Juno News - November 23, 2022


Liberal ministers joked about sending in tanks to break up Convoy

Topics
Guests
Mentioned
Convoy lawyer Brendan Miller kicked out of Public Order Emergency Commission Chrystia Freeland Testifies | Emergencies Act Inquiry

Episode Stats


Length

43 minutes

Words per minute

183.65

Word count

8,040

Sentence count

317

Harmful content

Misogyny

1

sentences flagged

Toxicity

13

sentences flagged

Hate speech

3

sentences flagged


Summary

Summaries generated with gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ .

In this episode of The Andrew Lawton Show: Canada's Most Irreverent Talk Show, we talk about your freedom to protest, your freedom from vaccine mandates, and your right to own property, which is also under attack by a liberal amendment that will dramatically expand the guns on the list that the government wants to prohibit.

Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Topics generated with Qwen2.5-3B-Instruct.
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 Welcome to Canada's Most Irreverent Talk Show.
00:00:05 This is the Andrew Lawton Show, brought to you by True North.
00:00:13 Hello and welcome to you all.
00:00:16 It is Wednesday, November 23rd, 2022.
00:00:20 This is another edition of the Andrew Lawton Show,
00:00:22 Canada's Most Irreverent Talk Show on True North.
00:00:26 You got to be very careful.
00:00:27 Sometimes if you're typing that out, it auto-corrects you to irrelevant.
00:00:32 And I mean, that may actually be what the show is sometimes, Canada's most irrelevant show.
00:00:37 I try to be irreverent and never irrelevant, but sometimes you mix those up and you give your critics lots of ammunition.
00:00:43 But regardless, I thank all of you for tuning in as we stand up for your freedom.
00:00:49 That is really the theme of the show, I think, most days.
00:00:52 But certainly today, as we talk about your freedom to protest, your freedom from vaccine mandates, and also your freedom to own property, which is also under attack by a liberal amendment that will dramatically expand the guns on the list that the government wants to prohibit.
00:01:09 This was an amendment put forward on committee yesterday that has gotten virtually no.
00:01:15 I did a look at this about five minutes ago, and as of when I looked, it had not a single
00:01:22 mainstream media story about.
00:01:25 And I just saw like one minute before I went on air, Brian Lilly in the Toronto Sun published
00:01:30 something, but nothing in the Toronto Star, nothing in the Globe and Mail, not even in
00:01:34 the National Post.
00:01:35 We're going to talk about it here with Rod Giltaka from the Canadian Coalition for Firearm Rights.
00:01:40 And we're talking about a gun ban that eliminates, absolutely eliminates, any ability for the government to fall back on.
00:01:49 We're not going after hunters and sports shooters.
00:01:51 This latest change will effectively ban any semi-automatic gun that shoots anything larger than a 22-round bullet.
00:02:00 So we're not talking about a ban here that has anything to do with public safety.
00:02:04 it's broad and it's sweeping so that's coming up in about 15 minutes time i should say if you can't
00:02:10 tell already i still have not entirely gotten my voice back i feel slightly better than yesterday
00:02:15 but i'm still going to make my way through the show i should have found some like 10 minute long
00:02:20 clip that i could play just to give myself a bit of a break but we have a few smaller clips that
00:02:25 we'll get to uh but they are not enough they're not for my benefit they're for your benefit so
00:02:30 I do hope you enjoy. Before we get into all the firearm stuff, I want to talk a little bit about
00:02:36 the Public Order Emergency Commission today, where we're just like rotating through the
00:02:41 cabinet ministers that had portfolios which were adjacent to or directly involved in the
00:02:47 Emergencies Act. Yesterday, we had Marco Mendicino. Two days ago, we had Bill Blair. We also had
00:02:54 Dominic LeBlanc yesterday. And today, we had three ministers. We were getting spoiled.
00:02:59 Three is a crowd, they say.
00:03:01 I've already forgotten.
00:03:02 So many of them are still forgettable now.
00:03:03 I'm trying to remember who.
00:03:04 The first one was David Lemeny, the justice minister, who took us most of the day.
00:03:10 And then Anita Anand, the defense minister, just wrapped up.
00:03:14 And I believe right now we have Omar Elgabra, the transportation minister.
00:03:19 So if you'd rather hear Omar Elgabra than me, you have options.
00:03:24 But I don't think you want to do that.
00:03:25 And as with before, we have a couple of folks monitoring that.
00:03:29 So we can cut in if anything big happens while Omar El-Gabra is on the stand.
00:03:34 I will say I'm not optimistic.
00:03:36 And I don't say that as a slight against Omar El-Gabra.
00:03:39 I say that in general because the ministers that we're seeing,
00:03:43 you can tell have been very well prepped for this.
00:03:46 The ministers are coming with talking point binders.
00:03:50 The ministers are coming with their defenses already planned out.
00:03:54 They've had months and months and months in which they've had to defend the emergencies act.
00:03:58 So now there isn't really any real accountability when they're on the stand.
00:04:03 And some of the timeframes here are so condensed.
00:04:06 So the way it works is whenever a minister or someone is going to testify,
00:04:11 there's a process that goes on behind the scenes of deciding how long they're going to testify.
00:04:17 And then it becomes a question of who is going to question them for how long.
00:04:22 For example, when Peter slowly took the stand, he was on for two full days.
00:04:27 It was a Friday and a Monday, and on the Friday was all his examination, and then on Monday was
00:04:33 all the cross-examination. So everyone who cross-examined him got a fair bit of time.
00:04:39 You look at some other people that have been up there, like Anita Anand. She was on the stand for,
00:04:43 I think, maybe two hours, and in that time, there's maybe 30 to 45 minutes for her to be
