Juno News - April 25, 2024


Liberals claim their big-spending, tax-hiking budget is about "fairness"

Topics
Mentioned
‘This is not justice’ — member of Coutts 3 responds Trudeau’s war on Canadian energy won’t save the planet

Episode Stats


Length

50 minutes

Words per minute

188.2

Word count

9,536

Sentence count

433

Harmful content

Misogyny

7

sentences flagged

Toxicity

1

sentences flagged

Hate speech

7

sentences flagged


Summary

Summaries generated with gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ .

In this episode of The Andrew Lawton Show: Canada's Most Irreverent Talk Show, Andrew Lawton revisits the capital gains tax increase in the Liberal government's 2019 budget, and takes a look at the impact on Canadian doctors.

Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Topics generated with Qwen2.5-3B-Instruct.
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 Transcription by CastingWords
00:00:30 Thank you.
00:01:00 welcome to canada's most irreverent talk show this is the andrew lawton show brought to you
00:01:19 by true north hello and welcome to the andrew lawton show canada's most irreverent talk show
00:01:29 here on true north thursday april 25th and we are going to have a grand old time here as we close
00:01:35 out the week at least in so far as the andrew lotten show is concerned but we got off the
00:01:40 record coming up on uh well tomorrow i don't know why i was going to give a day of the week there
00:01:44 and also i should make a point of letting you know if you're in the ottawa area i'm going to be
00:01:49 speaking this weekend on sunday on a panel about my favorite topics free speech ethics and democracy
00:01:56 It's going to be at the Lansdowne Park Horticulture Building.
00:02:00 It's part of the Ottawa Food and Book Expo, and I like both food and books.
00:02:05 Ottawa, I'm a little bit iffy on, but I like food and books, and I'm indifferent to expos.
00:02:10 But I think it'll be a grand old time.
00:02:12 Julie Panessi, who has been on the show a couple of times, will be on the panel as well,
00:02:17 as will Randy Hillier, who dislikes me because he's always, like, firing, like, these pot shots at me on Twitter.
00:02:22 But I've, you know, only ever had favorable interactions with him in person.
00:02:26 So it should be fun, but that's going to be coming up on Sunday.
00:02:29 So if you are in Ottawa and you want to get some tickets, you can head over to Eventbrite.
00:02:33 And I think if you search my name, I believe this is the only thing that comes up.
00:02:37 So if there's another Andrew Lawton that's, you know, some folk singer touring Dubuque, Iowa on Sunday, that's not me.
00:02:43 I'm the one at the Ottawa Food and Book Expo, but that should be great fun there.
00:02:49 I wanted to kick things off by revisiting this capital gains increase in the budget.
00:02:53 Now, to be fair, when the Liberal government announced the increase to the capital gains tax in the budget that was released last week, I didn't think that would be the thing to get legs, but it has gotten legs.
00:03:04 It has been a thing that a lot of people have been talking about.
00:03:07 One of the more notable criticisms of this was from Canadian doctors who were saying, well, hold on.
00:03:13 I mean, doctors, if they have professional corporations, which most of them or almost all of them in private practice do, they've been using capital gains basically as their retirement plans.
00:03:23 So now when government is putting a pretty significant increase to the capital gains
00:03:29 tax, that is going to disadvantage Canadian doctors, so much so that many of them have
00:03:33 said they will probably shut down their practices, retire early, or leave the country altogether.
00:03:39 Now, this is a country in which it's very difficult for a lot of people to get a family
00:03:43 doctor or to get access to a family doctor if you have one.
00:03:46 So when you've got doctors that are, by and large, not a particularly political group
00:03:51 getting up and saying, whoa, whoa, whoa, this is a big problem here.
00:03:53 that's what the Canadian Medical Association did, governments should pay attention. But it was
00:03:59 amazing how one of the ministers that was dispatched to the media to defend and sell the budget
00:04:04 really had no answer whatsoever for this. This is the small business minister in Canada
00:04:10 going up against David Poutine for the CBC. Cochran, take a look.
00:04:16 There has been some pushback that this could affect family doctors and other professionals
00:04:20 who incorporate their practice for the tax advantages that a corporation would have.
00:04:25 So while individually, if they were, say, working in a hospital,
00:04:30 they would not necessarily be affected by the new capital gains inclusion,
00:04:33 but if their corporate structure is such that they're relying on corporate investments
00:04:36 to pay for their future and their retirement, they're going to be hit.
00:04:39 And in a country that's already struggling to have enough family doctors,
00:04:43 this creates a disincentive for some of them to work in Canada.
00:04:47 We recognize that, but one of the things that we will continue to do is encourage
00:04:51 foreign credential recognition to help. We know that coming out of the pandemic our health care
00:04:56 has really been hampered and there's a really challenge with labor, but the investments we
00:05:01 made with foreign credentialing, we've already made a significant investment in previous budgets
00:05:05 and in this year we've topped that up and we will continue to invest to ensure we're encouraging
00:05:10 bringing talent from other countries to get their credentials recognized and that will also
00:05:16 encourage them to get more jobs here and fill the desperate labor market needs that are
00:05:21 required in our health care industry.
00:05:23 No, and I understand the impetus to try to accelerate health professionals in particular
00:05:27 to be able to work in Canada through the standard, but if doctors who are here now, who are set
00:05:33 up through the existing corporate structure that relies heavily on capital gains income
00:05:38 for their retirement and for their future because they wouldn't have a pension in this
00:05:41 sort of a situation, if they balk at the situation that has been created by this change, I mean,
00:05:47 how do you deal with that? The goal is to not increase the gap in medical coverage, right? So
00:05:52 how do you respond to the concerns being raised by people in that sector that this is potentially
00:05:56 punitive to them? If I take a step back to what I mentioned earlier, and you heard the prime
00:06:01 minister said it, what we're really trying to do is really create a Canada that is fair for every
00:06:06 generation. So her answer to, hey, all of these doctors are concerned they're going to leave the 0.79
00:06:14 country. What are you going to do? I don't worry about it. We'll just make sure we bring in some
00:06:19 foreign doctors and that'll be that and we'll get their credentials recognized. Now, to be fair,
00:06:24 I don't think she's as dumb as she sounds. I think what's happened is ministers get loaded up with so 0.99
00:06:31 many talking points. She's been told, okay, doctors, anytime you're asked about a doctor
