Juno News - May 09, 2023


Liberal members want Trudeau to restrict free speech online

Topics
Mentioned
Justin Trudeau has LOST THE PLOT! Is Twitter the future of media?

Episode Stats


Length

37 minutes

Words per minute

186.66

Word count

7,084

Sentence count

338

Harmful content

Misogyny

8

sentences flagged

Toxicity

4

sentences flagged

Hate speech

4

sentences flagged


Summary

Summaries generated with gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ .

In this episode of Canada's Most Irreverent Talk Show, host Andrew Lawton takes a look back at the Liberal Party's policy resolutions from the party's convention in Vancouver this past weekend, and considers whether or not the World Health Organization should just shut up and go take a long walk off a short pier.

Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Topics generated with Qwen2.5-3B-Instruct.
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 Welcome to Canada's Most Irreverent Talk Show.
00:00:05 This is the Andrew Lawton Show, brought to you by True North.
00:00:14 Hello everyone and welcome to you all.
00:00:17 This is Canada's Most Irreverent Talk Show, the Andrew Lawton Show here on True North.
00:00:22 On this Tuesday, May 9th, just after 4.02 Eastern Time.
00:00:27 Every now and then we had, well, maybe it just happened the once, but I'm going to roll with it as every now and then we get like the truthers that think it's not actually live.
00:00:35 And I keep meaning to get like a print copy of a newspaper, except I try to avoid leaving the house and I don't want to get a subscription to have one delivered here.
00:00:43 So I can instead show you the, I can't show you the date on my phone because I have like texts that I don't want you to read that are on my home screen.
00:00:51 There we go. So we are actually live today, and we try to be as much as possible simply because things happen at such a breakneck speed, it's difficult to otherwise keep up with them.
00:01:02 But I do want to today take a little bit of a look back at the Liberal Convention this weekend and some of the policy resolutions that the Liberal Party members of Canada have decided to call on their government and their Prime Minister to put into effect.
00:01:18 I also want to talk about some other things that are happening.
00:01:20 We'll get our friend Rachel Emanuel back on for a check-in on what's happening in Alberta politics
00:01:25 and the politicization of the horrific wildfires that are taking place there.
00:01:30 But I want to begin by talking about something that I hope, in spite of everything else in the world,
00:01:35 we can all unite on, and that is that the World Health Organization needs to just butt out,
00:01:41 shut up, and go take a long walk off a short pier.
00:01:45 I don't know if you criticize the World Health Organization, if you get like the misinformation label slapped on you now, but we'll see. 0.77
00:01:51 It might even be appearing in real time below on YouTube and Facebook. 0.61
00:01:55 But the Killjoys at the World Health Organization came out with this observation just this past weekend.
00:02:04 They say there is no safe level of alcohol consumption.
00:02:09 Their argument is that the risk of cancer increases even with low levels of alcohol consumption.
00:02:16 So you are not allowed to have any alcohol, apparently, even just a little bit.
00:02:21 You were supposed to keep that graphic up.
00:02:23 Oh, goodness.
00:02:24 Well, OK, well, we've already just dispensed with the idea.
00:02:27 This is not a World Health Organization edition, approved edition of The Andrew Lawton Show here.
00:02:32 So I'm going to raise a glass to the killjoys at the WHO and be utterly ignorant of their advice.
00:02:39 Let me just take a sip here so I can get through the rest of the show.
00:02:44 Oh, lovely.
00:02:46 Buttery, a little bit oaky, not too much.
00:02:49 And best of all, not approved by the World Health Organization.
00:02:53 The argument that, by the way, normally I guess I could fill up this thing with wine.
00:02:57 There has been a bit of a controversy on the True North team.
00:03:01 One of our colleagues thinks that the mugs are too heavy.
00:03:04 So he's actually, when it's full, not sufficiently strong to like lift the mug up to drink it.
00:03:09 So we thought we maybe need to add like a second handle on it.
00:03:12 Or you can just fill it with wine.
00:03:14 But I'm going with the coffee in the mug, wine in the glass,
00:03:17 and Klaus Schwab and Dr. Ted Ross standing over heckling me on the sidelines here.
00:03:22 But the reason I want to bring up that World Health Organization tweet is twofold.
00:03:26 Number one, I wanted an excuse to sip my wine in the middle of the show.
00:03:31 Lovely.
00:03:33 And number two, there are going to be some of you like assessing how much it goes down
00:03:37 as the show progresses.
00:03:38 And like when it gets to zero, I might need to like throw on a commercial break and like
00:03:42 go and refill it.
00:03:42 So you don't know.
00:03:43 But that was the number one.
00:03:44 Number two, and this is, I think the most important thing, the World Health Organization
00:03:49 bureaucrats were the ones who largely were responsible for making it.
00:03:53 So we couldn't travel, we couldn't work, we couldn't leave our homes for much of the
00:03:58 last three years.
