Juno News - February 26, 2025


LIVE Coverage of the FINAL Liberal Party Debate

Topics
Mentioned
“We must do everything in our power to enable Ukraine to secure a just and lasting peace.” - Trudeau Carney Caught LYING again!?

Episode Stats


Length

2 hours and 13 minutes

Words per minute

175.63

Word count

23,441

Sentence count

1,389

Harmful content

Misogyny

17

sentences flagged

Toxicity

9

sentences flagged

Hate speech

19

sentences flagged


Summary

Summaries generated with gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ .

Join us as we cover the final liberal party debate, the leadership debate, and all the reaction to it. We have a special live show for you where we cover it for you with our co-host, Kian Bexty.

Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Topics generated with Qwen2.5-3B-Instruct.
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 hi and welcome to the canis welcome show i'm your host canis milk we have a special live show for
00:00:12 you tonight to cover the final liberal party debate the leadership debate there's just two
00:00:18 last night was the french debate tonight is the english debate and we are going to have the entire
00:00:23 debate for you and i'm joined on this broadcast very pleased to be joined by kian bexty kian
00:00:29 bexty is a co-founder of juno news my business partner and he is a host here as well kian welcome
00:00:34 to the broadcast thanks for having me i'm excited to see what happens today if mark carney drops
00:00:40 the ball again uh or if he's going to be a little quicker on his feet in english well it's pretty
00:00:46 unbelievable i mean this guy has sort of come from nowhere he's the savior of the liberal party it's
00:00:51 really unbelievable seeing what's happened in the polls over the last six weeks it's it's really
00:00:56 unbelievable. I could not have predicted that we would be back in a situation where we're neck and
00:01:01 neck, where the liberals and the conservatives are tied in national polls. There was a poll
00:01:05 at TodayKian that showed that Mark Carney was up, that the liberals were up by 2% over the
00:01:10 conservatives. I've never seen anything like this. I think that the media is in overdrive doing
00:01:17 absolutely everything that they can to promote their man, to promote the World Economic Forum
00:01:22 Davos elite, Mark Carney, that they want him to be leader. They're covering for him.
00:01:27 It was a complete disaster for him last night. And yet you barely even saw coverage of that
00:01:31 in the legacy media today. It'll be interesting to see what happens in the debate. I think
00:01:36 not much will happen. They all agree with each other. They all have the same platform and the
00:01:40 same opinions. It's really just a matter of who the messenger would be. And it seems that Mark
00:01:44 Carney has the highest favorables and he is pretty much the shoe in. What do you think of all this?
00:01:51 They have their playbook down pat, and it works time and time again.
00:01:55 I mean, it worked for Justin Trudeau, one of the most incompetent people in the world.
00:01:59 So it's going to work for Mark Carney.
00:02:01 It appears like it's working for Mark Carney.
00:02:03 And the playbook is this.
00:02:05 Make sure that absolutely no critical questions get asked.
00:02:09 None at all.
00:02:10 Control everyone who's allowed to be close to Mark Carney.
00:02:13 Control his itinerary.
00:02:14 Do not share that with anyone.
00:02:16 You control the message so long as you control the questions.
00:02:19 And they did that.
00:02:20 The police dragged me out of his very first press conference. That was the stage that they set with Mark Carney's leadership bid. And it's what they've been going with ever since. I don't know if we'll be able to pull up this video quickly enough, but it's basically a question that Mark Carney gets asked by a local journalist from some sort of ethnic media.
00:02:41 that he just drags out this question that's like two minutes long explaining why it's an important
00:02:46 question to ask and who this guy is that's asking the question and how credible he is.
00:02:51 And it just went nowhere. And Mark Conning was thrilled because it ate up the press's time to
00:02:54 ask anything serious like, hey, what's up with your friendship with Jelaine Maxwell? Why are
00:03:00 you such good friends with her? And why is your wife such personal friends? Did you know that 0.96
00:03:04 Jelaine Maxwell was the person that she was while you were such good friends with her over the last
00:03:09 decade you know these questions are like pretty obvious you'd think that the cbc would be
00:03:14 interested in asking just the bare minimum about who this guy is but really we have no idea outside
00:03:19 of his investment banking history where he um and central banking history where he claims credit for
00:03:26 the work of others um we don't know anything about him which is why he's pulling well you know some
00:03:31 people say that the the liberal party might be pulling well because there is nobody at the top
00:03:37 to be taking the bruising from the punching but I I don't know I you know maybe maybe once uh he's
00:03:44 the leader the mainstream media will start asking him critical questions but I highly doubt it I
00:03:48 highly doubt it it will fall to us again. No they won't they don't want to know they don't want
00:03:52 anybody to know I mean this is the reason that Ruby Dalla got disqualified right we know this 0.99
00:03:56 we heard a liberal strategist former chief of staff to a liberal minister Stephen O'Brien going
00:04:01 on CBC and she literally said, I hope that they find a credible reason to disqualify Ruby Dalla
00:04:07 because if she's allowed on that debate stage, it will be a circus. And basically they don't 0.96
00:04:13 want dissenting opinions. They don't want dissenting views. They don't want any difficult
00:04:16 questions being asked to Mark Carney. So that's why, again, I predict that tonight will be an
00:04:21 absolute snooze fest. It will be completely boring. The debate last night, basically what we saw
00:04:27 was everybody agreeing about everything.
00:04:31 The few gaffes happened because Mark Carney, it turns out,
00:04:34 doesn't speak French very well.
00:04:35 So he's not even a very good Davos elite, right?
00:04:38 Like he's a Laurentian elite that never bothered to learn French.
00:04:43 Tell that what you will about that, that he never bothered.
00:04:48 And yet, you know, again, the media didn't pick up on that,
00:04:52 didn't cover it very clearly, the fact that it wasn't a good night for him.
00:04:56 I don't know if it'll be any better.
00:04:57 I don't find him a very charismatic or interesting politician.
00:05:00 I think he's quite milquetoast and boring.
00:05:02 And maybe that's for his favour because Canadians prefer that.
00:05:06 And he's being billed as sort of a steady hand in a time of crisis.
00:05:09 And that's why, again, you heard last night all of the candidates talking about how we're
00:05:15 facing this existential crisis as a country and that this is like bigger than COVID and
00:05:20 the financial crisis all wrapped into one, kind of like beating the drum, like a fear
00:05:25 mongering Canadians, this idea that like our country is at stake here and only a liberal can
00:05:29 save us. And the frustrating thing is, Kian, it seems to be working, at least among a certain
00:05:34 subset of voters, the ones who swung the 26% swing that we've seen over the last six weeks in polls,
00:05:41 that they prefer, you know, the more they beat the drum of anti-Americanism, the more Canadians
00:05:46 fear the Americans. Liberals say that the Americans are now our enemy. And the more people 0.53
00:05:53 rally around that liberal flag it's it's maddening uh what do you make of all this i think that katie
00:05:58 telford should send donald trump a bouquet of flowers and a box of chocolates i think that
00:06:04 donald trump is doing more to save katie telford's job than anyone in canada ever possibly could
00:06:11 she was going to go to the dustbin of history her career was going to be over you know it still might
00:06:15 be over i i have hope that these polling numbers that we're seeing are not legitimate um pollsters
00:06:21 are the biggest fraudsters in our political climate here in Canada and in the US, honestly.
00:06:29 They constantly lie for their own gain. And I tend to not believe these polls as they're coming out.
00:06:36 There's no way that the Liberal Party is even with the Conservative Party right now. It's
00:06:41 definitely some mirage that we're seeing because there's no current leader. But there's no doubt
00:06:48 that they're doing better than they were the day before Justin Trudeau resigned. And that is because
00:06:53 of Donald Trump. Say what you will about him. I would have supported him over Kamala Harris. I
00:07:00 think that he's probably better for the United States than her, definitely better for the United 0.99
00:07:03 States than her. But for Canada, you know, he decided that we were the enemy, or at least the
00:07:10 Trudeau government was, and they were able to make political hay out of that, which has been,
00:07:15 And, you know, I mean, this is this is he he's he's good at what he does.
00:07:21 And if a weak Canada is good for the United States, the best way to do that is to keep the liberals in power.
00:07:27 So maybe this was calculated. Who knows?
00:07:29 Well, I think Trump is a chaos agent and he kind of plays off that.
00:07:33 That's almost the genius in what he's doing. Right.
00:07:35 Like during his first four years in office, there were no major wars.
00:07:38 There were no major escalations because everybody was terrified of him.
00:07:41 Like there's a funny story that he told about the Taliban and he basically told the Taliban later, like, hey, here's a picture of your house.
00:07:48 If any American serviceman gets harmed, I know where you live, basically.
00:07:52 And because of that, no Americans died in Afghanistan under his watch after that point.
00:07:57 And, you know, it's it's it's pretty incredible, but it works.
00:08:00 Right. And so when it comes to Canada, like I'm I'm still of the position that this is some big troll that he is. 0.66
00:08:07 this is art of a deal. He's throwing out something wild and watching everybody react. And it's all
00:08:13 to his benefit. The only thing is, every time he mentions the word 51st state, it throws Canadians
00:08:18 into a frenzy. And it's actually backfiring for conservatives in Canada. So I take your point.
00:08:24 And yeah, there's one thing I don't like that Trump is doing. That's it. I want to bring this
00:08:28 back to Justin Trudeau, because there's just so much hypocrisy here, Kian. I'm going to play this 1.00
00:08:33 clip. This is what Justin Trudeau said when he was announcing his resignation way back on
00:08:37 January 6th. I intend to resign as party leader, as prime minister, after the party selects its
00:08:47 next leader through a robust, nationwide, competitive process. So this doesn't really
00:08:55 feel like a robust, nationwide, competitive process when the Liberal Party has been tossing
00:09:00 out any potential candidate that they like because they pose a threat to Mark Carney, presumably.
00:09:06 We have Ruby Dalla, who I don't think she was a frontrunner. 1.00
00:09:10 I don't think that she posed a serious threat to Mark Carney.
00:09:14 But she was speaking to Juno News' Cat Canada.
00:09:17 And she said that she was getting in the way of the coronation of Mark Carney.
00:09:20 And that is why they got rid of her.
00:09:21 Let's play that clip.
00:09:23 Well, I think that they wanted to complete the coronation of Mark Carney.
00:09:28 They did not want to have Ruby Dalla on that debate stage or on that ballot. 0.99
00:09:32 And ultimately, they were denying, not Ruby Della, but they denied the thousands of people that were supporting me and wanted to vote for a Liberal Party that would be brought back to the centre.
00:09:43 And most importantly, a party where all the membership and the grassroots would actually have a voice.
00:09:50 So, I mean, basically, Ruby Della was getting in the way of that, Kian, and that is why they got rid of her. 0.54
00:09:58 What do you think?
00:10:00 Well, the last thing the Liberal Party brass wants is to move back to the center. 0.86
00:10:04 The most effective thing that they've done over these last few years is turn Jagmeet into the biggest clown that Ottawa has ever seen.
00:10:15 Jagmeet Singh has embarrassed himself to a huge degree, allowing his political capital to be spent for Justin Trudeau.
00:10:25 If I was him, I would be so disgraced with the failure of my party that it has seen since he took hold of it.
00:10:34 Let's look at the polling numbers right now.
00:10:38 The NDP have dropped massively over these last few weeks, just in the last few weeks, because people realize that if they want to stop Pierre, they can just vote for the general.
00:10:50 Look at this.
00:10:50 The NDP are polling at 12 percent right now.
00:10:53 and we hear about them way too much for that the liberals have realized that all they have to do
00:11:00 is suffocate the NDP away from their political uh political base and they'll win and that's
00:11:08 exactly what they're doing right now it's really unbelievable okay folks so we have the liberal
00:11:13 debate it's happening any moment now it's supposed to start at eight o'clock eastern time and it runs
00:11:19 for two hours which god help us kian two hours of four liberal candidates basically just all
00:11:25 in agreement with one another about uh their liberal agenda um kian and i are going to be back
00:11:31 at some point later in the broadcast to provide our commentary um but we will send it over to
00:11:38 the live feed so that you can you can watch the debate along with us um kian what are you expecting
00:11:44 to see tonight? I'm going to see, I'm going to expect to see Mark Carney try to make up lost
00:11:51 ground from last night. And that means he's going to be throwing a few punches, try to make sure
00:11:56 that any, you know, let's put it this way. If he makes a similar mistake to what he made last
00:12:03 night saying that he agrees with Hamas, which that was, you know, chalk that up to him not
00:12:09 speaking French well. But if he has a similar gap to that, people are going to start questioning,
00:12:13 is this guy really a good politician he's never been one before um he's always been in the back
00:12:18 rooms uh not not trying to relate uh any sort of charisma to voters if he makes a similar mistake
00:12:26 tonight in his own native tongue people might start seriously thinking is christia actually
00:12:30 is is it better to take the baggage of christia freeland and her relationship to justin trudeau
00:12:36 um if if mark carney isn't able to stand up on a debate stage because he's going to have to whoever
00:12:42 wins this debate wins this leadership race is going to have to go toe to toe with pierre paulia
00:12:47 who obviously we know can debate really really well so if mark carney can't debate in his own
00:12:53 native tongue today he is going to be losing a lot of support and he's going to be in a lot of trouble
00:12:59 all right well i'm getting word that the debate is starting right now folks we are going to throw
00:13:03 to the liberal party debate stage live in montreal quebec come to the english language
00:13:10 liberal leadership debate here in Montreal. I'm Hannah Thibodeau, the Executive Communications
00:13:15 Officer with Global Public Affairs. Tonight I am very thankful to be moderating this debate.
00:13:20 Tonight our candidates, I'm going to introduce you, Karina Gould on the left, Frank Bayless,
00:13:26 Chrystia Freeland, and Mark Carney will tackle four key themes. And those themes were informed
00:13:33 by registered liberals across this country. I'm just going to remind you what those were. If you
00:13:37 you didn't watch the french language debate last night you missed a lot but tonight i'm glad you're
00:13:42 with us it's canada's place in the world growing a strong economy supporting canadians and of course
00:13:49 climate change i want to welcome all of you to the debate this evening i'm so happy to be here with
00:13:53 you great to be with you so i'm going to explain to viewers a little bit about the format and
00:13:59 remind everyone here too because we go off a little bit so here's the format in each theme
00:14:04 there is an opportunity for candidates to answer a one-minute question. They'll each get that one
00:14:10 minute and the same question. Also in the themes there will be opportunities for five-minute debates
00:14:15 and we're going to have closing statements. Some of tonight's questions did come from registered
00:14:22 liberals. None of the candidates or their teams know what the questions are. They're in my head.
00:14:27 They will come out. Let's start. I want to get right into this and begin with opening statements
00:14:32 and this order was decided by a random draw.
00:14:36 Mr. Bayless, your 90 seconds starts right now.
00:14:39 Thank you.
00:14:41 Good evening, everyone.
00:14:42 My name is Frank Bayless, and I'm a professional engineer.
00:14:45 As a businessman, I built several companies
00:14:47 in the healthcare sector, and along with that,
00:14:50 I've created thousands of good-paying,
00:14:52 high-technology jobs.
00:14:54 I know how to build strong teams.
00:14:56 I know how to find good people
00:14:58 and work with them to achieve results.
00:15:00 I've also been elected as a Member of Parliament from 2015 to 2019, so I have an understanding
00:15:08 of how government works.
00:15:10 Now this combination of my private sector and my public sector experience puts me in
00:15:15 a unique position to be able to build systems, work with the government, and make it work
