Juno News - May 27, 2024


Liberals might let illegal immigrants stay in Canada

Topics
Mentioned
More human caused fires in Alberta Liberal MP pushing Trudeau to recognize "Palestinian state"

Episode Stats


Length

43 minutes

Words per minute

174.0

Word count

7,636

Sentence count

264

Harmful content

Misogyny

1

sentences flagged

Toxicity

1

sentences flagged

Hate speech

8

sentences flagged


Summary

Summaries generated with gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ .

In this episode of The Andrew Lawton Show: Canada's Most Irreverent Talk Show, Andrew talks about his recent trip to Taiwan, and why he thinks Canada should take illegal migrants and let them stay in Canada.

Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Topics generated with Qwen2.5-3B-Instruct.
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 Transcription by CastingWords
00:00:30 Thank you.
00:01:00 Welcome to Canada's Most Irreverent Talk Show.
00:01:16 This is The Andrew Lawton Show, brought to you by True North.
00:01:24 I'm back, baby!
00:01:26 Hello, welcome to The Andrew Lawton Show,
00:01:28 Canada's most irreverent talk show here on True North.
00:01:32 The Andrew Lawton Show hosted once again by Andrew Lawton.
00:01:36 Yeah, that's me. Hi there. Howdy ho.
00:01:38 Thank you so much to the great Chris Sims for filling in in my absence.
00:01:44 We will have Chris back on the show.
00:01:46 You have to wean yourself off of Chris Sims.
00:01:49 You can't go cold turkey on quitting Chris Sims.
00:01:53 So she'll be back on for her regular Monday spot in just about, I don't know, 13 minutes or so.
00:01:58 as we enter Monday afternoon, at least Monday afternoon in Eastern Canada.
00:02:03 Don't hold that against me here.
00:02:04 It's been a busy week.
00:02:06 So I was in Taiwan last week, and I've never been to the country before.
00:02:11 I was supposed to go at the invitation of the Taiwanese government in 2020,
00:02:16 but you may recall there was a little, you know, just minor tiny disruption
00:02:20 to international travel that took place then.
00:02:23 I got postponed, postponed, postponed, and then I was supposed to go last year
00:02:28 or it might have been early this year.
00:02:29 And I had to cancel, there was something I had to cancel.
00:02:32 I can't remember what it was.
00:02:33 And Harrison Faulkner, my colleague at True North,
00:02:35 went as well and he had such a wonderful time.
00:02:38 I was very grateful the Taiwanese government had me back.
00:02:41 So over the next few days,
00:02:42 I'll have some written coverage from my time there
00:02:45 talking to a very resilient people
00:02:47 in a part of the world where they live every day
00:02:50 with the threat of China entering,
00:02:53 the threat of Chinese invasion.
00:02:55 And the fact that that is just a thing
00:02:57 that they talk about as flippantly as we talk about the carbon tax in Canada. Like, oh yeah,
00:03:02 just, you know, China could invade any day now is quite remarkable. And I met some amazing people
00:03:07 there. I learned a lot about semiconductors, about the Taiwan Strait, about defense, and a little bit
00:03:12 about stinky tofu, which I did not try. I didn't chicken out. It was just that I didn't have an
00:03:18 opportunity and I didn't create an opportunity. But anyway, if you've been to Taiwan or familiar
00:03:23 with stinky tofu you'll know i did smell stinky tofu and let me tell you it very much lives up to
00:03:28 its name but we'll have some more updates on that as over the course of the week i do want to talk
00:03:34 about this bonkers bonkers story that i came back to canada to where mark miller this is the
00:03:40 immigration minister that's like finally along with justin trudeau conceding that maybe just maybe
00:03:47 they've had too much in the way of immigration to this country to not strain the system and 0.96
00:03:56 mark miller is now talking about a very novel idea he is uh finding a weird way of making the
00:04:02 immigration system work so take undocumented migrants and let them stay in canada now uh this 0.97
00:04:10 is when we are seeing just put that headline up again there if you don't mind sean so i just want
00:04:15 want to point out, this is the Globe and Mail taking the Liberal government's framing on this.
00:04:25 You see how they say undocumented migrants. So undocumented, you hear this in the United States
00:04:30 as well, it actually means illegal. These are people who are in the country illegally. Maybe
00:04:35 they came in legally on a visitor visa, on a student visa, the visa expired, they never left.
00:04:41 they are without legal status. They are illegal, you might say, but the government euphemistically
00:04:47 calls them undocumented. So Mark Miller is putting a plan to cabinet, to the Trudeau government to
00:04:52 let illegal migrants in Canada stay in Canada legally. So all of a sudden people that maybe
00:04:59 cut the line, people that wouldn't have been eligible to come in through existing permanent
00:05:03 residence streams, didn't want to wait, people that just had no disregard for the law, we're
00:05:08 going to perhaps give them legal status. Now, it's not happening yet. It's still a potential
00:05:14 proposal. It's a thing the government is mulling doing, but I wouldn't put it past them. And in
00:05:19 fact, it would be very par for the course on this government, a government that has at every turn
00:05:23 just decided to crap all over the integrity of the immigration system and have no regard for the 0.99
00:05:30 many, many, many immigrants that did everything right, that played by the rules because they 0.54
00:05:36 believe in the rules and they believe in Canada and they don't want to, again, I don't want to
