Juno News - May 03, 2023


Liberals are not backing down from their gun grab

Topics
Mentioned
The equity agenda is ruining academia (feat. Dr. Carol Swain) The cost of speaking out as a teacher (Ft. Chanel Pfahl)

Episode Stats


Length

37 minutes

Words per minute

173.25

Word count

6,430

Sentence count

272

Harmful content

Misogyny

1

sentences flagged

Toxicity

9

sentences flagged

Hate speech

1

sentences flagged


Summary

Summaries generated with gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ .

On today's show, Andrew Lawton is joined by Christine Van Gein of the Canadian Constitution Foundation and Rod Giltaka of the Coalition for Firearms Rights (CCF) to discuss the government's backtrack on Bill C-21 and the ongoing challenge to the legislation, as well as to the use of pepper spray against journalists.

Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Topics generated with Qwen2.5-3B-Instruct.
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 welcome to Canada's most irreverent talk show
00:00:04 this is the Andrew Lawton show brought to you by True North
00:00:08 hello everyone and welcome to you all it is Wednesday May 3rd 2023 the Andrew Lawton show
00:00:19 at True North here and it is my absolute pleasure to be speaking to you midway through the week
00:00:26 Hopefully you are getting through this and it's all downhill from here or all uphill.
00:00:30 I've never actually known which is the good one because as the old quandary goes, downhill is easier, but like down is bad.
00:00:37 Uphill is harder, but up is good.
00:00:39 So whether uphill or downhill is the better one, I hope that's the direction you are headed as the week continues and culminates in what I hope is a much deserved rest break on the weekend.
00:00:50 And we're going to be talking about a couple of the big picture issues of the political climate today.
00:00:55 Joining me later on is Christine Van Gein from the Canadian Constitution Foundation, the CCF,
00:01:01 to talk about the last legal guardrail against the government's use of the Emergencies Act.
00:01:07 That is the legal challenges underway against this and what happened a little over a year ago in Canada.
00:01:14 That's the CCF. We also have the CCFR, the Canadian Coalition for Firearm Rights,
00:01:20 well represented in today's show with Rod Giltaka standing by, as we'll discuss the
00:01:25 Liberals' backtrack that's not really a backtrack, amendments that aren't really
00:01:30 amending anything on Bill C-21, which is the Firearms Regulation Bill. But let me just first
00:01:36 start off by doing something I try to avoid doing for my and your mental health, and that is
00:01:43 liberally quoting Justin Trudeau who today decided to honor World Press Freedom Day. Now I must
00:01:50 confess I did not know it was World Press Freedom Day. The World Press Freedom Day parade didn't
00:01:56 pass by my house today so I didn't have World Press Freedom Day in my calendar I don't think.
00:02:03 Let me just look because sometimes I get like really weird holidays that I don't know exist
00:02:06 on my calendar like what's this Mother's Day or something. Anyway my mom listens that was a
00:02:12 terrible, terrible joke. But anyway, the point of this, though, is that we are to celebrate press
00:02:18 freedom around the world. It's great. I'm all for press freedom. I'm for freedom of speech. I don't
00:02:23 believe that journalists are in a particularly special category. I think journalists' free
00:02:28 speech is the same as ordinary citizens' free speech. But I realized that journalists play a
00:02:33 rather pivotal role in democracy and in free society. So when Justin Trudeau tweets,
00:02:39 journalists inform Canadians and hold governments accountable their work is independent and
00:02:44 indispensable as they continue to face harassment censorship and violence simply for doing their
00:02:51 jobs let me say this we will always support and promote the freedom of the press hashtag world
00:02:58 press freedom day and it links to a longer statement that basically says more of the same
00:03:03 So it's interesting to see Justin Trudeau coming out and denouncing harassment, censorship, and violence faced by journalists when his government is responsible for harassment, censorship, and violence against journalists.
00:03:20 Yes, even violence. I would point out a few different things here that have happened.
00:03:24 Harassment is commonplace.
00:03:26 If you are an independent journalist like yours truly, you try to go to a liberal press conference, you will be told you do not belong there.
00:03:33 You may even have police called and they may remove you.
00:03:37 This has happened to me.
00:03:38 It's happened to Kian Bextie of The Counter Signal.
00:03:41 It's happened to journalists at Rebel News.
00:03:43 It's happened to other folks as well.
00:03:45 Censorship.
00:03:46 Well, just a few weeks ago, we had Lauren Gunter of the Edmonton Sun on the program.
