Juno News - March 06, 2024


Liberals not committing to Emergencies Act reforms – just "consultations"

Topics
Mentioned
Canadian Police FAILED to protect an event with G7 Leaders Are chemical abortions impacting the water supply?

Episode Stats


Length

44 minutes

Words per minute

167.38

Word count

7,415

Sentence count

357

Harmful content

Misogyny

4

sentences flagged

Toxicity

1

sentences flagged

Hate speech

11

sentences flagged


Summary

Summaries generated with gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ .

In this episode of The Andrew Lawton Show, Andrew takes a look at the Public Order Emergency Commission's report on the use of the Emergencies Act by the Trudeau government, and why perhaps Canadians are not as woke as you may think or fear.

Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Topics generated with Qwen2.5-3B-Instruct.
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 Transcription by CastingWords
00:00:30 Thank you.
00:01:00 welcome to canada's most irreverent talk show this is the andrew lawton show brought to you by true
00:01:19 north hello and welcome to you all welcome back my friends to the show that never ends that is
00:01:30 an old i i wouldn't call it classic rock it's a song by emerson lake and palmer that palmer that
00:01:36 used to be on my old radio show a part of my theme song and when i moved the show over to
00:01:43 true north i was not able to get the rights to use the song so we got like you know generic
00:01:48 royalty-free intro music a but it's kind of grown on me so hope you enjoy it as well and if not well
00:01:53 it's short and then i come on and i'm i guess uh more pleasant to the ears less pleasant don't uh
00:01:58 interrogate that point too much but good to talk to you wherever in this lovely country or world
00:02:04 you are tuning in from whether you're listening or watching live or catching us on the podcast or
00:02:09 perhaps reading a transcript uh you know 973 years in the future i hope the weather is lovely and the
00:02:16 global warming hasn't destroyed you all. Going to talk about a few of the big picture issues of the
00:02:21 day in the program this afternoon. Going to talk about wokeness and why there might actually be
00:02:27 just a little bit of good news on the horizon. Perhaps Canadians are and Canada is not as woke
00:02:33 as you may think or fear. Also going to give the latest on Bill C-63. This is Justin Trudeau's
00:02:40 latest assault on free speech, trying to curb what you can say and see online under the guise
00:02:47 of online hate, of tackling online hate. My air quotes are always lopsided because I'm like trying
00:02:52 to avoid punching the, well, now I've just punched the bottom of the mic. So anyway, we're having fun
00:02:56 today. And what else do we have later on in the show? I will, well, actually let's get to this
00:03:02 right now because the Emergencies Act was one of the most dangerous pieces of legislation that
00:03:08 Justin Trudeau has ever decided to cozy up to. It's a bill that was put in place to deal
00:03:13 predominantly with the idea of war and strife and catastrophe. And Justin Trudeau decided to
00:03:19 invoke the Emergencies Act when he had bouncy castles in his front yard. That was, and not even
00:03:25 literally his front yard, on the street near his office. That was what Justin Trudeau saw
00:03:29 as being war, catastrophe, calamity, strife, unrest, and all of that. So it's been litigated now,
00:03:36 both literally and figuratively for quite some time, that the Emergencies Act was used by the
00:03:42 government because it just did not like the truckers. It didn't like the people that were
00:03:46 protesting vaccine mandates. It didn't like the people that were doing all of this stuff that was
00:03:52 embarrassing the government and trying to hold them to account for the COVID era policies that
00:03:57 I think very much caused divisions and strife in society, not the convoy. It was the policies that
00:04:02 the convoy came in response to that were causing division. So the government looks at this, realizes
00:04:08 its window is closing, says, okay, we're going to invoke the Emergencies Act. We're going to use
00:04:12 this unprecedented piece of legislation, this unprecedented tool. We're going to conscript
00:04:18 tow truck drivers. We're going to declare protests, no-go zones. We're going to criminalize
00:04:23 protests basically. And we're also to cap it all off, going to freeze the bank accounts of anyone
00:04:28 that we think is giving support. It doesn't matter if they've been charged or convicted
00:04:32 of anything. If we hand their name on a list to the banks, the banks are going to do our bidding
00:04:37 and they are going to freeze those people's accounts. That was what happened. And I'm putting
00:04:42 a glib 30-second summary on it, but we cannot overstate just how extreme and how severe
00:04:48 these measures that the Liberals championed were and remain in history as. So you fast forward a
00:04:56 little bit after and the Public Order Emergency Commission convened. Justice Paul Rouleau was
00:05:01 appointed as the commissioner, and he ultimately found, it was very narrow, but he ultimately found
00:05:06 that the government had made a reasonable or justified decision. He looked at the evidence,
00:05:11 he convened testimony, he had pages and pages, thousands of pages of evidence, ended up producing
00:05:17 what I think was a 5,000 page report, but he ultimately sided with the government. Now we'll
00:05:23 get to in a moment why that isn't quite the win that Justin Trudeau has tried to convince people
00:05:28 it is. But before I go there, I should point out that even with that, he listed several
