Juno News - December 29, 2025


Liberals' immigration mess continues?

Topics
Mentioned
True North's Daily Brief Christmas special More taxpayer-funded 'news'?

Episode Stats


Length

31 minutes

Words per minute

179.98

Word count

5,665

Sentence count

279

Harmful content

Misogyny

3

sentences flagged

Toxicity

5

sentences flagged

Hate speech

24

sentences flagged


Summary

Summaries generated with gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ .

As we begin to wrap up the holiday season, and I hope that you and yours are enjoying a Merry Christmas and a Happy Hanukkah, we re again diving headfirst in one of the most pressing issues facing our nation: immigration. Michelle Rempel-Garner, immigration critic and shadow minister on that most essential of files, joins us again, and we re thankful for her time.

Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Topics generated with Qwen2.5-3B-Instruct.
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 Hi, Juno News. Alexander Brown here back for another episode. Hope you're having a Merry
00:00:06 Christmas. I'm the host of Not Sorry. I'm a writer, communicator, director of the National
00:00:11 Citizens Coalition. While you're here, take advantage of our promo code. Go to junonews.com
00:00:16 slash not sorry for 20% off. As we begin to wrap for the holiday season, and I hope that you and
00:00:22 yours are enjoying a Merry Christmas and a Happy Hanukkah, we're again diving headfirst in one of
00:00:27 the most pressing issues facing our nation. Immigration, or should I say mass immigration, 0.82
00:00:32 the breaking of immigration, the chaotic, out of control immigration system that's been spiraling 0.94
00:00:37 under the liberals for too long. Michelle Rempel-Garner, immigration critic and shadow
00:00:41 minister on that most essential of files, she joins us again, and we're thankful for her time.
00:00:47 A few weeks back, I appeared before Immigration Committee to be questioned by Michelle and others,
00:00:52 and to share the common sense concerns of organizations like the National Citizens Coalition,
00:00:57 as well as our audience, who know that we're on a path that isn't sustainable,
00:01:02 and that we can no longer ignore the massive second-order effects from including unvetted
00:01:08 access to Canada like it's some stocking stuffer, and we can no longer ignore that it's vitally
00:01:13 important to send home those on expired and expiring papers who never planned to leave in the
00:01:19 first place. Our population, for the first time in a long time, it's decreasing, but that's still
00:01:25 decreasing from record highs. We need to put together many years of outflow, high productivity
00:01:32 inflow, and return this program to what it once was under the Harper years to get this country back
00:01:38 on track on so many levels. The conservatives haven't always gotten this right. They'll admit
00:01:44 that leading into the Trudeau years, some of the loosening of the reins on immigration, it was a mistake.
00:01:49 Corporate lobbyists and disloyal businesses have become addicted to cheap foreign labor,
00:01:53 and many of those influences remain. And yet, Michelle and others have been relentless in pushing
00:02:00 for real reforms to fix this mess. They've scored serious wins. The numbers are coming down, but we
00:02:06 know that still doesn't go far enough, and we know some of those numbers are depending on the fact that
00:02:11 people are just going to leave willingly, and we know that's not the case. So let's not pop the champagne
00:02:16 yet. A new report from the Globe and Mail shows, for example, that there's a rise of birth tourism in
00:02:21 Canada. And we know that liberal chain migration, this bill that's now law, to the concern of many,
00:02:27 including the conservatives, it could pose a real problem there. Let's talk to Canada's most
00:02:32 important shadow minister. And first, a word from our sponsor. Folks, I want to take a minute to thank
00:02:37 today's sponsor, which is Macamie College. So Macamie College has an applied politics and public
00:02:43 affair program. It's a two-year evening online program available across Canada. Students have the
00:02:49 opportunity to learn to run political campaigns, organize grassroots movements, and push policy in
00:02:54 the right direction. Students will also have hands-on placements in their community or with the party
00:02:59 they believe in. So when they graduate, they have real job-ready experience. Applicants only need a high