00:03:51 This is a veteran journalist and columnist in Canada.
00:03:55 But the federal government actively tried to have his column on immigration policy censored.
00:04:00 censored. They literally, as we saw in documents, went to social media companies and said, you have
00:04:05 to take down this Lorne Gunter guy's column. And thankfully, the social media companies declined to
00:04:11 do it. We also know that C11 is now law in Canada. This, when the regulations are cemented, will
00:04:18 have government pulling the levers on the algorithms, which will again censor and demote
00:04:25 some content will promote and elevate others and violence i try not to make you look at my face too
00:04:32 too much but since you're already seeing it let's put up this graphic from february of 2022 when i
00:04:39 was in ottawa covering the freedom convoy and the emergencies act was in effect police were trying
00:04:44 to clear things up and i had just gotten a hefty dose of pepper spray there for doing my job as a
00:04:51 journalist. Alexa Lavoie was hit with a canister of tear gas in her leg for doing hers. There was 1.00
00:04:57 a photojournalist from New York who, again, with a mainstream outlet, was thrown to the ground,
00:05:02 zip-tied, and had his camera smashed all while Justin Trudeau's enforcers were out to dismantle
00:05:09 not just the Freedom Convoy, but also to take aim at those who dared to tell the story of the
00:05:14 Freedom Convoy. So Justin Trudeau, if you want to take aim at harassment, censorship, and violence
00:05:21 against journalists, perhaps, sir, you should look in the mirror first, you hypocrite. But I don't 0.99
00:05:27 want to talk just about press freedom. It would be a little too indulgent. I want to talk about
00:05:31 firearms rights here, which I've always said, if you're not a gun owner or you don't particularly
00:05:36 like guns, you should still pay attention to this issue because it is a property rights issue. If
00:05:43 The government has the right to take away your property, to reclassify things, to say you're no longer allowed to own this.
00:05:49 If they can do it with guns, they could do it with cars.
00:05:52 They could do it with anything else you own conceivably.
00:05:54 Or like what we were seeing in the UK a couple of years ago, going after pointy knives because some celebrity chef decided that he should play by different rules than others.
00:06:04 Well, yesterday, Marco Mendicino came out and discussed what the Liberals are doing on their Firearms Control Bill C-21.
00:06:12 This is a bit of a primer that Marco Mendicino gave.
00:06:17 I'm proud to announce a package of reforms that will strengthen both Bill C-21 and Canada's ban on AR-15 assault-style firearms.
00:06:27 It includes amendments to the bill that will be brought forward by Liberal members,
00:06:32 and it will also include upcoming changes that will strengthen our gun control laws.
00:06:39 These reforms are about keeping AR-15 assault-style firearms off of our streets,
00:06:45 while at the same time respecting gun owners.
00:06:49 Significantly, the amendments will include a standard technical definition
00:06:54 which contain the physical characteristics of an assault-style firearm.
00:06:59 This definition, which would apply going forward, would be inserted into the Criminal Code.
00:07:05 It provides the clarity that gun owners and industry leaders need
00:07:10 and the protection that advocates have long called for.
00:07:15 I want to remind you of something.
00:07:18 In the last election, the Conservative Party pledged to get rid of our ban on assault-style firearms.
00:07:28 These amendments will ensure that any future government will have a very, very difficult time making assault-style firearms legal again.
00:07:39 And this is what we owe to Canadians.
00:07:42 Furthermore, the action we are going to take through regulation will take the burden away from gun owners
00:07:49 and make manufacturers responsible for classifying their firearms
00:07:54 because they too have a responsibility in keeping our community safe.
00:08:02 Now, Marco Mendicino, I should say, is a guy where, you know,
00:08:06 we in the firearms community refer to 22 as a caliber.
00:08:10 Marco Mendicino refers to 22 as IQ.
00:08:14 He is not the brightest guy.
00:08:16 He doesn't understand the file.
00:08:17 And he thinks that if he keeps saying assault-style firearms, assault-style weapons, that it'll make it more true.
00:08:24 But it's playing off of ignorance in Canadians who don't understand guns and in many cases just haven't been exposed to them. 0.66
00:08:32 And this little amendment is trying to deal with some of the bad press and pushback they got from their previous proclamations that they would be banning by their own admission hunting rifles and hunting shotguns.
00:08:44 But it's hardly a reprieve.
00:08:46 Joining me is Rod Giltaka from the Canadian Coalition for Firearm Rights.
00:08:51 Rod, explain to me, first off, what's different?