00:05:33 recommendations. I think it was about 56 recommendations total, 22 that were specifically
00:05:39 pertaining to amendments that he thought, this is Commissioner Rouleau, the Emergencies Act
00:05:45 warranted. And I want to play a small clip here of Justice Rouleau announcing his findings.
00:05:51 after careful reflection i have concluded that the very high threshold required for the invocation
00:06:00 of the act was met in particular for reasons that i discuss in detail in the report i have
00:06:07 concluded that when the decision was made to invoke the act on february 14 2022 cabinet had
00:06:16 reasonable grounds to believe that there existed a national emergency arising from threats to the
00:06:25 security of Canada that necessitated the taking of special temporary measures. I do not come to
00:06:33 this conclusion easily, as I do not consider the factual basis for it to be overwhelming.
00:06:40 me reasonable and informed people could reach a different conclusion than the one I have arrived
00:06:48 at I determined that the measures taken by the federal government were for the most part
00:06:53 appropriate and effective and contributed to bringing a return to order without loss of life
00:06:59 or serious injury to people or property I also found however that in a number of respects these
00:07:08 measures were deficient. These included important aspects of the emergency economic
00:07:14 measures order, such as the absence of any discretion related to the freezing of accounts
00:07:21 or assets, and the failure to provide a clear way for individuals to have their assets unfrozen
00:07:29 once they were no longer engaged in legal conduct.
00:07:33 so that was a bit of the oversight and I think the key point there is when he says yes I found
00:07:40 that the government was justified however it was not overwhelming evidence and moreover he said
00:07:46 another reasonable person could look at this and come up with their own conclusion now I won't go
00:07:52 through the whole 5,000 page report which I'm ashamed to admit I have actually read most of
00:07:58 that's how little of a life I had that when this came out it took me quite a while and I kind of
00:08:02 jumped back and forth as I was going to and from the more interesting parts. I'm not going to read
00:08:08 all of the recommendations, but if you look at the recommendations that he made, a lot of it is
00:08:12 about communication between different branches of law enforcement. A lot of it is making sure that
00:08:17 there isn't this jurisdictional overlap or conversely that gaps are being created because
00:08:22 of jurisdictional fights between the federal government and provincial governments and all
00:08:27 of that. He's talked about the importance of beefing up police liaison teams, which ended
00:08:31 up becoming quite a crucial part of the discussion and debate around law enforcement. But he's also
00:08:37 mentioned in a number of points here, some specific recommendations for the Emergencies Act. Now,
00:08:43 the federal government is supposed to take that and issue a response. They're supposed to take
00:08:49 this to heart. They don't need to give him everything he's asking for. They don't need to
00:08:53 do it all, but they need to basically show that they're acknowledging it. Now, the government has
00:08:57 been slow walking this. They've waited until the very last day, I believe, or the very last week
00:09:02 of when they had to respond. And in doing so, they're kind of showing that this is an afterthought.
00:09:08 They're showing that this is not really something about which they care all that much. And I think
00:09:12 to understand that, you have to fast forward to the fact that the federal government had its rear
00:09:17 end handed to it a few weeks back when the federal court ruled that the use of the Emergencies Act
00:09:23 was unconstitutional. It did not meet the threshold. And more importantly, the things
00:09:27 they used the Emergencies Act to do violated unjustifiably the constitutional rights of
00:09:33 Canadians. Now, ever since that moment, my theory on this, and again, I could be wrong
00:09:38 to use the Commissioner Rouleau line, a reasonable person can come up with another
00:09:42 conclusion. But my theory on this is that the federal government has kind of been embarrassed
00:09:47 by this. They've actually, for the first time in the course of their handling of COVID and the
00:09:51 Convoy and the Emergencies Act, they've had to endorse, well, they've had to accept a bit of
00:09:57 shame when it's a shameless government normally, but in this case, they've had to really accept
00:10:01 that. And in doing so, what is abundantly clear, abundantly clear is that they do not want to talk
00:10:08 about the Emergencies Act anymore. They don't want to have a debate about amendments to it because
00:10:11 they don't want their record to be front and center once again, which brings us to this morning
00:10:17 and Dominic LeBlanc, who is the president of the Treasury Board,
00:10:21 saying that the government's not really going to amend the Emergencies Act at all.
00:10:25 They're kind of going to leave it as is, at least for now. Take a look.
00:10:28 Commission's final report found that the high threshold to invoke the Emergencies Act was met
00:10:34 and the decision was appropriate.
00:10:38 It also contained 56 recommendations to address gaps that were identified
00:10:42 and proposed changes that should be made if the Act were ever to be invoked again.
00:10:49 The government's response focuses on ongoing and next steps as they relate to each of those recommendations.
00:10:58 February 2022 marked the first time that the Emergencies Act was invoked since it became law in 1988.