00:03:58 So the one little joy that someone might have, which is being able to, I don't know, just sit back and have a cocktail with a friend or have a glass of wine over dinner or have a beer when you sit at the side of the pool because you're not allowed to go anywhere else, to which they now say, even that you shouldn't do.
00:04:14 That's just too dangerous, too much of a risk.
00:04:16 Well, the one way we delegitimize authority is by not abiding by authority.
00:04:21 I'm not even a drinker.
00:04:21 I'm like drinking on principle right now just to spite the World Health Organization, and I would encourage you to do the same.
00:04:28 Let's talk about some of the more pressing issues of our time, though.
00:04:31 If you follow British media, which is sometimes very significant,
00:04:36 I mean, I know we have our own problems here,
00:04:37 but you get a lot of a glimpse of what comes ahead and what comes down the road
00:04:44 if you pay attention to other countries and specifically Europe.
00:04:48 But the British broadcast regulator, which is the British answer to the CRTC,
00:04:53 It's called Ofcom, has decided to sanction GB News over a broadcast it did in October featuring my friend who's been on this show in the past, Mark Stein and Naomi Wolf, who is formerly a darling of the left, a feminist author and scholar who's now become very endeared to the right because she has gone against much of the progressive orthodoxy on things like vaccines and individual choice and your health care decisions and all of that.
00:05:21 And Mark and Naomi Wolf, who I suspect disagree on a great many things, had a discussion in October about what they were arguing were the harms of vaccination.
00:05:31 And Naomi Wolf, a practicing Jewish woman, said that I'm not even actually, to be honest, I don't even want to say what she said because then I'm going to get this show banned from YouTube.
00:05:40 But she made claims, which you can look up for yourself in the full context.
00:05:44 And I'm not talking about those things here.
00:05:46 I want to talk about what happened.
00:05:48 So this discussion seven months ago, seven months ago, is subject to this prolonged investigation by Ofcom, which this morning issued a finding that their conversation was essentially unlawful, that it violated the British broadcast regulations on protecting the audience from harmful opinions, effectively.
00:06:09 That is what they said, that the audience must be protected from her views and that radio stations, TV stations have an obligation to protect people from their views.
00:06:19 Now, this, I wrote a substack about which you can check out today.
00:06:23 And I mentioned in the headline there, soon only official narratives will remain.
00:06:28 And I believe wholeheartedly in that because we are seeing the decreasing bounds of debate.
00:06:34 You are allowed to have the official narrative, the official position, the government-approved position, and anything else is misinformation.
00:06:42 Again, YouTube, for example, outsourced for much of the pandemic, and I think to a large extent still today,
00:06:48 its decisions on misinformation and what you're allowed to say in YouTube videos to the World Health Organization.
00:06:54 So if you are in noncompliance with the—I mean, maybe just by drinking wine I'm in noncompliance with the YouTube World Health Organization regulations.
00:07:03 But this is, I think, a huge problem that right now we are seeing and we are going to see more of.
00:07:08 So why do we as Canadians, mostly Canadians, care?
00:07:12 Because Ofcom is, I think, what Justin Trudeau wants the CRTC to be.
00:07:17 An organization that doesn't just deal with the bare decisions to do with compliance.
00:07:22 And are you setting up the right wattage for your transmission tower?
00:07:26 And are you making sure that you're on Channel 7 and someone else is on Channel 8 and we don't have three people on the same channel?
00:07:32 but actually regulating content, which is what the CRTC is now able to do thanks to Bill C-11.
00:07:40 They are expanding just from being a facilitator and to being an active participant in content,
00:07:47 manipulating the algorithms as the CRTC now expands its power from the realm of TV and radio to the realm of the internet.
00:07:56 And CRTC, if you look at this from the CRTC website, this was yesterday,
00:08:02 C11 passed a week ago, and CRTC has already announced its plans to modernize the broadcasting system.
00:08:09 They did not waste any time at all.
00:08:12 This was adopted. It was passed by the Senate, received royal assent,
00:08:16 and without waiting a week even, the CRTC is launching public consultations
00:08:22 to figure out how exactly it's going to use all of its newfound powers.
00:08:26 And we should be very concerned about this, especially when you look at what people want to have happen from here.
00:08:33 To focus on the UK for a couple more moments, they are in the midst of the Conservative government,
00:08:39 Conservative government, passing something called the Online Safety Bill.
00:08:44 Now, the Online Safety Bill is largely what the Liberal government wants to do with its proposed Online Harms Bill
00:08:53 or online hate speech bill, whatever you want to call it, in Canada.
00:08:56 They want to put in more tools, more mechanisms
00:08:59 to regulate what they view as being online harms.
00:09:03 Now, this is a very, very broad category.
00:09:06 Included in it are things like hate speech
00:09:08 and things like child pornography and things like misinformation.
00:09:12 And child pornography, I think we can all safely agree, is terrible
00:09:15 and should not have a place on the internet or anywhere else.
