Juno News - April 17, 2025


LIVE Coverage of the 2025 French Election Debate

Topics
Guests
Mentioned
Violent pro-Hamas thugs are being violent all over the country EMERGENCY LIVESTREAM: debates commission CANCELS debate scrum to stop Juno News

Episode Stats


Length

3 hours and 45 minutes

Words per minute

157.23

Word count

35,497

Sentence count

1,747

Harmful content

Misogyny

33

sentences flagged

Toxicity

6

sentences flagged

Hate speech

71

sentences flagged


Summary

Summaries generated with gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ .

Candice Malleolo gives her immediate reaction to the first of two French-language debates, the third and final debate of the night. She also talks about the removal of the Greens from the debate, and why she's suing the government.

Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Topics generated with Qwen2.5-3B-Instruct.
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 Hi, I'm Candice Malcolm. This is a very special live edition of the Candice Malcolm Show. We are
00:00:11 here to broadcast on the French language debate, folks. It's finally here. If you're anything like
00:00:17 me, you wish that there were more of these debates. I wish that we had more of an opportunity
00:00:21 to get to know the candidates, to get to know specifically Mark Carney. And, you know, he's new
00:00:25 to the scene in politics. We don't, we haven't known him very well for very long. Even just as
00:00:30 recently as like three months ago, his name recognition among Canadians was like single
00:00:34 digit percentage. So we have tonight and tomorrow, the two opportunities to get to know the candidates.
00:00:40 So there's a lot of pressure. A lot of people are predicting, especially on the conservative
00:00:45 political right side, that Pierre Polyev will just like mop the floor with Mark Carney and that it's
00:00:51 going to be a bloodbath. I personally am rooting for that. I hope that's what happens. I don't
00:00:55 want to set expectations too high, though, because I know that Mark Carney has been working in
00:01:00 overdrive to practice his French, to make sure that he is hitting the absolute correct tones.
00:01:06 But I think tonight's debate may even prove to be more important than tomorrow night's debate
00:01:12 because it really, for Mark Carney and the Liberals, they must win in Quebec. They must win
00:01:18 big in the suburbs around Montreal in order to win this election. And so in some ways,
00:01:24 even though, you know, I would have much preferred to see a Carney versus Pierre
00:01:28 Polyev one-on-one debate tonight. And it annoys me that, you know, we have the NDP up there,
00:01:35 which will be just grandstanding left-wing issues. Same with the bloc. They have no chance of forming
00:01:39 a government. They're not a national party. And yet they're there. And yet tonight, I think that
00:01:43 is very important because if Jagmeet Singh performs well and is able to capture back many
00:01:49 of those left-wing voters who have shifted to Mark Carney, that could be very good for the
00:01:53 Conservatives. And if the bloc leader, E. Francois Blanchet, performs well, that could also be good
00:01:59 for the Conservatives because if he's able to pick up that support in suburban Montreal,
00:02:03 again, it will help the Conservatives with their road to victory. Now, I also want to point out
00:02:10 something that i think is fantastic and that is that the greens have been removed from the debate
00:02:15 tonight we were reporting this from juno news and this this is like karma like this is just
00:02:20 beautiful cosmic justice folks because this idea that the greens i mean they're pulling
00:02:25 it like three percent nationally it's it's it's it's not really a party at this point it's more
00:02:30 just like a bumper sticker and you know they decided they made a strategic decision to not
00:02:35 run candidates in safe conservative seats so they decided to pull out of the places that they didn't
00:02:39 think they could win against the conservatives. And because of that, they got removed from the
00:02:47 debate, which is great news for Canadians because that's one fewer irrelevant party leader that
00:02:51 Canadians have to listen to, more time on the candidates that could actually win this election.
00:02:58 Now, I reported this earlier. I'm very excited. We have three reporters on the ground at the event
00:03:04 in Montreal, including my co-founder at Juno News here, Kian Bexty. And then True North has been
00:03:10 able to send two reporters. They've all been accepted by the Debates Commission. Remember,
00:03:14 this entire debate is run by the government. Of course, True created a new government department
00:03:20 to manage the debate. It's like, really, we need government for this. The private media
00:03:24 consortium used to do it, and they did just fine. It was just fine before. But True North likes to
00:03:29 involve government in every aspect of our lives. And so it's a government thing. And because of
00:03:35 that, you have to apply in advance. And we've had issues in the past where they tried to deny us and
00:03:39 say, you're not journalists. Actually, in 2019, we sued the government. I don't know if you
00:03:44 remember that. But in 2019, my reporter at the time was Andrew Lawton. We applied to get him
00:03:50 into the debates. He was rejected at the 11th hour. And it was all very mysterious the way they
00:03:55 rejected. The email came from a different government department than the department
00:04:00 that was running the debates. It came through the parliamentary press gallery. There was a whole
00:04:03 bunch of things that just didn't add up. So we decided, hey, we're going to sue and try to get
00:04:07 in. At that time, Ezra Levant at the Rebel heard that we were suing and called me up and said,
00:04:12 hey, we're going to sue too. And so we both sued. They put our case together. And it was a very
00:04:19 exciting day. We were in downtown Toronto at the courts. I actually brought my son with me. He was
00:04:24 a baby at the time because I didn't have a babysitter. I was on maternity leave. And so I
00:04:28 brought him with me. We were at the courts and we ended up getting an emergency injunction and the
00:04:33 judge ordered that True North and the rebel be accepted. So Andrew Lawton jumped on a plane.
00:04:39 Interestingly, Ezra Levant and the rebel sent their journalist, Kian Bextie. Kian Bextie was
00:04:44 their correspondent and their reporter. So they got on airplanes and flew to Ottawa for the debate.
00:04:49 And to me, that was the best moment of the debate because hearing Andrew Lawton get to ask his question about press freedom, hearing Kian Bextie get to ask his question at the time, the scandal was blackface and asking basically, you know, Justin Trudeau, well, he asked if he had called any African leaders to apologize.
00:05:08 And then he followed up with a great question about that West Point Grey Academy yearbook.
00:05:13 And so I'm looking forward to that again.
00:05:16 We have three of our reporters on the ground, like I said.
00:05:19 Now, interestingly, the debate is being held at the CBC building in Montreal.
00:05:24 And Kian Bextie is reporting to me, he's just texting me right now,
00:05:27 saying that the CBC has banned him from doing any live hits.
00:05:31 So he was going to call into this show and he was going to tell us about what was happening.
00:05:34 But because he is in their property, on their property,
00:05:38 they allow the CBC to have a booth and they're allowed to do a live broadcast,
00:05:42 but nobody else is allowed to.
00:05:44 Of course, when you are the government, when you are part of the government,
00:05:47 which the CBC basically is, you know, you have the control, the regime control. And so that is
00:05:51 what happened is happening. Kian saying that the debate is on their property at the Radio Canada
00:05:56 building. They told us to take our equipment, go outside. But of course, if you go outside,
00:06:00 you lose your spot in line. And there's sort of a game theory behind getting a question to the
00:06:05 right leader. And so part of the reason we have three guys there is so that they could properly
00:06:09 queue and make sure that they're in the right position, that they will hopefully get a question
00:06:13 to Mark Garney as well as Pierre Polyev and the other leaders as well. So I'm going to throw to
00:06:19 a clip. We have a clip from Clayton Domaine. So the True North journalists that are there
00:06:23 are Alex Zoltan and Clayton Domaine. Here is Clayton Domaine doing a stand-up from the debate
00:06:29 in Montreal. Thanks, Candice. Yeah, so I'm here with True North at the French debates.
00:06:37 we i was going to join the call inside but i was chased out by staff um it is really cold
00:06:46 wet and damp i don't know if you could tell we didn't have the luxury of having a warm tent
00:06:52 set up to broadcast from as the cbc has um alex zolton will be asking our questions hopefully to
00:07:01 the uh the leaders after the french debate as they come out our plan is just to be on our feet
00:07:07 and try to get into the line as soon as possible
00:07:09 and ask our relevant questions to the relevant candidates.
00:07:14 I even asked where the Q&A line was going to be,
00:07:17 and I was told that we would have to find out, and they couldn't tell us.
00:07:20 So we're really going to be keeping an eye out
00:07:23 and trying to get those questions in.
00:07:26 There was a Palestinian protest as well that showed up,
00:07:31 and they tried to drown out the Polly Eve and Karni supporters.
00:07:35 Notably, not a single NDP supporter came out to welcome the leaders as they as they came in.
00:07:43 I guess you could say maybe some of the pro-Palestinian crowd might have been the NDP supporters, but not a single orange sign for Jagmeet Singh.
00:07:53 Also, not not a Bloc Quebecois sign.
00:07:56 So it was really just the Kearney supporters, Paliyev and Paliyev supporters and the pro-Palestine people.
00:08:04 So, of course, we're going to be watching the debate, and hopefully we get our questions in.
00:08:09 Thank you.
00:08:10 Great.
00:08:10 Thanks so much, Clayton.
00:08:12 We're really looking forward to that.
00:08:13 And, of course, there's a Palestinian protest. 0.98
00:08:14 What would a Canadian election debate be without the Hamasniks out there making fools of themselves? 1.00
00:08:20 Okay, I am joined by a special guest, a guest co-host today, David Knight-Legg, one of my favorite guests on the Candace Malcolm show. 0.83
00:08:28 David, are you there?
00:08:28 Can you hear me?
00:08:29 I'm here.
00:08:30 Yeah, I can hear you.
00:08:31 Okay, great.
00:08:32 So, well, first of all, before we get to our conversation, I just want to say we're on YouTube and we turn on the Super Chat feature.
00:08:39 I've never done it before, but we got we got them rolling in.
00:08:42 Stefano has given us one hundred thirty nine dollars.
00:08:44 Wow. Thank you so much, Stefano.
00:08:47 He writes, Candace, thank you.
00:08:48 Let's go, Pierre.
00:08:49 Yes. OK, so keep those Super Chats coming, folks.
00:08:54 David, what is your prediction?
00:08:55 What are you looking forward to tonight?
00:08:58 Oh, I think this is going to be great.
00:08:59 I think Canada's unique in that we've got the Quebec factor in play.
00:09:04 And that's going to be really interesting because it means that, you know, Pierre has an advantage in the French language skills.
00:09:13 And I think if he plays it right, he's going to be able to emphasize that.
00:09:17 And I hope that he comes up with some fun turns of phrase that it'll take Marc Carney a little while to grok.
00:09:23 I think Mark Carney's been very lucky with the dynamics in in Quebec, the fear factor, the boomer factor, the fact that they get all of their media through state run television. 0.77
00:09:36 And that's had a direct effect on what you're seeing the polling numbers look like.
00:09:40 I think Blanchette's come out looking very much like he's going to attack that.
00:09:44 And I think of the five different things that they're going to debate, that issue around immigration identity, those are going to be the issues where you're going to see a really interesting dynamic.
00:09:55 And Carney has not shown that he's very agile in figuring out what principled perspective he's willing to take and defend.
00:10:03 So the problems he's gotten into the last few weeks, and you're starting to see it in his poll numbers, are that he doesn't take a principled position and defend it.
00:10:10 he borrows a couple of conservative policies and then when push comes to shove or gets challenged
00:10:15 on those in a place like quebec he basically implies that he's not going to actually follow
00:10:19 through on pipelines things like that so i think it's going to be an interesting debate because
00:10:22 quebec itself is going to highlight some things where it's going to be very hard for mark carney
00:10:27 to you know be able to talk out of both sides of his mouth i think pierre uh you know needs to
00:10:34 figure out a way to smile, relate to his family, something that I think has helped him in the polls.
00:10:41 He's got two big demographics that he's challenged by. One is with women and the other is with
00:10:47 seniors over the age of 60. Interesting. Yeah. So we have, we're keeping an eye on the debate
00:10:54 in the corner of the screen there. Oh, it just disappeared, but we will keep an eye. The debate
00:10:58 is supposed to start at 6 p.m. This is kind of amusing that it was supposed to start at 7. That's
00:11:03 what they originally announced. And then it turns out that there's a Habs game on right now. And so
00:11:07 there was some outrage and they were up at arms at the block that how could we possibly compete
00:11:12 with a hockey game? Come on guys, it's Canada. So they've moved the debate an hour forward,
00:11:17 which I appreciate because I'm like, I'm a morning person. My kids wake me up at the crack of dawn
00:11:22 every day. And so like, usually by like eight o'clock, I'm like, my screens are off and I'm
00:11:27 like getting ready for bed. So I'm much happier doing a 6 p.m. show than one starting at like
00:11:34 eight and then going all the way to midnight. But anyway, I want to pick up on that immigration 0.99
00:11:38 question that you asked, because it is a different issue in Quebec than the rest of Canada. It seems
00:11:42 like they're much more willing to be critical of immigration and not just from an economic
00:11:46 perspective. Pierre kind of plays it safe. Pierre Polyev and the conservatives play it safe. And
00:11:50 they only focus on the economic side of things and the impact on housing and that kind of thing.
00:11:53 Whereas in Quebec, you see more willingness to talk about Canadian values, Quebec values, and saying that, you know, newcomers must adhere to those.
00:12:02 We did a poll here at Juno this week and our Juno News poll just came out. One of the questions we asked, which we hadn't asked before, was support when it comes to immigration. So we described the three parties policies without matching it to a policy so that the person taking the poll wouldn't identify necessarily with the position of the party they prefer.
00:12:24 And so when it came to Mark Carney's position on immigration, which we presume is the century
00:12:29 initiative, let's get to 100 million Canadians by the end of the century, which would mean about
00:12:35 a million newcomers year after year, only 5% of Canadians wanted that view. Whereas Pierre
00:12:40 Polyev's position, which is let's return back to Stephen Harper levels, a pledge that he made
00:12:44 in his exclusive interview with Juno News, where he said that's the levels that he would
00:12:49 bring it back down to, which was about 250,000 a year compared to the current levels, which are
00:12:56 upwards of 400,000. So 57% of Canadians, you see that on the screen, support Pierre Polyev's
00:13:02 immigration plan without knowing that it was Pierre Polyev's. So on the immigration issue,
00:13:06 conservatives, I think, need to really play hard on this issue. It is a tricky one because you don't
00:13:12 want to be perceived as being like mean-spirited or xenophobic or whatever. However, I think if
00:13:17 anything in Quebec, there is more of an appetite to hear the other side of the issue on immigration,
00:13:22 which is that, you know, let's question whether or not it's actually working for a country and
00:13:26 whether this is a path that we want to continue on. And, you know, I think that tonight is perhaps
00:13:32 an opportunity. What do you think? Do you think it'll come up? Do you think it will play a role
00:13:35 at all in this debate? I think it has to. I think that if you look at several of these issues tie
00:13:42 to immigration you know obviously the question about identity uh but the issue of housing ties
00:13:47 to immigration the issue of cost of living ties to immigration the issue of of employment ties
00:13:53 to immigration and in some cases unfairly people attribute you know the current economic malays
00:14:00 which has so much to do with liberal policies and not as much to do with immigration but it because
00:14:06 the liberals have failed so badly on controlling immigration and allowed they've allowed asylum 0.99
00:14:12 fraud they've allowed immigration fraud to run rampant and that you know the interesting thing
00:14:18 i remember when this came up in the american um polling and one of the most fascinating poll
00:14:25 numbers was that immigrant communities that had come in legally were the most opposed to illegal
00:14:31 immigration and the most frustrated by the mistakes being made policy-wise on immigration.
00:14:37 And I think you find the same thing here. If you talk to one of my good friends who's a very strong
00:14:43 conservative supporter who's Sikh about what's happened within the Sikh community, within some
00:14:49 of the fraudulent schools that are used, gangland issues, his point to me has been it's the Sikh 1.00
00:14:57 community that's the most offended by the fact that these criminals aren't put away, that they
00:15:02 openly defraud the immigration system, the asylum system, the welfare system to support criminal
00:15:07 syndicate behavior, and sometimes even Calistani terror networks, etc. And that is well known in
00:15:12 the community, and they hate it. And they wish that there was a direct response to it and decent
00:15:17 law enforcement and laws that were honored. And I think that Pierre actually has a very strong hand
00:15:22 play on this because canada was the example of a modern pluralistic western society that was able
00:15:29 to use immigration to buttress and build our economic momentum without allowing it to turn into
00:15:36 the uh ghettoization of of groups and in the sort of violent unrest that you saw in parts of france
00:15:43 parts of sweden etc where immigration had just happened on the basis of sort of compassion but
00:15:48 but have been used by criminal syndicates to take advantage of these countries, the liberals have lost control of that badly.
00:15:57 And, you know, when they've been challenged on it, they've made, you know, they've sort of added insult to injury by making across the board changes to education policies,
00:16:06 which, you know, they simply needed to deal with immigration, not to destroy a bunch of kids that had actually come in on scholarships validly and were attending good schools.
00:16:15 So I think there's something in that. The problem with so many of these issues is that they've been reduced.
00:16:21 I'm going to interrupt you, David. Just going to give an update on the bottom of our screen there.
00:16:24 We see the leaders are already taking their place. The debate's not supposed to start for another 10 minutes.
00:16:28 Perhaps this is just sort of to get us all pumped up and psyched about the debate.
00:16:32 But it looks like the leaders are taking the stage. So don't worry, folks, we're going to monitor it.
00:16:37 We're not going to talk over the debate. We're going to let you watch that in full.
00:16:42 and then david and i uh will be back afterwards and so like i said i think you know the base
00:16:45 can be fun it's going to be good and i really have high hopes for the whole evening and uh
00:16:50 what we're able to find out about mark carney um but i think that the most important part of the
00:16:55 show will be the end when the journalists get to ask questions because they've allowed independent
00:17:00 media in there so we have kian bexty we have clayton domain of true north and alex olton
00:17:04 the three of them and i said earlier they've got like a game theory plan here they are going to
00:17:09 get a question in and we are very excited about that the rebel is also there and there's also
00:17:14 other independent journalists so i i have high hopes about that and um and then we're gonna
00:17:19 then we're gonna join you at the end and we're gonna do a post debate uh you analysis and and
00:17:26 tell you what we thought were the highlights of the debate and hopefully at that point we'll be
00:17:29 able to get a call in from kian bextier one of the other reporters uh to ask them about how it
00:17:34 it went from the inside so just to give you a little preview of that folks and so David I haven't
00:17:41 had you on my show so far during this election cycle just wondering quickly if you could tell
00:17:45 me like what do you think the main theme of this campaign has been I'll tell you I think it has
00:17:50 been the Chinese election interference even though that hasn't dominated the headlines I think it's
00:17:54 really shaken Mark Carney and he's not quite had the ability to answer those questions and it's
00:18:00 of undermining his campaign is chipping away at his credibility um and and the fact that he's not
00:18:07 very likable he's not very natural he doesn't seem to like canadians very much um that's all
00:18:11 kind of coming up um but i i wonder what you think are the main themes of the campaign and then if
00:18:17 you have any kind of predictions for the debate tonight yeah look that's that's a uh big question
00:18:25 Maybe I'll start with the issue. I think that what defined the first half of this campaign
00:18:34 and what defined the shift at the Liberal Party, the change of leadership at the top,
00:18:39 was Donald Trump. And Trump's team has had three kind of overlapping mandates. One is to deal with
00:18:48 the debt crisis in the United States, which is what's driven Doge. It's what's driven the
00:18:53 repricing nine and a half trillion dollars of debt this year that's behind a lot of the things that
00:18:58 are going on in terms of what they're doing with tariffs the other one is trade and the third one
00:19:02 is security china is involved in all three of those themes and china is the critical thing
00:19:10 the united states has to deal with on all three of those trade manufacturing nearshoring of critical
00:19:15 minerals dual use technologies ip theft what's happening in terms of strategic realignment on
00:19:21 security etc canada is actually caught between the china and united states dynamics right now
00:19:30 in a very fundamental way and in ways that we are not acknowledging openly or dealing with openly
00:19:35 and one of those is fentanyl the americans are well aware that our port of vancouver
00:19:40 is completely penetrated by the chinese triads three big triads they just had a huge super lab 0.99
00:19:45 bust another one up in bc we've got this dogma in canada that somehow this is all just a ruse and
00:19:53 that we don't really have a drug problem yet we've lost 50 000 kids to drug deaths in the last 10
00:19:59 years since the liberals took over 50 000 kids canadian kids have died from opioid abuse 93
00:20:07 of that has been fentanyl and yet we've we're acting uh hurt by the fact that we're being told
00:20:13 that we have a fentanyl problem because we've only captured 45 kilograms or whatever this
00:20:17 completely bizarre myopic number is the reason that we've only captured that is because we don't
00:20:22 have the right law enforcement and we don't have the screening at our ports etc and sam cooper's
00:20:27 done a phenomenal job of spelling out just how bad this has gotten the other issue that we have
00:20:32 in addition to fentanyl is we have a huge laundering operation the iranians are very 0.98
00:20:37 involved with it the chinese are very involved with it we've had absolutely no effectiveness
00:20:42 on this. We've lost track of what's estimated to be 600 IRGC agents inside Canada since we named
00:20:48 them a designated terror group in June of last year. The degree to which Canada has lost control
00:20:53 of its own security is almost impossible to describe unless you go through a list of things.
00:20:58 You're seeing it kind of come out now with these RCMP letters over the foreign influence of these
00:21:04 nine members that Carney has now re-enlisted in his current cabinet. But this party has a big
00:21:10 problem with China because they got too close and the Chinese play for keeps, right? The Chinese 1.00
00:21:16 are definitely operating secret police stations. They're definitely putting bounties on dissidents.
00:21:22 They're definitely controlling the media. They're definitely working hard to have somebody that's
00:21:26 pliant and weak and brittle like Mark Carney that they can manipulate. And I think what's happened
00:21:31 is Mark Carney finds himself in a very tough place. He's been to China multiple times. I want
00:21:36 to go on the record by saying, I think we need to engage China. I think Chinese people are
00:21:40 phenomenal. They're great at business. They've got a terrific economy. They've worked super hard.
00:21:45 They've got, they're beating our, they're beating us on science, math, you know, engineering, tech,
00:21:51 right? The Chinese people are not the Chinese Communist Party. The Chinese Communist Party
00:21:55 is a very small percentage of elites that have managed to take over and try and run the society.
00:22:00 They're actually very brittle. They don't control a lot of what goes on. That economy proceeds on
00:22:06 pretty capitalist terms in most parts of the country and it's to our benefit and to the
00:22:11 world's benefit that we have free and open trade and i believe that what the trump team is after
00:22:16 is using the current trade war leverage to try and get to freer trade that's certainly what
00:22:21 they're trying to do with canada they've made that point multiple times but i think to your point
00:22:26 the thing that has defined this election has been the trump dynamic and the trump dynamic has played
00:22:31 its way through because what they're really after is china but they're dealing with they dealt first 0.95
00:22:37 with their two closest largest trading partners mexico and canada for a reason and then they
