Juno News - March 15, 2023


Liberals won't say how much Volkswagen battery plant is costing us

Topics
Mentioned
Serious countries want nothing to do with Canada This is a DISGRACE!

Episode Stats


Length

45 minutes

Words per minute

189.96

Word count

8,627

Sentence count

361

Harmful content

Toxicity

3

sentences flagged


Summary

Summaries generated with gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ .

In this episode of The Andrew Lawton Show: Canada's Most Irreverent Talk Show, host Andrew takes a trip down memory lane to a couple of his favourite places in the province. In St. Thomas, Ontario, a new Volkswagen battery plant is coming to a southern Ontario town, and in Oxford, ON, a Conservative candidate has been disqualified from the party nomination race.

Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Topics generated with Qwen2.5-3B-Instruct.
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 Welcome to Canada's Most Irreverent Talk Show.
00:00:05 This is the Andrew Lawton Show, brought to you by True North.
00:00:14 And welcome to you all.
00:00:16 This is Canada's Most Irreverent Talk Show, the Andrew Lawton Show, here on True North.
00:00:22 It is Wednesday, March 15th, 2023.
00:00:25 Hope you are having a wonderful day.
00:00:27 It is the latter end of the midway point through the week.
00:00:32 So if you are a Monday to Friday worker, you've just crossed over the threshold and it's all,
00:00:38 I don't know if it's downhill, I can't say it's all downhill from here.
00:00:41 This is like the big old confusion because downhill implies that it gets worse.
00:00:45 But if I say uphill, that implies it's harder.
00:00:47 So I will say it hopefully only gets easier for you or you've just like procrastinated
00:00:52 all the week's work to Friday and now you have to condense five days of labor into one.
00:00:57 I didn't actually realize it until we were having a heck of a time trying to find guests for yesterday's show
00:01:02 that this was March break, because March break only matters when you are a child or have children.
00:01:09 And despite how I act on some occasions, some people may think I am not a child and I do not have children,
00:01:14 so I had no idea that it was March break.
00:01:16 So if you are enjoying March break right now with your family,
00:01:19 I hope you are going to really get the most out of it before getting back into the real world in a few days' time.
00:01:25 Maybe you don't want the week to end, so ignore that whole Wednesday, hump day, uphill, downhill thing.
00:01:31 Lots to talk about today.
00:01:33 Going to delve into local politics, but I think there's a national flavor to it very shortly
00:01:38 with the latest news out of Oxford, a Conservative stronghold with an upcoming by-election.
00:01:45 And the Conservatives have disqualified one of the nomination candidates,
00:01:48 and there is a little bit of a suspicion about why, and it has something to do with his beliefs.
00:01:53 So that's going to be coming up with Scott Hayward from the group right now.
00:01:58 Another local story that I think is national in nature is not far from me.
00:02:02 I'm in London, Ontario.
00:02:04 And this week we learned that in St. Thomas, which is just a town about, I don't know,
00:02:09 30, 25, 30 minutes south of me, they are getting a giant 600 hectare Volkswagen electric vehicle
00:02:16 battery plant.
00:02:17 Now this sounds exciting.
00:02:18 It's a big employer for the city.
00:02:20 There used to be in Talbotville, which is just outside of St. Thomas, you're getting all of the southwestern Ontario geography today, a giant Ford plant.
00:02:29 They made the Crown Vicks there, and at a certain point, they shut down that plant and left a lot of people who had skills in the automotive industry out of work.
00:02:37 So from a St. Thomas perspective, from a southern Ontario perspective, this is great news.
00:02:43 Investment, development, it's a new plant, it's electric vehicles of the future.
00:02:47 but you look a little bit further through it and you kind of wonder
00:02:50 all right how is this coming to fruition is this Volkswagen looking around and saying you know we
00:02:57 really think this is the place that makes the most business sense because it's affordable land
00:03:03 there's a labor pool or is it that they were paid to come here now this is where we get into the
00:03:09 nitty-gritty of this and I want to let Francois Philippe Champagne the industry minister have the
00:03:15 first word on this because he won't actually say how much the federal government spent to bring
00:03:21 Volkswagen to St. Thomas, Ontario. In addition to what you laid out, I'm going to ask you very
00:03:28 bluntly, Minister. Did you have to cut them a check and how big of one? Well, listen, you always
00:03:34 have to be part of the, I always say government have to be part of the equation when you come to
00:03:38 these large investments. You mentioned the Inflation Reduction Act in the United States.
00:03:42 you will recall that in the thought economic statement we said that uh we intend to to level
00:03:47 the playing field that we would be selective um so obviously government have to be a part of the
00:03:53 equation and i appreciate all those points and i'm certainly not trying to take away from them
00:03:57 but it's a really long-winded way of not not answering minister that the original question
00:04:01 i posed am i to interpret from your answer that the federal government did invest did cut the
00:04:07 company a check and again i'm going to ask on behalf of canadians i'm not saying the investment
00:04:11 isn't a worthwhile one but how significant is it how big is the size of the check you had to cut
00:04:15 so i'll answer very clearly your question canada uh had to be part of the equation and i'm not
00:04:21 going to go into the details because we have discussions with many others so discussions
00:04:25 are commercially sensitive but as always vashi will recall we always we always make that
00:04:31 information public in due course i i like how he prefaces i'm prefaces that with i'm going to be as
00:04:41 clear as I can before saying nothing at all except for we had to be quote part of the equation. So
00:04:48 we know that this is a big deal here, billions of dollars. This is the first North American
00:04:54 electric vehicle battery manufacturing plant Volkswagen has. We look into some reporting
00:04:59 that's been done outside of Canada, specifically in the Financial Times. There was a report in
00:05:05 the Financial Times that said Volkswagen was putting plans for a European battery plant on
