Juno News - October 18, 2023


Media and politicians blame Israel for failed Palestinian rocket

Mentioned
Liberals promise bill regulating "online harms" Pro-Palestine protesters HATE Justin Trudeau

Episode Stats


Length

47 minutes

Words per minute

164.38

Word count

7,743

Sentence count

367

Harmful content

Misogyny

1

sentences flagged

Toxicity

1

sentences flagged

Hate speech

17

sentences flagged


Summary

Summaries generated with gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ .

500 people were killed in a single Israeli airstrike on a hospital in Gaza City, Palestinian health ministry says. But is this an accident or a deliberate act of war? And what does Justin Trudeau and others have to say about it?

Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 Transcription by CastingWords
00:00:30 Thank you.
00:01:00 welcome to canada's most irreverent talk show this is the andrew lawton show brought to you by true
00:01:20 north hello and welcome to you all another live edition of canada's most irreverent talk show
00:01:30 this is the andrew lawton show on true north on this wednesday october 18th 2023 we are coming
00:01:38 to you live in the midst of a bit of a strange standoff between israel and hamas and i'm not
00:01:45 talking about the conflict that has taken several lives now, instigated by Hamas and its brutal 1.00
00:01:52 attacks on Israeli civilians a week and a half ago. But I'm talking about this, he said, she said,
00:01:58 about who was responsible for this massive attack, an airstrike on a hospital in Gaza. Now,
00:02:08 targeting civilians, targeting a hospital is illegal. It is incredibly wrong morally,
00:02:14 forgetting about norms and standards in international law.
00:02:17 And as you saw from some of the headlines,
00:02:19 an Israeli attack on the Al-Ali Baptist Hospital claimed 500 lives.
00:02:25 Now, this was a narrative that took hold.
00:02:28 You very quickly saw condemnations of this from people all over the place,
00:02:32 including in Canada and certainly including the media.
00:02:36 And it was interesting, for example,
00:02:38 this is CBC's original headline on this whole thing.
00:02:42 hundreds killed in Israeli airstrike on Gaza City Hospital,
00:02:47 Palestinian health ministry in Gaza says.
00:02:50 Now, they're attributing to the claim,
00:02:52 but when they credit the Palestinian health ministry in Gaza,
00:02:55 they're crediting Hamas.
00:02:57 Anytime someone quotes a so-called official in Gaza
00:03:00 at any department of government, they are quoting Hamas.
00:03:03 So the media, which would normally be skeptical about things,
00:03:06 or at least should be, was taking Hamas at face value.
00:03:09 Notably, the very serious claim that an Israeli airstrike killed hundreds at a hospital in Gaza.
00:03:17 The New York Times also went for this.
00:03:19 Now, in their case, they went through several iterations of this,
00:03:22 in which at first they took the claim at face value in the same way that CBC did,
00:03:27 and then they walked back a little bit more, and then they walked back beyond that.
00:03:32 Oh, yeah, you get the whole before, after, and after that.
00:03:35 Israeli strike kills hundreds in hospital, Palestinians say.
00:03:39 At least 500 dead in strike on Gaza Hospital, Palestinians say.
00:03:44 And at least 500 dead in blast at Gaza Hospital, Palestinians say.
00:03:49 So by the time you get to the end of it, it was just a blast that took place.
00:03:52 It wasn't an Israeli airstrike or an airstrike at all.
00:03:55 It's not something we can lay at Israel's feet.
00:03:59 Now, let's talk about the facts of this.
00:04:01 Because yesterday we heard a condemnation from Justin Trudeau
00:04:04 that was very deliberately, I think, nondescript about what it was he was actually condemning.
00:04:10 Take a look.
00:04:12 The news coming out of Gaza is horrific and absolutely unacceptable.
00:04:20 International humanitarian and international law needs to be respected in this and in all cases.
00:04:27 There are rules around wars and it's not acceptable.
00:04:30 His rhetoric suggests this was an act of war, not just a byproduct of war.
00:04:38 Again, very notable there.
00:04:40 Melanie Jolie, who is Canada's foreign affairs minister, at least purportedly, had this to say on Twitter.
00:04:47 Bombing a hospital is an unthinkable act and there is no doubt that doing so is absolutely illegal.
00:04:54 At the risk of getting too hell-bent on semantics, bombing a hospital.
00:04:58 This refers to an act that is, one might argue in her framing of it, deliberate or at the very least active rather than accidental.
00:05:07 A caveat I put in there for a very particular reason.
00:05:11 Now, some people are not as measured with their words.
00:05:13 The National Council of Canadian Muslims came out guns blazing in its rhetoric on this.
00:05:19 If you look at the tweet from the NCCM yesterday, a Canadian Muslim advocacy group,
00:05:24 What you are watching here is a heinous act of ethnic cleansing by the Israeli military.
00:05:30 500 people killed in a single airstrike on Al-Ali Hospital in Gaza City.
00:05:36 Will every Canadian politician clearly condemn this horrific act of violence?
00:05:43 There is a very serious and very deliberate and very specific allegation there.
00:05:50 Now that was in the evening.
00:05:51 We have a bit more daylight today in Gaza and in Israel.
00:05:56 We can see very clearly what happened and where it happened.
00:06:01 Let's look at this tweet from Elliot Higgins.
00:06:06 That is the parking lot adjacent to the hospital,
00:06:11 which has cars still very much in it, I might add,
00:06:15 in the aftermath of this so-called Israeli airstrike on the hospital.
00:06:20 Let's look at Visegrad 24, which has this picture of the wreckage and carnage.
00:06:28 I have seen potholes bigger than that.
00:06:32 I have seen potholes on my city streets, which have never been to my knowledge subject to an Israeli airstrike,
00:06:37 than that so-called crater that Gaza has tried to say is an Israeli airstrike on a hospital that killed 500 people.
