Juno News - February 08, 2024


NDP MP wants to jail people for promoting oil and gas

Topics
Mentioned
Poilievre (finally) gets it right on the trans issue Danielle Smith on transgender policies, Alberta energy, and Justin Trudeau

Episode Stats


Length

39 minutes

Words per minute

167.86

Word count

6,639

Sentence count

214

Harmful content

Toxicity

2

sentences flagged

Hate speech

6

sentences flagged


Summary

Summaries generated with gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ .

The verdict in the Mann v. Steiner and Simberg case is in the process of being delivered, and the jury is in its fourth week of deliberation. There's a lot going on in Washington, D.C. today, including the ongoing trial of climate scientist Michael Mann and his co-accused, Mark Steinschnitzky, as well as the ongoing investigation into Jerry Sandusky, the disgraced former head of the Penn State University football program.

Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Topics generated with Qwen2.5-3B-Instruct.
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 Transcription by CastingWords
00:00:30 Thank you.
00:01:00 welcome to canada's most irreverent talk show this is the andrew lawton show brought to you by true
00:01:20 north hello and welcome to you all canada's most irreverent talk show here the andrew lawton show
00:01:30 on true north on this thursday february 8th we are once again live and out of the corner of my
00:01:37 eye i've been on jury watch for the bulk of the day so you may recall over the earlier part of
00:01:44 this week and last week i was covering in washington dc the trial of mark stein and
00:01:49 Ran Simberg. They've been sued by prominent climate scientist Michael Mann, formerly of Penn
00:01:54 State, over comments they made linking what they view as the whitewash of the investigation into
00:02:00 misconduct allegations against Michael Mann into the whitewash of the investigation into Jerry 0.59
00:02:06 Sandusky, the disgraced pedophile and rapist who had been the head of the Penn State athletics
00:02:12 program. Now, the question here is not, do you believe in global warming, which was kind of the 0.95
00:02:19 argument that michael mann and his lawyers were putting forward but it's do you have a right
00:02:24 to make criticisms of a scientist that are uh perhaps a little bit colorful or inflammatory but
00:02:31 can it be inflammatory without being defamatory that was the juxtaposition that was put forward
00:02:37 by rand simberg's lawyer so i've been following this trial it's now in its fourth week this is
00:02:42 is the fourth day of the fourth week and the jury is excuse me deliberating the jury is out
00:02:48 in the most literal sense of the word they went out at about 4 p.m yesterday afternoon
00:02:53 they had about 45 minutes of deliberation before the union mandated close of business at the court
00:03:00 kicked in and then they had to all go home and restart again this morning and that process began
00:03:06 somewhere after 9 a.m. or so, but the jury has been out for the last three to four hours. And I
00:03:14 have the Zoom box or WebEx box open on my monitor here. And they've just put like a flash card up
00:03:20 in front of where the courtroom would normally be saying the jury is deliberating. So if it looks
00:03:24 like movement's coming, I might keep an ear on that. I don't know if we can, I was going to say
00:03:28 maybe we could just go to the court stream when they're reading the verdict, but I think I might
00:03:31 find myself in contempt of court in the District of Columbia, which is not a fate I would wish on
00:03:36 myself or on anyone so that is what we are keeping an eye out for and I actually had a lovely email
00:03:42 from Tim that I wanted to read Tim sent a very kind note which he said if I can find the note
00:03:49 here he wanted to convey his appreciation for a great run of content recently he said from Stein
00:03:55 to Danielle Smith and deserved questions of Polyev you've asked great questions and struck the right
00:04:00 tone I've particularly enjoyed the unjust transition series putting faces names and
00:04:06 finer detail around the amorphous oil and gas sector is a master stroke. And he says he's
00:04:11 learned a great deal. Well, that was a note that made me incredibly happy, Tim. So I thank you for
00:04:15 it. And we will have the last installment of that very series, that unjust transition series
00:04:20 coming up in just, I don't know, however many minutes. It'll be in today's show.
00:04:25 But I want to talk just on the note of oil and gas, talk about feeding right into the discussions
00:04:31 I've been having on the show here. The whole point is that our politicians don't understand
00:04:35 the oil and gas sector. There's misinformation. The media doesn't get it. And because of that,
00:04:39 Canadians don't get it. And then we have Charlie Angus, old Charlie Angus, the member of parliament