00:06:35 shortage. Talk about foreign credential recognition. And she just like only heard the word doctors and
00:06:41 was like going through the mental Rolodex. Hang on. I've got a talking point about doctors. I've
00:06:45 got no, no, no, not doctoring. No, not documents. Foreign credential. And then she just committed
00:06:51 to it because her answer actually had nothing to do with the federal budget. It had nothing to do
00:06:57 with the question that was asked. To be honest, had nothing to do with what we would argue is
00:07:01 perhaps common sense or reason. But you know what? She was doing her best there. The question had
00:07:07 doctor in it. So she found an answer that had doctor in it. And that was it. And then when he
00:07:12 follows up and says, well, hang on. Okay. Yeah, that's all well and good. But what about doctors
00:07:16 who are literally leaving the country right now? Then she says, well, it's about fair. Then at that
00:07:21 point, you just go to the generic talking point. The I've run out of things to say talking point
00:07:25 and you default to, well, this budget is about fairness. This budget is about fairness. It's
00:07:30 like the old joke I told after watching an Aaron O'Toole press conference. If my wife asked me if
00:07:35 I emptied the dishwasher, I say, well, you know, I'm a big fan of clean dishes. And that's basically
00:07:40 it. And we don't need to get down into anything resembling facts or sense or a connection of the
00:07:46 answer to the question. But all of that is to say that the federal government right now is getting
00:07:51 hit from all sides on this. They're getting hit from a lot of their own wealthy elites that are
00:07:55 like, hang on, why are you going after my capital gains tax? And a lot of people that are middle 0.98
00:08:00 class Canadians. Many doctors in this country are not wealthy. They have, in lieu of fee increases,
00:08:05 received an arrangement by which they can make investments through their professional
00:08:09 corporations. And now they're going to see a steep increase in the taxes that they pay
00:08:13 on those. So the capital gains increase isn't just this crusade against the rich and wealthy. It's
00:08:19 not just about the people with yachts and private jets, as Justin Trudeau would have you believe.
00:08:24 It's about a group that is, generally speaking, broader than that. And the government still
00:08:29 keeps holding to this idea that it's about fairness. Here's Chrystia Freeland.
00:08:35 I asked about changes to the capital gain tax. And, you know, we've heard from local physicians
00:08:40 that they're concerned about how this will impact recruitment and retention. And we have doctor
00:08:45 shortages in Newfoundland and Labrador and across the country. What do you say to them right now?
00:08:49 Well, look, I would start by talking about what the objective of our budget is, what
00:08:59 the mission of our budget is.
00:09:02 And our budget is about fairness for all Canadians, about giving all Canadians, especially younger
00:09:11 Canadians, Millennials and Gen Z, a real opportunity to have a middle class life.
00:09:18 And we know that that requires investments.
00:09:21 It requires investments in housing.
00:09:23 It requires investments in affordability.
00:09:26 It requires investments in economic growth.
00:09:30 And so to make those investments, we need to find a way to finance them.
00:09:34 And what we're saying in the budget is we're asking those in our country who are doing
00:09:40 the best to contribute a little bit more.
00:09:44 And that really is fair.
00:09:46 Fairness is the name of the game. Today's show is brought to you by the letter F.
00:09:52 Fairness, fairness, fairness, fairness. So anytime they're facing any questions about it as well,
00:09:57 it's, you know, we're all about the fairness. This is not fair what we have now. And it's
00:10:02 the same mentality that we had in that clip I shared yesterday of Justin Trudeau talking about
00:10:06 how the economy is not working for young Canadians. The same people who bristled at anyone who has
00:10:12 said that Canada is broken are now saying that Canada is not a fair country to live in. Canada
00:10:17 is not fair. It's not fair to younger people. Now, look, I would agree that the deck is stacked
00:10:22 against them, but I would also agree that the appropriate time to talk about this would have
00:10:26 been years ago when other people were, and you were just saying, oh no, it's all sunny ways.
00:10:32 Everything's fine. Everything is all hunky-dory. And the Liberals have been so focused on pursuing
00:10:37 is an agenda of censorship, curtailing civil liberties, and not focused on the structural
00:10:42 barriers that exist between Canadians who want to live a pleasant, comfortable middle-class
00:10:48 existence and that existence itself. And I wanted to, just before we get into this a bit further
00:10:54 with Aaron Woodrick, who will be joining us in a couple of moments, and I want to talk about this
00:10:58 big Honda announcement as well. I wanted to bring up this clip from Australia, which I found quite
00:11:04 amusing. So you may know that Canada is in the process right now of trying to push forward a
00:11:08 rather significant curtailing of your right to speak and debate and discuss online. It's Bill
00:11:14 C63. I've talked about it extensively and will continue to. But one of the things that I always
00:11:20 bring up is that you have to trust that a government that is going to give itself the
00:11:24 power to regulate speech is going to be motivated by the right things to use that power. And I just
00:11:31 simply do not trust government to do, well, most things, but certainly to do that. So here is
00:11:35 Australian Prime Minister Anthony Albanese as Exhibit A on why you should not trust governments
00:11:42 with this power. Media platforms have a responsibility to make sure that misinformation
00:11:52 isn't got out there. I noticed today, for example, on the way up here, they've removed
00:12:00 various sites that were up containing fake images of myself, superimposed on other people.
00:12:13 That's the sort of thing that is going on on social media.
00:12:17 Social media has a responsibility to do the right thing here.
00:12:24 So the Prime Minister of Australia, by the way, a far cry from former PM Tony Abbott
00:12:29 that we had on the show a couple of weeks ago.
00:12:31 I like Tony Abbott a lot more than Albanese here, 1.00
00:12:34 but he's basically using his example, his pride, his joy
00:12:38 that tech companies have taken down things he doesn't like about himself.
00:12:43 So the Australian government has used online harms,
00:12:47 online safety, misinformation as a cudgel to go after people
00:12:53 that post satirical images that the ruling class finds offensive to its sensibilities.
00:12:59 Now, whether he was personally sitting in his office and said, I want that one gone,
00:13:03 I want that one gone, I want that one gone, I don't know, probably not, but he is certainly
00:13:07 cheering for that use of the law.
00:13:10 So this is why I do not trust at all for a second the idea that a prime minister like
00:13:15 Justin Trudeau or anyone else, liberal, conservative, even some hypothetical situation in which Jagmeet
00:13:21 Singh manages to claim an iota of relevance and becomes prime minister himself, none of
