Malaysian state censor honoured at London media freedom conference
Episode Stats
Words per Minute
164.80113
Summary
The first ever Global Conference for Media Freedom in London, co-hosted by the governments of Canada and the UK, aimed at exporting the idea of a free press to countries around the world. It's an important topic, one about which I care a great deal, but one that I'm not particularly optimistic the host governments care much about. They care about talking about it, but their actions don't match the words. One example of this is apparent in who they've invited to participate in the conference: a number of representatives of fundamentally unfree countries are here. The Pakistani Foreign Minister, for example, is a special guest in the proceedings of this conference, but there was one speaker in particular that piqued my interest. He was honored on stage at the beginning of the second day of the conference by British Foreign Minister Jeremy Hunt. He is the Malaysian Minister for Communications and Multimedia.
Transcript
00:00:00.000
I'm at the first ever Global Conference for Media Freedom in London, England,
00:00:13.440
co-hosted by the governments of Canada and the United Kingdom, aimed at essentially exporting
00:00:18.880
the idea of a free press to countries around the world. An important topic, one about which I care
00:00:24.640
a great deal, but one that I'm not particularly optimistic the host governments care all that
00:00:29.680
much about themselves. They care about talking about it, but their actions don't match the words.
00:00:36.240
One example of this is apparent in who they've invited to participate. A number of representatives
00:00:42.480
of fundamentally unfree countries are here. The Pakistani foreign minister, for example,
00:00:48.480
is a special guest in the proceedings of this conference. But there was one speaker in particular
00:00:53.920
that piqued my interest. He was honored on stage at the beginning of the second day of the conference
00:00:58.640
by British Foreign Minister Jeremy Hunt. He is the Malaysian Minister for Communications
00:01:04.320
and Multimedia. There he is there. Now Minister Singh Deo spoke very effectively about how he cares about
00:01:11.360
a free press and free speech and he wants to combat fake news. That's his words, not mine. But when you
00:01:17.440
look into this particular minister, his track record is the exact opposite of standing up for free speech.
00:01:24.400
For example, last September, there was a British publisher, a London-based publisher of the popular
00:01:31.760
website Malaysia Today, that made a comment about a police chief in Malaysia, a Sikh man who wears a
00:01:38.160
turban. And he said the comment may have been in poor taste, that the turban may have been on too
00:01:44.240
tight. It was restricting blood flow. Now this may not be a comment you agree with or stand by, but it's the
00:01:50.240
type of comment that free speech allows even if it's disagreeable or offensive. Well, what this
00:01:56.080
particular minister did in response was say not only that it's unacceptable and shouldn't have a place
00:02:01.120
in society, but that speech like that should be prosecuted even when the person who utters it
00:02:08.000
doesn't live in Malaysia. This is what he said in a Facebook post. Minister Singh Deo argued for an
00:02:14.720
extraterritorial law that would allow prosecution worldwide against those who run afoul of Malaysia's
00:02:22.320
very strict and stringent speech reforms. In a later example, he spoke about wanting a law that would
00:02:28.800
regulate social media companies and even regulate the comments on news outlets, holding media companies
00:02:36.160
accountable if someone writes what he called an inflammatory comment on a news story that's publicly
00:02:41.600
accessible, prosecuting news websites for allowing users to comment on them. Now these may be things
00:02:48.080
that you would expect to hear from the Minister of Communications and Multimedia from Malaysia. In fact,
00:02:53.520
I wouldn't be all that surprised about it, which is why I looked into this man in the first place.
00:02:57.680
What is surprising, and I would say the paragon of hypocrisy, is that this man was not only invited to a press
00:03:03.600
freedom conference, but given billing on stage alongside the foreign ministers of Canada and the United
00:03:10.000
Kingdom, introduced as someone who was on the front lines of the free speech battles in his country.
00:03:16.000
That's what happened with this particular minister. Now I asked Minister Freeland about this in a press
00:03:22.320
scrum, and her response was that this isn't about perfection. You can look at her answer for yourself.
00:03:28.480
This is not meant to be a group of angels and a group of countries that are perfect.
00:03:34.800
What it is meant to be is a group of countries that are, and not just the attendance, the attendance is
00:03:42.400
open, and I'm actually quite happy to have people who don't believe in media freedom be here to listen
00:03:50.160
to us and have an opportunity to hear why we think it's important. But in terms of the group of countries,
00:03:56.480
for example, signing on to our media pledge, the group of countries on a stage, it's not meant to be a
00:04:02.080
gathering of angels, what it is meant to be, or of saints, it's meant to be a gathering of countries
00:04:08.720
that sincerely appreciate the importance of media freedom, and crucially, sincerely believe in the
00:04:18.400
value of working hard to get better. And I think in introducing the Malaysian minister, Secretary Hunt
00:04:25.280
was very clear that that was the reason that the invitation had been extended to Malaysia.
00:04:30.480
Now, I happen to agree with Minister Freeland's assertion that this isn't about perfection, that
00:04:35.120
no country has a 100% successful track record at upholding free speech. But there is something to
00:04:41.600
be said about the judgment of the countries that are telling us we need to take their lead when the
00:04:47.200
people they're inviting aren't doing the same. And it's proof of what I've said all through this
00:04:52.480
process, which is that Canada and the UK aren't interested in actually getting into the uncomfortable truths
00:04:57.520
about free speech in their own countries and those of other countries here. They're more interested in
00:05:02.320
talking a big game. And they've already, without having known how this conference would shape up,
00:05:07.520
committed to having another one next year. And it's hard to imagine things will be any clearer then.
00:05:14.960
We've heard from advocates and activists and NGOs that have been complaining about declining press
00:05:19.840
freedom around the world, even in developed countries like Canada and the UK.
00:05:23.680
You can be 8th on the list for global press freedom, you can be 18th as Canada is or 33 as Britain is.
00:05:29.920
But these are relative rankings. This doesn't mean that you are doing things right in your own country
00:05:34.880
and you are protecting the free press and free speech rights of your country.
00:05:39.600
But now they're wanting us to learn from Malaysia, from not just a government,
00:05:44.640
but an individual government figure and politician who thinks that you should be able to prosecute
00:05:49.840
internationally anyone who makes a mean comment online. And this is what we've learned at the
00:05:55.760
Global Conference for Media Freedom. For True North from London, I'm Andrew Lawton.