Juno News - November 22, 2022


Marco Mendicino Testifies - Emergencies Act Inquiry

Topics
Mentioned
CBC says crosswords are racist Liberal ministers joked about sending in tanks to break up Convoy

Episode Stats


Length

5 hours and 49 minutes

Words per minute

110.89

Word count

38,756

Sentence count

1,288

Harmful content

Toxicity

3

sentences flagged

Hate speech

6

sentences flagged


Summary

Summaries generated with gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ .

In this episode, we speak with Minister of Public Safety and Emergency Preparedness, Marco Mendoza, MP for Eglinton-Lawrence, about his role in the response to the January 26, 2020 protest in Ottawa, Ontario.

Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Topics generated with Qwen2.5-3B-Instruct.
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 Thank you very much.
00:00:30 Your name is Marco Mendicino, M-A-R-C-O, M-E-N-D-I-C-I-N-O.
00:00:54 Gérez-vous que le témoignage que vous allez rendre aujourd'hui sera la vérité et rien d'autre que la vérité que Dieu vous internaide? Je le jure.
00:01:15 So, we'll just start with a little housekeeping, which is the entry of your witness summary.
00:01:19 You'll recall sitting for an interview with Commission Council on September 5th this year?
00:01:23 Yes. And after that interview, Commission Council prepared a summary of the interview.
00:01:28 Have you seen and reviewed that summary? I have. Yes. And can you confirm that it's accurate to the
00:01:33 best of your knowledge and belief? Yes. Okay. For the record, Mr. Clerk, that's WTS 5054. No need to
00:01:40 pull it up. So, Mr. Mendocino, I understand you were appointed Minister of Public Safety in October
00:01:47 2021. Is that right? That's correct. Okay. And can you briefly outline, well, first of all,
00:01:52 your background before that the background in politics and then and what you did before that
00:01:57 i was first elected in 2015 and have been serving as the member of parliament for eglinton lawrence
00:02:05 which is a constituency in north toronto uh have been re-elected twice both in 2019 and in 2021
00:02:12 and prior to getting into politics i was a practicing lawyer in ontario where i served
00:02:19 for about a decade as a federal prosecutor and then subsequently
00:02:49 ... receiving information and sharing information from law enforcement to colleagues within
00:03:12 the federal government, making sure that we were staying in touch and engaging with different
00:03:17 levels of government, both provincially and municipally, making sure that we gave advice
00:03:23 to the government with regards to the decision to invoke the Emergencies Act and then subsequently
00:03:29 to revoke the Emergencies Act, being a communicator on behalf of the government to Canadians to
00:03:35 keep them apprised of the situation last winter, and a number of other roles, but those are the
00:03:43 was okay and we're going to explore a lot of uh the details of what you what you just outlined
00:03:48 today so we'll start with the time period before the convoy arrived in ottawa so mr clerk can i
00:03:54 ask you to pull up ssm.nsc.can401790
00:04:11 so mr manchino to situate you um this is just on january 26th i believe um oh i'm sorry if you
00:04:19 just scroll down a little bit you would ask commissioner lucky i believe to to brief you on
00:04:24 the convoy do you do you recall that i do recall that by the end of january there were reports
00:04:31 about a massive protest that was mobilizing from across the country and so to to be sure that we
00:04:39 were again kept aware of of how police were going to respond to that protest we asked for briefings
00:04:47 okay and the next document i'll ask you to pull up mr clerk is pb.nsc.can 50992
00:04:58 so these uh to situate you again as the documents being pulled up minister are uh talking points
00:05:05 for the briefing on january 26 i believe the commissioner lucky's talking points
00:05:10 um so they're not yours but i'm going to take you through them and you can confirm to us whether
00:05:15 this was the sort of information that was being provided to you that day so 26 before the convoy
00:05:21 arrives we scroll down mr clerk to where you see the goal uh there we go so the goal of the
00:05:27 nationwide protest is to disrupt traffic flow and general business of government in the hope
00:05:33 that the canadian government will lift all covet 19 related restrictions below that although the
00:05:39 majority of information indicates organizers are planning a peaceful event. Many social media posts
00:05:46 suggest some participants may attempt to disrupt government buildings and further
00:05:51 cause disruptions throughout the city. Was that information conveyed to you? Yes it was. Okay
00:05:57 scrolling down again to page two please.
00:05:59 it is unknown how long the protesters plan to stay in ottawa however the rcmp has located
00:06:10 social media posts indicating some participants may stay around the downtown core until january
00:06:17 31st in hopes to disrupt the house of commons sitting that day so with that information
00:06:23 conveyed to you and more broadly can you tell us what your expectation was before the convoy
00:06:29 arrived of how long it would or might stay. That information was conveyed to me and a number of
00:06:36 other colleagues at cabinet level and my immediate reaction was to question the quality of the
00:06:48 intelligence about the duration with which this protest was going to occur. One of the things
00:06:55 that struck me was that there were reported reports about a significant number of vehicles
00:07:01 that were coming from across the country and it certainly seemed to me that that just given the
00:07:10 amount of time that it would take to get to Ottawa and other locations in the country where
00:07:15 these demonstrations would occur that there there may very well be an intention to stay
00:07:21 longer than the short period of time that some of those initial briefings had suggested that they
00:07:27 would stay there combined with some of the public statements around the original manifesto
00:07:33 which in my opinion was the spark for the so-called freedom convoy the stated political
00:07:39 and ideological objectives within that document to force the government to reverse course on
00:07:46 pandemic policies or else to see the government overthrown or resign suggested to me that there
00:07:53 may be an entrenchment and as time went on we certainly started to probe those questions more
00:07:59 once they arrived at the end of january okay so just to sum that up and to make sure i have it
00:08:04 right when you say uh question the intelligence you sort of do you mean question the assessment
00:08:09 in the end of the conclusion that this is likely going to be gone by the end of of the weekend
00:08:13 you were you were concerned that it would stay longer than that that's correct okay um scrolling
00:08:19 down to page three please mr clerk we see there we go perfect with respect to the threat picture
00:08:27 there has been an increase in online narratives supportive of the convoy among both ideologically
00:08:33 motivated networks we've heard a lot about ideologically motivated networks and imvu over
00:08:38 the past week or so, as well as in general public discourse. And then scrolling down a little bit
00:08:43 more, the Convoy is attracting individuals who are not aligned with any specific ideology or group,
00:08:50 but who have experienced personal hardships such as job loss due to COVID-19 and are upset with
00:08:57 provincial or federal government responses as COVID continues to impact daily life.
00:09:01 open source monitoring has identified associated posts advocating violence and there's potential
00:09:09 for anti-government groups to join the demo with violent intentions um then it talks about online
00:09:16 posts feeding the conspiracy narrative with misinformation and disinformation
00:09:21 raising tensions scrolling down a little bit more please mr clerk um open source reports
00:09:28 also suggest that police are setting up roadblocks and such reports seem to fuel unintended some
00:09:35 truckers agitation uh a post to the event facebook group asked for known mp's addresses in ottawa
00:09:42 including the pm's residence and cottage and this suggests that the convoy should break apart
00:09:46 to to these locations is that all information that was conveyed to you yes and if i could just
00:09:51 be permitted to expand uh briefly because you touched on a few important points and if i could
00:09:56 just ask for the technicians to scroll back up. So right under the words on January 22, 2022,
00:10:07 there's a number of bullet points that I just want to shed some additional light on. So the
00:10:14 fact that the convoy was attracting individuals with different grievances was one of the
00:10:20 phenomenon around the expressly stated ideological political and in some cases extremely uh extreme
00:10:29 stated objectives of the freedom convoy um and this was something that that again was the
00:10:38 a recurring theme in our discussions with law enforcement with the security and intelligence
00:10:42 community the fact that um it was pulling uh in people with different grievances not just in
00:10:49 relationship to the pandemic but grievances regarding the government and other democratic
00:10:55 institutions similarly the the potential for violence was stated at the outset i mean there
00:11:03 were a number of very public statements by individuals like pat king who had said that
00:11:10 that this could end in bullets or that it would end in bullets potentially
00:11:13 was a signal of intent, at least that was my opinion, that certainly not all, I mean,
00:11:21 there were many thousands of Canadians who participated in these demonstrations and in
00:11:26 the blockade who were there for entirely legitimate and lawful purposes, but some were prepared to
00:11:32 become violent. There's a bullet point there about threats to public figures. We were concerned about
00:11:40 whether or not the blockade might target the prime minister. And then, as you will have heard
00:11:46 by now, there were subsequent many threats that were made towards not only elected public figures,
00:11:52 but equally law enforcement and representative of the media, which to me, again, signaled that
00:11:59 this was a movement that in some cases was prepared to attack our democratic institutions
00:12:06 to force change around policies.
00:12:10 Okay, I'll just stop you there and scroll down to the next page, Mr. Clerk,
00:12:13 because I think this is, or actually I think it's page six.
00:12:17 This is touching on the point that you just made, Minister Mendogino.
00:12:20 So at the top of that page, it says effective January 11th something
00:12:27 for announcements and public functions has been put in place for eight individuals
00:12:32 and it lists off Minister Jairi, Freeland, yourself, a few other ministers, and Dr. Tam,
00:12:37 and without obviously getting into what's behind that Section 37 redaction, is it fair to assume
00:12:42 that that means that some sort of, there was a security risk identified?
00:12:46 That's exactly correct, and the RCMB had briefed in the early days of the convoy,
00:12:52 certainly within the first week, that there needed to be a significant change in the security posture
00:12:58 regarding the ministers that are in that paragraph.
00:13:04 And in part, I think that was a response
00:13:06 to the heightened degree of posts
00:13:08 that were violent in nature,
00:13:12 the overtly criminal threats that were being made
00:13:14 against the lives and the security and safety
00:13:17 of identifiable public figures.
00:13:20 And so as a result of that,
00:13:22 the security detail did change around a number of
00:13:25 both me and my colleagues in cabinet.
00:13:27 Okay, and last point on this, if we just scroll down a little bit more, there's, you'll see a line that says concerns from Minister LeBlanc specifically, and what we'll be hearing from Minister LeBlanc early, later on today, but it says Minister LeBlanc has reached in to Minister Mendicino, noting MPs are concerned for their safety and amid reporting of demonstrators attending their residences. This is being taken into consideration as part of the above planning for deployment of resources.
00:13:56 And I think that that is worth emphasizing as well, because in addition to the security that was provided to ministers and cabinet, there was a heightened security posture around the Hill and around being able to access Parliament.
00:14:10 And indeed, one of my main concerns was that given, again, some of the stated objectives by some, including the potential to become violent, that that we were just returning from winter session.
00:14:26 And the first day of the resumption of Parliament coincided with one of the early days in in the blockade and subsequent occupation right here in Ottawa.
00:14:39 And I was worried about a significant number of people being able to both ingress and egress from the hill.
00:14:50 And so there was a heightened security posture so that we could continue to host Parliament or to hold Parliament.
00:15:00 It was a very important priority that Canadians see that the business of government continue, notwithstanding the blockade and the convoy.
00:15:09 But there were challenges. And I had many conversations with parliamentarians, disproportionately women, I would point out, who were the recipient of harassment, intimidation, expressions of hate through the convoy.
00:15:24 So that additional security was very much driven by the reality on the ground.
00:15:29 Okay, that was actually my next question, whether these concerns were based on identified threats having been identified, I'm going to use that word twice, but by the intelligence services or by law enforcement, or whether these were based on what was being seen on social media, or based on essentially complaints or worries expressed by members of parliament and the individuals involved.
00:15:52 All of the above. And so it was a combination of what we were seeing on the ground in the activities of the convoy and probably the most aggressive demonstration of their presence was the parking of ultimately hundreds of trucks on Wellington Street, which is one of the main arteries that runs through the parliamentary precinct.
00:16:15 and again I'll just pause here I mean that that visual suggested to me that we were going to be
00:16:25 in it for quite some time rather than just the weekend but I'll come back to that we were I'm
00:16:31 sure that the RCMP were taking into account what they were seeing online what they were hearing
00:16:37 from various parliamentarians regarding potential security threats and so for all of those reasons
00:16:43 again, security was elevated, not only for cabinet, but for parliamentarians and for staff
00:16:48 who were working in the parliamentary precinct. Okay, and we will get to the actual arrival of
00:16:53 the convoy, but there's one more document I'd like to pull up before we get there. So,
00:16:57 So, Mr. Clerk, that is SSM.nsc.can401809, and so this, Minister, may go to what you were
00:17:18 just expressing about your heightened level of concern.
00:17:21 This is Friday, January 28th at around noon, so this is as the convoy would be starting
00:17:27 to roll in you send an email to mike jones can you tell us who mike jones is because his name
00:17:33 will come up a few times i think this morning mike jones is my chief of staff and the email that you
00:17:38 put up which is dated friday january 28th at about 5 38 pm reflects the questions that i
00:17:47 intend to put to the table so looking at latest estimate on numbers both in terms of vehicles and
00:17:54 people, trying to ascertain whether or not there was any intelligence of individuals who may be
00:18:01 on a watch list regarding threats to national security. The third question that I put in the
00:18:11 email there, which is written as latest on what-if scenarios, what I was really, I think,
00:18:19 foreshadowing was a discussion around potential contingencies. Like, what if the convoy doesn't
00:18:29 disengage? What if they don't leave? And from a very early point, as I had said earlier, had
00:18:38 concerns that this was not just going to be a one or a two day event, that it was going to last much
00:18:43 longer and so i wanted to extract from um the community the law enforcement community the
00:18:50 intelligence community what do we do if that's the case how do we make sure that we keep public
00:18:56 safety um and and what are the contingencies around that okay um so just a couple of things
00:19:03 the first is is for the record and and for ease of understanding you'll see the the notation plus
00:19:09 four zeros there. That means that the timestamp is in Greenwich Mean Time, so it's minus
00:19:14 five hours. So that was around 1230. And as you say, you're asking, what if scenarios?
00:19:20 What if they don't leave? What if it lasts beyond Monday? What if it turns violent? What
00:19:26 if they come before parliamentary residences? And we know now at this point that what ended
00:19:34 up happening as of i think january 28th was uh a group of ministers consisting of yourself
00:19:41 i believe minister leblanc minister uh blair and minister al gabra were briefed daily by
00:19:48 uh a variety of officials from pco and various agencies under public safety
00:19:54 would that have been done in response to this request um i i think it was understood
00:19:59 early on that we were going to need to take a whole of government approach responding to the
00:20:05 convoy. So the initial group that you just highlighted of ministers was eventually expanded
00:20:11 and then ultimately, as I'm sure we'll get into, the Prime Minister convened a meeting of the
00:20:16 incident response group, which included a number of others. But I should highlight the two last
00:20:21 points which are in the email to Mike Jones, which suggests that at the time I was also
00:20:29 concerned about making sure that we were staying up on threat assessments as well to senators as
00:20:36 well as the governor general in addition to elected parliamentarians and finally I wanted to get a
00:20:42 sense of what outreach was being done to the organizers and my thinking there was let's try to
00:20:50 allow for the space for a lawful protest keep it within the boundaries of the law because it is a
00:20:56 hallmark of our democracy that people can take opposing different views um and and so i wanted
00:21:04 to make sure that there were some lines of communication with the organizers of the of
00:21:08 the convoy from the early days okay so we'll just skip a little bit ahead now uh so the convoy
00:21:14 arrives it doesn't leave on sunday or monday as expected and then we're into the first week of
00:21:20 the protest so i'll ask you a few questions about what that first week was like from your perspective
00:21:26 And with the assistance right now of the following document, pb.can401870, please.
00:21:46 Okay, so, Minister Mendocino, this is a text from Mike Jones, who's in the blue.
00:21:52 well if there's no one there's no one else i think in the and it's not blue but there we go now it's
00:21:56 blue um and the text is to brian clow can you tell us who brian clow is yes brian clow is the deputy
00:22:04 chief of staff to the prime minister okay so just scrolling down a little bit please mr quick so we
00:22:08 can see the text so this is sunday february 6th and and mr jones mike jones writes to mr clow so
00:22:16 my boss that would be you yes is pretty amped up he's concerned that ops have lost jurisdiction
00:22:23 as there's no control at all over what's happening on wellington also concerned for pm safety if he is
00:22:30 returning to this this week what does that mean if he was returning this week just pausing there
00:22:37 my recollection is that he was out of ottawa for some period of time and then would be returning
00:22:42 to to ottawa and to ultimately the house of commons and and so i was i was outlining my
00:22:52 concern about his ability to for him and his uh his staff and and and the rcmp that work with him
00:23:01 to protect him to get into and out of parliament safely because by then and the date of this text
00:23:09 is Sunday, February the 6th. So we're fully now, I think, about a week into the convoy. And this
00:23:17 would have been after the first weekend. And the concerns that I was expressing was that
00:23:24 by that first weekend, it was my opinion that it was virtually impossible to enforce the law
00:23:32 on Wellington Street. Given the rampant behavior, not only the noise that was being made by
00:23:42 the excessive honking of horns well into the evening, but some of the early reports,
00:23:49 and again, bear in mind, this is Sunday, February 6th. By then, there were a number of press
00:23:56 conferences that the Ottawa Police Service had held expressing serious concerns around
00:24:01 the reports of intimidation, harassment, and violence, if memory serves. I think there was
00:24:07 a press conference where the Ottawa Police Service had indicated that there were reports
00:24:13 of firearms that had been brought into the nation's capital. And subsequently, again,
00:24:19 I'm going from memory, but there was at least one arrest that was reported of somebody that
00:24:24 was making their way potentially to the convoy where the firearm was seized. You know, there were
00:24:32 efforts, I think, by law enforcement to try and get the situation under control, but they were
00:24:38 overwhelmed. So there were a series of events leading up to the text that Mike Jones had sent
00:24:46 to Brian Clough that had led to my concerns being elevated about our ability to restore public safety
00:24:57 on Wellington Street in the nation's capital, which is the seat of the federal government.
00:25:03 I would also just add that my concerns were not just about Ottawa, that by then there were already
00:25:08 reports as well about borders being uh blockaded and i would just recall for you uh and and uh and
00:25:17 for judge rouleau that in my job as minister of public safety i'm not just looking at the nation
00:25:24 the nation's capital or the parliamentary precinct i'm looking at the entire country and so by then
00:25:30 a number of critical infrastructure and borders had become either the target of or in fact
00:25:38 blockades which had a significant impact on critical supply chains so there was a lot that
00:25:44 was i think um i'm i'm interpreting and extracting a little bit exactly uh from the language but i
00:25:51 think that's what mike jones was conveying to brian cloud okay so it just scroll down a little
00:25:55 bit more mr clerk so the next part of the text says he wants to go out that would be you want to
00:26:01 go out and say that ops needs to get control over the situation and if they need more from obp they
00:26:08 should make that clear but they should get working on removals within the next 24 hours and if they're
00:26:14 not if they aren't going to do it then we may need to look at other measures let me know if you want
00:26:18 to discuss so this represents where your your thinking is as you say at the end of the first
00:26:24 week so this is sunday february 6 and you've just told us why you've come to this this uh viewpoint
00:26:31 can i ask what you meant by we need we may need to look at other measures at that point
00:26:36 At that point, I think looking at offering additional resources to local police and, you know, there had been informal requests communicated to me and to my office for additional RCMP services, which we provided on a number of different occasions prior to the invocation of the act.
00:26:57 So that was certainly one of the other potential measures
00:27:02 that we could explore, which was,
00:27:03 how do we get more boots on the ground
00:27:06 to help the Ottawa Police Service?
00:27:09 And let's not forget the Ontario Provincial Police
00:27:12 who were the first stop if OPS or the Ottawa Police Service
00:27:18 could not restore public safety.
00:27:22 And so that's what I believe I was foreshadowing at the time.
00:27:25 okay uh well we're about to get into some of those resourcing discussions because the next topic
00:27:30 we're going to cover is the tripartite meetings right we've come to know as the tripartites so
00:27:35 um mr clerk if you can pull up while while i'm talking pb.nsc.can402335
00:27:45 so you meant you mentioned minister manichino that at this point there'd been a number of
00:27:55 requests made from uh from the ottawa police from various i think provinces at this point
00:28:01 even there'd been an approach from alberta but we're not really getting into alberta right now
00:28:05 but uh in any event around the 7th or 8th of february the 7th a decision was made that it
00:28:12 be a good idea to convene the federal provincial and municipal governments to discuss the situation
00:28:18 in ottawa and the way forward from there including the provision of resources as you mentioned
00:28:23 uh there are a lot of issues to cover that come out of the tripartites we're going to focus on a
00:28:28 few a few of those issues are the rcmp resources there's the lack of the ops plan and there's uh
00:28:34 what seems to be expressed as a a lack of engagement from the province of ontario so
00:28:39 I'm going to take you through a few extracts that focus on some of those topics. So the document in
00:28:46 front of us now is a readout of the February 7th tripartite, and that was the first tripartite
00:28:52 meeting. Is that right? Yes. Okay. Scrolling down, Mr. Clerk, when you see the initials,
00:28:59 M-M. Okay, M-M. M-M is Marco Mendocino. That's you? Yes. Okay. Minister Mendocino or Marco
00:29:05 managino one of the two so mm call last week with watson was productive it is stressful period for
00:29:13 you and chief feels like things have turned around a bit today we have confirmed 250 mounties have
00:29:19 been deputized supporting local law enforcement we have been timely and responsive in putting our
00:29:25 response together minister jones will want to have a discussion with what they can contribute
00:29:31 uh letter addressed to and scroll down yeah there we go both pm and premier we are going to be in
00:29:37 touch okay so from your recollection minister who attended that first tripartite meeting
00:29:44 um well from the federal level of government myself minister blair our officials some of
00:29:51 our political staff mayor watson i believe his chief of staff and um i'm trying to recall
00:30:00 whether or not uh there were any officials from the ontario government not elected um or not but
00:30:08 but i mean the majority of the participants were um the political levels from the city of ottawa
00:30:15 the federal government and supporting staff and officials okay and that's fair this isn't
00:30:19 a memory test anyway but um so minister jones obviously did not attend because you were talking
00:30:23 about getting her to attend in this in this uh exchange here okay um can we just scroll down
00:30:29 again to page two please keep going a little bit please mr clerk there we go where it says watson
00:30:39 on tripartite table so the discussion before this pertains to um rcmp numbers how many resources
00:30:47 are being provided there's some frustration expressed throughout this by the mayor of
00:30:51 ottawa mayor watson about how many rcmp boots are actually on the ground so that's being discussed
00:30:57 and then we get to Watson on tripartite table has the province agreed to this and Minister Blair then
00:31:05 says both of us have reached out mm that would be you and I she wasn't able to join today
00:31:11 unfortunately we'll continue to engage to encourage them to join these talks and then
00:31:18 Mayor Watson expresses an opinion that the province is reluctant to be a part of what's going on
00:31:23 and then expresses some frustration about that.
00:31:27 Would you agree with that characterization of Mayor Watson in that line?
00:31:31 The province was reluctant to be part of what was going on.
00:31:36 I would agree that at that particular point in time that there was a common desire to have Minister Jones
00:31:46 or additional representation from Ontario at the tripartite meeting for the purposes of
00:31:53 cooperating and coordinating the response to the convoy in Ottawa. Now, I would add that that's not
00:32:00 to say that the province was not engaged at all. And I know, for instance, that Premier Ford had
00:32:07 made a number of very strong statements about the state of the convoy, condemning it, saying,
00:32:13 you know it was out of control it pronounced very definitively and declaratively that it was time for
00:32:19 for people to go home if i recall correctly that would have been before this tripartite there were
00:32:25 other conversations that i was having bilaterally around around the tripartite so i would say
00:32:33 despite the fact that they were not at that table there were still conversations with ontario but
00:32:38 yes we would like to have seen them at the tripartite there's no doubt about that
00:32:43 okay um can we just scroll down again please mr clerk last point i think on this one page three
00:32:50 please sorry there we go where it says mm again wellington so mm wellington has invoked a lot of
00:33:00 images but the site of a crane trucks in front of pmo pco were particularly concerning uh need
