Juno News - March 10, 2026


LIVE: Watch the Travis Dhanraj hearing

Topics
Mentioned
Senators blow THOUSANDS on BOOZE and disco parties EXCLUSIVE: Travis Dhanraj’s lawyer SPEAKS OUT on EXPLOSIVE testimony

Episode Stats


Length

2 hours and 10 minutes

Words per minute

146.03

Word count

19,085

Sentence count

642

Harmful content

Misogyny

8

sentences flagged

Toxicity

1

sentences flagged

Hate speech

3

sentences flagged


Summary

Summaries generated with gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ .

Join us as we hear from members of the Committee on the State of the Journalism and Media Sector and friends of Canadian media as they give their perspective on the state of journalism and media in Canada. We also hear from a panel of experts and experts in the field of media ethics.

Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Topics generated with Qwen2.5-3B-Instruct.
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 I would ask all in-person participants to please read the guidelines written on the
00:00:05 updated cards on your table, measures that are in place to help prevent feedback incidents
00:00:11 and protect the health and safety of all, including and especially our interpreters.
00:00:17 There is a QR code on that card that links to a short awareness video if you need more
00:00:22 information.
00:00:25 Pursuant to the routine motion adopted by this committee, I can confirm that all the
00:00:28 witnesses have completed the required connection tests in advance of this meeting. Please wait
00:00:34 until I recognize you by name before you speak and all comments should be through the chair.
00:00:42 Pursuant to Standing Order 1082 and the motion adopted by the committee on Monday, September 22,
00:00:46 2025, this committee is meeting to study the state of the journalism and media sectors.
00:00:53 so quite a broad study and with us today we have travis danraj former journalist association
00:01:02 des radiodiffuseurs communautaires du quebec angela carrero executive director welcome
00:01:09 freshnet news janet clo and mario bartel with friends of canadian media we have raj shown
00:01:17 and Randy Kitt. Honest Reporting Canada, we have Mike Fegelman, Amanda Eskenasi, and Dr.
00:01:26 Horan Shani-Narkis, please forgive me if I've butchered your name, and Paul Deacon from News
00:01:33 Media Canada, good to see you again sir. So everyone or your organization will have five
00:01:39 minutes for an opening statement and then we'll open up the floor to members for questions.
00:01:46 we'll start with mr dan rush you have the floor now for five minutes sir
00:01:52 let's press this there we go appreciate it good morning uh madame chair and members of the
00:01:56 committee as a kid growing up in alberta i wasn't like most of my friends every night i watched the
00:02:03 national with nolton nash he represented a public broadcaster that belonged to canadians not to
00:02:11 power not to party, but to the public. And that is the CBC that I believed in. Now, many Canadians
00:02:18 know the story about one of my tweets. In April 2024, I publicly stated that Canada Tonight had
00:02:24 requested an interview with then-CBC President Catherine Tate, and the request was declined.
00:02:30 Facts. Shortly after, I was removed from the air. On May 7th, 2024, Tate told this very committee
00:02:39 she was, quote, not aware of any repercussions. Yet 24 hours earlier, ATIP records show her
00:02:46 vice president, Barb Williams, briefed her directly about my situation. And that matters
00:02:52 because trust matters. The tweet was not the beginning. It was the breaking point. For months
00:02:59 prior, tensions had been building, not over performance, but over control. While I was
00:03:04 publicly held up as a bold, diverse host, my ability to lead the very program carrying my
00:03:10 face and name was quietly being stripped away. CBC's stated commitment to diversity contrasted
00:03:17 with realities of tokenism. Still, I pushed forward, creating a nightly panel to showcase
00:03:24 real diversity, including of thought. I questioned unequal pay. Why, for example,
00:03:30 one contributor who was Indigenous always needed to be paid, while others weren't. When a prominent
00:03:36 Black journalist requested compensation after appearing doing the exact same job, I was told
00:03:41 to reconsider booking him moving forward. I attempted to end this discriminatory practice.
00:03:47 Instead, the panel was cancelled. When it came to politics, interviews were blocked under guardrails,
00:03:54 governed by an internal document never made public, titled Parameters for Political Guests,
00:03:59 Political access was centralized. Booking decisions controlled elsewhere.
00:04:04 It did not happen once. It became a pattern. It became the standard.
00:04:09 Power and Politics, hosted by David Cochran, was given gatekeeping authority over which politicians could appear on Canada tonight.
00:04:16 When I questioned that control and who was in control, I was viewed as disruptive.
00:04:23 Now, at the same time, I raised concerns about a toxic environment.
00:04:26 After I sat down with Speaker Greg Fergus for a conversation on Black History Month,
00:04:32 Chief Political Correspondent Rosemary Barton circulated internal communications questioning my program, 0.63
00:04:38 copying senior leadership, insinuating she or Mr. Cochran should have done the interview.
00:04:45 It was an intimidation tactic, which management ignored.
00:04:49 I and others raised concerns about bullying behavior by senior figures, including Mr. Cochran.
00:04:54 But while he remained on air, I faced discipline and marginalization.
00:04:59 Now, the transcripts of these meetings show the issue was not about my journalism, but about reputational risk to the corporation.
00:05:06 I received a written warning carrying the threat of termination.
00:05:09 I was placed under confidentiality restrictions that prevented me from correcting public and internal narratives.
00:05:16 CBC silenced and intimidated me simply for trying to do my job and fulfill my public service role to Canadians.
00:05:22 Now, this is not about left or right. It's not about one tweet or one career. It's about systemic control, tokenism, selective enforcement, and a toxic culture where intimidation went unchecked.
00:05:38 When I refused to waive my rights under the Canadian Human Rights Act in a proposed confidentiality agreement right here, and a gag order, essentially, my role was not renewed.
00:05:49 My union, tasked with protecting my rights as an employee, told me explicitly, quote, it's very much a normal thing that we use.
00:05:58 After 25 years in journalism, my career ended.
00:06:01 That dream I had as a kid of working at CBC shattered along with my trust in it.
00:06:07 Now, inside the newsroom, the message was unmistakable and did not need to be spoken.
00:06:11 I raised concerns. I challenged centralized control and bias.
00:06:15 I fought for real diversity and equal standards.
00:06:18 I tried to do my job as a journalist.
00:06:20 Within months, I was pulled off the air, disciplined, restricted from speaking,
00:06:24 stripped of my primetime program, and eventually out altogether.
00:06:29 Now, if you were still working there, would you feel safe raising similar concerns?
00:06:33 this is how silence becomes culture. It's how whistleblowers are intimidated. Public institutions
00:06:40 do not weaken from scrutiny. They weaken when they avoid it. The CBC that I believed in was
00:06:47 strong enough to withstand accountability. If it is to endure as a public broadcaster worthy of
00:06:53 Canadians' trust and over $1.4 billion of their money, it must be strong enough to withstand it
00:06:59 again accountability is not destruction it is survival thank you for your time
00:07:07 thank you and next we go to angelica carrera for the association
00:07:18 i don't know if i said your name correctly but you have five minutes starting now thank you
00:07:26 you. Madam Chair, members of the committee, thank you for giving me the opportunity to share some
00:07:33 observations as part of the study on journalism and the media in Canada and Quebec. I would also
00:07:40 like to commend the work of the committee, which made accurate and relevant recommendations in its
00:07:45 third report. As the Executive Director of the Association of Community Radio Broadcasters of
00:07:50 I have the privilege of observing the work accomplished by these stations.
00:07:54 We have 37 radio stations spread across the province from Montreal to Matagami and the Ile de la Madeleine, for example.
00:08:03 Most are francophone, but some are bilingual or anglophone, such as the station in Blanc-Sablon.
00:08:10 They therefore cover a huge area, sometimes with only meager revenues per year.
00:08:18 the work they do is creative tireless and sometimes miraculous there are also
00:08:25 media outlets that have been around for many years which have stood the test of
00:08:29 time despite the difficulties the vast majority of stations employ at least one
00:08:34 journalist sometimes two or three or four for a total of about 50 journalists
00:08:40 who work to provide local news coverage rooted in the reality of their respective
00:08:47 communities community radio stations have always enjoyed the public's trust and this was confirmed
00:08:54 by a study conducted by our association in 2024 furthermore it is not enough to simply say that
00:09:01 you are doing local journalism you have to actually do it the physical presence of journalists
00:09:08 in community stations is to be distinguished from cases where news is generated by means
00:09:13 other than humans or where broadcasts merely relay information from the largest nearby urban center
00:09:20 but in addition to the physical presence of journalists and all their volunteers because
00:09:24 there are many volunteers it is their mission and raison d'etre that make them excellent ambassadors
00:09:31 for the local community their mission is to serve the community in which they are rooted in fact it
00:09:36 is the community that creates and manages the radio station that has the community's interests
00:09:41 at heart it is important to remember that these are non-profit media outlets and they play an
00:09:49 essential role in protecting freedom of the press and defending the public's right to quality
00:09:55 information their content is diverse non-partisan comprehensive and reliable we therefore provide
00:10:04 the kind of local journalism that the committee refers to in its second recommendation and it is
00:10:10 true to say that it needs support a lot of support indeed as i said at the beginning community radio
00:10:16 stations operate on meager revenues that are dwindling year after year and when people seem
00:10:21 to say they are heavily subsidized that is very unfortunate because the only provincial subsidy
00:10:27 they receive for their operations does not even cover the normal salary of one of the company's
00:10:31 employees or barely these subsidies are difficult to renew even after many years for the federal
00:10:38 government we have the local journalism initiative which we really appreciate and a little project
00:10:43 funding is offered for those who managed to qualify but it is not enough fortunately we are
00:10:48 stepping up our efforts to promote the community radio initiative which could be managed by the
00:10:55 community radio fund of canada in an attempt to increase the funds available to all community
00:11:01 radio stations in the country we are asking the government for annual operating funding
00:11:06 of approximately 30 million dollars to provide around 85 000 per station which is still very
00:11:12 modest compared to the funding provided or needed by other broadcasters this assistance would help
00:11:20 ensure basic financial visit viability otherwise radio stations must rely on advertising revenue
00:11:28 to try to make up for this shortfall but as several experts have already pointed out this
00:11:33 advertising revenue has clearly shifted to foreign platforms which are gobbling up almost everything
00:11:38 this is not new canadian government money is being used to grow the financial assets of large
00:11:43 american companies multinationals this goes against the bi-local policy promoted by this
00:11:50 same government i would also like to highlight the work we are doing along with our two sister
00:11:55 associations the ncra the national campus and community radio association and the alliance of
00:12:02 community radio broadcasters of canada to try to issue a clear directive on local advertising
00:12:10 a specific portion would be systematically allocated to community advertising
00:12:16 together our three associations represent independent non-profit community radio stations
00:12:23 across Canada. We believe that this directive would encourage governments to allocate more
00:12:29 of the funds that are already there but used elsewhere to local media. It is a reallocation
00:12:36 of existing funds, it's not a new request. But above all, we believe that advertising
00:12:42 broadcast in this way would have a much greater and more lasting impact on Canadians. As the
00:12:49 The Government of Canada continues to invest in public communications to raise awareness
00:12:54 of its programs and services, it is increasingly important to ensure that these messages are
00:13:00 delivered through channels that truly reach the intended audiences, rather than through
00:13:05 digital giants that have no roots or support in Canada.
00:13:10 Advertising that does not take into account geographic, linguistic, or digital barriers
00:13:14 risks leaving some communities confused and misinformed.
00:13:18 short the general idea is to help the government fulfill its mission of informing the country's
00:13:24 entire population and having a more significant impact on it thank you very much thank you
00:13:32 clou and mario bartel from freshnet news collectively you have five minutes i'm not
00:13:38 sure how you want to share that thank you for the opportunity to speak at this committee
00:13:43 my name is mariel bartell and my name is janice clue and along with theresa mcmanus and cornelia
00:13:49 naylor we are the co-founders of freshet news the first non-profit news cooperative in western
00:13:54 canada that's union supported we are veteran community news reporters editors paginators
00:14:00 with more than 100 years of combined experience covering new westminster burnaby and the tri-cities
00:14:06 in british columbia approximately 600 000 people outside of the city of vancouver
00:14:12 Last April, Glacier Media, now called Low Star Media, closed our three online publications,
00:14:18 the New Westminster Record, Burnaby Now, and Tri-City News, in the middle of the federal election.
00:14:24 It meant we couldn't cover the all-candidates meetings, our candidates couldn't get their messaging out,