00:03:04 school diploma or homeschooling equivalent to apply. Intake starts in September and January. And folks,
00:03:10 we are very excited to announce that anyone who applies and is successful in enrollment will get
00:03:17 a $500 scholarship from Juno News. So apply using our link. It's in the description. You can go to
00:03:22 CandiceMalcolm.com slash Macamie. That's M-A-K-A-M-I. And if you apply through that link and you're
00:03:29 successful, you get a $500 Juno News scholarship. You know, I went to the University of Alberta and studied
00:03:35 political science. And the thing you realize when you're doing a university degree is that it doesn't
00:03:40 lead you to a job. And so for me, after three years of being a political science student, I looked
00:03:45 around and realized I had no job skills. I had never worked in politics. Everything was theoretical. It
00:03:50 was all in the classroom. And I had to start working on political campaigns just to get my foot in the
00:03:55 door. The hard thing about politics is that you need experience to get a job, but jobs require
00:04:00 experience. And so doing something like this, I mean, the fact that you can do it online, the fact that you
00:04:04 do it on the evening is really helpful. If you're interested in politics and you're watching the
00:04:07 show, I presume you are. This is something that you really might want to consider, or hey, maybe
00:04:11 one of your adult children might be interested in doing something like this. So again, check out
00:04:17 this link at CandiceMalcolm.com slash Macamie College. Michelle Rumpel-Garner joins us. Michelle is
00:04:23 the shadow immigration minister, the immigration critic. Michelle, thanks for coming back on the show.
00:04:28 Thanks for having me. You've been really busy, Michelle. You've been fighting the good fight.
00:04:33 One thing I wanted to touch on, I was reading the Globe and Mail report today and recording this on
00:04:39 December 18th, which is that they found this rise in birth tourism. I believe the number is there's
00:04:45 a 44% increase in non-resident births at some hospitals. How do you believe this trend sort of
00:04:52 undermines the value of Canadian citizenship, the work to reform the immigration system at large,
00:04:57 and what policies could we advocate for to better address this?
00:05:04 The Globe and Mail article that you're talking about, not only does it talk about the increase
00:05:08 in birth tourism, it also highlights some information that we got from Statistics Canada
00:05:13 out of a line of questioning that I had earlier in the year on the amount of overall births to
00:05:20 non-citizens. That number is up quite dramatically. That shouldn't be a shock to anybody because
00:05:30 the Liberals increased the number of non-permanent residents by millions in a very short period of
00:05:39 time. We started to see this trend in birth tourism. That's people basically on visitor visas who come to
00:05:47 Canada, particularly to give birth so that their children have citizenship. But, you know, we've
00:05:55 also seen things like hospitals, particularly in regions where there are colleges in Ontario that
00:06:01 have utilized and really juiced the numbers of temporary student visas. They've started to charge
00:06:07 people for having children there. So, you know, this is why earlier in the fall, we said, the Conservatives
00:06:15 announced, we actually moved it in an amendment to Bill C-3, that we believe, in alignment with
00:06:21 virtually every other peer country in the world, that in order for somebody to pass citizenship down
00:06:26 to their descendants, at least one of the two parents have to have at minimum a permanent residency
00:06:31 in Canada. And that's just to show that there is a connection to Canada, especially now in light
00:06:38 of Liberal Bill C-3, which we sought to amend. This is the Liberals' chain migration bill, which allows
00:06:44 people to pass citizenship down virtually with almost no connection to Canada, generation after
00:06:50 generation. There needs to be a value to Canadian citizenship. And I think that this is a common
00:06:56 sense proposal that a lot of Canadians across the political spectrum get behind.
00:07:01 Yeah, I think so. And at a time of talking here, there are some who are celebrating that Canada's
00:07:08 population has declined, that we are finally seeing that, you know, we're sort of over the mountain.