00:33:06 to know from the chief what the plan is and chief there is chief slowly what the plan is
00:33:11 to have those vehicles removed with appropriate boundaries on operational independence how is the
00:33:17 convoy being broken up and disengaged can i just ask you to speak at this point on what you meant
00:33:22 there by appropriate boundaries on operational independence in this context well that's a very
00:33:29 important uh question because um the principle of operational independence has to guide the
00:33:35 relationship between police and the elected branch of government and again from my past professional
00:33:44 experience as a prosecutor and as a practicing lawyer i would have been very familiar precisely
00:33:49 because i had worked closely with police in a variety of different cases and the need to in
00:33:54 respect that principle at all times so i wanted to be sure that even as though we were asking
00:34:02 questions of police to provide some detail and some clarity around how they intended to restore
00:34:09 public safety that at all times it was respectful of that principle at the same time i do think it
00:34:15 bears emphasizing that police and the elected branch of government do not operate in two silos
00:34:21 and nor should we that there needs to be a dialogue between both branches to be sure that
00:34:26 police have the resources that they need which was one of my core responsibilities in the response
00:34:31 to the blockade as well as potentially additional tools to respond to the unique and unprecedented
00:34:37 nature of this convoy which is something that we ultimately came to so i know you may have
00:34:42 more questions about operational independence but i wanted to flag really early on that that
00:34:47 you know as we were asking questions we were mindful of that the other thing i would just
00:34:51 stress if i could is that in ultimately forming the opinion that we needed to invoke the emergencies
00:34:58 act one of my main concerns was the inability to enforce the law adjacent to critical infrastructure
00:35:06 and that would have included parliament and the nature of the parliamentary precinct is such
00:35:11 that wellington street falls within the jurisdiction of the ottawa police service
00:35:16 so i was certainly trying to reconcile in my mind that these are federal democratic institutions
00:35:25 But we did not have total jurisdiction over that space.
00:35:30 In other words, it wasn't at the sole or exclusive discretion of the RCMP, which is the Federal Police Service, to go and assert itself on Wellington Street to bring the situation back into control.
00:35:44 So we had to navigate different levels of government, including municipal and provincial, because Ottawa Police Service has that jurisdiction as of this moment.
00:35:54 And if they did not have the resources to respond to the occupation at that point, including the ability to remove hundreds of large vehicles on Wellington Street, including the ability to remove a crane, which had been parked right adjacent to the Prime Minister's office and the Privy Council office, including the ability to simply enforce the law,
00:36:21 then they could then next go to they then statutorily under the Ontario Police Services
00:36:28 Act could go to the Ontario government to ask for the Ontario Provincial Police Service
00:36:32 to backstop any gaps there but I would point out that there is no statutory link beyond that
00:36:39 to go from the Ontario Police Service Act to the Emergencies Act and I know that's something we're
00:36:44 going to come to. Okay there's a lot you've said there and we'll unpack that slowly but surely
00:36:49 But for the purposes of the discussion we're having right now about the tripartites,
00:36:55 would it be fair to say that part of the idea in holding the tripartites
00:36:59 would be to sort out the jurisdictional issue?
00:37:01 All of that.
00:37:02 It was really to make sure that all of the key players at all three levels of government
00:37:08 were able to navigate around the jurisdictional challenges and complexities.
00:37:15 But beyond that, the situation on the ground, which, you know, by then, as you pointed out in an earlier exhibit and text, it was on the brink of being completely ungovernable, if not already by then.
00:37:33 Okay. We'll go now to the next tripartite, which is the following day, February 8th.
00:37:39 Mr. Clerk, that's ssm.nsc.can402052.
00:37:56 So, these are notes taken of that tripartite.
00:38:00 Just again, to situate us a bit with the names here, Zita Astrovis, we've heard, is Mr. Blair's Chief of Staff.
00:38:07 Samantha Khalil, can you tell us who that is?
00:38:11 Samantha Khalil works in the Prime Minister's office, and I believe she works in the Issues Department of the Prime Minister's office.
00:38:19 Okay, so this is essentially a readout or notes from that tripartite on the 8th.
00:38:23 Scroll down a little bit, Mr. Clerk.
00:38:26 There we go.
00:38:27 MM, good to be back on these calls.
00:38:29 it's only been a day stay focused on the task at hand received your letter and the mayor then says
00:38:35 why no soljan attendance soljan is is minister jones that's correct okay and you say no word
00:38:42 back so you're conveying there that you you attempted to call or attempted to contact minister
00:38:47 jones and and had not heard back at that yes that's right okay and then uh the mayor says
00:38:53 he's speaking to the premier tomorrow and he will ask that his minister be at the table he goes on
00:38:59 to talk about a call that he'd had with the prime minister which we we went through in some detail
00:39:04 a few weeks ago um and then minister blair chimes in on ontario involvement and says i know marco's
00:39:12 been having good conversations with ontario they are worried about being visible and then being
00:39:18 asked about what the province is doing. Now, I appreciate that these are Minister Blair's words,
00:39:24 not yours, but do you know, do you recall what he was talking about when he said they were worried
00:39:28 about being visible? Well, again, as you pointed out, these are my colleague Minister Blair's words
00:39:36 that are being captured in a summary of a readout. I believe he was referring to the fact that at the
00:39:45 point in time that we were having these trilateral conversations that there was a lot of attention
00:39:50 that was being placed on both the city of Ottawa as well as the federal government and you know I
00:39:56 believe he was conveying a perception that that Ontario wasn't at the table at the time and so
00:40:03 again what we really were driving at here and as I think the summary communicates was an effort to
00:40:11 bring Ontario to the table. And I had reached out to Minister Jones, had not heard back at that
00:40:18 point, I believe, if memory serves, I was able to get in touch with her shortly after that
00:40:23 time. But it was it was really a full court press to try and have everybody at the trilateral table
00:40:31 because as we've discussed, there were operational complexities and jurisdictional complexities. And
00:40:38 to the extent that we could be all aligned, then that would help to restore public safety.
00:40:44 Okay. And we'll get back to that topic. I'm going to scroll down and take you to something else I
00:40:49 want to ask you about here. This is, sorry, scroll down a little bit, Mr. Clerk, until you see page
00:40:57 three slowly for every action should be a little bit down from there there we go so just scroll
00:41:08 down there we go thank you slowly so there's a chief slowly speaking and you're asking what
00:41:16 does the trend look like for removal is it going slow slowly going down or is it stop and start
00:41:21 and she slowly says for every action we do there is a counter reaction then that can exceed our
00:41:28 resources we saw that in coventry so he's discussing there the the give and take or the
00:41:34 the reactions and counter reactions in ottawa specifically but then he then says our public
00:41:40 request for more uh for 1800 more people resulted in the activity in windsor plus a national call
00:41:48 for protesters to drive to Ottawa so they can outnumber even increased police presence. Their
00:41:54 national implications and local implications here, they are very well organized and able to
00:41:59 mobilize people. So can you tell us, expand a little bit on what you were hearing about that
00:42:04 at that time, the level of organization and to the extent that you were hearing this and
00:42:12 the interconnectedness or not of what was going on across the country?
00:42:16 That is a critically important intervention by Chief Slowly at the time for a couple of reasons.
00:42:24 First, he's flagging as a very serious concern that locally they are outnumbered.
00:42:34 And he says that it is exceeding their, or he suggests that it is very close to exceeding their current resources,
00:42:43 which is why they had asked for some additional help, including from the RCMP, which by then we would have responded to.
00:42:51 There were a couple of installations prior to the invocation of the act that I think numbered in the hundreds,
00:42:59 somewhere between, you know, 200 at the outset and then eventually getting up to about 500 all told.
00:43:05 There were questions about exactly how those resources were being deployed by the RCMP in conjunction with Ottawa Police Service.
00:43:13 But the real important point is he's saying, we're outnumbered and we need help.
00:43:18 That's what I took from that intervention.
00:43:21 The other thing that he mentioned in that intervention is Coventry.
00:43:30 And through a number of briefings in the lead up to the invocation of the Emergencies Act,
00:43:38 there was a discussion of two different groups that were at play in the blockades.
00:43:42 There was a large group, again, of Canadians who were exercising their lawful right to protest against certain policies by the government.
00:43:50 But then there was another group that had other more extreme objectives that was much more sophisticated and organized.
00:44:00 And it's my recollection that that latter group was interspersed in a number of different locations very tactically,
00:44:07 but that there was a concentration of that latter group at Coventry Road that was made up potentially of individuals who had previously served in either the military or in law enforcement.
00:44:18 And that, to me, raised a concern, a very serious concern, about some of the counter operations that could be run by that group to overwhelm legitimate law enforcement.
00:44:32 And that, I think, is exactly what Chief Slowly is getting at when, you know, if numbers are being reported publicly about how many additional reinforcements are being sent in, then the word could go out to call for more protesters to descend into the nation's capital or, you know, again, quite frankly, to deploy across the country.
00:44:56 And again, I would hasten to add, this was not just about Ottawa.
00:45:01 This was about the entire country, where we would see the levels of protest go up and go down.
00:45:07 And the time that I thought was most dangerous were typically the weekends.
00:45:13 And that's when there was a surge of people who came and descended into the parliamentary precinct.
00:45:22 And that, if I read Chief Slowly Wright, was in part a tactical decision that was being informed by some within the group who had the skills and the experience to overwhelm whatever police resources were available at the time.
00:45:41 Okay, so going back to a few things you said, the first one you mentioned that there were some questions about boots on the ground and how many RCMP officers were being provided.
00:45:50 And we've heard about that, but from your perspective as Minister of Public Safety, what was your understanding of what was going on there and why?
00:45:58 Well, my understanding was that Ottawa Police Service did not have the resources to respond at the time.
00:46:07 And therefore, they were putting out a request for assistance from different levels of government and different levels of law enforcement, including the RCMP.
00:46:16 and that is one of and so my response as minister of public safety is let's get you what you need
00:46:22 let's get you the additional boots on the ground and in dialogue with commissioner the commissioner
00:46:28 of the RCMP we were responsive to that request on more than one occasion deploying additional RCMP
00:46:35 members to to assist to restore public safety here in the nation's capital there was also
00:46:43 other requests including in alberta but we can come back to that well i was uh before we get to
00:46:48 alberta when you say let's get you what you need do you mean let's let's get you what you need from
00:46:52 the rcmp or let's get what you what you need from the opp and then only then from the rcmp i wouldn't
00:46:59 say that there was necessarily that strict sequencing my my job as minister of public safety
00:47:06 was to be responsive to the requests that were coming in from the city of ottawa
00:47:13 vis-a-vis the ottawa police service and so we facilitated those requests they were not you know
00:47:22 they were not necessarily subject to the ontario provincial police responding at the time i wanted
00:47:27 to be as supportive as i could i was very much sympathetic to the plight of the residents in
00:47:35 Ottawa. I was very concerned for their safety and their security. We were beginning to see
00:47:40 counter-protests manifesting because I think at that time residents felt that they had to
00:47:44 take matters into their own hands. That was extremely concerning to me because I thought
00:47:48 that it represented a significant risk of more serious violence as a result of frustration and
00:47:55 fatigue and we were seeing an abundance of expressions of that in reporting and on social
00:48:01 media so i wanted to be as supportive as i could to the city of ottawa and to the ottawa police
00:48:06 service and chief slowly i think rightfully was was flagging his concerns about resource capacity
00:48:13 and potential counter operations that were being run by um the blockade and the occupation so
00:48:19 getting back to that last concern about the uh the counter operations the action the reaction
00:48:26 Were you concerned then that this could spiral into something where police resources would actually be overwhelmed and stretched beyond capacity across the country?
00:48:38 Was that the nature of your concern, or was it in specific areas there wouldn't be enough available locally?
00:48:44 Or was it a broader concern than that, or was it just the specific instances?
00:48:49 It was a broader concern that was national in scale.
00:48:53 At the end of the day, in my opinion, this was an illegal protest that was national in scale, that occurred at critical infrastructure, including a number of borders and ports of entry, including at legislative assemblies, including here at the seat of the federal government.
00:49:15 and the initial responses of law enforcement to get the situation back under control
00:49:22 were clearly overwhelmed and as a result of that the consequences were devastating to people to
00:49:30 the economy to our international relations and so at all times I was assessing not any one of
00:49:39 these events in isolation, but rather the situation in its totality. And when looking at
00:49:46 the timing of it and the concurrence of all of these events in the same short critical period
00:49:52 of time, the types of targets where the individuals were showing up for the express purposes of
00:50:00 creating a disruption and undermining public safety, and the type of tactics that were being
00:50:06 used which was through sheer size and force of people of vehicles and behavior that this was a
00:50:14 very singular and unprecedented event so being able to assess all of that in its totality
00:50:21 was very much part of my job to restore public safety and to maintain it did you have any actual
00:50:27 evidence of what chief slowly is referring to here that interconnectedness or was this this
00:50:32 more you saw correlation or chief slowly is here but you agreed with it that one one action then
00:50:39 seems to have a counter reaction or provoke a response amongst protesters nationwide but did
00:50:45 that come from evidence or did that come from essentially observation it it came from observation
00:50:50 uh what what i was seeing with my own eyes on the ground uh was that when police tried to enforce
00:50:57 the law they were overwhelmed they were swarmed there were reports about there being threats made
00:51:03 to them as they tried to do their job and they were clearly identifiable in uniform you know
00:51:09 indicating that it was time to go home and these were not just interactions i mean they ultimately
00:51:15 did lead to hundreds of criminal charges being laid including assault peace officer which is a
00:51:21 very serious offense to be charged with this was all a counter reaction to the reaction of law
00:51:28 enforcement to try and restore public safety on the ground and it wasn't just in ottawa it was at
00:51:34 ports of entry in uh at the pacific highway in surrey in british columbia where again there
00:51:41 were very clear statements by canada border service agents as well as local law enforcement
00:51:46 there through the RCMP, that it was time to go home. And in the face of those instructions,
00:51:52 not only did members, participants double down, I mean, there's a very notorious incident
00:52:00 involving a large vehicle that was painted with military fatigues that tried to crash
00:52:05 a barrier. To me, that poses a serious threat of violence. And I think we'll come to Coutts,
00:52:13 Alberta which was again a very and arguably the most egregious risk that coincided with the
00:52:19 blockade but I was at all times both using the observations that I was making for myself as well
00:52:26 as the advice and the intelligence that I was receiving in my capacity as Minister of Public
00:52:31 Safety. Okay and we will come there but first I'm going to take you three now to sort of close the
00:52:37 loop. Sorry, you can take this one down, please, Mr. Clare. So, can you just pull up quickly
00:52:49 SSM.CAN.NS C402676. This is the third and last tripartite, and there's just a couple
00:53:00 of things i want to highlight here minister i'll ask you about which is sorry here we go
00:53:08 let's just scroll down a little bit more thanks latest from rcmp okay
00:53:16 so towards the middle of that paragraph you say phase has moved beyond inconvenience or
00:53:23 disruption so this is now february 10th they have moved to disrupting the economy we are having
00:53:29 very intentional conversations with the province about how confident they are around enforcement,
00:53:35 the ability to take appropriate action quickly and decisively, whether in Ottawa, Windsor, Sarnia,
00:53:40 etc., spoke to Minister Jones. It was a focused conversation, and I'm looking forward to hearing
00:53:46 back from her on what OPP can do to assist you. Okay, so I'll take it from that, and we'll get
00:53:51 back to the conversation with Minister Jones, but Minister Jones was not at the third and last
00:53:57 tripartite here is that correct that's correct okay um so thank you mr clerk so i'm just going
00:54:04 to try and put together the chronology of what happened here and i'll take you back to february
00:54:09 5th ssm.can407854
00:54:33 this is a text exchange between you and minister david lametti
00:54:38 um just scroll down a little bit please mr clerk not sure what you're referring to you say uh you
00:54:44 were perfect today thanks so were you buddy then should i so the blue is a little collegial
00:54:49 support at a very stressful time slash bromance okay um i think he might he might resent that
00:54:56 suggestion so were you buddy should i call downy you've spoken to sylvia downy there would be a
00:55:02 a reference to Doug Downey? That's correct. Okay. Can you tell us who, just for the record,
00:55:09 can you tell us who Doug Downey is and why Minister Lametti might be calling him?
00:55:12 He's the Attorney General of Ontario. He's Minister Lametti's provincial counterpart.
00:55:16 Okay. And so you have spoken to Sylvia, he says, and you say, I have spoken with Sylvia. You should
00:55:23 call Downey. We need them in the right space to respond to any RFA for OPP assistance. And then
00:55:29 And Minister Lamedi replies, spoke to Doug Downey, needs slowly to be quick, quick, quick.
00:55:36 Can you tell us why would Minister Lamedi be calling Doug Downey about this?
00:55:41 So you're speaking to your counterpart, he's speaking to his, and what capacity would that be?
00:55:46 Well, again, I mean, you're asking me to interpret or infer why Minister Lamedi has reached out to Doug Downey.
00:55:55 The best answer that I can offer is I believe he is reaching out to a provincial counterpart to understand what Ontario's response is to the situation, not only in Ottawa, but elsewhere, including in Windsor at the Ambassador Bridge.
00:56:11 And by then, the blockade was causing significant interruption to the economy.
00:56:17 Again, thousands of people were temporarily laid off.
00:56:20 Businesses were impacted in the auto manufacturing sector.
00:56:23 So I think he's trying to gain some understanding from the Attorney General of Ontario about perhaps what advice he is offering to the Ontario government.
00:56:34 Again, I'm drawing some inferences here, but I think it's a combination of that.
00:56:39 But I think more broadly, just to keep lines of communication strong between the federal government and the government of Ontario.
00:56:45 Okay, so you actually asked him to call Downey. So do you have a recollection of why or is it essentially what you just told us?
00:56:53 Um, yeah, no, actually, there it is right there. Yes. So I would say that was my thinking at the
00:57:00 time was to, to try and keep lines of communication open, and to be sure that, that we had some
00:57:07 understanding about, you know, what advice may be provided to the Ontario government.
00:57:13 Okay, thank you, Mr. Clerk. Next document is ONT401141. So, so I understand that there was a call
00:57:21 that took place between you and Minister Jones on the 7th.
00:57:26 And in that earlier text exchange,
00:57:27 you seem to refer to an earlier call before the 5th.
00:57:31 I don't know if you...
00:57:31 Do you have any recollection of that one?
00:57:35 I'm sorry, which document am I looking at here?
00:57:38 Sorry, yeah, that's my fault.
00:57:40 The last document, the text exchange with Minister Lamedi,
00:57:43 you say, I have spoken with Sylvia,
00:57:45 and that appears to be on the 5th.
00:57:47 So do you remember a conversation prior to the 5th?
00:57:51 um in the context of the blockades uh i not off the top of my head okay this moment well we know
00:57:58 that one happened on the 7th and uh this this document is minister jones's notation of that call
00:58:05 and she says uh so she's talking to you marco medicino jim watson wants an interlocutor i think
00:58:13 that may have mean interlocutor but i'm not sure um wellington will be uh fast and jurisdiction
00:58:21 fpt ftp table to support the city 1500 obp 38 kitchener um can you tell so so the interlocutor
00:58:31 that is that a reference to an interlocutor was that part of the discussion you were having um
00:58:37 you know again if if if we could have the document just scroll back up to the top
00:58:41 i just want to february the 7th jim watson watson i i agree with you i think that
00:58:49 the word there may be misspelled and is referring to an interlocutor
00:58:56 and you know beyond that i i i couldn't say much more about that particular uh note but i did have
00:59:05 a conversation with uh minister jones yes you did and uh around that around that time or shortly
00:59:12 thereafter okay and we're gonna get to a report of what was said in that conversation as well
00:59:18 but before we get there i want to just go through a little bit um the call you subsequently had with
00:59:25 uh minister minister with premier ford because at this point so can you take us through that
00:59:30 minister jones doesn't you have a conversation on the seventh actually why don't we go there now
00:59:35 So that conversation is reported in a text exchange.
00:59:40 Can you pull up, Mr. Clerk, ssm.nsc.can403127?
00:59:50 So while that's getting pulled up, this is a text exchange on February 11th between Samantha Coyle, who you've told us is a PMO staffer, Mike Jones, your chief of staff, and Seda Astrovis.
01:00:01 and uh so smith says thanks guys long day okay so writing here is mike jones your chief of staff
01:00:10 and oh no i'm sorry this is i this is sam kalil i think writing here she says
01:00:17 hey so on trilateral meeting got it wrong again it's zeta writing so ms astro says hey so on
01:00:24 trilateral meeting sam i don't know what you think but i really think we need jones at the table
01:00:29 perhaps your boss can push again your boss there so mike jones he's talking about you
01:00:35 he says by jones i assume you mean ontario and can have my boss reach out again but the last
01:00:42 call got pretty frosty at the end when he was saying we need the province to get back to us 0.97
01:00:47 with their plan quote unquote i don't take edicts from you you're not my fucking boss uh scroll down 0.99
01:00:54 again. Yes, obviously not you. She said that. Does that accord with your recollection of the 0.99
01:01:01 conversation you had with Minister Jones? There was definitely some colorful vernacular
01:01:06 towards the end of that call. I'm happy to say that both Minister and Jones and I still enjoy
01:01:13 a very productive and positive rapport. But the real thrust of the call was to engage Minister
01:01:25 Jones to understand exactly where her thinking and where the Government of Ontario's thinking
01:01:31 was at in responding to the requests of Ottawa Police Service to get additional resources,
01:01:37 And more broadly speaking, to restore public safety on the ground.
01:01:42 And, you know, I think certainly by the end of the call, it was quite clear that the inability
01:01:53 of law enforcement using existing authorities to restore public safety on the ground was
01:02:00 of increasing concern to me in my capacity as the Minister of Public Safety, as well as
01:02:07 the federal government. And we wanted to be sure that Ontario was exercising all of its capacity
01:02:15 to support not only Ottawa, but other communities as well in this province, including Windsor. So
01:02:23 it was an important engagement. It was obviously a very stressful time. And, you know, I
01:02:30 I think that we could all be forgiven for some rather blunt language.
01:02:35 I'm sure, you know, we've all heard it in various interactions.
01:02:39 But having those lines of communications open was critically important at that time.
01:02:45 Okay. So regardless of the language, it's fair to say you were encountering some resistance
01:02:49 in obviously coming to the tripartite table, and it was described as a call that didn't go well.
01:02:55 And we know that on the 9th, you spoke directly with Premier Ford.
01:02:59 So we can take that document down, please, and we'll pull up the readout of your call from Premier Ford, which is ssm.can.nsc402832.
01:03:11 How did that call arise? Did you call Premier Ford? Did he call you? Tell us how that happened.
01:03:17 The Premier called me. And by then, again, it's important to place the timing and the
01:03:26 chronology of this call into the broader context. This would have been February 9th, so we're now
01:03:32 beyond a week into the occupation here in the nation's capital and with significant interruptions
01:03:41 at critical infrastructure and borders, including at the Ambassador Bridge in Windsor, at the
01:03:47 Windsor-Detroit border, which quite clearly is in the province of Ontario.
01:03:53 The Premier called me to, I think, express a few things, and the readout is there on
01:03:58 the screen, but one, I think he was calling to keep lines of communication open with the
01:04:03 federal government.
01:04:04 Two, he was indicating to me that his chief public health officer was going to be going
01:04:10 out in the very short term to communicate the end of vaccine passports and the end of mandates.
01:04:18 But he also was very supportive and said that he was prepared to stand with the Prime Minister,
01:04:26 which I took as a, again, as a very constructive suggestion to show unity across different levels
01:04:33 of government responding to what was then a very urgent state of crisis and emergency,
01:04:38 and having that demonstration of solidarity I thought would reassure Ontarians and Canadians.
01:04:46 I also did say to him that I would relay what I interpreted to be a bit of a nudge
01:04:54 by Premier Ford around the federal government's posture around pandemic policy to the Prime
01:05:01 Minister, more broadly just the fact that the call had occurred. And I did take the opportunity to
01:05:08 expressed two really important things. First, I was really concerned about restoring public safety
01:05:17 at critical infrastructure, including the Ambassador Bridge. And I also said that I was
01:05:23 concerned that even if there was an announcement around a change in pandemic policy, that they may