00:08:54 What's actually changed here from the previous iterations of C-21?
00:08:59 Thanks for having me on, Andrew.
00:09:00 The approach has changed, but the results are the same as the withdrawn amendments and could possibly be worse.
00:09:08 So the approach, well, the announcement that Marco made was a couple of new amendments to Bill C-21, and also he's talking about some regulations and some other things that feed into it.
00:09:21 So I guess the most efficient and quick way to explain this is if we're talking about the actual gun bans that they have in store for Canadians, instead of having a list and having a definition, as they did in the amendments G4 and G46 that were withdrawn,
00:09:36 They now have no list. They have a definition and they're telling Canadians, well, don't worry. Everything that you own today is fine. It's safe. It's only this definition of a prohibited firearm being semi-automatics with detachable magazines, basically, will only go forward when Bill C-21 receives royal assent.
00:09:55 So it's just for the future. But also we're reforming CFAC, which is the Canadian Firearms Advisory Committee, and they will determine what firearms that should be prohibited in the interim.
00:10:08 And then we will prohibit those firearms using orders in council. And there's no criteria mentioned by the minister.
00:10:15 So basically, it's a committee made up by the people that he wants on there.
00:10:19 They could just take the list that was G46 and just go down the list and say, this is what we recommend.
00:10:25 But they could continue past and say, well, rapid-fire firearms like lever actions or pump actions should be on the list, too.
00:10:31 There's no telling where this will go eventually.
00:10:34 And they're certainly not in this, I don't even want to call it a walkback because it really isn't, but they're not unbanning any firearms.
00:10:41 I mean, the things that they banned by order and counsel in May 2020, the 1500 variants, including AR-15 style firearms and so on, like those are going to remain banned.
00:10:52 So which I think proves the point here that they're just going to find a way to apply this new definition to whatever they don't want people to have. 0.97
00:10:59 Well, they're basically calling everyone stupid. 0.99
00:11:02 They're saying you're you're all so dumb that we'll say, oh, we're going to walk back all these things. 0.99
00:11:06 We're not first it was we're not banning hunting rifles until it's like, well, here's the hunting rifles are banning. 0.98
00:11:11 And then they're like, well, and then Justin Trudeau came out, if you remember, and said, well, yes, maybe some of these guns are on different, you know, and all while screaming about misinformation and disinformation and how terrible people like us are, the gun lobby.
00:11:25 Well, they got caught with all that.
00:11:27 They walked it all back because it was a public relations disaster for them, because it's really all about politics.
00:11:31 It's all about votes and splitting Canadians, right?
00:11:34 Well, now they're saying, oh, don't worry.
00:11:36 We're not taking anything.
00:11:38 But we can't control the committee that we set up.
00:11:41 you know it's it's their fault it's now they it's just basically a strategy so that they can
00:11:45 sidestep accountability for doing exactly the same thing that they were going to do in the first
00:11:49 place i i want to play a clip for you rod this is from the gun control activist group uh called
00:11:56 poly colloquially and their criticisms of this and i want to get your take on this afterwards
00:12:02 this this is it for you we cannot understand how we can have a real strong permanent ban
00:12:15 on assault style weapon how with which government mr mendicino today says that to complete the list
00:12:23 it will ask a committee i've been on that committee and we never decided anything and
00:12:31 And they, and they were a majority government, they never consulted us on anything strong.
00:12:38 And they table and get adopted, Bill C-71.
00:12:43 So they cannot tell me that's a strong measure, first.
00:12:47 Their definition is not strong.
00:12:49 But why would the Liberal government propose a new bill on gun control?
00:12:55 say that it's very great and the strongest thing in the new in this generation if that's it we're lost
00:13:07 now i i don't want to take away from you know the the horrific event that uh the members who
00:13:13 formed this group initially went through back in in 1989 canadians are are very well aware of it
00:13:18 and and i think it's often been used uh quite wrongfully to push an agenda that has nothing
00:13:23 to do with that horrific tragedy. And as we see now, this group is basically wanting gun control
00:13:30 to the point where guns are just completely prohibited in Canada. And anything short of that,
00:13:35 they don't like. But the problem, when you have an initiative like this that's derided by gun
00:13:40 control advocates and gun advocates, does it not give the government a bit of cover to say,
