Juno News - March 27, 2024


Liberal MP compares Poilievre to Nazis – again

Topics
Mentioned
Liberals have spent $42 million on gun "buyback" without getting a single gun GamerGate 2.0 is OUT OF CONTROL!

Episode Stats


Length

48 minutes

Words per minute

169.03

Word count

8,152

Sentence count

296

Harmful content

Misogyny

5

sentences flagged

Toxicity

2

sentences flagged

Hate speech

5

sentences flagged


Summary

Summaries generated with gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ .

In a world of cancel culture where mistakes never cease, our man Justin Trudeau tries to find some peace, he apologizes, but the damage is done, and his reputation undone. But let's not forget that people can grow and change ever more.

Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Topics generated with Qwen2.5-3B-Instruct.
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 Transcription by CastingWords
00:00:30 Thank you.
00:01:00 welcome to canada's most irreverent talk show this is the andrew lawton show brought to you
00:01:19 by true north hello and welcome to you all canada's most irreverent talk show here the
00:01:29 Andrew Lawton's show on True North on this Wednesday, March 27th. Sometimes you need to
00:01:34 break through the midweek doldrums. Hopefully this show will help you do exactly that. Although I must
00:01:41 admit, I got very much sidetracked this morning. We've still prepped the show out. We've still
00:01:46 booked it. I've still planned everything and researched and all of that. But I learned, I don't
00:01:51 know, maybe like 90 minutes ago or so of this program I had never heard of called Suno, S-U-N-O.
00:01:59 and it is an AI. So AI is all the rage now. You can do AI-generated news, AI-generated words,
00:02:06 content writing, AI-generated photos, AI-generated videos. And this was the first time I heard of
00:02:12 AI-generated music. Now, people have used ChatGBT, which is one of the AI programs, to come up with
00:02:18 lyrics. And quite frankly, if you listen to most of the crappy songs that are put out now, AI-generated
00:02:23 is generally better than a song with one line about doing unspeakable things to people's bodies.
00:02:29 that's basically pop radio now but this app which was like free uh you could they only got a certain
00:02:34 number of credits which i burned through in like half an hour this morning when i wasn't working
00:02:38 you could make songs and i was like all right let's actually just have some fun with this so
00:02:44 i i decided to play around and and see if this could come up with a theme song for true north
00:02:50 And this is what we got.
00:03:07 Beacon of light, I like it.
00:03:17 True, we do.
00:03:20 All right, here's the chorus. 0.99
00:03:47 All right, then it's just, you know, an exit.
00:03:49 It's just a little guitar solo at the end there,
00:03:51 which normally I would never cut out the guitar solo,
00:03:53 except in this case, it's not a real person playing.
00:03:55 It is an AI.
00:03:56 That is AI generated.
00:03:57 So that is the new True North.
00:03:59 We're not actually adopting it,
00:04:00 but the new True North theme song, Voices of Truth,
00:04:03 which I quite like.
00:04:04 And I think I gave it like a one-line prompt.
00:04:06 I just give it like an energetic rock ballad
00:04:09 about the Canadian media organization, True North.
00:04:12 And this is what we got.
00:04:13 Honest journalism, a beacon of light,
00:04:15 True North strong, shining so bright.
00:04:18 Well, that's lovely.
00:04:18 but you know we can't all just go to jingles and that stuff you have to have some fun with a
00:04:25 program like this so i thought it might be good might be to get a song about canada's prime
00:04:32 minister now we could do any so we could do a song about the carbon tax we could do a song about snc
00:04:37 lavalin we could do a song called experiencing it differently although i don't know what rhymes
00:04:43 with experiencing it different what rhymes with experiencing it differently yeah i don't know
00:04:47 potently and see i couldn't kind of this is why we leave it to ai so this is the song that we landed
00:04:53 on oh dear old justin with charm and grace a little beloved by his canadian base what a tale
00:05:03 resurfaces causing quite a stir apartments in blackface so how the rumors blur in a world of
00:05:11 cancel culture where mistakes never cease our man trudeau tries to find some peace he apologizes
00:05:22 but the damage is done a spotlight on his past overshadowing the fun oh justin dear justin what
00:05:33 have you done in blackfish you dance your reputation undone but let's not forget or
00:05:41 let's not ignore that people can grow and change ever more
00:05:47 so that was it sounded like al jolson doing it although to be honest i could actually picture
00:06:00 Justin Trudeau doing that song himself in one of his old outfit that is uh it's called a Canadian
00:06:06 our colleague Artem says that should be the new outro music for the no no no we don't want to
00:06:10 make that the outro music I actually got uh now now everyone on the show is just making requests
00:06:15 uh Sean's asking if I can like get one in the style of Cole Porter so uh well basically anything
00:06:21 goes which is you know one of the great Cole Porter shows that's basically Justin Trudeau's
00:06:24 government as it is in olden days a glimpse of stalking was looked on to something shocking but
00:06:29 now god knows anything goes that's basically trudeau's whole approach right now where anything
00:06:35 goes although it's finally catching up with him with the poll numbers we've been talking about
00:06:40 over the last our numbers probably just plummeted when i started singing although believe it or not
00:06:45 i have i have actually performed before not well uh but my my friend tal bachman who's the
00:06:50 fantastic singer songwriter uh he was uh doing a musical night on the mark stein cruise and he's
00:06:57 He's invited me to sing along with him a couple of times.
00:06:59 So I performed with, I'll say, Rock Loyalty, no, Rock Royalty in Canada.
00:07:05 See, I should just get AI to generate the show and we'll go from there.
