Juno News - September 26, 2023


Liberals scapegoat Anthony Rota for honouring Nazi veteran

Topics
Mentioned
Liberals invite Nazi veteran to House of Commons Anthony Rota's resignation doesn't end shameful Nazi scandal

Episode Stats


Length

44 minutes

Words per minute

179.24

Word count

8,005

Sentence count

333

Harmful content

Misogyny

1

sentences flagged

Toxicity

3

sentences flagged

Hate speech

3

sentences flagged


Summary

Summaries generated with gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ .

Speaker Anthony Rota has been the target of criticism from all sides of the aisle of Parliament for his handling of a Nazi hero honouring a Canadian hero who happened to be a Ukrainian Nazi veteran. He has been attacked by both sides of politics, the Liberals and the Tories, and he has had to defend himself against them.

Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Topics generated with Qwen2.5-3B-Instruct.
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 Transcription by CastingWords
00:00:30 Thank you.
00:01:00 welcome to canada's most irreverent talk show this is the andrew lawton show brought to you by true
00:01:20 north hello and welcome to you all this is the andrew lawton show canada's most irreverent talk
00:01:31 show here on true north great to have you with us 1 p.m eastern 10 a.m pacific 11 a.m in the
00:01:38 wonderful province of alberta i always forget what time it is in saskatchewan because i know that
00:01:43 half the year it's in a different time zone than the other so i just choose i love saskatchewan
00:01:47 I've been there several times, but I choose to gloss over it in the time zones.
00:01:51 I want to say they're two hours behind, but they may actually be one hour behind.
00:01:57 To be honest, it may be like Saturday morning at 4 a.m. in Saskatchewan.
00:02:01 Who knows these days?
00:02:03 And then if we head over to our wonderful friends in Atlantic Canada,
00:02:06 it is just 2 p.m. in much of the Maritimes,
00:02:10 but of course 2.30 for all you crazy cats in Newfoundland.
00:02:13 So wherever you are in this great country or beyond,
00:02:16 I welcome you to the show.
00:02:17 You are probably having a better day, whoever you are and wherever you are, than Anthony Rota, the Speaker of the House of Commons.
00:02:26 We spoke about him yesterday. He was the chap who introduced and honored a Canadian hero who happened to be a Ukrainian Nazi veteran on Friday.
00:02:37 I mean, who among us has not made that mistake at work? You know, just the other day on the show.
00:02:41 Wait, no, I've never done anything like that. But that's what Anthony Rota did on Friday.
00:02:45 yesterday, he had a fair bit of support from the Liberals. They were doing the finger wagging thing,
00:02:51 the I'm disappointed in you thing. Just as a matter of protocol here, if you've ever watched
00:02:57 House of Commons proceedings, because perhaps like me, you have no life, you'll know that all
00:03:03 comments have to be directed to the Speaker. So if you're talking about someone on the other side
00:03:07 of the aisle, you don't actually get to say, Justin Trudeau, I think you're a big smelly jerk. 1.00
00:03:11 you have to say, Mr. Speaker, the right Honorable Prime Minister is a big, sticky jerk. 1.00
00:03:18 When you're complaining about the Speaker, you actually get to talk to the Speaker, 0.99
00:03:22 and he's just got to sit there and at the end of it go, thank you for your comment, and move on.
00:03:27 So he has had to be bearing the slings and arrows of members of Parliament, deservedly so.
00:03:32 But what was interesting is how the Conservatives were the ones trying to throw him a bone.
00:03:37 We saw one such example of this from Chris Warkington, a conservative MP from Alberta, who was like, I mean, the Speaker must have wanted to leap out of his chair and give him a big old hug for this.
00:03:48 Mr. Speaker, I know your desire to take this on, but I don't believe for a second that you went, verified each person who was invited to this place, verified that they were not a security risk, and then stood at the door and let them in.
00:04:07 And I know that wasn't the truth.
00:04:10 So this attempt by the government to state that this was your doing and your doing alone,
00:04:16 that you alone are responsible and that they have bare no responsibility, is to send a
00:04:21 signal to all Canadians and all of our allies that we're not serious about anything.
00:04:27 Well, I'm not going to take collective responsibility for what in fact is the government's responsibility.
00:04:34 And Mr. Speaker, I'd recommend you not do it either.
00:04:37 That was Chris Warkenton throwing Anthony Roda a bit of a bone there.
00:04:43 We also saw a similar comment from Michael Barrett, a conservative MP,
00:04:47 who you may recall Michael Barrett as the guy that led the charge on the Wee scandal
00:04:52 as the ethics critic, which is a very...
00:04:55 I mean, ethics critic used to be a very minor position,
00:04:59 but the ethics critic became a pretty important role
00:05:01 when you're the official opposition against the Trudeau government.
00:05:04 But I digress. Here was Michael Barrett.
00:05:06 Time and time again, this Prime Minister and his Liberal House Leader say,
00:05:11 I had no idea it didn't involve me.
00:05:14 Time and time again, this Liberal Prime Minister fails in his duties to Canadians
00:05:20 and has someone else take the fall.
00:05:22 This week, it looks like he's going to come to you, Speaker,
00:05:25 and ask you to leave and to take the garbage out with you on the way out.
00:05:29 Is that really what this government wants to show to Canadians?
00:05:32 Mr. Speaker, again, that Honourable colleague would have seen your statement yesterday,
00:05:43 heard your apology in the House today, where the Speaker confirmed that this was his decision
00:05:49 and his decision alone to invite this individual from his riding to acknowledge him in the gallery.
