energy into it 20 page report is
00:38:49 bizarre let's say you like rebel and you like ezra well then you want to let them in let's say
00:38:53 you don't like them at all well then let them in because then all that happens is they line up with
00:38:58 the mic for the chance to ask a question and then that's just it and it fizzles away if you don't
00:39:03 There's a big fight. It's a news story.
00:39:05 It becomes a question in and of itself.
00:39:07 It draws attention to stuff.
00:39:08 I mean, it is just bizarre.
00:39:09 It's self-defeating.
00:39:10 It became a drama that it didn't need.
00:39:11 And then Trudeau getting up and answering the question
00:39:14 and going apoplectic, virtually apoplectic about Rebel
00:39:19 and how terrible they are. 0.97
00:39:21 And I thought, this silly man, this is just lending to the drama. 0.98
00:39:29 And it gives them a story. 0.97
00:39:31 And don't target any news outlet as prime minister, as president.
00:39:34 We were told that was a negative of Trump.
00:39:36 I mean, regardless, take Rebel out of the equation.
00:39:38 I mean, I feel like it should be beneath the prime minister to just go and start nitpicking
00:39:41 and needling like one news outlet.
00:39:44 Like, just, you know, relax.
00:39:45 It's usually like, I don't know who the reporter was that asked the question, but, you know,
00:39:48 it's not her organization.
00:39:49 She's just asking the reporter.
00:39:50 She's asking a question, and he's going on this whole rant.
00:39:52 And this is the guy that, like, you know, I'm old enough to remember when he was railing
00:39:57 against a conservative saying that they were divisive and that they were belittling people
00:40:00 and that they were, you know, creating wedges in society or, you know, that they were putting
00:40:05 people at risk because of their dangerous rhetoric.
00:40:08 And then we have the prime minister, like, saying those people, those people who hate
00:40:13 science, those people who hate vaccines.
00:40:15 It's like, what I see is it's an establishment viewpoint, right?
00:40:19 You have the debates commission.
00:40:20 It said no to Maxine Bernier, even though, what, he's at 10% in the polls now.
00:40:23 I mean, English, I know you're a bit skeptical of some of those polls, but he's pulling a
00:40:27 better probably than anime followers one yeah absolutely i mean they had at least for them for
00:40:33 the leaders because they put out criteria now you can argue the criteria are very arbitrary but at
00:40:37 least they publish criteria um the thing that they did this time that they didn't do last time is
00:40:42 again to your point of them sort of learning a lesson or trying to pull the same thing again
00:40:47 is they put a timeline that said you must pull over four percent within a certain number of days
00:40:52 of the election being called and they kind of came up with this whole uh criteria around it
00:40:56 you can argue the criteria was set up to specifically deny um uh the next agreement
00:41:02 from being in a debate uh i don't know if you want to make any evidence of that but
00:41:07 they did come up with this criteria but again right now it's right now it's clear that the
00:41:13 pbc is the fourth more popular uh uh party for maybe the fifth depending they could end up more
00:41:20 votes in the bloc if some of these polls are true and the idea that they wouldn't be in the debate
00:41:24 is of course fairly ridiculous well and then to me it's like the double right it's like no to
00:41:29 regular media no to regular politicians it's like what is that saying about the establishment in 0.55
00:41:34 canada you have these fringe parties on the left and i mean the ndp sure maybe they're becoming more
00:41:40 more legitimate but they still have pretty fringe ideas that are that would easily be considered
00:41:45 for left right you have anime fall in the green party that's not really even a party i don't know
00:41:49 know if they're going to win any seats i don't know what they're going to really survive it kind
00:41:53 of used to be like a one person part a personality party around elizabeth may and then she finally
00:41:58 sat back it was like it could have been the greens moment and instead they have these weird
00:42:03 petty internal divides um but but you have this room in canada for left-wing groups far left groups
00:42:09 um that are perfectly legitimate you can say the same thing about the media landscape right you
00:42:13 have the national observer you have all of these independent far left or left-wing media companies
00:42:19 and they're totally welcome and they're totally fine but then you know the rebel you know not
00:42:24 everyone's cup of tea and and you certainly there's room to to criticize them but to say like
00:42:29 as a country you know we're okay with like everything over here if you go like slightly
00:42:34 over this way then you're just you're not allowed and i think that's really troubling and vernier
00:42:39 was at one of the debates last year the sky didn't fall like what's the big deal yeah and it's
00:42:44 trickle down right to uh writings where there are some really strong ppc candidates and they've been
00:42:51 banned from the debates and i think that their perspective should be welcome and you know
00:42:59 they're not going to win but uh it let it sets uh feet to the fire to the other candidates
00:43:07 and maybe you know get some hard questions answered the communist candidates show up at
00:43:13 but all-party, all-handed debates and local rights.
00:43:16 It's usually like a Marxist communist.
00:43:17 Yeah, it's like a 70-year-old.
00:43:18 It's like a communist party person.
00:43:20 They get into all their little inflating.
00:43:24 And that's the thing.
00:43:26 Like, they sort of demonize the entire right.
00:43:29 And so what you're left with is, and I'm sorry,
00:43:32 I do think that Aaron O'Toole has run a really strong campaign.
00:43:35 There hasn't been any major missteps.
00:43:37 He seems to foresee whatever liberal bomb is going to get thrown,
00:43:42 I mean he's handled it with precision like he's running a great campaign but watching
00:43:46 the French debate last night I just I didn't see a lot of difference in in terms of policy
00:43:52 in terms of ideas it seemed like all the leaders just sort of agreed on everything there wasn't
00:43:57 really a lot and you know at least at least last time around you know you had Andrew Scheer
00:44:01 who at least had a slightly different view it was still you know he agreed with liberals
00:44:06 and other parties on a lot of things but you know he he he carved out a different path whereas
00:44:12 there in Attila I just feel like you know all the parties kind of you know when it comes to climate
00:44:16 change we all agree when it comes to COVID we all agree it's like there just isn't really a lot of
00:44:22 choice. The thing that I think separates Aaron Attila from the other two parties is the
00:44:28 the spending issue, and the economic issues, and one would hope that he would be more accountable
00:44:38 and more concerned about our deficit, although he's not going to eliminate it in the very
00:44:43 near future, but we can only pray that that happens, but the other two, Trudeau and Jagat
00:44:53 seeing it just spin us right into an even bigger black hole i think that's my perspective
00:45:01 but this is sort of the dream of the laurentian right is to return to sort of bland uh consensus
00:45:08 politics in the 1950s and 60s where you know all the major parties divided by personality
00:45:14 and a little bit of policy but not an awful lot and at the stand we have this big mushy center
00:45:18 The irony is that they're screaming against the wind because what we've seen with the
00:45:25 internet had ended up in the polarization of politics across the Western world.
00:45:30 So this ending up in this world where all the parties are more or less the same, it
00:45:36 won't last because people will end up in a form of a backlash and they'll do it around
00:45:41 other parties.
00:45:42 We've seen in this country in the past with the reform party emerging in the late 80s
00:45:46 And, you know, and we'll see how many votes the PPC gets on election night, but their message really more than anything else is we're out for the consensus.
00:45:54 And, you know, I don't think they're going to end up at 10% like they told the other day, but we're going to get more votes to the Greens.
00:46:03 Yeah, I mean, similar to what happened with Fort Nation, you know, when people like Rob
00:46:11 Fort, you know, they sought out somebody who wasn't like everybody else and was not, you
00:46:20 know, smooth and all that kind of stuff.
00:46:23 So people like us, you know, the elitist.
00:46:26 Yes.
00:46:27 Not elitist.
00:46:28 and he did very well at first. So yes, I think people are crying for that and that's why it's so disappointing that the PPC hasn't been involved in any of the debates, hasn't given any chance because, you know, whether they win or they don't, they probably will get more votes than anybody imagines, but they elevate the, I think, the debate onto issues that aren't being discussed, like we've talked about before.
00:46:58 those sort of things. Security, safety and security in Canada, that's a big issue. It's a big issue in urban centers.
00:47:05 Absolutely, and instead of really tackling the issue, we just get this fake debate about assault rifles and who's for them and who's against them.
00:47:12 Folks, we're just going to take a quick one-minute break. Please bear with us. We're having a little bit of technical difficulties.
00:47:17 We'll be back in one minute to continue with the analysis for the pre-debate show here.
00:47:28 Let's get started.
00:47:58 We'll be right back.
00:48:28 Thank you.
00:48:58 Thank you.
00:49:28 Let's go.
00:49:58 Oh, that's it.
00:50:28 Thank you.
00:50:58 We'll be right back.
00:51:28 We'll be right back.
00:51:58 Thank you.
00:52:28 We'll be right back.
00:52:58 Thank you.
00:53:28 We'll be right back.
00:53:58 Thank you.
00:54:28 We'll be right back.
00:54:58 hi folks thank you so much for bearing with us i know we had some pretty bad audio problems i
00:55:23 really apologize you know we're a digital startup we don't have the budget of the cbc
00:55:27 we don't get 1.2 million dollars from the taxpayers so sometimes stuff like that happens but i really
00:55:32 appreciate you uh staying on we're gonna give a little bit more analysis and have a couple more
00:55:37 minutes of conversation uh before we get to the debate i have it on the screen in front of me so
00:55:42 i can see that the uh leaders are there in studio they're doing a really cheesy uh photo op right
00:55:48 now and as soon as the questions uh start to come we will go over to that but for now let's
00:55:54 take advantage of the last few minutes that we have here. So, Hamish, you were talking off air
00:55:58 a little bit about the format of the debate and how it's a little weird. It doesn't really lend
00:56:02 itself too good back-to-back. So, what people want in these debates is they want to see the people
00:56:08 who are likely to be prime minister have an argument about things that actually matter.
00:56:12 So, they've done a decent and okay job. They've got five themes that we discussed. Affordability,
00:56:17 climate, COVID recovery, leadership and accountability, and reconciliation. So,
00:56:22 So two or three of those are not bad choices.
00:56:26 But then what happens is there's a question from a voter that goes to one leader, which
00:56:31 doesn't really provoke interaction.
00:56:33 Then the moderator can ask a question to each leader.
00:56:37 It's not clear if it's the same question or if they all have to answer different ones.
00:56:41 And then they have this leader-to-leader thing where three of the leaders chosen by law end
00:56:45 up debating each other.
00:56:47 So you could end up with Anne-Marie Paul and Blanchet debating Trudeau about reconciliation
00:56:55 and points that aren't big divergences, which will not make exactly exciting television.
00:57:01 If leaders are smart, especially if Trudeau is not in their little group of three, they
00:57:06 can take shots at Trudeau when he's not, or any of the other leaders, when he doesn't
00:57:11 have the ability to respond.
00:57:13 And that can make things interesting if they're strategic and use the format.
00:57:16 And then there's a final section
00:57:17 where for each of these groups
00:57:18 there's an open debate
00:57:19 between all five leaders
00:57:20 which I suspect will just be
00:57:22 everybody rounding on
00:57:23 whoever was left out of the...
00:57:25 Well, I'm told that we are
00:57:27 going to go over to the debate
00:57:28 because it looks like
00:57:29 it's starting a few minutes early.
00:57:30 So, folks, thank you so much
00:57:32 for joining our True North analysis
00:57:33 and our pre-debate show.
00:57:35 We are going to head on over
00:57:37 to that live debate.
00:57:38 Enjoy it and we will be back
00:57:39 in two hours for more analysis
00:57:41 with the panel.
00:57:42 Thank you so much for tuning in
00:57:44 and let's go to the debate.
00:57:46 11.
00:58:07 I'm with the
00:58:19 left to work.
00:58:36 .
00:58:37 I'll come back in there one minute.
00:59:07 We're back in studio, that was a bit of a false alarm there, quick to the trigger here
00:59:25 at True North, but we're going to keep the analysis going because they haven't quite
00:59:29 started the debate.
00:59:31 So, Hameshi, you were explaining the format.
00:59:33 I mean, for me, I don't mean to be cruel to Anna May Paul because she seems like a nice lady.
00:59:38 And in some ways, last night of the French debate, it was a bit refreshing because she doesn't really talk like a politician.
00:59:43 She doesn't have talking points.
00:59:45 When she's asked a question, she actually just answers and gives her opinion.
00:59:48 If she doesn't know something, she says, I'm not very familiar with that topic.
00:59:51 And in that way, it was refreshing.
00:59:53 In the way of thinking, you know, we're trying to choose our prime minister as a country here.
00:59:57 And, you know, hearing from a person who just has no chance of winning, same with Yves Blanchet.
01:00:02 I mean, sure, it made sense for him to be part of the French debate when the whole focus
01:00:05 was on Quebec, but for the rest of us and the rest of the country, we can't even vote
01:00:09 for him.
01:00:10 So it just seems like a major distraction to have these contrasts with the U.S. election
01:00:14 where it's just, you know, head-to-head Democrat versus Republican, and you really, they really
01:00:19 hold each other to the fire, hold the feet to the fire, they get their blows in, you
01:00:22 get a really good look, not just at their ideas, but at their character, because how
01:00:26 they handle themselves on the ground.
01:00:28 I would love to see a Trudeau versus O'Toole head-to-head.
01:00:31 And I wish that we had more of that in this debate.
01:00:35 Yeah, that's a really good point.
01:00:36 I mean, to your point, you know, you've got Trump versus Clinton or whatever it is.
01:00:40 That's what people want to see.
01:00:41 That's the main event. 0.99
01:00:42 You can imagine if the Green Party candidate or I think Roseanne Barr was running for president as well. 0.92
01:00:46 Then if she had been on the stage there and yet to give her equal airtime, it just wouldn't be, you know, the main event. 1.00
01:00:52 You want the main fight card up there.
01:00:54 I also think the topics are a little frustrating in tonight's debate.
01:00:59 I mean, Hamish listed off those main topics.
01:01:01 And of the five, three, three and a half of them are also provincial and municipal domain.
01:01:08 I mean, they are not they're not following the subsidiarity principle very well.
01:01:11 And the one thing that doesn't have its own topic, foreign affairs, that's not a municipal issue.
01:01:17 That's not a provincial issue. That is the exclusive domain of the federal government.
01:01:20 And if you ask some libertarian purists, you know, what should the federal government do?
01:01:24 They probably cancel half the federal departments out there.
01:01:26 But, of course, keep foreign affairs, because that is, you know, one of the original duties of any time a federal government has formed in history.
01:01:33 So it is frustrating, particularly in the intro, Candice, you were saying earlier in the hour, we've got Afghanistan, we've got China.
01:01:40 I mean, these are things that really have to be hashed out.
01:01:43 And when you want to talk about housing, I mean, there's, as Sue Ann has covered very well, there are committees at city halls all across this country that are delving into housing and throwing billions at it.
01:01:52 Maybe we can talk about foreign affairs just a little bit.
01:01:54 Well, and to your point, I mean, that's the whole sort of purpose.
01:01:58 And we were talking a little bit earlier, at least I was, about how it feels like the leaders kind of have the same opinion on a lot of things.
01:02:04 Maybe if we were having a broader debate, including, you know, Hamish, the poll that you did for Turn North,
01:02:08 we found that conservatives and liberals care about very different issues.
01:02:11 So if you're a liberal, you care about COVID and climate change.
01:02:14 If you're a conservative, you care about debt and the economy and jobs.
01:02:17 And so it just seems like the topics are geared more towards liberal voters and the liberal worldview.
01:02:23 and then form policy on top of that.
01:02:26 I mean, maybe that is where we would see a bit of a contrast
01:02:28 between Trudeau and O'Toole,
01:02:29 but we won't get to know, unfortunately.
01:02:31 And that's the thing.
01:02:33 That's where there's a disconnect
01:02:35 between the federal leaders or Trudeau's commission
01:02:39 and the average guy on the street.
01:02:42 So what we care about on the street is the economy
01:02:45 and how we're going to come back from COVID.
01:02:47 What we care about is safety and security
01:02:49 and how we're going to deal with,
01:02:52 Not with assault rifles, but with the massive shootings and the absolute enabling in our justice system of the criminals and not giving them tough consequences.
01:03:11 What we care about is the drug addiction issues and mental health issues, which is one thing that Erin O'Toole has covered quite well.
01:03:21 But this is what we're caring about in cities when we see addicted drug users walking the streets, when we see just the absolute enabling of crime and shootings and, you know, and people, that's what people on the ground are worried about.
01:03:41 Yeah, and yet there's very, very sort of little about that. Even the issue of childcare, which is something that a lot of people do. I know both of you fellows over there have young kids, and I have young kids as well. We probably have like 10 kids between us, almost. But anyway, yeah.
01:03:59 Do fur kids count?
01:04:00 Yeah, we have fur kids.
01:04:01 If you prefer fur babies, then yeah, we have.
01:04:04 But even that debate issue, it's talked about in such a trite sort of way
01:04:10 that it doesn't even really feel like it's addressing parents.
01:04:14 It's like, do you believe in government daycare or not?
01:04:17 And that's like the confine of the debate.
01:04:20 And it just seems like a missed opportunity to your point
01:04:22 to connect with voters on the issues that are in their day-to-day life
01:04:26 and they really care about, not sort of the abstract,
01:04:28 the climate change stuff that people are everybody wants to have a clean environment everyone wants
01:04:32 to have a good planet for the future but it's not really top of mind when you're in a pandemic and
01:04:37 you don't have a job and you you know you're walking by needles on your way to work or whatever
01:04:41 people are you know talking about this at the door uh 50 of the people or more are worried
01:04:48 about affordability that's what they're worried about uh the other topic i mean even though it's
01:04:53 provincial responsibility look at all the lives lost seniors lives lost and our our lack of
01:04:58 respect for seniors for the seniors population we need to have a national strategy the federal
01:05:04 government has to start thinking about how they're going to treat seniors from this day forward so
01:05:09 at the other end of the scale yeah there's no can talk about that and it was top of mind during
01:05:16 COVID and then just fell right off the radar. It seems to happen with so many issues. So,
01:05:22 okay, well, it looks like the debate is actually starting this time. The leaders have just been
01:05:26 introduced. So we will leave it, leave it there. It's been so great to have this conversation with
01:05:32 everyone. Thank you, Anthony Hamish and Sue Ann for coming by in the studio and joining us. It was
01:05:37 an interesting conversation and let's, let's go to the debate and see what happens.
01:05:41 leadership and accountability climate change reconciliation affordability and covid recovery
01:05:51 tonight for undecided journalists rather for undecided voters and journalists maybe the
01:05:58 journalists are undecided as well we'll be putting their questions directly to the leaders
01:06:03 and you leaders you've agreed to tonight's rules and format so before we begin please
01:06:10 answer the questions you're asked, do not interrupt each other. I don't want to cut
01:06:17 you off, but I will if I have to, okay? All right, let's get started.
01:06:26 You will each get a different question, and you have 45 seconds to answer. You all have a
01:06:32 countdown clock. The theme is leadership and accountability. Your speaking order has been
01:06:37 determined by draw. And Mr. Singh, you are first. Hi, Mr. Singh. Hi there. Mr. Singh, you are popular
01:06:45 and you inspire many Canadians, but your platform is full of big promises. And when it comes to how
01:06:53 you'll pay for it all, there's not a lot of details. Given this, how can Canadians know
01:07:00 that you are really ready to lead? I really appreciate the question and I want to say
01:07:05 Good evening to everyone tuning in.
01:07:08 There is a serious question
01:07:09 that people are asking themselves in this election.
01:07:11 They're wondering who's gonna pay the price
01:07:14 of this pandemic and the recovery.
01:07:16 And we do have bold plans about how we can invest in people.
01:07:19 But we are the only party with a credible plan
01:07:22 that will not put the burden on people,
01:07:24 that will not cut the help that they need,
01:07:26 unlike Mr. Trudeau and Mr. O'Toole,
01:07:29 who voted against making the ultra-rich pay their fair share.
01:07:31 We believe that billionaires should pay their fair share.
01:07:34 We should end the loopholes, end the offshore tax havens
01:07:38 that mean billions of dollars are lost,
01:07:40 that we are not able to invest in people.
01:07:42 We want to put the burden on those that are at the very, very top
01:07:45 so we can invest in the solutions that people need.
01:07:47 Tackling the climate crisis, investing in housing.
01:07:50 All right, thank you, Mr. Singh.
01:07:52 Next to you, Mr. Trudeau, because you wanted a new mandate,
01:07:56 you plunged the country into an election,
01:07:59 even as the pandemic spurs thousands of new cases.
01:08:02 But over the last 18 months, opposition parties have largely stood with you, putting the nation above politics.
01:08:12 Why aren't you doing the same?
01:08:13 How can you justify an election at this time?
01:08:18 Thank you, Ms. Curl.
01:08:19 I think, first of all, I want to thank Canadians for being here tonight, making an important choice,
01:08:25 and also, quite frankly, for everything you've done over the past number of months to help get ourselves and our neighbors through this.
01:08:32 Tonight, over the next couple of hours, you're going to hear some very, very different, very strong ideas that are radically different about how we're going to move forward through this pandemic to end it, how we're going to build back better.
01:08:46 Those decisions are going to be taken by your government now, in the coming weeks, this fall, not a year from now, not two years from now.
01:08:53 Could it not have waited a few months, Mr. Trudeau?
01:08:55 I know you want to go harder and faster on vaccinations.
01:08:58 I know you want to go harder and faster on climate change, and you get to choose exactly that in this election.
01:09:04 All right, that's time. Thank you.
01:09:06 Mr. Blanchet, to you.
01:09:08 You deny that Quebec has problems with racism, yet you defend legislation such as Bills 96 and 21,
01:09:15 which marginalize religious minorities, Anglophones, and Allophones.
01:09:20 Quebec is recognized as a distinct society, but for those outside the province,
01:09:26 Please help them understand why your party also supports these discriminatory laws.
01:09:32 The question seems to imply the answer you want.
01:09:37 Those laws are not about discrimination.
01:09:40 They are about the values of Quebec. 1.00
01:09:43 And yet religious minorities, sir, cannot progress if they wear their religious gear. 1.00
01:09:48 Quebec is not recognized as a distinct society. 0.80
01:09:51 it's been recognized as a nation on june 16th by the parliament 281 votes said that quebec is a
01:10:03 nation and everybody here seems to agree with that no more distinct society which never had
01:10:09 any meeting anyway meaning not meeting so again why the discriminatory laws and your support for
01:10:16 sir you may repeat as many times as you want that those are discriminatory laws we are saying that
01:10:21 those are legitimate laws that apply on quebec territory and there seems to be people around here
01:10:28 who will share this point of view which is a game by itself for quebec all right thank you mr mr
01:10:33 blanchette miss paul to you for millions of voters this is the climate change election but at this
01:10:42 you've been bogged down in internal strife.
01:10:45 If your own party doesn't fully support you,
01:10:49 how can Canadians trust you to lead
01:10:52 through one of the most defining issues of our times?
01:10:57 It's an excellent question, and it's an honor to be here
01:11:00 tonight on the unceded territories of the Algonquin peoples.
01:11:05 It has been a very difficult period,
01:11:07 and do I wish that our party had been further ahead,
01:11:10 particularly at this moment? Absolutely.
01:11:13 Do I believe that we have wonderful candidates
01:11:16 running all over the country
01:11:17 that you should consider voting for? Absolutely.
01:11:21 Being who I am and in this position
01:11:23 has been incredibly hard.
01:11:25 Being here tonight was not an obvious thing.
01:11:28 I've had to crawl over a lot of broken glass to get here.
01:11:32 I'm proud to be here.
01:11:33 I'm proud to be the first of my kind,
01:11:35 and because I am the first of my kind,
01:11:37 I know that I won't be the last.
01:11:39 Thank you, Ms. Paul, and to you, Mr. O'Toole.
01:12:05 party. And we have a plan to get the country back on its feet after a difficult 18 months in this
01:12:11 crisis. I'm a pro-choice ally to the LGBTQ community. That comes from my service in the
01:12:17 military, where I served alongside people from all backgrounds, all orientations, putting the
01:12:22 country first. And our platform, including a detailed plan on climate change, is about making
01:12:28 sure we secure the future, jobs, accountability, national leadership on mental health. So is it
01:12:33 Are you, sir, or your caucus that's driving the bus?
01:12:36 I am driving the bus to make sure we get this country back on track,
01:12:40 and I'm here to defend the rights of all Canadians,
01:12:43 women, members of the LGBTQ community, Indigenous Canadians.
01:12:47 I want to make sure we all secure a future together.
01:12:50 Thank you, Mr. O'Toole.
01:12:52 All right, leaders, thank you.
01:12:53 It is now time for our first face-to-face debate.
01:12:56 Mr. Trudeau, Ms. Paul, you're up.
01:12:58 Starting with Mr. Trudeau, based on this question. 1.00
01:13:02 You call yourself a feminist. 0.99
01:13:03 But on your watch, sexual misconduct in Canada's armed forces continues to run rampant.
01:13:10 Tell me, why are you allowing these unacceptable conditions to continue?
01:13:15 I think we recognize that there are systems and institutions that need to change across the country.
01:13:19 And that's why, from the very beginning, we stepped up with policies, new policies, stronger policies and processes to support every survivor, everyone who comes forward.
01:13:29 because nobody deserves to work in a workplace
01:13:32 where they are being discriminated against,
01:13:35 where they are being harassed or hassled.
01:13:39 We have been unequivocal about that.
01:13:40 My leadership has been unequivocal about that.
01:13:43 Yes, these problems continue in workplaces across the country,
01:13:46 particularly in the military.
01:13:48 That's unacceptable,
01:13:49 which is why we've taken even stronger measures.
01:13:52 It's unsatisfactory to have to say,
01:13:54 we're relying on process in this.
01:13:57 We want to just be able to have easy answers.
01:13:59 Ms. Paul, what's your response to that?
01:14:01 But this is not an issue with easy answers.
01:14:02 You have to fall back on process.
01:14:04 I have said before, and I'll say again tonight,
01:14:07 that I do not believe that Mr. Trudeau is a real feminist.
01:14:10 A feminist doesn't continue to push strong women out of his party
01:14:14 when they are just seeking to serve.
01:14:18 And I will say their names tonight and thank them.
01:14:21 Thank you, Jane Philpott.
01:14:22 Thank you, Jody Wilson-Raybould.
01:14:25 Thank you, Selena Cesar Chavinez.
01:14:27 and I'm here tonight thanks to the work that you have done.
01:14:30 I believe that if there were more women on this platform tonight
01:14:34 and in previous years, that we, in fact, 1.00
01:14:36 would have better laws in our military.
01:14:40 We would have childcare at this point.
01:14:43 We would have many of the things that we need.
01:14:45 I am the only woman other than Elizabeth May
01:14:48 to be on this platform in the last 18 years.
01:14:51 The Liberal Party has never had a woman leading.
01:14:54 I think it's time for the party to examine its priority.
01:14:56 Paul, you'll perhaps understand that I won't take lessons on caucus management from you.
01:15:00 I think what I will keep focused on is making sure that our first woman finance minister
01:15:07 has moved forward on child care.
01:15:10 Mr. Trudeau, I'm sorry, that's time.
01:15:12 We have to move on.
01:15:13 Mr. Blanchett, Mr. O'Toole, and Mr. Singh, this next topic is for you to debate.
01:15:19 Canada's transition to a green economy depends on pipelines.
01:15:23 At a time when Ontario and Quebec face uncertain energy supply over Line 5, this country cannot extract nor distribute oil domestically.