00:04:49 questioned by commission counsel, 15 minutes to be cross-examined by this party, and some of them
00:04:54 get like five minutes with her and when she gives a long meandering answer like there was one
00:04:59 exchange that Anita Anand had with a lawyer for the Canadian Civil Liberties Association I won't
00:05:05 play it for you because it already you know took two minutes off of my life I don't need you to
00:05:09 suffer through that as well but she was asked it was like a simple yes or no question you were out
00:05:14 of the country for the first week of the convoy protest right and Anita Anand goes I was in
00:05:20 Ukraine. I was in Latvia. I was in Belgium. I was talking to our partners of the Russia's invasion
00:05:26 of Ukraine. And we were preparing Canada's strong defense. And we were, and I was like, oh my good
00:05:31 ma'am, this is a Wendy's for crying out loud. It was a yes or no question. Were you in the country?
00:05:36 No, done, move on. But that eats up like, you know, 80% of the five minutes or whatever it was.
00:05:42 And, you know, the lawyer was able to ask a few more questions of Minister Anand. You start to be
00:05:48 very careful about what you ask and it's like you know checking your rhetorical ammo because you
00:05:54 only have you know three sentences that you can get out so you choose them very carefully and so
00:06:00 she does this thing and I'm like so somehow like the emergencies act will have lots of information
00:06:05 about Canada's strong commitment to supporting our Ukrainian ally which is very helpful in
00:06:10 navigating whether Justin Trudeau was justified in invoking the emergencies act for some reason
00:06:16 or maybe not but that's what happens so sometimes you have very compressed time frames and today
00:06:22 you were starting to see a little bit of jockeying going on where they're all like swapping time like
00:06:27 they're trading cards where you know the city of ottawa will give five minutes to the jccf and then
00:06:32 freedom convoy organizers will give five minutes to the jccf and then jccf actually gets 15 minutes
00:06:38 which uh lets anita and and answer like two questions about ukraine or something but what
00:06:43 was fascinating about all of this is that they're all coming and they can see where the questions
00:06:50 are going. And they try to preempt where it's going. Like there was one exchange just a little
00:06:56 while ago where Anita Anand was being asked a question that was, again, a very simple binary
00:07:02 question. Is the National Defense Act a law in Canada? And she just like she knew what was being
00:07:09 asked of her so she wouldn't give a straight answer and then you know kept trying to outsmart
00:07:14 i think it was rob kittredge who was the lawyer for the justice center for constitutional freedoms
00:07:19 and it ended up just becoming a repetitive game of 20 questions where you just want the car ride
00:07:24 to be over so the game can end but i do want to talk about some of the more substantive details
00:07:29 that came out of this because as always sometimes it's not the testimony that is the most revealing
00:07:35 but the documents and in particular the unfiltered raw document exchange that takes place between
00:07:42 cabinet ministers not in the scripted talking point laden question period answers or testimony
00:07:48 but how they actually engage with each other when they're just chatting us friends or colleagues
00:07:56 and the big one today that comes out is this text message exchange between the public safety
00:08:02 Minister Marco Mendicino and the Justice Minister David Lamedi. And I'll ask that we pull this up
00:08:08 on the screen here because this is actually quite a fascinating, fascinating display. So just for
00:08:15 context here, Marco Mendicino is in the gray and David Lamedi is in the blue. So David Lamedi says
00:08:23 to Marco Mendicino, you need to get the police to move and the CAF if necessary. That's the Canadian 0.73
00:08:28 Armed Forces. Too many people are being seriously adversely impacted by what is an occupation. I am
00:08:34 getting out as soon as I can. People are looking to us slash you for leadership and not stupid people. 1.00
00:08:42 People like Carney, Kath, my team. Okay, pull this down for a second. So just for context, this is on 1.00
00:08:49 February 2nd. So the convoy has not even been in Ottawa for a full week at this time.
00:08:56 February 2nd. So the reason I bring this up is because this exchange is happening. The convoy
00:09:03 got there earlier, like the early days of the convoy were on the Friday. And it's now been
00:09:10 Saturday, Sunday, Monday, Tuesday, Wednesday, five days. And Marco Mendicino is now getting
00:09:14 like a call from Justice Minister David Lamedi, essentially calling on him to bring in the police,
00:09:21 to direct police, to send in the military, to do all of this stuff. But then the absolute best part
00:09:27 of this, people are looking to us and you for leadership, not stupid people, people like Mark 1.00
00:09:34 Carney. And I assume Catherine McKenna is Kath. It might be like Catherine McKenna, the non-binary 1.00
00:09:41 councillor and former mayoral candidate. And so it might've been them, but I think it was Catherine
00:09:48 McKenna and Mark Carney. So all of a sudden government policy in this country is being done
00:09:54 to pacify Mark Carney and Catherine McKenna. Not the rest of you idiots. You're all stupid people. 1.00
00:10:01 Your opinions don't matter. We got to keep Mark Carney and Catherine McKenna happy. Like this is 1.00
00:10:06 the sort of stuff that conservatives make fun of the liberals about, but the liberals actually talk
00:10:11 like this, that they're taking their marching orders in a way from people like Carney and
00:10:16 McKenna and my team and David Lamedi's staffers as well. So not the dumb people, but only those 0.99
00:10:23 little smart people here. And they're saying that they take their marching orders from them, 1.00
00:10:28 apparently. So that is, I think, part of it. But if we can throw the text message back up on the
00:10:32 screen there. So that's what David Lamedi says to Marco Mendicino. And then Marco says, how many