00:05:10 hold because it could get nearly 15 billion dollars in subsidies for a north american plant
00:05:17 now it sounds like they might have been talking about this one given that it is the first and so
00:05:22 far only north american plant and it's meant to serve an international market here so we're talking
00:05:28 about billions billions with a b that is being given probably by the provincial government as
00:05:35 well this is not just a federal government issue to build this plant banking on electric vehicles
00:05:40 being the future and as Vashi says maybe it is a good investment maybe there's going to be an ROI
00:05:46 maybe it will generate all that and more but this to my view looks like smells like sounds like
00:05:53 corporate welfare and if the business case were there why does government need to in
00:05:57 Minister Champagne's words be a part of the equation joining me on the line now is
00:06:02 at Macdonald-Laurier Institute Senior Fellow, Philip Cross, formerly with Statistics Canada,
00:06:07 now in the evil, scary private sector. I appreciate you joining me, Philip. Good to
00:06:12 talk to you again. Thanks for having me back, Andrew.
00:06:14 So let's talk first off about, I think, the landscape here. We know that manufacturing
00:06:19 has been in decline. The automotive sector has been just pummeled in recent years. There are
00:06:25 a number of reasons for that, economic, trade-related, and so on. I mean, in southwestern
00:06:29 Ontario, it's particularly acute. And I never like to poo-poo something that will employ my
00:06:34 neighbours, my friends, people, and my family. But you have to look at the bigger picture here.
00:06:39 And this is, I mean, corporate welfare. There's no other way to put it, right?
00:06:43 No, and particularly when you're talking about $15 billion, we've moved to a whole different
00:06:47 level. I mean, we've seen this is an industry that is chronically dependent on government-first
00:06:52 subsidies. But typically, you know, when it's GM and Toyota and Ford and so on, it's a billion
00:06:58 hear a billion there um but you know 15 billion is just off the scale uh it makes you wonder if
00:07:06 there if there is a sound business case for this and the the addiction of this industry to subsidies
00:07:12 contrasts with other industries you can look at high tech and you know they're based in california
00:07:18 you know that's where apple and google and uh everybody is and then up to up the road you have
00:07:24 Microsoft in Seattle. They moved there because they want to be as far away from Washington as
00:07:29 possible. Bill Gates said he deliberately put Microsoft in Seattle because he didn't want
00:07:35 anything to do with with Washington politics. He wanted to be away from all that. That to me is
00:07:42 that's the kind of industry you want here. You don't want an industry here where they're only
00:07:47 here because you bribed them. But it's a sad comment in Canadian business environment that
00:07:53 that the only way we can get investment in this country is to bribe people to come here.
00:07:57 I mean, it's staggering that investment has fallen 17% since 2014 in this country.
00:08:03 We have a real problem attracting business here,
00:08:06 and it appears the only way we can get businesses here is if we give them ever larger amounts of money.
00:08:13 Yeah, I read one article that was talking about a plant that's being built in Windsor by Stellantis,
00:08:20 which is double the size of this one that's being talked about in st thomas and it's valued at five
00:08:26 billion dollars now i mean obviously different costs come from different places but but if you
00:08:31 can build something for twice the size at five billion dollars and we're talking about potentially
00:08:35 15 billion dollars in subsidies we're not just talking about bankrolling the entire construction
00:08:40 of this plant but also its operations for i don't know how many years and at this point i don't even
00:08:45 think you can say volkswagen is doing it this is just a canadian government factory with a
00:08:50 Volkswagen logo on it? Yeah. Well, it's a little worrisome, too, that Volkswagen doesn't have any
00:08:54 history in this country. It's not like Toyota, Honda, GM, Ford that have deep roots here,
00:09:00 that obviously came here. They have workers that have been here and trained for a long period of
00:09:05 time. So it makes you think at the first downturn in the auto industry, and the auto industry
00:09:09 always has downturns, the first plant Volkswagen is going to close is going to be this one,
00:09:14 since they don't have any real business case reasons to be here in the first place.
00:09:21 So the other problem is, and I've seen the academics at the University of Windsor point out
00:09:28 that it's very likely that a lot of these auto investments would have been made anyways.
00:09:32 That firms decide ahead of time, okay, we're going to put a plant here.
00:09:36 Let's see how much money we can extract from government.
00:09:39 And that's just become part of the game.
00:09:42 Although as a new arrival, I must say, Volkswagen, as I say, has mastered this game in a way that nobody else has.
00:09:48 Yeah, they've learned the game very well.
00:09:50 But let me actually push back on that point a little bit, Philip, because I wonder if one of the problems here is that because this is the rules of the game now,
00:09:57 and this is basically how things work, if the only way to get investment from one of these companies is to just throw money at them.
00:10:05 Like I remember a few years ago when Amazon was doing this Amazon 2.0 and building the second headquarters, they turned it into a contest almost.
00:10:14 They basically opened it up to a public bidding thing and said, you know, governments just come and tell us what you're going to give us to set up shop there.
00:10:21 Right. And it's very funny you should mention that because just in the last week, Amazon announced the suspension of work on this new headquarters that we were all dying to get.
00:10:32 Including Ontario. Ontario was putting together a multi-billion dollar bid.
00:10:36 No, and Toronto was one of the supposed 20 finalists, although you knew that Amazon was never going to leave the U.S.
00:10:42 But, you know, and that's what makes you worried that, you know, corporations can take all these subsidies and there's no guarantees that the plants will stay open, how long they'll be open.
00:10:54 As I say, I think it's a little worrisome that Volkswagen in particular doesn't have any traditional roots here in the Ontario economy.