01:15:35 Our theme is leadership. Tell me, which one of you is best to lead on these complex issues?
01:15:42 Mr. Blanchet, per the draw, you begin.
01:15:45 I'm not very much interested in leading Canada.
01:15:47 However, I am very much interested in making sure that Quebec is entitled to its own vision for the future.
01:15:56 You know, in Quebec, we do not have energy issues that much because we are lucky.
01:16:01 We are lucky.
01:16:01 It's a piece of luck that we can produce green energy in a large amount.
01:16:06 But the whole planet cannot afford this idea, this very Canadian idea, this very conservative idea.
01:16:12 And as far as I know, this very liberal idea that we have to produce more oil, export more oil, believing that the money from it will reduce gas emission, which won't happen.
01:16:23 All Canadian families deserve an economic recovery, including families in Western Canada that feel left out after six years of Mr. Trudeau.
01:16:32 When it comes to leadership, our natural resources sector is a leader in environmental, social governance.
01:16:38 Any time Canadian resources are removed from the global supply chain, you know who fills that gap?
01:16:44 Saudi Arabia, Venezuela, Russia.
01:16:46 All of these organizations and companies are getting their emissions down.
01:16:50 Let's get emissions down and Canadian resources to market so that we can have jobs opportunity and fight climate change.
01:16:57 When it comes to leadership on fighting this essential crisis, one of the biggest crises we're up against,
01:17:05 we've got a difficult choice for Canadians.
01:17:07 You've got on one side someone who doesn't believe there's a crisis, and then on the other, you've got Mr. Trudeau who doesn't act like there's a crisis.
01:17:14 And what it's going to take is real leadership, because the solutions are there.
01:17:17 We can invest in green energy, clean energy.
01:17:20 We can invest in renewable energy.
01:17:21 Mr. Singh, a real leader doesn't give up on tens of thousands of workers across the country.
01:17:24 We'll never give up on workers.
01:17:25 We're workers that are working hard for their families, so we can get our resources to our party.
01:17:29 Okay, one at a time, gentlemen.
01:17:31 Mr. Trudeau, then back to you, Mr. Singh.
01:17:32 I want to see Canadians get back to work in all sectors and in all regions.
01:17:37 And I'm proud of what we produce in our country,
01:17:39 whether it's our resources or the resources in the heads of our young people.
01:17:43 We need to get emissions down and get our energy to market.
01:17:47 These workers need a plan that's going to create jobs for the future.
01:17:50 And that's the responsibility of government.
01:17:51 We've seen six years of Mr. Trudeau, and workers can't afford another four years.
01:17:55 What we need to do is invest in a diversified economy, clean energy.
01:18:00 We need to electrify transportation.
01:18:01 We need to invest in retrofitting homes and buildings.
01:18:04 We need to create good jobs to work and plan now.
01:18:07 But we need an economic recovery in all sectors that have failed workers.
01:18:11 Last word to you, Mr. Blanchett.
01:18:13 Last word to you, sir.
01:18:14 Leadership is not only saying the words.
01:18:17 It's proposing solutions, admitting a problem which they're not doing.
01:18:22 All right.
01:18:22 Thank you.
01:18:23 My next question is for all of you.
01:18:26 We've had some encouraging news out of Kabul overnight with the escape of 43 Canadians.
01:18:33 That said, thousands of people who helped Canada during Canada's mission in Afghanistan
01:18:40 have been left behind in their hour of need, and it is unknown if we will ever get them all out.
01:18:47 To each of you, what would you have done differently?
01:18:50 Mr. O'Toole, per the draw you began.
01:18:53 Canada should never leave behind people that are at risk because they helped us.
01:18:57 When Afghanistan was falling, there were 1,200 Canadians and hundreds more translators and others waiting for help from Canada.
01:19:04 What did Mr. Trudeau do?
01:19:06 You called an election, sir.
01:19:08 You put your own political interests ahead of the well-being of thousands of people.
01:19:12 Leadership is about putting others first, not yourself.
01:19:17 Mr. Trudeau, you should not have called this election.
01:19:19 You should have gotten the job done in Afghanistan.
01:19:21 that. Mr. O'Toole, as of the beginning... Hold on. This is not open debate, leaders. This is
01:19:25 a situation where we're asking a question to each of you. No problem, Mr. Trudeau. I'm trying to
01:19:32 keep track of myself. I would like him, Ms. Curl, because he called an election in the fourth wave
01:19:36 of a pandemic with fires in British Columbia and with unfinished business in Afghanistan,
01:19:40 Mr. Trudeau. All right. Thank you, Mr. O'Toole. I'm going to give the opportunity next per the
01:19:45 draw to Mr. Singh. You guys will have tons of time to debate, so hang tight. Mr. Singh.
01:19:49 sadly what's happened in in afghanistan is a tragedy that was something we knew about we
01:19:57 knew about the withdrawal date we knew from president biden what that date would be and
01:20:01 and sadly i agree with mr otul on this one point that it was a bad decision to call an election
01:20:07 while this crisis was going on particularly because we've got allies on the ground that
01:20:12 put their lives at risk to support our canadian forces who are now looking at peril for their
01:20:17 lives and may never get out of afghanistan we know the impact on women and girls in afghanistan
01:20:22 it's heartbreaking and it could have been avoided veterans had told mr trudeau and his government
01:20:28 for a long time that the current approach was not working those calls were not heated and as a result
01:20:33 we're in this really horrible situation thank you thank you mr singh mr blanchett first good news
01:20:39 i seem to understand from what i read a few hours ago that kabul airport is now being open for some
01:20:45 to get out of the country, which is very good news.
01:20:48 This should have been worked a long, long time ago.
01:20:51 I agree with Mr. O'Toole that Mr. O'Toole
01:20:54 should have put those people's interests before his own.
01:20:57 However, the problem is that Canada has failed many times
01:21:00 to create some strong partnerships with other countries
01:21:04 in order to be stronger facing a situation like Afghanistan now.
01:21:09 Because by itself, we must admit, Canada is not a world power.
01:21:14 Thank you, Mr. Blanchet. Mr. Trudeau, I invite you to respond now.
01:21:18 Thank you, Ms. Curl. It's unfortunate to hear the members, the leaders on this stage talking down the incredible work that our Canadian Armed Forces, that our diplomats, that our consular officials did from the beginning of the summer to ensure that as of the very beginning of August, well before this election, we were getting flights out of Afghanistan.
01:21:39 We got 3,700 people out of Afghanistan, and over the past weeks, we've been working with the Qataris, for example, on exactly that good news that we've seen of more people, more Canadians getting out of Afghanistan.
01:21:52 We work closely with our allies because we know Canadians sacrificed in Afghanistan for a better future.
01:21:58 We need to stand by the people who helped us, who helped themselves, and we will with even more people coming to Canada in the coming months.
01:22:06 All right, Mr. Trudeau, Ms. Paul.
01:22:08 As a former diplomat and with a husband who provided advice on the peace negotiations in Afghanistan,
01:22:16 we were hearing the stories all the time in the months leading up that this was foreseeable.
01:22:22 And so it seems like we got better information on our smartphones than Mr. Trudeau got from our entire intelligence service based on what he's saying.
01:22:29 the thing is that when you people count on you when you make a promise to them then you do it
01:22:36 so that people can count on canada's word when someone is your partner you go with them you go
01:22:41 for them or you don't amount to much and so leaving behind people in afghanistan rocking up
01:22:47 to rito hall and calling an election under these circumstances was not the right thing to do
01:22:52 and to borrow a line from mr singh from 2019 mr chadokha just say hey man i messed up all right
01:22:57 Ms. Paul, thank you very much. Thank you all. And now it is our time for a first attempt at open
01:23:04 debate. Jumping off of this question, Michael Kovrig and Michael Spavor have been in Chinese
01:23:11 prisons for 1,004 days. The next prime minister has key decisions to make about our already tense
01:23:20 relationship with China, such as telecommunications security and foreign investment.
01:23:25 Some say this all comes down to a trade-off between Canada's economic growth and recognition of human rights
01:23:32 I'd like to know where you all stand. I'm sure you want to exchange on that. Mr. Singh, for the draw you begin
01:23:37 Leaders, you may jump in
01:23:38 Thank you very much
01:23:40 We know that we can't imagine what it is for Mr. Spavor and Mr. Kovrig to be going through
01:23:46 A thousand plus days in a prison without access to human rights
01:23:51 I can't imagine what their friends and their families are going through right now
01:23:54 All I know is we have to do everything possible to secure the release of these two Canadians.
01:23:59 We need to work with our allies, apply pressure, and make sure that we return these Canadians home.
01:24:04 That's what we've got to do. 1.00
01:24:05 And that's exactly what we've been doing.
01:24:07 Over the past three years, we have worked with international allies to put pressure on China in every single one of their meetings.
01:24:14 We've worked closely with the United States. 0.56
01:24:16 We at the G7 a few weeks ago worked with the international community to make sure we're moving forward on challenging China where necessary and human rights, competing with them economically where we need to and holding them to account on the rule of law as a global community.
01:24:32 And Canada's voice has been very strong on that.
01:24:35 Canada's voice has been absent, Mr. Trudeau.
01:24:38 We have not worked with our allies on Huawei.
01:24:41 We have not stood up for the 300,000 Canadians in Hong Kong.
01:24:45 We've not fought for the two Michaels and put pressure on the communist regime.
01:24:50 We have not stood up for human rights.
01:24:52 Sir, you did not show up for a vote declaring a genocide towards the Uyghur people.
01:24:56 You didn't show up.
01:24:58 Canada is the country that was leading the fight against apartheid.
01:25:01 We created the UN Human Rights Code.
01:25:05 We should be leaders for our values, sir. 0.97
01:25:08 And you've let the Michaels down, and we have to get serious with China. 0.92
01:25:11 If you want to get the Michaels home, you do not simply lob tomatoes across the Pacific. 0.66
01:25:18 That is what Mr. Harper tried for a number of years and didn't get anywhere.
01:25:21 You need to engage in a sophisticated way with our allies every step of the way.
01:25:26 You have to take the same position on Huawei.
01:25:28 And that's exactly what we have done every step of the time.
01:25:31 On cyber security, Mr. Trudeau, we are out of step and our allies are wondering where Canada's gone.
01:25:38 You started as Prime Minister saying you admired China.
01:25:40 I'm coming to you, Ms. Paul, just a second.
01:25:44 I want to get to Mr. Singh and then to you, Ms. Paul.
01:25:47 I appreciate it. Thank you very much for the opportunity.
01:25:49 I want to also talk, we're talking about leadership and accountability.
01:25:52 And in this pandemic, one of the moments, I think, of leadership that has been a failure
01:25:55 is the fact that when we talk about leadership, it means finding solutions.
01:25:59 And in our long-term care homes here in Canada, we saw the worst conditions in the for-profit.
01:26:04 We're going to have time to chat with that later.
01:26:06 The topic is China, human rights and economic growth.
01:26:09 To you, Ms. Paul.
01:26:10 Yes, and this is an area where, certainly,
01:26:13 lines are being redrawn all across the world.
01:26:16 And the main thing that Canada is going to have going forward
01:26:20 in terms of currency is its word.
01:26:23 When we make a promise, we have to keep those promises.
01:26:27 That's how, when we need help, we get it.
01:26:29 You know, my mom grew up on a farm in a small community,
01:26:32 and she learned very young and taught us
01:26:34 that you have to give your word to your neighbors,
01:26:36 and they have to be able to count on it
01:26:38 so that when you need help, they're there for you.
01:26:40 And so when we don't show up, when we're asked for vaccines from COVAX and then we take vaccines from COVAX, 0.84
01:26:47 when the Uyghur ask us for help to declare a genocide and we don't do that,
01:26:52 when we don't show up on the climate by setting targets that are ambitious but at the same time in line with our international partners and do our fair share, 0.97
01:27:01 then our word doesn't count for much and then it makes it very hard for us to help people like the Michaels when they need us the most.
01:27:07 Mr. Blanchett, did you want to get in on this?
01:27:09 Stirring tomatoes might not be the solution,
01:27:12 but I would submit humbly that doing nothing
01:27:14 might not be the solution either.
01:27:16 The Minister Trudeau's record on human rights is not perfect.
01:27:20 We might name the two Michaels.
01:27:21 We might name Weigur in Xinjiang. 0.69
01:27:24 We might name Taiwan, Hong Kong.
01:27:26 We might name Catalonia and Mr. Puigdemont.
01:27:28 We might name the worst of all.
01:27:30 Mr. Blanchett.
01:27:31 Raif Badawi being still held in Saudi Arabia
01:27:34 because Canada wants to sell weapons and military supplies to Saudi Arabia.
01:27:39 Mr. Blanchet.
01:27:40 Mr. Blanchet.
01:27:42 Okay, okay, gentlemen, one at a time.
01:27:45 The parliament voted unanimously to give citizenship to Haif Badawi.
01:27:50 Nothing has been done afterward.
01:27:52 All right.
01:27:53 Mr. O'Toole, Mr. Trudeau, Mr. Singh.
01:27:57 Mr. Blanchet is correct.
01:27:59 Canada is needed back on the world stage.
01:28:00 We may be smaller than China with respect to population and economy, but we are a giant when it comes to our commitments to human rights, to dignity, and to the rule of law.
01:28:09 And we have to start working with our allies to take a more serious approach for human rights, standing up for our workers on fair trade, and making sure that our voice is a principled one on the world stage again.
01:28:20 The problem with Mr. O'Toole and his principles is he says all the right-sounding things,
01:28:25 and he's working on reassuring everyone that he's right there as a strong leader.
01:28:29 But he can't convince his candidates to get vaccinated.
01:28:32 He can't convince his MPs to fight.
01:28:35 Let's keep the theme.
01:28:36 Mr. Singh, you wanted to get in.
01:28:37 I'm giving the last word to Mr. Singh.
01:28:41 Mr. Trudeau, please.
01:28:42 To you, Mr. Singh.
01:28:43 Leadership means standing up.
01:28:44 It means standing up for the Uyghur in China.
01:28:46 It means standing up to defend people around the world.
01:28:48 and also means showing leadership
01:28:50 when it comes to fighting the climate crisis,
01:28:51 we've got the worst record under Mr. Trudeau in the G7.
01:28:54 So that's not leadership, certainly not.
01:28:56 All right, thank you very much.
01:28:57 Thank you, leaders.
01:28:58 We are now moving on to our next theme,
01:29:01 which is climate change.
01:29:07 All right, this time we're starting with a question
01:29:09 from Trevor McMullen.
01:29:11 He is a high school teacher in Lunenburg, Nova Scotia.
01:29:14 He's standing by.
01:29:16 Trevor, what's your question?
01:29:18 hey good evening as leader what immediate actions would you take to make green technology more
01:29:26 accessible and affordable so that everyday canadians don't have to bear the financial
01:29:30 burden of being environmentally ethical all right thank you trevor leaders you've heard trevor's
01:29:37 question mr miss paul i apologize miss paul you're going first thank you so much for that
01:29:43 question and it you know trevor that's exactly where your head should be at that's where all
01:29:47 of our heads should be at.
01:29:48 How can we use this opportunity to seize the moment
01:29:53 to create a green economy?
01:29:55 How can we incentivize every single person in Canada,
01:29:58 every company and every enterprise
01:30:00 to adopt green technologies?
01:30:03 How can we become a global leader?
01:30:05 And so absolutely, if you look at our platform,
01:30:07 you will see that we propose incentives
01:30:09 all the way from buying electric cars new and used
01:30:12 to retrofitting homes, you know,
01:30:16 to all of these items that will help make life easier for you
01:30:19 and help for you to do your part.
01:30:21 But this is a national and international issue.
01:30:24 We need national leadership on it,
01:30:26 and we need it across party lines.
01:30:28 Thank you, Ms. Paul.
01:30:29 Mr. Singh.
01:30:30 Thank you.
01:30:30 Thank you, Trevor.
01:30:31 I really appreciate the question.
01:30:32 And I'm sure you speak to a lot of young people as a teacher
01:30:34 and are seeing the fear in their eyes,
01:30:37 the worry and the desperation that young people have
01:30:39 because they don't know what type of future they're going to inherit.
01:30:42 And they're worried about the impacts of the climate crisis
01:30:45 because it's hurting us now
01:30:46 and it's only going to get worse
01:30:48 if we don't do anything about it.
01:30:49 And to invest in that future,
01:30:51 we need to make choices.
01:30:52 And right now, we look at the choices
01:30:54 Mr. Trudeau has made over the past six years.
01:30:56 He has promised to end fossil fuel subsidies,
01:30:59 but instead of ending them,
01:31:00 he has increased them to $900 million per year.
01:31:03 That is money we could spend
01:31:05 on investing in clean technology,
01:31:08 in making it easier for people
01:31:10 to access that technology
01:31:11 and to do our part to fight the climate crisis.
01:31:14 So it's a matter of choices.
01:31:16 We can't afford another four years of Mr. Trudeau's choices.
01:31:18 Thank you, Mr. Singh.
01:31:19 To you, Mr. O'Toole.
01:31:21 Thank you for the question, Trevor. 0.86
01:31:23 I was raised by two strong women who were teachers,
01:31:25 and they told me to be straight up.
01:31:27 This is an area where the Conservatives,
01:31:29 we had to win back some trust.
01:31:30 We hadn't met the expectations of Canadians on climate change.
01:31:34 It's an important issue for me as a father of a high schooler,
01:31:37 and we talk about it all the time.
01:31:39 That's why in April, long before the election,
01:31:41 I put out a substantial package, pricing carbon to meet our Paris targets.
01:31:47 And what's interesting, our low-carbon savings account will allow people to actually make green choices to lower their carbon footprint.
01:31:54 This approach is innovative because it would allow all Canadians to know what their carbon footprint is and make those innovative investments to lower it.
01:32:02 I think we all have a role to play, and our plan is detailed, and we'll deliver on it.
01:32:07 Mr. Blanchet.
01:32:08 Thank you to be with us, sir.
01:32:09 I hope you appreciate a little bit blunt answers first you cap you put a ceiling on any production
01:32:17 of oil and gas you take all the money that the federal government is placing into that industry
01:32:23 even more by the liberals than the conservatives before and you put that into green energy and you
01:32:29 take the money for Trans Mountain and you give it to Alberta for Alberta to initiate its own
01:32:35 transition toward a greener economy this is the way to do things because if we don't do that and
01:32:41 keep dreaming about reducing gas emission while increasing production we will never get there
01:32:48 thank you mr blanchett mr trudeau thank you trevor for your question from one teacher to another i
01:32:55 know that you need to ground your decisions and what you share with your students in science and
01:33:01 all these leaders on here have various claims about what their climate change plan is going to
01:33:06 do. Unfortunately, if you look at what the experts and the climate scientists and the economists have
01:33:11 said, we are the ones with the strongest plan to fight climate change. And how to answer your
01:33:16 question specifically, how to make it more affordable for Canadians? Well, the first thing
01:33:20 we did on that was bring in a national price on pollution that incentivizes businesses to go
01:33:25 cleaner at the same time as it puts more money in families' pockets. We are going to put a cap on
01:33:31 oil sands and oil and gas emissions and decline it until net zero and create those opportunities
01:33:37 and investments that are going to make it more affordable for you and your students for many
01:33:41 years to come. Thank you, Mr. Trudeau. Thank you, Trevor. Have a good evening. I'm turning it back
01:33:47 to the leaders. It is time for more debate. The draw has Mr. Trudeau and Mr. O'Toole facing off.
01:33:53 Your topic is climate change. Even today, one in four Canadians don't believe that climate change
01:34:01 is caused by human activity. How can we achieve real progress when so many people are still
01:34:10 debating the fundamentals? Mr. O'Toole, you begin. Climate change is a real threat, not only to Canada
01:34:17 and to the world. That's why we have to take a serious plan to tackle it. That's why, as I said,
01:34:21 we put our plan out in April because we had to restore some trust on this issue to make sure we
01:34:27 can show Canadians we can get emissions down and get the economy working again. That is key. We
01:34:33 have a plan to meet our Paris targets but minimize the impact on jobs and investment. We're also
01:34:39 going to make major investments in electric vehicles, in the hydrogen economy, small modular
01:34:45 reactors. There is so much we can do to get our emissions down but grow a strong economy because
01:34:50 Because without a strong economy, we can't tackle climate change, we can't tackle the
01:34:55 issues of today.
01:34:56 But the reality that Mr. O'Toole has never understood is you can't have a strong economy
01:35:00 unless you tackle climate change.
01:35:03 And you ask about how we're going to convince the quarter of Canadians who still don't think
01:35:06 climate change is real, well, Mr. O'Toole can't even convince his party that climate
01:35:11 change is real, because they voted against that.
01:35:12 And that's perhaps why his plan is so weak.
01:35:15 His plan is to go back to the Harper targets, to the Harper approach on fighting climate
01:35:19 which doesn't work. His costed platform, which he just put out last night, cuts two billion dollars
01:35:26 from climate investments and from things. And for our friends in B.C., Mr. O'Toole has proposed to
01:35:33 restore the northern gateway pipeline to the Great Bear Forest and the tanker. Mr. O'Toole always
01:35:42 forgets one fact. He has never made a target for climate change. He has great ambition. That's part
01:35:48 of the reason we're in an election in a pandemic is his ambition he doesn't have achievement well
01:35:53 he never meets his target the target is in 2030 so it's actually quite difficult to meet our
01:35:58 countries nine years away except for the fact that right now we are on track gentlemen we have to
01:36:04 wrap this segment all right we are moving on we are moving on leaders next up is mr singh
01:36:11 mr blanchette and ms paul i'd like each of you to describe how you'll implement a national approach
01:36:17 that best recognizes the significant regional differences involved in fighting climate change,
01:36:24 you begin, Mr. Singh. You may jump in one at a time, please.
01:36:28 Of course.
01:36:29 Well, here's the thing. We just heard Mr. O'Toole and Mr. Trudeau argue about who's worse.
01:36:34 And honestly, it's a tough question to answer.
01:36:37 Let me tell you, you're not stuck with these two. Better is possible.
01:36:41 We can invest in a clean economy. We can end fossil fuel subsidies.
01:36:46 We can make sure we're creating clean transportation, and we can invest in provinces and territories to make sure they have the resources necessary to fight the climate crisis.
01:36:55 I'm hopeful. I'm optimistic. I'm going to be a dad soon, and I want to make sure my child grows up into a future that has the same opportunities that I had, that has clean air, clean water, a clean place to live.
01:37:07 I want to make sure that that's different.
01:37:08 As far as I understand it, it is not a national or even less original issue.
01:37:14 it is a planetary issue and it has to be tackled by everybody at once but i would be glad to give
01:37:23 some of my precious time to mr otul because a week ago a little more than that he said in french
01:37:29 that he did not want anymore to have a pipeline to go through quebec that was quite a statement
01:37:35 he said that in french no more pipeline through quebec i want to hear that in english tonight
01:37:40 Please, please.
01:37:42 Hold on, hold on.
01:37:44 This segment is quite frankly.
01:37:49 We're not going to let that happen.
01:37:50 This on the climate, this sort of approach is going to get us nowhere, and I mean but nowhere.
01:37:57 It is, and the question was an excellent one.
01:37:59 This is a global issue.
01:38:01 This is a national issue.
01:38:03 This is a nonpartisan issue, and we have got to be able to come together across party lines.
01:38:08 I wanted I said that I was available for a debate just on the climate because it's that important but we and we've invited many times all of the parties to join us in a joint cabinet a cross party cabinet to deal with this the way that we dealt with the pandemic together people were so inspired to see these leaders come together in the early days of the pandemic we have got to bring that same approach here let's come together because that's what's needed.
01:38:34 Thank you very much. I absolutely agree. We do need to come together. I can lay out what we
01:38:38 shouldn't do and what we need to do. What we shouldn't do is what Mr. Trudeau did,
01:38:42 set targets and missed them. We shouldn't promise to end fossil fuel subsidies and then increase
01:38:46 them. We shouldn't put a price on pollution and then exempt the biggest polluters. What we need
01:38:50 to do is end those fossil fuel subsidies, invest in provinces and territories with infrastructure
01:38:56 that's going to help us fight the climate crisis. Hold on, Mr. Singh. With the greatest of respect
01:39:03 With the greatest of respect to Mr. Singh,
01:39:05 we have been making this invitation for years,
01:39:08 and it has never been accepted by the NDP or any other party.
01:39:12 So it's great to hear that they agree.
01:39:14 We have to wrap this section now, leaders.
01:39:16 It is time for me, with great pleasure,
01:39:18 to welcome Mercedes Stevenson of Global News.
01:39:21 She is joining us now, and she's going to be asking
01:39:23 each of you a direct question on climate change.
01:39:27 This round starts with Mr. Trudeau. Hi, Mercedes.
01:39:29 Hi. Thank you so much for having me.
01:39:31 much for having me. Hello, candidates. It's a pleasure to have the opportunity to ask you
01:39:35 about a question that is on a lot of Canadians' minds, the question of climate change.
01:39:39 Mr. Trudeau, starting with you. On your watch, Canada's greenhouse gas emissions have gone up
01:39:45 every year since 2016, giving this country the worst emissions reduction record in the G7.
01:39:52 According to the most recent data from your government, Canada's emissions in 2019
01:39:57 were just as high as they were 15 years ago.
01:40:01 Environmentalists say that your performance is insufficient.
01:40:04 If you're so serious about climate change,
01:40:06 why are Canada's emissions still going up?
01:40:09 We inherited a government from conservatives
01:40:13 that did not believe in the fight against climate change,
01:40:16 and we had a lot of catching up to do.
01:40:17 But what we were able to do in six years
01:40:19 is bring in national price on pollution,
01:40:21 ban single-use plastics,
01:40:24 move forward in protecting more of our coasts
01:40:26 and oceans and rivers than any government in history, and we are right now on track
01:40:32 to exceeding those 20, 30 targets set at the beginning at Paris, down to 36 percent.
01:40:39 And we've gone even further with that with a concrete plan that the experts have said
01:40:44 is the only one that can achieve a 40 percent reduction.
01:40:47 Which they say you're unlikely to meet.
01:40:48 That is what we're dealing with.
01:40:49 Okay, Mr. Trudeau.
01:40:51 Mr. Beauches.
01:40:52 Madame.
01:40:53 Your party often criticizes the oil and gas industry in Canada's western provinces.
01:40:59 You've said that you would block pipelines trying to go through Quebec.
01:41:02 While you were the environment minister, though, you allowed oil exploration and carbon-intensive projects without environmental assessment.
01:41:09 So why the double standard, and what do you say to Canadians who feel that you're blocking their prosperity?
01:41:15 There were three issues that have been raised since I've been into this election.
01:41:21 The first one is having reversed the 9B line of Enbridge, which has been reversed a few years sooner without any evaluation or anything.
01:41:31 The second one is a project in Bédé Chaleur, which already had been submitted to an evaluation, an environmental evaluation.
01:41:41 And the other one was to have an environmental, I will come to that, evaluation after the exploration.
01:41:49 This is all a buildup made by the previously environmentalist Sylvain Guilbault from the Parti Liberal, which the prime minister did not even know about when he attacked me with it.
01:42:02 My record is also I've been having signed the carbon market with California,
01:42:08 which is still considered the best way to tackle the gas emission through incentives and tariffs around the world, at least North America.
01:42:20 That is time. Mercedes, your next question.
01:42:22 Mr. O'Toole, you're next.