00:07:14 But one thing I want to highlight to our audience is that StatsCan's assumptions are based on people
00:07:19 leaving when their visas expire. That's right. It's, you know, it's nice to be encouraged by a population
00:07:25 report showing our numbers are going down from record highs. But why might we not be getting the full
00:07:30 picture here? Well, first of all, this fall, again, the Globe and Mail reported that there was at least
00:07:37 500,000 people in Canada who have no status whatsoever, so are completely undocumented.
00:07:43 And then there was a news article just actually in the last couple of weeks that showed that
00:07:46 Statistics Canada themselves had undercounted the amount of permanent or non-citizens in Canada by a
00:07:55 huge percentage in the last census. And then, you know, you've watched me, you've even appeared at
00:08:00 the Standing Committee at Immigration yourself. I did.
00:08:02 You've watched me question officials on data. And it's very clear that the government is not
00:08:08 considering things like the amount of people who, you know, an incredible number of people, over 3
00:08:14 million people in Canada who are on temporary visas right now, those visas are about to expire, they don't
00:08:19 have a plan to remove them. What does that mean going forward? And those numbers aren't accounted for
00:08:26 in a lot of planning. And even it's not even accounted for by the government's own emission and
00:08:31 things like health care capacity. So I think that we need better data, of course, but also, you know,
00:08:38 the reality is, is the Liberals welcome too many people to Canada too fast for housing, health care
00:08:45 and jobs to keep up. And of course, that's going to have an impact on both the economic infrastructure
00:08:50 and Canada's social infrastructure as well. So we'll need to continue to address these issues
00:08:56 in a sort of a macro way, like you were talking about, talking about integration, aspects of
00:09:01 integration, but also in the programmatic aspects of the immigration process in Canada as well to
00:09:06 everything from ensuring that people are removed from Canada when their visas expire, that non-citizens 1.00
00:09:13 who are convicted of serious crimes are deported, and that also that immigration levels are set
00:09:19 fairly. People who play by the rules are the ones who are welcomed in first, and that the numbers
00:09:25 are set at a lower level, because we've seen the strain that the high levels have, and unsustainable
00:09:31 levels have placed on, you know, both Canada's economic infrastructure, and again, our social fabric
00:09:37 as well too. Yeah, they sure have. And I was lucky enough to appear before a committee virtually, so maybe
00:09:43 it wasn't as scary. But in my remarks to yourself and your esteemed colleagues, I wanted to hit on
00:09:52 outflow, because we hear so much about, you know, bringing in all these people, but there seems to be
00:09:57 this like deliberately obtuse approach from Lina Diab and the liberals that they're just not addressing
00:10:04 the elephant in the room, that if so many people came here over the last few years under a certain
00:10:10 pretense of staying forever, that we're going to need to work really hard to actually get them out
00:10:15 the door. And they're not, they're not putting that on paper. They're not, they're not telling
00:10:19 you there's an exit plan. And which tells me that there is a an amnesty plan, a sit back and, and don't
00:10:26 worry about a plan. And I even think of the work that you've highlighted recently, where really
00:10:31 important stuff, because like, we're not even deporting people convicted of serious crimes like sexual
00:10:36 assault. Do you like do these current enforcement efforts, like we know that they're not sufficient,
00:10:42 but like what, what can you move? How can the public help you move something in the new year
00:10:48 to further crack down on not just deportations, which are necessary, but really putting the boots 0.93
00:10:54 to some of these scumbags who are taking advantage of our laws? Well, I just want to, 0.92
00:11:00 the last thing you said here, I want to be clear, the vast majority of people who come to Canada,
00:11:05 they play by the rules, they understand the responsibilities associated with being in
00:11:10 Canada, as well as the privileges. And so it's not fair to them, or to anybody who's already in
00:11:16 Canada, to have immigration law, the spirit of immigration law, just completely ignored by the