01:05:28 not leave. I think in the end, that proved to be true. And then finally, I said that we needed
01:05:36 sylvia and there i'm referring to minister jones at the table and i'm referring to the tripart table
01:05:41 and i ask that the premier instructor to be there okay um so i think you've taken us through pretty
01:05:47 much all of that um on the point of stand with the pm we'll just pull up another document um which is
01:05:56 ssm.nsc.can402952 so this is a a text while it's being pulled up to katie telford who's
01:06:10 the prime minister chief of staff you send her a text sort of reporting on this call with premier
01:06:16 ford and uh did i get the wrong document number it appears that i did
01:06:26 um okay you know what i'll just i'll read it to you we can we can look for the document number
01:06:33 in a second it it says just got called from ford they're pivoting he will announce they're lifting
01:06:42 passports possibly more measures said he would stand with the p.m said i and then he said said
01:06:50 i would relay i said the situation at ambassador bridge is serious it's hurting working families
01:06:55 killing jobs. So by stand with the PM, you said, I didn't quite catch what you said you thought
01:07:02 that meant. Stand beside the PM and... My interpretation from Premier Ford saying that
01:07:10 to me directly was that he wanted to show solidarity with the federal government in
01:07:16 responding to this emergency. And I thought that that was a constructive suggestion because it
01:07:23 would reassure Ontarians and Canadians more broadly that different levels of government
01:07:28 were working together to restore public safety, to keep people safe, which was my job.
01:07:34 And my request to him to have Minister Jones attend the tripartite was an effort to show
01:07:41 that alignment at all levels of government, not only from Premier to the Prime Minister,
01:07:45 but equally from at the ministerial level in the portfolio of public safety, because
01:07:51 by being at the same table at the same time, we could really troubleshoot issues together,
01:07:56 including, again, some of the operational challenges that police were having, again,
01:08:01 not only in Ottawa, but right across the province, and equally, some of the jurisdictional complexities,
01:08:07 and whether or not there were any other measures or tools that we could offer
01:08:10 from the elected side of the government to police if it were necessary.
01:08:14 Okay. For the record, Mr. Clerk, the document number is ssm.nsc.can402952. So what I wanted to ask you, Minister Mendicino, was did you sense that that, or was your interpretation that standing with the PM was any way tied to what you described, I think, as a gentle nudge to ease public health measures?
01:08:37 No, it wasn't. And again, I think we saw subsequently in the lead up to the invocation of the Emergencies Act that following the first minister's meeting that the Prime Minister and Premier Ford were very much on the same page about the necessity of having to invoke the Emergencies Act.
01:08:55 And at that point, the government had not yet taken a final decision with regards to pandemic policy and in specific regards to vaccines.
01:09:05 Okay. The last point I want to ask you about on all of this is to get your reaction to something we heard from Mr. Mario Di Tommaso when he testified, which was, and I'll paraphrase what he was saying, but essentially part of his thinking or his explanation of why Ontario was reluctant to participate in the tripartites is that, insofar as these were a forum to discuss policing resources,
01:09:33 Ontario, governmental officials shouldn't be participating in that because that's a law enforcement matter.
01:09:39 The question of deploying police resources is something for law enforcement, not for governmental officials.
01:09:46 What's your take on that in the context of what we'd raised earlier about the lines of operational dependence of the police?
01:09:55 Yeah, here again, this is a very important question.
01:09:58 First, I can't speak for the Deputy Minister of Public Safety or the Solicitor General in Ontario,
01:10:05 but from where I sat, the Premier of Ontario actually showed very important leadership in the early days of the blockade,
01:10:16 going out publicly, saying that this no longer was a lawful protest and that people needed to go home.
01:10:26 And that was a signal, I think, to any fair-minded individual who abides by the law that the situation was no longer safe.
01:10:36 I would also point out that, you know, in the context of the discussion around operational independence, and I've obviously given this a fair bit of reflection since the occupation, and I did touch on it a little bit earlier, that there are important boundaries that should not be crossed by elected officials.
01:10:58 and for good reason. We do want to safeguard against the politicization or making partisan
01:11:08 important and independent decisions which are made by law enforcement and the prosecution
01:11:17 services around the country so that we can preserve the integrity of the administration
01:11:24 of justice. And at all times, we adhere to that principle in the federal government.
01:11:31 That having been said, there does need to be a dialogue and there is a dialogue between police
01:11:38 and the elected branch of government when it comes to providing additional resources and tools. And
01:11:46 I can offer a number of, you know, very concrete examples, not only in the general, but in the
01:11:52 specific context of our response to the blockade. So if I could, when I received a call at the
01:11:59 beginning of February from the Premier of Alberta, the then Premier of Alberta, Jason Kenney,
01:12:06 one of the concerns that he'd expressed is that he and Alberta did not possess either the resources
01:12:11 or the tools to clear the blockade at Coutts, which had mobilized pretty much since the end
01:12:18 of January or beginning of February. And as part of the federal government's response to that
01:12:25 situation, I authorized under Article 9.3 of the existing police services agreement between Canada
01:12:32 and Albert, the deployment of additional police resources. That is a very concrete example of how
01:12:39 we have customized through convention the relationship between the elected government
01:12:45 and the authorities that are exercised through this office, the Minister of Public Safety,
01:12:50 in response to the operational decisions that are taken by police to restore public safety.
01:12:57 I would say, more broadly, there are other important examples where elected representatives
01:13:04 that occupy this office are responsive to the needs of police around tools,
01:13:10 You know, be it in, you know, responding to either this situation or others.
01:13:17 And obviously there are the priorities around the foreign deployment of RCMP in different countries, for example, in Ukraine, which are priorities which can be set by the elected branch of government where conventional police forces are deployed.
01:13:33 So I guess my broader point is that both in the specific context of the blockade, but even beyond in the general, there does need to be a dialogue.
01:13:44 And there was a dialogue between the elected branch of government and the police who were exercising operational independence at every time to ensure that we could get them the additional resources that they need in the parts of the country where they needed it.
01:13:59 And again, I emphasize and stress this was not just an isolated incident, that these events were occurring across the country so that we could restore public safety.
01:14:11 When the RCMP officials testified last week, so Deputy Commissioner Duhame and Commissioner Brenda Leckie testified, there's a few things that came out of their evidence that I want your reaction on.
01:14:24 One of them is that I believe Commissioner Luckey said that there were times, or I think it was Deputy Commissioner Duhaime,
01:14:35 said that there were times where it may have felt to him like officials may have stepped a little over that line, that line between church and state.
01:14:43 Now, I think they did say specifically, I remember, I recall Commissioner Luckey saying that she never felt pressured by her ministers, you and Minister Blair.
01:14:52 She did say that at some point you sort of had to educate or educate it.
01:15:00 And she didn't point to any sort of instance where it was necessary,
01:15:03 but she said you educated and it fell to you essentially to educate the rest of Cabinet, I think.
01:15:08 It was the February 10th IRG on where that line was and the importance of operational dependence.
01:15:15 Do you recall that?
01:15:16 I do. And I wanted to be sure that as colleagues around the cabinet table were expressing the same concerns that I had, that others had about the ineffectiveness of existing authorities and resources to restore public safety up to that point, and we are approaching now two weeks into the blockade, that nevertheless, we should not violate the principle of operational independence.
01:15:41 Because, again, just situate yourself in our shoes for just a moment.
01:15:47 Our paramount concern is restoring public safety.
01:15:52 And by then, there were countless reports of the very dire consequences that had been visited upon Canadians.
01:16:00 But that could never be a license for assuming the roles and the responsibilities of police
01:16:08 when it came to making the tactical and operational decisions around how to restore public safety.
01:16:14 So it was important to strike a balance between respecting that principle,
01:16:20 but also fulfilling my role specifically in holding the RCMP accountable
01:16:27 for their role in restoring public safety,
01:16:31 and more broadly, the government's role in understanding why it was
01:16:37 that despite existing authorities and resources, we could not achieve the goal of getting a law
01:16:46 and order back on the ground. And when I look back now, and I ask myself why it was in the
01:16:54 perception of the commissioner that she felt that some, not all, were coming up to the line,
01:17:00 it is because of the unique and singular nature of this public order emergency.
01:17:08 It was the fact that the scale of this was national.
01:17:12 It was the fact that what sparked this movement in the opinion of the government
01:17:16 was an expressly stated political objective that at times was expressed in violent terms
01:17:24 that led to the entrenchment of a significant number of individuals to ignore the direction
01:17:32 of law enforcement at the risk and at the peril of Canadians. It was the challenges that we had
01:17:39 in government around having the appropriate intelligence tools to understand how those
01:17:46 initially stated objectives could pull in people from many different walks of life with different
01:17:52 backgrounds and different grievances and coalesce them around something that so significantly and
01:17:59 persistently caused significant interruption to public safety, to the economy, to our international
01:18:05 relations. And all of that was, I think, part of the reason why people were really trying to probe
01:18:13 and understand that despite the fact that you had a criminal code, you couldn't use it. Despite the
01:18:19 fact that you had provincial statutes around the Highway Traffic Act, they couldn't be effectively
01:18:24 used, despite the fact that we had tow trucks, you had many tow trucks, that they could not be
01:18:29 deployed to clear the blockades. And all of that was leading to an escalation of the risk and the
01:18:38 threat of serious violence as time went on. And that is why I think that the commissioner both
01:18:44 signaled her concern, but also appreciated my intervention, that we still had to be respectful
01:18:50 of that principle of operational independence. Okay. So just to go back on that a little bit,
01:18:55 I mean, what we've heard over the weeks that we've been here at the commission,
01:19:01 there's what could be described as, quote unquote, pressure all over the record. So there's a real
01:19:05 sense of urgency from politicians and from officials. We need to do something about this
01:19:11 now we need to do this quick quick quick we need to do this has to end etc etc and how does that
01:19:18 not constitute can you explain how that does not constitute pressure on law enforcement to do
01:19:23 something to clear up this protest in whatever way they can well to be clear there was pressure
01:19:29 on all of us i mean this was an extremely tense situation uh so i mean i think that is just a
01:19:35 natural reaction to all of the events that were occurring but the reason why i'm confident and
01:19:40 the reason why i believe commissioner lucky testified that we didn't violate the principle
01:19:45 of operational independence is because at no time um were we instructing police on how to do their
01:19:52 job on the ground so at no time were we were we saying you must arrest uh people under the
01:19:58 following provisions of the law you must prosecute these people um you know in it to the fullest
01:20:06 extent you must um you know to the granularity of detail deploy you know five people here and
01:20:14 100 people there and to prioritize all these operations we at all times steered clear of
01:20:21 that zone which would have been a violation of the principle of operational independence
01:20:26 and that's why i think i'm you know very confident that uh that that we didn't cross that boundary
01:20:33 okay so the line is politicians and the government has a role to play in in expressing a desire let's
01:20:41 say to or the need to solve a situation but not in telling the police how to do it that's right
01:20:47 you don't want me as an elected official putting on a badge or a uniform uh and going out there
01:20:52 and uh and doing the job that that police are there to do that's not my role that's not my
01:20:58 responsibility however it is my responsibility as minister of public safety to be accountable
01:21:04 to Canadians when it comes to equipping police with the tools and the resources that they need
01:21:12 to restore public safety and by then on February 10th we did not have public safety in the nation's
01:21:19 capital and at other critical infrastructure across the country and so because of that we
01:21:24 really wanted to understand why existing authorities were ineffective at that point and
01:21:31 that was the balance that we struck another issue that we we've heard a lot about over the last few
01:21:37 weeks is the idea the notion of um one could put it as negotiating or we put it as engaging with
01:21:46 demonstrators or protesters um so we've heard that that was an issue that was discussed is there a
01:21:53 way to sort of to to end this or to ameliorate this um by engaging directly with demonstrators
01:22:02 there's reference in the in sylvia jones's notes of the february 7th call to having an
01:22:07 interlocutor um engage with the protesters and we've heard a lot about uh an effort by your
01:22:15 deputy minister deputy minister rob stewart uh around the 10th 11th of of um february to create
01:22:24 what's become known as the engagement proposal so can you tell us a little bit from your perspective
01:22:32 how those engagement efforts if i can put it that way and eventually the engagement proposal
01:22:37 uh came to be and uh and evolved engagement was always an option and i had articulated
01:22:46 on a number of occasions that law enforcement should be the last resort um and and you saw
01:22:53 from one of the exhibits that you had put to me a little bit earlier in my testimony this morning
01:22:57 that i had turned my mind right at the very beginning of the briefings that it was important
01:23:04 for uh there to be some engagement with uh those who were participating in uh the convoy and the
01:23:11 blockade and wanted to be briefed on that by law enforcement who i thought was the most appropriate
01:23:17 actor in this um in this context uh to be engaging with um given that you know in my estimation that
01:23:25 it was operational and tactical that didn't mean that um that i wasn't still having conversations
01:23:31 with individuals outside of law enforcement about an engagement proposal,
01:23:36 but there was early contemplation and reflection about having an engagement strategy.
01:23:43 I would say beyond that, there were conversations between the Prime Minister and myself
01:23:49 about searching for a suitable mediator or interlocutor,
01:23:54 someone who would have had the experience to de-escalate and resolve situations that are
01:24:01 complex. And beyond that, by the time we got to the ERG, there was a report that was given by
01:24:10 Deputy Minister Stewart about information that he had gleaned from conversations that he was having
01:24:16 with the Ontario government and the OPP around the intelligence of what the group was constituted of
01:24:23 in terms of adherence to, you know, ideology, the desire to, you know, double down and hold
01:24:30 the line and et cetera, and all that versus everybody else who might have just been there
01:24:35 to express another point of view. And so as a result of that report that he offered at the ERG,
01:24:42 there were taskings that were listed by the clerk of the Privy Council at the end of that meeting,
01:24:48 one of which was to continue to develop a potential engagement strategy.
01:24:53 And so that's what the deputy minister set about to do.
01:24:57 And I know that there was some additional work on that front.
01:25:01 Okay, so you knew that this was, you were aware that this was being worked on by your deputy minister?
01:25:06 Yes.
01:25:07 Okay.
01:25:08 Mr. Clerk, can we pull up ssm.nsc.can40's 2958?
01:25:18 so minister this is a text from you to katie telford the pm's chief of staff um the date of
01:25:38 it is february 11th it's at 6 49 p.m so just to situate you in time the erg happens on february
01:25:45 10th uh there's no org i think on on february 11th um so you write to ms telford hey there
01:25:53 we got some very last minute and thin paper tonight on an engagement strategy from my dm
01:25:58 who apparently socialized it with p pco rcmp commissioner and the ontario government and not me
01:26:06 we only found out about it during a call tonight i placed to him the dm's outreach during the day to
01:26:12 the Ontario government on this engagement proposal resulted in the Ontario Deputy Solicitor General
01:26:18 sending my DM a draft letter addressed to unnamed protesters proposing engagement,
01:26:23 which would be co-signed by Ontario government and an unnamed official from the federal government.
01:26:28 It's unclear whether PCO, RCMP, or Ontario government has given their support to the
01:26:35 engagement proposal. Flagging as a concern and inconsistent with good info flow, I've addressed
01:26:41 with him wanted you to know i will be replying to dm and letting him know that there's some
01:26:46 redactions and the last thing you say is sorry but had to let you know can you explain to us
01:26:53 what you were expressing in this text i'm expressing a concern that the deputy minister
01:26:59 had socialized with a different level of government and engagement proposal that i
01:27:04 would have wanted to have some input into prior to that and you know again admittedly
01:27:13 in this particular moment everybody is working extremely hard long hours trying to quickly
01:27:20 fulfill the tasks that had been accomplished or i fulfill the tasks that had been assigned i beg
01:27:26 your pardon at the end of the last erg and so i wanted to be sure that we were together
01:27:32 thinking through not only the engagement proposal, but also mitigating and thinking through
01:27:41 some of the very real and practical considerations that had to be woven into the strategy
01:27:49 if one was going to be deployed.
01:27:51 For example, and I pose some of those questions, who are we going to send this to?
01:27:57 Where is it going to take place?
01:28:00 How can we be sure that if we do engage in it, that we can maintain public safety?
01:28:05 Because the situation was extremely volatile and very tense.
01:28:10 And among the concerns were whether or not there was actually any cohesive structure to the occupation at that moment in time.
01:28:22 And so understanding who we were sitting down with was critically important.
01:28:26 and so I just was I wanted to be sure that that that Ms. Telford was aware of that because
01:28:35 ultimately when we go back to cabinet I am responsible and accountable for my department
01:28:40 including the deputy minister and wanted to be sure that I was equipped to answer any questions
01:28:47 from colleagues about what this engagement proposal would look like so you know I say
01:28:51 again in fairness to everybody this was an exceedingly difficult and challenging time and
01:28:57 I know that that Deputy Minister Stewart was doing his level best to fulfill a task that had been
01:29:04 assigned to him after the ERG and was I think trying to action it and and get some traction
01:29:11 at the Ontario level of government and we did have a good conversation about that and you know
01:29:16 Subsequently, I think as we saw on February 14th, that despite the efforts of the City of Ottawa to engage some of the members of the occupation here in Ottawa,
01:29:29 that it ultimately unraveled, I think, for many of the reasons and concerns I previously articulated.
01:29:34 Okay, so your concern, if I understand it then, is not with the engagement proposal itself, with the work that was being done, it's the information flow?
01:29:44 Correct.
01:29:44 and the fact specifically that it had been uh socialized as you put it with the ontario government
01:29:51 without you knowing about it at that at that particular moment in time and just wanted to be
01:29:55 sure that i had a line of sight and understood it and also that it was part of a broader effort
01:30:02 by both me and others from within the government to explore engagement and as i pointed out
01:30:06 seeking and briefings and information from police right from the beginning about how we were engaging
01:30:14 with members of the occupation equally the conversations that i had with the prime minister
01:30:19 around finding potentially a mediator to de-escalate so we could avoid law enforcement
01:30:26 as much as possible and you know ultimately this engagement proposal as well it was
01:30:31 all a suite of things that we were doing together uh to to really try to restore public safety as
01:30:38 quickly as we could i believe deputy minister stewart's evidence was that he he hadn't
01:30:45 socialized it with uh mr de tomaso but with commissioner korea so would that change your
01:30:51 view at all as to as to whether that engagement was appropriate um i i'm not sure i i i think
01:31:02 the the the broader concern was just making sure that i could stay up to speed
01:31:06 um and recognizing again the pressures on everybody to go about and complete these taskings
01:31:13 um i just wanted to be sure um both me and and my staff had an opportunity to contribute
01:31:20 uh to the idea before it got um um before it was shared with other not only other branches
01:31:28 of government but as you pointed out other branches of law enforcement and i wanted to
01:31:32 be sure we were really um you know staying on the same page but it was it was an exceedingly
01:31:39 difficult time in fairness to uh to the deputy minister everything was happening very quickly
01:31:44 there's no doubt about that um the other the reason i asked you whether you were concerned
01:31:50 about the the proposal itself is because one of the one of the bits of evidence we've heard
01:31:56 is that commissioner lucky and the rcmp may have had some concerns about it or uh about the proposal
01:32:01 in the sense that it may cross the line between church and state.
01:32:05 So again, we're back to this issue of police independence, operational independence.
01:32:10 And I'd like you to speak for a moment, if you could, about how the idea of where does political negotiation fall into that piece?
01:32:19 And just for a little to situate you in background, what we know now is that there were different lines of potential engagement going on almost simultaneously.
01:32:30 There was an attempt at engagement in Windsor, there was an attempt on the part of Mayor Watson to corral trucks up onto Wellington Street and get them off the residential streets where they were disturbing the residents on those streets.
01:32:47 and then there was the federal government's engagement proposal so we have these different
01:32:51 lines going at the same time um and that could arguably at least be put as something that makes
01:32:57 it difficult for law enforcement to do their job um what's your reaction to that yeah i i would
01:33:03 agree with you i i think it was extremely difficult for law enforcement to figure out how to engage
01:33:12 in a constructive way with the occupation and the blockades not only here in ottawa but across the
01:33:18 country i know from the early days that members of police liaison units these are individuals
01:33:26 within law enforcement who have very specific expertise in engaging with people who protest
01:33:35 to sort of set the boundaries of what just just to be sure that everybody can be safe
01:33:42 um so here's here's what we can all sort of agree to and i think that there as you've heard
01:33:48 previously there was some effort to do that certainly at the local level here in ottawa
01:33:53 but to come back to what i think that like the core of your question is you are absolutely right
01:33:59 that it becomes a lot trickier and more complex once elected officials start to penetrate into
01:34:09 the terms and the conditions by which you negotiate a disengagement of the blockades
01:34:16 and the occupation if it involves let's say you know the moving of vehicles the moving of people
01:34:23 the moving of police officers, all of that I would submit is much more within the operational domain
01:34:31 and by extension independence of police, which was one of the concerns that I had in navigating this
01:34:40 appropriately. So that was, I think, part of what I was getting at in my text to Ms. Telford was just
01:34:45 I wanted to be able to think that through with everybody, and especially if we were going to be
01:34:51 sharing it with other levels of law enforcement so that we were respectful of those principles
01:34:57 of operational independence as well.
01:34:59 Okay, I now want to ask you, turning to, we know the engagement proposal didn't go anywhere
01:35:05 in the end, and chronologically, we're now getting to the crux of events and when the
01:35:12 Emergencies Act was actually decided on.
01:35:15 So I know it wasn't decided necessarily on the 13th, but that's the day we're going to
01:35:19 talk about.
01:35:20 um there's some evidence uh and i'll ask you if you you know about this first um so shortly before
01:35:30 we understand there was a an erg irg meeting the afternoon of the 13th followed by a meeting of the
01:35:36 full cabinet uh in the evening at 8 30 p.m the commission has seen evidence shortly before that
01:35:43 8 30 meeting uh commissioner lucky sent an email let's get the email up uh it is ssm.nsc.can402280
01:35:57 so
01:36:11 this is an email the time stamp on it is it's just shortly before eight o'clock once you do
01:36:16 the greenwich mean time adjustment this is your chief of staff mike jones sending this to you
01:36:21 and copy to deputy minister stewart evening minister responses from the commissioner below
01:36:28 uh and this is we've seen this already in the inquiry so i won't go through it at length but
01:36:32 there's a sort of a wish list or these are these are tools that could be effective and then at the
01:36:38 very bottom of the email there commissioner lucky says this said i am of the view that we have not
01:36:47 yet exhausted all available tools that are already available through the existing legislation
01:36:53 there are instances where charges could be laid under existing authorities for various criminal
01:36:58 code offenses occurring right now in the context of the protest the ontario provincial emergencies
01:37:04 act just enacted we skipped that in the narrative but we know that happened february 11th will also
01:37:10 help in providing additional deterrent tools to our existing toolbox so my first question mr
01:37:16 mendicino is did you see this before the cabinet meeting i don't recall exactly when i would have
01:37:22 seen it um this as you pointed out was sent just prior to the commencement of of the cabinet
01:37:30 meeting i will say to you importantly that a couple things first the commissioner did not
01:37:36 express that opinion to me at any time directly and um and i actually spoke to the commissioner
01:37:43 earlier that day on February 13th. And while she did not at all address that last point that you
01:37:53 raised in the email, she did call me and only me, this was a conversation between just her and I,
01:38:00 to be clear, to express her very grave concerns about the situation in Coutts. And she underlined
01:38:09 for me that the situation in Coutts involved a hardened cell of individuals who were armed to
01:38:18 the teeth with lethal firearms, who possessed a willingness to go down with the cause.
01:38:27 And the reason why this was such a sensitive conversation was that we had RCMP