00:11:07 The hindsight provided by the Commission's work, as well as the work undertaken by the Government of Canada and parliamentarians, offers us a critical outlook on potential changes that could be brought to the Emergencies Act.
00:11:22 As such, the government of Canada will engage directly provinces and territories, Indigenous partners, stakeholders and civil society on all 22 Emergencies Act related recommendations, including seeking views on potential legislative amendments as described in those recommendations.
00:11:45 so he's saying oh yes we're we're going to have some consultations we're going to talk about it
00:11:52 we won't do anything unless we talk about it we're going to have some some more chit chat we'll talk
00:11:56 to indigenous groups i don't know why you need to talk to indigenous groups about the emergencies
00:12:00 act we're going to talk to other stakeholders didn't really specify who those were i presume
00:12:04 all people that will just rubber stamp what the government did will he talk to protesters will he
00:12:10 talk to people in the Freedom Convoy? Will he talk to other people that the government might
00:12:14 want to use the Emergencies Act to seize the civil liberties of? I'm not sure we didn't get 0.99
00:12:20 that level of specificity from Dominic LeBlanc. Now, if you look at what the commissioner's
00:12:26 report called for here, a lot of these things are very reasonable. One of them is they should
00:12:31 eliminate from the Emergencies Act the section that refers to the CSIS Act definition of threats
00:12:38 to the security of Canada. This ended up becoming really the linchpin of the government's argument,
00:12:43 which was, what is the definition of a threat to the security of Canada? And the Emergencies Act
00:12:48 outsources that definition to another piece of legislation, to the CSIS Act. And interestingly,
00:12:53 it was the CSIS head who said, yeah, he didn't think that the threshold was met.
00:13:00 So now the Emergencies Act is basically in the position that the government wants it in,
00:13:05 which is there's a source of confusion around it, which the government can kind of leverage
00:13:09 for its own political gain. A commissioner also called for a review to ensure that the definition
00:13:16 of a public order emergency is exactly what it should be and what it needs to be. What else did
00:13:21 he recommend here? That there should be a consultation requirement with the territories,
00:13:26 not just the province. So that's more of a technicality. This one I find is quite interesting.
00:13:31 the federal government should engage in discussions with indigenous communities
00:13:35 to establish the appropriate parameters for consultations regarding possible recourse
00:13:40 to the act. So they're trying to put in this race-based litmus test to how the act and how
00:13:46 consultations are dealt with. That is, the government's only going to screw up. They
00:13:50 never do anything on the indigenous file particularly well. That's certainly been 1.00
00:13:54 true of this liberal government, as a great many indigenous advocates and activists have said.
00:13:58 and they also say that the provinces and feds need to mitigate infringement on provincial
00:14:04 jurisdiction. Well, mitigate is a bit of a weird one because you had all the provinces but Ontario
00:14:10 saying, we didn't ask for this act. Why are you doing this act that basically lets you storm
00:14:15 into our province and our provincial jurisdiction? So all of these questions, and more by the way,
00:14:22 I just read a sampling, are questions that the commissioner put to the government that said,
00:14:26 okay, yes, I'm siding with you in part, but here are all these things that you've got to deal with.
00:14:32 And the federal government has now just said, we're taking our marbles and going home. We liked
00:14:37 that you said we won. We wanted you to just end it there. We didn't really want all these
00:14:41 recommendations. We don't want to deal with those. When the federal court came and smacked down the
00:14:45 federal government by saying it was unconstitutional, the government just completely lost
00:14:50 all interest in dealing with the Emergencies Act. The government turned around and basically said,
00:14:55 all right. Yeah, we're kind of done with this now. We only liked this when it looked like it was a
00:14:59 win for us. But now that people are starting to turn on that, we want you to pretend it never
00:15:04 happened. So this is the Liberals in denial through and through. It's the Liberals not
00:15:09 wanting to deal with what will become, maybe not in the next election, but certainly in the history
00:15:14 books, one of the most profound failings of the Justin Trudeau government, because this was
00:15:19 literally invoking the closest Canadian legal equivalent of martial law. I realize it wasn't
00:15:26 military control, which is why I'm couching my language there. The closest Canadian equivalent 0.71
00:15:31 to martial law and invoking that to deal with, again, bouncy castles and horns. And the horns
00:15:37 weren't even that bad near the end of the protest, as police officials attested to in their testimony
00:15:43 before the Public Order Emergency Commission. But everything else, it's the government was just
00:15:47 embarrassed. And humiliation on a grand national scale is not, I guarantee you, a national
00:15:53 emergency, not in any interpretation of the law. But again, the assaults of civil liberties do not
00:15:58 end with Justin Trudeau's invocation of the Emergencies Act. Bill C-63, the so-called
00:16:04 Online Harms Act, is the government's very direct way of reining in what it says is hate speech.
00:16:11 And again, every time I talk about this issue, I have to put this caveat in. Hate speech is
