Juno News - October 25, 2023


Liberals think bill banning vaccine mandates is "waste of time"

Topics
Mentioned
The government’s own polling says Canadians think Trudeau is failing Ontario councillor SUSPENDED WITHOUT PAY for opposing gender ideology

Episode Stats


Length

49 minutes

Words per minute

166.87

Word count

8,263

Sentence count

382

Harmful content

Misogyny

1

sentences flagged

Toxicity

2

sentences flagged

Hate speech

3

sentences flagged


Summary

Summaries generated with gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ .

In this episode of The Lawton Show, host Andrew Lawton takes a deep dive into the Pandemic Era, and takes a look at the push for a bill that would ban all federal mandates on vaccines and travel during a pandemic.

Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Topics generated with Qwen2.5-3B-Instruct.
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 Transcription by CastingWords
00:00:30 Thank you.
00:01:00 Welcome to Canada's Most Irreverent Talk Show.
00:01:16 This is The Andrew Lawton Show, brought to you by True North.
00:01:20 hello and welcome to you all this is canada's most irreverent talk show here on true north
00:01:34 the andrew lawton show on this wednesday october 25th you're kind of at the midway point just
00:01:39 after lunchtime on well in east eastern time anyway in the middle of the week so hopefully
00:01:45 you are surviving it's all downhill i actually i never know because this is like a weird tangent
00:01:51 but all downhill sounds like a bad thing but it also sounds like it's meant to be easier so
00:01:56 it's all improving from here we'll just abandon the jack and jill like hill analogies anyway
00:02:01 uh it is just after one o'clock eastern time i promised yesterday i'd give a little bit of
00:02:06 tribute to our atlantic listeners so if you are in the beautiful maritimes it's just after two
00:02:12 o'clock eastern or in Newfoundland it is 2 30 for you can't forget those half hour time zones
00:02:18 we are going to be doing a bit of a deep dive into the pandemic era which for the most part I think
00:02:24 has left us behind or we've left behind depending on which type of person you are though not
00:02:30 entirely not entirely it's amazing if you look around especially at a lot of these pro-hamas 1.00
00:02:35 protests at the number of people that still want to keep their masks on we at true north nation
00:02:41 were like going to jokingly have a sign up at the door that said everyone needs to wear an N95 to
00:02:46 be admitted. But we were worried that someone might not get the joke and the whole place would
00:02:50 be just like met with protests. And we didn't want to like be the ground zero of some new Freedom
00:02:55 Convoy 2.0 or 3.0. So we didn't do the mask gag. Thankfully, there were no masks in sight. We had
00:03:01 a bit of normalcy. You had the misfortune if you were there of having to see my face in full. But
00:03:07 we do have still very much hanging over us this threat that these things could be reimposed at
00:03:14 any given time, that some other winter virus comes along and governments panic, and all of a sudden
00:03:19 we're right back into vaccine mandates and vaccine passports and mask mandates and all of the like
00:03:24 once again. So it is encouraging, perhaps symbolic, but still important, I think, that the federal
00:03:31 government has to make a decision on whether or not it will support a private member's bill by
00:03:36 Conservative MP Dean Allison and supported by party leader Pierre Polyev to ban federal mandates.
00:03:43 The bill is C-278 and yesterday it came up before the House of Commons and I believe is going to be
00:03:49 voted on today as well. But on this bill it's basically the federal parliament demanding that
00:03:57 governments ban federal vaccine mandates. So before you do what all these people on the left
00:04:02 love to do and say, oh, but mandates are provincial. This is talking about the mandates which are
00:04:07 federal. The mandates surrounding the public service, surrounding air and rail travel,
00:04:13 surrounding truckers and crossing the border. That's what this bill would prohibit.
00:04:19 Now, obviously, it's not a constitutional amendment, which means theoretically,
00:04:23 just as Parliament could pass this law banning it, Parliament could repeal that law
00:04:27 or temporarily suspend the law in the future. But it would force any future government
00:04:32 to have to go through an additional step, which is why even if it is symbolic and theoretical
00:04:36 at this point, it is still, I believe, important because it's parliamentarians saying
00:04:41 we do not believe government should ever have this power or authority again.
00:04:46 Pierre Polyev spoke in support of this private member's bill yesterday. Take a look.
00:04:51 Before the prime minister proceeds once again to maliciously divide and attack,
00:04:58 Let me remind him that the position put forward in this bill is now the position not only of common-sense conservatives,
00:05:09 but it is also the position of the majority of provincial governments,
00:05:14 of the Liberal member for Louis-St. Louis-Barre,
00:05:21 of the Military Review Complaints Commission,
00:05:26 the tribunal responsible for hearing grievances from members of the armed forces,
00:05:31 and I will remind the position of the Prime Minister
00:05:34 that the position reflected in the bill is now his position.
00:05:39 Now, you might question why I would say that.
00:05:41 The reason is that he had the temerity to go on television about three months ago
00:05:48 and claim he had never forced anyone to get vaccinated.
00:05:52 That he claims that it should be a matter of personal choice.
00:05:56 He wanted us all to forget the way he divided and insulted and name-called millions of people
00:06:03 right across this country, patriotic, law-abiding, decent people.
00:06:07 So if he really believes he never forced mandates on anyone,
00:06:12 surely he'll be happy to vote for this bill to ensure that those mandates don't apply anymore
00:06:17 and will never be reimposed again.
00:06:22 How do you like them apples, as I believe the common political parlance dictates now?
00:06:27 Yes, if Justin Trudeau is so eager to say he's never divided Canadians,
00:06:30 he's never forced anyone to get vaccinated.
00:06:32 No, no, I've always viewed it as being a matter of personal choice.
00:06:37 he said that with a straight face, believe it or not,