00:13:26 these people should have that power.
00:13:29 because they're only going to use it to uphold the regime.
00:13:32 They're going to use it to take away criticisms.
00:13:35 Just one story very briefly.
00:13:37 I had a couple of years back the opportunity to go to London, England
00:13:40 for the Global Conference for Media Freedom,
00:13:43 which Canada was co-hosting with the UK.
00:13:46 And in the course of this,
00:13:48 Christopher Freeland got up on stage and was lauding the,
00:13:52 I forget his name, it was Singh Deol, I believe,
00:13:55 or Singh Deol, Singh Deol, Gobinder Singh Deol.
00:13:58 He was the Malaysian Minister of Communications or something of that sort.
00:14:03 And she was holding him up as being this, you know, hero to press freedom.
00:14:07 And I Googled for, you know, all of like three seconds or whatever and found that he had tried to weaponize Malaysia's online speech laws against a blogger who lived in a different country because that blogger was saying mean things about him.
00:14:21 And Malaysia is a country where the government can get away with doing that.
00:14:24 But we can't import that sensibility into Western nations.
00:14:27 So good on the Australian Prime Minister for saying the quiet part out loud, which is that he loves the government's ability to censor online because he doesn't like when people post satirical images of him online.
00:14:39 That is, thank you, Prime Minister, for making our point for us.
00:14:43 I couldn't come up with a better criticism of this bill than you saying what you've been using that law for yourself.
00:14:48 Well, let's shift gears here, no pun intended, to yet another big-ticket automotive funding announcement
00:14:55 from the federal government in Canada and also the provincial government in Ontario.
00:15:00 Justin Trudeau stood and made this proclamation about Honda today.
00:15:06 Today, Honda is making Canadian automotive history.
00:15:10 With this announcement, we will be investing to create Canada's first comprehensive electric vehicle supply chain from start to finish.
00:15:22 Today, we announced that Honda will invest to create the first complete supply chain of electric vehicles in Canada.
00:15:31 A whole ecosystem will be built with four new manufacturing plants in Ontario, including an EV assembly plant, a standalone battery manufacturing plant, and two plants for battery components.
00:15:46 These investments will create well over 1,000 well-paying manufacturing jobs as well as many, many construction jobs and, of course, jobs all across Ontario and the country for auto parts suppliers.
00:16:04 But this announcement isn't just about creating jobs.
00:16:07 It's about securing good jobs and careers for the coming decades and even the coming generations.
00:16:15 Honda has set a goal to make EVs represent 100% of vehicle sales by 2040.
00:16:23 In Canada, our target is that 100% of all light-duty cars and passenger truck sales be zero emission by 2035.
00:16:32 And that underlines what we've always said, climate policy is economic policy.
00:16:39 and with its impact on families and communities around here it's also social policy
00:16:46 wow it sounds phenomenal it's social policy it's environmental policy it's economic policy it's
00:16:54 great you notice in that announcement he mentioned that honda is investing 15 billion dollars he's
00:17:00 there announcing honda's investment honda's putting the money forward well look i think
00:17:05 of honda wants to spend 15 billion dollars and build four electric vehicle plans in ontario
00:17:09 that's great but it isn't just honda that is putting money towards this this part has been
00:17:15 buried a little bit even in the government press release it's way way way down below what honda's
00:17:20 putting up it's what you and i are putting up aaron woodrick is with me he is the head of the
00:17:25 domestic policy program over at the mcdonald laurier institute aaron what's uh what are we
00:17:30 missing here it's not just honda's money is it no it's not and you you wondered if it was honda's
00:17:35 money what on earth would all these politicians be be doing they're stepping up to a podium it's
00:17:39 great if you have a company that wants to invest that kind of money in canada that's a great sign
00:17:43 but of course the devil's in the details and it turns out andrew you and i and other taxpayers
00:17:48 in canada ontario we're on the hook for five billion out of that 15 billion so a whole third
00:17:53 of that is going to be coming out of our pockets uh to go to honda who are doing okay i checked
00:17:59 this morning when I saw the announcement, you know, they made $8 billion U.S. in global profit
00:18:03 last year. So this is not a company that is hard done by. This is clearly a company that's got the
00:18:08 resources to invest their own money, which is great. And they should do that. And we should
00:18:12 welcome that. But that does not explain why Canadian taxpayers are being forced to stick
00:18:17 $5 billion of their own money. You know, we pay taxes for public services, Andrew. Instead,
00:18:22 they're turning around and giving it to a very profitable multinational corporation.
00:18:26 I don't consider myself to be a mathematician. I always double check with a calculator to make
00:18:32 sure I'm not getting anything right. But I was told that this would create a thousand jobs. Now
00:18:37 you may think, okay, a thousand jobs, that's phenomenal. And I remember billions are the
00:18:40 ones with nine zeros. So I can work back from there. That works out to be, again, correct my
00:18:46 math here, $5 million per job. That's exactly right. And Andrew, it is as crazy as it sounds.
00:18:53 people might say, well, that doesn't sound quite right. Well, it is right. They are actually
00:18:57 subsidizing the equivalent of $5 million per job. So you heard the prime minister there. He said
00:19:02 they'd be well-paying jobs. Boy, I hope they're really well-paying jobs if we're paying $5 million
00:19:07 a pop just to create them. Yeah. And again, I mean, not that I'm recommending this as policy,
00:19:12 but it would literally be cheaper just to walk around Alveston and give everyone a million
00:19:17 dollars and would probably have more of an economic benefit because then at least their
00:19:21 people are spending it like this is absurd and there's no roi on this like you'll never make
00:19:26 that money back no and look uh you know the the government always has i know all the lines right
00:19:31 now if you're familiar with these types of announcements you can pretty much sing the song
00:19:35 um they're going to talk about spin-offs they're going to talk about you know other impacts in the
00:19:39 community but the reality is we are paying these companies to create these jobs you know andrew
00:19:43 when i hear politicians talk about good paying jobs and the importance of them that's always on
00:19:47 the presumption that they're being generated by the private sector. If you're going in
00:19:51 and essentially paying the salary of these people for the company, it's not really a private sector
00:19:56 job. It's essentially a government job masquerading as a private sector job. That has a very different
00:20:01 impact, a very different impact on the bottom line of the government, right? The whole reason