00:16:16 something that has a very specific meaning. It has a very specific definition. Hate speech is not
00:16:22 just speech you don't like, except a lot of these measures are applied to that. This is what we see
00:16:28 in social media speech codes from platforms like, not as much Twitter anymore, but historically
00:16:33 platforms like Twitter and Facebook. So hate speech is supposed to be something that has a
00:16:39 very significant, very strict meaning, but the government is muddying that and they're using
00:16:44 the apparatus of the state. They're using the Canadian Human Rights Commission under
00:16:48 Bill C-63 to go after it. The result is going to be online discourse, which is throttled and
00:16:54 managed by the liberal government in this malign alliance between big tech platforms who are
00:16:59 forced to basically uphold the government's so-called hate speech edict. So I want to talk
00:17:04 about this, as I've said, continuously. I want to hit this issue from all angles because this is,
00:17:09 for me, the big battle here. This is the hill to die on. Free speech, it always has been.
00:17:14 John Carpe is the president of the Justice Center for Constitutional Freedoms.
00:17:18 And just as a matter of disclosure, I will remind you that I am on the board of the JCCF,
00:17:22 but this is not, for your sake, John, a performance evaluation by any stretch.
00:17:27 Always good to talk to you. Thanks for coming on today.
00:17:29 Glad to be with you, Andrew.
00:17:31 So you and I have spoken in the past about this.
00:17:33 The government has done us the courtesy of being very transparent about what it wants to do for quite some time.
00:17:39 And we've seen in the course of the last couple of years that this trio of Internet regulations from Bill C-11, which puts a podcast registry and brings the regulatory control of the CRTC to government and or to the Internet.
00:17:54 And then you have C-18, which throttles online news.
00:17:57 And now you've got this finishing move on online discourse here.
00:18:02 And let me just ask first and foremost, when the government comes out and says, we are duty bound to protect the charter.
00:18:09 does that pacify your concerns? Oh, no. Governments always claim to be, pretend to be
00:18:18 in favor of charter rights and freedoms. It's almost unheard of that a politician's going to
00:18:26 up front say, oh yeah, we're violating your charter freedom of expression. No, no, no. They
00:18:32 insist that this is not going to have any adverse impact on free speech. And that's outrageous to
00:18:42 assert that. That's false. We're going to have new powers given to the Canadian Human Rights
00:18:48 Commission. We're going to have regulations passed by Prime Minister Trudeau and his cabinet
00:18:54 colleagues, censorship regulations without input from parliament enforced by the online
00:19:00 offline digital safety commission. We've got, you know, preemptive punishment for people where
00:19:08 a judge can order you to wear an ankle bracelet and be under house arrest because you might
00:19:13 commit a speech crime. It is just to suggest that this is, you know, has no impact on free
00:19:21 expression is just ridiculous. It's outrageous to assert that. I wanted to ask you about that 0.81
00:19:27 thought crime aspect? Because I remember when that Tom Cruise movie some years back, Minority
00:19:31 Report, came out. It was literally a dystopian thriller. The premise of the movie was that
00:19:38 police could see the future and they'd go around arresting people for crimes they were about to
00:19:42 commit. And in this particular case, you literally have government taking the thing that was like
00:19:48 the conspiracy theorist warning about what this dystopian futuristic government could do
00:19:53 and enshrining it in legislation?
00:19:55 Well, if the online harms bill passes in its current form
00:19:59 and the Justice Centre is actively mobilizing to stop that,
00:20:04 we've already had over 26,000 people sign our online petition.
00:20:08 I hope to be delivering hard copies of that to Parliament in April.
00:20:15 But if it passes in its current form,
00:20:18 indeed there's a provision there where you can go before provincial court,
00:20:22 a judge. You can say, well, I think my next door neighbor, let's call him Mark Smith. Apologies to
00:20:28 any Mark Smiths out there. I think Mark Smith is going to commit a speech crime. He's going to
00:20:34 promote anti-Semitism or he's going to advocate for genocide. I think he's going to do that. 0.95
00:20:40 Mark Smith has to appear in court. Now, the judge does need a reasonable basis that the fear is
00:20:49 is well-founded, that there's a reasonable basis for the fear. So it's not automatic. However,
00:20:55 just the specter of that, that you could be hauled before a court where a judge, if a judge believes
00:21:02 this complainant that you might commit a speech crime, already the judge can say,
00:21:08 okay, it's an ankle bracelet, house arrest. We're telling you there's certain people you cannot
00:21:14 contact or communicate with. There's places where you can't go. You have to turn in your legally 0.89
00:21:19 owned legally acquired firearms you get all these conditions placed upon you without having
00:21:26 committed any crime that's in the bill if it passes in its current form when we talk about
00:21:33 the the speech aspect of this one of the things that has changed between section 13
00:21:38 in its original uh form this is the the provision of the human rights act that
00:21:42 uh was repealed by the previous conservative government the provision allowing the prosecution
00:21:46 of online so-called hate speech and and now is that we have a bit more clarity from the supreme