00:06:40 then, well, let's just go the whole distance here
00:06:42 and commit to banning this type of legislation in the future.
00:06:48 But this is not what Justin Trudeau wants to do.
00:06:50 The federal government has embraced one of the largest
00:06:52 and most institutionalized forms of gaslighting
00:06:55 I've ever seen in the wake of COVID.
00:06:58 All of the things that they did,
00:07:00 that they did aggressively, that they did openly, brazenly,
00:07:03 they're pretending they never did.
00:07:05 Oh, I never insulted the unvaccinated, Justin Trudeau said before the Public Order Emergency
00:07:10 Commission. I never called anyone racist and misogynistic and white supremacist, except for
00:07:15 that time that I called the unvaccinated racist, misogynist, white supremacist.
00:07:19 Oh, I never forced anyone to get vaccinated, except for when I yelled enthusiastically 0.84
00:07:25 at a campaign rally in Calgary that you may have a right sort of ish to not be vaccinated,
00:07:31 but you can't like get on a plane. You can't get on a train. You can't, you know, risk other people.
00:07:37 And it's almost as though they were trying to carve themselves a bit of an out there to say,
00:07:43 well, yes, you have the choice, but if you make that choice, you can't work, you can't travel,
00:07:51 you can't go see grandma, you can't do this. Is that really a choice? Hell no, it's not.
00:07:57 And that is exactly what the government wants you to believe, that when they stripped away all of these abilities you had as a free individual in Canada, if you are not vaccinated, when you strip that all away, then you don't actually have the right to live your life anymore.
00:08:16 and they're trying to tell you that this was all just a free choice.
00:08:21 Imagine if, and I've made this comparison before,
00:08:23 in the last six years we've had a bit of a renaissance
00:08:27 and discussions about sexual consent.
00:08:29 And you see the Me Too movement, campus advocacy, all of that.
00:08:32 And people have re-evaluated.
00:08:34 The one thing that we are all told about consent
00:08:36 is that it must be clear, unequivocal, and enthusiastic.
00:08:41 Coercion is not consent.
00:08:44 And that is exactly the line that we are all told,
00:08:47 I think understandably so when it comes to sexual consent.
00:08:49 But with vaccination, we're told that coercion is entirely legitimate.
00:08:53 Coerced consent is consent in the eyes of the government.
00:08:58 Now, we look at the facts of the situation here,
00:08:59 and I'll talk about this a bit more later with Christine Van Gein and Joanna Barron,
00:09:04 who have a fabulous book out about the pandemic era.
00:09:07 But one of the interesting details is that it didn't work.
00:09:10 So all of these vaccine mandates and restrictions that were done to get the vaccination rate up a slight bit because it was already at close to 90% didn't actually amount to a hill of beans.
00:09:21 This came out this week where COVID passports in Quebec and Ontario did not convince more than a few people to get vaccinated.
00:09:30 This is a peer-reviewed study, such as it is, that looks at the effect that vaccine passports in those two provinces had on overall vaccination rates.
00:09:39 and it found that it affected 0.9% in Quebec, 0.9% and in Ontario 0.7%. So let's just split
00:09:49 the difference here. Less than 1%, 0.8% of vaccination was affected by vaccine passports.
00:09:56 Now, I would argue this is not a failure of government policy because the policy
00:10:01 government officials knew was not going to increase vaccination. It was meant to punish
00:10:07 the unvaccinated. It was meant to say you have been non-compliant with government edicts,
00:10:12 therefore you don't have the right to go to a movie theater, go to a restaurant,
00:10:15 or in Quebec's case, to even go shopping at a big box store. One of many infringements on
00:10:22 civil liberties that we'll talk about with Christine and Joanna very shortly. But I want
00:10:27 to pivot to another topic here. If you've been following tnc.news this week, you'll no doubt
00:10:32 have seen two really great stories with a third to come in just a couple of hours from my colleague
00:10:37 Noah Jarvis who has written about this little known federal crown corporation called the
00:10:44 Sustainable Development Technology Canada. Now this is a group which is by design tasked to
00:10:49 distribute tons of taxpayer money for innovation and development and clean technology and all of
00:10:55 that and you may think okay whatever government spends billions on this stuff. Well this crown
00:11:00 corporation has been given a huge amount of money with very little oversight over how it's spent
00:11:06 the government actually suspended its funding to this organization a little while back when a
00:11:12 report found that there was a lot of mismanagement conflict of interest and all of that now my
00:11:18 colleague Noah has got the receipts as they say and found even more than was in the report and he
00:11:23 joins me now Noah good to talk to you thanks for coming on today thanks for having me on Andrew
00:11:28 So, I mean, this was you and I were chatting about this when you were working on the stories and it sounded like this just started out as something that was in one way kind of a standard story.
00:11:37 And the more you learned, the more you realize just how insane what was happening was.
00:11:42 Yeah, exactly. I mean, we were sent a tip through the email and basically we were sent this report from SDTC that basically showed that the SDTC has a just a culture,
00:11:56 a corporate culture of corporate mismanagement, funding companies in which board members have
00:12:01 conflicts of interest in and trying to hide these conflicts of interest, whether that be
00:12:05 through firing employees who would speak up about this, or whether that be through the president
00:12:12 backdating documents to cover up the fact that she was working with people and funding companies in
00:12:19 which there's a conflict of interest. It's quite concerning that board members of this
00:12:24 crown corporation who are responsible for distributing hundreds of millions of dollars
00:12:29 annually of taxpayer dollars are possibly distributing money to which they have
00:12:34 personal financial vested interests and perhaps even distributing money to their friends and
00:12:40 colleagues. Yeah and your first story on this subject really just listed like board member by