00:05:57 we were all caught off guard by this we all stood and applauded because we were led to believe that
00:06:05 this was an individual who he was not and that is something that hurts all of us and embarrasses all
00:06:12 of us but there was no prior knowledge from the government i i was going i it would have been in
00:06:20 poor form given the circumstances but i was kind of thinking of that old hogan's heroes bit i won't
00:06:26 do the voice because i i'm terrible at impressions but you know i know nothing i see nothing like
00:06:30 that's basically been the liberal government's approach on this which is that it had nothing
00:06:34 to do with it it doesn't know who is speaker what speaker what nazi what not we we were we just got
00:06:39 out of bed one morning and there's this whole controversy and it must have been anthony rhoda's
00:06:44 fault and all the liberals who realize they have a bit of egg in their egg on their faces here
00:06:48 are saying that well you know maybe people who are being partisan are the real problem so
00:06:54 Like I predicted yesterday, it becomes a learning opportunity for all of us.
00:06:59 Now, all of this is besides the point in some way.
00:07:03 There was a thing that happened on Friday that was very disgraceful and very embarrassing.
00:07:08 As True North has written about as recently as this morning, you can see it has been a headline around the world.
00:07:15 The Prime Minister who thumped his chest and said Canada's back when he was elected has presided over yet another global laughingstock that is a made-in-Canada export.
00:07:27 You know we're not exporting a lot of stuff, we're not exporting as much oil, but you better believe we are exporting national shame with abandon.
00:07:34 If you could invest in national shame, you'd actually be a very rich person because that stock is getting higher and higher in value with each passing day of this government.
00:07:43 Now, this is, for a lot of people, very challenging.
00:07:47 Jews who were trying to commemorate and honor Yom Kippur, the holiest day of the Jewish calendar,
00:07:53 have instead been speaking around their dinner tables and lunch tables about this and about the shame they feel.
00:08:00 And I am not Jewish. I know many, many Jewish people, and I have a great many Jewish friends,
00:08:05 and I've loved my two times in Israel, and I think these people have been through a fair bit.
00:08:10 And the historic trauma they carry about the Holocaust is certainly emblazoned when acts
00:08:16 of Holocaust denial or Holocaust diminishment come up, or even ignorant things like this
00:08:22 that are re-traumatizing those who have a very deep history with the Nazis for understandable
00:08:29 reasons are upset about stuff like this.
00:08:32 And no one is defending it.
00:08:34 I mean, I shouldn't say no one.
00:08:36 I mean, you get some people that are saying, well, you know, maybe they're not that bad.
00:08:38 but no legitimate voice is defending this. The only question is who is responsible for it. And
00:08:45 you know, one thing that is problematic here is that when you have political staffers who have
00:08:51 never picked up a book in their lives, have never read anything about history, have apparently
00:08:56 never even watched an old war movie rerun on whatever the movie channels are, I don't know,
00:09:01 Turner Classic movies or whatever. These people, I don't even know if they get, I don't really
00:09:05 watched that myself, so I'm not judging there. But you get these people who know nothing about
00:09:09 history, where anyone could have just looked at this and said, hang on, fighting against the
00:09:17 Soviets in World War II. Okay, something, but maybe I'm just going to Google. 30 seconds of
00:09:23 Googling, this problem is solved. Unless, as Ezra Levant purported yesterday, this was not an
00:09:29 accident at all, but was perhaps something more intentional. Who knows? As I said on the show,
00:09:35 this is really taking the enemy of my enemy is my friend to new extremes here when someone is
00:09:41 honoring a Nazi just because they happen to be against the people who are today's bad guys in
00:09:47 Russia. Now one thing I'll point out from Karina Gould here that I think is particularly disgraceful
00:09:54 is that she as the liberal house leader decided the answer to what happened was to erase it from
00:10:02 history. You think I'm joking? Watch this. I'd like to ask for unanimous consent to adopt the
00:10:08 following motion, that notwithstanding any standing order, special order, or usual practice
00:10:14 of the House, the recognition made by the Speaker of the House of an individual present in the
00:10:19 galleries during the joint address to Parliament by His Excellency Vladimir Zelensky be struck
00:10:25 from the appendix of the House of Commons debates of Thursday, September 21st, 2023,
00:10:30 and from any House multimedia recording.
00:10:33 Thank you, Mr. Speaker.
00:10:36 Oh, yes, the Honourable.
00:10:39 I guess we have to go to the—we'll ask about unanimous consent, then go to it.
00:10:44 All those opposed to the Honourable Minister's moving the motion will please say nay.
00:10:49 We don't have unanimous consent.
00:10:52 This may seem like a bit of parliamentary theatrics, but what happened here is the
00:11:03 Liberal House leader introduced a motion to go back to the Hansards, which is the official record
00:11:09 of every word uttered in the House of Commons going back to Confederation in 1867, and she
00:11:15 wanted to have that edited out. Edit it out. So if you were to read through it, there would
00:11:22 basically be a gap and nothing would have happened. It was as though nothing, it was that it would
00:11:28 never, never took place. And even the official parliamentary video record, it would be edited
00:11:35 out. So you'd be scrolling through and there'd be like a 30 second jump there. And you'd wonder,
00:11:39 oh my goodness, what was that? Maybe there was a tech glitch, but that's what they wanted to do.