00:07:09 Sean is asking if Tal Bachman is related to Michelle Bachman.
00:07:12 No, he has, she has two N's on Bachman.
00:07:15 He has one.
00:07:16 Although, believe it or not, I have sung with her as well.
00:07:19 We sang on a previous cruise, Sway, in the style of Michael Buble.
00:07:24 So there you go.
00:07:24 You're learning all sorts of stuff about me on The Andrew Lawton Show today.
00:07:28 Have to start off on a fun note, although we have a little something planned for the end of the show we'll get to on that as well.
00:07:34 But I don't think it beats the Al Jolson, Justin Trudeau number there.
00:07:38 But let's talk about the Liberal government in free fall here.
00:07:43 As I mentioned, their poll numbers have not been favourable.
00:07:46 The polls are showing, at the very least, a massive Conservative majority.
00:07:50 but more importantly reducing the liberals to some polls are saying third party in some ways
00:07:56 it might conceivably end up where they are the fourth party behind the NDP and the Bloc Québécois
00:08:02 but what's fascinating about this is the way they behave there's a particular amount of hubris we're
00:08:09 seeing and one example of this comes from Ken Hardy who is a British Columbia Liberal member
00:08:14 of Parliament who is kind of like the Mark Gerritson of Twitter I mean I guess Mark Gerritson is the
00:08:19 Mark Garrison of Twitter, but he's very Mark Garrison-like in that he just spends his time 0.85
00:08:23 saying these ridiculous and absurd things online. Now, unlike Garrison, Hardy will get called on it
00:08:29 and will apologize for it, and then we'll do the same thing a little bit later on. In particular,
00:08:34 one of the things he loves doing is comparing Pierre Polyev and the conservatives to Nazis.
00:08:40 Now, this is a tweet, this is the original tweet, so not the one from this week. This is the original
00:08:46 tweet where Ken Hardy says, if Joseph Goebbels can pick up question period down there, he will
00:08:51 be so proud of conservatives spouting a lie often enough and loudly enough. It is a tried and true
00:08:58 tactic, spouting multitudes of them. The Tories have perfected this. This is Ken, I mean, Joseph
00:09:05 Goebbels, the Nazi propagandist, one of the most horrific people of that era of history. And Ken
00:09:11 hardy is just making that comparison rather freely it's the old line godwin's law that all
00:09:17 internet arguments will eventually devolve into an invocation of hitler uh invoking hitler is kind
00:09:22 of the starting point for uh people like ken hardy now he apologized for this this was him in
00:09:28 the house of comments yes mr speaker uh i did go elbows up on twitter and i apologize for that
00:09:37 I did, though, attempt to raise the issue the other day of the frequent misrepresentation
00:09:43 coming from the conservative side, but elbows up was a little too much in this case, and I do apologize.
00:09:51 So he gets called on it. He apologizes.
00:09:54 We're all supposed to believe that everything is fine.
00:09:57 Everything is fair game here.
00:09:59 And then we see this tweet from him just this week.
00:10:04 He references the previous controversy.
00:10:07 Now, I got into a bit of trouble a while back
00:10:10 by invoking an awful historical figure
00:10:12 when pointing out Pierre Polyev's use of the big lie strategy.
00:10:16 But, oh no, he went, he did the but.
00:10:18 But day by day, there's more and more proof
00:10:21 that this is exactly what he does
00:10:23 because he doesn't have much else to offer.
00:10:27 So once again, we have Ken Hardy again,
00:10:30 aware of this, aware of the previous controversy.
00:10:32 He's saying, yeah, I know I said it
00:10:33 and I know I apologize for it,
00:10:35 but every day it's seeming more and more appropriate.
00:10:38 Now, Melissa Lansman, who is a,
00:10:40 she's been on the show before.
00:10:41 She's the deputy leader of the conservative.
00:10:43 She is a very prominent and outspoken member
00:10:46 of the Jewish community as well.
00:10:48 The type of person who is, as a result,
00:10:51 I think particularly sensitive to Nazism 0.96
00:10:53 and Nazi comparisons.
00:10:54 Now, Melissa Lansman herself,
00:10:57 you may recall during the Freedom Convoy,
00:10:59 was accused by Justin Trudeau of standing with swastikas
00:11:03 or standing with people who wave swastikas.
00:11:05 whatever his line was. She jumped on Ken Hardy's comments here, and I wanted to share that with
00:11:10 you. She says, does this guy have no one in his life that will tell him to stop invoking Nazis,
00:11:15 especially now? Are you serious, Ken Hardy? I'm glad I won't have to sit in a room with you after
00:11:21 the next election. I'm sure there are a few of your colleagues who feel the same way after this
00:11:25 tweet. Read the room. And she's referring, of course, to the fact that Ken Hardy is likely to
00:11:31 be ousted next year. His riding, he carried it pretty decisively the last couple of elections,
00:11:36 but it's historically been conservative. And if you look at some of the polling numbers
00:11:40 in and around BC, I think he's in the Surrey area. It's particularly not hospitable to the
00:11:47 liberals. So he's apologized once again, sort of. Some folks object to my invoking unsavory past
00:11:55 figures when noting Pierre Polyev's habit of lying. Okay, I apologize. As for the widespread
00:12:01 view that he lies, well, some free advice from Cicero. Oh, he's dropping another historical
00:12:07 figure now. When people speak ill of you, live so that none would believe them. So, I feel he just
00:12:13 like, yeah, Sean is saying it's very cryptic. I feel he just like searched for a quote about lying
00:12:18 and he basically just used an AI generated tweet machine for that, I think. He actually, actually,
00:12:23 I should have gotten Ken Hardy's tweet done as a song.
00:12:26 Maybe I'll do that for tomorrow.
00:12:28 Because it would be more entertaining to listen to Ken Hardy
00:12:30 in some AI-generated pop ballad
00:12:33 rather than some AI-generated member of parliament talking.