00:10:39 tanks are you asking for? I just want to ask Anita how many we've got on hand. And then a couple
00:10:47 hours later at 10 57 PM, David Lometti says, I reckon one will do. You got to like include the
00:10:53 inflection for the exclamation mark. I reckon one will do. So David Lometti says one tank is what
00:11:00 they think they'll need to go in and break up this group of peaceful protesters five days after
00:11:05 they arrived in Ottawa. Now, if you look at that on its face, you think, wow, this seems
00:11:10 pretty damaging that they were talking about sending in the military. Well,
00:11:15 you just need to get a sense of humor. Here's how David Lamedi explains it.
00:11:25 Remember, I'm interacting here as a colleague and Minister of Justice around the Cabinet table. I'm
00:11:30 not interacting as Attorney General. Minister Mendigino and I have a close relationship.
00:11:35 There's some banter here. There's some humor here. That's a reference to my favorite Christmas movie,
00:11:40 the quick, quick, quick part. And so I think we could take the temperature down here.
00:11:49 Oh, it's just a little bit of banter, just a little bit of banter, just a little bit of humor.
00:11:54 You know, when I banter with my friends, I always talk about sending in the tanks. But the great
00:11:58 thing is when you actually have the power to do it this banter takes a little bit of a different
00:12:04 tone it's like just a matter like in fairness to david lametti i can't believe i'm about to say
00:12:09 this if i were the cia director and i were to have like a casual conversation with friends
00:12:17 i would probably just like joke about having people assassinated like that sounds like something
00:12:22 that would be fun to do for the first three weeks of your job not actually doing it but i'd be like
00:12:26 you know you want me to have him whacked or something i know a guy but then i'm like it's
00:12:30 different if you actually do it after so i don't buy the this is just playful joking banter when
00:12:36 the government actually came perilously close to sending in the military and certainly when the
00:12:41 government later used wartime powers which is what the emergencies act bestows upon them
00:12:47 to crack down on protesters so it's not a joke when you actually start living the punchline of it
00:12:55 which is what David Lamedi and Marco Mendicino and their colleagues around the cabinet table did
00:13:00 in about two weeks from that message being sent. So yeah I'm all for gallows humor but you can't
00:13:07 just retreat to this oh I'm just kidding when it sounds like you're seriously considering those
00:13:13 policies and I mean all these comparisons to Tiananmen Square that have been going rampant
00:13:17 on Twitter today I kind of get those I absolutely get those because the government was using that
00:13:23 kind of rhetoric. And remember when there were those leaked WhatsApp messages from RCMP officers
00:13:28 talking about how, oh, don't, don't arrest them all. We want to get in and get our overtime. And
00:13:32 oh, you know, wait till they hear our jackboots on the ground. And oh, you know, I love how you
00:13:37 trampled that indigenous lady. Maybe we can practice that maneuver when we get back to camp 1.00
00:13:41 or I'm paraphrasing, but that was the sentiment in those messages that were leaked. So I get when
00:13:46 you have a high stress, tense job and you're in a tense situation, you crack jokes about things,
00:13:52 But these don't actually sound like jokes when you see how the government responded.
00:13:58 And that is so critical.
00:14:00 And I will say, there was a remarkable bit of self-awareness that came from one of the exchanges that we saw in the evidence here.
00:14:09 Now, this is a text message exchange about the Emergencies Act one day before the Emergencies Act was invoked.
00:14:15 And it's between Greg Fergus, who's a backbench Liberal MP, and David Lamedi.
00:14:21 Why don't you take a look at this?
00:14:22 so what e is being said here that is greg fergus on the left and he in the gray and he's referring
00:14:30 to the caucus call that the liberals just had here's the consensus use the emergencies act
00:14:36 close down coventry and baseline bases of operations put a solid rcmp or caf spokesman
00:14:43 oh justin trudeau would not approve of the use of the word spokesman anyway rcmp or caf spokesman
00:14:49 before the press since we politicians have pissed away our credibility now after that i will just
00:14:54 say uh david lametti has a bit of self-awareness as well no solid rcmp spokesperson so uh clearly
00:15:01 a belief on his part that brenda lucky was not earning her poutines if you will uh but greg
00:15:07 fergus says we politicians have pissed away our credibility so there was an understanding by
00:15:14 February 13th that a by one Liberal member of Parliament anyway that the Liberals could not
00:15:20 capably sell the Emergencies Act and their response to protesters to the protests in Ottawa
00:15:26 that they had no credibility and that they were responsible for it and I think this was actually
00:15:33 a remarkable bit of self-awareness now Greg Fergus has said a lot of things with which I disagree he
00:15:38 was one of the ones that went up there and made these sweeping accusations of racism in the convoy
00:15:43 protests and obviously it sounds like there was consensus the liberal caucus was on board with
00:15:49 use of the emergencies act but a lot of them we know were kind of coerced into it there were
00:15:54 people that raised some frustrations like nathaniel erskine smith and joelle lightbound
00:16:00 and they only went along with it because they had to thanks to justin trudeau's declaration that
00:16:06 this was going to be a confidence vote and ergo one that he needed to whip but all of this is right
00:16:13 now part of a liberal strategy, it seems like, that was moving towards it. David Lamedi was
00:16:18 talking about the Emergencies Act going back to February 3rd. So the convoy hadn't even been there
00:16:25 a week and he was already talking about Emergencies Act powers. And that's why I actually don't think
00:16:30 it was just in jest when he talks about sending in a tank, which, by the way, reminded me of this
