Juno News - February 20, 2019


Mainstream media says Alberta convoy is "white nationalist"

Hosted by
Mentioned
Justin Trudeau is fighting to impose a TAX on Canadians Trudeau's immigration numbers boost poses many challenges

Episode Stats


Length

5 minutes

Words per minute

184.33

Word count

1,087

Sentence count

67

Harmful content

Hate speech

2

sentences flagged


Summary

Summaries generated with gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ .

In the wake of the United We Roll convoy's protest in Ottawa, the mainstream media has been quick to portray the protesters as a bunch of racist hillbilly hillbillies. But there's a lot more to it than that.

Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 Hundreds of truck drivers, allies, and average ordinary Canadians descended on Ottawa this week to call on the government to do a better job at representing them.
00:00:10 But what does the state broadcaster see? Just a group of angry Albertans.
00:00:15 Yes, that was the tweet that CBC News put out accompanying a story that had a very similar narrative to it.
00:00:21 That this convoy that started in Red Deer, Alberta, and made its way all the way to the state's capital this week was really just a group of angry, disgruntled Westerners.
00:00:31 Which has been pointed out by a number of people to really be a CBC slur.
00:00:35 The fact is this may have started in Alberta, but this has been a nationally unifying event.
00:00:40 As we saw from footage of people flashing their high beams and honking their horns as these trucks made their way through their towns and provinces on its way to Ottawa over a four-day trek.
00:00:51 But in spite of this, people that want opposition to a carbon tax enshrined in law, people that want a pipeline built, people that want better government on issues ranging from taxes and government spending to immigration.
00:01:03 CBC looks at them and sees nothing more than a group of racist hillbillies.
00:01:08 It's much like that sketch CBC did about the Yellow Vest protest on the alleged comedy show This Hour Has 22 Minutes, depicting them as just a bunch of redneck racists.
00:01:18 Except we're not talking about sketch comedy here.
00:01:20 We're talking about average Canadians.
00:01:22 The kind that are the most impacted by decisions or indecision from the federal government.
00:01:28 The kind that have to bankroll CBC but are clearly looked down upon by the state broadcaster more than they're represented by it.
00:01:36 You've seen the CBC tweet about the angry Albertans.
00:01:38 The story it's promoting isn't much better.
00:01:41 It accuses the convoy of being a magnet for extremist anti-immigrant elements.
00:01:46 Except the interesting thing is that nowhere in the CBC story does it reveal what these anti-immigrant extremist elements are.
00:01:54 It quotes a number of the organizers of the event who are very clear in saying they condemn racism.
00:01:59 It quotes some expert on racism to say that racism is bad and whatnot.
00:02:03 But the story doesn't actually acknowledge what it says it's about.
00:02:08 Which is that there's apparently this anti-immigrant and very racist sentiment that exists in the United We Roll convoy.
00:02:14 And some of the peripheral protests that have cropped up around it.
00:02:17 The same thing happened in another CBC story about Yellow Vest protests that were taking place in Red Deer.
00:02:23 Now the Yellow Vest movement is different from the United We Roll convoy.
00:02:27 But there is a lot of overlap because there are a lot of people that have very similar objectives that are grassroots members or at least supporters of both organizations.
00:02:37 And the CBC story about these organic protests had less to do with the actual protests themselves.
00:02:43 And more to do with this mythical idea that immigrants or refugees might be offended by it because the protests were taking place about a block away from a newcomer resettlement center in Red Deer.
00:02:57 Except the story, when you read the text, wasn't actually about the Yellow Vest protesters.
00:03:01 It was maligning.
00:03:02 It was actually focusing on a group called Soldiers of Odin.
00:03:06 Which is a group that has some very concerning views on immigration.
00:03:09 And it's a group that's not represented by these mainstream protest groups.
00:03:14 And is actually outright condemned by them.
00:03:17 But CBC decides to make them the focal point of a large-scale grassroots movement across the country.
00:03:23 And of course it's not just CBC.
00:03:25 Columnist Tabitha Salvi took aim at the fact that this event has role in the title.
00:03:30 Which is probably the weirdest nit to pick on something like this.
00:03:33 But she says it mythologizes what, in her view, is just a garden-variety white nationalist event.
00:03:40 That perspective that this was a white nationalist event was co-signed by Jonathan Goldsby of Canada Land.
00:03:46 Oh, well, it must be true then.
00:03:48 Not.
00:03:49 You know, I can't speak for every single person that attends these events.
00:03:53 The fact remains that grassroots movements are, by their nature, grassroots.
00:03:57 Which means anyone can be a part of them.
00:03:59 Anyone can show up.
00:04:00 It's the goal of the official voices of any movement to condemn the voices that are doing more damage.
00:04:06 And the voices that don't speak for the overarching aims.
00:04:09 And when it comes to the Yellow Vest protesters and when it comes to United We Roll, we're seeing that. 0.63
00:04:14 These groups are focusing on the overarching, unifying message that we need to resist what Justin Trudeau is doing to Canada.
00:04:21 On energy policy.
00:04:23 On immigration.
00:04:24 On taxes.
00:04:24 And this is why the event saw so much mainstream support from Maxime Bernier and Andrew Scheer, from a number of conservative members of parliament, and from people in the media who are of a conservative bent.
00:04:36 There are a few of us out there that looked at this event and saw a message that was positive.
00:04:42 So what the media will do, though, the mainstream media, is find the one person expressing a radical view and say that they represent the whole.
00:04:50 Now, the worst part about this is that these are the same people that stand up and say that we can't do that with radical Islam, for example.
00:04:58 We can't let one radical Islamist speak for the entire Muslim faith. 0.65
00:05:03 And I agree wholeheartedly.
00:05:04 But why, then, are they taking people that have radical views or people that are inarticulate and trying to make them the poster boys and poster girls for a movement that overwhelmingly is made up of the average, ordinary people that need to be at the center of representation in Canada's government?
00:05:22 It's true that CBC just doesn't get it.
00:05:26 But unfortunately, we still have to pay for it.
00:05:28 It's never been more important to have a voice in the media that is standing up for the issues you care about and, more importantly, for the people like you.
00:05:36 I'm proud to be doing that at True North, but I can't do it alone.
00:05:40 There's a link in the description box where you can join the Heritage Club or the Patriot Club with a monthly contribution to let us keep doing this work that the state broadcaster and a lot of their colleagues are not doing.
00:05:51 For True North, I'm Andrew Lutton.