00:12:36 But that is basically his approach here.
00:12:39 He's going to call Pierre Polyev a senior Nazi,
00:12:42 apologize, reference it, do it again, apologize again.
00:12:46 So basically, we just need in Ken Hardy's office,
00:12:49 like one of those old factory things,
00:12:50 If it's been zero days since our last accident, it's been zero days since our last Nazi reference.
00:12:56 And you won't even need to buy a lot of numbers because you're probably not going to get more than one or two days before he does it again at the rate that he's going.
00:13:04 Absolutely absurd.
00:13:06 And what we're seeing here, though, is a very desperate liberal party.
00:13:10 Now, look, there are always going to be some people in caucus that are a bit more outspoken, that are a bit prone to foot and mouth disorder.
00:13:17 but what we see here is that when the liberals are as desperate as they are they go i mean they
00:13:24 literally go nazi they that's the line that they go to with conservatives are nazis because they
00:13:30 genuinely believe it and this is the problem we hear all the time from people like justin trudeau
00:13:35 for example about the need to reinstill civility in politics and we need to build bridges we need
00:13:41 to work across the aisle, all of that. And where is that attitude? Where is that desire to be
00:13:47 conciliatory and magnanimous when you have liberal MPs that are accusing people of being Nazi
00:13:53 propagandists because they disagree with them about the carbon tax? It is an absurd, absurd
00:13:59 development here. Yet it's the kind of thing that they get a pass on. Now, Ken Hardy, look, he's not
00:14:06 a senior member of the Liberal caucus by any stretch. He's not a cabinet minister, but he is,
00:14:12 I don't think, saying anything that he doesn't truly believe. And that's the most important
00:14:16 point here, is that we're not talking about someone who made some errant slip of the tongue
00:14:20 in a debate. We all get heated. We all say things that maybe we wish we could take back. We're
00:14:25 talking about someone who is being very transparent about what it is that he genuinely believes,
00:14:30 what it is that he thinks of conservatives and you expect conservatives or I mean let me back
00:14:38 up and say it another way do you expect people to reach across the aisle and work with folks
00:14:42 who think they are Nazis so it's only people on the right that tend to be criticized for not being
00:14:50 as collaborative and cooperative people say oh well Pierre Polyev he's just a name caller he
00:14:55 doesn't have a plan. Well, he's not the one calling people a Nazi because he disagrees with
00:15:00 them. This is, I mean, there's that old meme that's been circulating for a while. I don't
00:15:04 know how old it is, but for a few years right now, there's a meme that's been circulating where
00:15:08 it's basically the fake cover of a children's book. And it's, you know, everyone I don't like
00:15:12 is Hitler or everyone I dislike is Hitler. And that's basically the liberal campaign platform 0.58
00:15:17 in this country. It's just, if you don't like them, they are Hitler, they're Nazis, they're 0.93
00:15:22 far right they're going to you know do xyz and historically you've had a media in this country
00:15:29 that i think is willing to adopt this language at least in part willing to adopt the language at
00:15:35 least in part now i wanted to turn to uh the i mean again we have to talk about the carbon tax
00:15:41 because everyone on the internet everyone in the country seems to be talking about this because it
00:15:45 is coming into effect the increase is coming into effect on Monday a 23% hike in the carbon tax
00:15:53 which is adding insult to injury for Canadians who are already grappling with rising cost of
00:15:58 living you're going to see instantly an increase in the cost of fuel and you'll also see the
00:16:02 trickle-down increases in the cost of groceries the cost of your gas bill and all the like but
00:16:09 one of the things that I will point out about this is that the liberals have not listened to
00:16:16 anyone. They don't want to listen to anyone. They are purely ideological on this. Now, Justin
00:16:22 Trudeau has been faced with mounting criticism from premiers, not just conservatives, from
00:16:27 premiers, from provincial party leaders saying, we've got to give people some release. We just
00:16:31 can't deal with this. He sent a letter to premiers, a letter to premiers thanking them for raising the
00:16:39 issue of Canada's carbon pricing system. He says, our government is acutely aware of the increasing
00:16:44 financial pressure facing Canadians. We know that they want to make life more affordable.
00:16:50 This is what we're doing. This is why we made this revenue neutral. He claims that the Parliamentary
00:16:55 Budget Officer has confirmed that, which is, by the way, simply untrue. The Parliamentary Budget
00:16:59 Officer has not given any confirmation of that whatsoever. And it goes on and on. But then here
00:17:06 is the kicker of this. He says, since Canada's carbon pricing system was first introduced in
00:17:14 2019, we have made it clear that we are open to working with any and all provinces and territories
00:17:18 that want to establish their own pricing systems as long as they meet or exceed the national
00:17:23 benchmark. British Columbia, Quebec, and Northwest Territories continue to operate their own systems
00:17:29 and are not subject to the federal backstop. When we engaged with you in 2022, all of your
00:17:36 governments either did not propose alternative systems or proposed systems that didn't meet the
00:17:40 minimum standards. So he's saying, well, it's your fault because you haven't come up with your own
00:17:46 alternative, except the problem is provinces have very little latitude and autonomy because there
00:17:51 is a federal minimum. So the only latitude provinces have is to actually come up with a
00:17:56 higher carbon tax than what the federal government is doing. So Justin Trudeau is taking aim at
00:18:02 provinces. He's blaming provincial governments. We can take that down now. He's blaming provincial
