Juno News - March 26, 2024


Liberals have spent $42 million on gun "buyback" without getting a single gun

Topics
Mentioned
Election date change might make dozens more MPs eligible for pensions Chestermere responds "We definitely like Mayor Colvin"

Episode Stats


Length

44 minutes

Words per minute

173.58

Word count

7,668

Sentence count

270

Harmful content

Misogyny

5

sentences flagged

Toxicity

3

sentences flagged

Hate speech

4

sentences flagged


Summary

Summaries generated with gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ .

On this episode of The Andrew Lawton Show, we discuss the Canadian government's attempt to crack down on gun ownership in the wake of the Aurora shooting, and why it might not have been as bad as it appears.

Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Topics generated with Qwen2.5-3B-Instruct.
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 Transcription by CastingWords
00:00:30 Thank you.
00:01:00 welcome to canada's most irreverent talk show this is the andrew lawton show brought to you by true
00:01:19 north hello and welcome to you all this is canada's most irreverent talk show here the
00:01:29 andrew lawton show on true north on this tuesday march 26 i i want to give you just on on a
00:01:35 programming note because coming up in about a week and uh two day no a week and one day
00:01:42 the canada strong and free networking conference will be once again taking place in ottawa the
00:01:48 Weston Hotel. Yours truly will be doing his show live from the, well, basically live from the
00:01:54 hallway, which doesn't sound luxurious or anything, but we have a True North booth that we'll have
00:01:58 there once again, and we'll be doing live shows over the course of the conference. It should be
00:02:03 a lot of fun, and I'm also going to be on stage. It was just announced this week doing one-on-one
00:02:09 fireside chats with Danielle Smith, the Premier of Alberta, who I've had on the show a number of
00:02:15 times. I used to work with her and guest host for her. I know Premier Smith very well, and I'll also
00:02:20 be doing one with New Brunswick Premier Blaine Higgs. Now, I don't actually know Premier Higgs.
00:02:26 I've never spoken to him. I've never met him, but I am honored to be able to do the onstage
00:02:30 interview. Certainly, we'll be talking about parental rights. I suspect the carbon tax will
00:02:35 also come up, and if there are any other questions you want to hear from either Premier Smith or
00:02:40 Premier Higgs on, please do let us know in the comments. We won't ask the dumb ones, 0.98
00:02:45 but we'll try to, you know, come up with the good ones 0.98
00:02:47 and then I'll just take credit for them on stage.
00:02:49 It's actually the interviewer's prerogative.
00:02:51 So nevertheless, that is going to be in a week and a half.
00:02:54 Now, I don't know if we're going to be able to show
00:02:55 the full interviews on the Andrew Lawton Show.
00:02:58 So if you want to get the full experience,
00:02:59 definitely come in person if you're going to be in Ottawa
00:03:02 or you like to travel to Ottawa
00:03:04 or you're willing to tolerate Ottawa,
00:03:06 which, well, I won't tell you where I am on that one.
00:03:08 But also we will, well, I have another event coming up,
00:03:12 but I'll tell you about that later on
00:03:14 because it's not for a few weeks.
00:03:15 and it's also in Ottawa, so I don't want to start galvanizing. It's the only place that I'm booked
00:03:18 to speak apparently. But we will be talking later on in this show about the ballooning size of
00:03:25 government. Speaking of Ottawa, and as we know, it is getting much, much too big. We'll also be
00:03:30 talking about this controversy in a British Columbia city where it's actually quite interesting
00:03:36 here. They have decided to, well, they're deciding to twist themselves into knots because they were
00:03:46 exposed to a set of opinions they didn't like. And those opinions are contained in a book that
00:03:52 True North actually published called Grave Error. We'll have Tom Flanagan on the program. Oh,
00:03:56 there you go. Tom Flanagan, one of the co-editors of that book, will be on very shortly to talk
00:04:01 about what's going down in the city of quenelle british columbia i hope i'm saying that right or
00:04:07 if not that you'll correct me and by the time we get to 1 30 i will be corrected and able to say
00:04:12 it right i'll get that jordan peterson re-education camp but uh let's begin talking about this uh one
00:04:17 of the rare situations in which i tend to be a supporter of government ineptitude and government
00:04:24 incompetence it doesn't happen often in fact it might never happen except for on this and only
00:04:29 this issue. But let's go back in time first. So it was May 1st, 2020, when the Liberal government
00:04:37 imposed a sweeping order in Council that banned 1,500 types of firearm overnight. It just
00:04:44 instantly made it so that these guns, which were legally on store shelves, which were legally in
00:04:50 gun owners' cabinets at the shooting range, could no longer be used. One of these was the often
00:04:55 misrepresented a maligned AR-15 platform of firearm, and other non-restricted hunting guns
00:05:02 that were used without issue and have been used by law-abiding gun owners in Canada for years
00:05:07 overnight are prohibited. Now, the government did not have a plan. They did not know what they were
00:05:13 doing. They saw that there was a bit of public momentum on their side against firearms because
00:05:18 this was, you may recall, in the aftermath of that horrific, horrific killing spree starting
00:05:24 in portapique nova scotia and the liberals decided that they had to pounce at that moment to crack
00:05:30 down on lawful firearms owners now they do this and of course we learned that the guy did not