00:05:41 use a crass term here, but they don't want to just, I'm not coming up with anything that's not
00:05:48 crass. They don't want to piss all over the laws of this country when they come here. So this is,
00:05:54 I think, quite devastating. Again, not all that surprising and I wouldn't be surprised to see it
00:05:59 come to fruition in the next few months. And again, what better way to generate some new voters
00:06:05 then all of a sudden taking people who are in here illegally and saying ta-da you're going to
00:06:10 be legal you can be a citizen in just a couple of years and then hey you can vote liberal what
00:06:15 what do you know vote for the government that let you stay here when you were probably on track to
00:06:21 be deported not that canada is doing much in the way of deportations even among those who have had
00:06:26 deportation ordered now i this is a clip from a press conference this morning by a group called
00:06:32 the Migrant Rights Network, making this demand that Mark Miller is now seeking.
00:06:39 Speaking to you from the unceded and never surrendered territory of the Algonquin
00:06:43 Unisputed Peoples, and my pronouns are she, her, L. So I'm here today to show union solidarity
00:06:49 with undocumented workers and their families, women, 2SL, LGBTQI, plus migrants, all who have
00:06:57 living in fear of being detected and being deported. Undocumented people live here and 1.00
00:07:03 build our communities and our economy. But without status, they are vulnerable to abuse and
00:07:08 exploitation. And growing racism and xenophobia are making them even more vulnerable. Employers
00:07:16 can violate their rights of undocumented workers, stealing wages, forcing them into unsafe working 0.98
00:07:22 conditions stopping workers from asserting their rights under the threat of deportation.
00:07:28 This abuse results in an overall worsening of wages and working conditions for migrants
00:07:33 and citizens alike. Regularization will allow workers to leave bad jobs and punish bad actors.
00:07:40 It's leveling the playing field of improving working conditions for everyone. That is why in
00:07:46 in 2019, we as a CLC and our affiliated unions launched a small pilot to give permanent residency
00:07:52 to undocumented workers in the greater Toronto area. A broad regularization program means that
00:07:59 people can now contribute to the fullest potential to Canada's economic and social future. We,
00:08:05 the Canadian Labour Congress, call on the government to do what is right. Bring in regularization now.
00:08:12 i i love the term regularization not uh not legalization not amnesty regularization take
00:08:20 people who are remember when the liberal government was talking about irregular border
00:08:24 crossers no they they mean illegal border crossers undocumented immigrants irregular immigrants no
00:08:30 you mean people who are in the country illegally all of the fears that she just describes the fear 0.99
00:08:36 of being detected and deported well those are fears that could be allayed by wait hang on it's
00:08:44 just on the tip of my tongue there's there's there's got to be a solution by not being in the
00:08:50 country illegally look i i love canada i love this country and i love that so many people from around
00:08:55 the world love this country which is why we have one of the most generous generous approaches to
00:09:03 immigration in the world. We allow so many opportunities for people from all around the
00:09:08 world to come here on a temporary basis and even on a permanent basis. We have 500,000 new permanent
00:09:15 resident slots a year, a number the Liberal government has committed to increasing over the
00:09:21 last several years. And the next couple of years, we have pathways because we believe that we should,
00:09:26 as a country share in the bounty. So I have very little regard and respect. In fact, I'll say I
00:09:34 have no respect for people that simply do not want to follow the law. And by the way, when she talks
00:09:41 about the contributions of undocumented migrants to Canada, what she's missing here is that these
00:09:51 are people who their first order of business as potential Canadians is to disregard the laws of
00:09:56 the country. Their first order of business. How much can you build yourself up as a would-be
00:10:03 citizen of a country when your foray into Canadian-ness is built on a lie? It's built on you 0.86
00:10:10 violating the laws, not respecting the laws. Now, these are people, they have not sought asylum
00:10:17 necessarily. In some cases, maybe they've sought asylum and have had their requests rejected again
00:10:22 because we determined that that was not a way they were supposed to come into the country.
00:10:25 these are in many cases people who have had an international student visa then they just never
00:10:31 return home they just try to sort of hide and hope no one notices and she says they're vulnerable to
00:10:36 abuse yeah because they don't have status they're not legally able to work here so the fact that
00:10:42 the government's answer to that is all right well yeah you beat us you did it one way or another
00:10:47 we're gonna let you stay now like what motivation is there for other people to not do the same thing
00:10:54 you know there was a reason that joe biden's big giant like magic wand disappearance of federal
00:11:00 student loans was so concerning because all the people who had paid their student loans were
00:11:04 looking around and being like well hang on what why did i do it right where's my gift where's my
00:11:08 great privilege and and what a slap in the face this proposal is that the government is even
00:11:13 considering this to every single hard-working immigrant in this country who came here and did 0.99