00:20:05 we want these jobs is because they generate tax revenue that we can spend on public services.
00:20:09 Instead, these kinds of announcements, they are taking resources out, things we're not spending
00:20:14 on things like roads and hospitals and schools and the kinds of things you expect your tax money is
00:20:18 supposed to go towards well and the other part of it too is that the companies themselves tend to
00:20:23 have very little in the way of oversight to maximize how many jobs they're creating i mean
00:20:28 one big example this week has been the letter from the union representing a lot of workers
00:20:33 at the uh stellantis plant in windsor that they're being that they're building and they're saying
00:20:37 well hold on we were told this was going to be to create canadian jobs yet we're seeing a large
00:20:41 number of foreign workers that are being brought in so Korean workers are benefiting from this
00:20:47 money that the federal and provincial governments have given to Stellantis and LG and of course the
00:20:52 government says oh well it's you know specialized skills and whatnot and then you have Oakville and
00:20:57 Ford again a heavily subsidized EV battery plant delayed I think until 2027 so now you have a
00:21:03 company that is for business reasons as it's permitted to do dragging its heels on this so
00:21:08 So we're not even getting the benefit of these jobs that we were all promised.
00:21:11 And this is happening time and time again in these cases where it's not even like that core deliverable even pans out.
00:21:18 Well, it never does.
00:21:19 And it's because it comes down to the fact the government is trying to they're trying to do central planning here within it with what who's supposed to be a private actor.
00:21:25 I mean, that's the very fact that you're setting a number saying you have to hire a thousand people.
00:21:29 Well, companies normally hire based on what they need, right?
00:21:32 They hire or let people go based on their economic need, what makes sense for them, what they can afford.
00:21:37 The government sets this number.
00:21:38 I mean, it doesn't make sense to tell a company you have to hire exactly a thousand people or you don't.
00:21:42 I mean, it is just completely undermines the very ethos of like a private sector company.
00:21:48 The other thing, Andrew, that I noticed that was interesting is they mentioned in the press release that it's not just about the thousand new jobs, which, by the way, are often just jobs taken from other sectors.
00:21:57 They're not net new jobs.
00:21:58 They talk about retaining existing jobs.
00:22:01 So that starts to sound to me a lot like something like a ransom fee.
00:22:05 Right.
00:22:06 you've got 4,000 people already employed at this plant, you know, be a real shame if something
00:22:10 happened to those jobs, if we don't get this handout. So I find that a very troubling development.
00:22:15 One of the arguments that you always get from people on this, and I'm curious how you refute
00:22:20 it, is this idea that, well, this is just the rule, these are the rules of the game,
00:22:24 is that if we don't, you know, Iowa's going to, or New York State is going to, and we just don't
00:22:30 get any of it. And you saw this particularly exploited by Amazon when they were launching
00:22:36 their Amazon headquarters. And they basically just put out this open call, hey, who's going to pay us
00:22:41 the most to set up shop there? But what is the answer to that? Because no one likes this idea
00:22:46 that we just say, all right, we're not going to play this game. All right, well, everyone's going
00:22:50 somewhere else. Yeah, well, two things. One, it's hard to blame companies for this when governments
00:22:55 signal that they're willing to play the game. They get taught to do this, right? They get taught
00:22:59 that like I should look for the handout, frankly, because what if my competitor does and I don't?
00:23:03 I'm kind of, then I'm on the back foot. Look, the short answer is there's this assumption always
00:23:07 that we need to be in that line of work, right? Like we have to outbid the Americans on aerospace 0.82
00:23:11 or we won't be able to build planes here. We need to outbid the Americans on EVs or we won't be
00:23:15 able to, well, it's just assumed that we need to be in the business of building EVs. I'm sure it's
00:23:20 nice to be in the business of building EVs if it makes economic sense, but to be in it for the sake
00:23:24 of it, if it costs you more to be in it than you get from being in it, it doesn't make any sense.
00:23:29 And the example we always use, and others have pointed this out, is Australia. I mean, Australia
00:23:33 used to be a place where they built cars. Eventually, they just gave up because they
00:23:37 didn't want to play this game. Guess what happened? There was no recession. There was
00:23:40 no mass unemployment. It's just that the capital went into other industries and jobs and companies
00:23:45 were created in other sectors. So this myth that if we lose building cars, we don't build cars in
00:23:51 Canada there will be this huge hole it's simply not true it is not played out anywhere else and
00:23:56 you know we have to start pushing back on this assumption that we must be in the business of
00:24:01 doing this one specific thing well and the other aspect too and I played that clip before you came
00:24:06 on of Justin Trudeau saying this isn't just an economic policy but it's an environmental policy
00:24:10 and a social policy I mean he thinks that's a good thing I think that makes it worse because
00:24:14 it means the government is trying to inject almost like a a social engineering into what 0.78
00:24:19 could be and should be economic policy and i think on electric vehicles that's particularly
00:24:24 concerning because we have huge issues with electric vehicles you have a declining consumer
00:24:29 interest in them it's not to say that they won't eventually become the thing that everyone uses but
00:24:34 we're not there right now so government is trying to manipulate the market and create a supply when
00:24:41 there isn't a demand there so it's not even like for setting aside the moral question of whether
00:24:46 uh you know corporate welfare is good it's not even like they're targeting it in a way that
00:24:50 is particularly sustainable this is still an emerging industry absolutely they're wasting
00:24:55 a vast amount of resources pursuing that social goal and i mean you can agree or disagree with
00:24:59 that goal but the amount of resources they're deploying uh towards it are massive right i mean
00:25:03 i followed the bombardier file for close to a decade and the amount of money we're talking
00:25:07 about on the ev files about 10 times you know what what what sunk into bombardier which was
00:25:12 itself a disaster so it's it's a huge sum of money in pursuit of a goal that you know i don't think
00:25:18 i mean i don't have a problem with electric vehicles but the you know they're going to become
00:25:21 prominent when the market says so when they make sense for most people when the price comes down
00:25:26 when the infrastructure is in place it's not going to happen by government fiat it's not going to
00:25:29 happen because the government subsidizes the heck out of the production and the purchase uh you know