00:15:20 for all Canadians.
00:15:21 Now, I recognize that we're living in challenging times, but having said that, I'm very optimistic
00:15:28 about our future.
00:15:29 yes i believe in canadians and i believe in canada and with my plan i'm certain we'll
00:15:34 reach our full potential i'm going to focus on three priorities number one i want to build a
00:15:41 strong and resilient economy that we all benefit from number two i want to improve our healthcare
00:15:48 system so it becomes the best healthcare system in the world and it's not going to cost more money
00:15:53 it's going to save money and three i want to modernize the federal government such that it
00:15:57 becomes much more efficacious, better at delivering services to our Canadian citizens.
00:16:03 Together, we will build a proud and prosperous Canada for all Canadians.
00:16:09 Mr. Bayless, thank you kindly for that. Ms. Gould, your 90 seconds starts right now.
00:16:14 Meeting the moment. That's why we're here tonight. Growing up in a middle-class family
00:16:19 in Burlington, Ontario, and now having two kids of my own, I get what Canadians are going through.
00:16:25 Worrying about how to pay your mortgage, keep gas in the tank or whether you'll be able to retire.
00:16:31 I know it hasn't been easy as we face serious challenges to our economy and to our sovereignty.
00:16:38 But these challenges also present us with incredible opportunities to unite our country,
00:16:43 defend our economy and protect our values from the threats we are facing from south of the border 1.00
00:16:48 and our own little version of Trump here at home. I got into politics to do good things for Canadians.
00:16:55 And with a decade of experience, I know how to get that done.
00:16:59 I am so proud to be Canadian, especially right now,
00:17:04 as Canadians across this country meet the moment.
00:17:08 And tonight, each of us on this stage need to meet the moment.
00:17:12 Tonight, I am going to raise the tough questions we need to confront as Liberals,
00:17:16 have an honest conversation about where we stand on the big issues we face as Canadians
00:17:21 and present a clear plan for the future of this country.
00:17:24 If we do not do that, we will lose the next election.
00:17:28 Our opponents may wish that Canada is broken.
00:17:31 But we know as Liberals, this is a great country.
00:17:34 Now is the time for hope.
00:17:36 I am the leader we need.
00:17:38 And together, we can build the Canada we want.
00:17:41 And I'm asking you to join me.
00:17:43 Ms. Gould, thank you kindly.
00:17:45 Ms. Freeland, you're up next.
00:17:47 Ms. A few weeks ago in Saskatoon, I met a four-year-old girl named Ari.
00:17:53 She asked me, can you stop Trump from invading Canada?
00:17:58 Ari is a smart girl and she's asking the right question.
00:18:03 I'm running to be leader of the Liberal Party and the next Prime Minister of Canada
00:18:08 because Trump is posing the gravest challenge our country has faced since the Second World War.
00:18:16 He's threatening us with economic warfare.
00:18:19 That's not new.
00:18:21 Last time, he threatened to rip up NAFTA, and he imposed tariffs on our steel and aluminum.
00:18:27 I fought back, and I won.
00:18:30 This time, Trump's threats are even worse.
00:18:35 He wants to make us the 51st state.
00:18:39 Trump is unleashed and empowered.
00:18:43 As your Prime Minister, I will be too.
00:18:46 I have the experience, the plan, and the guts to stand up to Trump, to tell him that Canada is not
00:18:55 for sale, and if he hits us, we'll hit him back. We need a leader who understands the seriousness
00:19:03 of the challenge and is ready to meet it. A leader who can say to Ari and to everyone across our
00:19:10 great country. I will fight for you. I will fight for Canada. And together, we will win.
00:19:18 Ms. Freeland, thank you kindly. And we move now to Mark Kearney.
00:19:21 Thank you very much. Good evening, everyone. My name is Mark Kearney.
00:19:24 I was born in the Northwest Territories and I grew up in Edmonton. During my career,
00:19:28 I've had the honor of serving our country, including as Governor of the Bank of Canada
00:19:33 during the financial crisis of 2008. Right now, as my colleagues have said,
00:19:38 Canada faces one of the most serious crises in our history.
00:19:42 To get through it, we will need to build a strong economy,
00:19:45 and that requires big changes.
00:19:48 Canadians have been telling me that they want change.
00:19:51 They want positive change that builds this country.
00:19:54 I can bring that change.
00:19:56 I know how to manage crises.
00:19:58 I know how to build strong economies.
00:20:01 Yes, there are a lot of uncertainties.
00:20:05 but during a crisis it's important to distinguish what you can't control what we can control we
00:20:11 can't change donald trump but we can control our economic destiny we are masters in our own home
00:20:22 i have a plan a plan that puts more money back in your pockets a plan that makes our companies
00:20:30 more competitive. A plan that builds a strong economy that works for you.
00:20:37 Canadians are ready to stand up for their country. I'm ready to stand with them and bring the right
00:20:42 change for Canada. Thank you. Mr. Carney, thank you. Thank you all. And we're going to get right
00:20:48 into our first theme of this evening, Canada's place in the world. So for all these one minute
00:20:55 questions you are all going to get that one minute chance to answer the same question that's where
00:21:00 we're starting this evening and here's a warm-up for you tonight because it comes from deborah in
00:21:05 british columbia but i think deborah really is showing what many canadians are asking right now
00:21:11 she asks how will you stand up for canada against us president donald trump but i would like to add
00:21:18 to what she has to say. Why are you the best person positioned to do this? And the order was
00:21:25 picked ahead of time. And Mr. Bayless, you're first on this. One minute on the clock.
00:21:28 So I've negotiated hundreds and hundreds of contracts with Americans over my 40-year career.
00:21:34 And from time to time, I run into the character of Mr. Trump. So it's not new to me.
00:21:38 On this point, I published a letter one day before his inauguration when I said clearly,
00:21:43 he's not going to put 25 percent tariffs on everything but he is going to attack certain
00:21:47 industries the first one i said he's going to attack is steel it's exactly what he did i tell
00:21:53 you this to tell you that i know how to deal with him and it's important to understand that mr trump
00:21:58 is a bully and you do not give one inch to a bully in that case we cannot be learning this on
00:22:05 the job that's where i come in i have the experience and the expertise to deal with
00:22:11 Donald Trump. I can predict what he'll do, and then I can help build our defenses to
00:22:16 stop him from doing those things, and also counterattack, which unfortunately is going
00:22:20 to be necessary. This way I will protect our country, I will protect our economy, I will
00:22:26 protect our culture, and I will protect our sovereignty.
00:22:29 We're staying on time for the one minute. Appreciate that, Mr. Bayless. Mr. Kearney,
00:22:33 over to you now.
00:22:34 Thank you very much, Hannah. I think in a situation like this, you need experience in
00:22:38 in terms of crisis management, you need negotiating skills,
00:22:42 but you also need economic expertise
00:22:44 because part of the way to deal with this situation
00:22:47 is to do what we should have been doing
00:22:48 and what we need to do as a country,
00:22:50 which is to build a strong economy.
00:22:53 Now, we're gonna spend time on building a strong economy,
00:22:56 so I'll go through my plan for that later.
00:22:58 But let me start by being clear.
00:23:01 We will never, ever be part of the United States
00:23:05 in any way, shape, or form.
00:23:07 We have to recognize that the Donald Trump of today
00:23:09 is different than the Donald Trump of several years ago.
00:23:13 Then his objective was to take more of our market.
00:23:17 Now he wants to take our country.
00:23:21 Let me finish by pointing out one other thing.
00:23:23 Who's the worst person to stand up to Donald Trump?
00:23:26 It's Pierre Polyev.
00:23:27 He worships the man.
00:23:28 He uses his language.
00:23:30 He's not the right person for our country at this crucial time.
00:23:33 Again, thank you for sticking to time on that.
00:23:35 Ms. Gould, you're up now.
00:23:37 Thanks Hannah and thanks Debra for the question. Look men like Donald Trump have
00:23:43 always underestimated leaders like me but they underestimate me and that's
00:23:48 their mistake and I think as Canadians we know what that's like. We know how to
00:23:53 stand up for who we are and to stand up to bullies and that's something that I've
00:23:58 been doing in the House of Commons for the last decade. I know how to stand up
00:24:02 to people like Pierre Polyev who when it comes to Donald Trump would rather
00:24:06 imitate him then stand up for Canada. I know how to stand up to people who want
00:24:11 to take from us what is rightfully ours. We are a proud sovereign country and as
00:24:17 Canadians we have so much to offer but also the Americans depend on us and you
00:24:22 can't bring a calculator to a knife fight. You have to fight very strongly
00:24:27 and with the right tools and that's exactly what I'm going to do as Prime
00:24:31 Minister. Ms. Gould, thank you kindly. We're going to move into our first five
00:24:35 minute debate oh my gosh that's first mistake by the moderator my apologies
00:24:43 miss Freeland thank you thanks Anna Trump represents the biggest threat our 1.00
00:24:51 country has seen since the Second World War I have recognized that from the
00:24:56 outset I've built my campaign on a plan to answer that threat I do think though
00:25:04 it is a big mistake for Canadians to think that because we can't change Trump, we can't negotiate
00:25:11 with him. Of course we can't change him, but we can outwit him. And the way to do that is by using
00:25:20 our leverage, by recognizing that, yes, we depend on the U.S., but they depend on us too. We are
00:25:28 their largest market by far, we sell them the things we need. A smart, tough negotiator who
00:25:35 stands up to Trump can activate those Americans who need us, get them to lobby him. That's how we
00:25:44 get a win-win outcome. That's how Canada wins. And now we will move into that first five-minute
00:25:51 debate. Thank you for pointing that out. This is an open debate. Mr. Bayless, we'll start first
00:25:55 with you. Others can join in on this debate, but please try not to talk over each other too, too
00:26:01 much. We will control that. So here's the question. Knowing the why is vital in negotiations, or
00:26:09 you're essentially just negotiating against yourself. So why is President Trump doing this
00:26:16 to Canada? Well, President Trump needs to show that he has a win on the border, and he's got
00:26:21 himself elected by saying he's going to deal with illegal immigration. And right away, he puts out
00:26:26 a tweet saying there's a problem with Canada and Mexico. The problem is, for him, there is no
00:26:32 problem with Canada. We know it and the Americans know it. So he's trying to make one so that he
00:26:36 can later solve it. Now, I want to point something out. This is not a negotiations. This is a
00:26:42 shakedown. We have an agreement. He negotiated the agreement. He signed the agreement. The problem
00:26:48 we have is he's not respecting the agreement. So you believe it's the border is what I feel for 0.99
00:26:54 you. I'm saying that that's his that's his red herring that he's trying to say we're a problem
00:26:59 with the border that he's going to solve. Ms. Freeland and then Mr. Carney. Trump is starting
00:27:04 with us for a very simple reason. If you can show the world that you can beat up on Canada,
00:27:11 your best friend, your reliable, trustworthy neighbor, then think about how the rest of the
00:27:18 world feels. It is the demonstration effect. It is saying, if I can beat up on those guys,
00:27:23 imagine what I can do to you. And that's why a smart Canadian strategy needs to start with
00:27:31 looking for allies, working in the first instance with Mexico, Panama, Denmark, and the EU who all
00:27:40 face the same sovereignty challenge. I think we need to invite the Secretary General of NATO
00:27:45 to that first summit that I will host right after becoming Prime Minister. Working with our allies,
00:27:52 we form a common front and stop Trump from doing what he wants to do, which is pick us off one
00:27:58 after the other. Mr. Carney, you're up next. I want to pick up on what Krista just said,
00:28:04 because I think underlying all this
00:28:07 is what President Trump is looking for,
00:28:09 is to dominate the hemisphere.
00:28:12 He wants to enlarge U.S. power into Canada,
00:28:15 into Greenland, into the Panama Canal,
00:28:18 as was just mentioned.
00:28:19 So the stakes are very, very high.
00:28:23 This is a serious crisis,
00:28:24 not just an economic crisis.
00:28:25 It's a crisis of sovereignty.
00:28:27 So yes, we do need to build our allies.
00:28:31 In the interest of time,
00:28:32 I'm going to add one other thing.
00:28:34 And we'll come back to this later.
00:28:35 We also need to build our economy.
00:28:37 We need to build our economy right here.
00:28:39 If we have one Canadian economy instead of 13, that more than outweighs the impact of
00:28:44 what he's trying to do to us.
00:28:46 Ms. Gould?
00:28:47 Yeah, thank you.
00:28:48 And as I see where my colleagues are going, and I appreciate, I think all of that is probably
00:28:54 true, except what did we just see in Ukraine?
00:28:58 He did a deal with Putin for critical minerals in Ukraine.
00:29:03 else has critical minerals canada and so we need to understand what the u.s is trying to do here
00:29:10 but we also need to make sure that we are standing up for our sovereignty and for our economy you
00:29:15 know last night there was a bunch of conversations with colleagues who said well i'm not even going
00:29:18 to talk to donald trump well guess what we don't have that choice we have to talk to him that is
00:29:24 something that we absolutely have to do on behalf of canadians we might not like it but that is the
00:29:29 role of the prime minister to stand up and fight for canada every single day and that is exactly
00:29:35 what i am going to do stand up for canadians stand up for our industries and to say that we have
00:29:41 leverage we have things the u.s wants and we're not afraid to use them and if that means that
00:29:48 americans are going to see increased prices or american industries are going to suffer we will
00:29:53 make sure that we put everything on the table as canada because our sovereignty our economy our
00:29:59 jobs are non-negotiable okay mr bayless uh let's try to go 30 more seconds because we have more
00:30:04 interactions here let me tell you the first thing i'm going to do i'm going to go fly down and meet
00:30:09 president scheinbaum of mexico it's a very strong smart lady and i'm going to make a deal with her
00:30:14 and say look we need to stand up together to mr trump he said he's putting 25 percent tariffs on
00:30:19 both of us he can't do that it'll destroy his economy so we need to call his bluff and then
00:30:24 what we need to do is take off the table what was already given for nothing which is the worker
00:30:28 that we were going to do on our border for $1.3 billion
00:30:30 and the work that she was going to do on her border
00:30:33 and say, you know what, that's off the table now.
00:30:35 We're back to square zero.
00:30:36 That's how I will deal with President Trump.
00:30:38 Okay, Mr. Carney, do you want to jump in?
00:30:39 And then Ms. Freeland. 0.96
00:30:40 Yeah, let me make two points.
00:30:41 One is you have to be able to do more than one thing
00:30:43 at one time as prime minister.
00:30:45 So that means building the economy.
00:30:47 It means negotiating with allies,
00:30:49 leveraging our critical minerals,
00:30:50 leveraging our clean energy with those allies.
00:30:52 That's critically important.
00:30:54 And hitting hard with a real negotiation
00:30:56 with President Trump,
00:30:57 which includes dollar-for-dollar tariffs, includes using all the cards potentially that we have,
00:31:02 and they are considerable as the U.S.'s largest client.
00:31:05 Let me get Ms. Freeland in first and then... 1.00
00:31:09 Just one second. Ms. Freeland and then I'll come to you, Ms. Gold.
00:31:11 The thing to recognize about President Trump is with him, weakness is a provocation
00:31:16 and capitulation is not a negotiating strategy.
00:31:19 The great thing is right now, Canadians get it.
00:31:23 There is this wave of patriotism in Canada, and Canadians are going to stand and fight for Canada.
00:31:29 They need a leader who knows how to lead that fight and rally that wave of patriotism.
00:31:35 I'm the leader who can do that.
00:31:36 Ms. Gould.
00:31:37 Thank you.
00:31:38 Well, one thing that I would like to ask Mr. Carney, because yesterday he made some mentions of sectors that he would protect over others.
00:31:45 And I think what is really important is to understand which sectors you're willing to protect, but which sectors you would negotiate away.
00:31:52 And that is something that I think as Canadians, we need to understand because as Prime Minister, I'm not going to negotiate any of those sectors away.
00:31:59 I'm going to stand up for people in every single province and territory, every single sector to make sure that we protect Canadian jobs and protect our industries.
00:32:08 Okay, as moderator, all due respect, I'm going to try to ask the questions, but I am going to give Mr. Carney the opportunity to respond to that as well, Ms.