00:11:22 government. And what's what what is already in the law, what is a foundational principle
00:11:26 of the fairness of Canada's immigration system is that if you are here on a temporary visa,
00:11:31 you need to leave at the end of your temporary visa, number one. And number two, if you don't
00:11:39 uphold the rule of law, if you are a non citizen, and you are convicted of a serious crime, you should
00:11:45 leave. Those are the two things that are already in Canadian law, they're just not being enforced by
00:11:49 the government. And they're also being in some cases really perverted by the judiciary. So you know,
00:11:55 you and I've talked about this already, I have a bill in front of Parliament right now to end the
00:12:00 practice of judges giving leniency to non citizens convicted of serious crimes like sexual assault,
00:12:07 so that they can be that they can stay in Canada. We don't want that to happen. If somebody's convicted
00:12:12 of a serious crime, and they're a non citizen, they should be removed. It shouldn't be a judge, 0.90
00:12:17 an activist judge saying, well, we want them to stay in Canada. No, that's we want the spirit of the
00:12:22 law to be upheld, number one. And number two, we, you know, you watched me try to amend Bill C12,
00:12:29 the Liberals border bills over 30 times with significant changes to streamline the efficacy
00:12:36 of the removals process for people who have no legal reason to be in Canada, everything from
00:12:41 ensuring that people who have no legal reason to be in Canada don't make bogus asylum claims,
00:12:46 that people don't have the ability to make endless appeals to removal orders,
00:12:52 unless you know, there's a significant change in circumstance in their country.
00:12:57 That's there's, we weren't just opposing the government this fall, we were also proposing
00:13:01 common sense measures. And I hope the government comes to their senses and steals some of these
00:13:06 measures. Because the fact that the Liberals aren't doing them, that's what's undermining
00:13:10 the consensus for immigration in Canada right now.
00:13:14 Yeah, and so much of what I do, I suppose, on the immigration file is try to communicate the
00:13:19 extent of some of the, the extent of some of the monkey business that's happened here. I was talking
00:13:23 to a former immigration official the other night. And they told me that after Trudeau changed the visa
00:13:30 requirement with Mexico, for example, they would be the immigration officials would be at the
00:13:35 airport, like politicians would be there to study this phenomenon, half of the plane would be arriving
00:13:40 and making an asylum claim and claiming asylum. And like you would have, I'm not even kidding,
00:13:45 like you would have a husband and wife with three kids, just just with like a thing where it's like
00:13:51 he's saying, like, I'm a persecuted homosexual, I'm claiming asylum. And it's like, hold on a second,
00:13:56 like you're here with your wife and three kids, like it's it just immediately overnight became became such
00:14:02 a thing. And that that is still occurring to the day to today. And what a failure there and what a failure
00:14:08 on. I also think of one click virtual citizenship. I know that that yes, that's sticking with you. How the heck
00:14:15 can we change that? And, and, and surely that is undercutting sort of Canadian cohesion or limiting that
00:14:22 buy in that immigrants are supposed to feel to to our country. 0.99
00:14:25 So those you're talking about two proposals that that I've worked hard on this fall. So first of all,
00:14:34 we proposed, I think the most substantive set of reforms to the asylum system, we propose these this
00:14:41 fall that we've seen in decades to prevent the abuse of the system. So everybody, everything from
00:14:46 disincentivizing people from making bogus claims to begin with, you know, common sense policies, like if
00:14:52 somebody is making an asylum claim, when they arrive in Canada, they should state their reasons on the
00:14:57 record immediately, to so that they can't game the system by unscrupulous through unscrupulous
00:15:03 consultants and lawyers. We've seen this happen many times. Also, you know, just just ensuring that
00:15:11 people aren't overstaying their visas, and then getting federal benefits that many Canadians aren't
00:15:17 entitled to. So we moved in a proposal to ensure that people who are who have made bogus asylum 1.00