00:14:29 and our readers were lost about who to vote for.
00:14:31 This is dangerous to democracy.
00:14:34 When I originally landed at the Tri-City News in 1991,
00:14:38 virtually every community in the Lower Mainland was served by at least two local papers.
00:14:45 Consolidation and closures winnowed that down to one in most communities by 2015.
00:14:50 Then in August 2023, the same month our meta-social media shut down,
00:14:55 Glacier Media stopped printing our newspapers altogether.
00:14:58 The company said online was the only way forward.
00:15:01 It wasn't.
00:15:03 Less than two years later, five rapidly growing cities in two villages immediately east of Vancouver
00:15:08 were left with little or no local news source that meant decisions made at city
00:15:13 halls and school boards got no independent coverage there were no
00:15:17 stories about young athletes and emerging artists no coverage of local
00:15:21 events festivals parades what may have been no longer economically viable to
00:15:27 glacier media was untenable to the journalists who have dedicated their
00:15:31 careers to sharing those stories after all we live in those communities too so
00:15:36 four of us got together with a co-op developer and with the support of our union you know for
00:15:41 local 2000 we put together a plan to keep our communities informed we spent the summer and
00:15:47 early fall of 2025 learning about co-op structures and governance fundraising and doing community
00:15:53 outreach people told us they didn't know what was happening in their hometowns anymore
00:15:59 on october 15th we launched freshet news online a single title covering all our communities
00:16:06 It's named for the annual spring runoff from the northern snows that washed down the Fraser River, past our cities.
00:16:12 It symbolizes renewal, a fresh start.
00:16:15 Two months later, we revived a print edition.
00:16:18 We're monthly for now, but we plan to increase to twice a month in April, with our ultimate goal to return to weekly publication.
00:16:26 We're four journalists who never had to give much thought to the business side of our craft,
00:16:30 the ads that ran between our stories and the distribution network that got those stories to readers.
00:16:35 the learning curve has been steep but our journalism skill set has made us adept to
00:16:40 changing gears when needed the communities are responding our website traffic grows every week
00:16:47 as do subscriptions to our weekly email newsletter advertisers are eager to get into our newspaper
00:16:52 and readers are scooping up the newspapers 20 000 of them from our distribution points at city halls
00:16:58 community and cultural recreation hubs grocery stores coffee shops and barber shops senior
00:17:05 residences we even get calls to replenish we truly we truly feel our model of non-profit
00:17:12 locally rooted journalism that's accountable to the communities we serve is a way forward
00:17:17 as corporate media gives up but what we're doing is not new in fact across the united states as
00:17:23 corporate media abandons communities due to lack of profits reporter-led news organizations and
00:17:28 collectives are filling the gap still supports are lacking for journalism startups in canada
00:17:34 we've come this far mostly on a volunteer basis as we continue looking for jobs
00:17:39 our severance and ei benefits have dried up our fundraising at community events and through
00:17:44 online through an online crowdfunding platform has comprised mostly small individual donations
00:17:51 10 25 100 at a time we don't have charitable status so we can't issue tax receipts that might
00:17:57 shake loose transformative big money support foundation funding frequently looks for a proven
00:18:04 history something that's difficult for a startup to provide grant opportunities are often like
00:18:08 fitting a square peg into a round hole and the few that are journalism specific like the local
00:18:13 journalism initiative are already over subscribed and don't provide funding for critical supports
00:18:19 like hiring ad reps who can bring in ad revenue or covering costs like software subscriptions
00:18:24 insurance printing and distribution make no mistake many of the media's industry's wounds
00:18:32 are self-inflicted too much growth too quickly back when times were flush too much consolidation
00:18:38 too many resources expended chasing bad ideas too many owners that are investors rather than people
00:18:44 who believe in the mission of news those owners would have would have us believe the news business
00:18:50 is dead but our from our experience in the past few months since we started fresh at news has
00:18:55 been quite the opposite people want to be connected to each other and their communities
00:19:00 free from algorithms businesses want to share their stories local customers and journalists
00:19:06 want to be able to write and keep sharing the stories putting community back into community
00:19:11 news is the way forward thank you thank you it's a very effective use of sharing your time and as
00:19:18 a former community reporter i really appreciate your efforts thank you for all you're doing
00:19:25 next we have the friends of canadian media rash shown and randy kit i expect an equally engaging
00:19:31 back and forth between the two of you yeah the floor for five minutes thank you madam chair
00:19:37 members of the committee friends is a non-partisan public interest organization dedicated to ensuring
00:19:42 that canadians have access to strong independent canadian journalism and storytelling we advocate
00:19:48 for citizens not for corporations because a healthy media system is essential to a healthy
00:19:53 democracy let me begin plainly the state of journalism in canada is poor and in most
00:19:58 communities it is deteriorating further over the past decade and a half hundreds of local
00:20:03 news outlets have closed across the country millions of canadians now live in communities
00:20:08 with little or no local news coverage newsrooms have shrunk journalists have been laid off
00:20:14 entire beats have disappeared this is not simply an industry transition it's a democratic deficit
00:20:21 local journalism scrutinizes municipal councils it covers courts it informs citizens about public
00:20:27 health education and emergencies when journalism disappears civic participation declines
00:20:34 polarization increases and misinformation fills the vacuum governments have taken important steps
00:20:40 including the journalism labor tax credit the local journalism initiative the online news act
00:20:46 the online streaming act and support for cbc these measures matter they demonstrate recognition that
00:20:52 journalism is not just another sector it's democratic infrastructure but the structural
00:20:58 disruption facing canadian journalism remains profound the economic model that sustained local
00:21:04 news has been destabilized by global digital platforms that capture advertising revenue while
00:21:10 investing minimally in canadian news production that brings me to five areas where federal
00:21:15 leadership is essential first the online news act and the online streaming act are critical to
00:21:21 creating a sustainable funding framework for local news these laws must not be weakened
00:21:27 traded away or hollowed out through exemptions or side deals regulatory certainty and enforcement
00:21:33 are essential second eligibility for the journalism labor tax credit should be expanded to include
00:21:38 broadcasters broadcast newsrooms particularly local television radio face financial pressures
00:21:45 similar to print the they too are pillars of local accountability third parliament should close the
00:21:51 loophole in section 19 of the income tax act that allows full deductibility of advertising on
00:21:56 foreign digital platforms canadian advertising dollars should not receive preferential tax
00:22:02 treatment when they're directed to foreign platforms rather than canadian outlets fourth
00:22:07 the federal government should commit to directing at least 25 of its advertising budget to trusted
00:22:13 domestic news organizations both publishers and broadcasters big and small this would
00:22:19 strengthen local journalism while ensuring canadians receive critical public information
00:22:24 through reliable channels fifth canadian news creators must be protected from having their
00:22:29 content used by artificial intelligence companies without permission or compensation copyright
00:22:35 protections licensing frameworks and transparency requirements must ensure journalism is not
00:22:41 harvested without value flowing back to those who produce it finally a vibrant cbc is part of a
00:22:47 strong ecosystem alongside successful private and independent media as the national public
00:22:53 broadcaster it plays a foundational role in connecting regions serving official language
00:22:57 minority communities and maintaining news capacity where commercial models are under strain
00:23:03 i will now turn to my colleague randy kit thank you raj chair members of the committee
00:23:08 uniform represents approximately 9 000 media workers across canada in the last several years
00:23:13 alone hundreds of journalists and media employees have lost their jobs when newsrooms shrink the
00:23:19 consequences are immediate fewer reporters at city hall fewer investigative projects fewer
00:23:25 rural correspondence and more reliance on centralized news content and yet the demand
00:23:30 for reliable information has never been greater as fresh at news can tell you we are living through
00:23:37 a period of geopolitical instability rising information and increased public cynicism
00:23:43 journalism is one of the few professions capable of grounding public debate and verified fact
00:23:49 failing to stabilize canadian journalism means surrendering not just jobs but our sovereignty
00:23:55 losing our local accountability shared facts and democratic resilience that safeguard our nation's
00:24:01 independence journalism is essential to a functioning democracy and the canadian
00:24:06 government should treat it like a national park something that must be nurtured protected
00:24:12 and properly funded for future generations a strong journalism sector is not a luxury
00:24:18 it's infrastructure for democracy and it's imperative that we sustain it we thank the
00:24:23 the committee for undertaking the study and stand ready to assist thank you very much uh we'll now
00:24:31 turn to honest reporting canada i have mike fegelman in the room do you have colleagues
00:24:35 online i don't oh they are here we go are you all joining in the five minute opening
00:24:41 joining in the q a component okay very good very good you have the floor now for five minutes
00:24:46 good morning my name is mike fegelman and i'm the executive director of honest reporting canada
00:24:51 we're a non-profit organization that ensures fair and accurate Canadian media coverage of Israel.
00:24:56 We started more than 20 years ago, but the overt media bias that we have experienced and seen over
00:25:01 the last two and a half years has made that era look quaint by comparison. Just hours after
00:25:07 thousands of Palestinian terrorists invaded Israel on October 7th, carrying out an orgy of murder,
00:25:12 rape, torture, and kidnappings, our taxpayer-funded broadcaster leapt into action. In a letter to
00:25:18 Editorial staff, George Ahe, CBC's former director of journalistic standards and practices, warned journalists not to use the word terrorist when referring to Hamas, not to admit that it was, and even when Canadian officials refer to Hamas as terrorists.
00:25:36 He wrote that reporters, quote, should add context to ensure that audiences is a.
00:25:46 It's to be.
00:25:49 And for a wide swan of the Canadian media landscaped, their role was not.
00:25:55 But to use the immense influence to promote a narrow ideological agenda.
00:26:01 agenda. Present day, news outlets parrot talking points from pro-Palestinian activists.
00:26:15 When anti-Israel groups sneeze, it achieves wall-to-wall news coverage. When Amnesty
00:26:20 International accuses Israel of committing a genocide, going so far as to make up a new
00:26:25 definition in order to do so, or when a discredited group of non-experts make such
00:26:29 The unfoundry claim of genocide and starvation were promoted to media, and as it soon became
00:26:47 clear that those allegations were false, reporters didn't apologize, they simply moved on.
00:26:53 Now, like a cat chasing laser dot on the wall, the worst offenders in anti-Israel media bias in Canada, whether the CBC, the Globe and Mail, the Toronto Star or others, take their cues not from what's newsworthy, but rather what complaints are being made by pro-Palestinian activists.
00:27:10 When reporters document the worrying rise of Islamic radicalism in Canada, the presence of Iranian regime officials in our nation, or the impact of Qatari dark money in Canadian universities, they are treated as persona non grata.
00:27:24 When a Canadian mosque recently honoured Iran's Supreme Leader Ayatollah Khamenei and glorified him as a martyr, our journalists ignored this brazen support for terrorism.
00:27:34 Our journalists have a solemn duty to hold the powerful to account, to not act as their water carriers.
00:27:41 But that's what they've done, promoting hardline anti-Israel disinformation and acting as unpaid publicists for immense web of extremist actors in Canada.
00:27:52 This media coverage directly contributes to a spike in anti-Jewish hate crimes.
00:27:57 When Israel is painted as a genocidal and pariah state and opponents are widely silenced,
00:28:03 a target is drawn on the back of Canadian Jews.
00:28:06 The incessant demonization of Israel, and by extension Jews,
00:28:09 has led to an unprecedented attack on the Jewish community,
00:28:12 with terrorist rallies now a regular occurrence on Canadian streets,
00:28:16 and Jewish schools and synagogues, as we saw this past week, shot at, while far too many elected
00:28:23 leaders and law enforcement ignore this cancer that is in our midst. Over the past two years,
00:28:28 our media promoted ideology over facts, and in the case of the CBC, did so at the taxpayer's
00:28:35 expense. I'm happy to recount numerous examples of Canadian media bias that we have confronted.
00:28:40 When our media act as stenographers for a regressive and hateful worldview, it's not
00:28:46 reporting the news, it is creating it. And when our leaders stay silent, they let it happen.
00:28:52 Our elected leaders must take the lead to remedy the situation. In my written testimony and
00:28:57 submission to this committee, I've offered three concrete courses of action that you can take
00:29:02 directly to counter these critical issues, and I would be happy to elucidate them today for anyone