00:09:18 That's why it is criminal.
00:09:20 but you get to misinformation and hate speech
00:09:23 and these things are a little bit trickier to define
00:09:25 and a suspicious person like myself
00:09:27 would wonder why the liberals want to include
00:09:30 hate speech and misinformation in the same bill
00:09:32 and the same discussion as child pornography.
00:09:35 Perhaps it's because they know that anyone like me
00:09:37 who's going to say,
00:09:38 actually, I don't think you should regulate
00:09:40 what people say online.
00:09:42 They're going to turn around and say,
00:09:43 oh, you like child pornography, 0.96
00:09:44 which is absolutely absurd, 0.99
00:09:46 but mark my words,
00:09:47 that's going to be the discussion.
00:09:49 And that's going to be the caliber of the discourse.
00:09:52 But to bring it back to the UK, what's happening right now is WhatsApp, which is owned by Meta,
00:09:57 the parent company of Facebook, is huge in Europe.
00:10:00 I use WhatsApp as well, but everywhere else in the world, it's used a lot more fervently
00:10:05 and frequently than it is for Canadians. 0.99
00:10:07 And this is true among Brits.
00:10:09 It's true among Europeans, Asians.
00:10:11 I believe Africans as well are fairly large WhatsApp users.
00:10:15 And it's a messaging app.
00:10:17 It works similar to a text message, except it's going over IP protocols.
00:10:21 And the thing about WhatsApp is that it is encrypted from end to end.
00:10:25 And this is a big selling point.
00:10:27 It's supposed to be more secure than your cell phone SMSs are.
00:10:31 It is probably not as secure as Signal, if you're a user of Signal, but very similar idea.
00:10:37 And this means that even WhatsApp is unable to read your messages.
00:10:41 This is the pitch that they make to users.
00:10:44 Well, WhatsApp is saying that when the UK's regulations come in, which will put reporting requirements in place for so-called unlawful content for social media companies, they're saying that they would actually no longer be able to use end-to-end encryption because all of a sudden they have to start spying on what people are saying in their private messages in order to officially endorse what the government is expecting them to do,
00:11:09 which is report if so-and-so sends an illicit or illegal missive to someone else.
00:11:17 And when WhatsApp said to the UK government,
00:11:20 listen, we may have to pull out of the UK market over this,
00:11:23 you had a bunch of conservative MPs, again,
00:11:26 who are predisposed to online censorship, apparently,
00:11:30 saying this is all misinformation.
00:11:31 You don't need to get rid of end-to-end encryption.
00:11:33 There's no privacy risk.
00:11:35 One MP, I think it was Damian Collins was his name, said,
00:11:38 no, no, no. All we're saying is that they need to report illegal content that they see. Well,
00:11:45 how does this work unless they start policing what their users are using WhatsApp for?
00:11:52 But this is the era we are entering into. It's an era in which the internet is not a free place.
00:11:58 The internet is going to be subject to regulation, surveillance, and oversight to a larger degree
00:12:03 than we have today. And we look no further than the Liberal Convention on the weekend to bring
00:12:09 it back home here, where of the many policy resolutions passed by Liberal MPs, one of them
00:12:15 in particular was to combat what the Liberal members behind this policy resolution, members
00:12:22 from British Columbia, which I guess shouldn't surprise you, say is combating disinformation
00:12:26 in Canada. We talked about this a little bit last week. They view disinformation as, quote,
00:12:32 an existential risk to humanity.
00:12:35 This is like the same language they use for climate change,
00:12:37 three-page earlier, if I'm not mistaken.
00:12:40 They say that online information sources
00:12:42 are the source of most disinformation aimed at Canadians.
00:12:46 They say that those who produce misinformation
00:12:48 undermine trust in people and institutions.
00:12:52 They say that the demand for information 24-7
00:12:55 has increased the need for programming
00:12:57 contemporaneously with the loss of ad revenue
00:13:00 to online platforms.
00:13:02 And they say that mainstream media no longer has as many reporters as they used to.
00:13:07 So all of this is bringing us to their resolution.
00:13:10 Be it resolved that the Liberal Party of Canada request the government provide additional public funds
00:13:16 to support ad-free news and information reporting by Canadian media
00:13:20 through an arm's-length non-partisan mechanism.
00:13:23 So be it resolved that the Liberals subsidize media more than they already are today.
00:13:28 And more importantly, request that the government explore options to hold online information services accountable for the veracity of material published on their platforms and to limit publication only to material whose sources can be traced.
00:13:43 So the two prongs of that, number one, that we hold online platforms accountable for the veracity of material.
00:13:51 So when someone says, well, actually, World Health Organization, you can stuff it.
00:13:56 I'm going to enjoy a glass of wine.
00:13:59 Oh, delicious.
00:14:01 Then what happens is the government is to go to that person and say,
00:14:05 hey, you know what?
00:14:06 We're going to hold the social media company and you do account
00:14:09 because we don't believe this is sufficiently voracious or true.