00:16:37 like 16-year-old fear-mongering campaign ad that the Liberals used against Stephen Harper
00:16:43 in the 2006 election. It's a famous one, but take a look.
00:16:51 Stephen Harper actually announced he wants to increase military presence in our cities,
00:16:58 Canadian cities, soldiers with guns in our cities.
00:17:05 in Canada.
00:17:10 We did not make this up.
00:17:15 Choose your Canada.
00:17:18 No, you weren't making it up,
00:17:20 except you were the ones doing it.
00:17:21 Tanks in our streets, in our cities.
00:17:25 We are not making this up.
00:17:27 Well, no, you're not.
00:17:27 You're doing it.
00:17:28 You're actually doing it
00:17:29 or talking about doing it.
00:17:31 So my goodness,
00:17:32 this is a fascinating, fascinating display.
00:17:34 Now, I think what's interesting here is that the government has positioned itself as being incredibly transparent about all of this.
00:17:43 But yesterday, as we saw, they were fighting tooth and nail to maintain redactions of documents that they've published.
00:17:50 They're not entirely waiving cabinet confidence, and they're still holding firm on solicitor-client privilege.
00:17:57 And I want to play this clip from David Lamedi, who is both the Justice Minister and the Attorney General, which means he is the Government of Canada's lawyer.
00:18:07 And the government's lawyer actually, sorry, the lawyer representing the government in the committee hearing, so not Lamedi,
00:18:15 preemptively asserted solicitor-client privilege to prevent David Lamedi from speaking about things that involved his advice to the government that was legal advice.
00:18:25 Take a look.
00:18:26 Thank you. Good morning, Commissioner. It's Andrea Gonzales, counsel for the Government of Canada.
00:18:31 The next witness will be Minister of Justice David Lamedi. In addition to being Minister of Justice, of course,
00:18:39 the Minister is the Attorney General of Canada, the lawyer to the Government of Canada.
00:18:46 And I wanted to put on the record that the Government of Canada continues to assert and maintain
00:18:51 all of its claims of solicitor client privilege in respect of all legal advice and opinions.
00:18:59 Minister Lametti's attendance here as a witness is not a waiver of any claims of privilege by
00:19:05 the government of Canada, which he has an obligation to protect. We will be objecting
00:19:11 to and Minister Lametti will be refusing to answer all questions that would delve into
00:19:15 areas of solicitor client privilege. So I just wanted to put that on the record at the front end.
00:19:21 And hopefully examinations can be appropriately tailored to keep the objections to a minimum.
00:19:29 Okay, well, it will be an interesting maneuver throughout the testimony, but I'm sure everyone will be on their guard.
00:19:38 So with that, perhaps we can swear the witness.
00:19:43 Now, at the end of Minister Lamedi's testimony, the commissioner was very measured about it,
00:19:50 but he was raising issues about how all of a sudden this privilege is blocking what's become
00:19:55 a pretty significant part of this inquiry, which is what legal advice the government had on the
00:20:03 Emergencies Act. Now, I am not a lawyer, which is probably a very good thing for would-be clients
00:20:09 of mine. But the thing that's interesting about this is that I realize solicitor-client privilege
00:20:14 is sacrosanct. It's very important. And even the government is entitled to solicitor-client
00:20:19 privilege. But we're talking about legislation that is under investigation right now. And we're
00:20:25 talking about legislation where the government's legal advice is very important to what information
00:20:32 the government had about the applicability of the Emergencies Act. Because remember, if you do a
00:20:37 plain text reading of the Emergencies Act, it says that a threat to the security of Canada has a
00:20:43 definition that is the one set out in the CSIS Act. And if you read the CSIS Act, you don't see
00:20:49 anything there supporting the government's interpretation that that existed in Canada.
00:20:55 And the government has now said, and we've heard from a couple of witnesses, that, well,
00:20:58 there's sort of a broader definition than just the CSIS Act, but nowhere in the legislation does it
00:21:04 say that. So if the government went to its lawyer, David Lamedi, and said, Councillor, tell us,
00:21:10 where is our legal basis for this i think his advice is entirely material and it's despicable
00:21:17 that this government claims to be transparent they're like oh we're so transparent we're even
00:21:21 sharing joking text messages between ministers but they're not sharing the stuff that actually
00:21:27 matters the stuff that gets to the core of why the government thought it could pull one over on
00:21:33 canadians suspend their civil liberties all the while claiming they were not and this was another
00:21:40 takeaway today from david lametti's testimony that infuriated me because the government's line
00:21:46 about this has been that oh the emergencies act is charter compliant yes it says right in there
00:21:51 it's charter compliant it can say whatever it wants it can say that the sky is purple
00:21:56 that doesn't mean it's true because we know the police went in and removed protesters that were
00:22:03 on sidewalks that were behaving peacefully that didn't have trucks and threatened them with arrest
00:22:09 if they did not leave. Lamedi was questioned about that. Watch.
00:22:19 When Minister Mendicino was here yesterday, he said that he believed that, although he would
00:22:25 characterize, I think, at the same way that the protest was illegal, that there were thousands
00:22:30 of people who were aiming to protest lawfully, and thousands of people who were. So not people
00:22:36 who were blocking trucks, people who were simply on the streets, on their feet, protesting peacefully.
00:22:42 Yeah, I grant you that possibility.
00:22:44 Okay. And the orders that were put in place under the Emergencies Act required those people
00:22:50 to leave the area as well.
00:22:53 That's correct.
00:22:54 Thank you.