00:32:17 So, let me be clear about a few things.
00:32:20 one, not everyone would have watched the debate last night. So in a negotiation, if there are
00:32:25 things that should never enter into the negotiation, language, culture, our water,
00:32:31 you make clear at the start of the negotiation that they are off the table. Second thing is that
00:32:38 the other aspects, for example, our auto sector, I'll give an example, which is intimately
00:32:42 and interconnected with the United States.
00:32:48 We're going to negotiate around maintaining a good deal
00:32:52 for our auto sector, but that is not the same
00:32:56 as accepting a bad deal, Karina.
00:32:59 Well, actually, when it comes to the auto sector,
00:33:01 in the previous NAFTA negotiation,
00:33:03 we got a better deal than we had before.
00:33:05 We changed the rules of origin for car parts
00:33:07 that gave an advantage to high-wage Canadian workers.
00:33:12 That's the kind of approach we need to take.
00:33:13 Ms. Gould, do you want 10 seconds before we move on?
00:33:16 No, I'm okay.
00:33:16 Okay, we are going to move on then.
00:33:18 Thank you.
00:33:18 That was a great, fulsome debate.
00:33:20 We're going to move on to the next section where it's a one-minute response each for this question.
00:33:27 So Donald Trump said again yesterday, I'm sure we all know, the 25% tariffs are coming on March the 4th.
00:33:35 Only days later, one of you will become the prime minister of this country.
00:33:40 What is your first move?
00:33:41 And again, this was drawn ahead of time.
00:33:43 And Mr. Bayless, your start.
00:33:46 So first of all, I don't take him at his word.
00:33:49 He said March 4th, but I would expect him to hit us beforehand.
00:33:52 And I expect him to hit us again.
00:33:54 What he's going to do is look at industries where he has overcapacity in the United States.
00:33:59 Because he'll be thinking that's going to hurt the American economy the least, I should say.
00:34:04 So I'm going to be looking at softwood lumber, and I'm going to be looking at dairy as the next two industries he's going to attack.
00:34:10 And what we're going to be doing is supporting those industries completely.
00:34:13 We're not going to let them take our jobs away.
00:34:15 And we're going to be putting into place very intelligent counter tariffs.
00:34:19 And then we're going to be waiting.
00:34:21 And we're going to be waiting.
00:34:22 Because he's not going to stop until he gets the lesson that he can't get away with this.
00:34:27 Then what I am going to do is, as I said, I will go down and meet with President Scheinbaum of Mexico.
00:34:32 Come together with her and say, listen, let's hold the fort together.
00:34:36 Let's call him on his 25% tariff bluff.
00:34:39 Let's just call it.
00:34:40 Tell him, do it.
00:34:41 And let's take everything that he already took from us off the table.
00:34:44 Mr. Bayless, thank you.
00:34:46 Ms. Freeland, you're up next.
00:34:47 And again, days later, it's you that becomes prime minister.
00:34:50 What is your first move?
00:34:52 My first move is dollar for dollar retaliation.
00:34:57 And let me be very clear with President Trump.
00:35:00 If I am prime minister, I will not flinch.
00:35:03 We will retaliate.
00:35:04 If you hit us, we will hit back. 0.99
00:35:07 But our retaliation will be a lot smarter than their dumb tariffs. 0.99
00:35:13 And it's the Wall Street Journal, usually a supporter of Trump, that described this Trump effort as dumb. 0.98
00:35:20 Canada, by contrast, is going to be smart. 0.92
00:35:24 We are going to have a targeted retaliation that exerts maximum pain in the U.S. and does minimum harm to us.
00:35:31 We're going to hit Trump's best friends.
00:35:33 I will impose a 100% tariff on Teslas.
00:35:37 I'm going to hit Wisconsin dairy.
00:35:39 I'm going to hit Florida orange juice.
00:35:41 And you are going to see a stock market reaction.
00:35:44 You're going to see people like the American Farm Bureau
00:35:47 complaining about the Canadian potash they need that costs more.
00:35:51 And that reaction, that pain, will cause Trump ultimately to back down,
00:35:57 just like you did last time.
00:35:58 Ms. Gould, you're up next.
00:36:00 Only days later, you become Prime Minister.
00:36:02 What's your first move?
00:36:03 My very first move is to call a meeting
00:36:05 with the Council of the Federation
00:36:07 and bring the premiers together
00:36:08 to make sure that we share our plan for Canada.
00:36:11 Because this is every single province and territory,
00:36:14 every business leader in our country,
00:36:16 every union leader, every single Canadian.
00:36:20 And then to share the plan with the entire country
00:36:23 because Canadians deserve to know what we are doing.
00:36:26 Absolutely, we retaliate against Donald Trump.
00:36:31 We do a major Team Canada approach in the United States
00:36:35 where we engage with American leaders,
00:36:38 but also American citizens,
00:36:40 because it is American citizens
00:36:42 who are going to feel the impact of these tariffs.
00:36:45 And we need to let them know
00:36:46 that this is not Canada's decision.
00:36:48 This is the decision of the United States.
00:36:51 And I'm gonna call on Canadians to stop going to Florida, 1.00
00:36:55 to stop buying Florida orange juice,
00:36:58 because that's a $50 billion economy
00:37:00 in that state alone.
00:37:02 Canadians matter to the United States.
00:37:04 Ms. Gould, thank you kindly.
00:37:06 Mr. Carney, days later, you become prime minister.
00:37:09 What's your first move?
00:37:10 Well, I'll pick up on a few things.
00:37:12 First, entirely agree with what Karina just said.
00:37:15 First item call, I would call it a first minister's meeting
00:37:19 as opposed to council of federations,
00:37:20 but first minister's meeting, sharing the plan,
00:37:23 but also developing our broader response,
00:37:26 our broader domestic response, including project.
00:37:28 Secondly, I entirely agree with Christian, dollar-for-dollar tariffs, maximum impact
00:37:33 on the United States, minimal impact here in Canada.
00:37:39 Thirdly, put them on notice on the broader aspects of our commercial relationship.
00:37:47 We are their largest supplier of energy.
00:37:50 We are their largest supplier of electricity.
00:37:52 We are their largest supplier of uranium.
00:37:54 I could go on, but I will exhaust all my time.
00:37:58 There is the first signs in the United States now of the economic impact of the Trump policies.
00:38:07 We will amplify that, and that will begin to create the leverage.
00:38:11 And then I will call President Trump.
00:38:13 And then you'll call President Trump.
00:38:14 Well, it's going to be a long day.
00:38:16 Okay, Mr. Carney, thank you.
00:38:18 Ms. Gould, this is a five-minute section, and I'm going to start with you on this.
00:38:21 Others can jump in, again, if we can try not to talk over each other.
00:38:25 Ms. Gould, what do you think Canada should be doing with our allies, and we did hear some discussion in the opening statements about this, given the shifting geopolitical sands around the globe?
00:38:37 Well, look, I mentioned that over the past week, Donald Trump has been negotiating away Ukraine's sovereignty and their territorial integrity.
00:38:47 We saw President Trump abandon the free world throughout this process.
00:38:51 We absolutely need to shore up our allies with democracies around the world because our democracy is under threat.
00:39:01 We need to protect the values that we care about.
00:39:05 What does that look like?
00:39:06 It means reaching the 2% NATO target, not because the U.S. asked us to, but because we need to as Canadians.
00:39:12 It means making sure that we stand up for our values around the world, that we continue with our important international assistance.
00:39:18 We saw Trump take away from USAID.
00:39:22 Canada can't fill that void, but we can maintain our commitments.
00:39:26 And it means making sure that we live our values on a daily basis on the international scene.
00:39:32 The world needs Canada, and Canada will be there for the world.
00:39:35 Ms. Freeland?
00:39:36 It's a great question, because what is different about this unleashed and empowered President Trump
00:39:44 is he is clearly threatening our sovereignty.
00:39:48 and we need to respond. For the first time, the U.S., rather than guaranteeing, for the first
00:39:55 time since the Second World War, rather than guaranteeing the rules-based order, the U.S.
00:40:00 is turning predator. And so what Canada needs to do is work closely with our democratic allies,
00:40:07 our military allies. I've been foreign minister. I know how to do that. That's why I would start
00:40:13 with our nordic partners specifically denmark which is also being threatened and our european
00:40:18 nato allies i would be sure that france and britain were there who possess nuclear weapons
00:40:24 and i would be working urgently with those partners to build a closer security relationship
00:40:31 that guarantees our security in a time when the united states can be a threat and i would also
00:40:37 crucially reach out to our Asian democratic partners, Japan, South Korea, Australia,
00:40:45 they need to be part of the conversation too. We need to be ready for a world where the US 0.93
00:40:50 is not the leader of the free world anymore. Canada can be and must be a leader in building
00:40:57 this new order. Our allies are looking to us and if we do this, we'll make ourselves safer as well.
00:41:04 Mr. Bayless.
00:41:05 Thank you.
00:41:06 So we're in a lucky position in the sense that Donald Trump has targeted many other countries, European Union.
00:41:13 We've talked about the other ones as well.
00:41:15 So we can use this to our advantage.
00:41:17 Now we can say to them, let's get together and target Donald Trump and target some of his industries.
00:41:22 I'll give you an example.
00:41:23 So Boeing Airlines, they have to sell planes all around the world,
00:41:27 and they have competitors that can also compete with them and sell planes we can buy from Embraer,
00:41:32 we can buy from Airbus and that.
00:41:34 So we should get together with them and say, look, we're going to bankrupt Boeing.
00:41:38 The Canadian government should also do this.
00:41:40 Under the same guise that he's using to impose these tariffs on us,
00:41:43 we should say, you know what, it's an emergency situation,
00:41:46 and we've got to re-look at our defence spending.
00:41:48 We're buying planes from the United States.
00:41:51 We're buying all kinds of defence industry products from the United States.
00:41:54 And you know what, we're going to put them on hold for now,
00:41:56 and if this continues for a couple more weeks, we're going to cancel them.
00:41:59 We start this process, other people follow us,
00:42:01 it will hit them exactly where it hurts.
00:42:04 Mr. Carney.
00:42:05 Well, it's interesting.
00:42:06 I was asked a question a few weeks ago.
00:42:08 It was in Amherst, Nova Scotia,
00:42:10 and I was asked a question by some British journalists
00:42:15 about whether the UK and Europe could avoid the impact of President Trump.
00:42:21 I said, good luck with that.
00:42:23 Now they're beginning to see the impact.
00:42:25 We've seen it through Ukraine and elsewhere.
00:42:28 So there is an opportunity, in fact, a necessity, an imperative here for us to work with like-minded countries on the new security architecture.
00:42:39 Yes, we have to step up for our contribution.
00:42:42 How we protect our Arctic, which is under threat not just now from the Russians and the Chinese, but from potential U.S. incursions. 0.59
00:42:50 Serious, serious issue.
00:42:52 We have to work on our, I'll call it our data architecture, how we're going to handle artificial intelligence.
00:42:57 last point, because a lot of people want to come in. We need to leverage all of our assets from
00:43:02 critical minerals to clean energy and well beyond to harden those partnerships in Europe and in Asia
00:43:10 with like-minded. Ms. Gould. Thank you, Hannah, and thank you to my colleagues, I think, for some
00:43:15 very interesting ideas. Mark, you talked about reaching NATO targets, but of all of us on stage,
00:43:23 you plan to reach those not until 2030 but the imperative to do that is now you talked about the
00:43:29 fact that the arctic is under threat um we don't have time to wait for this we have to actually
00:43:36 make sure that we are investing here in canada reaching those targets because our country our
00:43:41 sovereignty is under threat and we are in a new world and so at the time to make those investments
00:43:46 is now i i do have a question about the targets coming up so we will get to that uh and just
00:43:51 I do believe we need to hit 2% by 2027 and we
00:43:55 need to be focused on spending the money here
00:43:58 in Canada with Canadian companies.
00:44:00 But I want to be sharing a message from all of us
00:44:04 directly with President Trump.
00:44:06 What you are hearing from the Liberal Party of
00:44:09 Canada is our sovereignty is not negotiable,
00:44:12 Canada is not for sale, we are going to stand
00:44:15 with all Canadians and not become the 51st
00:44:18 with all Canadians and not become the 51st state.
00:44:21 And Pierre Polyev wants to imitate you.
00:44:23 But we are going to defeat him.
00:44:25 And together, we're going to fight for Canada.
00:44:28 So guess what?
00:44:29 That question is coming up right now, Ms. Gould.
00:44:31 So we can follow up.
00:44:32 Mr. Carney, I'll give you the opportunity.
00:44:33 Because today, the British Prime Minister,
00:44:36 Keir Starmer, announced 2.5% of their GDP
00:44:40 for defence spending by 2027.
00:44:43 Everybody has spoken about boosting our own GDP.
00:44:48 in different years. So we'll clarify with you. Would you do the same 2.5% by 2027?
00:44:56 Well, look, the first thing we're starting from a different position than the UK is.
00:45:00 But it also goes to the heart of what we're trying to accomplish. I think this goes to
00:45:05 a fundamental point about how to manage government. The outcome here is securing
00:45:11 Canada to protect Canadians. Now, I was born in the Arctic, born in the Northwest Territories.
00:45:18 I know it well. I know the imperative. The imperative in the Arctic is to have at least
00:45:24 two new bases in the Arctic, probably Tuktoyaktuk and in Iqaluit.
00:45:31 We need to build out on NORAT. We need to build out cyber capabilities. We need to build out
00:45:36 frontier. The core point, I will spend defense dollars in Canada, not the 80% that this government
00:45:43 has spent in the United States up until now. 80% of capital's defense dollars have gone to the
00:45:49 United States. I will spend them in Canada, and I will spend them as rapidly as possible
00:45:54 to secure for Canadians. But that is a management thing. It's not an arbitrary target.
00:46:01 Ms. Gould makes a good point, though. You had mentioned, I think, 2030.
00:46:05 I said by 2030.
00:46:07 Right.
00:46:07 And I said when I said it that we will do faster if we can deploy it faster in Canada.
00:46:12 This is a management point. This is a core point about delivering security.
00:46:18 And that is the issue, not just pushing money out the door.
00:46:21 One minute for you, Ms. Freeland.
00:46:23 I think what it is about is will and a plan and commitment to defend our country.
00:46:31 So I've put forward a plan to hit 2% by 2027.
00:46:36 It is critical that we spend that money here in Canada on Canadian companies.
00:46:43 And we need to be thinking about the next generation of warfare.
00:46:46 As we're seeing in Ukraine, drones, AI, these are really important.
00:46:50 Our 2% should not be about sending checks to the United States.
00:46:55 Critically, we need a plan to defend our own borders, very particularly the Arctic,
00:47:01 and we need to be working with our Nordic and EU-NATO partners.
00:47:07 They have nuclear weapons.
00:47:08 We need to say to them, we need a plan to protect and defend our shared Arctic without the U.S.
00:47:16 and Canada will step up
00:47:20 because it's our sovereignty that's at stake as well.
00:47:23 Mr. Bayless, you have one minute now.
00:47:26 So about a year ago, I published a letter
00:47:28 and said that we should meet our 2% GDP in defence spending
00:47:31 and that we should do it by 2030.
00:47:33 That was a six-year time frame.
00:47:36 And even at six years, to do it intelligently,
00:47:38 it's actually quite compressed.
00:47:40 So anybody can spend money and everybody can waste money.
00:47:43 But to do it intelligently
00:47:44 and such that it packs and comes into Canada
00:47:47 and we're buying Canadian products,
00:47:49 Canadian services and that,
00:47:51 that's not as easy.
00:47:52 So I can't say that we would get to 2%
00:47:54 by in three or four years.
00:47:55 I don't think that's doable in an intelligent way.
00:47:58 There are some things we can do,
00:47:59 which I did say,
00:48:00 which is we should pay our armed forces much better.
00:48:03 We're not doing that.
00:48:04 We need to raise their pays,
00:48:06 raise their benefits.
00:48:07 Then I proposed something called CARD,
00:48:09 which is the Canadian Agency
00:48:10 for Advanced Research and Defence.
00:48:12 And this is taking something
00:48:13 that the Americans do and they have their program called DARPA. So I'm copying that program where
00:48:17 they invest in research and development in Canadian companies. They develop something.
00:48:22 Now we see it's working. Then we can procure it. So I want to make the spending, but it won't
00:48:26 happen that fast. Okay. Ms. Gould, now over to you. Thank you, Hannah. So, I mean, I think you hear
00:48:31 from all of us that we want to increase our defense spending. It's just a matter of who's
00:48:35 going to do it in the timely way that we need to do it. And I'm committed to doing it by 2027.