00:11:43 Talk about Orwellian censorship to go back and cover up this disgraceful episode
00:11:48 by pretending it never happened.
00:11:51 This is not the first time this has taken place.
00:11:55 You may recall a few years back,
00:11:56 I believe it was 2019 or it may have been 2018.
00:12:02 And what is 2018 actually?
00:12:03 There was a debate on Parliament Hill
00:12:05 in a committee on online hate
00:12:07 and I was there covering it.
00:12:09 Mark Stein, my colleague Lindsay Shepard
00:12:11 and John Robson were the witnesses.
00:12:14 And at the beginning of their session,
00:12:16 there was a motion introduced to rip, to literally rip out of the Hanserts, to rip out of the record
00:12:23 something that happened at the previous meeting, which was a conservative MP, Michael Cooper,
00:12:28 quoting from the New Zealand mosque killers manifesto to make a point. Now, I can't even
00:12:36 remember what the point was or what the excerpt was, but he did it. He was denounced and that was
00:12:41 that. And people could see what he said. They could see the denunciation and they could decide
00:12:45 for themselves in the full context what the appropriate response was. But what the committee
00:12:51 members did was expunge that from the record. So if you go back now, they've actually changed
00:12:59 history. They have changed the audio and video feed of that meeting. They've changed the written
00:13:05 transcript and have removed it. Now, fortunately, in this day and age, people like me have captured
00:13:11 and transcribed these things before they can do it.
00:13:14 We would have had a video clip that we could have shared.
00:13:17 But in the official record, if you are a historian 50 years ago
00:13:20 looking for a debate that took place in Parliament Hill,
00:13:23 you would have an amended version.
00:13:25 And I know I'm focusing a lot on this,
00:13:27 but you can actually not, in my view,
00:13:30 overstate the significance of a government
00:13:32 whose response to a shameful display like this
00:13:36 is to pretend it never happened,
00:13:39 that believes the antidote to a wrong is to rewrite history and make an erasure of this nature
00:13:46 rather than to own up to it and to be held to account for it,
00:13:50 which in some people's minds will be solved if Anthony Roda tenders his resignation,
00:13:55 as I'm hearing some sources say could be coming as quickly as at 2 o'clock Eastern today,
00:14:00 so in about 45 minutes.
00:14:02 Let's talk about this in a bit more detail here.
00:14:04 Aaron Woodrick joins me.
00:14:06 He is the Domestic Policy Director for the Macdonald-Laurier Institute, and it's always good to talk to him.
00:14:12 Aaron, Nazi on the floor of the House of Commons, or I guess in the gallery, not something either of us would have had on our bingo cards, was it? 0.53
00:14:19 No, I mean, this is just a colossal mess, and obviously the Trudeau government has no shortage of problems on its plate right now,
00:14:26 so this is really not something that they needed today.
00:14:29 Look, put me in the camp of saying that the Speaker needs to resign on this, right?
00:14:34 It's not a point of principle. And this is something that's been absent from this government, because let's I mean, the speaker does have a degree of independence, but he is still a liberal MP. And this government has continually dodged what's known as ministerial responsibility. You know, you know, it used to be, Andrew, that when you wanted to take responsibility, there had to be some consequence, right? You had to pay some price, you had to resign. Now, you just say the words, I take full responsibility, and it's supposed to go away. And I think a lot of people think that's very hollow.
00:15:01 And so the point here is, you know, I don't believe for a second that Anthony Rota deliberately, you know, found this guy or even had any idea really who he was.
00:15:11 But that's not the point. The point is that someone needs to be held responsible.
00:15:14 And in our system of government, whether it's the speaker, whether it's a minister, when your staff or someone below you screws up, you have to fall on your sword.
00:15:22 That's the price you pay. It doesn't matter that it wasn't your fault directly in the sense that you didn't do something deliberately wrong.
00:15:28 You have to pay the price. And I think, as you already mentioned, now even Liberals are coming out and saying they don't know how he can continue. So I think he will go. I don't know that's going to put an end to it because, of course, the Conservatives are going to assert that PMO knew. I don't know either way whether they did. But again, it's certainly in keeping with the pattern where this government wants to always throw someone else under the bus and say, we had nothing to do with it. It's not our fault. That's just the way they operate. And this situation is no different.
00:15:57 Yes, and we certainly see the Liberal government here being very convenient in its detachment of the Speaker as a Liberal member of Parliament from the Liberal Party and Liberal government.
00:16:09 I mean, yes, the Speaker of the House of Commons is an ostensibly nonpartisan role, and the Speaker is supposed to preside over debates fairly and even-handedly.
00:16:18 But at the end of the day, this is a man elected as a Liberal member of Parliament.
00:16:21 And when it was expedient for the Liberals to just throw him under the bus, their point was to stress the independence of the role, the independent Speaker of the House.
00:16:31 I think it was the Prime Minister's office had called or had referred to him as in its statement.
00:16:38 Yeah, it's very convenient now, right?
00:16:40 So, again, but that's par for the course for this government.
00:16:44 You know, I did want to play devil's advocate a bit on one thing, Andrew, and that is sort of people saying, how could people have missed this?
00:16:50 because you had, you know, you have the Speaker, the real problem is that he was recognized in