00:11:01 And it makes you wonder how deep their commitment is here in the first place.
00:11:08 The dollars and cents of it here.
00:11:10 And again, obviously, we don't have the specifics, which I think is in and of itself noteworthy.
00:11:14 Because oftentimes when governments are handing out big giant checks, they want to be telling everyone and bragging and shouting from the rooftops about we're investing this much.
00:11:22 So the fact that they're not doing that suggests that even there might be a bit of embarrassment about it.
00:11:26 Yeah. And remember, too, this long-term strategy of the Ontario and the federal governments of subsidizing auto plants. In the long term, it hasn't stopped a long-term shift in this industry, which is increasingly to Mexico, a certain amount staying in the U.S. and a declining proportion in Canada.
00:11:47 The Canadian auto industry's share of North American production is in long-term decline.
00:11:52 So, you know, we shouldn't trumpet this as a winning strategy.
00:11:56 If anything, we're just, you know, slowing or minimizing the losses here.
00:12:01 Instead, a better strategy would be to focus on making our economy and our industry so competitive that firms will want to be here.
00:12:09 Because of the hospitable business environment.
00:12:14 Because of well-trained workers.
00:12:16 because we have good infrastructure.
00:12:18 These are the reasons why you want industry to hear.
00:12:22 It's why the high-tech industry moved to the West Coast, as I mentioned earlier.
00:12:27 These are the ways to attract investment.
00:12:31 I may be wrong about this,
00:12:33 but it strikes me that there may be an ideological component here
00:12:36 given what they're manufacturing here.
00:12:38 This isn't just a garden-variety widget factory.
00:12:41 It's not even a car factory.
00:12:42 It's an electric vehicle battery factory.
00:12:44 And we know that government, this particular government has been very, very much focused on climate initiatives, on green tech and all of that. And I think that when you start letting these things cloud your economic judgment, you're not making economically sound decisions.
00:12:59 uh very much so i couldn't agree more i'm glad you brought that up it was a point i wanted to
00:13:04 make that this really does seem to fit the um uh um the ideology of this government but as usual
00:13:13 with this government too you know the facts in the ground don't really support it i think most
00:13:17 people would would agree that electric vehicles aren't that much better for the environment than
00:13:23 than internal combustion engine vehicles uh that this is really a lot of greenwashing i mean the
00:13:29 life cycle of manufacturing a battery is is insane for uh for emissions for environmental harm all
00:13:34 of that yeah yeah so i mean if you were really committed to reducing emissions you would want
00:13:41 people to just drive in less to change their lifestyle but of course you know no government
00:13:47 will mention that because the mention the minute you start telling people you're going to have to
00:13:51 live in downtown in small homes you're not going to be able to travel much you can forget about
00:13:55 flying around the world, immediately you're going to lose the next election and you're going to lose
00:14:00 badly. So instead, what we do is, yeah, we subsidize firms, we tell them to build electric
00:14:07 battery vehicles, and, you know, we pretend the problem's solved.
00:14:15 To make a business case for this amount of money, I mean, if you could, and I'm kind of of the mind
00:14:21 that I don't think it can be made, but if you were the government that has to come out and sell this
00:14:25 when that dollar figure eventually comes out, how do you at all demonstrate that ROI?
00:14:30 I mean, I'm looking here, $15 billion divided by $50,000, a reasonable annual salary amounts
00:14:37 to 300,000 years of full-time work.
00:14:40 Like, I feel you could probably generate more employment by just giving people the $15 billion
00:14:45 in St. Thomas.
00:14:47 Yeah, or I mean, there's all kinds of demands on the government for money these days.
00:14:52 I mean, just look at health care.
00:14:54 you know we could use a lot of money that would create it's very labor intensive that would create
00:14:59 a lot of jobs um you know at the same time the government's been being very cheap in in supporting
00:15:05 ukraine uh you know the americans give right to checks to ukraine for billions here and billions
00:15:11 there and we hand out 10 and 20 million here and there and um you know there's a lot of different
00:15:18 you would think there's a lot of more useful ways of spending 15 billion dollars than building one
00:15:25 electric battery plant no matter where it is so there's an argument here i think that if
00:15:32 a bank wouldn't give that money why should a government do you think that's fair do you think
00:15:36 there is a rule for government to invest to use their word in a way that isn't as focused on
00:15:42 business case well the auto industry seems to be the exception i mean that seems to be an industry
00:15:48 that as i say is just so completely addicted to subsidies and they've made the case so well and
00:15:54 they don't forget bombardier you're they're feeling left out of that analysis um but you
00:15:59 know it's it's uh it seems to be the that industry is the worst uh and i i i don't know at this point
00:16:07 if we're going to be able to stop it but we should at least start capping the subsidies
00:16:11 uh at some point you know i thought we had international trade agreements that were going
00:16:16 to stop this kind of nonsense amongst other things i i should mention i mean you look at how the
00:16:21 americans complain about subsidies in the lumber industry and yet when it comes to the auto
00:16:26 industry it's you know everybody subsidizes everyone and nobody makes a free trade complaint
00:16:31 about it so um you know you would think at some point somebody's gonna to blow the whistle on this
00:16:38 but the point you raise about bank loans is a very valid one uh why if if the business case is so
00:16:45 compelling then why don't firms just do this on their own and um you know i i suspect you know
00:16:53 these academics in windsor are right that if we just stop subsidizing i don't think the industry
00:16:59 would disappear tomorrow i don't think it would pull up roots it has deep roots it has a lot of
00:17:04 traditions and a lot of workers and links established with suppliers in southwestern