00:29:07 interested. As well, I've brought with me here today two colleagues, Dr. Haran Shani-Narkas,
00:29:13 CEO of InnoHives, and Amanda Eskenazi, Director of Education at HR Canada Charitable Organization.
00:29:20 They conducted a comprehensive review of the CBC's coverage of the Israel-Hamas war
00:29:25 and have provided real scientific evidence of asymmetric coverage. It isn't an opinion that
00:29:30 the CBC is one-sided. We now have scientific, irrefutable proof. Canadian taxpayers fund
00:29:38 public broadcasters to provide accurate, impartial, and reliable information.
00:29:42 When media outlets choose ideology over facts, they fail in this fundamental duty,
00:29:47 leaving Canadians misinformed on issues of national security, on issues of terrorism and international conflict.
00:29:54 This is not merely a concern for one community.
00:29:57 It affects every Canadian's right to understand the world as it truly is. 0.69
00:30:02 Restoring trust in our media is not a partisan issue, but a national imperative.
00:30:08 parliament must act now to ensure that our media serve canadians with facts
00:30:12 with fairness and with integrity because an informed public depends on it
00:30:16 and our democracy requires it thank you thank you and finally we have paul deegan
00:30:23 with news media canada welcome sir you have five minutes starting now
00:30:28 Bonjour. Media d'Info Canada represents about 550 news titles across Canada, from independent weekly
00:30:41 community newspapers to large urban and national dailies. The advertising market in Canada continues
00:30:47 to remain very challenging. Simply put, too many ad dollars are being scooped up by Google. Last year,
00:30:53 a U.S. federal court judge ruled that Google, which operates in all three areas of the market,
00:30:58 the buying, the selling, and the ad exchange itself illegally monopolize the ad tech market
00:31:05 through anti-competitive conduct. News publishers fully embrace and support the responsible and
00:31:11 ethical use of artificial intelligence. At the same time, despite deploying bot blockers, we are
00:31:18 seeing the theft of our intellectual property on an industrial scale. Companies like Google,
00:31:24 Microsoft, OpenAI, which is familiar to all of you in terms of the role their employees didn't play
00:31:30 in alerting authorities to the Tumblr Ridge incident, perplexity, and even Canada's Cohere
00:31:36 are ingesting, repackaging, and distributing copyright-protected content directly from
00:31:42 published news articles. These companies aren't just providing snippets that one would find
00:31:47 through a traditional search. They're providing very detailed summaries and passing it off as
00:31:52 their own creation. They're depriving news publishers of audience, subscriptions, and
00:31:57 advertising, capturing the value journalism depends on for its survival. Moreover, Google,
00:32:04 which is dominant in search, has embedded AI-generated summaries directly into their
00:32:09 search interface without providing publishers with an effective opt-out mechanism. If publishers
00:32:15 want to block Google's AI crawler, they find themselves de-endexed or unable to attract traffic
00:32:21 to their sites news is an essential input to the knowledge economy it helps people businesses and
00:32:27 investors make better more informed real-time decisions it's also a necessary input for the
00:32:34 output of the ai companies but the value transfer cannot be asymmetric the user needs to pay the
00:32:40 creator the content theft by a com ai companies must stop and government can help first public
00:32:48 Services and Procurement Canada and Treasury Board can work together to ensure that those on
00:32:53 the government's list of artificial intelligence suppliers, and there's a hundred and some odd
00:32:57 companies on that list, sign a supplier agreement that states that they will use AR material
00:33:03 ethically with a commitment to the principles of transparency, consent, and attribution with
00:33:09 respect to all copyright protected source content. Second, the industry minister can ask the Comp
00:33:15 Bureau to look into the state of competition with respect to search and AI. Google bot should be
00:33:21 split into two crawlers, one for AI and one for search. That would help level the playing field
00:33:27 between publishers in Google and between other AI companies in Google. Those companies have no
00:33:33 incentive to sign commercial agreements with publishers when Google's AI services are getting
00:33:38 the content for free. Third, the Copyright Act should not be amended to include a text in data
00:33:44 mining exception or be weakened in any way. Rights holders must be protected, no exceptions.
00:33:51 On the positive side, the Online News Act, Well and Perfect, is working for Canadian news
00:33:56 publishers. Prior to the act and in an effort to thwart it, Google and Meta did content licensing
00:34:02 deals with a number of news publishers. Most of our members, however, were left out in the cold,
00:34:06 without assent. Today, whether you're a large publisher or a smaller independent,
00:34:11 you're getting about $16,400 per year per full-time journalist. For example, the World
00:34:18 Spectator from Moosem in Saskatchewan received almost $80,000 last year. Prior to the Online
00:34:24 News Act, most of our members never saw a dime in content licensing from these American big tech
00:34:30 firms. Between the Online News Act and the Canadian Journalism Labor Tax Credit, which rewards those
00:34:36 who maintain and grow journalism jobs, there's finally a level of predictability for business
00:34:40 planning which is translating into a level of stability in many newsrooms where we are seeing
00:34:45 investment after years of cost cutting. Both these measures should be maintained. Let me turn briefly
00:34:51 to government advertising. Despite the government stated by Canadian policy changing its agency of
00:34:57 record and spending tens of millions of dollars each year, news publishers are not seeing any
00:35:02 meaningful federal government ad dollars. Yet when a bank, a retailer or a car company runs a national
00:35:08 or regional campaign, news publishers do okay. That's because their chief marketing officers
00:35:14 know we are a great way to reach and engage Canadians. So why are we only seeing micro
00:35:18 pennies on the dollar when it comes to the federal campaigns? It's simple. The government's agency of
00:35:24 record is doing what is easiest and most profitable for them, and that's programmatic advertising
00:35:29 through American big tech firms. We hope the committee will recommend an advertising set
00:35:34 aside that you heard about earlier and ad set aside done right with with on the publishing side
00:35:40 we for example reach 86 percent of canadians who engage with reach newspaper content each week
00:35:46 it's time for the government to think more like a marketer who cares about reach and efficacy we can
00:35:51 help you reach engaged audiences better than anyone for advertisers whether governments or
00:35:57 the private sector credible journalism strengthens trust while delivering better business results in
00:36:02 in a brand safe environment. There's absolutely no reason the federal government shouldn't
00:36:07 use Canadian news brands to inform Canadians.
00:36:12 We are in an age of misinformation and disinformation amplified by algorithms. Facts are essential.
00:36:25 information created by real people who have fact-gathering, fact-checking,
00:36:32 editorial and legal review, and being accountable costs real money. Thank you.
00:36:36 Questions from members starting with Mrs. Thomas for six minutes.
00:36:43 You have the floor. Awesome, thank you so much. Thank you to each of you for being
00:36:47 here today. My first set of questions is going to go to Mr. Danrash. Mr. Danrash,
00:36:52 I'm just curious. There was a document that you talked about in your opening remarks called
00:36:56 Parameters for Political Guests. Would you be willing to table that with the committee?
00:37:01 I would. Perfect. Thank you very much. Appreciate it. Now, I just want to get to the bottom of this.
00:37:06 Can you talk a little bit about any pressure that you experienced at the CBC
00:37:11 to shape stories in a particular fashion? Sure, I can. But I do want to spend part of my time
00:37:18 because i i am here speaking and this is my story but over the past several days and even when this
00:37:24 story initially came out there have been other cbc employees current and former that have come
00:37:30 forward to me that are afraid to speak out publicly and they have sent me some statements
00:37:35 so i'd like to if i can read into the record some of what i have been getting from current
00:37:40 and former employees uh this is a current employee at the cbc i've been with cbc for 10 years and i
00:37:46 And I have witnessed and experienced multiple incidents of the misuse of taxpayer dollars, racism, favoritism, nepotism, sexual harassment, and verbal abuse.
00:37:55 And then she goes on to outline specific examples.
00:37:59 This next individual was someone that you would all know if I said their name.
00:38:04 They left the CBC after a 10-year career.
00:38:08 The end of their statement says,
00:38:09 without exaggeration, I experienced toxicity every single day, and it was almost always from
00:38:16 the same people. It was not subtle. It was not hidden. It was part of the daily reality of
00:38:21 working there. She goes on to say that she was set to interview Catherine Tate on air.
00:38:28 I introduced myself to her in the makeup room as the host. In front of others, she responded,
00:38:33 I didn't know I'd be interviewed by somebody who looks like she is 14. That moment stayed with me.
00:38:38 It was dismissive, inappropriate, and reflected a broader culture in which respect was not always equally extended to everyone. 0.86
00:38:47 On Mr. Cochran, this is one of his former producers, his toxic behavior extended beyond editorial matters and was more often than not deeply hypocritical.
00:38:56 While he publicly presented himself as a supporter of diversity, he actively undermined the contributions of colleagues who were minorities.
00:39:03 This is somebody who left the industry and had to go to another country.
00:39:11 After about a year of working there as an anchor, this is in Vancouver, I was suddenly removed from the anchor desk.
00:39:17 I was told the decision was related to the color of my skin, that as a white person, I did not fit the diversity targets they were trying to meet.
00:39:26 No concerns about my performance had ever been raised.
00:39:29 my concern was the system and the reasoning behind the decision my frustration was never
00:39:35 directed at the individual who stepped into the role she was also said that she was forced to
00:39:40 check a box if somebody of a diverse background appeared on the air and she said that that was
00:39:46 concerning to her i believe it's important to include a broad range of voices and perspectives
00:39:51 but reducing interview subjects to a check bar box felt like an overly simplistic way of
00:39:56 approaching something that deserves much more care and thought and i can go on there are a number of
00:40:02 these stories and it is shocking these people have been traumatized they are scared to come out they
00:40:08 are scared of the professional repercussions and management like laundry lao like brody fenlon like
00:40:15 kathy perry like chris carter they are concerned about protecting the reputation of the organization
00:40:23 as opposed to dealing with these issues when it comes to employees.
00:40:28 So, Mr. Danmash, during your time there, which, sorry, can you just outline what years were you there?
00:40:33 I was there. I finished at Global, I think, in 2020, 2021.
00:40:39 It's in the bio that I provided.
00:40:42 And then I came to Ottawa. I was a parliamentary reporter.
00:40:45 I flew around with the Prime Minister. I covered Parliament Hill.
00:40:49 You know, I was, then I went back to Toronto.
00:40:52 I was on Marketplace.
00:40:53 I covered the Queen's funeral.
00:40:55 And then I got my own show, which I thought, you know,
00:40:57 I'd have some say in terms of how that show went.
00:41:00 And on the intersection panel, you know, this is a picture here
00:41:05 of all the folks that we had on the panel.
00:41:07 You know, we've got here one with Raheem Mohammed and Rachel Gilmore.
00:41:11 I don't know if you can get two people very far apart
00:41:14 on the ideological spectrum.
00:41:16 Is that Sheila Copps, Brian Lilly, and Faye Johnston, right?
00:41:20 We were having the Canadian conversation, and this panel was cancelled.
00:41:24 And you also have issues of pay equity when it comes to all of these folks.
00:41:29 So, okay, so obviously your point here was to create a panel that was full of diversity,
00:41:34 not just in skin colour or ethnicity or religious background, perhaps, but you wanted diversity of thought.
00:41:40 Correct.
00:41:41 Were you given the journalistic freedom then to move forward and do that for the sake of the Canadian public?
00:41:47 No, I mean, the issue became with the panelists, we had a list of 43 people or 45 people that Power and Politics gave us that said, do not go near these people, right?
00:42:03 And some of these folks were like reporters, like Robert Benzie.
00:42:06 There's a story breaking at Queen's Park, and we're on at 7 o'clock.
00:42:10 We should be able to call somebody who covers Queen's Park and talk to them.
00:42:15 But there were these continued hurdles and roadblocks that were set up to really have a certain group of folks in Ottawa in control of who was allowed on programs.
00:42:29 Particularly mine was a concern.
00:42:31 And there were repeated episodes of conservatives being blocked.
00:42:35 I mean, I have the G-chats right here.
00:42:38 I said, you know, in terms of getting folks on, that we need to have balance.
00:42:45 It's not about just having a show with conservatives or just with liberals.
00:42:49 But if power and politics is going to have liberals talking points on all the time, we should have balance as a network.
00:42:56 And I said we are in contravention of Section 11 of, I told Brody Fenlon this, and also Andre Lau, repeatedly, we are in contravention of the Broadcasting Act if we are not providing equitable time for all perspectives.
00:43:10 So I don't want to flood the show with conservatives, but I do want to have balance.
00:43:14 And there are, you know, I can talk to my legal team because some of this is before the Human Rights Commission in terms of how this happened.
00:43:23 But there were repeated attempts over and over and over again.
00:43:27 At one point, I heard, okay, well, maybe you can have NDP folks on, but conservatives are a no.
00:43:34 I mean, it should blow the Canadian public's mind that this was the stuff that was going on.