00:18:07 government, unless it's already down, and I'm just seeing it on my screen as a holdover from when it
00:18:11 was up, so don't mind me. But thank you. We can see what Justin Trudeau is doing here. He is
00:18:16 blaming other provinces, blaming other leaders, blaming provinces for not coming up with ideas
00:18:21 when he has literally been the reason that provinces do not have the ability to come up
00:18:27 with their own climate plans, because the government has said you have to have this
00:18:31 minimum standard. And I forget what the dollar value is, but it's the one that keeps going up
00:18:34 and is increasing yet again on Monday. So it's a particular level of brazenness here and
00:18:43 shamelessness, I'd also say, to look at provinces and premiers as the problem. They're supposed to 0.63
00:18:48 be members of confederation that have not quite equal, kind of equal standing. They're supposed
00:18:53 to be partners in confederation, partners in the federation of Canada. But Justin Trudeau has
00:18:58 decided to basically kick federalism to the curb and tell the provinces it's his way or the highway
00:19:05 and then turn around and blame them for inexplicably not being able to do something that
00:19:11 he has not allowed them to do. And this is why we have, I think, increasingly frustrations from
00:19:18 people that have previously gone along with it or even people who are at their core on board with
00:19:23 the idea of a carbon tax. But Justin Trudeau has a number of positions on this that just don't seem
00:19:30 to align with the reality. He says that this is a market-based, he basically says it's a market-based
00:19:37 product, which I simply don't get altogether. And we also have the idea that he is claiming
00:19:44 it's revenue neutral, which again, it is not entirely clear. And it's certainly not revenue
00:19:48 neutral for individual Canadians who are ending up in many cases spending more on this than they're
00:19:53 receiving, despite government's claims to the contrary. And it's perhaps why you see this issue
00:19:58 being weaponized politically by Pierre Polyev, who's going around the country having rallies with
00:20:03 hundreds or thousands of people, depending on where he is in the country, all rallied around
00:20:09 this idea of spike the hike, axe the tax, whatever the rhyming scheme is he's using in any given
00:20:15 protest. There was a great piece in the Financial Post by our friend Ross McKittrick, who is a
00:20:20 professor of economics at the University of Guelph. Wanted, a federal leader who will be
00:20:26 honest about climate policy. Ross McKittrick joins us once again. Ross, always good to talk
00:20:32 to you. Thanks for coming on today. You are muted there, or maybe I'm muted. No, you're muted.
00:20:40 Yeah, I'm not able to hear you, Ross. Hopefully we'll get that sorted out in a moment.
00:20:45 But one of the things that I find fascinating here is that the Liberal government, and I'll just
00:20:49 pluck from Ross's point on this in the column. He says, the conservatives would rely on the heavy
00:20:55 hand of government through regulation and subsidies to pick winners and losers in the
00:20:59 economy as opposed to trusting the market. And this is a complete rejection of the reality,
00:21:06 which is that his program insists on heavy regulations. The emission reduction plan
00:21:11 has 240 pages of regulations, subsidies, mandates, and winner picking grants. And he is saying that
00:21:20 his product is simple. His program is simple. It's the conservative one that's going to be causing
00:21:26 all of those problems. So this is where you see this weird sort of illusion work that's being
00:21:33 done by the government on this. Now, sometimes you get leaders like Stephen Gilboa who are
00:21:38 remarkably transparent about this. They just want this punitive, heavy-handed approach that targets
00:21:43 what they believe is the great culprit of climate change. But Justin Trudeau tries to have the best
00:21:49 of both worlds. On one hand, he tries to pretend that this is this minimally disruptive, revenue
00:21:55 neutral thing. I mean, the line they've been committing to in the last little while is, oh,
00:21:59 you're all better off with it. You're all making more money. You are better off with the carbon tax.
00:22:03 You're profiting from this.
00:22:05 And then you have Canadians saying,
00:22:07 well, it sure doesn't look like that.
00:22:08 You know, my price of gas is going up.
00:22:10 And if it is actually the case
00:22:12 that most people are getting their money back,
00:22:14 then what's the point of the whole thing?
00:22:16 So it doesn't actually really incentivize
00:22:19 the behavior the government is trying to incentivize
00:22:22 or purporting to incentivize.
00:22:24 And the reason for that is that
00:22:26 so many of these emitting activities
00:22:28 are not optional for Canadians.
00:22:31 Driving to work for a lot of Canadians 1.00
00:22:32 is not optional.
00:22:33 picking your kids up from school is not optional going to the grocery store to buy food not
00:22:39 optional so where are you supposed to cut back we i believe we have ross mckittrick back on the line
00:22:45 now ross uh good to talk to you here what does it feel is really the the misdirection taking place
00:22:50 here where the government is saying on one hand that this is not a heavy-handed regulatory process
00:22:56 on its part? Well, the comment that I made in my op-ed was that it's one thing for Trudeau to say
00:23:04 we believe in the economic principles of efficient climate policy, but his actual policies are
00:23:11 anything but. Yes, he's got this elegant little carbon tax going, but the real cost of his policy
00:23:18 are all the other regulations, the clean fuel standard, the EV mandate, the building energy
00:23:24 efficiency codes all these other regulations massively increase the costs of his climate policy
00:23:31 so the carbon tax itself it's costly there's no question about it but there's actually much worse
00:23:38 stuff in his policy mix and and he was talking as if none of that is there now on the conservative