00:17:11 Ontario, it's not going to wreck that overnight. So, but you know, it's just a matter of no
00:17:18 government is brave enough to be the first to say no. Yeah, very well said. Philip Cross from the
00:17:25 Macdonald-Laurier Institute. Always a pleasure. Thanks for coming on today. Thank you. Thank you.
00:17:30 I would add to that as well. I mean, one of the challenges is that subsidies delay necessary
00:17:37 industrial, I don't want to use industrial revolution in a grand sense, but they delay
00:17:41 revolution within industry. There's a better way of putting it. Because if you are being propped
00:17:46 up by subsidies, you have no reason to look inward and say, hey, maybe something we're doing isn't
00:17:52 right. Maybe something we're doing needs to change. And in this particular case, I mean,
00:17:57 electric vehicle manufacturing is probably one of the biggest rackets because the consumers are not
00:18:03 there. Governments are there, but consumers are not there. Consumers are being told every day
00:18:08 how great electric vehicles are. And some people want them. Some people try them out. Some people
00:18:13 rave about them. One thing that Tesla has done, which I think is tremendous, is they've made
00:18:19 electric vehicles cool. It used to be an electric vehicle was a Prius or a Nissan Leaf, where there's
00:18:25 no way to look cool. In fact, you look the opposite of cool driving a Prius or a Nissan Leaf. But
00:18:30 what's happened with Tesla is they've actually revolutionized people's relationship with
00:18:35 electric cars. But does Tesla exist the way it does now without governments heaping billions
00:18:42 and billions of dollars to subsidize consumer purchase of them? If you looked back when Ontario,
00:18:48 and I don't have the numbers handy because I wasn't going to talk about this, but back when
00:18:52 the Wynn Liberals were in power in Ontario, they were putting millions towards luxury electric
00:18:58 vehicles because it was the luxury cars that people were buying and they were getting each
00:19:03 on each one of these like tens of thousands of dollars I think it was off the purchase price
00:19:09 just to buy one of these things so you looking like a badass with your Tesla whatever the model
00:19:14 was was subsidized by Kathleen Wynne and all of that is I think part and parcel of why this is an
00:19:23 industry that lives on subsidy and the people that talk about this in ideological terms
00:19:28 are very inauthentic.
00:19:30 I don't have the clip handy,
00:19:31 but when we were covering the World Economic Forum
00:19:34 a few weeks back in Switzerland, in Davos,
00:19:37 there was this one mining executive
00:19:39 that was on this panel.
00:19:40 I think his name was Andrew Forrest.
00:19:42 I can't remember the name of the company,
00:19:43 but a mining executive on this panel talking about,
00:19:46 oh yeah, we need to switch to electric.
00:19:48 We need to get off of this.
00:19:49 And, you know, mining, as I said at the time,
00:19:52 is one of the most resource intensive industries
00:19:55 in the world.
00:19:56 mining, oil and gas, forestry
00:19:58 these are like the big three evil companies
00:20:00 the only one that could possibly be worse than them
00:20:03 to the left is the tobacco industry
00:20:05 but even the tobacco industry
00:20:06 is the definition I guess of green
00:20:09 so the industry that is probably
00:20:12 one of the most vilified mining
00:20:13 and here's this mining executive saying
00:20:15 we need to transition away from oil and gas
00:20:17 and you say well that seems a bit odd
00:20:19 until you look at all the mining that his company did
00:20:21 and you find that oh they're on the cutting edge
00:20:23 of lithium mining
00:20:24 the lithium that is going to be needed when we are putting batteries in everything
00:20:30 and when the world is to be a battery-powered world. 0.99
00:20:34 So all of this is often from people who do not believe the crap they are selling. 0.96
00:20:41 And I would talk about this in terms of Volkswagen. 0.99
00:20:45 I mean, Volkswagen, I don't blame them for this
00:20:48 because they've actually come hat in hand to government in Canada and in Ontario.
00:20:53 Doug Ford is, like I said, not squeaky clean in this, I'm almost certain.
00:20:58 And these governments have given them to the tune of $15 billion.
00:21:02 Like, 15 billion.
00:21:05 Like Philip was saying a few moments ago, Philip Cross,
00:21:08 when there's a $1 billion investment, people get a little bit uncomfortable with it.
00:21:14 When there's a $2 billion investment, people get really uncomfortable.
00:21:17 We're talking about here $15 billion in subsidies.
00:21:20 This will pay for the plant.
00:21:22 it will pay for the staff of the plant it will pay for espresso machines at the plant it will
00:21:27 pay for this whole operation for several years to the point where i'm wondering what on earth it is
00:21:32 volkswagen is even putting forward here what on earth is volkswagen even shelly go because right
00:21:38 now it seems like this is an entirely canadian initiative an entirely canadian prospect where
00:21:45 the private sector is not even having to pony up any money and this is a subsidy driven industry
00:21:52 right now that Canadians bear the brunt of Canadian taxpayers have to bear the brunt of
00:21:57 and and just to again play this clip here that well this is I think another clip of the same
00:22:01 interview of Philippe Francois Champagne not acknowledging the price tag
00:22:07 and I can appreciate the commercial sensitivity and you're dealing with a company on this but
00:22:15 But there is going to be an announcement at some point on how much money we're actually investing, right?
00:22:19 Just for transparency.
00:22:20 As always.
00:22:21 So when can we expect to hear that, sir?
00:22:23 Well, in due course, because, like I said, we are having discussion with a number of players in the ecosystem.
00:22:29 And for now, this is commercially sensitive.
00:22:32 But as always, David, we always disclose that these informations in due course.
00:22:38 And Canadians will have a chance to see that.
00:22:40 okay sorry i made a mistake there different interview same talking points but but these
00:22:50 are the magic words in due course we'll find out how much the government spent on this in due
00:22:55 course and by that time it will probably be after the next election when conveniently the number
00:23:01 will have less utility than it does now so uh you know what was that old ronald reagan line about