00:22:42 declared an overall trade uh tariff war on all fronts for a reason which is because they knew
00:22:48 china was repurposing multiple different ports of entry to access the us and i think that carney's
00:22:55 ability to sort of run this bizarre elbows up theme much longer i think that's getting old i
00:23:01 I think people are starting to mock it now.
00:23:03 I think he's sort of, he's running very close to the tape here.
00:23:06 I think if this election was another four weeks, I'd actually predict we would be back
00:23:11 in landslide territory.
00:23:12 Well, it should be, right?
00:23:13 If Mark Carney was an honorable person, if he was doing the right thing, he wouldn't
00:23:18 be trying to game the system to just maximize the odds of him winning.
00:23:21 Like, that's not the way that our democracy, that's not the spirit of our democracy, right?
00:23:25 So, like, he's a new, unknown, he's a caretaker prime minister at this point.
00:23:30 He doesn't even have a seat in Parliament.
00:23:32 And so, you know, if he was just a person who was guided by his moral compass, he would say, OK, I'm going to I'm going to call for the longest election possible so that Canadians can really get to know me.
00:23:42 I'm going to do as many debates as possible so that we can really discuss the ideas of our country.
00:23:48 Right. That that that's the spirit of democracy.
00:23:50 But Mark Carney doesn't have those values. His values very much are globalist, elitist.
00:23:55 You know, they try to pretend that being part of the World Economic Forum is no big deal.
00:24:00 It's not just that Mark Carney was part of the World Economic Forum.
00:24:03 He kind of is the World Economic Forum.
00:24:05 He embodies it.
00:24:06 He was the sort of person pushing hardest for net zero policies.
00:24:11 I think his mindset is very much elitist.
00:24:12 Like, I know what's best.
00:24:14 I'm the responsible person.
00:24:15 I will run things.
00:24:16 I don't want to take any questions.
00:24:18 And that's just sort of like how he sees the world.
00:24:20 And that's why he put the shortest election possible and did the fewest amount of debates possible.
00:24:27 And he put a lid on it, right?
00:24:28 Like he canceled his campaign.
00:24:29 Anytime Trump is in the news, he'll use it as an excuse.
00:24:32 So he's paused his campaign three times now to deal with Trump because that's all that they want Canadians thinking about and talking about because the more people are thinking to talk about Trump, the better he resonates.
00:24:42 Just for the audience, we are keeping an eye on the screen.
00:24:45 I know it was a little confusing.
00:24:46 Leaders came out.
00:24:47 They started jotting down notes.
00:24:48 It seemed like it was eminent. They were getting mic'd up. But then on Francais, they said that
00:24:53 there was a six minute countdown. It's down to two. So I promise as soon as this debate starts,
00:24:58 we will throw to it. We're not going to talk over it. I have my producer here telling me
00:25:02 that they gave a two minute warning. So I promise we will go back to that. But I guess just a final
00:25:10 question here before we go to the debate, David, what do you think of the polls? Because, you know,
00:25:15 you said that we would be back in landslide territory. So I'm guessing that, you know,
00:25:18 you've been following along that Pierre Polyev was up at 45, that he dipped his low as like 30,
00:25:23 and now it looks like he's edging up. Our Juno News poll today had him at 37 with the liberals
00:25:28 and Carney at 39. So neck and neck. And, you know, I think it's close. I don't fully support,
00:25:34 I don't fully trust the polls. I think they're probably off by two or three points. Obviously,
00:25:38 they're capturing some kind of mood. Like, I don't think it's going to be a conservative
00:25:41 landslide. But I do think that they're off. What do you think? Yeah, look, polls, I did a lot of
00:25:48 polling, did my PhD and, you know, involved with very heavily with polling. Polls model the
00:25:54 selection of the different demographic cohorts based on what happened last time, in part. And
00:26:00 I don't know that that's going to be as good a guide to this group. I think people are very
00:26:04 motivated. And I think they're probably oversampling the over 60s by a few points,
00:26:09 and that that would would give Kearney a few points. The Main Street poll most recently just
00:26:14 had Pierre Ahead by a point, which was interesting. So I think, I think, you know, we have a dead
00:26:20 heat. I don't know about the efficiency. The Conservatives always beat the Liberals by,
00:26:25 you know, in numbers, but we haven't beat them in the efficiency of the seed distribution.
00:26:29 And so I think we need to really have a breakthrough. And one of the big breakthroughs
00:26:33 will be what happens tonight if Quebec starts to, you know, lose their love of Mark Kearney.
00:26:39 Um, and the fact that his French is bad could contribute to that.
00:26:43 We could see a bit more of a vote split in Quebec.
00:26:45 And if we see that, we can see some momentum in the conservative.
00:26:48 Okay.
00:26:48 Sorry to interrupt you here, David, but it looks like they are live here.
00:26:52 So we'll go to the bait and stick with us folks.
00:26:54 Cause we're going to have our analysis at the end.
00:26:56 So enjoy.
00:26:57 And, uh, we'll be back again.
00:26:58 Thanks for, thanks for joining us.
00:27:00 And thank you to the super chats, uh, farm girl also gave us $25.
00:27:03 Really appreciate it.
00:27:04 Okay.
00:27:04 We'll go to the other feed and then we will be back.
00:27:09 The U.S. threat is huge, but there are other issues at stake.
00:27:19 We choose Quebec.
00:27:22 Donald Trump has attacked our country.
00:27:24 We have to defend our workers.
00:27:30 Live from Maison Radio Canada in Montreal, this is the Leaders' Debate 2025 with Patrice
00:27:37 Roy.
00:27:38 Good evening, ladies and gentlemen. Welcome to the French Leaders' Debate.
00:27:43 We are joined by Marte Carney, leader of the Liberal Party, Pierre Poiliev, leader of the Conservative Party,
00:27:51 Yves-François Blanchet, leader of the Bloc Québécois, and Jacques Meitzing, leader of the New Democratic Party.
00:27:57 Good evening to all four of you.
00:27:59 Good evening.
00:27:59 Thank you for being here.
00:28:01 Ladies and gentlemen, it's what, 6 p.m. and a few seconds?
00:28:05 this important event has been moved forward to give as many people as possible the opportunity
00:28:13 to tune in without missing a decisive moment for another one of our passions hockey and by the way
00:28:21 i'll go off script here for a few seconds and say that the montreal canadians you'd better win
00:28:29 i also would like to say that the leaders invitations were managed by the leaders
00:28:34 Debates Commission and the podium places on the set were designated at random. But the questions,
00:28:40 subjects and editorial choices are ours. I'll be managing speaking time fairly within a fair limit.
00:28:51 There are five themes tonight. Obviously the trade war with the United States, the cost of living,
00:28:58 energy and climate immigration and foreign affairs and finally identity and sovereignty
00:29:07 and i'll also have a few rapid fire questions at the end of the debate this debate is your debate
00:29:12 this evening you will be free to speak as much as possible the only rule that i ask of you
00:29:18 is not to speak at the same time if you start talking over one another i'll ask pascal our
00:29:25 sound engineer to turn off your mics so let the debate begin or i was going to say good game
00:29:31 so we'll move on to our first opening question you'll have 45 seconds each to answer this
00:29:37 election to many according to many has been hijacked by trump so to assert our sovereignty
00:29:46 early in this debate i'll ask you to name two things you'd put forward concrete things that
00:29:52 that will change the lives of Canadians,
00:29:55 but that have nothing to do with the United States.
00:29:57 45 seconds, Mr. Carney, you're first.
00:30:00 Well, first of all, thank you very much, Mr. Roy.
00:30:02 And I'd like to thank everyone watching at home
00:30:06 for joining us tonight.
00:30:07 And I'd like to thank the other leaders
00:30:09 for your service to Canada.
00:30:10 Two things that don't include Mr. Trump.
00:30:15 First of all, we need to double the rhythm
00:30:19 of construction of new homes here in Canada.
00:30:22 That's absolutely fundamental.
00:30:24 And the second thing, we need to promote and strengthen our cultural institutions in Canada.
00:30:33 45 seconds, Mr. Poiliev.
00:30:37 Two things that you would promise Canadians to change their lives that have nothing to do with the United States.
00:30:43 Thank you, Mr. Roy, and thanks to my colleagues for being here today.
00:30:48 Clearly, life is no longer affordable.
00:30:51 The promise of an affordable life is broken.
00:30:55 I have a plan to make life more affordable by cutting taxes by 15%.
00:31:01 That's one thing that will reward work for the middle class 0.99
00:31:05 and for seniors who've already worked.
00:31:08 Second thing, we're going to scrap the GST on new houses
00:31:13 and we're going to incentivize cities to reduce their taxes too
00:31:18 so that our young people can save up to a hundred thousand dollars on a new home and restore the
00:31:25 promise of Canada. I would like to come back to something that I do all year long. First of all,
00:31:33 thank you for having welcomed us. I have been waiting for this moment for a long time.
00:31:40 I'd like to insist on two things for Quebec that I was talking about before the Trump crisis is
00:31:46 Quebec's right to have a different and open economy open to the world based on its own
00:31:52 natural resources on its own attachment to a green economy but also Quebec's right to be different
00:31:58 to have a different language to have a different culture to have different values to have different
00:32:03 immigration models that need to succeed these are elements that should always have been mentioned
00:32:09 but that have a particularly new sense with this new crisis great Mr Singh 45 seconds two things
00:32:15 that have nothing to do with the American?
00:32:19 Thank you for the question. Good evening, everybody.
00:32:21 First, I'd like to talk a little bit about values.
00:32:28 What are the values that underpin the answer to this question?
00:32:32 Canadians and Quebecers like taking care of one another.
00:32:36 We come together. That is what we believe in. That is a basic value for us.
00:32:41 And this value is embodied in our public health care system, which has nothing to do with the US.
00:32:49 We want our health care system to be nothing like the American one. 0.99
00:32:53 We will expand pharmacare so that everyone can access the medications they need.
00:32:59 And I also want to talk about dental care. I also want to expand that program, which owes itself to us.
00:33:04 Thank you. I'd like to reassure you, Mr. Singh. I think you were disappointed.
00:33:08 We are going to talk about health as well, and I'll ask questions about that later.
00:33:14 First theme, therefore, obviously, the trade war.
00:33:23 Trump is going to be tough.
00:33:24 We don't know what's in store with him.
00:33:27 I don't think any solution is going to be possible.
00:33:30 We always thought they were our ally.
00:33:32 It doesn't make sense.
00:33:34 You can't reason with him.
00:33:35 The government will have to stand firm, stay firm.
00:33:38 We have to put him in his place. Otherwise, he'll destroy us totally.
00:33:43 The answer should be pragmatic.
00:33:46 It would be good to pause some of our services to the U.S.
00:33:49 They need us. An eye for an eye. No messing around.
00:33:54 Get us out of this mess.
00:33:55 We need a leader who can make decisions to destabilize Trump and make him respect Canada.
00:34:03 What does he plan to do with the new President of the United States?
00:34:08 what do you plan to do with this president that is the elephant in the room so for your information
00:34:17 there are 1060 73 days left in donald trump's term why do you think that you're the best person
00:34:25 here tonight to negotiate with mr trump mr poly of 35 seconds first of all we will never
00:34:34 be an american state we will remain sovereign on my first day as prime minister i will restart
00:34:42 negotiations to accelerate a deal that will put an end to the tariffs and protect our sovereignty
00:34:50 we can't control trump but at the same time we have to control what we can control we need to
00:34:56 reverse liberal economic policies that have weakened our country we need to unleash our
00:35:02 resources cut taxes and bring jobs back home so that we can face trump from a position of strength
00:35:10 all right well first of all in a crisis you have to plan for the worst possible situation and you
00:35:17 have to have a plan a plan to build a strong economy here in canada and we need to react with
00:35:24 strength and those are the elements that will allow us to succeed with mr trump he respects
00:35:31 strength he respects people who understand how the world works and who understand how the private
00:35:37 sector works and canada needs to create other options new reliable partnerships around the
00:35:45 world and that's what i'll thank you mr corney mr blanchet mr trump will hang from his own noose
00:35:55 because their economy is dependent on ours but there will be a lot of harm done to canada to
00:36:02 europe to mexico before then we have to realize that our joint gdp is bigger than the states our
00:36:11 population is bigger than the states and so retaliation is going to hurt the states but
00:36:17 we have to negotiate in a rational way and we shouldn't fall to fear and we shouldn't spin
00:36:23 It's all about priorities. For me, now is the time to invest, not cut. It is the time
00:36:34 to protect what we hold dear, our farmers, our culture, the French language. These things
00:36:40 should not be sacrificed. It is time to defend who we are, what our values are. And we believe
00:36:49 in helping one another. That's what we will do. How? We will strengthen our health care system.
00:36:55 We will not let it be Americanized. That is crucial. We must defend who we are.
00:37:00 So open debate to begin now for about 15 minutes. Mr. Poiliev, you have called Kearney
00:37:08 a political grifter, a globalist banker who's disconnected from reality. And Mr. Kearney,
00:37:15 said Pierre Poiliev is a career politician who knows nothing about how the real world works.
00:37:21 So I ask you the question, which of you first is capable of standing up to Donald Trump?
00:37:29 Mr. Poiliev. I am because I'm going to put Canada first.
00:37:33 I will never compromise Canada's interests and I will control what we can control here.
00:37:42 Obviously, no one will be able to control the decisions of Donald Trump, but we can control our economy, our domestic economy, by overturning liberal economic policies that have weakened our country and made us more dependent on the Americans.
00:38:00 The issue is, Mr. Poiliev, you would make Canada more like the United States.
00:38:06 You would Americanize our healthcare system, privatize it.
00:38:09 Everyone knows that's what conservatives do. 0.93
00:38:13 Mr. Carney, you said that you're better?
00:38:15 All right. First of all, I know how to negotiate, and I agree with Mr. Singh.
00:38:21 We need to start by saying what's never going to be on the table.
00:38:27 The French language, Quebec's culture, and supply management will never be on the table.
00:38:32 Our resources, that's the first thing.
00:38:33 Second, in terms of Mr. Blanchet's point, the opportunities that we have with the European Union are there,
00:38:44 and I've already started building new relationships with the European Union.
00:38:50 As Prime Minister, I met with the President of France and with the President of the European Commission.
00:38:56 There's a lot to unpack in there, let's be honest.
00:39:00 Perhaps it's right.
00:39:01 You say that you're an expert in managing a crisis, but you say you're a negotiator, but perhaps negotiate with tax havens.
00:39:12 But when it comes to trade agreements, I haven't seen the proof.
00:39:15 We apparently have to believe you with no political experience.
00:39:19 And so I find this kind of funny because people say we have to unite and work together.
00:39:23 On the one hand, you have never spoken to me before this evening.
00:39:27 you're not trying to figure out how to collaborate between equals quebec canada mexico european
00:39:35 partners you're trying to score divisive points that only serves the united states of america
00:39:43 all right i've just started as prime minister i've been prime minister for a month
00:39:48 in the first week i signed an agreement with the premiers of all the provinces the premier of quebec
00:39:56 and the premiers of all the provinces and territories concerning free trade within Canada.
00:40:02 It's also an agreement that deals with trade corridors.
00:40:05 That's an example.
00:40:06 That's an example.
00:40:07 You haven't sat with any premiers.
00:40:10 You've sat with MPs that will be elected at the same level as you if you're elected.
00:40:15 The problem, Mr. Carney, is that your party has been in power for 10 years.
00:40:20 And in that time, it's not meetings that are going to change things.
00:40:27 It's your policies that have blocked resources.
00:40:31 C-69, which blocks not just pipelines, but also dams, mines, and liquid national gas exploration.
00:40:41 We have a deal with Europe, a trade deal.
00:40:45 The Conservatives negotiated it.
00:40:46 But liberal legislation has prevented development, and you continue to support those laws.
00:40:53 Those laws need to be repealed and replaced with laws that will unleash our resources
00:40:59 and allow us to export abroad and allow us to become truly economically sovereign and have energy sovereignty as well.
00:41:11 Mr. Carney, unfortunately, your priority is, well, you had time to meet with the king,
00:41:18 but you did not increase the amount of money people receive when they lose their jobs due
00:41:23 to the trade war. These days, people receiving EI get maybe half of their salary.
00:41:32 For people who have already lost their jobs, that is not enough. It won't cover the bills.
00:41:36 it won't cover their rent costs that shows your priorities for me workers are number one we need
00:41:44 a system to support our workers we'll hear some in a few seconds but mr carney response and then
00:41:49 i have another question for blanche first of all we need to fight in a trade war we need to fight 0.68
00:41:56 with counter tariffs and all the money collected from our counter tariffs will go directly to
00:42:01 workers and the businesses that are the most affected by this trade war they won't be used
00:42:08 for tax cuts the way that mr poliev is going to do you always want to increase them you're liberal
00:42:15 we want to cut taxes started as prime minister for a fourth liberal term i've just started you
00:42:22 were justin trudeau's economic advisor have you forgotten that honestly let me cut in here both of
00:42:30 them would cut taxes for billionaires and millionaires. They have already done it in the past.
00:42:41 Your first step was to reduce taxes for the millionaires. Pierre Polyev would do the same
00:42:46 thing. You're not thinking of regular people. We've cut the consumer carbon tax.
00:42:51 Mr. Singh, Mr. Blanchet, you've been telling Canadians for several days that it would be
00:42:57 better to have a minority government you said it clearly
00:43:06 with trump can canadians not want a majority government that's stronger i don't know where
00:43:11 that reasoning comes the minority government would be weaker than a majority government
00:43:18 go tell that to the germans who have only governed through coalitions 1.00
00:43:22 coalitions recently many countries have coalitions and if that is the population of the people
00:43:26 then great. At this point, it's possible that Canadians and Quebecers, perhaps, 0.87
00:43:35 choose to trust in someone who has the least experience in politics.
00:43:41 Quebec has a different economy, different interests, different everything.
00:43:48 We want a parliament where our economic difference is taken into account.
00:43:54 Let's talk a little bit about minority governments.
00:43:58 The whole point of a minority government is to help people, to make a difference in people's 0.97
00:44:03 lives. But honestly, Mr Blanchet, unfortunately, in the last minority government, you showed
00:44:12 that you were as useless as the monarchy is. You did nothing for people. What is worse, 0.92
00:44:19 you voted against measures that would help quebecers dental care pharma care these are
00:44:26 measures that have helped hundreds of thousands of quebecers quebec jurisdiction dental care
00:44:33 health care people in quebec pharma care people money that we send to ottawa
00:44:39 ottawa does not have the expertise or the jurisdiction we are back to us
00:44:44 Mr. Roy, Mr. Roy, please let me finish one sentence.
00:44:48 Please wrap it up.
00:44:49 When we want to be effective, we give the money to the experts,
00:44:54 those who have the legal jurisdiction to spend the money.
00:44:56 And that is Quebec in this case.
00:44:58 The NDP gave $2 billion to an insurance company.
00:45:03 Everything is going fine until now, but Mr. Carney, in terms of the minority government.
00:45:10 Mr. Rouat, we are in a crisis, the most serious crisis of our lives.
00:45:18 We need to react with resounding, overwhelming strength.
00:45:23 Yes, we need to cut a few taxes.
00:45:25 Yes, we need to cut bureaucracy.
00:45:27 But the government needs to act in a time of crisis.
00:45:31 So we need to have a government ready to act.
00:45:34 But when you were Justin Trudeau's economic advisor, you weakened our economy.
00:45:40 we need economic sovereignty and that means bringing back production to canada and i would
00:45:49 reverse liberal policies around development i would uh expedite construction permits
00:45:58 we would have pre-approved permits and that would and i would also make sure that we could send our
00:46:08 energy to Europe to break Europeans' dependence on Putin and to break our dependence on the U.S.
00:46:17 The Conservatives and the Liberals both prioritize the ultra-rich, not you, not regular Canadians.
00:46:22 Great, we do have a segment on that. That's the difference.
00:46:24 We have a segment on energy and pipelines, so we'll come back to that later.
00:46:29 There are people who are watching us who are concerned. There will be negotiations with the
00:46:34 Americans, obviously. Well, you'll all say supply management here, but I'd like to say that Canada
00:46:44 gave up market shares during the last three trade deal negotiations. We're talking about more than
00:46:50 450 million a year in losses for Canadian farmers. So what is something you wouldn't concede in a
00:46:57 negotiation? I will defend supply management. I will defend the French language. I will defend
00:47:03 our health care system i will defend our decisions and our laws we will always be sovereign and the
00:47:11 way we're going to restore that sovereignty canadian sovereignty is by making our economy
00:47:19 stronger we need to cut red tape by 25 for businesses we need to reduce development
00:47:26 charges taxes on housing we need to support labor and energy and domestic production that's how we
00:47:35 can be more sovereign management facing in the face of the u.s it's nice to say supply management
00:47:41 but we've said it three times and it hasn't been done so well this is the first time that
00:47:48 i will be at the table if i am elected as prime minister
00:47:55 i've said a number of times and since the beginning of my campaign in maurice
00:48:00 we'll never touch a supply management we won't put quebec culture or the french
00:48:04 language on the table and i think we all agree on that point and that's important
00:48:08 we have to be very clear from the beginning when talking to the americans one area that we don't
00:48:14 agree on is that Pierre Polyev would cut our health care system. You said it, everyone knows
00:48:23 it. You said that you want to cut, you would cut dental care, pharmacare, you called them bad ideas.
00:48:29 And unfortunately, Mr. Carney's plan to budget the operating budget in three years would lead
00:48:37 to 43 billion dollars in the next segment cost of living we'll talk about tax cuts later and choices
00:48:46 and we will underscore that none of you has a table they costed plan these are just promises
00:48:54 mr blanchet on we have tabled a program first of all second of all we are not the ones who decide
00:49:01 that what's on the table if mr trump says i want to talk about this no one will be able to stop him
00:49:06 from at least talking about it.
00:49:08 We've never sacrificed the principle of supply management.
00:49:12 So it's empty words.
00:49:13 Little bits have been sacrificed every single time
00:49:16 at a cost of hundreds of millions of dollars every single time.
00:49:19 All Mr. Trump wants is a wave of Wisconsin milk
00:49:25 with hormones, with no protection against antibiotics.
00:49:29 So what would you do concretely?
00:49:31 We will bring back an act that everyone approved.
00:49:35 The Liberals before Kanye approved it, everyone had approved it, but then there were certain intrigues with unelected senators.
00:49:41 There's a number of unelected members of parliament that seem to be making decisions.
00:49:47 What would protect better?
00:49:49 Well, maybe I agree with that law, but my point is that we need to invest in Canada.
00:49:57 Our plan, which will be unveiled this weekend, will catalyze $500 billion, $500 billion of investment in Canada over the next five years.
00:50:13 And that will be important in our negotiations with Mr. Trump.
00:50:18 I'd like us to listen to a worker together from Stellantis.
00:50:23 For him, this crisis with the U.S. is very clear.
00:50:27 he's just lost his job i was laid off by stelantis because of the trade war with the u.s
00:50:35 how will your government stop mr trump from attacking our industries one by one and how
00:50:43 will you protect our jobs concrete measures how will you help workers you all have different
00:50:52 proposals. Mr. Poyev. First of all, I already announced a fund to help companies keep jobs,
00:51:02 to keep workers in their jobs, because the priority of workers is to keep working. Secondly,
00:51:09 there will be EI to protect people who are having, who have fallen on rough times. I will be there
00:51:16 for people who've lost their jobs at the same time we need to stimulate investment to strengthen
00:51:24 our economy and to encourage new companies we need to unleash our natural resources
00:51:31 and we need to create more jobs in resource industries we also want to create more jobs
