Juno News - January 25, 2024


Liberal MP backtracks after calling for review of Trudeau's leadership

Topics
Mentioned
It's official: Trudeau broke the law Tucker Carlson comes to ‘liberate’ Canada (ft. Rachel Emmanuel)

Episode Stats


Length

44 minutes

Words per minute

182.16

Word count

8,174

Sentence count

288

Harmful content

Misogyny

7

sentences flagged

Toxicity

6

sentences flagged

Hate speech

3

sentences flagged


Summary

Summaries generated with gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ .

A fly just flew in and killed my coffee, and now there's a fly sitting in front of me. These are the first world problems we get on the Andrew Lawton Show, and they're not the only ones we get.

Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Topics generated with Qwen2.5-3B-Instruct.
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 Transcription by CastingWords
00:00:30 Thank you.
00:01:00 welcome to canada's most irreverent talk show this is the andrew lawton show brought to you by true
00:01:20 norton but a fly just flew in literally just dive-bombed my coffee like a second before the
00:01:32 show began and it appears to have killed him but now there's a fly sitting these are the first
00:01:38 world problems we get on the andrew lawton show i just may i hadn't even taken a sip of that thing
00:01:43 yet all right so let me know in the comments do i just pull the fly out and drink the coffee
00:01:48 or do I dump the coffee altogether?
00:01:52 Or I guess there's a third option,
00:01:54 which is do I continue to drink the coffee
00:01:56 and like let the fly really steep it? 0.78
00:01:59 That's a big ass fly in there too. 1.00
00:02:02 All right, yeah, I gotta move it.
00:02:04 I'm gonna accidentally drink from the coffee
00:02:06 and you're all gonna be repulsed by me.
00:02:07 So I'm just gonna like move it way over there.
00:02:10 I needed that to get through the show.
00:02:12 If I just like keel over by 1.15, that's why.
00:02:14 It's because the fly was so rude as to sully my Americano.
00:02:20 I am a man of the people, though, so welcome to the Andrew Lawton Show.
00:02:24 We call that a cold open in the business, although in this particular case, it is a hot open, especially for that fly.
00:02:30 May he rest in pieces.
00:02:33 Nevertheless, this is Thursday, January 25th, 2023.
00:02:37 You are tuned into Canada's Most Irreverent Talk Show.
00:02:39 Was that a sufficiently irreverent opening to the program here?
00:02:43 I'm going to be talking a little bit later on about Alberta Premier Danielle Smith taking the stage with Tucker Carlson in Alberta, where he started his efforts to liberate Canada.
00:02:56 Has Canada been sufficiently liberated after what happened 24 hours ago? We'll find out, I guess.
00:03:00 But also talking later on about the fallout from the federal court's ruling on the Emergencies Act, finding that Justin Trudeau was not only not justified in invoking the Emergencies Act, but that the way he did it violated Canadians' constitutional rights.
00:03:17 We've been covering this all week. We will continue as the show progresses.
00:03:21 But I wanted to actually start off with a bit of like inside politics, inside baseball here for Canadian politics,
00:03:27 because there is in a majority government, a ton of members of parliament you've never heard of before.
00:03:33 In a minority government, not as many, but there are still some that are backbenchers in the governing party
00:03:39 where even someone like me who follows politics a lot, I'll hear their name and I'll be like, I have no idea.
00:03:44 It could have been like my doctor or something.
00:03:46 I have no idea who these people are.
00:03:48 And this is the case with the Liberals.
00:03:51 You've got a few people that they only kind of make news when they do something notable.
00:03:56 And for most Liberal back members of Parliament, they will never do anything notable in their life.
00:04:01 But there was one in particular that stood up and took a principled stand not that long ago
00:04:06 when the Conservatives were taking aim at yet another increase to the federal carbon tax.
00:04:12 Now, Ken McDonald is a member of parliament in Avalon, which is in Newfoundland, and Ken
00:04:19 McDonald decided to vote in support of a conservative motion that was calling on the
00:04:24 Liberals to, I forget the exact wording of it, but it was basically taking aim at the
00:04:28 Liberals' increase to the carbon tax.
00:04:31 The Liberals, you may recall, had given an exemption that applied only to Atlantic Canadians,
00:04:36 or not spelled out that way, but that was the implication of it because they were exempting
00:04:42 home heating oil which is used predominantly by people in atlantic canada now ken mcdonald
00:04:47 voted in favor of giving a carbon tax break to canadians this was how he defended it
00:04:54 in an interview later on so tell us why you decided to vote against your own government
00:04:59 same reason as i did it the first time it was that i felt that uh this is not the time to be
00:05:07 making things more expensive in our communities
00:05:10 and in the province of Newfoundland and Labrador.
00:05:12 I think, I've said before, I do believe in climate change
00:05:16 and that we need to do something about it,
00:05:18 but not to increase prices at this time.
00:05:21 I just think it's a wrong time to bring in those policies.
00:05:24 The Conservatives gave you a standing ovation yesterday.
00:05:27 I'm wondering if you're worried at all about the optics
00:05:29 and what your colleagues said to you afterwards.
00:05:32 No, nobody had anything to say, actually.
00:05:34 They did the same thing, I think, the first time I did it.
00:05:37 and they did it again yesterday,
00:05:39 but I guess they just wanted to recognize the fact
00:05:41 to say thank you for standing up on our side of the House for a change.
00:05:46 Has your government given you any guarantee
00:05:48 that they will increase the rebates for rural Canadians?
00:05:52 No, my understanding, they are looking at it.