00:12:45 board member all of these companies they're involved in that have received in some cases
00:12:50 tens of millions of dollars from sdcc from sustainable development technology canada
00:12:55 and what i found interesting about looking through that we don't know i mean they have
00:12:59 a conflict of interest policy and that theoretically these people could have recused themselves from
00:13:04 those individual votes but the report that was done as you shared with me was that like a lot
00:13:10 of the time they weren't even following the conflict of interest policy right and the only
00:13:14 reason why this report was done was because uh whistleblowers from sdtc uh about a dozen or so
00:13:21 uh current and former employees were sick and tired of the corporate mismanagement and they
00:13:26 asked iscd which is the ministry responsible for administering sdtc that's led by francois
00:13:32 philippe champagne that's correct um they asked iscd to do a report and an investigation on this
00:13:39 They took about six months to do the investigation, and they found that, yes, SDTC, they have a culture of funding companies in which there are conflicts of interest with board members.
00:13:51 Board members seldom recuse themselves from votes in which they are funding companies in which they have conflicts of interest.
00:13:58 the report also found that there is very little if any dissension dissent within the board of all
00:14:06 of the votes for funding companies were done unanimously there was very little evidence of
00:14:11 vote mixing and the report notes that this is very concerning because the clean tech industry or
00:14:18 whatever you want to call it is a very small industry and you know there's a lot of people
00:14:22 who know each other and thus it makes it very important that there is a strong conflict of
00:14:28 interest policy there. And not only is there a very weak conflict of interest policy, this
00:14:33 conflict of interest policy was seldom followed. Yeah, and even with this report, SDTC has been
00:14:40 pretty unrepentant, it looks like. They've basically told the government to go pound
00:14:44 salt and said, we've done nothing wrong. Exactly. I reached out for them for comment,
00:14:48 and basically SDTC said, oh, there's nothing to see here. There's no wrongdoing. They put out a
00:14:54 press release a day after Minister Francois-Philippe Champagne announced that they would be cutting
00:14:59 funding to SDTC until December 31st. They put out a press statement saying, we don't need an
00:15:05 investigation on this matter. Everything's completely fine. Nothing to see here.
00:15:09 Yeah, it's always great when someone says, we don't even need to investigate. We're that
00:15:12 confident. There's no, don't even look. No, no, no. Please, please, please don't look.
00:15:17 Exactly. And it's concerning that Francois-Philippe Champagne is basically entrusting the people
00:15:21 implicated in this report they're trusting the board members and the executives to carry out
00:15:25 these reforms to sdtc uh for their conflict of interest policy when these are the people that
00:15:31 have been funding you know their friends and you know companies in which they're personally
00:15:35 invested in uh one example i want to point out too is a board member who served on the sdtc
00:15:41 board for six years between 2015 and 2021 andre lee's method she is the head of a venture capital
00:15:48 firm and if you go on their website this is all public information you go on their website seven
00:15:53 out of the 25 companies that cycle capital is invested in they have received money from sdtc
00:16:01 millions of dollars from sdtc while she served on the board uh enterchem for example she also sits
00:16:07 on the board of enterchem they received 12 million dollars in 2016 while she sat on their board and
00:16:11 the sdtc board and andre lee's method also sat on the project review committee which reviews the
00:16:19 the companies in which they plan on uh funding before it actually goes to a vote before the
00:16:24 board so she has a lot of power uh within uh sdtc as well as many other board members who 0.72
00:16:31 also sat on the project review committee now i just to to give people the benefit of the doubt
00:16:36 here and i know you reached out to this woman for your story and as i understand it she didn't
00:16:40 respond but to give them the benefit of the doubt if it is a small space and you know there aren't
00:16:45 that many players in the space and obviously people might know each other and uh they try to
00:16:49 be diligent and recuse themselves were you able to look into the meeting records and see if each
00:16:56 individual member recused themselves on these things where there was a conflict or a potential
00:17:01 conflict i i personally wasn't able to look into their meeting records but uh because they're not
00:17:07 public is they're not public but uh grant thornton uh they did an investigation and they got you
00:17:14 know those internal internal access uh to the documents and the meeting uh notes and their
00:17:20 report basically outlines that you know from looking at the meeting minutes do like rarely
00:17:24 if ever do they even talk about uh potential conflicts of interest and you know rarely if ever
00:17:30 do board members recuse themselves uh from these meetings you know don't take my word for it take
00:17:35 the people that the government hired to investigate the matter. So you said that the funding
00:17:41 suspension from the federal government goes until the end of this year. Do you have any
00:17:45 indication at this point of what's going to happen come January 1st? I mean, the government
00:17:52 is entrusting these board members and executives implicated in the report to do these reforms. And
00:17:57 I guess if Francois-Philippe Champagne feels as if SDTC has made enough steps into correcting
00:18:03 their corporate mismanagement, quite frankly. If he feels as if they've taken enough corrective
00:18:11 measures, they'll probably restore funding. But it's quite concerning because this SDTC is
00:18:18 responsible for distributing hundreds of millions of dollars annually. I think in 2021 or 2022,
00:18:23 they distributed $140 million worth of taxpayer dollars. And the report basically notes that
00:18:29 about 20% of the projects that they looked into,
00:18:33 it's more than 20%, but I'm being generous,
00:18:35 about 20% of the projects that they've looked into,
