Juno News - May 14, 2024


Liberals misrepresented police intel to justify Emergencies Act

Topics
Mentioned
Are anti-Israel encampments a free speech issue? Trudeau still thinks he's not going anywhere

Episode Stats


Length

47 minutes

Words per minute

180.27

Word count

8,515

Sentence count

297

Harmful content

Misogyny

3

sentences flagged

Toxicity

3

sentences flagged

Hate speech

8

sentences flagged


Summary

Summaries generated with gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ .

In this episode of The Lawton Show, host Andrew Lawton talks about a strange discovery his wife made while travelling the world with him, and why it's a good thing she has a lot of Tylenol in the house.

Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Topics generated with Qwen2.5-3B-Instruct.
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 Transcription by CastingWords
00:00:30 Thank you.
00:01:00 welcome to canada's most irreverent talk show this is the andrew lawton show brought to you by true
00:01:19 north hello and welcome to you all canada's most irreverent talk show the andrew lotten show on
00:01:29 true north before we get into it i just have to share with you the sudden realization i've learned
00:01:35 about my wife which is that she has this okay let me let me take a step back here so i i for like
00:01:42 several hours today i've had a headache which is of no interest anyone except for its necessary
00:01:47 setup to the story here and I don't get headaches a lot but when I do it's like I'm in caffeine
00:01:52 withdrawal because I haven't had a coffee or I haven't eaten which believe it or not does actually
00:01:57 happen from time to time that I forget and so I like this morning and at lunch you know I had
00:02:02 coffee I ate and the headache didn't go away so moments before the show I realized that maybe I
00:02:07 need a pharmaceutical intervention and let me just run and try to see if we have Tylenol and I went
00:02:12 to where I believe the Tylenol are kept in my home. And I like found that my wife has been
00:02:19 collecting, uh, basically Tylenol from around the world anytime we've traveled. So there was like,
00:02:24 uh, uh, there's a paracetamolo. So this was, we, I mean, we were in Italy like two years ago. So
00:02:30 this has still lingered in, uh, paracetamol is what they call acetaminophen in Europe. Uh,
00:02:35 this one is from, this one is German, uh, paracetamol tabletin. Uh, so this one I would
00:02:41 have been from Austria or something. And then this one, which I saw is, can you see, make out
00:02:47 the Arabic script? I believe that means paracetamol in Arabic. And I'm just wondering why we can't
00:02:55 just like take the Tylenol from one country when we travel, why we need to like amass this. So
00:02:59 anyway, I've learned that the medicine cabinet in my home is like the United Nations of
00:03:03 paracetamol. So I took the German one. So if I start breaking out into some German folk song
00:03:09 midway through the show. That's why. It was because I took the German paracetamol, which
00:03:14 translated is still paracetamol. Anyway, all of that, this just happened like two minutes ago.
00:03:21 So I'm like, oh, this is like a fun story. Men can relate where you just open up a cupboard and just
00:03:24 have no idea how anything that was there got there. And that's what marriage is. But you know
00:03:29 what? I highly recommend marriage, which is why we're going to be talking later on this show
00:03:34 about families and some of the problems that we have in Canada from a demographic perspective.
00:03:40 one of which is the fertility crisis.
00:03:42 We'll talk about that with Tim Sargent later on in the show.
00:03:45 Also going to be talking about kids in the classrooms
00:03:48 and why some activists are saying they are not going far enough,
00:03:53 the Ontario government, in getting rid of cell phones in the classroom.
00:03:58 But I want to begin first and foremost by just talking,
00:04:02 well, actually, before we get into the topic I want to talk about now,
00:04:05 just as a programming note, you may recall over my right shoulder there,
00:04:09 We have a book coming out, Pierre Polyev, A Political Life, the first ever biography of Pierre Polyev, of which I'm aware, coming out on May 28th.
00:04:19 Now, I've heard that at some bookstores, they have jumped the gun, and it's actually already on shelves now.
00:04:26 I saw on the weekend, people were sending me pictures of seeing this thing on store shelves, but technically it's not out yet.
00:04:32 But I do want to let you know, because I know we have listeners and viewers to the show from across the country, that I'm going to be doing a book tour.
00:04:39 It's a small tour.
00:04:40 We're only going to a handful of cities,
00:04:41 but I will be in Calgary, Toronto, and Ottawa to start
00:04:46 when the book comes out.
00:04:48 So I'm going to be in Calgary Wednesday, May 29th.
00:04:51 This is, you can see it on the screen there
00:04:53 at the Ranchman's Club.
00:04:55 I'm going to be in Toronto May 30th at the Albany Club.
00:04:58 And Ottawa, we're still fine-tuning the details.
00:05:00 I think it's going to be June 5th.
00:05:03 Now, these events are being sponsored
00:05:05 by the Modern Miracle Network
00:05:06 in the case of Calgary and Toronto
00:05:09 and Canada Strong and Free Network
00:05:10 in the case of Ottawa.
00:05:12 But we're going to have all the details up.
00:05:14 So actually, Sean,
00:05:14 can you put that page up there, please?
00:05:17 So you can find that page,
00:05:19 which has the link to get tickets
00:05:20 at modernmiraclenetwork.org
00:05:24 slash Lawton.
00:05:25 I know it's a long, long description,
00:05:27 but modernmiraclenetwork.org
00:05:30 slash Lawton.
00:05:31 If you can't find it,
00:05:32 just send me an email,
00:05:33 andrew at andrewlawton.ca
00:05:35 and I can send you the link there.
00:05:37 But there are only a limited number of tickets.
00:05:40 So do, if you want to come out
00:05:41 and you're in Calgary or Toronto or Ottawa,
00:05:44 let me know.
00:05:44 And conversely, people have asked,
00:05:46 oh, why aren't you coming to here?
00:05:47 And they'll come up with like the name of a town
00:05:49 I've never heard with four people in it.
00:05:51 I'd say, I'd love to.
00:05:52 If you have a group that's willing to sponsor
00:05:54 and bring me out there, great.
00:05:56 The problem is that when you buy books,