00:15:23 claims, they, you know, flat out said, like, their claims have been rejected, that they shouldn't be
00:15:28 able to continue to claim federal benefits. And then I want to get to the the whole value of Canadian
00:15:34 citizenship thing in a second. But I think it's really important to note, Alex, that, like, you talked
00:15:39 about the Mexican visa lift, right? I was the immigration critic back in 2016, when the Liberals made this
00:15:46 change. And I remember sitting in the immigration committee going, why this is going to result in
00:15:50 a mass of asylum claims that are bogus and fraudulent, it's gonna have a huge cost to taxpayers,
00:15:56 and I was called racist, but I was right. I don't want to be right in these scenarios. But it just it
00:16:02 proves that we need safeguards briefly on the one click citizenship ceremony thing. You know, you've
00:16:08 started to talk about this, I want to hear your thoughts more. But we do need to start talking about
00:16:12 the value of Canadian citizenship. So low hanging fruit in this was that the Liberals allowed moved so
00:16:19 that people could just click a box online to become a citizen instead of going and giving the oath in
00:16:25 person. I think that that that physical in person demonstration of the understanding of the
00:16:32 responsibilities of Canadian citizenship is a unifying experience. There's no reason why something
00:16:37 it is a beautiful thing. I mean, I was one of those school kids who, you know, every now and then you
00:16:42 get a citizenship event at a ceremony like at your assembly. And I think you know, you that see teachers
00:16:47 crying. It was wonderful. We lost so much over the last few years through zoom. I mean, I, I get to do
00:16:54 this show through, you know, webcam. And I think that's terrific. But yeah, but no, it this has to mean
00:16:59 something if we're going to properly integrate people if we're going to prevent them from balkanizing,
00:17:03 if we're going to prevent them from just being lost in the shuffle, that we're supposed to all
00:17:08 be coming together here. And it strikes me as just such a foundational failure.
00:17:12 I'm actually writing a piece right now, trying to get the thought right. But, you know, I've heard so
00:17:17 many people, even even, you know, former conservatives and stuff, they talk about immigration solely from
00:17:24 an economic perspective, right? And there is a benefit to Canada's economy to, you know, attracting
00:17:30 people who are very skilled. But oftentimes, where immigrant economic immigration has gone in the last
00:17:37 decade under the liberals is to bring in low skilled foreign laborers, keep them in an indentured 0.99
00:17:45 situation and allow, you know, corporate profits to be juiced. And in that scenario, there's another
00:17:51 concept of immigration that has, I think, been really lost over the last decade, with the focus of
00:17:57 talking about immigration, just from an economic perspective, and that's integration. You know, we
00:18:03 need, you can't just talk about immigration from an economic perspective, you have to talk about
00:18:08 processes in a way that is also talking about, well, how are we nation building through immigration? And
00:18:17 so all the things you and I've just talked about, I think it all just fits under that umbrella, things
00:18:21 like, if you come to Canada, and you're a non citizen, and you commit a serious crime, you should be
00:18:27 removed, because you haven't adhered to the rule of law, you haven't adhered to Canadian cultural norms,
00:18:35 as they're enshrined in the Immigration Refugee Protection Act, you've lost the privilege of being
00:18:41 here. And so, you know, just when you hear these debates, and these arguments about economic
00:18:47 immigration, like, it's, it's sort of hollow, it's sort of cold. Yeah, we have to talk about 1.00
00:18:55 immigration in the context of Canadian pluralism and Canadian identity. And that's where I think
00:19:01 I'm going to be pushing some of my writing and my policies, we've got so many policies that we
00:19:06 rolled out, but it kind of falls under that umbrella. And so you're going to hear me talking
00:19:10 about that more in the new year. And I look forward to that, because I think of,
00:19:16 because that's the last piece. It's like, we're just kind of just stuck in the maw of this, like,
00:19:20 GDP go up, go up machine, but we're not, we're not, golly, like this used to kind of mean something.
