Juno News - September 25, 2023


Liberals invite Nazi veteran to House of Commons

Topics
Mentioned
Still no "buyback" program for Trudeau's banned guns (ft. Rod Giltaca) Liberals scapegoat Anthony Rota for honouring Nazi veteran

Episode Stats


Length

45 minutes

Words per minute

164.77

Word count

7,557

Sentence count

354

Harmful content

Misogyny

2

sentences flagged

Toxicity

8

sentences flagged

Hate speech

21

sentences flagged


Summary

Summaries generated with gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ .

A Ukrainian-Canadian World War II veteran was honoured in the House of Commons on Friday, and the reaction in the Commons was... not exactly what you'd expect. And the reaction from the Prime Minister, the Speaker of the Commons, and other politicians was... well, let's just say... not good.

Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Topics generated with Qwen2.5-3B-Instruct.
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 Transcription by CastingWords
00:00:30 Thank you.
00:01:00 Welcome to Canada's most irreverent talk show.
00:01:16 This is the Andrew Lawton Show, brought to you by True North.
00:01:20 Wow! Fridays in Ottawa are normally the most boring thing imaginable.
00:01:31 The only thing more boring than a Friday in Parliament is any hour of CBC programming.
00:01:39 But boy, did last Friday change that up a little bit.
00:01:43 In fairness, it wasn't even what happened on Friday because no one quite noticed in real time
00:01:49 or at least no one said out loud what was happening.
00:01:51 It was only over the weekend when people started to digest
00:01:54 and wonder, did that really happen?
00:01:57 I'm referring, of course, to this moment.
00:02:01 We have here in the chamber today,
00:02:03 Ukrainian-Canadians, Ukrainian-Canadian world veteran
00:02:06 from the Second World War
00:02:08 who fought the Ukrainian independence against the Russians
00:02:12 and continues to support the troops today,
00:02:17 even at his age of 98.
00:02:19 His name is Yaroslav Hunka, and I was going to say he's in the gallery, but I think you
00:02:35 beat me to that.
00:02:37 But I'm very proud to say that he is from North Bay and from my writing of Nipissing
00:02:42 to Miskaming. He's a Ukrainian hero, a Canadian hero, and we thank him for all his service. Thank
00:02:55 you.
00:03:05 Ah, and just like that, everyone rises to their feet. A standing ovation for a Ukrainian hero
00:03:11 and a Canadian hero. Now that in and of itself is not news, but when you delve into the details a
00:03:18 bit and you listen closely to the introduction, a Ukrainian who fought against Russia in World
00:03:26 War II, you start to wonder, okay, well, I, you know, maybe you don't have to be a huge history
00:03:31 buff to realize that Russia or the Soviet Union as it then was, was inexplicably, well, not
00:03:37 inexplicably but was inexplicably to today's understanding of things in a modern context
00:03:42 the good guy in that conflict. Yes the Soviet Union was one of the allied forces against the
00:03:48 Nazis there was very good reason for that and as it stands things happened afterwards that 0.97
00:03:53 made us realize if we didn't already perhaps they weren't the good guys overall in history but in
00:03:58 that moment they were on the right side. So it stands to reason that those fighting against
00:04:03 the Soviets in World War II were on the wrong side. Now, history is complicated, and war is
00:04:12 complicated, and sometimes you can easily go down the road of believing that the enemy of your enemy
00:04:17 is your friend. And I point that out because I think for a lot of Ukrainians who saw and understood
00:04:23 the incredible genocide that had taken place against them at the hands of Stalin and the
00:04:28 Soviet Union, they would say that, well, maybe the Soviets are our enemies more than Nazi Germany. So
00:04:34 even if they are on the wrong side of history overall, you can understand how Ukrainians may 0.96
00:04:40 have looked at the Soviets and not been as fond of having them as an ally as Britain and the US
00:04:46 and Canada and France, etc. were. Now that is not excusing people who embrace Nazism, certainly not 0.50
00:04:55 today. And I think it's not excusing the things that were done by the 14th Waffen Grenadier
00:05:00 Division of the SS, the first Galician, which later on was rebranded for obvious reasons as
00:05:06 the first Ukrainian division. That was the unit in which this man, Yaroslav Hanka, was a member.
00:05:13 That is the division in which this man fought for his country, but ultimately fought for the Nazi
00:05:21 war efforts. And it is not something that a lot of people commenting on really knew about, I don't
00:05:28 think. I think people could have probably put two and two together, as you kind of saw House of
00:05:32 Commons Speaker Anthony Roda doing there, that if someone was fighting against the Soviets, they
00:05:38 must have been fighting with the Nazis. There are some people who knew history really, really well
00:05:42 that would have assumed when this came up that perhaps he was one of the Ukrainian nationalists
00:05:49 who were trying to establish an independent Ukraine in the 1930s and 40s
00:05:53 and were fighting against the Nazis and the Soviets.
00:05:56 That was the interpretation that I've seen from some people
00:05:59 who do know that chapter of history very well.
00:06:01 And they assumed that the vetting had been done.
00:06:04 They assumed that if we are looking at this guy in the House of Commons
00:06:06 and honoring him, that surely we're not putting up a guy there
00:06:10 who fought with the Nazis.
00:06:13 But alas, that did not, in fact, take place.
00:06:16 And it was really, really interesting to see the condemnation start to flow.
00:06:21 Now, Karina Gould, who decided to pose for this photo with Mr. Hanka,