00:05:58 there's actually not a thick enough margin
00:06:00 to justify going everywhere.
00:06:02 So you need to have like another group
00:06:03 that wants to host you and bring you in.
00:06:05 But happy to go anywhere.
00:06:07 And I'll be talking lots about the book when it comes out.
00:06:09 And hopefully you'll be interested in it.
00:06:11 And, you know, just to tell you what it is,
00:06:14 it's a biography of Pierre Paulyev.
00:06:16 It's not a whitewash.
00:06:18 It's not meant to be a piece of promotion.
00:06:20 It's meant to be a pretty fair and journalistic take
00:06:22 on who this guy is and where he came from.
00:06:25 And I think there's a lot in there
00:06:26 that people who like Pierre will take away,
00:06:28 people who don't like Pierre, people who are unsure.
00:06:31 That's the spirit in which it was written.
00:06:33 So anyway, if you've already picked up a copy, thank you. And if you haven't, you can probably get it now. If not in a couple of weeks time, you'll be able to. But let me talk about this RCMP revelation that came out and True North reported on this yesterday.
00:06:47 Cosman Georgia, who hosts the Daily Brief most days, the RCMP's long-awaited review of its handling
00:06:56 and its experience, basically, throughout the Freedom Convoy has finally come out. And there
00:07:01 were some interesting takeaways in this. Now, the RCMP police did a canvas of a lot of their
00:07:09 officers' responses to this. And frontline officers were incredibly frustrated with how
00:07:16 the RCMP brass behave. Frontline officers were concerned that their role was being heavily
00:07:22 politicized. They were concerned, one thing that I found really significant was that police intel
00:07:28 reports, so what police were unearthing, were being misrepresented by the government. So the
00:07:34 government would come out and say, oh yes, police are saying this, this, this, and the RCMP officers
00:07:38 are saying, well hang on, that never, that's not what we said, that's not what we told them about.
00:07:42 and also that the government wanted these hourly briefings but because they wanted them every hour
00:07:48 police were so focused on preparing the briefings they weren't actually able to collect the
00:07:52 information that they needed to be in the briefing so you had this situation where
00:07:57 the government was getting half-formed thoughts and half-formed reports because the they were
00:08:02 just forcing the police to spend all their time doing the reports and briefings and not actually
00:08:07 policing and we go back to what we learned during the public order emergency commission
00:08:11 which was that the federal government wanted the emergencies act when no police were asking for it
00:08:18 this was not at all the case where police were saying absolutely we're our hands are tied we
00:08:23 need more powers if anything police were saying hey we're we've already got this just let us do
00:08:27 our job and the ottawa police service the opp rcmp they were all really clamoring around trying to
00:08:34 get their piece of the pie here ottawa police was being territorial the rcmp we learned the
00:08:39 commissioner was fairly deferential to Justin Trudeau, Brenda Luckey, the OPP seemed to be
00:08:46 the ones that were really in control of a lot of the crucial aspects, but were being really edged
00:08:51 out. They were being frozen out about this. And it was interesting, just to give you a reminder
00:08:56 from the Public Order Emergency Commission, that the federal government was really actively trying
00:09:01 to screw the ottawa police take a look there minister blair discusses throwing ottawa under
00:09:10 the bus that was your note uh that was my note correct all right and i take it when he's saying
00:09:19 ottawa he's talking about the ottawa police service is that fair it's not the city of ottawa
00:09:23 Correct. Right. So his plan on that date is he's intending to throw Ottawa under the bus, being the OPS for any failures that have been dealt with with respect to policing. Is that fair?
00:09:39 He could have made a comment during the meeting saying that he was not satisfied with the work that's being done by Ottawa Police Service.
00:09:45 that was uh brendan miller there the lawyer representing the freedom convoy organizers
00:09:53 cross-examining rcmp brass on the stand and then you also have this the acknowledgement from brenda
00:10:00 lucky of what's been established time and time again we're just doing a little refresher course
00:10:04 here because this was a little while ago now that the convoy was not a threat to the security of
00:10:10 Canada and thus could not be a national emergency. Commissioner Lucky, you were present for both
00:10:18 the February 13th IRG as well as the February 14th cabinet meeting.
00:10:26 Yes, I think there was the cabinet meeting was on the 13th. And well, yeah, and so the IRG meeting,
00:10:36 they according to the text messages and the messages that we've reviewed they never even
00:10:41 asked you to speak um not on the definitely not at the cabinet meeting and i don't i what i did do
00:10:51 i don't think i spoke at either um i i thought i did because i had speaking notes but i did brief
00:10:57 the minister before that meeting right and the minister never asked you what your opinion was
00:11:01 with respect to whether or not there was a section 2 CSIS Act security threat is that correct
00:11:07 in respect to whether or not there was a threat under section 2 as defined in the CSIS Act if
00:11:12 there was a threat to the security of Canada no he would have to ask CSIS right and CSIS you're
00:11:17 aware told him that there wasn't that's what I've been told so you're gonna have to thank you those
00:11:23 are my questions so that's just again to bring us up to speed here and where we are now and you look
00:11:30 Look at this report that came out, and it's 92 pages.
00:11:33 So if you're looking for some, I don't know if enjoyable is the right word,
00:11:36 but you're looking for some interesting, I mean, even interesting is a bit.
00:11:39 I'll try to give you the highlights here.
00:11:41 But if you're looking for some reading anyway, you can look it up yourself.
00:11:43 It's linked to in True North's story on this yesterday.
00:11:46 But I want to read one of the paragraphs here.
00:11:49 The Government of Canada's demands for hourly briefings left no time for intelligence units