00:11:19 everything right, who waited years to come to this country, who did everything right to start a
00:11:25 business, to get a job, to bring their family in here, to support their family, to contribute to
00:11:29 the Canadian economy. And now they realize, oh, well, all we had to do was just come here,
00:11:34 oversee our visa, hang out, lie low for a little bit. And then ta-da, the government would just
00:11:39 say, well, it doesn't really matter. That's what these activists are seeking. This is what the
00:11:44 Liberal government is entertaining. Now, I don't know if this was exactly the reason that some
00:11:50 Liberals have started to sour on their government. I suspect the timing is just coincidental there,
00:11:56 but I think it's interesting to note that Liberals are not exactly feeling the love when it comes to
00:12:01 Justin Trudeau. So, unrelated story, but I saw in the Hill Times this morning, this is the headline,
00:12:07 crappy polling numbers make some Liberal MPs uneasy about electoral prospects, but still consider
00:12:13 next election worth fighting oh that was a quote i'm glad liberal mps still think the next election
00:12:18 is worth fighting interesting but here is the interesting part for me sean casey who's a
00:12:26 liberal mp from atlantic canada he was doing an interview with the hill times and he's doing the
00:12:32 big rah-rah-rah we've got a year to turn it around the campaign's gonna matter we've got to get
00:12:36 people engaged canadians we owe it to canadians to keep plugging to keep working so he's really
00:12:41 trying to rally the troops and say the liberals can turn it around. And then we go to this
00:12:45 paragraph here. Well, a few paragraphs. When asked whether given low public support for the
00:12:51 Liberal Party and the Prime Minister, Justin Trudeau is the right person to lead the party
00:12:55 in the election, Sean Casey declined to say. That's his decision, he said. My opinion doesn't
00:13:04 matter pressed again he said i'm not going to share my opinion with the public never have three
00:13:12 paragraphs said so much about the state of canadian politics so for starters we have a liberal mp
00:13:17 saying his opinion doesn't matter his opinion of his own party's leader does not matter he says
00:13:22 it's not not up for him as a caucus member as a liberal to decide no no it is up to justin trudeau
00:13:28 alone to decide so justin trudeau yeah maybe technically trudeau is the guy that has to
00:13:34 decide whether he's going to stay or go before the next election but it's hardly a ringing
00:13:40 endorsement of justin trudeau that liberal mps are not even able to utter the words i support
00:13:46 him or not able to utter the words i think he can do a good job sean casey is one of these guys
00:13:51 that's probably going to lose his seat probably going to lose his seat in large part due to
00:13:58 the liberal government's just horrendous approach right now it's horrendous track record
00:14:03 and it's horrendous campaign because justin trudeau is and this may come as a shock to
00:14:07 everyone well basically it may come as a shock to justin trudeau he is not that popular right
00:14:12 now people that have been liberals for years people that were inspired by him in 2015 are
00:14:17 now saying okay can we just get like just get rid of the guy for crying out loud and it's why pierre
00:14:22 Paulie have that guy behind me there is doing so well because he is now capturing into an energy
00:14:29 and a hope and an optimism that Trudeau by the way a decade ago had harnessed he did that when
00:14:35 he was up against Stephen Harper so this is where we talk about the declining fortunes of the
00:14:41 liberals but even the liberal so if you have a liberal MP ask them on the record film it what
00:14:47 they think of Justin Trudeau as leader and see if they're as equivocal as Sean Casey is there
00:14:52 Just since I mentioned the book, my book, Pierre Polyev, A Political Life,
00:14:57 technically comes out tomorrow, although like everyone's been reading it now.
00:15:01 Indigo put it on shelves early.
00:15:03 Amazon's been shipping it out.
00:15:04 My publisher has been shipping it out.
00:15:05 So I was kind of when I was away last week in Taiwan, I was caught off guard because
00:15:09 I was expecting I'd have that week and not have to worry about it.
00:15:12 And then all of a sudden I'm fielding like interview requests every which way because
00:15:16 the book was basically out.
00:15:18 But several of you have already said you've gotten a copy and have started reading it.
00:15:22 thank you so much if that's the case. If not, you can grab your copy from Amazon, from Indigo,
00:15:28 from your local neighborhood bookstore. You can also grab it from, well, where else? From
00:15:33 Sutherland House, the publisher directly. And they, not that this is the reason you should do it,
00:15:37 but they have like the neatest packaging job they ever do that anyone could do if you order a book
00:15:42 from there. But anyway, all that out of the way, we will have a lot on this book. And I have an
00:15:47 excerpt in the line today, which is Jen Gerson's and Matt Gurney's publication about the story of
00:15:53 Pierre and Anna Polyev. So if you're interested on how that dynamic duo got coupled up in the
00:15:59 first place, read that excerpt and the full details are in that book there. But all of that
00:16:04 aside, we were very well looked after last week with Chris Sims, regularly our Monday guest,
00:16:11 but last week she took the reins in my Taiwanese absence. Chris, welcome back. Thank you so much
00:16:16 for uh holding down the fort last week well it was an honor to be asked andrew truly and thank