00:06:29 was very indignant at this whole thing, urged anyone and everyone to not politicize it.
00:06:34 She ended up speaking in the House of Commons,
00:06:37 doing the number one two-step of the Liberal government,
00:06:40 which is to point the blame at someone else.
00:06:43 Mr. Speaker, I would just like to respond to my honourable colleague because I think
00:06:49 we both share the frustration about what happened on Friday, but I do want to reiterate, and
00:06:55 as you have made very clear in your statement, Mr. Speaker, that this was your initiative.
00:07:01 The Government of Canada had no knowledge of this individual coming to—the Government
00:07:08 had no knowledge. The Speaker is responsible for this chamber. He invited him of his own
00:07:14 accord, and he made the decision himself to recognize him. Neither the Government of Canada
00:07:22 nor the delegation of Ukraine had any knowledge of this. I would respectfully submit, Mr. Speaker,
00:07:29 that you clarify this for the members opposite, because it's important that this information be
00:07:34 clear and that these false allegations do not continue because they're not true thank you mr
00:07:40 that's right the honorable opposition house leader then the government house leader before anything
00:07:46 starts i just want to make it clear that it was my decision and my decision alone this was a
00:07:53 constituent who wanted to see what wanted to be here and i recognized him it was my decision and
00:08:02 i apologize profusely i cannot i cannot tell you how regretful it is and it may not be good enough
00:08:09 for some of you and for that i apologize and i'll let the honorable opposition house leader
00:08:16 take it from here and then we'll go to the government house leader he has faced a great
00:08:23 many criticisms over the last couple of days from the center for israel and jewish affairs
00:08:29 Seja, which has condemned this incident, from B'nai B'rith, which is another Jewish advocacy
00:08:35 group, also from the Friends of Simon Wiesenthal Center, again, another group that does very good
00:08:42 work on this, and is actually led by a former Liberal member of Parliament in Michael Levitt.
00:08:48 And despite all of this condemnation, by the way, on Yom Kippur, when the Jewish people would love
00:08:54 to be focusing on that and instead have to feel very aggrieved by the standing ovation given for
00:09:00 a literal Nazi veteran in the House of Commons on Friday. Anthony Roda has apologized. He's taken
00:09:08 responsibility. He said it was his and his decision alone. The Liberal government knew nothing about
00:09:14 it. The Prime Minister knew nothing about it. Trudeau never met with the guy. Ignore that
00:09:18 little photo that Karina Gould took in the hallway. But then there was this post from one of the
00:09:24 members of the veterans family. Teresa Hanka, who shares this image of this man, Yaroslav,
00:09:32 waiting for Trudeau and Zelensky, waiting in the reception hall. Now, I've not seen a photo of him
00:09:39 with Trudeau and Zelensky. I don't know if any of them met. Maybe they were promised a meeting and
00:09:45 it never happened. Maybe they thought they were getting a meeting. But nevertheless, it's not
00:09:49 exactly something that we can just put at Anthony Roda's feet and say this has nothing to do with
00:09:55 anyone else, which is what the Liberals have been committing to. As it stands now, the NDP has called
00:10:01 for Speaker Anthony Roda to resign, as has the Bloc Québécois. The Conservatives have called for
00:10:06 accountability. They don't believe the Speaker is the problem. They believe Justin Trudeau is the
00:10:11 problem, and I think there's probably some good reason for that. Here's a guy who loves theatrics
00:10:16 at every turn a guy who has never seen a photo op he didn't like and what happens when he is caught
00:10:23 literally literally presiding over a moment in the house of commons in which there is a
00:10:28 veteran who served with the nazis up in the gallery not just there he didn't just sneak
00:10:33 in the back he was an invited guest and the liberals are saying well yeah this is we all
00:10:37 need to do they're doing their whole learning opportunity thing this is
00:10:41 Now a learning opportunity for everyone but the people responsible.
00:10:46 I will say two things on this that may be a little bit unpopular.
00:10:52 I am one of the most, I should back up and say that I actually had the great privilege
00:10:56 in 2011 of visiting Yad Vashem, which is the Holocaust Museum and Education Center in Israel.
00:11:03 And I was able to build off of my high school civics and rudimentary, high school history
00:11:08 and rudimentary first-year university history by steeping myself in Holocaust history.
00:11:14 It was a very challenging week, but I learned a great deal that I have carried with me in
00:11:18 the interceding 12 years.
00:11:20 I am very, very keen on history and remembering the Holocaust and honoring those who lost
00:11:27 their lives in this, which means I have zero, zero sympathy whatsoever for Nazis.
00:11:34 And I say that while also understanding, as I mentioned earlier on in the show, the complexity
00:11:39 of history, that there are people who did not fight alongside the Nazis because they
00:11:43 had it out for the Jewish people.
00:11:45 They fought the Nazis because they believed, as many Ukrainians did, that Hitler was going
00:11:50 to be their liberator.
00:11:52 So when you look at the full history of this, and Canada went through this in the 1980s,
00:11:58 was something called the Deschenes Commission, which looked at Nazi war criminals in Canada.
00:12:04 And they ultimately decided, this commission, that they would not view the 14th Waffen Grenadier