00:11:55 to prepare an assessment, nor to collect the most up-to-date information.
00:12:00 Former Commissioner Brenda Luckey provided joint ministerial briefings to several ministers
00:12:04 before the Freedom Convoy arrived in Ottawa, and then daily from January 30th to February 23rd.
00:12:10 Updates were also shared, and it goes on and on and on and on and on.
00:12:13 And they're basically saying that the RCMP needs to have a better way of sharing information
00:12:19 because this was just not working because of the government's demands.
00:12:24 But then you also have this line here.
00:12:26 some Government of Canada partners would misrepresent information or misattribute third
00:12:33 party information as police information. Interviewees, so that's those they canvassed
00:12:39 for preparing this report, often noted that various Government of Canada partners would
00:12:43 reach in directly to specific intelligence teams or individuals which did not respect the chain
00:12:48 of command or established protocols. So you had the government going to people they wanted to go
00:12:53 to, not keeping in mind, not respecting the chain of command. And it's understandable when you learn
00:12:59 that the chain of command was finding what we heard time and time again through the Public
00:13:03 Order Emergency Commission, that this was not an insurmountable problem that needed the Emergencies
00:13:11 Act. So you may say, what's the point of this? I mean, the RCMP, like a lot of government
00:13:16 bureaucratic agencies, does not move quickly. So the fact that it's taken more than two years for
00:13:21 this report to come out is not hugely surprising on my part but nevertheless we have yet another
00:13:29 reminder of this basically this fundamental lie that the federal government told people which is
00:13:35 that police were asking them for this police weren't asking for it the city of Ottawa wasn't
00:13:40 asking for it CSIS wasn't asking for it it was the government itself that pushed this and you may
00:13:46 have seen there was an access to information request recently that was someone had asked for
00:13:52 basically the legal opinion that was used the briefing the legal briefing that was given to
00:13:57 the federal government on the emergencies act and whether it was legally justifiable and the whole
00:14:02 page was blacked out the whole page was as black as Justin Trudeau's face at a house party you 0.57
00:14:08 could not see anything in it because the government will not reveal the legal opinion it got and I
00:14:16 suspect it's because it was probably a thin or tenuous basis on which they declared the
00:14:22 Emergencies Act necessary. And as we've talked about time and time again, as I wrote about in
00:14:26 my first book, which was about the convoy, they saw their window was closing. They wanted to go
00:14:31 after the bank accounts. They wanted to declare this a political win. But the government being
00:14:37 embarrassed is not, I repeat, a national emergency. So that is what we have on this for now. But
00:14:43 whether there will be a reckoning is anyone's guess. Wanted to turn to an issue that is near
00:14:49 and dear to a lot of those of you watching and listening to this. And that is what your child
00:14:53 is learning in the classroom. And more importantly, how effectively they are learning. Now I had it
00:14:58 easy because I think like there were no hand, there were the only handheld device that I had
00:15:04 to contend with when I was of school age was I think a Tamagotchi, which at one point was like
00:15:10 beeping up a storm in the classroom. So the teacher just took it and put it in her desk.
00:15:15 And I don't even think I ever saw it again, to be honest. So that Tamagotchi is probably long
00:15:19 since died by now. Or maybe it's just, you know, living up the life in my teacher's retirement.
00:15:24 But now kids have everything. They have like their iPhones, their iPads, their all of these
00:15:29 different devices. I was going to name other devices. And then I realized I don't know any
00:15:32 more devices now because iPods aren't a thing. I think they've just been replaced by the iPhone,
00:15:37 basically. But the Ontario government has tried to do something about this. They've come up with
00:15:41 a policy that effectively keeps devices out of the classroom up to a certain point and then says
00:15:47 from grade seven and up, I think it is, that with teacher permission they can be used. Some people
00:15:53 are welcoming this, but others are saying it does not go far enough. Joining me is Paige McPherson,
00:15:59 the Associate Director of Education Policy for the Fraser Institute. Paige, always good to talk
00:16:04 you. Thanks for coming on today. My pleasure. Thanks for having me. So let's talk first off
00:16:10 about the why here, because I think there are some people that just take an anti-distraction
00:16:16 and anti-tech view, and they don't want kids on their phones in class. But the data actually
00:16:20 support this as being a fairly significant thing when it comes to educational achievement and
00:16:25 performance, doesn't it? Yeah, absolutely. So we have really interesting and valuable PISA data.
00:16:31 So that's the Program for International Student Assessment from the OECD that looks, probably most
00:16:37 people know that as the sort of gold standard international test of 15 year olds that is done.
00:16:42 So PISA has great student performance data in math, reading and science, but they also have
00:16:48 an insights report that has data on a whole bunch of different things. And they looked at smartphones
00:16:53 and digital distractions in classrooms in their most recent report. And what it found is that
00:16:58 there's actually a measurable impact on math scores in particular when it comes to digital
00:17:05 distraction in classrooms. So that's from people either being distracted by their own devices
00:17:11 or people being distracted by the devices of people in the classroom around them and that's
00:17:16 really informative for when it comes to crafting smartphone ban policies in classrooms because it
00:17:22 it means that it's not just what one student has on their own desk that matters to have an actual
00:17:29 measurable impact on their math scores. And other research has shown really their cognitive
00:17:34 development or that they're actually cognitively impairing to have this digital distraction going