00:05:37 legally have guns he was not legally authorized to own them he had imported his guns illegally
00:05:43 from the united states and they were not coming out of the legal civilian market in canada none
00:05:49 of that mattered to the liberals they just wanted to say that guns were the problem and that this
00:05:54 measure which only targets the law-abiding gun owners in the country would somehow be justifiable 0.64
00:05:59 so that was may 2020 now it was a very aggressive plan they said these guns are prohibited but
00:06:06 we're putting a two-year amnesty period in place so if you legally own an ar-15 you actually get
00:06:12 to keep that for two years well we put together this buyback program buyback this is the language
00:06:18 the government uses as though the gun was once theirs to begin with they will just buy it back
00:06:23 from you that's all uh we're supposed to believe that it's going to be fair market value and all
00:06:28 that but as it happened there was no buyback there is no buyback there has never been a single gun
00:06:34 bought back nor for that matter has there been a firearm confiscated under this program yet as we
00:06:41 learned i got it from brian passive human the national post but it actually came from an order
00:06:46 of paper an order paper question in the house of commons or the the senate rather the government
00:06:51 has spent 42 million dollars on a buyback program that doesn't exist they have spent 42 million
00:06:59 dollars and with that have not purchased confiscated acquired destroyed relocated adopted
00:07:07 they have not touched a single firearm under this program and they have spent 42 million dollars to
00:07:15 do it so this is not in the cost of the guns themselves this is just in the bureaucracy
00:07:20 and management and maintenance of a program that does not exist now as a taxpayer i think this is
00:07:27 egregious as a taxpayer i think it's offensive i think it's destructive as a gun owner i'm kind
00:07:31 of happy about this i actually love the idea that the government has not in four years been able to
00:07:37 do this that the government has not actually in four years managed to collect a single firearm
00:07:42 because that is exactly the problem here the government is trying to do something that is not
00:07:47 going to amount to a hill of beans when it comes to real gun crime so there are no victims when we 0.62
00:07:54 talk about the lawful gun owners who would never hurt a fly who would only well maybe they'd hurt 0.98
00:08:00 a fly if it's you know fly season but they never hurt a human they never break the law they're so
00:08:05 diligent about the regulations and how they have to store the guns we we all are because we don't
00:08:10 want our guns to be taken away our property to be seized we don't want to be criminally charged the
00:08:15 stakes are very high if you are a licensed gun owner in this country and you screw up and the
00:08:21 reality is that the people that comply with regulations are the people who are not breaking
00:08:25 the law it's not as we talk about time and time again the case that the guns picked up on the
00:08:31 streets after some gang shootout in surrey or toronto were coming from the civilian market in
00:08:37 In fact, they were coming from organized crime.
00:08:40 They were smuggled in across the border.
00:08:42 Some of them were stolen, but most of them are coming across the longest unprotected
00:08:46 border in the world, which we share with a country that has much wider access to firearms.
00:08:52 And the idea that we can, in Canada, regulate away gun crime without dealing with gun crime 0.51
00:09:00 at the border is absurd, but it's what the federal government has tried to do.
00:09:05 So as a result, they spend $42 million.
00:09:07 Legal taxpayers in this country are the ones forced to pick up that bill.
00:09:11 Legal gun owners are the ones who will eventually be targeted by this.
00:09:15 And one of the core problems here is that the government presented this.
00:09:19 I didn't want to force you to listen to Bill Blair, so we didn't pull the Bill Blair clip.
00:09:23 But when he presented this and when Justin Trudeau presented this, they used language that was very extreme,
00:09:28 as though there was a crisis, as though every day these guns were out in the country, people
00:09:33 were losing their lives. These guns, Trudeau said, were designed to kill as many people as possible,
00:09:39 as quickly as possible. That was a near direct quote of Justin Trudeau. If it was that dire,
00:09:46 and if they pose that much of an emergency and that much of a public safety risk,
00:09:52 you wouldn't think the government would drag its heels for two years to do something about it.
00:09:56 We saw in the COVID era, also in 2020, by the way, how swiftly government can move when it
00:10:03 feels it has to. Now, that doesn't mean it makes the right calls, but they're capable of moving
00:10:07 quickly when they want to. Now, in this case, maybe they're not. Is it that they're trying to
00:10:12 just delay it, delay it, delay it so they can campaign on it in the next election? Quite
00:10:16 possibly. Or is it that they are just woefully inept? It's always that divide in government of 1.00
00:10:21 do you attribute it to malice or incompetence? Or is it malicious incompetence, which I think
00:10:26 increasingly describes things that our government does. I wanted to share with you a brief clip
00:10:31 because I did a documentary about this in 2021. So it came out just a year after the order in
00:10:37 council. And at the time, there were already grave concerns about the effect this was having
00:10:44 on firearms businesses. Take a look. How is a business like yours supposed to operate when
00:10:51 anything that you sell could one day be illegal on eggshells take it a day at a time i visited