00:04:45 for Timmons, James Bay, a longtime new Democrat. He had this to say at a press conference this week.
00:04:53 Oil has always relied on the big tobacco playbook of delay and disinformation. And so to tackle this
00:05:00 immense threat to human health, we need to use many of the strategies that finally took down
00:05:06 Big Tobacco. In 1997, the Canadian Parliament banned advertising from Big Tobacco because of
00:05:12 the clear threat to human health. This is why I'm so proud to stand here today with representatives
00:05:19 of Canada's medical community to state that the time has come to ban all oil and gas advertising.
00:05:26 the big tobacco moment has finally arrived for big oil bill c-372 will quote provide a legislative
00:05:35 response to a national public health and environmental problem of substantial and
00:05:40 pressing concerns the bill will make it illegal for big oil and gas lobby and the gas lobby or
00:05:46 their front groups or paid influencers to falsely promote the burning of fossil fuels as a benefit
00:05:52 to the public. The legislation will make it illegal to falsely claim that the use of one
00:05:58 fuel fossil fuel product is somehow better than another fossil fuel product in improving the
00:06:04 environment. And this legislation will target advertising that falsely claims that oil and
00:06:10 gas are having a positive impact on the global economy. And we recently learned that toxic
00:06:16 contamination from Canada's oil and gas industry is 6,000 times higher than officially reported.
00:06:24 This legislation will make it illegal for Canada's oil and gas giants to falsely identify themselves
00:06:30 with the health and positive lifestyles of Canadians or with reconciliation of Indigenous
00:06:36 people on whose lands the toxic contamination is highest. The big tobacco moment has arrived
00:06:42 for companies like Suncor, Imperial, and the oil and gas giants of Canada.
00:06:51 The big tobacco moment is here.
00:06:55 So what Charlie Angus is saying there is that we need to treat oil and gas advertising
00:07:03 the way we treat tobacco advertising, which is to basically send it the way of the dodo bird.
00:07:08 Now, here I'm going to read a little bit from the preamble because it sets the tone for what
00:07:13 he's advocating. Whereas climate change represents an unprecedented and existential threat to people
00:07:19 in Canada and around the world, whereas extreme weather events such as the 2021 heat dome in BC
00:07:25 are already proving deadly in Canada and are expected to increase in frequency and magnitude
00:07:30 due to climate change. Whereas Canada had its worst wildfire season ever last year, he left out the
00:07:36 part where a vast majority of that was all attributed to arson, not to the big oil companies
00:07:42 or big tobacco or anyone else apart from many climate activists and arsonists. He says,
00:07:48 whereas Canada has made international climate commitments to reduce fossil fuel consumption
00:07:53 and reach carbon neutrality, whereas protection of the environment is a valid use of the federal
00:07:58 criminal law power, whereas air pollution from fossil fuels causes millions of premature deaths
00:08:04 globally and tens of thousands of premature deaths in Canada alone. Sorry, my air quotes
00:08:09 are lopsided. There we go. I don't know. I don't know how I got lopsided. Maybe my arms are just
00:08:14 not functioning. I bet it was fossil fuels. I bet it was oil. I don't know how, but to use the
00:08:18 Charlie Angus playbook, I bet it was oil. It's a climate emergency and he says fossil fuel
00:08:23 advertising needs to stop. So here's the thing that is so baffling about this is that he's looking
00:08:31 at this big, giant, evil, scary boogeyman
00:08:34 of the oil and gas sector.
00:08:35 And he's saying they should not be allowed
00:08:37 to do any promotion whatsoever.
00:08:39 They cannot promote their products.
00:08:41 They cannot say they're better.
00:08:43 They can't even promote what they're doing for oil and gas,
00:08:46 what they're doing for the environment.
00:08:47 So they would not be allowed to say,
00:08:49 hey, here's what we're doing to meet net zero commitments.
00:08:52 They couldn't do it.
00:08:53 They couldn't say,
00:08:54 here's what we're doing for indigenous communities.
00:08:56 They couldn't say,
00:08:57 here is what oil and gas is to the Canadian economy.
00:09:01 So he is literally, by definition, criminalizing the other side of the bait.
00:09:07 He does not want anyone to be able to put forward a position that is in contradiction
00:09:11 with the position he has, which is oil and gas equals evil, bad, scary.
00:09:15 So this is literally, I mean, this is tin pot dictatorship nonsense here.
00:09:19 When you say that no one should have the legal right to debate you, to debate your position,
00:09:24 no one should have the right to disagree with you publicly.
00:09:27 That's what Charlie Angus is saying there, and he is being absolutely unequivocal about it.