01:42:24 Under your plan, Canada would abandon its current climate target.
01:42:28 Instead, you would settle for a weaker one.
01:42:31 In fact, it's one set six years ago by Stephen Harper.
01:42:34 World leaders are meeting this fall to ratchet up their commitments on climate change on the global stage,
01:42:40 yet you would walk ours back.
01:42:42 You've said that climate change is real and you've endorsed carbon pricing,
01:42:46 but your target is the lowest of all of the major parties who are here tonight.
01:42:51 Why should Canadians settle for your plan and a plan that would take our targets back in time?
01:42:57 Because Canadians deserve to have a plan and leadership to make the targets.
01:43:01 Mr. Trudeau went to Paris.
01:43:03 The targets I'm talking about making are the ones he signed on to,
01:43:07 and then for six years did not make them.
01:43:10 He likes to blame everyone else but himself for action.
01:43:14 So what we did, because as I said, Mercedes, we have to build trust on this issue,
01:43:18 we went out and worked with the top consultancy in the country
01:43:21 to come up with a plan to price carbon, to get our emissions down to meet Paris,
01:43:25 but to also get people back to work after COVID-19 with half trillion dollars worth of debt put on by
01:43:32 Mr. Trudeau with a cost of living crisis we also need to have a strong economy to get our emissions
01:43:37 down. We will make our emission targets and I think it's important for Canada to have a plan
01:43:42 to meet what it signs on to internationally. Ms. Paul of the Green Party obviously environment a
01:43:50 big focus in your plan, calls for a 60% reduction in Canada's emissions by the year 2030. Other
01:43:56 countries that are making that commitment don't face the same challenges that we do
01:44:00 here in Canada. We live in a cold, northern, sprawling country, and our economy still relies
01:44:06 on resource extraction, much of which you've said you would shut down completely in your
01:44:11 platform. How would you offset the economic harm that would result from meeting such an
01:44:16 And first let me say that when I think about our future
01:44:19 and I think about the future of energy,
01:44:21 Canada will remain an energy superpower,
01:44:23 but we will be a renewable energy superpower. 0.70
01:44:26 And I think about my brother, who was a roughneck
01:44:29 out on the oil patch until the bust during the pandemic.
01:44:33 And I think about his future.
01:44:35 And I know that we have got to diversify our economy.
01:44:38 But I tell the people of Canada today
01:44:40 that what happens next is really up to you.
01:44:43 We need to be able to do that.
01:44:45 We can keep moving towards a mirage and that is what these promises are, a mirage that's just out there in the distance that we never arrive at.
01:44:53 Or you can send people back to Ottawa from every single party who are committed to working together across party lines on the greatest existential challenge of our time and seizing the opportunity of a truly green recovery.
01:45:07 Mr. Singh, you accuse the Trudeau government of being all talk and no action when it comes to
01:45:15 climate change and yet you won't even give Canadians a straight answer on whether or not
01:45:19 you would cancel the Trans Mountain Pipeline expansion. You've had years as NDP leader to
01:45:24 develop a climate plan. Your platform has lots of big ideas and big targets but almost no details
01:45:31 on how you would get there. Don't you owe Canadians a clear answer on your climate roadmap and will
01:45:36 you provide one tonight absolutely and i'm honored to do so we've got a bold plan that's going to
01:45:42 take a lot of courage that requires lots of investment because we know how serious this
01:45:46 crisis is and we know what we're up against unlike mr trudeau we're not going to blame
01:45:50 previous governments we know that in power we have the power to make a change and if we vote
01:45:56 for the same things we're going to get the same results so i want canadians to know you have a
01:45:59 choice we are committed to ending answer we'll lay some of it out one of it is to end fossil
01:46:04 fuel subsidies, use that to invest in clean energy. We would make sure we prioritize investing
01:46:10 in electrified transportation. We would invest in retrofitting homes and buildings to reduce
01:46:14 our emissions. There is so much that we can do. We are confident we can do it. But there is a cost
01:46:20 if we continue down the same path of conservative or liberals who don't take this seriously. You
01:46:25 have a choice. All right. Thank you. Now it is time for open debate. Mercedes is going to keep
01:46:33 you leaders on theme. I'm going to keep you on time and make sure everyone has a chance to be
01:46:38 heard. Ms. Paul, we're starting with you. Back to you, Mercedes. Thank you. Canadians want their
01:46:45 government to fight climate change, but they also worry about the cost for their families,
01:46:50 and we know there will be a cost to this. Why should Canadians trust your party to see us
01:46:56 there is a global green rush going on now to create the competitive green economy of the future
01:47:06 what the greens don't want to see is canada being left behind because that is exactly what's
01:47:12 happening you know i'm sure that the last candle maker was the person that had the market cornered
01:47:19 on candle making but if everyone has moved on to led lights then you're in trouble and so what we
01:47:24 want to see is a seizing this opportunity and mercedes to your earlier question if denmark and
01:47:29 greenland other cold countries can end oil exploration then certainly we can do it and
01:47:34 if 27 countries in the european union can come together collaboratively to have an ambitious
01:47:39 plan for the climate then surely with leadership we can do the same here in canada i know canada
01:47:45 can do anything that any other country can do absolutely i think we absolutely can if if any
01:47:51 type of energy is removed from the global market, Canadian energy. It's replaced by a bad actor
01:47:57 country that doesn't have carbon reduction programs. It doesn't have human rights. It 0.63
01:48:02 doesn't have engagement with indigenous communities. Indigenous partnerships in natural 1.00
01:48:07 resources is huge. So you said the cost. There are tens of thousands of jobs that deserve an
01:48:12 economic recovery just as much as anyone else. There are indigenous partnerships, economic
01:48:18 reconciliation and a move towards a made in Canada net zero by 2050. So let's be leaders
01:48:24 in getting carbon emissions down and being world leaders on how we have natural resources,
01:48:31 whether it's energy, timber, rare earth minerals for EVs, then we can be world leaders again.
01:48:37 Let's talk about the cost. The cost of inaction is an entire town of Lytton being wiped out by a
01:48:43 climate forest fire. The cost of inaction is forest fires and flooding and heat waves that
01:48:49 mean Canadians lose their lives. The cost of not acting means a young woman I met in Hamilton
01:48:54 who looked me in the eyes and said, what's the point of me pursuing my education? What's the
01:48:59 point of me finding a partner or even starting a family when I don't know what type of future
01:49:03 I'll live in, let alone my child? That's the cost of inaction. That's the cost of Mr. Trudeau,
01:49:09 who had six years to do something about this.
01:49:13 It's not two years.
01:49:14 It's not a small mandate.
01:49:16 Six years, and he failed you and cost all of us.
01:49:21 When we talk about a climate crisis, we have to deal in facts.
01:49:24 And one of the facts I need to correct right now that everyone has laid into
01:49:27 is we have not missed any of our targets.
01:49:30 We are on track to exceeding our targets.
01:49:32 And it's important that we are on facts.
01:49:34 Secondly, I do have a question for Mr. Singh.
01:49:37 We need to talk about science.
01:49:38 We need to talk about experts.
01:49:40 We agree on that, you and I both.
01:49:42 So how is it that the experts that have rated our plan on climate to be an A have rated your plan to be an F?
01:49:49 Who are these experts?
01:49:50 I rate your track record an F, Mr. Chido. 1.00
01:49:53 You've had six years. 1.00
01:49:54 You don't get to rate.
01:49:55 People know.
01:49:56 Well, not just me.
01:49:57 Experts.
01:49:57 Why did the experts give you an F on your climate plan?
01:50:01 Let me respond to this.
01:50:04 You're talking about the future.
01:50:06 Let's talk about right now.
01:50:07 You had six years, and you've got the worst track record in all the G7 after six years.
01:50:16 How can people trust you?
01:50:18 Why didn't you put forward and ask someone that is for you?
01:50:21 Mr. Trudeau, then Ms. Paul, then Mr. Blanchard.
01:50:24 I don't accept that, first of all.
01:50:26 I don't accept that at all.
01:50:26 We've got a bold plan and a strong plan.
01:50:28 Mr. Singh, thank you very much, Mr. Trudeau.
01:50:31 He cannot explain why his plan is being...
01:50:36 is being panned by experts.
01:50:39 Now, every politician up here says,
01:50:40 we have the best plan.
01:50:41 We actually have a record. 0.51
01:50:43 And what Mercedes questioned was,
01:50:45 how do we make sure it's affordable?
01:50:47 We brought in a price on pollution
01:50:49 across the country
01:50:50 that puts more money back in the pockets
01:50:53 in the provinces where it had to be imposed
01:50:55 because conservative politicians
01:50:57 fought against it every step of the way.
01:50:59 Miss Paul, with the greatest of respect,
01:51:03 I think the five PhDs
01:51:05 in our shadow cabinet
01:51:06 who put together our green recovery policy
01:51:10 would disagree with you, with the experts.
01:51:12 But I do want to say more generally
01:51:14 that, again, this is getting us nowhere.
01:51:17 We have got to be able to come together
01:51:20 across party lines,
01:51:21 not only to face the existential crisis
01:51:25 that Mr. Singh described,
01:51:26 but also to seize the greatest economic opportunity
01:51:30 that Canada has seen within our lifetimes.
01:51:32 We are being left behind.
01:51:34 And if the United States can do it,
01:51:36 if the european union can do it i know that we can do it it's about a change in the culture
01:51:41 all right thank you miss paul mr blanchette did you want to get in that i'm quite behind everybody
01:51:46 else and i have 12 seconds left take some time with the basic statement there's possibility
01:51:53 to create more wealth to absorb the cost of the changes that we need we must stop opposing
01:52:00 environment and creating wealth it may go together well this is the change that we have to do
01:52:09 thank you sir thank you mercedes and now leaders we are moving on to our next theme reconciliation
01:52:23 now we are going to our first time voter merrick mcleod in sous saint marie he's got a question
01:52:29 to all the leaders merrick you're 18 years old you're a first-time voter what is your question
01:52:34 to the leaders go ahead merrick the leaders are listening honey bojo in the ojibwe culture trust
01:52:43 and respect is key to any relationship oh oh shoot you got it merrick keep going how can i trust and
01:52:53 respect the federal government after 150 plus years of lies and abuse to my people and as prime
01:52:59 minister what will you do to rebuild the trust between first nations and the federal government
01:53:05 thank you merrick leaders you've heard the question how do you respond to merrick mr
01:53:10 trudeau you start this round thank you merrick for your question you're absolutely right
01:53:16 over the past 150 years canada has failed in its relationship with indigenous peoples
01:53:22 people who we should be working with and shared stewardship of the land,
01:53:26 working with in partnership as we draw from the bounty and the beauty of this land
01:53:31 to build a better future for all.
01:53:33 That is why over the past six years, we have stepped up on the path of reconciliation.
01:53:38 We have ended boil water advisories in 109 different communities.
01:53:43 We have made sure that tens of thousands of young people get to go to school in better classrooms.
01:53:49 We continue to move forward on fighting for the missing and murdered indigenous women and girls
01:53:55 and ensuring a true partnership as we move forward in respect.
01:54:00 Mr. Blanchet.
01:54:02 Your question is quite moving.
01:54:05 I would say that no one is entitled to tell any nation what to do or what to think
01:54:15 and that every nation has to be recognized as such either it is a nation of 300 people
01:54:23 like there is in quebec or eight million people nation like quebec is it calls for a relationship
01:54:31 between equals it calls for a relationship in which nobody tells the other party that they are
01:54:39 bigger, richer, and therefore, you will do as you are told,
01:54:44 even if we say it politely.
01:54:46 And first, you provide clean water to everybody.
01:54:50 Thank you, Mr. Blanchet. Ms. Paul.
01:54:52 Yes, and thank you so much for the question.
01:54:55 And I understand the anguish in it as well,
01:54:59 because justice delayed is justice denied.
01:55:02 And coming from a diaspora, myself,
01:55:05 where we have been robbed of our culture,
01:55:07 of our languages, of our history,
01:55:09 I have no idea where my ancestors were born
01:55:11 or where they're buried.
01:55:12 I completely understand how important this is
01:55:14 and how frustrating it is not to have seen the action.
01:55:17 I am tired of being up on these stages
01:55:19 without indigenous leadership here to speak for itself.
01:55:23 Jody Wilson-Raybould, Mumalak Kalak,
01:55:25 I'm thinking of you right now.
01:55:27 And when Mumalak, Ms. Kakak said that without action,
01:55:33 that the parliament would be hollow, she was right. 0.99
01:55:36 So indigenous sovereignty, self-determination
01:55:39 determination, nation-to-nation engagement. That is my commitment. Mr. O'Toole. Mr. McLeod, thank you
01:55:46 for the question. And the way you phrased it is so important. Reconciliation is about trust and
01:55:51 respect and restoring it after a century and a half of a federal government failing. That's why
01:55:58 as opposition leader, my first question when I rose in the House of Commons was on a call to
01:56:02 action on reconciliation with respect to Indigenous health. We need to build partnerships. We need to
01:56:08 restore trust. And that trust is eroded when you make commitments on safe drinking water on
01:56:15 reserve, when you make commitments on the calls to action in the Truth and Reconciliation Report
01:56:20 and have no plan to fulfill them. So I want to build partnerships and have Indigenous leaders
01:56:26 have governance over the federal government finally delivering on our commitment to Indigenous
01:56:31 peoples. Mr. Singh. Thank you very much, Merrick. Thank you for your question. How to restore trust.
01:56:37 how do you restore trust when indigenous communities suffer injustice and it continues
01:56:45 in an unbroken line to this very day how do you restore trust when you've got a prime minister
01:56:52 that takes a knee one day and then takes indigenous kids to court the next and how do you restore
01:56:58 in a country as wealthy as ours,
01:57:02 a G7 nation in the 21st century
01:57:06 that still does not provide clean drinking water
01:57:09 to every single indigenous nation,
01:57:12 it starts by actually walking the path of reconciliation,
01:57:16 not with the empty words, but real action, clean water,
01:57:19 nation to nation, and respect.
01:57:21 Okay, thank you, Mr. Singh.
01:57:23 Merrick, did the leaders answer your question?
01:57:27 All right, yeah.
01:57:32 All right, thank you very much.
01:57:34 Miigwech.
01:57:35 Miigwech.
01:57:36 Miigwech.
01:57:37 Messieurs Blanchet and O'Toole, it is your turn to debate now.
01:57:42 You've promised more money to search for unmarked graves,
01:57:46 but so much more needs to be done
01:57:48 to achieve meaningful reconciliation.
01:57:51 Mr. Blanchet, you begin.
01:57:53 Tell me, how are you better positioned
01:57:56 than Mr. O'Toole to restore justice?
01:57:59 I am not better positioned than Mr. O'Toole
01:58:02 because I believe that this is a relationship
01:58:05 between nations, and, you know, your presence in nation,
01:58:08 I feel I represent another one,
01:58:10 and we are discussing with a lot of other nations.
01:58:13 But I will remind everybody
01:58:15 that on the last day of the last session,
01:58:18 we had a motion adopted unanimously by the parliament,
01:58:23 parliament and this motion was precisely saying what we had been told to carry by
01:58:30 the First Nation leaders and we had it adopted this might be the way to do it
01:58:34 many times the Bloc Québécois said even if we don't agree with everything that
01:58:39 we would share our seats and our voices in the parliament with the First Nations
01:58:44 in order to have them being heard by the whole country after the tragic finding
01:58:52 graves in Kamloops, Cowessess, and other former residential school sites, we offered to work in
01:58:58 a bipartisan fashion on calls to action 71 to 76. Those are related to former residential school
01:59:04 sites. And we need to act faster. I know Mr. Trudeau cares a great deal about reconciliation.
01:59:09 I know we all do. But this is an issue where we have to act. We can no longer say that we recognize
01:59:16 the calls to action. We need a plan to achieve them. And what I'm proposing is a plan that builds
01:59:22 partnerships, that builds governance, that has indigenous leaders, incredible ones, like
01:59:27 Jody Wilson-Raybould, to allow us to actually hold ourselves to account. All parties, all
01:59:34 future governments. This is the big scar in the history of Canada. And we have to tackle
01:59:40 it, not just with good intentions, but with a good plan to deliver for all indigenous
01:59:45 people.
01:59:46 Mr. Blanchet, briefly.
01:59:46 that the prime minister has nominated
01:59:50 Gouverneur Générale, I don't know how to translate that,
01:59:53 who speaks in Uqtutuk, which is great,
01:59:55 but does not speak French.
01:59:56 Still, he does not agree with the idea of acknowledging,
02:00:01 recognizing First Nation languages
02:00:04 as official languages in his country.
02:00:06 All right, we will leave that segment there.
02:00:09 Ms. Paul, Mr. Singh, Mr. Trudeau, you're up.
02:00:12 Tell me, what is your plan
02:00:15 to end the ongoing disproportionate violence
02:00:18 against Indigenous women and girls.
02:00:21 Ms. Paul.
02:00:22 The first thing is to make space for Indigenous leadership
02:00:26 because, you know, we have done all these things
02:00:28 and made all these promises.
02:00:29 We know what needs to be done.
02:00:31 The recommendations are there in the calls for justice
02:00:34 and the missing and murdered Indigenous women and girls report,
02:00:37 and yet we still don't have the action.
02:00:39 And so, as I said before,
02:00:40 it should be Jody up here answering that question.
02:00:43 And it should be Mumala Kakak up here answering that question.
02:00:46 We need to make the space for Indigenous leadership to guide this process.
02:00:51 And above all, we need to make this a priority.
02:00:55 All that is left now is political will.
02:00:58 But that is exactly what we have been doing, Ms. Paul.
02:01:00 When we called the National Inquiry into Missing and Murdered Indigenous Women and Girls
02:01:05 after years of governments avoiding doing that,
02:01:08 we ensured that we brought the truth forward.
02:01:10 And then we worked with indigenous leaders groups, indigenous women's groups to co-develop the action plan that we are now fully funding so we can get justice for the victims, healing for the families and put an end to this ongoing national tragedy.
02:01:25 It will take a lot of work by all of us, but we are walking this road in partnership because we know it needs to be done and there is much more to do.
02:01:35 Mr. Trudeau, sadly, and I don't take any pleasure in this,
02:01:38 the calls to justice are out there, and you haven't acted on them.
02:01:41 And I meant it when I said you can't take a knee one day
02:01:44 if you're going to take Indigenous kids to court the next. 0.98
02:01:46 That's not leadership. 0.93
02:01:47 Mr. Singh, you love that line about taking Indigenous kids to court.
02:01:51 It's actually not true.
02:01:53 We have committed to compensating those kids who went through that.
02:01:57 And what's more than that, this is important, Mr. Singh.
02:02:00 No, you can't say you're not taking them to court when you're taking them to court.
02:02:02 There are kids out there that are being fought by you in court.
02:02:05 Leaders, I would actually remind you the question is about violence against indigenous women and girls.
02:02:11 Let me recenter you on that.
02:02:13 I appreciate it because you can't continue to say that.
02:02:15 That doesn't make any sense.
02:02:15 And Ms. Curl, I will say again, I said this last night in the French debate,
02:02:20 this is why we need more diversity in politics.
02:02:22 This is why we need people who are most directly impacted by issues to be able to speak for themselves
02:02:27 because we are drifting off into things.
02:02:30 we have only dedicated two minutes to talking about how we are going to bring true justice
02:02:35 to Indigenous women in this country.
02:02:37 If we could stick to the topic.
02:02:39 Mr. Trudeau.
02:02:39 Ms. Curl, on this topic, and it was brought up in the earlier one, and we talked about
02:02:43 Indigenous women, I want to talk about those kids buried in unmarked graves across the
02:02:47 country, because it was a tragedy for all Canadians, one long known by Indigenous peoples.
02:02:52 But when I went to Cowessess to speak with Chief Kasmus DeLorme, we not only grieved
02:02:57 those kids. We signed an agreement, a landmark agreement, to keep kids at risk in their
02:03:03 communities, to take them out of the provincial system. That is how we moved forward. It took
02:03:08 years to sign that agreement, but we got it, and we are empowering Indigenous communities
02:03:13 to care for their own kids. Mr. Trudeau, we're out of time. Mr. Singh, I'm going to give you
02:03:16 a very brief moment to respond briefly. We're over time. We need to implement all the calls
02:03:21 to justice. We need to listen to Indigenous women and girls. We need to make sure that they're safe,
02:03:26 and we have the steps that they've laid out that we need to follow.
02:03:29 All right. Thank you very much, leaders.
02:03:31 Now, I'm really pleased to welcome Melissa Ridgen of APTN News.
02:03:36 Melissa is going to be asking you each a direct question on our theme of reconciliation.
02:03:42 Your first question, hi, Melissa, is to Mr. Blanchett.
02:03:45 Over to you.
02:03:47 Tonje, thank you all for being here.
02:03:48 It's a pleasure to be here with you to ask some questions for our APTN audience.
02:03:53 Mr. Blanchett, I'm going to start with you.
02:03:55 You know, numerous government reports, including in Quebec,
02:03:58 have sounded the alarm that systemic racism exists,
02:04:01 from Joyce Eshaquon dying as she's taunted by hospital staff,
02:04:06 to policing, the justice system.
02:04:09 What will you do as Black leader to address systemic racism
02:04:12 in your own province, in Quebec, and also elsewhere in Canada?
02:04:15 First, never underestimate the weight, the sadness of those dramas.
02:04:21 Second, I acknowledged, I recognized the existence of systemic racism in June 2020.
02:04:30 And then, what happened?
02:04:32 It became a political tool against Quebec.
02:04:35 It became a tool to say Quebec is this and that and racist and xenophobic and all of that.
02:04:41 Instead of opening a discussion, trying to find solution, consulting experts, discussing with the First Nations themselves, 0.69
02:04:50 It became this white society against this other one white society. 0.80
02:04:58 We build nothing.
02:05:00 So the words became toxic.
02:05:02 I'm absolutely open to the idea of discussing all of that on a quiet stage without this
02:05:10 aggressivity, being aggressive as this debate has become.
02:05:15 All right, Mr. Blanchet, we have to move on.
02:05:17 Your next question, Melissa.
02:05:18 This question's for you, Ms. Paul.
02:05:20 You know, Canada has more children in government custody right now than at the height of residential schools.
02:05:26 New legislation, child welfare legislation, actually takes the onus and puts it on the First Nations communities 0.56
02:05:33 to bring their kids back, cleaning up the mess that Canada has created, essentially.
02:05:38 And those children are going to have to be brought back to all of those same problems that still exist
02:05:43 that were the grounds for apprehension.
02:05:45 What would you do in the House of Commons to make sure that poverty and trauma issues are addressed?
02:05:52 Thank you very much for that question.
02:05:54 And absolutely, we mentioned that not that long ago in one of our statements that the residential school system had been replaced by children in care and that this was just perpetuating the legacy of trauma.
02:06:10 It really comes back to what I said before, which is that the Indigenous leadership is there.
02:06:15 It is ready to guide all of these processes.
02:06:17 We have all of the recommendations we need.
02:06:19 What we are missing is political will.
02:06:21 What we are missing is those who have been in power for a very long time,
02:06:25 making space for new voices and diverse voices.
02:06:29 I actually had to pull my jaw up, which just dropped,
02:06:32 when I heard what Mr. Blanchett said.
02:06:35 I invited Mr. Blanchett to get educated about systemic discrimination.
02:06:39 I extend that invitation again.
02:06:41 I would be happy to educate him.
02:06:42 It's nice to want to educate me.
02:06:44 This is my time, sir.
02:06:45 It is.
02:06:46 Nice time to insult people.
02:06:48 That was not an insult.
02:06:49 It was an invitation to educate yourself.
02:06:50 This is leader direct questions, Melissa.
02:06:53 There should be some discency in this debate.
02:06:56 Since I'm many minutes behind everybody else, there should be some discency in the debate.
02:07:01 You have had every opportunity to jump in an open debate.
02:07:03 It's your responsibility, not mine, but some things cannot be said.
02:07:05 And I am fulfilling my responsibility, sir.
02:07:07 Melissa, we're going to keep moving on.
02:07:08 Is it my turn?
02:07:09 It is your turn.
02:07:10 Thank you.
02:07:11 Mr. Trudeau, this is for you.
02:07:13 You know, your liberal government has turned Indian affairs into two separate massive bureaucracies
02:07:18 that eat up large portions of funding that will never see it onto reserve.
02:07:23 It doesn't leave the bureaucracy.
02:07:25 You know, you've promised clean drinking water, but billions of dollars later, that's not happened.
02:07:29 Many still do not have clean drinking water.
02:07:31 You know, Canadians and Indigenous people are losing patience with the lack of results from all of this spending.
02:07:39 So I guess the question is, why would they believe you this, a third term, that they
02:07:43 would get results and you would be accountable for all that spending?
02:07:46 One of the enemies of progressive politics, Melissa, is cynicism, is discounting the hard
02:07:53 work that millions of people have been involved in over the past years.
02:07:56 And yes, there's always more to do.
02:07:59 Progressives always know there's more to do.
02:08:01 But when we came into office, there were 105 long-term boil water advisories.
02:08:06 We lifted 109 of them, and for each of the ones that are remaining, we have a project lead, a project team, and an action plan, and we are going to lift those all.
02:08:16 There are tens of thousands of kids across this country, indigenous kids, who've started the school year in new schools or refurbished schools.
02:08:24 We have moved forward on settling more agreements and more land claims and more partnerships than any other government over the years.
02:08:31 We continue to work in partnership and respect and invest more money in Indigenous communities than any previous government.
02:08:38 And no, we're not done yet.
02:08:40 I think the money, I don't think anybody's questioning the money spent.
02:08:43 I think that they're questioning the results for the money that's spent.
02:08:46 My next question is to you, Mr. Singh.
02:08:48 You know, federal forces, including the RCMP and the Department of Fisheries and Oceans,
02:08:52 have been used throughout Canada's history to prevent First Nations from exercising their treaty rights to fish and to hunt and to defend land and water.
02:09:01 This is happening right now on both coasts, including under the NDP party in British Columbia with regards to fishing and logging.
02:09:09 So my question would be to you as prime minister, what would you do to ensure indigenous rights and title are finally respected in this country?
02:09:17 I really appreciate the question. First of all, we need to respect indigenous treaty land and rights.
02:09:22 That's a fundamental step towards walking the path of reconciliation in a real meaningful way.
02:09:27 But you mentioned the RCMP, and I've got to talk about the really sad reality that there's been violence, heavy-handed violence, against indigenous communities, against peaceful protesters.
02:09:39 And we have long called, I have long called, for reform of policing.
02:09:43 When I was in the provincial level, I fought against carting.
02:09:46 I've continued to use every platform I have to say, we've got to stop the use of force.
02:09:51 We've got to overview it.
02:09:52 We've got to change the RCMP's mandate.
02:09:54 And that's something we can do at the federal level.
02:09:56 That's something that Mr. Trudeau said he would do and yet has yet to do.
02:10:00 And it's something I'm committed to making sure it happens.
02:10:04 Mr. O'Toole, my next question is for you.
02:10:07 You know, you voted against the UN Declaration on the Rights of Indigenous People
02:10:10 that would share decision-making power with Indigenous people
02:10:13 over what happens on their land.
02:10:15 And you also want to criminalize Indigenous dissent
02:10:19 that's expressed through blockades or protests.
02:10:21 So the question is, if you're a Prime Minister,
02:10:22 how could Canada build a respectful nation-to-nation relationship with Indigenous people?