00:51:38 for trades people at a time when they need work to build new houses let's stay on workers mr singh
00:51:46 If a business wants to sell cars in Canada, they should be required to have a factory in Canada, a presence in Canada.
00:51:56 I would put this in a law. We are a major market. If you want to sell here, you should create jobs here.
00:52:04 Let me add, the first thing Mr. Paulyev said in 2022 when he became Conservative leader is that he would cut EI contributions.
00:52:14 So, it is not credible that he would increase support to people when he talked about eliminating contributions.
00:52:23 For workers, you've said you want to go back to a pandemic-style wage subsidy.
00:52:28 The principle of that, we said that even before the campaign.
00:52:33 To paraphrase Mr. Poilier, EI is fairly broken.
00:52:38 People have difficulty accessing it, and I disagree with Mr. Carney's suggestion to say that money will be invested in training.
00:52:44 You've lost your job, but we're going to train you and you're going to have another kick at a can at the age of 55.
00:52:49 Not a good idea.
00:52:49 The idea of the wage subsidy was to allow the worker to have a link to their job by giving them a subsidy so that the employer, should they want to, could rehire them, someone who had the skill to do the job.
00:53:10 So there would be a transitional period where there could be temporary job losses, like for the case we've just heard.
00:53:17 Well, first of all, three things.
00:53:20 All the money from our counter tariffs will go directly to workers.
00:53:24 Second, we have a strategic fund for manufacturing in Canada, specifically for the auto sector.
00:53:33 And third, our counter-tariff system for the automotive sector contains an incentive of $7 billion for the automakers to keep production and workers here in Canada.
00:53:48 That's very important.
00:53:51 But the reason that we've done all of this is so that we can have strong positions to negotiate with Trump.
00:53:59 Just to conclude, I think we need to encourage Canadians to buy Canadian-made cars.
00:54:06 And that's why, as long as there are tariffs, we will scrap the GST on cars and trucks that are built here, mainly built here in Canada. 0.59
00:54:17 That's good.
00:54:19 I think the tariff is a good idea. 0.84
00:54:25 what allows companies to buy and sell more then yes i do agree with that approach 70
00:54:31 mr polly have copied our idea we announced the gst lifting for canadian made cars before him
00:54:37 now there are a lot of things that are in all of your platforms we'll come back to that
00:54:42 now 70 of canadians say that they're buying fewer american products it's a big number
00:54:47 you leaders could you please name me one made in usa product that you no longer buy
00:54:59 i buy my own strawberries so you don't buy strawberries i buy quebec strawberries and
00:55:04 i do my own shopping by the way what products have you not bought mr carney no more wine
00:55:10 no more alcohol no more american alcohol i do my own shopping and i cook at home
00:55:19 lots of products fruits there's a lot of canadian so you're making an effort yes
00:55:25 i'm making an effort with apples other fruit strawberries strawberries everyone is eating a
00:55:33 lot of strawberries these days i bring it up because i do my own grocery shopping which carny
00:55:41 does not this is a delicious conversation it's beef in my case i buy canadian beef
00:55:53 it's the best beef in the world but i never buy american strawberries either
00:55:58 Well, let's share some of that.
00:56:04 All right.
00:56:05 It's very beautiful to see.
00:56:06 Our next theme is the cost of living.
00:56:13 We can manage our money.
00:56:15 We're having a hard time here.
00:56:17 I hope they'll be able to balance the budget
00:56:21 and maintain the same quality of services.
00:56:24 inflation, lower taxes.
00:56:28 I earn a good salary, but it's hard to pay for groceries,
00:56:30 for childcare, for our kid, for everything.
00:56:34 Education is expensive.
00:56:36 Prices keep going up.
00:56:37 The middle class is hurting.
00:56:39 And for the poor, it's worse.
00:56:40 We're retired and we're counting every penny.
00:56:43 We're getting poorer.
00:56:45 I feel like no one really listens to young people 1.00
00:56:47 on housing or the cost of living.
00:56:50 So what does the future hold for us young people?
00:56:54 What does the future hold for young people?
00:56:58 I'll give you a few figures here, very briefly.
00:57:02 I'm sure this won't come as a surprise, but in Montreal,
00:57:05 housing prices have more than doubled over 10 years,
00:57:08 from $300,000 to $671,000.
00:57:11 Remarkable growth in Toronto and Vancouver as well.
00:57:14 So my question, and you'll have 35 seconds, first of all,
00:57:17 how can we improve access to housing, for example,
00:57:21 for this young woman that we just heard from, Mr. Blanchet.
00:57:25 Clearly, it's through the starting capital
00:57:28 and then other GST-based policy.
00:57:33 There needs to be access to capital for a down payment.
00:57:36 My children can't pay for a house. 1.00
00:57:39 A lot of them have jobs, good jobs.
00:57:42 It's essential that we give them a little boost using
00:57:46 public money, for example.
00:57:49 And it's not during a crisis and in cutting budgets that we will be able to do so.
00:57:55 We need to reduce speculation on house prices.
00:57:59 We need to invest in affordable housing, social housing, student housing
00:58:02 to give a good price and reduce pressure in the residencies of Canada.
00:58:12 I'm with you with all those who are having a hard time affording their groceries.
00:58:19 young people who can't buy a house. After a decade of liberal inflation,
00:58:25 liberal policies have increased the cost of living the most in 40 years.
00:58:32 I will cut your taxes for the average worker by 15 percent. We will scrap the GST on new homes
00:58:40 and we will incentivize municipalities to speed up permits and construction so that young people
00:58:46 can once again buy a home and restore the dream of home ownership in order to fix this crisis in
00:58:54 the cost of living we need to make sure that canadians have more money in their pockets
00:58:59 and they need to have more canada in their pockets so that means a tax cut for the middle class
00:59:05 and our plan is almost $800 per family, cut the GST on first homes and increase competition.
00:59:18 And in Canada, we have dental care, pharma care, and daycares.
00:59:24 We need to protect that, and we need to double new housing construction in Canada with our plan.
00:59:30 Very good. Thank you, Mr. Singh.
00:59:34 Thank you.
00:59:36 When I talk to people and the cost of living comes up, there are two main topics. First,
00:59:42 grocery costs. Second, housing costs for groceries. Major grocery giants are gouging us. We saw this
00:59:51 with the price of bread, the price of meat. They drive prices up and they are gouging the Canadian
00:59:58 public. We would put price caps on essential groceries. We would also stop corporate landlords
01:00:04 from buying up affordable housing and apartments.
01:00:08 We are in it for you.
01:00:10 Thank you very much, Mr. Singh.
01:00:16 245,000 housing units were built in 2024.
01:00:20 You've all promised to massively accelerate the pace of that construction.
01:00:25 The Liberals have said 500,000, the NDP 600,000.
01:00:29 Mr. Singh, you're going to start this part of the open debate.
01:00:32 How does this grow on trees?
01:00:35 we have a clear plan for how to make this happen first we would not sell off our federal land we
01:00:40 would keep it and we would build affordable housing on it 100 affordable we would train
01:00:46 canadian workers to build more homes we also must keep the affordable housing that we do have and
01:00:52 unfortunately the two major parties have let rich speculators buy up affordable housing and now we
01:01:00 have no more that's a major issue we need to keep our affordable housing and build more housing
01:01:06 in general a couple of ideas first of all i would like to talk for quebec
01:01:14 there are delays of hundreds of thousands of houses to be built and we don't have the human
01:01:19 resources to do so but there are initiatives for small housing for social housing modular housing
01:01:24 that would allow us to build quicker with fewer resources and cheaper to accommodate as many
01:01:33 people as possible. But I'm looking forward to hearing everyone's financial framework because
01:01:37 the Conservatives want to cut, cut, cut. They're going to have to cut spending at some point as
01:01:42 well. The Liberals want to cut in revenue but increase expenditure. There's some financial
01:01:48 magic that's in there somewhere. I would like to hear their financial framework or even their
01:01:54 electoral platforms that would be nice but mr carney 500 000 housing units and we need to get
01:02:02 started so that we can get the housing market working better with a reduction uh in
01:02:13 bureaucracy at the municipal level and in fees but we are proposing a new institution build
01:02:21 canada homes which is going to build affordable homes using lumber from quebec using lumber from
01:02:31 british colombia using canadian wood and using new canadian technologies we are going to create
01:02:37 a new industry how can you say 500 000 units i mean i could say 800 000 400 000 where is this
01:02:44 coming from you know you know if i can have 35 seconds we need to add funding of 25 billion
01:02:53 dollars for the development of affordable homes and 10 billion dollars for mr polyev you haven't
01:03:01 costed your objective yes we will in our platform which is going to come out in a few days but mr
01:03:08 Mr. Kearney, you're repeating exactly the same promises that Justin Trudeau has been
01:03:14 making for 10 years during the liberal decade when you were the economic advisor, the cost
01:03:21 of housing has gone up and you inflated the cost of housing then too.
01:03:28 You have a terrible record in England for real estate costs there, real estate prices.
01:03:34 The problem is that the liberals want to build bureaucracy.
01:03:38 They want to balloon bureaucracy by creating new departments, new bureaucrats.
01:03:44 We don't need more bureaucrats. 1.00
01:03:46 We need more homes, more new doors on new homes for young families.
01:03:51 The reason why housing has become so expensive today is because of taxes and bureaucracy.
01:03:58 I will eliminate the GST on new homes.
01:04:01 I will incentivize cities to free up land and accelerate permits so that we can build
01:04:08 build and build your home.
01:04:10 Interesting then, Mr. Carney.
01:04:11 Let us talk records. Mr. Polyev, you were a housing minister.
01:04:15 Yes, absolutely.
01:04:16 How many homes did you build?
01:04:19 Over 200,000.
01:04:20 I'll tell you, six. You built six homes.
01:04:22 200,000.
01:04:23 Six.
01:04:24 200,000.
01:04:25 We cannot believe what you're saying.
01:04:26 You asked a question, can I answer it?
01:04:27 We cannot believe, Mr. Polyev.
01:04:29 He only built six homes when he was in power.
01:04:35 Can I answer?
01:04:36 We know the answer.
01:04:36 Can I answer? It was $200,000 that year and the cost of the average home was $450,000.
01:04:46 So thanks very much for reminding everyone of my record. It was a good record.
01:04:50 During the 10 years the Conservatives were in power, rent doubled, housing costs doubled.
01:04:58 And then when the Liberals came in, they doubled again.
01:05:01 Unfortunately, Mr. Carney benefited from the housing crisis when he was the board chair at Brookfield Investments.
01:05:10 His company benefited from the housing crisis by buying up affordable buildings and tripling rents.
01:05:19 Okay, Mr. Poiliev's approach is everyone for themselves.
01:05:25 In the COVID crisis, he said, okay, let's cut taxes, let's cut bureaucracy.
01:05:29 this crisis now that we're facing the greatest crisis of our lives he's saying cut taxes cut
01:05:36 bureaucracy in a crisis you have to do that to a certain point but you have to act as a government
01:05:43 and if i may you need to have capital to catalyze investment and with a small amount of catalyzing
01:05:52 investment from the government of canada we can create huge private investment and a new
01:05:59 canadian industry another proposal that i find interesting is to allow parents who have money
01:06:08 in savings for their retirement to take the money temporarily to help for their kids down payment
01:06:18 that's not 500 billion dollars that will be required these are not civil servants that
01:06:24 will be fired this is a logical decision made by parents like myself who want to help their kids
01:06:30 without money from the state with a tax measure that helps retirees who want to help their
01:06:36 children would that not be more concrete than programs after programs that are just empty words
01:06:43 and for which there's no financial framework yeah i'll come back to that in a minute but let's let
01:06:47 Mr. Kearney, in 2020 and 2021, you said that inflation wouldn't happen and that it would have been a good thing if it did.
01:07:02 You were quoted in the media and you even advised Justin Trudeau to print money and that's what
01:07:08 caused our inflationary crisis. You're just like Justin Trudeau. You have exactly the same policies,
01:07:15 the same approach we need change and you mr kearney you do not embody change you represent
01:07:21 the ultra rich mr polievre is not justin trudeau i'm not justin trudeau either okay in this
01:07:28 election the question is who is going to succeed who is going to face mr trump
01:07:37 same parties same ministers same caucus same ideology same hostility against quebec
01:07:43 it's not just because the leader changes that the philosophy will magically change overnight.
01:07:50 You are all proposing or just about all of you are proposing tax cuts.
01:07:56 We'll see them up on the screen here. Mr Carney announced that on the first day of the campaign.
01:08:01 Mr probably has been announcing them for a long time. So for a couple earning $90,000 a year,
01:08:06 You can see the numbers up here, $1,299 in savings for the Conservatives, $1,011 for the NDP, $577 for the Liberals.
01:08:15 And the cost of those measures is really what I want to underline here.
01:08:18 Mr. Poliev, you're spending more on tax cuts than the NDP or Liberals.
01:08:26 Now, you've all arrived here this evening with no costed financial plan.
01:08:32 It's been a long time since we've seen that at the time of the leaders' debate, the leaders don't have a costed plan.
01:08:38 So we don't know how you're going to pay for these tax cuts.
01:08:43 Now, I'm going to be careful how I word this, but don't you think it's irresponsible to Canadian voters to do this?
01:08:50 Mr. Carney, you said you've got the numbers, but where's your costed plan?
01:08:54 As I've just said, we'll be presenting our costed platform this weekend.
01:09:00 But why not earlier at an event?
01:09:02 There are 10 days left in the election campaign.
01:09:06 It's about the same thing as Mr. Poilievre, as I've seen.
01:09:10 And it is going to be costed, and the operational budget will be cleaned up.
01:09:19 We'll balance it in three years, but at the same time, we will be investing in Canada and in Canadians.
01:09:24 Mr. Poilievre, where would you make the cuts?
01:09:28 This comes back to my earlier question to Mr. Carney, in terms of the cost of plants.
01:09:32 What do you have to hide?
01:09:34 Will transfers to provinces go down, for example?
01:09:36 We're going to cut consultants.
01:09:38 Believe it or not, a Canadian family is spending $1,400 in federal tax just to pay for consultants.
01:09:48 That's been a 100% increase.
01:09:50 I'm going to cut consultants.
01:09:52 Secondly, we're going to cut the cost of bureaucracy through attrition.
01:10:01 People will be retiring and we don't need to replace all of them.
01:10:06 We can slowly, gradually reduce the cost of the bureaucracy.
01:10:11 Third, we're going to pass a dollar-for-dollar bill.
01:10:15 For every new dollar in spending, there will have to be a dollar in reduced spending.
01:10:23 And we are going to generate $70 billion more in revenues.
01:10:31 But again, you and Mr. Carney don't have a costed plan that we've seen.
01:10:38 We are the only party that has talked about ways to increase government revenues.
01:10:43 We've talked about closing tax loopholes, getting rid of tax havens, empowering the CRA to go after
01:10:53 corporations that are not paying their taxes. These are not tax increases. These are taxes that
01:10:59 are already supposed to be paid. The CRA has said that tens of billions of dollars in revenues are
01:11:05 being lost pier poliev has been very honest with canadians he will cut he will cut health care
01:11:12 no he will not true that's false he said this back in 2022 when he became leader of the conservative
01:11:20 party and mark carney has also said very clearly that he would make massive no no no he would cut
01:11:28 43 billion dollars worth for the first time no that's not right at all i've said there is
01:11:38 an operational budget that's over 200 billion dollars a year and that budget has grown nine
01:11:47 percent year over year over the last 10 years we need to slow down that growth and we'll do that
01:11:56 with technology we'll do that with attrition as mr poiliev has suggested and we can do that and
01:12:03 we will do that and it's necessary but we're not going to cut transfers to individuals nor
01:12:11 transfers to the provinces so the provinces will not get less money mr blanchet is that what you
01:12:15 believe well i have an issue with this these are harry potter financial frameworks you need a lot
01:12:22 of magic to make it work there needs to be more money but we're going to do cuts they want to be
01:12:26 be more conservative than the conservatives basic economic state that when there's a threat of
01:12:32 recession or slowdown that is when the state well that's what why we're not saying cut taxes we're
01:12:37 saying make good investments we want to invest in our military forces it's the time to do so with
01:12:43 canadian companies the quebec tramway that mr probably doesn't want to do that's what we have
01:12:48 to do we have to have targeted investments health transfers so that the miserable hospital can be 0.66
01:12:53 renovated it's time to invest in infrastructure public infrastructure with public money so that
01:12:59 everyone can keep their jobs so no tax cuts no it wouldn't be a tax cut there would be a specific
01:13:05 budget for it it's necessary we have to keep going they want to do one thing and the other
01:13:10 cut but somehow make more money that something doesn't work we've started with the cost of
01:13:16 living we have to cut taxes for the cost of living what mr blanche has said is true you
01:13:19 You were talking about a magic spell here, Mr. Carney.
01:13:26 This is one rare moment where we agree.
01:13:29 On February 16th, you sat down with Rosemary Barton
01:13:32 and you said that you would cut spending in the operational budget.
01:13:37 Yes, operational spending.
01:13:39 That's different.
01:13:40 You said, one at a time, please,
01:13:42 that this would affect transfers from healthcare and to individuals.
01:13:47 No, Mr. Carney.
01:13:48 I have a question.
01:13:49 That's not right at all.
01:13:50 That's not right at all.
01:13:51 Mr. Carney, you'll have the opportunity to answer later.
01:13:54 The question that people are asking themselves, and you may have heard this, Mr. Singh,
01:13:59 you know, you've promised that every Canadian will have a family doctor,
01:14:04 that there will be vastly more nurses.
01:14:08 Does the federal government need to continue developing more national plans
01:14:13 like pharma care and dental care?
01:14:15 or option two, should they be giving more money to the provinces for health care?
01:14:20 Mr. Carney, you'll start off.
01:14:23 More programs or more money?
01:14:25 First of all, the priority for the federal government is to invest and to catalyze investment
01:14:32 in the most serious crisis we're facing in our lives.
01:14:36 We need to catalyze private investment in our economy to create new and good jobs.
01:14:41 that's the first thing we need to do in terms of transfers to provinces for health care. Yes,
01:14:47 there are limits to the federal government's activity. No new programs. No.
01:14:54 Mr. Blanchet? It's easy. All premiers from the provinces and territories unanimously
01:15:01 asked for a 35% health transfer. I would like to re-explain it. The federal government receives
01:15:11 more money than it needs it needs ten dollars it gets 12. quebec needs ten dollars but it only gets
01:15:17 eight so the federal government could take its surplus and say i would like to invest in your
01:15:24 jurisdictions the liberals and the conservatives are green agree on this and the ndp loves butting
01:15:29 its nose into provincial jurisdiction the constitution sets out jurisdictions the easiest
01:15:36 way is to give the money without conditions you've said that we do need to step in that
01:15:42 we need to have more programs like this let me explain absolutely we need to increase health
01:15:51 transfers absolutely in order to help out the provinces what is more we are now in the midst
01:15:57 of a crisis a healthcare crisis it is being felt here in Quebec and all throughout the country
01:16:01 we should recognize that a leader is someone who looks for solutions not excuses
01:16:08 i believe that we should be investing more in fixing problems and yes we can work with the
01:16:13 provinces to hire more healthcare workers we can work with them to get through this crisis
01:16:20 pharmacare is one area where everyone can come together to bring down the cost of medication
01:16:25 We believe in helping people.
01:16:29 Deciding Quebec's priorities isn't your jurisdiction.
01:16:34 I don't go to your house and tell you how to pay your award, do I?
01:16:38 It's money that you would refuse to give Quebec.
01:16:41 We can do two things at once.
01:16:43 We can transfer money and then work with the provinces and other solutions.
01:16:46 Mr. Puglia, more money to the provinces or more federal programs?
01:16:49 I think the federal government is taking too much tax revenues and delivering too
01:16:57 little and that's the Liberal track record after 10 years and the question for Canadians
01:17:02 is you can't afford your groceries and you can't afford your rent or your housing because it's
01:17:07 too expensive now after three terms of Liberal government. Will a fourth Liberal term change
01:17:13 things for you? Enough for you to be able to buy a house and have a beautiful life?
01:17:19 Okay, for the health program? I didn't understand.
01:17:24 What I propose on that is a program that the federal government could coordinate,
01:17:31 and that is to do with licenses for doctors and nurses. It would be a voluntary program,
01:17:37 as has previously existed to allow immigrants to be licensed and be able to work in our hospitals
01:17:45 to reduce your wait times. So everyone agrees on health transfer. The question is the 13 premiers
01:17:52 of the 13 economies of Canada. Canada doesn't have one economy, it has 13 economies. These requests
01:17:58 were made to stop the deterioration of the healthcare system next theme energy and climate
01:18:16 the carbon tax was something that was supposed to help the environment but now what are we doing for
01:18:22 the environment it worries me a bit our planet is starting to die i really want to see someone
01:18:27 who can prioritize climate change and the economy in canada we shouldn't be building a pipeline
01:18:35 the environmental consequences are very serious even if for ecological reasons it's not the best
01:18:41 solution well i think we have to think about it there was a good project in place but then it
01:18:47 was dropped a pipeline would have a major impact we may have to make sacrifices if we want to be
01:18:53 more independent?
01:18:57 Drill, baby drill, says Donald Trump.
01:19:03 But I have a very simple question for you, and I would like just a simple answer as well.
01:19:08 You have a 35 seconds open debate.
01:19:12 Do you want Canada to increase oil production, yes or no?
01:19:18 Mr. Singh.
01:19:20 I would be in favor of investing in clean energy, renewable energy with our public money.
01:19:29 I would spend on projects like an east-west clean energy grid.
01:19:35 That's the sort of thing we need.
01:19:36 We need renewable energy for our future.
01:19:38 That is where we should invest our public funds.
01:19:41 So more or less oil or the same amount as right now?
01:19:46 You want to increase it?
01:19:48 That's what people want to know.
01:19:49 Are you increasing oil production?
01:19:51 There are a few measures that I support.
01:19:56 Investing in clean energy, bringing down our emissions, we'll get to that in the open
01:20:02 debate later.
01:20:04 But the question is very simple, I think.
01:20:06 Mr. Karnak.
01:20:07 Yes.
01:20:09 More oil so that we can reduce our imports, especially our imports from the United States,
01:20:15 a country that is threatening us right now but in order to do that we need to have
01:20:24 low risk oil canada is a low risk country and low cost oil canada's more or less that right now but
01:20:31 we also need low carbon oil because we need to be competitive over the long term so at the same time
01:20:36 we need to have pipelines we need to invest in carbon stockage uh carbon capture as well that's
01:20:43 It's very important for our competitiveness.
01:20:45 Mr. Pauliev, should we produce more oil in Canada?
01:20:48 Yes.
01:20:49 And we have to be able to get it to market by pipeline.
01:20:55 Unfortunately, the other parties passed an unconstitutional law, C-69,
01:21:03 which is a no more pipelines bill.
01:21:08 And that's why Canadians and Quebecers now have to buy 139,000 barrels of U.S. oil every day.
01:21:14 I will repeal C-69 to allow for the construction of hydroelectric projects, mines, and also pipelines,
01:21:25 so that we can get around Donald Trump and be sovereign when it comes to energy.
01:21:31 There's a competition as to who will be the biggest oil head here.
01:21:35 the americans buy our oil we buy their oil because that's how geography works
01:21:41 i want less oil but let us be let's be clear the the one that approved 9b for enbridge was me when
01:21:51 i was the environment minister but i say that we have to progressively wean off of petrol and oil
01:21:57 because the cost on families will be far worse than what Mr. Poeliev says.
01:22:03 Paying for the consequences of climate change will cost billions of dollars every single year per family.
01:22:10 Let us invest in Quebec's green energy.
01:22:13 I'd like to ask a question to launch the debate.
01:22:15 Mr. Carney, for 17 years now, the Liberals have been telling us