00:14:12 And then you have the other part of this.
00:14:14 Limit publication only to material whose sources can be traced.
00:14:18 So right now, you can trace this if you really want.
00:14:21 I'm in my little home office, True North.
00:14:24 You know where we're headquartered.
00:14:25 But if someone decides to post something anonymously, this may not be traced.
00:14:30 So perhaps it needs to get taken down.
00:14:32 This is what the Liberals want.
00:14:33 Anything whose origins they cannot trace, they do not want to see the light of day, basically, they can have pulled down.
00:14:42 And it's easy to dismiss this as the Liberal commentary it has.
00:14:47 As well, this is, I mean, it's just a policy resolution.
00:14:50 It's not policy for the party officially.
00:14:52 It's not platform.
00:14:54 It's not a liberal government bill.
00:14:56 It's just what the members say.
00:14:57 But this is like the unrestrained id
00:14:59 of what liberal members of parliament want.
00:15:02 This is if you leave liberals to their own devices
00:15:04 and you put them in a room and say,
00:15:06 come up with what you believe is the vision for Canada.
00:15:09 This is what they come up with.
00:15:11 This is what Justin Trudeau and a majority government
00:15:13 would have to do to keep his party's members happy.
00:15:17 And if you look at the list,
00:15:18 there are some things here that are bonkers.
00:15:21 One of them is the,
00:15:21 I mean, the word climate appears like 72 times, but it's like more times than Trudeau has been
00:15:26 in black, but well, not that many. But it says climate crisis. Whereas we are living in a climate
00:15:32 emergency and the 2022 intergovernmental panel on climate change report made it clear that any
00:15:38 further delay and concerted global action will miss a brief and rapidly closing window to secure
00:15:43 a livable future. Be it resolved that the Liberal Party of Canada urges the government of Canada
00:15:50 to require public investment funds to divert from fossil fuels.
00:15:55 So they don't think that CPP or any public investment funds
00:15:59 should have any investment whatsoever in anything to do with traditional oil and gas.
00:16:05 So the Liberals say we need to divest from one of the most significant industries in Canada
00:16:12 and be it further resolved that the Liberal Party of Canada urges the government
00:16:18 to ensure the end of all subsidies to the fossil fuel sector before 2025.
00:16:23 Now this, I'm actually for if we eliminate all green energy subsidies as well.
00:16:28 How about we put all our cards on the table?
00:16:30 We'll get rid of the oil and gas subsidies.
00:16:32 You get rid of the green energy subsidies.
00:16:33 And how do you like that?
00:16:34 But they're never going to go for that.
00:16:36 And that's exactly why these arguments are so disingenuous.
00:16:40 But this is what Liberal members want.
00:16:42 And I think it probably speaks to where the Liberal Party is
00:16:46 and where Justin Trudeau is more than he may admit
00:16:49 when you see Liberal members coming out and saying this.
00:16:52 And the best response that the Liberal commentators have is,
00:16:55 oh, well, I mean, they're just members doing their little thing.
00:16:59 They're not really, we pay no heed to the man behind the curtain.
00:17:02 So right now, the Liberals would love nothing more
00:17:05 than to see in Canada what we were describing in Britain,
00:17:08 where you can't actually say what you want in a broadcast.
00:17:11 You can't say what you want online.
00:17:13 You can't perhaps as an anonymous source talk to the Globe and Mail because, oh, well, this is information whose source cannot be traced by the government.
00:17:21 It's almost as though sources that can't be traced by the government are the great selling point of the Internet.
00:17:27 And, you know, there's a bigger picture problem here.
00:17:30 And when I said in that substack of mine that only official narratives will remain in the future, I'm talking about both a cultural problem and a legal problem.
00:17:40 The cultural problem is one that I spoke about a couple of weeks ago, the decline of debate, the dwindling confines of debate.
00:17:48 But the legal problem is when things that would normally be rejected and denounced by people,
00:17:55 things like misinformation and hate speech, become terms that are weaponized against dissent.
00:18:01 I mean, I'm against hate speech, I'm against misinformation, I'm against dishonesty, I'm against all of these things,
00:18:06 and I deplore these things, but I'm also very distrustful of government's ability to define
00:18:12 these things in a way that is fair and not weaponized or politicized. Like I had a conversation
00:18:19 with someone, not a particularly pleasant conversation a few weeks ago, who very much
00:18:24 does not believe in free speech and was completely open about this. And what this person said is that,
00:18:30 well, you don't get to debate facts, which fair enough. I mean, if you have two people that are
00:18:34 standing in the street in a torrential downpour, soaking wet, and they're debating whether or not
00:18:40 it's raining. You may look at this and be like, well, this, I mean, this is, why are we giving
00:18:43 false equivalents to this, these two positions? Why are we letting someone say it's not raining?
00:18:48 But the only way that you, if you take that argument to its natural end, you get to really