00:25:34 and and lays down this fiat that's saying we have to have it by this date so this government is
00:25:38 trying to speed something along that has to happen at its own pace that the market is going to see to
00:25:43 it and they're wasting a massive amount of resources along the way. Aaron Woodrick from
00:25:47 the Mcdonald-Laurier Institute, always a pleasure sir. Thanks a lot Andrew. All right thank you.
00:25:53 Well we will move from one form of social engineering to another. We have spoken a fair
00:25:58 bit in the last few weeks about immigration in Canada which is often defended most significantly
00:26:04 by governments who point to a very low birth rate in this country and use that as an excuse
00:26:11 to basically say that we can't do immigration. So we're going to play in a little bit an interview
00:26:16 I did with Jenny Roth on that. Do stay tuned for that. But I want to first and foremost talk about
00:26:21 the other thing that government does that they pretend is scientific. They pretend is science
00:26:26 based policy, but is actually anything but. And this comes from the environment. Now we have all
00:26:32 heard time and time again. In fact, maybe someday we should put together a montage. Anytime there's
00:26:37 any weather event in Canada that takes place, it is linked to man-made climate change that can only
00:26:43 be solved by a carbon tax. If it's really windy one day, well, that was climate change. If there
00:26:49 are wildfires, that's climate change. If there is flooding, if there's water, it's climate change.
00:26:54 If there's no water, it's climate change. Snow, rain, wind, fall. They've taken like the old USPS
00:26:58 slogan, which I'm trying to remember now. Let me look it up because it'll be funnier if I do it
00:27:03 right. Never mind. I can't find it. The old like, oh, neither snow nor rain nor heat nor gloom of
00:27:08 night stays these couriers. Well, for the government, it's snow or rain or heat or gloom
00:27:13 of night is all climate change. That's basically the Stephen Gilboa approach to this. Now,
00:27:17 never mind the fact that in Alberta, we had from officials yesterday, a rather shocking
00:27:24 announcement, although maybe not too shocking, depending on where you stand on this, that all
00:27:29 of Alberta's wildfires in 2024 were human caused. Every single one, except for a couple of smaller
00:27:37 ones, was caused by man. And this is not man-made climate change. This is man-made wildfires that
00:27:44 are often blamed by federal officials on climate change erroneously to justify their policy. So
00:27:51 the reason I bring this up is to say that we should probably have a look at the data. And there
00:27:56 was a study from the Fraser Institute that came out, I think, late last week, that all of these
00:28:01 assumptions and assertions made by lawmakers on weather extremes, increasing in frequency and
00:28:06 severity, spurred on by humanities, greenhouse gas emissions, that that actually doesn't hold
00:28:12 water at all. That is the contention put forward by Kenneth Green, who is a senior fellow at the
00:28:19 Fraser Institute, and joins me now. Kenneth, always good to talk to you. Thanks for coming on
00:28:23 today. Good to be with you. So this is, we hear this time and time again from politicians. It's
00:28:29 used to justify whatever ham-fisted climate policy they're putting on us. Usually it ends
00:28:34 with a carbon tax. We have wildfires that we're told are the cause of climate change. We have
00:28:40 rain, snow, doesn't matter. You're saying that, by the way, even the increased frequency is not
00:28:45 valid that they're hinging on this well that's right um we we should start at the beginning
00:28:50 which is there is some there is evidence that the climate is getting warmer the atmosphere is getting
00:28:55 warmer satellite uh satellite recordings suggest that the climate has been warming about 0.15
00:29:00 degrees centigrade per decade since they started taking those measurements in around 19 around
00:29:04 1980 um but the the subsidiary weather events uh that relate supposedly related to the increased
00:29:12 warming um are much much more ambiguous sorry ambiguous and ambiguous in terms of of being
00:29:20 able to see trends that that correspond to the warming so uh when you look at trends in wildfires
00:29:25 they're actually down over the last several decades in both number and the area of the of the
00:29:30 countries burned in canada and the us um now there are there are anomaly years that are higher than
00:29:35 than normal but but the anomaly doesn't set the trend right so if you look at hurricanes for
00:29:40 example, tropical cyclones, there's not evidence of increasing severity or number, but in fact
00:29:46 decreasing severity and number. If you look at flooding and droughts, the evidence on flooding
00:29:51 and drought are similarly contradictory. Drought is not seen generally around the world as increasing
00:29:58 nor flooding. And so the extreme weather that's being pounded on by people like Minister Gabo
00:30:05 and others as being absolute proof that climate change is happening now and is being destructive
00:30:11 now and therefore we can't wait to act we must act immediately with everything we have all at once
00:30:16 um that that's simply not based on uh actual empirical reality and an observation of real data
00:30:23 and one of the things that i i find interesting here is that there is no i mean this is a political
00:30:29 question so you can self-select out of answering if you'd prefer but they act like there's so much
00:30:35 certainty on this they don't even say listen it's possible and we're concerned and there could be
00:30:39 they they come out and it's that same fervor that you and i have spoken about that they exhibited
00:30:43 with covid policy as well they they believe they are the sole truth tellers and that they don't
00:30:49 even leave any room for doubt so when you come in here with your uh pesky facts uh you know someone
00:30:54 would look at this and be like well what on earth are they trying to sell us right um well i mean
00:31:00 that's a that's a point i make often i think i've made before with you which is
00:31:04 I don't tend to speak in terms of governments and places and politicians as being as lying so much
00:31:10 about climate change as simply exaggerating that what's known and how well it's known.
00:31:16 And this is where the IPCC, the United Nations Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change,
00:31:20 falls short of being a really clear source of the sciences because they also overstate their
00:31:30 certainty um and confidence and if you question them that gets you an automatic label of denier
00:31:36 and uh and you're cast out of polite discourse um but but there was there is no question that
00:31:43 these claims of what we know about extreme weather are exaggerated we just we don't our
00:31:47 data is not that good really we haven't been monitoring the entire earth in detail via robust
00:31:53 satellites and technologies for more than 50 years right it really only started in around 1980
00:31:59 and with a decent measurement.
00:32:02 So we're talking about limited data, a very big planet,
00:32:06 and the data is almost all in the developed countries,
00:32:10 the high-resolution data.
00:32:12 And so to talk about that information