00:17:40 on, but it actually matters what other students in the classroom have as well.
00:17:45 Now, I don't know at what age kids are getting phones. I'm assuming there's a bit of a range here,
00:17:50 But the policy really, I think, where it's relevant is from the 7 to 12.
00:17:55 So grade 7 to 12, not age.
00:17:58 And that's where the teacher can say, okay, if maybe you want to have your phone, that's fine.
00:18:03 Or the teacher could say no.
00:18:04 I feel bad for teachers here because now all of a sudden they're the bad guys and they're the ones that have to enforce this.
00:18:11 And if you've got some 16-year-old boy or girl that doesn't want to put their phone down, even if the teacher has said no, that's really the end of it here.
00:18:19 So the enforcement, I think, will be a huge problem here.
00:18:22 And it's, again, another thing teachers have to deal with.
00:18:25 I totally agree with you.
00:18:26 I think this is one of the flaws in the policy that Doug Ford's government has put forward
00:18:31 that you pointed out is that there's a much more uniform, strict ban in the younger grades.
00:18:37 And where, yeah, we do know that kids are starting to get smartphones in grade three,
00:18:41 four, five, which might come as a shock to some parents.
00:18:45 my oldest kid is six and I can't believe that this is a reality it's almost around the corner
00:18:51 but this is this is true but the likelihood of that kid bringing their smartphone to school and
00:18:56 being distracted by it during the day it exists but it's it's a lot lower whereas we know that
00:19:02 the stats on on smartphone ownership in high school are through the roof almost all teenagers
00:19:09 have these devices and they're the ones who are much more likely to be glued to their devices
00:19:13 throughout the day so having a policy that is the most uniform as possible and really as strict as
00:19:19 possible when it comes to just removing the digital distraction from teenagers in particular
00:19:25 and and middle schoolers as well where there's middle schools in Ontario that is something that
00:19:31 you know I think that's a big flaw in the policy and the other thing as well is that so the 2019
00:19:36 smartphone so-called ban which wasn't really a ban that the Ontario government had in place left it
00:19:42 up to school boards this new policy which i still will not call a ban um is it leaves it up to
00:19:49 teachers discretion which as you say makes teachers the bad guys teachers need to know that yeah they
00:19:56 can be the bad guy sometime and discipline in classrooms is really important and teachers
00:20:01 maintaining you know calm control over their classroom we know from the research this is a
00:20:07 really important um thing for for great student outcomes but teachers also need to know that
00:20:12 they're supported by their administration principals school boards and the provincial
00:20:17 government so that they can say to kids look this is the policy it is what it is with very few
00:20:23 exceptions like for example kids that need to check um for medical reasons if they're monitoring
00:20:28 their blood sugar they need their cell phone to um uh to to help in that okay there's going to be
00:20:33 be some exceptions, but as uniform and blanket as the ban can be so that it takes it out of
00:20:38 teachers' hands, stops teachers from surveilling and nagging throughout the day, I think the better
00:20:43 the policy will look. One thing I wanted to ask about, and this is when we talk about school as
00:20:48 a preparatory influence for the real world, is that the real world is one in which people are
00:20:53 surrounded by phones and phones are a part of everyday life. In the same way that I think the,
00:20:58 you know, the negativity surrounding calculators has sort of gone away because most of us in life,
00:21:04 and again, probably wrongfully so, but most of us in life will never need to, you know,
00:21:08 memorize our multiplication tables or whatever. But is there not something to the argument that
00:21:12 we should be using technology as an educational tool in the classroom? Because that's the counter
00:21:20 I've heard to this is that, well, no, no, no, it's not realistic to, you know, have this
00:21:24 technologically sterile environment. So let's just make sure that we're leveraging this and
00:21:28 using the advantages of these devices for learning. That is definitely one of the most
00:21:34 prominent counter arguments. What I would say to that is that school is for two things. School is
00:21:40 for preparing students for the world in terms of their learning and their academic achievement.
00:21:47 Students need to go to school to learn. We know that once a student is distracted by a smartphone,
00:21:53 it can take, one research study showed, 20 minutes to regain focus. A full 20 minutes. That's an
00:22:00 entire lesson in some cases. Just after one distraction. Just to drill into that point. So
00:22:06 if I, you know, look at my phone for a second and look away, I would assume that the distraction has
00:22:11 now ended, that I'm back. But you're saying with kids, that's actually not the case at all.
00:22:16 Kids don't have the same amount of brain development that has happened that adults have.
00:22:19 they don't have the same prefrontal cortex development that controls impulse. So they
00:22:25 don't they aren't able, you know, if you feel your phone buzzing in your pocket, you might say,
00:22:30 you know what, I'm going to get to that later, because I'm working on something. And we know,
00:22:34 as adults, it's really difficult for us as well. But for kids, it's so much more difficult,
00:22:38 because they just don't have that impulse control. They don't have that same level of
00:22:42 brain development that we have as adults, which makes smartphones in general, really problematic
00:22:47 for a lot of kids and teenagers, but certainly when it comes to focus, there are big impacts
00:22:53 and there's been a lot of work and research in psychology that has been done on this exact
00:22:58 topic. Jonathan Haidt's book is a really great resource on this. He's a psychologist that has
00:23:03 written about this. Recently, he calls for a ban of smartphones in schools, says that they should
00:23:08 be put into a lockable pouch or a locker for the school day. The reason being that kids just don't