00:16:20 you so much to yourself and the team and all of your viewers and listeners they were very kind on
00:16:24 their youtube comments so thanks so much for that i i'm glad i i didn't get a chance to i didn't get
00:16:29 a chance to watch any whole shows because of the uh the time difference but i saw some clips you
00:16:32 did a bang up job as always and let me ask you about this cbc business so i woke up uh franco
00:16:39 terrazzano your colleague and our regular guest here uh from the ctf has decided to put the gears
00:16:45 to CBC for, shockingly, not being transparent about the money it's dishing out. What's going
00:16:51 on there? Yeah, for sure. Franco actually just went home because his mom famously lives around
00:16:55 the corner from me here in Lethbridge. So he actually did an interview from this chair like
00:17:00 last week. So that would have been a little bit funny for people to see. But yeah, Franco
00:17:04 Terrazzano and our team there at the Ottawa Bureau for the Canadian Taxpayers Federation,
00:17:09 we are quite often demanding transparency and accountability from the state broadcaster,
00:17:15 from the CBC because, of course, they take about $1.4 billion from us every year. That's a heck
00:17:21 of a ton of money. And quite often we find a lot of funny answers, right? They're playing fast and
00:17:28 loose with some numbers quite often, especially at the CEO and the managerial level. So we wanted
00:17:35 to know, Andrew, how much the seven top executives were paid out in bonuses. So we filed an access
00:17:43 to information request. Now they were due to release that information within a certain window
00:17:49 of time but what the CBC did is they filed a 30-day extension. That extension just so happened to kick
00:17:57 that information down past CEO Catherine Tate's appearance at committee. We wonder why. But it's
00:18:04 worse than that, Andrew, because when they did finally cough up some information about the
00:18:09 executive pay scale on May 10th, they didn't mention how much of this was bonuses, which is
00:18:16 exactly what we were asking for. All they gave us was this overall number. So out of the seven
00:18:22 executives at the CBC, we paid around $3.7 million with an M. That works out to about $540,000 per
00:18:33 person but we don't know how much of that is bonuses like we don't have the actual details
00:18:39 so we have launched a legal challenge with the office of the information commissioner
00:18:44 and we hope the cbc will be much more forthcoming now yeah i mean the problem with the the access
00:18:50 to information system in canada is that it's incredibly incredibly broken it's incredibly
00:18:55 backlogged and because so many government departments are terrible at managing their
00:18:59 a tip request the oic the office of the information commissioner is uh typically i mean i i more often
00:19:05 than not when i file complaints with them about uh these issues uh they'll respond like six months
00:19:10 later after the department i was complaining about has responded and said oh it seems like it's all
00:19:15 sorted out now okay great so are you gonna let them off the hook is what i'm asking no this is
00:19:21 one of those things that i think our supporters uh with the taxpayers federation and i'm guessing a
00:19:26 a lot of your viewers, we don't have patience for that.
00:19:29 So the CBC is not a private company, okay?
00:19:32 If they were a private company, the Taxpayers Federation wouldn't care what the CEOs are
00:19:36 making in bonuses or salary.
00:19:38 This is not.
00:19:39 It is government-funded media to the hilt.
00:19:42 So again, taxpayers are handing over $1.4 billion.
00:19:46 That could build a state-of-the-art super fancy hospital.
00:19:50 could pay for 7,000 paramedics and 7,000 cops every year on our streets. But instead, we're
00:19:57 handing it to the CBC, which, by the way, of course, is tanking in its ratings. So a tiny
00:20:02 little fraction of Canadians are now watching their supper hour news. They won't even come
00:20:07 clean, frankly, about their ratings that way. Do you remember, Andrew, the last time that Tate was
00:20:12 at committee? She said something to the effect of, oh, yes, we know that the TV ratings are
00:20:17 are nosediving that we're really losing viewers there, but we're making up for it in GEM subscriptions,
00:20:23 which is their online app or something. And it's like, okay, how many GEM subscriptions do you have?
00:20:29 Oh, we don't share that information. Like it's so secretive and they have no right to be because
00:20:34 this is taxpayer's money. So that is again, why we are going kind of elbows up here. Like we asked
00:20:40 nicely, there was an extension. And even then when they coughed up some information, they didn't give
00:20:46 us the exact amount of the bonuses, which is what we want. And to be clear, this isn't just the CBC,
00:20:53 right? The CBC is the one that is not behaving properly here. When we asked Canada Mortgage
00:20:57 and Housing Corporation this kind of information, they told us. When we asked the Bank of Canada,
00:21:02 another crown, this sort of information, they told us. But it's the CBC that is playing funny
00:21:08 with these numbers. I remember years and years ago, you'd probably remember better than I am,
00:21:13 CBC had given, because they were really getting dragged for not being transparent about salaries.
00:21:18 And they had published this ridiculous, like fake list of salaries that had like their top people making like, you know, four and a half dollars a year.
00:21:26 It was not that bad, but it was like, they were basically saying that everyone was working for, I think it was like $80,000 a year.
00:21:31 Yeah, exactly.
00:21:32 Including like people like Peter Mansbridge.