00:32:15 with such overwhelming confidence
00:32:18 that you can't be challenged and you are absolutely right,
00:32:22 it's intellectual and political hubris, really.
00:32:26 And I wanted to point out here as well,
00:32:28 you're not drawing your data from, you know, Bobby Joe's science blog. You're drawing data from,
00:32:36 just to read through some of the footnotes here, the World Meteorological Organization,
00:32:40 the Royal Society, the Journal of Hydrology, the World Meteorological Organization as well. I mean,
00:32:46 it's their own data that are showing what you're describing here, which is that, you know, we're
00:32:50 not seeing an increase in droughts. We're not seeing an increase in hurricanes. We're seeing
00:32:54 a decline in flooding so how is the data from all of the how are the data from the official sources
00:33:01 getting reinterpreted as saying really the opposite of what they say well that and that's
00:33:08 a problem again with with the united nations intergovernmental panel on climate change
00:33:13 communication process as well as just the broader climate change literature which is um these these
00:33:20 data sources are generally covered by those those groups that are reported in climate change but
00:33:24 they also do bring in the other sources they bring in other other anecdotal and smaller sample size
00:33:31 studies there are many many studies on these things so the United Nations IPCC does their
00:33:37 report summarizing the literature yes they will refer to the same things I did which are actually
00:33:42 the just the hard data I'm looking for when I'm when I'm reporting my data I'm just looking for
00:33:48 measurements using robust technology, not small studies of modeling of change, for example. Most
00:33:55 studies, when you look at for wildfires and things, they're computer models of what they
00:34:01 think has happened in the trends, not actually measurements. So that's why it gets distorted in
00:34:08 the political process because they don't limit themselves only to these sources that are measured
00:34:12 data they bring in a whole bunch of modeled computer studies that are both retroactive
00:34:17 retroactive and prospective that what's going to happen in the future and they match them together
00:34:21 as if they're all equally robust as going out and counting and measuring something uh when they're
00:34:27 not and they tend to be they tend to easily be exaggerated in the in the direction of of of um
00:34:34 bad change right negative change so they get published a lot too uh i think the the wildfire
00:34:39 one I always find the most interesting because when there's a flood, you generally don't assume
00:34:44 that some guy in Somalia left the tap on too long and it caused the ocean to flood. I mean, 0.99
00:34:49 you can't really blame the flooding on individuals, but with wildfires, you can. And we know
00:34:53 increasingly that intentional or accidental forest fires are quite commonplace. And in Canada,
00:35:00 we've seen this when there were wildfires in Quebec, they were linked back to arson in Alberta.
00:35:04 I mentioned a few moments ago, the government has come out and said almost all of their wildfires
00:35:08 as of late have been human caused and and this is not something where there is at all an increase
00:35:13 but even with arsons there has been a decline in wildfires over recent decades yes there's been a
00:35:20 there's been an overall decline in number and area extent burned even with increasing arson
00:35:25 assuming it's increasing we don't know i mean i haven't looked at arson uh arrest data so we don't
00:35:30 know if there's more or if it's always been this way and there have been a lot of fire bugs what
00:35:33 which we called him when I was a kid.
00:35:35 But one of the things about wildfires, as well as drought, and as well as floods,
00:35:40 is that these are multifactorial things.
00:35:43 We're talking about them in the context of climate change,
00:35:45 and that's how politicians are wanting to talk about them,
00:35:47 as part of the climate crisis and all of that.
00:35:49 But what causes more fires are forest management as well is a big factor.
00:35:56 Land development is a big factor.
00:35:58 Deforestation can be a big factor.
00:36:02 The same is true of drought, which is changes in the land from developing areas, converting to
00:36:07 farmland from forested areas. These are multifactorial things that have human elements
00:36:13 far beyond the emission of greenhouse gases that warms the climate a little bit and then comes back
00:36:18 down somehow, changes the hot weather pattern so it's a little hotter every summer or in summertime
00:36:24 and you get more fires. It's a very simplistic connection they have made between greenhouse
00:36:30 gas emissions and climate change and changes in weather events drought flooding hurricanes
00:36:36 uh there are far more factors involved in that well fascinating stuff as always you can head on
00:36:41 over to the Fraser Institute's website and read this report extreme weather and climate change
00:36:46 uh Kenneth Green always appreciate the truth telling and narrative shattering you provide
00:36:51 so thank you so much thank you Andrew it's always good to be with you all right Dr Kenneth Green a
00:36:55 a pleasure as always. Well, one, we did things a little out of order here. Kenneth was early,
00:37:00 so I was glad we could bring him on early. But I did want to share this interview I did with
00:37:04 Ginny Roth last week. She is with Crestview Strategies. But we were talking about birth
00:37:08 rates. And again, there are some things in here you might find uncomfortable because anytime the
00:37:13 question is about should government do something, I understand the impulse to say no. So it was at
00:37:17 least worth exploring because government uses low birth rates as justification for high immigration.
00:37:23 But is that really saying that they could or should be doing something on the core demography of birth rates?
00:37:30 That was at least the starting point for this conversation we did at the Canada Strong and Free Network Conference in Ottawa.
00:37:38 Very pleased to be sitting down right now with Jenny Roth, who is a partner at Crestview Strategies,
00:37:43 also one of the preeminent conservative commentators of the era.
00:37:47 You see her work all over, including in the hub.
00:37:49 You see her on TV panels, and we are pleased she is gracing us with her presence today.
00:37:54 Jenny, good to talk to you. Thanks for sitting down.
00:37:56 Very nice to be here.
00:37:57 So I wanted to talk to you as someone who has written about some pretty complex and sometimes controversial issues,
00:38:03 but someone who's also worked very much in mainstream politics about how we navigate what is often seen as a third rail,
00:38:10 which is family policy, and there are a lot of places to go within that in the current political context.
00:38:15 And I'll ask you first off, what a conservative policy on family would look like that you would champion
00:38:21 that would also be viable within the political confines we have today?
00:38:26 Sure, yeah. Look, there's no question regular people get a little bit nervous when you start talking about family
00:38:31 because it feels like something that's kind of private, it's people's own personal decision.