00:13:44 see, it's moderate? Well, as I said before, their plan now is to sidestep all accountability.
00:13:52 And yeah, I mean, it's, you know, I think they were successful in dividing Canadians
00:13:57 in the last couple of elections based on the silhouette of an AR-15.
00:14:02 And, you know, conservatives want to weaken gun control and liberals want to strengthen
00:14:06 it, all the rest of this rhetoric.
00:14:09 But, you know, gun control is a sword that cuts both ways, right?
00:14:14 So if you think that your votes are in urban centers and the voting profile, the people
00:14:20 that are going to support you are pro-gun control because they don't know any better, let's say,
00:14:24 just for sake of argument, then you're going to try to get those votes and consider the
00:14:31 law-abiding gun owners to be a smaller pool of votes for you. And somehow you'll win an election.
00:14:37 I think it's worked reasonably well for them. But I think, and this is my fantasy that you'll
00:14:45 just indulge me in for a minute, I think that Canadians are starting to wake up a little bit.
00:14:49 They're realizing that our violence problem is not licensed gun owners shooting at shooting clubs like we have for 150 years in Canada, by the way, since before Canada was a country.
00:14:59 Our issues are the opioid epidemic, which is just being made worse by liberal policies.
00:15:05 Disasterous, prolific offender issues as made worse by the Liberal Bill C-75 that law enforcement across the country have said, you need to repeal Bill C-75.
00:15:14 It's making our streets unsafe to even walk on.
00:15:17 So bail reform issues and a raging gang problem.
00:15:21 Like Canadians, I think, are starting to figure it out that they've been gaslit for seven and a half years and it's just not working for them.
00:15:27 So now they're putting a little bit more effort into kind of walking things back and repackaging the same product and whatnot.
00:15:34 I think they're they're dancing a little bit now.
00:15:35 They haven't made anybody happy.
00:15:38 No, and I'm looking at what Marco Mendicino has said here.
00:15:43 And again, as we've discussed, it's not really going to make a material difference if you are a gun owner.
00:15:48 They can tweak the process or say they're tweaking the process, but we know the outcome they want.
00:15:53 And basically, we're seeing a government, and correct me if I'm wrong, that will not stop until every semi-automatic firearm has been prohibited.
00:16:02 Well, but it won't stop there.
00:16:03 and this we've been telling the the hunting community for a long time you know how how
00:16:08 confident are you that the liberals are just going to stop just short of the firearms that you own
00:16:13 like they're going to be like okay well we got the we got the ar-15s and even wooden you know
00:16:19 stocked firearms that could be like the sks that we still think are assault weapons we've got those
00:16:24 well you know what we're on a roll why would they stop there so at the end of the day they want you
00:16:29 have a break action if at all uh or a bolt action and maybe that'll be what's left it's uh it's yeah
00:16:37 i mean i think i think they've demonstrated as a political party after running canada for seven
00:16:43 and a half years they can't be trusted they'll never say what they actually want it's uh it's
00:16:48 it's a real mess and i think it has backfired on them i'd like to think so the the one thing that
00:16:52 marco mendicino mentioned there that i i found very well i found a lot of it concerned i found
00:16:57 all of it concerning actually but but one in particular is when he talked about effectively
00:17:00 trying to bind future governments he he said the conservatives have already said they want to roll
00:17:05 this back and have more uh gun rights what is he referring to there and and is he correct that a
00:17:11 Pierre Polyev government theoretically who has been on the record as as opposing this gun control
00:17:16 that he would actually have difficult untangle a difficulty untangling this is that the case
00:17:20 well um when so the original way that they were going to do it with um amendments well both
00:17:26 amendments g4 and 46 where they were going to legislate these firearms as prohibited so right
00:17:32 now they're legislate they well they want to legislate a um a definition of what an assault
00:17:39 style uh firearm is but which will be different from any real definition as we've known i mean
00:17:45 the pr definition for that that the government uses is is not anything that exists in canada
00:17:50 well if you look at paulie says if you have a press release they called everything assault
00:17:55 weapons. They said assault weapon, I counted because I have the video, counted like eight
00:17:59 times they called them assault weapons. But nonetheless, it's a propaganda war, first and
00:18:04 foremost. But the firearms that they ban using an order in council can be repealed by a minority