02:10:29 Thank you, Ms. Ridge. And this goes very similar to Mr. McLeod's question on trust and respect.
02:10:34 I want to build those partnerships. And that's why our only concern with the United Nations
02:10:38 Declaration was how free and prior informed consent was defined so that it didn't stop
02:10:43 partnerships from being formed. I'm really glad to say one of the early leaders behind the UN
02:10:49 Declaration, Chief Willie Littlechild, has agreed to serve as a special counsel to me
02:10:53 on the implementation of that to make sure that there are partnerships and opportunities.
02:10:59 What I want to do as Prime Minister is build that type of nation-to-nation dialogue and
02:11:03 partnership so that the next generation has intergenerational wealth and opportunity transfer,
02:11:09 not trauma.
02:11:11 And building that trust will be core to me.
02:11:13 It's why, as I said, my first question was on reconciliation.
02:11:17 We have to make progress.
02:11:19 All right.
02:11:20 Thank you, Mr. O'Toole.
02:11:21 Now we move on to open debate, a reminder that Melissa will be here to keep the leaders on theme.
02:11:26 I will be here to do my best to keep you on time.
02:11:29 And all of you have an opportunity to jump in after Mr. Trudeau begins with a question from Melissa.
02:11:37 Okay.
02:11:37 I think if there's one thing that Canadians and Indigenous people can all agree upon, it is that this Indian Act system is not working for anybody.
02:11:44 How would you dismantle this broken, top-down system, and what would you replace it with
02:11:49 that would ensure that Canada still is living up to its constitutional obligations to Indigenous people? 0.75
02:11:55 First of all, we are looking forward to dismantling the Indian Act.
02:11:59 It is a commitment of ours, but it is not something that Ottawa gets to decide.
02:12:04 And what replaces the Indian Act will vary from community to community as we live up to our obligations.
02:12:10 And that's why over the years, as we've moved towards self-government, we have accompanied communities, some who want to start with health, some who want to start with education, some who want to start with economic development.
02:12:22 Every community, every nation across this country gets to help define what its path is forward.
02:12:28 We will be there to listen, to partner, to build a better future every step of the way.
02:12:34 The way to go forward is to listen to leaders. And Mr. Trudeau ignored one that he had in his
02:12:39 own cabinet, Jody Wilson-Raybould. That was a huge lost opportunity. We've been speaking to people
02:12:44 with how we can accelerate treaty resolution. There are some treaty negotiations, Ms. Ridgen,
02:12:49 that have been going on, as you probably know, for decades. We need to solve it and we need to
02:12:53 work with Indigenous leaders. There's incredible Indigenous leaders in non-profits, in the private
02:12:59 sector in industry in academia we need to use that governance capacity to finalize treaties
02:13:05 and build partnerships absolutely because the best way forward is success for indigenous peoples
02:13:11 alongside their neighbors along this one point i think absolutely the solution has to be indigenous
02:13:20 led and i think that's the starting point and for a long time we've seen that there's been a
02:13:25 top-down approach that has to change it has to be indigenous people at the table but i want to talk
02:13:29 just so we understand how severe this is,
02:13:31 how the Indian Act is creating injustice
02:13:34 and perpetuating injustice.
02:13:36 I spoke to Bea, who's a young woman, a young girl,
02:13:39 who lives in Niskanthika, and she told me in her own voice,
02:13:42 she said, I'm a 12-year-old girl,
02:13:45 and I'm fighting for clean drinking water.
02:13:47 How does that make any sense?
02:13:49 Those words haunt me to this day.
02:13:50 I think about what 12-year-olds do,
02:13:52 and they certainly aren't fighting for clean drinking water.
02:13:55 That is a legacy.
02:13:56 That is the impact of the Indian Act.
02:13:59 I want to go back to what Mr. O'Toole has been saying, because he's very able at saying all the right things, but there are countless examples of him actually not living up to his words.
02:14:08 We've seen him on a number of times during this campaign, but on indigenous issues specifically, he says we need to listen to indigenous peoples.
02:14:15 Well, he proposed that he would raise the flags that are at half mass for the kids in unmarked graves in residential schools.
02:14:23 And he didn't talk to or listen to any indigenous leaders when he made that decision.
02:14:28 And that's something that is important and symbolic, but wouldn't cost a cent.
02:14:32 How do we believe that he would be able to actually make the investment early necessary?
02:14:38 I'm going to give Ms. Paul and Mr. Blanchett a chance to jump in.
02:14:42 We haven't heard from them yet.
02:14:43 Time permitting, I'll come back to you, Mr. O'Toole.
02:14:45 And I really again want to...
02:14:47 I asked Mr. Trudeau to move immediately.
02:14:49 Hold on, hold on, Ms. Paul. 0.99
02:14:51 I really just want to try to re-center our conversation on indigenous peoples
02:14:55 and what we are going to do to fulfill
02:14:58 the many unfulfilled promises and commitments
02:15:00 that have been made.
02:15:02 And I would say, perhaps, to pick up on what has been said,
02:15:05 you know, that it seems all too often
02:15:08 that reconciliation is treated like a buffet.
02:15:11 You can opt in for this, pick this, you know,
02:15:13 pick this plate, but not the other one.
02:15:16 And that applies to what we've seen with Mr. Trudeau
02:15:19 and the liberals.
02:15:21 You can't, on the one hand, say reconciliation
02:15:23 and then go and not allow Mi'kmaq fishers to be able to have a decent, moderate living for all of these years. 0.98
02:15:30 You can't call reconciliation and then take Indigenous peoples to court.
02:15:34 But, Mr. Singh, you also can't say reconciliation and then support the NDP government
02:15:39 in putting pipelines through Indigenous territories,
02:15:42 or support Line 5 after the Anishinaabeg made it very clear that they did not support that project.
02:15:48 Ms. Paul, I'm going to allow Mr. Blanchett to get in.
02:15:51 He's been signaling he wants to.
02:15:52 I will come back to the two of you.
02:15:53 Mr. Blanchet.
02:15:55 First Nations and Quebec have something in common.
02:15:58 They are binded by a document they never signed.
02:16:02 And any relationship between nations
02:16:05 should be dealt with,
02:16:08 with freely signed treaties or agreements or something.
02:16:13 The Indian Act has to be replaced
02:16:17 one nation at a time, if need be,
02:16:20 by and with freely signed treaties and agreement.
02:16:25 There's no other way.
02:16:26 And if I may come back a few seconds on something else. 0.95
02:16:29 Quebec wants religion out of the state affairs
02:16:32 because religion never protected equality for women 0.75
02:16:36 and never will.
02:16:38 We are over time.
02:16:40 I'm going to give you both a chance to briefly respond.
02:16:42 Mr. O'Toole, then Mr. Singh, briefly, please.
02:16:45 I am proud of this country.
02:16:47 And I think if you love your country,
02:16:48 you can dig deep to make it better.
02:16:50 So as prime minister on the National Day of Reconciliation on September 30th,
02:16:55 I will raise the flag with a commitment to move forward on calls to action.
02:17:00 Mr. Trudeau promises things, doesn't deliver,
02:17:04 and then when people protested him, he mocked them.
02:17:07 That is not reconciliation.
02:17:09 So you can be proud of your country as you strive for it to get better.
02:17:11 Thank you, Mr. O'Toole, Mr. Singh, briefly.
02:17:14 I think that Mr. Trudeau may care.
02:17:16 I think he cares.
02:17:17 but the reality is that he's often done a lot of things for show and hasn't backed those up with
02:17:22 real action. And the harm is, is that indigenous people continue to suffer. And that's what I want
02:17:27 to stop. I want to stop the suffering and lift up indigenous people. Five seconds, Mr. Trudeau,
02:17:32 then we got to go. Mr. Trudeau, five seconds. Unfortunately, the cynicism that Mr. Singh is
02:17:37 showing on saying we did nothing is harming reconciliation and the path we're moving forward.
02:17:42 We have lots more to do and we are doing it. All right, leaders. Thank you. Thank you,
02:17:47 Melissa. Marcy, Marcy. Marcy. And now it is time for our fourth theme for the night, affordability.
02:17:58 It's time now to bring in Janet Falla. She is a senior working part-time in Burlington,
02:18:04 Ontario. Good evening, Janet. Please tell us what your question is to the leaders.
02:18:08 my question is this at my age i never imagined that i would have to keep on working but i have
02:18:18 to to afford to live where i do so i'd like to know when they become prime minister
02:18:25 what will they do to help us seniors survive thank you janet leaders you've heard janet's
02:18:33 We're starting with you, Mr. Blanchet.
02:18:35 Merci, madame.
02:18:37 For many months now,
02:18:39 the Bloc Québécois has demanded for the government
02:18:43 to increase the amount of money being provided
02:18:47 on a monthly basis to our elders.
02:18:50 It's nowhere in the Conservatives' program,
02:18:54 and in the Liberals' program,
02:18:56 it starts at 75, nothing below 75 for this pension.
02:19:01 I'm not sure about the word in English.
02:19:03 It has to be done.
02:19:04 Those people are those who suffered the most from the pandemic.
02:19:08 Their power to buy things was reduced.
02:19:11 The fact that they were alone more than never before was made worse.
02:19:18 And the stress, the anxiety they lived with is terrible.
02:19:22 We want something to be done,
02:19:24 and it has to start with a monthly check seriously increased.
02:19:28 Thank you, Mr. Blanchett, Mr. O'Toole.
02:19:30 tool? Thank you, Ms. Valla, for the question. This is a crisis facing our country, affordability,
02:19:37 and it's hitting our seniors the hardest. That's why in Canada's recovery plan, our plan
02:19:43 to give you a break, we're going to double the Canada workers' benefit. There are many seniors 1.00
02:19:48 like you having to work to keep up with the cost of living. We're going to double that for you to
02:19:53 give you a break. We're going to get bills down for internet, for cellular phone. We're going to
02:19:58 get grocery bills down. That is our plan and our commitment. And in December, we're going to give
02:20:02 you a break with the GST holiday and help bricks and mortar stores in the process. Mr. Trudeau
02:20:08 is borrowing every day $424 million, and he's causing an inflation crisis. We have to secure
02:20:16 our future, and that's our commitment to you. Thank you, Mr. O'Toole. Mr. Trudeau.
02:20:21 Ms. Fellers, thank you so much for your question. We know that seniors have been
02:20:27 deeply affected by this pandemic, the isolation, the extra costs, which is why we stepped up
02:20:32 with a one-time support so you could help get through this pandemic. But we need
02:20:36 longer-term supports. One of the first things we did was increase the guaranteed income supplement
02:20:40 for our most vulnerable single seniors when we first got elected. We're doing that again
02:20:45 in our proposal in this election. We're also moving forward with increasing the OAS for all
02:20:52 seniors over 75 because we recognize that the costs continue to increase as you get older and
02:20:59 continue to want to live at home. We're giving you more supports so you can stay at home safely
02:21:04 and make those renovations, importantly. We will continue to have your backs as we have through
02:21:09 this pandemic and into the future. Thank you, Mr. Trudeau. Mr. Singh. I want to thank you so much
02:21:14 for your question. And one of the things that you mentioned is that you didn't think you would have
02:21:18 to keep on working. And I don't think our seniors should have to work. If seniors want to contribute
02:21:23 by working, that's absolutely their right. But you shouldn't have had to work. And in a country
02:21:28 as rich as ours, we should make sure our seniors are able to retire with dignity,
02:21:33 that you've got the supports necessary to live a life of dignity. So what we're proposing to do
02:21:38 is put in place a guaranteed income for seniors so they can live with dignity and not have to
02:21:42 worry about paying the bills. That's a starting point. What we've seen so far is that Mr. Trudeau
02:21:48 and Mr. O'Toole both are going to either cut the help that you receive or put the burden back on
02:21:54 people like you. We believe that the ultra-rich should pay their fair share for once and invest
02:21:59 in you, invest in families, invest in people. Thank you, Mr. Singh. Ms. Paul.
02:22:04 Thank you very, very much for the question. And as someone who comes from a family where my
02:22:09 had to work until, actually, they were kicked out of working
02:22:14 because they needed to keep working to afford the basics.
02:22:17 I completely understand what you're saying.
02:22:19 And this is an opportunity for us to learn the lessons
02:22:23 from this pandemic and to really get to the heart of things
02:22:26 and to stop talking about the symptoms
02:22:28 but get to the root causes.
02:22:29 We need to have, absolutely, and it's so wonderful
02:22:32 to see the consensus building around
02:22:34 a guaranteed livable income
02:22:35 so that whatever your circumstances,
02:22:37 you can live with dignity.
02:22:38 We need universal long-term care.
02:22:40 That's a huge expense. It was for my family.
02:22:43 And we need more affordable housing. 0.87
02:22:45 Let's get to the root causes.
02:22:48 Thank you, Ms. Paul.
02:22:49 Mr. Singh and Mr. Blanchet, you will both square off now.
02:22:53 You both talk about affordable housing,
02:22:56 but we know that affordability means different things
02:23:00 to different people depending on where in the country they live.
02:23:03 So when you talk about affordable housing,
02:23:06 housing, who are you really talking about? Per the draw, Mr. Singh, you begin. Mr. Blanchett,
02:23:11 you may jump in anytime. We're talking about people who are spending right now more than
02:23:17 half their income on housing. That's not affordable. People should not be spending so
02:23:22 much on housing that they have no money left to pay for their groceries, to pay for their bills.
02:23:27 And the sad reality is since 2015 to now, the average cost of housing nationally has gone up
02:23:35 to buy a home by $300,000.
02:23:38 So, so far, the housing crisis has gotten worse
02:23:40 over the past six years.
02:23:42 We want to invest in housing.
02:23:43 We want to invest to make it easier to buy your first home
02:23:45 and to invest to make sure there's available,
02:23:48 affordable rental homes.
02:23:49 Let Mr. Blanchet respond.
02:23:51 Could anyone tell me how to translate logement social?
02:23:53 Social housing.
02:23:54 Social housing might be a solution to another problem.
02:23:58 People are paying, at least in Quebec,
02:24:00 people are paying far too much for houses
02:24:02 because the prices have increased tremendously the idea is to reduce the speed of that increase
02:24:11 while helping people who cannot even afford decent lodging if we build more social lodging
02:24:19 which price are obviously very lower much lower then it will lessen the pressure on those houses
02:24:26 become more and more expensive.
02:24:31 And it will help reduce this...
02:24:32 I wouldn't speak about an inflation crisis,
02:24:35 but I would speak about an inflation worry,
02:24:38 which we must have at present times.
02:24:41 So I believe one thing might be part of the solution
02:24:44 for the other thing when we speak about...
02:24:47 All right, Mr. Blanchet, that's time.
02:24:49 I'm sorry, Mr. Singh, that's time.
02:24:51 You speak about inflation, Mr. Blanchet,
02:24:54 and that brings us to our next topic.
02:24:56 So, Mr. O'Toole, Mr. Trudeau, and Ms. Paul, you're up.
02:25:00 Inflation is at its highest level in a decade,
02:25:03 and it is squeezing Canadians on staples such as groceries, gas, rent.
02:25:09 What's your message to Canadians who are struggling to make ends meet?
02:25:13 Per the draw, you begin, Mr. O'Toole.
02:25:16 Well, unlike Mr. Trudeau, I will care about monetary policy
02:25:20 because we need to keep inflation low.
02:25:22 There is a crisis hitting families,
02:25:24 And Mr. Trudeau seems completely oblivious to that.
02:25:28 Bills are going up.
02:25:29 There's a housing crisis, as we talked about.
02:25:32 And he's making it worse with, as I said, almost half a billion dollars of borrowing per day.
02:25:38 There's real risks on the horizon.
02:25:40 So we have a plan to get people work, get people, get their bills down, give them a break.
02:25:46 Canadians deserve a break and balance the budget over the course of the next decade.
02:25:50 That's exactly what we need to fight against Mr. Trudeau's inflation.
02:25:53 Give families a break.
02:25:55 Ms. Paul, try not to interrupt anyone.
02:25:57 You know, it's just an excellent question.
02:26:00 And if you come to my neighborhood of Toronto Centre,
02:26:02 you will see those people living in inadequate housing.
02:26:05 You will see people paying more than half of their income
02:26:09 just for things like childcare.
02:26:11 And, you know, there's this expression in my culture
02:26:14 where you talk about soon come.
02:26:16 It's the things that you delay to tomorrow and tomorrow
02:26:20 that should have been done today.
02:26:21 This is soon come, soon come is now.
02:26:24 We have got to learn the lessons of the pandemic
02:26:26 and make sure that we have a social safety net in place
02:26:29 that lets everyone live with dignity.
02:26:31 When we invest in our people, we are investing in our future,
02:26:35 and this is the time for us to do that.
02:26:37 It costs us not to do it.
02:26:40 Over the past year and a half,
02:26:41 I made a straightforward promise to Canadians
02:26:43 that we would have your backs, and that's what we did.
02:26:46 During this pandemic, we were there to support people,
02:26:48 but at the same time, we need to continue that.
02:26:51 That's why we've put forward a $10 a day child care proposal that will save the average family in Toronto close to $10,000 more than Mr. O'Toole's approach on child care, which he would cancel.
02:27:04 We also put forward a national housing plan that will invest $4 billion to work with municipalities to create 1.4 million homes.
02:27:13 The housing crisis has gotten worse under you, Mr. O'Toole's plan on housing.
02:27:15 Let him respond, Mr. O'Toole.
02:27:16 Mr. O'Toole, let Mr. O'Toole respond.
02:27:18 Sorry, let me just finish this.
02:27:19 Mr. O'Toole's plan on housing gives half a billion dollars on breaks to the wealthiest landlords and nothing for building new houses.
02:27:29 The housing crisis has gotten worse under Mr. Trudeau.
02:27:32 And months ago, he fought against us trying to take foreign non-resident money out of our housing market.
02:27:38 We've got a plan to get rental housing built.
02:27:40 We've got a plan to get density, a million new homes in the next three years.
02:27:44 And to give first-time homebuyers a break by a longer mortgage.
02:27:49 And Mr. Trudeau, Canadians are worried you're going to be taxing their primary home sale.
02:27:54 Your advisors have said it.
02:27:56 Your candidates have said it.
02:27:57 It's on page 14 of his policy book.
02:28:00 He's introducing a new tax on the sale of homes.
02:28:02 Leaders, there will be more opportunity to speak about these issues.
02:28:07 Thank you.
02:28:07 Because guess what?
02:28:08 I'm bringing out Rosemary Barton of CBC News. 0.91
02:28:11 And she's going to be asking you more direct questions and opening up more opportunities for debate.
02:28:16 on this theme of affordability.
02:28:19 Hey, Rosie.
02:28:20 Hey, Shanti, thanks, and good to see everybody.
02:28:21 I appreciate you being here.
02:28:22 Let's try and get some answers this time, shall we?
02:28:25 Ms. Paul, I'll start with you.
02:28:26 One of the plans that you've laid out
02:28:28 to tackle affordability is a guaranteed livable income.
02:28:31 You mentioned it just moments ago,
02:28:33 give people a set amount of money to deal with their lives.
02:28:35 There was an expert panel in British Columbia
02:28:37 just recently that said that that is not the way forward,
02:28:41 but that actually is too complicated
02:28:43 for the needs of our society,
02:28:44 that the needs are too diverse.
02:28:46 Why do you think this is still a policy worth pursuing?
02:28:50 Guaranteed livable income is a policy whose time has come.
02:28:54 We saw at the beginning of the pandemic
02:28:55 how many people were thrown immediately
02:28:57 into financial crisis
02:28:59 because our patchwork system simply isn't working.
02:29:02 There is a growing consensus.
02:29:04 The members of the Liberal Party
02:29:05 voted for it at their convention.
02:29:07 The members of the NDP Party voted at their convention.
02:29:11 50 senators signed a letter calling for it.
02:29:14 The time has come to ensure that everyone has the support that they need to live in dignity in this country.
02:29:20 The parliamentary budget officer looked at guaranteed livable income.
02:29:24 He examined the model in Ontario, and here's what he said.
02:29:28 He said that it would lift half of the people who are in poverty now out of it,
02:29:32 that it was affordable, and that it would not disincentify his work.
02:29:37 This is the time for a guaranteed livable income.
02:29:39 Let's do it together.
02:29:40 That's time. Thank you.
02:29:41 Mr. O'Toole, child care, as you know, is a huge expense for families.
02:29:44 You would scrap the deals that the Liberals have made with provinces,
02:29:47 which drops fees by 50% immediately and creates spaces
02:29:52 and eventually will reduce fees to $10.
02:29:55 Instead, you're proposing a tax credit that would reimburse just some families $6,000 a year.
02:30:01 So what does your plan do to create spaces and lower fees?
02:30:05 Because as you know here, it's not just about affordability, but also about access.
02:30:10 It's about helping all families now, not in five years helping some.
02:30:15 And our plan would help lower-income families with up to 75% of the cost.
02:30:20 Our plan will also help that nurse on shift schedules that has jobs in the evening, that needs flexibility.
02:30:27 What we want to do is help all families get ahead and provide more support for the lower income.
02:30:31 But if the nurse can't find a spot, Mr. O'Toole, what does she do?
02:30:33 If the nurse can't find a spot, what does she do with her children?
02:30:36 This gives her as much flexibility as possible.
02:30:38 If there's not one in her suburban community, there is no space in five years under Mr. Trudeau's
02:30:44 program. We want to give families the tools to make the best decision for the position they're
02:30:49 in now, to have ability to help them in their circumstances. Our plan will be immediate. It
02:30:55 will help all Canadian families. Mr. Singh, you're promising to tackle skyrocketing housing prices.
02:31:00 One of the ways is with that 20% tax on the sale of homes to foreign buyers, two-thirds of Canadian
02:31:06 families actually own a home already if you're successful at cooling the housing market that
02:31:11 would mean that people who have invested their life savings in their homes may not have it anymore
02:31:17 they're relying on that for their retirement so what is more important to you helping younger
02:31:21 people get access to the market or allowing older canadians who rely on the value of their homes
02:31:28 to live it's a really fair question and when i spoke to people i go door to door in my riding
02:31:35 at Burnaby, who people have got beautiful homes. I ask them, what's the number one concern? They
02:31:39 say housing. And I kind of look around at their house and say, well, you've got a home. They say,
02:31:42 well, I'm not worried for myself. I've got a place, but I'm worried about my kids.
02:31:46 And they're more concerned that their kids will never be able to find a home
02:31:50 than their own circumstances because they're okay. They are worried about their kids.
02:31:54 And the reality is it is impossible for young people to even imagine buying a home,
02:31:59 let alone renting a place that's in their budget. So we've got to get the big money out of housing,
02:32:04 Young people, young families, professionals shouldn't have to compete.
02:32:07 So your answer is that it is more important for young people to get into the housing market
02:32:10 rather than protect people who have equity in their home now?
02:32:12 We can do both.
02:32:13 And our plan is that everyone's telling us the number one concern they have for their kids
02:32:17 is that they're not sure they're ever going to be able to own a home.
02:32:20 We want to change that.
02:32:21 It's gotten worse with Mr. Trudeau.
02:32:23 We're going to fix it.
02:32:24 Thank you.
02:32:24 Mr. Blanchet, nice to see you, sir.
02:32:26 Seniors, as you were talking about off the top,
02:32:28 they're really worried about the increased cost of living.
02:32:30 you, as you said, have criticized the liberals
02:32:33 for increasing old-age security only for those 75 and older.
02:32:37 But statistics show time and again
02:32:39 that older seniors are less likely to have employment income
02:32:44 and they actually have higher health expenses. 0.94
02:32:47 So why should an increase in seniors go to all seniors
02:32:50 instead of those who need it most?
02:32:52 First, let's say that this prime minister
02:32:55 is supposed to be the champion
02:32:57 who fights against all kinds of discrimination,
02:33:01 and it did create himself two classes of elders, seniors.
02:33:07 What do you want is for those between 65 and 75
02:33:11 to spend their private funds in the meantime.
02:33:15 No, but I've just given you the example about why the government may have done that, sir.
02:33:21 It's because people who are 65 to 75, may I follow up, please,
02:33:25 that those people generally stay employed
02:33:28 and generally have fewer health costs.
02:33:31 Those people have worked all their lives
02:33:35 until 65 years old.
02:33:38 They have paid for a pension
02:33:40 that should be the same for everybody.
02:33:44 And for some financial issues,
02:33:47 the government creates two classes of seniors.
02:33:50 It is unacceptable and no calculation whatsoever
02:33:54 should be so unethical.
02:33:57 All right.
02:33:57 Thank you, Mr. Blanchet.
02:33:58 We are now moving to the open debate section.
02:34:01 I just have a question for Mr. Trudeau, I believe.
02:34:03 I'm very sorry.
02:34:04 If you don't mind.
02:34:04 I don't think we should let him off the hook.
02:34:06 I think we would all agree.
02:34:07 I got a little mixed up there.
02:34:08 I like the way you're making some of our arguments
02:34:09 from the other ones.
02:34:10 Well, we'll make you uncomfortable now, sir.
02:34:12 Here we go.
02:34:12 You said in 2019 that Canadians should never have to make the,
02:34:16 and these are your words,
02:34:17 impossible choice between paying for medications
02:34:20 or putting food on the table.
02:34:22 We have seen you, particularly in these recent months,
02:34:24 willing to spend billions of dollars on programs that matter to your government, daycare would
02:34:29 be another example of that. Why is there no money in your platform or in your most recent budget
02:34:34 for a national pharmacare program? Is it no longer a priority and should you not just tell Canadians
02:34:40 that sir? No, it continues to be a priority because indeed no one should have to choose
02:34:45 between paying for groceries and medications. On health investments, we were all focused on
02:34:51 COVID-19 and supporting the provinces and making sure that on that we were giving the support we
02:34:56 needed so we could have Canadians' backs. But at the same time, we worked with a number of
02:35:02 different jurisdictions, and we've actually signed with Prince Edward Island a national
02:35:08 universal pharmacare first step. You've signed one deal, sir, but there's nothing in your platform
02:35:13 in terms of costing. I understand the pandemic kept you busy. What about going forward? Why
02:35:18 Why wouldn't you put that in place?
02:35:19 Going forward, we are going to continue to, but we know that it's not something we did
02:35:24 with Prince Edward Island.
02:35:25 We're going to continue to do with others in respect of the provincial jurisdiction
02:35:30 that is delivery of healthcare.
02:35:32 We can't impose pharma care on a province that doesn't want it, unlike the NDP proposes.
02:35:37 We are going to work in partnership, as we have on so many things, to get it done like
02:35:41 we did on childcare.
02:35:42 Okay, and now we're going to move to open debate.
02:35:47 Okay, and we start here, I believe, with Mr. Blanchet.
02:35:51 That's correct.
02:35:52 So, Mr. Blanchet, what is one policy change
02:35:54 that you think would make the biggest difference
02:35:57 to Canadians or Quebecers, in your case,
02:36:00 in terms of their cost of living,
02:36:02 the one change that you would like to see
02:36:04 that would help them the most?
02:36:05 Cost of living, that's quite interesting
02:36:07 because that's a worry that we have.
02:36:09 We believe that the most important thing
02:36:13 is changing the way we create wealth.
02:36:16 We believe that transforming our own resources, natural resources, with our own clean energy in our regions of Quebec will create more wealth.
02:36:28 This wealth will come from an environmental, I will get this word, environmental preoccupation as well.