00:06:48 Now, the facts of this suggest, and the IDF, which obviously is a belligerent in this conflict,
00:06:53 but the IDF shared intercepted audio of two Hamas officials in which one of them learns from the other
00:06:59 that it was their own rocket.
00:07:01 It was a misfire of a Hamas rocket fired from behind the hospital,
00:07:07 fired from a cemetery, by the way, which to Hamas is completely fair game to use as a rocket launching pad 0.96
00:07:13 that misfired and fell flat in the hospital parking lot. Thankfully, there were no 500
00:07:19 casualties, there were no hospital bombings, there were no strikes, and there was certainly
00:07:22 nothing of the allegations of Israel's conflict and complicity in this that was at all to blame.
00:07:30 It was a misfired rocket by Hamas that created a pothole in a parking lot that the media and
00:07:37 the political class ran with as being some evidence of Israeli war crimes. Now, I mentioned
00:07:43 the comments yesterday from Justin Trudeau and from Melanie Jolie. Even this morning,
00:07:49 Liberal cabinet ministers were not exactly being circumspect in their remarks. This was a tweet
00:07:53 from Minister Francois-Philippe Champagne, who says,
00:07:57 The attack on the Al-Ali Arab Hospital in Gaza is horrifying and against international
00:08:03 humanitarian law. My thoughts are with the victims and their loved ones. Let's be clear,
00:08:09 there can be no justification to strike a hospital nor civilians. That was at 6.51 a.m. this morning
00:08:17 Eastern Time. Hours and hours after, it became abundantly clear that the airstrike on this
00:08:22 hospital simply did not exist, and any inflicted damage was actually the consequence of Hamas,
00:08:28 which deliberately puts its civilians in harm's way, but it was their own actions and nothing by
00:08:36 the state of Israel that was to blame for this. Now to go back to the CBC and the New York Times
00:08:42 and the Toronto Star is no exception to this, they all come out with the explosive allegation
00:08:47 and then the edits take place a little bit more subtly and quietly after the fact. Maybe they
00:08:52 append an editor's note on the story, but that is the extent of it. I received yesterday push
00:08:58 notifications alerting me to this horrific act, and only this morning I got one push notification,
00:09:05 to its credit, from the Toronto Star, acknowledging that they had made an error or at least had
00:09:11 clarified their previous reporting on this, had clarified their headline. We saw lots of public
00:09:18 proclamations from the Liberal government, from Conservatives, even from some New Democrats,
00:09:23 from journalists, calling out Hamas's brutality a week and a half ago. Because when we were
00:09:29 confronted with the actions of Hamas kidnapping hostages, killing seniors and babies, raping
00:09:35 women and teenagers, it was easy for everyone to stand up, you'd think, and say Hamas is absolutely 1.00
00:09:42 in the wrong here. But as time goes on and as the story shifts from those initial attacks into a
00:09:48 conflict that appears on the surface to be a more conventional war, the benefit of the doubt that
00:09:55 Israel was given by people in those first couple of days has been eroded. And I'm not to say there
00:10:00 aren't legitimate criticisms we can make about Israel and its response to things like this. I
00:10:05 am not at all going to give the IDF carte blanche because Israelis were targeted by horrific acts
00:10:11 of violence. There are still rules pertaining to proportionality, and there are still laws which
00:10:17 are not in an international context as authoritative as people might think, but they nevertheless
00:10:22 do exist. But what's missing from the story every time this comes up is all of the efforts through
00:10:29 which Israel goes to be proportional, to urge citizens to evacuate or to be evacuated rather,
00:10:37 to urge entire parts of this territory to evacuate. This is what Israel goes out of its way to do. 0.99
00:10:44 It's Hamas that tells people, no, stay put, do not leave, because Hamas is the one that wants dead Palestinians more than Israel does. 0.64
00:10:51 In fact, that is Hamas's entire MO, to have more dead Gazans so that they can turn around and point to Israel as being the enemy, 0.66
00:10:59 rather than the Hamas terrorist thugs who put their young, their women, their children, all of them, directly in harm's way.
00:11:08 So it's particularly disgusting when you see people in Western leadership positions that
00:11:13 should know this full well, that start to drink the Kool-Aid, even if they attempt to
00:11:18 measure their words, which is not a reactive, not a relative product of them having a nuanced
00:11:24 position, but is in fact a byproduct of them wanting to pretend to have a nuanced and non-extreme
00:11:32 position. I will draw your attention to this comment by NDP leader Jagmeet Singh. And I should
00:11:38 point out, I always, always, always have to caution whenever we talk about Jagmeet Singh to say that I
00:11:43 don't want to mistake him for being relevant. But it was noteworthy and revealing when he said this
00:11:48 about the conflict in the Middle East right now. International law must be upheld and respected.
00:11:56 Make no mistake, collective punishment is a violation of this law.
00:12:03 Canada must insist that all those who broke these laws are held accountable,
00:12:09 even those nations we have called friends.
00:12:12 Canada must call for a ceasefire to end the killing of innocent civilians in Gaza immediately.
00:12:19 We cannot allow for the continuing dehumanization of an entire population.
00:12:28 When we stop seeing each other as humans, when we stop believing that each life has value,
00:12:36 this is when the seeds of genocide take hold.
00:12:41 The seeds of genocide take hold.
00:12:45 Now, if you listen very carefully, he's not coming out and making any accusation about anyone.
00:12:52 He's not talking about Israel. He's not talking about Gaza. He's not talking about Hamas.