00:23:44 side it's legitimate for them to point people to the high cost of the climate policy but
00:23:51 But what they need to do is say, well, explain how can they be committed to things like the Paris Treaty and the net zero goals without actually planning to incur any costs of meeting them?
00:24:04 That doesn't square up. So what I'd like is for some politicians somewhere to be honest with the public and either say, we're going to do this and it's going to cost a fortune.
00:24:17 So just get used to it or say, okay, we've heard from the public that there's an upper limit to
00:24:24 what they're willing to pay. This is the most we can hope to accomplish and we'll stick with that.
00:24:29 Yeah, I think that's a valid point on all fronts because it's easy to target. And certainly for
00:24:34 political reasons, I understand why you target the consumer carbon tax, that retail carbon tax
00:24:38 that you see, that's a line item on your gas bill that you see buried in the price of fuel,
00:24:44 for example but even i mean if we look at what the alberta government did under jason kenney where
00:24:49 they said let's go after the industrial side of things that makes a very much more convoluted and
00:24:55 as you're saying their complex process and they're still doing in effect one of the same things but
00:25:00 it's a lot more opaque how it's happening sure yeah when uh when they don't like taking heat
00:25:05 from consumers and they say well we'll make industry pay i think by now everybody realizes
00:25:12 that's just a shell game it all ends up for the consumer one way or the other
00:25:16 it's either buried in the price that you pay at the pump in the case of gas
00:25:22 or you you pay it directly out of your own pocket but there's as economists
00:25:28 as economics textbooks always say costs can be shifted around but they can't be avoided
00:25:33 so what is the i i mean just from an economics perspective here let's just say that we agree
00:25:39 with the core premise and we agree with the core goal which is debatable on how much we need to
00:25:44 reduce emissions by what is from your perspective the path that a government should take to do that
00:25:50 if that is its stated objective here well if it wants to meet the paris target and then go from
00:25:56 there down to some kind of net zero target uh later in the century we would uh to get to paris
00:26:05 I would estimate we'd need maybe a $200 ton carbon tax and then to get to net zero,
00:26:14 something more like a $500 a ton carbon tax. I'm not sure even that would do it. And so
00:26:25 the current policy mix that we have, even the federal liberal policy makes more,
00:26:29 I don't think it'll get us to the Paris target and it certainly won't get us to
00:26:32 to net zero beyond that but that's a conversation that no one's having that i mean none of the
00:26:38 political leaders are willing to talk to people about the costs of what they're proposing to do
00:26:44 so and that i guess gets at what i was hoping to touch on here which is that
00:26:48 this commitment itself is boxing us in in effect like there's no way to get to that without some
00:26:55 sort of really aggressive plan that even the conservatives who i mean again to be fair to
00:27:00 critics of pierre paulia he has not he has committed to this he has committed to paris he
00:27:04 has not talked about uh changing the core target right and so there's an incoherency there because
00:27:13 uh he's justified in in saying to people look we we hear you the cost of fuel is too high
00:27:20 cost of living is too high all these policies are are um are driving up the cost of living in
00:27:26 unacceptable ways um but there's no magic alternative if at the same time you're going
00:27:33 to remain committed to hitting the paris targets so um if for instance they think that you can get
00:27:40 rid of the carbon tax and there'll be a whole bunch of far cheaper ways of doing it then
00:27:45 they're wrong that is not the case and people have tried including past conservative governments and
00:27:52 it just doesn't work one of the the challenges and a lot of the green energy activists i find
00:27:57 are guilty of this where they commit to policies and that are based on technologies that don't
00:28:02 really exist yet or don't do what they say they're going to do but i also feel that a lot of people
00:28:07 that try to say market-based solutions are the solution are also doing the same thing because
00:28:14 you and even mentioned at the bottom of your piece there you know yeah maybe there's a technology
00:28:18 that will come along that will change the math on this but right now that hasn't happened um
00:28:25 yeah so and that's exactly the point that given the current technology that we have
00:28:31 um we're fairly limited in what we can do and um we don't know maybe a new technology will come
00:28:39 along five years or 10 years from now the key is if you can um if you can decouple emissions from
00:28:49 combustion basically if you can find a way to burn fossil fuels without releasing co2
00:28:54 we've decoupled lots of other emissions from combustion we've decoupled sulfur dioxide
00:28:59 and carbon monoxide and lots of other types of lots of other types of emissions from combustion
00:29:07 but there's no technology that does that for co2 at least not yet as far as we know now how much of
00:29:14 a because the government says it is looking at that as well and they say that all of these uh
00:29:20 solutions are going to be part of the overall plan but but how much have they actually committed to
00:29:23 r d on that or is it really just left to industry to come up with it on its own uh i think that uh
00:29:30 um i think there is some some um uh funding for that kind of research much more in other countries
00:29:39 i mean canada is not a big player in research in any case but um sure people are thinking about
00:29:45 it working on it but um there's no easy answer for it so um uh because of that um you know it's
00:29:54 right now it's kind of a lot of talk but um there's uh as far as i know there's