00:05:55 Whether it will come to fruition or not, I don't know.
00:05:57 And part of the reason why I did this was to also support Premier Fiori.
00:06:03 He's asking for the same thing, for it to be stalled.
00:06:05 and I stand with him for that for the constituents that I represent.
00:06:10 So Ken Macdonald gives a very reasoned answer there.
00:06:13 The Conservatives, of course, did give him a standing ovation for backing their motion.
00:06:18 That doesn't make him a Conservative.
00:06:19 It just makes him a responsible Canadian and a respectful representative of his constituents
00:06:25 by effectively saying, yeah, I don't want these people saddled with the carbon tax.
00:06:29 Now, when the Liberals gave that exemption to Atlantic Canada,
00:06:33 That seemed to be all it took to get Mr. McDonald there to just pipe down, shut up and fall in line because he looked after his constituents.
00:06:40 It didn't actually matter about the rest of Canadians when all was said and done.
00:06:46 So why am I talking about Ken McDonald again?
00:06:48 Well, this week, Ken McDonald showed once again a little glimmer of independence.
00:06:53 He stood up and said that Justin Trudeau should face a leadership review.
00:06:59 He says, every leader, every party has a best before date.
00:07:04 Our best before date is here.
00:07:08 Now, this is actually a very important thing.
00:07:10 Justin Trudeau has had a very ironclad grip on his caucus.
00:07:14 There has been very little dissent.
00:07:16 Joel Lightbound, who was that Quebec MP that criticized the Liberal government's pandemic
00:07:21 policies, he was one example of a guy who had a little bit of independence.
00:07:26 But we haven't heard from Joel Lightbound in quite a while.
00:07:28 So he effectively fell in line.
00:07:31 So Ken McDonald wasn't calling on Justin Trudeau to step down.
00:07:35 But he did an interview, and he said the party should have a leadership review
00:07:39 that allows for members to permit rivals for the leadership to come forward.
00:07:44 So he was saying that Justin Trudeau, if he's going to stay on, should have to fight for it.
00:07:48 He said, as a party, let's clear the air.
00:07:50 And if people are still intent on having the leader we have now, fine.
00:07:53 but let's at least give people the opportunity to have their say in what they think the direction
00:08:00 the party is going i decided not to do it with the accent i feel that would have been offensive
00:08:05 to some of the people in newfoundland i may i may slip into the accent later we'll see
00:08:09 but uh again maybe there's another poll question for you should andrew do his most offensive newfie
00:08:14 accent but i never i will say i so years ago i was on masterchef canada which was a reality
00:08:20 cooking show. And I was eliminated in the first episode in a montage. So if you blinked, you missed
00:08:25 me. But when we were filming, there were two people from Newfoundland on the show who like
00:08:31 the drunker they got, the heavier the Newfie accent got. And at the end of it, it was only
00:08:34 they could understand each other. And we were all just looking like, I think what they said was a
00:08:38 joke. I didn't hear the punchline or the setup. But anyway, love Newfoundland, spent only a few
00:08:44 hours there, but it is an absolutely lovely place. Ken McDonald does what he does best. He's trying
00:08:50 to be independent. He says we should have a leadership review. Well, that story came out
00:08:55 yesterday. Let's fast forward to the headline today. I know, so heartbreaking. Ken McDonald
00:09:04 walks back his comments that liberals need a leadership review. So what Ken McDonald is now
00:09:11 saying is that Justin Trudeau is a great campaigner, which is as backhanded a compliment
00:09:18 as you can give someone that's like watching some terrible movie and saying that uh well i i think
00:09:24 the lighting was good like you're trying to find like the weirdest strangest compliment that you
00:09:30 can think of to offer and it's a bit of a weird one but he says in a statement so the statement
00:09:37 is what you send out when you don't want to go before the press again because you know you're
00:09:41 going to say the wrong thing again he said the intent of my recent public comments was not to
00:09:46 personally call for a leadership review and I am not calling for one now and then he of course
00:09:53 goes on to say Justin Trudeau is a great campaigner he says the government now of today
00:09:57 is getting to be an old government those were his words in the interview but in the statement it's
00:10:02 no no I'm not saying anything of the sort I so I suspect what happened is Ken McDonald was at home
00:10:07 in Avalon minding his own business he got a knock at the door and then he opened the door and this
00:10:12 was the group that awaited him. I think he got like the Lebrano's mob squad just at his front
00:10:17 door, desperately telling him to get into compliance there. And so then what happened
00:10:25 is we had, of course, Ken McDonald do an about face in less than 24 hours and say, no, no, no,
00:10:31 no, no, no. I'm not calling for a leadership review at all. Never. No, no, no. I divide a
00:10:37 visit a boat tonight. No, sorry, I said I wouldn't do it. So here's what's happening. Anytime some
00:10:43 liberal dares to show just the slightest bit of independence, they get the hook, they get pulled
00:10:49 off stage, the music plays, the microphone goes down, and they are going to be never heard from
00:10:54 again. He's going to show up, you know, ball gagged and bruised when the House of Commons resumes in
00:11:00 just a few days time, because Ken McDonald will never make that mistake again of saying what he
00:11:06 thinks and look i i feel for him the liberals deserve a great deal of credit the only party
00:11:12 i can think of that has had as good a job as good a track record as trudeau and the liberals
00:11:21 of keeping caucus dissent in check would be doug ford and the progressive conservatives in ontario