00:18:11 government in the future. The firearms that they ban, either by definition or by name,
00:18:16 that are in legislation, they would need a majority government or a coalition government
00:18:20 to repeal that. So that's, that's the difference. So, I mean, if, if I'm really searching around
00:18:26 for something positive, it's like, it's, it would be the, you know, Marco saying, well, we're going
00:18:31 to, we're going to ban these things by OIC because that can be reversed, but it's one thing legally.
00:18:35 And it's another thing politically because no government, including the conservatives want to
00:18:39 be a one-term government. So it'll be just as much work for organizations like ours to get these
00:18:45 firearms and rights back as it will fighting the liberals for that last seven and a half years.
00:18:50 The one thing that strikes me here is that the Liberals don't even believe their own fear mongering. And one example, you were featured and the CCFR was a very generous supporter of the documentary we reproduced a couple of years ago called Assaulted.
00:19:04 And at the time, we did that around this time in April of 2021, and it had been about a year since this order and council came in, and we talked to a lot of gun owners and gun business owners who had said, yeah, my AR-15 inventory and all this other inventory was prohibited.
00:19:22 The government put a freeze on it immediately.
00:19:24 We're still saddled with it.
00:19:25 The government said it's dangerous to have these things out in the country.
00:19:28 Well, two years have passed since then, three years since the ban, and this buyback that they've promised still hasn't materialized.
00:19:36 And we still haven't seen this rash of so-called assault weapon crime in Canada to back up what the Liberals said was the necessary and inevitable outcome of these guns existing.
00:19:47 So, I mean, their own fear, like if it was that urgent, they would have figured this out and collected all these things by now.
00:19:53 Well, you would have thought they would have figured it out before they made the announcement that they were going to do this in short order. But another thing I would point out to your viewers is that all this talk about gun control. So right from the Liberals' first majority government, where they brought out Bill C-71, you had the May 2020 gun ban, that OIC, you had the handgun freeze, you've got C-21 coming down the pike at us.
00:20:18 And it's like, well, Canada is more dangerous than it's ever been right now. And yet back in
00:20:23 the Harper era in 2013, it was that year had the lowest level of firearm related violence
00:20:29 since StatsCan started collecting data on firearm related violence. And we had far less gun control.
00:20:35 We didn't have all this gun control. So it's funny, you know, you got these advocates that
00:20:39 are like, well, less guns in a society, more firearm regulation, you know, less violence.
00:20:44 And it's like, well, clearly, those two things don't correlate at all.
00:20:49 So it's just kind of an interesting phenomenon in real life.
00:20:53 Yeah, I think we need more bail control right now, not more gun control to deal with crime.
00:20:58 Rod Giltaka from the CCFR.
00:21:00 I will see you in a few weeks for CCFR members out there.
00:21:03 I'll be at the annual general meeting in June.
00:21:06 So I thank you for the invitation.
00:21:08 And thanks for coming on today, Rod.
00:21:10 Thank you.
00:21:10 And we'll see you then.
00:21:11 All right.
00:21:12 Thanks very much.
00:21:13 I want to talk about this bigger picture story here about the Emergencies Act, which if we talk about the fallout of the Freedom Convoy, I would say that this protest back in January, February of 2022 really morphed from being about vaccine mandates to more broadly being about civil liberties.
00:21:31 I shared with you that image of me, and not a particularly flattering one, but no image of me is, of me being pepper sprayed.
00:21:39 And the Emergencies Act, I'd say, was something that united a lot more people than were already united in the cause of the Freedom Convoy.
00:21:47 And I bring this up now because Christine Van Gein, who is the litigation director at the Canadian Constitution Foundation,
00:21:55 had a great piece in C2C Journal in which she talked about the legal challenges underway
00:22:01 to the federal government's use of the Emergencies Act.
00:22:05 She calls it the last guardrail of accountability.
00:22:08 And I want to quibble with that in one sense that we'll get to,
00:22:11 but I thought it was an important point here.
00:22:13 And I wanted to speak to Christine about this.
00:22:16 It's good to talk to you.
00:22:17 Christine, thanks for coming on today.
00:22:18 Thanks for having me on, Andrew.
00:22:20 So let's start first off with the wake of the Public Order Emergency Commission,
00:22:25 which I think was a bit of a nail-biter.