00:21:34 Yeah.
00:21:35 Like he was making under $200,000 based on this scale.
00:21:38 I remember that coming out.
00:21:39 I think that was just after Sun News Network was shut down or around that same time.
00:21:43 It was laughable because, of course, anyone who's worked in the news industry knows for a fact that that's not true.
00:21:50 OK, especially back in the day of when anchormen and I use that term affectionately when anchormen were paid the big bucks.
00:21:58 OK, that included in both private and in government funded news media.
00:22:03 If you anchored the evening news, you were pulling in the dough.
00:22:06 Now, that has changed dramatically, of course, especially in the private sector, as viewership has completely fallen off of a cliff.
00:22:14 From what I understand, anchors are now making a fraction of what they used to back in the day.
00:22:20 And by the day, I mean like 10 years ago.
00:22:23 And interesting, I would love for, so I know that there's some people who watch your show for fun who probably still hold down jobs within the mother corp.
00:22:31 I really want to know, Andrew, how much their at-issue panel is paid.
00:22:35 because we've asked several different ways. And of course they try to say, oh,
00:22:39 that's commercially sensitive, blah, blah, blah. We can't let that out because it's kind of like
00:22:43 a talent fee. But back when I worked at CTV a billion years ago, the rumor was that those
00:22:49 ad issue panel hits were between 250 and 350 per hit. Meaning every time they opened their mouths
00:22:58 on like a weeknight show, they were getting paid that amount of money. I would love to know if
00:23:03 that's still the same or if it has declined no and i i recall that because i know someone that
00:23:08 went on that didn't want money and they literally didn't have a mechanism to let them do it for free
00:23:14 and it was because they're a union shop that was basically why so it's like guests are getting like
00:23:19 like i'm typically lucky like i'll like i've never paid to be a guest but you know getting paid to be
00:23:24 a guest is an incredible rarity i'm not even sure if it's ever uh come to think of it happened so
00:23:28 i'm getting paid what i'm worth i guess in that sense but uh it's it's brutal and i'll ask you
00:23:33 chris about this do you think it's time for a federal sunshine list oh yeah yeah big time so
00:23:40 here in alberta all of these issues would go away if the federal government did what say they're
00:23:44 doing in ontario every year yes exactly so ontario does it well alberta has a version of a sunshine
00:23:49 lift i list i think it's at 125 000 it used to be at 100 000 but you know inflation and so now i
00:23:57 believe it's 125,000. In fact, Andrew, it's funny you should mention that. The CTF just finished
00:24:02 presenting at committee a few weeks ago, where the NDP opposition here in Alberta was pushing
00:24:09 really hard to have unionized jobs within the government within the provincial government
00:24:14 exempt from the sunshine list. So you know, that's just basically all of them. Like you could just
00:24:20 imagine. Basically, they want managers only not these bureaucrats at the lower level that are
00:24:24 cashing $150,000 a year salaries. Exactly. You're working for AHS and just pulling in the dough,
00:24:30 you know, sitting at a desk and handing paper around to your other four friends all day. Yeah,
00:24:34 they want them exempt from the sunshine list as if, right? And normal people don't go after
00:24:39 like a super hardworking frontline paramedic. Like that just doesn't pass the taste or smell
00:24:44 test with most people. What people want to know is exactly to your point, are there, there's this
00:24:50 huge glut of middle management that is raking in the money. So yes, we definitely need a federal
00:24:56 sunshine list and it should cover all these sort of things. But again, we want the granular data
00:25:01 here, especially when it comes to the executive pay at the CBC. And again, it's really simple.
00:25:07 There's seven of them. How much of that was bonuses? To give you an idea, CEO Catherine
00:25:14 Tate of the CBC is listed as CEO level seven. In federal government talk, they have a grid.
00:25:22 You can find it on the Treasury Department website. She's number seven. As of right now,
00:25:27 2024 to 2025 budget year, she is now making between $468,000 and $551,000. She's also entitled
00:25:39 to up to 28% bonus.
00:25:43 They call it performance pay, but it's a bonus.
00:25:46 So again, that's an awful lot of money.
00:25:49 And taxpayers want to know how much of that money is she paid 1.00
00:25:52 and how much of that money is bonuses.
00:25:55 Especially because, again, their viewership is going downhill.
00:25:58 So few people are watching it.
00:25:59 You usually just get a bonus when you're doing a good job.
00:26:04 Brutal.
00:26:05 And no one who's watched CBC can say that would at all be a term
00:26:09 we'd use to describe them.
00:26:10 Well, great work.
00:26:11 Keep us posted
00:26:11 if you get an update on that.
00:26:13 I expect it'll be any time
00:26:15 in the next decade
00:26:15 that you'll get
00:26:16 that information there.
00:26:18 Chris Sims,
00:26:18 always good to talk to you.
00:26:19 Thanks again for last week
00:26:21 and thanks for coming on today.
00:26:23 You bet.
00:26:23 Thanks, Andrew.
00:26:25 Always good to check in
00:26:26 with our friend Chris Sims.
00:26:28 And of course,
00:26:28 a big thank you once again
00:26:30 to Chris for filling
00:26:31 into my absence last week.
00:26:32 Hopefully you are still
00:26:34 happy to have me back
00:26:34 and she didn't do
00:26:35 like such a good job
00:26:36 that you just don't want