00:10:57 jeff's store one year after the liberals order in council and there in his warehouse were tens
00:11:03 of thousands of dollars of now prohibited firearms they're illegal to sell or to use and
00:11:08 cannot even be sold back to the government despite the promise of a buyback it's a rule of retail if
00:11:13 you're not moving inventory you're losing money something felt by a lot of the gun store owners i
00:11:19 heard from is that this is a feature not a bug of the liberals gun measures you know we're we're
00:11:24 sitting on inventory right now that we can't sell and that's tying up a lot of dollars which in
00:11:29 retail is is a cardinal sin the the biggest sin in retail is not to turn your inventory over
00:11:34 um so you know it it's created some financial hardship and uh but i i try not to complain
00:11:41 about it too much because i know i'm not alone i know that every other business whether you're
00:11:45 wholesaler or distributor in the country has been affected. I liken it to the automotive industry
00:11:50 and imagine you own a car lot and Environment Canada walks onto your lot one day and says
00:11:56 we're banning V8s and by the way you can't sell them they have to sit on your lot 1.00
00:12:01 and maybe someday two or three maybe four years down the road we might pay you cost we might pay
00:12:06 you retail or we just might be a flat amount we're going to give you but in the meantime all the
00:12:11 parts that you have for them and your vehicles are tied up so as retailers and wholesalers that's
00:12:15 where we're at right now our inventory inventory is tied up that we can't sell it your entire
00:12:20 business model has been destroyed and there's a lot of people out there unfortunately in this
00:12:24 country we're in that situation right now because of the OIC. That last gentleman was Scott Carpenter
00:12:33 who is the owner of International Shooting Supplies in Surrey and one thing that I mentioned
00:12:38 surrey earlier surrey bc has incredible incredible issues with organized crime you've got gang fights
00:12:44 there you've got issues with shooting and those issues do not have anything to do with firearms
00:12:49 that are sold on the shelves of international shooting supplies quite the contrary those are
00:12:54 the guns going to people that are interested in sport shooting collecting hunting they are
00:13:01 firearms that are used by people who have nothing to do and actually deplore the issues with
00:13:07 organized crime in their community and once again when government says we listen to the experts
00:13:12 they're not interested in the law enforcement experts they're not interested in the firearms
00:13:16 experts they're not interested in all of the people who have universally pretty much come out
00:13:21 except for a narrow subset who are activists committed to ending civilian gun ownership in
00:13:26 canada they don't listen to the people who are saying hey you're not going to do anything about
00:13:31 crime but the government knows the liberals know that firearms restrictions play well in the polls
00:13:38 they know that overwhelmingly canadians are not gun owners gun owners represent i think about two
00:13:43 million people in this country i don't know what the adult population is specifically but it is a
00:13:48 minority of canadians that own guns of the people who don't some are sympathetic to gun owners
00:13:54 married to a gun owner others are indifferent and others are hell-bent against guns but it's
00:13:59 a group that is not itself a sizable enough voting block to sway elections most of the time
00:14:06 and we also see the government really love to just stoke those fears they use misinformation
00:14:11 loaded language like assault rifle assault weapons things that the average person doesn't really
00:14:17 understand are loaded and they do this so i'm convinced that yes there's probably some
00:14:22 bureaucratic incompetence here but the liberals are also wanting to extend this debate protract
00:14:28 this debate so that it comes up in the polls once again, and they can go into their old bag of tricks
00:14:33 and say that, oh, the evil, scary boogeyman conservatives with their gun fetish are the
00:14:38 problem. That's going to be the liberal government's strategy. You can take that to the bank. I mean,
00:14:43 don't cash it for a couple of years until you know I'm right, but that's the check. You can
00:14:47 probably cash that in a couple of years, and who knows with inflation what it'll be worth. But
00:14:51 speaking of which, we'll talk about the ballooning size of government, and it's actually a rather
00:14:56 natural segue because government tends to just spend money that it doesn't have that isn't its
00:15:02 own and not do it in a particularly efficient way i mentioned that they've spent 42 million dollars
00:15:08 without confiscating a single gun but you know that money is going towards staff they're
00:15:13 administering a bureaucracy they're commissioning reports they're doing all of this stuff that
00:15:17 government does that private sector enterprise would never want to do nor would it be able to
00:15:22 get away with doing it but it times well with this report that came out from the fraser institute
00:15:28 just on how large government has gotten and this is not just a federal problem but you see it at
00:15:34 the provincial level as well a new study says that uh in 2000 from 2007 to 2022 government spending
00:15:42 in 8 out of 10 provinces so 80 percent of the country in terms of uh provinces uh and went up
00:15:50 government spending increased in these provinces and also public sector employment rose not just
00:15:54 an 8 out of 10 but rose across the board in all provinces so government is getting fatter
00:16:00 and more costly even if we have a lot of economic situations in that that would not necessarily