00:43:41 Thank you, Madam Chair, and thank you all for those opening remarks.
00:43:49 My first question is for Ms. Klu and Mr. Bartel.
00:43:52 Firstly, it's a pleasure to meet you both.
00:43:54 Ms. Royer speaks very fondly of you.
00:43:56 I'd like to focus on a highlight of your opening remarks.
00:43:59 You noted a lack of support.
00:44:01 I quoted this because I thought it was interesting and well said.
00:44:04 Grant opportunities are like fitting a square peg into a round hole.
00:44:07 From your experience in building a new outlet, what are the biggest barriers facing in the
00:44:11 independent journalism, startups in Canada,
00:44:12 and what do you believe would best help address those barriers?
00:44:21 We're journalists, and we've run head-on
00:44:25 into some of the challenges of creating a viable business
00:44:29 and some of the costs of that.
00:44:32 The local journalism initiative has stepped up with some funding for us,
00:44:36 so that helps cover some wage for our crew.
00:44:41 but you know that that doesn't deal with we need to hire someone who can sell ads we don't know
00:44:46 how to do that we shouldn't be doing that we're journalists so we need to have we want to maintain
00:44:50 that that separation between between the ad side and the journalism side so luckily we have found
00:44:57 some people who are willing to help us and off the side of their desks and get us going and but
00:45:02 you know to go forward to to ramp up we have to become professional at every level of this and
00:45:08 And so, you know, some of that infrastructure support is critical to this.
00:45:12 You know, we ran in headlong into just how expensive some of these things are, software licenses to get to allow us to produce a newspaper, web hosting fees, insurance.
00:45:24 All these things that we were completely oblivious to in our role in the newsroom have come home to roost.
00:45:31 And, you know, luckily, our crowdfunding gave us a good foundation to start tackling some of these things.
00:45:36 But again, as we move forward, becoming a viable business will mean backfilling a lot of those things with support.
00:45:46 Fantastic. Over the past few years, certainly, we've seen a significant number of community newspapers close or reduce their reporting capacity.
00:45:53 You highlighted this in your opening remarks.
00:45:55 From your perspective as a longtime local journalist reporter, could you speak to what happens to community accountability and civic engagement when local news coverage disappears?
00:46:03 I believe you highlighted that it was dangerous to local democracy but I'm
00:46:07 keen to see you expand on that if possible. We became a news desert. We have
00:46:13 news deserts and news poor jurisdictions and Glacier Media closing us
00:46:19 in the middle of the federal election was was quite bad. So we've had people
00:46:25 pretending to be reporters sit at the media desk in council meetings and
00:46:34 they're reporting when we're not so that's dangerous
00:46:41 perfect thank you uh your association has represents 37 different radio stations as
00:46:49 you know many community radio stations depend on volunteers and limited funding what are the
00:46:55 biggest operational challenges that community radio is facing today i'm thinking of lower
00:47:01 advertising revenue digital disruptions with foreign platforms well you stated it well
00:47:10 there are all of the operations done by volunteers which isn't ideal because even though those
00:47:18 volunteers give their time medicate themselves make these radio stations work any operation that
00:47:26 is based on that model is hard to keep up over the years but it's the case they they manage
00:47:34 but funding for operations that's the basic need that's what they need and it's what they don't
00:47:41 have and then advertise as i said and others have said advertising revenue aren't there anymore
00:47:52 it's gone to foreign platforms so it would be very good to have a clear government directive
00:48:00 and then radio stations could contribute to getting the government's message through
00:48:06 and then you mentioned the digital transition that's another element that's a major challenge
00:48:13 radio stations are cornerstones for their community they're on the FM station but also
00:48:25 on the web they can be listened to there are podcasts news so these are really complete
00:48:32 media outlets but we need to help them with the digital transition it can be harder depending on
00:48:38 the station.
00:48:39 Parfait.
00:48:40 Mr. Schultz, Canada's broadcasting and media regulatory framework was designed at a time
00:48:46 when traditional television and radio dominated the landscape.
00:48:49 Given the rapid rise of global streaming platforms and digital media companies, do you believe
00:48:53 Canada's existing regulatory tools are still adequate for protecting Canadian journalism
00:48:58 and cultural sovereignty in the digital age?
00:49:00 I believe the tools are there.
00:49:03 I think perhaps the CRTC has been a little bit slow in terms of taking action.
00:49:07 The CRTC has done some good things and certainly the government of Canada has done some good
00:49:12 things.
00:49:13 The Online Streaming Act, the Online News Act has been enormously helpful.
00:49:16 The tax credit has been helpful, the local journalism initiative.
00:49:19 The CRTC made a very important decision last year to ask streamers to contribute a base
00:49:25 contribution of 1.5% of its annual revenue to support local news.
00:49:30 That's being challenged in court right now, but we feel confident it will go the CRTC's
00:49:34 way.
00:49:35 are all important steps but more needs to be done especially given the the canadian center for policy
00:49:42 alternatives conclusion that a significant portion of the canadian population i believe
00:49:49 it's 2.5 percent have access to no local news or only one local news outlet so that's really
00:49:54 a problem that needs to be corrected the tools are there and the regulator needs to be encouraged to
00:49:59 use them now we go to mr shampoo for six minutes thank you madam chair i'd like to thank our
00:50:13 witnesses today we have a great panel who represent the importance of the topic we are
00:50:19 covering with the study madam chair before speaking to the witnesses i'd like to table a motion
00:50:24 i've discussed it with a few members around the table it's a motion that i will read
00:50:30 and i'd like us to keep a little time at the end of the meeting to debate it i will read it
00:50:36 and then we can discuss it a little later to not interrupt questions to witnesses it is a motion
00:50:43 being tabled in relation to radio canada's decision to offer its programming its news
00:50:51 on the Prime Video platform owned by Amazon.
00:50:55 We find that this is a decision that needs to be explained and questioned.
00:51:01 So the motion is that, pursuant to Standing Order 108-2,
00:51:05 the committee invites the CEO of CBC Radio-Canada, Marie-Philippe Bouchard,
00:51:10 to appear before the committee for a minimum of two hours
00:51:13 to explain the decision to make EC-APDE's programming available
00:51:19 on the prime video platform owned by the american multinational amazon even before it is made
00:51:24 available to quebecers and francophones in canada on two point tv or on a canadian-owned platform
00:51:30 madam chair i've prepared this in french and english it's available to committee members
00:51:38 if i may i'd like to ask us to reserve time at the end of the meeting today to discuss this motion
00:51:46 so we can explain the spirit of this request from the block cubiqua i think everyone agrees
00:51:54 thank you thank you madam chair once again thank you to all of the witnesses for joining us today
00:52:03 i think this is an extremely important study it's a very concerning topic
00:52:09 and the variety of media perspectives here are a testament to that.
00:52:16 I'll start with Ms. Carrero because we've heard a lot about community media
00:52:23 and we know that times are tough.
00:52:27 Support isn't what is needed.
00:52:33 I also want to ask a question to Mr. Deegan who represents written media
00:52:37 but you talked about the local journalism initiative have you noticed a decrease in
00:52:47 support through that program for your members is the support still what your
00:52:56 members need it to be because I know it's essential for local coverage in
00:53:00 Quebec and elsewhere so what is the state on the ground for your members
00:53:04 with the local journalism initiative.
00:53:07 Yes, the LJI is something we appreciate.
00:53:10 It's funding that's there for stations.
00:53:14 We haven't noticed a specific decrease as such.
00:53:18 Stations request it and they hope to obtain it.
00:53:22 However, we always hope it will be renewed in time
00:53:28 for budget 2026.
00:53:30 That's what we are hoping for.
00:53:32 and sometimes even if a station has that lji it needs to be possible to hire someone not just
00:53:45 getting the subsidy but being able to use it but that's another kettle of fish but i just wanted
00:53:50 to mention it the lji is something we really appreciate and we really hope to see it renewed
00:53:57 in Budget 2026. I'd like to ask a question to Paul Deegan as well. I know
00:54:01 your members often use that very important program, the Local Journalism
00:54:09 Initiative, for written media. It's very important. Andriane LaRouche, the
00:54:13 member for Shefford, received from the Val West newspaper in her area, she was
00:54:22 told that the funding had decreased by 30% this year, which has a huge impact on small written
00:54:29 media in the regions and community outlets. Is this a concern you've seen at News Media Canada?
00:54:40 Yes. For newspapers, it's about 37,000 per journalist this year.
00:54:47 but we have about 200 journalists under this program it's very important for weeklies and
00:55:01 other independent community media have you heard from your members that the program was less
00:55:07 generous with them this year yes yes so there's still the expectation that this program would be
00:55:14 increased, which is necessary to address media deserts. Media deserts, news deserts are everywhere.
00:55:21 Thank you very much. Back to you, Ms. Carrero. We heard earlier about artificial intelligence,
00:55:28 and this will be coming up often in the study, surely. As community media, I imagine you don't
00:55:35 use AI to prepare the news and broadcast it, but some media are using that technology
00:55:42 due to economic reality, but often they use programs that you don't have access to.
00:55:49 So what is your perspective on that distortion and the equity of the rules?
00:55:56 I imagine it wouldn't be a cause for celebration.
00:56:01 Correct.
00:56:02 I think you are correct.
00:56:05 community radio is based on principles that they try to keep up and if there are people who could
00:56:18 use AI it would be community radio stations because they don't have staff they don't have
00:56:24 the necessary funds but it doesn't it's not consistent when we see that others can benefit
00:56:32 from subsidies so this is a real issue we need to maintain our mission those
00:56:38 tools are there we can't deny it but we would like to have assistance in that
00:56:43 regard a question to everyone for advertising from the federal
00:56:50 government the transfer of advertising from traditional media towards digital
00:56:59 media since 2019 I've been in this role and since 2019 the same thing has been
00:57:04 asked that the government spend less on foreign digital media and more on
00:57:09 traditional media the friends of Canadian media have been talking about
00:57:14 that for years I'm sorry mr. shampoo but your time is up there's no time for an
00:57:20 answer you can answer a little later thank you the next time perhaps you do
00:57:26 you now have the floor for five minutes. Thank you, Madam Chair. Mr. Dunraj, I found your
00:57:33 testimony quite fascinating. I was a journalist for myself for 30 years. I was also a national
00:57:41 director of the Canadian Association of Journalists. Journalism has indeed changed. You noted that
00:57:47 you used to sit down and watch Norton Nash as the voice of, you know, a trusted voice.
00:57:55 I also remember Lloyd Robertson as a kid watching him.
00:58:00 Peter Kent, Stanley Burke.
00:58:03 Ironically, Peter Kent stepped down in 1978 after criticizing political interference from the Liberal Prime Minister.
00:58:13 So the CBC does talk about being diverse, inclusive, fair and balanced.
00:58:21 Yet one of the CBC's premier segments is something called At Issue, which features Toronto Star journalist Chantal Ebert, Athea Raj, and Globe and Mail journalist Andrew Coyne.
00:58:37 In what universe is this diverse, fair, or balanced as a news panel?
00:58:44 well i i mean the the national uh makes their own decisions i suppose in terms of uh who who they
00:58:53 put on that that panel uh you know and it's rosie's panel so uh miss barton's panel so i i guess
00:59:01 you know you can have to you can have to talk to her about the editorial decisions but you know
00:59:05 what i was attempting to do on this program was have that diversity of opinion and you know when
00:59:11 they canceled the panel I sent in a note to panelists asking for feedback and I was disciplined
00:59:18 for that and I just want to talk about this NDA that I got because it's important because I was
00:59:25 raising concerns about editorial and and I was slapped with and this NDA here which is a practice
00:59:32 that the CVC is using frequently which was raised by Dave Seglins and you guys all have the paper
00:59:39 However, Dan Resch has considered whether he has a human rights complaint with respect to the issues in dispute, and by his signature below confirms that he does not.
00:59:49 Further, he confirms that he seeks no right or remedy under the Canadian Human Rights Act as amended with respect to the issues in dispute, and any such claim is barred by this agreement.
01:00:01 That should be shocking to every member on this committee.
01:00:05 And I hope that other members on the committee take an interest in terms of the issues that I'm outlining here.
01:00:13 Because it is very important.
01:00:14 We should not have a public institution silencing their own employees and having them waive their rights under the Canadian Human Rights Act.
01:00:23 That should be shocking.
01:00:26 Getting back to the bigger issue of the fairness and balance in news.
01:00:32 um you mentioned at one point that uh cbc management actually prevented you from
01:00:39 interviewing conservative conservative leader pierre paulia on your show can you describe
01:00:44 what happened there yeah well we i i mean i basically wasn't allowed to pick up the phone
01:00:49 and and talk to uh conservatives i have some g chats here which i just want to you know read