00:26:38 me to return. The one little bit of baseball trivia I know is that I believe that's what
00:26:43 happened to Lou Gehrig, where he was like the fill-in for Wally Pip and then did better than
00:26:48 Wally Pip. And I don't know that because I follow sports. I know that because I heard it referenced
00:26:52 in a sitcom I like. So anyway, don't worry about that. Let's take a look at the bigger picture.
00:26:57 I always like doing that from time to time, especially in this country. And when it comes
00:27:01 to legal matters anyway, there are a few people, in fact, I'd say probably no one better to do it
00:27:07 with then Bruce Pardee, who is the executive director of Rights Probe and also a professor
00:27:13 that is probably worth anyone in law going to Queens just so they have a chance at getting
00:27:19 Bruce Pardee as a prof. Bruce, good to talk to you. Thanks for coming on today.
00:27:22 Great to see you, Andrew. Thank you. That's very kind of you.
00:27:25 You had this great piece in C2C Journal, Canada's constitutional mistake, how the rule of law gave
00:27:32 way to the managerial state and normally with these sorts of things i do like a bit of a wind
00:27:37 up before i bring the guest on but i actually thought it would be more prudent here to let you
00:27:42 describe what is your thesis here what is it you're saying okay here's here's the core of the idea
00:27:49 we we've gone through centuries of legal and political reform in starting in england to go back
00:27:58 to the original problem the original problem was these kings who ruled for centuries and
00:28:05 some of the kings were bad and some of the kings were better but essentially the kings
00:28:10 had absolute power whatever they said was the law and then slowly starting perhaps with the magna
00:28:17 carta in 20 in 1215 we started this long process of taking power away from the king and giving it
00:28:26 to legislatures and eventually we got to the stage in the british system of arriving at this
00:28:34 idea called legislative supremacy meaning the legislature is supreme not the king the
00:28:40 legislature can enact any laws that it wants because after all it has democratic legitimacy
00:28:47 but the problem was this that legislatures turned out that they could be tyrannical as well
00:28:54 as kings and then the americans came along and the newly independent americans said okay we're
00:29:00 going to fix this problem as well we're going to enact a bill of rights and they put that
00:29:04 in their constitution and then 200 years later we did the same thing in canada with the charter of
00:29:08 rights so what they did was take power away from legislatures and give it to courts
00:29:16 problem is that the courts now kind of abuse their power by doing policy and making decisions that
00:29:22 are not based upon the text and the living tree and all these kinds of things you'll hear people
00:29:27 complain about this all the time so here's the problem all we've done from the very beginning
00:29:34 is move power around from place to place to place to place from king to legislature to courts and
00:29:41 now from courts and legislatures back to if you like the king in the in the form of the administrative
00:29:48 state. And so we proceed with this idea that the final word has to rest somewhere, but nowhere
00:29:57 seems to work. And that's the mistake. The mistake is, instead of moving power around,
00:30:04 we should have taken power away, so that the power rests with us individually.
00:30:11 It's a fascinating thesis. And I'm glad I had you explain it, because you did it so eloquently
00:30:16 there. And what strikes me when you describe that there and also in your essay in C2C Journal is
00:30:22 that at every stage, we've been told that the shift is to give power to the people. When power
00:30:29 is taken from the king and given to legislatures, going back to running me to Magna Carta, it's
00:30:34 because, oh, well, the legislators are the representatives of the people. When it's taken
00:30:37 away and you have a constitution, I mean, the sales pitch from the founding fathers of the United
00:30:41 States. And I believe them to, with my knowledge of history, be authentic in this desire was that
00:30:46 we need to put a constraint on the state's power. But you cannot do that without an intermediary,
00:30:53 without an adjudicator. And that's where we go to the courts. Now, I'd say in the United States,
00:30:58 the courts have done a better job at keeping to the intent of the Constitution. But in Canada,
00:31:03 we have the opposite. I mean, the quote that I bring up from our former Chief Justice from time
00:31:08 to time, Beverly McLaughlin, is where she described in her memoir her job as being to take a step back
00:31:13 and hear the facts of the case and then decide what's best for society, which is actually more
00:31:18 dangerous than just letting the legislature have free reign, I think, is to have someone for whom
00:31:23 there is no accountability trying to really, by very definition, socially engineer. So we have
00:31:30 this libertarian utopia that we seek of wanting individuals to be sovereign. How is that possible?
00:31:38 Right. So if you start with the opposite premise, so the premise that we have now essentially is
00:31:46 that the state and the state comprised of these various institutions, legislatures, courts and
00:31:51 administration, that the state has the authority to govern. And these various branches of the state
00:31:59 are supposed to act as checks and balances on each other, but they're all basically on the same page
00:32:03 now. So they don't really act as checks and balances very effectively anymore. So the opposite
00:32:07 premise would be instead of authority of those who govern it would be the consent of those who