00:19:27 And I think of what the TFW program, for example, used to be used for, which was like fruit pickers in
00:19:33 Kelowna. And they would, they would live in a bunkhouse for a couple months, and there'd be some pros and
00:19:39 cons to the program, but it was, they were sort of kept away. And it was like, deliberately,
00:19:44 they weren't integrating because it was like, this is seasonal employment. But now we've launched
00:19:49 our entire immigration program on that on, you know, you're forced into sort of a co-ethnic network,
00:19:56 you're not properly adopted by the community, you are taken advantage of and overly beholden to your
00:20:02 employer. And then we turn around and go like, gee, why are people so upset, including immigrants, 0.72
00:20:07 about the fact that this wave, it's not fair to anybody, it's not fair to anyone, we're inviting
00:20:12 them in to, we, you know, we haven't made the bed, we haven't, we haven't gotten our house in order.
00:20:18 And then of course, they're going to fail. Of course, this is going to fail and make everybody,
00:20:22 everybody has a harder time. And it's not fair to anybody. If you don't think about the overall
00:20:29 macro level system that we're asking newcomers to integrate to and, you know, again, like I'm kind
00:20:36 of noodling with this on a piece, I'm trying to write this, this concept, but people will say,
00:20:40 well, Canada is a nation that's, you know, full of immigrants, and it's the descendants of
00:20:45 immigrants. It's true. However, previous waves of major immigration, like, you know, you see it
00:20:51 pre and post war, you know, early 1900s, you can't compare current immigration to that context,
00:21:00 because, you know, you have air travel, you have global, you know, global communities that
00:21:06 it's, it's not like we're a bunch of people where you have to figure out how to speak a common
00:21:11 language and, you know, work with each other, unless the country puts effort into that now. And I feel
00:21:19 like there's a lot of people, particularly, you know, sort of left leaning industry leaders who have
00:21:24 really relied on high levels of indentured foreign labor, which isn't fair to them either.
00:21:32 They talk about it, like, like, like the integration component, like it just magically happens.
00:21:37 Yeah, where it's like, it's like, well, no, we haven't built, we haven't built out enough
00:21:41 healthcare infrastructure. How, you know, I look in Alberta, I saw some really startling statistics in
00:21:48 my home province of Alberta here, where it's like, I think it was 30% or higher of children
00:21:54 who are in primary education don't need ESL training. And like, so how are we dealing with
00:22:01 that? And like, I want to be very clear, I'm not pointing the finger at newcomers who want to come
00:22:07 to Canada to a point to build a better life. And I think that a lot of Canadians feel the same way.
00:22:14 Yeah, we do need to look at the government, the lobbyists that have implemented these poorly
00:22:21 designed policies and, and levels that have set everybody up to fail, not just from an economic
00:22:28 perspective, but also from this, you know, more integrative national identity perspective. And,
00:22:35 you know, I think, you know, you've addressed this a lot. But the question of how do we maintain
00:22:41 Canada's pluralism in the aftermath of a decade of post nationalism from the liberals from mass
00:22:48 immigration from the liberals is something that we have to be seized with it. Otherwise, 0.98
00:22:51 it will collapse, we're seeing it start to collapse. And so we have to fix it, right?
00:22:57 Yeah. And who's defending the Canadian worker? Like, I know that you are, I've sat in your committee,
00:23:02 but I was struck by the fact that when I was in committee for my my little appearance and wrestling
00:23:07 promo that I got to cut, which was the other witnesses, much respect to them. They were just
00:23:13 talking about more TFWs and more and like, no one was mentioning the Canadian worker. And I'm sitting
00:23:19 there going, like, I guess I have to be the bad guy. Because there's a gentleman from Quebec asking 0.93
00:23:24 for more welders. And I can appreciate that, you know, sometimes you can't find the right skill. But
00:23:28 it's why are we not spending more time talking about training our people about exactly our people?