00:23:14 have that level of impulse control. But the other thing that I would add is that school, yes, for
00:23:19 learning, that's the primary purpose of school. It's not just to prepare kids for the modern world
00:23:24 or whatever the sort of rhetoric around that will be. It's also for genuine socialization, right?
00:23:30 It's for kids to be able to do things face-to-face, to interact with their teachers, interact with
00:23:36 their peers face-to-face. When you put away the digital devices that are in front of kids' faces
00:23:41 and distracting them throughout the day,
00:23:44 you're going to have more of that genuine face-to-face socialization,
00:23:47 which I also think is quite important for kids
00:23:49 in many, many real-world contexts, socially, but also professionally.
00:23:55 Yeah, it's funny you mention that because I've seen some people argue,
00:23:58 and again, I've got a bigger issue with this,
00:24:01 but I certainly understand the argument of banning them
00:24:05 at all points in the school day.
00:24:07 So even in the lunchroom, you shouldn't be able to have your phone out.
00:24:09 And that's really one of the reasons when you talk about socialization there is that the whole point is that you have a time in your life in which you're all in the same room.
00:24:17 You can all get together. You can all talk and have fun and laugh.
00:24:20 And I suspect if you walk into most lunchrooms now that everyone is just glued to their phones.
00:24:25 Absolutely. So if you ask my personal opinion on it, I think that phones should be banned throughout the day.
00:24:31 Most of the experts who are out there on this topic agree that the ban should be throughout the day for those socialization aspects.
00:24:37 but also because we know that phones and some of the PISA data actually speaks to this as well.
00:24:44 The eight and 10 kids in Canada say that they're anxious when their smartphone is not with them
00:24:49 at all times in the day. We need to break that cycle. That's actually higher than the OECD
00:24:54 average, which is closer to 60% of kids. We also know from that data, again, that kids are
00:24:59 distracted by their own devices, yes, but they're also distracted by others' devices as well.
00:25:03 So if kids are thinking about the next moment that they're going to get to their smartphone, thinking about the next moment that the person beside them is going to get to their smartphone, if, you know, kids in schools are, they're taking videos of one another, they're showing each other things on their phones.
00:25:20 If you think, okay, my kid has pretty good self-discipline, that's one thing, but the ability for them to be distracted by other kids is really significant as well.
00:25:31 And parents play a role in this too, right? Parents, a lot of parents want to be able to get in touch with their kids at all times during the day. And this is a situation wherein I do think provincial governments need to show leadership. I believe that parental involvement in schools, providing consent, being informed if they want to be about what their kids are learning in school, offering feedback on that.
00:25:55 there's good research to show that that's really important for beneficial student outcomes,
00:26:00 student achievement being stronger as well. But parents will need to get on board with a policy
00:26:07 that they know that if there is a true emergency, they can call the office and not get in touch with
00:26:12 their kids throughout the day. So there are there are stumbling blocks beyond just, you know, that
00:26:17 one child and their smartphone and how much they're using it throughout the day. There's a digital
00:26:22 distraction that is so much larger than that um in classrooms if we allow the sort of okay well you
00:26:28 can have your smartphone now you can you you can um get it back and then you give it back and then
00:26:33 you know this this throughout the day um there's logistics that have to be worked out when you
00:26:37 think about things like lockable pouches some of your viewers might have gone to a concert or a
00:26:42 comedy show where they had to put their in a lockable pouch um because the the show was being
00:26:47 recorded for a streaming service they probably enjoyed the show a lot more because they didn't
00:26:51 have distractions and then they got their phone back from that lockable pouch from security at
00:26:55 the end of the concert teachers can employ that um or schools and you can do that with cell phone
00:27:01 lockers as well it does become a little bit logistically tricky when you think about high
00:27:05 school students moving from class to class but independent schools across north america um you
00:27:11 know there are examples of schools that have done this with quite large student populations it's
00:27:15 very doable. And I think the benefits of having focus from kids during classroom time so far
00:27:21 outweigh the costs. When you and I are the same age, and I recall maybe on two or three occasions
00:27:30 in the entirety that I went to school where something was so urgent that my mother needed
00:27:35 to call the school and have the office page the classroom and have the teacher send me to the,
00:27:40 Like it's not that common in most cases that you're going to need that, but there was a
00:27:45 process available and, you know, maybe it took, you know, four minutes longer than, you
00:27:50 know, just texting me would have.
00:27:51 But I also wonder how much, and you may have, I know it gets outside of the educational
00:27:56 policy realm, but as a parent, you might have thoughts on this.
00:27:59 The idea that parents might be more of the problem than kids in some of these cases that,
00:28:04 you know, parents are the ones that are in that emergency mindset.
00:28:07 i mean the kids may want their phones for other reason but that that emergency need for contact
00:28:13 argument i just don't think is really as real as some parents might make it out to be yeah there
00:28:18 is you know it's sort of a byproduct of our modern world um this sort of safetyism culture that we
00:28:24 need to be able to monitor kids 24 7. um it is certainly prevalent um and i do think that you
00:28:30 know when it comes to policies like this you do need to have people you know the policies need
00:28:35 to be thoroughly explained to parents. They are a critically important stakeholder in education,