00:18:39 board members and executives
00:18:40 have conflicts of interest with these companies.
00:18:42 So if you extrapolate 20% out to $140 million,
00:18:46 that's tens of millions of dollars annually
00:18:49 in which companies are being,
00:18:50 more money is being given to companies
00:18:52 in which these board members have personal
00:18:55 and financial connections to.
00:18:56 But, you know, as I stated, you know, these same board members and executives are being entrusted to enact these reforms, and it would be very disappointing if Francois decides to reinstate their funding without any serious personnel change on the board and the executive of SDTC.
00:19:15 Yeah, self-investigations are rarely, if ever, appropriate for correcting wrongdoing.
00:19:21 Well, you've done great work on this.
00:19:23 I know you have a third part coming out in just a few hours,
00:19:25 so people can head on over to tnc.news.
00:19:27 Noah Jarvis, thanks so much.
00:19:29 Thanks for having me.
00:19:31 All right, to get back to the COVID file here,
00:19:33 I mentioned earlier on in the program the issues we were having
00:19:38 with trying to have some level of accountability
00:19:40 for what the federal government did over the COVID era.
00:19:44 And I mentioned that bill that Pierre Polyev and the Conservatives have gotten behind, Dean Allison's private members bill.
00:19:52 And this is a bill, Dean Allison just like retweeted me one second ago, so I didn't know if he was listening to the show.
00:19:58 But he was retweeting me in my comment about what I was just about to bring up here.
00:20:02 The Liberals are displeased that anyone is trying to muck around on their record.
00:20:08 We saw one tweet from Seamus O'Regan, which accused Pierre Polyev of wasting time.
00:20:15 Pierre Polyev tabled a bill to ban vaccine mandates.
00:20:17 Today we have to waste time debating it.
00:20:19 Oh yes, heaven forbid you have to debate legislation and policy.
00:20:23 That's what Polyev wants to talk about right now.
00:20:25 Not affordability, not inflation, not housing, not what's happening in Europe or the Middle East vaccine mandates.
00:20:31 Well, my comment to Mr. O'Regan was that perhaps he wouldn't need to waste time debating your
00:20:38 government's egregious violation of civil liberties if you didn't egregiously violate
00:20:42 people's civil liberties. And then Mark Gerritsen decided to weigh in with his own comment on this
00:20:49 to the same sort of effect there. The anti-vax club. That's what Polyev is talking about right 0.85
00:20:55 now. Not affordability, not inflation, not housing, not the war in Europe or the Middle East
00:20:59 vaccine mandates. Did that sound similar to the other tweet? It's almost as though they just got
00:21:05 like a fresh batch of talking points sent down the pipeline from the PMO and they're all just
00:21:10 copying and pasting. Now, if Pierre Polyev were truly debating something irrelevant in the House
00:21:15 of Commons, he would be debating Mark Gerritsen. But that is not what was happening. He was talking
00:21:19 about vaccine mandates, which affected millions of Canadians and not only the individual people,
00:21:26 but affected the core civil liberties and right to make individual medical choices that all
00:21:32 Canadians enjoy. When you attack the freedoms of one Canadian, you attack the freedoms of
00:21:38 all Canadians. And it is noteworthy that the Liberals do not want any real scrutiny of their
00:21:44 record, that they don't want to rehash this, that you see the government so fervently telling
00:21:50 everyone when there are court cases up that, oh, we need to dismiss this. It's moot. We can't talk
00:21:55 about this, we don't need this, because they don't actually want people going back to that
00:22:00 three-year period of 2020 to 2023, really, and seeing the extent to which these policies did
00:22:08 break the law, did violate people's rights. They don't actually want to have that discussion.
00:22:13 And it's kind of interesting. There was that call from, I believe, Emily Oster is her name,
00:22:18 a writer last year for Pandemic Amnesty, which was basically, yeah, we all said some things,
00:22:24 we all did some things, you know, it sucks, but it was a difficult time. Let's all just move on.
00:22:29 Let's just, you know, let bygones be bygones. And it's a lot easier for the people who were
00:22:34 responsible for some of the violations of people's rights to call for pandemic amnesty. It's in fact,
00:22:40 it's very similar to Hamas attacking Israel and then calling for a ceasefire as if to say, 0.88
00:22:45 okay, we hit you. Now we just want to stop. We just want to get rid of this all. But that's kind
00:22:50 of what's happening here. The people that are calling for us to move on and never look at this
00:22:53 again, are the people that were very directly involved in the reasons we should look into this
00:22:59 period. Joanna Barron is the executive director of the Canadian Constitution Foundation. Her
00:23:05 colleague, Christine Van Gein, is the CCF's litigation director. The two have a fascinating
00:23:11 piece in C2C Journal about this and an even more fascinating book that is coming out in the next
00:23:17 few days here called Pandemic Panic, how Canadian government responses to COVID-19 changed civil
00:23:23 liberties forever. They don't want to move on from this without a deep dive into all that went wrong
00:23:28 and perhaps setting out a roadmap for how to avoid this in the future. Christine and Joanna,
00:23:35 wonderful to talk to you. Thanks so much for coming on today. Thanks for having us on.
00:23:40 I mentioned a couple of moments ago in court cases where these restrictions are coming up,
00:23:45 we're often hearing from the government's lawyers these appeals to mootness. It was kind of this
00:23:49 just little moment. It was almost like the twilight zone. It's not really where we are now.
00:23:54 So there's no point in dealing with this. They've had some success on that, notably
00:23:58 in the travel vaccine mandate case, although it stands to reason what's happening with the
00:24:03 federal court of appeal there. But let me just ask you on that. Why is it important to not just
00:24:08 let this era be put in a box and stowed away on some back shelf? Well, I don't think that you've
00:24:15 seen in recent memory an extraordinary, you know, areas of life, just an extraordinary array of