00:38:35 And ultimately, if you, like me, believe that we should err in the direction of sort of freedom
00:38:41 and letting people choose things for themselves and not imposing things from on high,
00:38:46 then you have to be thoughtful about family policy.
00:38:48 Look, I think there's cultural things conservatives can do,
00:38:51 like make the argument for families, make the argument for a culture that supports families.
00:38:55 But that's a little bit high-minded.
00:38:57 There are also practical things we can do.
00:38:59 So at the federal level, the liberals are doing their own family policy, and I think it's bad.
00:39:06 I think their child care, very, very one-size-fits-all.
00:39:10 It has to be between nine and five.
00:39:13 There's a massive shortage of supply.
00:39:15 So there are all these subsidized spaces, not enough supply to actually give families spots in most neighborhoods.
00:39:22 It's just not going to satisfy people in the long run.
00:39:25 But, you know, the Harper era subsidizing people and giving them checks if they have kids,
00:39:32 which, you know, to Trudeau's credit, he actually, first he leaned into that policy.
00:39:36 Then he went with this one-size-fits-all child care.
00:39:38 I think if we can go back to that, this idea that money follows the family, and that certainly
00:39:45 that you're not penalized for having kids, and there are some penalties that we should
00:39:49 remove, but also that you're encouraged to, and you're going to be supported if you do,
00:39:52 because it's hard, and especially in the cost-of-living crisis, it's especially hard.
00:39:57 And then there are a couple things I think we do at other levels as well.
00:40:00 So to go back to some of those Harper policies, I mean, the one that comes to mind immediately
00:40:04 is the child fitness tax credit.
00:40:06 That's a very family-oriented policy.
00:40:08 It makes things easier for families.
00:40:09 Income splitting, which was a bit more contentious than the Harper government,
00:40:12 that's, again, an issue that makes things easy.
00:40:14 But a lot of the problems with these issues is that they don't actually go to the core of building families.
00:40:19 They certainly don't encourage people to have families.
00:40:21 And, you know, on one hand, the idea of government centrally planning family
00:40:24 just terrifies me as much as government centrally planning anything else.
00:40:28 But on the other hand, we do have a problem.
00:40:30 I mean, we do have a birth rate issue in Canada,
00:40:31 and I don't think there's been a time that I can recall a Canadian politician talking about it.
00:40:36 But it is a factor there.
00:40:37 So what role should government have, if any, in correcting that?
00:40:41 And if so, what's the mechanism you can get there that doesn't necessarily look like government trying to go around and manage people's family compositions?
00:40:50 Sure. Well, I actually think income splitting could make a huge difference.
00:40:55 And the reason I think income splitting is powerful is because it tells families, we're going to tax you as a family unit, not as individuals.
00:41:02 And I don't know about other people.
00:41:04 I find when I go to file my taxes, it's weird to file taxes as an individual.
00:41:07 That's not how we run our household. 1.00
00:41:08 We run our household as a family, and we should be kind of taxed that way.
00:41:11 And if there's a way you can structure your family because one of you wants to stay home
00:41:14 part-time or full-time, and that means someone has a disproportionately lower income, being
00:41:19 able to not be penalized for that effectively and making that choice just a little bit easier
00:41:25 for people, I think could actually be pretty powerful, not just for the literal policy
00:41:30 outcome, but because of the cultural message it sends, which is as a government, as a country,
00:41:36 We value families.
00:41:37 I think that you see Hungary experimenting with,
00:41:40 I think it's like after a certain number of kids,
00:41:42 it's either four or five or something,
00:41:44 they just pay no income tax.
00:41:46 That I think is meaningful, right?
00:41:47 Like you may choose to have four kids just because,
00:41:51 it's like if the government's gonna make it that easy for me,
00:41:52 maybe it's worth doing.
00:41:54 And I wonder if if you were to do things like that,
00:41:56 it would have trickle down cultural impacts
00:41:58 so that you'd end up being in environments
00:42:00 that are more kid friendly.
00:42:01 It wouldn't be so weird if your kid's crying on a plane.
00:42:03 Maybe you apologize if your kid's crying.
00:42:05 Like, what kind of society is that?
00:42:06 Yeah, and there's also, I don't want to put the blame squarely on government here,
00:42:11 even predominantly on government, because there's a tremendous cultural and societal problem.
00:42:14 I mean, you certainly don't have big role models and popular culture figures
00:42:18 that are speaking up and bolstering the idea of family.
00:42:21 If anything, it goes the other way.
00:42:22 You get, you know, Meghan Markle does an interview or something
00:42:25 and talks about how, you know, children are terrible for climate.
00:42:27 So you do see these cultural forces that try to discourage and disincentivize.
00:42:32 And that's, I guess, the big problem is that you don't have anyone that's really leading the charge and saying families are important.
00:42:39 And historically, that's been the domain of, I'd say, a subset of the political class that's often not really all that mainstream.
00:42:46 That's right. And, you know, when you think about the subtle influences that culture has, there is a role for public policy to play in that.
00:42:52 I think about schools and curriculum. You know, our kids are spending hours and hours, you know, the huge portion of their day in school is being taught curriculum by teachers.
00:43:00 And today, I think they're being taught climate change is threatening the planet, and if you
00:43:05 have kids, you're contributing to that.
00:43:08 And so just letting parents choose what schools their kids go to and therefore what curriculum
00:43:12 they consume.
00:43:13 I mean, I'm from Ontario.
00:43:14 We don't have that option.
00:43:16 In Alberta, at least, if you're a parent who wants your kids to be exposed to the kind
00:43:19 of values that would support family formation, you can choose to do that.
00:43:22 You can send them to a classical school.
00:43:23 You can avail yourself of school choice.
00:43:25 We don't have that option in Ontario and a number of other provinces across Canada,
00:43:29 and I think that could make a big difference.
00:43:30 I don't want to do like the safe, safe, conservative leader thing of making everything about the economy.
00:43:34 But I also do think that economic policy can be and often is family policy.
00:43:38 Like if you're looking at inflation, cost of living, all of these things, that is a very real consideration.
00:43:44 If you've got a family with two kids that's struggling to put food on the table as it is, the incentive to have a third kid is just not there.
00:43:50 Absolutely not. Yeah. Look, the birth rates crowd would resist that argument a little bit because a lot of the research they do says that people fundamentally,