00:22:28 A lot of people on both sides seemed to think that it could have gone either way.
00:22:32 But as we know, the federal government ultimately was somewhat vindicated
00:22:36 by the Public Order Emergency Commission.
00:22:39 But that was not the end of the story here.
00:22:42 Yeah, exactly.
00:22:43 And we were participants in that inquiry.
00:22:45 We were advocating for, obviously, a different outcome than what we got with that report,
00:22:53 which was a disappointing act of deference but the other line of accountability is your judicial
00:23:00 review in the courts and the courts have different procedures the courts have different
00:23:05 tools the court can actually have a finding of liability that the inquiry could not so what we
00:23:14 did was we filed an application for judicial review of the decision to invoke the emergencies
00:23:19 Act, and that judicial review was heard this April. There were a number of other organizations
00:23:25 that brought judicial reviews as well, and they were all consolidated into one hearing. So we
00:23:30 were heard alongside the Canadian Civil Liberties Association and a group of individuals who were
00:23:37 directly, some directly impacted by the Emergencies Act measures. For example, some of them had their
00:23:43 bank accounts frozen, and another group called the Canadian Frontline Nurses. So that was heard
00:23:48 in early April of this year. Now, what's the substance, if you will? And I know that each
00:23:54 of the groups involved may have had its own approach here, but what's the substance of
00:23:57 the argument? Is it really constitutional in nature? Is it going for just the threshold set
00:24:02 out in the act, or is it a bit of all of the above? So it's both. So there were two major
00:24:06 themes. The first theme was that the threshold to invoke the act was not met. The Emergencies Act
00:24:13 has specific internal thresholds that says you can only declare a public order emergency if this
00:24:19 particular criteria is met. One of those criterias is that the act is an act of last resort, so no
00:24:27 other laws are available to deal with a situation that is national in scope and critical and urgent.
00:24:34 And we've argued that that threshold was not met, that there were other tools that were available.
00:24:41 the RCMP even said all legal tools were not exhausted. A number of police witnesses at the
00:24:47 inquiry said that the Emergencies Act was helpful, but not necessary. And of course, that does not
00:24:54 make it a last resort if it's just helpful. That's not the standard. The other internal threshold
00:24:59 is this requirement to invoke a public order emergency. There needs to be a threat to the
00:25:05 security of Canada. And that is a term defined by reference to another statute, the CSIS Act.
00:25:12 Now, I don't want to get too into too complex details, but basically CSIS said there was no
00:25:18 national emergency. Cabinet said, well, we think there was. We don't care what the intelligence
00:25:25 experts have to say. We're going to come to our own conclusion. And even though CSIS's definition
00:25:31 that they work with regularly wasn't met and that's the definition that we're going to have
00:25:36 to apply in this case we're going to find that the two definitions are different so that was
00:25:42 one theme that was the one major theme that the internal thresholds of the act were not met
00:25:46 the other theme was about the charter and we can talk about that as well yeah i want to get to that
00:25:52 but but first i just wanted to ask about the emergencies act and whether there is a level
00:25:58 of deference built into it to depart from that they need to explain why they're departing from
00:26:05 CSIS's assessment right CSIS is the one who works with intelligence CSIS is the one who understands
00:26:12 intelligence much better than politicians do they work with this on a regular basis if they want to
00:26:22 reach a different conclusion they need to explain why and they haven't done that there's an
00:26:26 explanation that the government provided it's called section 58 explanation it's required by
00:26:32 the legislation on this issue of last resort uh basically cabinet just the the um the section 58
00:26:41 explanation just said um yeah it was a last resort so these these issues are really important because
00:26:49 cabinet just doesn't automatically get a higher level of deference because they are cabinet right
00:26:57 and that was one of the really troubling things about the the hearing the government the attorney
00:27:04 general's lawyers was arguing that cabinet deserves a special and higher level of deference
00:27:11 that they're the apex decision maker and accordingly its authority is basically
00:27:17 unconstrained by the emergencies act and the mere assertion that cabinet believed it was acting
00:27:24 reasonably that's all that they need and that the problem with that is basically that would make any