00:12:56 He's just saying generally, he's just throwing it out there.
00:12:59 And if anyone did anything like this, then, well, that should be condemned.
00:13:03 When he talks about collective punishment, he's not actually condemning Hamas's decision to collectively punish Israelis.
00:13:10 he's condemning Israel's decision to cut off power and water supply to Gaza for a time. 0.85
00:13:18 So he's directing his scorn towards Israel, not towards the Hamas terrorist thugs.
00:13:23 When he talks about sowing the seeds of genocide, I'm not in his mind,
00:13:29 but I do not believe he is talking about the attempted extermination of the Jewish people,
00:13:34 which is a stated mandate of Hamas in its charter.
00:13:37 They literally put in writing their goal to wage war against Jews, to take up jihad and to annihilate the state of Israel.
00:13:44 No, he's talking about Israel's self-defense.
00:13:47 That's what he believes is, quote, sowing the seeds of genocide.
00:13:52 The last couple of days have showed us that politicians will, when absolutely confronted with unequivocal evil, perhaps say the right thing.
00:14:01 But when the dust settles, when the bodies cool, when the carnage is less apparent and in your face than it is in those early days,
00:14:10 they go back to their natural resting position, which is an utter contempt for Israel 0.90
00:14:16 and an utter disregard for the realities of the ground and for Israel's right as a nation to defend itself against a people who want it destroyed,
00:14:25 a people who want it dead.
00:14:27 That is not a description of the entirety of the Palestinian people.
00:14:31 It is a description of the governing authority in Hamas, however.
00:14:35 And the country that we see defending itself will try to save those civilians
00:14:41 when its own so-called government wants them in jeopardy.
00:14:46 And I didn't have the clip for today, but there was a Liberal member of Parliament,
00:14:50 Samir Zubari, who is a backbencher.
00:14:53 But he was just, I mean, very emotional this morning on his way into the National Caucus meeting for the liberals as he speaks about if he said the exact quote here, if I was behind an artillery cannon and I knew this would fall on hospitals and schools, I would not push that trigger.
00:15:10 And he was, again, being very careful with his words.
00:15:14 He was asked, are you accusing Israel?
00:15:15 He's, well, I'm not saying one way or another.
00:15:19 But you have all of these people that are trying to pretend that Israel is the guilty party of this,
00:15:25 that Israel is the instigator, that Israel is the ethnic cleanser, 0.98
00:15:29 that Israel is the genocider of this to create a word that I wish I didn't have to. 0.98
00:15:35 But that is nowhere near the case.
00:15:39 And it is a fundamental rejection of every bit of reality.
00:15:42 Now, I don't have a lot of time for Joe Biden.
00:15:45 In fact, when I say the date at the beginning of the show, I think even that would have
00:15:48 lost Joe Biden.
00:15:48 He doesn't know where he is or what day it is at any given time.
00:15:51 But his government has been remarkably lucid on Israel, which I think is very important.
00:15:56 And the U.S. has come out and said, look, they've seen the intelligence and there is
00:16:00 no information supporting at all the idea that Israel was behind this strike.
00:16:05 We've had unequivocal denials from the IDF, from the Israeli government, and you may say, well, they're biased, we can't take them at face value.
00:16:14 No, but it's also going to be the case that these people are not going to say something that can be proven false by objective evidence.
00:16:21 And if Israel wanted to destroy that hospital, it would be leveled to the ground right now.
00:16:28 So who do you trust more?
00:16:29 I mean, even if you don't like Israel, who do you think has a more capable military force, Israel or Hamas? 0.54
00:16:35 It is far more plausible that Hamas accidentally misfired a rocket and blew up three square feet of a parking lot.
00:16:43 That is a lot more easy to believe than the fact that Israel tried to blow up a hospital and couldn't manage to get six inches below the surface of the pavement. 0.79
00:16:53 So that is absolutely what we're seeing here.
00:16:56 And again, this is all contextual here.
00:16:58 I've been talking about the political and media response where people, at least on the surface, believe they shouldn't be condemning Israel and defending those who want to annihilate Israel.
00:17:08 But if you take a walk out to your neighborhood protest, you'll find it's an entirely defensible and normal position in a lot of cities to stand up there and hold signs that celebrate death of death to the Jews and that celebrate Hamas attacks against Israel. 0.78
00:17:24 One of these rallies took place over the weekend.
00:17:28 We saw a number of them.
00:17:29 We also saw another one in Toronto yesterday, which my colleague Harrison Faulkner took
00:17:34 some time out to see here.
00:17:35 And he's also covered a number of these protests.
00:17:38 Harrison, it's good to talk to you.
00:17:39 I mean, what is the actual tone there?
00:17:42 Because I know that we all can point to the one crazy sign at a protest and try to extrapolate
00:17:47 from that.
00:17:47 But these don't seem to be outliers from all of these things that I've seen.
00:17:51 These seem to be relatively mainstream positions, these more extremist slogans and sentiments.
00:17:57 Yeah, well, I think it's safe to say, Andrew, that there is a lot of anger at these crowds.
00:18:02 They seem to be growing and the tone seems to be shifting.
00:18:06 I think when I was on the ground on the 9th, that Monday protest at Nathan Phillips Square, there was a lot of anger there.
00:18:14 But last night was different.
00:18:16 I mean, one of the things you heard was the people leading the protests saying that Justin Trudeau, Doug Ford and Olivia Chow had blood on their hands for what happened at the Gaza hospital.