00:11:26 anytime someone in the pc caucus of ontario has dared to be independent they have been like kicked
00:11:31 out of caucus it happened to randy hillier and belinda carahalios and roman babber and then you
00:11:37 fast forward to 2022 and what do you get no independent mpps the only people that want to
00:11:43 be independent end up resigning or retiring from office so here's what's happening we have the
00:11:49 liberals who are very much long in the tooth the poll numbers are in absolute decline they are in
00:11:55 In free fall, not a single person, not a single person I have spoken to,
00:12:01 and I have many people that I know in my life, believe it or not,
00:12:03 who voted for Justin Trudeau, at least in one of the past three elections,
00:12:07 oftentimes two of them, and not a single one of those people that I've spoken to
00:12:12 has said they will vote for Justin Trudeau again.
00:12:14 Now, some of these people are not fans of Pierre Paulyev.
00:12:16 Maybe they'll stay home, maybe they'll vote NDP,
00:12:18 maybe they'll just, you know, flee Canada altogether.
00:12:21 But this is an incredibly important point.
00:12:25 that we all need to be aware of here which is that the call has to come from within
00:12:30 if you want anything to change before the next election the NDP is not going to pull the plug
00:12:35 Jagmeet Singh wants his pension the conservatives cannot pull the government down without getting
00:12:41 the NDP on board the Bloc Québécois are in a similar boat so if Justin Trudeau is to be gone
00:12:47 before 2025 the call needs to come from within the house and the number of people in that caucus that
00:12:53 cannot put their long-term interests front and center is actually shocking because if you're a
00:12:58 liberal member of parliament in, you know, let's say the GTA, you're in Vancouver, you're in
00:13:04 Atlantic Canada, you are not going to have a job in two years if the party continues on the path
00:13:11 it's on. So either these people are just complete and utter cowards, they're complete and utter 0.98
00:13:16 morons because they can't actually see the writing on the wall here, or they just don't care if they 1.00
00:13:20 go down with the ship. And to be honest, I think there's some truth to that idea that a lot of 1.00
00:13:25 these people genuinely do not know that things are as bad as they are. I mean, this is the
00:13:31 Sunnyways government, but I think a lot of liberal members of parliament, believe it or not,
00:13:35 are just so enamored with Justin Trudeau themselves. They don't realize just how
00:13:40 unpopular he is. I won't play it for you because if you've seen it before, but the liberals
00:13:45 recirculated Pierre Polyev's Apple video. And the text accompanying it was like about Donald Trump
00:13:52 winning New Hampshire. Like it was a bizarre thing. And I'm like, you don't realize Polyev 1.00
00:13:57 comes out looking pretty good in this exchange, but all they can do is be like, Trump, like that's
00:14:03 the only liberal, the liberal platform is actually just going to be a picture of Donald Trump and a
00:14:07 picture of Polyev. And then like 19 pages of just like, you know, Mad Libs or, you know, picture
00:14:12 books and crosswords or whatever like they don't even need a platform in their view they can just
00:14:16 say paliev is trump and that's going to be enough for them nevertheless the big news of the week has
00:14:23 not been the flip-flop of ken mcdonald but it's been the federal courts uh trump card if you will
00:14:29 on the federal government declaring that the use of the emergencies act was unlawful it did not
00:14:35 comply with the emergencies act and the measures employed did not comply with the canadian
00:14:40 constitution. We've talked a lot about what this means in terms of the legal arguments that are
00:14:46 being put forward. We spoke a bit yesterday on the longer term implications of this and what
00:14:51 it'll mean if it goes to the federal court of appeal and most likely beyond that to the Supreme
00:14:56 Court. But I wanted to delve into this in a bit more detail because there have been a lot of
00:15:00 questions. And one big one is how this has been such a divergence from a lot of the other case
00:15:07 law on constitutional freedoms in the last few years, which have been, as I've said on the show,
00:15:12 very deferential to the government and not particularly mindful of protecting people's
00:15:17 freedoms. James Manson is the Director of Legal Services with the Justice Center for Constitutional
00:15:23 Freedoms and joins me now. James, it's good to talk to you. I should say to my audience,
00:15:28 by way of disclosure, I sit on the board of the Justice Center for Constitutional Freedoms, but
00:15:32 that has no bearing on this interview. And this is not to be taken, James, as a performance review
00:15:37 by your board thanks very much you showed up on time so you're getting a passing grade so far but
00:15:44 welcome let's start there i mean we've seen a lot of dismal rulings on constitutional freedoms
00:15:49 in the last several years on covet era cases on free speech cases why did this one in your view
00:15:55 go the other way like where was the judge going with this that we haven't seen many of his
00:16:00 colleagues go? That's an excellent question, Andrew. And, you know, I have been struggling
00:16:07 with the answer to that question for a couple of years, probably like you, probably like a lot of
00:16:13 the viewers and listeners. Why is it that these courts have been so unwilling to, you know,
00:16:19 even consider the Charter of Rights or consider these very important issues dealing with all the
00:16:26 COVID stuff? Why were they so unwilling to do that? And yet, a couple days ago, Justice Mosley
00:16:32 comes right through and gives us that win that we were looking for so desperately. Why was that the
00:16:38 case? And I think part of it may be legal. There may be a legal answer to part of that. There also
00:16:45 may be a psychological answer to part of that. Now, I'm not a psychologist, of course, but