01:00:57 you part of this. I'm talking to my senior producer. I'm saying, okay, this is an editorial
01:01:03 discussion. Can we get a conservative perspective on this is essentially what I'm saying. It is a
01:01:09 no to the conservatives, I'm told. We can't chase anyone from the entire party. The chase is with
01:01:14 PNP. So if Power in Politics is not able to secure a conservative or somebody that presents
01:01:23 an alternate perspective then we are not allowed to i'm told at one point we're sure that there's
01:01:28 a myriad of other types of interesting guests that you can chase outside of the conservatives
01:01:33 uh can i be included on conversations with power and politics that's not how we work
01:01:39 i say to uh to management by playing petty office politics we feed into conservative narratives
01:01:46 that we have a bias against them canada tonight is a melting pot of news of the day and politics
01:01:51 and decisions from it largely impact Canadians.
01:01:56 So we need flexibility to respond to emerging stories.
01:02:01 So yes, I wasn't even allowed to pick up the phone
01:02:04 and call to request Pierre Polyev.
01:02:07 Look at what happened when I had Melissa Lantzman
01:02:09 on my show, right?
01:02:10 I was threatened to be pulled off the air,
01:02:12 which CBC then said in a news statement
01:02:14 they didn't threaten to do that.
01:02:15 There were recordings of them trying to do this.
01:02:18 Why do you think they were doing that?
01:02:21 I mean, there's an effort to essentially protect those in Ottawa in terms of their perspectives on these things, in terms of who they want on the show.
01:02:35 It should be about, you know, we did an interview with Karen Johnson, my co-host on the new podcast I'm doing.
01:02:41 It is out right now.
01:02:43 She's another former CBC employee that is talking about the toxic culture.
01:02:47 She said that she alleges that she was called a brown Barbie, a bimbo.
01:02:53 But she says that it's a very high school culture.
01:02:57 And these are things that this is fine.
01:02:59 If you have hosts doing that, it's not fine.
01:03:03 But OK, but management, you are responsible for dealing with it.
01:03:08 And so if management is not going to do anything, if the president of the CBC is going to come
01:03:15 here and expect a tongue lashing and then be able to go back to the CBC and continue to get funding
01:03:21 without accountability. These practices will continue. So shame is clearly not enough to get
01:03:29 the CBC to a place where they will hold themselves accountable. So it's incumbent
01:03:34 upon this committee to do that. Ms. Royer, you have the floor now for five minutes. Go ahead.
01:03:41 I'd like to begin by welcoming witnesses from my community, Janice Clue and Mario Bartel
01:03:50 of Fresh It News.
01:03:52 Thank you both for your decades of service.
01:03:56 When Glacier Media's Tri-City News closed last year, it was a devastating loss for our
01:04:02 riding of Port Moody, Coquitlam, and I'm extremely grateful that veteran reporters like yourselves
01:04:07 I'm sorry, Ms. Royer, your audio is a little low for the interpreters. I'm hearing that
01:04:15 they are having trouble hearing you. Can you try moving your boom closer to your mouth
01:04:20 and see if that's any better?
01:04:23 Is that better? Madame Chair, is that better? 0.92
01:04:30 Yeah, I think it's better. Just keep that boom close to your mouth.
01:04:37 just sounded that you were a bit far away i'll keep it close and is that um are we going to start
01:04:43 the clock from the beginning no you can have your time back okay great thank you thank you thank you
01:04:50 okay merci madam chair i'd like to begin by welcoming witnesses from my community janice
01:04:56 clue and mario bartell a fresh no i'm sorry ms roy the audio is not getting it oh no okay
01:05:07 let me just check the connection i'm going to suspend for a minute while we try and work this
01:05:16 Okay, merci.
01:05:46 Thank you.
01:06:16 Thank you.
01:06:46 Thank you.
01:07:16 Thank you.
01:07:46 We do not have good sound
01:08:16 from Ms. Royer. So instead, I'm going to pass the parole to Mr. Tumba.
01:08:25 The floor goes to Mr. Tumba for five minutes, starting now.
01:08:33 Thank you very much, Madam Chair.
01:08:38 Excuse me. It won't be long.
01:08:46 I'll start with Ms. Carrero. Thank you for your presentation. I think my colleague Férez
01:08:59 raised the point earlier. I'd like to hear you tell us about, well, community media outlets
01:09:09 ask for advertising how much can that help radio stations can survive well in fact as i was saying
01:09:19 earlier there's a subsidy that's received but it doesn't cover this the salary or barely of
01:09:28 one employee for a radio station so community radio stations have to be creative and find
01:09:34 other ways and advertising revenue are one of those ways to make up for that shortfall
01:09:42 there are also other ways of proceeding community radio stations have bingos for example
01:09:49 that helps with funding as well so these are ways to address a need
01:09:58 that isn't covered by subsidies so it's something very important and has always
01:10:04 served the model of these media outlets. That's how they operated for a long time. It's nothing new.
01:10:12 So it's a loss from recent years and that's why we're really calling for a return
01:10:18 of that advertising revenue. Thank you Ms. Carrero. Mr. Batel, Ms. Klu,
01:10:28 what you experienced last year, I don't know how to describe it.
01:10:33 But you are a model of resilience in the face of challenges, because despite what you went through, you came back and we can tell you love media, you love your work.
01:10:46 My question is, when you talk about having bigger donations, do you have like a number in mind in terms of funding?
01:10:57 well we did we did launch a founders club that allowed people to donate a thousand dollars a
01:11:06 minimum thousand dollars um and we recognize them in in ads in our newspaper house ads in our
01:11:11 newspaper and and uh we're we that the campaign didn't really get going as well strongly as we
01:11:18 wanted to because we kept running into roadblocks with trying to issue tax receipts we're not a
01:11:22 charity and a few efforts we did try would have run afoul of CRA and we didn't want to do that
01:11:28 we didn't want to run do anything illegal or that would come back and bite us so we don't know I
01:11:34 mean we you know we got some support from our union and some other groups that did step up
01:11:40 selflessly and say you know we believe in this too this is important this is important for our
01:11:45 community but you know we don't know what kind of potential is out there if we don't have some of
01:11:51 these tools available to us like being able to issue tax receipts and that and you know we spend
01:11:57 a lot of time trying to investigate things my colleague here janice has spent a lot of time
01:12:01 writing grant applications and and as we said it's it's often fitting a square peg into a round
01:12:06 hole where we're trying to get grants as as cultural or as institutions things like that that
01:12:12 that we kind of fit into but it all depends on how you look at it uh so it's it's it's a lot of
01:12:18 a lot of effort to find money wherever we can to try and give us that foundation that we can build
01:12:25 upon. I listened to your opening remarks. You want Canadian media, you want the government of Canada
01:12:39 to consider them. Do you think some media outlets are not taken into account by the government of
01:12:47 Canada what would be your proposal to move forward last year I think the
01:12:57 government spent about 75 million dollars on advertising but for all of
01:13:10 newspapers of canada it's less than two million dollars
01:13:18 for la presse in montreal when la presse has a campaign
01:13:25 or let's say a big canadian bank had a campaign a campaign in quebec la presse
01:13:34 did okay with ads but the government gives them nearly zero we are a great
01:13:46 avenue to reach Canadians but the agency of record means that it's more
01:14:01 profitable and these are programming ads like with google thank you now the floor to mr shampoo for
01:14:10 two and a half minutes i'll talk to the friends of canadian media i was asking a question about
01:14:17 the recurrent call and it's not just from you it's from all media owned in canada the government is
01:14:24 disinvesting in traditional media and investing in online platforms which are all owned by foreign
01:14:32 companies so do you think at some point the government will understand that part of the
01:14:39 survival of our media depends on advertising by government regardless of the level but here we're
01:14:45 talking about the federal government which spends a lot of money on digital platforms compared
01:14:51 to what it spends on traditional media. What is your position? Do you think we need to continue
01:14:55 and be even louder on this? I think there's two steps the federal government could take. First
01:15:01 of all, as we said in our opening remarks, if they allocated even 25% of their annual revenue,
01:15:06 their annual advertising revenue, a budget to publishers and broadcasters, that would have a
01:15:11 substantial effect. Even a relatively small diversion of internet advertising revenue to
01:15:17 canadian news media would be hugely beneficial to these entities over and above that as you
01:15:22 mentioned earlier the advertising deductibility issue has been something that friends has been
01:15:26 raising for countless years we issued a report in 2017 2018 called close the loophole i encourage
01:15:32 everyone in the room and on the committee to to google the report and listen to it um this has
01:15:36 been a long-standing issue we think it's a simple clean easy measure that has a very successful
01:15:41 precedent and traditional advertising would actually raise money for government rather than
01:15:45 cost money and we haven't really seen any serious arguments against it um and quite frankly it the
01:15:51 precedent has been in place since the 1960s we think it would continue to be effective
01:15:59 what would this be for community radio stations it's a matter of survival for how many of your
01:16:04 members in your view all of them all of them i'll say it again subsidies don't allow for their
01:16:12 survival it's advertising revenue to a greater degree and there have been election campaigns we
01:16:19 saw it last year from the federal government there was nearly nothing that was invested nothing was
01:16:25 invested in local media and yet the message would really have gotten through but it's necessary for
01:16:33 all radio stations thank you very much i imagine it would be the same thing for written media
01:16:39 weeklies are affected by this as well yes in ontario the government of premier for the
01:16:47 conservatives give 25 percent of their advertising budget to media thank you you have the floor now
01:16:56 for five minutes thank you um mr downage i'm just curious in your other remarks or your previous
01:17:05 remarks i should say sorry you mentioned that there was a black list of i think you said 45
01:17:09 people who were not permitted to appear on the cbc um and that this list came down from management
01:17:15 would would you be willing to table that list with committee today yes okay thank you um mr
01:17:20 danage i'm curious during during your time or do you have knowledge of the pmo the prime minister's
01:17:27 office ever talking to the cbc with regard to how a news angle should be covered or taken or
01:17:35 content that should be reported on? I know concerns were raised. I know concerns were raised
01:17:43 from people that were on power and politics. I have documentation related to those concerns being
01:17:52 raised. And I know that the, you know, the folks that raised these concerns, they're fearful of,
01:18:01 you know, exactly the same thing that all these other folks are fearful of, right? Professional
01:18:05 reprisal. But I also know that this was raised repeatedly. And whether or not there was influence
01:18:13 from the former prime minister's office in terms of editorial decisions that were being made on
01:18:19 power and politics or not, even the allegation of that on its face needs to be investigated.
01:18:26 And from my understanding, and CBC can put out a statement correcting me if I'm wrong on this,
01:18:33 I don't think that there was ever an investigation. That is a serious concern, right? I mean, if there are repeated, you know, allegations made about perhaps there's too much influence here.
01:18:48 Now, let me just say this as well. I was a reporter in Ottawa. I've been at Queen's Park. I was the Queen's Park Bureau Chief for Global. Reporters have sources. We all know that. But there's a line where that leads into editorial decision making. And you have to make sure that that is clear. And if there's even an allegation that that may have been crossed, you have to look deeper.
01:19:14 I guess to that end, then, we know that public trust for the media in general is on the decline.
01:19:22 We know that that is true with the CBC. There's no exception there.
01:19:26 In your mind, then, you know, is that lack of trust justified?
01:19:32 I think that right now, the CBC, by continuing to put out statements and to come to these committees and say, yeah, you know, we might have a little bit of a problem.
01:19:41 but you know overall we're not biased that's gaslighting Canadians Canadians can see that
01:19:49 this is an issue right and and this is you know folks have accused me of coming here being a
01:19:56 cheerleader for the Conservatives I am not a cheerleader for the Conservatives I'm sorry
01:20:00 I'm not a cheerleader for the Liberals either I was trying to do my job as a journalist and part
01:20:06 of that is being balanced. And so when you have, you know, when I was pulled into these disciplinary
01:20:12 meetings, I was told that it was editorializing because I put that Catherine Tate wouldn't come
01:20:17 on the program and it's unfortunate. This is unfortunate, was editorializing, right? And it
01:20:23 was perceived bias. There's a lot of perceived bias going on that I don't see any discipline
01:20:30 around so i think cbc needs to have uh you know a wake-up call here in terms of accountability
01:20:38 uh and really that's incumbent upon this committee i have made recommendations there are 11
01:20:44 recommendations in terms of how to uh you know move some of this forward when it came to mr
01:20:50 cochran you know this is during the convoy for example we were talking about tamara litch who 0.90
01:20:57 was an individual who was involved in the convoy having that we were doing a story around that
01:21:01 uh and you know off the hand marks remarks can be made at times uh and i said i think that she has