00:18:28 And I think in general for their support of Israel, they also would go through the list of all world leaders in the West and saying that they have blood on their hands for what's happening to Palestinians right now in Gaza.
00:18:40 So I think you're right to point out, Andrew, that the tone is shifting at these protests.
00:18:44 And what we saw last night in Toronto was something that we saw in other parts all over the world yesterday.
00:18:51 So it is something worth noting.
00:18:54 Yeah, and I think that's really the point here.
00:18:56 I mean, I'm sympathetic to the idea that we don't want to import very hotly contested conflicts from other countries.
00:19:03 I mean, you've covered the India file well.
00:19:05 I mean, that's one of the biggest failures of Canadian multiculturalism is that we take conflicts from elsewhere and we bring them into Canada.
00:19:11 In this particular case, Israel is a very different situation.
00:19:15 It is a country in which the global picture matters a great deal because we're talking about countries that recognize Israel's rights under international law or countries that don't.
00:19:25 And in Canada, it is weird how we're seeing that, as you say, that tone shift where, you know, Saturday, Sunday, Monday of last week, every politician, even, you know, ones that don't like Israel knew what they had to say, which was, you know, we condemn Hamas's violence.
00:19:39 We support Israel. And now that is shifting for them a lot.
00:19:44 And I think these protests are very concerning because it shows that there is a large contingent here that is going to be calling up its members of parliament's offices, calling up the premier, the prime minister, and saying, you know what, I'm not going to vote for you if you support Israel.
00:19:57 And I don't know who outnumbers whom in this case.
00:20:01 Yeah, I think it is also worth noting that, yeah, these protests are going to happen again tonight.
00:20:08 They had said publicly that they're going to be there every night as long as they can go.
00:20:12 and of course, Andrew, you know, these people want to show that they have the public on their
00:20:21 side, that they have the majority showing up to these protests. And I think whether we like it
00:20:26 or not, protests do have that ability to, I guess, get in the heads of local politicians.
00:20:33 Politicians want to be on the side of the public. And I think that's what we're going to see.
00:20:37 One thing we did have last night that was worth mentioning, since you brought up the politician
00:20:41 element was you had what was described as a local first responder wearing what looked like a lab
00:20:47 coat addressing the crowd last night at Bloor & Young from standing on top of scaffolding,
00:20:53 telling everyone there that they had to write to their MPs and local politicians to get them to
00:20:58 condemn Israel for the bombing of the Gaza hospital. We're not going to get into the
00:21:03 different elements of that, but that is what they're trying to get at. They were there last
00:21:08 night in response to what happened in Gaza, and they are there trying to get politicians to
00:21:13 condemn Israel for this. So there is definitely a politics element to this, of course. The hospital 0.79
00:21:19 situation is a really useful example of why this is so difficult. I mean, here we have,
00:21:26 and I just spent the first 15 minutes of the show going over it. We've got tons of evidence that
00:21:30 shows this was misreported, that the media that took Hamas's claims at face value, the politicians
00:21:35 who then took the media's reporting at face value yesterday were wrong, but there are still people
00:21:40 that will refuse to let this change their preconceived notions in the same way that last
00:21:45 week, the big source of controversy was whether infants were beheaded by Hamas. And you had people
00:21:50 that just said, you know, in spite of the reporting and the evidence, no, there's no way I won't
00:21:54 believe it. I can't believe it. And that's happening here. And, and it is bizarre in a way,
00:22:00 yet unsurprising that we see in real time just this complete rejection of truth in support of
00:22:06 the narrative. And I mean, Al Jazeera, which is obviously not a pro-Israel publication by any
00:22:12 stretch, had, and I'm going to pull up the headline here because I think it's revealing,
00:22:16 what is Israel's narrative on the Gaza hospital explosion? So right there, they're saying anything
00:22:22 Israel says is just propaganda, but anything Hamas says is apparently fine. Yeah, it's obviously, 0.99
00:22:28 this is this is something that we didn't we it's not first time we're seeing this of course at the
00:22:32 beginning of the ukraine-russia war we saw things like this happening all over the place all
00:22:37 throughout social media everybody i think would be very wise to understand that we're watching a war
00:22:43 take place here involving belligerents who are trying to take the moral high ground for themselves
00:22:49 we have to be aware of what's of what's happening here and recognize that of course the messaging
00:22:55 we get from either side is not going to be exactly what they want uh what they want to come
00:23:00 out and what the other side wants people should be uh should be reasonable when they look at this
00:23:05 and recognize we're watching a war information that we get from the ground is never going to
00:23:10 be exactly accurate um and and and that is what we're going to see here so because of this as they
00:23:16 said yesterday night at the protest in toronto i imagine we're going to see again another protest
00:23:21 tonight outside of the Israeli consulate, right at Yonge and Bloor, and likely in Mississauga as
00:23:25 well. This is going to keep going on because really what we're watching are two sides trying
00:23:31 to take the moral high ground from one another. And that's just, I think, part of this war we
00:23:36 have to be aware of. Yeah. No, very well said. Harrison Faulkner, you can catch Ratioed Mondays