00:16:49 I think that back in those days, a couple, two, three, four years ago, we all remember the
00:16:56 the fear right that was going on in our society there was a lot of it going on and i mean i think
00:17:04 maybe some of us felt it to a greater or lesser degree but i think a lot of people in society
00:17:10 were very very afraid and i think that that fear extended throughout society which would include
00:17:17 government the the judiciary a lot of people in positions of authority and i think a lot of this
00:17:24 may have come from the reticence the fear to say I can't take a position on this I can't hear this
00:17:31 I'm too afraid of getting COVID and getting sick and potentially dying or you know all the horrible
00:17:36 things that we were talking about back a few years ago I think a lot of that may have been
00:17:41 partly what was responsible and so the reason I say that Andrew is because now we're three years
00:17:48 later we're four years later we're not quite so worried anymore about COVID now COVID is a bit of
00:17:53 punchline i don't mean to be that glib about it but people say oh i got covered over the weekend
00:17:58 and it sucked and i had to stay home and no big deal that's where we are now with code right so i
00:18:03 think partly there's a psychological explanation but the other explanation andrew is more in my
00:18:09 bailiwick which is legal and so i think maybe the covet stuff was um much more scientifically driven
00:18:22 it was much more about you know whether there is a scientific explanation for vaccines
00:18:28 or whether or not staying at home is is the right thing to do medically or whatever and
00:18:32 there's all these scientific expert reports flying around for all that stuff and the courts were
00:18:37 really reticent to get involved in all that because of course expert opinions expert evidence
00:18:42 in the courts it's always very very tricky and in this particular case we weren't really talking so
00:18:49 much about any of the stuff that was really covid really hardcore covid stuff it was a totally
00:18:56 different question which was about the emergencies act which is a very very um you know complicated
00:19:04 issue but it's very legal it's very constitutional it's much more it's something that that a judge
00:19:11 or a court would have much easier time grappling with in the abstract than covid science medicine
00:19:18 all that stuff and i mean don't get me wrong andrew i totally um think that the courts should
00:19:25 have gone there anyway with all the science they totally should have but that's that ship has
00:19:31 already sailed of course yeah i mean to find a judge who is an expert in science and medicine
00:19:37 is is very very difficult it's incredibly rare so judges have to be deferential to the the experts
00:19:43 and when the government puts out you know all of these people in lab coats it's very easy to say
00:19:47 say, well, okay, yeah, that must be science. And your point about the legal aspects, I think,
00:19:53 is incredibly important. Now, I'm not a lawyer. I kind of play one on TV sometimes because I've
00:19:58 studied these cases and covered them. And I have people like yourself whose expertise I get to
00:20:02 claim credit for in later shows when I repeat it back to my audience. But the Emergencies Act is a
00:20:08 very well-written piece of legislation, I think, in terms of spelling out the test. And I actually
00:20:14 found it very easy to go kind of point by point through all of the premises and caveats that it
00:20:20 gives and try to line that up with the government's argument. And to be honest, there was not a lot
00:20:26 of subjectivity in the test for a national emergency, in the test for a threat to the
00:20:31 security of Canada. The only time you got into a pretty ambiguous territory was when it talks
00:20:36 about cabinet has to have a reasonable belief because they're carving in a bit of subjectivity
00:20:42 there. But that was where I thought Justice Mosley's decision was much stronger than Commissioner
00:20:49 Rouleau's decision in the Public Order Emergency Commission, because he was really accepting the
00:20:54 government's very muddied and muddled interpretation of that legal test, whereas Justice Mosley was
00:20:59 much stricter and more literal with it, which is, I think, how it was intended. I agree. I totally
00:21:04 agree i i can't improve upon your comments andrew i mean i mean i think that um i mean we're talking
00:21:14 about two different animals obviously the the public order commission and then this and i think
00:21:19 the listeners and viewers know all about what those two different animals are designed to achieve
00:21:24 one may be totally different than the other one is subject to appeal and one is subject to much
00:21:30 more rigorous cross-examinations and evidentiary requirements and the other one is not etc
00:21:34 all that stuff but i think really what every reasonable observer needs to um i think admit
00:21:44 at the end of the day is that this decision from from from the federal court is much more
00:21:49 authoritative shall we say with respect to the actual you know text of the of the legislation
00:21:54 the actual intent of the parliament in in bringing it into effect i mean remembering this all came
00:22:00 out andrew from the war measures act back in 1970 and the whole debacle of the flq crisis
00:22:06 basically parliament got together and said we have to change this it has to be much harder
00:22:12 to invoke these very very stringent very very um serious powers and this is what they came up with
00:22:20 Right. And so to say that the government suggested or maybe Justice Rouleau acquiesced in in in to suggest that it should be easy or that it should somehow fall to the executive, to cabinet, to just be able to do this whenever it basically wants to.
00:22:40 is crazy in my view it is it is it is totally totally anathema to what parliament
00:22:49 did in in you know enacting this brand new piece of legislation a few years 50 years ago right