02:36:37 and we will do that and we should be entitled to do that with our part of the money that is being
02:36:43 sent again and again in oil and gas. There's one thing I want to add, even if it's not exactly,
02:36:51 I don't know if there's time eventually. Not really, but quickly, quickly, quickly. I will
02:36:55 take a few of those seconds. Yes. Will we have some seconds to speak about French-speaking
02:36:59 communities and Acadians? Well, not in this section. This is about cost of living, sir.
02:37:03 And to you, Mr. Singh.
02:37:04 It's nowhere.
02:37:05 That's my problem.
02:37:06 It's nowhere.
02:37:06 One of the things we know,
02:37:08 the cost of living has gone up.
02:37:09 The cost of medication is going up.
02:37:11 The cost of being able to afford the medication
02:37:12 that keeps you healthy.
02:37:14 Mr. Trudeau,
02:37:15 zero dollars in your fully-costed budget
02:37:17 means zero commitment to getting a diet.
02:37:19 You don't have a fully-costed platform.
02:37:20 Zero dollars,
02:37:21 but you've shown your evidence.
02:37:23 With your costed budget,
02:37:24 you've shown Canadians,
02:37:26 clearly,
02:37:26 you've got no interest in doing something.
02:37:28 You have no costs in your platform, Mr. Singh.
02:37:31 You promised to do it two years ago.
02:37:33 You committed, you campaigned on it, you included it in your throne speech,
02:37:37 and now you've completely abandoned it.
02:37:40 How can people trust any promise you make when there's zero dollars in your plan?
02:37:45 Okay, brief response, then Ms. Paul, then I'm coming to you, Mr. O'Toole.
02:37:49 $25 billion in our fully-costed platform for health for the priorities that Canadians have told us on.
02:37:57 Better support for seniors in care, better support for mental health services across the country,
02:38:02 particularly for young people, and access to a primary care doctor or team.
02:38:07 That is what $25 billion over the next four years gives.
02:38:11 Mr. O'Toole's money for health is backloaded to six, seven, eight, nine, ten years from now.
02:38:17 All right, Mr. Trudeau, thank you.
02:38:19 I'm reminded what the question was.
02:38:21 The question was what policy would have the biggest impact on people's cost of living?
02:38:25 Ms. Paul.
02:38:26 And I think that we have a perfect example of this again here,
02:38:29 because the biggest thing that could make a difference
02:38:32 in the cost of living for people
02:38:34 is a change in the culture in Ottawa.
02:38:37 It is so painful for me,
02:38:39 because I've had the experience of, again,
02:38:41 having my grandparents work until they were 75
02:38:44 and living six and 800 square feet
02:38:46 and wondering how we were going to feed ourselves some nights.
02:38:49 I've had that experience,
02:38:50 and I know that one day of delay is too much.
02:38:53 So when I think that we could have been in Parliament now,
02:38:56 working to get people the help that they need...
02:38:58 What is the policy, Ms. Paul?
02:38:59 These are anecdotes.
02:39:00 What is the policy with the question?
02:39:01 It's not an anecdote.
02:39:02 The thing that we need is a change in the culture.
02:39:05 I hear you.
02:39:06 I see you, Ms. O'Toole.
02:39:07 It's a change in the culture because there are several parties on this platform right
02:39:09 now that agree on guaranteed livable income and universal pharmacare and childcare.
02:39:14 My policy.
02:39:15 But it's always soon come.
02:39:16 It's always soon come.
02:39:17 All right.
02:39:18 Thank you, Ms. Paul.
02:39:19 Mr. O'Toole, you've been waiting.
02:39:20 I'm going to get you in.
02:39:21 We're doubling the Canadian workers' benefit.
02:39:22 That amounts to a dollar per hour raise for working families.
02:39:26 These are people working very hard.
02:39:28 And I respect whether they get up to work a shift in a restaurant or work to open their
02:39:33 small business.
02:39:34 We're going to have your back.
02:39:35 We're also going to get costs down. 0.97
02:39:37 We're the only party with a recovery plan that includes all Canadians.
02:39:42 And when it comes to cynicism that Mr. Trudeau talked about earlier, all of the commitments
02:39:47 continue to be a priority.
02:39:49 He's going to get to the calls to action.
02:39:51 He's going to have transparency.
02:39:53 He's going to make targets.
02:39:55 He announces things and never delivers.
02:39:58 Mr. Trudeau, a prime minister has to deliver on the words,
02:40:01 not just fancy words to make promises, a plan to get there.
02:40:06 By the way, Mr. O'Toole, I won't take lessons from you
02:40:09 on making promises and not following up.
02:40:11 You should take a few lessons, sir.
02:40:13 When we see you're beholden to the gun lobby,
02:40:14 we're beholden to anti-vaxxers, you're beholden to a range of people.
02:40:17 Remember, this is affordability, and Mr. Trudeau,
02:40:19 I'm sorry we're out of time now, sir.
02:40:21 I've been responding to people.
02:40:22 Can I answer Rosie's question directly?
02:40:24 You have five seconds, sir.
02:40:25 We were able to lift a million people out of poverty and create a million jobs at the same time with the right kinds of investments over the past five years.
02:40:33 And Mr. Trudeau, I have to I'm sorry, sir.
02:40:36 I have to wrap you right there because it is now time for our next theme on COVID recovery.
02:40:41 Rosie, thank you so much. Thank you very much.
02:40:43 Thanks.
02:40:44 okay from saskatchewan ethan herman is standing by in saskatoon he's an undecided voter and he
02:40:57 wants to hear from you about covid recovery hey ethan go ahead
02:41:02 hey good evening leaders my question is this
02:41:08 Coming out of this pandemic, how are you, if elected as Prime Minister, going to unify and drive Canada forward with respect to health care, jobs and the economy, and ensuring a higher quality of life is achievable for all Canadians, regardless of race, colour, creed, or sexual orientation?
02:41:28 All right, leaders, you've heard from Ethan. Mr. O'Toole, you're up first.
02:41:31 Thank you, Mr. Herman. That is exactly why I launched Canada's recovery plan on the first day of the campaign.
02:41:37 We're going to create a million jobs in one year.
02:41:39 We're going to clean up the accountability mess in Ottawa.
02:41:42 We're going to have national leadership on mental health.
02:41:45 We're going to be more ready for a pandemic, and we're going to get our finances under control.
02:41:49 I want to get people working.
02:41:50 I want to give families a break.
02:41:52 And since the moment I became Conservative leader, I've been reaching out.
02:41:57 Whatever your background, your faith, your colour, your sexual orientation, whether you're Indigenous, whether you're a new Canadian,
02:42:03 you're important to Canada's recovery and you're important to the Conservative Party and I'd ask
02:42:08 you to look at Canada's recovery plan after these 18 months as a country. We need a plan and a leader
02:42:15 that will actually deliver. Thank you, Ms. Paul. Thank you, Mr. Herman and I swear I did not line
02:42:22 up that question. He's not a ringer but this really comes to the heart of the matter which
02:42:27 is about changing the cultur of politics in Ottawa.
02:42:31 We have heard from outgoing MPs in the last parliament
02:42:34 how incredibly important that is,
02:42:36 that the cultur has become toxic,
02:42:38 that it has become hyper-partisan.
02:42:41 And, you know, there used to be a time...
02:42:43 I worked as an intern in a nonpartisan way
02:42:46 in the Ontario Legislature.
02:42:47 You know, you would make a fuss in question period,
02:42:50 and then you'd get to work across party lines and committees
02:42:53 to find the solutions to help people in Canada.
02:42:55 Canada. And so we need less partisanship. We need more diverse voices so that we can get the
02:43:01 access to the best ideas in a more cooperative and collaborative way. Mr. Singh. Thank you. Mr.
02:43:07 Herman, thank you for your question. And your question touched on a number of things. Healthcare
02:43:13 is something very near and dear to my heart. And we've seen in this pandemic that our healthcare
02:43:17 system simply hasn't been there. And it's not because of the pandemic. A lot of these problems
02:43:22 were there from before. So our commitment is to invest in our healthcare system, to defend it.
02:43:27 Unlike Mr. Trudeau and Mr. O'Toole, who believe in private long-term care delivery, we want to get
02:43:31 out profit, get out the greed from the delivery of long-term care. We want to invest in pharma
02:43:37 care for all, not promise it in 2019, and then have zero dollars to commit towards it. We want
02:43:42 to see everyone have access to medication. We want to include dental care into our healthcare system
02:43:47 and mental health services. And to do all that, we want to make sure that the billionaires are
02:43:52 paying their fair share so we can invest in you thank you mr singh mr trudeau ethan i think the
02:43:57 folks on this stage missed the very first part of your question which is you know once we get out
02:44:01 of this pandemic and yes we have plans for being even more ambitious on climate change and making
02:44:05 sure people get good jobs but we have to get out of this pandemic first and that's why the
02:44:11 unequivocal leadership that we've shown as a government on making sure that everyone gets
02:44:18 vaccinated is what's going to get us through. We cannot rebuild the economy until we get through
02:44:24 this pandemic. And unfortunately, Mr. O'Toole, who says he wants to get all of Canada vaccinated to
02:44:31 90% in the coming two months, can't even convince his own candidates to get vaccinated to 90%.
02:44:39 We have to get through this. We are unequivocal that vaccinations are the way to do it.
02:44:43 Thank you, Mr. Trudeau, Mr. Blanchette.
02:44:45 I think Mr. Trudeau forgot the second part of your question, which is about health care.
02:44:51 Let's be efficient.
02:44:53 Health care is a jurisdiction of the provinces and Quebec.
02:44:58 Those are the territories, the jurisdictions who should have the resources to do their job.
02:45:04 The promises of the conservatives is 3.5% of increase a year for the first three years,
02:45:11 which is very far from what the province has asked for.
02:45:15 And what the province has asked for is not even in the program of Mr. Trudeau.
02:45:20 So it will be hard to be efficient if those who are responsible of health care
02:45:25 do not have the resources which are owed to them.
02:45:29 Thank you, Mr. Blanchett.
02:45:30 Thanks, Ethan, for your question.
02:45:32 Have a good night.
02:45:33 We're going to let you go.
02:45:35 It is now time, Ms. Paul and Mr. Singh, to go face-to-face,
02:45:39 starting with Ms. Paul.
02:45:41 And I want to talk about Canada's parallel pandemic,
02:45:45 the opioid crisis.
02:45:47 Since it has taken hold,
02:45:49 more than 20,000 Canadians have died,
02:45:52 often in the shadows.
02:45:54 This is an insidious killer
02:45:56 that is tearing families apart.
02:45:59 To both of you, starting with Ms. Paul,
02:46:02 does the political will exist to confront it?
02:46:06 We called many times
02:46:08 during the last session of parliament,
02:46:10 across party lines, again, for us to first recognize
02:46:13 that this was a national health emergency,
02:46:17 and then to decriminalize simple possession,
02:46:20 because we know we need to end the stigma,
02:46:22 and create a national safe supply program.
02:46:25 We asked every party to do it,
02:46:27 because 17 lives, on average, are being lost every day.
02:46:30 We didn't hear anything from anyone.
02:46:32 And it comes back to Mr. Herman's question about unity.
02:46:35 Can we not unify on something like this where it's clear what we need to do?
02:46:40 If we can't do that, then none of these other things are possible.
02:46:44 And so that's what we have to try to do.
02:46:45 We definitely need to respond to this crisis with everything we have.
02:46:49 We've long called for it to be declared a national public health emergency.
02:46:53 And what we know is the approach that has been taken for decades simply doesn't work.
02:47:00 The approach of arresting someone, putting them through the criminal justice system,
02:47:04 putting them in jail does not make
02:47:06 communities safer, and it doesn't help people.
02:47:09 So we have been saying, and I believe
02:47:10 very firmly, we need to provide
02:47:12 health care responses to people that are
02:47:14 dealing with addiction. We need to make sure we are
02:47:16 doing everything we can to secure a safe supply.
02:47:19 We need to look at the evidence
02:47:20 and say really clearly,
02:47:22 if there is any step we can take that will
02:47:24 save lives, we've got to take it.
02:47:26 So there's a lot to do, but does the political
02:47:28 way exist to do it? That is exactly
02:47:30 the question. Is there the political
02:47:32 There doesn't seem to be, because we need a national safe supply program.
02:47:36 We wanted it before Parliament dissolved, and here we are.
02:47:39 And lives will be lost in my riding of Toronto Centre
02:47:42 probably today because of it.
02:47:43 Alright, Ms. Paul, I have to wrap you there.
02:47:45 It's good to hear, Mr. Singh, that it is at least coming from you.
02:47:48 Mr. Trudeau, Mr. Blanchette, Mr. O'Toole, this round to you.
02:47:53 Starting with Mr. Trudeau, during the pandemic,
02:47:57 Canadians watched in horror the suffering
02:48:01 suffering of their most vulnerable and frail loved ones in long-term care. What if tomorrow
02:48:08 you had to place a family member in a long-term care facility? Would you do it? Beginning with
02:48:15 you, Mr. Trudeau, Mr. O'Toole, Mr. Blanchett, you may jump in. Tomorrow is my mom's 73rd birthday,
02:48:21 so that is certainly something we're reflecting on, but she's doing wonderfully right now. We
02:48:25 won't have to make that decision right now. Don't worry, mom. The reality is we've heard from seniors
02:48:30 across this country who have been tremendously worried
02:48:33 through this pandemic, and family members worried about that.
02:48:35 We know that the conditions of work for the people
02:48:38 who are in those long-term care homes
02:48:40 are often dictating the conditions of care for seniors,
02:48:44 which is why we propose to hire 50,000 new personal support workers
02:48:51 working with the provinces with the money for that,
02:48:53 also increasing the minimum salary to $25 an hour
02:48:57 for people who care for our elders and most vulnerable
02:49:00 So if you had to put mom in long-term care, you would do it?
02:49:03 I would make sure that, yes, that they are people who are properly well-cared and that there is enough of a proportionate.
02:49:10 And that's where we will work with the provinces to deliver exactly that because we put real money forward for that.
02:49:16 Thank you, Mr. Trudeau, Mr. O'Toole.
02:49:18 This is where we need partnerships for long-term care for the CHSLD in Quebec.
02:49:22 We're going to have a $3 billion fund that the provinces can draw on for infrastructure upgrades to long-term care.
02:49:28 That's in addition to our record, almost $60 billion commitment over 10 years to the public health care system.
02:49:35 Universal access with no conditions.
02:49:37 We need to partner with the provinces, not create fights.
02:49:41 And long-term care, learning from the gaps in the first part of this pandemic is something we need.
02:49:46 Would you put a loved one in long-term care tomorrow, Mr. O'Toole?
02:49:49 I have a grandmother in one, and we've been in touch with her.
02:49:52 But I have to touch on what Mr. Trudeau said about the recovery.
02:49:55 We have to get through the pandemic first.
02:49:57 Why did you not have that approach to the election, Mr. Trudeau?
02:50:00 We're in the fourth wave.
02:50:02 Everything in the recovery relates to getting out of the pandemic first.
02:50:05 Mr. Blanchet, I'm going to let Mr. Blanchet in.
02:50:09 You have had four minutes more than I did.
02:50:12 So now I think it's enough.
02:50:13 The debate is almost over.
02:50:15 Some dads and some moms don't have to worry.
02:50:19 They will have the money, of course.
02:50:22 Some do.
02:50:22 And in order to give them the care they need, the care they deserve, those responsible for those cares, provinces and Quebec should have without conditions because it is their responsibility, their knowledge, their expertise, the resources required.
02:50:45 When the army came in Quebec, they did, they wrote a report afterward.
02:50:49 What did they say?
02:50:50 They did not say Quebec is not good enough to take care of its seniors.
02:50:55 They said they lacked resources.
02:50:59 They lacked the money.
02:51:00 Thank you, Mr. Blanchet, leaders.
02:51:03 We are starting to get out.
02:51:05 We're running out of time.
02:51:06 I am sorry.
02:51:07 I am sorry, Mr. Trudeau.
02:51:08 You've had the most time tonight.
02:51:10 I'm sorry, Mr. Trudeau.
02:51:11 We are now moving on to our final journalist of the night.
02:51:15 I am welcoming Evan Solomon from CTV News.
02:51:18 He's going to be putting questions to you on COVID recovery, starting with Mr. Singh.
02:51:23 Hey, Evan.
02:51:23 Hi, Shachi, and hi, leaders.
02:51:25 Good to see all of you.
02:51:27 Mr. Singh, I'll start with you, sir.
02:51:29 Your pandemic recovery plan is uncoasted.
02:51:32 You have no plan to balance the books, but you promised to pay for your expensive promises.
02:51:37 New programs like Universal Dental Care with Taxing the Super Rich and Taxing Corporations.
02:51:42 What specifically would you do to create the 1 million jobs you're promising and make sure Canada stays competitive?
02:51:50 We have the only credible plan that's not going to cut help to Canadians, that's not going to put the burden back on the same people that have struggled.
02:51:59 We're the only ones on this debate table that I can say clearly, we would tax the billionaires.
02:52:04 We would make sure companies like Amazon start paying their fair share so we can invest in those new jobs, so we can invest in people.
02:52:12 left to Mr. Trudeau or Mr. O'Toole, they are going to put the burden back on you. They've
02:52:16 already started. Mr. Trudeau has already started by cutting the CRE, cutting help to people.
02:52:21 But what new programs, sir, specifically? Well, I believe in making sure we invest
02:52:24 in pharmacare, we invest in dental care, we invest in retrofitting homes and buildings.
02:52:29 In doing this, we're going to lower the cost of living, help people save money,
02:52:33 but also create jobs by investing in the future economy, the economy of the future.
02:52:37 All right. Mr. Trudeau, to you. Only four months ago, you released a budget that was billed as a pandemic recovery program, a plan that had $101 billion of new spending. Since then, COVID numbers are up, growth numbers are down. Now you've got a new plan that adds $78 billion of new spending, essentially rendering your last budget out of date.
02:52:57 How do Canadians trust that these new massive spending promises will not just keep growing in another few months?
02:53:04 And what do you say to the next generation who say, how are we going to pay for this?
02:53:08 First of all, I made a promise during this pandemic to have people's backs.
02:53:11 Every time I came out of my house early on in the pandemic to talk directly to Canadians, I told them, I'd be there for you.
02:53:18 And that's exactly what we've done.
02:53:19 And it wasn't just being there for people because we're nice, although, of course, we are.
02:53:24 It was being there because that is the best way to ensure a strong recovery.
02:53:29 Now, yes, our budget showed our ambition for this country, including with $10 a day childcare that Mr. O'Toole is planning on ripping up.
02:53:36 But it also shows a responsible fiscal track.
02:53:40 And even with our fully costed platform that is even more ambitious on the fight against climate change, on housing, on supports for people,
02:53:48 the debt of our country as proportion of the GDP continues to decrease.
02:53:54 Yes or no? Is it important to have a plan to balance the budget because you don't have one?
02:53:57 It is important to stay fiscally responsible. And that's what we're doing. Our debt continues
02:54:01 to decrease as a share of our GDP. Ms. Paul, to you now, you have not been clear if you support
02:54:08 the need for vaccine passports or mandatory vaccines for federal workers or even mandatory
02:54:13 vaccines for your own candidates. Given that the fourth wave is really a pandemic of the
02:54:17 unvaccinated and threatening to overwhelm many health care systems, how do you justify not
02:54:23 supporting the very measures that have proven to be most effective at increasing vaccination rates?
02:54:29 Evan, we just filmed a video today asking everyone to get vaccinated. We have been unequivocal
02:54:34 in our support for vaccinations. Mandatory vaccinations and vaccine passports.
02:54:41 Well, again, you know, this is just a, you know,
02:54:44 this is, again, where policy gets put aside
02:54:48 for partisan advantage
02:54:50 because there is everyone on this stage understands
02:54:53 that everyone who can be vaccinated should be vaccinated.
02:54:57 We need to encourage people to do it.
02:54:58 Vaccine saves lives.
02:55:00 And every single person on the stage has also said
02:55:02 that, of course, there are going to be people
02:55:04 who are not able to get vaccinated for certain reasons,
02:55:07 and we have to reasonably accommodate them.
02:55:09 We will always be guided by the science.
02:55:11 We will never put partisan concerns ahead of public health.
02:55:15 Mr. O'Toole, you promised a $60 billion increase in health care transfers over the next 10 years,
02:55:21 but according to the Independent Parliamentary Budget Officer,
02:55:24 it's actually only a transfer of $3.6 billion for the next five years,
02:55:29 which is not much different than the status quo.
02:55:31 But you also support private-public synergies, in your words.
02:55:34 Can you specify here tonight exactly what kinds of private health care innovations you want to see more of?
02:55:41 And if a province introduces more private health care, would you enforce the Canada Health Act by holding back any of your promised funding?
02:55:50 I 100 percent support our public and universal system.
02:55:54 I've said it's paramount.
02:55:55 And after COVID-19, we need to rebuild it.
02:55:58 So we have the most substantive plan to do that.
02:56:01 6% increase per year, stable, predictable, without conditions funding to partner with
02:56:07 our provinces. We will respect them running and putting priorities to get wait times down,
02:56:13 to give more choice for universal public access. That's what we need. On top of that, Evan,
02:56:20 we have a substantial commitment in mental health and treatment for addiction. There are going to
02:56:25 be lingering aspects from this pandemic that we're going to do in addition. The provinces are in
02:56:31 charge of their system. We will respect that. Public and universal elements need to be at the
02:56:36 core of our system, and our investments will save it and give relief to front lines like our nurses,
02:56:42 physicians. Mr. Trudeau doesn't hire those people. All right, we got to wrap you, Mr. O'Toole.
02:56:48 Mr. Blanchet, Quebec has relied on the federal government for life-saving vaccines and key
02:56:53 programs like the CERD, and as you mentioned, the Canadian Armed Forces came in to save
02:56:57 people in long-term care homes in the province of Quebec.
02:57:00 Some believe this crisis has enforced the argument for a strong federation and undermines
02:57:05 your fundamental argument of separatism.
02:57:08 Given that, if the federal government, say, gives billion dollars for long-term care homes,
02:57:12 which Quebec failed to protect, why should they not also enforce national standards?
02:57:19 I have still not heard from all those brilliant people all over the place and all over Canada
02:57:26 what a Canadian can do that a Quebecer cannot do.
02:57:30 In what way whatsoever would a Canadian norm be any better than a Quebec norm?
02:57:38 I don't see that, and I'm not, you know, I don't have this complex.
02:57:41 I don't feel that I'm any lesser person than a Canadian because I'm a Quebecer.
02:57:45 I'm asking about enforcing national standards.
02:57:46 If you pay for something, should you be able to enforce it?
02:57:48 National norms or standards.
02:57:52 And I would say that the premier Legault of Quebec today said
02:57:55 no one is to be entirely trusted in this group of people.
02:58:00 Some are worse than others.
02:58:01 I think they recognize themselves.
02:58:03 But even those who are a little bit less terrible
02:58:07 need a watchdog because they're not entitled to a majority government.
02:58:11 So if Quebecers want, I will lead the watchdogs.
02:58:14 Okay.
02:58:15 This is the open debate section.
02:58:17 And I'll start with you, Mr. O'Toole, but everyone, please jump in, not all at once.
02:58:22 The pandemic recovery is about the future path of Canada.
02:58:25 And all of the leaders here tonight have made promises that require historic levels of spending.
02:58:31 But as you all know, politics is about hard choices.
02:58:33 With some Canadians still in real need of support and other industries experiencing real labour shortages,
02:58:40 What specific programs will stay and what will go in the next year and who will pay for all of this?
02:58:47 Mr. O'Toole.
02:58:48 That's a great question, Evan, because we didn't see the government adapt to the changing crisis.
02:58:54 What we support and we all work together, the wage subsidy, the CERB, needed to be adapted as there were labor shortages in Quebec, as we can't find enough people for restaurants and service industries.
02:59:04 We need to target the highly impacted sectors.
02:59:08 That's what our plan, Canada's Recovery Plan, does.
02:59:10 We get those service, tourism, restaurants back on their feet, get people working,
02:59:16 and with keeping cases low, we can then wind down the other programs
02:59:20 because we need to focus on work.
02:59:22 We have a job boost that will actually incentivize the hiring of people
02:59:26 that are going out of work for 10 months or more.
02:59:30 Mr. O'Toole and Mr. Trudeau are jumping over each other
02:59:33 about who is going to cut help to people first.
02:59:36 I don't agree with that.
02:59:37 approach i don't think it makes sense to say oh i'm going to have people's back but i'm going to
02:59:42 cut as quickly as i can i'm going to cut the help to people who need it as much as they can
02:59:46 we're the only party right here clearly is going to say to you you're not going to have to pay more
02:59:51 we're not going to cut any programs we're going to ask the 44 we're giving working
02:59:55 we're going to ask the 44 richest billionaires pay their fair share for months that's what we're
03:00:02 going to do respond to that because this is the second time that mr singh has said we're the only
03:00:06 party where you know just us um mr singh you know that's hold on mr singh unless you're trying to
03:00:12 ghost me you know that you're also okay sure so yes as well okay thank you thank you all right
03:00:17 mr trudeau you're trying to get in mr singh continues to pretend that it makes no difference
03:00:22 whether there is a progressive government or a conservative or progressive government or a
03:00:27 conservative government we know that it makes a huge difference to families whether they have
03:00:34 $10 a day child care, whether they have a government that has their back, a government
03:00:38 that has a plan to move beyond the Harper targets on fighting climate change.
03:00:43 Now, Mr. Singh may feel that for the NDP, it makes no difference who forms government.
03:00:48 I know for Canadian...
03:00:49 Mr. Blanchet, you haven't been in yet.
03:00:53 Mr. Blanchet.
03:00:55 Wage subsidy.
03:00:56 Wage subsidy.
03:00:58 Did any of you three guys refund the wage subsidy that you received up to about $3 million?
03:01:04 That would be something, at least for the principal.
03:01:07 After that, there's an important issue, labor shortage.
03:01:11 They are promising jobs.
03:01:13 They should be promising workers.
03:01:15 We need people to work.
03:01:18 And that raises the question of productivity.
03:01:21 This is the most important issue.
03:01:23 And some programs should be turned toward that issue.
03:01:27 Mr. O'Toole.
03:01:28 In this pandemic election that Mr. Trudeau called after everyone asked him not to,
03:01:32 He says he doesn't worry about monetary policy and inflation.
03:01:36 Now he's saying he doesn't ever intend to balance the budget.
03:01:39 He's spending $424 million a day more than Canada's bringing in.
03:01:45 The question was, what programs will stay?
03:01:46 We need to wind down the support programs in a fair way and get the country working again.
03:01:52 We have got to remember.
03:01:52 Thank you.
03:01:53 Last minute of play, leaders.
03:01:56 Last minute of play.
03:01:57 Ms. Paul, five seconds to you.
03:01:59 I'm coming to you.
03:01:59 Ms. Paul.
03:02:00 Thank you.
03:02:00 We have got to remember the pandemic is not over.
03:02:03 And all over this country, people still need the benefits.
03:02:05 They should be there until the pandemic is over.
03:02:08 And to the people of Canada, it is unfortunate we are in this election.
03:02:12 You can see that there is a lot of work left to do.
03:02:14 We need to get back to doing it in a more cooperative way.
03:02:17 Okay, thank you, Ms. Paul.
03:02:17 Mr. Singh, I see you, Mr. Trudeau.
03:02:19 Mr. Singh.