00:23:41 and Thursdays at True North. So always good to check in with you, Harrison. Thanks for coming on.
00:23:46 Thank you.
00:23:47 One of the things I will point out about this, I mean, look, if someone wants to protest at
00:23:52 the Israeli consulate, that's their right in Canada.
00:23:55 And I have always been unequivocally in support of free speech.
00:23:59 But one thing I'll point out that I find a little bit interesting here is that there
00:24:03 was also, I mentioned yesterday, a big giant conference on anti-Semitism in Ottawa, hosted
00:24:08 by SEJA, the Center for Israel and Jewish Affairs.
00:24:11 SEJA has had this on the books for quite some time, not knowing they were going to have
00:24:16 this backdrop against which to have this conference of the conflict in the Middle East.
00:24:21 But why this is interesting is that this is still an unobjectionable, uncontroversial
00:24:26 idea that we need to stand up for, well, stand up against anti-Semitism.
00:24:32 And I should say that when Islamophobia was the discussion we were all having a few years
00:24:37 ago around M103, most of the Jewish groups stood up and said, yes, absolutely, let's
00:24:41 condemn Islamophobia as long as you guys condemn anti-Semitism.
00:24:44 And they all just held hands and said, great, we're friends.
00:24:47 And all of those voices that were standing up for the fight against Islamophobia four
00:24:53 or five years ago have curiously been silent in the face of anti-Semitism that is running
00:24:59 rampant and is always the most pervasive form of hatred in this country.
00:25:04 And I would point out a few different aspects of this.
00:25:08 One is that the Canadian Anti-Hate Network, I believe, has so far reached day 13 of the
00:25:14 its silence in the face of these attacks. Day 13. No, maybe it's day 12. My apologies. I've
00:25:22 already gotten to Thursday here. But the Canadian Anti-Hate Network, which gets huge amounts of
00:25:27 money from the federal government to be the primary spokesperson and advocate against hate
00:25:32 founded by Bernie Farber, has had zero to say about the Israel-Hamas conflict. It's had nothing
00:25:38 to say about the nasty death to the Jews signs we see at rallies. It has had nothing to say about
00:25:45 any of that. Where are the anti-hate voices? Amira El-Gawabi, formerly the head of the National
00:25:51 Council of Canadian Muslims. I've met her and she's a very lovely woman in person, but she has,
00:25:56 when I last checked yesterday, been silent. Her Twitter account has been dormant since this all
00:26:02 happen. Now, she is Canada's special envoy on the issue of Islamophobia. You might think that if
00:26:08 fighting against hate is something everyone is doing in the trenches together, that she would
00:26:13 be there to stand in allyship with Jews that are facing anti-Semitism when they stood in allyship
00:26:19 with her and the NCCM and Muslim voices when Islamophobia was the discussion. Now, I'm going
00:26:26 to put some caveats there in the sense that I do not like the false equivalents of Islamophobia and
00:26:32 anti-Semitism because while there are examples of horrific bigoted attacks on Muslims, it does not
00:26:38 exist in the same way that anti-Semitism has existed and always will exist unless something
00:26:46 significant changes. And by that, I think in the geopolitical context here, we see countries which
00:26:52 want to annihilate the Jewish state. We do not have countries that want to annihilate the Arab
00:26:58 world. And you can, you know, take whatever jokes you're going to take about, you know,
00:27:01 American foreign policy. But the reality is anti-Semitism is systemic and institutionalized
00:27:07 in a way that so-called Islamophobia is not. But again, if we are going to take the anti-hate
00:27:13 approach, we should condemn all hate equally. And that is not anything that's being done by
00:27:19 the official voices against hating Canada, people who make a great deal of money from the government
00:27:24 in doing this. And this sort of forms a natural segue into a discussion I started yesterday,
00:27:30 which was about the federal government's goals of re, I don't want to use the word criminalizing
00:27:35 because criminal codes are different, but of re-outlawing so-called online hate speech and
00:27:42 doing so through human rights law. Now, the one prevailing sense that we all need to get here,
00:27:49 that we all need to realize is that if something is illegal offline, it is illegal online. And the
00:27:56 government tries to pretend this isn't the case. If it is illegal for you to disseminate child
00:28:00 pornography, you can't do that on a computer or on the internet. If it's illegal for you to
00:28:05 threaten violence against someone, you can't do that on the internet. If it's illegal for you to
00:28:09 share non-consensual sexual images of someone, you cannot do that using the internet. So when
00:28:15 the government talks about regulating so-called online harms, what they're talking about doing
00:28:21 is regulating a different aspect of things that in most cases are already illegal. And why that's
00:28:28 so dangerous in the context of its attack on hate speech is that we already have a criminal code
00:28:35 definition of hate speech, which has a very, very high bar because we realize that free speech is
00:28:41 supposed to be expansive and liberal and cover contentious, offensive, difficult, and even
00:28:46 emotionally hateful things. So when the government is talking about regulating and banning hate
00:28:52 speech, they're actually talking about lowering that threshold. And that brings us to this online
00:28:57 harms bill. Now the caveat here, we have not yet seen the bill itself. We haven't seen the text of
00:29:03 it, but we have seen former versions of this and we know where the government has drawn its
00:29:08 inspiration from. And the line they used when they tried to reintroduce Section 13 of the
00:29:14 Canadian Human Rights Act in 2019 or 2021, it was rather, was that speech that is fomenting