00:27:31 decision to invoke the emergencies act reasonable so we completely disagree with and it also have
00:27:39 huge implications in other areas of law where cabinet is the decision maker if you're going to
00:27:44 say cabinet is always acting reasonably because it was cabinet, that's a no-go for me in terms
00:27:51 of government accountability and rule of law. One thing that I'm always interested in when I
00:27:56 cover trials or any sort of administrative proceeding like the Public Order Emergency
00:28:01 Commission is judges sometimes have these little sort of indulgences of sort, these things you can
00:28:06 tell they're kind of interested in that might not even be core to the case. I mean, in the case of
00:28:11 Paul Rouleau and the emergency commission I know one thing he was asking a lot of people about was
00:28:16 whether there were any alternative sites proposed whether protesters were told yeah they could
00:28:21 continue to protest somewhere else I'm just curious in your hearing if the judge was really
00:28:27 kind of focusing in on certain details if there was something that you sort of took as a point
00:28:32 of interest for the judge well one thing that stood out to me that is I mean it's not a point
00:28:38 interest to the judge but one thing the judge mentioned was that he actually used to work as
00:28:43 a commercial trucker uh in southern alberta when he was a young man uh that to me was a really
00:28:48 interesting little tidbit um i i think i i posted about this on our youtube channel when i was
00:28:55 covering and summarizing each day's proceedings and people really that got a really big reaction
00:29:00 in terms of what justice mostly was interested in one of the things he really zeroed in on
00:29:05 was the freezing of the bank accounts and the government had made the argument that
00:29:12 the freezing and of assets was not a search or a seizure under section nine of the charter so
00:29:20 the canadian charter of rights and freedoms guarantees the right to be free from an
00:29:24 unreasonable search and seizure and as we know the freezing of those bank accounts was done
00:29:30 without a warrant and you know sometimes warrantless searches can can be reasonable but in this case
00:29:38 we're arguing that they were not reasonable but the government was arguing it wasn't even a search 1.00
00:29:44 it wasn't even a seizure even though it it clear i mean it clearly was like this is a stupid 0.95
00:29:52 question but what was it did they have a name for what they think it is no they just it was 0.89
00:29:57 just it just happened it was just a thing information but and and and the government
00:30:02 said even if it was a search that the information in your bank account is not especially valuable
00:30:10 information but think about how how you would feel if your neighbor uh went through your credit card
00:30:17 statements i mean i think about how my my husband would feel if he went through my credit card
00:30:22 statements. I want privacy over that information. That's very personal information, right? It can say
00:30:29 where you have coffee, where you go to the gym, if you go to the gym, if you see a doctor,
00:30:37 what, like a psychologist or a therapist, who that therapist is, that's very deeply personal
00:30:44 information that the government dismissed as, oh, well, this is, it says how much money you have
00:30:51 to your name. This is very important information. It wasn't time limited. There was no limit on
00:30:58 those orders that said from where, from when until when that information is available for
00:31:06 disclosure. So, I mean, Justice Mosley was very interested in that argument. He said that he was
00:31:13 having a lot of difficulty accepting the argument that this was not a search, which is, I think,
00:31:20 gives me some hope for this decision that that he's gonna find it was an unreasonable search
00:31:26 should should we take from that that the federal government thought it was was going to be so hard
00:31:32 to sell to say that it was a reasonable search and seizure that they really just fell back to
00:31:37 claiming it wasn't a search and seizure at all is that because that would be how i'd look at it
00:31:40 they really don't think they can defend it on the reasonableness ground so let's just try to
00:31:45 reinvent the english language uh no i wouldn't say that i would just say this is just a legal
00:31:49 tactic where you throw everything you throw up every possible blockade that you can and we dealt
00:31:54 with a lot of blockades in this hearing at the very beginning we spent two hours of the government
00:31:59 arguing we shouldn't be here at all saying that the whole case was moot that the emergencies act
00:32:05 had been repealed that it's there's nothing to see here and there had already been this inquiry
00:32:11 so just just on that christine has the judge ruled on the mootness yet or is he dealing with
00:32:16 it all at the same time no he hasn't i don't know if he'll be dealing with it all at the same time