00:24:22 areas of life that we never imagined the government could start regulating in. Health, our social
00:24:28 lives, our religious lives, our expressive lives, pretty much you name it. And if we can't go and
00:24:34 see how our judiciary, how our politicians even, because politicians ideally should use the charter
00:24:41 as a sort of guardrails for their behavior. If we can't have an honest accounting of how we
00:24:47 fared at this stress test, we are certain to see other public health emergencies, pandemics,
00:24:54 who knows what other nature of thing in the future that will affect all of those domains
00:24:59 of life. And we're doomed to repeat it. So as you rightly noted, we opened this book by being sort
00:25:05 of against the pandemic amnesty. No, we can't have amnesia about all these things that happen.
00:25:12 I'll ask you about this, Christine, as well, because one of the challenges here is that
00:25:17 there's a legal aspect. And I know you're approaching this book as two lawyers, and a
00:25:21 lot of your advocacy on these issues has been through the legal lens. There's also the political
00:25:25 aspect and the cultural and the media aspect. And I'm curious how much you think this is really a
00:25:32 legal question versus a political question? Well, it's a legal question because a lot of
00:25:37 these issues were addressed by the courts. But I think there's also a political question as well,
00:25:42 and also a cultural one. And one of the things that we noticed in writing this book was how the
00:25:48 culture around civil liberties seems to have shifted really dramatically. I think that there
00:25:53 became this pendulum swing towards expediency and towards deference among the members of the public
00:26:04 to government decisions that didn't quite exist before. I think we were more skeptical of state
00:26:10 power before the pandemic. And during the pandemic, it seemed like there was only one way
00:26:16 that you could think about government restrictions, and it was to wholeheartedly celebrate them,
00:26:21 even when they violated some of our most fundamental tenets of our Constitution.
00:26:26 These things are all interconnected, right?
00:26:29 The politics, the culture, and the court decisions that come out of it.
00:26:33 And it kind of operates in a cycle.
00:26:35 And now we have a number of pretty terrible precedents legally
00:26:40 where courts evaded judicial scrutiny of rights violations through procedural reasons.
00:26:50 Mootness is one example that you gave, and we dealt with mootness a lot.
00:26:54 Another example is standing.
00:26:56 There were cases where cases were dismissed for lack of standing.
00:27:02 And the really important and novel questions about our rights in the context of an unprecedented crisis were never resolved.
00:27:12 And if we don't resolve those issues from the courts, we don't have good precedent to protect ourselves against intrusions in the future.
00:27:19 We don't have everything resolved, right?
00:27:21 We're still waiting for some decisions.
00:27:23 We have to put the book out at some point.
00:27:26 I actually just received my copy this afternoon.
00:27:29 I was happy to see your endorsement on the back there, Andrew.
00:27:32 Oh, I'm happy it made it to it.
00:27:34 I'm glad it was useful.
00:27:36 But yeah, not everything is resolved.
00:27:41 In particular, we're waiting for the result in the Emergencies Act Invocation Judicial Review,
00:27:47 which we had brought.
00:27:48 and we're expecting that maybe in the next few months. Let me actually ask you, I'll start with
00:27:53 you, Joanna, but if you want to bring in your own perspective, Christine, please do, about the
00:27:58 Emergencies Act, because some of the government's arguments on trying to dismiss these challenges
00:28:03 have been insane, and one of them, I'm crudely paraphrasing here, is basically, well, this was
00:28:08 a once-in-a-lifetime fact pattern, so therefore, you know, there's no point in really, you know,
00:28:15 having it out because the next time the emergencies act is brought in, it's going to be under
00:28:18 different circumstances. And that's a really dangerous argument because every case has its
00:28:24 own unique facts. And the point of precedent is not that you have a one size fits all solution,
00:28:28 but certainly you start defining this. So the fact that this never before used legislation,
00:28:34 the emergencies act came in, we've never had judicial guidance on how to use it. And the
00:28:40 government doesn't want that is incredibly concerning. Have I misrepresented anything
00:28:45 there, Joanna? No, certainly not. And I would add that in addition to the government pointing to
00:28:51 the so-called unprecedented nature of the freedom convoy, as you say, it's not clear to me that
00:28:58 there couldn't be some other type of emergency. We have climate issues. We have global security
00:29:04 issues. The world is a dynamic and changing place. But the important thing to add, even beyond
00:29:09 speculation is that at the hearings, both at the Public Order Emergency Commission hearings,
00:29:14 as well as the judicial review hearings, the government very specifically and very stridently,
00:29:20 I would say, pushed an interpretation of the application for the Emergencies Act,
00:29:25 which would give them very wide ambit to act. So specifically in the Emergencies Act, which
00:29:32 defines threats to the security of Canada in a way that's linked to the CSIS Act and that thus,
00:29:37 you know, relies on a CSIS assessment, an independent assessment specifically to avoid
00:29:44 concentrating too much power in the hands of the executive. We heard the prime minister himself
00:29:49 directly say that his interpretation, his government's interpretation of that was that
00:29:54 he could declare a state of emergency throughout Canada based on his understanding of threats to the
00:30:01 security of Canada as the governor and counsel, independent from any external threat assessment
00:30:07 And at both hearings, he declined to provide any type of legal brief, legal memo, let alone external threat assessment, which we know from the testimony of Jody Thomas was never provided.
00:30:19 So actually, if that standard rules the day, Justice Rouleau seemed to accept that.
00:30:26 And we know that the federal government, which is going to be bringing forward proposals for amendments to the Emergencies Act,
00:30:33 they're going to seek to separate out the CSIS Act definition so that basically the prime minister can decide when an emergency exists.