00:12:10 Division as inherently criminal, despite the fact that it had been called such at Nuremberg.
00:12:16 In Canada, they didn't go that distance.
00:12:18 And they said that it was down to individual conduct.
00:12:21 And these people didn't hide that they were in this division like other Nazis did. 0.67
00:12:26 These people didn't lie about it.
00:12:27 And in this particular case, we have no evidence of what this man individually did during World
00:12:32 War II.
00:12:34 So we can say that perhaps he was not involved in anything that would make our skin crawl and
00:12:40 anything that would just have us calling for justice. But we can also say that he should not
00:12:44 be given a standing ovation in a hall of government in Canada. And in a lot of ways,
00:12:51 I don't know this man. I will never know this man. I don't know if the liberals have not just
00:12:59 hung him out to dry and now spend his dying days living with the shame and embarrassment and
00:13:05 humiliation of this when he just kept his head down. No one would have known who he was. No one
00:13:11 would have questioned his past and that would have been that. So I feel for his family who are going
00:13:16 through something now they probably never thought was going to happen to their father, their
00:13:19 grandfather, their great-grandfather. But this is exactly the situation we're in with a society that
00:13:25 does not know its history and a society that believes the enemy of your enemy is your friend
00:13:30 because we've decided in the Russia-Ukraine conflict for good reason as you've heard me say
00:13:36 that Russia is the bad guy anyone who fought against Russia irrespective of the circumstances
00:13:40 therefore must be a good guy that was what led to this horrendous and shameful display on Friday
00:13:48 now let me just before we go to our first guest on this show share a bit of a clip because we
00:13:54 have seen some denunciation from the folks involved here, like Jennifer O'Connell, the Liberal
00:14:01 Member of Parliament. I'm curious if she thinks there should be consequences or retrimand for
00:14:10 members of this House who meet with known Nazis, who spread misinformation, disinformation,
00:14:17 glorify the Holocaust, who speak against anti-Muslim rhetoric.
00:14:25 I'm just curious if she's talking about online hate and privacy of Canadians and regulation.
00:14:30 Does she condemn her actions by meeting with a known Nazi in this country
00:14:36 who spout anti-Muslim rhetoric?
00:14:40 Oh, wait, I'm sorry. That was the wrong clip.
00:14:43 No, no, no.
00:14:43 She was not talking about the literal Nazi that was in the House of Commons.
00:14:47 she was talking about a German member of the European Parliament, Christine Anderson, who
00:14:52 tweeted this morning that she is just rolling on the floor laughing at this whole thing after
00:14:57 the display that she got. But surely Justin Trudeau has denounced this Nazism, right? 0.87
00:15:03 Mr. Speaker, when did the Prime Minister lose his way? When did it happen?
00:15:08 The Right Honourable Prime Minister. Mr. Speaker, Conservative Party members can stand with people
00:15:17 who wave swastikas point of order uh the honorable member for thorn hill mr speaker i am a strong
00:15:24 jewish woman and a member of this house and a descendant of holocaust survivors and i have
00:15:28 never made to it's never been singled out and i have never been made to feel less except for today
00:15:33 when the prime minister accused me of standing with swastikas i think he owes me an apology i'd
00:15:38 like an apology and i think he owes an apology to all members of this house when conservative
00:15:44 members of parliament meet with a German member of the European parliament, that is greeting and
00:15:50 meeting a Nazi. When the conservatives support freedom convoy demonstrators, that is standing 0.89
00:15:57 with people who wave swastikas. When parental rights advocates descend on Parliament Hill and
00:16:02 locations across the country, the liberals, the activists, the media will all jump up and down
00:16:07 and say, these are Nazis. It's amazing how in this day and age, anyone and everyone is a Nazi, 0.65
00:16:13 except for someone who literally fought with the Nazis.
00:16:17 That is the level of dissonance here.
00:16:19 And you often hear the expression
00:16:20 that when everything is racist, nothing is racist.
00:16:23 When everyone's a Nazi, no one is a Nazi.
00:16:26 And that's, I think, the thing here that people forget
00:16:28 is that Nazi means something.
00:16:31 And we are not so far removed from history
00:16:33 that there are not Nazis who walk on this earth,
00:16:36 which is why Simon Wiesenthal and his followers
00:16:39 have become so dogged in their pursuit of justice
00:16:42 for aging Nazi criminals.
00:16:45 There will come a time 0.98
00:16:46 when there are none left on this earth
00:16:48 and some of those will have managed
00:16:50 to escape and evade justice.
00:16:52 I am not calling for justice
00:16:54 for Yaroslav Hanka.
00:16:56 I don't know enough about his history
00:16:58 to say whether that is warranted,
00:16:59 but I am saying that
00:17:00 at the very, very minimum,
00:17:03 the lowest, lowest bar possible,
00:17:05 so much that the seven dwarves 0.99
00:17:07 could play limbo under it,
00:17:08 is that we shouldn't honor them
00:17:10 and give them standing ovations
00:17:11 in the House of Commons.
00:17:13 Ezra Levant was one of the first people, if not the first person, to notice this.
00:17:18 He is the Rebel Commander at Rebel News and joins me now.
00:17:22 Ezra, it's always good to talk to you.
00:17:25 I mean, you're a Jewish man yourself, and I know you have a very high tolerance for
00:17:29 free speech and for people having controversial and even hateful opinions, but just on a personal
00:17:35 level, how did you feel when you saw this and clued in to what people in the House of