00:16:06 support such growth jake fuss is back with us he is the fiscal studies director for the fraser
00:16:12 institute jake always good to have you on thanks for coming back today good afternoon thanks for
00:16:16 for having me on. So just to talk about what is at stake here and what you're seeing, is this the
00:16:22 normal growth to keep up with growth in the country or is this a disproportionate growth
00:16:26 that you're tracking here? Yeah, what we're seeing is that the size of government as measured by
00:16:31 spending is growing faster than the Canadian economy, like you mentioned, in eight out of
00:16:35 10 provinces, but also nationally. So when we're looking at local, provincial and federal levels
00:16:40 of government, we're now seeing government spending representing more than 40% of the
00:16:44 Canadian economy, whereas it was about 37% in 2007. So there's been a pretty substantial increase
00:16:51 in government spending as a share of the economy over the last 15 years or so. And it's been a
00:16:56 pretty much across the board change in all provinces across Canada, except for PEI in
00:17:02 Saskatchewan, which saw small declines in the size of government in that 2007 to 2022 period.
00:17:08 Do you know what it is that accounts for that, for those two?
00:17:12 It's a good question. There have been some changes over time. So I think some of it might
00:17:16 have to do with some changes during the pandemic as well, because generally we were seeing, you
00:17:21 know, Saskatchewan actually had a higher spending in 2019 than it does in 2022, for instance.
00:17:27 So there might be some certain temporary programs being removed or other things. So we'll have to
00:17:33 keep track of Saskatchewan and Prince Edward Island over the long run to see if this is
00:17:37 actually a trend or just a blip on the radar. But in PEI's case, even though they had a declining
00:17:43 size of government, their size of government is still about 58% of the size of the economy,
00:17:47 for instance. Whereas a province like Alberta, which yes, increased in terms of size of government,
00:17:53 their size of government is about 27% the size of the economy. So there's a marked difference here
00:17:58 between a lot of the provinces in Canada, especially Western provinces compared to
00:18:03 eastern provinces. We're generally seeing smaller governments in western Canada relative to eastern
00:18:08 Canada. Obviously in that range a couple of events I think have to be noted here. 2007-2022 you've got
00:18:16 the the 2008 recession and we know that was just an example for government or of governments
00:18:21 shoving money out the door as quickly as they could. You also mentioned the pandemic another
00:18:26 situation in which governments were racking up insane amounts of spending. How much do those if
00:18:31 at all skew the overall trajectory you're looking at?
00:18:35 I think they definitely have an impact.
00:18:37 I mean, especially when you look at the 2020 COVID pandemic, for instance, you do see a
00:18:42 huge spike in government size during that time.
00:18:45 But what was interesting is that it basically became a permanent increase, maybe not to
00:18:50 the levels that we saw at the height of the COVID pandemic, but we basically had a permanent
00:18:54 increase in the size of government between 2019 and 2022.
00:18:58 So that really tells us that, yes, COVID does have an impact, but governments are actually
00:19:02 just increasing in size over time anyways.
00:19:06 And we had seven out of 10 provinces increase their size of government between that three
00:19:10 year period between 2019 and 2022.
00:19:13 And of course, you know, the financial crisis in 2008 also has an impact on the size of
00:19:17 government as well.
00:19:18 But, you know, in the years when you're winding down temporary programs or other things, we're
00:19:23 still seeing that permanent ramp up in government spending that really has nothing to do with
00:19:27 the pandemic is just simply increase bureaucracy, increase government spending over time.
00:19:33 Yeah, and I was kind of curious about the public sector growth. Now, I know this study doesn't
00:19:38 doing a public-private sector contrast, but I think we do know that private sector employment
00:19:42 is not immune to economic trends. Private sector employers that don't have a taxpayer to lean on
00:19:48 have to make very difficult decisions. They all slash their workforce, not all, but many of them
00:19:53 slash their workforces during COVID. But we see a continual increase in, as we were talking about
00:19:58 earlier, every single level of government, every single province here over that span.
00:20:03 Yeah, that's right. I mean, essentially what we've seen from 2007 to 2022 is an increased
00:20:08 share of the workforce employed in the public sector, for instance.
00:20:12 So not just raw numbers, it's the share that's going up.
00:20:14 Yeah, exactly. So it's basically growing faster than private sector employment, for instance.
00:20:19 So if we look at 2007, about 19 percent of total employment in Canada was in the public sector.
00:20:26 Now in 2022, it's about 21 percent.
00:20:30 And we've seen that across the board in all provinces.
00:20:32 All 10 provinces had increases in public sector employment relative to total employment in Canada.
00:20:38 So, yes, private sector employment is still increasing over time, but it's not growing as fast as public sector employment is what these numbers show us.
00:20:46 One of the challenges, and I know it's going outside the scope of this study, but you can
00:20:51 look at these numbers, and again, just to pull them out here, in Nova Scotia, government's size
00:20:56 relative to the economy, 63%, and in Alberta, 26.8%. So, you know, even if it's going up in