00:29:22 detestation or vilification. Now, they try to say this doesn't mean we're tackling free speech. It
00:29:29 doesn't mean we're censoring. It just means if you're purveying speech that's doing that,
00:29:35 it's going to fall under this banner. Now, we have a bunch of history from the Canadian Human
00:29:41 Rights Commission of going after speech that any reasonable person should look at as being worth
00:29:47 protecting, not because we agree with it, but because we agree with the fundamental and
00:29:52 inalienable, we're supposed to believe anyway, principle of free speech and in the Canadian
00:29:57 legal context and terminology, freedom of expression. So let's talk about this in a bit
00:30:03 more detail. John Carpe is the president of the Justice Center for Constitutional Freedoms and
00:30:08 joins me now. And I should just clarify for those tuning in, I am on the board of the JCCF, although
00:30:14 that has no bearing on my decision to invite John, who I have had on the show many times before he
00:30:19 worked for me, which I guess is technically true, but not really. John, always good to talk to you.
00:30:23 Thanks for coming on today. Glad to be with you, Andrew. So this is an example, again, put the
00:30:28 necessary, you know, caveats out of the way. We haven't yet seen the bill, but we've heard the
00:30:32 government describe it and we know what the government wants to do here and for a civil
00:30:37 liberties organization you must be looking at that saying this is the ball game right it it sounds
00:30:44 like a step in the wrong direction as you pointed out just a minute ago uh it is already illegal to
00:30:50 willfully promote hatred online as it is with a hard copy pamphlet brochure newspaper what have
00:30:57 you so it's already a criminal offense to willfully promote hatred against a group
00:31:01 based on race, religion, ancestry, ethnic origin,
00:31:06 sexual orientation, gender expression, and so on and so forth.
00:31:12 And that was upheld very narrowly by the Supreme Court of Canada.
00:31:16 It was a 4-3 split decision.
00:31:18 So that's already illegal.
00:31:19 So what I see here is the government stepping towards,
00:31:23 it's a small step towards becoming a repressive regime.
00:31:27 And one of the hallmarks of repressive regimes,
00:31:30 whether it's today's communist China, communist North Korea, whether it's Germany, Italy, Spain
00:31:36 in the 1930s, whether it's the theocracies that are running Iran and Saudi Arabia, one thing they
00:31:43 all have in common is they all censor, and the governments take it upon themselves to determine
00:31:48 what is true or false, right or wrong, good or evil, and they will censor in the name of the
00:31:54 public interest and the common good, because politicians never violate your rights and
00:32:00 freedoms without offering some pretext. They're going to tell you it's national security, it's
00:32:05 fighting communism, it's fighting fascism, it's the environment, it's fighting a virus.
00:32:12 There's always a pretext for taking away our rights and freedoms. So this really looks like
00:32:16 a step in the wrong direction. One of the things I want to, not to put you on the spot here, but I'm
00:32:23 curious about your take on it because the government has said in the past that its
00:32:26 definition of hate speech is going to be informed by the Watcott Supreme Court decision from some
00:32:32 years back, which we don't need to get into the details of the case. But the Supreme Court has
00:32:37 not in Canada always taken the strongest view on freedom of expression. And I want to read a line
00:32:42 from this particular Supreme Court decision. Truthful statements can be presented in a manner
00:32:49 that would meet the definition of hate speech. And not all truthful statements must be free
00:32:54 from restriction. That is a very dangerous line that the government is embedding in its approach
00:33:00 to freedom of expression, which is that something can be true, but you aren't allowed to say it.
00:33:05 Well, the WhatCott decision weakened prior Supreme Court of Canada jurisprudence on free speech that
00:33:12 was better. It was not a good decision. It could have been a lot worse. The problem with hate
00:33:19 speech regulation or even laws against it is that hate is an emotion that is in the human heart
00:33:28 it is subjective it is not necessarily a bad thing if it's directed against injustice or
00:33:34 oppression or falsehoods you know if you hate injustice then hatred can be a good thing but
00:33:39 the problem with with laws or regulations trying to govern hate is simply the fact that it's very
00:33:45 subjective. I could be listening to somebody. I could suspect that they might have hatred in their
00:33:52 heart. I really don't know. You or I could be giving a speech and some of your listeners might
00:33:59 subjectively feel that your speech is hateful. Other people listening to the exact same speech
00:34:04 think it's not hateful. It's just the expression of an opinion. So rightly or wrongly, we've got
00:34:10 the law on the books to criminalize willful promotion of hatred. We shouldn't go any further
00:34:16 down the road of having governments regulate the internet and take away from the right of Canadians
00:34:22 to have full access to information and to a diversity of viewpoints. Well, and that exchange
00:34:29 is so paramount. I mean, just to use a contemporary example, I started off the show by talking about
00:34:34 this back and forth between Israel and Hamas about what happened in this hospital attack
00:34:39 yesterday. And, you know, a bunch of people that are very sympathetic to the Hamas cause are saying
00:34:44 one thing happened. It's only through the exchange of these conflicts that we can interrogate and
00:34:49 find out what the truth is. And I'd say in that case, I mean, I would even say false statements
00:34:54 are protected free speech in some context because it is through the falsity that you can then