00:28:40 but ultimately schools ban certain things that we know are negative for kids. There are going to be
00:28:47 some, like I said, exceptions for medical reasons and whatnot, but this is not something that school
00:28:54 is for, right? School is not to be distracted by their smartphones all day. And if parents can sort
00:28:59 have come to understand that the improved cognitive abilities of their kids during the
00:29:07 school day, the reduced anxiety, the increased genuine socialization, the increased ability for
00:29:15 teachers to maintain, excuse me, maintain control over their classrooms, reduce the nagging, reduce 0.99
00:29:20 the surveilling that they're having to spend so much classroom time on. We know that parents
00:29:25 are in many cases dissatisfied with falling student performance results as well. These are
00:29:32 important outcomes for kids to ensure that they have bright futures and to ensure brighter futures
00:29:37 for our provinces. So ultimately, knowing that smartphones in classrooms distracting kids
00:29:43 are a significant component of this problem, and knowing as well that, you know, we've got big fish
00:29:49 to fry when it comes to education policy, but this is one that is pretty easily solvable with
00:29:55 a simple, elegant, not very expensive policy solution that we already have at our fingertips.
00:30:01 We just need courage from provincial governments to implement this policy. So yes, parents are
00:30:06 going to need to come on board. We have to push back against that safetyism culture just a little
00:30:11 bit when it comes to this, but knowing that parents can get in touch with their students
00:30:17 if needed, perhaps keeping in mind that a consistent engagement between schools and
00:30:23 parents so parents can feel very involved in that process that's an important component of education
00:30:27 too um but but everybody kind of acknowledging that this is an issue that we can very easily
00:30:32 solve because all of our kids deserve um an environment in their classrooms that is free
00:30:37 of digital distraction no very well said and it was part of the fun too the the announcement comes
00:30:42 and calls someone to the office everyone else in the classroom gets to go oh it's part of the fun
00:30:47 why rob your children of that uh you know potential public shaming or whatever anyway
00:30:51 All right, Paige McPherson, always good to talk to you.
00:30:53 Thanks for coming on today.
00:30:55 Yeah, I like that you've highlighted that we lived in the golden era
00:30:58 of Tamagotchis and public shaming over the announcements.
00:31:02 Yes, my Tamagotchi, I think, lived like 14 days.
00:31:05 It was like my first experience at loss and heartbreak, I think.
00:31:09 But anyway, set me up well for the future.
00:31:12 And now it's like the Tamagotchi is like the most like you. 0.93
00:31:16 I would actually love to, if you've still got one kicking,
00:31:19 because I bet the thing like the batteries on those things lasted forever so they're probably
00:31:23 still alive like give a kid today a Tamagotchi which I had a screen that was like Sean you got
00:31:31 to find a picture of a Tamagotchi before the end of the show the screen was like a tiny little like
00:31:36 stamp size screen I think the thing had like two buttons on it and uh this was like this kept us
00:31:42 entertained and I'm imagining if you were to like give a kid a Tamagotchi as a gift he would look at 0.98
00:31:47 it or she would look at it and be like what the hell is this stupid like what do you even do with 0.96
00:31:52 it i don't even know what you did with it but we liked it it's like a game boy my uh my parents uh 0.97
00:31:56 not that long ago found like my old childhood game boy which is still working and they uh gave
00:32:01 it to my nephews with my permission and they they liked it for like three minutes and i think
00:32:05 probably went back to the uh nintendo switch or whatever kids use now anyway we're doing all the
00:32:10 nostalgia here but talking about kids is a good segue into our next topic which is the reality
00:32:16 that most Canadians are not having them or I shouldn't say most but Canadians are having
00:32:21 children in fewer and fewer numbers and I would say fewer and fewer young Canadians are coupling
00:32:26 up and actually building that basis of a family that might in turn have children. We have a
00:32:32 fertility rate that is well below replacement and no one from a policy perspective has really
00:32:38 decided to tackle this head-on which is why we end up talking about this in the context of
00:32:43 immigration as a population growth mechanism because there are not Canadian families having
00:32:49 kids with enough numbers to increase the population that way. It's a third rail in politics and policy.
00:32:56 We talked about it a little while ago with Ginny Roth when we caught up at the Canada Strong and
00:33:01 Free Network conference, but it was delved into in a very thoughtful piece that was published at
00:33:06 The Hub. We are not taking Canada's fertility crisis seriously enough. The author of that is 0.98
00:33:12 Dr. Tim Sargent, who's a distinguished fellow with the Centre for International Governance
00:33:16 Innovation, and also the Deputy Executive Director at the Centre for the Study of Living Standards.
00:33:21 Tim, it's good to talk to you. Thanks so much for writing this and for coming on today.
00:33:25 Thanks for having me, Andrew.
00:33:27 So let's begin by talking about the term crisis here. And why is this, in your view,
00:33:32 something we can call that?
00:33:35 Well, for me, it's a slow motion crisis, but it's a crisis nonetheless.
00:33:41 You have a society that's basically not reproducing itself.
00:33:46 You know, that's not a society that's probably going to exist over the very long term.
00:33:50 And it's a little bit like like boiling the frog.
00:33:52 We've had the low replacement fertility rates for quite some time.
00:33:55 But we've seen just in the last 10 years, our fertility rates gone from 1.6, which wasn't great, but it was a similar level to countries like the UK, the US.
00:34:05 And now it's down to 1.3 and it's dropped quite rapidly.
00:34:08 and this is something that started before covid so it's related to something i think quite deep
00:34:13 seated in in our society one of the things that i i find interesting is that we used to people that
00:34:20 talk about this issue and look at this issue look at japan as being the worst of the worst 0.87