00:22:56 yeah and i wanted to ask a little bit about the the mechanics of the next step we know the federal
00:23:01 government is going to be appealing this which means it will likely go to the federal court of
00:23:06 appeal. I've heard several lawyers say that the federal court of appeal is almost certainly going
00:23:10 to take this up given the circumstances. But I'm curious, and I don't know if you can actually
00:23:15 drill this down into a statistical analysis, but how commonly are trial court decisions from the
00:23:23 federal court overturned by the federal court of appeal? Or is it really a toss up? Yeah, I don't
00:23:28 have that statistic. You could probably, I'm not sure if you could find it if you looked. I can tell
00:23:33 you though that um in this particular case um first of all just so that everybody's clear
00:23:40 it's not a question of whether they will take it up they have to take it up if the federal court
00:23:46 of appeal gets a notice of appeal from the government they they have to do the appeal
00:23:51 because the government and and you know anybody on our side also would have the right to an appeal
00:23:57 in this case the second appeal which in this case would be to the supreme court of canada
00:24:03 that one would need to be done by permission you would have to get what they call leave to appeal
00:24:09 so anyway we're in the first step this is this is a um this is an appeal as of right which means
00:24:15 that you can you can appeal it there will be an appeal now the question becomes what happens on
00:24:21 the appeal you know there's different tests and different factors and different things that
00:24:26 happen on an appeal based on the type of of proceeding we're talking about okay so this
00:24:33 isn't a trial with a jury for example this is this was what we call a judicial review
00:24:40 i don't need to bore everybody with it with exactly what that means it's a bit different
00:24:44 than just a regular case but basically when you go on appeal from this decision um from a judicial
00:24:52 review, the standard of review, which is what we use to say, what does the court of appeal do?
00:24:58 What is their function? What are they looking for? Sometimes the appeal court has got a very
00:25:05 narrow function. They're only looking for some place where the judge made a mistake,
00:25:09 screwed up, did something really, really wrong. In other cases, like this one,
00:25:15 Basically, it's kind of a rehearing. It's kind of a do-over. Not entirely a do-over, but kind of a do-over, which is to say that what the appeal court has to do is take a look at the lower court judge's reasons and determine if they basically applied the right standards of review to the declaration and whether or not they applied it all properly.
00:25:43 Now, that's all very formal language to say it's kind of a do-over. So we're going to have to see how much of a do-over we're talking about here. Are we going to literally have 11,000 pages of the record put before the Court of Appeal? Are we going to have a multi-day hearing in the Court of Appeal? Is it going to take months to get there while everybody prepares their briefs again a second time?
00:26:07 I don't know as I sit here. I hope not, because I don't want to have a totally, you know, second kick at the can on the part of the government.
00:26:21 My thinking, my hope anyway, is that this is going to be a fairly, fairly tailored process.
00:26:29 But nonetheless, it's possible that we get into everything all over again, that we get into the mootness again.
00:26:36 It's possible that we get into the national emergency finding again.
00:26:40 It's possible that we get into the national security threat finding.
00:26:44 It's possible that we get into the Charter of Rights again, because, of course, the Section 2 and Section 8 violations of, you know, with those regulations, those horrible regulations, freezing people's bank accounts.
00:26:58 It's possible that we have to revisit all of that.
00:27:00 And given the way the government is going these days, that they seem to be completely unable to recognize and respect the rule of law.
00:27:12 I'm sorry to be to be so spicy when I say that, but it appears like I honestly can't believe, Andrew, that a government would consider appealing a decision like this.
00:27:24 Well, yeah, I mean, I can't believe they would have done the first thing, which was freezing the bank accounts right in the get there.
00:27:29 so that's a fair point i mean they're only they're only real recourse is to just keep digging in and
00:27:34 hope that eventually they're going to get some seal of approval from from a court i guess well
00:27:38 and as you said in your last segment i mean we're not going to get help from mr singh so
00:27:42 yeah it's basically it's basically 2025 or bus right true yeah yeah very very well said
00:27:49 james manson is the director of legal services with the justice center for constitutional
00:27:53 freedoms thank you so much james thanks andrew cheers all right thanks here i was thinking on
00:27:58 the show we would have all of these like great insightful and in-depth comments about uh ken
00:28:02 mcdonald and avalon about justin trudeau and jagmeet singh about the constitution of canada no
00:28:08 everyone's commenting on the damn fly so if you want an update on flygate i i plucked it out of 0.75
00:28:13 the coffee his uh lifeless limp soggy corpse is sitting on my coaster and actually oh sorry no 0.95
00:28:19 that is uh those are justin trudeau's poll numbers uh sorry i thought it was the fly
00:28:22 but uh then we also had uh richard peters says man up and drink the coffee sean is just worried
00:28:29 about the flies family sean is a a bit of a closet hippie here and angry canadian we see this is what
00:28:36 i was concerned about angry canadian on youtube which is probably many of you fit that name says
00:28:40 it's courtesy of klaus schwab yeah this is like i spent too long in davos and now the bugs are just