00:16:55 Parliament, right? The Speaker chose to recognize this person. And in a way, it's a really unfortunate
00:17:00 series of events. The only reason this person is there is because he happens to be a constituent
00:17:04 of the Speaker, right? The Speaker represents North Bay, Ontario riding. This guy lives in
00:17:09 North Bay. Apparently, his son asked the Speaker if he could come. So, you know, it is a little
00:17:15 bit unfortunate that nobody did their homework. But the thing is, people say, well, how could you,
00:17:19 you know, knowingly, you know, applaud a Nazi. Well, I would say this, Andrew, in 2023, if 0.90
00:17:25 someone said, you know, it's a, we have a veteran here who is in the Ukrainian First Division who
00:17:30 fought the Russians, you know, that sounds kind of, if you're, if you're a young person in 2023,
00:17:36 there's nothing offensive about that. Of course, if you say there, there were an SS member who
00:17:40 fought the Allies in the Second World War, that is obviously a problem, but that's, that's not
00:17:45 way it was phrased so i think the language played a big role here is that you know if if people had
00:17:49 used the right terminology and as you said earlier if people had just done a little bit of digging
00:17:54 saying okay ukrainian first division what is that right that that could mean something very different
00:17:58 in 1944 than it does in 2023 and i think that was the big mistake someone did just not connect the
00:18:04 dots and say this person was a literal you know nazi uh i i simply think that nobody bothered to
00:18:11 check yeah and i mean and if you look up the history of it the first ukrainian division was
00:18:17 a bit of a rebranding to as i've understood distance from the ss vafa name so yes i mean
00:18:22 that name is itself a euphemism and i i wanted to go back to that comment you made about you know
00:18:28 just saying you take responsibility doesn't actually amount to it uh pardon the pop culture
00:18:33 insertion here, but it reminded me of this moment. I declare bankruptcy.
00:18:56 Hey, I just wanted you to know that you can't just say the word bankruptcy and expect anything
00:19:01 to happen i didn't say it i declared it still so that's basically what the speaker has done here
00:19:09 isn't it it is but and you know i've mentioned other ministers in this government have done the
00:19:14 same thing where they if at first they deny or deflect eventually they say well you know what
00:19:18 i accept full responsibility and then as soon as a reporter says well what does that mean
00:19:22 the response is well it means i accept full responsibility that's that's that's all it is
00:19:26 and i i think that you know we talk a lot these days andrew about declining trust and cynicism
00:19:31 in public. And I think this contributes to it, right? Like in the real world, if you make a
00:19:35 mistake, there's usually some consequence or some punishment or something. It's not just,
00:19:39 you know, if you're a kid, you get grounded, you know, you lose your allowance or you get fired
00:19:43 or you get suspended, your pay dock. What is a minister in the Trudeau government or the speaker
00:19:49 in this case, what is the price they're paying? What is the consequence? There is none. And I
00:19:53 think that's why most people think it's a pretty hollow thing to just use the words.
00:19:57 well and i would also point out here that the these sorts of blunders on a rather epic scale
00:20:04 are not really out of character for this government now and i you know i mentioned when
00:20:08 we were talking about the india stuff which was you know the biggest story in the world for a
00:20:12 week before this thing came up there is something to this government i think about it having really
00:20:17 surrendered the right to get the benefit of the doubt and i really think because of its conduct
00:20:22 and its history of these sorts of things when something like this arises people are not really
00:20:27 willing to give them that benefit of the doubt anymore. Yeah, I agree. And look, there are people
00:20:32 that won't like this government because of the policy choices they make. I certainly have been
00:20:36 a big critic of most of the policy decisions of this government. But more fundamentally,
00:20:40 there's a competence issue, right? And I think, you know, and you've even heard liberals,
00:20:45 especially ones who've parted this government, say so out loud is that, you know, the prime
00:20:49 minister has a very small circle of people, in some cases, maybe even one person now in the form
00:20:54 of Katie Telford that are basically trying to run the whole country. And it's a bit of a bottleneck 1.00
00:20:59 to say the least when you have everything having to flow up this very narrow bottleneck. And that
00:21:03 leads to these kinds of things, all kinds of decisions that aren't getting treated very
00:21:07 seriously or in a timely way. So aside from your policy differences, if you don't like what this
00:21:13 government's doing, there's just a basic competence issue. They're just not able to deal with things
00:21:18 because of his bottleneck problem.
00:21:21 Just moving forward here, I mentioned a few moments ago,
00:21:24 I've heard reports that the Speaker could resign as quickly as at 2 p.m. today,
00:21:29 so coming up in about 40 minutes,
00:21:31 and the resignation, I've been told, will effectively come into force on Thursday.
00:21:36 So I guess then there's a bit of time to have an election for another Speaker.
00:21:41 He has a garden party tonight too, Andrew.
00:21:43 The liberals are banking on them being able to really contain this crisis
00:21:47 to this guy alone if he's no longer speaker he sits in the liberal caucus like all of a sudden
00:21:53 he's a colleague of theirs in a more literal and clear-cut way yeah so that's going to be another
00:21:58 question you say well he's independent now he's back in your caucus what uh what are you going