00:17:40 Commons didn't really clue into?
00:17:41 Yeah, I mean, talk about tricky language. I mean, the guy was a Nazi. I'm not saying he was like a regular GI, just a conscript in the army. He was a volunteer with Hitler's SS. That was the political hunter killers. Those are the folks who would go after the partisan resistance. Those are the folks who would hunt for Jews in the attics. 0.55
00:18:04 these were the vicious Hitler errand boys. They trained near Dachau. They were the division for 0.99
00:18:14 the battalion that would shoot Jews and bury them in mass graves. So he wasn't just fighting. He was 0.99
00:18:21 a Nazi, an SS officer. I'm curious if he has the telltale SS tattoo under their armpit. They would 0.76
00:18:28 have an SS tattoo and then their blood type. Now, I wonder if Yaroslav Hanke has that. It would be
00:18:33 terrifying to find out. This guy sort of sneaked into Canada. According to David Pagliese, Canada's
00:18:41 leading military journalist and historian, a lot of these guys sneaked into Canada by changing the
00:18:47 name of the battalion. They said instead of part of the 14th Vafin SS, they were with the 1st
00:18:53 Ukrainian Battalion. And about 2,000 of these folks managed to sneak into Canada. This guy,
00:18:58 Yaroslav Hanke kept a low profile for a long time. I mean, he's 98. Maybe he was worried that some
00:19:04 Mossad Nazi hunter would show up one day and get him, but he's 98. And imagine getting the phone
00:19:11 call. You're a Nazi. You've been living low key. You sort of lied to get into Canada. One day you 0.99
00:19:15 get a phone call from the government, not to prosecute you, but to champion you as this hero.
00:19:21 Anthony Roda literally called him a hero. I got a question for you. Do you think for one second
00:19:29 that being a guest of honor for the entire parliament, when the foreign president of
00:19:37 Ukraine is there, so you've got high security, everyone's been going through the metal detector
00:19:41 because this guy Zelensky is under an assassination risk. Do you think for one second that Yaroslav
00:19:48 hunker was not scrutinized by not just one but probably 10 people do you really think trudeau
00:19:55 the master thespian didn't know who was who and you think christia freeland whose own grandfather
00:20:02 was a ukrainian nazi who actually expropriated a newspaper from a jew and turned it into a
00:20:08 nazi propaganda machine do you think for a second that christia freeland didn't know exactly what 0.99
00:20:13 was going on and you were so right andrew these liberals call everyone a nazi it's projection
00:20:21 they are the nazi lovers and it wasn't until the internet including myself
00:20:28 connected the dots no regime media bothered to say oh who's that guy fighting against russia oh
00:20:35 that's our friend why did it take independent journalists like myself when not a single
00:20:40 regime journalists said, hmm, that's a bit weird. Who would have fought against Russia
00:20:46 in the early 40s? Well, on that note, I mean, the most charitable interpretation for this is that
00:20:54 they are idiots, is that you have people that don't understand the history or lack the logic 1.00
00:21:00 and reason to just put two and two together. You don't buy that, it sounds like. You know, 1.00
00:21:05 Jaspal Atwal, and you guys broke this story. He was the terrorist. The judge called him a terrorist
00:21:11 who was convicted of attempted murder when an Indian cabinet minister was visiting BC. Jaspal
00:21:17 Atwal tried to kill him. He was convicted, declared a terrorist. Justin Trudeau invited
00:21:22 him to go to India with him. Oh, I didn't know. You didn't know? Or you were playing domestic 0.77
00:21:28 politics. Just like Trudeau plays domestic politics with the Sikh community, he plays 0.99
00:21:32 domestic politics with the large Ukrainian-Canadian community. And by the way, my family's originally
00:21:37 from Ukraine as well, from the city of Dnipro. So I'm not hostile to Ukraine. I just think that
00:21:43 you got 2,000 Nazis who came from Ukraine to Canada. Most of them have passed away. You find
00:21:48 the one guy who's 98, he's probably one of the, I'd be surprised if there's five others in the
00:21:53 whole country. You found the one Nazi, not a fake Nazi, not a rhetorical Nazi, not a neo-Nazi,
00:22:01 but a real nazi who's probably got the ss tattoo under the armpit who probably if he was active for 0.82
00:22:09 so many years probably murdered a few jews and a few resistance fighters he probably did andrew i
00:22:16 mean i don't know you don't have any evidence specifically i don't man i i absolutely don't
00:22:22 and he will go to his grave unprosecuted and he's lived a charmed life andrew he's 98 the last 73
00:22:30 years or 72 years in this country imagine what a bizarre ending to his life he's invited to ottawa
00:22:37 the whole parliament jumps to their feet and applauds him and they call him a hero and he's
00:22:42 thinking i'm vindicated i'm redeemed adolf hitler's must be thrilled with them and then it all comes
00:22:48 undone what a bizarre bizarre life i i've seen i mean there was i can't remember the name of it now
00:22:54 There was a mini series on Netflix about John Dimanovich was, or Dimanovich, I recall the name, the one they thought was, you know, Ivan the Terrible.
00:23:04 And, you know, you watch this and you just see this horrible, horrible man, but to his family, he's grandpa.
00:23:10 He's the guy that they've known that has probably never committed any criminal wrong for the last 70, 80 years of his life.
00:23:16 And here we have a guy who's probably in a very similar boat.
00:23:19 He's known as a loving family guy, community guy.
00:23:22 if he had just kept his head down for two years he goes to his grave with nothing now this is his