00:22:54 They always had the option to go somewhere else to protest legally. When the blockade
00:22:58 was cleared, people moved down the street, Wellington Street in Ottawa, towards Booth,
00:23:03 and they protested on the side of the road, not impeding traffic, not impeding pedestrians,
00:23:09 manifesting their political beliefs, waving signs. That was completely legal. Throughout
00:23:14 all of this, those people had an option to move to protest legally, and they didn't.
00:23:21 okay so you had a right to protest you just couldn't protest there so yeah this is actually
00:23:29 a great strategy the government can just say no no no you're not allowed to protest on wellington
00:23:34 street but if you want to go up to like baffin island and protest you are free to do so and
00:23:38 yeah no you can protest uh down the road keep going yeah no keep keep going i'll tell you when
00:23:43 you get there no no no keep yeah keep keep going if i can still see you you're too close yeah okay
00:23:50 yeah more more more just just go so far away we can't see you that is not defending the right of
00:23:57 lawful assembly so minister lametti's point here is that oh and anyone could keep protesting they
00:24:02 just had to move well that doesn't deal with the question that first off government never
00:24:06 communicated to that police never communicated that which is why there were stories of folks
00:24:12 being threatened with arrest or actually arrested who had no vehicles that were just walking down
00:24:18 Albert Street. And this was something that even if the government intended it, which I don't
00:24:23 believe it did, was not filtering down to the situation on the ground. So we are going to talk
00:24:30 about this more in future shows. But again, the man does not live on Public Order Emergency
00:24:34 Commission alone. I want to talk about this story, which has not gotten a lot of coverage. In fact,
00:24:39 as of last look, had no coverage in the mainstream media. And that is the amendment put forward by
00:24:45 the liberals in committee to bill c-21 this is the firearms regulation bill that's coming down
00:24:52 the pipeline and this amendment i just want to read directly from the amendments that were put
00:24:58 forward before committee changes the definition or adds to the definition of a prohibited firearm
00:25:05 the following a firearm that is a rifle or shotgun that is capable of discharging center
00:25:11 fire ammunition in a semi-automatic manner and that is designed to accept a detachable cartridge
00:25:18 magazine with a capacity greater than five cartridges of the type for which the firearm
00:25:24 was originally designed. Now, if you're a gun owner, you're seething right now. If you're not
00:25:28 a gun owner, you're like, what the hell did he just say? It is a firearm that has a round of
00:25:33 ammunition that's basically anything other than a .22, which is a little tiny cartridge and has
00:25:37 a magazine that takes more than five rounds of ammunition. Let's talk about why this matters.
00:25:43 Rod Giltaka is here, head of the Canadian Coalition for Firearm Rights. Rod, good to talk to you as
00:25:49 always. Thanks for coming on today. Thanks for having me. So what types of guns are we talking
00:25:54 about here that are not prohibited already by the Liberals that would be caught by this amendment?
00:25:59 Well, for all intents and purposes, it's a centerfire, semi-automatic rifles and shotguns
00:26:04 they can take a detachable magazine. So there's some nuance there when you talked about a magazine
00:26:09 that could, that was, uh, or a firearm that was originally designed to take a magazine that could,
00:26:14 uh, hold more than five rounds. There's, there's a lot of nuance there, but basically any magazine
00:26:20 fed firearm could take a magazine that could hold more than the prescribed number of rounds.
00:26:25 If you get ahold of it and who knows what it was designed for in the first place, it was just
00:26:29 magazine fed. So I guess for purposes of our discussion, all semi-automatic rifles and
00:26:36 shotguns that are center fire that accept removable magazines, and that's probably around
00:26:39 2 million firearms that are now going to be prohibited if that amendment
00:26:44 is passed into the bill and the bill is passed through the Senate and receives royal assent.
00:26:50 One of the things that I find interesting about this is that there's been a lot in Canada of
00:26:55 haggling over magazine limits. And oftentimes on firearms, there's a pin in a magazine,
00:27:00 so it could theoretically take more rounds, but a government regulation has capped it at five
00:27:06 rounds. Would a magazine that is pinned to five rounds, but could theoretically, if you were to
00:27:11 illegally remove that pin, take more, would that satisfy this in your view? Well, the way that it's
00:27:17 worded is quite ambiguous. And those are the kinds of laws that the government seems to love. They
00:27:21 don't like, you know, straightforward stuff. But the way that it's written, it's like, I guess
00:27:27 we'll use the most infamous rifle ever, which is the AR-15, which is just another semi-automatic
00:27:32 rifle, just like any other. It was designed originally to have a 30-round magazine. But of
00:27:38 course, in Canada, we can't have those. It's apparently too dangerous. So we have a pin
00:27:43 inserted, a rivet, to limit it to five rounds. But that firearm was originally designed to hold
00:27:50 a 30 round to use a 30 round magazine. And so thus it would now be prohibited. If the original
00:27:56 design had some stubby little five round magazine, it would apparently be okay. So again, more
00:28:01 completely nonsensical, ridiculous rules designed for one reason, it's just to punish people that 0.91
00:28:06 are unlikely to vote for the liberals. Yeah. And, and, you know, this abandons in my view, 0.90
00:28:11 the pretense, I mean, it was long gone. I'm sure you and I could agree, but really abandons the
00:28:15 pretense that nothing that the liberals are doing target sport shooters and firearms owners that
00:28:20 are there that own guns for hunting which has always been their line because you know justin