00:32:17 are governed and by that I mean not the will of the majority I don't mean consent as a group
00:32:23 I don't mean I don't mean by vote or referendum I mean every person gets to give their individual
00:32:30 consent to be subject to laws. Now, if we're going to premise the system on consent, you start with
00:32:39 that idea, which means by definition, if you like, that no one, whether your fellow citizen or the
00:32:46 state, can impose force against you. They can't coerce you. And that becomes the first rule of
00:32:54 the legal system. No force, no coercion, no threat of force. And then from that, we get all kinds of
00:33:00 rules about theft and battery and assault and all those lots of things that we already know and love
00:33:08 in our legal system. But then once you get beyond that rule, then for all the other rules that have
00:33:15 nothing to do with force, each of those laws requires the individual consent of each individual
00:33:22 citizen without which those citizens are not subject to those laws. Now, that's a radically
00:33:29 different system and people will obviously have lots of questions and and and understandably so
00:33:35 and those questions can be worked out but let's not throw away the idea just because it's strange
00:33:42 because it needs to be strange because the system we have right now isn't working very well
00:33:50 i think there might be some minor steps that have been i i don't want to say missed but really
00:33:56 sub steps that have taken place in this trajectory that you explain and one of them that i studied in
00:34:01 school and i should probably have ted morton on the show to talk about it uh is the establishment
00:34:06 of what i mean you're well aware of it he called the court party which was basically courts
00:34:10 becoming overly deferential to social justice groups and activists and this was like the 1990s
00:34:17 that he wrote this and i think the problem has gotten much worse since then so you even have
00:34:22 within that this subcategory of disproportionate weight being given to special interest groups
00:34:27 which has i guess fallen under the the banner of the judiciary and i i wonder if the next stage of
00:34:33 this the where we're heading is not necessarily ruled by the mob but but ruled to this this even
00:34:41 more obscure and malleable group that is really embedded in the courts embedded into the political
00:34:49 class embedded into the bureaucracy which i mean at its core is really dei
00:34:55 sure yes well what we would say we we have a we have a huge managerial state problem
00:35:03 the way i would put it and the bureaucracy and well frankly all three of them the bureaucracy
00:35:09 the courts and the legislatures uh are are working together essentially i don't mean that they don't
00:35:15 have their disputes and quarrels they do and i don't say i'm not saying that the courts never
00:35:20 overturned decisions of the legislature and or the bureaucracy that's not true either
00:35:25 but in a general sense in a broad sense they all fundamentally agree believe in the need
00:35:33 to manage society and they all work towards that end and so you're not going to have a genuine
00:35:41 check and balance from any of these outfits so you can you can see the way people react
00:35:47 to bad decisions when a court makes one of these creative decisions uh based upon the living tree
00:35:54 or uh you know a interpretation of the words that the words don't really seem to reflect
00:35:59 then they'll complain about the courts having power and fair enough but then you know when
00:36:04 legislatures say that they're going to invoke the notwithstanding clause they react kind of the same
00:36:10 way which is well the the legislature is abusing my charter rights and i want the court to have
00:36:16 the final say but you just finished saying that the court wasn't doing a very good job
00:36:19 and then when we have a bureaucracy bureaucracy making the final call like during covid you know
00:36:25 you'll wear a mask here and take a vaccine there and so on people complain that the that the
00:36:29 bureaucracy is making the calls and not the legislature okay well come on people make up
00:36:34 your mind the problem is there is no good answer to this they're all also it's it's it's word they
00:36:40 want the outcome and they don't really care how they get to the outcome so there's no desire
00:36:45 to be consistent on when they want legislative supremacy and when they want judicial supremacy
00:36:50 it's whatever gets them where they want to go see you you are getting now to the nub of the
00:36:56 difference between what the law actually is and what it actually does compared to what it's thought
00:37:02 to do so one could go so far as to say this the role of the law in society maybe maybe is not
00:37:12 reasoning to a result it's justifying a result that they want to reach and those two things are
00:37:19 quite different and where we may be giving the law too much credit for being you know objective and
00:37:26 solid and immovable and and and immune to the currents of cultural change it's an institution
00:37:34 it's none of those things it's this it's it's liable to be influenced by culture in the same
00:37:39 way that any other of our political institutions are and so we have to acknowledge the reality of
00:37:45 the way the thing works i think there are and you and i have spoken about this in the past
00:37:50 some structural issues in how canada's charter was created this idea of having the section one
00:37:56 which really nullifies much of the rest of the charter the notwithstanding clause itself is
00:38:01 problematic and and i say that to contrast it with the united states which has had a i i think their