00:21:52 court of canada on what that uh what hate speech is and that came through a decision called the
00:21:58 watcott decision which uh the government kind of copied and pasted in defining what hate speech is
00:22:04 here and i wanted to ask you first off if you could just explain you're smirking so why don't
00:22:09 you just go with whatever's on your mind right now about this decision well the supreme court
00:22:14 devoted no fewer than 4,000 words trying to explain what hate is outside of the criminal
00:22:23 code context. So what does hate mean when human rights legislation bars hate speech?
00:22:30 And it is the most meandering, muddled, confusing 4,000 words you could read. There is zero clarity.
00:22:37 The reason I'm smiling is because it's hilarious in a way, and it's also sad and twisted and sick,
00:22:43 but it's hilarious that the government very proudly proclaims that they're going to bring
00:22:48 laws into compliance with the great clarity that the Supreme Court provided in the Whatcott
00:22:57 decision. Look, if you can't say what hate is in less than 4,000 words, there's a reason for that.
00:23:03 It's because hate is an emotion and it is subjective. You and I could hear or see the
00:23:08 exact same, listen to the same podcast, see the same YouTube video. You could say it's hateful.
00:23:13 I could say, no, it's not. Or I could say it's hateful. You would say it's not. So the Supreme
00:23:18 Court actually said that it is okay to ridicule and belittle and hurt the feelings of people
00:23:24 and to promote dislike and disdain. However, do not cross the line into detestation and
00:23:31 vilification. So you tell me, Andrew, what's the difference between detestation, which you cannot
00:23:38 promote detestation that's hate speech but you can promote disdain which is not hate speech
00:23:44 yeah i i read i've re i read this every time i talk about the issue and i'll read it again
00:23:49 because i think it underlines the absurdity you're describing here john which is um that
00:23:53 this is from the online harms act hate speech means the content of a communication that expresses
00:23:59 detestation or vilification of an individual or group of individuals on the basis of a prohibited
00:24:04 ground of discrimination for greater certainty. So we're supposed to be more certain at the end
00:24:08 of this paragraph, the content of a communication does not express detestation or vilification
00:24:13 solely because it expresses disdain or dislike, or it discredits, humiliates, hurts, or offends.
00:24:20 So you can hurt, but you can't vilify. You can dislike, but you can't detest. You can disdain,
00:24:27 but you can't vilify or detail. I mean, look, this is going to come down to that old, I think
00:24:34 it was Oliver Wendell Holmes on pornography in the US Supreme Court. I know it when I see it,
00:24:39 which is not exactly instilling a big dose of confidence in very rigorous, clear lines on free
00:24:46 speech. No, the Canadian Human Rights Commission, if the bill passes, will once again have the power
00:24:53 to prosecute Canadians, even based on anonymous complaints. So you could have like an atheist in 0.99
00:24:59 Vancouver follows a complaint against a Christian lady in Halifax over having made disparaging
00:25:06 remarks about a mosque in Toronto. Okay. And that could be anonymous. And even if the members of
00:25:14 that mosque are not offended by it, it doesn't matter. And then you get these unelected,
00:25:21 unaccountable bureaucrats, most of them progressive, woke, they're going to look at your speech and
00:25:27 decide whether it's hateful or not, regardless of whether anybody was damaged by it. You don't
00:25:32 even need a victim. You could just have the Human Rights Commission bureaucrat prosecute you because
00:25:37 she thinks that what you said is hateful. It will go before the tribunal. And if you are found guilty
00:25:45 of violating the new regulations through the Online Harms Act, then penalties could be
00:25:53 paying up to $50,000 to the federal government, plus on top of that, up to $20,000 paid to the
00:26:01 victim of your hateful speech. $70,000, you could be out of pocket, and that doesn't even cover
00:26:08 a penny of your legal bills. So that's a new reality that we're going to be into if this
00:26:15 legislation passes. I should point out it was not Oliver Wendell Holmes. It was Justice Potter
00:26:21 Stewart who used that line. So with all due apology to Potter Stewart for attributing his
00:26:27 quote to someone else. But I think he had lifted it from like Arthur Conan Doyle or something. But
00:26:31 anyway, let me ask you about that fine. Because, you know, one of the things that strikes me from
00:26:36 reading this is that you don't even really have to have suffered a loss or a harm to be eligible to
00:26:41 be a victim and a complainant. Someone could make an inappropriate comment about some group that
00:26:46 you're a member of, it wasn't applied to you individually, and you could be the one who found
00:26:50 it and reported it and, you know, be the one who complains to the Human Rights Commission.
00:26:55 And, you know, again, I don't want to be too, I don't even think it's a conspiracy at this point.
00:26:59 I could see a bunch of people that check off all of these diversity boxes sitting on their computer
00:27:04 all day and just mining Twitter to try to find something. And you could end up, you know,
00:27:10 amassing like, you know, $2 million in the span of a few weeks of work, just trying to find these
00:27:15 things that you can complain about. And again, that's not to say that the tribunal will go along
00:27:19 with that, but it doesn't seem like the law itself would do anything to stop that because