00:23:28 legacy and i i mean i don't think that there was any 3d chess being played here to try to destroy
00:23:34 this uh family's life but my goodness that's the consequence of this because now no one will rest
00:23:39 until they understand this people that had never heard of this division are now asking questions
00:23:43 about whoa why did canada just open up its doors to people that had done this let me throw a few
00:23:49 quick things at you before I go. Number one, three months ago, Justin Trudeau went to Kiev and met
00:23:54 with Martin Melnick. He was Ukraine's ambassador to Germany, and he was fired by Zelensky for
00:24:06 denying the Holocaust. Fired by Zelensky. Trudeau met with him. Point two, Chrystia Freeland posed, 0.59
00:24:13 And you guys broke this story, too, with the scarf that was for Stepan Bandera, the Ukrainian Nazi.
00:24:21 How many, and by the way, if you look at David Paglia's story in The Ottawa Citizen,
00:24:28 Chrystia Freeland and the government have met with the Nazi as a battalion and instructed the Canadian Armed Forces to keep a low media profile.
00:24:37 So that's not one dalliance with Nazis.
00:24:40 That's two, three, four.
00:24:42 How many times does Justin Trudeau and Chrystia Freeland get to hang out with Nazis and say, whoopsies, didn't mean to?
00:24:50 And remember, Chrystia Freeland's own grandfather was a Nazi, and she helped cover that up for years.
00:24:55 Well, and on the note of Freeland, too, I mean, if we go back to the ignorance argument, the ignorance plea here, Chrystia Freeland, if there is one person in the House of Commons that has no right to plead ignorant, it is Chrystia Freeland, because she knows this history intricately.
00:25:11 it is part of her family history she's got a i think it's like a condo or a house in you know
00:25:16 downtown kiev she knows ukraine well it's like most people like for example if someone had handed
00:25:21 me the bandera flag i wouldn't have known what it was christia freeland did and and that's the
00:25:25 thing is that if there's one person in that government that doesn't get to just hide behind
00:25:29 that it's her yeah you know what i it's amazing how the the regime media are rushing to give
00:25:37 Trudeau and Freeland the benefit of the doubt, when you have a real live SS officer in parliament,
00:25:44 but you call it, but they demonize every conservative, every trucker, everyone who's
00:25:50 worried about gender ideology in school, they call them Nazis. Never again, Andrew, can we accept
00:25:56 the accusation of bigotry or Nazism from the liberals. They are the only government in the
00:26:03 world that I know of that has brought Nazis into Parliament and cheered them. And Trudeau should 1.00
00:26:10 never be allowed to forget that for the rest of his days. You know what? Pierre Trudeau
00:26:16 motorcycled around Montreal with a Nazi helmet in the 40s. It was a big joke. Well, 80 years later,
00:26:23 his son brought a Nazi into Parliament. Justin Trudeau is a disgrace. We should never let him 1.00
00:26:29 forget that yeah and it makes it look quaint when a few years ago the liberals forgot to mention
00:26:34 jews on the plaque of their holocaust memorial i don't know if you remember that and you know
00:26:38 they were that was again another whoopsie uh well ezra i know you have to go i appreciate you coming
00:26:43 on your coverage on this started on twitter and i know we'll carry on into your show tonight at
00:26:48 rebel news so thank you very much thanks my friend bye-bye all right that was ezra levant the rebel
00:26:54 commander of Rebel News. And let me reiterate, as I pointed out to Ezra, I have zero evidence
00:27:00 or knowledge whatsoever of Yaroslav Hanka's individual conduct. We don't know anything
00:27:06 about his war record, and we wouldn't have known his name had he not been paraded, at least
00:27:11 metaphorically, in front of Canadians in such a large and public way. And here's the thing. I know
00:27:19 some people in this audience may have varying views on the Ukraine-Russia conflict. I believe
00:27:24 Ukraine is far from perfect, but I believe Russia is the aggressor. And it is interesting when you 0.98
00:27:30 look at Russia's prime argument that they needed to denazify Ukraine. Now, I do not believe Ukraine
00:27:37 has an active Nazi problem. I believe the Azov battalion is a problem, and I believe that we 0.99
00:27:43 should also acknowledge this is a country that elected a Jewish president in Zelensky. Nevertheless,
00:27:49 Ukraine's history does have Nazi problems, and there are certain pockets of the population,
00:27:54 of course, that will hold any number of views, which are reprehensible and should be called out.
00:28:00 But that aside, I'm just making sure you know where I'm coming from on this. Can you imagine
00:28:04 the propaganda win that has been given to Putin and given to Russia by literally Zelensky there
00:28:12 giving a fist up for a Nazi on the floor of the House of Commons of Canada,
00:28:18 one of the countries that's funneling huge amounts of money
00:28:21 into the fight against Russia, the fight for Ukraine.
00:28:23 Imagine how easy Justin Trudeau has made it for Vladimir Putin.
00:28:28 We will have more on this tomorrow, I am sure.
00:28:31 I was going to say we should segue into lighter things.
00:28:34 I don't exactly know how light it is,
00:28:35 but nevertheless, we will move on to a different topic here
00:28:38 because taxpayer waste is a perennial subject in this country.
00:28:42 And as such on the show, we always try to make note of it here.
00:28:45 And the one thing we can always agree on,
00:28:47 regardless of our perspectives on global geopolitical conflict
00:28:51 and all of that, is that we should probably defund the CBC here.
00:28:56 So this is an interesting story.