00:23:34 Like, where's the exactly if we waste billions of dollars on saving the spotted owl and Micronesia?
00:23:41 Why are we not spending money on training young people on on interprovincial mobility for our
00:23:46 trades? Like, why aren't we looking in house instead of just looking for replacement cogs?
00:23:50 Because for the last decade, multinational fast, fast food chain owners have been able to convince the
00:24:01 liberal government as well as like a vast swath of immigration consultants, immigration advocates
00:24:07 that all profit off of low skilled temporary foreign labor coming in in an indentured servitude model,
00:24:15 profiting off that system. And then all of a sudden, people are like, well, why do we have a 20%
00:24:19 youth unemployment rate? Well, it's like, maybe this has something to do with it? Of course it does.
00:24:26 And you're right, like you when we were sitting in that committee meeting together,
00:24:30 you know, I think I asked one of the people who were there, well, what about betting on Canadian kids?
00:24:35 You know, what about that? You know, I hear I hear fast food chain workers saying like, well,
00:24:42 I just, you know, I need to hire I need to hire a cook from, you know, this ethnic background,
00:24:48 because there's no possible way.
00:24:49 Yeah, why do they have to be from a country like India? 0.98
00:24:52 Why don't you just teach a kid how to cook? Like, like, that's, it's pretty anti Canadian to say,
00:24:59 I'm not going to teach a Canadian kid how to cook in Canada. Like, and we need to just start calling 1.00
00:25:05 out the emperor for having no clothes, these myths that the left has perpetuated, these lobby groups
00:25:11 have perpetuated. It's like, no, enough, enough. We're not the United Arab Emirates. We don't have a,
00:25:17 we shouldn't have a secondary class of citizen that's doing certain types of jobs. That's not
00:25:21 fair to newcomers coming to Canada. And it's not fair to our kids enough. 1.00
00:25:25 Yeah, yeah, we're not. I've heard this recently from immigration officials as well past past and
00:25:30 present or where, yeah, you now have these restaurants going like, well, I need a chef
00:25:35 of this descent. And it's like, what are you talking about? Like, we, we have a very vibrant,
00:25:40 diverse culture, like you can go find this kid, like the best chefs in New York don't have to be
00:25:45 Italian. Japan sends their, their cooks abroad to train. It's like, it's such a shoddy argument.
00:25:51 Well, some of the best, I mean, like also some of the best French chefs I know are
00:25:55 Japanese. I mean, like, it's, I digress. You're right. 1.00
00:25:58 The best, some of the best New York chefs are Dominican and like, they're not, I know, 1.00
00:26:01 Dominican food and it, no, it's, you have these, these, these corporations too,
00:26:06 like a, let's say a Tim Hortons who,
00:26:09 I'll be mean to them if you'd like, I'll take that one on the chin. Cause I don't,
00:26:13 I don't buy their food anymore. I think it sucks now, but they, they will refuse to,
00:26:18 to adjust their wages. Like instead of being competitive, it's like their lobbying will be 0.84
00:26:22 like, instead of just realizing like the market is asking for more and better and that like our,
00:26:27 our Canadian kids deserve to not be making peanuts. They'll just, they'll just fight like 0.99
00:26:33 heck to prevent, to, to protect this like $16 an hour abuse system. 0.98
00:26:38 Yeah. And, and just, you know, briefly on that point, the other thing that I hear from
00:26:43 certain franchise owners is, well, Canadian kids don't want to show up for work. It's like, 0.55
00:26:47 we'll make them show up for work, teach them the value of work. And on the other hand, like,
00:26:52 you know, there's, there's a lot of young Canadians now who don't have the same
00:26:56 hope of achieving major adult milestones in their twenties. Like,
00:27:00 let's say I would have, for example, owning a home or, you know, getting married and starting
00:27:05 a family and be able to afford it in their twenties. So, and, and a lot of that is to do
00:27:09 with the fact that over the last five to 10 years, the government has allowed the suppression of wage
00:27:16 growth in certain industries because they've brought in too many foreign laborers too fast.
00:27:21 It's not fair to the foreign laborers who are getting paid low, low wages and are stuck to one 1.00
00:27:26 employer. It's not fair to Canadian kids who are having that, that first job opportunity taken