00:28:24 trudeau's uh explanation no one needs an ar-15 to take down a deer okay well when they're talking
00:28:29 about shotguns and other semi-automatic centerfire rifles that are used for hunting people i mean
00:28:36 who don't know guns don't realize that they're just blatantly misinforming people yeah it's it's
00:28:42 it's uh it's all gaslighting um yeah long gone are all the promises that they they're not going
00:28:48 to affect hunters or sports shooters or anyone else. They're coming for everything. So I have a
00:28:56 few firearms of my own and I'm not unique in that. If I look through my gun cabinet, I'm probably
00:29:03 going to have a couple of guns left after all the dust has settled. So they're coming after
00:29:08 basically everything other than lever actions. There may be some pump action shotguns that will
00:29:15 be prohibited too which is a dangerous precedent so all of those will end up going uh you may have
00:29:20 single shot like break action you know shotguns left and some bolt action rifles and and for some
00:29:25 people that's enough um for most people there isn't but there's always a question how do you
00:29:31 justify doing this like why are you doing this to all these people and they keep saying public safety
00:29:36 and of course it's you know they don't offer any proof of that um so yeah just the gaslighting
00:29:42 continues. And why they're doing this, it's anyone's guess. Well, I think it's important
00:29:47 to not look at C-21 in isolation either. And I think for that, we go back to 2020 and that
00:29:53 initial prohibition of 1,500 types of mostly semi-automatic rifles. And then you follow that
00:30:01 with their efforts to ban handguns. And then you follow that with this latest amendment to C-21.
00:30:07 and and you are right that at a certain point they're attacking in very rapid succession uh
00:30:12 almost every type of firearm except for like at the end of it it's going to be you can have
00:30:18 a revolutionary war musket and that'll be it and then that'll go well it's uh apparently they're
00:30:24 going to include the sks in this and some rimfire rifles as well just because they look scary uh
00:30:31 this is this is there you know it's funny even one of those like tactical looking 22s which i
00:30:38 think most gun owners think are kind of ridiculous but but those those 22s that look scary they could
00:30:42 be prohibited in your view well yeah and i mean i think the the salient point here is everything
00:30:48 that the liberal government says and let's not forget the culpability of the ndp and um and the
00:30:56 block québécois because they're supporting this too everything they say to you is a lie it is it
00:31:01 is a lie top to bottom um and you know first at first it's like oh it's only these guns just these
00:31:08 dangerous assault weapons are they assault weapons no but we have we're going to call them assault
00:31:11 style so that's close enough so they had that whole thing we're going to buy them back it's
00:31:15 like no we're not going to buy them back almost three years later nothing's coming nothing's
00:31:19 forthcoming they have nothing then it's like well handguns oh we're not and then i of course i went
00:31:23 to committee on bill c21 and i have the ndp mp um alistair mcgregor say well nobody's really
00:31:30 banning your handguns right it's a freeze let's let's uh let's be clear and i'm like what do you
00:31:35 mean if i i have handguns so if i die the rcmp are going to come to the house they're going to
00:31:39 take them from my grieving window and my kids that are licensed and they're going to take them
00:31:44 without any compensation and destroy them and they'll take them by force they'll be like well
00:31:48 either you give them up or you go to jail so but it's not a ban don't call it a ban so i think you
00:31:52 were just talking about the the the Emergencies Act inquiry and how they keep saying these things
00:31:58 even though they're demonstrably untrue and I mean this is this this is a government these are
00:32:03 a group of people I don't think that we've ever seen before not at this level no and and you and
00:32:08 I have talked about this in the past and you were very graciously a big supporter of and star in the
00:32:14 documentary I did about this a year and a half back you know and the public education about guns
00:32:20 has always been I think very poor and it's not for for lack of effort on the part of gun owners
00:32:24 it's that gun owners are a very small minority relatively speaking of the Canadian population
00:32:29 and you have a lot of urbanites in this country that have never encountered a gun and to their
00:32:34 knowledge have probably never met a gun owner that really buy into the narrative that they're fed by
00:32:40 the government and fed by a lot of the mainstream media in this country and when stuff like this
00:32:46 happens it's terrible that if a conservative leader puts forward a very sensible opposition
00:32:52 to this they get cast into that oh he wants everyone walking around you know with an ar-15
00:32:57 on the streets it's like no that's not what's being debated here yeah they want to make assault
00:33:01 weapons legal again and i mean it's such a misleading it's such a misleading statement
00:33:05 on its face because assault weapons have been banned since 1977 so they'd actually have to
00:33:11 clarified and say assault style weapons legal again so it's it's a it's it's the reason why
00:33:16 it's so effective is it's a fear-based narrative right it's they they they are always and when i
00:33:21 say i mean the liberals again with the ndp right alongside them and the bloc quebecois they're
00:33:27 marching the public using the government's resources educational resources and media
00:33:32 resources marching them along saying there's a direct connection between somebody like me that
00:33:36 has a firearms license that gets background checked every day that has legal storage that
00:33:41 could have my home searched to make sure I'm storing my firearms properly whose handguns are
00:33:45 registered whose AR-15s were registered can only shoot those at an approved shooting rate all that