00:27:25 there is nothing saying that you couldn't just weaponize the complaints process or just profit
00:27:29 from it. Well, that's what happened before when you have Mark Stein and Ezra Levant were
00:27:34 prosecuted under Section 13 for Islamophobic or anti-Islam or whatever statements, whatever it
00:27:45 was, but they were huge legal bills, and it's very stressful. The women that the Justice Center 0.99
00:27:54 represented in British Columbia that were getting targeted by this person by the name of Yaniv,
00:27:59 who identified as a woman and had the male body parts and wanted a Brazilian bikini wax and would 1.00
00:28:08 phone these women, many of them working out of their own home with children. And the women would 0.99
00:28:16 say, well, sorry, we only provide this to women. And then Yaniv would file a human rights complaint.
00:28:22 And it was hugely stressful for these women that you get this letter from the BC Human Rights
00:28:26 commission saying a complaint has been filed against you. Legal proceedings have been commenced
00:28:32 and it's horrifically stressful. It's very time consuming. And if you don't have
00:28:38 the justice center or another group that's providing a lawyer for you, it can be
00:28:44 extremely expensive as well. Yeah. And I guess as we look forward here, obviously this is going to
00:28:51 go before committee testimony. I hope that you're called as a witness to testify. I don't think it
00:28:56 will be Justin Trudeau that calls you up for your counsel or or input on this but you know I hope
00:29:01 they at least hear it but what are what recourse is even available right now obviously you've got
00:29:06 a petition it's really politicians that have to be the one at this stage to stand up against this
00:29:11 is it not well people should also contact senators uh senators are far less under the control of
00:29:19 Prime Minister Trudeau than the Liberal Party members of Parliament. But people should contact
00:29:27 their MP, regardless of what party affiliation, and particularly if your MP is a Liberal or New
00:29:35 Democrat, if they're hearing from a lot of constituents that there's opposition to this
00:29:41 bill, they care about their re-election, they're nervous, and you could contribute to their being
00:29:48 internal opposition, you know, the only thing necessary for evil to triumph is for good people
00:29:53 to do nothing. So let's not do nothing. Let's phone and email our MPs and let's, you know,
00:30:00 sign petitions. Let's spread the word to our neighbors and let's foment, let's exercise our
00:30:07 responsibilities as citizens in a democracy. John Carpe, Justice Center for Constitutional
00:30:14 freedoms. Thank you very much, John. Thank you, Andrew. All right. Well, let's take a bit of a
00:30:19 turn to the bigger picture here. With laws like this getting onto the books in Canada, it's easy
00:30:23 to take a rather pessimistic view at the state of things. And I warn you that I oftentimes am
00:30:29 guilty of being the source of pessimism. I try to be smiling about it, but then I read what I've
00:30:34 said and I'm like, oh man, we really, as a country, went down that road, didn't we? But
00:30:38 there is a little bit of a reason to be optimistic. And that is that spending time talking to real
00:30:42 people, as I try to do as much as possible, real people will often give you more confidence in the
00:30:49 country than reading headlines will. And it was interesting, this jumped up on my radar the other
00:30:54 day. Eric Kaufman, who's been on the show a couple of times in the past, he's a Canadian, but he's
00:30:59 living in the UK and he's a professor at the University of Buckingham, did a piece that was
00:31:05 quite fascinating with the Macdonald-Laurier Institute that found, there you see it right
00:31:11 there, the politics of culture wars in contemporary Canada. It found that Canadians are actually not 0.58
00:31:17 as woke as you might be led to believe by many of those in positions of power in the media and in
00:31:23 the political elites. I wanted to bring on Eric to talk about that a bit further. Good to talk to
00:31:28 you again, Eric. Thanks for coming back on the show today. It's good to be here, Andrew. Excuse
00:31:33 me, I've got a slight cold, but hopefully not. That's quite all right. Hopefully we won't strain
00:31:37 you too much in the next few minutes here. You and I spoke about your desire to bring a bit of
00:31:42 an academic focus to wokeness in the past. So it was interesting for this to come up here.
00:31:46 What did you set out to question first off? Well, yeah, this was, I've done surveys on the
00:31:53 culture war opinion in the US and Britain in 2021 and 2022. I was just interested as a Canadian to
00:32:01 see what the Canadian public opinion looks like in relation to Britain and the US. Clearly in
00:32:06 public policy terms, Canada has charted the kind of most what you might call woke or cultural
00:32:12 socialist path compared to the other countries. And so I was wondering if we could pick up that
00:32:18 trace in public opinion. And what really surprised me was that the Canadian public was basically a
00:32:25 carbon copy of the British and American publics. There was really no consistent difference in
00:32:30 their level of support for the woke position on whether that be um gender ideology critical race
00:32:37 and history um it seems like there's no real difference what i find fascinating about that
00:32:44 is that the institutional approach to these issues is vastly different in these countries i mean you
00:32:50 live in the united kingdom i follow uk news quite a bit you have issues of police departments that
00:32:55 are knocking on your door if you tweet the wrong pronoun there. And you have this non-crime hate