00:30:01 people have been thinking about it for 50 years and there hasn't been any breakthrough on it so
00:30:05 it's not like put a billion dollars up and someone's going to figure it out right now all
00:30:10 we have is carbon caption storage which is very limited in its applicability we uh we lost your
00:30:17 video there but as it happens we're coming to the end of our time anyway so if it's going to happen
00:30:20 that's the best moment for it uh ross mckittrick from the university of guelph great piece in the
00:30:25 financial post wanted a federal leader who will be honest about climate policy hopefully you'll
00:30:30 get your wish there thank you very much all right thanks andrew for talking to you all right thank
00:30:34 you that was well ross mckittrick you can even see on the screen there rm uh one thing i will say on
00:30:39 this is that you can't i mean dilithium crystals i believe was the old star trek term you can't base
00:30:45 your policy on things that don't exist yet and a lot of people have all of these great ambitions
00:30:50 about, oh, solar will do this and wind will do this, and they just don't. And the really efficient
00:30:55 and effective and clean sources of energy that we do have, like, for example, nuclear, they never
00:31:02 seem to want to talk about. So with that, we'll, I'm sure, revisit this as we get closer to the
00:31:08 weekend, and then big protests are going to be on Monday. And I think we just learned this morning,
00:31:14 Pierre Polyev, he'll be doing his own rally in Nanaimo, but there are protests in Lloyd Minster
00:31:19 outside Alberta, Ottawa, Toronto, all over the place.
00:31:23 So do send in your footage of those.
00:31:26 Wanted to shift gears here to healthcare,
00:31:29 the other hot button issue.
00:31:30 Now, this is such an infuriating one for so many people
00:31:34 because virtually every Canadian who's had some exposure
00:31:36 with the healthcare system has experienced something
00:31:41 that didn't work the way it was,
00:31:42 or the way they thought it was supposed to.
00:31:45 Whether it is cases of people being treated in hallways,
00:31:48 people who have been on waiting lists for months and months and months to see a specialist not to
00:31:53 mention to you know actually be treated by that specialist so we all defend the ideal of the
00:31:59 healthcare system in Canada but not the application of it so how do we get to that ideal or is it that
00:32:05 our core expectation is flawed well one of the things that's quite interesting and I'm actually
00:32:10 surprised to see this is that most Canadians would be open to and welcome major changes to
00:32:16 the health care system. There was a Leger survey of 2,000 Canadian adults, that's quite a large
00:32:22 sample size for a poll of this nature, that found health care ranks among the top three priorities
00:32:26 for politicians, and that two-thirds of those respondents said they wanted significant changes
00:32:33 to the system. Now, these obviously have, in some cases, come up against challenges in the courts.
00:32:40 Most recently, the Canby Surgical case in British Columbia, which I'm sure we can talk about in this
00:32:46 context, but let's just talk about what Canadians want here and what's standing in the way. Joining
00:32:50 me is a counsel for the Canadian Constitution Foundation, Josh DeHaz. Josh, good to have you
00:32:55 back on the show. This is a little bit encouraging. I must say it was a pleasant surprise to see this
00:33:00 because so often this is treated as just this third rail political issue that you're not allowed
00:33:04 to do anything with. Yeah, absolutely. So in one sense, it's really bad news because Canadians see
00:33:11 healthcare system that's in crisis but what i did find encouraging is the fact that canadians are
00:33:17 saying they're ready for major change so like you said two-thirds say they want major change
00:33:23 and only five percent of people actually say that they want to do the thing that uh you most often
00:33:30 hear in the media which is you know just throw more public funding at this problem right so
00:33:35 uh people are are presented with those options more public just more public funding or some
00:33:40 major change and everyone is basically saying we want major change and uh one really interesting
00:33:47 part of this too was it was kind of kind of counterintuitive to us at the ccf but
00:33:51 women in particular are saying that they are worried about the healthcare system and want 1.00
00:33:56 major change 72 percent of women surveyed said that they think the healthcare system is going
00:34:02 to be worse for future generations if we don't get those major changes and that was a lot higher than
00:34:08 men and we're trying to figure out why that was but uh we we think the reason might be that women 1.00
00:34:13 just make a lot more of the health care decisions they do a lot more of the sort of caregiving and
00:34:19 so that might explain uh why they're more worried about it simply because they you know interact
00:34:25 with the system a lot more you have in this country a relatively small group of activists
00:34:31 that care very much about the structure of the system like canadian doctors for medicare for
00:34:35 example but most canadians i feel care more about outcomes and you look at some of the priorities
00:34:41 that were listed here uh 46 say they want more family doctors as a top priority uh shorter
00:34:48 emergency room wait times was behind that shorter times for common surgeries and other treatments
00:34:53 those have nothing to do with who delivers it with how they access it those are just outcomes those
00:34:58 are things that people want and and i believe that if you were to put forward a system that says
00:35:02 listen you're not going to go bankrupt looking for health care that's not what we're pushing here
00:35:06 but you will get a better quicker product canadians would be on board with that but
00:35:12 but you have again this very small group that stands in the way of that yeah you're completely
00:35:17 right uh one thing a lot of people i don't think realize is that you know a lot of the opposition