00:48:41 and there are two ways that we can do this.
00:48:44 First, by increasing the salaries of our Canadian Armed Forces,
00:48:48 we do not pay our military personnel a sufficient wage in this country
00:48:53 and they are there for us when we need them most.
00:48:57 And so we need to pay them more.
00:48:59 That's something that I would do immediately as Prime Minister.
00:49:03 Second, what can we do?
00:49:05 You know, Mr. Carney talked about military procurement,
00:49:08 but our military procurement isn't working.
00:49:10 We have a lot of orders on the docket.
00:49:12 We need a procurement czar to get those orders moving. 0.96
00:49:15 And while I entirely agree with a Made in Canada solution, 0.82
00:49:19 we need to ensure that our troops have the equipment, the tools,
00:49:22 and the resources that they need to fight and protect us here at home and around the world.
00:49:28 Okay, this isn't a debate period, but I do see everybody wants to jump in.
00:49:31 Ms. Freeland and then Mr. Kearney.
00:49:33 I just want to push back against the idea that managerial or technocratic obstacles
00:49:39 should get in the way of defending Canada.
00:49:42 We really need to act with the fierce urgency of now.
00:49:46 We need to recognize President Trump has said dozens of times
00:49:51 he wants us to be the 51st state.
00:49:55 I don't think any of us wants to be the leader
00:49:57 who was asleep at the wheel and didn't get Canada defended,
00:50:02 did not work with our democratic allies
00:50:05 to protect our borders.
00:50:07 They want to work with us. It's time for us to step up at home, to urgently reach out to them and build a new world order where democracy and Canadian sovereignty is protected.
00:50:19 Mr. Carney, you're up next.
00:50:21 I'm going to associate myself. I'm going to agree with that.
00:50:24 The only amendment I'm going to make is, unfortunately, it won't be a world order.
00:50:28 It will be a subset of the world order because the number of like-minded countries is much smaller with U.S. exiting.
00:50:34 But I want to make an important point.
00:50:37 Because a huge element of securing Canada is going to be related to information warfare.
00:50:44 It's going to be related to cyber.
00:50:46 It's going to be related to artificial intelligence.
00:50:48 And it's crucial that we're in Montreal.
00:50:50 We're in one of the centers of artificial intelligence excellence.
00:50:53 There are others in this country.
00:50:54 It's crucial that we're building those capabilities on Canadian technologies, to Canadian values,
00:51:02 to protect Canadians because we can't rely on foreign suppliers for them.
00:51:10 That is one of the new realities that are there.
00:51:12 So the natural approach here is gone.
00:51:16 And that's one of the main priorities I would have in terms of securing Canada.
00:51:21 Mr. Bayless, jump in there.
00:51:22 So I'd like to give you an example of how we can do this intelligently
00:51:26 and how we can do it the wrong way.
00:51:27 If we try and push tens and tens of billions of dollars out the door
00:51:31 within three years for government procurement of defense,
00:51:34 it's going to be wasted.
00:51:36 It's going to be splashed all over the place
00:51:38 and we're not going to get what we need.
00:51:39 The program that I'm calling for, CARD,
00:51:42 Canadian Agency for Advanced Research and Defense,
00:51:44 what we would do, I'll give you an example with respect to drones.
00:51:47 Right here in Quebec, we have a very strong aerospace industry.
00:51:51 So we would give out five or six research contracts,
00:51:54 and none of this, by the way, is subject to our trade agreements,
00:51:58 and see who comes up with the best drone.
00:51:59 And once we have that, then we can go and say, we're going to buy that from you.
00:52:03 But to develop it and get it done like that, that's not going to happen.
00:52:06 So if we try to do this too quickly, we're going to be wasting money and we're going
00:52:09 to be wasting an excellent opportunity to build Canadian industry.
00:52:13 Ms. Gould.
00:52:14 Thank you.
00:52:15 I would push back gently on that to say that getting our troops the equipment and the supplies
00:52:19 and the tools they need to defend Canada is not wasted money.
00:52:22 It's actually imperative for them to defend and protect us in this time.
00:52:27 But Mark brought up an interesting point about capabilities here in Canada.
00:52:32 And as the Minister of Democratic Institutions, I put in place Canada's first ever and only plan to protect our country from cyber attacks in our democracy.
00:52:42 And as part of that, I know that we have one of the premier cyber security institutions through the CSE here in Canada.
00:52:49 But what we don't have is our own intelligence agency that can work to collect foreign intelligence.
00:52:55 Now might be the time that we need to establish those capabilities.
00:52:59 We heard earlier today that the Americans had thought about removing Canada from our 5I partnership.
00:53:05 We rely too much on the Americans for intelligence internationally, 0.99
00:53:11 and we need to ensure that Canada has the capacity and the capability to protect ourselves,
00:53:16 to work with democratic partners, and to ensure more than anything,
00:53:20 more than anything, we are protecting Canadians, Canadian industry, and our economy at a time of
00:53:26 intense cyber espionage. And this is something that is an important policy for today in 2025.
00:53:32 Ms. Freeland, jump in there. 1.00
00:53:33 You know, I really believe in Canada and Canadians, and there is this wave of passion in our country
00:53:41 to defend our country. One of the reasons that I decided to run for the leadership
00:53:46 is I had a conversation after Trump made his 51st state threat
00:53:52 with a couple of very brilliant young technologists
00:53:56 who worked with Jeff Hinton, the Nobel Prize-winning father of AI.
00:54:01 And they said to me, we know what's happening in Ukraine
00:54:04 and we see how technologists are leading the fight.
00:54:07 We are patriotic Canadians.
00:54:10 We believe in our country.
00:54:11 We need a government that gets that, that invests in us, because we are ready to stand on guard for Canada.
00:54:20 And that is the approach we need to take.
00:54:21 I think we need to have confidence that Canadians, empowered and led by a government that believes in them, will do this.
00:54:28 Mr. Carney.
00:54:29 Okay.
00:54:30 This is a crucial conversation.
00:54:33 And I'm really heartened by both the seriousness, the range of ideas.
00:54:39 But I'm going to bring up one related aspect, which Karina just touched on, which is about
00:54:44 foreign interference, foreign interference in our democratic institutions.
00:54:49 And the responsibility of all politicians, particularly leaders of parties, and certainly
00:54:55 the prime minister, is to be fully briefed on these issues.
00:54:59 Garipoliyev hasn't ever bothered to get his security clearance.
00:55:05 I've already, during this leadership campaign, filled out my forms.
00:55:08 It wasn't that hard to do, I have to say, and put them in.
00:55:11 And I fully expect to get it in the near future.
00:55:14 This is the kind of irresponsibility at a time when our country is under threat that we cannot afford.
00:55:20 We cannot afford a leader like Pierre Pauliette.
00:55:24 Mr. Bayliss?
00:55:24 I'd like to just do two things.
00:55:26 First of all, clarification on Ms. Gould.
00:55:27 I put out my defense plan before yours, and in it I made it very clear that I was going to raise salaries.
00:55:33 But that's not going to spend tens of billions of dollars.
00:55:35 Having said that, what we do need to do is increase enrollment, and that will come by getting better salaries and benefits.
00:55:42 And also, there's another area where I'd like to see a step up, where we've really fallen far behind.
00:55:47 We're down to 33 UN peacekeepers in the world.
00:55:50 This is not acceptable for Canada, the country that brought peacekeeping to the world.
00:55:54 So I'd like to really invest in recruiting, strengthening the number of people in our armed forces, and putting some out in peacekeeping roles.
00:56:01 I want to thank you all. That was a great first theme.
00:56:04 we are going to move on now to the second theme of this evening and this is going to be a question
00:56:09 for all of you it's a one minute question and i'm going to start with mr carney this time so
00:56:13 canadians are living in tough economic times as prime minister what would your priority be to
00:56:20 strengthen our economy well i think i'll start my answer by saying this will be one of my top
00:56:28 priorities with jointly with these issues that we just touched on largely with the us and the
00:56:32 threats to our security a focus on building our economy on several layers first and foremost
00:56:40 this is a time to build we have an enormous opportunity to build our economy that means
00:56:46 building millions of homes we're millions of homes short in this country everyone who's trying to buy
00:56:51 a home is aware that's particularly young it's building infrastructure both conventional energy
00:56:56 infrastructure and clean energy infrastructure it's building out building up on the conversation
00:57:00 we just had on intelligence infrastructure it is diversifying our trade partners with
00:57:05 new trading routes and it's creating one canadian economy instead of 13. that's what's necessary
00:57:11 to move this country forward from where we are today which has become quite a weak position
00:57:19 economically we will dig into some of those topics a bit more miss gould you're up next
00:57:23 thanks thanks hannah um okay we wanted to jump in folks just for a minute wow is this boring
00:57:28 i i i'm sorry i'm listening i'm trying to follow along but they all sound the same they're not
00:57:32 saying anything it's like they're all filibustering and just filling time not really getting into any
00:57:37 depth the only thing that they really feel passionately about is their anti-americanism
00:57:42 and their dislike of donald trump and their fear-mongering about how canada has to change
00:57:46 and the whole world is going to be completely different uh to to me there's just nothing
00:57:51 nothing there folks we will get back to the debate in a minute but i wanted to jump in right now and
00:57:56 And just first of all, thank you for supporting independent journalism.
00:57:59 Thank you for supporting Kian and my new venture, Juno News.
00:58:03 I'm urging you and encouraging you to head on over to our website, junonews.com, and subscribe.
00:58:08 Subscribe to our news.
00:58:09 Never miss an update.
00:58:10 We have the reporters of True North doing incredible deep dive research, putting out
00:58:15 half a dozen news stories every day and more.
00:58:18 We're growing, and we do a live news show every day, The Candace Malcolm Show.
00:58:22 Kian Bexley is going to be introducing his own podcast very soon.
00:58:25 And we need you to join our movement, help us build the future, help us build an alternative to the CBC, an alternative to the bought and paid for press that prop up this liberal government, prop up Justin Trudeau, and will continue.
00:58:39 They will prop up Mark Carney, I promise you.
00:58:41 They won't tell you the truth.
00:58:42 They won't tell you just how bad he is, how empty he is.
00:58:47 I mean, hearing him talk about how he would negotiate with Donald Trump, that wasn't inspiring to me.
00:58:52 He was talking about basically selling out the auto industry, that taking certain things off the table, not the auto industry.
00:58:58 I mean, people are reckless. And the fact that the media is not telling you the truth is a big problem.
00:59:02 The media is lying to you. So please, I'm urging you to head on over to Juno News and subscribe for about eight bucks a month.
00:59:10 And you can get all of our coverage. Kian, what do you think so far?
00:59:14 It was just completely vapid on most of their parts.
00:59:18 you know the first question donald trump second question donald trump third question donald trump
00:59:24 nothing about out of control immigration nothing about justin trudeau's record of corruption
00:59:29 nothing about the housing crisis nothing about fentanyl no serious questions whatsoever it was
00:59:34 all trump trump trump trump trump america tariffs blah blah blah nothing about actually governing
00:59:38 this country this tariff stuff is going to pass donald trump is not the primary concern of most
00:59:44 Canadians right now. Canadians want to afford a house so that they can have kids. They want to 0.98
00:59:48 make sure that their brother who just OD'd last night has a hospital bed to go to and has, you
00:59:54 know, a functioning healthcare system so that they can get the help that they need. They want to make
00:59:58 sure that their streets are safe so that the downtown east side of Vancouver isn't more
01:00:04 dangerous than a war zone. These are the things that Canadians want answers to, not whatever the
01:00:09 liberals are talking about. It's an absolute disgrace what we're watching right now. And
01:00:13 there's another hour left of it i'm horrified but i do want to say to everyone watching thank you
01:00:17 very much i encourage you to go to juno news.com get a founding subscription today doing that is
01:00:25 the best way to help us uh maintain uh the work that we're doing so that we can keep up um asking
01:00:31 the questions that the mainstream media obviously refuses to ask uh and to publish the stories that
01:00:37 the mainstream media tries to sweep under the rugs well thank you so much for that kian uh just one 0.95
01:00:42 point you know it's interesting they're talking about cost of living right now and we'll head
01:00:45 right back to the debate so folks can continue it was just so boring i had to break it up i'm like
01:00:48 i don't know two hours with these people they all sound the same they're not saying anything
01:00:52 just nothing is uh what one funny thing that happened last night was during the french
01:00:56 language debate they asked the candidates how much a canadian spends the average canadian family
01:01:02 spends on groceries uh none of them knew mark carney didn't didn't know i don't think that
01:01:06 that got enough attention christie freeland guessed that it was uh i think 250 a week
01:01:11 It turns out it's $300, which surprises me.
01:01:13 I mean, I have a family with four kids, so I think we spend more than the average.
01:01:17 But $300 on average per week is so expensive, and that is Justin Trudeau's record.
01:01:22 That is what happens when you have out-of-control inflation and when you impose a carbon tax and, you know, a tax on everything.
01:01:29 So, okay, we'll go back to the debate so folks can continue to watch that.
01:01:33 But please head on over to Juno News.
01:01:34 Help us build the future.
01:01:35 Help us build the biggest alternative independent media company in the country.
01:01:38 And hey, who knows, maybe one day we'll be the biggest media company in the country.
01:01:42 Okay, let's go back to the debate.
01:01:48 For first time, homebuyers.
01:01:50 This is a crucial point, getting on the home ladder.
01:01:53 We need to, if we have one Canadian economy, we can reduce prices by 15%.
01:01:59 If we have greater competition in our economy, which my government will deliver,
01:02:06 in groceries, in broadband, in transportation.
01:02:09 That will bring prices down.
01:02:11 That will help people move ahead.
01:02:12 So we have to tackle the affordability issue
01:02:15 across the board.
01:02:17 Last point, absolutely have to keep in place
01:02:20 the progress that the government has made
01:02:23 on crucial things such as childcare,
01:02:26 on dental care and farmer care,
01:02:28 because that helps those who are most vulnerable.
01:02:31 We'll talk a little bit about healthcare soon too.
01:02:33 Ms. Gould, you're up next.
01:02:34 Thank you, Hannah.
01:02:36 You know, when my colleagues talk about households, I talk about families.
01:02:40 When they talk about, you know, the macro picture, I talk about what it means for individuals.
01:02:45 And I'm so proud that I was able to deliver affordable child care for families across this country.
01:02:52 And I would expand that to include before and after school care as well.
01:02:56 But when we're talking about people who are going to food banks, we're talking about the most vulnerable in our society.
01:03:02 A middle-class tax cut or removing the GST on new homes isn't going to help those folks.
01:03:08 But you know what will?
01:03:09 Modernizing our social safety net.
01:03:12 Making sure that seniors who live on a fixed income, persons with disabilities, 0.51
01:03:17 folks who have lost their job, who need support to retrain and rebound, are better off.
01:03:23 And that's why I'm talking about opening a path towards a basic income.
01:03:28 Poverty costs money.
01:03:30 That's why we need to work to eliminate homelessness, it's why I would work with provinces and
01:03:34 territories to have specific accords to ensure that folks who get into housing can stay stable
01:03:40 and that they can enter the workforce and join and be prosperous.
01:03:44 We need to tackle poverty in this country.
01:03:48 It is urgent for us to do and it is something that I am promising that I will work on with
01:03:53 Canadians to ensure that every person in this country has a real, viable opportunity for
01:03:59 success.
01:04:00 you're up next i am so glad to have child care mentioned as finance minister one of the things
01:04:07 i was so grateful to be able to do was to introduce in my first budget a national system
01:04:13 of early learning and child care and it was wonderful to work first with ahmed hussein
01:04:18 get that first crucial deal with bc and a bunch more and then ahmed handed the baton to karina