00:23:07 you know governments i'm going to get it wrong so i won't even bother but it was the line about if
00:23:11 it stops if it moves regulate if it moves tax it if it stops moving subsidize it if it keeps moving
00:23:16 again regulate it or something to that effect but it's basically that the circle of life is
00:23:21 subsidization and regulation and nowhere does government say hey hands off this let the private
00:23:27 sector do its best let the private sector do its work and then we move on from there i want to shift
00:23:34 gears here to a different topic one that is not actually all that far from the storied plant in
00:23:41 St. Thomas Ontario this is in Oxford County which again is just like what I don't know 30 minutes
00:23:47 down the road from yours truly here although my hands are clean in this I don't live in Oxford
00:23:51 County I'm not a voting member of the Conservative Party or anything like that but there is a
00:23:57 nomination battle going on right now for a by-election Dave McKenzie the longtime Conservative
00:24:03 MP, retired from his seat in February just over a month ago, and now there are a bunch
00:24:10 of Conservatives vying to replace him as the Conservative candidate, which in Oxford County
00:24:15 is pretty much a sure bet that you're going to be elected as the Member of Parliament.
00:24:21 It's pretty much a sure thing that whomever wins the nomination will be the next Conservative
00:24:26 MP in Oxford.
00:24:27 And it's been quite hotly contested.
00:24:30 Arpan Kanna, who is a Brampton lawyer, formerly Ontario co-chair for Pierre Polyev, he's running.
00:24:36 And you have Rick Roth, a Toronto political strategist who's there.
00:24:40 You have Deb Tate, who is the daughter of Dave McKenzie, the recently retired MP.
00:24:46 And then you have Garrett, or had, up until last night, Garrett Van Dorlen.
00:24:51 Now, I've met Garrett because I've interviewed many conservatives in my career,
00:24:58 and he worked with Lesley Lewis on her leadership bid.
00:25:01 He's right now working in the office of a conservative member of parliament.
00:25:04 He's been involved in conservative politics, but he's from Otterville, which is in Oxford County.
00:25:10 And Garrett Van Dorland is pro-life.
00:25:13 If you look at, I probably should have pulled it up on the screen here,
00:25:16 but on his website, he talks about faith, he talks about family, he talks about freedom.
00:25:21 Those things are not really compatible with the government of Canada today, but they are certainly compatible or are supposed to be with the conservative movement in this country.
00:25:31 But last night, Gerrit Van Dorland was disqualified by the Conservative Party of Canada's National Candidate Selection Committee.
00:25:40 And I'm going to give you what the party says is the reason for the disqualification.
00:25:46 And you can read the full story on this over at tnc.news.
00:25:49 But what the Conservative Party said, and I'm quoting directly from a statement I got from their spokesperson,
00:25:56 is that Garrett Van Dorland, a nomination applicant in Oxford, was disqualified from standing in a nomination race
00:26:03 by the party's National Candidate Selection Committee due to a failure to comply with the obligation to disclose
00:26:09 required information during the candidate application process.
00:26:14 The recommendation to disqualify this individual was first made by the local candidate nomination committee.
00:26:20 And just by way of reference, candidate nominees have to provide to the party a list of all current and former social media accounts and websites,
00:26:29 a copy of any deleted or publicly inaccessible social media or other online content,
00:26:35 and a copy of all articles, media coverage, quotes, interviews that relate to the candidate.
00:26:40 And I just want to give you some perspective here, because I've been a candidate.
00:26:44 I ran in 2018 unsuccessfully for the Progressive Conservative Party of Ontario.
00:26:50 And in doing so, I had to go through this application process, and it was insane what
00:26:55 they asked for.
00:26:56 They actually asked for a full export of my Facebook account, of all social media accounts.
00:27:02 Now, if you don't know what you're doing, and you just go into Facebook and click the
00:27:06 export button what you don't actually realize is that you're not only giving an archive of
00:27:10 everything you've ever posted and everyone who's ever commented on it and all of your comments
00:27:14 you're also giving the party an archive of your direct messages your private correspondence which
00:27:21 is no different than handing over a copy of your email inbox and your text message history so
00:27:26 people don't realize they're handing that over when i was doing my uh form i actually went in
00:27:31 and I removed the direct messages from the zip file that I was giving them because I happen to
00:27:37 know how to do that. But other people are handing over everything which lets you be I think incredibly
00:27:43 susceptible to blackmail from your own party if they feel like it down the road. The federal
00:27:47 conservative application is even larger and more comprehensive than the provincial application that
00:27:53 I had to deal with. The party did not specify what details he didn't give them so we reserve
00:28:00 judgment on that. But Scott Hayward says it's not about this. It is about his pro-life belief.
00:28:06 Scott Hayward is the co-founder of Right Now, which I should disclose, as I have on the show
00:28:11 before, was an organization that supported my candidacy in 2018. But that doesn't color
00:28:16 my approach. I've been an open supporter of them before and since, irrespective of that.
00:28:22 Scott Hayward joins me on the line now. Scott, good to have you back. Thanks for coming on today.
00:28:27 Yeah, thanks for having me, Andrew. Really appreciate it.
00:28:28 So why do you think, first and foremost, that this was about Garrett's pro-life beliefs?
00:28:34 Well, I think it's a combination of a couple of things.
00:28:36 Like, I think that does play a role in it, Garrett's strong pro-life beliefs.
00:28:41 But I also think that in the riding, there are, and I don't know if you reviewed this already, so I'm sorry if I'm repeating myself,
00:28:47 but there are four contestants that are contesting for the Conservative Party of Canada nomination in Oxford for the upcoming by-election,
00:28:55 since Dave McKenzie announced that he's no longer running for re-election
00:28:59 and has since resigned the seat.
00:29:00 So in that by-election, or pardon me, in this nomination for that by-election,