03:02:19 One of the specific programs we demanded 22 times in Parliament for Mr. Trudeau to expand
03:02:25 was paid sick leave.
03:02:27 Because in this pandemic, people had to make the impossible choice going into work sick
03:02:31 or not being able to because they couldn't pay their bills.
03:02:35 22 times over 18 months, we demanded an expansion.
03:02:40 And Mr. Trudeau said no to you and said no to your family.
03:02:42 We are actually expanding sick leave to 10 days of paid sick leave for federal industries.
03:02:47 Now, in the election, and this is important, you have seen tonight the extreme differences
03:02:52 between the perspectives of these parties.
03:02:54 We need Canadians to make the right choice so we can move forward together.
03:03:00 We're out of time.
03:03:00 Evan, thank you.
03:03:02 Leaders, thank you for your participation tonight.
03:03:05 That's it for the English language leaders debate.
03:03:08 Voting day is September 20th.
03:03:11 Get your ballots.
03:03:12 Make sure you're registered on behalf of the leaders debate consortium.
03:03:17 I want to thank the crew, the producers, everyone who made this happen.
03:03:21 I'm Shachi Curl.
03:03:23 Good night.
03:03:23 Good night.
03:03:24 Good night.
03:03:25 Thank you.
03:03:29 True North's live debate night show.
03:03:32 I'm your host, Candice Malcolm.
03:03:33 Thank you so much for staying with us.
03:03:35 That was a long two hours.
03:03:37 I thought it was pretty much a train wreck.
03:03:40 I mean, the issues that they touched at the beginning of the debate,
03:03:43 the first hour, maybe even the first hour and a half,
03:03:46 were things that just didn't really matter to Canadians.
03:03:48 It felt like it was special interest groups.
03:03:50 It was niche issues, really going down rabbit holes,
03:03:53 talking about things like universal basic income and just all kinds of issues that don't really
03:03:59 resonate to canadians we didn't get to the meat the crux of the debate the important issues at
03:04:06 least from my perspective until the last what half an hour and by then i can't imagine anybody
03:04:10 stayed on it i thought that that was a horribly run debate as far as the leader's performance
03:04:15 trudeau to me seemed really on edge really angry really irritated i know he has his sort of tricks
03:04:21 and his style that he uses and that he sort of gets applauded for by the, you know, Laurentian
03:04:28 elite journalists on social media. But tonight, I just felt like everything was falling flat.
03:04:33 I thought that Aaron O'Toole came out pretty strong and then just sort of faded away. He
03:04:37 didn't really have much of an impact throughout the rest of the debate. I felt like Jagmeet
03:04:42 Singh did a pretty good job as well. But there were so many times when, you know, it would be
03:04:46 like Trudeau and O'Toole talking about an issue. And then instead of like letting the two of them
03:04:50 go on, or Trudeau would say something, and instead of going back to a tool, the moderator
03:04:54 would jump in and give the spotlight to Blanchette or Anna May Paul, and it's like, we don't
03:05:00 really care what they have to say.
03:05:01 I mean, those are sort of my observations from the top.
03:05:05 I'll let either of you jump in.
03:05:07 Well, I don't think Anna May Paul, and although I thought she handled questions very well,
03:05:11 I don't think she should have been in the debate, and definitely not Blanchette.
03:05:15 I mean, it was just a total waste of airtime, and I agree with you.
03:05:19 You said right at the beginning that he has no interest in becoming prime minister.
03:05:22 No.
03:05:22 It's like, why are you here then?
03:05:23 I mean, what a waste.
03:05:25 They should have just had the three leaders, leading leaders, going head to head.
03:05:30 And I agree with you.
03:05:31 I mean, it was, I think people, they lost people after the first hour because they only
03:05:37 talked about basically social justice issues.
03:05:39 And that indigenous reporter who just asked repeatedly about...
03:05:43 She wasn't really a reporter.
03:05:44 She felt like an activist.
03:05:45 She was really, she had her opinions.
03:05:47 And look, obviously that stuff is important.
03:05:48 and I think that it should be covered in a debate.
03:05:51 We should talk about it maybe for two or three minutes.
03:05:54 Forty-five?
03:05:55 We spent a lot of time on that issue,
03:05:56 and we were really driving home very special, very niche issues.
03:06:00 And again, it is important to some people,
03:06:03 but this is a national debate.
03:06:05 It's the only English debate we have.
03:06:06 We didn't talk about the economy or jobs at all
03:06:09 in the first, I think, hour and a half of the debate.
03:06:10 I remember when we, you know, before the pre-show,
03:06:14 where I said, you know, you have to connect with people at the grassroots level.
03:06:19 People's concerns about affordability, about housing, about the economy, coming back from COVID.
03:06:26 To jam that into a half an hour was just absolutely shameful from my perspective.
03:06:32 Yeah, and, you know, everything we've always seen when you look at the viewing habits in these debates
03:06:36 is people tune out after the first 15 or 20 minutes.
03:06:39 And the first 15 or 20 minutes is this real sort of grab bag of issues under the rubric
03:06:46 of leadership.
03:06:47 There was some foreign affairs stuff in there, which I thought was nice to hear, was unexpected
03:06:50 and positive, but then it would sort of veer to something completely different.
03:06:54 And then affordability, which the media has been telling us nonstop is the issue of the
03:06:57 election, turns up at the end.
03:06:59 And then on top of it, they had this really, the format was so bizarre in that you had
03:07:04 this situation where the moderator kept on going back to making sure that all five of
03:07:09 the of the leaders got a fair enough say or at least were able to jump in but there was enough
03:07:13 leeway that if a leader wanted to push through they could get more and more time Blanche at one
03:07:18 point complained that Trudeau had spoken for four more minutes than him um which you know makes
03:07:23 sense in that one of those guys is running for prime minister and that really allowed i think
03:07:28 it really allowed um saying to sort of use the format to his advantage that he just jumped in
03:07:33 all the time and everybody else kind of deferred to him and let him push through so especially in
03:07:39 the you know the sort of last two-thirds of the debate it was really the Jagmeet Singh show now
03:07:43 I don't think he's saying anything radically different the interesting thing is the NDP
03:07:47 campaign in this election seems to be doing something they were not interested in doing
03:07:51 not been interested in the past which is attack Justin Trudeau from the left um we'll see if it
03:07:56 has any impact but Singh's in a battle to to hold on to his vote right we saw we saw on the poll we
03:08:02 talked about earlier today, Candace, that as many as 20% of NDP and Green voters say they are very
03:08:10 likely to vote Liberal to stop the Conservatives from winning. If Singh loses those votes, he's
03:08:15 going to be right back down to more or less what he got in the last election. So he's got to show
03:08:19 to those people that you can't just vote Liberal. That's really what it was about for him. We'll see
03:08:23 over the next week whether he's successful or not. Well, I agree that Singh did a good job. He
03:08:27 showed his personality, kind of came through, and you're right, he jumped in in ways that I wish
03:08:31 Erin O'Toole would kind of push back more and part of it again was the moderator because a lot of
03:08:35 times it would be like you know they do the two person back and forth and they wouldn't she wouldn't
03:08:41 let the person respond and then she would just randomly go to someone else look I like I kind
03:08:45 of like anime Paul I think that she has a nice personality she actually had some really strong
03:08:49 moments in the campaign and she called Trudeau out for being a fake feminist right to your point 0.91
03:08:54 Hamish right in the beginning when everyone was paying attention and she talked about Jodie 0.98
03:08:58 Wilson-Raybould. I thought that was devastating to Trudeau because he couldn't really say anything.
03:09:01 He didn't have anything to go back on. And so I don't begrudge her, but a lot of times she just
03:09:06 wasn't really relevant to the conversation. I wanted to see more Trudeau versus O'Toole.
03:09:11 And again, I thought that O'Toole really, in this one, earlier in the pre-show, I was complaining
03:09:16 that in last night's French debate, I felt like there was just too much. They all agreed and
03:09:21 there wasn't really a lot of interesting divergence of views. I felt differently tonight.
03:09:26 I felt like Aaron O'Toole did a better job defending conservatism, that there were a few moments where he really was pushing back against this sort of mainstream narrative.
03:09:34 But I just felt that overall, the debate just missed the mark in terms of the issues that Canadians care about.
03:09:41 Like, we're in the middle of a pandemic.
03:09:42 We have all these issues with small business owners, with people not being able to find employees,
03:09:48 for people worried about the future of their industry, particularly folks in Western Canada.
03:09:53 And I feel like none of that.
03:09:54 I felt like that was an Ottawa debate.
03:09:56 It wasn't a Canadian debate.
03:09:57 It was a very, very Ottawa-centric debate.
03:10:00 It was an activist debate.
03:10:02 And, I mean, it was so far from the experience of the people that you talk to on the streets
03:10:09 or the people that I've encountered at doors in Midtown Toronto.
03:10:15 They're not talking about, you know, other than a couple of minutes,
03:10:19 they're not talking about indigenous issues and they're not talking about climate change that is
03:10:25 so yesterday i mean we have to be concerned about it obviously but they're thinking about how do
03:10:32 they come out of this pandemic whole how do they deal with their life that has been turned upside
03:10:39 down many many lives have been turned upside down it's funny because at one moment in the debate
03:10:44 they said that to many Canadians this is the climate change election and I felt like that
03:10:49 was so out of touch I was like you know I felt like climate change was a really really big issue
03:10:53 maybe like five years ago when people were first starting to kind of debate it it was a big issue
03:10:58 for liberals when Trump became president because he had in the past said that he thought it was a
03:11:02 hoax and so it was really important in that moment in the sort of Paris context but that that moment
03:11:08 is not this moment not to completely contradict you but as we saw in our poll climate change is
03:11:12 the number one issue for liberals so when they say that when they're saying it's a big issue for
03:11:17 canadians it's a big issue for liberals we saw that people who are voting conservative it's much
03:11:22 much lower on the list of priorities and undecided voters it's much lower than a list of priorities
03:11:26 so you know it goes to your point that this was a debate amongst for all the topics that people in
03:11:31 that that you know that bubble that bubble in ottawa care about and the people they talk to
03:11:37 right well and it's funny because even though they had representatives and voices from across
03:11:41 the country, the people all echoed the same sort of sound that, like, I'm sorry, you know,
03:11:46 they had a guy who asked a question from Saskatchewan. He didn't sound like people from Saskatchewan
03:11:50 I know. Like, he just, I felt like the issues that they chose, the way that the debate was
03:11:54 framed, even the format and how they had it, I think that Canadians are so much better.
03:12:00 This is the only English debate. It's the only opportunity that we have to see the leaders,
03:12:04 given the way that Justin Trudeau just doesn't really answer questions, he doesn't really,
03:12:08 And we're about to see it.
03:12:09 We're going to go to the scrums in a few minutes here when they start.
03:12:13 But the idea that Trudeau doesn't really answer questions even though he has the adoring love
03:12:20 of the journalists who he speaks to.
03:12:22 And you can see the back and forth.
03:12:24 There's been a couple moments in this campaign where Trudeau has just unabashedly talked
03:12:28 about how much he loves the journalists and how brave they are and how amazing they are
03:12:32 and just totally, totally sucking up to them.
03:12:35 you know, you see the reciprocity in the way that they treat him, the softball question. So we don't 0.97
03:12:40 really ever get to see Trudeau back up against his wall, making him explain his positions and
03:12:46 sort of calling him out for his bad behavior. It was great to see Anna Mae Paul do that. There
03:12:51 were a couple moments where Aaron O'Toole certainly had him, you know, about the two Michaels or
03:12:57 talking about Kabul. I felt like the foreign policy stuff, again, was a real strong suit
03:13:01 for O'Toole, but, I mean, this is it.
03:13:04 I mean, we're going to the polls, what, a week, Monday?
03:13:06 Well, no, actually, advanced polls open tomorrow morning.
03:13:09 You know, millions of Canadians are going to start voting tomorrow.
03:13:13 So, you know, the elections, you know,
03:13:15 the voting is happening in big, big numbers.
03:13:18 And, you know, I think, you know,
03:13:19 if people were tuning into this debate to see,
03:13:22 hold on, Aaron O'Toole could win the election,
03:13:24 what's the deal with Aaron O'Toole?
03:13:26 Which I think would be a normal thing
03:13:27 for a lot of undecided Canadians at this point.
03:13:29 We're trying to make that decision between Trudeau and O'Toole.
03:13:32 I don't think they got a particularly good answer to that.
03:13:35 And I think it's primarily the fault of the format
03:13:37 that didn't really allow Canadians to see the choice that actually matters.
03:13:42 Who cares about Blanchette having a debate with Paul
03:13:47 or Singh about something in English Canada?
03:13:49 Well, that's exactly it, because that was the thing that I heard, again,
03:13:54 at the doors, is that they were waiting to see.
03:13:56 A lot of undecideds said they were waiting to see how the leaders handled themselves in the debate.
03:14:01 Oh, really?
03:14:02 Which is the idea of a debate.
03:14:03 That's why we're doing them.
03:14:04 But, I mean, they were, I mean, these people at the doors would be grossly let down
03:14:08 because I would imagine that they were looking for the issues that struck them near and dear to the heart
03:14:16 and big one being affordability.
03:14:19 And why would you leave that to the last couple of questions and then jam it in?
03:14:24 In fact, I thought it was supposed to be evenly divided, and the last 10 minutes was left to COVID recovery.
03:14:32 Well, my goodness, we've been living through 18 months of lockdowns and vaccine screw-ups and all kinds of stuff.
03:14:40 I cannot believe that they didn't have that right off the top.
03:14:43 Did they even ask any questions about government debt, government spending?
03:14:46 Is that something that we just decided we don't care about anymore?
03:14:48 I can't help but wonder if this was kind of framed to help Mr. Trudeau, the Prime Minister.
03:14:57 Of course, this is a question I'm sort of wondering is, Trudeau has had a spectacular fall from grace in this election.
03:15:04 He was really going in thinking he was going to get a majority.
03:15:06 He was riding high in the polls.
03:15:08 And it has been a big surprise.
03:15:09 I'm sure he really regrets calling this election.
03:15:11 I honestly think that he is up at night thinking, oh, my goodness, I could lose the prime ministership.
03:15:16 This could be all over for me.
03:15:18 And I kind of wonder, you know, he has a week to turn things around.
03:15:21 Did he do that tonight?
03:15:22 Because from my perspective, and I know I don't see Trudeau.
03:15:25 You were saying, Hamish, that you either love Trudeau or you hate him.
03:15:28 And I obviously don't fall in that first category.
03:15:30 I have a hard time really trying to figure out what it is that people see in Trudeau.
03:15:35 But, you know, seeing his performance, I noted on Twitter that maybe it was hot in that room
03:15:39 because he seemed like he was really red.
03:15:41 He seemed frazzled.
03:15:42 He seemed angry.
03:15:43 He didn't seem to perform in the way that he needed to from my perspective
03:15:46 in order to sort of recapture the imagination of the country.
03:15:49 I don't really know what he's running on
03:15:51 in terms of like, you know,
03:15:52 what his big ideas are for his next term.
03:15:55 I don't really know what the ballot question is for him
03:15:58 other than just, hey, I've been doing a good job.
03:16:00 Don't you think I deserve a majority?
03:16:01 And it's pretty clear that Canadians aren't saying that.
03:16:03 So I was kind of expecting a better performance from him.
03:16:05 I was expecting some big lines,
03:16:07 some of his sort of like, you know,
03:16:09 liberals go back to their greatest hits.
03:16:10 And instead, I just saw like a lot of negativity,
03:16:13 a lot of sort of franticness, fast talking,
03:16:16 angry. It didn't seem like Trudeau was having a good night from my perspective.
03:16:21 Yeah, I don't think he turned off anybody who already liked him, though. I agree. I don't think
03:16:26 it was a winning performance that he picked up a ton of extra votes. But I don't think he turned
03:16:30 anybody off. And often the incumbent gets a bit of an advantage, a bit of the devil you know. And
03:16:35 if it's choice for people who are trying to decide between the devil you know and somebody new,
03:16:39 the incumbent gets a bit of leeway. So I'm not sure, you know, for me, this debate was the big
03:16:45 big opportunity for Aaron O'Toole to show he was
03:16:47 a Prime Minister, to show all those people
03:16:49 who are saying, ah, maybe who are saying
03:16:51 they're voting Conservative but they're not entirely
03:16:53 sure yet, or people who are wavering
03:16:55 about it. And
03:16:56 I don't think he really got the chance to do that.
03:16:59 So does that, you know, it doesn't
03:17:01 matter that Truro's performance wasn't as
03:17:03 strong as it could have been?
03:17:05 Maybe it's all he needs to do.
03:17:07 We'll see, but I think
03:17:09 the, you know, I think the
03:17:11 format really
03:17:12 did not help canadians make that decision i think there's too much noise yeah from the others just
03:17:19 too much noise too many questions not organized i think things were thrown out there uh it was
03:17:28 it was a hot mess talk about hot mess it really was and i i wouldn't be able if i were undecided
03:17:34 i wouldn't be able to decide from tonight right and and again you know it was both too long and
03:17:40 too short, right? Because it was like, this was the only opportunity we had in English to see
03:17:44 the leaders together. And yet it dragged on so long. It was hard to watch. I'm a political junkie.
03:17:50 You know, I'm going to watch this stuff all the time. And I just, I was like, are they still
03:17:54 talking about climate change? Why are they still talking about climate change? And it just, I felt
03:17:58 like they just lost the room. They lost the country. Like this is not what people care about.
03:18:03 And then we were talking about the format, like what would have been, Rex Murphy had a great piece
03:18:08 in national post yesterday about how we would have just been much better served to have smaller
03:18:13 debates in each region you know go to british columbia get a bunch of journalists from vancouver
03:18:18 or victoria and get them to ask questions that matter to british columbia and go to alberta and
03:18:22 get a bunch of journalists from alberta get them to ask questions and it would have been really
03:18:26 interesting to hear if justin trudeau had a different tune speaking out west as opposed to
03:18:31 you know to his base and to his core in quebec and in ottawa and ontario uh you know go out to
03:18:36 to the Maritimes and talk to people out there. Like, this is a national election. Go up north.
03:18:42 You know, have a debate just for First Nations issues. Aaron O'Toole is the first leader who
03:18:48 is going to be speaking. So we'll cut our analysis and head right to the Scrum where
03:18:53 Aaron O'Toole is taking questions now. Good evening. Good evening, Mr. O'Toole.
03:18:59 Ryan Tomlin, National Post. I want to ask about your climate change plan, the plan for the personal
03:19:03 carbon savings accounts.
03:19:05 If you're successful in the election, if you're Prime Minister,
03:19:07 can you tell us how quickly that
03:19:09 program will be brought in
03:19:10 and what you'll do with Mr. Trudeau's carbon tax
03:19:13 in the meantime? When will
03:19:15 it end? When will the carbon savings account
03:19:17 start? What happens in the in-between?
03:19:20 Well, this is part of the reason why we
03:19:21 put out our plan in April. We wanted
03:19:23 to show provinces
03:19:25 another option to price carbon, to make
03:19:27 our Paris commitments, but to also
03:19:29 have economic recovery. So those
03:19:31 conversations will go underway. We want to partner with the provinces and I think after six years of
03:19:36 Mr. Trudeau having an Ottawa Knows Best approach for everything, I want to see more collaboration
03:19:41 within our confederation and climate change will be an important part of that. Mike, number two,
03:19:47 please. Good evening, Mr. O'Toole, Andrew Lawton, True North. Thanks in large part to high vaccine
03:19:53 uptake, we've seen cases and hospitalizations decouple. A lot of restrictions, even some under
03:19:58 federal control still remain in place, though, for vaccinated and unvaccinated individuals.
03:20:03 If you're Prime Minister, what is the metric you're going to use to decide when the pandemic
03:20:08 is over, basically? Is it going to be cases, hospitalizations, vaccine rate? What is the end
03:20:13 result for you? We're going to work with public health officials to make sure that we can keep
03:20:18 people safe. That's got to be the priority, not to have a fifth wave after a fourth wave,
03:20:23 and to balance the economy.
03:20:25 Our main concern with Mr. Trudeau,
03:20:28 he was so slow on just approving rapid testing.
03:20:31 That is a tool that, if used properly,
03:20:33 can be a very important build on to vaccines and to distancing.
03:20:38 It lets us have openings.
03:20:40 That's where we want to see more federal leadership 0.89
03:20:42 to balance off the need to get our economy back on track.
03:20:46 We'll take a question from the phone now.
03:20:48 Operator, is there a question on the phone?
03:20:53 Operator, is there a question from the phone?
03:21:05 So we will take a question from the room and we'll come back to the phone and try and compensate
03:21:09 that question.
03:21:11 Mic number one, please.
03:21:12 Thank you.
03:21:13 Mike LaPointe from the Hill Times.
03:21:15 Mr. O'Toole, Conservatives are the traditional party that look to balance the budget as quickly
03:21:20 as possible. And after a year of unprecedented spending, if elected, what would you do to bring
03:21:28 the government finances back to normality? Great question. Mr. Trudeau is spending $424 million
03:21:37 per day, more than we're bringing in. So we launched Canada's recovery plan, which is going
03:21:42 to focus on getting our economy back on a strong footing, getting people working, particularly
03:21:46 highly impacted sectors that we want to see, we want to focus on work and get our budget back
03:21:52 to balance over the course of the next decade. The parliamentary budget officer just confirmed
03:21:56 our plan. That is what we need, a plan to get back to a fiscal stability in our country so that
03:22:03 we safeguard our programs and avoid a debt crisis that Mr. Trudeau is leading us towards.
03:22:11 So we will try the phones once again. Operator, is there a question from the phone, please?
03:22:16 From the phone, please.
03:22:23 Mic number two, please.
03:22:24 Mic number two, please.
03:22:25 Thank you, Mr. Atul.
03:22:26 Rosina's support from the UK Daily Telegraph.
03:22:29 There's been very little foreign policy discussion in the campaign so far.
03:22:33 So if you were prime minister, how would you set yourself apart from Mr. Trudeau on the world stage?
03:22:39 And what message do you have for Canada's closest allies like the UK in terms of international collaboration
03:22:44 on everything from Afghanistan to climate change.
03:22:47 Well, as I said this evening,
03:22:49 I think it was a failure of leadership
03:22:50 for Mr. Trudeau to call an election
03:22:52 and leave behind 1,200 Canadians
03:22:55 and hundreds of other translators and people
03:22:58 that are at risk in Afghanistan
03:22:59 because they served with our forces,
03:23:01 with our diplomats.
03:23:03 Canada doesn't leave people behind.
03:23:05 And Mr. Trudeau put himself first.
03:23:06 I want our NATO allies,
03:23:09 our Five Eyes allies to know
03:23:10 we will be there as a strong partner.
03:23:12 We will stand up for human rights.
03:23:13 We have a lot of concerns with the conduct of the communist government in China.
03:23:18 And we will look at innovative partnerships like my Kanzuk initiative.
03:23:23 There's lots of interest to work even closer with the United Kingdom, Australia, and New Zealand.
03:23:29 So we will try from the phones once again.
03:23:31 Operator, can we have a question from the phone?
03:23:34 From the phone.
03:23:41 Mike, number one, please.
03:23:42 Mike, number one, please.
03:23:43 Mr. Atul, Murad Hamadi from The Logic.
03:23:49 Your platform states that you will, quote,
03:23:51 pass strong legislation to protect privacy more effectively
03:23:54 than the current government's weak Bill C-11.
03:23:58 What specifically is wrong with Bill C-11,
03:24:00 and how do you propose to regulate businesses' use of data and AI?
03:24:04 We have been speaking to people about the need
03:24:07 to allow people to have ownership and control
03:24:10 over their footprint, over their privacy,
03:24:13 particularly in a digital age.
03:24:15 We need to make sure that there's ownership there.
03:24:18 It's also why we support open banking, for example,
03:24:20 so that people can own that and control it
03:24:23 and have certainty with respect to their personal information.
03:24:27 Canada's recovery plan is about making sure our economy bounces back
03:24:30 and that we safeguard Canadians in the digital space.
03:24:35 Mic number two, please.
03:24:37 Good evening. Jenna Kokulo with The Wire Report.
03:24:40 In your run to be party leader,
03:24:41 you said you wanted to defund the CBC's digital services
03:24:45 and cut its English TV services by 50%.
03:24:48 Now you've kind of walked that back in your party platform.
03:24:51 What changed for you since then?
03:24:53 What I've said is I think with the digital age,
03:24:55 you know, my own kids watch a lot of streaming services on YouTube,
03:24:59 we need to make sure that we preserve content creators in Canada,
03:25:03 that we have a competitive landscape,
03:25:05 and that in some areas like English television and digital,
03:25:08 We shouldn't see the government competing with the private sector that is trying desperately to innovate and hold on, particularly with advertising.
03:25:16 So we'd like to see a modernization to see less of that competition, less government subsidizing newspapers and other organizations,
03:25:25 taking that state competition out and making sure we support the creation of private sector content and creation.
03:25:34 And let's try the phone line once again.
03:25:37 operator is there a call on a question from the phone from the phone yes our first question
03:25:43 tonight is from uh dylan robertson from winnipeg free press please go ahead your line is open
03:25:49 mr otul why won't you tell us how many of your candidates are vaccinated
03:25:55 as you know as you know i encourage all canadians to get vaccinated they're safe and effective for
03:26:04 use, and I've been fighting for better access to supply, and I will respect personal decisions
03:26:09 about health care, and we need to work together to overcome any questions that people may have.
03:26:15 In fact, I was proud to work with Mr. Singh and the other leaders tonight to film a video talking
03:26:20 about how important and safe vaccines are in our fight against COVID-19. What I haven't liked
03:26:26 with Mr. Trudeau's pandemic election is this attempt to divide people when we should be
03:26:32 working together in our fight against COVID-19.
03:26:35 Operator, please, we'll take another question from the phone.
03:26:46 Mic number one, please.
03:26:49 Jean-Sébastien Cloutier, Radio-Canada.
03:26:50 Bonjour, Monsieur O'Toole, bonsoir.
03:26:53 Vous avez entendu Monsieur Legault aujourd'hui au Québec
03:26:56 qui a laissé sous-entendre qu'un gouvernement
03:26:59 minoritaires, conservateurs,
03:27:00 serait peut-être la meilleure idée,
03:27:02 que les autres partis étaient centralisateurs.
03:27:05 Avez-vous vu ça comme un appui de la part de M. Legault?
03:27:08 Quelle a été votre réaction?
03:27:10 Comme je l'ai dit, j'ai beaucoup de respect
03:27:12 pour le premier ministre Legault et son leadership
03:27:14 pendant la pandémie.
03:27:16 On a beaucoup d'enjeux en commun,
03:27:19 particulièrement la création de réussies
03:27:21 et une relance économique.
03:27:24 Et j'ai un contrat avec les Québécois et les Québécoises
03:27:27 because I will always respect the competencies and have a fédéralism of partnership.
03:27:36 I will continue to work in collaboration with all provinces, including Prime Minister Legault.
03:27:45 And let's try the phone lines once again. Operator, is there a question on the phone?
03:27:49 On the phone. Yes, thank you. The next question is from Raymond Fillon, TVA. Please go ahead. The line is open.
03:27:56 Merci. Merci. Bonsoir, M. Autour.
03:27:58 Je voudrais savoir si vous êtes d'accord avec la première question
03:28:01 qui a été posée à M. Blanchet par la modératrice ce soir
03:28:03 sur les lois 21 au Québec, 96 aussi sur la protection du français.