01:38:33 undercover personnel deployed in the field and she was justifiably concerned that there not be
01:38:41 any leak of this information because lives literally hung in the balance and for me this
01:38:45 represented far and away the most serious and urgent moment in the in the blockade to this
01:38:54 point in time and so it also spoke volumes to me about the commissioner's state of mind which was
01:39:01 that we were potentially seeing an escalation of serious violence with the situation in Coutts.
01:39:10 And it certainly, I think, was in the broader context of the preponderance of the advice that
01:39:18 we were getting from the commissioner at that time as a result of conversations not only in
01:39:23 the ergs about where there were gaps in authorities, in existing authorities to return public safety
01:39:32 to the ground, could not have drawn any other inference that she was supportive, as she later
01:39:40 expressed that she was, of the decision to invoke the Emergencies Act. This was a singular moment
01:39:46 for me in my mind. And it was so urgent that I said to her, well, look, I can't just keep this
01:39:55 information to myself at a minimum. I have to be able to share it with the prime minister,
01:39:59 which I then subsequently took steps to do. Shortly thereafter, I reached out to Ms.
01:40:05 Helford. Sorry, just to be clear, which information are you talking about?
01:40:09 About Coutts and about the potential for gun violence and for the loss of life and the fact
01:40:15 that there were RCMP personnel that were in the field, and all of this occurring literally within
01:40:21 hours, not even days, of the invocation to the Emergencies Act, I was extremely concerned that
01:40:28 this had reached a new height of both urgency and emergency, and so I felt I had a responsibility
01:40:33 to let, at a minimum, the Prime Minister know and his staff know, while respecting the operational
01:40:41 sensitivity at the most delicate levels to protect the people on the ground. And so I did that. I
01:40:48 spoke to Ms. Telford afterwards, where I conveyed to her both the best information that I had at
01:40:55 the time around COOTS, and asked her to keep this, to respect, in effect, the Commissioner's
01:41:03 request that we treat this information with the utmost sensitivity, so that we could ensure that
01:41:10 we were keeping people safe but this was this was a threshold moment for me there's no doubt about
01:41:16 it and that was on you had that conversation on the afternoon of the 13th that was the same day
01:41:21 yes okay so just to recap a little bit you didn't see this email from commissioner lucky before the
01:41:28 cabinet meeting again i i i i'm trying very much to reconstruct the the sequence of events things
01:41:36 moved very very quickly it literally came in inside of a half hour of the commencement so
01:41:41 i don't want to say definitively i didn't see it i was much more preoccupied with the actual
01:41:47 direct conversation that i had with commissioner lucky earlier that day where she had imparted to me
01:41:54 perhaps the most um urgent information to date with regards to uh the the occupation and the
01:42:01 blockades and that was a threshold moment okay fair enough so if you did see it it didn't register
01:42:07 as much as what she said about coots put it that way in your recollection was that information put
01:42:13 before cabinet so we know that that commissioner lucky wasn't called on to speak um do you recall
01:42:19 this being expressed to cabinet that evening no okay um and you certainly obviously and i wasn't
01:42:27 permitted to share or i was asked not to share the information about coots with anyone else except
01:42:33 for the prime minister which um which i did okay if you had known this information and i appreciate
01:42:41 you're not entirely sure on whether you saw this information or didn't would it have changed your
01:42:47 mind at all i i don't think so at that point um my interactions directly with the commissioner
01:42:52 were actually going in the opposite direction, and certainly the fact that we were on the
01:42:59 precipice of engaging in an operation in Coutts where people were armed with a significant
01:43:09 number of lethal firearms where they possessed body armor, where there was intelligence or
01:43:15 information that they had ideologically extremist views and symbolism that was attached to the
01:43:21 group that they were prepared to go down with the cause was a very strong signal to me that
01:43:26 the commissioner was of a heightened concern around the state of affairs. And again, it was
01:43:31 consistent with the advice that we were getting contemporaneous to the decision of the invocation
01:43:37 of the Emergencies Act around tools to address the gaps that existed. So, you know, the need to
01:43:44 deploy RCMP officers, the need to procure essential services, importantly the need to declare
01:43:51 no-go zones or prohibition of assemblies. Let me just say on that last point that I wasn't just
01:43:57 hearing about that from the RCMP. The CBSA had briefed cabinet on at least one occasion for sure
01:44:06 if not more about their explicit concerns about the lack of their authority and jurisdiction to
01:44:13 clear roads on the way to the border. And so, you know, all of those powers were subsequently
01:44:22 included in the declaration and the regulations under the Emergencies Act.
01:44:27 Okay, well, let's actually stop there for a moment. I'm going to go back to what we
01:44:31 were talking about. But PB.CAN 1864, please, Mr. Clerk.
01:44:43 So, this is a text from John Ossofsky, president of the CBSA, the evening of February 13th.
01:44:59 And he says, the gap, well, you asked, is it possible to direct CBSA officials to take
01:45:07 a harder line or the heightened sense of vigilance as far as it goes?
01:45:11 And he writes back, the gap is the fact that there is not an inadmissibility in IRPA,
01:45:18 Immigration, Refugee, and Protection Act, for coming to a protest. We have directed back 29
01:45:24 so far for other reasons as part of our enhanced vigilance. And you say, right, okay, so nothing
01:45:29 we can do to strengthen our position there. I think our position broadly is that it's an illegal
01:45:34 blockade and it goes on so that is sorry go on um so i scroll down a little bit please
01:45:43 if you're blocking a border hurting canadians it would warrant a tougher position and then you ask
01:45:47 the 29 were sent back because it was believed they had violent intentions or on what grounds
01:45:52 were they sent away we don't have the text after that but first of all is this a is this a text
01:45:56 conversation that was happening during the the cabinet meeting that evening um well i'd have to
01:46:02 go back and take a look at the time stamps uh about 9 23 pm i think could could very well have
01:46:08 been uh i assume it was this is february 13th right that's right yes so i uh would have been
01:46:15 trying to really get a clarity of understanding about what the gaps were and what the then
01:46:23 president of the cbsa is expressing to me is that they need something that they don't have
01:46:28 and what they don't have at this moment in time is any existing authority to turn away foreign
01:46:35 nationals who are attempting to enter into Canada where there are reasonable grounds to suspect that
01:46:42 they may want to support what at this point is an illegal blockade and so that is again a cry
01:46:51 an obvious request for some assistance here as a result of a gap in an authority and there is a
01:46:59 direct line between that gap and the subsequent powers which were included under the emergencies
01:47:06 act there is no other way for me to interpret the information that i'm getting from john azowski
01:47:12 is certainly not to do anything about it and subsequently we did provide that authority and
01:47:18 And there were, as my understanding recollects, at least, I think, one or two individuals who were turned away on February 19th by CVSA on the strength of the Emergencies Act authorities that were provided to them.
01:47:31 I think we know it was two. And the answer to the question here is that the 29 were sent back because under enhanced vigilance, because generally speaking, I think because they weren't they didn't meet the vaccination requirements.
01:47:45 requirements i think your interpretation is right and i think mr zowski is is he's communicating to
01:47:52 me that we're we're working with what we got but it's not it's not enough and we're concerned that
01:47:57 we don't have the authority that we need and this was in addition to what i think is one of the other
01:48:03 significant concerns that cbsa expressed to me and to other cabinet colleagues which is that
01:48:09 they did not have the authority or the jurisdiction to clear the roads leading to the border
01:48:15 And certainly that limited their capacity to keep the border open and by extension, critical supply chains, food, fuel, health supplies, all the like.
01:48:25 The people in the border communities, and I'm certainly familiar with the community in Windsor as a result of some family relationships, but people got to go about their daily lives.
01:48:36 And this was completely impossible at that time.
01:48:40 And so, you know, I think he's expressing two very legitimate gaps.
01:48:46 And and so, again, the only interpretation for me is that we need some help here.
01:48:51 And so we endeavored to provide that help to them through the Emergencies Act.
01:48:55 OK, I'm at the end of my time.
01:48:57 Mr. Commissioner, I just wanted to just clarify, because I think the impression was left inadvertently or otherwise, that these are the ministers, Texas, opposed to the chief of staff.
01:49:05 I'm sorry. You're right.
01:49:07 I apologize for intervening.
01:49:08 for interviewing no thank you that's helpful um mr commissioner i'm at the end but if i can ask for
01:49:14 five minutes to ask some concluding questions oh it's your call when you uh you you still have time
01:49:21 so not a lot oh actually no i do have my account you have lots of time actually you can count better
01:49:29 than i am but better than i can i was thinking of the old time allocation okay so something rarely
01:49:35 heard in a in any kind of a proceeding no well i have a lot of experience following time
01:49:42 or not following it um so it's just uh just wondering if you wanted the break now or later
01:49:47 sure let's take the break now sir before we take the break um i just have a quick application i
01:49:54 apologize sir uh i think it's important i've just met mr alexander cohen he's present uh in this
01:50:02 room and sir mr cohen as we have heard throughout this proceeding has relevant and material evidence
01:50:13 to this proceedings mandate he has very relevant evidence with respect to the inquiry as to the
01:50:21 circumstances as to the invocation of the emergencies act he also has relevant and
01:50:27 material information with respect to misinformation of which this commission has been tasked with
01:50:34 exploring beginning with the text messages between himself and mary liz power that are already in
01:50:42 evidence in building the narrative with respect to the protesters in ottawa being extremists
01:50:49 and thereafter essentially setting out that they are, in fact, proprietors of Nazi symbolism.
01:51:00 Sir, this commission is in hearing from various...
01:51:06 Can I just interrupt? What's your application?
01:51:09 I'd like to call him as a witness, sir.
01:51:11 Have you written any... Is there a...
01:51:13 I didn't expect that we would have the opportunity.
01:51:16 you haven't at the moment there's no application so well this is my application sir i'm making it
01:51:22 orally and i'm asking for the commission to have him testify after the minister he has
01:51:31 relevant material information i'm not going to do this orally right now well so we're given 15
01:51:37 minutes to cross-examine to elicit relevant material evidence and we have relevant and
01:51:44 witnesses here. The government of Canada has redacted without lawful authority all of these
01:51:51 statements from these staffers and have suppressed records. I have no idea at this point where this
01:51:56 is going so I'm going to take the break and if you can speak to Commission Council which I think
01:52:03 I've repeated many times is the way to at least raise the issue and then we'll see if they can
01:52:09 resolve it or not but we have a schedule and sir this is the schedule is not as important
01:52:15 as getting to the truth there's no question we want to get at the truth but you know what
01:52:20 it's a very complex issue and it's not all about what you want it's about what the commission
01:52:27 needs to do what the parties want to do and I'm trying to control a process and we have witnesses
01:52:37 we have a schedule it's been going for a while please speak to commission council
01:52:43 we'll see where we go and the we'll take the morning sir i understand but i just ask for
01:52:50 a ruling after the morning break thank you so we'll take 15 minutes the commission is in recess
01:52:57 for 15 minutes to let me see on the vipokans minute
01:53:07 Thank you.
01:53:37 Thank you.
01:54:07 Thank you.
01:54:37 Thank you.
01:55:07 Thank you.
01:55:37 Thank you.
01:56:07 Thank you.
01:56:37 .
01:57:07 Thank you.
01:57:37 Thank you.
01:58:07 Thank you.
01:58:37 .
01:59:07 Thank you.
01:59:37 Thank you.
02:00:07 Thank you.
02:00:37 Thank you.
02:01:07 Thank you.
02:01:37 Thank you.
02:02:07 Thank you.
02:02:37 Thank you.
02:03:07 Thank you.
02:03:37 Thank you.
02:04:07 Thank you.
02:04:37 Thank you.
02:05:07 Thank you.
02:05:37 Thank you.
02:06:07 Thank you.
02:06:37 Thank you.
02:07:07 Thank you.
02:07:37 Thank you.
02:08:07 Thank you.
02:08:37 Thank you.
02:09:07 Thank you.
02:09:37 Thank you.
02:10:07 Thank you.
02:10:37 Thank you.
02:11:07 The Commission has reconvened, La Commissaire La Plane.
02:11:23 Sir, the Commission Council has not completed her application.
02:11:28 I understand that sir, and your Council has advised you that.
02:11:31 No, I know you've directed, you wanted the application.
02:11:34 I'm sorry, I'm speaking.
02:11:36 Yes sir.
02:11:37 The application, if you want to do it, you've been advised it's to be done in writing, not in the middle of the presentation.
02:11:44 Sir, we filed two motions in writing at your direction that you've refused to rule on with respect to the redaction of documents from the government of Canada.
02:11:52 You're speaking.
02:11:53 That has not been ruled on and has been filed for days.
02:11:56 I will take a break while you're asked to leave.
02:12:00 I will return in five minutes if security could deal with the council.
02:12:07 Commission the research looks going to me
02:12:37 Thank you.
02:13:07 Thank you.
02:13:37 no need to stand I'm not a judge here just a commissioner the commissioners reconvene
02:13:52 Okay, thank you, Commission Council.
02:14:01 Welcome back, Minister.
02:14:07 I want to take you back to something you touched on before the break, and I'd like to get your reaction on.
02:14:14 I asked you whether if you had seen and absorbed, let's put it that way,
02:14:19 Lucky's statement that they had not yet exhausted all available tools. Law enforcement still had
02:14:26 tools available. I asked you whether that would have changed your mind as to the necessity of
02:14:30 the Emergencies Act, and you answered no, and you explained that you're concerned about COOTS.
02:14:35 How do you reconcile that position with the notion that the Emergencies Act is a measure of a last
02:14:41 resort well first i would say that the absence of having a direct conversation with commissioner
02:14:52 lucky and i pointed out the call that we had earlier today but that wasn't the only one
02:14:57 there were other meetings at ergs and daily briefings um really uh was an impediment at
02:15:04 that point to have the kind of back and forth exploration of that advice uh which she had
02:15:09 included in an email to to my chief of staff mike jones i think the other thing the other reason why
02:15:17 i don't believe it would have substantially changed my views at that point are twofold one
02:15:23 it didn't really expand at all on how she had come to that point of view so when she talked about a
02:15:36 plan um there was no elaboration on it and i would point out that for the better part of the
02:15:44 two weeks leading up to the uh to february 13th that there were times where the commissioner and
02:15:51 others uh at those daily calls that we were having were expressing concerns about the absence of
02:15:56 a plan with existing authorities so um at that particular moment in time it
02:16:04 It seemed to me as a conclusory statement that was not substantiated with any kind of particular detail.
02:16:13 And the second reason why I don't believe it would have changed where my thinking was at that particular moment in time was predominantly because of the call earlier that day, which was top of mind.
02:16:26 And as I explained before the morning break, I beg your pardon, it just spoke volumes about what her state of mind was, which was that this was potentially an escalation of violence that could result in there being gun violence and potentially serious injuries or even fatalities to members of law enforcement and Canadians.
02:16:53 One thing I didn't mention was that my worry, my real fear, was that had that operation not gone down peacefully, that it might have sparked other gun violence across the country.
02:17:13 And I recall early reports from the Ottawa Police Service that guns had been brought into the National Capital Region and potentially into the parliamentary precinct.
02:17:30 And there wasn't a lot of detail around that, I want to be clear, but we were operating with the best information that we had available to us.
02:17:39 So that elevated my concerns. And so that was where my state of mind was, as opposed to the one bullet point that she had sent to my chief of staff shortly before the cabinet meeting on February 13th.
02:17:54 So you're expressing here a concern that what was going on in Cootes might be going on in other places. Not evidence of that, but you were nevertheless concerned about it.
02:18:05 on the basis of both previous information and reports publicly available from Ottawa Police Service
02:18:14 that firearms had made their way into the Capitol, and as well, again, a report about an arrest
02:18:22 involving someone who was participating in the convoy here that ultimately resulted in the seizure
02:18:29 of a firearm. So I was worried about the potential chain reaction, that if the operation
02:18:42 did not go flawlessly, that it might actually escalate in more violence. And that's why
02:18:48 I think she communicated that, you know, very clearly, and rightfully so. I want to be clear
02:18:54 that Commissioner Luckey was entirely appropriate and justified in signaling that this was a,
02:19:00 you know, potentially much higher level of concern around the state of affairs.
02:19:05 Okay, so I'll put this to you and you can tell me right or wrong, but are you sort of saying
02:19:10 your concern was okay, but what if it gets worse?
02:19:14 my my concern was um that this was that this information was highly sensitive it involved
02:19:26 a hardened cell it involved guns it involved ideological symbolism potentially and
02:19:33 that if that operation to arrest those individuals did not go efficiently and smoothly and peacefully
02:19:43 that it may have created a chain reaction elsewhere across the country,
02:19:47 because there were past reports about the presence of guns.
02:19:51 Okay, so I should have put my question more clearly, maybe,
02:19:54 but with respect to the availability of tools and whether law enforcement had what it needed,
02:19:59 are you saying, and you may not be, so I'm asking you,
02:20:02 but are you saying that regardless of whether there may have been tools available,
02:20:08 there was a concern that the situation would get worse?
02:20:11 Yes. And again, the urgency with which we had that conversation, the confidentiality around it, the operational sensitivity about it, the jeopardy of having lives at stake, the potential chain reaction of other gun violence across the country on the basis of reports, and the concurrent advice that we were getting about tools that could only be granted in the Emergencies Act because resources were ineffective at restoring public safety.
02:20:40 and there were gaps around deploying RCMP efficiently.
02:20:45 I mean, you'll recall the swearing provisions, the no-go zones, the procuring of tow trucks.
02:20:52 All of that was where my state of mind was.
02:20:56 Okay.
02:20:58 And by the way, those were conversations that we did have in person at the ERGs
02:21:03 and at the cabinet table around where those gaps were.
02:21:07 Where the gaps were.
02:21:08 Yes.
02:21:08 so we have heard evidence about gaps that have been identified that were identified we also heard
02:21:13 um from a number of officials and we saw in documentation a lot of hesitancy around the idea
02:21:19 of using the emergency fact and the possibility that it may inflame tensions that may make things
02:21:25 worse uh there was a lot of if i could put it this way doubt around that um in light of that
02:21:33 and in light also of a lot of discussion that we've had here in the commission
02:21:37 about whether the threshold itself was met under the Emergencies Act.
02:21:43 Can you go there at this point and explain to us your understanding
02:21:47 of why the threshold was met and why it was necessary
02:21:51 in light of the hesitancy that had been expressed about the need to invoke it?
02:21:57 Well, you've touched on a few important points in your question,
02:22:00 So I'm going to try and unpack the questions that you put to me.
02:22:05 Just first on hesitancy, I would be more inclined to describe it as reluctance.
02:22:12 And I think that that instinct was the right one, that this was a statute that was created
02:22:19 coming out of the aftermath of the October 1970 crisis and there being real concerns
02:22:25 about using, resorting to the War Measures Act and using the military to restore public order,
02:22:32 which is not the mandate or the expertise of the military, a very blunt instrument.
02:22:39 And the creation of the Emergencies Act, which very consciously and deliberately
02:22:47 does not make any reference to military powers, but nevertheless affords the government
02:22:54 broad scope to respond to public order emergencies.
02:22:59 And just by virtue of its title, you know, if you're into an emergency,
02:23:06 this is obviously a very serious situation.
02:23:08 So you don't want to have to use it unless it's necessary.
02:23:11 So that is the right posture, I think, of every government,
02:23:15 that this is not a piece of legislation that we should be using
02:23:20 in a way that is anything reserved but for the most serious situations.
02:23:27 So that's my answer in regards to the reluctance around it.
02:23:33 You also mentioned in your question that this business about there being the concern
02:23:40 that if we invoke the Emergencies Act, that it might actually lead to more violence
02:23:43 or radicalization, as I believe you heard from Mr. Vigneault and CESIS.
02:23:48 I was very mindful of that, but I also and colleagues at the cabinet table also had to weigh the risks of not invoking the Emergencies Act because there were the materialization of counter protests from individuals, specifically in Ottawa, because they were so frustrated at their inability to go to their jobs, take their kids to daycare,
02:24:18 get access to emergency medical services, their prescriptions and the like, I mean, it was utter
02:24:22 and total mayhem. I mean, let's call a spade a spade. And so that frustration was boiling over.
02:24:29 And my concern in my capacity as the Minister for Public Safety is that if we don't equip police
02:24:36 with the additional tools and the authorities that they need to specifically address the gaps
02:24:41 that they had been consistently briefing us on, then that might lead to more violence.
02:24:46 And so we also had to weigh the risks of not taking the decision to invoke.
02:24:53 And so we weighed in the potential concerns around radicalization, but ultimately we came down on the side of invoking.
02:25:03 Okay. On this point then, Mr. Clerk, can you pull up ssm.nsc.can50290?
02:25:16 Excuse me. 0.93
02:25:34 So this is a readout of minutes of the guns and gangs.
02:25:41 Can you situate us actually, Mr. Menachino, and tell us, guns and gangs, what does that
02:25:45 refer to that meeting um sorry this is a document published by it's a it's a reading or minutes of
02:25:54 a meeting that was held date alex okay the date of it isn't clear actually but we know that it's
02:26:01 post invocation because it refers to the invocation of the emergencies act um and it says schedule
02:26:08 was changed guns and gangs instead it's it's a guns and gangs meeting and there's a report from
02:26:15 you. M3, I think, refers to you. That's a notation that's often used to describe you. MMM3. Why M3?
02:26:23 Minister Marco Mendicino. I should have been able to answer that. Okay.
02:26:28 Bullet number three here. You're discussing, okay, well, let's go from the bullet number one.
02:26:33 Update on current state of affairs. The blockades that started a month ago aiming critical
02:26:37 infrastructure had a very significant and negative impact on our security, sovereignty,
02:26:42 and integrity at the borders. We worked very closely with FPT to get a grasp of the risks to
02:26:48 public safety and international security. The important one, which I'll slow down on, is the
02:26:54 third one. We took unprecedented decision to invoke Emergencies Act on the advice we received
02:27:02 from many branches of enforcement on every level. What I want to ask you about here is
02:27:08 the advice you received from branches of enforcement, was that advice to invoke the
02:27:15 Emergencies Act specifically? The advice that we received was around tools that could only be
02:27:24 granted through the Emergencies Act. And the reason why I say that is that there's an express
02:27:32 element of the test that says that you don't get to the threshold unless you've exhausted
02:27:38 authorities or if you unless unless it can be established that existing authorities are
02:27:45 ineffective at restoring public safety and for me that is the operative word because there were
02:27:51 authorities that were on the books but the fact is that on the basis of what I was seeing
02:27:56 and what I was hearing that those existing authorities were not sufficiently effective
02:28:03 to restore public safety and that is consistent with the advice that we were getting from various
02:28:08 partners within the public safety community, including law enforcement, including CBSA
02:28:14 and other officials, as you've heard. Okay, so just to recap then, the advice you're talking
02:28:22 about is the advice that's identifying gaps in tools, not specifically advice to invoke the
02:28:29 Emergencies Act, but advice that goes to identifying gaps or tools. And tools, as you
02:28:36 actually saw in the email from Commissioner Luckey on February 13th that would be invoked
02:28:42 in the Emergencies Act. She used that language in her email to me. Okay.
02:28:50 Then the very last question, I think I actually am now out of time. So the last question I want
02:28:56 to ask you, Minister Medellino, and your legal background shows and how you unpacked my triple
02:29:02 barreled question last time around so this is the last barrel the third barrel that we that you
02:29:06 didn't get to in your answer which is the threshold for for invoking uh a public order
02:29:12 emergency as you know depends on identifying a threat to the security of canada with reference
02:29:18 to the cesus act we've heard a lot of discussion at the commission about how that threshold
02:29:23 may or may not have been met and we know that there was no specific threat to the security of
02:29:28 of Canada, assessed by CSIS. Nevertheless, the government concluded that the threshold was
02:29:36 met, presumably, because the Act was invoked. How, in your view, was that threshold met?
02:29:42 Well, first, let me address the piece about CSIS's conclusion, and I know you've heard some
02:29:48 evidence about that. But I do think it is important to emphasize that they are assessing
02:29:53 through their mandate, which is conventionally confined to espionage and foreign interference
02:29:59 and potential threats to cybersecurity for the purposes of establishing a legal threshold under
02:30:06 that statute, which then leads to potentially obtaining warrants judicially authorized so that
02:30:13 we can mitigate against those potential security threats. This was very different. This was not
02:30:20 about isolating a lone wolf or a small group. Rather, it was about looking at a protest
02:30:29 which became illegal at a national scale. And completing that exercise also had to take a look
02:30:39 at the broader objective and scope of the Emergencies Act, which means looking at Section
02:30:45 two of that statute where it talks about the presence of a serious threat or a threat of
02:30:54 serious violence so as to exceed the capacity of any province to respond on the basis of authorities