00:22:02 to do although i am interested to see you know how far the opposition parties will pursue that
00:22:07 you know i i you can argue the conservators are making the point on principle saying well don't
00:22:11 take all the blame it's also clear they want the prime minister's head on this right i mean at the
00:22:15 end of the day, if you're not a fan of the prime minister, you'll, any excuse will do to see the
00:22:19 back of them. And this would be as good as any. So I fully expect that the people that are, you
00:22:24 know, not fans of Trudeau are not going to let this drop. Yeah. And I think one of the big things
00:22:30 that we will have to say, I mean, for just for starters, we put up this poster, we can put up
00:22:35 this poster we have. This was the invitation that was sent out to that speaker's garden party
00:22:40 tonight 6 p.m to 9 p.m at 15 barnes road i'm only comfortable giving the address because it's
00:22:46 already publicly out there and there's a gate so don't try to crash that party but so far i was
00:22:51 looking as recently as uh this afternoon right before i went on air not been canceled i don't
00:22:56 know how many people are showing up though yeah talk about the worst garden party of all time i
00:23:01 mean that's going to be a real awkward one especially if the speaker who invited people
00:23:05 is no longer speaker by six o'clock tonight by which i think there's a there's decent odds that's
00:23:09 the case so uh look this is just uh this is this is a disaster all around um i i i mean i'm not
00:23:17 privy to the details about who actually knew what but there are definitely going to be consequences
00:23:21 uh that flow from this it's not going to be the sort of thing that the government can just turn
00:23:25 the page on aaron woodrick is the domestic policy program director at the mcdonald laureate institute
00:23:31 thanks so much aaron always a pleasure thanks a lot andrew that was aaron woodrick now let me
00:23:37 point out here that you know I think Anthony Roda does deserve a fair bit of the blame here. I don't
00:23:43 believe that he is just a puppet in some decision that was orchestrated by Justin Trudeau. I do
00:23:50 believe however that the Justin Trudeau government, the Liberal Party, has to take ownership over
00:23:57 Anthony Roda. He is one of their members of parliament and this was an event that was not
00:24:01 strictly a House of Commons event. This was an event that in actuality was being orchestrated
00:24:09 by the Protocol Office, by Global Affairs Canada. It was a visit by a foreign head of state, by
00:24:16 Volodymyr Zelensky, who was in the House of Commons, and as I mentioned yesterday, has now
00:24:21 given Vladimir Putin like the biggest propaganda win, because the Russians have been saying
00:24:25 since the invasion started in 2022 that Nazis are basically running rampant in Ukraine,
00:24:31 And now here we have the president of Ukraine in the House of Commons of Canada applauding a guy who was a Nazi veteran himself.
00:24:39 And this is not the kind of like when I first saw this, because I didn't get a chance to watch the whole thing on Friday live.
00:24:47 So when this first came up, I was seeing on Twitter on the weekend and I was like, surely there's some like people talk stuff.
00:24:55 And I was looking, surely this isn't as it's being described.
00:24:58 And then you look in and I saw Ezra Levant's Twitter thread.
00:25:02 And then I saw a piece in Forward, again, an American Jewish publication.
00:25:06 And then beyond that, I started to look into it myself and realize this is exactly as it's
00:25:11 being described here.
00:25:13 And this was not just a speaker's problem because, like I said, it is the whole government
00:25:20 that right now was involved in this.
00:25:22 And the government has been very conveniently trying to say, oh, well, the speaker's independent.
00:25:27 And okay, well, once he resigns, he's going to be one of your caucus members.
00:25:32 So what is the conduct that you expect of the people who are sitting in your caucus?
00:25:37 And maybe they'll just go to the next level and say, we have to kick Anthony Roda out
00:25:42 of caucus.
00:25:42 But again, they're doing everything in their power to draw a line between them and him.
00:25:50 They're trying everything to make it so that he is not the guy responsible.
00:25:55 and that is something that I don't think will necessarily hold and to be honest this is one
00:26:00 of these cross-partisan issues where it's breaking out into the mainstream discourse people that
00:26:06 aren't specifically partisans that are none too pleased with what the government has done here
00:26:11 turning to another issue you may recall last week we spoke to Rod Giltaka who is the head of the
00:26:18 Canadian Coalition for Firearm Rights the backdrop of the discussion was the looming deadline for
00:26:25 the so-called amnesty period that the federal government has for newly banned guns coming to
00:26:31 an end in just about a month and a week so maybe five and a half weeks or so until about 1500
00:26:37 variants of firearms including ar-15s and mini-14s that were banned in may of 2020 by order and
00:26:45 council are going to be no more there right now if you owned one before that order and council
00:26:51 came in. You've had it locked in your safe. You've not been able to take it out. You've not been able
00:26:56 to take it to the range to sell it. And the government's so-called buyback, which let's be
00:27:01 real, is a confiscation scheme, hasn't happened. So I have an AR-15. I have not been able to ever
00:27:08 fire it. And the government says that it's so unsafe it should be in their hands. Well, I've
00:27:13 not been able to put it in their hands because this program does not exist. I wanted to shine
00:27:18 to light on another dimension of this, which I don't often do on this show, because when I talk
00:27:23 about gun issues, usually I'm talking about them from the perspective of gun owners. But just to