00:21:03 Alberta, it's still nowhere near the size in Nova Scotia and Atlantic Canada generally. So,
00:21:10 if you're looking at this as a taxpayer, not an economist, and you're trying to figure out
00:21:14 what's the sweet spot? Is there a sweet spot? Is there a size that it should be or is supposed to
00:21:19 be? Yes. So we know from empirical research that generally the optimal size of government is
00:21:24 generally between 26 to 30 percent of the size of the economy. And this is when you get historically
00:21:30 maximizing your economic growth rates when you start to exceed these levels and you can actually
00:21:35 start hindering your economy and then you can ultimately start hindering living standards for
00:21:40 citizens as well. So Alberta is the only province that is actually within that optimal range of 26
00:21:46 to 30%. All other provinces are well above 30%. In fact, most provinces are well above 40%
00:21:53 and some of them are even exceeding 50 or 60%. So they're well above that optimal range.
00:21:58 And they're at that point where they're likely harming their economies and harming the living
00:22:03 standards in those provinces as well, rather than helping the citizens by having that optimal range
00:22:08 of government in that 26 to 30 percent of the size of the economy that's actually quite interesting
00:22:14 so i i wasn't familiar with that that data you referenced so basically we do see an inverse
00:22:19 relationship between size of government and overall economic prosperity or health yeah exactly
00:22:25 and that analysis is based on a whole bunch of oecd countries very advanced countries around
00:22:30 the world it's a historical analysis you can even extend the analysis a little bit more if you want
00:22:35 to punch it out a little bit more to about 24 to 32% of the size of the economy. But generally what
00:22:41 we've seen is that these countries around the world have actually maximized their growth rates
00:22:45 when it is within that range. So it provides a good barometer for governments to actually
00:22:50 track their progress and to ultimately see, you know, is there ways that we can actually
00:22:55 improve economic growth and can we address this through government spending as the size of our
00:22:59 economy? Are we too high, too low? Are we in the optimal range? And I think that's an important
00:23:03 metric for governments to track over the long term so if we took the national picture here
00:23:08 canada has a government at 40.5 percent the size of the economy what's needed to take that down to
00:23:15 that uh range that we're talking about well it's certainly a complicated question because it's not
00:23:20 just one level of government um you know when we're looking at the federal level of government
00:23:24 we also have provincial governments and local governments included in that so really it's a
00:23:29 a cohesive effort between all three levels of government to actually track their progress on
00:23:34 this. Right now, we're really seeing an explosion in government spending and debt at really all
00:23:38 levels of government. And that's certainly a concern moving forward. So I think it's going
00:23:43 to be important and imperative for governments to begin to review the amount of spending,
00:23:48 what they're spending on. Are we getting value for this money? Is this actually leading to
00:23:52 economic growth? Is it leading to improved living standards for Canadians? Because right now,
00:23:56 what we're really seeing is economic stagnation. And we're not seeing those improved living
00:24:00 standards for Canadians. And just because we have more government spending isn't necessarily
00:24:05 leading to better results for us. So I think we need to rethink what we're ultimately doing
00:24:10 on government spending as a share of the economy and what we're spending this money on too.
00:24:15 All right. Well, fascinating numbers. As always, Jake Fuss, Director of Fiscal Studies
00:24:19 for the Fraser Institute. Thanks so much, sir. Thanks very much for having me.
00:24:23 All right, we will talk to you soon as the problem is sadly not going away.
00:24:28 One of the problems with government spending, of course, has been a question that I think goes along with government priorities.
00:24:35 Government loves to look at ways to collect revenue, not as keen on looking at ways to stop spending.
00:24:41 For example, the carbon tax, which I will continue beating the drum on, is going up once again on April 1st.
00:24:49 this is an increase that the liberals have decided to make their political hill to die on
00:24:54 and i think electorally speaking it may well be the hill they die on but let me talk about this
00:25:00 very briefly because the left the pro-carbon tax lobby is bringing out the big guns yes here is an
00:25:08 open letter oh yes an open letter from economists on canadian carbon pricing yes they're rebuffing
00:25:17 the and why are they rebuffing or are they rebutting i think they're they're both they're
00:25:21 rebutting with buffery they're they're rebuffing with buttery i don't know they are rebuffing and
00:25:26 rebutting the carbon tax critics claims that carbon pricing won't reduce greenhouse gas emissions
00:25:33 uh that it drives up the cost of living and is a major cause of inflation and i you can't see it
00:25:38 in that screenshot but underneath their rebuttal of claim two uh they say oh well no you can see
00:25:44 into the bottom there oh no no carbon taxes uh carbon pricing has caused less than 1 20th of
00:25:49 canada's inflation well uh for starters those figures are disputed but i would also point out
00:25:54 that it is a mechanism that is entirely optional and adds insult to injury when you are trying to
00:26:01 get to the bottom of why the cost of living is increasing no one has said the carbon tax is