01:21:07 uh a couple of different last names people who live in trailers usually do you know okay off
01:21:15 color remark but if this is a pattern right you have to if your staff on your own show
01:21:22 are raising this if people are leaving the program you have to look a little bit deeper into it
01:21:30 as opposed to pulling me off the air for saying it's unfortunate the president didn't come on
01:21:34 the show so the canadian public is paying for this to the tune of about 1.4 billion dollars
01:21:40 and then of course the government also increased that by an additional 150 million dollars
01:21:45 at the end of the day then the public is the shareholder and also the ones that are supposed
01:21:49 to be benefiting from this news coverage in your estimation what changes are needed to actually
01:21:53 restore that trust i think that there needs to be an overhaul when it comes to management i've
01:21:58 you know you have my specific recommendations but i will also say this i am not here as somebody who
01:22:04 does not believe in public broadcasting i was on jonavision i started as an audience coordinator
01:22:09 when i was 19 years old at the cbc i worked on the air force i worked on the red green show
01:22:14 i then left i came back i worked at cbc edmonton i worked at cbc toronto left came back again i took
01:22:21 a pay cut to come back to the cbc i used to walk around the cbc broadcast center when i was 19
01:22:27 years old and sneak into the newsroom and i thought this is this i want to be at this place at some
01:22:32 point this is the heart of this building the news organization and and it has gotten so far away
01:22:40 from what it was, the CBC should not be a polarizing force. It needs to bring Canadians
01:22:48 together, and it has the infrastructure to be able to do that. But until there's a recognition
01:22:54 of the problem from management, nothing will happen. And they fail to recognize this. I am
01:23:01 willing, I would be willing to sit down tomorrow with the new president to talk about some of this
01:23:06 stuff right but good people are leaving they're being forced out and and their concerns are being
01:23:13 dismissed because it's about protecting reputation well here's you know some news i don't have to
01:23:20 be wanting to destroy the cbc because management and executives are doing a great job of that on
01:23:26 their own thank you uh we're gonna try one more time with ms roy to see if we have sound now that
01:23:34 have a new headset you have the floor for five minutes fingers crossed okay excellent excellent
01:23:39 so i'd like to begin by welcoming witnesses from my community and that is chanis clue and mario
01:23:45 bartell of freshet news and i want to thank you both for your decades of service and of course
01:23:52 when glacier media's tri-city news closed last year it was a devastating loss for our riding
01:23:58 of port moody coquitlam and why is this because democracy only works when citizens can see the
01:24:06 truth clearly and that requires strong independent journalism so that voters can make informed
01:24:12 choices and hold leaders accountable janice in your own words you actually said that this is
01:24:17 dangerous so this brings me to the matter of journalistic integrity and the journalist code
01:24:23 of ethics and i'd like to really drill down if i could with uh with you and mario so with the
01:24:28 advent of podcasts and online news there's a great deal of misinformation how refreshing
01:24:33 journalists trained and is that the norm i was trained in britain under a program called the nctj
01:24:43 national council training of journalists there's a standardized curriculum in colleges and
01:24:49 universities in Britain you do a year program and take legal courses
01:24:57 municipal government courses shorthand you then go out in the field for 18
01:25:02 months and then we all write a national exam in the end we don't have this in
01:25:05 Canada we need this in Canada it's similar to a trade like Red Seal and it
01:25:11 would help with municipalities that are struggling with reporters who call
01:25:17 themselves reporters and they're not professionally trained it would help
01:25:21 the municipalities figure out who should be at the table who should be at the
01:25:25 media table hmm okay got it can you can we drill down a little bit further and
01:25:33 speak to the core principles so what really are the core principles of the
01:25:37 code of ethics for journalists what are the what are the pillars well you try to
01:25:43 balanced you try to give both sides of an issue you you try to uh give a fair representation of
01:25:50 you know when we cover city council you you try to give a fair representation of the the concerns
01:25:56 that were raised and and and how they were raised so that when readers read how a decision came to
01:26:02 be they they have some knowledge as to what what uh what some of the downfalls might be what some
01:26:07 of the advantages might be uh and you just sort of you report you don't interpret you report
01:26:16 i'm i'm actually understanding that um yeah just just what you said mario that
01:26:21 accuracy and verification are absolutely key multiple sources um that there needs to be um
01:26:29 journalists themselves need to be free from conflicts of interest and there can't be any
01:26:34 exchange of gifts or favors um there is a a high level of accountability and transparency can you
01:26:42 speak to uh some of these these principles and how you report um and and also avoiding
01:26:49 bias how you bring that into fresh at news well i think i think we we do as we've always done we
01:26:58 we stand apart. We don't try and cultivate friendships or favor with anybody. We go in
01:27:07 there and we go in with a fresh mind as to what is being discussed, what the issues are.
01:27:13 And, you know, you give a fair ear to all sides and report accordingly.
01:27:19 i know that there was a gap between the closure of tri-city news glacier media and freshet opening
01:27:30 and of course the closure happened just ahead of the election what do you feel the impact was
01:27:36 on the electorate in making decisions in in the lead up to the election what what actually happened
01:27:42 It said in the opening, as we had said in the opening, we couldn't cover candidates and the readers were lost.
01:27:53 They didn't know who to vote for. They didn't know where to go. And again, it was very dangerous to democracy.
01:28:01 So having corporate media pull out in the middle of the federal election was devastating to our readers and to the advertisers and to the candidates.
01:28:11 Well, in a normal news cycle, too, we would be there covering all candidates meetings and bringing, you know, bringing readers who were there.
01:28:19 We're kind of the proxy for people who don't go, but still may be interested.
01:28:23 They may not be interested in sitting around for two hours and at a meeting or they just weren't able to go.
01:28:27 So we're the proxy. That's how we see ourselves. Same city council, anything we cover.
01:28:31 We're kind of the proxy for the public.
01:28:33 so when you uh are able to give a flavor for for a candidate and and what they said and the the
01:28:39 issues that were raised by by people at all candidates meetings that's that's bringing
01:28:43 information to to the larger public as well and and uh hopefully that then informs everybody a
01:28:49 little bit better about when it when it comes to marking their ballot which which way they're going
01:28:53 to go we also cover a very large we also cover well and i noticed that there was a prevalence
01:28:59 of other sort of freelancers journalists that we've never heard of before that were sort of
01:29:04 taking up the space in the news desert and I think people were then tuning into that because
01:29:10 they were hungry I think the electorate is particularly hungry for um this is all the
01:29:15 time we have for this question I'm sorry but I really appreciate that you make the point that
01:29:21 journalists have to be in the room at the school board meetings and at the city halls and in the
01:29:26 courtrooms. And when people say AI can take over the job of journalism, I think they don't understand
01:29:32 what journalism has done because AI can't be in those rooms. Mrs. Thomas, you now have the floor
01:29:38 for five minutes. Awesome. I'm going to ask one quick question and pass it off to my colleague.
01:29:43 My question is for Mike, Mr. Kittleman, or your colleagues. And my question is this,
01:29:50 you made a statement with regards to linking the safety and security of the Jewish community here
01:29:54 in Canada to biased coverage from the news media and I would like you to take a moment and just
01:29:59 expand on that in terms of the consequences that are that are there sure so you cut out there for
01:30:04 a sec uh I'll speak to a bit of a portion then I'm going to hand off to my colleagues on zoom
01:30:08 as well the first thing is what's reported today becomes domestic and foreign policy tomorrow
01:30:13 and uh and I echo Mr. Dan Raj's comments about a very let's call it a jaundiced marketplace of
01:30:21 ideas. What we have seen in the past couple of years, most certainly as it relates to the CBC,
01:30:26 is the elevation of radical voices, giving them a platform, giving them undue legitimacy,
01:30:33 which we feel really does serve to elevate the fringe and marginal voices who are traditionally,
01:30:41 you know, again on the fringe trying to work their way into the mainstream, and then it serves
01:30:45 fundamentally to fan the flames of hatred against Israel and the Jewish community. More specifically,
01:30:51 HR Canada Charitable Organization and InnoHives did a long-term two-year study on the Hamas-Israel
01:30:58 war, which found that there was this asymmetry in the CBC's coverage, most specifically that
01:31:05 it elevated radical voices like Independent Jewish Voices, which is a radical anti-Zionist
01:31:11 hate group. And giving them this platform, again, it bestows this kind of credibility,
01:31:16 which they don't deserve but um i'll allow dr haran shanarkis and amanda eskenazi
01:31:22 to speak in more detail about their work
01:31:29 um so i'll just say briefly first of all thank you and thank you mike can you hear me right
01:31:36 hopefully okay um so i'm here as a scientist um and if there are any questions about the research
01:31:44 we conducted i'm happy to answer i'll just say that taking into account the asymmetry that's
01:31:51 already inherited in the israeli gaza war um we found some very troubling evidence showing for
01:31:57 example how the cbc is using headlines in order to promote one side of the story um
01:32:05 such that even when you compare that to the actual reporting by the cbc
01:32:09 Madame Chair, there's an issue with the audio. The interpreters are struggling to interpret.
01:32:17 I'm sorry, we don't have good sound for your intervention there.
01:32:23 Is that better right now? Or if not, maybe Amanda can take that? 0.99
01:32:29 I'm sorry, no.
01:32:32 OK. OK, maybe I can try to speak to this then and just sort of offer one final thought on this that, you know, my colleague Haran is a scientist and he deals with data and numbers and, you know, objective truth.
01:32:49 I'm also a scientist but a different kind of a social scientist and I look at behavior and trends and sort of human behavior and how people react to what it is that they see in the news and and what they are presented with.
01:33:04 And when we have a organization like the CBC, which is a Canadian institution that is supposed to be well-respected, has a history in our country of being the place where you are supposed to be able to get real honest news about what's going on in the world, and they are beating a very one-sided drum, a very one-sided narrative.
01:33:29 And that's what's being offered to Canadians. Of course, Canadians are going to be angry, they're going to be upset. Because what they're being told the reality is, is upsetting and angering. And when you only present one side of what is going on, you end up with a very ideologically, you end up with an ideology, you don't end up with reality, and with the facts.
01:33:59 And so I think when you are feeding Canadians, the CBC is not telling Canadians
01:34:08 how to think about an issue. They're showing Canadians what to think about the issue.
01:34:14 And that should not be the role of our public broadcaster. And to just return it to your
01:34:20 question, Mrs. Thomas, that if you have consistently one-sided narratives like this,
01:34:27 of course you are going to have people who feel that they need to do something about it
01:34:31 and when we have one-sided narratives that demonize an entire group of people because
01:34:36 that's what's happening then of course you are going to have people who are angry about that
01:34:40 and feel that they need to do something about that and that unfortunately is what we're seeing
01:34:45 on the streets in canada right now and what we saw this weekend in toronto
01:34:49 thank you mr miles you now have the floor for five minutes great thank you very much and thank you to
01:34:59 everybody for being here today and and uh getting this study started off in a very lively way um i
01:35:05 want to talk i think we're all very interested in making sure that there's a diversity voices
01:35:10 in journalism and that's what makes great journalism one thing i'm curious about is the
01:35:14 right balance you know well how we can create an ecosystem where the private broadcasters and
01:35:20 and journalists thrive as well as a public broadcaster like what the balance looks like
01:35:25 especially in rural communities i find that one thing and i think it speaks to what's been
01:35:30 mentioned is is that often rural voices are not actually particularly as more and more newspapers
01:35:36 in small towns close more and more radio stations in small towns close how do we make sure that
01:35:43 things aren't centralized just in the cities of Canada, but the voices of rural Canadians
01:35:47 are also part of all the conversations we're having. Maybe I'll start with Paul to speak
01:35:53 about that, if you get some thoughts. So much. I think one of the programs that's important for
01:36:00 Rural Voices is the Local Journalism Initiative. You know, many of our members would be a couple,
01:36:07 let's say perhaps in their mid-70s, they own the local community newspaper, their kids have moved
01:36:14 to the city or doing something else. And the LJI is a way of getting a reporter into that community,
01:36:22 invested in that community, you know, covering cops, courts, city hall, that kind of stuff. So
01:36:28 I think the LJI in terms of the rural coverage is absolutely critical. One thing I will say about
01:36:35 the CBC, and this is an issue in particular in rural communities. CBC has been poaching