00:27:29 set the stage, gun businesses were also severely affected by this. And I wanted to play a clip
00:27:35 before we get into this segment too deeply from a documentary I produced in May. Well, it came out
00:27:41 in the summer of 2021. So just after the one year anniversary of the Order and Council, and it was
00:27:48 called Assaulted Justin Trudeau's War on Gun Owners and in this I took a look specifically
00:27:53 in one of the episodes at firearms businesses and this one in particular this clip that I'm
00:27:59 going to show spoke about two businesses that were at the time dealing with this for over a year
00:28:05 and are in the exact same position nearly two years later take a look how is a business like
00:28:11 You're supposed to operate when anything that you sell could one day be illegal.
00:28:17 On eggshells, take it a day at a time.
00:28:19 I visited Jeff's store one year after the Liberals' order in council,
00:28:23 and there in his warehouse were tens of thousands of dollars of now-prohibited firearms.
00:28:28 They're illegal to sell or to use, and cannot even be sold back to the government
00:28:32 despite the promise of a buyback.
00:28:34 It's a rule of retail. If you're not moving inventory, you're losing money.
00:28:38 something felt by a lot of the gun store owners I heard from is that this is a feature not a bug of
00:28:44 the Liberals gun measures you know we're we're sitting on inventory right now that we can't sell
00:28:48 and that's tying up a lot of dollars which in retail is is a cardinal sin the the biggest sin
00:28:54 in retail is not to turn your inventory over um so you know it it's created some financial hardship
00:29:00 and uh but I try not to complain about it too much because I know I'm not alone I know that
00:29:06 every other business, whether you're a wholesaler or distributor in the country has been affected.
00:29:11 I liken it to the automotive industry. And imagine you own a car lot and Environment Canada walks
00:29:17 onto your lot one day and says, we're banning V8s. And by the way, you can't sell them. They
00:29:22 have to sit on your lot. And maybe someday, two or three, maybe four years down the road,
00:29:27 we might pay you costs, we might pay you retail, or we just might be a flat amount we're going to
00:29:31 give you. But in the meantime, all the parts that you have for them and your vehicles are tied up.
00:29:36 So as retailers and wholesalers, that's where we're at right now.
00:29:39 Our inventory is tied up.
00:29:41 We can't sell it.
00:29:42 Your entire business model has been destroyed.
00:29:44 And there's a lot of people out there, unfortunately, in this country
00:29:46 who are in that situation right now because of the OIC.
00:29:51 The first gentleman was Jeff Toombs, who has a store near Peterborough, Ontario.
00:29:57 I haven't chatted with him too recently, but Scott Carpenter, who has a store in Surrey.
00:30:02 I ran into him at an event not that long ago.
00:30:05 And he said that the inventory that he was talking about when I spoke to him there is still in his warehouse.
00:30:11 This is an issue that has saddled gun stores with, in some cases, hundreds of thousands of dollars of inventory that they cannot move.
00:30:18 And even outside of those specific prohibitions, it is an uncertainty that has now affected this,
00:30:24 where why would you run a business when the government could ban the things that you are trying to sell?
00:30:30 I wanted to talk about this issue a little bit more from the perspective of the industry itself,
00:30:36 which, by the way, is not dominated by these big multinational billion-dollar corporations.
00:30:41 It's often small mom-and-pop shops across this country.
00:30:44 Wes Winkle is here.
00:30:45 He's the president of the Canadian Sporting Arms and Ammunition Association.
00:30:50 Wes, it's good to talk to you.
00:30:51 Thanks for coming on today.
00:30:53 Thank you very much for having me.
00:30:55 Just set the stage here first off.
00:30:57 I alluded to it there, but what is the profile of a firearms business owner in Canada?
00:31:04 Typically, you hit the nail right on the head.
00:31:06 It's one of those things where most of them are mom-and-pop shops.
00:31:09 Typically, you're looking at an employee base of 5 to 12 employees.
00:31:15 In many cases, a rural business or in a non-urban area is where most of our businesses are located.
00:31:21 one of the things i should point out when i was filming uh that documentary in which your
00:31:27 your predecessor in your position was a featured guest one of the challenges whenever we were
00:31:32 interviewing owners of gun stores is that every five minutes someone's walking in and they were
00:31:37 old friends they knew each other i mean these things have actually become somewhat of community
00:31:42 hubs as well your neighborhood gun store for people that are in sport shooting and in hunting
00:31:46 and and that's not something that a lot of businesses in this day and age get to do
00:31:50 No, it's a very unique situation. We always like that old hot stove league mentality where you have a lot of folks coming in on a regular basis to go ahead and chew the fat about their event and their sport, and they like to come in and talk about it.
00:32:10 And it's a very small, close-knit community for sure.
00:32:13 And it crosses a lot of different realms of employment.
00:32:17 You know, there's people that are farmers and rural shooters and hunters.
00:32:22 But then you have lots of urban gentlemen and ladies that participate in law enforcement and the military
00:32:27 that like to practice their craft outside of their work.
00:32:30 So there's a lot of different aspects at play.
00:32:33 Okay. So I know that the handgun ban, when I believe we lost you, so we'll have to get Wes 0.98
00:32:41 back there. I'm speaking to half of my, there we go. I was speaking to half of my logo there.
00:32:46 I know that the handgun ban was actually quite a boon for gun stores. I know gun stores all of a