00:09:33 So I would say to him that it is tremendously revealing that he does not believe in free speech, does not believe in civil liberties, does not believe in the right to debate, and has an incredibly misguided view of the oil and gas sector and everything it is and does.
00:09:51 And I kind of just had a moment where I was distracting myself from work today.
00:09:55 So I tried to do something that didn't feel like work, but I could justify as being work.
00:09:59 And I use, there's this website called, well, it's a service called Mid Journey, which you
00:10:03 can make AI generated images.
00:10:05 So I used an AI generated image to make this.
00:10:08 So I don't want you to think this is some that I'm, oh yeah, there it is already.
00:10:12 So these are, yeah, two prisoners.
00:10:13 The one on the left says, what are you in for?
00:10:15 The one on the right, I said the oil and gas sector was good for the Canadian.
00:10:21 economy. That is the two prisoners there chatting. Now, I realized after I made that image that we
00:10:30 find the one upside of this, the one upside of Charlie Angus trying to criminalize the oil and
00:10:35 gas sector and promotion thereof is that we finally found a way to make the NDP care about
00:10:40 crime. That's the one silver lining of this. We found a way to make it so that the NDP
00:10:46 cares about crime and cares about justice. So someone had responded to me on Twitter or X as
00:10:52 it's now known. I should have pulled the screenshot to put up there, but it was in the
00:10:56 replies to that. They had said, yeah, well, the guy on the left is a pedophile and he'll be out
00:11:00 next week. But the guy on the right who promoted the oil and gas sector, he gets the two-year
00:11:06 jail sentence, which is sadly a reality. So maybe we can kind of converge two things here. Remember,
00:11:11 I spoke a few weeks back about how they're making Law & Order Toronto. Maybe the first episode,
00:11:16 the premier of Law & Order Toronto can be, you know, some oil and gas advocate that accidentally
00:11:22 put up a tweet that promoted oil and gas and then Charlie Angus goes and slaps the cuffs on them
00:11:28 and then they have to get themselves off in the courtroom for the remainder of the episode. I
00:11:33 think that would be a very Canadian Law & Order Toronto. They don't go after the guy on the subway
00:11:39 that's taking a dump in the corner they don't go after the guy who's shooting up outside your kid's
00:11:44 school but they go after the guy who dared to talk about the benefits and virtues of oil and gas
00:11:50 and if you if you look at the detail of this the detail of this uh bill uh private members bill c
00:11:58 372 uh they're they're literally saying that oil and gas are the new tobacco so that that shows the
00:12:06 narrative here that they're trying to peddle and the fact that you couldn't even disagree with that
00:12:09 you couldn't say that oh well this is a net zero product this is a way that we're promoting carbon
00:12:16 capture this is exactly why the people that have this rabid and this rabid hatred this
00:12:23 rabid antagonism of canada's energy sector are so dangerous because they genuinely believe that this
00:12:30 is a sector that is meant to be vilified and demonized and by trying to literally criminalize
00:12:36 because that's what they're doing it's a literal criminalization of the oil and gas sector they
00:12:42 are being tremendously revealing of what their agenda truly is so uh you know basically this
00:12:49 is the new future if the ndp has its way i wanted to share a graphic this is from first nations lng
00:12:55 and they put up this post on x that charlie angus's bill prevents touting the industry as a
00:13:04 tool for Indigenous reconciliation. So they say, should Karen Ogun get two years jail or a $1
00:13:10 million fine? She's the CEO of the First Nations LNG Alliance. She promotes LNG development as a
00:13:17 way to lift Indigenous people and their communities out of poverty. So if you advocate, if you are an
00:13:23 Indigenous person advocating for resource development that benefits the Indigenous people,
00:13:28 that is literally, literally against the law under this.
00:13:33 And I'll read the direct quote.
00:13:35 It is prohibited for a person to promote a fossil fuel
00:13:38 or the production of a fossil fuel
00:13:40 in a manner that states or suggests that a fossil fuel
00:13:44 or the practices of a producer
00:13:45 or of the fossil fuel industry
00:13:47 would lead to positive outcomes
00:13:49 in relation to the environment,
00:13:51 the health of Canadians,
00:13:53 reconciliation with Indigenous peoples
00:13:55 or the Canadian or global economy.
00:13:58 So if you, like that lovely woman there, say that oil and gas benefits Indigenous reconciliation or Indigenous people or the Canadian economy, you will be found to have broken criminal law.
00:14:12 And you can be literally sent to jail.