02:30:59 that exist. And so in my judgment, you need to kind of look at both. And that was precisely
02:31:06 the skill set that I was applying in my role as Minister of Public Safety, drawing on my
02:31:14 understanding of the law and the principles as they were being applied to the facts that existed
02:31:21 on the ground at the time. And so looking at everything in its totality, we had a situation
02:31:28 where for two weeks we had a protest that was national in scale that overwhelmed the resources
02:31:37 of police and other border officials very deliberately for a protracted period of time
02:31:43 were despite the existence of statutes and resources, and in my view, as informed by
02:31:52 counter operational tactics that were specifically deployed to stop people from restoring public
02:32:01 safety, the extraordinary jeopardy that it placed our economy and the thousands of Canadians who
02:32:08 had their jobs interrupted, the fact that businesses were shuttered, that sectors were compromised,
02:32:12 that are the literal and figurative engine of our economy.
02:32:16 The fact that all of this was tied to a politically stated objective
02:32:23 to overthrow the government if it refused to reverse course on pandemic policy
02:32:28 and the challenges that were presented to the security and intelligence community
02:32:33 and the broader law enforcement community in understanding what the nature of this protest was
02:32:38 and why it was so difficult and challenging to restore public safety,
02:32:42 all drew me to the conclusion that we met the threshold.
02:32:46 And ultimately, for me, at the end of the day, it worked.
02:32:50 I'm not saying that the Emergencies Act is a perfect instrument,
02:32:54 and my sincere hope to the Commission is that there will be some reflection about that.
02:33:00 But it was a measure that was successfully deployed by law enforcement
02:33:05 to restore public safety without significant injury or any fatalities at all.
02:33:10 And the fact that that as part of the invocation of this act, that we now have an opportunity to go over the circumstances that led to that decision in great forensic detail with witnesses testifying is, I think, an important pillar of our democratic process, which, of course, was one of the things that we were very much concerned with preserving throughout.
02:33:33 so i mean that that's that that is my answer with regards to the threshold and
02:33:38 um why i think it's important that i'm here today mr questioner those are my questions i'll pass the
02:33:44 baton okay so now uh cross-examination start with the convoy organizers please
02:33:52 good morning good morning sir my name is keith wilson council for the convoy organizers
02:34:02 I apologize for my voice. I'm recovering from a cold.
02:34:05 I have a bit of the same.
02:34:07 Thank you, sir.
02:34:09 Sir, we're not in a position to proceed with CROSS at this time, and there's two reasons.
02:34:13 One is the federal government has disclosed over a week ago an extension volume of documents that are highly redacted.
02:34:24 It is obvious from the face of the documents that they don't meet the criteria for lawful redactions.
02:34:32 a motion was made last week for those redactions to be lifted the submissions closed on Thursday
02:34:39 evening we still have no ruling a number of days have passed for the cross-examination and the
02:34:47 discovery of truth process to be valid and effective the parties require access to the
02:34:53 documents we don't have that so we would appreciate some indication as to when the
02:35:00 Commission is actually going to rule on that and hopefully compel the proper disclosure of the
02:35:06 records so that cross-examinations can be effective. I emphasize that these documents are not related to
02:35:12 future witnesses but present witnesses. So we're making the process inefficient with all due respect
02:35:18 by not allowing the parties to have access to unredacted documents. Second reason we're not
02:35:25 in a position to proceed with our cross-examination at this time with this witness is uh our lead
02:35:31 counsel mr brendan miller who had prepared for the cross as you know sir has been removed from
02:35:36 the room by you when he was raising a motion to find a way around the absence of a ruling on the
02:35:43 redaction so we're just not in a position to proceed on crosser okay well just on your your
02:35:51 first question it uh it is uh expected that the ruling will come out at the during the lunch hour
02:36:00 it's there have been a fair amount of back and forth without going into detail there's there's
02:36:07 some let's say uh innovative type of issues that had to be dealt with uh so that should come out
02:36:18 at lunchtime which I'm happy to I will do my utmost it's going to come out
02:36:25 unfortunately probably and not on the record the website because it won't be
02:36:31 translated which is one of the issues we have to deal with but we will in light of
02:36:36 what you say you'll issue it in English only for the moment and it will become
02:36:41 be posted when it's bilingual but I understand that submission so that that should enable you
02:36:49 so we can put off the cross-examinations till after the lunchtime in terms of the other problem
02:36:56 that's not something I can deal with I've dealt I'm trying to deal the best I can with
02:37:02 the situation and quite frankly if the issue had been raised the way you
02:37:10 have now i would have given the answer i'm giving now so um what i propose then since this witness
02:37:18 will be here after lunch we simply delay till after lunch if you could endeavor because i see
02:37:24 you have uh uh mr will uh you have a co-counsel so can sort out how that can be done that would
02:37:31 be appreciated thank you sir okay so the next i'll call on the opp please
02:37:39 good afternoon afternoon minister chris diana council to the opp good afternoon we received
02:37:58 some documents last night that we're all frantically trying to review some of them
02:38:02 are quite interesting and one of the ones that i'd like to start with mr clerk is pb dot can
02:38:08 And this appears to be a text exchange with you and an unidentified person who I'm hoping you'll be able to help us identify.
02:38:23 And if we can go to page 26.
02:38:38 All right. So if you could help situate us as to kind of context here, this appears to be a text with someone, I believe you're on the left and somebody else is on the right.
02:38:48 If you could scroll down a little bit so that the witness has a chance to review it.
02:38:52 Do you know who this text exchange was with?
02:38:54 I believe it's Mike Jones.
02:38:55 And he would be your chief of staff, correct?
02:38:57 Yes.
02:38:57 And someone who you would have been in touch with, obviously, every day that you're closest to contact within your system.
02:39:05 All right, and so we scroll to the top again to set the time context here.
02:39:10 Monday, February 14th at 12.48 a.m., so very early in the morning, February 14th.
02:39:15 So basically the night of February 13th, if we were to look at it that way.
02:39:19 And the context here is that the Ambassador Bridge had just been opened to traffic, I believe, about 30 minutes earlier.
02:39:27 Is that correct?
02:39:28 Yes.
02:39:28 That, of course, with your recollection of when this text exchange took place?
02:39:31 It does.
02:39:32 there were some questions about whether or not it was fully opened and exactly when CBSA would
02:39:36 declare that it was officially open. But on the whole, yes, there were reports that it was opened
02:39:41 in the early hours of February the 14th. Yeah, but I think for clarity, I think the Windsor Police
02:39:46 Service Institutional Report identifies 1212 a.m. on that day. So that sounds about right to me.
02:39:52 All right. And so you would agree that everything you had heard was said while it was open,
02:39:55 there was still a concern about potential volatility, correct? That's right. All right.
02:39:59 There were reports of flare-ups, if I'm not mistaken, either on the 13th, but certainly after the 14th as well.
02:40:06 All right.
02:40:06 So I'm interested in the text that says, and I'll read it, following the declaration, we should go to Ambassador and inspect the bridge reopening and thank law enforcement and RCMP, assuming things go according to plan.
02:40:20 So I'd like to follow up on what, and this is you texting Mike Jones, correct?
02:40:24 Yes.
02:40:25 Your term following the declaration, I assume you're talking about the Emergencies Act declaration?
02:40:30 Yes.
02:40:31 And you would agree the Emergencies Act had not yet been invoked at this point, correct?
02:40:35 That's correct.
02:40:36 And in fact, there had not even been consultation with the provinces at this point, correct?
02:40:40 That's, well, to be clear, the first minister's meeting had not yet occurred, which occurred the next morning.
02:40:47 There were conversations with provincial and territorial counterparts, but it was before the first minister's meeting.
02:40:53 Right. But I think and I'm not going to go to the document for lack of time, but I think it was made very clear by the prime minister and others that that his mind hadn't been made up yet, that the consultation was essentially being done in good faith.
02:41:05 Yes. Correct. Yes. And I wasn't communicating that the decision had been finally taken, but rather the assumption that it it may have been.
02:41:12 Not may have been following the declaration. It sounds to me like you're pretty convinced that it was going to be made regardless of what happened at the consultation.
02:41:19 I won't dispute we were definitely trending very much in that direction. Yes.
02:41:23 Okay. Assuming things go according to plan. And so what plan are you referring to here?
02:41:30 Restoring public safety. And Ambassador Bridge was one of the real flashpoints, as you'll recall, because not only of the impact domestically in Windsor, but Ambassador Bridge was one of the reasons why I was engaged by my American counterpart, Secretary Mayorkas, who had reached out and was very concerned that it was going to have an impact on two-way trade.
02:41:53 And you will be familiar with this by now, I assume, but at Ambassador Bridge, we do the most significant amount of our day-to-day land trade.
02:42:01 So there was a lot at stake in restoring public safety at the Ambassador Bridge in Windsor, Detroit.
02:42:07 Right. So a cynic might suggest, and we're both lawyers and there are a number of us in that category, a cynic might suggest that it appears here, you're talking about setting up a photo op in Windsor, even before the Emergencies Act is invoked.
02:42:22 i i agree with you a cynic may suggest that but that was not my um my my intent um the the point
02:42:29 was this was a very stressful uh time and um i wanted to be in a position to reassure canadians
02:42:38 that we were storing a public safety uh right across the country including in windsor detroit
02:42:44 and and that was an idea that i had uh proposed at the time to my chief of staff okay so let's
02:42:50 read the rest of it. Your chief of staff says, okay, do you know when that will be? Presumably
02:42:55 being the invocation of the act, correct? Yes. Your response, I'm hearing it's late as tomorrow
02:43:00 morning. I think it's a powerful visual. Otherwise, it's just tweets. So basically what you're saying
02:43:06 is I should go there, get some pictures, get some video because it sends a better image than just
02:43:12 tweeting about it. Fair? Well, I think what I'm getting at is that people are anxious and are
02:43:19 concerned and want to be confident that we are restoring public safety. I mean, I would point
02:43:25 out that that is not the end of the matter. And there's some additional back and forth between
02:43:30 my chief of staff and law enforcement. Ultimately, I chose not to go on sober reflection.
02:43:36 All right. So let's go to that then. The OPP was not impressed with this idea. Is that fair to say?
02:43:42 I didn't speak directly with the OPP, but it was expressed to me that law enforcement had concerns
02:43:48 about me or any other elected official going all right if we can take up the document id opp4582
02:43:56 and i'm going to be taking you to text message messages between commissioner kareek and deputy
02:44:01 commissioner chris harkins on february 14th and once that's up if we can go to page 71
02:44:18 all right so you can see the top it says dana called and that would be a reference to dana
02:44:26 early as you know and this is from chris harkins dana called she is not happy the rcmp called and
02:44:31 the federal public safety minister and that would be you correct yes is coming tomorrow for a photo
02:44:37 op tour the command post etc not appropriate optics are terrible can we stop it commissioner
02:44:44 Karik responds a little while later saying visit is being postponed so you could see here that
02:44:50 obviously the OPP was not happy with the idea and described it as a photo op. Yeah their advice
02:44:54 changed my mind. Part of the reason that they were concerned of course and I think you heard
02:45:05 this from the RCMP as well was the potential that it could further inflame the situation if you
02:45:10 actually showed up and took pictures. Fair? And I had to balance that against what my initial
02:45:15 thought or objective was, which was to assure, to be accessible and to assure people that we had
02:45:22 restored public safety. So in the end, I took that very much into consideration and was actually
02:45:28 quite deferential and respectful to the advice that we got back from police and chose not to go.
02:45:32 Okay. Can we go back to the other document, which is pb.can.1849? And this is back to your
02:45:39 text exchange with Mike Jones. And page 32. Here it says RCMP and this is I believe Mike Jones
02:45:56 saying RCMP Commissioner also strongly advising against a trip to Windsor concern that is still
02:46:02 quite volatile and things have been inflamed by today's announcement. Someone drove at an officer
02:46:07 again i want the visual as well but with two levels of forces asking us not to my two cents
02:46:13 is that it's not worth the risk of going and something happening in response delaying gives
02:46:18 us more time to plan etc scroll down okay i hear you let's discuss so essentially it was your chief
02:46:25 of staff that was saying look we've heard from two police services let's not do this yeah solid
02:46:30 advice and i took it in retrospect and i raise this because you know i think you would agree
02:46:36 that sometimes having politicians attend these kinds of sites can have perhaps unintended
02:46:41 consequences fair absolutely yes and that in retrospect you would agree that it probably
02:46:46 wasn't a good idea to have gone yes that's why we didn't go yes
02:46:55 and in my last minute i'm going to ask you about consultation and i've put these questions to other
02:47:01 witnesses but i'm just simply going to ask you or put to you the proposition about consultation
02:47:06 with law enforcement and the suggestion that i'll put to you is that it's a good idea that
02:47:13 when there is consultation with law enforcement on tools that that be done in writing for purposes
02:47:18 of accountability so we can go back and check exactly who said what to whom right would you
02:47:23 agree that's a good idea totally and and you would have heard my um my evidence a little bit earlier
02:47:29 this morning where i talked about navigating the principle of operational independence i referred
02:47:33 to Article 9.3 under police service agreements, which we reach with provinces, which actually do
02:47:39 set out a mechanism and a protocol by which additional resources are requested from the
02:47:45 Office of the Federal Minister of Public Safety, as well as the Office of the Provincial Ministers
02:47:53 of Public Safety. One thing I didn't mention, but I do think is really relevant, is that in those
02:47:59 police service agreements, it is expressly contemplated under either 9.1 or 9.2 of those
02:48:05 agreements that prior to the deployment of intra-provincial RCMP resources, it is the elected
02:48:13 provincial minister of public safety who has to form the opinion that there is a state of emergency
02:48:20 before they can be deployed. And it is only if existing RCMP resources within the province
02:48:28 are overwhelmed or insufficient to deal with that emergency, that you then take the next step of
02:48:36 requesting for the deployment of RCMP resources outside of the province to deal with the situation,
02:48:42 which is Article 9.3. And that is a request that comes to this office. My point is, I agree with
02:48:49 you that there is a protocol there. The Emergencies Act, unfortunately, does not prescribe that
02:48:56 process. So what we did instead was we did the best that we could having various meetings daily,
02:49:05 ultimately in the ERG and the cabinet meetings where we were soliciting inputs, including as
02:49:10 you saw in the email that I received from Commissioner Lucky the day before, where she
02:49:16 very specifically and thoughtfully prescribes tools that could only be granted under the
02:49:22 Emergencies Act. But I agree that maybe some additional thought ought to be given to this
02:49:26 protocol. Right. And I am out of time. So as I'm leaving, I'm just going to say that we've heard
02:49:29 evidence that some ambiguous evidence spoke conversations within the RCMP, perhaps with
02:49:34 others that haven't been written down. And I think you would agree that it'd be helpful to have
02:49:38 everything clear and ambiguous. So there's no room for doubt. Yes. Thank you, Minister. Thank
02:49:43 you. Okay, next call on the Ottawa Police Service, please.
02:49:56 Good afternoon, Minister. My name is Jessica Barrow, and I'm one of the counsel to Ottawa Police Service.
02:50:04 Good afternoon.
02:50:06 Prior to the arrival of the convoy, would you agree with me that there was conflicting information about how many protesters may participate in Ottawa, as well as how long they may stay?
02:50:16 I do agree. And by the way, the range was very broad. I mean, I'd heard something in the low thousands and then it quickly escalated as we got closer to the weekend, upwards of seven or eight thousand. So, yes.
02:50:27 And so that was a real difficulty from a planning perspective at all levels of government and law enforcement. Is that fair?
02:50:33 Yes.
02:50:34 and in fact you testified earlier that you were concerned that even the intelligence you were
02:50:40 receiving from your team maybe didn't fully capture all of what you were seeing in terms
02:50:45 of public narrative is that fair i recall that yes and deputy minister stewart testified last
02:50:51 week that there was a difficulty amongst the intelligence community at that time in assessing
02:50:56 the information that was being received because much of that evidence was open source and there
02:51:01 was difficulty ascertaining the credibility of that information. Would you agree with that?
02:51:05 I would agree with that. And so again, that's something that all levels of law enforcement
02:51:09 would have been grappling with at that time. I agree. And so ultimately, no one really had a
02:51:14 very clear picture in advance of the scope of the event, as well as the behavior of the protesters
02:51:20 before it arrived. Is that fair? Yes. And I think you've heard from a number of individuals,
02:51:25 including me, that that posed challenges with regards to assessing the intelligence and the
02:51:30 information about who the protest was made up of how many would participate how long they would
02:51:37 stay what would be the kind of conduct they would be engaging in could it become violent there was
02:51:42 a lot of information to have to sift through and assess and it was as you pointed out at times
02:51:49 varying and conflicting and so that that definitely posed some challenges and ultimately what we did
02:51:55 see here in ottawa as well as elsewhere in the country was entirely unprecedented both in terms
02:52:01 of the scope as well as the behavior we ultimately saw from protesters is that correct yes it is
02:52:08 i want to move on to the police response once uh the protesters arrived here in ottawa and
02:52:13 we've heard considerable evidence to the effect that when ops and its partners engaged in ad hoc
02:52:19 enforcement actions or ticketing bylaw enforcement things like that it could create dangerous
02:52:24 situations for officers we heard about swarming uh harassment i think you spoke to earlier so
02:52:29 you would agree that that type of thing was occurring in ottawa correct it was and i was
02:52:34 worried as i said earlier that it was the um the function of some counter operational advice that
02:52:41 was being provided to uh the uh the block in the occupation and it was in addition to police
02:52:47 officers it was public figures and we've heard many reports about serious criminal violent
02:52:53 threats, including death threats. I received a death threat. My family received a death threat
02:52:58 throughout the convoy. It was members of the press who were trying to report on
02:53:04 the facts that were occurring on the ground. There were many, many, I think, efforts to try to
02:53:13 crowd out legitimate law enforcement. Right. And so that was a real difficulty for law
02:53:18 enforcement on the ground, particularly OPS, since that was the bulk of the officers, obviously,
02:53:22 at that time, that to be able to engage in any real enforcement was a real challenge as a result
02:53:28 of what they were facing in response. Yes. And that remained the case until they had sufficient
02:53:33 resources, correct? That's right. And at that time, they did not have the sufficient resources
02:53:39 to really engage in meaningful enforcement in a way that people could maybe see it as meaningful.
02:53:45 Is that fair? And I would say both Chief Slowly and then Interim Chief Bell both expressed
02:53:51 concerns about having sufficient resources in the ground, which is why in my capacity as Minister
02:53:57 of Public Safety, I was facilitating additional help with the assistance of the Commissioner of
02:54:02 the RCMP by providing those resources. And when that didn't work, looking at other tools leading
02:54:08 up to the Emergencies Act. So specifically with respect to the resources, you would obviously
02:54:13 agree that that messaging coming from both OPS and Chief Slowly was from the very beginning,
02:54:19 essentially. Once it became apparent that these protesters were not leaving, it became equally
02:54:23 apparent that there was insufficient resources. Is that fair? That came very early on, yes.
02:54:28 And would it be fair to say that any concerns in relation to operational plans or the level
02:54:34 of enforcement should not be taken as some kind of suggestion that OPS should have engaged
02:54:39 enforcement action without the resources they needed? Well, that was certainly the subject
02:54:45 of discussion that was going on between the rcmp the opp and the ops as it was reported to me
02:54:54 it was about making sure that we understood what the plan was and what was needed by
02:55:00 the ottawa police service to restore public safety and from where i sat one way in which
02:55:06 we could support the formulation and the ultimate implementation of a plan would be to offer
02:55:12 additional rcmp resources and that we did right and so none of the sort of like we could call it
02:55:18 criticisms about uh the lack of enforcement or the lack of a plan should be pers uh perceived
02:55:25 as a suggestion that there was that ops should have been engaging in enforcement notwithstanding
02:55:30 the fact that they didn't have the resources to do that safely i would agree that um we shouldn't
02:55:35 be sending out any police officer into the field if they can't be safe right and and so this
02:55:42 particular event was singular and unprecedented as you pointed out earlier and therefore it did
02:55:48 require sufficient and significant resources to restore public safety and something you said
02:55:54 earlier and i just want to expand on it if i can you indicated that it was essentially impossible
02:56:00 to police those on wellington street do you recall making a statement to that effect
02:56:05 yes i held that view throughout the entirety of the blockade and the occupation until we invoked
02:56:10 the emergencies act and and that's because if you compare the sort of lawlessness of the behavior
02:56:16 of the protesters as compared to the resources that were there to deal with that situation
02:56:21 there was a disconnect is that fair it was disproportionately skewed towards those who
02:56:25 were participating in the occupation and um and i believe at times that was a tactical decision
02:56:33 and when police tried to enforce you know they were they were crowded out they were swarmed they
02:56:40 were intimidated in some cases uh reports of of assaults so yes they were overwhelmed
02:56:48 and so when we talk about the operational plans and you've touched on it a couple of times
02:56:53 would it be fair to say that the reason the plans were required was to ensure that if the resources
02:56:58 were provided there was an understanding by those agencies about how they would be used
02:57:03 to safely and productively contribute to an end of the event yes and so it wasn't a question of
02:57:10 undermining the actions of ops it was about ensuring collaboration is that fair yes and
02:57:17 there was never any suggestion that ops should have engaged in an overall operation to end the
02:57:23 event before it had the resources to do that safely i think that makes sense okay i want to
02:57:29 move on and quickly uh discuss a couple of points referenced in your witness statement
02:57:33 in relation to the engagement proposal um i don't think i need to bring up your witness statement
02:57:38 but i'm happy to if that's necessary um deputy minister stewart testified that the purpose of
02:57:44 the draft engagement proposal was to give protesters in ottawa a potential exit strategy
02:57:49 do you agree with that statement uh to the best of my recollection yes that sounds right
02:57:54 and that view came from deputy minister stewart's conversations with the inspector bowden who you
02:58:01 may or may not know is an expert from opp on protester engagement through his plt work are
02:58:06 you aware of that yes i have some recollection of that and he also testified he being uh
02:58:12 deputy minister stewart that the proposal had buy-in from both opp and ops were you aware of that
02:58:18 i believe so yes and you testified earlier that you saw it to be your job during this time or
02:58:25 perhaps the job of your department to ensure that law enforcement had both the resources
02:58:30 and the tools they required that's correct and so in your witness statement you indicated that
02:58:37 there were two issues with respect to why the enforcement or sorry the engagement proposal
02:58:43 didn't come to fruition. The first was questions that were left unanswered about the convoy
02:58:50 organizers, who they are and who was in charge. And the second related to safety concerns about
02:58:56 the person engaged in the proposal. Do you recall saying that? Yes. And in addition to that, the
02:59:01 logistics of where engagement would occur. Okay. So I just want to pull up a couple
02:59:05 documents in relation to that. The first is OTT 405318.
02:59:35 If we could scroll to the bottom.
02:59:42 So this is an email, sorry, up a little so we can see who it's to, yeah.
02:59:47 Sorry, the email at the bottom of the first page.
02:59:52 Yes, there.
02:59:56 So this is an email from someone at Ottawa Police State, Vicki Nelson, to a number of
03:00:00 people, including Deputy Minister Stewart, and as you can see, it says,
03:00:05 good morning on behalf of general counsel, please find attached the list of the convoy leaders and
03:00:09 their affiliates. That's on February 7th. And then if you scroll to the top, it's an email back from
03:00:15 Mr. Stewart saying thank you. And so you would agree with me that there is some level of engagement
03:00:20 with OPS to get the information your department needs about those convoy organizers and their
03:00:26 affiliates to assist with this proposal. It would appear so on the basis of that email exchange. I
03:00:33 i don't uh recall being briefed at the time about who those individuals were or moreover
03:00:40 how those individuals would help to ensure the clearing of the of the convoy but yes on on what
03:00:47 you're showing me it does seem that there is a back and forth between um deputy minister stewart
03:00:52 and uh the ottawa police service on who the leaders of the organization of the organization
03:00:59 might be. Thank you. I'm just going to bring up one last document. This one's pb.nsc.can2963.
03:01:29 If we go to the second page right there, we see the first bullet.
03:01:45 Would the signatory of the letter or the person who goes to the meeting be putting themselves
03:01:49 at risk?
03:01:50 Is that a big concern?
03:01:51 And this is an email exchange between yourself and Mr. Stewart amongst various other people.
03:01:57 this reflect the concern that you're referencing in relation to whether there would be a risk to