00:28:58 CBC, which has been under the boot potentially
00:29:01 because Pierre Polyev has pledged to defund it
00:29:04 and turn it into housing for Canadian families.
00:29:07 But CBC has been sitting on, we learned through the latest documents from the Canadian Taxpayers Federation, a $400 million real estate portfolio. $444 million in real estate. It's downtown Toronto headquarters on Front Street is about two-thirds of this, but you have other properties in various parts of the country.
00:29:30 and what's interesting about all of this is that we're looking at CBC which has a budget of about
00:29:37 well a taxpayer subsidy of about 1.3 billion dollars every year that's 1.3 billion that's a
00:29:43 lot of money so if you were to go into government and you were to do nothing else but get rid of
00:29:49 CBC's subsidy which doesn't mean shut it down it just means let it find money on its own or lay
00:29:55 people off and roll back operations to keep costs in check, you would save $1.3 billion a year.
00:30:03 That's astronomical. But then you also take into account CBC's holdings and you say, okay,
00:30:07 we're going to sell these all off. Well, boom, you make $444 million, which is not bad if you
00:30:16 are working towards balancing the budget, which admittedly does seem like it's going to take
00:30:20 the better part of two-thirds of a century to get to. So I was watching with interest when these
00:30:27 documents, which came out from the Canadian Taxpayers Federation originally, and were also
00:30:32 added by an order paper question that was submitted by Conservative MP Adam Chambers,
00:30:37 and they were looking at all of this and finding this is just for 12 properties,
00:30:43 12 corporation-owned properties across the country. Now you throw in other assets into the mix, like
00:30:48 perhaps their camera equipment and some of their audio equipment and Peter Mansbridge's old hair
00:30:54 piece I believe it's actually been donated to a museum but you never know all of this stuff is
00:30:59 part and parcel of where we are going to be getting the money from CBC if we decide to cut
00:31:05 the cord on this Chris Sims joins us every Monday from the Canadian Taxpayers Federation Chris not
00:31:11 that we want to go and start picking out the furniture here but have you set your eyes on
00:31:15 anything right some of those desks look pretty fancy the ones that light up from inside also
00:31:22 the nerd in me wants that robot I don't know if it's still in on duty but do you remember when
00:31:27 we were kids Andrew we found out about these two kind of roller robots that deliver all the mail
00:31:33 to all the CBC employees at that front street location so like you just pointed out it's the
00:31:40 downtown toronto location that takes the lion's share of this money i think it's something crazy
00:31:46 like 300 million dollars or so so yeah if they still have those two little bots that roll around 0.94
00:31:52 like r2d2 delivering uh people's mail uh i'd probably get my dibs on that one well to be
00:31:58 honest i mean the bots could probably do a better job anchoring i think than a lot of the people
00:32:03 they have on air so maybe we just you have to forgo the robot and you instead get rosie barton
00:32:08 And, you know, you'll just basically do a little swap there.
00:32:11 But, you know, I look at this and look, downtown Toronto real estate is important.
00:32:16 I mean, most media companies want to be downtown because they, you know, will get more access and it's easier than just like plopping it out in, you know, like Huntsville, Ontario or something.
00:32:25 But we know that CBC is incapable of doing anything affordably.
00:32:30 And this is a day and age in which, I mean, True North has been growing as a media organization with an all remote operation.
00:32:36 I know you're doing this show as you do a lot of your work from home in Alberta.
00:32:40 You know, it's not to say they could switch to all remote, but they could probably do with a lot less and choose not to.
00:32:46 Yeah, they really could.
00:32:47 We have different examples across Canada of journalist owned TV stations, for example.
00:32:53 There's one in Victoria where it was going to get shut down and the journalists got together and they said, hey, we don't feel like being unemployed.
00:33:01 How about we actually buy into this thing?
00:33:03 and it's a very humble modest operation but they get their news out every single day and it works
00:33:09 that way and that's what's funny about it is that whenever we start going after the cbc andrew
00:33:14 saying hey you guys take 1.2 billion dollars per year for folks who can't quite figure out
00:33:20 what a billion is picture a brand new hospital that's how much money this costs right building
00:33:26 a brand new hospital every single year that's what the cbc costs and when we start getting
00:33:31 onto them about that, they'll say something self-serving like, oh, well, what about, you
00:33:35 know, First Nations programming? Uh-uh. When you actually check the documents, they spend more on
00:33:42 their executive suite pay, Andrew, than they do on First Nations programming. And instead, when you
00:33:49 turn on something like APTN, for example, which takes a fraction of the taxpayer dollars and does
00:33:55 way more with it. I think they broadcast in 12 different First Nations languages. So the CBC
00:34:01 will try to cloak itself in this, you know, essential service, you know, Canadian fabric
00:34:06 thing. And it just isn't that anymore. And the example of that downtown Toronto location
00:34:12 is exactly it. Well, and the one thing I would point out too, is that CBC likes to hide behind
00:34:18 that. They like to hide behind their Northern coverage and their rural and remote coverage.
00:34:23 which by the way, most folks in rural parts of the country