00:18:54 do anything about that is if you decide to make someone the arbiter of what is true and make
00:19:01 someone the arbiter of facts and give someone the power to decide which things cannot be debated so
00:19:07 i would say as a free speech lover let the two people in the street in the rain debate whether
00:19:11 it's raining and let us all laugh at the guy who's soaking wet trying to tell us that it's not raining
00:19:16 because every now and then you may find out that guy ended up right maybe someone was dumping
00:19:20 buckets from above and we couldn't see it at the time but even if not even if not what we see here
00:19:26 is the only way to avoid government shrinking free speech and shrinking debate is to allow
00:19:32 the debate and allow the debates about things, even when we are offended by an argument that
00:19:37 someone puts forward, or even when we believe that they're so wrong, they don't even deserve
00:19:41 a fair hearing. Because the alternative is Justin Trudeau and his liberal cronies getting to decide
00:19:48 this issue is settled. You don't get to debate it. It's Ofcom saying, well, actually, Naomi Wolf,
00:19:53 you don't get to talk about vaccine harms.
00:19:55 You don't get to do that
00:19:56 because it is going to be harmful for people
00:19:58 to hear your perspective.
00:20:00 That is the outcome that these internet regulators want
00:20:04 and we absolutely cannot let them have it.
00:20:07 One thing that I said I would do a couple of weeks ago
00:20:10 is cover the Alberta election as it goes on.
00:20:13 I mean, this is going to sneak up on us.
00:20:15 The election day is in just 20 days,
00:20:17 less than three weeks time.
00:20:19 And we haven't seen too much movement in the campaigns.
00:20:22 They're still mostly staying in Calgary, although Danielle Smith did do a press conference in Edmonton.
00:20:28 But the campaign has had a bit of a hitch with the wildfires raging in parts of Alberta.
00:20:35 Obviously, if you listen to the Daily Brief, you heard Rachel Emanuel and I chat about this a little bit yesterday.
00:20:40 But it's become a bit of a political issue as to campaigning in the midst of crisis.
00:20:47 Danielle Smith was criticized by Rachel Notley for talking about this at a campaign event.
00:20:52 And then Rachel Notley went along and did a campaign event.
00:20:55 And my colleague, Rachel Emanuel, asked her how she squared campaigning herself during a tragedy.
00:21:00 Take a look.
00:21:01 Rachel Emanuel, to more with Ms. Notley, how is the Premier showing insensitivity
00:21:05 when you're here in Calgary today hosting a campaign event and she's up at Edmonton dealing with the wildfires?
00:21:11 I believe that we are both continuing to work on the campaign.
00:21:15 Indeed, we've seen both of us do that, and so that's what we're doing.
00:21:22 But in the meantime, when it comes to making announcements that impact the victims of the wildfires,
00:21:31 then that should be done in a political way.
00:21:33 So is the criticism the Premier is receiving for the campaign event she attended over the weekend
00:21:38 or other campaign events she might choose to hold inappropriate,
00:21:40 Is it right for her to continue campaigning, considering, as you said, we are in an election period?
00:21:46 My concern is only that she chose to announce the provincial state of emergency to her campaign workers
00:21:54 before she announced it to the victims, the tens of thousands of victims of the one fire.
00:22:00 And that's all the time we have today. Thank you so much.
00:22:02 We have questions from seniors here in the room who have some questions for Rachel.
00:22:06 That was just at the tail end there, Jonathan Bradley of the Western
00:22:36 Standard, not having the forcefulness of our very own Rachel Emanuel. He gets blocked and
00:22:42 accused of hate speech, which admittedly is probably all in a day's work for an NDP campaign
00:22:47 staffer. But nonetheless, Rachel Emanuel lived to tell the tale. She joins us now. Let's just talk
00:22:53 about that little exchange there first, Rachel, because obviously Rachel Notley has been dogged 0.99
00:22:58 for not talking to independent media on this campaign. But you did get your question in there.
00:23:04 You didn't encounter any roadblocks yourself?
00:23:07 Well, there were certainly some roadblocks.
00:23:10 When I got to the press conference, I could tell they didn't maybe recognize me or maybe they did.
00:23:14 One of the NDP staff or the one that was featured at the end of the video came up, introduced himself.
00:23:20 I let him know that I was from True North.
00:23:21 That's when you saw the whispering among the NDP staffers beginning.
00:23:25 What were they going to do?
00:23:26 How were they going to deal with me?
00:23:28 I was surprised when the press conference began and they didn't ask me to leave.
00:23:32 you might remember a couple weeks ago kian bexty of the counter single and alex dollwell of rebel
00:23:37 news were actually asked to leave to the point that security was even called up called on them
00:23:42 and they were escorted out of the premises but no the press conference began and i realized the
00:23:47 problems were going to begin afterwards when all the legacy media reporters lined up to get their
00:23:53 question and i noticed i was at the tail end of that and in between asking their questions the
00:23:57 legacy media reporters would hand the microphone back to the ngp staffer who would decide who would
00:24:03 get it next i was second last in line behind me was jonathan bradley and when it was my turn to