00:33:49 stuff they're always trying to draw a line between people like me and the shootings that they see in
00:33:54 downtown Toronto or downtown Vancouver their entire narrative is hung on that so it's it's
00:34:00 incredibly deceptive but it is very effective because their side of the story can be told
00:34:05 with taglines like more guns equal more death it's like well for me to for me to debunk that
00:34:10 it takes about 10 sentences and you'll never get that on a mainstream legacy media format
00:34:15 so it's very effective that way and that's what we're up against and uh yeah it's it's it's it's
00:34:20 it's a difficult fight but we're not gonna just lay down and let them take them you mentioned the
00:34:25 sks now just for for people that don't know the sks they're mass-produced soviet you often rifles
00:34:33 that you could just buy for dirt cheap
00:34:35 because they're surplus.
00:34:36 I mean, I think a lot of people get them
00:34:38 for like under 200 bucks back in the day.
00:34:40 Maybe they're a little bit more now.
00:34:41 They're semi-automatic.
00:34:42 They're not particularly accurate. 0.96
00:34:44 They're dirty, but they're fun to shoot. 0.75
00:34:45 They're fun. 0.96
00:34:46 They look cool.
00:34:47 And there are, I don't know if there's an exact number,
00:34:50 but I would assume there have to be tens of thousands
00:34:52 of these in Canada right now, correct?
00:34:54 About a million of them.
00:34:55 A million SKSs.
00:34:56 And they're non-restricted,
00:34:59 which means that if you have a license, you buy one.
00:35:01 It's not registered to you.
00:35:02 Something like this, I feel is just logistically impossible to prohibit because you can't enforce
00:35:09 it when you don't know where these things are.
00:35:11 And so if the law abiding, dutiful, diligent citizens will hand theirs back into the government
00:35:15 and the people that don't have regard for the law will still have them.
00:35:19 Well, there's a problem occurring here, Andrew.
00:35:22 And the problem is, is that laws have to be reasonable and they have to be justified.
00:35:26 When the government says we're going to use the capacity to project force that you've paid for, it has to be justified.
00:35:37 So what they're saying is we're going to use that force on you.
00:35:39 It doesn't matter.
00:35:40 This is part of our political agenda.
00:35:42 And what happens is reasonable, law-abiding people are just like, well, wait a minute.
00:35:47 This isn't fair.
00:35:48 This is wrong.
00:35:49 I'm actually, you're extracting money and taxes from me in order to be able to do this to me.
00:35:54 I'm going to consider noncompliance.
00:35:56 and the minute that you start looking at a scenario that like right now what the government's doing
00:36:00 and you're like a reasonable person might start considering non-compliance like that is that is
00:36:05 creating cracks that's a violation of the social contract is what they're doing right now but it's
00:36:10 creating cracks in in in our society and that's that's bad so you know while this seems to be a
00:36:16 big joke to liberal mps and liberal supporters while they think this is funny doing this to
00:36:21 well probably a roughly a million Canadians are licensed to own these firearms well I guess I
00:36:28 guess 2.2 million but a million Canadians probably own these firearms they seem to think this funny
00:36:32 but it's not funny it's very corrosive to our society it's destroying the relationship and an
00:36:36 important one at that between uh productive citizens and the government and productive
00:36:42 citizens and law enforcement because somebody's going to come looking for those guns and it's
00:36:45 not going to be Justin Trudeau he'll be hiding in the cottage right just like he did during COVID
00:36:49 that's that's very corrosive to our society so you got to really think about when you want to
00:36:54 use government force and and laws um and make sure that's justified so if you say it's for public
00:36:59 safety it has to be and you have to prove that or you're just you're just destroying the social
00:37:04 fabric of our country and i think i think people forget that in this hyper-partisan time up until
00:37:10 a couple of months ago i i thought that the main ways you could combat this was uh the legal route
00:37:16 which I know the CCFR has taken and is taking about that order in council back in 2020,
00:37:21 the political route, getting political leaders to enact change, and to a lesser extent,
00:37:26 the public education route, which you hope then people will call on their politicians.
00:37:30 But there's a new avenue that opened up in the last couple of months, which I think is a fascinating
00:37:35 one, and that is provinces declaring that they will not enforce these laws. Alberta was the first,
00:37:42 and then there was Manitoba, and then there was New Brunswick and Saskatchewan.
00:37:46 So you've got four provinces here.
00:37:48 I believe Yukon, I can't remember, there was a nuance with Yukon,
00:37:51 but you've still got four provinces there that have said
00:37:53 they do not believe this is an adequate use of police resources.
00:37:57 And the federal government has really had to admit
00:37:59 that it has no way of forcing them to enforce this law.
00:38:03 So is that something you're optimistic about
00:38:06 really driving in the future with other provinces?
00:38:08 Well, Alberta and Saskatchewan have both already put out statements that they are condemning this new amendment that was brought through in Bill C-21 or that was presented. It hasn't passed. They have the votes to pass it because, of course, the Bloc and the NDP will support them.
00:38:23 um but so there's a there are some green shoots there as well but i think the fact going back to
00:38:29 what you said in the beginning of of your question the fact that four provinces in a territory have
00:38:34 said you know what we're not even going to cooperate with you that should be another
00:38:37 indication to the federal government they should be like well wait wait a minute maybe we should
00:38:40 rethink what we're doing maybe what we're doing isn't right if we're actually having provinces