00:34:25 want nothing to do with CBC,
00:34:26 but that's neither here nor there.
00:34:28 But you go to cbc.ca
00:34:29 and none of that stuff is what's on the homepage.
00:34:32 They've got their latest news story
00:34:34 in which they're competing with private media outlets.
00:34:36 They've got commercial advertising,
00:34:38 again, competing with private media outlets.
00:34:42 I'm scrolling down here.
00:34:43 They've got CBC Gem.
00:34:45 So, oh, I can watch some Dragon's Den
00:34:47 or some 22 Minutes.
00:34:49 Okay, well, you know, 22 Minutes is an example
00:34:52 of something the market wouldn't provide. So probably for other reasons, but the things that
00:34:56 they like doing are the things that are the popular stuff that competes with private players.
00:35:02 I mean, they want to play the Olympics and they want to hold the Oscars. That's what they want to
00:35:06 be doing. Because then, so you get into this, this vortex of them trying to do stuff that's
00:35:13 popular so they get people to watch them, but them also not providing the things that they
00:35:18 actually are supposed to through their mandate. And so it's this vicious little cycle that goes
00:35:23 round and round. And they've already lost Hockey Night in Canada. Why are they duplicating the
00:35:27 things that private enterprises are trying to now compete with them with? It goes back to,
00:35:33 you remember a few years ago before the COVID mess hit everybody, when it came to light that
00:35:38 it's their online print, it's their online physical typing that you can read on their website
00:35:43 that gets the most eyeballs. Well, that's not in their mandate. Their mandate was to broadcast,
00:35:50 that's why it's the Broadcasting Corporation, to Canadians. And then they really rubbed it in
00:35:55 the newspaper website's faces. They started saying things like, no paywall. Okay, so we've got private
00:36:03 media organizations, both right and left, we don't care, private media organizations that are paying
00:36:08 their journalists who are then having a subscription fee so you can read their news online
00:36:14 because they got to eat. They have to pay the bills. CBC takes money from government, takes
00:36:20 money from taxpayers, posts the same story, sometimes duplicating the same story, by the
00:36:25 way, and then actually rubs it in and says no paywall. So they're really eating the lunch
00:36:31 in many cases of private media organizations. And now again, this isn't the smoking gun,
00:36:37 but it really adds to the narrative that the CBC is big and bloated and it is not delivering the
00:36:44 programming that people expect them to. Yeah and I would also add to that as well that when we're
00:36:50 talking about the galvanizing of private media this is the government that as you and I have
00:36:56 spoken about is putting in Bill C-18 because they believe it's the responsibility of big tech
00:37:00 companies to save media in Canada and that the government is the one that should just you know
00:37:05 play with the puppet strings here. Well, if you were to take out this big competitor that's
00:37:10 basically bigfooting them, that would help them more than C18 will, which has effectively banned
00:37:16 them from social media. Yes. And to make it worse, C18 will actually give the CBC the lion's share
00:37:23 of that money. So at first this was basically- Oh no, no. I asked Pablo Rodriguez about that.
00:37:29 And he said, the Australian experts say it won't. Oh, well then if Australia is doing it,
00:37:34 then we don't need to discover it anymore.
00:37:36 Stop studying, everybody.
00:37:37 We're good.
00:37:38 Seriously, this is how this works.
00:37:40 I've spoken to the people who actually helped read and write the legislation.
00:37:43 It's the cumulative amount of links that are posted.
00:37:47 And so if you add all those up in like a little bucket,
00:37:49 like we were just describing with their eyeballs they get for online print,
00:37:52 guess what?
00:37:53 They get the lion's share.
00:37:54 Now, at first, this was big tech versus media.
00:37:57 So we're like, not exactly taxpayers.
00:37:59 But now it's big tech being forced to pay money to government media, to the CBC, which is just a wing of the federal government.
00:38:08 So now this is a tax issue.
00:38:11 Wanted to turn away from CBC for a moment, although I should point out that Pierre Polyev has said he can't wait until this Toronto real estate is given up to Canadian families as housing. 0.60
00:38:22 So if you're looking for a condo on Front Street, when Polyev's in there, you might be able to get one. 0.96
00:38:27 You can do the Man's Bridge suite and the Barton suite.
00:38:29 it'll be wonderful but i want to ask you about this cabinet retreat the liberals got together
00:38:34 in pei a little while back spent 275 000 on this retreat now this was cabinet this wasn't the big
00:38:43 caucus retreat for all 170 of them or whatever this was uh or no there weren't there aren't that
00:38:48 many now but however it is uh this was just the cabinet 275 like how much is lobster going for
00:38:55 this is what they were billing this was just brutal and so credit where it's due our folks
00:39:00 at black locks reporter dug up these documents and you're right this was get this folks so remember
00:39:05 last summer when inflation was really bad i mean it's really bad now but it was really bad at the
00:39:10 grocery store it was a real fight to try to afford even hamburger for your cart remember also that's
00:39:16 when interest rates started skyrocketing okay things were tough a year ago the cabinet of
00:39:22 prime minister justin trudeau's government got together and said holy smokes look at all this
00:39:26 wreckage let's have a an inflation summit okay that's a good idea but instead of having the