00:24:09 ask a question they decided to take questions from the phone so after taking one question from the
00:24:14 phone i thought this is ridiculous you and i have both experience not being able to ask questions
00:24:19 when we call into ndp press conferences or when we video in over the zoom and so i thought no this is
00:24:26 is my chance so I just sort of yelled my question out I thought she can answer it or she can't but
00:24:31 everyone's going to hear it I know this is being live streamed and I certainly have it on video
00:24:35 and to her credit Rachel Notley did have the ability and was willing to answer my question
00:24:40 I don't know why they felt the need to make such a stink out of it I think it would have been a lot
00:24:43 easier for everyone if they just handed me the microphone and then they decided to end questions
00:24:48 from the press after I got my questions in unfortunately Jonathan Bradley was blocked
00:24:52 as you saw in the video and was unable to get his questions in.
00:24:55 Yeah, he hesitated because you just like continued with the question.
00:24:59 He like faltered, which sort of gives them the window to get in there.
00:25:02 But let's talk about the actual substance of it here,
00:25:04 because I think you're raising an important point.
00:25:06 I mean, whenever there is a fixed election as there is now,
00:25:10 obviously the campaign is going, people are going to be voting,
00:25:12 you need to get your message out.
00:25:14 But having the wildfires throws a wrench in that,
00:25:17 especially if you are the premier and you actually have a governmental role
00:25:21 and you have emergency services to deal with and she's been doing this i mean she declared the
00:25:26 provincial state of emergency she's spoken to justin true in this capacity so what was rachel
00:25:31 notley's issue really so rachel notley decided to continue her campaign and i asked her about that
00:25:38 you know she's allowed to do that it is a fixed election campaign we're voting on the 29th it
00:25:42 would be very difficult i'm not even sure how entirely possible it would be to move that
00:25:46 election day it looks like the chief electoral officer would have the power to delay the vote
00:25:50 in certain writings but you know in a country like canada you expect to have your election in
00:25:55 a timely manner you expect to have the votes results in a timely manner and so rachel notley
00:25:59 said she was asked before me by a ctv reporter if she had considered delaying her campaign and she
00:26:05 said you know it's a difficult situation for albertans but ultimately we are in an election
00:26:09 period and then i asked her about it again because she started criticizing danielle smith just before
00:26:14 i asked my question there calling the premier insensitive now the reason she called danielle
00:26:19 Smith insensitive is because on Saturday, Daniel Smith announced a state of emergency in the
00:26:23 province due to the ongoing wildfires. There were over 100 at the time. But before she announced it
00:26:29 to the public, she just let a group of UCP supporters at a fundraising event, she let them
00:26:33 know she was going to be announcing that she was going to be emergency. And there was a video of
00:26:38 this circulating online. So it was revealed that Daniel Smith had announced this incoming emergency
00:26:43 to UCP supporters before announcing it very shortly after at a actual press conference.
00:26:50 And so Rachel Notley was criticizing the premiers without calling it insensitive.
00:26:54 Now, let's be honest, I don't know that anyone actually really cares about the fact that
00:26:58 Daniel Smith let a couple UCP supporters know that she was going to be calling a state of
00:27:02 emergency an hour before she announced it to the province. I think the people who have actually
00:27:06 been displaced by the fires and have lost their homes are quite a bit busier with other things
00:27:10 at this time and I think it's disappointing to put make a partisan issue out of something that
00:27:15 is a natural disaster which is really a crisis in the province and which is affecting Albertans you
00:27:20 know imagine waking up one day to the news your home has been burned down all your lively possessions
00:27:25 they are gone that would be extremely difficult news this is really when Albertans look to their
00:27:30 leaders to sort of rally together and so I couldn't help but take note of the fact that well
00:27:35 Danielle Smith other than that one fundraising dinner she attended on Saturday afternoon has 0.89
00:27:39 completely stepped back from campaigning. She is dealing entirely in her role as premier to address
00:27:44 the fires over these past couple of days. Meanwhile, Rachel Notley is out campaigning,
00:27:48 as is her right to do. You know, that's her decision. And yet she's criticizing the premier 0.55
00:27:52 from the sidelines. Well, the premier has made the decision not to campaign. So I felt I needed
00:27:56 to ask her about that. You know, I asked her why she thought it was fair to call the premier
00:28:00 insensitive while she's out campaigning. And, you know, you heard her response there.
00:28:04 Now, neither has actually like officially suspended their campaign, correct? 0.99
00:28:08 Danielle Smith, in her case, she's just more taken a lower key approach the last few days. 0.91
00:28:13 Exactly.
00:28:14 Neither of the leaders have officially suspended their campaign.