00:34:25 japan has always been the standout example of a country with a true fertility crisis and they're
00:34:31 at 1.3 so we're at really what we've always looked at as being the worst in this around the world
00:34:36 that's right so we always used to look at country like germany for instance and and say that well
00:34:42 they had a lower fertility rate than us but now germany is higher than us we're at 1.33 they're
00:34:47 they're at 1.45 so we really are dropping down the league tables here and we're down to levels
00:34:53 close to italy or italy or japan you know we're not as bad as a as a career for instance which
00:34:59 is now down at 0.72 um but we're still at you know quite low levels now i mean what what 1.3
00:35:05 means is that for every 10 Canadians, there will be only four grandchildren.
00:35:13 Now, the one thing, there are two aspects of this. There's the domestic picture, and then
00:35:18 there's the global picture. And the one thing that we fail to take into consideration, even if you
00:35:23 say, okay, well, Canada can perhaps grow its population by immigration. Well, that still
00:35:28 isn't changing the global crisis that we see unfolding, because this is happening around the
00:35:33 world. Countries like Hungary that have really, as a matter of government policy, tried to right
00:35:38 this trend are in short supply. What do you think that is? Is it that countries are just
00:35:45 uninterested in talking about this issue because there is a, because they just are scared of it,
00:35:51 they're afraid of the politicization of it? Or is it that no one has found a solution?
00:35:57 I mean, I think it's both. I mean, some countries, I mean, Hungary is one, but of course,
00:36:03 Even in Canada, if you look at Quebec, for instance, in the late 1980s and early 1990s, they were introducing policy to encourage people to have more children.
00:36:13 I mean, partly, I think nobody wants to be seen to be telling women how many children that they should have.
00:36:19 You know, nobody wants a sort of a handmaid's tale kind of society.
00:36:24 But the reality is, if you actually ask women how many children they want, they will generally say more than two.
00:36:29 on average it's a little bit more than two that's true not just in canada but across across the
00:36:33 western world um so then the question is why aren't women having having more children even though they 1.00
00:36:39 say that that's what they want um you know urbanization um i think is a key factor here
00:36:46 obviously people you know have more money um they're likely to find leisure pursuits and things
00:36:52 you know ways to spend that money um uh rather than uh starting a family um if you look at
00:36:59 countries around the world i mean nobody's nobody's had huge success um even in a country like
00:37:04 hungary where now you know if you if you're a woman and you have four children you don't pay
00:37:09 any income tax um which sounds i think pretty attractive to to a lot of us um they've managed
00:37:15 to move their birth rate up but they're still significantly below fertility um countries like
00:37:20 poland have tried this as well uh these try to increase fertility so we're seeing you know perhaps
00:37:26 you know doing a little bit better um quebec when it had its baby bonus did see its fertility rate 1.00
00:37:33 tick up from around about 1.4 to around about 1.6 1.7 um so countries do seem to have some success
00:37:40 on the margin but the only advanced country now that has an above replacement rate fertility is
00:37:45 is israel and of course there's some very special circumstances around israel there's a wicked 1.00
00:37:51 problem aspect here in that you have a number of different you know influencing factors here and
00:37:57 you could tackle one and not the other i mean one that you touch on in your study is the delay in
00:38:03 many young canadians in leaving home so if you have one-fifth of adults 25 to 34 living with their
00:38:09 their parents these are the data you've showed then that that raises a number of practical
00:38:15 challenges to uh your dating life for example it raises challenges then in partnering up with
00:38:21 someone where you so that that's one example and we can look at then okay why are canadians living
00:38:26 at their living at home is it economic okay well we have an economic issue a housing issue
00:38:31 you could solve that and you maybe have only accounted for let's say 10 of the problem
00:38:38 when you have all of these other factors exactly um so you have to kind of look at people's
00:38:44 life cycles here i mean you know in order to have a children you know first you know most people will
00:38:50 want to be in a couple before they do that um in order to be a couple most people you know need to
00:38:55 kind of leave home and set up a new family unit so you know certainly there are explanations like
00:39:01 housing for instance i mean if you want to leave home you need somewhere to live and to start a
00:39:05 family you probably want a bigger house so those are explanations that that do touch at um this
00:39:10 whole sequence of events that needs to happen. But there's probably some deeper social cultural
00:39:16 things going on as well. And as you say, Andrew, you know, you can't just look at one aspect of
00:39:21 this problem. There seems to be something that the traditional model of, you know, you grow up,
00:39:26 you leave home, start, you know, find a life partner and then have children. That traditional
00:39:32 model just doesn't seem to be as popular amongst Canadians or frankly across the Western world as
00:39:38 it used to be. It's still what most people are doing, but few and few people are doing it.
00:39:43 I've heard mixed weight given to economic factors for people not having children,
00:39:49 because I think we often hear, oh, it's too expensive to have kids, it's too difficult.
00:39:53 But I've also heard some studies that have showed that's really not the reason people aren't,
00:39:58 that very few people are refraining from having children because of the cost. And I was wondering
00:40:01 if you could weigh in on that. Sure. I mean, the reality is our grandparents
00:40:07 parents, you know, had way less in terms of resources than we have, and yet tended to have
00:40:12 more children. You know, my grandmother lived in a small village in the north of Yorkshire,