01:04:24 and we work together this is generational it's transformational for canada my affordability plan
01:04:32 includes a hundred thousand more child care places it includes a middle class tax cut it includes
01:04:39 a cut on credit card fees it includes a cut on taxes for first-time home buyers and the critical
01:04:46 thing for us to all remember is the real threat to canadian families the real threat to people 1.00
01:04:54 working really hard and struggling to get by is not anyone on this stage. It is Pierre Polyev.
01:05:02 He will cut, cut, cut. He will bring in a cruel austerity that will hurt all the people in Canada
01:05:11 who need the help the most. And that's why I'm proud to be a Liberal and that's why I'm running
01:05:16 to be the next leader of our party. Mr. Bayless, I'm trying to pick up some time here. 30 seconds
01:05:20 to you and then I'm going to come over to you. So you mentioned food banks. I've actually been
01:05:24 on the board, the board directors of a food bank for 11 years. And you'll note that I was over the
01:05:29 time that I was a member of parliament. So normally I stepped off all boards because you don't want to
01:05:33 politicize them. But the food bank said, Frank, we don't care. We need your help. Please stay on
01:05:37 the board. So I understand this intimately. Now, what tends to happen with politicians, they did
01:05:43 it this time. They brought the grocery store owners in and they yelled at them and screamed 0.96
01:05:46 them. But the reality is this. If you want to buy an orange, that grocery store has to go buy it in
01:05:51 United States in U.S. dollars, bring it to Canada, convert it to Canadian dollars. Every time our
01:05:57 dollar goes down, the price of that orange goes up. Now, if we want to get that down, working,
01:06:02 we need to bring our dollar up and bring oranges, bananas, everything else down. That's the solution.
01:06:08 Mr. Carney? I want to be clear, and Canadians feel this, I want to be clear about the
01:06:16 quote, strength of our economy. Our economy over the last five years has been driven by a big
01:06:24 increase in the labor force, which was largely because of a surge in immigration that is now
01:06:29 trying to be controlled, and by government spending that grew over 9% year after year after
01:06:38 year, twice the rate of growth of our economy. So our economy was weak before we got to the point
01:06:45 of these threats from President Trump.
01:06:48 That's why we need big changes.
01:06:51 That's the reason I'm here.
01:06:52 That's why we need big changes
01:06:53 to how we're managing this economy.
01:06:56 I want to make one last point,
01:06:57 which goes to workers.
01:07:00 My plan, it's a time to build,
01:07:02 build across this economy
01:07:04 and go into more detail.
01:07:06 It is going to be a great time
01:07:08 going forward to be a worker in Canada.
01:07:11 It is going to be a great time
01:07:12 to be in the trades in Canada
01:07:14 because we are going to build this country across this country for Canadians and with Canadians.
01:07:20 Ms. Gould, I'm going to give you 30 seconds. We are out of time, but I want to...
01:07:24 Look, I'm not going to talk down Canada.
01:07:26 I am only ever going to be a champion for this country.
01:07:30 And when it comes to the question that was asked about poverty,
01:07:34 we actually have to talk about people in poverty and what their lived experience is.
01:07:39 When I was the Minister of Families, I worked on a national school food program
01:07:43 that is now going to be supporting thousands of kids across this country and delivered child
01:07:48 care but let's be clear poverty costs us money and investing to tackle and end poverty like things
01:07:55 like the Canada child benefit or increasing senior supports is going to benefit all of us
01:08:01 and 30 seconds to you Ms Freeland and then we'll move on I just want to say really quickly that
01:08:06 we need to be really careful not to repeat conservative talking points Canada most
01:08:12 definitely is not broken. We are a strong, resilient country. Canadians live four years
01:08:19 longer than Americans and median wealth in Canada is higher than in the US. Trump is giving us an
01:08:25 opportunity to make a strong economy even stronger and more resilient. And I think as Liberals,
01:08:32 we have to remember the great legacy of Jean-Cretien Paul Martin. We are the party that believes in
01:08:39 social policy and economic policy.
01:08:42 We know how to deliver jobs and growth
01:08:44 and we know how to support people.
01:08:47 We believe in both and that is the kind of party
01:08:51 and that is the kind of government I will lead
01:08:53 as Prime Minister.
01:08:54 We're going to have one more one-minute issue
01:08:58 and we can talk about all of the other stuff
01:09:00 in that as well.
01:09:02 So I'm going to start, this is supposed to be
01:09:04 with Ms. Freeland as well on this one
01:09:06 because it was previously drawn.
01:09:07 As Prime Minister, and we're coming back to what we were talking about when it comes to managing the nation's books,
01:09:14 how would you manage the nation's books at this critical time?
01:09:18 And, of course, you were the former Finance Minister.
01:09:22 Yeah, well, I would start by pushing back very forcefully against Conservatives who taught Canada down.
01:09:32 The reality is Canada has a strong fiscal position.
01:09:36 We have a AAA credit rating and we have the lowest debt and the lowest deficit in the G7.
01:09:43 That was important for me to maintain a fiscally responsible position because I know that we have
01:09:51 needed to keep our fiscal fire powder dry because I saw that Trump was coming. Today, we need to
01:09:59 seize the opportunity that Trump presents us to harness this wave of Canadian patriotism
01:10:05 and to build a Canadian economy which is even stronger
01:10:09 with more jobs, more investment, more prosperity.
01:10:14 And critically, we need to remember that standing up to Trump
01:10:18 is the foundation of all economic policies
01:10:21 and there could be some pain involved.
01:10:24 The government has to be there to support workers,
01:10:27 to support businesses.
01:10:28 As Prime Minister, you have my commitment that I'll do that.
01:10:32 Mr. Bayless, your one minute starts now.
01:10:34 So as I mentioned, I'm going to bring fiscal discipline to Ottawa.
01:10:38 Now, when I say that, a lot of people think, okay,
01:10:40 is he going to cut services or is he going to raise taxes?
01:10:43 It's neither.
01:10:44 There is a third option, which is to increase productivity.
01:10:48 So if we increase productivity, we increase richness,
01:10:51 we increase our tax base and everything.
01:10:53 Now, as a business owner, I've done that.
01:10:56 When I brought a company from two people to 1,000,
01:10:59 I know how to invest intelligently to increase productivity.
01:11:04 Added to that, as I mentioned, I've also been elected, so I'm the one person here that understands both sides of the coin, and I'm going to use that skill set to then say, okay, how do we put in place government programs that are going to help the economy work, government programs that are going to be à la bénéfice to the benefit of businesses, and take away ones that are hurting, such as, for example, I wrote well over a year ago that the increase in capital gains was a very bad idea
01:11:32 because it goes against what we want.
01:11:34 It discourages investments when we want to encourage them.
01:11:37 Ms. Gould, you're up next.
01:11:39 Thank you, Hannah.
01:11:41 Look, I'm all for increasing productivity.
01:11:43 And in fact, last week I announced a plan
01:11:46 to create a million new entrepreneurs in this country.
01:11:49 I'm the daughter of a small business owner.
01:11:51 I grew up working in the family business.
01:11:53 And I think we need to unleash that economic potential.
01:11:57 But if someone tells you that they're going to balance the books
01:12:00 in a very short period of time,
01:12:03 increasing our productivity in that period of time is not going to be sufficient.
01:12:07 And at a time when we are facing potentially one of the greatest economic shocks our country has
01:12:12 experienced, we need to ensure that the government can be there for Canadians like the federal
01:12:18 government was during the pandemic with the Canada emergency response benefit, the business loan,
01:12:25 as well as the wage subsidy, because we will win against Donald Trump. But we need to ensure that
01:12:31 Canadians have the income support they need and the jobs to get to when we eventually win. Thank
01:12:36 you. Mr. Carney, the last in the one minute. Okay. Well, it was my privilege to work with
01:12:41 Paul Martin when he balanced the books and kept the books balanced. And one of the lessons of that
01:12:48 is the need for government to continue to focus on how effectively it is spending precious
01:12:56 taxpayers dollars in other words a focus on the outcomes of programs as opposed to the dollars
01:13:02 going in and one thing you can see is that the scale of increase in spending and the scale of
01:13:08 increase in the public service hasn't been matched by greater productivity in certain areas so the
01:13:13 focus does have to go to that in order to create the room and maintain the room for those social
01:13:20 programs, because that is what the Liberal Party is about. One of the core things, which is to
01:13:26 manage responsibly our fiscal position so that we can support the vulnerable in society so we can
01:13:32 move forward as a society. So we need to spend less and invest more as a country. We're going
01:13:40 to move into a six-minute debate on this. Yes, because this is something we want to continue
01:13:45 to discuss. Ms. Freeland, I'll go to you first on this one. Productivity seems to be sort of a
01:13:51 sleeper issue. When you mention it to Canadians, they go, how will you fix productivity in this
01:13:59 country? Well, I think that President Trump is giving us this golden opportunity to fix some of
01:14:10 the long-standing well-known obstacles to Canada being more productive. Interprovincial trade is
01:14:17 the standout example and we now have the will to do it. Recognizing foreign credentials of people
01:14:24 who are already here, you know, that famous person we all know who is driving a taxi but is a nurse or a
01:14:30 doctor, that's another example. Another one is just cutting red tape to get big projects built. 0.96
01:14:36 But we're coming to the end of the economic section, and I do want to talk about a part of the economy where there have been huge leaps in productivity, which is central to Canada's resilience and economic strength, particularly as we face up to Donald Trump, and that is rural Canada and our farmers.
01:14:57 I am the daughter of a farmer. I grew up on a farm. There are no people in Canada or the world who work harder than farmers. And I do think it's really important for us to have government policies that support our farmers.
01:15:12 They give us food security. They are an important source of strength when it comes to this standoff
01:15:19 with the U.S. And we need to be very clear with Canada's dairy farmers that we will stand for
01:15:26 supply management. I mean, isn't it a good thing that we produce our own milk, our own eggs, our
01:15:34 own butter, our own cheese, that we're not dependent on U.S. factory farms for that? So we need to
01:15:41 remember and stand with our farmers. Ms. Gould, your next please. Thank you, Hannah. Look,
01:15:46 Chrystia, I'm really glad you mentioned the rural economy and agriculture. One of the first things
01:15:51 I would do as Prime Minister in my speech from the throne is to ensure that we protect supply
01:15:55 management. It was a piece of legislation that unfortunately died when we prorogued Parliament,
01:16:01 but I think it is imperative that we protect our supply managed sectors. But I think one of the
01:16:07 frustrations that rural Canada has had with us as a government is that we haven't spoken enough
01:16:12 about sectors in rural Canada whether that is mining whether that is you know energy whether
01:16:20 that is agriculture whether that is forestry and you know for us we have to really ensure that we
01:16:25 talk about productivity we're not just talking about new sectors we're talking about existing
01:16:30 sectors and this is where ai can be used as a tool to enhance productivity in those sectors
01:16:37 and that's something that i'm really excited about but one thing that i i do want to mention
01:16:42 and mark i'm glad you talked about paul martin because i know you were a really excellent
01:16:46 deputy minister of finance who did really good work and is that we also need to remember that
01:16:53 the economy is about people it's not just numbers or points on a graph it's about how do we make
01:16:59 the economy work for people and Hannah your question about productivity what does that mean
01:17:04 to the average Canadian when they're saying I can't afford my groceries and I'm having a hard
01:17:09 time paying my rent we need to talk about the things that matter to Canadians not because we're
01:17:15 talking as politicians but because we're talking as people who understand and experience what
01:17:20 they're going through and that's something that I bring to the table okay I'm gonna have to stick
01:17:24 to time on this topic. Mr. Bayless, you wanted to jump in on that and then Mr. Carney after that.
01:17:30 So when we talk about productivity, one of the first places I'm going to look at
01:17:33 is the federal government itself. That's when I talked about modernizing the federal government,
01:17:38 one of my three priorities. I'll give you an example here. Revenue Canada is the biggest
01:17:43 pain point for both individuals and businesses in trying to pay their taxes. This is ridiculous. 0.96
01:17:48 This is such a waste of time and that wasted time directly impacts their productivity.
01:17:54 so i'm going to fix revenue canada i'm going to get it working the way it should work because the
01:17:58 people that are calling and trying to work with revenue canada are good people they're trying to
01:18:02 pay their taxes other things i'm going to do i'm going to build two pipelines two gas pipelines
01:18:09 to get our great alberto natural gas to the east coast and the west coast that's going to have a
01:18:14 huge impact on our economy it's going to diversify us away from reliance just on the americans and
01:18:20 And yes, it's going to have a very positive impact on the world's environmental situation
01:18:25 because it'll allow our Asian and our European allies to come off of coal and oil and start
01:18:31 using a much cleaner fuel, liquid natural gas from Alberta.
01:18:35 Mark Kearney.
01:18:36 One of the reasons why families have a hard time to afford their groceries is because
01:18:41 we haven't had productivity.
01:18:43 That's the issue.
01:18:44 It's that their wages aren't keeping pace with prices.
01:18:48 That's because they're not being given the right tools to work with.
01:18:52 We're not working as smart as we should.
01:18:54 So that's the challenge that we're talking about.
01:18:56 And that's the result.
01:18:57 And that's the connection.
01:18:58 As Prime Minister, you need to make the connection between policies that make that difference that go to families.
01:19:06 So both are connected.
01:19:07 A couple of quick points.
01:19:08 Number one, one Canadian economy will drive huge productivity.
01:19:13 Secondly, productivity in government, as Frank just says.
01:19:15 I won't go on about it, but it's absolutely essential.
01:19:17 when we have not had the productivity need in government.
01:19:19 Thirdly, the two big drivers, productivity going forward,
01:19:24 will be the energy transition and AI.
01:19:27 Okay, I'm gonna give you each 15 seconds,
01:19:29 Ms. Freeland, with you, first.
01:19:32 Making Canada more productive,
01:19:34 which just really means making us all more prosperous,
01:19:37 means we have to invest in infrastructure.
01:19:39 We have to invest in physical infrastructure.
01:19:42 That's why I'm so supportive of high-speed rail.
01:19:45 We also have to invest in social infrastructure.
01:19:47 That is infrastructure too.
01:19:49 And early learning and childcare is such a great example
01:19:54 because this is a policy
01:19:55 which makes life more affordable for families.
01:19:58 It makes kids smarter because it's so high quality
01:20:01 and it adds to the labor force
01:20:03 without requiring any new homes.
01:20:05 So physical infrastructure, social infrastructure,
01:20:08 and we have the national will to really do this
01:20:12 because we know we need to be more resilient
01:20:14 because we're at this critical moment for our country,
01:20:17 facing the need to stand up to Trump
01:20:19 and defend our sovereignty and our economy.
01:20:21 That was not 15 seconds, but we'll try again.
01:20:24 Karina Gould, 15 seconds for you
01:20:26 and then I am gonna give Mr. Bayless 15 as well.
01:20:29 The job of Prime Minister is to connect with Canadians
01:20:32 and it's to ensure that you are placing the priorities
01:20:35 of Canadians at the centre of everything that you do.
01:20:40 That's why tackling things like homelessness
01:20:42 and housing affordability actually make people's lives more affordable.
01:20:47 That's the job of being a politician.
01:20:49 It's putting the human face on policy.
01:20:51 Mr. Bayless, 15 seconds.
01:20:53 So with respect to productivity, I'm one of those people that says, what's best practices?
01:20:58 Now one of the leaders in productivity in the world is Ireland, and they have a very
01:21:01 clear axiom of belief.
01:21:04 Capital gains should be lower because it encourages investments.
01:21:07 Whether you're on the right or the left of the spectrum, they all know that.