03:28:08 Est-ce que ce sont des lois discriminatoires, comme elle l'a dit?
03:28:13 Comme j'ai dit, je vais toujours respecter les chambres des compétences du Québec
03:28:18 et avoir une approche de partenariat.
03:28:20 and we have to respect the language, the culture, the laïcité.
03:28:27 I will always respect that and I will work on a team of collaboration
03:28:31 on the language, particularly with the law 101
03:28:36 for the federal government.
03:28:38 It's the time to respect all provinces and that would be my approach.
03:28:45 It's our time to work together and respect all provinces.
03:28:48 We need to partner, particularly coming out of COVID-19, and respect provincial jurisdiction and try and come together to partner. 0.59
03:28:56 I think we need to fight against the decline of the French language.
03:29:01 I think having French as the language of work, this is an area with Bill 101 and the federally regulated enterprises in the province.
03:29:09 I think it's a matter of fairness that those large players like the banks and others take the same approach that medium-sized players do, making French the language of the workplace in Quebec.
03:29:20 That's all the time we have. Thank you very much.
03:29:24 Merci beaucoup.
03:29:24 Thank you.
03:29:25 And really, I thought that Erin O'Toole did a great job, but there's a couple things
03:29:37 that I noticed. The first several questions were all about COVID and the economy, because
03:29:43 those are the issues that Canadians care about. Unlike the debate where we focused on climate
03:29:47 change, we focused on reconciliation, things that sure are important, but they're not the
03:29:52 dominant issues in the campaign, it was interesting that even the journalists, even the out-of-touch
03:29:56 journalists in Ottawa picked up on the issues that mattered to Canadians.
03:30:00 I thought that O'Toole did a great job.
03:30:01 He looked really comfortable, and, you know, he's confident.
03:30:06 He's got his message, and he sticks to it, and I thought he did a great job there.
03:30:11 Yeah, it is interesting that they focused on what was missing from the debate.
03:30:16 They didn't hear answers during the debate, so it's just natural that they would ask.
03:30:22 As you say, I just want to make one point because Andrew Lawton got a great question in there and it was great to have to North being able to ask that question.
03:30:34 It wasn't, you know, an easy thing for us to have Andrew there.
03:30:37 And the question he asked was, you know, what's the end point of this pandemic?
03:30:40 When are we out?
03:30:42 When can we go back to normal?
03:30:43 And, you know, I thought that O'Toole did a decent job answering that.
03:30:46 But I would really like to hear more politicians ask that question.
03:30:49 Like, when is this pandemic over?
03:30:51 When can we go back to normal?
03:30:52 And that's what I think is going to be interesting when we look at policies like vaccine passports, right, which we see are reasonably popular when you look at it on the polls.
03:30:59 But I think that's based on a tacit belief that most people have that they're a temporary thing.
03:31:04 Well, they'll have this vaccine passport until COVID is no longer a threat.
03:31:07 If you say, well, it's going to have this vaccine passport for a significant length of time, probably could the popularity be lower.
03:31:13 And Andrew's question is a very, very important one is what's the criteria for pulling back on all these restrictions?
03:31:20 Right, because we need actual, like, an endgame here.
03:31:23 It's like we keep having moving goalposts.
03:31:25 And I think a lot of the reason that people agree to vaccine passports,
03:31:28 I think, look, I think the vaccines are important.
03:31:30 I think everyone should go and get them, that they're safe and effective.
03:31:34 But the idea of the government trying to manage this passport system,
03:31:37 it really doesn't sit well with me.
03:31:39 I mean, we're watching this government debate right now.
03:31:41 They can't even figure out how to get the questions from the people on the phone to go.
03:31:45 And we're supposed to believe that they can manage this national vaccine passport system
03:31:48 with all of our help and it's kind of interesting too because we had a story about this at tnc.news
03:31:54 today about how city councillors here in toronto who oppose carding that will really oppose the idea
03:31:59 of carding which is just when police go up to an individual who might need a description of a
03:32:04 wanted criminal and ask for their id uh that's outrageous because apparently it's racist and yet
03:32:09 the same people who are for against carding are for vaccine passports which are far more intrusive
03:32:14 far more invasive require more id and they require everyone to have them at all times to go to a
03:32:19 restaurant go to a bar i mean to me it's just a massive overreach of government and i think that
03:32:24 more people uh you know the idea that oh if we just have these vaccine passports we'll go back
03:32:29 to normal that's really temporary thinking that's thinking okay i'll give up all these liberties uh
03:32:33 for like the short-term idea uh of some freedom but like do you really trust the government to
03:32:39 let this no one system go I think it's a terrifying slope that was a slippery slope and you know I
03:32:46 always think with governments if they tax something for example they're not going to remove the tax
03:32:52 so if they impose these passports so they impose these restrictions every time we agree to something
03:32:57 they're just going to keep opening it opens the door to more and more so right now we the way
03:33:03 they're talking we can't go into a restaurant we can't go into a gym without vaccine passports
03:33:08 we certainly can't travel without vaccine passports we can't get out of canada well right
03:33:14 now we can't even get to the states but you know they there are so many restrictions on us our
03:33:22 lives have completely changed i think it's a very fair question i'm not sure that politicians are
03:33:28 prepared to answer that question and we haven't really seen a very good answer but i will say
03:33:33 that you know erin o'toole was at least answered the question in the way he didn't he didn't give
03:33:37 a specific metric, which I think we're hoping for, like, you know, when 90% of people get vaccinated
03:33:42 or when COVID case rates go down to something like that. You know, we don't have that. But
03:33:48 again, this is a question I think that we should be demanding that our politicians answer.
03:33:53 But I think there is some point politicians have to understand that we're going to have to learn
03:33:57 to live with it without all these massive restrictions. We get vaccinated for the flu,
03:34:04 or most of us, I'm not sure, you know, I do every year.
03:34:08 And we're going to have to learn to live with it
03:34:10 and make, you know, the necessary accommodations,
03:34:13 but not restrict our lives and our travel
03:34:16 and, you know, our ability to move in the world.
03:34:20 Absolutely.
03:34:21 All right, well, we've kind of missed most of the bloc leaders' questions here,
03:34:24 but let's go to the federal debate
03:34:29 and listen to the rest of the scrum here.
03:34:31 — Est-ce que cette question-là peut influencer les prochains jours de la campagne, à votre avis,
03:34:37 puisqu'elle a été posée par une animatrice du débat, non pas que ça ne s'est pas passé dans un échange entre les autres chefs?
03:34:44 — Non, non, en fait, là, je me réentends en écho.
03:34:47 Bon, j'imagine que les autres chefs, s'il y avait eu un inconfort par rapport à la nature de la question
03:34:52 qui établissait que les Québécois sont des racistes, bien, ils l'auraient dit,
03:34:56 ça n'a pas l'air de les avoir dérangés trop, trop.
03:34:58 Est-ce que ça a un avenir? Est-ce que ça va influencer l'avenir de la campagne?
03:35:02 On en était déjà en train d'établir que les Québécois avaient besoin qu'il n'y ait pas de majorité accordée à qui que ce soit.
03:35:09 Mais c'est plus clair que jamais que ça prend quelqu'un qui va protéger les intérêts du Québec.
03:35:15 En général, je dis promouvoir, mais là je vais dire protéger, parce que ça a été l'objet d'une attaque, d'une agression contre le Québec.
03:35:22 But the need seems clearer than ever.
03:35:25 And, my faith, there are not many line candidates to protect Quebec in this parliament.
03:35:30 We will be there.
03:35:33 Question from the mic number two, please.
03:35:52 child welfare to Indigenous nations.
03:35:54 This bill is being challenged by
03:35:56 Quebec in court.
03:35:58 It's a constitutional challenge.
03:36:00 Are you willing to concede that
03:36:02 the nation-to-nation relationship
03:36:04 as you described it earlier today
03:36:06 will require power sharing
03:36:08 and jurisdictional sharing between
03:36:10 Quebec and First Nations?
03:36:11 I would invite you to ask this question to the Premier of Quebec.
03:36:16 Micro number one, s'il vous plaît.
03:36:17 Oui, bonsoir. L'inadible, la ministre canadienne.
03:36:20 Bonsoir, M. Blanchet. Moi, j'aimerais revenir
03:36:22 sur ce que M. Legault a dit ce matin,
03:36:23 parce que je pense qu'on ne vous a pas entendu y réagir.
03:36:26 Maintenant, vous savez exactement c'était quoi.
03:36:28 Oui, votre collègue derrière vous m'a entendu ce matin.
03:36:29 Il était là.
03:36:30 Non, parce que mon collègue, qui était sur le même autobus,
03:36:33 m'a dit que vous aviez dit que vous n'aviez pas tout entendu.
03:36:35 Non, je n'avais pas tout entendu, en effet.
03:36:36 Et que donc, vous nous parleriez plus tard.
03:36:37 Ça va me faire plaisir.
03:36:38 Nous sommes plus tard.
03:36:39 C'est sûr.
03:36:40 Attendez que je pose ma question.
03:36:41 Je pense.
03:36:42 Je pense.
03:36:42 Je pense gestuellement.
03:36:44 Oui, donc, vous avez dû y penser toute la journée.
03:36:46 On a tous compris que M. Legault était en train de dire aux Québécois
03:36:49 votez pour les conservateurs.
03:36:51 Ça, c'est des votes qui vous prend à vous
03:36:52 et j'aimerais savoir
03:36:54 si quand, aussi tout à l'heure, vous avez dit
03:36:57 à M. O'Toole en quittant le plateau,
03:36:59 vous lui avez dit
03:37:00 ça te prend un chien de garde.
03:37:03 Le chien de garde, c'est le bloc. Est-ce que vous êtes
03:37:04 en train de concéder que M. O'Toole...
03:37:06 Comment ça fait qu'on a entendu ce que j'ai dit en privé à M. O'Toole
03:37:08 sur le plateau? Non, non, non, c'est pas en privé.
03:37:11 C'était quand vous êtes sur le plateau.
03:37:12 Sur le plateau, on se parle après, puis on me pose des questions
03:37:15 sur ce que j'ai dit à M. O'Toole après
03:37:16 sur le plateau, avec un texte seul ou avec l'animatrice.
03:37:20 Vraiment.
03:37:21 D'accord.
03:37:21 Donc, est-ce que vous êtes en train de concéder que M. O'Toole
03:37:24 va devenir premier ministre et que donc, pour ce faire,
03:37:27 il vous prend, vous vote?
03:37:28 C'est ça ma question.
03:37:29 Et par rapport à M. O'Toole?
03:37:30 Prenez-vous des chaises parce que la question est assez longue
03:37:33 et intéressante, on va en parler longtemps.
03:37:35 Moi, mon interprétation, elle est complètement différente
03:37:38 de votre tout le monde.
03:37:40 Je ne sais pas c'est qui tout le monde en fait,
03:37:41 qui est tout le monde.
03:37:42 Moi, mon interprétation, c'est qu'évidemment,
03:37:44 un premier ministre du Québec doit interpeller
03:37:46 des gens qui considèrent qu'ils peuvent devenir chef de l'État.
03:37:49 C'est tout à fait normal.
03:37:50 Qu'est-ce que j'ai entendu?
03:37:51 J'ai entendu un premier ministre qui dit
03:37:53 « Il y a trois parties qui sont hyper centralisateurs.
03:37:57 Il y en a un qui l'est moins.
03:37:59 Mais je veux un gouvernement minoritaire.
03:38:01 Quand on est au Québec et qu'on veut un gouvernement minoritaire,
03:38:04 on ne parle pas du NPD et des Verts.
03:38:06 On parle du Bloc québécois.
03:38:07 Donc, c'est au moins autant une invitation
03:38:10 à considérer le Bloc québécois
03:38:11 qu'à considérer les conservateurs.
03:38:13 L'espèce de raccourci que j'ai entendu en effet toute la journée ne me semble pas fondé.
03:38:19 Moi, j'étais plutôt content. Je fais, bon, donc le premier ministre du Québec suggère de considérer le Bloc québécois parce que personne ne mérite une majorité dans ce Parlement-là.
03:38:27 Je rappellerai qu'en matière de transfert en santé, pour les trois premières années, c'est 3,5 % par année.
03:38:32 Ce n'est même pas le 6 % par année. C'est à des milliards et des milliards de dollars.
03:38:37 Avec ce calcul-là, d'ailleurs, la première année, on est déjà dans le tout de proche 30 milliards par rapport aux demandes des provinces.
03:38:43 and in terms of guard services, the Prime Minister of Quebec has been quite clear and said
03:38:47 hey, I want the guard services or I want to hear about the guard services that there are
03:38:51 with Quebec and that there are other provinces.
03:38:54 So, there are more spectacular resources than funded.
03:38:57 I have no doubt about what I heard and if I didn't have any of them during the day,
03:39:03 I would allow you to tell you that with the debate of this evening.
03:39:13 Like, you know, last night of the French debate, in the sense that he was there, you know, they were talking a lot about Quebec.
03:39:18 And at some points it was even, like, I appreciated his perspective because he was taking a little bit of a different angle.
03:39:23 For instance, when they were talking about labor markets, he was the only one that was sort of, you know,
03:39:28 talking about how a lot of people don't want to go to work because they get paid to sit at home and talking about CERB.
03:39:33 That was something that, like, all the other leaders were dancing around.
03:39:35 Tonight it's just, like, everything that Yves Van Gogh says, it's like, why is this guy here?
03:39:39 He's like the cranky uncle that no one really wants to have over for dinner, and yet he's still always there, ranting and raving.
03:39:46 It really just drills in the sort of Quebec favoritism that we have in this country, the pandering that happens.
03:39:53 And I don't know.
03:39:55 Look, Quebec is important, just like every other province is important.
03:39:58 But the tone that he takes, it just feels like a petulant child to me.
03:40:02 I wonder that Westfield is disenfranchised when they listen to two French debates,
03:40:08 or they encounter two French debates,
03:40:11 and they have this gentleman who really shouldn't be in the English debate
03:40:15 taking up airtime, and then now taking up airtime,
03:40:19 speaking in French yet again,
03:40:22 and you're thinking, okay, enough already.
03:40:25 We understand there's a province of Quebec,
03:40:27 but there are nine other provinces.
03:40:30 Yeah, it's just, you know, it adds insult to injury.
03:40:37 In theory, he's there because even though they run candidates in Quebec that, you know, what he says could be of interest to the Anglophones in the West Island of Montreal who, of course, vote, you know, like 3% of them vote for the bloc or 1% of them vote for the bloc or something.
03:40:52 You know, so he's there, in theory, speaking to a group of people who, by their very nature, are very disinterested in what he has to say.
03:41:00 The debates would clearly be better in a much more focused manner, but it's been a long
03:41:09 tradition.
03:41:10 I mean, I remember we used to have Preston Manning in the French debate when the Reform
03:41:13 Party wasn't barely even running any candidates in Quebec, and that wasn't any better.
03:41:17 But it was that we have this sort of bizarre idea that we have to, everybody, if you're
03:41:21 running more than a certain number of candidates or you've got MPs, you must be in all the
03:41:25 debates.
03:41:26 I was like, well, do you actually have to be?
03:41:28 Really?
03:41:29 Really?
03:41:30 how do you think that he is doing you're looking at the polls and the numbers is he resonating with
03:41:34 voters in quebec is he is he doing a good job from that perspective so look it depends on the
03:41:39 polls you look at some polls show most polls in quebec suffer from being raised with all sample
03:41:43 sizes because they have a large margin of error uh the bloc won 32 seats in the last election
03:41:49 in quebec which was a big jump for them they only had 10 in the election before so they you know
03:41:52 they more than tripled their representation which was a big win but the crazy thing is that there
03:41:56 There was another eight seats they lost by about another 5% or 6%.
03:41:59 Here comes Trudeau.
03:42:01 Should we go back to Trudeau?
03:42:02 Yeah, let's go back.
03:42:04 We'll go to Trudeau at the scrum and we'll continue.
03:42:06 Shout-out to Leila Fernandez. 1.00
03:42:08 I got off stage and discovered that she won the semifinals 1.00
03:42:11 and is on her way to the finals.
03:42:13 I think we're all very, very excited about her.
03:42:16 Je veux juste féliciter Leila Fernandez pour un match extraordinaire
03:42:20 que je n'ai pas pu voir parce que j'étais occupé,
03:42:22 mais j'ai bien hâte de voir les finales du U.S. Open.
03:42:26 Mike, number one, please.
03:42:29 Hi, Mr. Trudeau.
03:42:30 It's Annie Bergeron-Oliver with CTV National News.
03:42:33 Today, the other leaders criticized you and your government
03:42:35 for putting political goals above the well-being of Canada's Afghan allies.
03:42:40 Can you confidently say that this election,
03:42:42 the need to campaign right across the country,
03:42:45 in no way diverted your attention away from the situation in Afghanistan
03:42:49 and in no way slowed down Canada's evacuation response?
03:42:52 Yes, I can confidently say that.
03:42:54 I got regular briefings throughout the time, even as I was campaigning.
03:42:59 Our ministers were fully engaged, and mostly our Canadian Armed Forces, our diplomats,
03:43:04 our extraordinary consular affairs people continued to step up so we could get 17 flights out.
03:43:11 We engaged with the Qataris to make sure that more flights were coming out as this recent one came out.
03:43:18 We will continue to be there for the people of Afghanistan as Canadians expected to,
03:43:23 UNS Canadians open their homes and their communities to welcome 20, even 40,000 Afghan refugees
03:43:30 over the coming months. 0.91
03:43:32 Mic number two, please.
03:43:35 Hello, Mr. Trudeau.
03:43:38 I'm Alexander for Rebel News.
03:43:40 So, Mr. Trudeau, I'm going to talk quickly about what happened yesterday.
03:43:44 You have violated one of the rare media that doesn't receive money from the government.
03:43:50 Vous avez exprimé votre opinion en disant que nous propageons la désinformation.
03:43:56 Si c'était vrai et si c'était le cas, la Cour fédérale ne nous aurait pas permis d'être ici aujourd'hui.
03:44:02 Je suis moi-même scientifique et je me base sur les faits.
03:44:06 Ma question est la suivante.
03:44:08 L'Israël est l'un des pays les plus vaccinés au monde.
03:44:13 Ils sont rendus maintenant à leur quatrième rappel de vaccin.
03:44:16 They don't consider that those who have received two doses of vaccine are fully vaccinated.
03:44:22 My question is, many Canadians don't want to have a vaccine vaccine.
03:44:32 Will they remove their privileges related to the vaccine passport?
03:44:39 And, would you have to answer my question as Prime Minister, or would you still have to
03:44:46 destroy my media?
03:44:48 I shared my perspective on your organization this evening, I have nothing to say.
03:44:54 It asks you who you are. Thank you.
03:44:58 Question from the phone, please. The operator, is there a question?
03:45:03 Thank you. The next question is from Melanie Marquis, La Preche.
03:45:08 À vous la parole.
03:45:10 Merci.
03:45:11 Bonsoir, M. Trudeau.
03:45:12 Hier, au débat en français, vous avez fait une profession de foi québécoise bien sentie.
03:45:17 Aujourd'hui, le Québec, notamment la loi sur la laïcité, le projet de loi 96,
03:45:23 ont été attaqués par le truchement des questions d'animatrices.
03:45:27 Vous n'êtes pas intervenu.
03:45:28 Comment réconcilier le chef libéral d'hier et le chef libéral d'aujourd'hui?
03:45:34 First of all, I think we've all seen that the format prevented a little bit of an immediate response.
03:45:41 But I can say that first, the Quebecois and Canadians know my agreement with the Projet
03:45:47 of Law 21, but I can also say, as a proud Quebecois, that the Quebecois are not racist.
03:45:55 Mike, number one, please.
03:45:57 Thank you. Ben O. Schwinghammer with the German Press Agency, DPA.
03:46:00 Prime Minister, you and others have been facing in the last weeks
03:46:03 quite some hate on the campaign trail from a quite small but loud minority.
03:46:10 How would you say to deal with these people, listen to them or ignore them?
03:46:15 And do you think this hate is here to stay?
03:46:17 I think one of the things we need to make sure we're doing quite clearly
03:46:23 is making a distinction between those people who are showing up as mobs of anti-vaxxers
03:46:30 and protesting everything with racist and misogynistic anti-science approaches
03:46:36 and those millions of Canadians who haven't yet got vaccinated
03:46:40 because they still have questions and are unsure if it's right for them
03:46:44 or unsure if they really need to.
03:46:46 And our approach has been unequivocal on this.
03:46:49 We believe that people who have done the right thing, as almost 80% of Canadians have, and gotten vaccinated should be able to feel free from risk when they get on planes, when they get on trains, when they go into work.
03:47:05 And that's why we're working as well with the provinces on vaccine credentials that will allow people to enjoy non-essential services without fearing that their kid, who is seven and therefore not able to get vaccinated, could be exposed to someone who is.
03:47:23 We have to be very, very clear that we are a country of science in which millions of people have stood up to do the right thing for themselves and for their neighbors and continue to encourage that.
03:47:35 It's unfortunate that Aaron O'Toole can't even get his own candidates to get vaccinated
03:47:42 and pretends he wants 90% of Canadians to get vaccinated
03:47:46 when he can't guarantee 90% of his candidates are vaccinated, as I said during the debate.
03:47:53 Mike, number two, please.
03:47:54 That was quite the softball question from my friend over there,
03:47:57 so I'll try and ask a real one.
03:47:58 Kian Bextie with TheCounterSignal.com.
03:48:00 Mr. Trudeau, there has been some speculation that this poorly timed election
03:48:03 has been called in part so that you can stop Parliament, the former Parliament, from procuring
03:48:08 documents that they're constitutionally allowed to have in regards to the Communist Party
03:48:13 of China infiltrating the Winnipeg Lab that you are in control of, that you're responsible
03:48:18 for.
03:48:19 So I want to know, is it in Canada's national interest that you're protecting those documents?
03:48:23 Is it in China's national interest that you're protecting those documents?
03:48:25 Is it in your personal political interest that you're protecting those documents?
03:48:28 What are you trying to hide from not just Canadians but the world?
03:48:31 I think Canadians understand how important it is to protect national security and to
03:48:36 ensure that parliamentarians can oversee the work of our national security agencies.
03:48:42 That's why, as a commitment we made in 2015, we moved forward with something that conservatives
03:48:47 had always resisted, oversight by parliamentarians over our national security agencies.
03:48:54 And the National Security and Intelligence Committee of Parliamentarians actually works,
03:49:03 and we granted them full access to all the highly secure documents so as they could see
03:49:09 the decisions that our security professionals took and not put at risk the national security
03:49:17 of Canada.
03:49:18 Parliamentarians need to be able to do their work, which we have enabled, while we protect 0.87
03:49:23 Canada's national security from China and from others. 0.99
03:49:28 We'll take a question from the phone.
03:49:30 Zaire prend une question du téléphone au prêteur.
03:49:34 Thank you. The next question is from Raymond Filon, TVA.
03:49:38 Go ahead.
03:49:40 Merci, bonsoir, M. Trudeau.
03:49:41 Vous ventez depuis plusieurs semaines votre bonne entente avec le Premier ministre du Québec.
03:49:45 Or, aujourd'hui, François Legault a utilisé des mots très forts envers votre parti.
03:49:50 Il l'a qualifié de dangereux, inquiétant,
03:49:53 contre les valeurs de la nation québécoise.
03:49:55 Est-ce que c'est une trahison, selon vous,
03:49:57 ces propos-là de M. Legault aujourd'hui?
03:49:59 Non. On sait très bien que M. Legault va toujours défendre
03:50:04 ce qu'il voit comme étant les intérêts des Québécois.
03:50:07 Et, en tant que fier Québécois,
03:50:08 mais aussi en tant que premier ministre du Canada,
03:50:12 moi, je vais toujours défendre l'intérêt
03:50:14 de tous les Canadiens, incluant les Québécois.
03:50:17 But when we think about what the Québécois want and our values, I know enough to know that the Québécois do not want a conservative government
03:50:29 that will bring the targets of Mr. Harper and propose new pipelines across the country for the environment.
03:50:37 I know that the Québécois do not want to re-legalize,
03:50:42 to re-legalize, to re-legalize the weapons that we banned the past year. 0.73
03:50:47 I know that the Québécois, the Colombian families,
03:50:50 need more places in guardia,
03:50:53 and Mr. O'Toole propose to destroy the agreement
03:50:57 that I signed with Mr. Legault for 6 billion dollars
03:51:01 which will deliver tens of thousands of new places in guardia,
03:51:05 according to Mr. Legault.
03:51:07 I will always work in partnership with the Prime Minister of the province to deliver specifically for citizens.
03:51:15 But there is no one waiting for the federal government and provincial governments to agree, especially.
03:51:22 Mike Nguyen, please.
03:51:24 Hi, Mr. Trudeau, Abigail Beeman, Global News.
03:51:27 When your opponents criticized you tonight on Afghanistan, you gave a vague comment about helping to bring more people home.
03:51:33 wondering with the news of 43 Canadians coming out of Kabul, whether there's anything specific
03:51:37 you can offer about how many more Canadians are left to help, whether the government will send
03:51:41 planes, or whether there's any news about commercial air flights being able to leave there again.
03:51:47 As I've said, we have worked with our international partners on putting pressure on the Taliban to
03:51:52 allow Canadians, permanent residents, and indeed anyone with Canadian travel documents to leave.
03:52:00 And that's why over the past number of weeks, we've been talking with the Qataris specifically to enable facilitating Canadians leaving as they did just last night from Afghanistan.
03:52:13 We know there is much more to do, not just to get Canadians out, but to get the tens of thousands of Afghans that Canada is determined to welcome to a new home, new life in safety.
03:52:25 and Canadians quite frankly are excited about welcoming to their communities across the country.
03:52:32 Thank you very much. Merci beaucoup. This is all the time we have.
03:52:43 Interesting to see Justin Trudeau go up. He got two questions from independent media,
03:52:49 so we had a sort of long-winded triple question from the rebel, the French reporter there,
03:52:54 who asked this almost sounded like she was giving a speech but she was asking uh three distinct
03:52:59 questions trudeau just basically said i'm not going to answer that i already told you why
03:53:04 yesterday then the very next question came from kian bexy also an independent reporter also
03:53:10 a member of the independent press gallery of canada he asked a question about china and it
03:53:15 was really an interesting question because we don't really hear that much about the incident
03:53:19 that happened in the winnipeg lab we know that there's something there and that we're not being
03:53:22 he told it, but we don't really know. And so it was great to hear that question get put to Trudeau
03:53:28 and he actually addressed it. He didn't really answer it because Trudeau doesn't really answer
03:53:31 questions, but he didn't just completely say no to Kian Bextie and he answered it there. He seemed
03:53:37 pretty calm and confident just looking at his demeanor. It seemed like he felt like pretty
03:53:42 proud of himself and pretty good about his debate performance, just judging by his sort of smug
03:53:48 arrogance. But that's Trudeau, right? He seemed really agitated and really bothered during the
03:53:52 debate there. He seemed like he was back to his smug, arrogant self. And I just make one final 0.95
03:53:57 note. He had to go there once again. We could have had a drinking game. We didn't. We totally
03:54:03 dropped the ball tonight on the debate night drinking game. But if there had been a True
03:54:08 North drinking game, there would have been two points where we would have drank. But every time
03:54:11 Trudeau invoked the word Harper, which we got a Harper there. We got a couple of Harpers throughout
03:54:16 the course of the debate. And then also every time he called Canadians racist. And he called
03:54:21 Canadians racist, the ones that were protesting. So when, when there's angry conservatives is
03:54:25 because they're racist. Exactly. You know, Trudeau, uh, he doesn't like being, being
03:54:30 confronted in a, for, in a strong manner, right? That's why he, the debates, I think he got a
03:54:37 little flustered in the debate, especially when there was two or three leaders coming out of it
03:54:40 once and they were talking over each other. And it's why he doesn't really like the House of
03:54:43 Commons. Uh, and he tries to avoid it as much as possible. Um, but press conferences, he quite
03:54:49 likes him. Even questions from non-friendly reporters are generally not shouted in a way
03:54:54 that sort of knocks him off his game. He can take his time, respond to them, and he certainly was
03:54:58 much more sort of calm and collected here, even in the face of questions from non-friendly reporters
03:55:04 than he was during the debate. And it's, you know, so that's one of the reasons why we have so few
03:55:10 debates, right? You know, if Trudeau really loved debate or thought debate would add, we would have
03:55:15 more, he would agree to more debates. He would have gone to the city TV debate in Toronto
03:55:22 two years ago, or maybe he would have agreed to other debates. The Monk debates had talked
03:55:27 about having a foreign affairs debate at one point as well. But he doesn't like that, and
03:55:31 he knows he's on the defensive there, so that's why we don't have them, because he doesn't
03:55:35 want them.