01:22:21 that the only way to fight against climate change is to put a price on carbon.
01:22:27 with the carbon tax there was elections on this but the first day you came to power
01:22:35 you abolished this tax what should canadians understand from this is the fight against
01:22:41 climate change no longer a priority for liberals not at all it is still a priority
01:22:46 and it's a priority for canada we're talking a lot about diversifying our trade partners around
01:22:53 the world the european union we need to reduce greenhouse gas emissions in manufacturing and
01:23:01 energy in all of our products so that we can have better access to that market but in terms of the
01:23:07 carbon tax we cut the consumer carbon tax and that covers about six percent of the reduction in
01:23:17 greenhouse gas emissions we are maintaining the industrial carbon tax for big polluters but we're
01:23:23 creating a new market so that major polluters will pay people and households to make green decisions
01:23:31 you would axe the second carbon tax as well the industrial tax you would emulate both
01:23:39 so there's no not even a fight against climate change or no incentive except that's not true
01:23:45 less gas there's a cost associated with using energy already but my approach is a pragmatic one
01:23:54 for example the national bank calculated that if we export our natural gas our liquefied natural gas
01:24:01 to india for example to replace coal that could reduce emissions in india by 2.5 billion tons
01:24:11 That's three times the emissions of all of Canada and would also bring a lot of money back to Canada.
01:24:21 The Liberals are blocking the construction of the pipeline and of the LNG plants.
01:24:29 plants. For example, LNG Quebec is a project that would make it possible for us to sell our energy
01:24:36 very profitably to Europe and reduce Europe's dependence on Putin. And that's what I would
01:24:45 like to do instead of feeding into Putin's war machine. Mr. Carney's abolition of the carbon tax
01:24:52 means that Canadians outside of Quebec will receive a rebate for several weeks still
01:24:58 for a tax that has been cut. So, this puts Quebec in an unjust position. What are you asking in this
01:25:07 respect? Another element. It might give Mr. Connors an opportunity to answer. Last year,
01:25:14 Canada invested 30 billion dollars in oil. Trans Mountain cost 40 billion dollars. It took nine
01:25:22 years to build it. That means that with only just these elements, that's 16 billion dollars of Quebec
01:25:29 money that was invested in oil. Do you want a great energy worksite? It's Quebec's green
01:25:40 worksite. So let's invest there. We've got to the $3.7 billion. The government would preemptively
01:25:48 reimburse the carbon tax. Now they've canceled the carbon tax before the elections, but they're
01:25:54 still sending reimbursements for expenditures that people won't have to do because the carbon tax no
01:25:59 longer exists. Quebec is responsible and still has a carbon trade system like California. We're being
01:26:06 penalized. We're taking $800 million out of Quebec's pockets. That's $100 per person,
01:26:13 including newborn babies. $800 from everyone's pockets. $100 from everyone's pockets to
01:26:21 offer electoral baubles just before election. Is there not an injustice there?
01:26:25 It's not an injustice. Quebec is a pioneer in carbon markets, and that's clear. First point.
01:26:33 And the second point, Canadians outside of Quebec and British Columbia have paid the carbon tax, and as such, they receive the carbon rebate, and all Canadians, including Quebecers, will receive the middle class tax cut.
01:27:01 because we have we have what we've done what we've done there's a principle here there's an
01:27:10 important principle here yes you're going to speak in a moment just in terms of clarity for
01:27:16 those who are listening to us what reimbursement are you talking about the the rebate no not in
01:27:24 Quebec. No, not in Quebec. But there's a principle here. We are making people whole,
01:27:35 people who paid the carbon tax, and we're doing that in a fair way. Europe, Quebec,
01:27:41 and California has a system that incentivizes companies to reduce their greenhouse gas
01:27:48 emissions it's about nine cents per liter and it's much cheaper than the potential effects and
01:27:55 the future effects of climate change back to the debate topic we are talking about the climate
01:28:00 crisis here that is not something that is a long way off this is something going on right now we
01:28:07 are already in the midst of the climate crisis we have seen it here in quebec extreme temperatures
01:28:12 forest fires flooding i agree with mr blanchet that it is too high a cost to bear so we need
01:28:22 to do something i spoke with uh one mother before i became a father and she said i'm worried about
01:28:28 my children when they play outside i'm worried about the bc forest fires our children cannot
01:28:34 breathe the air outside and now that i am a father i feel the same anxiety
01:28:42 With forest fires, people cannot breathe the air.
01:28:46 So we need to do something.
01:28:48 We need to protect our environment and we need to protect our children.
01:28:51 Mr. Poiliev, you're clear.
01:28:53 You're saying that we need a pipeline?
01:28:57 If, in spite of all of your efforts with the indigenous nations, they say no,
01:29:04 would you impose it in spite of all of your efforts?
01:29:06 If Quebec says no, would you impose it?
01:29:07 Well, first of all, you shouldn't assume that because most Quebecers want a pipeline, according to the polls.
01:29:18 Look, there's no social acceptability for the status quo.
01:29:23 Thank you very much.
01:29:26 That is the most empty sentence I've ever heard in this debate so far.
01:29:29 Can I answer the question? 0.84
01:29:30 It's nonsense. Absolute nonsense. 0.79
01:29:33 I'll say what it means. I'll tell you.
01:29:35 Quebecers who buy oil from Alberta, it's got to go through the U.S. currently, which gives Donald Trump power over our own energy.
01:29:48 You say you're in favor of sovereignty. I'm in favor of economic sovereignty and energy sovereignty, and that requires a pipeline across Canada.
01:29:56 yet another scarecrow the u.s will never bomb their economy so much by sacrificing a hugely
01:30:05 profitable product that's such an amazing argument how much will your pipeline cross cost
01:30:14 trans mountain cost 40 billion dollars but now you want a 4 600 kilometer pipeline without
01:30:20 investors with europe that doesn't even want it in the first place just to clarify i
01:30:27 would never subsidize pipelines that's unnecessary they're very profitable the only reason why it's
01:30:36 expensive now is because there are rules and legislation that prevent the construction of
01:30:43 pipelines because of bureaucracy we're going to get rid of red tape we're going to open this up
01:30:50 cutting environmental regulations, if Indigenous nations, in spite of all your nice efforts, 1.00
01:30:57 I'm talking about Mr. Carney and you who won a pipeline, if they refuse, what do you do?
01:31:02 Refuse? Are you saying across the board?
01:31:06 Yes, we've seen this.
01:31:07 Because he can't say that. He doesn't get to impose his will.
01:31:14 Mr. Poliev, if there are Indigenous nations or provinces that are against it, what do you do?
01:31:20 Well, there are others who will be in favor.
01:31:24 For example, Mr. Kearney opposed a pipeline in the West
01:31:28 which would have enabled us to sell our oil to Asia, the Northern Gateway Project. 0.95
01:31:35 80% of First Nations were in favor, 20% were against.
01:31:39 And in a case like that, I think the majority rules.
01:31:42 And I think we need to allow our companies to pay some of their taxes
01:31:46 directly to first nations to fight poverty through industry production that's our approach would you
01:31:54 be ready to impose one no never impose can i respond please never impose no but a couple of
01:32:02 points first of all our relationship with the united states has changed everything so imports 1.00
01:32:11 from the united states and geography as mr poliev has said around pipelines those are problems
01:32:19 those are national security problems for us and we need to act that's the first point second
01:32:25 on march 21st there was a meeting of the premiers all the premiers were here in ottawa and we sat
01:32:34 down and we agreed all the premiers signed an agreement to have an energy corridor that would
01:32:41 cover oil natural gas clean energy and critical minerals and with that and with a process with
01:32:53 indigenous leaders we can and we could have a solution to this problem and that's an example
01:33:00 of leadership that's an example of bringing leaders together to meet a national goal we
01:33:09 need to do more than that over this crisis.
01:33:13 I'll ask the question again. If ever, Indigenous nations... 0.99
01:33:16 No, I've said no.
01:33:17 Against it, you forget the project?
01:33:19 No, you cannot force projects on people.
01:33:22 Listen, it's a question of...
01:33:24 I have another question about the environment.
01:33:27 Here's the question.
01:33:28 You have said that you are a pragmatic person.
01:33:32 Do you agree that it is not pragmatic to continue to subsidize oil companies
01:33:38 with billions of dollars that's not pragmatic at all would you agree well i agree with that
01:33:43 principle okay then will you commit to stopping these subsidies absolutely it's clear this is
01:33:51 why you need new democrats look at that we got a commitment from mr carney new it's not a new
01:33:57 commitment that's not a new commitment let's be very clear mid-february british columbia
01:34:04 you like all other canadian leaders said something in english that was if necessary you would use
01:34:12 the executive emergency powers you said it i heard it again yesterday you would force pipelines
01:34:19 through canada after two days after that mr that's not it that's not it at all no please be
01:34:28 nice we're almost friends but then you said to monsieur what i would never like to force this so
01:34:32 it's not rules no let's stop this it's social acceptability that stopped this
01:34:37 pipeline because people said no sir Carney please reply okay no it's the
01:34:42 use of emergency powers for the federal government that's for federal approval
01:34:48 but there also has to be approval for example here in Quebec there has to be
01:34:54 approval from the provinces and the support of indigenous people this is
01:34:57 canada that's how canada works but another point if i may we're starting to see cooperation
01:35:07 agreements come into place with the provinces to have one project one evaluation and that's going
01:35:13 to accelerate the approval of major projects in canada mr blanchet you said that i have a greater
01:35:19 chance of signing the canadian constitution than approving a pipeline but how could you really
01:35:26 paint yourself in such a corner and say never ever if our relationship with the u.s gets worse
01:35:33 the pie and the pipeline goes to the united states if our ports become trickier in terms of imports
01:35:42 what would you do what would you tie your hand is a very serious one but he won't self-destruct
01:35:48 the american economy and americans think that canadian oil is in their backyard there's no
01:35:54 rule that stops oil from being built or circulating but quebec quebecers didn't want it and mr carne
01:36:01 said i will like to respect quebec's environmental rules so there are certain elements that are
01:36:08 incoherent from him it's still no because quebec is the best placed in the world to develop
01:36:17 a green super energy market that goes right to the south without asking Ottawa's permission.
01:36:24 Why would we invest in oil that doesn't have economic benefits for Quebec
01:36:28 if it means that we still pay more at the pump?
01:36:30 Two quick comments.
01:36:33 You are slightly behind in terms of the tramway and the third link.
01:36:39 We're talking about the environment and public transit as well.
01:36:42 So the third link, would you fund this or the tramway?
01:36:46 one of the other one of the other or both yes for the quebec city tramway we support public transit
01:36:54 we are against projects that are bad for the environment so you're against the third link
01:36:59 exactly we are against the third link we support the tramway one solution to address the climate
01:37:06 crisis while at the same time helping our economy is to invest heavily in public transit this would
01:37:12 help municipalities, this would help provinces. We could work together with them and use transfers to
01:37:17 provide more funding for these projects, and they're the sort of projects we need.
01:37:21 They would create good jobs, while at the same time helping Canada reduce emissions.
01:37:26 Mr. Pauliev, tramway or a third link, both, or just the third link?
01:37:32 Just the third link. You have to make choices. And I would speak to people in the regions today.
01:37:40 The other parties are against the third link and they want to ban gas-powered cars.
01:37:47 That's not practical in the regions of our country.
01:37:52 You need a truck, you need a car in order to live in regional areas.
01:37:58 So I'm going to reverse that. You'll be able to keep your truck.
01:38:01 We will build highways and bridges so that you can live a good life in the regions.
01:38:09 both projects the quebec government wants the tramway the city of quebec city rather wants the
01:38:16 tramway the federal government needs to give the money required to the provincial government for
01:38:21 the tramway we don't know what a third link looks like we don't know where it's going to go under
01:38:27 over we don't know what color is going to be you are supposed to give your opinion on that for the
01:38:32 the past three debates. Please remind me of my past. Well, I can be quick. Tramway, yes,
01:38:41 because there is a project that's underway. We support it. And as Mr. Blanchet has said,
01:38:46 there is no project right now for the third link. But I think the third link will be a blue one.
01:38:54 It'll be blue. Right. I don't have a lot of time left, but I'll add one more question.
01:38:59 Do we have to speed up the development of nuclear power?
01:39:05 Yes. Yes, absolutely. And for a couple of reasons.
01:39:09 Across Quebec and Ontario?
01:39:10 Yeah. It's a choice that Quebec and the provinces will make.
01:39:17 But we have a major advantage here in Canada. We have uranium.
01:39:22 We have big nuclear companies, including Westinghouse, Candu, and others, and we have technology in small modular reactors, so it's a great opportunity.
01:39:36 I understand there are countries in the world that need nuclear energy. I don't think Canada needs nuclear energy. Quebec doesn't want it. I'm not going to interfere in Canadian energy.
01:39:47 Canadian energy. Quebecers don't want nuclear energy. I'm also the one that managed the
01:39:56 closure of the plant. But we're not going to reopen it.
01:40:02 As a national project, I am in favor of an east-west energy grid that would connect Quebec
01:40:11 with Manitoba and BC to transport clean energy. I'm not so much in favor of nuclear energy.
01:40:18 I support renewable and hydro energy more.
01:40:21 In favor. That's one of the best sources of electricity. It provides 60% of the electricity
01:40:29 in Ontario. Unfortunately, bureaucracy slows down construction without adding any safety.
01:40:37 I would take the politicians off the Nuclear Safety Commission and allow scientists to do the work
01:40:44 so that we can add that source of energy to the portfolio.
01:40:49 This is the first time I've heard Mr. Paulyev say something pro-science.
01:40:57 Next theme, immigration and foreign affairs.
01:40:59 there are lots of issues with immigration that are linked to donald trump it's hard
01:41:09 to immigrate these days i'd like to stay if i can find a good job we have to deal with
01:41:14 people who are arriving in droves because people arriving and they don't have work
01:41:20 should we let them in or not why not why not welcome them if we have the capacity
01:41:25 do you think we should let them let in anyone who wants to come 1.00
01:41:29 in the united in the united states there's one rule in canada there's another
01:41:34 i think everyone should follow the rule
01:41:36 we know there are over 500 000 haitians currently living in the united states who are now being
01:41:45 threatened with deportation they might lose their temporary protection i'll show you the numbers
01:41:51 here. This is the number of people crossing the border in Saint-Bernard-de-Lacol. 1411
01:42:01 people in the first half of April. That's more than in March, February or January. So you can
01:42:06 see the numbers are growing. Simple question. You have 35 seconds each. Would you accept these
01:42:12 Haitians into Canada or not? Mr. Carney. Well, first of all, this is a question of humanity.
01:42:18 this is a human issue and these are some of the most vulnerable people in north america
01:42:25 but there are limits we have to be human but we have to be realistic canada cannot accept
01:42:32 everyone and we have an agreement with the americans the safe third country agreement
01:42:38 And under that agreement, we will send back most asylum seekers. 1.00
01:42:48 So they would be mostly sent back to the U.S.
01:42:50 Mr. Blanchet.
01:42:52 The rules aren't tributary to the origin of the requester.
01:42:57 We can't say we'll welcome the Haitians, but tough luck to the Venezuelans. 1.00
01:43:04 The rules need to be the same for everyone.
01:43:08 I'm particularly sensitive to this because I often meet with Haitian representatives.
01:43:13 They are francophones, and so it's easier for them to integrate into Quebec.
01:43:17 If Quebec is able financially to welcome them, then I'm sympathetic.
01:43:22 But the rules have to be applied, and Quebec's welcoming capacity is at its very limit.
01:43:28 The formal rule now would be to send them back because they are in a safe third country, i.e. the U.S.
01:43:36 Mr. Singh. In general, we should do our part. It's a question of humanity and compassion.
01:43:51 We appreciate the fact that our country is founded on immigration. That is something
01:43:56 important to us. We want immigration levels that are in line with our needs.
01:43:59 but if yes we need to take in people but if we cannot accept people well we don't want them to
01:44:10 have a bad life here in canada or in quebec so we need immigration but we cannot take everyone 1.00
01:44:16 yes or no the specific question the question is is do we accept those people for the people crossing
01:44:23 the border at l'école would they be welcome to canada or not because we have the right to send
01:44:28 them back under the safety of their country agreement? Unfortunately they have to be returned
01:44:32 because immigration has to follow the normal entry points. Quebecers are extremely generous
01:44:41 and welcoming. They welcomed my wife as Mr. Blanchet mentioned but the Liberal government
01:44:48 has abused Quebecers generosity with an out of control immigration system. 1.00
01:44:54 the population has grown three times faster than the number of new homes built this has created a
01:45:03 housing crisis in Quebec they're at the breaking point and the government of Quebec has been given
01:45:09 the power to choose immigrants that was under the Mulroney government that that power was delegated
01:45:17 to Quebec so we need to have realistic numbers realistic based on our housing capacity
01:45:24 What Mr. Poilievre is saying is that immigrants should be blamed for something that is really the fault of successive conservative and liberal governments who have not invested enough in our resources, who have not built enough housing, who have not welcomed people in the way that they should have been welcomed.
01:45:42 This cannot be blamed on immigrants.
01:45:46 That's not true.
01:45:47 Quebec is now asking, given the number of asylum seekers in its territory, for $500 million.
01:46:01 That was the amount they asked for in 2024.
01:46:04 Mr. Poliev, you'll be starting this open debate.
01:46:07 Would you be sending a $500 million check to Quebec?
01:46:09 We have to work with the government of Quebec to fix the damage the Liberals caused
01:46:15 with an out of control immigration system and I also have to say that I reject the century 1.00
01:46:20 initiative which is a liberal policy to balloon Canada's population to 100 million people that's
01:46:27 extreme I think we should go back to immigration levels that are such that the population never 1.00
01:46:37 grows faster than the number of houses, jobs, or health care services available.
01:46:43 Mr. Carney, would you give more money to Quebec? And more generally,
01:46:50 where would you like to have the immigration quota set?
01:46:52 Yes, we'll start with the second part. We need to have a cap on all types of immigration for 1.00
01:47:01 a certain amount of time so that we can increase our capacity to welcome newcomers to Canada,
01:47:06 including in housing, in training and language training here in Quebec and make sure that the
01:47:12 social safety net can accept them. And in those circumstances, sorry, the targets announced by
01:47:17 your predecessor, Mr. Trudeau, you would bring them down further. Is that correct? Well, there
01:47:23 are some challenges here in Quebec, for example, challenges with temporary foreign workers, for
01:47:32 example and it's a question of distribution if i can say it that way the distribution of workers
01:47:40 across quebec and there's a shortage of workers but we will maintain the cap on immigration for
01:47:49 certainly a couple of years so that we can increase our ability to welcome
01:47:57 would you reduce the number of immigrants to canada in general
01:48:00 instead of answering with a simple yes or no i would want to base our response on the fact
01:48:06 it is obvious that we need immigration when i speak to quebec farmers they tell me yes we need 1.00
01:48:12 immigrants to work on our farms when i talk to small and medium businesses they tell me that we
01:48:20 need immigrants the question is what level of immigration we would base our immigration levels
01:48:28 on the findings of an expert panel which would study our capacities.
01:48:33 Then we would have a data-based number. But I do not want to fall into the trap of
01:48:42 fear-mongering or blaming immigrants for things. We need a facts-based, needs-based approach.
01:48:51 Temporary foreign workers are temporary. They're a different category. Foreign students are a 1.00
01:48:57 separate category and they are essential for our post-secondary establishments in quebec and in
01:49:04 canada unfortunately it's being used as a roundabout way to get asylum or and asylum is also
01:49:13 taken advantage of through smuggling and organized crime we don't want to import vulnerable workers 1.00
01:49:19 because we simply need people asylum seekers should be people who are in distress that we 1.00
01:49:24 need to welcome based on our welcoming capacity. We are not currently in Quebec able to welcome
01:49:32 as many people that are arriving. Quebec needs to be able to establish what its targets are.
01:49:36 And one clear element, the federal parliament, with a block Quebecois initiative,
01:49:46 decided to force the federal government to consult provinces within 100 days
01:49:49 to determine how many immigrants would be welcomed. No one can decide, apart from Quebec, 0.99
01:49:57 how much Quebec can accept and welcome. Another rare moment where I agree with Mr Blanchet.
01:50:08 Temporary foreign workers are often victims of power abuses. We would restrict the use of workers 1.00
01:50:16 who are exploited by major corporations the central initiative was 100 million immigrants
01:50:21 in canada before the end of the century dominic barton a parliamentary committee said that they
01:50:27 did not take into account the quebec the uniqueness of quebec and one of the two co-authors of the
01:50:31 center initiative and 100 million people is now one of mr carney's close advisors mr carney
01:50:40 on a different subject now
01:50:41 would you say that the immigration system in canada is going off the rails or has gone off
01:50:49 the rails in the last seven or eight years the system isn't working and especially after the
01:51:00 pandemic our population has gone up i think at about three percent per year because of immigration
01:51:14 and that's why we need to have a cap for a certain period of time and i can say i'd like to say that
01:51:23 Canadians, Quebecers, and all Canadians, they want to welcome immigrants.
01:51:33 There's no problem with Canadians' attitudes here at all. It's the responsibility of all of us
01:51:41 to increase our capacity to welcome newcomers. Is it normal? Now, in France,
01:51:47 it takes six months in germany eight months so why do asylum seekers 1.00
01:51:54 coming to canada take at least three years to be processed because canada is obstinate
01:52:01 in welcoming more people than they can process uh house and they're not taking into account
01:52:09 the proportionality of every province and territory i spoke with federal public servants
01:52:15 and they told me that there is a lack of resources there aren't enough workers to
01:52:21 manage all the files that are coming in it's unthinkable that people have to wait three years
01:52:27 for an answer but it's a huge problem so we need to have more people working on this
01:52:38 people who can make decisions or at the very least provide an answer because it is entirely
01:52:42 unacceptable that we have people waiting so long.
01:52:46 Mr. Poyev, is this problem solvable?
01:52:49 Yes. Look, it's all about efficiency. By screening out bogus asylum seekers, 1.00
01:53:02 that's what's slowing things down. We could reduce processing times by getting rid of the bogus
01:53:08 claimants and when people are forum shopping when they've been to other
01:53:15 places that also slows things down and discourages genuine claimants. My
01:53:21 point of view is that if someone's in danger in their country of origin they
01:53:26 should be able to decide to come to Canada but if they're not refugees for 1.00
01:53:32 example we've seen a situation in Mexico where people came here without ever
01:53:37 needing to be refugees. They never needed asylum, and that causes a bottleneck in the system.
01:53:44 And so what we're going to do is ensure that genuine refugees can come here and have their
01:53:50 lives saved through the generosity of Canadians. But how do you separate the real ones from
01:53:56 the non-real ones? Well, that's the problem, the machine, the apparatus is too cumbersome.
01:54:04 and Mexico was one of the causes in the problem. 0.92
01:54:08 So by eliminating that source, that helps alleviate the problem.
01:54:12 Is that an acceptable wait time in Canada?
01:54:14 No, it's not acceptable.
01:54:16 It's inhumane.