01:21:11 keep their capital gains tax very low and that encourages the investments that they need for
01:21:15 productivity. Literally five seconds Mr Kearney. It's time to build we should support builders and
01:21:22 those are people who take risk for our country. Okay we are going to move on to our third theme
01:21:28 this evening I want to thank you for that last one it was a really good debate and we're going to
01:21:33 start with you Ms Gould on this one. This is a one minute so each of you are going to get one minute
01:21:39 to respond to this. In 2015, Justin Trudeau swept to power in large part because young Canadians,
01:21:46 they liked him, they voted for him. But fast forward to today, that age group is really moving
01:21:53 towards the right. What will you do as Prime Minister to win back the support of that age group?
01:22:00 Thanks, Hannah.
01:22:02 Well, maybe the debate so far is indicative of why young people are not supporting the Liberals right now.
01:22:10 Because we're not talking about the issues that matter to them.
01:22:13 We talked a little bit about housing, but that's one of the biggest challenges that young people are facing right now.
01:22:19 My plan to really supercharge our housing investments, but also to ensure that young people can actually enter the housing market will make a difference in that regard.
01:22:29 We're not talking about the cost of living on how challenging it is to be a young person these days and the dream of owning a home or having that prosperity that's just not there.
01:22:42 And if I can be honest, you know, one of the things that we did was we lost trust of younger people because we weren't focused on the issues that mattered to them.
01:22:51 And so my pledge as Prime Minister is to ensure that I am building a future for you as young people and for future generations.
01:23:00 Thank you, Ms. Gould.
01:23:01 Frank Billis, you're up next.
01:23:02 So for young people, there's a few things that are critically important.
01:23:06 First of all, let's talk about education. 0.91
01:23:08 We've done something very silly.
01:23:10 By the way, my one minute is not on.
01:23:12 Should it be on?
01:23:12 I'll keep track.
01:23:13 Okay.
01:23:14 Sorry about that.
01:23:15 That was very honest.
01:23:16 Yeah.
01:23:17 There we go.
01:23:17 There we go.
01:23:18 And you'll get those extra seconds.
01:23:19 No problem.
01:23:20 so what i was going to say is that first of all i want to see real investments in our universities 0.84
01:23:25 we've been squeezing our universities and quite frankly that's the dumbest thing we should be
01:23:29 doing because that's the foundation of an advanced economy so i want young people to know that i will
01:23:34 be completely supporting your education second thing is they are the ones that are going to find
01:23:39 it hardest to buy a home so we need to help them buy a home and there's two things we can do there
01:23:44 well there's many things but two things that i'm proposing is to increase the amount for the first
01:23:48 home savings account it hasn't kept up with inflation in that so we need to increase the
01:23:53 amount of money that people can put aside so they can buy a home and the second thing we need to do
01:23:58 is really keep the investments going which have been lacking for so long in social housing the
01:24:03 government's got out of social housing and there's a knock-on effect that affects everybody when that
01:24:08 happens so we need to get back into social housing we need to help young people buy their homes and 0.99
01:24:12 what we need to do when i get the government in order what will happen is you'll have more money
01:24:17 in your pocket it'll take a little bit of time but you will be able to buy a home. Ms Freeland your
01:24:22 one minute is now. Well I was there in 2015. I had been a backbench MP for two years and I remember
01:24:31 how electric that campaign was and the reason we won at the heart of it was we recognized the pain
01:24:41 that middle-class Canadians, including young Canadians, were feeling. And we recognized and
01:24:48 identified that Stephen Harper led a lackluster recovery from the 2008 financial crisis. We
01:24:57 pointed that out and we said we are going to invest for jobs and growth. Today, we need to
01:25:03 do the same thing and we need to focus on affordability for young people. I have a plan
01:25:07 to do that. Cut taxes for first-time homebuyers. Cut taxes for the middle class. 100,000 new
01:25:14 child care places. Cap credit card fees. We need to be there for young Canadians so that they can
01:25:22 know if they work hard, study hard in the free trade schools I will offer them, they can have
01:25:28 a great Canadian middle class life. Mr. Carney, you're next. Okay. Are we going to talk about
01:25:35 housing we're getting there okay good one is housing central to this but i want to add to
01:25:42 the opportunity set for younger canadians which has shrunk in recent years let's expand it let's
01:25:48 expand it in all aspects of what we're doing first and foremost it's a time to build as miss
01:25:54 freeland just said focus on infrastructure building this economy out there is a huge range
01:26:00 of opportunities that comes as i say for the next 25 years being in the trades
01:26:05 fantastic if we follow through with the promise there.
01:26:08 That's the first.
01:26:09 The second is, as Mr. Bayless said,
01:26:12 let's look at our universities.
01:26:13 Their funding is being squeezed and has been squeezed
01:26:17 and it's been made up by having foreign students.
01:26:20 That's come to an end.
01:26:21 We need to be there for our universities
01:26:23 or we're gonna miss the opportunity.
01:26:24 Thirdly, we need broad-based skills training.
01:26:28 The federal government has a role there.
01:26:29 We need to leverage AI and others to deliver it.
01:26:33 Okay, we are going into a five-minute debate now.
01:26:36 And Ms. Gould, I'm going to start with you again on this one.
01:26:38 This is from a Liberal in Ontario, Carissa.
01:26:42 She's asked the question in this survey,
01:26:46 how do you plan to make owning a home,
01:26:49 and there comes the question about home ownership,
01:26:51 feel like a possibility to those stuck in renter's land?
01:26:56 Thank you, Carissa, for that question.
01:26:58 So there are two parts of my comprehensive plan on housing.
01:27:02 One, create an industrial housing strategy so that we can build millions of new homes.
01:27:09 We can use modular homes.
01:27:10 We can invest in co-op housing.
01:27:12 But also to increase the first-time homebuyers incentive.
01:27:16 Right now, it's about 5% to 10%.
01:27:18 I want to increase that to 50% so that first-time homebuyers can actually get into the market, build equity, and buy back that equity over time.
01:27:28 But I want to pick up quickly on the last question, because I was actually a young person in 2015, and I was excited about what the Liberal Party of Canada was offering, and I was excited about Justin Trudeau's leadership.
01:27:41 And you know why?
01:27:42 Because it was a bold, ambitious plan for our country.
01:27:46 It was progressive.
01:27:47 We were going to fight.
01:27:48 We fought climate change.
01:27:50 We talked about new ideas to move this country forward.
01:27:53 And the way that we're going to bring young people back to the party is not by being conservative light and not by being unambitious for Canada.
01:28:02 It's going to be by having bold ideas for this country where Canadians feel inspired and hopeful about the future that we're going to have.
01:28:11 That's what young people are looking for.
01:28:13 They're looking for a hopeful future where those opportunities exist.
01:28:17 And, you know, I'm not quite still a young person, although I'm younger.
01:28:21 You know, it's that energy, that drive, that optimism for the future that is going to build the best country in the world.
01:28:28 Ms. Freeland, you're up next, please.
01:28:30 So first of all, I want to say, Carissa, thank you very much for being involved and for asking that question.
01:28:36 I hear that question from so many younger people who are just frustrated that they're worried that they've lost out on getting into the housing market.
01:28:46 and maybe the kind of life that their parents had
01:28:49 is not going to be available to them.
01:28:51 It is absolutely essential for us as a country
01:28:55 that we say, we're not going to let that happen.
01:28:58 And if young Canadians work hard, have a good job,
01:29:03 studied hard, and they want to own a home,
01:29:06 we have to make that dream of homeownership achievable.
01:29:09 I have a plan to do it.
01:29:11 It starts with cutting taxes for first-time homebuyers to give them a leg up in the housing
01:29:18 market.
01:29:18 I'm so glad to hear so many people mentioning the first home savings account.
01:29:22 I introduced that as finance minister.
01:29:24 I think it is a great way for young people to save for that first home, and I would increase
01:29:30 the amount of money that people can put in that first home savings account.
01:29:34 Free trade school is going to help people get that first home too, because it will mean
01:29:39 there are more skilled trades people to build those first homes people need and then finally
01:29:44 i just want to say some people are going to want to buy their own home some people want to live in
01:29:49 affordable housing or maybe a co-op i lived in a co-op one of my aunts still lives in the co-op 0.99
01:29:54 she and my mom helped build there is though someone in canada who does not believe in affordable
01:30:01 housing who does not believe in co-ops pier poliev has actually called them soviet style housing and
01:30:08 so we all need to be very very clear we must defeat him because some canadians need affordable
01:30:14 housing too mr bayless you're up next so i feel for these young people when i look at the house
01:30:19 prices i shake my head and think my gosh when i was buying a house i thought it was hard and it
01:30:24 was my first home was 195 000 it's almost shameful to say that now but what back then buying a home
01:30:32 was about four times your salary your annual salary it's gone up to now 10 times your salary
01:30:37 so what are we going to do about that well we're not going to bring house prices down then so we
01:30:43 need to get your salaries up and we need to get more money in your pocket and we need to bring
01:30:47 the cost of living back in line so what i'm proposing to do is there's a number of technical
01:30:53 issues which i've listed on my website but in a general sense i would say to young people start
01:30:58 saving if i become prime minister i'll get to work on the economy i'll create the good jobs
01:31:03 that you need just like I've done in my own businesses. You'll have more money in your
01:31:07 pockets and will get the cost of living under control. And in a few years with the home saving
01:31:11 plans and that, you will be able to buy a house. So please do not lose hope on that. Okay, Mr.
01:31:16 Carney, I'm going to end this segment on you, please. Okay. So we need to double the rate of
01:31:21 home building in this country. That 10 times salary point, we need to double the rate in order
01:31:27 to even have the places for those people.
01:31:31 We obviously need to get those incomes up at the same time.
01:31:35 So there's two questions here.
01:31:36 How do we get the rate of home building going from $250,000 a year to $500,000?
01:31:42 We're going to need changes to how we build homes.
01:31:46 Much more technology, much more modular homes.
01:31:48 We're going to need a big surge, as was just mentioned, in tradespeople who can build those
01:31:53 homes.
01:31:54 need to cut the fees in municipalities for developers the federal government has a role
01:32:00 to play there we have a housing accelerator fund that's working i would supercharge that as part of
01:32:04 this and then on the other side of the equation we need to make it more affordable particularly
01:32:09 for young people to buy those homes now removing gst on first-time home purchases that's five
01:32:16 percent off the home which is a substantial proportion of the down payment there's other
01:32:21 financing mechanisms that come with that but in the end and let me finish on this this will come
01:32:27 back to our ability to build a strong economy it's not just building the homes it's building
01:32:33 the strong economy so people can catch up we're going to move on to our next segment it's not the
01:32:38 segment another theme but this is an important topic canadians are worried they can't access
01:32:43 a doctor or a nurse what would you do as prime minister working with the provinces of course
01:32:49 because it is provincial jurisdiction and territories to help solve this issue.
01:32:54 And Mr. Carney, you are up first on this one.
01:32:56 Well, this is a crucial issue.
01:32:59 Across the country, virtually without exception, in fact, I would say without exception,
01:33:05 access to a doctor, in many cases access to a healthcare professional, is not possible.
01:33:13 Healthcare is a right in Canada.
01:33:15 We are not living up to our commitments.
01:33:18 And this is not as simple as saying, I'm not saying you implied this, that it's a provincial jurisdiction.
01:33:24 So first and foremost, we have to meet our responsibilities as the federal government in terms of the health care transfers, but we have to do a lot more.
01:33:31 We have to make sure, and we should be part of this, that health care professionals can move across this country as readily.
01:33:38 So a nurse in Quebec can go to Alberta, can go to Northwest Territories and practice immediately.
01:33:43 We have to make it easier for foreign health professionals to work more rapidly.
01:33:49 We have to increase productivity in the health sector.
01:33:53 Mr. Bayless has ideas on that, including on portable data, portable health records, which are crucial,
01:34:00 but a broader use of AI and us, last point, us as a federal government,
01:34:04 accelerating those changes to deliver what Canadians deserve as Canadians, and we're nowhere close yet.
01:34:11 Ms. Gould, you have one minute on the clock now.
01:34:13 Thank you. My goodness. I mean this is something that every Canadian has experienced. The anxiety of not being able to have a family doctor or worried and what we're seeing across the country is emergency rooms that are closed or that are understaffed and hallway medicine.
01:34:30 This is absolutely a provincial jurisdiction, but the federal government has an important role to play in two regards.
01:34:39 When it comes to health transfers, we need greater accountability from provinces, not to the federal government, but to their own citizens on the outcomes and the outcomes that they expect to deliver for their citizens.
01:34:53 And then when the federal government can do is convene provinces and territories and colleges to ensure that our health care workers can travel across the country, but we also expeditiously can recognize foreign trained doctors and health care professionals so that every Canadian has access to a family doctor and the medical specialist that they need when they need it.
01:35:14 Mr. Bayliss, your one minute is on the clock.
01:35:16 So I've spent 40 years of my career in the healthcare industry and I can give you examples
01:35:21 where I've walked through emergency rooms down the hallways and I've seen people in
01:35:26 gurneys up and down there and it's broken my heart.
01:35:28 So I'm absolutely committed to fixing the healthcare system.
01:35:31 What we need is a change in paradigm.
01:35:34 Our system was designed in the 1960s when population generally was younger and it was
01:35:39 designed for acute care.
01:35:41 Now we have a chronic care problem.
01:35:43 So we need to redesign our system to treat chronic care.
01:35:46 Presently there's only two doorways into the system. If you're lucky you have a family doctor
01:35:51 and if you're not, what do they tell you to do? Go to the emergency room. So what I want to do is
01:35:56 open three more doors into the system. I want to go to pharmacists first of all and expand their
01:36:02 scope of practice. They can do so much I want them to do a lot more which they're trained to do.
01:36:07 Number two, I want to train 6,000 nurses to become what we call nurse practitioners. 0.98
01:36:13 that would allow them to do almost as much as a doctor and have them staffed across the country
01:36:17 and finally i want to invest in home care and miss freeland one minute for you as well um well thank
01:36:24 you hannah and i want to start by thanking the great hard-working people in the canadian healthcare
01:36:31 system a few days ago i spoke to a nurse practitioner her name was kathy in riding
01:36:37 mountain hi kathy i hope you're listening she's a liberal um and she talked to me about how much
01:36:42 she loves her job and cares for her patients but how much of a strain the strain on the healthcare
01:36:48 system imposes on her too so thank you very much we do have to make it better we have to make it
01:36:56 better by training more doctors nurses nurse practitioners here in canada by recognizing
01:37:02 foreign credentials and by allowing credentials to be portable across the country by inviting the
01:37:08 great doctors and nurses, Canadian ones in the U.S. who want to come home, encouraging
01:37:14 them to come home, making it possible.
01:37:17 And finally, we need to be clear with Canadians who care about their health care system.
01:37:22 You cannot trust Pierre Polyev with our universal single-payer health care system.
01:37:28 All he believes in is cuts, cuts, cuts, and that is one of the things that motivates me
01:37:34 as a liberal to defeat the conservatives in the next election we are going to go into an