00:27:32 away from them. So like the whole system, like these talking points, like, oh, well,
00:27:39 nobody wants to move here and do the job or, oh, I can't find a kid that has this experience or,
00:27:44 oh, you know, Canadian kids don't want to do these jobs. It's complete bull. 1.00
00:27:49 Like it is like, no, we have to remove the crutch, which is high levels of temporary foreign labor 1.00
00:27:56 that don't have places to live. We don't have the healthcare capacity to absorb and we don't
00:28:00 have the jobs for in order for that situation to improve. I mean, it's no brainer to me.
00:28:07 Unless you're an upside down underwater welder, I don't want to hear like, unless that's the need,
00:28:13 I don't want to hear that you need to go to a certain network for a certain person who you can 0.97
00:28:18 treat like crap, who's not going to integrate. So I wanted to end on this then. So, so how can, 0.79
00:28:24 because we know the excuse, we know the players, we know their game. Like how should, heck, the new
00:28:29 US ambassador works for a mass immigration lobby. Uh oh, how should Canada balance these apparent labor 0.86
00:28:35 needs, these apparent labor excuses without inviting unsustainable and non-integrated increases to its
00:28:42 workforce? Like what to you is the number there that makes sense? Heck, like, is there a year
00:28:47 that you can think of where it's like, this was the number that worked. This is exactly what we
00:28:51 should be going back to. Well, for starters, the temporary foreign worker program should be 0.99
00:28:56 completely abolished outside of legitimately hard to fill seasonal agricultural labor. We called for
00:29:02 that in September. And then the same thing goes for, um, you know, like I would just say that the whole
00:29:09 foreign student, uh, program where, you know, Sean Frazier, the former immigration minister,
00:29:14 bragged about setting it at unsustainable levels. That needs to be brought way under control. Um,
00:29:21 but then, you know, there's a couple of other things that we need to think about. First of all,
00:29:25 you know, you talked about high skilled labor that the government's like, well, we want to attract more
00:29:30 foreign researchers. Okay. But here's the reality. Most of the intellectual property that's generated at 0.95
00:29:37 Canadian universities and at Canadian companies, it gets exported out of the country. Those patents
00:29:43 get bought up or sent out to be operationalized or commercialized outside of Canada. So that there's
00:29:49 a whole issue there that needs to be addressed and also productivity. I mean, um, without an endless supply
00:29:56 of temporary foreign indentured labor, maybe Canadian industry would start investing in productivity
00:30:03 measures. And, you know, maybe there's an opportunity for the government to create incentives
00:30:07 or tax incentives or whatnot there, but that's where the public policy should be structured rather
00:30:14 than just, you know, senior public servants, politicians on the left saying, yep, we're going
00:30:18 to listen to an industry lobby that asks for more foreign labor. We should be, they should be,
00:30:22 the lobby should be going, how do we address productivity? How do we address retention of
00:30:27 intellectual property? How do we address skills training? As you said, for Canadian youth labor
00:30:33 mobility across the country from high unemployment areas to low unemployment areas. That's where the
00:30:39 public policy debate needs to go. Um, but no, the whole, like, yeah, we just need more TFWs and
00:30:45 foreign students and whatnot enough. Um, you know, the Canadian economy and our social fabric can't handle 1.00
00:30:51 that. The last five years have shown that. And, um, I'm going to continue being a thorn in the liberal side
00:30:56 on that front proposing concrete policy, whole suite of policies we put forward and legislative
00:31:03 proposals as well, but also opposing their bad decisions. Yeah. And we're thankful for that.
00:31:08 The lobbyist excuses, they're not going to fly anymore. The majority of Canadians want, you know,
00:31:13 more and more change. We're seeing it in the polls from, from all different kinds of communities,
00:31:17 whether it's the old stock or, or new immigrants who know that this isn't working. And so, Michelle,
00:31:22 you're doing important work. Thanks for this and, uh, Merry Christmas. Merry Christmas.
00:31:26 Merry Christmas.