00:28:45 like dive bombing themselves into my drink so uh this is like klaus schwab's you believe the bugs
00:28:51 he just like shipped it over and the fly landed uh perfectly so i don't do i do i i don't know
00:28:57 i'm i don't know we'll see maybe by the end of the episode i'm still awake though sean says the
00:29:01 fly was supporting three children so well unfortunately you can just go on a serb like 1.00
00:29:06 everyone else there fly and hopefully you'll be looked after all right the big news yesterday in
00:29:11 alberta was tucker carlson making good on his vow to liberate the country that's not just my wording
00:29:18 here he used that himself in a phone call to the prime minister. Thank you for your call you have
00:29:25 reached the media line for all urgent requests please send your request by email. Yes hi I
00:29:36 couldn't understand the French part but it's Tucker Carlson calling from the United States
00:29:41 and I'd be grateful if you pass a message on to the prime minister Justin Trudeau
00:29:45 we are coming to liberate Canada. We are coming to liberate Canada and we'll be there soon. Merci.
00:29:57 And so he did. I think there were a combined like 15,000 people out at his two events yesterday,
00:30:04 one in Calgary and then one in Edmonton in the evening. He had a star-studded panel there,
00:30:10 conrad black and w brett wilson and the of course jordan peterson who is a late addition and alberta
00:30:18 premier danielle smith now we'll get to danielle smith in a moment i want to show she tweeted this
00:30:23 picture which seems to just like trigger so many people here she says free speech means you don't
00:30:28 just have to talk to the mainstream media finished up in calgary off to edmonton next now i i liked
00:30:35 the photo, I thought there was a little something missing from it. It was a je ne sais quoi that was
00:30:41 missing from it. So I tried my own hand at fixing the photo and came up with this.
00:30:47 Yeah, I think that right there is the real photo. This is a Canadian heritage moment.
00:30:52 From left to right, there is Jordan Peterson, Premier Danielle Smith, Tucker Carlson,
00:30:57 and Baron Black of Cross Harbor. Not, just to be technical here, he should never be called Lord
00:31:03 Lord Conrad Black. It is Conrad Lord Black or just Lord Black or just Conrad Black. But
00:31:08 he's often erroneously referred to as Lord Conrad Black, which is just not the proper styling. But
00:31:14 anyway, this is what happens when you watch too much Downton Abbey. But all of that notwithstanding,
00:31:19 there was one more addition to the photo that I thought was even better than that. And I saw this
00:31:22 one this morning. Let's put up this one. Oh, right there. We've got Baron Black of Cross Harbor.
00:31:28 We've got Tucker Carlson, and then we've got Lady Rachel of Emanuel. 1.00
00:31:32 Rachel Emanuel, who is the host of the Alberta Roundup on True North and graced the stage last night and joins us now gracing our stage here. 0.85
00:31:42 Rachel, good to talk to you. Thanks for coming back on the show.
00:31:44 Happy to be here, as always.
00:31:46 So, I mean, Danielle Smith got a lot of heat when she first announced she would be participating in this. 0.88
00:31:52 And her answer, I think, has been pretty consistent, which is, yeah, I do interviews all the time.
00:31:56 that doesn't mean I disagree or agree with whatever's in them. But have we seen like those
00:32:00 heads exploding since she took the stage more than they were initially? People are pretty upset. I
00:32:06 mean, of course, the radical left mainstream media had their articles coming out. I think Danielle
00:32:10 put it very well when she joined the stage in Calgary yesterday. She said, look, just because
00:32:16 I'm here doesn't mean I agree with everything that's being said by my colleagues on the stage.
00:32:22 of course it's ridiculous that she would even have to say that but that's just really where
00:32:27 we are in the times today there's not a lot of free and open debate anymore that's not welcome
00:32:31 but she did make that clarification whether or not the media will actually take that call is up to
00:32:36 them. Yeah I know that today she did an appearance she was announcing something or other and was
00:32:42 already facing like yet again another question from it let's roll that clip. I do want to ask
00:32:47 about your attendance at both of Tucker Carlson's events yesterday this is somebody who has been
00:32:51 accused of defending white supremacy, spreading misinformation about the war in Ukraine,
00:32:55 as well as making disparaging remarks about women. So why did you believe that this is someone that
00:32:59 you should be giving time and attention to? Well, I take a wide range of media requests.
00:33:05 I've done, I've been told by my staff, 96 individual media events or interviews since I
00:33:10 got reelected, 24 press conferences. And I don't require, I don't do a screening test to make sure
00:33:17 that every person that interviews me matches 100% of what I believe and I
00:33:21 don't expect that I'm that they're going to that that that would be an
00:33:25 appropriate thing to do so I take a wide range of interviews from CBC all the way
00:33:30 through to alternative media because my job is to get our message out about
00:33:34 Alberta and I told everyone that I wanted to make sure that somebody who
00:33:39 has a very loud voice in America knew that we were a partner in being able to
00:33:45 provide energy security and energy affordability. And I got that message out. So a bit of a glimpse
00:33:51 from Premier Smith there on what that message was. But generally speaking beyond that, what did she
00:33:57 use that opportunity to discuss? I mean, she actually phrased it very well. I think that's
00:34:02 exactly why she agreed to do these events on stage is because she does want to get Alberta's message
00:34:07 out. And that is one of we are the place that has the cleanest energy supply and the rest of the
00:34:12 world should be coming to Alberta for our energy supply, and also that Ottawa is continuing to