00:32:21 he could break it and deal with mootness separately it was a separate motion that he
00:32:26 just heard uh simultaneously with the merits uh i don't think that justice mosley was buying the
00:32:32 argument i'm not in his mind so i can't i don't know but it did not seem like it was going well
00:32:40 And we, the applicants in the judicial review, none of us actually even made oral arguments on mootness.
00:32:46 We just made written submissions because I think the government's case on mootness is so weak.
00:32:51 Basically, to say that this case is moot means that you can never challenge an invocation of the Emergencies Act.
00:32:58 The government's hypothetical scenario was like, if we have a very long and extended
00:33:03 invocation of the emergency, which it's just unreasonable hypothetical.
00:33:12 Well, yeah, and it flies in the face of what Justin Trudeau himself said when he was selling
00:33:17 the Emergencies Act to people, which is that, yes, it's subject to the charter. Yes, you can
00:33:21 always go through this challenge. So to then turn around after and say, well, you can't,
00:33:25 And their argument was that, well, the circumstances will always be different in the future.
00:33:29 So there's no point.
00:33:30 I didn't find that all that compelling.
00:33:33 But I did want to just bring up the last guardrail aspect, which I think in terms of legal tools is something I would agree with.
00:33:41 I would say that the last, if the legal avenue fails, is still the political accountability, though.
00:33:47 I do agree there is political accountability.
00:33:52 I think this is the last procedural guardrail.
00:33:55 That's what I would say, that once this judicial review is done, and this could, of course, go all the way to the Supreme Court if they're interested in hearing it, this is the last procedure that we have at our disposal to hold the government accountable.
00:34:11 Political accountability is, of course, very important, and people like you who continue to talk about this subject when it's a year past now that this happened, it's very important.
00:34:24 it's very important that we not forget that this happened because when we forget it makes it easier
00:34:28 for the government to do it to us again very well said the piece is a fantastic one at the c2c
00:34:35 journal you can read it at c2c journal.ca the last guardrail of accountability the legal challenge
00:34:41 to the trudeau government's use of the emergencies at christine van gein always an absolute delight
00:34:46 to talk to you thanks for your insights and analysis on this as always thanks andrew it's
00:34:50 It's always great to talk to you.
00:34:52 All right.
00:34:52 Thank you very much, Christine.
00:34:54 We always like to end on a bit of a cheery note when possible.
00:34:57 This story was great.
00:34:58 Do you remember when I believe it was like 2020 to 2021 to 2022 into 2023?
00:35:06 So basically for the last three years, there was this wave where anything and everything
00:35:10 was a COVID symptom.
00:35:12 I remember like you'd go to the store and you'd see the big sign that says if you've
00:35:16 had a cough or fever or a bit of a limp, or if your left earlobe is itchy or your right earlobe
00:35:24 is itchy, or you've got, you know, a pimple on your back or like anything and everything was a
00:35:29 COVID symptom. And I kind of thought that had gone away for a little while, but then I saw this story
00:35:34 in the Toronto Star, of course, those itchy, red, watery eyes could be allergies. They could also
00:35:42 be a sign of COVID. And I don't know if you, oh, we, we, uh, the graphic now you don't even get
00:35:47 to see the full, uh, watery eyes of their, uh, their stock, uh, of the stock model here, uh,
00:35:53 who was photographed by a stock photo agency. And I don't believe has COVID may or may not have
00:35:59 COVID. Uh, but now we're saying that allergies, if you are one of these people that deals with
00:36:04 the allergy, the allergy season, and it bothers you tremendously. This is now a sign of COVID.
00:36:13 So ignore the allergies you've had. Now I'm going to show you an image. This is also, I believe,
00:36:17 a sign of COVID. Yeah. Oh, hey, come on, Sean. Sean said he had an image of someone who had
00:36:25 like COVID watery eyes. And then it's, that actually wasn't from the pepper spray. I got
00:36:30 COVID from one of those dirty, unacceptable fringe convoy people there. So that was me 0.91
00:36:36 two days into the truck-a-cron variant of COVID-19. Well played, Sean. You are fired.
00:36:44 We've got to end things there. My thanks to all of you for tuning into today's show. Back on Friday
00:36:49 with more of Canada's most irreverent talk show here on True North. This is The Andrew
00:36:54 Lawton Show. Thank you. God bless and good day to you all. Thanks for listening to the Andrew
00:37:00 Lawton Show. Support the program by donating to True North at www.tnc.news.