00:29:05 there is a candidate, Arpan Khanna, who is favoured by the party leader
00:29:11 and those around the party leader, which is, you know, fine to a certain extent.
00:29:17 But I think what was happening, Andrew, is that Garrett,
00:29:21 having actually been born and raised in the riding,
00:29:23 um having been involved in uh with the eda in the riding for a number of years i mean his family's
00:29:29 been there for a number of years uh he sold a boatload of memberships uh from what i talked
00:29:35 to people in the riding we're talking about close to 50 percent of the memberships either were
00:29:40 purchased for garrett or they were already members and they're identified as garrett van
00:29:44 dorlin supporters so when you're talking about let me just i know you're not talking about specific
00:29:48 numbers but let me just jump in there because because this is uh conceivably a period where
00:29:53 people who signed up to vote in the leadership race would still be members so you're saying even
00:29:57 with that his numbers are close to half of the riding membership numbers that's correct yeah so
00:30:03 the the the closure date of the nomination was at the end of February so you would have a number
00:30:10 of people in the riding who purchased a membership in February 2022 to support a number of candidates
00:30:17 including Pierre Polyev and those memberships even though they would expire at the end of February
00:30:22 because the closure happened before the end of February,
00:30:25 they would be eligible to vote.
00:30:26 So you're talking about just under 6,000 members of the party
00:30:31 eligible to vote in the riding, which is kind of a crazy high number.
00:30:35 You're talking about 6% of the population of the riding.
00:30:38 You're probably talking, you know, like Calgary West numbers.
00:30:41 Yeah, exactly.
00:30:42 You know, you're talking about something of like 12, 15% of those
00:30:46 who are eligible to vote in an election are members of the riding.
00:30:49 So it's a huge number.
00:30:50 And from what I've talked to different people on the riding,
00:30:52 in the riding, it sounds like Garrett has about half of them, just under half. So, you know,
00:30:57 when you're talking about four candidates running for a nomination, and one of the four has 50%,
00:31:01 which is well over the 25% that he's split up evenly. I mean, you're talking about pretty
00:31:06 close to first ballot victory. So I think that does play a big role into it. In addition to the
00:31:12 fact that that he is pro-life. But I think that's more of a secondary role than than the fact that
00:31:17 there is a favored candidate by the leader who is a good candidate for the record. Like Arpan Khanna
00:31:24 is someone we supported when he ran as a candidate in Brampton, where he's from, in the 2019 general
00:31:30 federal election. So I don't think anyone has a problem with Arpan. I think what people have a
00:31:34 problem with, both in the running and across the country, is the heavy-handed tactics that we're
00:31:38 currently seeing by the party that were supposed to go away with the removal of Aaron O'Toole as
00:31:44 leader, have now reared their ugly head again with Pierre as a leader. So I think a lot of people
00:31:49 would like to see that cleaned up. So from my perspective, at least, Andrew, I think those
00:31:53 are the two reasons. Number one being there is a favorite candidate. And number two, I do think
00:31:57 that there are people in the party who don't necessarily share Garrett's strong pro-life
00:32:05 beliefs. Yeah, you know, the thing about nominations is that oftentimes they're very
00:32:12 dirty they're very messy uh it's infighting which is never good in a party and i'd say worse than
00:32:18 leaderships in a way just because sometimes there's so little scrutiny on them but the challenge that
00:32:22 i've always had with them and i have a very personal history with this because i was standing
00:32:27 for nomination i was confident i was going to win the nomination and then doug ford appointed me
00:32:31 which made things very difficult for me for the riding for the other candidate uh and you know
00:32:36 there were reasons that the party didn't want him but it's much easier if the party just comes out
00:32:40 and says that when they don't want a candidate.
00:32:43 And, you know, I look at what's happening here
00:32:44 and obviously I don't have the specifics of this,
00:32:47 but, you know, when they're saying not completing,
00:32:49 when you want, when you have an application
00:32:52 as detailed as these applications are,
00:32:55 it almost strikes me as designed to fail
00:32:58 because you know that if you really want to get rid of someone,
00:33:01 you can probably find something in the 50 pages
00:33:03 where they missed the comma or something.
00:33:06 Like you could probably find something if you look for it.
00:33:09 Yeah, and it's interesting.
00:33:10 So I've spoken of members of the National Council who I've been in touch with about this issue for about a week now when it came to our attention.
00:33:18 And it seems like that the party has not shared with members of the National Council, at least as since we're recording this, the details of what that nondisclosure was.
00:33:30 Are we talking the fact that Garrett had an entire social media account that he deleted or a website that he deleted that he hasn't disclosed?
00:33:38 given that that's a question in the 50 plus page candidate application uh for the conservative
00:33:44 party of candidate which frankly is not a bad question to ask but i don't how are you supposed
00:33:49 to give copies of stuff you've deleted i mean i deleted it for a reason i didn't keep the copy i
00:33:53 mean that so that that in and of itself is i think a bit of a flaw in it but fair enough to
00:33:57 acknowledge the existence of this but we're talking like an entire website you've deleted
00:34:02 or whatever i think that's an issue or are we talking about you know a facebook or a comment
00:34:07 that garrett made on a post you know back in 2010 and three weeks later he thought well you know
00:34:12 that's kind of a not very terrible post i'm gonna or comments i'm gonna delete that comment are we
00:34:16 talking about something like that no one knows right what one one is reasonable right to not
00:34:22 one is reasonable for a candidate to be disqualified if they don't disclose something
00:34:25 as big as i had this entire website and i deleted it and i didn't tell you about it versus you know