00:34:17 kibosh these efforts. And if they continue to kibosh our efforts to reduce energy supply,
00:34:23 we're actually going to run into big issues in the province of Alberta, where tens of thousands
00:34:27 of people are moving from all over the country for the Alberta advantage, and operators are
00:34:31 unwilling to increase their baseload power out of fear that they will come into conflict with
00:34:36 Ottawa's 2035 regulations and now we're running into serious issues where we're facing potential
00:34:42 power outages like a couple weeks ago when we had that cold snap and people are worried if they're
00:34:46 going to be able to have power or whether there's going to be rolling brownouts and blackouts throughout
00:34:50 the province. So she delivered that message very clearly yesterday and honestly it's something that
00:34:54 we also saw Jason Kenney about you know for all his flaws when I covered his government he did
00:34:58 attend a senate committee in the U.S. and he spoke about that same message Alberta has the cleanest
00:35:03 energy on earth and the rest of the world should be getting our their energy from here no matter
00:35:07 what the federal government says yeah and I understand from the clip circulating she was
00:35:12 also like trying to introduce the idea of Stephen Gilbeau to Tucker Carlson and like enlist his help
00:35:16 in the fight against Stephen Gilbeau what was that all about that was definitely one of the best
00:35:22 parts of the day we all know Daniel Smith does not like Stephen Gilbeau she actually can't stand him
00:35:27 she said she said on multiple occasions she can't work with him and she said to Tucker yesterday
00:35:32 you know I think you should put Stephen Guibo in your crosshairs and later on she said I'm trying
00:35:37 to get him fired and I could use your help with that I thought that was absolutely hilarious
00:35:40 one of the best lines from the day another really good one was when Tucker Carlson he seems to
00:35:45 really dislike Christia Freeland he apparently knew her when she was a journalist and he says
00:35:50 this lady is not bright at all and he actually referred to her as a midget at one point and that
00:35:55 got quite a few laughs from the crowd one of the fan favorites for sure yeah but I saw that clip
00:36:00 He also said she had, like, the self-esteem that you could, like, hide under in the event of a nuclear attack or whatever.
00:36:05 Like, she's very self-assured, which is, I guess, a compliment in a roundabout way.
00:36:10 I think we have a clip of the Gilboa line you were just talking about.
00:36:13 Let's roll that.
00:36:15 I don't know if you know much about Stephen Gilboa.
00:36:17 I don't know if I've heard of him.
00:36:18 I'm wanting to learn less just by your introduction.
00:36:21 One thing I find so offensive, I mean, you talk about the disrespect to our province.
00:36:27 This is a guy who is an environmental advocate. He's best known for scaling the CN Tower in opposition of fossil fuels when he was working as an environmental advocate.
00:36:38 But he also scaled the house of our premier.
00:36:41 So he's a rock climber, not an engineer.
00:36:44 Maybe he'd be better at that. But imagine that. Imagine somebody going and taking a criminal offense, going onto the roof of a premier,
00:36:51 that they make that person in charge trying to dictate to us how to pull our resources out of
00:36:56 ground and how to manage our natural resources how to how to manage our electricity grid that's
00:37:01 what justin trudeau has done so i'm trying to get him fired and i would love your help on that
00:37:10 yeah i mean what she said they're entirely consistent with what she and minister rebecca
00:37:14 schultz have said about gilbo at many other occasions and affairs and i find it interesting
00:37:19 that the rhetoric on social media appears to be trying to like put on her things he said at other
00:37:25 points, either in his career or even at other points on stage, instead of like, does anyone
00:37:29 take issue with what she herself said at this event in front of a crowd of, I think a combined
00:37:35 crowd of like 15,000. And I don't know, I'm not aware so far, maybe you can correct me if I'm
00:37:39 wrong, Rachel, of any controversy stemming from anything she said. Of course there isn't, but
00:37:43 that's not what media is anymore. It's trying to associate with you with people that are perceived
00:37:49 to be controversial and trying to paint those people as controversial as possible by taking
00:37:53 clips out of context or saying that things are racist just because you're simply pointing to
00:37:57 the statistics of something or saying that mass immigration is a bad thing for our countries and
00:38:01 that it's actually making it so that our healthcare systems are failing and that we don't have enough
00:38:05 houses in our country and all these types of things and that's really all that media is and
00:38:09 it's one of the reasons why i just don't watch it anymore i don't pay attention to what the legacy
00:38:13 media does other than to occasionally point out major mistakes they've made because it's useless
00:38:18 and it's just untrue. So one thing that I think will be interesting here is that, and let me back
00:38:25 up. I'm sure there were many people on Daniel Smith's staff. In fact, I've heard whisperings
00:38:29 of it. They didn't love that she was doing this. And let's face it, there are things that I disagree
00:38:32 with from with Tucker Carlson on a lot of foreign policy stuff, as well as elsewhere. But it seemed
00:38:38 to be a win for her. I mean, she spoke to a crowd that might not even be connected to partisan
00:38:43 in politics because they were drawn there by an American speaker. And I think in that sense,
00:38:49 she was doing something that probably will help her long term. I mean, there was one guy,
00:38:53 I think it was Bruce Anderson, the pollster who said, oh, this is going to like hurt her in the