00:14:15 This is absolutely insane.
00:14:18 Now, I don't normally like quoting Warren Kinsella.
00:14:21 The only reason I don't like quoting Warren Kinsella is because it means that I have to think
00:14:25 about Warren Kinsella, which is not good for my or anyone's mental health. But Warren Kinsella had
00:14:30 posted this image on social media, which I will give credit where it's due. It's Charlie Angus
00:14:36 in the back of a pickup truck, a GMC Sierra, which does not look like a hybrid. It does not
00:14:42 look like it's electric. It's, I don't know why you're seeing half of my, you know, like torso
00:14:48 below that there we go uh it doesn't look like it is uh one of these you know fancy environmentally
00:14:54 friendly trucks you might even say that he is promoting he is promoting he's so cheery and
00:15:00 enthusiastic as he sits in the back of that truck in the flatbed that he is almost promoting
00:15:06 something that is rooted in oil and gas so i guess as warren kinsella writes there
00:15:11 maybe he should be turning himself into the police station maybe he's on route there right now because
00:15:16 that just seems a little too close for comfort i mean you wouldn't do that you wouldn't let yourself
00:15:20 be so excited in front of the tobacco aisle at the corner store would you there charlie no
00:15:25 so that's exactly where we are in the course of this so let's kind of drill down into why this
00:15:33 is dangerous i mean it's i've talked about the oil and gas sector and and the problems there
00:15:38 because it's just fundamentally based on misinformation and a misrepresentation of
00:15:44 what that sector is in canada how diligent they are at promoting environmentalism and conservation
00:15:51 but there's the free speech angle as well and you know i've had a couple of chats with people
00:15:57 about this over the last day or so since news of this private members bill was released but
00:16:02 the thing about it that is so disturbing is that i couldn't even say if i were to get into a debate
00:16:09 with charlie angus and i've invited him on the show in the past he's never wanted to come on
00:16:12 But I couldn't say, well, you know, Charlie, I think, you know, even if we disagree on oil,
00:16:17 your bill would be, it would be contradicting of free speech.
00:16:23 And that's not a Trump card.
00:16:25 I mean, he would say, so what?
00:16:27 Because you're talking about people who fundamentally reject the idea that free speech is a positive.
00:16:32 So if you were to say, well, this bill is bad or it's unconstitutional or it's anti-liberty,
00:16:36 if you were to say any of that, you would actually be very much at odds with any position
00:16:42 that they'd be willing to take on
00:16:43 because he is part of a group.
00:16:45 He's part of a cohort
00:16:46 that believes free speech is the problem.
00:16:49 He doesn't care.
00:16:50 His right to speak freely
00:16:51 against oil and gas is fine.
00:16:54 His right to vilify that sector,
00:16:57 his right to vilify indigenous people 1.00
00:16:59 that value resource development,
00:17:01 his right to do all of that is fair game.
00:17:03 His and his supporters' rights
00:17:05 if they want to protest projects,
00:17:06 maybe even by sitting
00:17:08 and camping out on rail lines,
00:17:10 all of that's fair game.
00:17:11 they have the right to do that, but no one who is taking the other position has that right. No one
00:17:18 who's taking the other position has that right. So this is to me a baffling, but not all that
00:17:24 unsurprising, if you can square those two terms development in the course of this debate here.
00:17:29 Now, one thing that I wanted to bring up when we talk about federal politics right now is that I
00:17:34 think most Canadians are probably not on Charlie Angus's side here. That's the one silver lining 0.50
00:17:38 of this all. So Justin Trudeau yesterday made a claim that he meant to be an insult, but I kind
00:17:44 of think it backfired on him in the delivery. This is from the House of Commons.
00:17:50 Mr. Speaker, what we hear from the leader of the opposition is under the previous conservative
00:17:56 government, everything was perfect. And what he is proposing to do is to make Canada great again.
00:18:03 That is not what Canadians want.
00:18:06 He is pining for a nostalgia that, quite frankly, Canadians do not feel.
00:18:11 They remember what he did as part of Stephen Harper's failed housing minister.
00:18:16 He remembers the rights of Indigenous peoples violated, 1.00
00:18:22 the ignoring of environmental responsibilities,
00:18:25 and the lack of an environmental and economic plan for the future.
00:18:28 We're going to continue on.
00:18:29 yeah you got all the you got the trifecta there it was uh stephen harper government uh oblique
00:18:39 trump reference and then we're gonna you know be the ones that are securing uh better the future
00:18:44 opportunities for canada so we had the trifecta there blame harper blame trump and make some