00:35:22 to any sort of reform or change in the canadian health care system a lot of that's sort of funded
00:35:27 by sort of special interest groups like, you know, health care unions. And what the message
00:35:33 that a lot of Canadians are not hearing is that, you know, Canada is just one country in the world.
00:35:38 And we've chosen to have a very strict restrictions on private payment for health care. But, you know,
00:35:46 if you look at all of Europe, they have universal health care. You don't have to pay with your
00:35:50 credit card if you need health care, if you're poor, if you're middle class, if you want to
00:35:54 access the public system. And most people are getting their health care through the public
00:35:58 system. But they also have this sort of release valve, which is that they have a private system
00:36:03 where if things aren't working, some wealthier people can go and they can pay to get health
00:36:08 care. And that takes pressure off the public system. And the sort of the proof is in the
00:36:12 pudding. You know, if you look at all the rankings that look at outcomes and wait times and even
00:36:18 equity, all of the European countries are basically doing better than Canada. So I think we really
00:36:23 need to start, you know, pushing back against that, that sacred cow that we can't allow any 1.00
00:36:29 sort of private payment in Canada. Just to bring the legal context here, I know the CCF
00:36:35 had taken up the long, long running Canby case in British Columbia there, which I spoke about,
00:36:42 I think it was with, I can't remember if it was with Joanna Barron or Christine Van Gein or both,
00:36:45 but when the decision came up, but as a bit of a primer there, how does that decision stand in the
00:36:51 way of what you and I are talking about and Canadians seem to want here?
00:36:56 Well, so British Columbia, like most provinces, has some restrictions on, you know, doctors
00:37:03 work on offering private surgeries or doctors or health insurance.
00:37:08 And each province is a little bit different.
00:37:10 But the idea is that Canadians supposedly want a government monopoly on health care.
00:37:16 And so we've got all of these restrictions.
00:37:18 And in that particular case, we said, you know, if you're waiting on a waiting list for a surgery and you're in physical pain and you could pay to relieve that.
00:37:29 But it's just a law standing in the way, you know, an arbitrary law that is supposed to guarantee you reasonable access to health care, but is actually forcing you to wait on a wait list.
00:37:40 That's violating your constitutional rights and that shouldn't be allowed to stand.
00:37:43 And, you know, there's a 2005 case that found that to be the case in Quebec, but it doesn't apply in the rest of Canada.
00:37:51 So we thought that in British Columbia we would be successful.
00:37:55 But the courts there said, no, this is a reasonable limit on people's charter rights, even though people suffer and in some cases die on waiting lists.
00:38:04 And so right now it's still apparently acceptable to do this in British Columbia.
00:38:11 And we don't really know what the status is in the rest of the provinces.
00:38:15 So, you know, we're always sort of looking for our next can be case.
00:38:19 The fight certainly isn't over.
00:38:21 Well, and there I think underscores how the ideology is getting in the way of the outcomes
00:38:26 here, because, you know, if someone pays out of pocket to take themselves off a wait list
00:38:30 and there's an available doctor, an available surgical center, no one is worse off.
00:38:36 Like absolutely.
00:38:37 know, in fact, the public system is better off because one more person has come off that wait
00:38:41 list, which helps the person behind them. So I really don't get how you like, it's such an
00:38:48 inexplicable decision, just not even looking at the law, just on the logic of it. Yeah, that's
00:38:54 right. Yeah. So, so I also don't understand that, like you can look at, for example, look at Norway
00:39:00 And it's the country that ranks better than any other country in the OECD for its health care
00:39:08 outcomes, for its health care equity. And it does better on cost than Canada. Canada has a very,
00:39:13 very expensive system. And they have only about 10% of people there have private insurance and
00:39:19 they get some specialist appointments quicker. They do get some surgeries quicker, but it's
00:39:26 optional and 90% of people are happy with the public system and stay in that system. But just
00:39:32 taking that, you know, half million Norwegians out of the public system makes the waiting lists in
00:39:37 the public system shorter for everyone. And, you know, Norway can actually do a lot more in their
00:39:42 public system because they're not, because they don't have to look after 100% of the population
00:39:48 all the time. An interesting sort of result from this survey that we did with Second Street and
00:39:55 uh mei was that canadians actually rank pharma care extremely low their priority it's it's like
00:40:02 ninth out of nine options only three percent set as their top priority and that's because canada
00:40:08 can't seem to figure out the basics like getting you your family doctor or uh reasonable er wait
00:40:14 times uh norway or they they can afford to actually do pharma care uh because they also
00:40:21 allow some sort of private money into the system so i think it's pretty clear at this point that
00:40:27 uh canada's system isn't working that it's you know violating canadians constitutional rights
00:40:32 and the survey that we've we've just done seems to show that the public is kind of had ahead of the
00:40:38 the media and some of the sort of politicians on this particular topic because canadians are ready
00:40:43 for change one thing i mean maybe i i'm i'm a bit of adult so it's probably easier for you than for
00:40:49 me here but it's navigating this issue of what is legal and what is just tradition has been
00:40:55 incredibly difficult i mean ontario is a great example of this where you've got a couple of