01:54:19 It's inhumane for asylum seekers. 1.00
01:54:23 And that's an indication that there is a problem with productivity in that department.
01:54:28 That takes resources, but it's also a question of productivity.
01:54:32 Why not hitting the brake pedal with kindness, of course?
01:54:38 Why not slow things down until we have a good system and a good public service for immigration that can deal with files in a few months? 0.54
01:54:47 The rhythm is far too quick, and so we can't succeed at this rate.
01:54:52 Great. People for economic reasons or who are in distress for other reasons come to Canada and they're lost because their files aren't being processed.
01:55:03 You can conclude, Mr. Carney.
01:55:05 I more or less agree with that. But we need to be, as you've said, we need to be neutral. We need to act in a neutral and fair way.
01:55:16 All right.
01:55:17 A fair way for all.
01:55:19 to save some time to talk about two other important files international uh aid ukraine and gaza we
01:55:26 think we've understood your position on immigration the question is simple should we cut international 0.95
01:55:32 aid or not i'll give you some figures here 2.1 billion dollars is being given to ukraine currently
01:55:38 that's a large amount of money for canada uh ethiopia also haiti there's a long list of other
01:55:45 other countries that we could have put up on the board. Mr. Polyev, you've said that we need to cut
01:55:51 international aid. What would you cut? Ukraine, Ethiopia, Haiti? No. I would start by cutting off
01:55:57 China. The Liberal government gave $250 million to the Chinese Infrastructure Bank in order to build
01:56:06 pipelines highways and other infrastructure to promote uh the expansion of beijing's empire i
01:56:16 don't think that's a good use of taxpayer money also we saw unraw the organization in the gaza
01:56:23 strip that took part or whose employees took part in the attacks of september 7th so i don't think
01:56:31 we should be funding that type of activity either the aid we give should be directly to people in
01:56:38 need and not through bureaucracies multinational bureaucracies and terrorists currently doctors
01:56:48 without borders just today said that the situation was worse than ever
01:56:53 So if you cut UNRWA, which might be an imperfect organization, but if you cut aid to them,
01:57:05 how can Canada help Calisthenians? 1.00
01:57:07 With not-for-profit groups, NGOs that will deliver the services directly to Gazans on
01:57:16 on the ground because it's a waste of money, that money that's not even getting to the people.
01:57:25 I will start by saying, if there's anyone in an organization with a problem, then yes, that should be investigated.
01:57:37 But what you said about UNRWA was disgusting. This is the only organization that is helping out people on the ground.
01:57:42 And you painted the entire organization with the same brush, calling it a terrorist organization.
01:57:48 That is unacceptable, that is hateful, and it is entirely inappropriate.
01:57:53 Mr. Carney, on the subject of Palestinians and international aid, would you continue to fund UNRWA?
01:58:01 Yes.
01:58:02 We are in a situation where we need to have an immediate ceasefire.
01:58:08 we need to have all the hostages returned and we need to resume humanitarian aid to Gaza
01:58:16 and at this time we have a hundred million dollars from the government of Canada that is ready to be
01:58:22 provided in humanitarian aid to Gaza with organizations that are working there and that's
01:58:30 key and i agree with mr singh there are only a couple of groups that are working in gaza right now
01:58:43 it's a very unique situation in canada and in quebec the jewish community is victims of radical
01:58:51 islamists palestinians are currently victims of terrible violence from the israeli regime
01:59:01 we have to help people in distress there and elsewhere it's the best way to have international
01:59:06 aid that is not military we need to allow people to live happily where they live and palestine
01:59:14 will not become mar-a-lago for americans that just want to chill on the coast we have to see
01:59:20 the money goes we have to see how much money is is taken by hamas is maybe less now but it was
01:59:28 huge in the past a lot of money was taken from the palestinians we have to help help palestinians
01:59:33 at the end of the day international aid so the three of you on this side would continue
01:59:38 mr poyev do you have an amount in in your mind of how much you would cut in in international aid
01:59:45 We're going to target waste in all programs.
01:59:51 We will audit to identify examples like UNRWA when they used funds for Hamas.
02:00:02 We're also going to find other examples of international waste because…
02:00:08 the decision is to protect Canadian taxpayers. We all agree that there's a lot of suffering
02:00:18 here in Canada and Canadians can't afford to pay their bills. So we need to find some savings in
02:00:26 order to reduce the cost of living here in Canada. And we need to look at all departments
02:00:33 in order to find those savings and protect affordability in Canada.
02:00:39 I'd like to come back to the question of Gaza.
02:00:40 Mr. Singh, I'm sorry everyone's had their piece to say.
02:00:42 The situation is heartbreaking.
02:00:45 It's heartbreaking to see innocent people being killed.
02:00:48 Mr. Carney, why don't you call things as they are?
02:00:51 This is a genocide.
02:00:53 People in Israel do deserve peace and security,
02:00:55 but people in Palestine do as well.
02:00:57 What is going on right now is a genocide against people in Palestine.
02:01:01 Why won't you admit it?
02:01:01 The situation in Gaza, in the Middle East, is horrible, but I never use that word in
02:01:16 a political way to politicize the situation.
02:01:19 But it's a matter of facts.
02:01:21 That was Mr. Carney's response.
02:01:23 I think we've understood your question, Mr. Singh.
02:01:27 Now, we'll be moving on to the next theme, identity and sovereignty.
02:01:36 It would be good to put flags out on our balconies to show our Canadian pride.
02:01:41 I was surprised to see how proud people were.
02:01:46 We're Canadian. We will not be Americans. 0.95
02:01:50 I think we're going to be more united.
02:01:53 I think I haven't seen this in a long time.
02:01:56 So yes, we've all seen this across Canada. All commentators have seen this.
02:02:03 There is a wave of patriotism in Canada, but we've also seen deep divisions in the West.
02:02:12 Alberta says it may separate. We've got six months to the next Prime Minister to meet its requests.
02:02:21 Otherwise, there could be a crisis of national unity that is unprecedented.
02:02:27 In Quebec, the Parti Québécois is nearing power and is promising a referendum during your turn, possibly.
02:02:37 At the end of the day, are we not as divided or as the US or very divided?
02:02:45 We'll go around the table, Mr. Poiliev first.
02:02:48 Unfortunately, yes, there are divisions all across Canada, all kinds of divisions.
02:02:53 And I think that we've had a federal government that has divided everyone,
02:03:02 pitting regions against one another and various groups against one another,
02:03:07 social classes pitted against one another.
02:03:13 We need to unite Canadians.
02:03:15 We need to unite around our common identity.
02:03:20 That includes the French language, our English language, our military, the promise of Canada
02:03:26 that anyone who works hard can have a great life in a beautiful house on a safe street.
02:03:31 Thank you.
02:03:32 Mr. Singh, is there not division in Canada?
02:03:37 When I travel throughout the country, I observe great unity, great solidarity.
02:03:47 Canadians want to defend our country.
02:03:49 They do not want to become the 51st state.
02:03:52 They want to protect what is dear to our hearts.
02:03:57 When I talk to people about identity, people tell me our identity is taking care of one
02:04:01 another.
02:04:02 We have programs for that.
02:04:03 For example, our health care system.
02:04:05 We need to protect these systems and strengthen them, not cut them or sacrifice them.
02:04:11 Now is the time to bring people together to get things done with our solidarity.
02:04:16 Thank you.
02:04:17 Mr. Blanchet.
02:04:18 I think that people confuse certain things.
02:04:25 Some people think that all Canadians should follow one single line behind the federal
02:04:30 government and so we only have one economy.
02:04:34 Mr. Trump's fear or rather the threat of Mr. Trump has to be taken seriously but instrumentalizing
02:04:41 it for nation building in Canada, where Quebecers are being asked to be attached to their language
02:04:51 as a frivolity, I can't agree with that.
02:04:55 Thank you.
02:04:56 Quebec's uniqueness is also economic and we have to be on the same level playing field.
02:05:02 well there's always a risk but i think that right now canadians are uniting and they want to unite
02:05:17 canadians want a positive agenda there is solidarity here health health care is a right
02:05:24 here in canada it's not a big business like in the united states we put a value on diversity here
02:05:32 And we also put importance on judicial independence.
02:05:37 And, you know, the potential of Canada is enormous because we're all in this together.
02:05:42 Thank you. So open debate, Mr. Blanchet.
02:05:47 How can we think that Quebec, if it's on its own and independent,
02:05:51 could be stronger to stand up to Trump in comparison with all of Canada right now?
02:05:58 Canada right now? Does Canada need to be a province of Mexico to be allied to Mexico
02:06:04 against the states? We're not in that debate this week, but Quebec does not need to be a Canadian 0.97
02:06:12 province to talk of its own voice. Our economy is doing fairly well, but our economy is different
02:06:18 to that of Canada's. And the announcements that have been made have helped Ontario steel,
02:06:24 Ontario banking, the Ontario automotive industry to fund Western oil.
02:06:30 Those were the investments made.
02:06:35 The counter tariffs on aluminium are very harmful
02:06:38 because people have to pay for the aluminium they sent to be processed in the States.
02:06:44 They then re-imported into Canada.
02:06:46 Two billion dollars to the States in countervailing tariffs.
02:06:50 For that, nothing happened.
02:06:54 But now, $2 billion has simply been signed by Mr. Carney for the automotive industry.
02:07:03 He sees himself as a negotiator, but he hasn't even been re-elected yet.
02:07:07 Should Quebecers not make sure that they have a strong voice that collaborates?
02:07:12 I've already said that we would work with Canada, but I've asked to speak to Mr. Carney, but he's never called me.
02:07:20 He's never wanted to talk to me.
02:07:21 I want Quebec to be at the negotiating table for a stronger negotiating position with Canada.
02:07:27 Is there also not a risk, like was the case with the automotive industry in Ontario,
02:07:38 because this could happen to the detriment of saving other industries in our country,
02:07:44 if we put all our eggs in the automotive basket?
02:07:47 Not at all. For example, our counter tariffs for the aluminum sector and steel.
02:07:53 No, no, they're not bad. They're not bad at all.
02:07:56 We import aluminium cans from the States that comes from our...
02:08:02 No, no, that's not mine at all.
02:08:06 If I may, the counter tariffs for the aluminum sector are 30 billion dollars.
02:08:13 the counter tariffs are 30 billion dollars rather the counter tariffs for the automotive sector
02:08:18 that's eight billion dollars that's a huge difference because you know there are a number
02:08:23 of reasons for this but our counter tariffs it's not just for quebec it's for the workers there
02:08:32 are much higher i don't know where that money came from i don't know when the industry will
02:08:37 get that money we are using we are using the counter tariffs what was it two billion dollars
02:08:41 for automotive immediately for them because we're shaking in our boots when the automotive industry
02:08:49 is at risk but aluminium was not supported there's no processing uh capacity there's no help for
02:08:54 temporary work losses two billion dollars for the automotive industry but nothing for aluminium
02:09:01 when it's ontario the checks come flying but it has to be the same for other places right
02:09:05 especially Quebec. That's the numbers. Your numbers are wrong. Mr. Paul Yev.
02:09:14 Yeah, but he's got a point when he says that the weakness in our country right now
02:09:20 threatens our unity. Your Liberal government for 10 years has the worst track record on immigration,
02:09:28 on housing on inflation on crime but doesn't it embarrass you to ask canadians for a fourth term
02:09:42 of office after the worst liberal record i've just become leader and same members of parliament
02:09:53 same it's the same old promises and i've been prime minister for one month and in that month
02:09:59 we have an agreement with the provinces we have an agreement with australia we have an agreement
02:10:03 with france we have an agreement with the united kingdom we have set up negotiations for the next
02:10:09 prime minister and that's a decision that people at home are going to make and we've done all of
02:10:15 that in this short time and we've also cut the tax we've put in place programs for workers who
02:10:25 are most affected by this terra for and all that in one month okay quebec sent a letter with five
02:10:34 requests no one responded to it we made requests but we keep hearing oh we spoke to provinces
02:10:43 things are great with Quebec, but we didn't get any response to our letter, is it because
02:10:50 of the final straight of the election campaign?
02:10:54 What's going on?
02:10:55 Mr. Carney, you described health care as a right, and I agree with that.
02:10:58 But you are talking about massive cuts to health care, you admitted it.
02:11:03 Mr. Singh, I let you speak earlier.
02:11:06 The long-time Liberal government House leader, Karina Gould, agreed that they would be cut.
02:11:13 I let you speak more earlier, but now we're nearing the end.
02:11:21 We're talking about Quebec and French.
02:11:24 Does Quebec have the right to defend French, even at the cost of using the notwithstanding clause upstream?
02:11:34 Mr. Poliaff.
02:11:37 Yes. Quebec must defend French.
02:11:42 It's the common language of Quebec, and I will defend French.
02:11:48 My father was a Francophone from Saskatchewan.
02:11:53 I lost my French a little bit when I was a teenager, but I married a Quebecer.
02:11:59 Our children speak French, and I understand why French needs to be protected.
02:12:03 And that is why I will continue to support laws and policies that allow Quebec and the federal government to protect French all across Canada.
02:12:12 using the notwithstanding clause to protect something, you're against that, Mr. Carney?
02:12:19 Well, there is a general question here around the use of the notwithstanding clause in a preventative way.
02:12:29 And it's not necessarily a question just for Quebec.
02:12:32 It's been used in Quebec, but it could also apply in Alberta, Saskatchewan, and Ontario.
02:12:38 And it has. And so the question is, do we have rights and freedoms here in Canada?
02:12:43 Are we equal? And we need to consider the right balance, certainly.
02:12:52 But the use of the notwithstanding clause in a preventative way, that's a question for the Supreme Court.
02:12:57 Mr. Blanchet, in terms of the use of the notwithstanding clause, obviously you have no problem with that.
02:13:03 Jean Chrétien, on behalf of Pierre Trudeau, negotiated with the provinces, and it led to the notwithstanding clause.
02:13:11 And this wasn't signed on by Quebec. It was tested.
02:13:18 It's not the type of use that is in question. It's how it is used.
02:13:23 The Supreme Court has already decided. Mr Carney wants to turn to the Supreme Court to disagree with itself in the decision it made with Quebec.
02:13:30 There are interveners from Quebec who have challenged this to the Supreme Court.
02:13:38 You are going to take Quebec taxpayer money to contest a Quebec bill that is under Quebec
02:13:44 jurisdiction that was adopted by the National Assembly of Quebec.
02:13:48 Mr. Singh on this notwithstanding clause for French.
02:13:52 I believe in protecting the French language.
02:13:57 During this debate, I have tried to bring up health a few times.
02:13:59 Mr Roy cut me off a number of times. Look at my time on the clock. Every time I tried to bring up
02:14:06 health care, I was responding directly to something that Mr Carney said, because health is
02:14:11 something that is important for me. It is about identity. It's something I am very passionate
02:14:17 about. And every time I tried to bring it up, Mr Roy called me out and cut me off. That is not fair.
02:14:23 For me, the question of health care is crucial. When I talk to people on the street and ask them
02:14:28 what is important to them, they say universal public health care. People ought to know that
02:14:35 the other leaders on this stage tonight would cut health care funding. And I think that's wrong.
02:14:43 No, no, no. Not now, Mr. Blanchet. No, neither Mr. Blanchet nor I have said this. And I need to
02:14:50 tell people because it's important. This is what I believe in. This is what I believe in and what
02:14:55 the NDP believes in. That's not right to make allegations like that. We talked about health
02:15:00 earlier, I let you speak, but now we're moving on to another topic. Yes, but now we need to bring
02:15:05 it up in in the context of identity. What is Canadian identity? Healthcare. We have to bring
02:15:11 it up in this part of the debate. Canadian identity is about taking care of one another.
02:15:16 We need our universal public healthcare system. It should be strengthened. It should be
02:15:20 protected we are in the midst of a health care crisis it's supposed to be an open debate so we
02:15:26 should be able to talk about whatever topic comes up there's a lot of risk when it comes to
02:15:34 the health of a language let's talk about language there's health care issues in quebec as well and
02:15:40 i am here to protect the healthcare system for everyone including quebec outside of quebec mr
02:15:44 Singh and others. The weighting of francophones has gone from 6% in 71% to 3.5% in 2021.
02:15:54 How will you reverse this trend? People are listening to you across Canada.
02:15:59 Well, first of all, we are going to increase the level of francophone immigrants outside of Quebec.
02:16:08 will increase that from 10 to 12 percent. Second, we will strengthen Radio Canada and CBC with new
02:16:18 governance structure and new money. Mr. Poliev wants to cut that. We are going to strengthen the
02:16:26 telefilm industry and the Canadian Council for the Arts so that we can increase training.
02:16:30 First of all, the Conservative Party supported the federal legislation to ensure that federally
02:16:43 regulated workplaces in Quebec follow Bill 101.
02:16:48 We also will increase funding to allow young people to take part in French immersion for
02:16:58 anglophones coming from outside quebec and that will enrich the french language and third we'll
02:17:03 make sure quebec has more control over immigrant selection so that they can better choose those
02:17:12 who can be francized and integrated into the labor market and quebec culture that's what
02:17:20 we want to do to protect the french language mr colliev of course your position on radio canada
02:17:26 and the CBC. It has created a lot of concerns. You've continued to say that you would protect
02:17:34 Radio-Canada because it provides a service to francophone minorities across the country,
02:17:38 but you would abolish the CBC. How is such a thing possible?
02:17:42 Well, it is possible. We have news networks.
02:17:47 But they share the same buildings. You understand how difficult it would be.
02:17:50 I do understand the situation. I will protect Radio-Canada's services because there's already other French-language news services.
02:18:02 TVA is an example. So it is possible to have a news service that's focused on French news services.
02:18:12 And the CBC can just operate with its own revenues as an NGO, as a non-governmental organization.
02:18:20 The principle is that the government should simply do what the market cannot do.
02:18:26 And the market would never be able to provide exclusive French services to francophones all across Canada.
02:18:37 So there is a role for the government to play in defending French news services.
02:18:42 When I was a young person in Calgary, that was the only way for me to get news in French.
02:18:48 So I would protect those services because there's a good reason to do that.
02:18:52 Let me translate that.
02:18:56 Mr. Poilier wants to get rid of Radio-Canada and CDC and then he would write a check to other companies
02:19:05 so that they can provide French language services. That's the wrong thing to do. We would protect 1.00
02:19:10 Radio-Canada and CBC, especially in the context of misinformation which is undermining our
02:19:16 democracy. I am not a Francophone, but I am a Francophile. I love the French language. I have
02:19:23 fallen in love with it. It enriches our country. Having Quebec benefits all of Canada.
02:19:31 the forward-thinking ideas that have come out of Quebec. We need Quebec. We need the French 1.00
02:19:38 language and we will protect them. For the first time since 2011, there are no women here as
02:19:46 leaders. I met with a young woman. This is a very short clip. I met with her earlier this week. Do
02:19:53 you have a question for the leaders, something you're concerned about? In Canada, the status of
02:19:58 women? Yeah, the status of women. You're worried about things moving backward? Yes, that there 0.99
02:20:05 could be a rollback of women's rights by some parties. That concerns me. My question, would 1.00
02:20:13 you commit to making sure that there are no women's rights that are rolled back? And for
02:20:19 example, would you push for having free contraception, as is already the case in some provinces?
02:20:24 Is that something that you would commit to, starting with Mr. Peliyev?
02:20:29 We will not eliminate that. We will protect women's rights. I have a message for Canadian
02:20:36 women who are watching. We will not pass legislation that would restrict the right 0.95
02:20:43 to abortion. That's been our policy for 20 years and it won't change. That's a guarantee that I 0.75
02:20:49 make to you we will in fact broaden women's rights by dealing with crime against women
02:20:58 women are often victims of assaulters who are released because of liberal legislation they're 0.98
02:21:08 released repeatedly and that allows serious criminals to repeat offend against women and
02:21:17 We are going to lock those men up to protect women against violence.
02:21:24 Of course, our party believes in women's rights. 0.67
02:21:28 We would never allow for any backsliding on that front.
02:21:34 You brought up Pharmacare. Well, it was the NDP that forced the Liberal government to bring in Pharmacare.
02:21:40 It covers now diabetes medication, but also contraceptives, and we believe that is crucial.
02:21:48 Rights are important, but being able to access the rights is also important.
02:21:53 We are also the only party running a candidate slate that is half women. 1.00
02:21:58 The other parties have seen backsliding on their candidate slates in terms of
02:22:03 diverse people and women. But for us, it's an important issue. Our candidate slate must 0.97
02:22:09 represent the Canadian public, and that means it should be half women. 0.82
02:22:16 For us, we will always defend women's rights and also access to those rights.
02:22:24 There is no member of the Bloc Québécois that will be able to table a bill or motions that are
02:22:31 against abortion. Preventive MAID will also not be allowed. With American influence, we are in a
02:22:43 very difficult place for women. There are many ways that invite women to participate in politics. We 0.98
02:22:53 have reached parity with the Bloc Québécois. We wanted it to be 50-50, but in our current political
02:23:00 culture and i have many great women in my party it's much more difficult at the federal level than 1.00
02:23:07 in quebec yes i think that this an aspect of politics right now the negative politics that
02:23:15 we're seeing it's becoming more and more difficult to recruit women as candidates
02:23:21 and really any candidate but absolutely we defend the rights of women all the time but what i'm
02:23:28 concerned about is the use of the notwithstanding clause not in a preventative way but after
02:23:38 supreme court judgments have been made that what does that do it takes away
02:23:44 canadians rights and freedoms and it creates and mr poiliev has proposed this
02:23:52 for you know for i know i know the situation but this is a very dangerous development because if
02:24:00 we start with that abortion could be give the right to the right to abortion could eventually 0.93
02:24:07 be next yeah if you can answer mr kearney i said in a case where a man kills six people
02:24:14 in a premeditated way and the court released that person that means he served four years for each
02:24:23 life he took the criminal in that case will be free in 50 years you're talking about danger
02:24:30 that's what's dangerous liberal laws liberal laws that allow criminals to circulate on our streets 0.99
02:24:40 I will never excuse for locking murderers up.
02:24:44 No, I'm sorry, but you're trying to change the Canadian Constitution.
02:24:49 All right, gentlemen.
02:24:50 That's what you've proposed.
02:24:52 I would use Section 33 to put an end to the crime that liberals caused with their policies.
02:25:00 Where will you stop?
02:25:02 By stopping murderers, yes.
02:25:05 Everyone knows that there should be severe penalties for murder.
02:25:10 You're trying to sow division here.
02:25:11 Everyone agrees on that front.
02:25:13 If someone kills someone, there needs to be a strong punishment.
02:25:16 You're not special for proposing that.
02:25:20 Everyone agrees.
02:25:23 All right, Mr. Blanchet.
02:25:26 Very quickly, please.
02:25:27 Mr. Carney said that I voted for the new Official Languages Act bill.
02:25:32 The money comes from the previous bill,
02:25:33 and the official language minority community money comes from the bill.
02:25:42 I was asked to bring changes.
02:25:44 We brought the changes we voted for,
02:25:47 but we didn't want it to apply to Quebec because it harms Quebec.
02:25:50 Gentlemen.
02:25:53 You know, things didn't turn out perfectly,
02:25:57 but Mr. Singh, you see you got 22 minutes compared to 24, 24, 25.
02:26:02 Roughly equitable.
02:26:03 I'm sorry that I did have to cut off your mic, but I'd like to wish all four of you good luck with the rest of the campaign.
02:26:10 And I hope that we'll see your costed plans as soon as possible so that we can see how much all of your promises will cost.