01:37:39 open debate section here on this and mr bayless yes i will start with you on this one i want to
01:37:44 ask a follow-up question on it is it simply a question of money when it comes to health care
01:37:49 and transfer payments increasing that money because i know provinces would love to have
01:37:54 more money for health care or does the structure of the health care system need to change
01:37:59 so a few years ago the federal government announced something like 40 billion dollars
01:38:04 more in healthcare spending and nobody went great finally it's solved we all shook our heads and said
01:38:10 great we're just shoveling more money into the fire because we do need to change the paradigm
01:38:15 now the wonderful thing i can tell you is that i have seen the technologies that can do that
01:38:20 develop right here in canada i'm working with one company i'm supporting and that they've developed
01:38:25 is amazing in terms of electronic medical records using artificial intelligence to wrap around and
01:38:31 read all your records anywhere they are and produce reports accordingly i've seen other ai
01:38:37 developments in canada again where they allow doctors to spend a lot less time note-taking in
01:38:43 fact no time note-taking and everything collage put together for them and doctors can be doctors
01:38:49 so we have the technology here we have the ability to go forward here this is what i'm going to bring
01:38:54 to the healthcare system and when i'm done we are going to have the best healthcare system in the
01:39:00 world believe it ms gould your next one this one thank you hannah look universal health care and 0.91
01:39:08 acts timely access to our health system is something that every canadian deserves and
01:39:14 should have and it was a liberal government that put universal health care in place we can be very
01:39:20 very proud of that legacy however when it comes to the actual system it is the provinces and the
01:39:27 territories that manage and deliver care the federal government provides transfers but what
01:39:33 we don't do enough of and while i support the increase in transfers that we did we didn't have
01:39:39 enough accountability for where that money was going it can go into the general revenues of
01:39:43 provinces and territories and we have no way of knowing how that money is spent and again it's not
01:39:48 to be accountable to the federal government. It's to be accountable to citizens. Citizens deserve to
01:39:54 know how that money is being spent and what the outcomes they can expect are. One of the things
01:40:00 that I did with the child care agreements is that all of that money was contingent on specific
01:40:05 objectives and outcomes for provinces and territories. That's what we need in healthcare.
01:40:10 Canadians deserve timely access to a doctor. They deserve to have a family doctor or a primary care
01:40:17 physician. And they deserve to know that when they get sick, when they need the healthcare system,
01:40:22 it's there for them. Because our healthcare workers are working around the clock. They are
01:40:28 doing everything they can to provide patients the care that they need. But the system itself needs
01:40:33 to be modernized. The federal government can convene the provinces and territories. We can
01:40:38 work with them to develop those objectives and those outcomes. But at the end of the day,
01:40:43 It is the provinces and territories that are responsible for the delivery of health care,
01:40:48 and they must be accountable to their citizens for how they are doing that.
01:40:53 Mr. Carney, you're up next, please.
01:40:54 So look at the service that we've received from our health care professionals
01:41:00 over the course of the last five years.
01:41:02 The enormous strains of working under the pandemic,
01:41:06 then the enormous strains that come after that on these professionals
01:41:10 We're there at the front lines for us, day in, day out, through the night, of a system that is short on resources, a system that has chronic care challenges as we age.
01:41:23 We have a responsibility, as the federal government, to be part of the solution here, and we have an opportunity to make a systemic change because of technology, and if we have an openness, the provinces have an openness, to use that in a way that empowers nurse practitioners, pharmacists, doctors, to provide a broader range of services
01:41:51 to more people, more effectively, last point, the federal government can help with that transition,
01:42:00 can help with the leverage, and can help drive that change.
01:42:03 Ms. Freeland.
01:42:05 Well, Hannah, you asked, does money matter? And I do think it's really important for liberals
01:42:15 in particular, to be clear, money does matter, and money helps. And so I was really glad to be
01:42:25 finance minister when we stepped up federal government support for the health care system,
01:42:31 $200 billion. We saw that the health care system was under unbearable strain after COVID,
01:42:38 and that Canadians were suffering, and we stepped up and we made that commitment.
01:42:42 I think we also have some real opportunities. Technology is a huge enabler, and I have seen
01:42:51 in Toronto, at the University of Toronto, some amazing AI technologies being used to deliver
01:42:57 better care in emergency rooms, better care for people after surgery, and not only is the care
01:43:04 better, it costs less money and takes less time of trained healthcare professionals. So there are
01:43:09 real opportunities but I just want to conclude by saying something about the provinces. I think
01:43:15 that transparency you know is the winning ticket here and having real transparency on health care
01:43:23 outcomes across the country would help all Canadians and it would help Canadians to see
01:43:29 what's working and what isn't. But I do want to say to the premiers of the provinces and territories
01:43:34 I respect your work running the health care systems.
01:43:38 It's really, really hard.
01:43:41 And as Prime Minister, I would work really collaboratively with you and would recognize you want a health care system that works too.
01:43:49 And you are the ones who are running it.
01:43:51 We are going to give 15 seconds to Ms. Gould and 15 seconds to Mr. Bayless before moving into the next theme.
01:43:57 Great, thank you.
01:43:58 so first of all my job as prime minister is to stand up for canadians whether that is to the
01:44:03 opposition or whether that is to premiers of course i would work collaboratively but you
01:44:07 have a responsibility to your citizens to deliver health care effectively but one thing that i think
01:44:13 all of us agree on on this stage is protecting our public health care system here polia is in
01:44:19 the pockets of people who want to privatize our health care system for profit that is not something
01:44:25 that i think any liberal stands for we will protect our universal health care system for
01:44:29 canadian frank bales so in the 1960s when the system was designed if you're unlucky enough
01:44:34 to have diabetes heart disease cancer you passed away much earlier today we have extended your life
01:44:41 expectancy now with that that's the paradigm change that we need our system wasn't designed
01:44:46 to look after those people so we need to readapt it redesign it to look after those people that's
01:44:51 how we'll have better health care and it'll actually cost less okay i want to thank you for
01:44:56 that third theme we're going to move into our final theme of this evening it has been whipping
01:45:01 by i must say uh and this is again a one minute question for everyone and it is again a question
01:45:07 from one liberal from alberta her name's rhonda she says are you keeping and we did hear this
01:45:14 in the french debate last night but not in the english so far are you keeping or getting rid
01:45:19 of the consumer tax but to that most of you here have supported this marquee government policy
01:45:27 for years if you agree with ending it why do you agree with ending it now so i am going to start
01:45:35 with mr carney on this one thank you uh thank you hannah thank you rhonda for this question fellow
01:45:40 l burden um yes i support ending the consumer carbon tax and to be absolutely clear that's on
01:45:46 consumers, it'd be on small businesses, it'd be on farms as well. The reason I do is twofold. One,
01:45:53 politics is about people and this has become too divisive for Canadians. Secondly,
01:46:01 the contribution of the consumer carbon tax is a little less than 10 percent of our emissions
01:46:06 reductions. I've spent a substantial portion of my career working on these issues and there are
01:46:11 are better ways to accomplish those emissions reductions, particularly on my proposal, is that
01:46:18 big polluters will pay Canadians, not taxpayers, big polluters will pay Canadians for their emission
01:46:25 reductions and will improve the options for and the ability of those companies, or some of our
01:46:31 most important companies, to get their own emissions down. Okay, we're going to come back
01:46:34 and debate this more, but Ms. Freeland, you are next with one minute. Well, since we're talking
01:46:39 about climate action I do want to start by recognizing the role that I think history is
01:46:46 going to judge very positively that Prime Minister Trudeau has played on climate action. He is the
01:46:53 first Canadian Prime Minister to really move the dial and under his leadership we have become a
01:47:00 country where the economy is growing while emissions are going down. That is a huge accomplishment for
01:47:06 our children and grandchildren. On the consumer price on pollution, I was the first candidate to
01:47:12 come out and say I would lift that. And the reason is really simple. Democracy is about listening to
01:47:19 people. And Canadians were very clear with us in conversations with me that they didn't think that
01:47:26 policy worked for them. What we need is carrots. We need incentives to double down on the incentives
01:47:32 I put in place the Canada Growth Fund, the investment tax credits to create a green transition
01:47:39 that delivers jobs and growth for the Canadian economy. I know that we can do that and I know
01:47:46 that that's what Canadians need. And if we let Pierre Polyev be elected, that will be the end
01:47:52 of climate action in Canada. Okay, we're on the one minute segment and Mr. Bayless, you're up next.
01:47:57 Thank you. So I will implement a climate policy that will have a direct and tangible impact on
01:48:02 fighting climate change and it's going to be recognized as we've all heard before polluter
01:48:06 pays model and everyone is going to do their share industries and individuals look there's a cost to
01:48:14 having our garbage collected there's a cost to having water treatment plants and we're happy to
01:48:20 pay those costs because we have clean earth and we have clean water and there will be a cost to
01:48:26 having clean air anyone who tells you there's no cost to it is not being honest with you
01:48:30 So to answer your question about this carbon tax, presently it's not working because what it's doing is just circulating money around.
01:48:38 So I'm going to adapt it. And what we're going to do is attack the problem directly.
01:48:44 So I'm going to invest funds into programs and Canadian companies that are bringing forth solutions to fight climate change directly.
01:48:53 And Karina Gould, you have said that you are not going to scrap the consumer carbon tax,
01:48:58 that you will stop the increase in April. Maybe discuss that a bit.
01:49:03 Sure. Well, politics is also about leadership and it's also about conviction. And I'm not going to
01:49:10 abandon the fight against climate change because Pierre Polyev is telling us to do that. I'm a mom
01:49:16 of two young kids. I cannot leave a planet that is burning to them. I got into politics in 2015
01:49:23 because I wanted to be part of a government that fought climate change. And we did that. And we did
01:49:29 that to great effect. And I am proud of that record. But I hear Canadians when they say that 0.95
01:49:35 this policy is something that is challenging for them. And you know what? We didn't do a good job
01:49:40 of talking about it. And when they are talking about the carbon tax, what are they talking about?
01:49:44 they're talking about affordability that's why we need a real affordability plan it's not that
01:49:49 they're against fighting climate change or they're against protecting the environment
01:49:53 but that also means that if you don't have the price on pollution you don't have the rebate
01:49:58 checks that millions of canadians depend on every single year if you have a fight if you have a plan
01:50:06 to fight climate change you also need to have a plan to fight affordability yeah we are okay
01:50:11 Let's just get right into the debate because Mr. Karniko.
01:50:14 I want to pick up on that point, last point, and really go to Pierre Polyev, the difference
01:50:20 between Pierre Polyev's approach here.
01:50:23 Ask the tax, he's got the t-shirt, he's got the slogan, that's all he'd do.
01:50:26 He doesn't care about the rebate checks disappearing.
01:50:29 He doesn't care about our businesses becoming more competitive.
01:50:33 We started this evening talking about the absolute need for our country to diversify
01:50:39 our trade to build with new allies climate change addressing climate change and i've spent
01:50:46 huge part of my career addressing it both in terms of policy and leading the largest clean
01:50:54 energy investor in the world okay but a big part of climate change is about the economic
01:51:01 opportunity we will not have access to the european market unless we make the progress here
01:51:06 So we have to do two things.
01:51:08 We have to supercharge some of the programs that have been put in place.
01:51:13 So businesses are getting their emissions down.
01:51:19 We are a clean energy superpower.
01:51:22 And we have to make all of those households whole on the rebate checks that they will no longer receive.
01:51:28 That requires a middle class tax cut.
01:51:30 It requires additional measures, including, final point, polluters paying those households.
01:51:36 so their energy is more affordable and cleaner we have two minutes and 30
01:51:41 seconds on the clock and we're gonna have to stick to this so I want to get
01:51:44 through all of you miss Freeland first Rhonda you asked something very specific
01:51:50 what was the moment when I recognized that we needed a different approach and
01:51:56 I can tell you very specifically what that moment was it was a meeting I had
01:52:01 with Wab Kanu, the premier of Manitoba, really shortly after he was elected. And he is a great
01:52:10 progressive leader in, I would say, the tradition of prairie progressives. He says the economic
01:52:15 horse has to pull the social cart. I love that. And he said to me, I believe in climate action,
01:52:23 but I've just been through an election and the people of Manitoba are telling me that the way
01:52:28 the consumer price on pollution works doesn't work for them can i do a deal with the federal
01:52:34 government where we hit our targets but we do it in a different way and that to me is leadership
01:52:42 leadership is listening to people it is not being inflexible and not telling people what their lives
01:52:52 are like, but hearing them. And so I really believe if we want climate action, which is
01:52:59 essential, we have to listen to Canadians. And if we fail to do that, the threat is,
01:53:05 the danger is that Pierre Polyev will be elected and he will dismantle all of the excellent work
01:53:14 we have done on climate. We have to recognize that. We have to show Canadians we hear them
01:53:19 and that we're listening to what they tell us
01:53:21 rather than telling them what they should be thinking.
01:53:23 Okay, I'm going to jump in there
01:53:24 because we do have to stick to time now.
01:53:27 Ms. Gould, you're on next.
01:53:28 Thank you so much.
01:53:29 So just a couple of things with respect to my colleagues.
01:53:33 Literally the whole reason why we have the carbon tax backstop
01:53:37 is because premiers across this country
01:53:40 decided they didn't want to participate.
01:53:42 So if Manitoba wants to participate,
01:53:45 then the consumer price on carbon
01:53:46 from the federal government disappears.
01:53:49 That's what happens in Quebec.
01:53:50 That's what happens in British Columbia.
01:53:52 With respect to Mark and the middle class tax cut,
01:53:56 the math just doesn't add up.
01:53:58 If you are a middle class individual,
01:54:00 that tax cut is looking at about $800 a year.
01:54:03 The carbon rebate for a family of four is $1,200 a year.
01:54:08 And it doesn't help low income or no income Canadians.
01:54:12 So it is really important to have a real conversation
01:54:16 with Canadians.
01:54:17 And if you don't have a plan for those checks, then we don't have a plan for affordability.
01:54:21 I'm going to come to you now, Mr. Bayless.
01:54:24 We are going to go into the one minute segment, but it's a good follow up to this.
01:54:28 I know you wanted to jump in to maximize Canada's energy advantage, new pipelines or other energy infrastructure probably is required here.
01:54:38 What is your plan for that?
01:54:40 And do you feel there is the private interest to get it done?
01:54:44 because a lot of private interest has now just gone, nope, not interested anymore.
01:54:50 So I have an energy security plan, which I've announced, and it's going to do a number of
01:54:54 things. First of all, as I mentioned, we're going to build two pipelines. And why private industry
01:54:59 is not interested is because what happens is every time a new government comes in,
01:55:03 they change all the rules. There's no certainty. So my idea here is that the federal government