00:26:06 single-handedly uh stoking inflation we have said that it is exacerbating it it is aggravating it
00:26:12 It is doing more to basically strain Canadians' ability to spend money.
00:26:19 And my goodness, we are finding time and time again examples of people that are trying to defend what is increasingly the indefensible.
00:26:27 And this is why you have premiers in a majority of provinces, including liberal leaders, liberal premier Andrew Furey, saying, yeah, the carbon tax is not working.
00:26:36 It's why conservative leader Pierre Polyev, of all the issues he could be talking about, he right now is doing a national tour of rallies.
00:26:45 And he, of all of these issues, is speaking on the carbon tax.
00:26:49 That is what he's decided to make the entire focal point of his tour, of his campaign.
00:26:54 He's doing the axe, the tax, the spike, the hike, the, you know, say no to the car.
00:26:59 I was trying to think of another rhyme, but I couldn't.
00:27:01 This is, I think, quite an interesting development.
00:27:05 it. And again, he's bringing out thousands and thousands of people collectively. I don't know
00:27:10 if this is an issue that, like if these people would come out for anything. If he were to say
00:27:16 this is the corned beef hash rally, if people would come out to celebrate corned beef hash just
00:27:21 because they like Gare Polyev, or if they're coming out because it's a carbon tax. But we do know
00:27:25 that there are thousands and thousands and thousands of people that online at least have
00:27:30 said they are going to show up to a series of rallies that are being held across the country
00:27:35 on april 1st this is the day the carbon tax is uh the increase is going into effect and there's a
00:27:42 i don't have the url handy but there's some website which is tracking uh basically the
00:27:47 national network of these protests sean do you have that url by chance i'll read it to people
00:27:52 if they want to check it out but uh there's going to be a big one in ottawa there's going to be a
00:27:56 big one in lloydminster which uh one of one of our alberta reporters isaac lamaru had said oh i'm
00:28:02 going to this because he's in edmonton and he's like oh i'm gonna go to this rally in lloydminster
00:28:06 and i'm like surely they're doing one in edmonton that you could go to that's closer he said oh no
00:28:10 no no and i thought he was crazy and then i looked into it oh no no lloydminster is actually going to
00:28:15 be the the big giant one here so and lloydminster is fun because it's a city that is half well i
00:28:21 I don't know half, but it's part in Saskatchewan and part in Alberta. So you get to just like,
00:28:27 if you're in Lloydminster, you get to just like have one foot in each province. And I mean,
00:28:30 I guess you could do that anywhere on the border, but I don't know. I like Lloydminster,
00:28:33 but the thing about it is that they're going to have a big thing there. And I think they're
00:28:37 going to be trucks involved because everyone has a bit of a convoy spirit now. Here it is. It's a
00:28:43 nationwide, I guess I could have just guessed the name of the website. It's nationwide protest
00:28:48 against the carbontax.ca, which is they, they went for the most literal interpretation possible,
00:28:54 but nationwide protest against the carbontax.ca. And again, I don't even know who's involved with
00:28:59 this. So I'm not endorsing the individual people. But if you look at the map, you've got, let me
00:29:05 just see, there's one in Vancouver, there's one in Lucerne, BC, which I'm not as familiar with.
00:29:12 uh you've got a couple in southern alberta one in coleman one in uh highway 1 and 22 interchange
00:29:19 uh which is perhaps not the name of the town uh lloydminster cypress county all of these uh great
00:29:26 great well i've never been to some of them but i'm assuming they're great places if if the people are
00:29:29 assembling to fight the carbon tax these are surely great places and then in uh toronto and
00:29:35 a lot of convoy spirit here a lot of these are not just individual locations these are
00:29:40 our roots. But the point is that Canadians have been, this has been a galvanizing issue for
00:29:45 Canadians. Canadians have been keen to get involved and are incredibly, incredibly frustrated
00:29:50 with what the government is doing. So I mean, what I said, this will be the hill that the
00:29:55 government wants to die on. And electorally, I think it very much will. So we'll certainly keep
00:30:01 tabs on that. And we've got reporters covering in at least three cities, the carbon tax protests
00:30:06 going on on monday but send in your footage send in your uh your photos your videos if you're at
00:30:12 one of these and let us know what is going on there i want to turn our attention to a
00:30:17 controversy in british columbia where a city council is reeling after people in the community
00:30:23 were exposed to heterodox views the uh setting for this is the city of quenelle where the mayor's
00:30:30 wife decided to hand out to some people copies of a book that was as it happened published by 0.83
00:30:35 true north the book is called grave error it was written well it was edited by cp champion and
00:30:42 professor tom flanagan it features a number of essays from uh some incredibly esteemed scholars
00:30:48 and contributors that are talking about canadian history a version of canadian history that you
00:30:53 aren't really getting even though it is a version that is supported by volumes and volumes of
00:30:59 evidence so it's put in a book a book that was a bestseller on amazon has sold thousands of copies
00:31:05 but has been blacklisted by several libraries and, as it happened,
00:31:09 is now facing this ridiculous investigation, inquiry, apology by a city council.
00:31:16 Tom Flanagan joins me now.
00:31:19 Tom, always good to talk to you.