02:26:17 And I hope that everyone listening tonight will be able to make an informed decision now.
02:26:23 Voting starts this weekend.
02:26:25 And the game.
02:26:26 And the match? I don't know.
02:26:28 there's still a couple of periods left all right thank you so much for being with us tonight
02:26:35 ladies and gentlemen that concludes this debate see you next time good night
02:26:58 just never end out they droned on and on and on about just pipelines and basically yeah it was
02:27:16 a lot then they finally moved on to immigration and instead of talking about Canada's immigration
02:27:22 plan. The question was framed about Donald Trump. So we heard that, well, let's see,
02:27:29 that Trump was terrible and that because of that, there were going to be asylum seekers coming 1.00
02:27:34 across the border. And the question was whether or not the leaders would accept asylum seekers
02:27:39 from the United States, which was just absolutely absurd way of framing it. And then we've done to
02:27:44 talk a lot about foreign aid. At that point, we heard that both Mark Carney and Jagmeet Singh are
02:27:50 strong supporters of UNRWA, which is quite surprising,
02:27:53 given the revelations that UNRWA was involved
02:27:55 in the October 7th massacre.
02:27:58 That is very well documented.
02:27:59 So that was an interesting little tidbit.
02:28:01 Then we went on to Canadian nationalism,
02:28:04 and then this whole, like, elbows-up thing,
02:28:06 we ended up talking back with Donald Trump again.
02:28:10 I said on X that if you were playing a drinking game,
02:28:13 and you, you know, had-
02:28:17 Every time they said Trump,
02:28:18 would be completely drunk within like five minutes of the debate because we just heard a lot
02:28:22 about donald trump and then the last 10 minutes um were focused on abortion um i don't really
02:28:30 understand why that was an issue given that all of the leaders agree which doesn't really give
02:28:34 canadians much choice like there's a lot of pro-life canadians there's a lot of catholic and
02:28:38 religious canadians and none of our views are represented by these leaders instead they're all 1.00
02:28:42 all trying to one-up one another over who will support abortion the most, I guess. And good for 1.00
02:28:50 Pierre Polyev at least to focus it on crime, because that is somewhere where they have a
02:28:54 distinction. And I like that policy of Pierre Polyev pledging to use the notwithstanding clause
02:28:59 to make mass murderers actually stay in jail for their whole lives as they should.
02:29:03 So, you know, as far as who wins, who won the debate? Well, Canadians certainly didn't. I'm
02:29:10 to put it to the chat on youtube you could tell us we put a chat up uh sorry a um um uh you can
02:29:20 vote up on our uh screen here we've got 350 so far um vote so go ahead and vote who do you think won
02:29:27 the debate i would i would probably go with the francois blanchett i thought that he had a strong
02:29:32 night and it will certainly wasn't carney carney came across quite weak to me and um i don't think
02:29:37 he did what he needed to do. It was interesting that Pierre Polyev had the most amount of time
02:29:43 speaking. It seemed like, you know, that's always kind of destined to happen because
02:29:47 he has the outlying views, right? The other parties tend to agree on most things
02:29:51 and the Conservatives tend to be the one that disagrees. There was some teaming up on
02:29:55 Mark Carney, but also plenty of teaming up from an ideological perspective on Pierre Polyev.
02:30:02 So David, what did you think of this debate? Who do you think won and what were your sort
02:30:06 of top takeaway moments uh carney lost badly i think um i have a french canadian link on that
02:30:15 and they said they believe that uh blanchette uh that the way it was playing in quebec from
02:30:21 their perspective carney lost badly um i you know if i didn't have that perspective i would still
02:30:27 say that uh blanchette was the winner he presented himself it's a distinctive voice it is a french
02:30:33 debate it's very much played around uh quebec and quebec's interests i thought that uh polyev
02:30:40 uh did great i thought he carried himself well he looked prime ministerial uh carney looked scared
02:30:48 he looked riddled he looked reactive he wasn't smiling i noticed it was odd he wasn't making
02:30:54 eye contact with blanchette when blanchette was speaking with him he was sort of maybe his team
02:30:58 and told him you know stare at the camera but some of the side views looked odd he seemed wooden and
02:31:04 it might be i'm sympathetic you know if i had to carry on a debate in french and didn't have the
02:31:09 skill set i think it could be tough i think though that he's run himself into a bigger problem we
02:31:15 talked before the debate about the fact that he's tended to say two different things in two different
02:31:21 settings and kind of hope that he can align past what that means and he was called out by very
02:31:26 directly by Blanchard, who made the point that he had said something in English language,
02:31:30 different from what he'd said in French language. But I think that Carney is going to wear some of
02:31:36 these issues. And I thought UNRWA is a terrible position for the Liberal Party to be in. That is
02:31:42 a completely Hamas-penetrated front operation. We know that for a fact now. It's disgusting 0.99
02:31:49 how many terrorists that they know were implicated by the October 7th events, as well as the
02:31:56 infrastructure run run completely controlled by hamas in the west bank the fact that canadian
02:32:01 tax dollars continue to go to organizations like that rather than held back by us on the premise
02:32:08 that there has to be release of hostages is extraordinary to me and again canada just
02:32:13 maintains this bizarre position on the international uh criminal court with respect to the islamist
02:32:19 judge going after netanyahu etc that we just were complete outliers in civil society on these issues
02:32:26 and i think that that's uh going to cost the carney and some very specific groups if i'm
02:32:32 a jewish voter in montreal or toronto right now you lost me on unra right i think they tried to
02:32:39 pin pauliev again pauliev's uh got to deal with his challenge with boomers and with women in
02:32:47 particular, and I think they were hoping to make that last dialogue around women an issue for
02:32:53 Pollyab, but I think you did a smart job making it about crime and security. So, bless you.
02:33:00 Well, and it was interesting because just, I think it was a week ago, someone in the audience at one
02:33:05 of his debates said that Israel's committing genocide, and he said, I know. And then tonight, 0.96
02:33:10 he was asked about that word because Jagmeet Singh is kind of obsessed with this idea that Israel
02:33:16 is committing genocide and so he was really trying to press carney on that and carney said i don't
02:33:21 like you using that word um which i agree with i think that that was the right thing to say we don't
02:33:26 just throw around the term genocide i wish his predecessors in the liberal party would have
02:33:30 taken that approach because remember prime minister just intrudeau said that canada is currently
02:33:34 committing a genocide um he said that with regards to the missing and murdered aboriginal indigenous
02:33:40 women file which um as we know that um sadly most of the uh women who die from that community you 1.00
02:33:50 know they're murdered by a partner in intimate partners like 90 so this idea that there's a
02:33:54 genocide happening in our country right now is absurd um i was happy that uh mark carney said no
02:33:59 about that um however yeah it's very interesting okay i want to give this little tidbit to the
02:34:04 audience we are waiting for the most exciting part i think of this debate which will be the
02:34:08 questions. Kian Bextie sent me a photo, and he is at the very front of the line. So when the leaders
02:34:14 come out, the first question will be our own Kian Bextie of Juno News. I think we have a picture.
02:34:20 Do we have that? Can we show it? Anyway, he's there. He said there's 20 CBC journalists behind
02:34:23 him, and he's number one. So we're looking forward to that, Kian, and I hope you have a good question,
02:34:28 man. So we're going to go back and forth between those questions, those scrums. It's going to be
02:34:32 happening. We've got, again, one eye on that. And so we'll just give a little bit of our reaction
02:34:37 from the debate. So, you know, I kind of ran through what the debate was about. We've got
02:34:43 a couple of clips from the debate, which, you know, I think that the first like 15, 20 minutes 0.87
02:34:50 of the debate was kind of silly. Like it was just totally about Trump. And, you know, they started
02:34:55 out by trying to say like, let's not make this whole debate about Trump. So talk about like one
02:34:59 thing or two things that aren't about Trump. But then everyone ended up talking about Trump a little
02:35:03 bit. And then the next question was, Trump, Trump, Trump. This is a good moment that Pierre
02:35:08 Polyev had early when most people are still probably watching. And that was when he told
02:35:13 Mark Carney, you know, you were Justin Trudeau's economic advisor because, you know, Mark Carney
02:35:19 was trying to play the whole, like, I'm an outsider kind of thing. And Pierre Polyev said,
02:35:25 no, you were there. I think we have that clip. Do we have that clip? If so, let's play it.
02:35:29 oh okay we don't have it yet um but i you know that to me the first 20 minutes david are kind
02:35:39 of like the thing that really counts it's when the stage is set and i don't really know that
02:35:43 there was a major like knockout punch moment in the debate this is as close as we got to one i
02:35:49 think it was a strong moment and i agree with you that carney just seemed weak he didn't present
02:35:55 like a strong confident person he seemed quite like easily shaken not really confidence i mean
02:36:03 i feel for the guy maybe it's because his french is quite not great from what i was reading um what
02:36:09 i was hearing i was obviously listening through the translated debate but perhaps it was because
02:36:13 his his french isn't that strong what do you think look i i think that the debate kudos to
02:36:20 the debate organizers this is one of the best debates that i've seen in that everybody got a
02:36:25 And there was there was a lot of divergent conversations, but it was controlled.
02:36:31 It had momentum.
02:36:33 The debate followed a track.
02:36:34 They got to all five key issues, but they allowed a fair amount of free form engagement.
02:36:40 And I don't think Carney has had much of that.
02:36:43 I think that almost everything he's done has been heavily scripted, heavily controlled.
02:36:48 I think that his engagement has been very scripted.
02:36:51 And this was the first time that you've sort of seen somebody able to take him out of the shadow boxing, sort of sparring in the ring moment.
02:36:59 And actually, he's now in an arena where he's facing people telling him he's wrong.
02:37:04 And I thought the engagement, particularly between Blanchett and Carney, showed Carney to have a weekend.
02:37:11 Absolutely.
02:37:11 Okay.
02:37:12 And then we do have other clips.
02:37:14 I thought that the kind of more interesting parts of the debate were later on.
02:37:18 there was a weird exchange where Polyev was talking about, or they were talking about housing,
02:37:23 which is a good issue. I wish I spent more time talking about that. But Polyev tried to, sorry,
02:37:27 Jagmeet Singh tried to say that Polyev didn't have a good record that he was once the housing
02:37:31 minister. And yet he had only built six houses. I don't know what that meant. And Polyev was like,
02:37:40 no, I built 200,000 homes. And Jagmeet Singh was like, no, you only built six. Like, I don't really
02:37:45 understand I didn't understand that that part what did you think of that well I think what's
02:37:50 happened you know the great thing about debates is that everybody allows their base to like publish
02:37:57 a fun meme or you know say something kind of snappy and it gains a life of its own even if
02:38:03 it's a little bit fact-free and what happens these leaders end up run down they've got almost no time
02:38:09 in the day to think for themselves they're out there they repeat things that have a bit of an
02:38:14 applause line on the hustings. And then they make the mistake of taking that into an actual debate
02:38:19 without actually having the fact base done. And I think Pierre was ready for that, because
02:38:23 that is something that I've seen both the liberals and the NDP using, and it's simply not a smart
02:38:29 argument. But it has played poorly, and it actually played very much into Polio's hands,
02:38:35 because I think that he was able to present himself as a safe pair of hands. He had a couple
02:38:41 moments where he was kind of laughing you know there's a bit of engagement on strawberries and
02:38:45 other things that you know it's sort of it's quirky but i think if you look at the dynamics
02:38:51 around how this election has evolved because of the proroguing he hasn't had much of a chance to
02:38:57 get a national platform in the way that he had had it before the proroguing and i think this in a way
02:39:05 humanized him now naturally i'm a partisan i'm a conservative i want him to win i want him to look
02:39:10 human i want him to do well but i would say even if he wasn't my guy on the stage uh i would have
02:39:17 thought that he did really well and i think you know i'll talk with a couple liberal friends
02:39:21 after we're done here and say what did you think and i think they'll be worried about carney my
02:39:26 guess is carney loses between two and four points on this debate alone but i think but i think he
02:39:33 loses a lot in quebec i think quebec will shift back to the block uh that's my my big prediction
02:39:40 i think it was that bad for him given what i'm hearing from from friends of mine that are in
02:39:46 quebec that i think are very centrist voters uh carney was wooden in in critical moments and he
02:39:52 was evasive particularly on the notwithstanding clause and i honestly if if i was one of his
02:39:58 his advisors have no idea why he chose to go technocrat on that clause when he knows what's
02:40:05 at stake for Quebec. And I think that, you know, his weird sort of idea that, well, you know,
02:40:11 Alberta and Saskatchewan, Ontario would also use this and we have to, I mean, it's just like,
02:40:14 of course we would, it's constitutional. And the idea that Quebec can't use it for culture and
02:40:20 language or that that would be controversial is crazy. Pierce was very strong on that. I think
02:40:26 going to strengthen his hand in Quebec. And I think that Bach is going to take votes away from
02:40:32 the Liberals. I think this could be the beginning of a shift. Interesting. I will say, just so the
02:40:37 audience knows, so 8.15 is when we're told Mark Carney is going to go. And like I said,
02:40:41 KMVX is first in line. So folks, this is going to be good. Get some popcorn.
02:40:50 So we're going to keep an eye on that. And I promise we'll go to it
02:40:53 as soon as possible i i obviously i have more of the conservative persuasion i think pierre
02:40:59 for my ears did really well like i liked what he was saying i think it's great the reason i said
02:41:03 that blanchette won the debate is because it's quebec like it's a french language debate so it's
02:41:07 for all canadians but really this was the quebec debate and i don't know how popular conservative
02:41:13 ideas are in quebec i'm told not very um i thought the pipeline part was interesting especially when
02:41:18 And Pierre Polyev said that pipelines are popular in Quebec and that people in Quebec support them, which I think is right.
02:41:26 I think that obviously there's the environmental crowd in Montreal, and those are the loudest and those are the people that don't want the pipeline.
02:41:32 Others sort of wonder what was in it for Quebec or, you know, there's risk, but there might not be a benefit.
02:41:36 And I think that Polyev did a pretty good job of explaining why.
02:41:42 So, you know, I think Polyev looked fantastic.
02:41:45 I didn't like the voice that they had for him.
02:41:48 I will say that was like a little pet peeve of mine.
02:41:52 I was like, oh, okay, hold on.
02:41:54 We have Mark Carney coming up on stage.
02:41:56 Okay, let's go to it.
02:41:57 Let's switch over to that.
02:42:15 with the numbers that go with them and it's not a question of cutting it's a question of
02:42:40 making the government more productive and we want to increase government productivity when it comes
02:42:45 to operational expenditure and we can have a discussion over the weekend and we have
02:42:53 about 10 days left in the campaign question well i understand but the debate is a good
02:43:01 time to be speaking to a high number of canadians compared to when you're making announces
02:43:08 announcements rather and now tonight you talk to us about 500 billion dollars you are planning
02:43:13 to invest in canadian economy where does it come from answer well it's a combination of
02:43:23 investments from the government of canada for instance the accelerator fund
02:43:29 enter in the housing area or or other initiatives and incentives in housing
02:43:37 will lead to more investment from the private sector and we will multiply the government
02:43:44 investment by 10.
02:43:46 So it's this approach that is necessary in this period of uncertainty at the global
02:43:56 level and here in Canada as well.
02:43:59 You have to have the courage in the political sense of the term, and as I always say, we are the masters of our own faith, and Mr. Poilier has picked up on that and is saying the same thing.
02:44:17 So we have the opportunity of building the strongest economy in the G7, and I have the plan to do that.
02:44:24 Hi, Mr. Gurney, Key and Bextie, Juno News.
02:44:27 In your estimation, was Justin Trudeau a good prime minister?
02:44:31 Yeah, Justin Trudeau and the previous administration made a number of contributions to this country.
02:44:40 I suspect since I have 10 minutes, I think, right, for the responses, I'm not going to enumerate them all.
02:44:46 I'll make one point which I think is relevant on the way looking forward,
02:44:49 which is, as I said the other night in an interview,
02:44:54 He and I, we share the same values in terms of solidarity, taking care of one another,
02:45:00 the emphasis on reconciliation, emphasis on equality of all Canadians,
02:45:06 and building a better country for everyone else.
02:45:09 The difference, one of the differences, there are many, but one of the differences between the two of us
02:45:13 goes to the question I was just asked, which is I put much more emphasis on the economy,
02:45:17 on growing the economy.
02:45:19 In fact, in this circumstance that we're in, given the scale of the crisis and what needs to be done, I would say a relentless focus on growing the economy to work for all Canadians.
02:45:29 Just to follow up, if I may, your entire campaign does seem to be predicated on putting you in the front and hiding the people that stood in lockstep with Justin Trudeau for the last 10 years.
02:45:39 You're kind of hoping that Canadians won't connect the dots that the people standing behind you in your caucus walked in lockstep with them.
02:45:45 And regardless of what you say right now, Stephen Gobeau made the carbon taxes life work.
02:45:50 The man that moved Paul Bernardo from a maximum security prison is now your chief of staff.
02:45:55 I'm wondering how you reconcile this and how you can trust their judgment when they thought those ideas were good ideas.
02:46:00 I'd say a couple of things to that rather odd question.
02:46:03 First is that the candidates in this election for the Liberal Party, I mean, you go and see when I make an announcement.
02:46:11 I don't think I've seen you at any of them, but next time you can come.
02:46:14 And you will see a wide range of the candidates that are there presenting themselves.
02:46:21 So, for example, with respect to our announcement on crime, we had Bill Blair, now the Minister of Defence, of course, formerly the Chief of Police in a long time in Toronto.
02:46:32 and Natalie Provo, who is a new candidate, we're honored to have her, and someone who's dedicated
02:46:40 their life to helping to end gun violence and violence against women. There is a very wide
02:46:46 range of candidates that have come to the party with me. There's a lot of fresh blood. There's
02:46:52 also a lot of experience that's there, and you need that combination of energy, new ideas,
02:46:56 experience and and a fundamental passion for making this country better uh in order to serve
02:47:04 at this crucial time thank you very much question question you said during the debate that you want
02:47:15 to introduce a cap on immigration in all categories mr trudeau had already taken steps to reduce
02:47:25 annual numbers in terms of immigration answer while my thinking is more in line in terms of
02:47:35 keeping the levels where they are currently for a long period of time and in the meantime
02:47:45 increasing our capacity of welcoming if i made the various people measures or levels of uh the
02:47:52 different classes of immigration as roughly as they are today so it's not a as the question was
02:47:58 a further reduction but we probably are going to need them to keep them at those levels for longer
02:48:04 until we have built up our capacity to uh to welcome which means housing language formation
02:48:09 other factors question you said that you wanted to increase oil production and that you're open
02:48:19 to pipeline projects from west to east while it can take years to build a pipeline how
02:48:28 are you going to present this as a way for canada to be more independent than the us if it takes
02:48:33 years to build answer i mean there are different aspects of this question if our relationship with
02:48:47 the us is being is there's an upheaval in that relationship and it is the case
02:48:54 as you said this reflects on the medium term and secondly
02:48:59 in canada we have this option and that will only strengthen our hand in the negotiations with the
02:49:08 president of the u.s and that is useful right now keep the answers and questions very short please
02:49:14 absolutely alex sultan with true north uh if you thought my friend's question was odd you're
02:49:17 going to love this one i'm glad you self self-assess that okay how many genders are there 0.79
02:49:23 In terms of sex, there are two. Thank you.
02:49:29 My follow-up question then, do you believe that women, biological women, have the right to their 1.00
02:49:35 own spaces? Their own sports, their own change rooms, their own prisons, their own homeless
02:49:41 shelters? I think we, this is Canada, and that as a general objective, yes.
02:49:50 we but we work in where we value all Canadians for who they are and we'll
02:50:01 continue to do so thank you very much thank you Missy oh okay so we got two
02:50:13 questions to Mr. Carney and interesting. I think that Kian Bexy's question really caught him off
02:50:22 guard and he didn't quite know what to say about Justin Trudeau because, I mean, I don't think he
02:50:30 was expecting that question at all. And as far as Alex Sultans, I mean, again, wow, really caught
02:50:36 him off guard uh david can you can you hear me what did you think of that yeah i i thought
02:50:42 those guys sean you know we need more of that in canadian media we've got um those are those
02:50:50 are the questions that people are actually asking around their dinner table that's what people talk
02:50:56 about right now people actually have a huge debate around what's happening with this trans madness 1.00
02:51:02 The high court in the UK has just determined women are biological.
02:51:06 That happened yesterday, right?
02:51:08 There's been enormous debate around this issue.
02:51:11 People are tired of seeing little girls hurt by men in sports that have different biology. 0.93
02:51:17 And, you know, the guys have just put their finger on it.
02:51:20 And I love Alex Hilton's self-deprecating way of setting up this question saying, you know, I know that you may not appreciate the question or you might find it crazy.
02:51:29 kind of crazy, but that's that's where people live their life.
02:51:32 And I think one of the things people forget about elections is that they pivot not just
02:51:36 on the they pivot on hearts and minds and the minds issues are the economy, trade, how
02:51:42 you manage Trump, immigration, you know, the issues of cost of living, et cetera.
02:51:48 But the hard issues are the issues where people look at what's happening around them and they
02:51:52 decide, can my can my wife or girlfriend walk through the street to meet me at a restaurant 0.99
02:51:58 tonight or is that just too dangerous is this is are the streets just not walkable like they are
02:52:03 in so many other countries right and uh can my kid go to school without being told that he might
02:52:09 have been born in the wrong body and that there's some kind of surgical process for dealing with
02:52:15 gender dysphoria rather than being encouraged to connect with his parents and connect to people 0.95
02:52:20 that can help him through that process those are the things that actually really move people
02:52:24 because they're asking a simple question is this the country that i want my kids to inherit
02:52:29 right and and on the economy stuff you don't want your kids to inherit all kinds of debt
02:52:34 that the boomer grandparents are going to pass on to them but on the on the cultural stuff that's
02:52:39 the thing that really actually moves people that's the stuff that keeps people up at night
02:52:43 and i think it's interesting too because those were the questions that we didn't get in the
02:52:47 debate right like kian's question was put him on the spot about justin trudeau right this remember
02:52:52 this happened with Kamala Harris. She was on The View. It was like a safe interview during the
02:52:57 2024 U.S. election. And she was just asked, like, what would you do differently than Biden? And she
02:53:01 didn't have a good answer. She stuttered. She said, I think we just saw something quite similar
02:53:05 to that with Mark Carney, because he it's like he wasn't prepped for that question. Right. And so
02:53:12 he just gave his honest answer, which was I love Justin Trudeau. I believe everything that he does.
02:53:17 We have the same vision of Canada, which has Jordan Peterson laid out very well in his video
02:53:21 critique of Mark Carney. Their vision of Canada and their values are not Canadian values.