00:38:07 bill of rights is a much stronger and more rigid document but but even so the problems between the
00:38:13 two are i think the same in that you know i used to look at the u.s constitution in a much more
00:38:18 favorable light than i do now not because the document itself is flawed but as my friend mark
00:38:23 stein says waving it around in the air doesn't really get you all that much and and that's when
00:38:28 we we go to the point that all of these things are not worth the paper they're printed on literally
00:38:34 if you don't have institutions that are upholding them and we've seen that the institutions are not
00:38:39 as rooted in what they need to be and i guess the question that i i fear asking about is can that
00:38:46 come back well the point that you made about the u.s constitution is quite right i think in many
00:38:51 respects i mean i think it has fared better as of right now than the canadian charter has but
00:38:56 it's not been a straight line i mean like the canadian charter the american bill of rights has
00:39:00 been subject to digital interpretation which is waxed and waned over time and some of the decisions
00:39:05 under the u.s bill of rights have not been decisions that you and i would like over time
00:39:09 so yes your point is quite right that it depends upon the institutions who are applying it
00:39:14 which makes the point that the document itself does not govern it's the people who are making
00:39:19 the decisions who govern and and that and you know it's a funny thing because people instinctively
00:39:26 understand that they make jokes about it you know it depends upon the judge i get
00:39:30 but there's actually more truth to that than they think and you can't language has inherent
00:39:37 ambiguities and so the idea that we're going to fix the charter or fix the bill of rights
00:39:42 by simply drafting it better you know more precisely now don't get me wrong there are
00:39:47 some really vague provisions in the cart in the charter that could have been done much better
00:39:51 but nevertheless it's it's unlikely that you can ever draft a document that compels every single
00:39:59 answer for every case under the sun it doesn't work that way so you're going to have to acknowledge
00:40:03 the fact of the ambiguity and and and acknowledge the idea that the way the system runs is in fact
00:40:10 going to depend upon the ideas and the heads of the people who run the institutions
00:40:16 so we have then two problems one of which is can the law be well i guess they're all really coming
00:40:23 under this one question which is can the law be safeguarded against people and it's ironic that
00:40:29 the law which at its core we want to be there to protect people is you know still being weaponized
00:40:36 by another group of people whether you want to call them the elites the state the institutions
00:40:40 the courts whatever the case is and it's a very strange dilemma because at its core we're back to
00:40:47 the original problem we have in a way which is that uh there is the need to save people from
00:40:54 other people and there isn't really the answer to how to do that well so it's funny you should put
00:41:00 it that way because if you if you like you can contrast the two competing ideas this way you can
00:41:06 say look if we stuck to the idea that the that the role of the law and the courts and so on
00:41:13 was to save people from other people from the interference of other people if we all agreed
00:41:18 about that then we might not have such a big problem but we don't agree about that the other
00:41:24 competing purpose that a lot of people think that the law should serve is to protect people from
00:41:31 themselves to put rules in place to prevent people from making their own decisions about
00:41:37 their own lives because other smarter people think oh that's not a very good idea you know
00:41:42 for my money that's a terrible thing but but a lot of people thoroughly believe that you know
00:41:48 i've said that those people who think they believe in liberty need to come to two epiphanies
00:41:54 not one but two and the first one is easy and the second one is not the first one is well i don't
00:42:00 want to be told what to do well that's that's easy anybody can come to that conclusion but the second
00:42:06 one is i don't want to tell other people what to do even though i think i'm more challenging yeah
00:42:15 until you get until you get there and until you get the people inside the system running our
00:42:19 governments to believe that as well then you're gonna have a problem and and that is where i
00:42:27 The one little bit of hope that I try to find in all of this is that there's always the hearts
00:42:32 and minds approach, is that what's on paper, what's in the institutions doesn't matter if people
00:42:38 are behaving the way we need people to, and that is embracing freedom, embracing free speech,
00:42:43 embracing the ability to self-govern in this sense. So it was a very, very thoughtful piece.
00:42:49 It's in C2C Journal. You can read it for yourself, and I would encourage you to do so.
00:42:53 Canada's Constitutional Mistake
00:42:55 How the Rule of Law Gave Way
00:42:57 to the Managerial State. Bruce
00:42:59 Party, always a delight. Thanks for coming on
00:43:01 today. Great to see you, Andrew. Thank you.
00:43:03 Alright, thank you. And that does it for us
00:43:05 for today. We'll be back tomorrow
00:43:07 with more of Canada's Most Irreverent
00:43:09 Talk Show here. Thank you, God bless
00:43:11 and good day to you all.
00:43:13 Thanks for listening to The Andrew Lawton Show.
00:43:15 Support the program by donating to
00:43:16 True North at www.tnc.news.
00:43:23 We'll be right back.