00:39:32 meeting in one of the dozen meeting rooms that they have access to in ottawa they jetted out
00:39:38 actually this one andrew was in vancouver oh this was the van this was last year sorry my mistake
00:39:43 yeah so this was at the hyatt in vancouver right they're not schlepping it on the east coast they're
00:39:47 on the expensive west coast here they blew like you said two hundred and seventy five thousand
00:39:52 dollars but get this forty six thousand dollars was on catering catering the the tone deafness
00:40:01 the let them eat cake level of this is almost vicariously embarrassing you're looking at it
00:40:07 saying people are struggling they're lining up at food banks they're cutting coupons they can barely
00:40:12 make it and you blow 46 grand on catering to yourself and there are 39 cabinet ministers so
00:40:19 that is more than a thousand dollars a person on food alone yeah that's a lot of money that's like
00:40:26 king henry the eighth level eating like we need to monitor them for gout because that's a lot of
00:40:32 shellfish that they'd be eating right i'm just picturing like the old medieval banquet style
00:40:37 of i don't know like you know uh pablo rodriguez just gnawing on like a giant turkey jump drumstick
00:40:43 and be like bring me bring me some more mead there's like a goblet in one hand and this big
00:40:48 bone meat in the other hand yeah that's what it would have been like and this is where it gets
00:40:52 gross king harry does canadian politics or something exactly this is their job to care
00:40:59 about the mess frankly they created through both money printing and carbon taxes so this is their
00:41:04 mess, inflation, and it's their job to deal with it. They make around close to $300,000 each for
00:41:12 salary. All of their expenses are always paid in Ottawa. But instead, to talk about this critical
00:41:18 issue of affordability, they jet out to Vancouver and stuff themselves with 46 grand worth of
00:41:23 catering. It's really bad. I should tell that this is a silly story, but I think it's an interesting
00:41:28 one. The Liberals in 2015 had a caucus retreat, so they weren't in government yet, in London,
00:41:34 Ontario. And this is when I had the opportunity to interview. The only time I've ever interviewed
00:41:38 Justin Trudeau was at this point. I remember that. And I didn't go too well for him. But
00:41:42 Sun News was around. They like played that tape until it broke. It was great. But I was out and
00:41:46 randomly I was at a mall, which is out uncharacteristic for me. And there was a liberal
00:41:50 MP, Judy Skrow there. And she was coming out of the Bay and I just, she didn't know me. I said,
00:41:55 oh, you know, Judy, I enter a lot and, you know, I'm a radio host in London. I didn't expect to
00:41:59 see you here. And she launched into this stump speech, but well, we're out here stimulating
00:42:03 local economies well i was like i was just saying hi but but it was interesting because it sort of
00:42:08 occurred to me that if we are going to have these retreats and we're going to spend money
00:42:12 why not spend the money in places where it's going to really help why are they not having their
00:42:17 retreat in some rural community where the factory is closed if they're really committed to it it's
00:42:22 because they're not actually interested in solving these problems they want to have a really really
00:42:28 glitzy getaway and that i mean there's no earthly reason that you should have a retreat in vancouver
00:42:33 which is going to cost you more
00:42:35 than anywhere else in the country.
00:42:37 Yeah, it's not so fun to go to Moose Town, right?
00:42:41 Why go there?
00:42:43 Yeah, we're in the caucus retreat in Lethbridge.
00:42:45 Exactly.
00:42:46 Don't give them ideas
00:42:47 and then I'll have to hammer them with questions.
00:42:49 But you're right.
00:42:50 They could be doing something like that
00:42:52 in order to do that.
00:42:53 But also we start worrying about costs there
00:42:55 because then you're hop, skip and jump flying.
00:42:57 Just have them in Ottawa, for goodness sake.
00:43:00 taxpayers pay a lot of money to maintain these buildings. They're all staffed. Everything's
00:43:05 transcribed. They already have hot meals delivered to them every day up on Parliament Hill. Why
00:43:11 outsource this to a different location and then charge people more money? And the very fact that
00:43:17 this was a special inflation summit in order to deal with the little people's problems. This was 0.99
00:43:24 straight out of Orwell. You know, all animals are equal, but some animals are more equal than
00:43:28 others. It's that scene at the end of the book where they're peeking through the window and they
00:43:32 can't tell the difference between the pigs and the farmers. You misunderstand, Chris. They're
00:43:36 trying to show us how bad inflation is by spending so much because this is just, it's tough for a
00:43:41 Liberal cabinet in this economy. I think we should actually just do full convergence here.
00:43:45 Next Liberal cabinet retreat, have it at CBC headquarters. We've already paid for it.
00:43:49 Done. I'm already catered to by the robots. All right. Before it gets kicked out and converted
00:43:53 to housing. Chris Sims from the Canadian Taxpayers Federation. Always great to talk to you. We will
00:43:59 see you next Monday. You betcha. All right. That was Chris Sims. My thanks to her and to Ezra
00:44:05 Levant for coming on the show today. We will talk to you tomorrow in 23 hours and 15 minutes here on
00:44:11 The Andrew Lawton Show, Canada's most irreverent talk show. Thank you. God bless and good day to
00:44:16 you all. Thanks for listening to The Andrew Lawton Show. Support the program by donating to True
00:44:21 North at www.tnc.news.
00:44:51 We'll be right back.
00:45:21 We'll be right back.