03:02:02 the person engaging with this proposal? Sorry, can we just go back up to the top of that document
03:02:07 from Rob to, right, sorry, scroll down a bit, and again.
03:02:15 so the way i i recall this is that the deputy minister stewart is responding to concerns that
03:02:31 i had raised with him about the engagement proposal right so if we scroll then to the
03:02:36 back up to the first page of the document it looks like we have the answers to those questions
03:02:41 um and if we look at the last or the second bullet we see uh the risk to the signatory
03:02:50 and government rep at a later date meeting is low assuming the meeting is virtual so again
03:02:56 would you agree that the concern that you've raised has been addressed as a result of a
03:03:01 conversation between uh deputy minister stewart and his opp expert i would say it begun to address
03:03:09 the concerns. I don't think I was wholly satisfied by the answers that I had gotten at that stage.
03:03:15 In particular, I would have explored the assessment that the risk to the signatory and to the
03:03:24 government rep was low because I needed to understand exactly where the setup was going
03:03:29 to be, how it was going to be undertaken. And bearing in mind at the time, the situation on
03:03:34 the ground was volatile and at times extremely chaotic and certainly with a very compromised
03:03:40 ability to enforce the law. I really wanted to be satisfied that those answers, that those
03:03:48 questions would be answered because if I went back to cabinet and was asked about the engagement
03:03:53 proposal that was being worked up by my deputy minister, I had to be accountable and I had to
03:03:58 be in a position to answer them. So if begun to answer some of those questions, I would say
03:04:02 not completely so you you said i would have as though it were hypothetical did you ultimately
03:04:08 continue that conversation or was the decision made at this point to kind of stop the process
03:04:14 no there was no decision to stop the process um and there were um some ongoing conversations
03:04:20 uh about about engagement and you know ultimately i mean this is february 12 12 25 um the following
03:04:29 day we have an erg and then a cabinet meeting and then the 14th is the day in which it's about a
03:04:37 about a day and a half after this email exchange we saw that the efforts of the city of ottawa
03:04:42 were not successful in the engagement proposal and by then we were into the invocation of the
03:04:48 emergencies act so you would say sort of events overtook and and and the proposal fell by the
03:04:52 wayside i would say there was a lot of work that was going on and i know that the deputy minister
03:04:56 at the time was working very hard to fulfill this task around the engagement proposal but we were
03:05:01 also you know meeting with enforcement officials meeting with cabinet meeting with and engaging
03:05:08 with provincial and territorial colleagues and then yes the the sequence of events that had to
03:05:14 be fulfilled prior to taking a decision on the invocation emergencies act was was pressing okay
03:05:21 thank you those are my questions thank you thank you uh next uh council for former chief slowly please
03:05:39 thank you minister tom curry for the former chief good afternoon um just on the point that was
03:05:48 last raise did you were you briefed on the outcome of the effort to try to engage protesters in
03:05:57 windsor by minister jones or by the opp and the letter from minister jones i recall some information
03:06:04 coming to me about that engagement and it being similarly unsuccessful i recall there being a
03:06:13 report about a letter being circulated to individuals who were part of the blockade
03:06:21 in Windsor and that my recollection is that it did it did not gain any traction with them
03:06:29 and so likewise here in Ottawa a lot of the concerns around the cohesive structure
03:06:35 of the blockade and the occupation raised legitimate concerns about whether or not even if
03:06:41 If a negotiated settlement had been reached, whether or not it would have been successful in disengaging and clearing the block in the occupation.
03:06:50 Thank you. The issue about whether a negotiated resolution was possible, was that taken eventually to cabinet and discussed?
03:07:04 It was discussed at definitely one of the ERGs where, as I said earlier today, my deputy at the time had briefed the members of the ERG on the constitution of the individuals that made up the occupation here in Ottawa and the degree to which they were entrenched and dug in and how we might shake in or loosen that through engagement.
03:07:31 So it was discussed, yes.
03:07:33 And similarly, did you become aware that the mayor of Ottawa had negotiated successfully for the relocation of some of the vehicles away from residential neighborhoods and that that was thought to represent a possible breakthrough?
03:07:51 I do recall there being discussions between Mayor Watson and I think there was an appointed
03:08:00 mediator that he had managed to secure. But I also remember being very concerned that the vehicles
03:08:08 that were clearing out of neighborhoods were actually coming back downtown into the parliamentary
03:08:14 precinct, and that that created a surge of vehicles that were, again, entrenching at the
03:08:23 seat of the federal government. And my concern was that it was actually growing the scale of
03:08:30 the occupation here, and that would have made it even potentially more difficult and challenging
03:08:37 to clear. A couple of things, if I could, just about the resources. The information that you
03:08:42 received about resources came principally from Commissioner Luckey. That's correct. Yes. And
03:08:49 did you become aware that the information that you were receiving from the commissioner
03:08:55 did not accord with the provision of resources to the OPS? Yes. In trilateral meetings with
03:09:05 Mayor Watson and in discussions with some of his officials, I think he articulated a concern that
03:09:11 perhaps there was a need to look more carefully at the number of, one, the number of RCMP
03:09:19 that were actually deployed, and two, what their taskings were. And I know that he
03:09:24 sort of underlined that latter part on a couple of occasions, that it wasn't just the numbers,
03:09:30 it was what were the RCMP going to be dispatched to do. And in fairness, those were questions that
03:09:35 we did put to Commissioner Lucky at the time, and I think she did her best to answer them.
03:09:40 Right. Understood. And you you relied in making you made very I won't take you to them in the time I have, but you made various public statements in response to questions from the from the media about what you were doing, what the federal government was doing to help the Ottawa Police Service.
03:09:54 And in reliance on the information you had from Commissioner Luckey, you made those statements, including naming the numbers of officers, I think at one time, 250 or 275.
03:10:04 In that range. Yeah. The reason why we were trying to we were trying to get the message out was that there were, I think, increasing questions and concerns from the city that they didn't have enough personnel.
03:10:18 And I wanted to communicate that on behalf of the federal government, that we were acting quickly and decisively to respond to those concerns by dispatching RCMP personnel.
03:10:28 And the idea that all you can do in your position, I presume, is rely on those, in this case, the commissioner, to provide you with information to the best of her ability, and then you can rely on that and convey it.
03:10:44 As it turns out, in this case, you learned that the information that you had and conveyed was not accurate.
03:10:51 Well, I would say a couple things.
03:10:53 One, when the commissioner is briefing me, I take that information, you know, specifically around operations very much into account as we're making decisions about what additional resources we can offer.
03:11:08 I was nevertheless interested to know whether or not we needed to do more to coordinate because the mayor and certain officials were saying it wasn't just about numbers, it was about tasking.
03:11:22 So there was a free flowing dialogue there. The numbers was the number, the issue of whether or not to be public about the numbers was also a concern because the commissioner said that she was concerned that if we posted numbers or we published numbers, that that might actually lead to a surge. And so we had to try to find a balance.
03:11:45 Right. And just for the, I'm not going to take it up, but in one of the statements that you made, it's captured at OPS 8365 at page five.
03:11:58 That's just for the record. I don't need it, Mr. Registrar.
03:12:01 You described, again, based on information that you had from the commissioner, that the RCMP had added 275 Mounties in the Ottawa deployment.
03:12:09 And as you pointed out, we learned later, and the commissioner and the deputy commissioner, I think, described it essentially as a mix-up about the numbers, that it wasn't actually that many Mounties.
03:12:21 It was a way of accounting for them that added up shifts and the like.
03:12:26 Did you subsequently become aware that that's how the numbers became, as they said, mixed up?
03:12:31 I was aware that there was an ongoing conversation between the RCMP and the OPS about exactly how many RCMP had been deployed to respond to the occupation and the blockade.
03:12:44 I will say, you know, ultimately, in the lead up to the invocation, my recollection is we did dispatch about a thousand RCMP officers.
03:12:53 Yeah. In the end, it was a massive deployment, which gets to the point you've already touched on.
03:12:58 And Chief Slowly has described this as unprecedented and representing a paradigm shift in the way we think about policing public protests.
03:13:06 Do you agree with that?
03:13:07 Yes.
03:13:08 And in terms of the circumstances in which every one of you found yourselves in, all of the participants,
03:13:13 and I include the convoy organizers who seem not also to have appreciated how many people were going to attend and maybe the nature of their sense of protest.
03:13:23 this this resulted in great frustration at all levels as you've expressed you were you were
03:13:30 frustrated about the pace at which this was being resolved fair i i was concerned about the fact
03:13:36 that for two weeks we could not enforce the law and maintain public safety in the capital and at
03:13:42 border communities across the country yes in your communications in the communications of
03:13:48 some of your ministerial colleagues um do you agree that in hindsight some of the language that
03:13:54 was used even internally was unhelpful to the to the cause because it added uh concerns and doubt
03:14:02 about the if the effectiveness of for example the ottawa police service or the chief in being able
03:14:09 to deal with the problem that had overwhelmed their service i think with the benefit of reflection
03:14:14 And, you know, you always look back and, you know, ask yourself, could you have expressed a sentiment with more diplomacy?
03:14:22 I mean, we've heard earlier today that there were some rather, you know, tense and terse exchanges.
03:14:27 I think it is completely understandable in the moment.
03:14:32 And it wasn't just government and police who were concerned and frustrated.
03:14:36 The people that I was most worried about were Canadians.
03:14:38 And the materialization of counter-protests and just the ability to be able to go about daily lives was my paramount concern.
03:14:49 And the only way we could get life back to normal is if we could uphold the law.
03:14:53 Right. And although you were expressing and Minister Blair expressed, I think, yesterday, and no doubt this has appeared in media because it was found in some of the documents, that he expressed his embarrassment about his former profession of law enforcement because of these circumstances.
03:15:11 We should not take any of those comments as reflecting on the hard work that was done by the OPS or Chief Slowly at the time.
03:15:19 No. And I know how much regard Minister Blair holds for law enforcement. I mean, he was a member of that community for decades. So, you know, look, this is a really tough moment for the country. It was a tough moment for the people who were impacted by the occupation. And at times, yes, emotions were definitely running high and it was challenging. But, you know, ultimately, we got the right players at the table to restore public safety.
03:15:47 Can I just ask one last thing, get your help with this, please, Minister. The issue that you've been asked about in terms of the difference between setting priorities in your role as Minister of Public Safety and interfering with operations.
03:16:02 Do you agree with me that describing for the commissioner the importance of, for example, the circumstances that the country found itself in with border blockades, having that discussion with the commissioner doesn't interfere with operational autonomy?
03:16:20 No, I don't think so. And I think, again, this is an area that is really important to this inquiry, which is to understand where those boundaries are within the context of an emergency.
03:16:32 So it is important that in my job as the Minister of Public Safety that I am holding the RCMP and other line agencies in the public safety portfolio accountable for doing the job of finding ways to restore public safety, exhausting every effort, using statutory authorities which exist, using authorities and resources that exist, and failing that to look and scan at what's left.
03:17:02 And so that is what took us to the Emergencies Act.
03:17:05 But throughout finding that, you know, that right balance of ensuring accountability without crossing the boundary is an extremely important part of this exercise.
03:17:16 I agree with that.
03:17:17 At the level both of the federal and provincial ministry, because both of the commissioner has seen expressions of of priorities by the provincial and federal government as to, for example, the blockade at the Ambassador Bridge.
03:17:31 That's appropriate in your judgment.
03:17:33 Yeah, that's right.
03:17:34 And, you know, I do think that there are some existing conventions that we can look to to have like an important conversation about what those principles are.
03:17:44 And I mentioned one under the police services agreement where there is the relationship between the elected branch of government and police when it comes to forming the opinion that an emergency exists and then the elected government responding to requests from police to deploy resources and additional tools which may not exist in any other statute.
03:18:08 Right. Including the commissioner might think about recommendations for how those priorities can be set so that, for instance, if this occurs again, the an entity or a police service like the Ottawa Police Service isn't caught between the federal and provincial government deciding which which is the first port of call, for example.
03:18:29 I think that's a very important question, because right now the linkages between municipal to provincial police services is clear through provincial statute, through the respective provincial police services acts.
03:18:44 But there is no direct link following that to federal law enforcement resources.
03:18:51 And that was something that we did have to navigate, given the unique circumstances that we found ourselves in.
03:18:58 And I do agree with the suggestion that was put to me earlier from a council for the Ontario Provincial Police that it may be appropriate to look at developing some protocols around that.
03:19:10 Final thing, in your dealings with Chief Slowly, do you agree that, to your observation, he performed his duties in good faith to the best of his abilities?
03:19:19 I think Chief Slowly did the best that he could in those circumstances, yes.
03:19:22 Thank you, Minister. Thank you, Commissioner.
03:19:24 Thank you. Next is the Ottawa Coalition, please.
03:19:28 good morning minister my name is paul champ and i'm counsel for the auto coalition of residents
03:19:48 and businesses hello hi uh i just have some questions for you uh today i'm going to cover
03:19:53 just two issues the time that i have um parliamentary staff are many of them are
03:19:59 residents of downtown ottawa are they not yes and and obviously their workplace was also right in
03:20:05 the middle of this this occupation as well yes and uh were you hearing from parliamentary staff
03:20:11 who were sometimes concerned about coming to work in the circumstances frequently yes and or were
03:20:17 experiencing other personal impacts due to the convoy occupation? Yes. I wonder if I could ask
03:20:24 the registrar to pull up a document, pb.can.0001850. And while he's pulling that up, Minister,
03:20:37 I just want to confirm, Mike Jones, he's your Chief of Staff, is that right? That's correct.
03:20:42 And I gather that Mr. Jones, he was advising you of information that he received from many sources?
03:20:49 Yes.
03:20:50 Okay.
03:20:50 So what I've pulled up here is text messages between Mr. Jones and an Ottawa City Councillor, Matt Luloff.
03:20:59 In blue is Mr. Jones and in grey is Mr. Luloff.
03:21:04 I was wondering if we could just scroll to page two.
03:21:07 Perfect.
03:21:07 And here you'll see in blue, Mr. Jones writes, maybe not for a public avail, but heard about an incident that's pretty angering. And Mr. Luloff says the small woman moved from blocking traffic. And then Mr. Jones writes from one of my staff, I won't be coming into the office while Convoy is there. However, my friend was directly threatened of rape yesterday because she was wearing her mask.
03:21:36 and that is super triggering for me as a survivor of sexual assault i know yasser sharing how
03:21:42 residents feel i gather just that's probably mr knack the mp for downtown ottawa but i would be
03:21:48 remiss if i didn't share that i don't even feel safe dropping my son off at daycare downtown and
03:21:54 kids have not been outside because of fear the educators will be yelled at for wearing a mask
03:21:59 understood uh were you hearing those kinds of stories uh minister i was and as i said i was
03:22:05 hearing them frequently and i was very concerned about the safety of the people that were working
03:22:13 on the hill i mean i think i testified earlier that i had expressed the view that we may want
03:22:20 to consider going completely virtual in parliament because i was worried about the concentration of
03:22:28 people um the fact that some of the expressions that you uh have pointed out today were were
03:22:34 were being targeted again disproportionately at women i was hearing from a lot of of of staff and
03:22:41 and from people on my team along the lines of of these types of incidents and that that really
03:22:47 preoccupied me and as you may recall i mean there was one day on which we did actually have to shut
03:22:53 down parliament i mean that is only the second time in the history of this country where that
03:22:59 has had to occur and that was uh entirely because of security concerns so this was very serious it
03:23:05 was uh if you just scroll to the next page uh mr you see understood and then uh mr jones says
03:23:13 when she reported to police they told her quote well maybe take your mask out when you're walking
03:23:18 outside so reduce any intention to you and um mr law says the city councilor of ottawa says yes
03:23:25 i've heard of these incidents too um so the um were you hearing about that as well that ottawa
03:23:32 police sometimes weren't following up on uh complaints uh from ottawa residents well i i can't
03:23:39 i i i don't know why but i do know that at the time that law enforcement was overwhelmed yeah
03:23:46 And so my interpretation of that was just by the sheer number of incidents, and I think at one point they numbered in the thousands, that it was difficult to investigate or take any kind of appropriate action to hold those who are responsible to account.
03:24:05 But there were hundreds of criminal investigations and charges that were subsequently laid.
03:24:11 Yeah, and indeed, Minister, we've heard a lot of witnesses in this proceeding, including many Ottawa police witnesses, and the thrust of the evidence, as I heard it, is just simply capacity. They were just so overwhelmed. They didn't have an opportunity.
03:24:24 Okay, thank you. Just the second issue I wanted to speak to you about, thank you for that, is, of course, as Minister of Public Safety, the RCMP and CSIS both report to you, is that right?
03:24:39 Yes.
03:24:39 And, Minister, you were receiving a range of information about the risks and threats from those agencies that were being posed by the Ottawa occupation?
03:24:51 Yes.
03:24:52 And we understand, we've heard other evidence, there were former military and law enforcement members who were participating in and assisting the convoy.
03:25:01 You were hearing that information?
03:25:02 I'd heard those reports, yes.
03:25:04 And I gather that was a concern for public safety because those types of individuals would have certain skills and expertise that could, you know, present some logistical or greater threats.
03:25:15 Yes, that's correct.
03:25:17 And now, have you also heard information that former CSIS officers were participating in the protests?
03:25:23 i i don't recall off the off the top of my head but i you know as you pointed out had the
03:25:32 concern generally about individuals and in the who had previously served in the military and
03:25:38 law enforcement for sure um and um would really need to um jig my memory about whether or not
03:25:46 that also included members from the service and were you also hearing information that current
03:25:51 members of law enforcement or military might be participating in the protests well there were
03:25:57 reports about leaks of information um during operations and um you know involved or entailed
03:26:05 some um what appeared to be snapshots of of of texts and so i do recall there being some concerns
03:26:13 about um active members being potentially sympathetic and uh do you know are you aware
03:26:19 minister are there any investigations of those issues internally within uh rcmp or any other
03:26:23 agencies i know that the rcmp um certainly uh wanted to to be sure that they were getting
03:26:31 to the bottom of any potential security um lapses and and that uh those investigations
03:26:38 were conducted okay thank you very much minister those are my questions thank you i know i've still
03:26:43 got some time maybe i'll try to roll it over to the next one that's to be encouraged um i may even
03:26:49 Allow that. So I think we'll take the lunch break now and come back.
03:26:56 Commissioner, if I may, just a couple of comments before lunch.
03:27:00 Rob Kittredge for the Justice Centre for Constitutional Freedoms.
03:27:03 I just wanted to express regarding the removal of my friend, Mr. Miller, this morning.
03:27:11 I wanted to express the Justice Centre's position on asking that you make a decision about his return to the room
03:27:18 during the lunch break and express our support for his room or for his return to the room
03:27:25 at the earliest convenience and i'm a big supporter of constructive communication
03:27:29 and i understand that may not have taken place this morning but i think his clients have a right
03:27:34 to representation here and we'd like to support his ability to cross-examine mr banditino today if
03:27:41 if you can make that decision at lunch that would be very much appreciated on our part
03:27:46 i'm certainly a favor of communication i believe uh that uh the convoy is still represented so it's
03:27:55 not a question of no representation i'm not aware of a request that he returned to uh the uh the
03:28:05 the room but if he's requests it uh i will consider it all right well thank you very much
03:28:10 The Commission is in recess until 2 o'clock.
03:28:16 The Commission is at 14 hours.
03:28:40 Thank you.
03:29:10 Thank you.
03:29:40 Thank you.
03:30:10 Thank you.
03:30:40 Thank you.
03:31:10 Thank you.
03:31:40 Thank you.
03:32:10 Thank you.
03:32:40 Thank you.
03:33:10 Thank you.
03:33:40 Thank you.
03:34:10 Thank you.
03:34:40 Thank you.
03:35:10 Thank you.
03:35:40 Thank you.
03:36:10 Thank you.
03:36:40 Thank you.
03:37:10 Thank you.
03:37:40 Thank you.
03:38:10 Thank you.
03:38:40 Thank you.
03:39:10 Thank you.
03:39:40 Thank you.
03:40:10 Thank you.
03:40:40 Thank you.
03:41:10 .
03:41:40 .
03:42:10 Thank you.
03:42:40 Thank you.
03:43:10 Thank you.
03:43:40 Thank you.
03:44:10 Thank you.
03:44:40 Thank you.
03:45:10 Thank you.
03:45:40 Thank you.
03:46:10 Thank you.
03:46:40 Thank you.
03:47:10 Thank you.
03:47:40 Thank you.
03:48:10 Thank you.
03:48:40 Thank you.
03:49:10 Thank you.
03:49:40 Thank you.
03:50:10 Thank you.
03:50:40 Thank you.
03:51:10 Thank you.
03:51:40 Thank you.
03:52:10 Thank you.
03:52:40 Thank you.
03:53:10 Thank you.
03:53:40 Thank you.
03:54:10 Thank you.
03:54:40 Thank you.
03:55:10 Thank you.
03:55:40 Thank you.
03:56:10 Thank you.
03:56:40 Thank you.
03:57:10 Thank you.
03:57:40 Thank you.
03:58:10 Thank you.
03:58:40 Thank you.
03:59:10 Thank you.
03:59:40 Thank you.
04:00:10 Thank you.
04:00:40 Thank you.
04:01:10 Thank you.
04:01:40 Thank you.
04:02:10 Thank you.
04:02:40 Thank you.
04:03:10 Thank you.
04:03:40 Thank you.
04:04:10 Thank you.
04:04:40 Thank you.
04:05:10 Thank you.
04:05:40 Thank you.
04:06:10 Thank you.
04:06:40 Thank you.
04:07:10 Thank you.
04:07:40 Thank you.
04:08:10 Thank you.
04:08:40 Thank you.
04:09:10 Thank you.
04:09:40 Thank you.
04:10:10 Thank you.
04:10:40 Thank you.
04:11:10 Thank you.
04:11:40 Thank you.
04:12:10 Thank you.
04:12:40 Thank you.
04:13:10 Thank you.
04:13:40 Thank you.
04:14:10 Thank you.
04:14:40 Thank you.
04:15:10 Thank you.
04:15:40 Thank you.
04:16:10 Thank you.
04:16:40 Thank you.
04:17:10 Thank you.
04:17:40 Thank you.
04:18:10 Thank you.
04:18:40 Thank you.
04:19:10 Thank you.
04:19:40 Thank you.
04:20:10 Thank you.
04:20:40 Thank you.
04:21:10 Thank you.
04:21:40 Thank you.
04:22:10 Thank you.
04:22:40 Thank you.
04:23:10 Thank you.
04:23:40 Thank you.
04:24:10 Thank you.
04:24:40 Thank you.
04:25:10 Thank you.
04:25:40 Thank you.
04:26:10 Thank you.
04:26:40 Thank you.
04:27:10 Thank you.
04:27:40 Thank you.
04:28:10 Thank you.
04:28:40 Thank you.
04:29:10 Thank you.
04:29:40 Thank you.
04:30:10 Thank you.
04:30:40 Thank you.
04:31:10 Thank you.
04:31:40 Thank you.
04:32:10 Thank you.
04:32:40 Thank you.
04:33:10 Thank you.
04:33:40 Thank you.
04:34:10 Thank you.
04:34:40 Thank you.
04:35:10 Thank you.
04:35:40 Thank you.
04:36:10 Thank you.
04:36:40 as reconvene la commission okay i think the next up is the government of alberta please
04:36:53 good afternoon sorry i'm having an issue i'm unable to start my video
04:37:09 okay uh do you want to take a minute or do you want to oh there you go
04:37:15 thank you good afternoon minister manichino my name is mandy england i'm counsel for the
04:37:20 government of alberta good afternoon i'd like to just take you back to something that you said
04:37:25 earlier in response to a question from commission council um i believe you said that premier kenny
04:37:30 expressed to you that he had neither the resources nor the tools to deal with the blockades in alberta
04:37:36 and i just wanted to clarify what you meant by tools often in this inquiry that term has been
04:37:42 used to refer to legislative tools or authorities such as you know being able to use the criminal
04:37:46 code and so i was hoping you could clarify what you meant by using that word yeah that's a fair
04:37:51 question what i was referring to were conversations that we had at the beginning of february where he
04:37:57 had indicated that he needed physical tools and assets to help clear the blockade i believe he
04:38:04 was expressing a concern that he was having a really hard time getting access to those assets
04:38:11 through either the rcmp or through provincial police services so he was putting to me the
04:38:18 suggestion that we might be able to assist him through military assets and i i'd said to him that
04:38:27 although statutorily requests for assistance were still within my office's authorities that they
04:38:34 were in practice being addressed by my colleague minister blair in the new ministry that was
04:38:39 created following the 21 election through the ministry of emergency preparedness and i took
04:38:45 that conversation and i committed to then premier kenny that i would relay it to both ministers
04:38:50 anand and blair okay thank you so you meant physical tools as opposed to legislative authority
04:38:56 at that point yes that's correct okay thank you um if i could could i please take you to document
04:39:03 ssm.nsc.can403069
04:39:24 and this is a text um the the portion that i will be reading will be a text between
04:39:30 zita estravas mr blair's chief of staff with mike jones your chief of staff and you can see the date
04:39:37 as we're scrolling is february the 6th at 8 49 p.m and in this text mrs strava says
04:39:45 your dm mike said the following heads up i've spoken to my alberta counterpart and flagged
04:39:50 that we are likely to decline the rfa so request for assistance as you were just mentioning
04:39:55 for a CAF equipment and optics and precedent
04:39:59 and provincial authorities not fully explored reasons.
04:40:03 She was not surprised, but said Minister McIver