01:55:08 will take on the responsibility of having the approvals for the two corridors. We'll work with
01:55:12 the provinces and we'll work with the indigenous communities, get all the approvals in place and
01:55:18 then go to tender so people can know with certainty that they can build these two pipelines.
01:55:23 That's one area of energy security. Another one is I want to invest heavily in nuclear energy,
01:55:29 small modular reactors. Canada used to be a world leader with our can-do reactors and nuclear energy.
01:55:35 We have to retake that position. Third thing I want to do is invest in transmission lines.
01:55:40 We don't have transmission lines going across the whole country.
01:55:43 With the electrification of our economy, we're going to need those.
01:55:47 So those are the three points I want to bring to the table.
01:55:50 Frank Bayless, thank you kindly for that.
01:55:51 And Mark Carney, you're up next.
01:55:54 I'll go back to where we started.
01:55:56 We're in a crisis.
01:55:58 We need to act.
01:55:59 We need to act to build this economy.
01:56:00 And part of those actions is or should be around our energy sector.
01:56:05 I would convene, as part of First Minister's discussion of the projects of national interest, which would include both clean and conventional energy, would include pipelines, getting consensus around those projects that we're going to move forward on.
01:56:23 Because we are a federation, we need multiple levels of government, but we need speed.
01:56:27 And we need the federal government to move with speed.
01:56:31 We also need to do, and we can do, and can lead in areas such as carbon capture and storage.
01:56:39 We can lead in displacing the 70% of oil in eastern Canada that comes from the United States
01:56:46 that is using the money to threaten us.
01:56:50 So this is part of a bigger set of opportunities for Canada.
01:56:54 I'd help to lead those changes, and I would do it right from the start.
01:56:58 Ms. Freeland, your one-minute starts.
01:56:59 I do want to go back to the critical moment our country is facing to the existential threat
01:57:08 that President Trump poses to our economy, to our sovereignty.
01:57:14 And Canadians get that. 0.65
01:57:16 One of the reasons I am so confident that we can get through this and that we can get
01:57:23 a good deal, that actually we can successfully negotiate with President Trump, is because
01:57:28 we are an energy superpower. Uranium, hydro, wind, traditional energy. This is a strength and we need
01:57:40 to double down on it. I am very proud to be the minister that got access for our energy to the
01:57:48 Pacific. That diversification is so valuable today. It gives us an alternative to the United 0.96
01:57:55 We need that more than ever.
01:57:57 I believe there is the national will right now
01:58:00 in Canada to double down on our energy strength
01:58:04 to use that as a source of economic security
01:58:07 and also of national security, including as
01:58:10 something that we can offer to our European
01:58:13 and Asian allies whose support we need for our
01:58:16 own security.
01:58:18 Okay, Karina Gould, one minute.
01:58:21 Thank you.
01:58:22 Energy security is imperative not just for
01:58:25 security but also for our sovereignty and as Canadians we know how to do
01:58:30 something really well we know how to skate to where the puck is going and so
01:58:34 that means that we need to have a conversation right now about what
01:58:38 securing our energy future looks like both with traditional energy but also
01:58:42 with new renewable energy if we think about where we're going to be in 5-10
01:58:48 years where our trading partners are going to be in 5 or 10 years we have to
01:58:52 have a real conversation about what Canada can provide for Canadians, but also for the world.
01:58:57 I'm from Southern Ontario, and we have incredible technology when it comes to nuclear. We have an
01:59:04 amazing opportunity to build renewable energy here at home, but also to export our energy and our
01:59:12 expertise around the world. This is the conversation for Canadians to be having right now, and to do
01:59:18 it with provinces and territories and with indigenous peoples we are going to go into the
01:59:23 that was the one minute debate we are going to go into the five minute final debate of the evening
01:59:29 and this is a question you can take it wherever you want how will you differentiate yourself
01:59:35 from the current prime minister justin trudeau uh start with yourself miss freeland i just i'm
01:59:42 actually going to carry on with the previous theme because we haven't touched on something
01:59:50 really important to Canada and that actually is an integral part of our energy security future
01:59:57 and is a really positive story. And that is Indigenous participation in energy projects.
02:00:05 One of the things I was so proud to be able to do as finance minister is create a $5 billion
02:00:12 Indigenous loan guarantee program to allow Indigenous direct participation, ownership of natural
02:00:20 resource projects, energy projects. This is transformational for Canada. And I think that we
02:00:27 really need to embrace the fact that we are a country that can move forward with Indigenous
02:00:33 prosperity. And we are a country whose path to reconciliation can include Indigenous people in
02:00:40 Canada being partners in building the energy security we need today more than ever. Okay thanks
02:00:45 and I will come back with that other question so I'm going to go back to my original question in
02:00:49 this debate how will you differentiate yourself from Prime Minister Trudeau? Sure let me just first
02:00:54 start by saying that I think it's wonderful what you raised Christia it's just that Indigenous 1.00
02:00:58 reconciliation is about more than a relationship with natural resources and this is something that
02:01:03 I think we can be extraordinarily proud of the legacy that Prime Minister Trudeau has put in
02:01:09 place when it comes to reconciliation. And we need to be very mindful that a Pierre Polyev-led
02:01:14 Conservative government will back away and backtrack on this really important relationship
02:01:20 that Canada has with Indigenous peoples. And I also just want to say that I'm actually really
02:01:26 proud of a lot of the work that we did as a government, whether it was the Canada Child
02:01:31 Benefit that has lifted over half a million kids out of poverty, the early learning and child care
02:01:36 agreements or the work that we did on fighting climate change. I'm proud of that legacy and that
02:01:43 record and I think all Liberals can be proud of that. Where I see a big difference is in making
02:01:51 sure that we stay and I stay connected to the grassroots and this is something that as Liberals
02:01:56 I want to talk to you specifically about. We need to hear your voices, we need to hear your ideas
02:02:02 Because it is always the liberal membership, the liberal grassroots that provides the next big idea for Canada and for Canadians.
02:02:11 And so my pledge to you is to ensure that we have a robust and vibrant party that is connected in our communities,
02:02:19 listening to Canadians and making sure that we can build that future that we want and lead Canada ambitiously into the 21st century.
02:02:28 So that's how you'll differentiate yourself from Mr. Trudeau?
02:02:33 I'm very proud of the record that we have. We've made some mistakes, absolutely. Nobody is perfect
02:02:38 but we've done a lot of good things for this country and I think we need to build on that
02:02:43 success. I can pinpoint the moment following the pandemic when inflation was getting out of control
02:02:50 and Canadians were saying to all of us collectively as a government they were saying we need help with
02:02:55 the cost of living and we were too late to the game to address those real needs. My pledge to
02:03:01 you is to listen to you and to respond to what your needs are today and for the future thank
02:03:06 you miss gould mr bayless you're up next how you differentiate yourself from mr trudeau so i would
02:03:11 say that i'm the candidate here that is the most distant from mr trudeau i was elected it was over
02:03:16 six years ago since i've been in the government and then i was not a minister so i've not been
02:03:21 a minister with mr trudeau's government nor have i have i been an economic advisor where i will
02:03:26 differentiated myself greatly is that I'll be focused much more on the economy. I'll be focused
02:03:32 on creating wealth. I'll be focused on getting more money into Canadians' pockets. That's what
02:03:38 I'm good at. I'm also going to look at building an innovation-based economy. So I really wanted
02:03:42 to do that. That's going to be my main focus. You need both when you're in government. You need
02:03:47 wealth creation and you need wealth redistribution. We've done a lot of wealth redistribution to the
02:03:53 point that we're renouncing programs we can't even pay for. And we're letting programs such as
02:03:58 healthcare fall apart. So what I want to do is get back in there. I'm a big supporter of these
02:04:02 programs. So I want to make sure we have the funds to pay for them. That's going to be where I'm
02:04:06 going to be much different from the previous government. Okay, Mr. Bayless, thank you for
02:04:10 that. Mr. Carney, you're up next. Thank you. Thanks for the question. Look,
02:04:14 I'm different in the following respects. First, focus on the economy. Laser focus on the economy,
02:04:24 and that means good jobs, people's wages growing faster than inflation. It means getting prices
02:04:30 down. It means building homes. It means building a future for this country. Secondly, I'm much more
02:04:36 hands-on. I'm much more of a hands-on person, hands-on manager. I focus on results and getting
02:04:42 things done. Thirdly, and I've heard this, I'm fortunate to have support in the caucus. I hear
02:04:49 directly from the supporters about more regular and two-way dialogue with the caucus. I meet with
02:04:56 my supporters virtually during the course of this leadership campaign to hear their ideas,
02:05:02 to hear their energy, to hear what's going on, what they're seeing on the ground, to share my
02:05:06 perspectives in order to move forward. Okay, and Ms. Rieland, I am going to come back to you on this
02:05:11 I only have about 30 seconds on this.
02:05:13 How would you differentiate yourself
02:05:15 after being in the Justin Trudeau government
02:05:18 for all of these years?
02:05:19 Well, first of all,
02:05:21 we as Liberals have to be proud
02:05:24 of the great things our government has done.
02:05:26 National system of early learning and childcare,
02:05:29 Canada child benefit, support for seniors,
02:05:32 CETA, NAFTA, we have done a lot
02:05:35 and we need to remind Canadians about that.
02:05:38 But, you know, for me,
02:05:39 this campaign has been a personal liberation and I am my own person and it is great. I personally
02:05:48 do not believe in a style of leadership which is a one-man band. I think that the best kind
02:05:56 of leadership is collaborative and listening and that's how I'm running my campaign. I believe that
02:06:02 we have to be practical and we have to focus on jobs and growth but most importantly I am
02:06:09 a ferocious mother and I will fight for Canada with the same ferocity that I fight for my kids.
02:06:18 I will fight for your kids too and the reason I am running is I am the leader who can stand up
02:06:24 to Donald Trump and win. Okay we still have closing statements as well so this is that
02:06:31 opportunity for each candidate. I may have to take some time away because of that and Ms. Freeland
02:06:36 You are chosen as number one to have your closing statement first, so your minute 30 is there.
02:06:43 We might have to clip it a little bit.
02:06:46 Well, first of all, I do hope Donald Trump, who takes a keen interest in Canada, is watching this debate
02:06:53 because what he will hear from all the Liberals is, we believe in Canada, we are not going to capitulate,
02:07:01 and we are going to fight for our country.
02:07:04 And Canadians across the country are coming together to fight for Canada. Hockey fans are
02:07:10 belting out O Canada. Restaurants pulling U.S. wine from their menus. Snowbirds not flying south
02:07:18 this winter. Our country is standing strong, smart and united. I am so grateful to be here with three
02:07:27 other liberals who love Canada and to have the chance to talk to 400,000 liberals who love Canada
02:07:34 too. Now, Pierre Polyev, he actually agrees with Trump. They both say that Canada is broken.
02:07:42 We know that's not true. We are leading a great wave of Canadian patriotism.
02:07:50 Let's use that passion to make our amazing country even better. I know we can do it. Let's
02:07:58 commit tonight to fight for Canada. All four of us on this stage, all of us liberals, all of us
02:08:05 Canadians. Together, we will win. Krista Freeland, thank you so much for your closing statements.
02:08:13 It's now Karina Gould, your time.
02:08:16 This is a critical time for our party and for our country.
02:08:21 And we have to meet this moment.
02:08:23 We will only win the next election by being liberals,
02:08:27 proudly, not conservative light.
02:08:30 Not by running from the progress we've made,
02:08:32 not by putting forward ideas that just tinker around the edges.
02:08:36 We need, we deserve, a leader who is honest with Canadians,
02:08:41 who can unite us around big ideas
02:08:43 and who has the political experience
02:08:45 to deliver real solutions to the problems we face.
02:08:49 A leader with a track record of standing up to bullies,
02:08:52 a leader who won't back down.
02:08:54 I've always been someone who will stand by what I believe in,
02:08:57 say what I mean and fight for what is right.
02:09:00 I've made the hard decisions and stood up for Canadians.
02:09:03 I believe Canada is the best place in the world
02:09:06 to start a family, grow a business and build a future.
02:09:10 Because we are a nation of dreamers and doers,
02:09:13 creators and innovators.
02:09:15 Because Canada is where opportunity, empathy,
02:09:18 and progress walk hand in hand.
02:09:20 I have a vision for Canada,
02:09:22 one that will allow us to deal with the problems
02:09:24 we face today and be ready for those we'll face tomorrow.
02:09:28 It's time for a new generation of leadership
02:09:31 that understands you and is focused on you.
02:09:34 I'm here for Canada today, tomorrow, and for years to come.
02:09:39 I'm the leader for the future and the future starts now.
02:09:42 Thank you.
02:09:43 Karina Gould, thank you so much.
02:09:45 Frank Bayliss, you're up next.
02:09:47 Thank you.
02:09:49 So Canada is a country of wide open spaces and big ideas.
02:09:52 And with my plan, we will build a strong and resilient economy
02:09:56 that will benefit all Canadians.
02:09:59 We will improve our healthcare system
02:10:00 and it will become the best healthcare system in the world.
02:10:05 We will modernize our federal government
02:10:06 so they can deliver its services to our citizens
02:10:09 in a very effective and efficient manner.
02:10:12 And yes, we will repel,
02:10:14 and we will overcome the attacks of President Trump.
02:10:19 Now, in the last 10 years, the world has changed profoundly.
02:10:24 And now, as a country, we need to go in a new direction.
02:10:29 As you look to choose your next leader,
02:10:31 I would ask you to reflect on these three points.
02:10:33 I have the best, most credible plan to build a strong, resilient economy.
02:10:40 I'm best suited to defeat Pierre Polyev and expose him for exactly what he is.
02:10:45 He's a career politician who likes to make up slogans and nothing else.
02:10:50 And I have the background, the experience, and the expertise to firmly stand up to President Trump.
02:10:57 I will successfully defend our nation.
02:10:59 I will defend against his attacks on our economy, on our culture, and yes, our sovereignty.
02:11:06 My fellow citizens, I represent that new direction.
02:11:10 So, let's be bold. Let's be ambitious.
02:11:14 Together we will build a proud and prosperous Canada.
02:11:17 My name is Frank Bayless, and to make this happen, I need your support.
02:11:22 Mr. Bayless, thank you so much for your closing statement.
02:11:25 And finally, we go to Mark Kearney.
02:11:27 Thank you, Hannah.
02:11:28 fellow liberals my fellow canadians from coast to coast to coast you've told me that you're anxious
02:11:36 in the face of an uncertain future you've told me that you're looking for positive change
02:11:42 that you want a leader that bridges divides you want a plan that defends our interests
02:11:49 and creates opportunities for everyone every experience in my life whether by accident or
02:11:55 design has led me to this moment I'm ready it's true I'm not a career
02:12:01 politician I am a pragmatist who knows how to get things done I've managed
02:12:08 economic crises built strong economies and run tough negotiations and this
02:12:14 gives me the experience to lead Canada at this crucial time we're facing a very
02:12:20 different world to the one we've known all our lives. The Canadians are ready
02:12:26 to unite and stand up for our country. We will seize this moment to win for
02:12:35 Canada. I love our country. Canada has given me everything. My family, my
02:12:44 education, my values, and in return, I'm ready to give everything for Canada. Thank you.
02:12:56 Okay, that brings us to the end of the English Liberal leadership debate. I want to thank all
02:13:02 four candidates for a great job this evening. Voting does start tomorrow. I know, I know,
02:13:09 and then the announcement of the next leader of the Liberal Party will be made on
02:13:14 march the 9th in ottawa so congratulations to all of you for putting your name in to do this