01:36:42 journalists from community newspapers, and this is a problem. There's a terrific column written
01:36:49 by Tim Schultz of the St. Albert Gazette, and I think you should all read it. It's in his own
01:36:53 paper, and it's also in the National Post. But take a look at that. I mean, we are losing
01:36:59 journalists to the CBC. They're getting more money, better benefits, and listen, we don't
01:37:05 begrudge the CBC, but I'll give you just one example. Jeff LG, who's an entrepreneur who owns
01:37:10 Village Media, Jeff trained a journalist. The journalist was hired by the CBC, went to Toronto.
01:37:16 Jeff sort of felt okay about that. The journalist is in Toronto for a while. Then they moved that
01:37:22 same journalist back to the Sioux competing with him, and he trained that journalist. And that's
01:37:27 a real issue. It's an issue in Franco-Manitoban communities, for example. This is an issue that
01:37:33 you know, we're very concerned about is, is the poaching of talent. And again, you know,
01:37:38 it's a free labor market, but to actually go after and pick off people from community newspapers
01:37:43 in communities like Banff, it's just not fair. I think that's, it's, you know, part of what I'm
01:37:51 looking to get at too, is it's some of those, those places of like that, you know, conflict
01:37:56 or whatever between the two sectors and how we can actually seek to support both in the ideal
01:38:01 world and to make sure that those voices are not particularly in the rural communities not uh
01:38:05 dismissed um are there others
01:38:11 i mean i i think you know one of the challenges that we've got is uh canada post um and just in
01:38:18 terms of sort of you know distribution so a lot of our members there these are a printed product
01:38:23 a community newspaper canada post has made a decision that if you have a canadian tire flyer
01:38:31 in your newspaper it falls under something called the consumer's choice program so if
01:38:36 a community says for example i don't want junk mail essentially then you're not able to deliver
01:38:42 that you know newspaper to the community with a canadian tire flyer and the canadian tire flyer
01:38:48 you know that might be for that particular publisher seventy five thousand dollars a year
01:38:52 in revenue that's two reporters so i think there's lots that the federal government can do
01:38:57 to ensure that um that you know rural community news outlets uh thrive and you know the cbc is
01:39:05 one avenue canada post is another um are you encouraged at all by the idea of cbc moving
01:39:12 into rural communities and broadening the base of of some of their stations look our our view is
01:39:16 cbc should be complementary not competitive and and if they move into communities that are already
01:39:22 well-served, that's an issue. They should move to areas that aren't served. And when you look at
01:39:30 the list that the CBC put forward in the editor's blog, they've done it twice in the last year or
01:39:36 so. Many of these communities are already well-served by community newspapers, community
01:39:43 radio stations. And so I think that's something we have to look at. They shouldn't be sort of
01:39:48 predatory in the marketplace if you will very very good um i had just one quick question on ad if i
01:39:54 have a couple of times a little bit of time just i just speaking with the ad thing when you're
01:39:58 saying i'm curious to know when you say private enterprise is actually kind of bought into local
01:40:03 advertising even more than the government what motivates that because we're a great way of
01:40:08 reaching canada 36 percent of canadians read newspaper content each week uh you know when
01:40:14 when you advertise in a community newspaper,
01:40:17 it's in a brand safe environment.
01:40:19 Some of these digital ads you do,
01:40:20 you have no idea where your ad is gonna wind up
01:40:22 on some porn site or something or other, right?
01:40:25 So we're a great way to reach Canadians.
01:40:28 We're cost effective.
01:40:30 And if we're getting ads from the banks,
01:40:35 the airlines, the telcos, et cetera,
01:40:37 how come we're not getting ads from our own government?
01:40:39 All of the federally regulated industries,
01:40:41 grocery stores they all advertise with newspapers and yet we don't really see a
01:40:46 dime from the federal government that's that's a problem sector oh sorry thank
01:40:53 you thank you I gave you a bit of leeway there but there's a there's a limit
01:40:58 mr. shampoo I will give you the floor for two and a half minutes thank you
01:41:05 Madam Chair, Mr. Fegelman, you surprised me earlier when you talked about radical comments
01:41:14 that distort media coverage. You have an organization, Honest Reporting, that looks
01:41:22 at the accuracy of reporting with the conflict in Israel against Hamas and now the conflict with
01:41:30 Iran and I think that's quite fine to have groups that look at the quality of
01:41:36 journalistic coverage with a conflict situation it's even more delicate I
01:41:39 think that's good I think it's important but your methods are unacceptable Mr.
01:41:46 Feigelman you have a website where you directly attack journalists who have
01:41:52 coverage work that does not please you and that to me I don't understand how
01:41:59 you call yourself someone who looks at the quality of coverage when you use
01:42:04 methods that look like harassment. Laura Julie Pero, Magdalene Butros are 1.00
01:42:09 targeted on your website. Rather than calling out the coverage that you find
01:42:14 not good enough, you attack the work of the journalists and you encourage your
01:42:18 supporters to write directly to them and you give them a template to write
01:42:24 directly to them. Thousands of emails have been sent to those journalists and
01:42:28 and maybe to others, do you think that harassment method of journalists is a constructive way
01:42:35 to ensure that coverage of these very important and sensitive issues, do you think that harassment
01:42:42 method of journalists is the right one? Do you stand by that? For your question, Mr. Shampoo,
01:42:48 if I may answer your question with a question to you, when your constituents contact you with
01:42:54 concerns and complaints would you characterize that as harassment not at all my constituents
01:43:03 expect that i do the work and they elected me and they have the right to contact me directly
01:43:09 you could contact the media that hires these people you could be in touch with the cbc
01:43:16 ombudsman that's how it works you don't directly contact the journalist it becomes personal
01:43:20 it becomes an attack on the work and often the integrity of the person because you are going
01:43:26 after someone who shouldn't be receiving thousands of nonsense emails as politicians we expect this
01:43:35 it's part of the job journalists shouldn't be undergoing this so go after elected officials
01:43:42 those who manage cbc radio canada la presse le devoir but let journalists do their work
01:43:48 and have comments from their bosses.
01:43:52 Don't you think that would be the right way to proceed?
01:43:53 We regard ourselves as an added layer of editorial oversight.
01:43:58 In a world where we're hearing of massive cutbacks in the Canadian journalism landscape,
01:44:04 where there's less verification, we found that actually most journalists value the work that we do
01:44:10 because we're, that may surprise you, because we're pointing out the unfairness.
01:44:16 Are you able, because I have very little time left, are you able to provide the names of journalists who support your work, journalists and media, not commentators, credible ones, which journalists support the style of approach you have with journalists regarding the quality of their work?
01:44:40 we could have this conversation for a long time i think the chair will interrupt me soon
01:44:44 but if you want to respond to what i've just said i would be pleased to read your comments you could
01:44:49 write to the committee send all the documents you wish and we can even pick up this conversation you
01:44:54 and i afterwards because i think this is a very important issue it's about the credibility of
01:44:59 your comments which could be very good in this debate perhaps they can provide that information
01:45:05 to the committee if you can come back with those names that mr shampoo has asked for
01:45:12 that would be later that we would accept that information because we're out of time quest to go
01:45:19 two minutes for each party before we finish this conversation before we get to mr shampoo is that
01:45:24 okay everybody okay with that okay mrs thomas you have two minutes
01:45:28 I'll be taking this for two minutes. Yeah, Mr. Fegelman, it was very interesting when you said
01:45:39 that you indicated that a CDC executive said that the network shouldn't refer to Hamas as
01:45:47 a terrorist group, even though the government of Canada has recognized them as a terrorist group
01:45:52 since 2002 why should the public be alarmed at this well in the Canada
01:46:00 Gazette it is publicly listed that they are a terrorist group their day job is
01:46:05 to strap a suicide vest on themselves and with the intent of maiming and
01:46:09 murdering innocents when our media sanitized language it effectively
01:46:16 legitimizes the actions or at least it distorts people aren't fully aware that
01:46:21 what these people do what their intentions are is to wipe israel and jews off the map so it is it 1.00
01:46:28 is really misrepresenting the facts on the ground language matters diction matters now your organization
01:46:37 did do a deep dive into the coverage that happened um throughout cbc since october the 7th can you
01:46:47 just reiterate some of that coverage, and you allege it was highly biased.
01:46:53 Well, I'd like to recount a couple of examples of CBC bias that we've come across.
01:46:57 The first, on February 16th, CBC Radio Canada's correspondent Elisa Serrett, who was later
01:47:03 suspended, uttered an anti-Semitic trope on air when claiming that, and I quote, the Israelis,
01:47:09 in fact, the Jews finance a lot of American politics and control a big machine. It's a 0.97
01:47:15 clear-cut anti-Semitic trope. CBC continues to use reporters who've expressed radical anti-Israel
01:47:23 views. They have a journalist named Sarah Jabakanji, who in 2021 signed an open letter
01:47:29 boldly proclaiming that there should be more pro-Palestinian coverage. That's just at the CBC.
01:47:36 I would refer you to my colleague, Amanda Eskenazi, who can talk in specifics about
01:47:41 some of the results of the study that they did about the CBC's bias.
01:47:48 Thank you.
01:47:50 I'm sorry, we just have two minutes for everybody.
01:47:53 It's a really quick, we call it the lightning round, kind of like a game show.
01:47:57 Mr. Miles, you have two minutes.
01:48:00 Sure.
01:48:00 You know, I think I'll just go right back to Paul because we got a little interrupted.
01:48:03 I'm sorry to keep on going back at you, but I just because I'm curious about this advertising piece
01:48:08 because I hear you.
01:48:10 I hear what you're saying as an opportunity, obviously, to support these, you know, journalists and the work of these papers and broadcasters.
01:48:19 But at the same time, there has been a decline in private advertising and newspapers, certainly.
01:48:26 That's a fact as well, right?
01:48:28 Yeah, absolutely.
01:48:29 So just for ballpark numbers, so advertising in Canadian newspapers a dozen years ago would have been about three and a half billion dollars.
01:48:37 today it's probably 900 million or so okay so the private sector has also abandoned that that route
01:48:45 is it i i wouldn't say abandoned i'd say you know they've they've changed in terms of their uh their
01:48:51 spend but we're still doing you know okay in terms of uh a lot of community newspapers i mean if you
01:48:58 pick up a community newspaper you're going to see the ad from the chevy dealer you're going to see
01:49:03 you know, the ad from the Remax agent, like we, we still do. Okay. It's, but disproportionately,
01:49:09 we don't do well with government and in particular with the federal government.
01:49:14 That's interesting. And is it because they believe that this is where the eyeballs are,
01:49:17 they should go where the eyeballs are? Is that not?
01:49:18 So the government has an agency of record, right? And I think this dates back to the sponsorship
01:49:23 era or the sponsorship scandal from years ago. So the government has an agency of record that
01:49:28 makes the decision. It used to be Cosette. It's now WPP. I think that those firms have done what
01:49:34 is easiest and most profitable for them, which is programmatic advertising. Those ads that just
01:49:40 sort of pop up everywhere. You develop much more of an impression. If you take out a full-page ad
01:49:47 in the Kelly of the Saint-Diosynthe bell exam, you're going to make much more of an impact than
01:49:52 little programmatic advertising that pops up okay thank you appreciate you i know there's
01:50:00 lots of individual mps advertising in our local media but that's a different budget and i won't
01:50:04 get into it uh uh you have the floor mr shampoo two minutes thank you madam chair i didn't know
01:50:13 i'd have this additional two minutes i'd feel bad if i didn't give mr fegelman the opportunity to
01:50:18 respond to my comments i thought we would continue our conversation by email or otherwise but mr
01:50:25 figgelman i'll give you a minute to respond to what i said earlier if you wish if you want to
01:50:31 pick up i didn't hear your question when you first asked if you don't mind asking the question forgive
01:50:35 me the audio is terrible for me the question i just asked well i'm giving you the opportunity
01:50:43 to respond to what i said earlier we ran out of time for you to respond
01:50:52 are you having the interpretation into english do you hear the interpretation testing on the
01:50:56 english channel we want to make sure that our system is working properly is it that you can't
01:51:03 hear or that there's no translation translation english channel if i speak can you hear can you
01:51:11 hear the english is the english interpretation coming through is there a problem testing on the
01:51:17 english channel one two three testing one two three can you hear me interpretation into english
01:51:26 is this working for you can you hear okay ah okay i didn't have my microphone on
01:51:34 is it working now is it working better
01:51:36 Okay, go ahead, Mr. Shampoo. My question wasn't really a question, Mr. Fegelman. I was giving
01:51:47 you the opportunity to respond to what I said earlier. We were interrupted. We ran out of time.
01:51:54 So, I am proposing that you respond to my comments for a minute,
01:51:59 rather than having this conversation later. I was just giving you the floor to respond.