02:53:26 Question on French, please.
02:53:30 You have been an MP for the last six years. Now you are entitled to retirement. Before that,
02:53:40 you were a provincial MP. In other words, the majority of your career has been at the expense
02:53:46 of taxpayers but you chose to boycott conservatives and right-leaning media such as ours
02:53:53 and you supported Justin Trudeau's bill that aimed to censor the internet so why do you think
02:54:02 that it's ethically acceptable to marginalize conservatives and refuse to treat them with
02:54:09 respect answer i do not answer questions from rebel news because it's an is it's a organization
02:54:17 that spreads disinformation so i'm not going to answer your question but i will take the time to
02:54:22 say that what's key in this election for me is this question of who's going to fight for you
02:54:28 and who's going to defend what's important for you health care for instance who's going to defend
02:54:35 the interests of everyday canadians and not just ceos and we have major companies who are scamming
02:54:45 people question you are banned from indian indian territory for your policies but here in canada
02:54:57 you support censorship and words that you think are unacceptable especially through censorship
02:55:05 online and you actually refuse to answer questions from journalists with whom you do not agree
02:55:10 as you have just done so you should be punished in one way or another is the impression that leaves
02:55:19 so how are you different than people who would put you in prison answer that is another example
02:55:26 of why i do not answer questions from rebel news because you are spreading this information and
02:55:31 your question is an example of this good evening mr singh you really wanted english i could do it
02:55:37 if you want no you're just joking uh kate mckenna from cbc news your party and the other parties
02:55:43 haven't released costed platforms how can you how can we have an honest debate about your promises
02:55:49 when voters can't see how you'll pay for them we're the only party that has actually laid out
02:55:54 clear examples of how we would raise money we talked about ending offshore tax havens
02:56:00 enforcing the Canada Revenue Agency to get the money that we're owed.
02:56:04 There's billions and billions, tens of billions of dollars that we're owed
02:56:07 that we're not receiving because of a lack of enforcement.
02:56:10 So we've laid out clear ways that we would increase revenue.
02:56:14 We've also talked about things that we would cut.
02:56:16 We would cut offshore tax havens, but we'd also cut fossil fuel subsidies
02:56:20 and private consultants and instead rely on our civil servants.
02:56:24 So we've laid out some of the real ways that we would do that,
02:56:26 whereas the Conservatives are very clear what they're going to do.
02:56:29 they're going to cut the services that people need. They've laid that out. And we've also seen
02:56:33 that, sadly, Mr. Carney has also talked about cutting services. And his plan to balance the
02:56:40 operating budget in three years would mean $43 billion in cuts. And so if you want someone
02:56:45 that's going to stand up and fight back against those cuts, hold the Liberals to account,
02:56:49 need to send new Democrats to Ottawa like you did before, and we're able to deliver dental care
02:56:53 and pharma care, send more new Democrats again to Ottawa, and we will fight back against these cuts.
02:56:58 You spoke the least this evening of all of the leaders.
02:57:01 I'm wondering how you feel about how you did tonight,
02:57:03 whether you were able to communicate your message to French-speaking Canadians.
02:57:07 Well, ultimately, the difference wasn't as big, but initially I was worried about it.
02:57:11 But I'm really proud that I was able to make the case to Canadians,
02:57:14 to Quebecers or French-speaking Canadians,
02:57:17 that what New Democrats are going to do is stand up for what matters most to you.
02:57:21 I made it a point to stand up for health care
02:57:23 because it is so fundamental to who we are as a country.
02:57:27 we fundamentally believe that we should take care of each other and healthcare represents that value
02:57:31 so I raised that I talked about how we can make life more affordable by by putting a price cap on
02:57:37 essential food items like other countries have done I talked about how we can stop big corporations
02:57:42 corporate landlords from buying up affordable homes I laid out how we would take the GST off
02:57:47 of your monthly bills like cell phone and internet and give people a real break and so in this
02:57:53 difficult time the question in this election is who's going to actually fight for you not the
02:57:58 billionaires and sending more new democrats to auto voting for us is how you have someone on
02:58:02 your side fighting for you question question you spoke about equal treatment from the moderator why
02:58:17 Why didn't you go after moderator in the debate answer?
02:58:21 Well, I was very passionate at that point in time,
02:58:25 but I spoke to Mr. Roy afterwards.
02:58:28 There's no issue.
02:58:29 I just wanted to talk about health care services,
02:58:33 something that saved my father's life
02:58:35 and something I used when I was studying law.
02:58:37 So I think it's fundamental that we defend health care
02:58:41 and health care services.
02:58:42 It's very personal to me.
02:58:43 So I'm very passionate about that.
02:58:45 And I had the opportunity of sharing to what extent it's important because we're faced with a crisis and it's a crisis that we can fix.
02:58:53 And I think people in Quebec, people across the country now know how important that is for me and how I can defend something that's key for me.
02:59:03 Question.
02:59:04 In the debate, you accused Pierre Paulievre of wanting to privatize health care.
02:59:09 What evidence do you have?
02:59:11 Answer.
02:59:11 Well, first of all, he proposes to make cuts in healthcare and in the programs that we
02:59:18 need so much.
02:59:19 And just like all other conservatives, when you look at their record, in every province
02:59:26 where you have conservatives who are allies of Pierre Collier, such as Daniel Smith,
02:59:32 for instance, Daniel Smith is in the process of massively privatizing the healthcare system
02:59:39 in alberta and she is she is allowing private companies to take up space in healthcare so
02:59:53 that is one thing they do and mr poilier is continuing the same tradition so he's proposing
02:59:59 massive cuts in healthcare and these cuts will accelerate privatization hello mr singh
03:00:06 Drea Humphrey with Rebel News.
03:00:08 Your party takes great pride in standing against hate,
03:00:11 such as white supremacy, Islamophobia, and online...
03:00:14 Sorry, I didn't get your outlet.
03:00:16 Drea Humphrey with Rebel News.
03:00:17 Okay.
03:00:18 You know where I'm going to go with this, though, right?
03:00:21 Can I speak?
03:00:22 Yeah, you can.
03:00:23 I'm just going to say you know where I'm going to go with it, though.
03:00:25 Your party takes pride in standing against hate,
03:00:27 such as white supremacy, Islamophobia, and online hate speech.
03:00:31 Yet you stay silent about ongoing attacks against Christians,
03:00:35 even after Conservative MP Jamil Javani's order paper question revealed that over 200 churches
03:00:41 have been targeted by arson and vandalism since claims of remains being discovered at former
03:00:47 residential schools swept the nation in 2021. These claims have been disproven by bands that
03:00:54 excavated and remain unproven by those that have not. Will you condemn the rise in acts of hate
03:01:01 against Christians today and explain what your party will do moving forward to keep Christians 0.75
03:01:07 safe from hate in Canada. Again, thank you, but I'm not going to respond to an organization that
03:01:13 promotes misinformation and disinformation like Rebel News, so no, I'm not going to respond to
03:01:18 your question. Please keep the questions and answers short. We're just getting up to the time.
03:01:23 Perhaps you didn't hear me. Over 200 Christian places of worship have been attacked in Canada
03:01:28 since 2021 many served first nations communities many were historic and they diverted police and
03:01:38 resources and put others at risk what do you say to canadians who see your refusal to answer
03:01:43 especially from one of the few media outlets here that are not funded by the state as proof
03:01:49 that a vote for you is a vote for a dangerous radical party that gaslights the public into
03:01:54 thinking it stands against hate when its silence is instead emboldening christophobia your question
03:02:02 is another example of why i don't respond to agencies like rebel news that promote misinformation
03:02:07 and disinformation question in french question for what outlet
03:02:21 converse it's an independent outlet in montreal many organizations including amnesty international
03:02:31 think that canada should withdraw from the third safe country agreement and the u.s supreme court
03:02:38 considers that the trump administration has taken illegal steps in this area so do you plan
03:02:46 to withdraw canada from this agreement on safe third country's answer while i'm faced with a
03:02:54 conundrum here because i don't quite know okay there's another journalist that i trust here so
03:03:02 i will answer your question i think it's a question about being compassion compassionate
03:03:09 if there are people in situations of crises and people are crossing the border because they are
03:03:15 afraid about what might happen to them in the u.s then we have to be compassionate towards them
03:03:21 i think the federal government hasn't been funding or providing the necessary resources
03:03:30 to help welcome people who are crossing the border illegally i've said in the past
03:03:39 that we need to suspend the safe third safe country agreement because we are aware of what's
03:03:47 happening in the us with donald trump and he's violating people's rights and there is when there
03:03:56 is a decision of the supreme court for instance he completely ignores it and puts people in danger
03:04:01 so we have to be compassionate and i maintain my position about suspending the agreement this was
03:04:08 the last question well Jagmeet Singh just completely embarrassed himself there right so you had
03:04:18 two women asking very good questions very interesting well researched well thought
03:04:24 out questions and he just has this weird he has this weird policy where it's just like i refuse
03:04:30 to talk to you it makes it look very small and petty i want to go back though to mark carney
03:04:35 because I can see on social media, the sort of usual voices in legacy media, people like Andrew
03:04:40 Coyne are very bothered by the fact that True North and Juno News were able to ask questions.
03:04:45 Well, guess what, Andrew Coyne? This is a free country. This is a democracy. And yes,
03:04:50 we have independent media. Our questions are different than the legacy media. And that is by
03:04:54 design, right? You ask the same boring questions that were already covered in the debate. Every
03:04:58 legacy media question is just rehashing something that we already heard about over the last two
03:05:02 hours. True North, Juno News, and The Rebel have different questions. We cover a different
03:05:07 perspective. We represent a different subset of Canadians. And the fact that Mark Kearney could
03:05:12 not answer our questions, right? He stumbled and bumbled his way through Keynes' response.
03:05:15 He couldn't decide whether he wanted to differentiate himself from Justin Trudeau.
03:05:20 The first 20 seconds of his response was absolutely brutal. And it wasn't until later
03:05:25 that he got up. And on genders, he didn't actually provide a good question, a good answer.
03:05:29 But the fact that he was stumbling and bumbling, again, show that he was caught off guard, which is good.
03:05:33 That's what you want of your leaders. That's the point of journalists.
03:05:35 Okay, Pierre Pauly-Everdon.
03:05:36 The French language outside of Quebec, are you talking about expanding, and you talk about expanding access to immersion.
03:05:42 But what do you think about hundreds of Francophone children who don't have a place for themselves in schools
03:05:48 because we are not building a sufficient number of Francophone schools outside of Quebec?
03:05:52 So will you support the construction of schools?
03:05:55 Answer. Thank you. This is a very good question.
03:05:59 i had the opportunity of going to a french immersion school where my father also taught
03:06:10 so this is something that is very important to me and i know that there's a lot of demand
03:06:16 but at the end of the day it's a provincial area of competence so it's up to them to decide what
03:06:25 schools are going to be built in what communities but i'm open to fully collaborate collaborating
03:06:32 with the provinces to make sure that more spaces are available but what i had in mind actually is
03:06:39 about an announcement we already shared on immersion opportunities which would allow
03:06:45 young adolescents to go to quebec to sagney and to other places where there is a high concentration
03:06:53 of uh french where they would only have the option of speaking french they would do that for five
03:06:59 weeks when i had when i was about 20 years old i had the opportunity to do something along those
03:07:05 lines and we would double such programs to allow young francophones to go to quebec and to take 0.99
03:07:13 part in these immersion programs so that they speak the french language better thank you question
03:07:19 francophone immigration outside of quebec mr carney announced their target going from 10 to 12
03:07:28 what's your objective what's your target answer i think it's a reasonable level i agree with him
03:07:36 on that and our party has already announced that we are in favor of increasing the number of
03:07:43 francophone immigrants who are who come to canada but who end up settling outside of quebec
03:07:50 so that we can add to the demographic weight and strengthen the french language so we will
03:07:56 work hand in hand with the different communities to increase the number of francophones who are
03:08:02 coming to canada to make it their country thank you sheila gun reed for rebel news yes we've seen
03:08:09 the NDP tonight refused to take questions from independent journalists. The Liberals have gone
03:08:14 one step further. The Carney campaign has called the police on independent journalists. Trudeau
03:08:19 before that brought in C-18, C-11. The Liberals are promising a revamped version of the Online
03:08:25 Harms Act. What would a Conservative government do to ensure the independence of the press
03:08:31 and protect Canadians' right to have access to information and hold their politicians to account?
03:08:37 We are the only party that's willing to protect freedom of the press, of all the media, and we will also repeal C11, the censorship law.
03:08:48 We will remove the censorship of Canadian news on web platforms like Facebook and Instagram, and we will fight back against any kind of Orwellian online censorship law like the one that the previous Liberal government instituted.
03:09:13 it was designed to create the possibility of preemptive arrests of people where you could
03:09:22 be arrested if you were suspected of sometime in the future planning to say something harmful
03:09:29 online you could be under a peace bond I mean that is it really is Orwellian and I note that
03:09:36 many people across the spectrum have spoken out against this censorship even someone like Margaret
03:09:42 Atwood, not known to be a conservative, has said that this kind of censorship is not only bad for
03:09:49 democracy, but inhibits artistic expression. So I stand for free speech, and we will respect the
03:09:56 right of Canadians to have access to the media that they choose. My follow-up, Canada's suffering 0.65
03:10:05 the most violent anti-Semitic crime wave in history. Yes. There have been shootings, fire
03:10:10 bombings, even a riot right here in Montreal. But not all of this anti-Semitic hatred and
03:10:16 incitement rises to the high level of a criminal co-defense. Do you believe that foreign nationals, 0.72
03:10:22 that is people who are not Canadian citizens, should be deported for participating in these 1.00
03:10:28 hate marches or other pro-Hamas activities that don't rise to the level of a crime?
03:10:33 Well, what I have said is when there is a crime involved, including crimes of vandalism, that visitors to Canada should be deported.
03:10:45 You simply can't come here and firebomb a Jewish bakery or someone's home or smash windows out of a political riot and expect to stay in this country if you are on a visitor visa.
03:10:58 We will be bringing in tougher laws to penalize those who are permanent residents and citizens who break laws and harm our communities. 1.00
03:11:08 But look, this is the disintegration we have witnessed after the lost liberal decade.
03:11:15 Everybody is divided. This group is divided against that group. There is crime and chaos in our streets.
03:11:22 The Liberals have promoted this division by saying one thing to one group
03:11:27 and then exactly the opposite to a different group.
03:11:31 We had a tradition in this country before this government
03:11:35 where you could come from conflict-ridden places in the world
03:11:39 and you would leave the fight behind.
03:11:43 You might have a debate about the politics of that place
03:11:46 when you sat down in a coffee shop in Montreal or Toronto,
03:11:49 but it never overflowed into street violence we need to get back to that you should know we welcome
03:11:55 people this country sure bring your culture bring your traditions bring your family but do not bring
03:12:02 foreign conflicts onto our streets we want we're going to have peaceful streets again and we're
03:12:08 going to be united we should put all of us should consider ourselves canadian first and put foreign 0.98
03:12:14 divisions behind us thank you for taking my question thank you please keep your questions
03:12:20 and answers short thank you christopher curtis the rover uh mr parliev uh question mr parliev
03:12:29 jagmeet singh referred to what's happening in gaza and said that it's a genocide i understand that
03:12:34 that's not your opinion but the government of israel is talking about emptying gaza of palestinians 1.00
03:12:42 So can you at least call that ethnic cleansing?
03:12:48 Do you have, can you even criticize Israel?
03:12:52 Answer, we of course can criticize anyone.
03:12:56 But let us not forget that Hamas attacked Israel without provocation, 0.87
03:13:01 with the sole purpose of killing and violating Israel 0.98
03:13:12 and the highest number of civilians possible.
03:13:18 So this was an invasion by Hamas, which was not provoked. 0.51
03:13:24 And unfortunately, there's a lot of suffering among Palestinians,
03:13:28 but the the blame is belongs to Hamas they are doing everything they can to 0.82
03:13:38 extend the conflict so I reject the approach adopted by mr. Singh we will
03:13:47 remain allies and fight against terrorism question well bombs have been
03:13:56 dropped on every university in gaza there is no longer a functional hospital and people
03:14:01 need everything so can you criticize israel at the very least for what they have done
03:14:13 answer well in a situation where you have a terrorist group who crosses a border
03:14:20 to deliberately target children, women, and civilians,
03:14:28 a country has no choice but to defend itself.
03:14:33 Now, should that country take every measure
03:14:38 to avoid other civilian tragedies?
03:14:42 Absolutely.
03:14:42 Absolutely. But Hamas wants to maximize the number of Palestinians who end up dying.
03:14:56 So that is their objective. They're maximizing the sufferance of the Palestinian people. 1.00
03:15:03 Thank you very much. Thanks, everyone.
03:15:07 okay david i know you have to jump off in a few minutes i'm going to try to get
03:15:14 kian bexty to jump on but uh i just want to inform the audience of the total meltdown that
03:15:21 is happening online and on the cbc uh i don't think we're able to clip and show but uh rosemary
03:15:27 barton uh on the cbc was very up in arms with the fact that true north asked that question
03:15:33 and we're seeing a meltdown um so david what do you think i think it's fantastic i honestly
03:15:40 this debate and these questions are renewing my sense of a civic culture of debate and open
03:15:48 discussion in canada it's exactly what canadians need and want there's just far too much that
03:15:54 happens in the country that hasn't been addressed i didn't know i you know and i consider myself
03:15:59 well-informed i didn't know that 200 churches have been vandalized or burned i didn't know it was
03:16:04 that extreme and to watch we track it you can go to arson tracker um arson what is the url anyway
03:16:10 if you go to juneau news we have a tab and cosmic georgia has been tracking it for the last three
03:16:15 years and his report has like it's like the most viewed thing ever on true north it's got like
03:16:22 tens of millions of views and it's featured on like cnn and all just like we were the ones doing
03:16:27 that but yeah i mean go ahead look i just think around the dinner table if the purpose of debate
03:16:34 in in a civil society is to force people to have hard conversations about what kind of culture
03:16:39 they want to live in what kind of society they want to live in the issues that were raised by
03:16:43 independent media are far closer to the conversations people are going to have around
03:16:47 their dinner table tonight and i think that uh i expect the mainstream media to melt down because
03:16:53 as their grit is loosened even in a moment like this basic questions about transgenderism basic
03:17:00 questions about a double standard when it comes to racism or the protection of christians versus
03:17:05 islamophobia which is a sort of pet this sort of uh commentary from the left you know the
03:17:13 those notions are the things that people care about talk about and want their country to reflect
03:17:18 and i think that the fact that they've been raised is fantastic i expect to see a meltdown
03:17:23 by mainstream media because they're losing power and part of the reason they're losing power is
03:17:28 because they're not asking some of those hard questions they're not challenging this bizarre
03:17:33 lack of evidence around the residential school issues they're not challenging the fact that
03:17:37 these churches are being burnt down and they're not challenging the double standards of some of
03:17:41 these political leaders jagmeet singh did himself probably the biggest disservice i've ever seen a
03:17:46 politician do to himself in the way that he reacted to the two women i think it was lavoie
03:17:51 and then uh the other andre drea yeah yeah and i just think his his contempt for the importance of
03:18:00 those questions he had the right to say look typically i don't respond to the rebel news
03:18:04 because i don't like the you know the way they they cut questions i think it's misinformation
03:18:09 you raise an important point here's here's the way i would respond to it there were graceful
03:18:14 ways to accept the premise of the question, respond to it without, and while still making
03:18:20 the point that he wanted to make that Rebel News wasn't his favorite outlet. But he showed himself
03:18:25 to be intellectually insecure and actually not a leader, not in this country, not respectful
03:18:30 enough of people and the questions they had to ask. So I loved it. So far, terrific, terrific
03:18:36 debate. I think Pierre is the winner coming out of this. Yeah, I agree. And I thought that he had
03:18:41 a great answer for Sheila Gunn-Reed, who had a great question as well. And I love the fact
03:18:46 that independent media are allowed. Because interestingly, when Mark Carney was answering
03:18:50 Kian Bexley's question, right? So I thought it was going to be number one. There's two lineups,
03:18:55 right? The way it works is there's two lineups and two mics, and we don't know which one's going
03:18:58 to go. So he was at the front of one lineup. The one was on the front of the other. So he got to
03:19:02 answer the question. Mark Carney clearly didn't know who he was. And so he answered, and he
03:19:06 actually, you know, I seemed to think that it was a good question because he said, I don't recognize
03:19:10 you you haven't been at my other press conferences and he kind of gave him a little invitation i'll
03:19:14 have to go back and watch exactly what he said but he basically invited kian to come back to
03:19:18 future press conferences which is interesting because obviously it's his people that are
03:19:22 blocking independent journalists from coming and so the media get up in arms about the fact that
03:19:26 we are able oh we've got kian here so let's go to him question kian uh tell us tell us uh what's
03:19:34 what's happening in Montreal. Hey, I'm just standing outside of the venue. The CBC is running
03:19:39 this operation. So they have banned us from actually reporting inside the venue, which is
03:19:45 really frustrating. So we're standing outside with no equipment calling into the show.
03:19:51 What's interesting, though, is if you look over my shoulder right here,
03:19:55 in these tents, you have Rosemary Barton right now, absolutely seething that so many conservative or 1.00
03:20:02 or independent journalists even, I mean, a lot of these people weren't really observable.
03:20:06 We'll get out of the wind here because it's quite windy here.
03:20:09 A lot of these independent journalists asked great questions, really, really thoughtful questions from Rebel News as well.
03:20:16 Drea, Sheila, they asked some of the most topical questions of the night, including Alex from True North,
03:20:21 who actually, you know, it's one of those classic gotcha questions.
03:20:25 How many genders are there? 1.00
03:20:27 but then he followed it up with a really, really substantive question about what's happening to
03:20:32 women in women's sports, in women's prisons even. So I think that if we didn't have independent 1.00
03:20:38 media here, we would have lost a lot. You know, I asked Mark Carney a pretty clear question about
03:20:43 the people that are standing behind him and how they're virtually identical to Justin Trudeau's
03:20:49 legion of liberals and how he can sort of stand behind that and defend their ideology, their
03:20:54 ideas and beliefs and sort of pretend like he's changed Stephen Gilboa's mind on carbon taxes,
03:21:00 which he obviously hasn't. Someone who climbs the CN Tower to protest in favor of locking down
03:21:06 the country to stop climate change is not someone who just changes their mind because there's a new