00:34:59 establish the truth oftentimes. And it's really dangerous to me that government is trying to take
00:35:05 that decision and take that process out of the hands of free people, because that's really what
00:35:11 they're doing here. They're making the Canadian Human Rights Commission the arbiter of what you
00:35:15 can and cannot say, and by extension, deputizing tech companies to do that, because that's the
00:35:20 other part of regulating online harms, is that it provides a vehicle for government to go to
00:35:25 Facebook and say, you shouldn't allow so-and-so to say that. You shouldn't allow so-and-so to post
00:35:29 that. Well, we've seen in the last three and a half years that governments are very, very effective
00:35:34 at getting millions of private actors, of private citizens to enforce government laws.
00:35:40 You saw that with the lockdowns and the vaccine passports where the government didn't need 0.98
00:35:45 to hire, although they probably did hire a lot more people, but they didn't need to
00:35:49 necessarily hire thousands of health inspectors because every movie theater owner, every gym
00:35:55 operator, every restaurant manager was an enforcement tool for the government to enforce
00:36:00 these rules. And so this is what the government seems to be moving towards is to regulate these
00:36:06 big platforms. And then they don't have to spend time, effort or energy trying to shut down the 0.88
00:36:11 Andrew Lawton show or the weekly Justice with John podcast, because these big entities will do it
00:36:17 for the government. You mentioned even false speech should be protected. And there's Supreme
00:36:23 Court authority on that. Yes. Part of that, one aspect of that is we don't even know if a statement
00:36:29 is true or false until after it's been investigated and debated and you've got two or three or four
00:36:35 different opinions and they clash and we look at the evidence. So even a law that says, you know,
00:36:40 we're making false statements illegal, that we did have a law in the criminal code that was struck
00:36:46 down in the Zundel decision. It was illegal in Canada, criminal code offense to spread false
00:36:52 news. And the Supreme Court struck that down and said, no, we don't even know what's false
00:36:58 until after we've had the debate.
00:37:01 Another interesting point is that,
00:37:04 and this is troublesome from Watcott,
00:37:06 from that decision where even a true statement
00:37:09 could be hateful and could be illegal.
00:37:11 The Criminal Code of Canada in criminalizing
00:37:14 the willful promotion of hatred says expressly
00:37:17 that truth is a defense.
00:37:20 So if you made some nasty comment about some group
00:37:23 based on skin color, gender, whatever,
00:37:26 if that you know if that statement happened to be true that would actually be a defense in a
00:37:33 criminal prosecution uh sounds like it's not going to be a defense when the human rights bodies get
00:37:38 involved yeah and that that's the big danger is all of a sudden we're taking a lower evidentiary
00:37:43 threshold and and also it's a civil proceeding so then you add uh the burden of proof aspect
00:37:49 changes from from criminal as well and the stakes are very high uh for people who will get their
00:37:54 lives drag through the ringer. We've seen what happens when these human rights commissions have
00:37:58 had free reign, like the Alberta Human Rights Commission going after Ezra Levant and the BC
00:38:02 Tribunal going after Mark Stein. And, you know, to go back to something I've talked about on the
00:38:07 show in the past, but kind of just was swept in very quietly in Canada. And I think it was the
00:38:12 last federal budget or two years ago, they reintroduced a criminal provision banning
00:38:17 Holocaust denial. And I think this is probably the perfect example of where the free speech 0.98
00:38:23 discussions go off the rails. Because I will say on principled free speech grounds, I oppose this.
00:38:29 I find Holocaust denial to be deplorable and wrong, but I do not think it should be illegal.
00:38:35 But the government will often use the emotional reactions people have to certain speech
00:38:40 as a way to really, as a cudgel, to justify banning it in the same way as that Mike Ward
00:38:46 case in Quebec, where, you know, yes, it's difficult to stand up and say, I defend making
00:38:51 fun of disabled 12 year olds, but it's not that I defend the act of doing it as I defend the right
00:38:57 to do it. Yeah. Well, that's, that's where, that's where the rubber hits the road. Incidentally, I,
00:39:03 like you, I find the Holocaust denial to be vile, vile speech. It disgusts me and it outrages me.
00:39:12 And I actually testified at a parliamentary committee to not amend the criminal code
00:39:18 regarding Holocaust denial, and the only reason for that is because the government should not be
00:39:23 in the business of determining historical truth or falsehood, period. It's not the role of the
00:39:29 state, and once you have the government doing that on one issue, it grows like a cancer.
00:39:37 The other interesting thing is that the groups lining up so far, this is from a CBC story that
00:39:43 i read the other day uh the center for israeli and jewish affairs and the national council of
00:39:48 muslim uh canadian muslims and the chinese canadian national council according to this story
00:39:55 want legislation to uh to regulate and then arguably punish if you violate the regulation
00:40:03 to regulate and punish websites and new emerging platforms and if we go down this road if we take
00:40:09 any step here, the number of groups lining up, what's going to happen is instead of just engaging
00:40:17 in debate and explaining, you know, based using facts and logic and evidence, instead of making
00:40:23 your case and trying to persuade people, instead of engaging in debate, you're going to see more
00:40:26 and more groups lining up, going to government and trying to get the government to shut up their
00:40:31 opponents. And that's fascism in practice. Yeah. And that's the other part of this is that even