00:18:49 vague platitude about the liberal government's willingness and ability to deliver now he butchered
00:18:55 the line there he was stumbling and fumbling as much as he was talking about a water bottle it's
00:18:59 the same he can't be uh it's a shame he uh he uh you know couldn't string out the one little bit
00:19:05 of a line and dialogue that he had trapped to try to prep for that i realize i flubbed my line when
00:19:10 i was accusing him of flubbing his so maybe it's something in the water but uh the point of this
00:19:14 that i i'm stressing here is that canadians are right now proving that they're kind of okay
00:19:20 with what polyev is putting out now obviously it's early there's a fair bit of vote parking
00:19:25 that happens when people get a call from a pollster and they kind of just say at that moment
00:19:29 in time what they want and maybe they don't vote that way when an election comes up. Realistically
00:19:34 we're probably about 18 months away from a national election but it's weird that Trump
00:19:42 comparisons have become the norm everywhere. I've said to people countless times before that stand-up 0.73
00:19:48 comedy has been killed in a lot of ways now because you have so many lazy hat comedians that
00:19:52 I don't know how to tell jokes or write jokes anymore. They just get up on stage and it's like,
00:19:56 oh, Donald Trump, am I right? And that's supposed to be in and of itself enough to bring the
00:20:00 audience on your side. And when people do this, it feeds into the political class. It feeds into
00:20:06 the political culture, which is where we see this unfolding now. So Trump and Trudeau have met
00:20:14 together. They have supposedly had good conversations, but Trudeau wants to turn around
00:20:18 and score political points off of Trump, who is going to be the Republican nominee. And in doing
00:20:25 so, he can then just try to link Polyev to Trump. So Doug Ford is Trump. Danielle Smith is Trump.
00:20:31 Pierre Polyev is Trump. Andrew Scheer was Trump. Everyone's going to be Trump. It doesn't really
00:20:34 matter. They don't even need to make the comparison stick. They just have to say it and they think
00:20:39 that's enough. So that's going to be like the lone liberal talking point that we get when we see the
00:20:46 next election, whenever that is. It's going to be Polyev equals Trump. And when you see him there
00:20:51 with his lovely family, talking about things that matter to Canadians, people are going to be like,
00:20:56 I don't know, maybe he's, maybe he's, I don't think he's, he's necessarily Trump-like. So
00:21:00 we have been promoting, to go back to how we started off this show, the positives of the oil
00:21:05 and gas sector. And one way we've done this is through this fantastic series that I've really
00:21:10 enjoyed called Unjust Transition, our inversion of Justin Trudeau and Jonathan Wilkinson's and
00:21:16 stephen gilbo's so-called just transition today is the last of the interviews we did with ceos
00:21:23 and executives from the energy sector to talk about the work they're doing and this one features
00:21:28 brian gould who is the ceo of aspen leaf energy so finishing off this wonderful series take a look
00:21:46 I'm joined now by Brian Gould of Aspenleaf Energy.
00:21:51 Brian, it's good to talk to you.
00:21:52 Just set this landscape here.
00:21:54 How does Aspenleaf fit into the Canadian energy sector?
00:21:58 Great.
00:21:58 So we are a private oil company started about 10 years ago.
00:22:04 Myself and three colleagues, former executives at Shell,
00:22:09 and we saw a business opportunity to acquire companies and assets in western canada primarily
00:22:18 alberta and produce uh crude oil so we produce 25 000 barrels a day like like crude oil now
00:22:26 and we started the company with a vision of not just being profitable for our investors but
00:22:34 we grew up with a mentality and a view of how a company should be run and so we're very passionate
00:22:41 about our culture commitment to working respectfully with our employees with the
00:22:48 communities which we operate being responsible in terms of environmental performance and we think
00:22:55 the all fit together under one umbrella which i call just strong corporate governance so what are
00:23:02 of the barriers for you that you're finding in the sector as an oil company that's obviously
00:23:07 successful, but is one of those giant players that tends to be the one that dominates the
00:23:11 discussion of the industry in Canada? I'd say probably access to capital and
00:23:20 investors, appetite would be the wrong word. We have investors that would like to stay invested
00:23:30 our company we're very profitable uh and yet the societal pressures on them to divest are
00:23:38 overwhelming and overpowering and so we're currently going through a frankly a restructuring
00:23:43 where some of our investors are going to be forced to divest uh despite rational economic performance