00:28:17 Candidates in ridings where the fires are out of control or where evacuation orders
00:28:21 have been issued have suspended their campaigns.
00:28:23 But those decisions are being made at a local level at this time.
00:28:26 And I don't suspect we are going to see a total suspension of either of the campaigns.
00:28:30 Danielle Smith did end up making an announcement earlier today.
00:28:32 that was her first announcement as party leader rather than premier since friday so far and again
00:28:39 you you can you can duck this question if you want i shouldn't have given you a note but i'm giving
00:28:43 you a note but do you think that when push comes to shove this crisis helps hurts or makes no
00:28:47 difference to danielle smith it ultimately will come down to how danielle smith responds to this
00:28:53 crisis i think she's done a very good job i've even seen shockingly some craze from left-wing
00:28:59 twitter you would twitter users and call them this you know saying she's showing herself to
00:29:04 be a real premier a real leader in this situation i think her decision to ultimately step back from
00:29:09 campaigning will be seen as the right one you know albertans and canadians at large they don't
00:29:15 really like election campaigns it gets very dirty it's very vicious it gets very personal and it's
00:29:19 tiring to listen to you're hearing these constant attack ads they all kind of seem to be saying the
00:29:24 same thing no one's being convinced of anything but here we have a natural disaster this is a
00:29:28 crisis that needs to be dealing with. So if a leader like Danielle can stand up and show that
00:29:33 she's moving forward and dealing with this crisis effectively, ultimately, I think it will be a good
00:29:37 thing for her in the long run. And I'm just not sure that Rachel Notley's decision to attack the
00:29:41 Premier while she continues her own campaign is going to prove to be the right one in the end.
00:29:46 All right, well, we appreciate the update. We'll let you get back to the campaign trail. Rachel
00:29:50 Emmanuel, our Alberta correspondent and host of the Alberta Roundup. And also we'll have an
00:29:55 announcement in the coming days about our coverage plans for election day so uh stay tuned for that
00:30:00 thanks very much rachel really appreciate it yeah thanks for having me all right uh rachel
00:30:05 emmanuel keep up with her work and other alberta election coverage over at tnc.news i just want to
00:30:12 mention as we uh wind down here i i didn't i've neglected to mention the coronation the problem
00:30:17 with doing the show on tuesday is that sometimes things that happen over the weekend just feel
00:30:22 like old news, whereas if we were on Monday, we'd be able to talk about them. And there was a big
00:30:27 one, which is the coronation of King Charles III. Now, I should say here, I know he is a very
00:30:35 polarizing figure to our audience. There are photos of King Charles and Klaus Schwab. He's
00:30:41 been very much an activist as Prince of Wales in a way that Her Majesty Queen Elizabeth II never
00:30:46 was. And I think as someone who values the traditions of the constitutional monarchy we
00:30:51 have in Canada. The big question will be, does he become a kingly version of Prince Charles or does
00:31:00 he adopt the role and embrace the role and be a king who is not an activist? And he has said
00:31:06 in the past that he realized that he needs to be a king for everyone. So perhaps his proclamations
00:31:11 on environmental catastrophe, which he makes when he gets off the private jet and gets into the car
00:31:16 and gets onto the other private jet, he realizes that perhaps he doesn't get to make those.
00:31:21 But nevertheless, surely we can all get together
00:31:24 and disagree with the way the woke respond to this.
00:31:27 There was one woman in particular who I had not heard of.
00:31:30 I mean, I shouldn't even say she's a woman
00:31:31 because you never know these days. 0.81
00:31:33 She does say she's a recipient of Women in Law Awards.
00:31:36 But Dr. Charlotte Proudman or Proudman, proud person?
00:31:40 Dr. Charlotte Proudman says she tweets this picture
00:31:43 of King Charles being crowned.
00:31:46 Coronated is not a word, I remind you.
00:31:48 And she writes,
00:31:49 what a beautiful photograph of white male privilege and entitlement
00:31:53 sums up who rules our country.
00:31:55 Now, this sort of stuff you can kind of roll your eyes at in general,
00:32:00 but as Twitter reminded people in the little context box before it,
00:32:05 for 134 of the last 200 years,
00:32:09 the United Kingdom's head of state, and that of Canada, by the way,
00:32:13 has been a woman.
00:32:16 So Charles is the guy right now, and she's saying it's a symbol of white male privilege and entitlement.
00:32:23 I should have just pulled up the picture of her late majesty's coronation,
00:32:28 which I don't think you would look at and see as being evidence of male privilege. 0.68
00:32:32 Certainly Queen Victoria, I think, would be mortified to learn that her reign,
00:32:36 which prior to that of her late majesty Queen Elizabeth II was a record,
00:32:41 was also a bastion of white male privilege and entitlement.
00:32:44 So it's basically like these people play Mad Libs using the same word in every slot.
00:32:51 And whether it works or not, they're just going to keep using it where it's like you would just be like on Jeopardy and you'd be like, you know, this was the longest river in Asia.