03:55:36 Salih, what did you think, Sue-Ann?
03:55:37 Well, you know, I love the long-winded question from the French rebel reporter, or the rebel
03:55:46 reporter speaking French, on and on and on, and then he just basically dismissed her,
03:55:53 which is classic Trudeau, of course. It's rude. Trudeau the feminist refused to take a question
03:55:58 from the young female reporter. Yeah. Well, it was classic, but, you know, 1.00
03:56:02 he shows his true colors yes he was calm uh because he thinks he can work the room basically
03:56:09 but um there was no added value at all from any of his answers do you think i i when trudo talks
03:56:17 i don't really get a lot of information i just hear a lot of word salads and i was sort of more
03:56:22 the same all right we've got uh ndp leader jagmeet singh out here answering some questions so let's
03:56:27 Let's go back over to that scrum.
03:56:30 I'm ready to realize the goals.
03:56:33 What I'm saying, and I want to be so clear,
03:56:37 my goal is to fight for people.
03:56:39 That means to invest in people,
03:56:42 to invest in our health care,
03:56:44 to face the climate crisis.
03:56:46 And as Prime Minister,
03:56:48 I'm ready to work with anyone who wants to work with me
03:56:54 We will take a question from the phone, operator, is there a question from the phone, please?
03:57:07 Thank you.
03:57:08 The next question is from Sheila Gunn-Reed from Rebel News.
03:57:13 Please go ahead.
03:57:14 Thank you.
03:57:15 Mr. Singh, the polls show that your party is between 15% and 20%.
03:57:19 No party here on the stage tonight is even close to representing a majority of Canadians.
03:57:25 This is an absolute divided country.
03:57:28 Yet when Conservative journalists like me ask you fair questions on behalf of Canadians,
03:57:33 you insult us and refuse to answer a single word.
03:57:37 You are like a child putting your hands over your ears.
03:57:41 Do you really think you can become Prime Minister by trying to freeze out any Canadian who disagrees with you?
03:57:47 In your own riding, you only got 38% of the vote.
03:57:52 Is this how you treat the other 62% of people who disagree with you?
03:57:57 No. Thanks so much.
03:57:59 Mic number one, please. Sorry, mic number two.
03:58:03 Hi, Mr. Singh. Olivia Stefanovic, CBC News.
03:58:05 You were criticized in the debate for having a platform that lacks details.
03:58:10 I'm wondering why that is. Why is your plan so general?
03:58:13 And do you have any regrets about releasing a platform so early, even before this election was called, without the fine details for voters to read?
03:58:21 Not at all. We laid out a plan, a vision of what we stand for.
03:58:25 And our plan is, not surprisingly, a lot of the things that we fought for before because Mr. Trudeau didn't do them.
03:58:32 We still believe that people should have access to medication and they shouldn't worry about how they can afford it.
03:58:37 We believe strongly that people shouldn't have to worry about whether they can afford or have coverage to get dental cover, dental care.
03:58:45 We absolutely believe that we need to make the ultra-rich pay their fair share.
03:58:49 And these continue to be really pressing questions on the minds of lots of people who can't afford their medication, who can't afford dental care, and are worried about who pays for the recovery and who pays the price of this pandemic.
03:59:00 We are the only party with a credible plan that says we're not going to cut the help
03:59:05 that people receive, and we're not going to put the burden back on the people that have
03:59:09 struggled.
03:59:10 We are the only party that clearly states we're going to make the billionaires, the
03:59:15 44 richest billionaires in Canada.
03:59:18 We increased their wealth by $78 billion in this pandemic and don't pay their share.
03:59:23 We're going to make them start paying their fair share, and that way we can invest it
03:59:26 in people.
03:59:27 to be clear, though, Mr. Trudeau and Mr. O'Toole have ruled that out. They have voted against
03:59:32 making web giants like Amazon pay their fair share, and that means they're either going to
03:59:37 cut the help that you need or put the pressure back on the people that have already struggled.
03:59:42 That's their plan. We have a different approach. Back on the people that have already struggled.
03:59:48 That's their plan. We have a different approach. Mike, number one, please.
03:59:54 Yeah, good evening, Mr. Singh, Ryan Hamilton, National Post.
03:59:57 You are voting tomorrow.
03:59:59 Canadians are beginning to vote tomorrow.
04:00:00 Yes.
04:00:01 Your party has not released a fully-costed platform at this point.
04:00:04 Do you think it's fair to Canadians to ask them to vote for you
04:00:07 without knowing what it will cost?
04:00:10 Yes, it is very fair, and I want Canadians to vote.
04:00:12 I'm going to be voting tomorrow, and if you want different results,
04:00:15 you're going to have to vote differently.
04:00:17 If you want the things that we believe in and that we're putting out,
04:00:20 you have to vote for it, so I want you all to get out and vote, please.
04:00:23 What we're saying to Canadians is,
04:00:26 we are putting a choice to you all.
04:00:28 And it's Canadians to decide this,
04:00:30 but the choice is,
04:00:31 can you afford another four more years
04:00:33 of Mr. Trudeau,
04:00:34 who has made a lot of promises
04:00:36 and broken them,
04:00:37 and that hurts people.
04:00:38 When he promised to bring in pharmacare
04:00:40 and breaks that promise
04:00:41 and walks away from it,
04:00:42 families continue to spend
04:00:44 thousands of dollars on medications.
04:00:46 People who need medication
04:00:47 constantly have to make the choice
04:00:49 between the medications that they need
04:00:51 or paying the bills that they also have to pay.
04:00:54 Those are choices that people continue to have to make
04:00:57 because Mr. Trudeau breaks those commitments.
04:00:59 So if you truly want universal pharmacare,
04:01:02 if you want to see childcare delivered,
04:01:05 if you want to see dental care,
04:01:06 the best way to make that happen
04:01:08 is to vote for New Democrats because we will deliver.
04:01:11 We are committed to it.
04:01:12 We are the party that's been founded by workers
04:01:14 and founded on the principles of healthcare that's public.
04:01:18 We are going to do it.
04:01:19 So if you need it and that's something that matters to you,
04:01:21 you can trust us to deliver it.
04:01:23 And we will go to the phones.
04:01:25 Operator, is there a question on the phone?
04:01:28 Thank you.
04:01:31 The next question is from Tom McCharles from the Toronto Star.
04:01:35 Please go ahead.
04:01:37 Hi, Mr Singh, thanks for taking my question.
04:01:39 Just following up on the lack of detail in your platform on costs and timelines and stuff,
04:01:45 the Liberals say that their childcare plans will cut fees in half next year
04:01:49 and they'll have $10 a day daycare by 2026?
04:01:54 You're promising $10 a day daycare as well,
04:01:57 but with no details, what's your timeline for that?
04:02:00 And are you pegging the same amount of money, $30 billion?
04:02:05 So I think it's a really important question.
04:02:08 What the Liberals have laid out, the plan is a good plan.
04:02:12 The problem, and so we would want to meet or exceed that type of deadline.
04:02:18 But the reality is, the real timeline of the Liberals is 30 years, because they started
04:02:24 promising this idea, which we absolutely believe in, 30 years ago.
04:02:30 And they have made people wait for three decades, despite having majority governments, despite
04:02:36 having the ability to get things done, they have made people wait for 30 years.
04:02:40 So I should say, we're not going to have the Liberal timelines of 30 years.
04:02:44 Our timeline is going to be to get it done as quickly as possible, because we know that
04:02:47 people need it. We believe in it. And I also put this to Canadians. If Mr. Trudeau really wanted
04:02:54 to get it done, why did he call an election? Why didn't he continue to deliver, knowing that we
04:03:00 would have supported any measure to bring in childcare? We could have got it done. He chose
04:03:06 an election instead. Folks should consider that when they're making their choice in this election.
04:03:11 If Mr. Trudeau wanted to do it, he could have. Why is he campaigning on it rather than actually
04:03:16 delivering it, working on delivering
04:03:18 it, making it happen.
04:03:21 Mic number two, please.
04:03:23 Hi, Mr. Singh. Benjamin Stephen,
04:03:24 the Charlatan, the Carleton University student
04:03:26 newspaper. Tonight, Mr. Trudeau
04:03:28 said your cynicism towards his government's
04:03:30 reconciliation work is damaging efforts.
04:03:33 How do you respond to this statement? 0.91
04:03:35 I mean, it's a pretty ludicrous thing 0.98
04:03:36 to say. What's damaging
04:03:38 reconciliation
04:03:40 is Mr. Trudeau
04:03:42 looking Indigenous people in the eyes and saying
04:03:44 I'm going to deliver clean drinking water 1.00
04:03:46 and then breaking that promise,
04:03:49 breaking that promise to the people of Nishkandiga,
04:03:51 breaking that promise to little B, a 12-year-old girl
04:03:54 who is fighting for clean drinking water in Canada
04:03:58 in the 21st century
04:04:00 because she's never seen that in her life.
04:04:04 She has never known what it's like to turn the tap on
04:04:07 and to be able to drink the water.
04:04:08 She is fighting for clean drinking water
04:04:10 because Mr. Trudeau promised to deliver it six years ago
04:04:15 and said it would happen by 2021
04:04:17 and then walked away from that commitment.
04:04:19 While at the same time,
04:04:21 in the beginning weeks of this pandemic,
04:04:23 he leapt to provide $750 billion in backstops
04:04:29 to the wealthiest banks in Canada.
04:04:31 That's what's eroding public trust.
04:04:35 That's cynical.
04:04:37 Thank you.
04:04:38 That's all the time we have.
04:04:39 Merci beaucoup.
04:04:40 Thanks so much.
04:04:41 I was ready for more.
04:04:42 I was excited, but that's all the time we have.
04:04:45 Thank you, Vic.
04:04:51 Well, I feel like Jagmeet Singh is just really in his element.
04:04:53 I remember during the last campaign watching him and just seeing him struggle,
04:04:57 and he just didn't seem like a very effective leader.
04:04:58 And I could almost say it's the exact opposite now.
04:05:01 Watching him come out, he's energetic.
04:05:02 He's obviously a character, right?
04:05:04 He's a little bit of a weird guy.
04:05:05 But he was really amicable, answering questions really clearly.
04:05:10 He had a couple of really strong pitches in there for the sort of swing voters
04:05:14 as to why not to go to Trudeau and why to go over to the NDP.
04:05:18 I think Jagmeet's really coming into his own as a leader.
04:05:21 It's good for the Conservatives, obviously,
04:05:22 because the stronger the NDP vote, the worse it is for the Liberals.
04:05:26 There was an interesting moment there where Sheila Gunn-Reed,
04:05:28 the rebel reporter, really started calling him out
04:05:32 on his inability to engage with people on the other side.
04:05:36 This is a theme that we sort of talked about,
04:05:38 how if you're on the right,
04:05:40 if you're kind of more of a hardcore Conservative
04:05:42 or more on the right wing, far right, you don't really have a place in Canada.
04:05:46 It's really weird the way that right wingers get demonized and Trudeau called them racist in the last bit
04:05:51 and here Singh again refusing to answer Sheila Gunn-Reed's question.
04:05:55 I think that it's unfortunate that he wouldn't even engage with Sheila
04:05:59 and again unfortunate that the left in this country has such a negative view of their political opponents.
04:06:06 It's a common theme at every level of government
04:06:09 And I certainly experienced it during my career as a journalist with Post Media.
04:06:15 And I think it's wrong.
04:06:17 I think that, you know, they talk about free speech.
04:06:21 They talk about being open and accountable.
04:06:24 And also inclusive and diversity.
04:06:27 And they're the most intolerant.
04:06:28 Some of those politicians from the NDP side of things are the most intolerant.
04:06:34 You know, I had NDP politicians bragging that they were blocking me on social media like it was some big game or competition.
04:06:44 So, I mean, I didn't think he handled that well.
04:06:48 And the other thing, I mean, he is a character.
04:06:51 He is really a character, but it's always that tax the rich thing that drives me crazy.
04:06:57 Right.
04:06:57 And, you know, they talk about it at the provincial level.
04:07:00 It's always the same thing.
04:07:02 Well, it's like a super simplistic idea, right?
04:07:05 It's like, oh, there's these 47 billionaires in the country,
04:07:07 so all we have to do is tax them.
04:07:09 It's like, well, you know that the deficit is, what, $350 billion?
04:07:13 So even if you took all the money from all those billionaires,
04:07:16 it wouldn't even be, like, the debt is a trillion dollars.
04:07:19 It wouldn't even do a dent towards the debt.
04:07:21 Like, we have a huge spending problem in this country.
04:07:23 You can't just say, like, oh, let's, like, you know,
04:07:26 we talk about how they demonize conservatives.
04:07:28 They really demonize billionaires.
04:07:29 I know.
04:07:30 And they really, really, you know, if there's one group of people that it's totally socially acceptable to just say, like, the nastiest things about, it's these billionaires.
04:07:38 And it's like, what are you going to do, take all their money?
04:07:39 They're the ones that are, in many ways, leading these huge companies and leading the growth.
04:07:43 They're job creators.
04:07:44 Right, exactly.
04:07:45 They're creating things that aren't there.
04:07:47 And it's like, we're going to go after these people.
04:07:49 Well, what's your economy going to look like after that?
04:07:51 Well, and not only that, you won't get it because the split second, it looks like you actually are going to get any of their money.
04:07:56 These people are extraordinarily sophisticated and their money will be offshore.
04:07:59 I don't know where it'll be.
04:08:01 I just feel it'll be out of reach somewhere.
04:08:04 Right.
04:08:04 Right, in a very, very short order.
04:08:07 Yeah, I think he had some effective lines.
04:08:09 I think your point, there were a couple of points in that Q&A.
04:08:12 He really laid out his pitch saying, here's why you should vote for me.
04:08:15 And, you know, for a long, long time, I remember in the last election,
04:08:20 the NDP campaign manager saying to me that the problem was that her voters
04:08:26 like Justin Trudeau too much, and that one of the problems is that every time they try
04:08:30 to take a shot at Justin Trudeau as the NDP, their own members would call up and complain
04:08:34 and say we're being mean, we're being like the Tories, et cetera, et cetera, et cetera.
04:08:37 And part of, I think, Trudeau's decline of popularity in the last month or so hasn't
04:08:43 just been conservative liberal switches being turned off of him, it's by NDPers being turned
04:08:48 off of him in a way that wasn't true two years ago and certainly wasn't true six years ago.
04:08:52 And as a result, that's given, in the NDP world, that's given Jagmeet and his campaign team the license to go more aggressive.
04:08:59 You know, we've seen attack ads on Twitter.
04:09:01 I mean, my Facebook, I live in a riding that's an NDP liberal switcher riding.
04:09:05 And my Facebook is full of NDP attack ads on liberals.
04:09:08 Some of them are more effective than others, but it's something we certainly didn't see in the past.
04:09:13 And Jagmeet, you know, did a couple of sort of drive-by smears on O'Toole tonight.
04:09:20 But he was really not the main target. Trudeau was his main target.
04:09:23 And we'll see if it works because the fact of the matter is that Singh had a good English debate in the last election
04:09:29 and there was all this talk that his numbers were going to go up
04:09:32 and then Trudeau was able to pull a whole bunch of those votes back to the Liberals at the end.
04:09:37 So for this, it's all about Singh winning those last two weeks
04:09:40 and making sure the NDP gets 21 or 22 percent and not 16 or 17.
04:09:46 I think if he's going to draw the Liberal vote, he was very effective tonight in presenting the reasons why he should.
04:09:55 And I think it's out there to be drawn.
04:09:58 I mean, he could, in fact, steal back those supporters.
04:10:03 I certainly sense that.
04:10:04 Sure.
04:10:05 Well, it's interesting, just to your point, that the NDP doesn't want to be too harsh on the Liberals because the NDP voters like them.
04:10:10 There are several times in that debate where I heard Jagmeet Singh say that he liked the liberal plan or that the liberal had a good idea or that he agreed with it.
04:10:18 And it's almost a little jarring watching a debate because you're so used to people saying, no, your plan's wrong.
04:10:24 This is why my plan's better. And it was it was weird to see Singh do that a few times.
04:10:27 But given that context you just gave, it kind of makes sense that at the end of the day, the NDP and the liberals agree on most things.
04:10:35 It's just a matter of like, how are we going to get to these same end goals?
04:10:38 Well, and not even how, but off just the timeline.
04:10:41 Somebody once said NDPs are just liberals in a hurry, right?
04:10:47 If the liberals say we'll do it in 10 years, NDPs say we'll do it in three, right?
04:10:50 And that's the big difference to them.
04:10:52 And I think that's a really interesting point, Candice, because he might agree with the liberal plan,
04:10:56 and he often says he agreed with Trudeau's intentions, but not his record in actually getting there,
04:11:00 which is, I think, where the NDP has clearly discovered that's their effective line of attack.
04:11:05 We say we can't criticize Trudeau's intentions because our voters won't believe that he's a bad man not trying to do these things.
04:11:11 But we can say he's been ineffective at delivering on the things that we care about.
04:11:15 Right, and that was that great line that Singh just had, saying that, look, you could have been implementing a national, I think it was pharmacare that he was talking about, but instead you call this election.
04:11:25 So, you know, you've been promising this thing for the last 30 years, and the liberals have, and Trudeau has in his political career.
04:11:31 instead of going and implementing it and working with the NDP.
04:11:33 This is a question that I wish that someone would have asked Jagmeet,
04:11:36 and it's interesting because usually the legacy media is so interested in process questions,
04:11:41 process questions, figuring out, you know, what's the strategic thing to do.
04:11:46 I was surprised when no one asked him whether he would be willing to prop up another Trudeau liberal minority
04:11:50 because given that that was what we just had, if Trudeau again wins a minority government,
04:11:55 I think it will be a huge loss for the liberals.
04:11:57 It will be a huge loss for Trudeau because he created this vanity election.
04:12:00 He's spending, what, $650 million on this election.
04:12:03 If the result is exactly the same, I think that that is a loss for Trudeau,
04:12:07 and he should be shamed and probably removed from his office.
04:12:10 He'll be gone, don't you think?
04:12:11 I think the Liberals would have good reason to try to remove him as leader, and Canadians too.
04:12:15 So it would be worth asking Jagmeet, are you going to prop this guy up again,
04:12:19 given that you just had propped him up, you could have worked together,
04:12:22 but instead he chose the election for the purpose of not having the NDP as a coalition partner,
04:12:28 an informal coalition partner.
04:12:30 So I'm a little surprised that no one asked him that question.
04:12:34 All right, we have Green Party anime, Paul.
04:12:37 I think this is probably just wrapping up soon,
04:12:39 but we can go to her for a minute and then we will wrap it up here.
04:12:42 It's the moment, finally, to go to the root,
04:12:46 to talk about discrimination, to talk about poverty,
04:12:50 to talk about affordable housing,
04:12:55 to talk about equity in our society.
04:12:59 It's like that we attack the crimes of criminal acts and that's how we avoid what we have now. 0.99
04:13:08 It's a representation of the indigenous peoples and also the black diaspora in our criminal justice system. 1.00
04:13:18 Mic number one please.
04:13:20 Good evening Ms. Paul, Justin Ling, freelance.
04:13:23 I want to hear you talk a bit about the exchange you had with Mr. Blanchet. 0.99
04:13:27 As you noted earlier, you're the first racialized woman to wind up or to earn her way out of this debate stage.
04:13:36 What was your reaction to sort of being hectored by the bloc leader over supposedly, I think in his words, as he said earlier, calling Quebecers altogether racist?
04:13:50 I'm not sure he said that in this.
04:13:52 Oh, he said it out here for sure.
04:13:53 Oh, did he?
04:13:54 Okay. I wasn't watching it, so I don't know what he said,
04:13:57 and I certainly didn't say that.
04:13:59 I mean, I have a great respect for the people of Quebec.
04:14:08 When I was speaking, when I was on the debate stage with Mr. Blanchet,
04:14:14 I simply made the point that if he is interested in learning more
04:14:20 about the experience of people like myself
04:14:22 or those who have said very clearly that systemic discrimination exists.
04:14:26 And let's keep in mind that the United Nations,
04:14:29 their working group on people of African descent,
04:14:31 said just a few years ago that systemic racism exists here.
04:14:35 Our Supreme Court has also acknowledged that systemic racism exists,
04:14:40 and we can see it in the data as well.
04:14:42 So if you would like to learn more about our experience,
04:14:44 then I, again, extend my hand in friendship and in understanding toward him.
04:14:50 Mic number two, please.
04:14:53 Good evening. I'm Jenna Kokula with The Wire Report.
04:14:56 Today, a member of your party tweeted that the Green Party was calling for a reversal of the CRTC's wholesale decision.
04:15:04 I'm just wondering if this is an official party policy and...
04:15:07 Sorry, which decision?
04:15:08 The wholesale decision.
04:15:09 Okay. No, not as far as I know. I wasn't aware of that.
04:15:15 I'd have to see the details, but based on what you're saying there, that would not be the case.
04:15:19 And what are your thoughts on how to lower internet bills?
04:15:23 Oh boy, this is, you know, we have a section in our platform dedicated to this.
04:15:27 We know that this is one of these unfulfilled pieces of business.
04:15:31 We need to invest in ensuring that every single community has access
04:15:35 and affordable access to high-speed broadband service.
04:15:40 We've seen during the pandemic, even in neighbourhoods like Toronto Centre,
04:15:45 which is a, you know, deeply urban,
04:15:46 that there are many people that simply don't have access
04:15:49 to what we have to agree now is an essential service.
04:15:52 We know that it's holding back rural and remote communities as well.
04:15:56 And so in the next session of Parliament,
04:15:58 it has to be a top priority to get that job done.
04:16:02 And those who want to take a look at our platform
04:16:04 will see our proposals for how we would do that.
04:16:07 Certainly, we need to have a greater diversity of providers as well
04:16:11 that's part of the solution.
04:16:13 We'll go to the phones.
04:16:15 operator? Is there a question
04:16:17 on the phone? Operators, there's a question from the phone.
04:16:21 Thank you.
04:16:22 Yes, the next question
04:16:23 is from David Menzies from
04:16:25 Rebel News. Please go ahead.
04:16:27 Your line is open.
04:16:29 Good evening, Ms. Paul. I hope you're doing well.
04:16:31 Ms. Paul, clearly this debate
04:16:33 is an insider's club
04:16:35 for the political establishment.
04:16:38 It banned
04:16:39 Maxime Bernier of the People's Party
04:16:41 of Canada, even though
04:16:43 he was ahead of the Bloc Quebec law and Jerome party, the Green party in the polls. It banned
04:16:50 me and Rebel News from even reporting until the federal court said that was illegal. Why have you
04:16:59 not spoken out against this? Don't you think all voices should be heard in Canada? Thank you for
04:17:08 Thank you for the question.
04:17:11 We did have an opportunity to provide recommendations
04:17:15 to the commission establishing the rules for the debates.
04:17:19 And certainly from our perspective,
04:17:22 having more debates is incredibly important.
04:17:25 It is incredibly disappointing
04:17:26 that we only had two hours to discuss so many important issues.
04:17:31 We spent, I think, 10 minutes or 20 minutes
04:17:35 It's talking about Indigenous peoples, for instance.
04:17:38 I don't think we spent even 10 minutes speaking about Afghanistan.
04:17:41 So we can see what this new system has created.
04:17:45 It's created less opportunities for people in Canada to get to know the parties,
04:17:49 to get to know the leaders of those parties, to get to know our positions.
04:17:54 That's not a good thing for democracy.
04:17:56 In the case of those parties who are not included,
04:18:01 I think we do need to find a way for small parties who are trying to establish themselves
04:18:05 to have a way of participating and getting known.
04:18:09 Otherwise, we do have the same old parties constantly monopolizing the discussion.
04:18:16 That's all the time we have.
04:18:18 C'est tout le temps que nous avons. Merci beaucoup. Thank you.
04:18:20 Merci beaucoup.
04:18:22 I wish I had to wrap it up.
04:18:23 Oh, I just thought she made the most...
04:18:25 All right. Well, thank you so much, everyone, for tuning in.
04:18:28 This has been True North's live election debate night.
04:18:31 I think we're into hour five.
04:18:32 It's past midnight here in Toronto.
04:18:34 I've got to get home to my little kids.
04:18:37 But Hamish Marshall and Sue Ann Levy, it's been such a pleasure.
04:18:39 It's so great to sit down and talk with you.
04:18:42 Just a quick reaction.
04:18:43 I thought that it was great that Anna Mae Paul finished on that note,
04:18:46 sort of echoing what we've said here.
04:18:48 And I don't expect to have a lot in common in terms of our policy visions for the country.
04:18:53 But the way that she just stood up and said, this debate hasn't worked.
04:18:57 This hasn't been a very good idea.
04:18:59 you know, we didn't cover enough ground, we didn't cover enough issues, we didn't have enough time,
04:19:03 we didn't include enough people. That's absolutely right. So good for Anime Paul for finishing.
04:19:08 On that note, to the folks at home who are still tuning in, you know, thank you so much for giving
04:19:13 us so much of your time this evening. I hope you enjoyed our analysis. Again, if you want to support
04:19:17 the work that we do at True North, we have investigative journalists, we've been putting
04:19:21 out exclusive reports every single day of this campaign. We've broken some really big stories,
04:19:24 really important stuff. We do podcasts every day, videos every day. We put out documentaries. We do
04:19:30 a lot of really interesting journalism over there. So go check it out at tnc.news if you're so
04:19:34 inclined. Please consider making a small donation to keep events like this going. And we will be
04:19:41 back again on election night. We're going to do a very similar type of program. So hope to see you
04:19:46 again on election night. Otherwise, I'll be back with the Candace Malcolm show tomorrow. Thanks
04:19:51 again for tuning in and have a lovely evening everybody good night good night
04:20:21 We'll be right back.
04:20:51 We'll be right back.
04:21:21 We'll be right back.
04:21:51 Thank you.
04:22:21 We'll be right back.
04:22:51 We'll be right back.
04:23:21 Thank you.