00:23:51 uh just to satisfy these what i'll call societal pressures i i mean it sounds like you're putting
00:23:57 a very charitable spin on it i mean these are very ideologically driven in many cases and i'm
00:24:01 wondering why that's stronger than clearly a market-based motivation to invest and to remain
00:24:08 investing if this is a sector that is doing as well as it is it's a great question uh all i can
00:24:15 tell you is i deal with managers of large like college endowment funds and they've been particularly
00:24:24 susceptible to these campaigns these orchestrated efforts yes and some of them are forced to divest
00:24:31 some of them are in a situation where they're not forced to divest their current holdings but they're
00:24:36 not allowed or permitted to invest in new opportunities and so i i put this all under
00:24:41 the umbrella of access to capital and the industry is frankly being starved of this access to capital
00:24:48 which is you know the like lifeblood of of a capital intensive industry and and yeah and i
00:24:52 I think that the important point here is that for capital, Canada is not in isolation here.
00:24:57 People can put their capital anywhere in the world. So if they're seeing an environment in
00:25:00 this country that doesn't seem like it's worth the hassle, then they are putting that money
00:25:06 elsewhere. They're still investing in it. It's just Canadian companies are not the beneficiaries
00:25:09 of it, right? Well, in part, it's Canadian companies. In part though, I would say it's
00:25:15 a global phenomenon. Many of our investors are based in the United States, for example,
00:25:21 and they simply can't invest in the sector, whether it's in Canada or elsewhere.
00:25:27 And the sad part of this for me is when I think about our investors,
00:25:30 you know, people think about, frankly, us guys, we're the fat cats and all this.
00:25:36 But the people that are invested in my company are pensions.
00:25:39 So I like to think of it, our profits pay pensions for retirees.
00:25:44 uh we have a very large investor who has a sizable medical institute i believe they funded
00:25:53 something like over 20 nobel prize when he was just in the field of medicine uh we fund a major
00:25:59 world famous art museum uh so so this isn't money going to you know fat cats smoking big cigars
00:26:07 uh i like to think of it that the profits from our industry are paying it forward to society
00:26:12 for education for retirement funds for medical research for medical treatment for the arts i
00:26:19 mean these are all i think causes that we all agree are are very worthwhile well and the people
00:26:25 you employ i mean that's the their lifeblood is this industry and when you hear the government
00:26:30 talk about this so-called just transition they're really imagining and i think saying as a an
00:26:36 inevitability that there is a future in which these people shouldn't have those jobs so that's
00:26:41 That's a great question. So, you know, although we're fairly modest in size,
00:26:45 when I look at our direct and indirect employment through, you know, contractors and such,
00:26:54 we probably employ about a thousand people. These are very high paying jobs. We have field
00:27:00 operators, many of whom, these are people without college educations. These are fantastic paying
00:27:07 jobs for them uh and and i it boggles my mind to think that in this transition that there will be
00:27:14 any kind of a placement for that kind of employment that quality of employment those number of jobs
00:27:19 in it and and i even hesitate to use the word just transition that's that's a fallacy well it's the
00:27:26 unjust i mean it's an unjust transition which is why we i've been using that language and and i
00:27:30 will always caveat it with the so-called and not just for alberta i mean when alberta is booming
00:27:34 this is attracting people from all across the country for those jobs 100 so this is of national
00:27:39 interest this is in calgary this is in alberta this is of national importance and i would argue
00:27:43 it's of importance to to the western more fully uh and then just so so i i'd like to challenge
00:27:50 two of your phrases please just and well they're not but let me clarify they're not my phrases
00:27:56 i'm quoting those ones but yes carry on so in my view there is nothing just about this
00:28:02 You know, I believe in a free open market economy, and if the broader economic forces decide that there's a better product than ours to supply energy, that's great, so be it.
00:28:15 But there's nothing just about an enforced transition.
00:28:20 And secondly, there is no transition.
00:28:22 uh so this is a complete pipe dream the fact the belief that the world will transition off of fossil
00:28:28 fuels in any rational time frame is a pipe dream i you know the stats i heard this morning i believe