04:40:05 would want to call Minister Blair and Mr. Jones says thanks.
04:40:10 And so I'd just like to break down this text.
04:40:14 The reference to your DM would have been a reference
04:40:17 to Deputy Minister Stewart, is that correct?
04:40:20 That's how I read it.
04:40:21 Can I just clarify, though, that you said Zita Estraves,
04:40:24 i note at the top of that text chain that the initials are mj and sk and previously we've read
04:40:31 email or sorry text exchanges uh where sk was sam khalil so i just thought i would
04:40:38 offer that clarification i'm not sure if if that makes any sense to you it makes sense um and i
04:40:44 actually i should have clarified at the beginning myself i believe it's a group chat in which all
04:40:48 three of them were present and so um it the uh indication with the document is that this is taken
04:40:54 from mrs stravis's phone um and then it indicates at the top of her screen the other two individuals
04:40:59 that she's texting with okay does that help clarify yes okay thank you and so uh would you
04:41:06 understand the reference here uh to uh deputy minister stewart what do you understand here um
04:41:14 in terms of what that means of the reference to deputy minister stewart having said that
04:41:18 your ministry was likely to decline the request for assistance because of optics um well i'm not
04:41:25 privy to this exchange um but uh it seems on the on the text that what's being indicated is that
04:41:35 your dm and so i agree with you i i infer that that is dm stewart said the following and a heads
04:41:42 up that dm stewart has spoken to as i interpret it his alberta counterpart and flagged that we
04:41:50 as in the federal government are likely to decline the request for assistance for calf equipment
04:41:56 and optics and precedent and provincial authorities not fully explored reasons of all of those
04:42:04 of all those itemized reasons the one that i have the least insight to is the optics
04:42:08 And to be clear, following my conversation with Premier Kenney, I really did delegate that task to Minister Blair and his office.
04:42:23 And just so that we are clear on the dates here, though, this text does predate that conversation with Premier Kenney, would that be correct?
04:42:32 This is Sunday, February 6th, the day after the request for assistance was sent.
04:42:36 I have to, again, try to jig my memory.
04:42:43 There may have been a conversation with Premier Kenney before the 6th.
04:42:48 It was certainly at the very beginning of February.
04:42:52 In any case, it actually seems to me to make sense that,
04:42:56 given the sequence of events as we've been discussing them this morning,
04:42:59 that I spoke to Premier Kenney,
04:43:01 indicated that Minister Blair would be the lead on processing the request for assistance.
04:43:05 And this then seems to be the follow through, if you will, of that exchange with his staff being on the email chain.
04:43:15 The reason why Deputy Minister Stewart is there is that he is both accountable to both me and Minister Blair.
04:43:25 I see.
04:43:26 And so you don't have any insight then is what you're saying into why Deputy Minister Stewart would have communicated to Alberta that a reason for declining the request was optics.
04:43:36 On the optics part, no, I was not privy to that exchange or that conversation at the time.
04:43:43 And did you have a concern about optics?
04:43:45 I had a concern about clearing Coutts, and I know that Premier Kenney was expressing the impasse that he found himself in and was, I think, engaging me to encourage both Ministers Blair and Anand to strongly consider a request for assistance which would provide him with military assets.
04:44:08 In the context of conversations that I had with Premier Kenney, he'd suggested that his provincial RCMP were saying to him that they had the appropriate equipment to remove the large commercial vehicles that had blockaded Coutts since the beginning of February.
04:44:28 So I think in essence what he was conveying to me is, look, I need help, and one of the ways in which you can help me is by looking very carefully at military assets which could help to clear the blockade in Coutts.
04:44:46 And he said he had a really hard time getting access to tow trucks that were large enough to accomplish that job.
04:44:53 Okay, thank you.
04:44:54 And in terms of the next reason that's given for declining the request, do you have any insight into why Deputy Minister Stewart might have said it was due to precedent?
04:45:07 Again, I'm extrapolating a little bit here, but I assume one of the concerns was that was being weighed in the mix was that if the request for assistance was granted.
04:45:19 in the case of Alberta that potentially others would. And, you know, again, I'm inferring a bit
04:45:28 here, but the use of military assets is something that is done on a very exceptional basis. So I
04:45:38 think there was a concern about potentially opening up the door to other requests to insert
04:45:47 the military and and as you've heard you know there was a lot of reluctance and restraint around
04:45:55 resorting to military um resources and authorities in the context of the blockade and the convoy
04:46:02 okay thank you um and as noted previously the text is sent voter of request was february 5th
04:46:09 this uh text is sent uh on february the 6th indicating that there was a conversation
04:46:15 at some point between the fifth and the sixth between Deputy Minister Stewart and someone
04:46:19 from Alberta would it be fair I also note that nowhere on the list of reasons does it say
04:46:26 that the request for assistance would be denied because CAF equipment wasn't suitable or they
04:46:32 didn't have suitable equipment would it be fair to say that the communication by Deputy Minister
04:46:38 Stewart was made before the possible CAF equipment options were fully explored?
04:46:45 I'm afraid I couldn't answer that. I don't know at that point exactly what Deputy Minister
04:46:50 Stewart has said or not said to the province of Alberta. And again, owing to machinery,
04:46:58 he would have been reporting the RFA to Minister Blair in conjunction with any dialogue that was
04:47:04 going on to minister anand okay thank you had you discussed the suitability of caf equipment
04:47:11 with mr anand before the evening of february the 6th i know we had an exchange i know i flagged for
04:47:17 her that premier kenny had engaged me to uh to to get some assistance and that i anticipated that
04:47:27 there would be an rfa a request for assistance that was submitted to us and i anticipated that
04:47:32 it would uh that it would engage uh her and her authorities so i just wanted to give her a heads
04:47:39 up but as to precisely what equipment was used what was suitable to remove or clear the blockade
04:47:46 in coots um i would have deferred appropriately to uh to her and the calf's assessment about that
04:47:54 in conjunction with minister blair's responsibilities and roles around processing
04:47:58 requests for assistance that related to CAF. Okay thank you very much.
04:48:07 Okay your time is up so if you can try and wrap up please. Okay certainly.
04:48:16 I just wanted to confirm very quickly on one quick point. You're familiar with the
04:48:24 report of the houses of parliament um the emergencies act consultations table february 16th
04:48:30 is that right yes so i'd like to pull up ssm dot can dot five zeros one two four and take you to
04:48:39 page three please and if we could scroll down to the bottom of that page um yep right there
04:48:58 so we can see that there's a discussion of engagement uh and under the first sub-bullet
04:49:04 point the Minister of Public Safety engaged with the Premier of Alberta on February 2nd and 9th
04:49:09 and then with the Premier and the Acting Minister of Justice and Solicitor General on February the 7th.
04:49:16 You also engaged with the Acting Minister of Justice and Solicitor General on February 1st, 5th, and 9th.
04:49:22 Can I confirm with you that in none of those conversations,
04:49:26 did you discuss the potential invocation of the Federal Emergencies Act with either Premier Kenney or Acting Minister Savage?
04:49:35 certainly with uh premier kenny i i can confirm that i would also note that it does confirm what
04:49:43 i had mentioned earlier which is that he and i had had a conversation on february the 2nd as i
04:49:48 recalled it which was prior to the february 6th exchange that you had pulled up earlier so i do
04:49:54 think that that does uh sit more neatly with the chronology and the sequencing of events as we
04:50:00 described um i i would say that my engagements with um the then minister of justice and solicitor
04:50:09 general uh sonia savage um very likely did not in in include any of any express references to
04:50:19 uh the emergencies act but i believe there would have been general references to whether or not
04:50:24 existing tools and authorities beyond physical assets were going to be sufficient to restore
04:50:33 public safety and it would have been in the very general nature so minister savage's evidence has
04:50:39 summarized in our institutional report is that you did not discuss the pedro emergencies act
04:50:44 would that be something that you would agree with or would you yes no i i agree with that yes
04:50:50 okay thank you um and i i know i'm out of time and so perhaps i don't have time
04:50:54 to take you to this um but there are emails um and text exchanges confirming that it was the
04:51:00 conversation on february the 7th um there's a readout um and text exchanges with uh yourself
04:51:07 and minister blair um that it was on that date that you had had the conversation with premier
04:51:11 kenny about the tow trucks with the agreement to relay it uh to minister blair and minister anand
04:51:17 would that uh you know uh jog perhaps your recollection on the chronology of when that
04:51:23 conversation might have taken place that sounds right okay thank you very much those are my
04:51:28 questions okay thanks next if i could call on the union of british columbia indian chiefs please
04:51:38 good afternoon minister my name is cheyenne arnold cunningham and i'm counsel for the union of bc
04:51:44 indian chiefs we've heard a lot today already on the topic of consultation so we'd like to ask did
04:51:52 you consult or cooperate with local First Nations or Indigenous groups during the Freedom Convoy
04:51:59 situation and or the decision to invoke the Emergencies Act? I would say that I've had
04:52:06 broad and ongoing conversations with representatives and leadership within
04:52:12 First Nations and Indigenous communities in my role and in my capacity as Minister of Public
04:52:18 safety i know that um you know in in the lead up to the invocation that a number of colleagues
04:52:27 that sit at the table including ministers miller and haidu are in routine and constant engagement
04:52:34 with first nations and indigenous peoples and the communities so there's a broad range of ongoing
04:52:42 dialogue that uh that that that is undertaken by representatives of the cabinet okay thank you um
04:52:50 from a public safety viewpoint do you think that it's important during a public order emergency
04:52:56 event for public safety canada and police services to engage with first nations in the local
04:53:03 territory i do uh so in your um mandate letter dated december 2021 you were directed um to
04:53:13 implement the united nations declaration of the rights of indigenous peoples which is also known
04:53:17 as undrip um are you familiar with bill c15 which came into force as federal legislation
04:53:25 in june 2021 to adopt and implement under it yes and i would just add to that that we are
04:53:33 leveraging UNDRIP to advance important reforms within the RCMP around First Nations and
04:53:40 Indigenous policing. And so, for example, over the last number of weeks and months in my capacity
04:53:47 as Minister of Public Safety, I have been deeply engaged with First Nations and Indigenous and
04:53:55 Inuit communities for the purposes of ensuring that there are more Indigenous-led public safety
04:54:02 initiatives including the creation of indigenous led police services which are independently
04:54:08 created we have also are in the process of co-developing legislation that expressly 0.99
04:54:16 recognizes that indigenous policing is an essential service so that we can move away
04:54:22 from the current first nations and indigenous policing program based approach to one that is
04:54:27 more structured and enduring and uses UNDRIP and the principles of reconciliation as the anchor for
04:54:35 a relationship between the federal government and First Nations and Indigenous policing. And then
04:54:40 the last thing I would point out is that we are currently debating Bill C-20, which is before
04:54:48 Parliament, which is an act that would create a new Public Complaints and Review Commission,
04:54:53 what we are referring to as the pcrc and we are again very engaged with first nations and
04:55:00 indigenous communities to to ensure that there is representation on that commission so that there
04:55:05 can be appropriate civilian review and accountability in the way that uh in the way that we police and
04:55:11 uphold the law in indigenous communities great thank you so much um i'll actually i'll jump off
04:55:18 um the last um few points that you made there so um speaking of lc20 and the work that that
04:55:25 you're doing there would you agree then that ensuring indigenous participation and presence
04:55:31 on oversight bodies of the rcmp as either decision makers or complaints investigators
04:55:38 would assist in that acceleration of rcmp reform moving forward i agree it's essential and that's
04:55:45 one of the things that um we talk about in our engagements and it's one of the reasons why we are
04:55:51 um co-developing the legislation around uh recognize the recognition that indigenous
04:55:57 policing is an essential service and in order to uh to to uh give life and and breath to that
04:56:04 principle um it means being at the table together uh starting from the premise that there needs to
04:56:10 be a recognition of the inherent right of indigenous peoples to chart out their own courses
04:56:15 to implement their own priorities as it relates to public safety including and leading up to
04:56:21 indigenous police services which are self-governed so both in that co-development
04:56:27 exercise as well as in bill c20 we are very much engaged with first nations and indigenous
04:56:33 people so that so that they are reflected in our institutions including when it comes to public
04:56:38 safety uh what about this the cesus act um are there any plans to ensure modernization of this
04:56:46 legislation in alignment with under it um well the reforms that i'm carrying out in my capacity
04:56:53 as minister of public safety has as part of the overarching mandate given to me by the prime
04:57:00 minister the need to adhere to the principles of reconciliation and part of that is addressing
04:57:06 long, enduring, systemic, structural challenges in the relationship between the federal government
04:57:17 and Indigenous peoples that go back to the origins of colonialism. And that would apply
04:57:26 not only to RCMP and CBSA, but right across all of my line agencies, including CSIS. So
04:57:33 So we are really trying to get at some of those inherent biases, which have led to the overrepresentation of Indigenous peoples interacting with the justice system and using UNDRIP as well to make sure that we reduce and ultimately eliminate those barriers.
04:57:54 Okay, thank you.
04:57:55 So in considering all the work that you're doing to implement UNDRIP and your mandate and Bill C-15
04:58:04 and another piece of your mandate, which is to work in partnership with Indigenous peoples to
04:58:10 advance their rights, considering UNDRIP's implementation, do you think that there should be
04:58:17 than distinct considerations on CSIS and the RCMP and their ability to monitor and respond
04:58:25 with enforcement action against nonviolent and unarmed First Nations people who engage in
04:58:31 activism pertaining to their lawful and distinct rights, even in situations that might be perceived
04:58:38 or profiled as being a public order event. I do, and that's one of the reasons why it's
04:58:45 really important as we implement these reforms that we modernize training to be culturally
04:58:50 sensitive of Indigenous language, of Indigenous culture and tradition and Indigenous laws,
04:58:56 and that is something that we are actively doing right now. And the hope is that by doing so that
04:59:05 we will create a relationship that is based on respect, on the nation-to-nation principles and
04:59:12 values that are informed by UNDRIP. And again, this is not just with regards to the line
04:59:21 agencies in my portfolio. This is work that has to be done right across our government.
04:59:27 Okay, thank you. And then in thinking about the practice of consultation and cooperation
04:59:34 with Indigenous peoples and in the context of responding to a situation like the Freedom
04:59:41 convoy situation or public order emergency events um and looking at it in this context of a multi
04:59:48 jurisdictional landscape and first nations jurisdiction and sovereignty and rights and
04:59:54 territories how is public safety canada then now going to build in consultation and cooperation
05:00:02 in these contexts by listening and that is one of the the the core principles that that that i feel
05:00:10 very strongly about and my department and my officials are in frequent contact building the
05:00:18 relationship on the on the ground i am also traveling with increasing frequency to indigenous
05:00:24 communities across the country to meet in person with indigenous leaders with residents i recently
05:00:30 had the chance to visit with the james smith creed nation following the mass casualty there
05:00:37 at the beginning of or at the end of summer I beg your pardon and so that that direct personal
05:00:44 experience is meant to foster a relationship so that we can move forward with the kinds of reforms
05:00:51 that are inspired and governed by UNDRIP and by the principles of reconciliation which have been
05:00:58 documented in the truth and reconciliation calls to action the mmiwg calls to justice
05:01:06 it's a full court press from the federal government to really move forward with those reforms
05:01:12 but you have to you have you have to meet with people and you have to respect um that inherent
05:01:18 right of of self-government and and that inherent right of self-determination and that includes when
05:01:25 it comes to public safety initiatives and i think by doing so we can break that intergenerational
05:01:31 trauma that that endless cycle that has seen a disproportionate number of indigenous peoples
05:01:36 caught up in in the criminal justice system for example and so that is work that i am deeply
05:01:43 committed to thank you so much for your time today those are all of our questions thank you
05:01:49 to the commissioner as well okay thank you uh next if i could call on the canadian constitution
05:01:56 foundation please commissioner minister uh my name is suji chowdhury i'm counsel for the ccf
05:02:12 minister i i'd like to begin by picking up on a comment you made i believe in during your
05:02:19 examination in chief where you said there's a dialogue between civilian leadership uh and
05:02:26 and law enforcement professionals and so i want to pick up on that idea in the context of your
05:02:32 relationship with commissioner loki and so and in the context of the convoy i'm wondering if you
05:02:39 could just answer you know a few questions i mean did were you getting daily briefings um were you
05:02:46 were you in frequent communication uh with her if you could just give us and i have limited times
05:02:52 if you could just give us a bit of a window into what your interactions were like with her
05:02:55 the short answer is yes and yes and to give you a little bit of detail we would have been meeting
05:03:01 daily on some days multiple times through different briefings um the purpose of those
05:03:08 interactions was to have a dialogue so that i could understand from her exactly what law enforcement
05:03:14 was doing to restore public safety and then ultimately in the lead up to the invocation to
05:03:20 seek some advice so that i could then impart some advice to the government around the invocation so
05:03:25 these were daily um and frequent um conversations that i was having with the commissioner so so when
05:03:32 When the February 7th letter came to you and the Prime Minister from Mayor Watson and Chair Deans
05:03:39 requesting a deployment of RCMP officers, I suppose you would have delivered that letter
05:03:47 to the Commissioner then? We certainly were in constant contact. Just to be clear, it wouldn't
05:03:52 have necessarily been my personal responsibility to transfer it. But there was a very clear line
05:04:00 of communication about the pressures that the Ottawa police service was under to muster the
05:04:06 resources that were necessary to restore public safety. It also would have been clear to Commissioner
05:04:11 Lucky some of the information and the feedback that I was getting from the city of Ottawa
05:04:16 around numbers and tasking and the like. And so those conversations and that dialogue would
05:04:24 have been occurring. Yes. And she was updating you then on her steps to respond to that request
05:04:30 for support she was okay so um mr registrar if you could put up on the screen um the following
05:04:36 document and i apologize it's pbnsc can four zeros two eight seven two underscore rel point zero zero
05:04:47 zero one and minister while this is coming up this is a document that's dated honor about february
05:04:52 10th and it's a memorandum of agreement between the rcmp um and the essentially the lps and the
05:04:59 OPSB about forced deployments. Have you seen this document before? I can't recall if I've
05:05:07 seen this document. Specifically, I am obviously generally aware of the ongoing arrangements and
05:05:13 agreements that were reached. So if we could go down to page three, please, Mr. Registrar.
05:05:20 If you could go to Clause 2.1. There you go. So as you'll see here that Article 2.1, Minister,
05:05:29 if you could just have a quick look at this. It says that the RCMP agreed to deploy to Ottawa
05:05:34 up to 250 members of the RCMP in a number of different capacities. And then it suggests later
05:05:41 down in that article that provision for over 250 members can be made for with subject to mutual
05:05:50 agreement. Yes. And does this seem familiar to you? Yes. Okay. And so I just wanted to
05:05:58 get a bit of clarification from you if you're able to. So when the RCMP was providing support
05:06:03 here to the OPS, to the best of your knowledge, would that be not include RCMP deployments
05:06:10 already, for example, in the parliamentary precinct or out at Rideau Cottage to protect
05:06:16 the prime minister? Well, I think that was certainly one of the issues that was raised by
05:06:22 Mayor Watson and his staff at the time, which was that some of the numbers that were being
05:06:29 reported were inclusive of pre-existing RCMP deployment, for example, in the precinct or
05:06:37 for protection. And so my responsibility at that point in my capacity as Minister of Public Safety
05:06:45 was to relay that to the commissioner to get some clarity about exactly how many we had deployed
05:06:52 and for what purpose and do you recall what that what information came back to you i do i have a
05:06:58 general recollection that one of the concerns that the commissioner had expressed at the time
05:07:02 was that while rcmp members were being dispatched or deployed to the city of ottawa that that it
05:07:12 wasn't clear to her what those taskings would be and whether or not or how exactly it would fit
05:07:18 into the ops's operational plan at the time and that was the feedback that i was getting but what
05:07:24 was clear despite that was that we were sending rcmp and that we were open to sending more rcmp
05:07:31 to support the city of ottawa to restore public safety so so if we could just call up another
05:07:37 document. It's OPB 401014. And so, Minister Mendocino, I'm not sure if you've seen this.
05:07:53 It's a chart of deployments by different police or law enforcement entities in Ottawa, up to
05:08:04 and including the 12th of February.
05:08:08 Have you seen this chart before or something similar to it?
05:08:12 I've not seen this chart.
05:08:13 Sorry, who is the author of this document?
05:08:15 So this is a production by the Ottawa Police Board.
05:08:18 So I'm afraid I can't give you more details
05:08:21 about who put this together,
05:08:22 but this is an evidence before the committee.
05:08:24 This is a City of Ottawa publication is what you're saying.
05:08:27 Well, it might be.
05:08:29 It's something that was put into evidence
05:08:31 by the Ottawa Police Board.
05:08:32 I can't speak to them, sir, about where they, how they generated it.
05:08:35 Okay. I don't recognize this document.
05:08:37 Okay. Well, then, then look, let's, let's soldier on. So if you look under regular members,
05:08:44 federal RCMP, yes, Mr. Registrar, thank you. It sort of says at the end of this line that 167
05:08:53 officers were deployed. And so that, I mean, were you aware of that figure on that day?
05:09:01 Well, setting aside the exact time frame, I am familiar with the initial figure of about 150
05:09:07 in that range. And again, you've heard previously that there was some ongoing back and forth on
05:09:15 exactly how many and when, but that was one figure that had came to me early on in that range.
05:09:20 In that range. And so, I mean, you'd agree that on his face, it does appear that these numbers
05:09:25 are lower than the 250 that are in the agreement I showed you.
05:09:29 Well, I agree that on the face of this document, that that is lower than $250,000, but again, without knowing more about the authorship or the origins of this document, it is very difficult for me to testify as to its accuracy.
05:09:42 And you're not able to say, and I think I know the answer, sir, but I have to do it for the record, you're not able to say of that $167,000, how many were at Rideau Cottage and on the parliamentary precinct?
05:09:51 I am not.
05:09:52 Okay.
05:09:54 Minister, I'd like to just turn to another theme, if I could.
05:09:57 And so this morning you made a number of statements.
05:09:59 You said it was virtually impossible to enforce the law in Wellington.
05:10:04 Wellington falls within the jurisdiction of the OPS.
05:10:07 The RCMP could not go and assert itself in Wellington to bring things under control.
05:10:12 Is that fair?
05:10:13 Yes.
05:10:14 Okay.
05:10:14 And so, Minister, were you able to, I know you're very busy,
05:10:18 but were you able to review or be briefed on Commissioner Lookie's cross-examination last week?
05:10:24 um i i don't know that i was briefed i may i may have read some some general reports about it in
05:10:30 the media so so my co-counsel went through some issues um in respect of those themes with
05:10:36 commissioner looking i just want to take you to what she said um if you wouldn't mind and so this
05:10:41 is transcript 23 mr registrar and we're on to page we're going to begin at page 241
05:10:47 and minister minister i know you're a member of the law society of ontario so this will be a bit
05:10:56 there'll be a bit of legal questioning here okay
05:10:59 great so if you can start at line five super okay so so my colleague mishan mcganathan was asking
05:11:10 questions of commissioner loki so i just want to take you through some of the back and forth if i
05:11:14 could. So my colleague says, my co-counsel, okay, so you'll agree that the RCMP officers
05:11:19 have the power to enforce the criminal code, for instance, and the commissioner says yes.
05:11:25 Then my co-counsel says, right, and they always have the power to enforce the code.
05:11:29 It's just part of what they're allowed to do. And the commissioner says, yes.
05:11:33 And then if you could scroll down, Mr. Registrar, my co-counsel says, right,
05:11:39 they don't need to be sort of the local police in a jurisdiction. This is a power they always
05:11:44 have and the commissioner says yes and then my colleague says uh right and there's nothing in
05:11:52 the code for example that says an rcmp officer can't enforce the criminal code in one particular
05:11:59 place they can enforce that anywhere in canada and then this and the commissioner looky is not sure
05:12:05 uh that's the and i'll let you read her response there sir and when you're done let us know and
05:12:11 i'll go to the next page and commissioner i know i'm a little bit over time but i think this is an
05:12:18 important point it goes to the jurisdiction in wellington um mr minister can we go to the next
05:12:24 page so if you could go to page uh 242. mr commissioner just i just do think it is important
05:12:30 that that the commissioner's evidence not be put that she wasn't sure but that she articulated that
05:12:36 that power she was describing was if you were to find committing um a criminal code offense just a
05:12:43 little bit witnesses not of course get past that of course it didn't mean i didn't mean to mislead