00:32:51 sudden couldn't like sell handguns quickly enough because there was a bit of a phase in period. But
00:32:56 for the order and council, this effectively locked up huge amounts of inventory that,
00:33:02 I mean, certainly in the cases of businesses I've spoken to, they've not been able to do anything with for effectively three years now.
00:33:11 Like, what are the effects of that if you're a gun retailer?
00:33:14 They're immense.
00:33:15 Just like you had mentioned in your previous segment about stale inventory and stale inventory is the death of retail as a whole.
00:33:22 But on top of that, you have costs associated with it, not just warehousing costs and holding costs, but insurance costs.
00:33:29 You know, for a lot of us that are holding hundreds of thousands of dollars in inventory,
00:33:32 it costs you $10,000 a year to insure that inventory,
00:33:35 especially when the government puts a prohibited tag name on it.
00:33:39 So it's a very expensive thing to keep in our inventory.
00:33:41 And we've had no ability to have a lawfully or legal aspect to dispose of this inventory.
00:33:49 And it's got a great deal of expense, as well as taking up very valuable warehouse and retail space.
00:33:54 has there been in the members that you've spoken to a sense that it's just not worth it anymore
00:34:00 like why would i spend so much of my time effort and money in this industry that the government
00:34:06 could basically outlaw overnight absolutely there's been a fatigue we've seen a lot of
00:34:11 businesses in the last six months across our great country close and it's it's a combination of
00:34:16 financial viability but just overall fatigue of over regulation it's not just on the firearm side
00:34:23 it on the ammunition side the regulations when it comes to importing and exporting i mean we're just
00:34:28 so heavily regulated that it yeah there's a level of fatigue and and you're in a situation where uh
00:34:33 you know it's it's a lot of these owners are a little older and therefore it's uh you know it's
00:34:39 a little bit harder for them to maintain uh keeping up with all these online regulations
00:34:44 and constantly being on the internet and logging into the rcmp website and giving permission to
00:34:48 to sell stuff, it just gets difficult and they just get worn down and retire from our industry.
00:34:54 In terms of representing the industry side, your group is pretty much unparalleled, I would go so
00:35:01 far as to say. So has there been at the very least consultation or adequate consultation
00:35:06 from the government on what a resolution would look like? Yes, we've had some consultation.
00:35:12 We didn't have any consultation before the OIC.
00:35:15 Which is ideally when you consult, before you do something.
00:35:19 Absolutely.
00:35:19 And to be honest, the OIC is so poorly written, which is why we've had this long delay and why there's so much, you know, it's so difficult to bring this program forward.
00:35:29 Because we're really at a spot yet where we still haven't quite determined what actually was prohibited.
00:35:35 You know, you mentioned at the start of your segment at 1,500 makes and models.
00:35:38 And that was what was originally listed by the government.
00:35:40 But then they've added on 300, 354 mixing models that they found out were caught under the same net as the original prohibition.
00:35:49 So we're still trying to determine what exactly was prohibited because it was so poorly written by the Minister Blair in his office at the time.
00:35:55 And again, if there had been consultation back before this, there may not have been quite such a mess.
00:36:00 But now, of course, we're stuck trying to figure out how to deal with this regulation.
00:36:05 And we're currently going through that.
00:36:07 now there is some consultation but uh you know the slow turning wheels of the government are
00:36:13 very difficult to fight through especially when you have such a convoluted program one thing a
00:36:18 lot of people don't understand about these firearms is they're so modular in nature and
00:36:22 there's so many different moving pieces and they're kind of like a mr potato head of guns
00:36:27 type of thing where you're putting different snapping different pieces on and some of those
00:36:30 pieces are prohibited some of them are not but some of them can be used in other firearms some
00:36:33 of them can't and therefore they're trying to figure out how to how to properly gather all the
00:36:38 information that is required there yeah and i was actually going to ask about that because you know
00:36:45 there certainly is a huge huge market for accessories for firearms and i've not been told
00:36:51 and you may have a different perspective this but i've not been told that a gun buyback would extend
00:36:56 to accessories so there may be a no real way to recoup that money well so again we only get to
00:37:03 deal with the business aspect we have no interest or no communication on the uh on the individual
00:37:08 buyback uh i mean from a business perspective if you have a bunch of accessories in your warehouse
00:37:13 which maybe you can return to the distributor but maybe you can't i mean there may be no compensation
00:37:18 for that and no retail market for it now yeah no there and there has been extensive consultation
00:37:23 on the on the um on all the parts and the different components of the firearms uh there has been an
00:37:29 extensive discussion going on about that uh obviously um uh from our dealer's perspective
00:37:35 because so many of these things are modular nature we wouldn't be a part of anything if the parts and
00:37:40 accessories were not included so uh we've been a large discussion on how those parts will be
00:37:45 compensated for especially from those of uh our members that are manufacturers you know they don't
00:37:50 want to have to take the time to assemble these firearms to be turned in it makes no sense