00:43:59 it's not about economics it's about culture having said that i think economics impacts culture it does
00:44:03 it does and so you know pierre paulia spoke earlier today and he said i can't remember the
00:44:07 percentage was but there's a huge terrifying percentage of young people who've just given
00:44:11 up completely on being able to have a home house um a house and maybe therefore a home right and
00:44:17 if you are psychologically accepting that you will never be able to afford a house
00:44:22 at what point do you say well i'm probably not gonna be able to have time to have kids
00:44:26 Which means, like, is there really a point in getting married?
00:44:29 Is there really a point in dating and having serious relationships?
00:44:32 Like, I think that has a really corrosive impact on even the really early stage choices you make around potentially having a family.
00:44:39 And it concerns me that today we don't even know yet, I think, what Gen Z is going to do when it comes to childbearing.
00:44:45 And I think we could see birth rates plummet even more.
00:44:48 Well, and Paulie has joked about it, but there's a serious point here.
00:44:51 I mean, if you're 25 and living with your parents, your dating life is probably going to be a bit cramped.
00:44:56 I mean, I would love to have been able to blame my dating issues on that when I was single, but I had myself to blame.
00:45:01 But there is a real thing about if you're delaying your entry into adulthood, in a way, you're delaying everything else.
00:45:08 And then at a certain point when you might be married and have a house and have a career, oh, you're 35.
00:45:13 And sure, you can have kids at that age, but it's a much different calculation internally than if you're there 10 years earlier.
00:45:18 That's right.
00:45:19 If you're a woman in her late 20s and you're trying to date and you're dating pool, these men are living in their mom's basements.
00:45:24 and who can blame them. They can't afford to live anywhere else. That's not conducive to the kind of
00:45:30 becoming an adult, going through those life stages, dating, successfully getting married,
00:45:36 that would then go on to, and to your point about this sort of fertility window question,
00:45:40 it's awkward, I think, for people to talk about. But I think culturally, we cover that up a little
00:45:44 bit too much. If you go to a doctor's office as a woman, they'll bend over backwards to tell you 1.00
00:45:49 how to avoid getting pregnant, right? And that's fine for many women in many situations. I'm not 0.98
00:45:53 saying that shouldn't be the case, but there's almost no education you get as a woman about how 1.00
00:45:58 to get pregnant. God forbid, you know? And then a lot of women find themselves at 35, sort of, 0.98
00:46:04 you know, maybe grateful they're able to have one child or in unfortunate situations, really wishing
00:46:10 that they'd been able to start earlier. So you worked with Pierre Polyev in his leadership
00:46:14 campaign as his director of communications. He's certainly been unafraid to tackle some
00:46:18 bigger issues. I've not heard him go down the birth rate road, but I'm curious, do you think
00:46:22 to put on your pundit hat here for a moment is he capable of having that conversation and
00:46:28 it's not even just a him question is canada capable of having a politician talk about this
00:46:33 so it was interesting in his speech today you know i think he's very careful to stick to the big
00:46:40 tough problems for which there are solutions right and for which he can if he were to win
00:46:46 and become prime minister he can kind of work his way through solve solving some of the basic
00:46:49 problems. Because I think he has some faith that if we, I mean, take crime, right? We talked about
00:46:54 housing, we talked about the economy. Well, there's a family policy for you right there.
00:46:57 Imagine if you could, I live in a neighborhood with lots of families and they're frankly up in
00:47:01 arms because we have a so-called safe injection. I don't think it should be called that a
00:47:06 consumption site in our neighborhood and kids are picking up fentanyl patches in the playground.
00:47:11 So I think his view is if we can get some of those basic things right, everything else will
00:47:15 kind of work itself out.
00:47:18 And I think he's careful to be consistent
00:47:20 in being that kind of conservative.
00:47:21 And I think he knows that if he gets sort of too
00:47:24 prescriptive about, and it's because I want people
00:47:27 to have more kids, or because I want to have
00:47:28 some sort of top-down solution that's gonna drive
00:47:30 family formation, that's gonna narrow his appeal.
00:47:34 And that's not what he wants.
00:47:35 He wants to be able to win the kind of mandate
00:47:36 where he can actually make a difference in people's lives.
00:47:38 And I think that's wise, right?
00:47:40 Honestly, it's why I'm glad that CSFN has this,
00:47:44 and why True North exists, right?
00:47:45 why we have all these players in the movement,
00:47:48 so that we can have some of the conversations that maybe
00:47:50 are appeal to a narrower group of people
00:47:52 and start to drive some public demand.
00:47:54 What I would really love to see is if, in a few years,
00:47:57 we can tell a story to the public where they go, yeah,
00:48:00 actually, I'm concerned about birth rates,
00:48:02 and there starts to be that demand,
00:48:03 then politicians can respond and meet that demand
00:48:05 with solutions.
00:48:06 Yeah, it's that old downstream of culture attitude.
00:48:08 Yeah, exactly.
00:48:08 And so let's let, you know, Polyev should
00:48:11 let us impact culture.
00:48:12 You and me, Andrew, we'll do it, just the two of us.
00:48:14 And then he should tackle politics.
00:48:16 All right.
00:48:17 Yeah.
00:48:17 And that's the thing.
00:48:17 A lot of people will look to politicians.
00:48:19 I don't want to let politicians off the hook entirely, but a lot of people will look to
00:48:21 them and say, why aren't you doing this?
00:48:23 And, you know, they can turn back and say, well, why aren't you doing it?
00:48:25 Why don't you prove there's some support for this?
00:48:27 And then I can go there.
00:48:28 So, all right.
00:48:29 Well, glad you're not afraid to take this on.
00:48:31 Jenny Roth, always good to talk to you.
00:48:32 You too, Andrew.
00:48:37 Jenny Roth, partner at Crestview Strategies.
00:48:39 Great writer, great contributor.
00:48:41 We've always had, whenever we try to get her on the show, there's always like a time
00:48:44 issue so uh it's hard to evade that when you can just like pull someone in the hallway at a
00:48:49 conference which is why uh it's just a horrendous thing that we all had to be uh zoom for everything
00:48:54 for like three years so uh good to have the return of the in-person world that does it for us for
00:48:59 today and for this week uh see some of you on sunday at the ottawa book expo that'll be a lot
00:49:04 of fun and we will see you tomorrow on off the record right here on true north and then back on
00:49:10 regularly scheduled programming on Monday. So lots coming up. Thank you. God bless and good
00:49:14 day to you all. Thanks for listening to the Andrew Lawton Show. Support the program by
00:49:20 donating to True North at www.tnc.news.
00:49:40 We'll be right back.
00:50:10 We'll be right back.