00:40:59 literally private hospitals that are there because they've just been grandfathered in
00:41:03 you have federal regulations but health care is provincial and and i think a lot of that
00:41:08 jurisdictional uh ambiguity is used by politicians that don't want to touch this issue provincial
00:41:14 leaders will say oh well the federal government handcuffs us on universal health care the federal
00:41:18 government will say, oh, well, health care is a provincial issue. So at its core, if we wanted to
00:41:23 have some progress on this issue, where's the starting point? Where's the way into that? Is
00:41:29 it at federal level with the core Canada Health Act or is it provincial? Yeah, I think it's
00:41:34 actually both. So the Canada Health Act is not as clear as people think it is. So just for a little
00:41:40 bit of background. I'm glad I'm not alone in being utterly confused when I look at it. I was reading
00:41:45 about uh certain aspects of it last night and it's it's confusing so the basic idea behind the
00:41:51 canada health act is that the federal government is going to give provinces money to spend on
00:41:56 health care even though health care is a provincial jurisdiction right so uh but to do so canada in
00:42:03 exchange for that money wants certain guarantees from the provinces for example that you know
00:42:10 people are not going to be charged user fees or things like that. But there's so much ambiguity
00:42:16 in it. One really good example is diagnostic services. So, you know, getting an MRI. Most
00:42:24 of Canada, you can walk into a private clinic, put down your credit card and get off the public
00:42:30 wait list if you want to by paying for that MRI. Well, one of the places you can't do that is
00:42:36 ontario unfortunately so you know we're stuck going to gatuneau or to buffalo if we are are
00:42:43 worried about uh being stuck on a wait list so oh yeah so i live just on that i live an hour from
00:42:48 port here on michigan you cross the border and billboards advertising to canadians you know get
00:42:53 your mri you know 129 or whatever you know go here open 24 7. yeah we we have them i'm in toronto and
00:43:00 we have them on the subway saying you know go to buffalo for all your surgeries or services but
00:43:05 But anyway, the point is that the federal government and the provinces don't even seem to know whether that is supposed to be covered under the Canada Health Act.
00:43:13 And the Trudeau government in 2018 said suddenly, actually, you know, this should be something that provinces are required to not only pay for, but stop anyone from buying privately.
00:43:25 And so in our opinion, this is contrary to the Canada Health Act, and they started fining provinces like Quebec and Alberta and British Columbia just for allowing people to get out of the public waitlist line, go to a private clinic and pay to have the health care that they need.
00:43:42 So there's a lot of ambiguity.
00:43:44 And I think you could clarify the Canada Health Act.
00:43:48 You know, I think it allows provinces to do a lot more than they say that it does.
00:43:53 But there's no reason why the federal government couldn't clarify the Canada Health Act and say, look, we're still going to fund universal health care.
00:44:01 We're still going to give you just as much money, but we're going to let provinces innovate to some degree because the status quo just isn't working.
00:44:08 So, you know, if I was in charge, I'd probably start with just clarifying that Canada Health Act.
00:44:14 Well, yeah, there we go.
00:44:15 And obviously, with polling, I mean, the cynic in all of us says politicians are responsive to polls more than their core convictions sometimes.
00:44:23 So if that's the case, your move, political class.
00:44:26 You can read more about this at theccf.ca.
00:44:30 Josh Dehas, always good to talk to you.
00:44:31 Thanks for coming on today.
00:44:33 Thanks, Andrew.
00:44:34 All right.
00:44:34 Thank you.
00:44:35 Let me know what you think.
00:44:36 so many Canadians have absolute horror stories. I had interviewed on the show a few years ago,
00:44:41 a woman, I want to say she was from Nova Scotia. It was somewhere out east where she and a friend
00:44:46 of hers had started a company where they literally just were concierges connecting Canadians who were
00:44:53 having trouble getting healthcare services with treatment programs in the U.S. And they did
00:44:57 incredibly well on this because there are so many Canadians that said, yeah, yeah, I want to spend
00:45:01 money and go to the U.S. I just don't know how to do it. And that itself reflects a pretty big
00:45:05 problem with the so-called universal offerings in the Great White North. All right, I said we'd have 0.87
00:45:11 some fun on the end. So at the beginning, I started off the show with a couple of these AI-generated
00:45:15 songs. I have not even listened to this one. This is completely new to me, but I asked for a little
00:45:21 bit of a PSA telling you all to listen to The Andrew Lawton Show, and I wanted it to sound
00:45:26 authentically Canadian. So here you go. Speaking of the East Coast. Oh, where did it go?
00:45:46 There we go.
00:46:16 make you laugh at no listen too long let the truth arrows be thrown the truth arrows be thrown
00:46:23 the shores of true north is signal strong he navigates for the voices wrong
00:46:32 with irreverence and facts he sails along tune in to long join his courageous
00:46:46 that part scared me all right tune into lawton join his courageous throng uh don't join my
00:46:53 courageous thong by the way you don't want to be there all right that does it for us for today we
00:46:57 will be back tomorrow to close out the week here on canada's most irreverent talk show i like that
00:47:04 the little the andrew lawton uh show sea shanty we'll have i i like our our current one which was
00:47:08 not uh to my knowledge ai generated anyway uh we will talk to you all tomorrow thank you god bless
00:47:13 and good day to you all thanks for listening to the andrew lawton show
00:47:17 support the program by donating to true north at www.tnc.news
00:47:43 We'll be right back.