00:33:01 And they would say, what is white male privilege?
00:33:03 And you say, well, OK, you lose on that one.
00:33:05 This is the bestselling novel by Margaret Atwood set in a dystopian land.
00:33:10 And they say, what is white male? 0.81
00:33:11 Well, that one actually works, I guess. 0.61
00:33:12 But you get the you get the gist.
00:33:14 They kind of just only have one line and that is the line.
00:33:18 So whether Charles is there or Elizabeth is there or, I mean, surely William is not going
00:33:24 to be white privilege.
00:33:25 I mean, white male privilege.
00:33:26 William is just, I don't even, well, William is not even privileged. 0.71
00:33:30 He's just boring now.
00:33:31 But anyway, we will revisit that.
00:33:35 I know he's polarizing, but he is your king.
00:33:37 So I'm not going to make you a bow or curtsy before him, but I will say that you can respect
00:33:41 the institution well, being a little bit skeptical of the man himself. As we talk about white male
00:33:48 privilege, let's talk about Mother's Day and Father's Day, which are approaching. If you haven't
00:33:53 gotten a Mother's Day present, you have until basically Sunday at whatever time you're meeting
00:33:59 with your mother, which is hopefully early on. And the reason this is relevant is because there
00:34:03 was a school I learned of in Winnipeg, Manitoba, which decided that it was just too offensive to
00:34:10 have Mother's Day and Father's Day. So they actually did a more inclusive shift away to a
00:34:17 commemoration that they say is about celebrating all people. They want to kind of celebrate all
00:34:23 people that are involved in raising children, not just mothers and fathers. This is the Kildonan
00:34:29 East Collegiate School in Winnipeg. The memo says they're going to encourage non-gender specific
00:34:35 observations of all those who support our students and like most public school uh public school
00:34:42 environments they misspelled the word students which is a really really great step here maybe
00:34:47 they should spend more time on staff literacy and less on trying to wokeify mother's day and
00:34:53 father's day but i thought this was a bad enough story and then today i find out that one toronto
00:34:59 Public School made the horrendous, horrendous mistake of celebrating Mother's Day. This is the
00:35:05 Q Beach Junior Public School in Toronto. They put a lovely sign up front ahead of Mother's Day. They
00:35:12 say, life does not come with a manual. It comes with a mom. Oh, that's so lovely. That's so lovely. 0.98
00:35:18 The sentiment there is that your mother guides you through life. There's no handbook. Your mother
00:35:22 will, and certainly in my case, tell you how to do a lot of things. She's been a wonderful woman.
00:35:26 Not everyone was raised with a mother, but I don't think we are sufficiently required
00:35:31 to dis-celebrate people that did have mothers that were influential in their lives.
00:35:36 Well, one person, it seems like, complained on Facebook about this.
00:35:41 And now the Toronto school has pulled the sign and they've replaced it with something else.
00:35:48 Now, this is just like laughably hilarious.
00:35:51 The sign they put up has nothing to do with mothers, nothing to do with parents.
00:35:55 it's a celebration of may they say make this month count that's for m accomplish your goals
00:36:02 that's a and you can do this which is why although hang on let's uh take a closer look uh it's not
00:36:08 accomplish your goals it's accomplish your goals um so perhaps they used all their m's on the first
00:36:16 line with m and make and month but now we are to accomplish our goals so i go back to perhaps
00:36:23 Top school administrators need to learn things themselves
00:36:26 instead of spending so much time.
00:36:29 See, Sean, you should work.
00:36:30 Sean, my producer, just said they could have used an upside-down W.
00:36:34 So they actually don't have any Ws in that sign.
00:36:36 They could have used a W.
00:36:37 Yeah, they could have used the upside-down W.
00:36:40 So I agree.
00:36:41 Or you even could do a sideways E.
00:36:43 If you're really, really, really desperate, you can do a sideways E.
00:36:46 So surely, if they didn't have an M, they had an E or a W.
00:36:50 or they could just, you know, get lost and not change the sign in the first place
00:36:55 because the Mother's Day sign was perfectly adequate.
00:36:58 Now, Sean says that he knows this psychology very well
00:37:03 because he went to a leftist beaches school in Toronto,
00:37:05 but he somehow came out and is working on The Andrew Lawton Show,
00:37:10 which I'm sure would mortify his former classmates.
00:37:12 But if you stuck around, Sean, you could have been the sign maker in chief.
00:37:16 You would have done a better job because you actually know how to spell,
00:37:19 unlike the the principal or vice principal there so i i think now you can be subversive in many
00:37:25 ways and my guidance to you is to be subversive by celebrating mother's day and celebrating
00:37:31 mothers that is uh i didn't think that would be a contentious or controversial point but apparently
00:37:36 it is so that does it for us for today we will be back tomorrow with more of canada's most
00:37:41 irreverent talk show here on true north this is the andrew lotton show thank you god bless and
00:37:46 Good day to you all.
00:37:49 Thanks for listening to The Andrew Lawton Show.
00:37:51 Support the program by donating to True North at www.tnc.news.