03:21:12 leader in town. I'm sure maybe cynically to grab more power and to consolidate that and to secure
03:21:18 another four years. But in the second year of their term, you know exactly what's going to
03:21:22 happen. In fact, I can't remember the name of the specific liberal. There was an Ontario liberal
03:21:27 candidate that just said today that she couldn't promise that the carbon tax wouldn't come back 0.88
03:21:32 in the next term, that this wasn't the end of the carbon tax. It was just a pause, which is
03:21:36 absolutely outrageous, but pretty obvious if you come to think about it, that leopards don't really
03:21:41 change their stripes, even though Mark Carney is trying to pretend like they're a different band of
03:21:46 politicians than Justin Trudeau had following him around as he destroyed the country. It's the same
03:21:52 people, the same problems, the same policies that destroyed this country. Well, maybe you can
03:21:57 remember a bit better than I did, but it seemed like Mark Kearney invited you to come back to
03:22:02 future press conferences. Did you catch him say something like that? Yeah, he said something along
03:22:07 the lines of that. I'm definitely going to keep trying. But of course, yeah, that was the one
03:22:11 takeaway was that he said he hasn't seen me around much, which is a little bit surprising
03:22:15 because he called the police on me at his campaign launch,
03:22:19 which is just, you know, people, Canadians understand what he's doing.
03:22:23 He's gaslighting. He is a gaslighter.
03:22:25 You know, I was going to ask him a question about Jelaine Maxwell
03:22:28 and how friendly he is.
03:22:30 You know, I sent Jelaine a letter in prison, actually,
03:22:33 to talk to her about Mark Carney's weird, strange history with her,
03:22:37 where they end up rolling around in the grass together in London
03:22:40 and spending a lot of time together.
03:22:42 I thought I'll take it easy on Mark, but he treated me quite poorly.
03:22:45 You know, I asked him a pretty fair question. Was Justin Trudeau a good prime minister? That's something that Pierre Polyev would be able to answer pretty clearly about Stephen Harper. But Mark Carney just waffled in a lot of ums, a lot of ahs. And he didn't really have an answer to the question, which I thought was pretty fair, given my history of some pointed questions that I usually ask politicians. I gave it to him easy.
03:23:08 And then the follow-up was a little bit harder, of course, but I had to be the way he was treating me.
03:23:12 I think that it's fair that we sort of, we sting him a bit with some questions that the CBC would never ask.
03:23:18 Well, exactly, right?
03:23:19 So when the legacy media showed up to the mic after the debates, they asked the same questions that we had already covered in the debates, right?
03:23:25 The debates talked a lot about the costing of the platforms, a lot about the environment, like they covered immigration.
03:23:31 And yet they just asked the same questions, whereas it was the independent press.
03:23:36 I love the fact that there were such an array of voices.
03:23:38 There were a couple of independent outlets that I had never heard of before asking questions.
03:23:42 I don't think that they were all conservative.
03:23:44 I think a couple of them were French language.
03:23:46 A couple of them were probably even on the left.
03:23:48 And that's fantastic.
03:23:49 And it's just so interesting to see the media melting down.
03:23:52 I know it's quite cold for you, Kian, so I don't want to keep you too much longer. 1.00
03:23:57 But, you know, any sort of final takeaway thoughts you want to share with the audience here?
03:24:03 Oh, it looks like we might have lost.
03:24:04 I think that the real debate, I hope you can hear me, the real debate is going to be tomorrow.
03:24:09 I always find it so funny that we pretend to be a bilingual country.
03:24:14 It's only really a bilingual country here in Quebec.
03:24:16 It's the only people that really care about tonight's debate.
03:24:19 Of course, there's people in the bubble like you and I and our viewers who care deeply about politics in the state of the country.
03:24:25 But most people in Vancouver are not tuning in tonight.
03:24:28 So tomorrow it's going to be big.
03:24:30 We're going to be making sure to ask some pretty tough questions tomorrow as well.
03:24:34 uh it's i guess we'll just uh we'll have to see what happens in that debate pierre was obviously
03:24:39 quite feisty today i think i i haven't watched the show yet that that you guys have been hosting
03:24:45 here today uh so i don't know what your thoughts were on it but i thought that pierre did pretty
03:24:49 well you know bias aside obviously i think conservatives perform better than liberals on
03:24:53 an average day but i think he did really well i think mark carney really failed from the french
03:24:57 people that i spoke with and from the translators that were really struggling to keep up i don't
03:25:02 really resonated with the French language that his campaign thought or at least hoped that he would.
03:25:09 But, you know, I'm willing to be persuaded one way or the other.
03:25:12 That's just my initial thoughts from what I saw.
03:25:15 Yeah, I think we tend to agree.
03:25:17 I think that Pierre held the zone.
03:25:18 And from my perspective, what he was saying was completely right other than the last bit on abortion.
03:25:23 But everything else I was right there for.
03:25:25 I think for the French audience, though, I thought that Yves Francois Blanchet did really well
03:25:31 did really well and our audience poll on youtube said that pierre poly of like wiped the floor i
03:25:35 think you got 90. david i know you have to jump off um so did you want to make any final uh
03:25:40 statements before we wrap it up here well first first again you know way to go this is what
03:25:46 canadians have been looking for this is you do so much hard work just to get yourself into the lineup
03:25:52 i don't know what tricks you had to pull to do that but i know there's a back story and i'd love
03:25:57 to hear about it but you know as a canadian that thinks that there's a lot to play for a lot to
03:26:03 fight for a lot to talk about in this country seeing you get up there and ask that question
03:26:10 and make the point just so encouraging this is what the nation needs more of of course rosemary
03:26:15 barton and andrew coin and others that have had these legacy positions they're boring they're
03:26:20 largely unwatched and and it's this that creates vibrancy but it also creates what we're talking
03:26:26 about before this is what people really want to talk about around the kitchen table there's a lot
03:26:31 of people that feel like they're losing their country as they see churches burn and police
03:26:35 disinterested in finding out who did it there's a lot of people that think that the scandal of
03:26:40 this academic fraud that blamed the churches for uh you know missing persons and residential stuff
03:26:47 that has never been called out and is actually being treated as hate speech in some quarters
03:26:52 is just wrong it's a violation of kind of ethics transgenderism is something we have to debate 0.93
03:26:56 all of those things are verboten for people like rosemary barton and andrew coin but they're what
03:27:01 everybody actually cares about in the country and wants to talk about because this is the country
03:27:06 their kids are going to inherit and and i so kudos to you to get to the front of the line
03:27:12 and i just couldn't be happier to see that debate i thought the debate was excellent
03:27:16 it was free form i thought i thought the host did a great job of allowing people to engage
03:27:20 and I think that independent media came out in a huge way on this and I'm glad
03:27:27 that traditional media is gonna melt down. Thanks for saying that I appreciate it
03:27:33 you're absolutely right there's a lot of there's a lot of toying around that goes
03:27:36 into the behind the scenes of getting in line first it's something I pride
03:27:40 myself in and being able to weasel my way in before anyone realizes that a line
03:27:44 is forming and then it's too late the lineup was 30 people long so it's it was
03:27:50 a very you know i got in there with alex we sort of had planned out how we were going to get in
03:27:54 there and make make the line instead of waiting for the line and that ended up working out and
03:27:59 seeing the legacy journalists like justin ling in the back uh just seething that they weren't
03:28:05 going to get a question in was uh really satisfying and you know you talk about rosemary
03:28:09 barton and i pointed out the little cabana that she's in right now talking with all of her friends
03:28:14 in the cbc if you want some entertainment tonight i really recommend watching some reruns of their
03:28:20 responses to independent journalists questions i've been getting texts all night about how
03:28:26 rosemary barton was just seething losing her mind that so many evil conservatives were asking 1.00
03:28:32 questions uh it was it's going to be some good watching with popper and when i go back to my
03:28:36 hotel i'm surely going to be watching a lot of that i got to get going uh thanks so much for
03:28:43 your time man and go uh go warm up and uh yeah we'll have you back on tomorrow thanks and uh
03:28:49 david i believe you have to go too so i appreciate your time is there any uh i don't know if you
03:28:53 have to jump off right now if you want to uh i've got five more minutes uh okay you know it's so
03:28:59 this was great great coverage janice but kudos to you and kian at being able to you know take
03:29:06 a moment like this and expand the horizon of people's thinking on these issues i think you
03:29:12 know, it's been a really tough election to watch as a conservative because I feel like so much,
03:29:18 so many of the things that really are worthy of debate have kind of been pushed aside by the
03:29:22 framing that's happened with the proroguing of parliament. The control over the media has meant
03:29:28 that mainstream media is worried about a conservative win. And that's kind of, you know,
03:29:34 added to the constraints, I think, on the Polly F campaign. There's been conservative infighting,
03:29:39 which we do all the time anyway, as conservatives, that have had taken a toll.
03:29:44 But I feel like this debate marked a bit of a turning point on a couple of key issues
03:29:49 and certainly a turning point for the role independent media has taken
03:29:53 in reframing the kinds of conversations that are going to happen around the country.
03:29:57 And I think all of that is going to set up here to have a different kind of week.
03:30:01 And I think Carney is going to wake up on the wrong side of some Quebec polls.
03:30:06 and i think that's going to put pressure on his ontario game um i think the outcome so three
03:30:11 things from this one i think this was blanchette's night and i think he's going to win some seats
03:30:16 back in quebec and that's going to hurt the liberals two i think it was pauliav's night
03:30:21 number two and uh he's gonna be seen in a different light by an important constituency i think he
03:30:29 you know is going to have a chance to redeem himself with boomers and with women on the way 0.97
03:30:33 some of these debates went but that's i expect to see more of that and i think that that ontario
03:30:39 um the ontario dynamic the 905 what happens with doug ford etc is going to become an important part
03:30:46 of what happens the next two weeks but um i think we'll see what happens at the polls but i think
03:30:52 we'll have to get another show going here soon because my guess is they're going to shift and
03:30:56 and we're going to be in, you know, two to three point differences tied all the way into probably
03:31:03 minority party either direction. I sense that you're right. You know, we did think that going
03:31:08 into this election that it could have been a landslide for the Conservatives, but it doesn't
03:31:11 look like that's going to happen. But I don't think it's over. I think it's incredibly close.
03:31:15 We had a pullout today done in-house by our Juno News pollsters. And, you know, it's within a point
03:31:21 or two so pierre has made up any of the lead that he may have lost throughout the campaign and i
03:31:27 think you're right i think that carney had a bad night tonight um i don't know that very many
03:31:30 canadians are watching these debates um interestingly uh some of the independent
03:31:34 streamers had really big numbers i noticed viva fry on x had like 13 000 people watching northern
03:31:40 perspective on youtube at one point had like 10 or 11 000 um the pleb had six or seven thousand
03:31:45 as well i think we had maybe two two two two and a half so pretty respectable but
03:31:50 like you know not not not huge huge numbers i think i suspect they'll be bigger tomorrow
03:31:55 um but the thing is these things get clipped right and those little moments um go far and
03:32:00 that's why i think that the questions that we ask are interesting because they're already
03:32:04 starting to prompt conversations on social media and they're just different than the questions
03:32:08 legacy media asks so you know whether you like them or not it's like the fact that carney couldn't
03:32:13 really answer either of the questions right he he stumbled bumbled through whether trudeau was a
03:32:19 good prime minister and that was telling that he felt very uncomfortable answering that question
03:32:23 and then same with the gender thing you know like he he didn't actually answer the question he said
03:32:28 when it comes to sexes too right but that's not the question and then when it came to uh women's 1.00
03:32:32 only spaces he just kind of gave boiler point like stumbled his way through as fast as he could and
03:32:37 then got out so the fact that he was deeply uncomfortable obviously he hadn't prepped at
03:32:42 all for those kind of questions which again is there's value to that right like that's the point
03:32:45 of journalists to ask tough questions like you might hate the questions but the job is to ask
03:32:51 tough questions and i think that both true north uh alex zoltan and juno's kian bexy just
03:32:58 accomplished that goal exactly and it was unfortunate that the uh rebel questions from
03:33:03 drea humphries and alexa dwa refused to be answered by jagmeet singh but again that really
03:33:09 reveals his character right he's been doing this shtick i think for three elections now
03:33:12 and people are like okay so you don't like these late these female reporters like that that's sort 1.00
03:33:18 of a bad reflection on you um it's a it's a closed-minded it's a closed-minded dogmatic
03:33:23 ideological position by somebody who's intellectually threatened by two bright women
03:33:27 asking hard questions about real issues that people talk about so and this is the classic
03:33:33 move by the left this is why no one trusts the left when they say they want to pass laws against
03:33:37 misinformation because what he showed in in the way he reacted to those people is he considers
03:33:44 other people's legitimate questions about his perspectives as a political leader in this
03:33:48 country to be beyond the pale simply by their affiliation with the platform that's asking
03:33:53 those questions that's the kind of guy that wants the legal right to determine what's misinformation
03:33:58 in this country no thank you right and he's illustrated why we can't trust people with 0.99
03:34:04 that kind of language and those kinds of leaders well and it's kind of interesting because at some
03:34:09 point in the campaign the left the cbc they were trying to take aim at pierre polyev for not
03:34:15 answering enough questions for legacy media pierre play would never do that and has never done that
03:34:18 just like knock down saying like i refuse to answer a question from the cbc like no he will
03:34:23 actually take a step further and embarrass the journalist by showing how little they know about
03:34:28 the topic so if jagmeet singh wanted to like flex his intellectualism and say i don't like the rebel
03:34:35 and this is why i'm going to dissect your question and tell you the seven reasons why
03:34:39 it's an illegitimate question that that would actually i would i would respect that now of
03:34:42 course he can't do that because the questions were well researched and they were intellectual
03:34:46 and they were real questions and jagmeet singh probably doesn't have the capacity to go through
03:34:51 them and dissect them like that but he quite embarrassed himself and it's interesting that
03:34:55 the media has is i i we we had um another journalist there who didn't ask the questions
03:35:01 but he sent us a video note and we're not gonna play it but he said that basically inside any time
03:35:08 that a leader was taking a shot at peer poly of that the journalists were all like kind of cheering
03:35:13 and laughing like they're you know politics is is like a it's like sports spectators for and
03:35:18 the journalists were like openly emotionally showing their disdain for pierre poly of during
03:35:24 in the debate mocking him laughing him um and so you know they they expected that all the other
03:35:29 journalists were like on their team and they didn't really quite realize that some of the
03:35:32 people in there were independent journalists who were actually like that in of itself is news the
03:35:35 fact that these journalists are like scoffing and laughing at Pierre Polyev and like happy when a
03:35:41 tough question gets asked at him and like you know like they've been exposed to just be total
03:35:48 partisan frauds, in my opinion.
03:35:50 Absolutely. No, they wear the same color jersey right under their outfit. They're wearing
03:35:56 team liberal party NDP jerseys. They have a vested personal interest. And this is typical
03:36:03 of the press, which is what makes independent press so important, because it's okay for there
03:36:08 to be hard left journalists. I don't mind if there's a Marxist journalist that wants to ask
03:36:11 a question of Jagmeet Singh or Per Polly. That's what makes society strong. If you don't know how
03:36:16 to respond to a question from someone that believes the state should own everything then
03:36:21 you shouldn't be a political leader in a country that has people that have that viewpoint because
03:36:25 the laws you have to pass will have to deal with that viewpoint and point out why that viewpoint
03:36:29 is horrible for humanity uh right like you've got to understand those things and that's what
03:36:34 creates strength in in any society and i think i think uh i just feel incredibly proud of uh it's
03:36:42 it's juno and true north and rebel showed up and asked great questions hard questions and they
03:36:48 showed by asking those questions what a guy like jagmeet singh is made of you know the illustration
03:36:55 the fact that he couldn't answer the fact that he tried to grandstand uh his non-answers has painted
03:37:02 him to into a corner and reduced him completely as an individual that hopes to lead so terrific
03:37:07 absolutely terrific night for the country terrific for independent media and a great debate that the
03:37:13 hosts should be very proud of themselves one of my favorite points by the way was i've got a lot
03:37:19 of friends internationally and they'll they'll sort of you know they'll they'll key into something
03:37:23 and i i think if you keyed into that debate and saw the seriousness with which it was announced
03:37:28 that because there's a hockey game on tonight we're pushing the day forward i mean it's just
03:37:33 there's something there's something stereotypically canadian isn't it it's beautiful yeah yeah well i
03:37:39 made a tick tock about that but i was saying i don't think we're a real country when the hockey
03:37:42 games who precedes democracy but you know maybe that's what we think that might that might mean
03:37:49 we've got you know less to worry about than we think if that's a lot enough that's a good point
03:37:55 that's a good point all right david well i really appreciate having you on hopefully we'll have you
03:37:57 back i think you're going to join us again tomorrow we're going to do the show again for
03:38:01 the english debate and i think it'll be really good we're really looking forward to that so
03:38:05 uh thanks for your time tonight as always that's david knight leg who is a political commentator
03:38:09 from alberta thank you so much you bet talk soon goodbye all right folks well we're gonna wrap it
03:38:15 up i really appreciate everyone who stayed on and watched thank you for the super chats as well let
03:38:20 me just pull open because i think we've been keeping a list of these super chats so we had
03:38:24 earlier in the show stavano who gave us 140 dollars said candace thank you let's go pierre yes
03:38:29 i would farm girl that gave 25 with no comment but thank you farm girl we had d.y pep ten dollars
03:38:36 this is carney's voice did they use ai when carney responds to full canadians uh i don't know but i
03:38:43 did i did comment that i didn't like the voices that they used for the translators i felt like
03:38:48 they gave pier poliev an annoying voice um and it it was very off-putting and i think that
03:38:56 Blanchett got the nice voice, the one with the British accent. So that was interesting. Anyway,
03:39:00 folks, I'll be back. I'm going to do a show tomorrow for the KS Podcast show. And I'm really
03:39:04 looking forward to it because I'm going to provide the highlights of the debate and some of the
03:39:08 lowlights of the responses to our questions. And you're going to want to see that. And then tomorrow
03:39:13 night, we'll be back. The debate is later, I believe it starts at 8pm Eastern time. And so
03:39:18 we'll have a similar format. And we'll also try to get our reporters to call in after the event.
03:39:23 and hopefully they'll get some more questions i don't know i don't know if they'll be allowed back
03:39:28 in the building after tonight but hopefully they will and you know this is the great thing about
03:39:35 these debates like the reason that independent media are able to come into the room is because
03:39:40 of a lawsuit that myself and ezra levant filed back in 2019 we sued the government uh i sued
03:39:47 to get andrew lawton who was then my reporter he's now a conservative candidate uh to get into the
03:39:51 room and ezra sued to get his reporter at the time who was keen bexty into the room we all went to
03:39:57 court that day in toronto i had my baby with me because i didn't have a babysitter that day but
03:40:02 we had to go to court we found out at the last minute that we had a court hearing the judge
03:40:06 sided with us and said these are journalists you cannot prevent them from going in and asking
03:40:10 questions and so he issued an emergency order for us to go in so andrew lawton and kian bexty
03:40:17 rushed to the debate, got their questions to Justin Trudeau. They both put great questions
03:40:22 to Trudeau. Back then Andrew Lawton asked about press freedom and tried to get Trudeau to pledge
03:40:26 to allow independent reporters into the room, which he obviously wouldn't do. And Kian Bextie
03:40:32 asked some great questions about Trudeau's time as a teacher at West Point Grey Academy.
03:40:38 And you know this is the point of a free society and a democracy is that we should have a free
03:40:45 press where journalists can ask any questions that they want they can ask whatever the hell they want
03:40:48 and the fact that the questions are different the questions make some elites feel uncomfortable
03:40:53 they make people like rosemary barton andrew coin clutch their pearls uh that's a good thing and you
03:40:58 know politics is supposed to be filled with important questions sometimes they make you
03:41:03 feel uncomfortable because we don't agree on everything and so i do want to know what mark
03:41:07 carney's position is on how many genders there are and the fact that he failed to answer that question
03:41:13 was interesting of itself and the fact that he swarmed his way through that other question about
03:41:18 women-only spaces a lot of women are listening to that a lot of women hear that they worry about 0.97
03:41:23 their their daughters in sports they worry about female change rooms female bathrooms 1.00
03:41:29 it's a legitimate concern and the fact that he could not answer that question is newsworthy right
03:41:36 and so i am very proud of those reporters for doing their job and i am very grateful to the
03:41:41 audience who has supported our ability to cover this election we have a fun going at support
03:41:47 juno.com if you want to support our ability to do these kind of things to pay the bills
03:41:51 to get these fellas onto airplanes to go ask questions to these leaders you can pitch in
03:41:57 over there really appreciate we've got a few more super chats here dean wolf gave us 25
03:42:02 dollars thank you very much dean i've got tracy irons at 279 thank you tracy and folks
03:42:09 If you're not already, please head over to Juno News and subscribe to our website, subscribe to our newsletter. We put out independent news. We put out 10 or 12 stories every day, multiple videos. We have all kinds of special perks for subscribers. I really encourage you to support independent media by paying for it.
03:42:28 It's a service that we provide, and it's, you know, I think that independent media proved itself
03:42:34 tonight very proud of the rebel and the questions that they were able to ask. Again, questions that
03:42:40 the legacy media should ask, right? The legacy media represents a very small portion of Canadians,
03:42:45 and there are millions, if not tens of millions of Canadians who fall outside of that very narrow
03:42:50 field of legacy media, the way that they think about the world, the questions they're interested
03:42:55 in the things that they care about and all the rest of us we deserve to be represented as well
03:43:00 and to have our voice heard on nights like tonight so appreciate everyone for your support we're
03:43:05 going to wrap up this live stream now i'll just say uh you know behind the scenes we had uh
03:43:10 producers sean and phil uh thanks guys you guys are awesome you guys rock um and then clayton
03:43:15 domain as well flew out to montreal hopefully he'll be able to get in line and get questions
03:43:19 for tomorrow. Of course, Alex Zoltan, a legend with that question, Epic, and Kian Bextie doing
03:43:26 just an absolutely fantastic job. So thanks so much, guys. And thanks, everyone in the audience
03:43:31 for tuning in. We'll wrap it up. Thank you so much. We'll be back again tomorrow. Get us welcome.
03:43:35 God bless.
03:43:49 Thank you.
03:44:19 Thank you.
03:44:49 Let's go.
03:45:19 Thank you.