00:34:30 there was this comment i had up for three weeks on a facebook post you know 15 years ago and i
00:34:35 I can't remember because it's 15 years ago and I deleted it.
00:34:37 So what are we talking about here?
00:34:39 No one seems to know, which suggests to me that they don't really have anything.
00:34:44 Otherwise, that would probably be shared.
00:34:46 Another national councillor told me that the party had told them that it's not so much what the content of any of the deleted stuff is,
00:34:57 because we all have stuff that we've deleted online, whether it be tweets or Facebook comments or posts or whatever.
00:35:02 I think very few of us who have been online for over 10 years, and maybe we're aging ourselves, Andrew, won't have something that they do.
00:35:09 My internet baggage beats yours any day of the week, Scott.
00:35:12 I think CBC can tell you that, too.
00:35:14 Yeah, exactly, right?
00:35:16 So the National Council kind of told me, well, if the content doesn't matter, then why do we care?
00:35:23 And if it's not that big of a deal, is it reasonable that he forgot this, or is it unreasonable?
00:35:28 And those are the questions that are left unanswered, even by two national councillors, again, which strongly suggests to me that there's nothing there.
00:35:36 Now, it's interesting that you mentioned, Andrew, when you were running for your provincial nomination in London West of, I believe, for the Progressive Conservative Party of Ontario.
00:35:43 And I think and I agree with you that you were well on your way to win that nomination.
00:35:49 And then all of a sudden you were appointed by the now premier, Doug Ford.
00:35:52 You know, I think that does a lot of candidates, even yourself, a disservice because it runs a lot of people the wrong way.
00:35:58 And it's interesting because I don't know if you've talked about this on your show yet or not, but Arpan himself has come out and said, well, Garrett should be reinstated.
00:36:07 And he sent a public letter to the National Council because the appeals could be heard over the weekend that Garrett should be reinstated.
00:36:13 And Rick Roth, who is another candidate running in the nomination, has said the same thing as well.
00:36:18 So, you know, if you are a candidate that is, you know, in a position to win with Garrett gone, you're probably not going to say anything, right? Because you're going to win the nomination with him gone. But like I said, I think Arpan is a good candidate, is a good person. And so I'm glad that he stated that.
00:36:41 And, you know, if Garrett thinks that he should run and RPAN thinks he should run and Rick Roth thinks he should run and members of the party think he should run and members of caucus think he should run, then I would certainly hope that members of National Council and the leader and those around the leader would also share that view.
00:36:57 You know, and just going back to the fundamental principles here, and I know people's eyes make glaze over when you start talking about, you know, what's in the party constitution.
00:37:04 But like, in all honesty, you get the outcome you want or you get the process you want.
00:37:08 If you want open and fair and transparent nominations, then have them.
00:37:11 If you want preferred candidates, which is an entirely legitimate approach to building a party.
00:37:16 I think it's entirely legitimate if the leader says, no, no, no, we need to put a certain type of candidate forward in each riding, then be transparent about that and don't go through the whole charade.
00:37:26 And nothing bothers me more.
00:37:27 And this was like Patrick Brown 101, where you say we're going to be the party of grassroots, the party of democracy.
00:37:32 But then every nomination is somehow manipulated to have the outcome that Patrick Brown wants.
00:37:38 Yeah, I would agree with you on that, to a certain extent. I think if there's an attempt to amend the Constitution of the Conservative Party of Canada to state that X number of ridings or in a by-election and outside of general, we're going to be appointing candidates as opposed to allowing the nomination process to go forward, I don't think that'll be very popular with a lot of supporters of the party.
00:38:01 But that proves the point, though, because the party has decided that open nominations are important.
00:38:07 in theory in practice something else completely and again i i go back like you know we're early
00:38:14 days into pierre polyos leadership and i think that there's um a lot of positive changes that
00:38:19 have been made in in relation to the previous leader and i think a lot of people would agree
00:38:23 with that uh but this is the type of stuff that led to the end of the leadership of baron o'toole
00:38:29 and i think a lot of people don't really want to see that happen with pierre i mean even if he
00:38:34 didn't vote for Pierre as number one. I didn't. I voted him number two. Lesnar was number one for
00:38:38 me. You know, we in the Conservative Party of Canada, they have gone through what, three
00:38:43 leadership races in five years or something like that. I don't think people are really interested
00:38:46 in doing that again. But it's stuff like this that inevitably kind of leads it down that road.
00:38:52 And so I hope those kind of close to him are learning this lesson today and throughout the
00:38:56 rest of the week. And I hope National Council does accept the appeal of Garrett and reverse
00:39:01 the decision that let's not go down this road anymore, because it isn't in the nature of the
00:39:06 party, like you were saying, if there was a move to amend the Constitution of the party to allow
00:39:11 for appointments, I think there would be a big uproar, whether those people are pro-life or
00:39:15 pro-abortion, or whether they are libertarians, or, you know, fiscal hawks, or foreign policy
00:39:23 hawks, or whatever the case might be, whatever type of conservative they are, I think we can
00:39:27 all probably agree, even red Tories, I would say, I think we can all probably agree, like,
00:39:31 all the way around, people just want to have an open, fair nomination process. Now, that being
00:39:35 said, I think a lot of people would also agree that there should be some sort of mechanism in
00:39:40 place to have disqualifications when necessary. Sometimes there are people who want to run for
00:39:46 public office who have done things in the past that are just extraordinarily problematic.
00:39:51 And that, you know, political parties are, at the end of the day, private clubs,
00:39:56 but at the same time they establish rules of the need to to apply even handedly so yeah a party
