Juno News - February 16, 2019


Liberal bill removes "advocating terrorism offences" from Criminal Code

Hosted by
Mentioned
Is it time for Justin Trudeau to become his own man? Justin Trudeau is fighting to impose a TAX on Canadians

Episode Stats


Length

7 minutes

Words per minute

167.35

Word count

1,297

Sentence count

59


Summary

Summaries generated with gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ .

Bill C-59 would make it illegal to advocate or promote the commission of terrorism offences under the Criminal Code. But what would happen if someone counseled someone to commit an act of terrorism? And who would be the person counseled?

Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:01 When former Prime Minister Stephen Harper put C-51, the government of the day's sweeping overhaul of national security laws into effect,
00:00:10 the left said that it was too broad, too sweeping, and didn't have enough of an emphasis on civil liberties.
00:00:17 Well, the Liberals' answer to C-51 is working its way through the parliamentary process right now.
00:00:23 Bill C-59, an act respecting national security matters. Right now, it is in the Senate Defense and National Security Committee.
00:00:31 It's been there since about December, and there's a lot of work to be done going through the details of this, of which there are many.
00:00:38 The act will go over about a dozen different acts, including the Criminal Code and other national security-related laws, and make changes.
00:00:48 Some of them are minor, and I think amenable to both sides, but there's one buried in this that has gotten virtually no media attention
00:00:54 that could have some very devastating consequences in the fight against terrorism.
00:00:59 If you look in Part 7, Section 143 of Bill C-59, it says the following.
00:01:06 Section 83.221 of the act, that's referring to the Criminal Code, is replaced by the following.
00:01:13 This section is going to be replacing an existing section of the Criminal Code, one that was put in there under C-51 during Stephen Harper's government reign.
00:01:39 And what we see here doesn't sound unreasonable to be an offence.
00:01:43 Yes, it should be a crime for someone to counsel another person to commit an act of terror.
00:01:48 But to understand why this has so many problems associated with it, we need to look at what it is in the Criminal Code that this section is going to be replacing.
00:01:57 And that section is as titled now, Advocating or Promoting Commission of Terrorism Offences.
00:02:03 Everyone who, by communicating statements, knowingly advocates or promotes the commission of terrorism offences in general, other than an offence under this section,
00:02:13 while knowing that any of those offences will be committed or being reckless as to whether any of those offences may be committed,
00:02:20 as a result of such communication is guilty of an indictable offence and is liable to imprisonment for a term of not more than five years.
00:02:29 Now, I know that's very government speak, but what it means is that under the current laws, it is a crime to advocate, even in general terms, the commission of terrorism offences.
00:02:39 So you could have a radical hate preacher, like we've seen many reports of, that gets up in front of his mosque and starts giving people a call to arms.
00:02:47 You could have someone who doesn't even have an organised mosque, who calls themselves a spiritual leader and goes on YouTube and advocates in general terms for the commission of terrorist offences.
00:02:57 Under the current law, that's illegal. Under a plain text reading of the proposed law by the Liberals, that would no longer be a crime.
00:03:05 Now, I'm not the first person to have raised these concerns.
00:03:09 And what Shimon Koffler Fogel raised in his testimony and in his Globe and Mail op-ed, was that in response to a provision that the government thinks is too broad,
00:03:17 their remedy is one that's too specific. A plain text reading of it requires that someone counsels another person.
00:03:25 This implies, Mr. Koffler Fogel suggested, a knowledge of who that person is in a very specific counselling.
00:03:32 Whereas advocating or promoting could take place in more general terms, in front of an audience or in front of a computer screen,
00:03:39 where you know people are going to see it, but you don't specifically know who those people are.
00:03:44 Now, I put these concerns to Public Safety Canada, which is the department that's tasked with driving this law through.
00:03:50 And this is the statement that was provided.
00:03:53 Bill C-59 does not propose to remove the advocating terrorism offence, but rather proposes to amend it.
00:03:59 As originally enacted, the existing offence of advocating or promoting the commission of terrorism offences in general,
00:04:06 seeks to prohibit the act of encouragement of the commission of terrorism offences generally,
00:04:12 rather than the commission of specific terrorist offences.
00:04:15 However, this formulation has been criticised as being too vague.
00:04:19 As a result, Bill C-59 proposes to clarify the offence using a well-known concept in criminal law,
00:04:25 so that it would apply where a person counsels, actively encourages another person to commit a terrorism offence,
00:04:32 without identifying a specific terrorism offence.
00:04:35 It would also apply whether or not a terrorism offence is committed by the person who is counseled.
00:04:41 So, the concerns that they're trying to ameliorate are, in short, that this would take a law that, right now,
00:04:49 exists for people that counsel or advocate or promote terrorism in general terms
00:04:55 and restrict it to the one-on-one counselling or the small group counselling.
00:04:59 And even in the explanation from Public Safety Canada's spokesperson, they talk about another person,
00:05:05 that a specific person has to be on the receiving end of this.
00:05:09 Not only does this law open the door for someone to essentially get away with openly and proudly advocating terrorism,
00:05:17 but doing so is not even consistent with other provisions of the law.
00:05:21 This is what Shimon Koffler Fogel said in his testimony before Parliament.
00:05:25 When it comes to the offence of instructing a terrorist activity, which is a different offence,
00:05:29 the criminal code is explicit.
00:05:31 The offence is committed whether or not the accused instructs a particular person to carry out the activity,
00:05:38 or even knows the identity of the person instructed to carry out the activity.
00:05:42 The same standards should apply to the counselling offence.
00:05:46 So when we look at instructing terror activity, which, by the way, is one that we saw charges very similar to
00:05:53 in the context of the Kingston bomb threat that was averted by RCMP just a couple of weeks ago,
00:05:59 you have in a separate but very similar law no requirement that a specific person has to be the target of such counsel.
00:06:07 But under Bill C-59, it needs to be directed to a specific person.
00:06:12 And knowing how terror cells operate, where you have different groups in isolation,
00:06:17 they may not even know the identity of other people involved, there may be a glaring loophole here.
00:06:22 Now, it's entirely possible this oversight is accidental.
00:06:25 Except even when this concern has been brought to the government, in the media, in testimony before Parliament,
00:06:31 in my request to public safety, there seems to be no willingness to accept.
00:06:35 Which raises the question of why the government is deliberately loosening the laws surrounding terrorism.
00:06:41 Now, I'm a free speech absolutist.
00:06:43 I believe that people should have the right to hold controversial opinions.
00:06:46 The extent to free speech is always the promotion of violence.
00:06:51 Advocating terrorism is a very clear-cut example of that.
00:06:55 But we have a government now that is so hell-bent on striking this balance between civil liberties and national security,
00:07:02 which is an important balance that they seem to be erring more heavily on the side of ignoring one of the most common ways that terrorist messages are now spread,
00:07:11 which is through the internet, through radical preachers.
00:07:14 And by doing this, we see a logically inconsistent position with a country that supposedly,
00:07:19 we're being told by Trudeau and his government, is taking these concerns very seriously.
00:07:24 True North is at the forefront of these battles, investigating in ways the mainstream media isn't.
00:07:29 It's important work, and we can't do it alone. We do need your help.
00:07:32 Please consider joining the Heritage Club or the Patriot Club. Links are in the description box here.
00:07:37 And with a small monthly contribution, letting us keep working for you and your rights as Canadians.
00:07:43 For True North, I'm Andrew Lawton.