00:33:01 incident thing that is incredibly chilling. Whereas in the US, you have kind of the opposite,
00:33:06 which is, sure, you've got infiltration of school boards, but you've got strong First Amendment
00:33:10 protections. You've got a very strong culture of debate and discussion. Canada is probably
00:33:15 somewhere in between. So how does that happen? Where on one hand, you have just these institutions
00:33:19 in these three countries that have wildly different approaches to these issues, but the people
00:33:23 are the same in all three. Well, I mean, I would say that I, you know, I think in Canada,
00:33:30 certainly on the gender issue, they were the latest to push back in the three societies,
00:33:36 especially if you consider the red states. But certainly in Britain, on gender affirmation,
00:33:41 there has been a very much more robust, you know, the Cass Review, they closed down
00:33:45 a major, the Tavistock Clinic. So it's just been a lot more responsive to public opinion. And
00:33:52 likewise on statues and history and there's now a review of sex education in schools in a way we
00:33:59 don't see that level of policy responsiveness in Canada. I mean one of the reasons one of the
00:34:06 things that jumped out in the data was that Canadians were more trusting of the media than
00:34:10 say British people and Americans and so one possible explanation is that the greater sort
00:34:18 of trust and leeway given to political elites by Canadians allows them to depart from public
00:34:24 opinion more than might be allowed in other countries. Well, and I would also say in the
00:34:30 UK, certainly you have a much more diverse media landscape. I mean, the British tabloids are all
00:34:36 the stuff of legend, but you also have in general, I think in the UK, there's much more of a presence
00:34:42 in mainstream media for conservative opinions. You've got the Daily Mail, the Telegraph and
00:34:47 GB News and Talk TV and all of these. Whereas in Canada, the independent media landscape has been
00:34:54 a more recent, it's a bit more nascent, I'd say. Yeah, I mean, you're right about that. I mean,
00:35:00 I think there are some, you notice in Britain, the politicians like in Canada, the conservative
00:35:05 politicians are quite timid on cultural issues and have been more focused on just that liberal
00:35:11 conservative fiscal conservatism um but i think have felt pressure more from the press perhaps
00:35:18 you're right i mean they've still been reluctant to move on a lot of these things but not as
00:35:22 reluctant as the canadian conservatives um now of course canadian conservatives we're starting to
00:35:28 see some movement uh starting in new brunswick with with premier higgs but but now pauliev has
00:35:33 said some things what we haven't seen however is any challenging of the critical race and historical
00:35:39 narrative so for whether that be the residential schools the genocide narrative and that approach
00:35:46 to Canadian history whereas in Britain in France in the U.S. that's been much more robustly
00:35:51 challenged and again what the survey data shows is Canadian two to one they're against removal
00:35:56 of statues of Sir John A. Macdonald 70 to 30 they say Canada is not a racist country I mean
00:36:02 more than Americans and Brits Canadians are reluctant to say their country is racist that
00:36:07 that just isn't being reflected at provincial or federal level, even if the gender debate is 0.99
00:36:13 starting to happen a little more. Yeah. And I was going to ask, because obviously the relative
00:36:18 value of Canada compared to the US and UK is interesting, but I'm also fascinated by the
00:36:23 absolute values in just Canada alone. And it is a clear majority that on all of these different
00:36:28 questions, and I was wondering if you just give a few more examples of which questions you've
00:36:32 probed here, but Canadians are overwhelmingly, if you can distill the binary into the woke option
00:36:37 and the non-woke option, it's the non-woke option winning every time, isn't it? Yeah, I mean, not
00:36:42 100% of the time, but on average, it's two to one against the woke option in public opinion. That's
00:36:48 a good rule to use. Now, there are certain questions. Should kids be separated by race
00:36:53 in school into oppressors and oppressed? 92 to eight against. Should school children be taught
00:37:00 there is is no such thing as biological sex only gender it's like 85 15 again you know massive or 0.83
00:37:06 which is quite massive because just to jump in on that eric if you because if you put that poll
00:37:10 question to your average uh teacher i think you're going to see a huge mismatch there exactly yeah i
00:37:17 mean the the i don't think a lot of canadians realize just how much these particularly the
00:37:22 radical end of things is is running against public opinion i mean set by a 70 to 30 margin for
00:37:28 Canadians to say they don't want teachers telling kids that Canada's a racist country.
00:37:33 You know, that is a that's a pretty massive opposition to to a policy which is kind of
00:37:38 running through a lot of schools, like the removal of Sir John A.
00:37:41 MacDonald. Again, public policy, the elite institutions are completely out of phase with
00:37:47 public opinion. And I think that really offers a lot of opportunities for the braver of the
00:37:54 Canadian politicians. So just to circle back to the trans issue, and you mentioned that the timidness 0.88
00:38:00 of Canadians, and I'd say Canadian Conservatives, this is one interesting one, because the UK Tories,
00:38:06 I would say, have never been a particularly culture warrior party. But in the last couple
00:38:11 of years, you've seen some movement on this issue. And I think there are probably some domestic