00:30:43 That would make it even more common that something like the Emergencies Act could be invoked again.
00:30:49 And perhaps Christine will talk a little bit about what that actually meant throughout all of Canada, not just Ottawa.
00:30:56 Yeah, it is important to remember that when the Emergencies Act was invoked, it wasn't geographically limited.
00:31:02 The Prime Minister had said, this is short, this is limited and temporary, but it was not limited.
00:31:10 It applied across the country, even though by the time it was invoked, the protests were only taking place in Ottawa.
00:31:18 Literally, quite literally, as the Emergencies Act was being invoked, the police were in the process of clearing the border blockades at Coutts and the blockades at the other border locations had already been cleared.
00:31:33 I think one of the interesting things that the book does, though, is it looks at this from a approach of constitutionalism and places a premium on the values of the rule of law.
00:31:48 law. And look, we're not here to cheerlead the convoy. I think that the convoy accomplished
00:31:56 the political goals that it set out to accomplish, but certainly there were aspects of that protest
00:32:01 that were illegal. And we have a whole chapter in the book about the rule of law and the
00:32:06 value of the rule of law. And we hold the federal government to the standard of the rule
00:32:12 of law. They can't invoke legislation when the legal threshold to invoke is not met.
00:32:17 They don't have this extraordinary power unless they're authorized by law. But on the same hand,
00:32:24 we need to hold members of the public who participated in the convoy to the standards
00:32:27 of the rule of law as well. And certainly there were illegal acts that took place. People should
00:32:32 face criminal charges related to those criminal acts. And certainly a protest cannot go on
00:32:38 indefinitely. By the end, the police were certainly entitled to exercise ordinary police
00:32:47 powers, to move large vehicles off of streets, not to permanently block a protest from proceeding.
00:32:55 I think there's no question you can protest on the lawn of Parliament Hill, but you certainly
00:33:00 can't indefinitely block Ontario highways. There's provisions of the criminal code that address that
00:33:08 though, and there was no need to resort to the use of the Emergencies Act. So I think that that's
00:33:14 one of the things that is going to challenge readers in our book is whatever your perspective
00:33:19 on this, on all of these issues, on COVID, on the Emergencies Act, I think you need to be prepared
00:33:24 to have that perspective challenged because these things are not straightforward. Whatever the
00:33:30 mainstream media might say, this is not a black and white issue. These issues are complex. And
00:33:34 that's why we required an entire book that took us years to write to go through all of this. So
00:33:40 I encourage anyone who reads the book to read it with a very open mind, because we really have
00:33:45 spent a lot of time trying to get the balance right on all of these issues. Well, one of the
00:33:51 things that you have both done in this, which I was very grateful for, is you've gone right back
00:33:55 to the beginning, because I think when the Convoy and the Emergencies Act came in, we're talking
00:34:01 about now more than two years after the onset of some of the earlier COVID restrictions. And
00:34:05 some of those early stories that almost sounded quaint in comparison of like, you know, oh, some
00:34:10 kid, you know, given a citation for using a public basketball court. Or I remember there was one in
00:34:16 Hamilton where a drug dealer was arrested for operating a non-essential business, as well as
00:34:21 for dealing drugs, like some of these things, which almost became novelties. But the reason
00:34:25 they did is because the government response to COVID got more and more severe. At that point,
00:34:30 we didn't know we'd be looking at church closures pastors in jail uh family gatherings being uh in
00:34:37 some cases you know raided by police and all of these things you know are too large to just say
00:34:44 we can't look into and i'm curious what your thoughts are on on the procedural aspects here
00:34:49 because i know there have been a lot of these charges that were issued that have just been
00:34:52 dropped because of judicial resourcing you know it's we don't have enough time to go through three
00:34:56 years of fines. Courts are backed up. The problem with that, of course, is that no one has had their
00:35:02 day in court. The arguments and the precedents haven't been made, but for the individual people
00:35:06 charged it to win. So how do you reconcile those two? I think we had one case that was like that
00:35:11 that we talk about in the book, and it relates to an individual protester in Kingston. And you're
00:35:17 so right. It's so quaint when you think back to it. It's also surreal. So the facts of some of
00:35:23 these stories, you know, like roping off the cherry blossom. So one of the stories we talk
00:35:26 about in this book is a case that we were working on at the Canadian Constitution Foundation. It
00:35:31 involved a man named Robert who was frustrated as a gym user and a supporter of small business. A
00:35:39 lot of his friends ran small businesses. He was frustrated with these sort of never-ending
00:35:43 lockdowns. I think we were on our third or fourth lockdown in Ontario and he decided to go in
00:35:49 protest. He wore a mask and he went by himself. He wanted to start his own protest to say end the
00:35:56 lockdowns. And he was charged under, I think it was at the time, the stay-at-home order. And
00:36:03 I mean, the idea that someone protesting or standing outside alone with a mask expressing
00:36:12 a political view poses some type of public health threat. It's just absurd. And so we wanted to use
00:36:18 this as an opportunity to challenge the broader lockdown provisions. But I mean, in the best
00:36:25 interest of Robert, the charges were dropped. So obviously, that's the route that we need to
00:36:30 proceed with. But the result of it procedurally is that you don't get a precedent. You don't get
00:36:36 to challenge the broader law, which is really what the problem is here.
00:36:41 Well, and you've also done something really interesting, Joanna, instead of organizing