00:40:38 if you fundamentally agree, which I don't, and I don't gather you do as well, that there should be
00:40:43 a limit to protect against hateful speech that is lower than the threshold now. The logical question
00:40:50 is, who do you trust to be the authority to determine that? And that is where we get, I mean,
00:40:56 this is a government, and I don't like going back to this, but this is a government that froze its
00:41:00 political protesters' bank accounts. Like, this is not a government that I trust with the switch
00:41:05 to censor people's opinions
00:41:08 and to censor people's expression of those opinions.
00:41:11 And it's broader than that.
00:41:13 There's a lot of people applaud.
00:41:15 I remember once I saw a video clip,
00:41:17 Bill Watcott, very outspoken social conservative activists
00:41:21 who articulates his viewpoint in ways
00:41:24 that most social conservatives don't even like it.
00:41:26 But he's got his free speech rights.
00:41:28 I saw him get arrested and handcuffed.
00:41:30 This is about five, six, seven, eight, nine, 10 years ago.
00:41:32 He was at the University of Saskatchewan or University of Regina, I forget which.
00:41:37 And he was handing out pamphlets on campus and critical of homosexual behavior.
00:41:46 And he was arrested and handcuffed and taken off campus in a police car.
00:41:52 And the group of students applauded.
00:41:54 And I thought to myself, you are very short-sighted.
00:41:56 Because what if there is this massive religious revival in Canada
00:42:00 and two-thirds of Canadians are fervent,
00:42:04 believing, devout Muslims, Christians,
00:42:06 Orthodox Jews, whatever.
00:42:09 Would these same students want
00:42:10 a fundamentalist religious government
00:42:14 to have the power to censor their speech?
00:42:15 They don't think about that, but they should.
00:42:19 Yeah, very, very well said.
00:42:20 John Carpe, president of the Justice Center
00:42:22 for Constitutional Freedoms.
00:42:24 Always a pleasure, John.
00:42:25 Thanks for coming on today.
00:42:26 Thank you very much, Andrew.
00:42:27 Yeah, and I expect the JCCF
00:42:29 will be out in full force on this
00:42:31 because this is a fundamental free speech question.
00:42:34 And the government will do what it did
00:42:36 when it introduced the Emergencies Act.
00:42:38 They'll say, we're protecting your charter rights.
00:42:42 We're specifically protecting freedom of expression.
00:42:45 And all of the do-gooders out there will say,
00:42:47 oh, well, that nice man with the nice hair
00:42:49 said that they're protecting free speech.
00:42:51 So I guess it's fine.
00:42:52 And or the one you'll hear, which is so annoying,
00:42:55 and I apologize if you've said this,
00:42:57 but I don't actually apologize.
00:42:58 when people say, well, there's a difference between free speech and hate speech.
00:43:04 What is the difference?
00:43:06 What is the difference?
00:43:08 And where do you draw the line?
00:43:10 I could go out on the street and give, I don't know, 10 people interviews and streeters.
00:43:15 And maybe we'll do this when we see the text of the bill and ask them if this thing is hate speech or if it's free speech.
00:43:21 And we'll come up with whatever the list should be.
00:43:24 And I bet everyone's going to have a different line on that.
00:43:26 Maybe you've seen going around the internet that old PETA billboard about like a list of animals and it starts with a cat and dog and then it goes all the way to a chicken and a fish and it says, where do you draw the line?
00:43:40 And one cheeky guy kind of put it between horse and cow and said right there.
00:43:45 But the whole point is people are going to look at that and have a different line on what is meat and what is a pet.
00:43:51 just as people are going to look at verbal expressions or written expressions and have a
00:43:55 different line on what is free speech and what is hate speech. So as a society, we have an
00:44:01 obligation to have the most expansive parameters necessary so that as individuals, we can decide
00:44:07 and debate and maybe scream at each other and maybe say that position is unwelcome in civil
00:44:13 society, but we decide that as members of a civil society. And there is a fantastic piece written
00:44:22 many years ago, I think in the 1920s by Lord Moulton called The Domain of Manners. And the
00:44:28 domain of manners, or it might be the realm of manners, I forget which one, but basically it's
00:44:32 that a society's freedom is really assessed by how large the gap is between the things you can do
00:44:40 legally and the things you will do morally. And the whole point is that society should have a
00:44:47 very, very wide, wide range of things you can legally do. And then it governs itself appropriately
00:44:53 to have a narrower view of the things you should do. And I think the real magic of that is that we
00:45:00 forget that being able to do something is not the same as being required to do it. It can be legal
00:45:08 to deny the Holocaust, while also being morally acceptable. It can be legal to do any number of 0.84
00:45:14 things that we would just not ourselves want to do. And to give you an example of this, how many
00:45:19 of you would commit murder today if it were not illegal? Murder is not wrong because it's illegal,
00:45:26 it's illegal because it is wrong. And that is not to say that we shouldn't have a prohibition on
00:45:31 murder, absolutely. We should ban things that violate the rights and liberties of others,
00:45:36 which is where we should draw the narrowest possible parameters of what is legal and what
00:45:41 is illegal. That is it for me. We will be back tomorrow to close out the week here on The Andrew
00:45:46 Lawton Show. You're listening to or watching True North. Thank you, God bless, and good day to you
00:45:51 all. Thanks for listening to The Andrew Lawton Show. Support the program by donating to True North
00:45:57 at www.tnc.news.
00:46:06 We'll be right back.
00:46:36 We'll be right back.