00:38:45 rebelling against us so but this is again right this is not this is not your your father or your
00:38:51 grandfather's liberal party this is an entirely alien group of people um that i think are very
00:38:58 dangerous for the country and they these these kinds of people they wouldn't think twice about
00:39:01 what they're doing they're like well i guess we got to put i guess we got to push harder
00:39:05 anyway we have to we have to people have to bend the knee to us and and normally you and i have
00:39:10 known each other for a while right like i don't usually like to use language like this but it's
00:39:14 getting to the point where it's like you know i i find myself almost in the past defending
00:39:19 the government and saying, well, maybe they just know not what they do, but man, this is just
00:39:23 getting really crazy. Yeah. And I mean, and a lot of police officers too, that I've spoken to
00:39:28 are themselves civilian gun owners. And, uh, you know, some of them for very practical reasons,
00:39:33 because, you know, they don't get enough range time as police. So they train on their own and,
00:39:36 and are enthusiasts and they have no interest in, in enforcing these laws. And obviously they will
00:39:41 ultimately, if that's the direction, but I'm hopeful that more provinces will step up because
00:39:46 again we clearly the federal government is entrenched in this position and i don't think
00:39:50 justin trudeau or bill blair or marco medicino are going to wake up one day and say you know
00:39:54 what maybe the law-abiding gun owners aren't the problem but i if they if they're finding a
00:39:58 resistance from the police uh that are supposed to uphold this and by that i mean the provinces
00:40:04 that are responsible for allocating those police resources they'll have a law with no enforcement
00:40:09 and i think they'll have to kind of retreat with their tails between their legs i don't know i don't
00:40:13 I, again, I, I take no pleasure in, you know, being in the position right now where I'm like,
00:40:19 I wouldn't put anything past them. I mean, we just heard that they were, they were considering,
00:40:22 uh, using, uh, you know, bringing tanks in to clear protesters, but it was not a semi-automatic
00:40:27 tank. It was fine. Yeah. It was a manually operated tank. Yeah. It was a bolt action tank.
00:40:32 Exactly. Right. Like it's just, it's such a strange time. I, and I, I, I just will,
00:40:37 I've been wrong as often as I've been right about, you know, how far they'll go. I don't think,
00:40:41 I don't think we can put anything past them. But as an organization, we're going to continue to
00:40:45 fight against them. We're going to continue to try to get our message out to Canadians, right? 1.00
00:40:49 That's really important. I'm hoping that Canadians, mainstream, middle of the road,
00:40:53 centrist Canadians, which most of us used to be, right? In the days before we were labeled
00:40:58 extremist. I'm hoping most people will come to their senses and go, these are not liberals.
00:41:04 This is a very dangerous group of people and they shouldn't be anywhere near power. And they're all
00:41:08 going to show up and bring their friends and family in the next election and get rid of these
00:41:12 people once and for all. That's what I'm hoping. I know the CCFR has a lot of business members.
00:41:17 Just anecdotally, have you heard about any upticks in sales of semi-automatics today? And I ask that
00:41:23 because I know every other time the Liberals have tried to ban something, they become impossible to
00:41:26 get because there's just a run on them. Well, it's, see, that puts, I mean, there probably would
00:41:33 be. I haven't heard anything. It's only been a day. But yeah, a lot of people might run out
00:41:37 and buy those by those guns that that may or may not be on the list, but certainly would fit the
00:41:42 the description of centerfire semi-automatic with a detachable magazine. But at the same time,
00:41:47 the liberals have instituted a backdoor gun registry, which, of course, they promised not
00:41:54 to do, but they've they've done it. So the government will know where all of those guns are
00:41:59 and they will just, I guess, in theory, send people to come and take those guns away if people don't
00:42:06 give them up voluntarily. So I don't know, that's going to temper sales quite a bit.
00:42:13 But one interesting point of this whole thing, if you watch the meeting at committee for Bill C-21
00:42:20 yesterday, the Liberals did not include a buyback for any of these firearms. So their intent as it
00:42:28 stands today is just to prohibit them all and that's it, you get nothing. Wow, just licensing
00:42:34 themselves to do an all-out confiscation terrible stuff uh we'll certainly follow this rod giltaka
00:42:39 from the canadian coalition for firearm rights always a pleasure and keep up the fight sir
00:42:43 thanks andrew thank you rod i yeah i mean when i looked at that and i was like in my looking at my
00:42:49 gun cabinet i'm like oh man this is gonna i'm gonna need a smaller cabinet at the end of this
00:42:53 because they're going after basically everything in it and i don't even have one of those like
00:42:57 revolutionary war muskets which at a certain point will be the only thing you're allowed to and
00:43:01 heck of a lot more risky to fire a musket than your average semi-automatic rifle but maybe we
00:43:08 need to do like a true north range day or something that would be fun good to bring
00:43:11 everyone out to the gun range the liberals would love that that does it for us for today we will
00:43:16 be back next week with more of the andrew lawton show friday with fake news friday and all the
00:43:22 public order emergency commission coverage you love and know and crave is going to be at tnc.news
00:43:28 So do check that out.
00:43:29 But I'll bid you adieu for now.
00:43:31 This is Canada's most irreverent talk show,
00:43:34 The Andrew Lawton Show on True North.
00:43:35 Thank you, God bless, and good day to you all.
00:43:38 Thanks for listening to The Andrew Lawton Show.
00:43:40 Support the program by donating to True North at www.tnc.news.