00:38:15 political realities there that aren't necessarily of interest to delve into for people. But I think,
00:38:21 You know, J.K. Rowling, I wonder if she plays a role in this in a lot of ways, because I think she has really given in Britain and I'd say around the world a face to the, you know, the right wing position, despite not actually fitting the mold of what people expect the right wing Haiti hate monger to be.
00:38:39 Yeah, I mean, you have a sort of vocal left-wing, often lesbian, gender-critical feminist group. 1.00
00:38:46 And, you know, it's interesting to watch because in The Guardian, they've been frozen out, which is the left-wing newspaper.
00:38:52 But they have found a voice even to some degree in The Independent, which is also somewhat left.
00:38:58 And so there is a kind of left-wing, gender-critical voice, which has been important, I would say, in Britain.
00:39:06 Rowling symbolizes that as well.
00:39:08 My sense in Canada, that's there, but they don't seem to have the public profile and they don't
00:39:13 seem to be moving the debate as much as they have in Britain. So yeah, I think on that question,
00:39:19 you definitely see the prominence of Britain, this joke about turf island. I think the turfs, 1.00
00:39:25 if you like, have had actually an impact in that particular policy area. It's quite noticeable.
00:39:30 And I don't know whether that's going to happen in Canada or not.
00:39:33 Now, I mean, obviously you're a scientist, so you don't necessarily like the prediction game,
00:39:39 but I'm curious if you were to just redo your UK and US surveys, do you think you'd see some
00:39:45 movement and which direction would that be going? And conversely, if you did the same in Canada,
00:39:50 say in two years, we might see some movement. I mean, there's been quite a bit of survey work on
00:39:55 attitudes on the sort of trans issue where just in the last three years, we've seen about a 20
00:40:01 point shift away from the woke position in Britain and the U.S. And in a way, given that a lot of
00:40:08 attitudes have kind of, if you think about gay marriage or interracial marriage, they've been
00:40:12 getting more and more progressive over time. This really sort of stands out. The British
00:40:17 Social Attitude Survey, I think, was the most recent one. And so it does appear like attitudes
00:40:23 on these questions are moving in the opposite direction that progressives would like, at least
00:40:29 in the U.S. and U.K. I suspect in Canada something similar is occurring, but again it just goes to
00:40:34 show that the momentum is moving away from the trans activist position. Now how do the
00:40:40 Conservatives in Canada handle that? You know clearly they're doing very well in the polls,
00:40:45 they probably don't want to rock the boat, but on the other hand they have to be at least somewhat
00:40:49 aware of what their grassroots are saying. And unlike an issue like abortion for example,
00:40:53 And these issues are, you know, two to one in the population.
00:40:56 So there's very little risk to go after them, I would say.
00:41:01 Now, I mentioned at the beginning, you and I spoke on this show when you had launched this class you were going to do on wokeness.
00:41:08 And I just wanted to get a bit of an update on that now that we're a couple of years into the term.
00:41:13 Well, the course on woke is well underway.
00:41:16 And, you know, people can definitely sign up, go to my Twitter and look at the pinned tweet.
00:41:20 yeah we've got probably four or five hundred expressed interests and the classes are the
00:41:26 seminar options I mean they're some of the most fun I've had no need to call on any students
00:41:32 everybody's got an opinion so yeah I think it's it's been a big success and I think it just shows
00:41:38 there's kind of a pent-up demand and people are coming at this I just did a little bit of a survey
00:41:43 you know because I'm such a survey wonk but it seems like the class splits roughly between left
00:41:48 and right in terms of their ideological affiliations. Some are more interested in the
00:41:54 gender side. Some are more interested in the critical race side. But yeah, I think it's been
00:41:59 very interesting. And it just strikes me, the outpouring of books on this. I mean, it seems
00:42:03 like every week there's another book. I've got one in May. So it's a crowded field, but somebody
00:42:07 has to sort of make sense of it all. And that would be Taboo, right?
00:42:12 Yeah. Yeah.
00:42:13 All right. The book is Taboo, How Making Race Sacred Produced a Cultural Revolution. So that
00:42:18 That is coming out in May.
00:42:20 We look forward to that.
00:42:21 We'll have to have you back on then.
00:42:23 Thanks, Andrew.
00:42:23 Thanks very much.
00:42:24 All right.
00:42:24 Thank you, Professor Eric Coffman.
00:42:26 Always a pleasure.
00:42:27 We will wrap things up there back tomorrow to close out the week of the Andrew Lawton
00:42:31 Show.
00:42:31 But as always, don't forget off the record on Fridays, I'll be back in the saddle this
00:42:36 week on in the saddle.
00:42:37 How are you in a saddle?
00:42:38 I've never actually questioned that term before because you should be on the saddle.
00:42:42 I mean, the horse is in the saddle, but that's not anyway.
00:42:45 Try not to picture it too much.
00:42:46 I'm already regretting it.
00:42:47 All right.
00:42:48 We'll be back tomorrow.
00:42:48 This is Canada's most irreverent talk show.
00:42:51 Thank you.
00:42:51 God bless.
00:42:52 And good day to you all.
00:42:53 Thanks for listening to the Andrew Lawton Show.
00:42:56 Support the program by donating to True North at www.tnc.news.
00:43:18 We'll be right back.
00:43:48 We'll be right back.