00:28:35 that 84 percent of the world's energy still comes from fossil fuels uh after decades of transition
00:28:41 that's maybe down a couple of percent and there are six to seven billion people in this world
00:28:46 are fundamentally short of energy and the world will need all sources of energy, including fossil
00:28:52 fuels, in my view, for the foreseeable future. And when I say for the foreseeable future, I mean
00:28:58 decades and decades beyond that. So this concept that there will be a transition away from this
00:29:04 source of energy is frankly just a fairy tale. You've heard what they want to achieve. What
00:29:12 would the real world implications of that be on your company? Not just your industry,
00:29:15 your company and your employees? If they were to achieve what they want to achieve,
00:29:22 our company simply would not exist. We would not exist. We would not be supplying these thousand 0.94
00:29:28 jobs, the taxes we pay. We have in our short lifespan contributed well over a billion dollars
00:29:36 to the economy and that would all be gone. And I don't mean this in a negative way,
00:29:40 but that's as a smaller company. That's as a very small company. So multiply that by many
00:29:45 many orders of magnitude many factors when you think about the size and the breadth of the
00:29:49 industry uh so i believe we're fundamental to the canadian economy and how it manifests itself
00:29:56 it's everything from who pays for the social services that we all expect and what who pays
00:30:01 for medical care what happens to the value of the canadian dollar when we don't this you know oil
00:30:06 and gas is far and away our largest export uh good luck buying your fresh food and vegetables
00:30:10 with a 50 cent dollar so all of these things will cascade through the economy into ways that every
00:30:17 canadian will will relate to very directly this this will cause a reduction in our standard
00:30:23 of living full stop uh and not only that it will compromise our national security uh even and and
00:30:30 these are fundamental very fundamental issues and the reason i'm not passionate about this topic for
00:30:35 my company i'm passionate about these topics for our country well it's a very important note to end
00:30:42 on and for people who aren't in the industry i think they can share that as well certainly when
00:30:46 they hear it put how you have uh phrased it there so eloquently brian gould thank you very much
00:30:51 thanks for having me pleasure that was the last installment of our unjust transition series and i
00:30:58 have credited on the show the modern miracle network which does very good work in advocating
00:31:03 for the oil and gas sector in Canada for connecting me with all of those folks and it's fitting
00:31:09 although it was not anticipated before I saw this bill from Charlie Angus that we have on
00:31:13 Michael Binion who we started this series with and now we inadvertently get to end it with him
00:31:19 as well from the Modern Miracle Network. Michael it's always good to talk to you thanks for coming
00:31:24 on today. Glad to be here I'm actually down in in Houston and the NAEP show so big big oil and gas
00:31:30 conference and i've just managed to get out i don't think about the perfect quiet place but i'm
00:31:34 but i'm happy all right well we'll we'll take in the uh the sites of houston where i would
00:31:39 much rather be from a weather perspective right now i just did this bill that has been proposed
00:31:44 i mean it's bonkers and most private members bills don't get a a hearing and and are unlikely
00:31:50 to pass but but it reflects i think an attitude which is very pervasive among people that do have
00:31:57 tremendous influence here and i just wanted to get your take on this first i mean is this
00:32:01 have you ever heard of anything going after your industry as aggressively as this you know this
00:32:08 they've been signaling this idea for quite some time that somehow fossil fuels are similar to
00:32:13 cigarettes and of course this whole bill is patterned on the the you know the advertising
00:32:17 and warning labels and everything that has to go on on cigarettes on on the basis that i think that
00:32:22 There was back in the 70s or whenever there was, in fact, some cigarette companies that were caught doing some promotion of their product without maybe talking about some of the risks of their product.
00:32:33 So I think that's the analogy they're trying to create.
00:32:36 The problem that I have with this bill is one is the whole preamble is based not on mainstream science, like as the International Panel on Climate Change doesn't agree with almost everything in their preamble.
00:32:47 This is an extreme view of apocalyptic warnings about the possibility of climate change, which I don't, as I said, the mainstream science I don't think agrees with.
00:32:59 The other thing is fossil fuels have saved millions and millions, if not billions, of people and made everybody's life better.