00:37:55 whatsoever to put that extra expense on there. So, you know, they have bins and bins apart to
00:38:00 these manufacturers and they need to be compensated for as well. Just in closing here, I'll ask you
00:38:06 about what the dollar value would be. Not an individual dollar value, but in general, the
00:38:11 approach to a dollar value would be that would take the sting out a little bit. Because if the
00:38:16 government were to say, we'll reimburse you for the cost you purchased this at to businesses,
00:38:21 that doesn't really take into account the warehousing the opportunity cost you know if
00:38:25 they had to you know take out debt for example to buy the inventory in the first place but i also
00:38:30 don't think government really wants to be enriching or in its view enriching business owners by paying
00:38:36 a premium like what would the reasonable middle ground be well there's probably uh you know what
00:38:43 is the current retail value of that item is probably where the current middle ground is
00:38:47 You know, it absolutely does not compensate us for our losses. You know, whenever you have inventory tied up for three years, there should be six to 12 turns on that on that inventory. And we're not going to get compensated for that. And we're well aware of that. But at the same time, storage and insurance costs aren't being compensated either. So our losses are still going to be immense.
00:39:06 but uh you know the middle ground that uh i am assuming we're going to hopefully end up at is
00:39:11 is the retail value for the items um and uh you know that's um remains to be seen if that's where
00:39:17 they go but it still won't take the sting out of it and uh especially the the biggest cost that
00:39:23 our businesses have is the is the training of staff it's the marketing that's
00:39:29 oh uh we i think we you muted yourself there wes oh i apologize there we go we got you now
00:39:39 sorry about that uh some technical stuff there uh but yes we have uh so much invested in the
00:39:45 marketing and and the training of our staff and the sting of that will never go away uh it's it's
00:39:50 something that uh you know business has had tens of thousands if not hundreds of thousands of
00:39:54 dollars invested in and that's all out the window and it's an absolute collapse of that part of the
00:39:58 industry. Wes Winkle is the president of the Canadian Sporting Arms and Ammunition Association.
00:40:04 I thank you for making your way through the tech issues there, right? You solved the better than
00:40:09 anyone else we have on the show is usually able to. So thanks very much, Wes. Good to talk to you.
00:40:15 All right. And of course, we end with you on mute. I jinxed it there, but in any event,
00:40:18 it was good to talk to Wes. And let me say that, you know, I remember there was one interview.
00:40:24 you should go back and watch Assaulted. I'm very proud of that. It's at assaulted.ca. And there
00:40:29 was one couple I spoke to, Wyatt and Shana Singer, this, again, husband and wife couple with a
00:40:35 beautiful, beautiful young son that lives on this great property out in rural Alberta.
00:40:39 And they just started in their shop, a firearms manufacturing business, because they wanted to
00:40:45 design a non-restricted firearm that would suit their needs. And it was entirely modular. They
00:40:51 designed it to the letter of the regulation to be non-restricted and they invested their life
00:40:57 savings in this they learned machining they bought a bunch of equipment they did so much
00:41:02 and they made this to follow the letter of the law and the letter of the regulations and then
00:41:08 the government just flips the switch and prohibits it it basically eliminated the only product this
00:41:14 couple sold and I showed this to a couple of people I know that are not fans of firearms
00:41:20 and one of them in particular had said well I don't like guns but I can't believe what they've
00:41:27 done to that couple and that to me is a win and I think it's important for gun owners to accept
00:41:33 that as I said in my keynote speech at the Canadian Coalition for Firearm Rights AGM which
00:41:38 you can watch online a couple of months back you know people that don't like guns are not going to
00:41:43 be wooed over by arguments about how owning guns should be a right they're going to be wooed over
00:41:47 though by human stories. And when people see what the government's approach to this has done
00:41:52 to ordinary people, to ordinary business owners that could own a bookstore or a gourmet food store
00:41:58 or a firearm store or a lawnmower store, it doesn't matter, people start to realize at the
00:42:04 very least the injustice in how it's being done and how the government has just kicked people in
00:42:10 this industry because it's decided that it can paint for political points gun owners as villains.
00:42:15 So we'll leave it there. My thanks to all of you for tuning in. We'll be back with more of the Andrew Lawton Show and perhaps a new Speaker of the House tomorrow. Well, we probably won't get a new Speaker until Thursday, but I will tell you also the event of the century, I'm going to be overly ambitious there, is True North Nation. It is coming to Calgary October 21st, which is a Saturday. It's going to be a full day event. I'll be there. Rupa Subramania will be there.
00:42:41 Harrison Faulkner, Rachel Emanuel, and a very, very, very special guest that we will be announcing
00:42:48 this week. So you might want to book your ticket now by trusting me that it's going to be a good
00:42:52 guest before things sell out, because I think they may sell out once we announce this person. So
00:42:57 that is coming up, and I do hope to see you all there. We will talk to you tomorrow, though.
00:43:01 Thank you, God bless, and good day to you all.
00:43:05 Thanks for listening to The Andrew Lawton Show. Support the program by donating to True North
00:43:09 at www.tnc.news.
00:43:39 We'll be right back.
00:44:09 We'll be right back.