00:40:17 and her husband was farm laborer, and they had four children. So, you know, some of these economic
00:40:23 arguments don't really work. Generally, what we see is the more money people have, the fewer kids
00:40:28 that they're having. And so, you know, I think to say, well, you know, we can't afford children,
00:40:33 well okay but you know why wasn't that true 20 30 years ago because certainly although incomes have
00:40:40 been you know haven't really been uh advancing that much in Canada the last the last couple of
00:40:46 years if you look over the last couple of decades um people now are a lot better off than they were
00:40:51 20 30 years ago in your proposals of just possible policies that we could include one that I found
00:40:58 interesting because it's not often, I don't often see it in this context, was looking at ways to
00:41:03 reduce the formal educational requirements for jobs. So to actually basically get people into
00:41:09 the labor market earlier. And I was wondering if you could expound on that a bit. Sure, because I
00:41:13 think one thing that's happening is people are spending longer and longer in formal education.
00:41:18 And particularly for women, that's a problem because fertility for women starts to fall after 1.00
00:41:24 the age of 30 and falls quite significantly after the age of 35. So the more time you're spending
00:41:31 in formal education and people usually, for obvious reasons, want to put off starting a
00:41:35 family until they've completed their formal education. Often you want to get kind of that
00:41:40 first job, get your first step on the career ladder before having a family. So all of that
00:41:44 is narrowing the window that people have to start a family and have children. And so I think we do 0.97
00:41:51 need to ask ourselves as a society do we necessarily need the you know the credentials do we need
00:41:57 people to be spending quite as long in informal education as they as they currently do um you
00:42:02 know canadians that were a very very educated society and and that's a good thing but we now
00:42:08 have so many people going to university there certainly a number of researchers have raised
00:42:12 the idea that we may just be getting into a bit of a rat race um you know think of medical school
00:42:18 for instance a huge number of people applying to medical school and so you can be choosy about who
00:42:24 you take you know in times gone by it may have been just enough to have had a medical degree
00:42:29 but now people want you to do another degree first and then maybe a master's degree and then maybe
00:42:35 some other training as well before you even get into medical school which is to say nothing about
00:42:40 the amount of time that you have to spend there so it's what economists call credentialism so
00:42:46 The idea is that university often just simply acts as a way to filter people according to
00:42:53 ability, and spending five years there as opposed to three years isn't necessarily
00:42:59 improving your human capital. Employees are just using university as a sorting mechanism,
00:43:06 which is all very well, but it means that more and more of people's reproductive years are being
00:43:11 spent you know going and getting these credentials well and there's also been a decline of careers
00:43:18 i mean we've all heard sort of the rise of the gig economy and i think the economy in some ways has
00:43:23 been a positive it gives people opportunities and flexibility and whatnot but a lot of that is not
00:43:28 coming about because someone has chosen to engage in gig work it's because it's been available to
00:43:33 them and that idea i mean not that we're ever going to go back to the eight days where you know
00:43:37 you started a company and you're there for 40 years and you retire and it's
00:43:41 great. Like, I think that era is pretty much over,
00:43:44 but the inability for a lot of people or the apparent inability to find a
00:43:50 career that gives them that stability is I think not helping.
00:43:54 Oh, absolutely. I mean, when, you know,
00:43:57 having a family is even getting married and settling down and buying a house,
00:44:02 I mean, that's a bet on the future.
00:44:04 And so you need to have a pretty positive view of the future. You need to have an idea that there's a, you know, there's a bit of a ladder there. You know, hopefully that you'll, you know, you'll have a fairly safe and stable stream of income.
00:44:18 And when you ask people about the future, Canadians are much more, especially young Canadians, are much more worried about the future than they used to be, much more concerned about their ability to have a house, to have a decent income.
00:44:34 And so, as you say, Andrew, yes, people may be making enough now, but will that stream continue in the future?
00:44:41 People just aren't as sure of that as they might have been 20, 30, 40 years ago when the labor market looked quite different.
00:44:46 well it's a fascinating piece in the hub and if that uh is not enough for you you should go and
00:44:53 read the actual report in the mcdonald laurier institute uh which is 56 pages but very readable
00:44:59 and i think very significant uh dr tim sargent well done and thank you so much for coming on
00:45:04 thanks for having me andrew all right well that does it for us for today let me know your thoughts
00:45:09 and just before we go i got i'm in shameless promo mode today so uh let's throw that event
00:45:14 page up. I, my book tour starts in just a couple of weeks, uh, courtesy of the Modern Miracle
00:45:20 Network in Canada, Strong and Free Network, starting in Calgary, uh, and then Toronto and
00:45:25 then Ottawa and perhaps some other cities. I, we, I think I have an event in London. I have an event
00:45:29 coming up in Norwich, but that one hasn't been announced yet, but I mean, and now I guess I've
00:45:33 just announced it, but, uh, I can't remember the date offhand, but, uh, if you want details about
00:45:37 those, the website is modernmiraclenetwork.org slash Lawton. Hope to see you out there and get
00:45:44 a copy of this bad boy behind me there that's it for today we will talk to you all tomorrow thank
00:45:48 you god bless and good day to you all thanks for listening to the andrew lawton show support the
00:45:54 program by donating to true north at www.tnc.news
00:46:14 We'll be right back.
00:46:44 We'll be right back.