01:52:06 I'll give you an example of some of the dialogue we had in recent days. We filed a complaint with
01:52:12 the Globe and Mail to their standards editor because they had published a column that had
01:52:17 said that Israel takes Palestinians hostage, which it does not do, which is a violation of
01:52:22 international law. We filed the complaint, they received it, they appreciated it, and they took
01:52:28 corrective measures to issue a correction. That's the kind of what we consider to be constructive
01:52:33 dialogue that is important and i would also say um with your comment about alleged harassment
01:52:39 if any of our subscribers we have about 80 000 subscribers from coast to coast
01:52:44 if anyone engaged with a member of the media in a way that we felt was unprofessional strident
01:52:51 knee-jerk reactionary we would be the very first to either try to um sensitize them to our concerns
01:52:58 uh and if they weren't listening and were uncooperative we would take them off our list
01:53:03 we don't think that that is helpful we think it's actually quite counterproductive
01:53:11 so if journalists told you they were embarrassed they were bothered
01:53:19 there's little time but if journalists told you we don't agree with the way you're operating
01:53:25 we'd prefer for comments criticism discussion of that nature be done with
01:53:31 the editors or the bosses of newsrooms rather than journalists directly you
01:53:37 would be open to that you would be open to that dialogue we're certainly open to
01:53:41 any kind of dialogue with any different leverage playing the Canadian media
01:53:44 landscape our challenge though is what we oftentimes encounter is window
01:53:52 addressing of accountability and evasive efforts on in terms of implementation of journalistic
01:53:58 standards, meaning we could bring a grievance to a journalist editor, and they may not reply
01:54:04 and are totally evasive. And we think that that's quite problematic. So I think there
01:54:09 is a necessity for an oversight mechanism. I think, broadly speaking, our goal should
01:54:16 be that look like very Canadian response with civic engagement, because I think that's
01:54:20 fundamentally constructed that's where we don't agree mr fegelman i think at a certain point we
01:54:26 have to accept the processes in place it's not up to journalists or workers who didn't ask to have
01:54:32 that relationship just to have that harassment directed at them i think there needs to be a
01:54:37 line drawn somewhere and i think the way you proceed with your call to contact journalists
01:54:43 directly by email i think you're crossing that line that's my opinion i think on that we can
01:54:48 end and we can talk about the motion yes exactly if you wish to begin mr shampoo you can introduce
01:54:58 no let's go ahead well we can continue five minutes oh if you'd like we're going to discuss
01:55:05 the motion that mr shampoo uh rose earlier today you don't have to leave you can stay to the end
01:55:11 but uh we have finished with our questioning of you i hope it was not too onerous we truly
01:55:17 appreciate all of your participation and keep in mind that you are welcome to send in any further
01:55:24 information or documentation i know mr dan raj you've been asked to supply certain documents to
01:55:29 this committee but we can take all of that or if there's something you forgot to say for example
01:55:34 don't hesitate to reach out to the committee and we can include all of that in our consideration
01:55:38 of our report thank you again mr shampoo thank you madame chair i read the motion earlier so
01:55:46 that it would be on the record i just want to give a little bit of context in quebec last week we
01:55:52 learned that radio canada had chosen to make available on prime video owned by amazon an
01:56:00 american giant which has trouble respecting our laws to give a framework for digital giants that
01:56:09 news was a real shock because radio canada's programming will be available on prime video
01:56:17 and is not available on two point tv radio canada's platform which should offer
01:56:24 all of the chains offered by the public broadcaster
01:56:30 so we've seen this in the media people will say it's quebec commentators really emphasize this
01:56:36 yes that's true but we've also seen it in la presse and in other media this is something
01:56:41 that really shocks people it's stunning i see that they want to reach as many people as possible
01:56:48 i understand that they want to be available and we want to have discoverability of content
01:56:54 journalistic and cultural content but in our view it's very difficult to justify
01:57:00 offering this streaming on an American platform on Prime Video, regardless of the motives,
01:57:08 the strategic motives of that decision before it is offered on a platform that is owned in Canada.
01:57:17 So that's the purpose of this motion, to invite Ms. Bouchard to come explain the decision to answer
01:57:24 questions from parliamentarians so we can understand the decision and understand why
01:57:29 quebecers and francophones across canada can't have access to abdi on a canadian platform
01:57:37 if not two point tv the platform canadians are already paying for mr janitor
01:57:46 we agree with the motion however i would add
01:57:50 well, I would give Mr. Shampoo the opportunity to say if it's a good addition or not, but I think
01:58:00 it would be good to hear from people who criticize this decision. So journalists, former employees,
01:58:11 or programming directors from Abdi, who are very outspoken right now on this in Quebec,
01:58:18 this is a decision that has people with their jaws dropped right now because it doesn't make
01:58:26 sense. Amazon doesn't distribute through its platforms news. It has cut news that's produced
01:58:35 and distributed in Quebec and Canada, especially in French. And now this company is contesting a
01:58:42 decision by the government of Canada so regarding the 5% and some witnesses will
01:58:50 surely tell us in the coming weeks well it's just inconsistent and I think other
01:58:57 people should also have the opportunity to speak not just at Edzio Canada's I
01:59:01 don't know if Mr. Shampoo is open to that
01:59:05 Next, and then I'll come back.
01:59:09 I think it would be worthwhile to have just the CEO alone for this discussion,
01:59:17 but if we can add the opportunity to talk about the strategic plan as well of Radio Canada at the same time.
01:59:26 This discussion is important, of course, but we could also talk about the strategic plan of Radio Canada.
01:59:33 so I would add that as an amendment I want to see if mr. miles is proposing
01:59:44 amendment but mr. generator was proposing a friendly amendment earlier for the
01:59:49 order of priority I don't know how you want to operate yes this is true mr.
01:59:55 that was a friendly amendment i would propose we add a meeting so two meetings two hours each
02:00:11 so we could have more witnesses who could be invited does everybody agree with that
02:00:19 okay we agree with that to have a second meeting and mr miles do you have another amendment or is
02:00:30 it covered no it's an amendment that would say that well it's an amendment to the motion on the
02:00:39 first meeting with the CEO of CBC Radio Canada to talk about the strategic plan it's a small
02:00:49 amendment I agree with the clerk she can come and talk about anything when she 1.00
02:00:58 comes I don't know if it's necessary mr. shampoo mr. shampoo it's a little what I
02:01:11 was going to say I agree with adding a meeting if it's the will of the
02:01:14 committee to hear from other witnesses on this topic the decision of the and
02:01:20 prime video that's what I was going to say to mr. miles once ms bushard is
02:01:23 here if we want to ask questions on strategic planning I think that's not
02:01:29 even unrelated because maybe this decision is due to strategic planning so
02:01:35 it's the same theme I don't think it needs to be added to the motion we don't
02:01:39 need to have an amendment on this as long as it's understood that way it's understood that
02:01:46 when a witness comes you can ask the questions you wish as long as it's on topic
02:01:57 do we need to have a vote madam chair
02:01:59 i think there is consensus do we want to talk about a date for witnesses i didn't put a date
02:02:12 in the motion on purpose because i think the study we have before us currently is important and we've
02:02:19 waited some time however i think it should be the priority after the current study so the
02:02:25 first thing we do after the study would be to hold this short two meeting study.
02:02:34 I totally agree.
02:02:38 We could have split it in two, so we could have had these two meetings, but we can wait.
02:02:44 But we would need to ensure that all members here
02:02:48 don't ask questions when the CEO is here so really we can cover this outside of our current study
02:02:58 because if we start to ask questions on this already well I can't tell others what to do of
02:03:04 course well to really try not to confuse the issues
02:03:11 maybe the CEO of Radio Canada CBC will talk about this when she comes it might well personally I
02:03:23 would have suggested a date to meet with the CEO of CBC Radio Canada and other witnesses as soon
02:03:32 as soon as possible to deal with this issue.
02:03:39 The two might overlap when she's here.
02:03:55 I don't think we can tell members what to ask the witnesses
02:04:02 is and they can ask what they want but as was said the the two topics are linked
02:04:12 as mr shampoo said i take your point but i don't think we can tell members
02:04:22 mr miles as long as it's not something that she comes and then two weeks later she's here again
02:04:31 well maybe that would be good for the CEO to come here often but if she comes 0.99
02:04:39 as a witness for this study because that's what will happen that it not be
02:04:44 because we have other studies too so I totally agree to have her come but if we
02:04:51 ask the questions at that point what happens when she comes two weeks later
02:04:56 so if you agree I'm flexible it's just to mention that it could be a little
02:05:04 strange to have her in once and then it often again and we've already asked the
02:05:12 questions on the platform to us and if it gets repetitive it gets repetitive
02:05:16 the clerk has heard from the CBC that they are available on April 14th to come
02:05:23 on the study that we're in the middle of now um so it's kind of in the middle we could finish
02:05:28 the study and be in ready inviting them right back again but that's okay
02:05:37 mr janitor i know the vice president did an interview i think it was last week today's
02:05:49 tuesday i wouldn't be surprised if radio canada sent someone else than the co but that's not what
02:05:57 we want that's the tricky thing we want to have the co come debate this issue because this is
02:06:05 a fundamental issue regarding radio canada they receive 1.4 billion dollars and the minister
02:06:13 announced potential cuts they receive 1.4 billion dollars a year CBC Radio
02:06:19 Canada and Canadians will have to pay 9.99 to have access to a day if they
02:06:28 don't have cable and they'll have to go through an American company the issue is
02:06:33 why would two point TV and gem not be free in Canada and personally after
02:06:42 After paying so much money as a Canadian, I think asking the question to Canadians, it would be pretty clear that they shouldn't have to pay again to have shows that are supposed to be special or to see a show a little bit earlier than it comes out.
02:07:01 I think it's absurd.
02:07:03 So that question will be raised as well.
02:07:07 the two hours with the co is necessary and then other witnesses can ask we can ask them questions
02:07:14 on those decisions as well that's important now within the study we're doing we're talking about
02:07:21 fairness in media yes it's about fairness at the macro level i think we need to ensure we have a
02:07:28 meeting or two, as we've just decided, on just this issue. I understand Mr. Miles' prerogative
02:07:39 will invite her and then we'll invite her again. I'd be very surprised if she came twice, three
02:07:45 weeks apart. I'd be very surprised because generally speaking, they don't really like to
02:07:53 come here especially the CEO so I'm not sure she'll want to come twice so what I
02:08:03 would propose is to have a date in the motion for on this specific issue and so
02:08:12 we could have a discussion with Radio-Canada I think it will be an
02:08:17 invitation after we finish the study but I'll go to mr. shampoo and then mrs.
02:08:22 Thomas two things because question period is coming up when we invite it as
02:08:28 your candidates always the CEO who comes it's her work it's in her mandate she's 0.71
02:08:35 the link between the public broadcaster and the federal government we determined
02:08:39 earlier that there would be two meetings after the study underway there won't be
02:08:44 any issue with the frequency miss Bouchard will come when she's invited
02:08:49 we'll have some flexibility with her busy schedule but I have no doubt that
02:08:53 she'll be delighted to come before the committee if we invite her she really
02:08:57 likes us well I know she really likes me sure I guess just a quick comment here
02:09:07 I think we have no control over what the folks at this committee determined to
02:09:10 ask the CEO when she comes obviously the issue that has been brought forward by
02:09:16 Mr. Shampoo is a timely one. It's one that matters. And so should folks, you know, wish to ask
02:09:22 questions with regard to that, it absolutely 100% relates to the study at hand, which has to do with
02:09:27 fairness in the media. And there's a big question around this is the CBC being fair when they're
02:09:32 requiring payment on top of tax dollars that have already been extended to them for this type of
02:09:38 programming. So I anyways, all that to say, you know, it's it's every everybody here is a duly
02:09:44 elected member of parliament and has complete freedom to ask the questions that they feel
02:09:47 need to be asked.
02:09:48 Agree.
02:09:49 And just to be clear, we will be inviting CBC on this study and then when this study
02:09:53 is done, we will invite them again on the study that Martin has proposed.
02:09:58 So it'll be two different studies when they come for the for this study, they'll be as
02:10:02 part of a panel, a wider panel.
02:10:05 So it's not like they'll be here on their own anyway.
02:10:07 All right.
02:10:08 Sorry, go ahead.
02:10:09 on that if you read the original motion the minister would come alone for two hours and the
02:10:20 ceo would be here for two hours am i mistaken on that yes there was there was an amendment
02:10:28 adopted to have the minister alone and then on a panel the ceo of radio canada okay
02:10:39 You