00:36:45 it chronologically, which I think probably would have been my instinct as a writer, you've gone by
00:36:49 basically sections of the charter and by individual rights and freedoms from freedom of assembly to
00:36:55 freedom of movement, freedom of expression, all of these things. And I think it's easy to just
00:37:01 look in general in the abstract or in the amalgam and say rights were violated. But when you go
00:37:07 through and point specifically to how and which rights, it's a very powerful case. And let me ask
00:37:13 you just on religion alone, because, you know, the government's defense of its restrictions on
00:37:18 worship ceremonies and services was that, well, you know, you have the right to, you know, be
00:37:23 a Christian, you have the right to be a Jew, you have the right to be a Muslim, but, you know, 0.74
00:37:27 this is just extraordinary times. But for people of faith, that is the government telling them
00:37:31 how their religion must be practiced. I mean, you look at with Judaism, which has very specific
00:37:37 guidelines on the number of people that need to be a part of prayer. Government was saying its
00:37:42 edicts matter more than these things that we supposedly have a right to define ourselves.
00:37:48 Yeah, absolutely. And we talk about in the book that, so for example, because of these,
00:37:53 you know, unprecedented restrictions, it brought out some of the frailties in the law itself. So
00:37:58 for example, freedom of subjective belief is extremely strongly protected in Canadian law,
00:38:04 but freedom of assembly has much weaker protection. And most of its protections are in the context of
00:38:09 like labor union strikes and things like that. And so it was quite jarring to religious, you know,
00:38:16 religious Canadians that the government had gave such short shrift to the value of in-person
00:38:22 worship. I was actually at a conference in the UK this past summer, and I was told that in London
00:38:27 or in England at some point, gathering limits were set at five people. At least in Ontario,
00:38:33 they were set to 10 people, perhaps in consultation with the Jewish community that would have let them
00:38:37 know the minimum amount of people needed for a minion. Having that aside, there are churches
00:38:43 in Canada that are important community hubs, particularly for new Canadians, which elderly
00:38:50 Canadians rely on because participating by Zoom isn't an option for them. And you really saw that
00:38:57 the government was just happy to say, well, you can just log on to Zoom and there's no violation
00:39:04 to your religious freedom. The government actually contended in most cases and was
00:39:09 countenanced by judges in many cases that these strict restriction and gathering limits didn't
00:39:15 even engage the right to freedom of religion. And you can read about some of those, some of
00:39:20 those faith communities in the book. Yeah. And I would also point out, I mean, at the early days,
00:39:27 there was a much different attitude. Like I remember when the Ontario government was
00:39:30 actually taking a bit of a bit of guidance from the Church of God in Elmer, which was the first
00:39:35 one to really try to make drive-in services a thing. And then you fast forward a few months and
00:39:40 you know, the government's having the doors locked and putting millions of dollars to fines down.
00:39:45 And had people at least hiding in the bushes, observing the congregants.
00:39:50 Yeah. And I actually had, there was one report that was handed over in Discovery in which I was
00:39:55 named as a person of interest in the police's investigation of that, because I had interviewed
00:40:00 the pastor and they were suspicious that I might attend the service. So they had preemptively put
00:40:06 me on the person of interest list, which was quite an honor. I had never had that before. I would
00:40:11 have preferred it to be about something I did rather than something someone thought I might
00:40:14 have done. But that's the insanity here. And I wanted to bring up another dimension of this that
00:40:19 I had almost forgotten. And it was seeing you cite me that I remembered this when the government of
00:40:26 Ontario had tried to give police the power to stop and question anyone who was outside their home
00:40:33 about what they were doing. And, you know, very gratefully, every police department in Ontario,
00:40:39 except for the OPP, I think in the next couple of days said, we're not going to do this. But
00:40:44 like that would have seemed insane if you had said in 2019 that that was at all something that
00:40:49 government would direct the police to do in a province. Yeah, you did some really great
00:40:54 reporting on that. That's, I think you were, you were the person who was literally, quite literally
00:40:59 counting which police. Well, I was like cold calling them all. I spent my weekend doing that.
00:41:03 Yeah. Great, great work, Andrew. And it's very valuable. And it's very important that we have
00:41:09 a record of that. The reality is that police are the ones who need to interact with the community.
00:41:16 And, you know, I'm generally skeptical of police power, but I know police as well. And I know that
00:41:22 for the most part, police want to have a good relationship with their community and have worked
00:41:28 hard to develop a relationship of trust with the communities where they are policing. And they are
00:41:34 not interested, generally, in stopping mothers taking their children on a walk to a playground,
00:41:41 which is what that stay-at-home order was going to do, combined with that police authority to
00:41:46 stop people. And I'll point out that this police power to stop people and demand, they identify
00:41:54 themselves and explain why they're outside their house. It's very similar to a policy that was
00:42:01 controversial in Ontario called carding, because carding had resulted in a lot of police interactions
00:42:08 with racialized communities, in particular, who are generally over policed. And the government
00:42:15 created a policy that they would no longer engage in carding. And there were constitutional concerns
00:42:21 around that policy. And in fact, when, and it is so similar to what was announced and what was
00:42:28 announced during the pandemic was actually more extreme than the carding policy, that everyone
00:42:34 sitting at that cabinet table would have known how similar this is to carding. And in fact,