00:40:03 should have the right to disqualify you know a lifelong liberal who just sees an opportunity to
00:40:07 co-opt a nomination for sure but but but these things should be done in the most i'd say narrow
00:40:12 way possible while keeping with what the grassroots want and i mean in some ways i might even say let
00:40:18 the liberal run because the members would reject them exactly that's a whole can of worms yeah
00:40:22 Exactly, right? Like, I think there's a lot of reasonable people within the Conservative Party of Canada that makes up its ranks and files in the members, right? And I think we've seen the reasonableness of party members, you know, in the last three leadership races, I would argue, right?
00:40:38 Right. And I think that there is a self-regulation mechanism there to to be had.
00:40:44 Right. And I think that the process of disqualification is something in an extreme.
00:40:49 You know, a problematic past might be someone who has a heinous sexual crime that they've committed in the past or something like that.
00:40:56 Where it's just it's just, you know, very, very inappropriate to to have a candidate like that.
00:41:01 But that's not what we're talking about here. Right.
00:41:03 We don't even know what we're talking about here because they won't tell us.
00:41:06 And in fact, Andrew, you have more information than the candidate himself.
00:41:10 The party gave you more information about the reason why he was disqualified, as little
00:41:13 information as was provided to you, than Garrett himself from when I spoke to him earlier
00:41:18 today.
00:41:19 So that's also interesting to me that the party is communicating with members of the
00:41:23 media more than they are with their own members and their own contestants.
00:41:28 I mean, it'd be very interesting, Andrew, if you were charged with a crime and you went
00:41:34 to appeal it and you had no evidence presented to you as to why they charged you with that
00:41:39 particular crime. And that's what we're experiencing here. So, you know, again,
00:41:43 these are things that we saw in the past under a previous leader in the pretty, pretty recent past.
00:41:48 And, you know, hopefully the lesson is learned here today in this week. And this is something
00:41:53 that can be reversed and something that we don't see again going forward.
00:41:56 Scott Hayward of Right Now, thanks very much for coming on today.
00:41:59 Thanks, Andrew. Really appreciate it.
00:42:01 Thank you. Just on that last point, I should say, I got into this weird, I don't know if it's a Twitter fight, because I was sort of just doing it haphazardly while I was doing other things. But a Twitter exchange, I broke my rule and I engaged with an anonymous Twitter account. So I beg forgiveness of the standards I've set for myself.
00:42:18 But someone who was taking aim at the fact that I, in the headline of the article I wrote about this for True North, said that a pro-life candidate was disqualified.
00:42:26 And I quoted Scott Hayward, a comment that he made earlier today, saying that he thinks he was targeted because of his pro-life beliefs.
00:42:33 And I included at the time that the party had not given any reason, which they hadn't.
00:42:38 And then I published the story.
00:42:39 And then, you know, like 30 minutes later, the party gives me a reason.
00:42:42 I include that in the story as I told them I would.
00:42:45 And then this person was like fighting with me
00:42:47 about misrepresenting
00:42:49 because he wasn't disqualified for being pro-life.
00:42:51 I never said the party said he was disqualified
00:42:53 for being pro-life.
00:42:54 I said he's a pro-life candidate who was disqualified,
00:42:57 which I think is very much the case.
00:42:59 And I appreciate Scott taking a bit of a nuanced view here
00:43:02 that he also appeared to be a front runner
00:43:04 when the party may have its own preferred candidate.
00:43:07 And look, I worked with Arpan many years ago in Ottawa.
00:43:11 I like Arpan a lot.
00:43:12 This is not about him.
00:43:14 In fact, Arpan is probably one of the most,
00:43:16 I mean, except for Garrett, who was disqualified,
00:43:19 Arpan is one of the most disadvantaged right now
00:43:21 because he now looks like he's being given
00:43:24 this invisible hand pushing him across the finish line.
00:43:28 If he was going to win, let him win.
00:43:29 And that's it.
00:43:30 Have a fair fight.
00:43:31 And that's what Arpan has called for.
00:43:33 It's what Garrett's called for.
00:43:34 It's what Rick Roth called for.
00:43:37 And I was just thinking Deb Tate,
00:43:39 who's Dave McKenzie's daughter.
00:43:40 I don't know if she's called for it.
00:43:41 I looked for her on Twitter
00:43:42 and I couldn't find her on Twitter.
00:43:43 So maybe she has or has not.
00:43:45 But nevertheless, there is always going to be more to nomination battles.
00:43:50 We'll cover that as the show progresses in the week ahead.
00:43:54 Just on our closing note here, I have to end with an update to the great quest for a special rapporteur on China's interference in Canadian elections.
00:44:04 I would like it noted that I lost because I predicted it was going to be Beijing Bev herself, Beverly McLaughlin.
00:44:11 It is not Beijing Bev. It is David Johnston. So David Johnston, the former governor general, who was also the, by the way, the commissioner of the, what was it called? The, I forget the name of it. The Leadership Debates, was it the Leadership Debates Commission? Yeah.
00:44:27 He was the leadership debates commissioner who made the decision to ban True North and Rebel from covering the debate.
00:44:34 So that is the eminent Canadian who's now the special rapporteur on interference in Canadian elections by China.
00:44:41 David Johnston did decide to accredit Xinhua, which is the Chinese state media agency, to the debate.
00:44:48 I'm not saying that's connected to this.
00:44:49 I just have a little bit of a bone to pick with David Johnston.
00:44:53 But for all of you who had David Johnston in the pool, you win the fully loaded electric Volkswagen that will be rolling off the line near St. Thomas in just a couple of years time.
00:45:03 So congratulations. You can pick it up at reception.
00:45:05 That does it for me for today.
00:45:07 We will be back with Fake News Friday in just two days time and then more of The Andrew Lawton Show next week.
00:45:12 Thank you. God bless and good day to you all.
00:45:16 Thanks for listening to The Andrew Lawton Show.
00:45:18 Support the program by donating to True North at www.tnc.news.