00:38:56 polls in the next election, which I'm like, yeah, good luck with that. Yeah, I agree with you. I
00:39:01 think that this event actually boded very well for her. And I think something we've seen the
00:39:05 premier really improve on, obviously, let's remember, she took a break from politics and 1.00
00:39:10 was a talk show host and as a talk show host you discuss controversial ideas and you sort of say
00:39:15 your thoughts on things and during the election you know the ndp rolled their clips of daniel
00:39:19 smith saying all these talking about ideas and they tried to paint it as some really controversial
00:39:23 and crazy lady for simply wanting open and fair discussion and so i think we've seen that be a bit 1.00
00:39:29 of an issue for her in the early days of her politics and even still she had that willingness
00:39:33 early on to continue that discussion and i think that she's really kind of coming into her own as
00:39:38 a politician and she's really learned to finally craft into her message and so i don't notice that 0.99
00:39:43 we're seeing those types of blips at events that she attends as often anymore because she's just
00:39:47 as really focused and i think she stays really on point on message and i think she did that yesterday
00:39:52 so i agree that this will really bode well for her in the long run all right well we look forward
00:39:56 are you going to be doing any of this on your show this weekend of course so you guys on saturday for
00:40:01 that so keep an eye out for the alberta roundup i i kind of assume i hoped because that would
00:40:06 would have been a really anticlimactic end of the interview. You said, no, we're doing something
00:40:09 else. So that'll be on Alberta Roundup this weekend. Rachel Emanuel, as always, keeping us
00:40:13 connected with what's happening in my, I don't want to say my favorite province in Canada, but
00:40:17 your favorite province. It's my favorite province in Canada. All right. Thank you so much, Rachel.
00:40:21 We'll talk to you soon. Talk to you soon. All right. That Sean says, Sean, you're from Toronto.
00:40:26 You don't get to how dare you me on that. Sean is like now defending the honor of Toronto when I
00:40:31 say that i love alberta every time i go out to alberta uh there were i there name one good thing
00:40:36 about ontario sean see he can't do it he says niagara falls you don't even live in niagara
00:40:42 falls and i don't i couldn't even tell you the last time i went to niagara falls i i should say
00:40:46 i grew up in ontario i i love ontario for the familiarity of it i can't even say the weather
00:40:51 is all that much better because i live in the middle of the great lakes we get like ice in our
00:40:56 faces they just end up like uh you're basically a human icicle you're jack frost when you walk
00:41:00 down the street in the winter and again here the fly i've never fly has never dive bombed my coffee
00:41:05 in alberta uh you may get a cougar attack in a parking lot of tim hortons but you're never going
00:41:09 to get a fly attacking your coffee so uh now this is like my whole chat is everyone's turning on me
00:41:14 all the ontarians i mean i'm an ontarian i'm one of you all right all of that notwithstanding we
00:41:19 will uh have that fight on our show we'll do alberta versus ontario if you're one of the other
00:41:23 provinces i'm sorry you have to find your own fights but uh that does it for us for today we've
00:41:28 got something very special planned next week, which I want to give you a bit of a glimpse of
00:41:32 now. So my friend and colleague Mark Stein has been on trial for the last two weeks in Washington,
00:41:39 D.C. in a, it's again, a case 12 years in the making. He was sued for defamation by Michael
00:41:45 Mann, who is a big climate Scientologist, not climate Scientologist, a climate scientist,
00:41:50 I was going to say. And he was the guy who came up with what's called the hockey stick graph,
00:41:55 which shows that like there had been no warming in the earth ever.
00:41:58 And then just, you know, in the industrial revolution,
00:42:00 it just shot up and we're all going to burn and die.
00:42:03 And Mark Stein has viewed that graph as a fraud.
00:42:07 That is an allegation he has made.
00:42:08 And it's one that Michael Mann sees as defamatory.
00:42:12 And he sued Mark Stein in 2012.
00:42:14 Only now is this case going to trial.
00:42:17 So the third week of the trial is going to be next week in Washington, D.C.
00:42:21 And this covers free speech.
00:42:23 It covers climate change.
00:42:24 And there's certainly a Canadian connection because the Canadian government under Paul Martin, I believe it was, was using the hockey stick graph to justify a lot of what it was doing when it was going into the Kyoto Accord.
00:42:38 So this has been an influential figure in Canada.
00:42:41 So we're going to be covering that on the show.
00:42:43 The show is going to look a little different next week just because of scheduling.
00:42:46 We're still trying to fine tune that, but we're going to have some interviews and there is going to be an Andrew Lawton show, but it won't be live.
00:42:52 and we will have daily updates from the trial in Washington, DC.
00:42:56 So stay tuned for that.
00:42:58 We're also going to have on Monday
00:42:59 Anne McElhenney and Phelan McAleer
00:43:01 who have been covering this to bring us all up to speed.
00:43:04 And they're doing a fantastic project on this
00:43:06 where they're doing daily reenactments
00:43:09 with actors of key moments from the trial.
00:43:12 And they've got phenomenal actors.
00:43:13 I've been keeping up to date through that process
00:43:16 and that podcast.
00:43:17 So that's something we'll have for you next week.
00:43:19 I know people have been asking about it.
00:43:20 So that is coming soon.
00:43:22 thank you to all of you have a wonderful weekend god bless and good day to you all
00:43:26 thanks for listening to the andrew lawton show
00:43:29 support the program by donating to true north at www.tnc.news
00:43:52 We'll be right back.
00:44:22 We'll be right back.