00:31:20 Thanks for coming on, and congratulations for all the success of the book, too.
00:31:24 Oh, thanks, Andrew.
00:31:25 So what on earth happened in this British Columbia community?
00:31:30 Well, the mayor's wife, her name is Pat Morton.
00:31:33 I don't know what her professional designation is, but her business is filing tax returns.
00:31:42 She read the book. She liked it, so she bought 10 copies and was giving them to
00:31:49 people or places where she thought it might do some good. There are four small Indian bands in
00:31:57 the area around the town of Quenelle and they heard of what was going on, that she was giving
00:32:04 out these books. So they sent a letter to city council, said they wanted to meet to discuss the
00:32:11 book. So they showed up and basically they bullied the council into voting to condemn the book,
00:32:20 even though none of them had ever read the book. They all said, no, no, we haven't read it. First
00:32:24 First time we've seen it, but we'll vote to condemn it anyway.
00:32:30 Then the same thing happened with the school board.
00:32:33 Pat had given a copy to the school board.
00:32:35 All this took place without the knowledge of myself or any of the other authors.
00:32:41 She just did it on her own.
00:32:44 So the school board voted to condemn it as well.
00:32:46 I still don't know if anybody's actually read the book out there.
00:32:50 Yeah, even some of the comments you hear are basically from people saying,
00:32:54 well, you know, I started reading it and I didn't like it, or, oh, I heard so-and-so said,
00:32:58 you know, this was offensive. You know, when I first heard of this controversy, you know,
00:33:03 distributed in the community, it sounded like someone had bought, like, you know, the entire
00:33:07 inventory on Amazon and was just like going out distributing them door to door. And then you learn,
00:33:11 as you've just shared, that a woman who liked the book bought a handful of copies and handed
00:33:16 them out. And I still fail to see how this is a city council matter. Well, it's because she's 0.99
00:33:22 the wife of the mayor, I guess.
00:33:25 Which has no
00:33:26 official, I mean, there's no first lady 0.98
00:33:28 of Quesnel. I mean, she has no official status
00:33:30 with the city, as I understand it.
00:33:32 Of course not, but they claim that because she's married 0.99
00:33:34 to the mayor that it makes a
00:33:36 difference. I should
00:33:38 say, in passing, that the
00:33:40 whole ruckus has been
00:33:42 a boost for our sales of the
00:33:44 book. You can track your
00:33:46 not the actual number of sales, but you can
00:33:48 track your ranking on
00:33:50 the Amazon website of where you
00:33:52 stand relative to other books and um we we shot up over 90 places in the books category once this
00:34:01 uh once this happened we had slipped down below 100 and the next day we shot up to seven
00:34:09 so um yeah it's been great for us well fair fair enough i mean you can embrace the silver lining
00:34:16 of that tom but let me ask you about kind of the context here because one of the terms that that
00:34:22 has been used in in coverage of this even and certainly cbc's narrative on what happened in
00:34:27 quenelle is that this is residential school denialism and they basically make claims about
00:34:33 the book or they make claims about what the book says that the book doesn't actually say no uh much
00:34:39 Much of the book is devoted to examining the announcement that came out of Kamloops, the
00:34:48 notorious announcement about 215 unmarked graves.
00:34:52 We also look at a couple of other similar announcements as well, like one from Blue
00:34:57 Quills.
00:34:58 There have been multiple from Blue Quills, but we looked at one of them that was available
00:35:02 at the time, and some others as well.
00:35:06 Trying to look at actual evidence.
00:35:07 The first thing to understand is that there is no physical evidence of unmarked graves.
00:35:16 The only evidence, if you could call it that, is the results of ground-penetrating radar,
00:35:21 which at best can show soil disturbances or soil anomalies.
00:35:27 It doesn't tell you what's there.
00:35:30 In order to know what's there, you have to dig.
00:35:33 And there had been a few digs around the country, most recently at Pine Creek Reserve,
00:35:39 on the border between Saskatchewan and Manitoba, in the basement of the Mission Church there.
00:35:45 Didn't find anything. None of the digs have turned up any, you know, no bones, no shrouds,
00:35:52 no caskets, nothing that could be linked to a burial.
00:35:57 So absolute absence of physical evidence.
00:36:03 I'm not saying that no child was ever buried near a residential school.
00:36:07 You know, you can't say that, but I think the burden of proof is on the other side to say, yeah, there were burials and they haven't come forward with any evidence that is at all persuasive.
00:36:17 They just demand that you believe on the basis of a combination of ground-penetrating radar and memories.
00:36:25 You know, at this point, these memories are really quite old schools.
00:36:31 The last school shut down in 1996, but most of them were shut down long before that.
00:36:36 So when you're hearing memories, they're usually actually something that somebody heard from his father or his grandfather.
00:36:43 You know, it could be 60, 70, even 100 years old.
00:36:49 So they're demanding that you believe this.
00:36:51 And if you don't believe it, you're called a denialist.
00:36:54 But we're not denying anything.
00:36:57 We're just saying, show us the evidence.
00:36:59 So that's a big part of the book, is looking at these claims about unmarked graves.
00:37:03 Now, related to that is the claim about missing children.
00:37:07 This is a related claim.
00:37:09 These unmarked graves supposedly hold the bodies of the missing children.