05:12:47 so i i take my friend's point um and so if we gave this go down to um to my colleague's next
05:12:55 question so okay so just to use sort of ability of a silly example if we have an rcmp officer
05:13:01 that's standing on wellington street in ottawa and they see someone committing an offense under
05:13:05 the criminal code they don't need to call up the ops to arrest the person they could go and arrest
05:13:11 the person themselves and uh and the commissioner answered yes and so we're sort of we're running
05:13:18 we're past time so i just want to ask you so that we put to the commissioner a number of questions
05:13:24 about the scope of rcmp officers under the rcmp act particularly section 18a and would you would
05:13:32 Do you have any reason to think that Commissioner Luckey is incorrect here?
05:13:37 I think she's right in saying that if any peace officer sees that the law is being broken under the criminal code,
05:13:46 that they may use their common law authority to effect an arrest.
05:13:52 But because of the important conventions around respecting jurisdiction and recognizing that,
05:13:59 and certainly in the province of Ontario, that there are municipal police services that are set
05:14:04 up under the Police Services Act, that they would not act unilaterally. And certainly,
05:14:12 and I hope I'm not going too far in trying to ascertain your line of questioning here,
05:14:18 but it would be somewhat chaotic for the RCMP to simply insert themselves unilaterally into
05:14:24 Wellington Street and start affecting arrests without coordinating very closely with the OPS
05:14:30 and the OPP. So that is why so much of the energy was around understanding what the operational plan
05:14:36 is, notwithstanding that, in theory, yes, this line of questioning is correct. You know, an RCMP
05:14:43 officer could affect an arrest if they saw the law being broken under the criminal code. Okay,
05:14:48 well, Commissioner, I'm well over time. And thank you, Minister Mendocino. Okay, thank you.
05:14:51 Next is the Democracy Fund, JCCF, please.
05:15:10 Good afternoon, Mr. Commissioner. Good afternoon, Minister Mendocino.
05:15:13 My name is Antoine Dailly. I'm counsel to Citizens for Freedom, representing the protesters in Windsor, Ontario.
05:15:20 I'd just like to take you through two aspects today.
05:15:23 First, some of the considerations that were made by you, Mr. Minister,
05:15:26 in considering some of the legal alternatives other than invoking the Emergencies Act
05:15:30 to deal with the protest, and also some specific questions about your communications
05:15:34 with the Windsor governance structure.
05:15:39 Just for the record, do you remember the mandate letter, jcf.0000189?
05:15:47 I don't think we need to pull that up, but that's the mandate letter you received on December 16th of 2021 from Prime Minister Trudeau.
05:15:55 Do you recall that letter?
05:15:56 Yes.
05:15:57 And I think on the fourth page, fifth bullet from the bottom, it mandates you to continue working with the Minister of Health and the Minister of Transport to protect the health and safety of Canadians through safe, responsible, and compassionate management of the border with the United States and other ports of entry into Canada.
05:16:14 Do you recall that portion of your mandate?
05:16:16 Yes.
05:16:17 And so I take it that the Minister of Health, the Minister of Transport, you work closely together, and that would be Minister Duclos and Minister Al-Gabrak. Is that correct?
05:16:25 Yes.
05:16:26 And is it also your understanding that Minister Duclos is an economist by formal educational training?
05:16:32 Yes, with an academic background, yes.
05:16:34 And then you're obviously a lawyer by background and former Crown prosecutor.
05:16:38 So with respect to the Freedom Convoy and the protest, would it be fair to say that, you know, a trucker protest, protesting about health mandates with concerns about public safety and border concerns, that this group between the three of you as part of your mandate, you were the key ministers involved in dealing with some of the concerns raised by the convoy.
05:17:05 Is that correct?
05:17:06 I would say there were a number of ministries that were engaged by the convoy and the blockade, not only my colleague Ministers Al-Gabra and Haidu, but equally, as you heard previously, Minister Blair under emergency preparedness, Minister Leblanc under intergovernmental affairs, and many others.
05:17:28 Minister. Sorry, just got limited time here. Yes and no answers where we can and where we need to
05:17:33 elaborate just as concisely as possible, please. If we could pull up a document ID, pb.can.00001868.
05:17:44 And this is from the emails that were received last night.
05:17:50 Do you recall hearing Jason Kenney's position that the trucker vax policy is obviously just
05:17:57 dumb political theater was that ever brought to your attention um well i'll wait to see what the
05:18:02 document um says to refresh my memory and sorry who who is uh this text exchange with or between
05:18:22 uh if we could scroll down so it should be the third attachment in the sixth email that was
05:18:30 received from mr brousseau last night there it is the trucker vax policy is obviously just dumb
05:18:38 political theater calling them nazis hasn't exactly helped do you do you recall being
05:18:43 informed of miss uh of premier kenny's position on this i i recall seeing that that was uh minister
05:18:49 LeBlanc's looks like a cut and paste of what Premier Kenney had relayed to him. Okay, and I
05:18:56 take it you disagree with Premier Kenney's position? Yes. But is it true, though, that the
05:19:02 Liberal platform in September of 2021 dealt with a mandatory vaccination policy across the entire
05:19:09 federal service and on federally regulated transportation? Yes, we put that to the electorate
05:19:15 in the 21 election and i believe you had 33 roughly of the popular vote there is that correct
05:19:22 well to the best of my recollection yes your your number's right on that okay and so would you say
05:19:27 then that that in part this this mandate or this must do activity uh is rooted at least in part in
05:19:33 a political or ideological purpose well it was part of i think two important things first the
05:19:40 best available medicine evidence and science that we got and it was our belief then and it continues
05:19:45 used to be now, that vaccines were the best way out of the pandemic. And secondly, in the lead up
05:19:51 to the 21 election, there was a very, I think, robust debate among all Canadians. I'm trying
05:19:59 to figure out what specific knowledge you had in dealing with the Minister of Health here. So
05:20:04 would it be fair to say that under the Department of Public Safety and Emergency Preparedness Act,
05:20:10 You are given the responsibility of exercising leadership at a national level relating to public safety and that the Department of Health has has a similar aspect in terms of promotion and preservation of health.
05:20:22 So what I'm trying to get at here is the separation of powers a little bit, because we did have an unprecedented emergency situation with the pandemic in Canada where some of these vaccines were pushed through very quickly.
05:20:32 And so, you know, perhaps by way of analogy, you know, if there's a new peanut that's coming on the market that may have been genetically modified, it would clearly be within the purview of the Ministry of Health to assess the safety of that.
05:20:44 But was there ever a consideration where, let's say, you're now implementing a mandate that results in 90% of Canadians ingesting this product?
05:20:53 Does that concern your mandate under public safety at all?
05:20:56 Well, first, there was a lot of thoughtful deliberation and research done prior to the decision of launching and implementing a national vaccine strategy.
05:21:08 But while there is a common objective between the public safety ministry and health in protecting the health and safety of Canadians,
05:21:20 public safety has a different mandate which includes um the law and there are agencies
05:21:27 under my portfolio that are responsible for upholding the law i understood so so minister
05:21:32 so so there is a little bit of overlap and and this is some of this overlap could have been
05:21:36 discussed through your mandate working with the minister of health and transport is that is that
05:21:40 fair to say well there were again very robust uh communications within uh government throughout
05:21:46 the pandemic and throughout the convoy and um that includes with uh minister leblanc minister
05:21:51 al gabra understood if we could pull up mr registrar jcf0000183
05:22:05 so this here is the regulatory decision summary published by health canada on september 16th of
05:22:10 2021 i believe this was the second uh that the purpose of this document was to transition the
05:22:15 approval of some of these vaccines from being authorized under an interim order to being
05:22:21 authorized under i believe it is schedule division eight of the foods and drugs act
05:22:25 so if we could go to page six at the first paragraph there
05:22:32 it states that an important limitation of the data is the lack of information on the
05:22:36 long-term safety and effectiveness of this of the vaccine were you were you made aware of this this
05:22:41 concern? I recall being privy to conversations where there were discussions about the efficacy
05:22:52 of vaccinations and also how there were other considerations around the administration of them
05:23:01 as part of an overarching health policy to deal with the pandemic. Right. And would you also agree
05:23:06 with me that because of the time constraints, because of the emergency situation that this
05:23:11 rollout had to occur within that that it did not go through the the regular rigorous testing that
05:23:16 it otherwise would have and if we could scroll to the last sentence of sorry just before you go on
05:23:21 i i just want to be clear i actually don't agree uh with that which part the last part that you
05:23:27 said in your question where you asked me if i agree that it was that it was sped up and rushed
05:23:31 and you linked it i think to um the events of the blockade and the convoy and i disagree with that
05:23:37 There was a lot of work that was done in the lead up to the rollout of the national vaccination strategy that predated the convoy.
05:23:45 So if we could look at page four of eight, was ever brought to your attention that in terms of the safety of evaluation for adolescents, only 660 adolescents, that's aged between 12 to 15, only 660 adolescents that have been followed for two months formed the basis of Health Canada's conclusion that this was safe or effective for this particular age group?
05:24:09 And were you aware that this is one of the concerns that was being brought by the convoy?
05:24:13 I know that in my conversations with Minister Duclos and other colleagues who participated both at the COVID committee as well as broader cabinet, that those conversations were informed by the best available science and data in the lead up to the national vaccination strategy.
05:24:29 okay and and if we can one more document here quickly jcf00008187
05:24:37 were you aware that at least our united our counterparts in the united states
05:24:43 that when they approved the pfizer biontech vaccine they stated that they determined that
05:24:49 an analysis analysis of spontaneous post-marketing adverse events reported under the fdca would not
05:24:55 be sufficient to assess known serious risks of myocarditis and pericarditis and identify an
05:25:01 unexpected serious risk of subclinical myocarditis and that in fact they ordered a battery of tests
05:25:06 requiring Pfizer to study adverse effects until at least May 31st of 2027. The question I'm trying
05:25:12 to get at, well were you aware of that first of all? I've not seen this document before. Okay and
05:25:17 so so my question to you is if you're exercising leadership within the realm of public safety and
05:25:23 and you have the statutory power to establish strategic priorities and exercise powers to
05:25:29 initiate recommend coordinate implement or promote policy programs or projects relating to public
05:25:34 safety was there ever any consideration of uh of initiating a review perhaps to of some of these
05:25:44 safety concerns because i understand that other countries had limited the use of some of these
05:25:49 vaccines for a under age 18 or under age 30 and that perhaps by exercising some of those powers
05:25:54 leading up to the entrenchment of the convoy or even you know as late as bring it to a question
05:26:00 please the 13th did you ever consider ordering or initiating additional tests to satisfy the
05:26:07 concerns of some of these protesters that that would not have been within my mandate my my mandate
05:26:12 was to make sure that we protected um public safety through the enforcement of the law and
05:26:17 this is a commission inquiry about the circumstances that led to it i'm not saying
05:26:22 your question is irrelevant i'm saying that would be a question that would be best put to the
05:26:25 minister of health and and was there any discussion between you and the minister of health about
05:26:29 perhaps engaging proactively in some of these additional studies to alleviate some concerns
05:26:34 of canadians well throughout the circumstances of the blockade and occupation i was in touch with
05:26:40 all of my colleagues in cabinet including minister duclos okay and i understand i'm running out of
05:26:45 time here but just quickly a couple you have run out of time so you're gonna have to focus here
05:26:50 understood uh can we pull up document win 0002295 i believe these are text messages between you and
05:26:57 mayor drew dilkins first like to take a look at page four and this question was put to uh mayor
05:27:04 dilkins earlier with respect to opp resources so just waiting for mr registrar here
05:27:23 page four so is it is it your unders it appears that it's your understanding on february 9th at
05:27:28 7 35 p.m that chief mizuno had not requested any additional police officers from the opp
05:27:34 uh was that your understanding and if so where did you attain that understanding
05:27:40 um this exchange is about trying to clear up what i think is um a miscommunication or
05:27:47 a misunderstanding between uh different levels of enforcement and um the city of windsor and so
05:27:54 what i'm really trying to get to the bottom of there is whether or not additional help had been
05:27:59 turned down by the city of windsor but it says apparently your police chief just told so i'm
05:28:05 the question is where did you ascertain that that belief for that understanding i am trying to
05:28:13 recall whether or not that was information that i got um either directly from uh commissioner
05:28:19 lucky or from other sources off the top of my head i can't say okay and lastly just on page
05:28:26 20 here last question here mr commissioner so on february 14th at 11 57 a.m says that to the extent
05:28:35 you so here being mr dilkins you can be supportive of any additional authorities that gets windsor
05:28:40 the resources you need to keep the bridge open people safe that would be great uh is it your
05:28:45 understanding that drew dilkins mayor drew dilkins invoked the city-wide emergency before or after
05:28:51 this text message um off again off the top of my head can't recall um but i i know first that the
05:28:58 ontario government had declared a state of emergency on the friday uh before which would have been um
05:29:06 i'm just doing so i think on the 14th the city of windsor declared an emergency by
05:29:10 by word yeah that sounds that sounds about right but recall but yeah the ontario the ontario
05:29:16 government had declared the friday before okay and last one here where you reference resources
05:29:22 do these resources include money um he he and i and other uh representatives of of the government
05:29:29 have had a conversation around uh potential compensation for losses suffered to businesses
05:29:34 and residents arising out of the blockade yes understood okay and i'm out of time so thank
05:29:38 you for the indulgence uh those are my questions thank you next uh the uh ccla please
05:29:46 Good afternoon, Mr. Mendicino, Minister Mendicino, my name is Kara Zwiebel, I am counsel for
05:30:15 the Canadian Civil Liberties Association. Good afternoon. I want to ask you about an area that
05:30:22 we haven't really talked about, and I'm going to ask for a document to be pulled up, and I have to
05:30:26 apologize. I didn't ask for this document in advance, but I don't think it'll be controversial.
05:30:30 it's just the emergency measures regulation it's com 50s 854
05:30:41 um and i just i think um you've probably given um some of the clearest testimony we've heard about
05:30:49 um this issue of the the separation of church and state the relationship between law enforcement
05:30:55 and government um and i think what you've said is that um you know there needs to be good lines of
05:31:02 communication open uh but that uh it's not government's role to direct the police and what
05:31:08 to do in an operational sense is that accurate yes okay um now in in the case of the um of the
05:31:16 emergencies act and the the enactment of these emergency measures regulations um would you agree
05:31:21 with me that ultimately um what these regulations do is empower law enforcement give law enforcement
05:31:31 more tools in which to exercise their authorities and discretion i would agree and just add tools
05:31:37 that otherwise don't exist in any other law right and um in the case of we won't pull them up but
05:31:44 But the other, the economic, the other side of this, the economic measures that were enacted,
05:31:51 in that case, it empowered both law enforcement and financial institutions with new powers.
05:31:59 Yes.
05:31:59 Okay.
05:32:02 And would you agree that although this is a formal way of doing this, by using the extraordinary
05:32:09 step of invoking the act this is a very clear message being sent by government to law enforcement
05:32:15 about what the law that needs to be enforced is right now in this moment these are the laws that
05:32:22 we need to be enforced and we need you to enforce them i think that's fair yes okay thank you um
05:32:29 now if we can scroll down a little bit mr clerk thank you um i think it's the second uh sorry
05:32:36 third page sorry next page a little bit further
05:32:46 okay so there's a definition of critical infrastructure and then keep scrolling please
05:32:52 just stop right here thank you so this is the prohibition on public assembly and i know you
05:32:57 said in examination by commission council you talked about your concerns about some of the
05:33:04 the protesters and their links to extremist groups, but you also said a few times that there
05:33:10 were a large number of people there who were there to exercise their lawful rights to protest.
05:33:16 Is that fair?
05:33:17 Yes, it is.
05:33:19 And that, in fact, I think you said there were thousands who were there for legitimate
05:33:22 and lawful purposes.
05:33:24 I mean, that was my lay estimation, but I believe that there were many Canadians who
05:33:30 were co-mingled with other elements of the occupation and the blockade, who were there
05:33:36 to express legitimate differences of opinions and views as it related to federal government policy.
05:33:45 Okay, thank you. Now, I know when the government made the announcement about the use of the Act
05:33:50 and what orders would be enacted, it talked about the measures being time limited because there
05:33:56 is an expiration date, so to speak, on the use. It also talked about the measures being
05:34:01 proportional. Would you agree with me that the definition of a public assembly, which is
05:34:08 prohibited, and if we can scroll down so you can see the whole thing, maybe we can just make it a
05:34:14 bit smaller so that it'll all fit. Thank you, Mr. Clerk. So a person can't participate in a public
05:34:22 assembly that may reasonably be expected to lead to a breach of the peace by the serious disruption
05:34:28 of the movement of persons or goods or the serious interference with trade let's just stop at that
05:34:34 one um you you might be aware uh as an mp coming from uh the province of ontario that um we've had
05:34:41 some labor strikes uh and threats of labor strikes in the last couple weeks um would you agree with
05:34:48 me that during the um existence of these orders uh a strike would likely be contrary to these orders
05:34:59 well i i do think that um we need to be very careful and circumscribed in defining what the
05:35:08 powers are so the prohibition of public assembly as it is itemized under the regs
05:35:15 does direct that people can't be part of a public assembly that may be reasonably expected to lead
05:35:22 to a breach of the peace by the serious disruption of the movement to persons or goods
05:35:26 or the serious interference with trade. Let me pause there and say that that is directly
05:35:31 responsive in part to CBSA's concerns around the lack of authority to clear roads adjacent
05:35:39 to critical infrastructure in the form of the border. And you can draw a straight line to the
05:35:45 rationale for that power. That having been said, in addition to that, the regs still have to comply
05:35:50 with the Emergencies Act, which is the parenting statute. And what that says is that, yes,
05:35:58 all of the individual rights that are there around freedom of assembly, including the right to
05:36:05 protest are preserved so long as you do not then cross the boundary into activity which could pose
05:36:15 a threat of serious violence. And that is the delineating limitation to how it is that we both
05:36:25 protect charter rights while at the same time giving circumscribed targeted powers to restore
05:36:31 public safety so you have to read this provision in in in my opinion in conjunction with the
05:36:37 parenting statute. Okay but but I mean the this definition is what law enforcement is going to
05:36:43 use when they go out and and decide whether someone is in violation of the order and this
05:36:48 is the document that perhaps a very diligent citizen would look to to find out what is permitted
05:36:55 Is that fair?
05:36:56 It is, but, you know, we count on law enforcement to interpret the law correctly.
05:37:01 And as part of the rolling out of these regulations and these circumscribed powers, it would have been part of the plan to implement that there is a respect for the right to lawful assembly.
05:37:16 In any event, by the time these regs had come into force, certainly it was clear to those who were still there that law enforcement had directed,
05:37:28 government officials had directed that this was no longer lawful because it was no longer safe.
05:37:33 Understood. So I'm not so concerned about whether there was a question that this applied to, for example, Wellington Street.
05:37:42 I'm concerned about whether there was a question about where else this might have applied
05:37:45 and the potential that it might have applied to a range of other places.
05:37:50 Would you agree with me that there's nothing in these orders that geographically restricts their scope?
05:37:55 There's nothing that says they're confined to Ontario or they're confined to border crossings?
05:38:01 I think by inference, you could say that certainly under sub 2.1 and the subparagraph A,
05:38:10 that there is some geographic circumscription there
05:38:16 and that there are a limited number of places
05:38:18 where you can seriously disrupt the movement of persons or goods
05:38:23 or the serious interference with trade.
05:38:25 And I think the border would be one.
05:38:28 Okay.
05:38:28 I want to just move to one other area.
05:38:31 You mentioned in your testimony
05:38:33 when you were being questioned by commission counsel,
05:38:35 and I think this is the first that we've heard about this,
05:38:37 that um and i think you said it was on the 13th this was when commission council took you to
05:38:43 um the email from commissioner lucky uh that uh you know that laid out sort of the current status
05:38:49 of things um and uh you talked about a a private conversation that you had with commissioner lucky
05:38:56 where she told you about the situation in coots and shared her concerns um and i think you said
05:39:01 that was a um a threshold moment for you um so and i appreciate that um that that would be a
05:39:08 frightening set of circumstances to to hear about um the the timeline of events is that we have the
05:39:15 the irg on the 13th in the afternoon um and then the cabinet meeting uh the evening of the 13th
05:39:23 um and then on the morning of the 14th the first minister's meeting and then the the acts and vote
05:39:28 First of all, there's no cabinet meeting between the First Minister's meeting and the invocation of the act.
05:39:33 Is that correct?
05:39:34 That's right.
05:39:34 Okay.
05:39:36 The morning of the 14th, I think you would have learned that the Ambassador Bridge blockade had been cleared
05:39:44 and that arrests had been made and that the police had executed a safe operation in Coutts leading to arrests.
05:39:52 That was true, but I would add that there were reports of flare-ups.
05:39:55 There was an exchange between the mayor and I. There were also public reports following that and some information that we had received in subsequent briefings about the threat of the blockade coming back to the Ambassador Bridge.
05:40:10 I would point out that it was a recurring theme over those two weeks that progress was not linear, that it was very much a whack-a-mole kind of dynamic.
05:40:18 And the idea was not only to restore public safety, but to maintain it.
05:40:24 And the objective of invoking the Emergencies Act was to maintain law and order to stop the whack-a-mole. 1.00
05:40:31 Understood. I know you said in your testimony to Commission Council that one of the concerns about Coutts was that it could lead to a chain reaction.
05:40:40 But would you agree with me that that didn't happen?
05:40:43 that when the arrests were made in coots, actually many of the other protesters decided to leave
05:40:49 because they actually weren't comfortable being associated with that level of violence.
05:40:54 They had different goals.
05:40:55 And once they learned that that's what was going on, they decided to voluntarily leave.
05:41:00 I agree, and I was relieved.
05:41:01 But I was also dealing with the best information available to me at the time
05:41:06 and surveying the landscape and being mindful that there were reports of guns and firearms
05:41:12 that were present at other locations
05:41:17 and not knowing exactly how it was
05:41:20 that the operation in Coutts was going to play out at that time
05:41:23 and bearing in mind the sensitivities,
05:41:26 the fact that the situation was combustible,
05:41:29 that the individuals that were involved in Coutts
05:41:33 were prepared to go down with a fight
05:41:35 that could lead to the loss of life,
05:41:38 that if that had happened and that occurred,
05:41:40 it still remains an open question in my mind as to whether or not it would have triggered
05:41:44 other events across the country. And so that's why I, in my mind, it was very much,
05:41:51 it was a threshold moment. Okay. I understand. I think I understand what you're saying. And I
05:41:55 just, I know I'm out of time. I just want to just clarify. I understand you're saying if that had
05:42:01 happened, but would you agree with me that the arrests happened in Coots and that didn't happen?
05:42:07 What happened was that we leave Cootes and that situation, at least that particular location, was resolved for the time being.
05:42:17 I think you may be putting it a little optimistically.
05:42:20 I know that after the Cootes takedown, that there were still engagements there.
05:42:28 I do agree that things did start to dissipate and disengage in Cootes.
05:42:34 But I also recall that people were still very much dug in in other parts of the country, including here in the nation's capital.
05:42:41 Thank you, Minister. Thank you, Commissioner.
05:42:46 Next call on the City of Windsor, please.
05:42:49 Mr. Commissioner, if I could just ask if I don't know if people still use the expression the division bells are ringing.
05:42:59 Oh, so we need a short break.
05:43:00 yes unfortunately the timing won't be precise uh but it would be timely now to break if we
05:43:07 want to do it in between examiners because it appears that otherwise it would be right in the
05:43:10 middle of the next examination okay so we'll take uh 10 minutes is that all that's needed or is it
05:43:16 longer we would hope that 10 minutes is all that's needed we're just at the end of question period
05:43:22 and so it will alert if it'll be any longer than that okay well i'll uh we'll take a 10 minute
05:43:27 break if it needs to be more uh please uh thanks your honor otherwise you'd have to watch me vote
05:43:34 digitally and i'm not sure i'd be allowed to do that
05:43:41 the commission is in recess for 10 minutes
05:43:57 Thank you.
05:44:27 Thank you.
05:44:57 Thank you.
05:45:27 Thank you.
05:45:57 Thank you.
05:46:27 Thank you.
05:46:57 Thank you.
05:47:27 Thank you.
05:47:57 Thank you.
05:48:27 Thank you.
05:48:57 Thank you.
05:49:27 You