00:42:39 we know from reporting from, it was from the CBC, they found, they had spoken to someone who
00:42:47 disclosed that in cabinet, the attorney general, the provincial attorney general had warned cabinet
00:42:53 that this policy is likely unconstitutional. And cabinet and the premier, Ford, proceeded to enact
00:43:00 it anyway. And I think that there's real concern that there's bad faith there. The bad faith is
00:43:06 that they knowingly enacted an unconstitutional law. And they did it because they wanted some
00:43:12 short-term gain. And they knew that any judicial oversight over that would not be heard in time
00:43:19 before this temporary measure had been repealed. And they would avoid any judicial scrutiny. And
00:43:27 I think that that's bad faith. And it's very, very concerning. I mean, there's some relief
00:43:32 that the police said we will not enforce this but it shouldn't just lay with the police to say
00:43:36 we won't be enforcing unconstitutional laws. I'll go back to you Joanna just as we wind down here
00:43:44 because the subtitle of the book how Canadian government responses to COVID-19 changed civil
00:43:50 liberties forever is a lofty one and I know in your conclusion you actually are rather forward
00:43:55 looking about this but I'll ask with a bit of trepidation because I don't want to know the
00:44:01 answer as I think I know the answer. Do you think these changes have been for the better or for the
00:44:07 worse? And I'll just add a bit of an asterisk there. When all of the legal procedures have
00:44:13 been exhausted, we have the definitive ruling. Do you think that we will end up with fundamentally
00:44:18 a less free country than we had going into COVID? I think we have a legal system that has shown
00:44:24 how effectively it can obfuscate answering the question with the declarations of mootness,
00:44:30 with the deference to government evidence. We were talking to another interviewer who found
00:44:37 it remarkable that a lot of these issues weren't dealt with under section one. So yes, we can
00:44:43 acknowledge there was a rights violation, but maybe under section one, which is the justification
00:44:47 clause, maybe you can say in public health emergencies, it was justified, but at least
00:44:53 to acknowledge for the record that these were rights violations. So we really have seen all
00:44:59 the ways that judges were able to wiggle out of telling the truth. Now, I will sort of conclude
00:45:05 my remarks on a more optimistic note, which maybe I'm a little bit more of an optimist than Christine.
00:45:11 I think it depends on us. I think it depends on the culture that we build. I think it depends on
00:45:15 our collective understanding and our collective assessment of whether this was good enough,
00:45:21 whether we think that if we have charter rights, which were, you know, agreed to democratically,
00:45:26 whether they should mean something. Um, and if we understand the sort of fiasco that happened
00:45:32 and we'll hold future governments accountable, just, you know, out of sort of shock of how
00:45:37 abysmally our, our, you know, culture during the last pandemic failed. Um, I think that
00:45:43 there could be hope, but it starts with, you know, looking in a sober way at how we actually
00:45:49 fared. If I knew that you were the optimist of the two, I probably would have reversed this.
00:45:53 So we get to end on Christine's dour note, but Christine, or maybe you do have a less dour note, but I'll give you the last word on this.
00:46:00 What's the forward-looking takeaway you have after writing this?
00:46:03 I'm pessimistic. I think not only did the courts do a terrible job protecting our rights, I think people have just shoved that memory away and forgotten it.
00:46:12 And I think that I'm very concerned about whatever the next crisis is, we've now broken the glass on the Emergencies Act.
00:46:19 it could be used again in the future, that our culture of civil liberties has been permanently
00:46:24 damaged because we've seen how easily people have come to justify huge intrusions into their rights.
00:46:30 I think that we're in a very dark time politically in our discourse where disagreement is not
00:46:39 tolerated at all. I'm completely pessimistic and I'm very dark. I'm in a very dark place,
00:46:45 Sandra. But, you know, that's why you definitely should have ended with Joanna. But yeah.
00:46:51 Well, I'll say I'll say this to try to put a somewhat optimistic flavor on it is that you
00:46:56 have to diagnose a problem to fix the problem. So even taking the approach that you have,
00:47:01 Christina, and the both of you have through this book, I think is essential to rectifying it,
00:47:04 because there is in a lot of cases, a political response available. And I, you know, I was
00:47:09 mentioning earlier, the private members bill in the House of Commons today, again, may or may not
00:47:14 passed. But, you know, if you have a change in government and a government is saying, you know,
00:47:18 this should never happen, I will not do this, we could perhaps try to normalize civil liberties
00:47:23 again. But I realize the courts will always remain a bit of a wild card there. Nonetheless,
00:47:28 it is an incredibly, incredibly important book. I was very honored to be able to write a small
00:47:34 blurb for you and even more honored that some of my work helped you put it together. It's called
00:47:38 Pandemic Panic, How Canadian Government Responses to COVID-19 Changed Civil Liberties Forever. It's
00:47:44 by Joanna Barron and Christine Van Gein. And you can also read a bit of their work in C2C Journal
00:47:49 this month as well to get a bit of a sense of what the book holds. Joanna, Christine, thank you so
00:47:54 much and well done with this. Thank you, Andrew. And the book's available on Amazon right now for
00:47:58 anyone interested. All right, wonderful. Yes, do head over there. And last time we had an author
00:48:02 on it like spiked up in the numbers. So I'm hoping we can replicate that here. Go to Amazon
00:48:06 on and check it out. Joanna, Christine, thanks very much. That does it for us for today. We will
00:48:12 be back tomorrow with more of Canada's most irreverent talk show here on True North. Thank
00:48:17 you. God bless and good day to you all. Thanks for listening to The Andrew Lawton Show. Support
00:48:23 the program by donating to True North at www.tnc.news.
00:48:36 We'll be right back.
00:49:06 We'll see you next time.