00:37:15 But just as there are no unmarked graves, there are no missing children.
00:37:20 The children were all carefully accounted for in the schools.
00:37:23 They had to be because the government was paying a per capita payment
00:37:29 to the religious bodies that ran the schools,
00:37:33 and the government wasn't going to fork over money
00:37:36 without some evidence that the kids were there.
00:37:39 So, and the churches weren't going to let the kids go missing
00:37:43 because they needed to proffer the evidence
00:37:46 so they could continue to get the money.
00:37:49 So there are no missing children.
00:37:50 Again, these allegations have been made.
00:37:54 Excuse me, Andrew, I'm getting over a cold
00:37:56 and it's not the greatest, but I'm doing the best I can.
00:38:01 Did children die at schools?
00:38:03 Well, absolutely.
00:38:04 um most of this took place before there was a cure for tuberculosis and tuberculosis was rampant
00:38:12 not only well in all of canada actually but particularly in native communities
00:38:18 uh was probably worse on the reserves than in the schools but it was bad enough in the schools and
00:38:25 yes kids died but there are there are death certificates um which you can get from the
00:38:31 Department of Vital Records of the provinces, you know, and they show cause of death and where the
00:38:37 child is buried. So, you know, there are no missing children. Now, there are some records that are
00:38:42 missing in the sense that over the course of 150 years, sometimes not everything gets kept,
00:38:49 but basically you can see what was going on. And once streptomycin was discovered, then the death
00:38:56 rate cratered phenomenally. Now, sadly, occasionally a kid would die, there'd be accidents, you
00:39:04 know, skating on thin ice, different things can happen over the course of 150 schools
00:39:11 over 150 years. There's going to be some tragic accidents, but there's no mass disappearance
00:39:18 of children. So much of the book is, you know, kind of prosaic, looking at the documentary
00:39:24 evidence about these claims of unmarked graves and missing children. Another claim is that
00:39:31 children were forced to attend. Well, again, this doesn't hold water.
00:39:37 Indian children were not required to attend any school until 1920,
00:39:43 amendment to the Indian Act at that time. Prior to that, all attendance was voluntary. And
00:39:49 And after 1920, attendance at a residential school was required only if there was no day
00:39:56 school convenient in a convenient location.
00:40:02 Just to bring it back, Tom, to the issues that sort of have come from you raising these
00:40:09 points is that people are not willing to engage in a debate on the facts.
00:40:15 They're not willing to engage in a debate on the merits.
00:40:19 because i mean you're a political scientist by by training and you have quite a lengthy career in
00:40:23 academia i mean i would assume that your hope would be that you put a book like this out and
00:40:27 if people dispute it they publish their own book they publish their own response and and we're
00:40:31 seeing now increasingly that people don't want to do that instead they say you know how dare you and
00:40:37 without actually arguing with a single premise or conclusion yeah very true it's sad the the
00:40:44 The contributors to the book are people whose careers involve dealing with facts, retired
00:40:56 professors in various fields like history or political science or sociology, lawyers,
00:41:03 judges, journalists.
00:41:06 That's the common denominator for almost all the contributors is a focus on fact, and that's
00:41:12 what we've tried to do in the book.
00:41:14 what's happening at cornell is a refusal to look at facts and just try and uh shout down the book
00:41:20 before anybody gets a chance to read it so well i'm glad i'm glad that it's been beneficial on
00:41:26 the sales front at least so a bit of a i i don't know maybe a bit of a pyrrhic victory for the
00:41:32 council in winning there well i appreciate you straining your voice to join us today tom always
00:41:38 good to talk to you drink some uh drink some nice honey and lemon tea or something and hopefully
00:41:42 you recover but appreciate your time as always thanks bye-bye all right and by the way i i just
00:41:47 read uh pivot or pirouette by tom flanagan which i picked up at a conference last year and uh even
00:41:54 he i believe he signed it i got him yeah he signed it for me which was quite nice uh and this was a
00:41:59 book not a new book but about the 1993 election which was a rather pivotal one in canadian
00:42:04 politics it was the election that brought uh kim campbell's progressive conservatives down to just
00:42:09 two seats and saw the reform party just absolutely explode onto the scene and i uh referenced it a
00:42:15 little bit in my own book which is coming out which is about pierre polyev called pierre polyev
00:42:21 a political life the first so far biography of the conservative party of canada leader that's coming
00:42:27 out on may 28th you can get details online about that it's on amazon indigo actually indigo has it
00:42:34 it on sale right now. So Indigo didn't carry my last book on store shelves. So we had a bit of a
00:42:38 negative relationship there, but they seem to be enthusiastic about this one. So if you have
00:42:43 already pre-ordered it, thank you very much. Hopefully you enjoy it when it comes. That does
00:42:47 it for us for today. We will be back in just 23 hours and 15 minutes with more of Canada's
00:42:52 most irreverent talk show. Thank you. God bless and good day to you all. Thanks for listening to
00:42:58 The Andrew Lawton Show.
00:42:59 Support the program by donating to True North at www.tnc.news.
00:43:28 We'll be right back.
00:43:58 We'll be right back.