00:33:06 It's net very positive for human health, as we've seen since we started using fossil fuels in the 1800s
00:33:13 and child mortality rates and longevity and health outcomes and equality.
00:33:18 All these things are literally miraculous in society.
00:33:22 And so that obviously is completely different than the cigarettes.
00:33:26 And then I guess to finalize it, I think if they were to go ahead with what they're saying,
00:33:30 to say you know you're not allowed to say that natural gas has less emissions than coal because
00:33:37 that would be promoting a fossil fuel well the environmental damage of not being able to pick
00:33:43 the best fuel and the best energy in its best place has been already well demonstrated for
00:33:48 example by our project in quebec where you know hundreds and you know thousands of megatons have
00:33:52 have you know would have been saved if only we'd been allowed to go ahead with a fuel that is that
00:33:58 has lower environmental impacts it's all it's like you said at the beginning it's bonkers
00:34:01 yeah and and i would point out as well when with that tobacco comparison that this bill doesn't go
00:34:06 after deceptive advertising could i be i'd be completely on board with some measured regulation
00:34:12 on deceptive or dishonest advertising this goes after truthful uh advertising and promotion of
00:34:18 the sector and and one that that i find particularly jarring especially for charlie angus who's from
00:34:23 Northern Ontario and should know Indigenous communities quite well, is that you cannot 1.00
00:34:28 even promote how these projects can benefit Indigenous people. And I've met through
00:34:34 introductions from you, Indigenous advocates for the energy sector that don't just support it as
00:34:39 a Canadian economic project, but specifically for Indigenous communities. And these people
00:34:43 could literally be jailed for having these same conversations publicly. I know. You know, I've
00:34:50 often said that the problem with the energy debate that we've had, and this is one of our
00:34:55 Modern Miracle Network messages, is we've been for too long comparing the benefits of one kind
00:35:00 of energy, alternatives, with the negative impacts of another kind of energy, fossil fuels. But what
00:35:06 about the benefits of fossil fuels, which literally are miraculous? And why are we not talking about
00:35:12 some of the impacts of alternatives, which are pretty large? And we're all of the above and put
00:35:18 best energy in its best place but we're also for a reasoned conversation on energy where we talk
00:35:23 about benefits and the impacts not just one or the other and and as you said this bill would say
00:35:29 we're going to make it illegal illegal to talk about the benefits of fossil fuels
00:35:35 yeah i mean i mean your entire initiative at modern miracle network is to promote the miracle
00:35:40 of hydrocarbon so so you're you and your board are getting thrown in the slammer when this bill
00:35:45 passes if it passes right well if we were to dare to advertise i guess it's yeah it's crazy right
00:35:50 it's it's crazy and so we're we're trying to promote i think a rational conversation not not
00:35:56 to ignore the impacts that fossil fuels are just the opposite we're we're big promoters of of
00:36:02 technology to to deal with the impacts of fossil fuels but we're just saying let's not throw out a
00:36:07 product that has created the miracle of modern society with you know without any thought or or
00:36:12 consideration and by the way as we're looking at you know the impacts of of alternatives in terms
00:36:18 of um landscape and i mean they're the worst energies there are in terms of land use and
00:36:25 materials use per gigajoule or kilowatt of energy and so you know there as i say wind and solar
00:36:31 you've got some work to do to really become a environmentally friendly energy and by the way
00:36:37 so do fossil fuels we've got a lot of work to do too so uh let's let's have that honest
00:36:42 conversation about the work that we need to do and let's have an honest conversation about the
00:36:46 benefits that are brought to people yeah and that's the thing i mean if you want to talk about
00:36:50 the negatives in your eyes fine with me but no one should be barred from discussing the positives as
00:36:55 well so uh well said i'll let you get back to your conference there michael but always good to
00:36:59 check in with you thank you so much for coming on yeah you bet all right michael binion executive
00:37:03 director and founder of the modern miracle network as i said a nice little cap off on our unjust
00:37:10 transition series and we'll put those all up on youtube so anytime you uh get an ndp candidate
00:37:14 knocking on your door and you want to uh perhaps share with them the stories that they want to
00:37:18 criminalize you can send a link to that maybe i'm going to be thrown in jail actually so i might need
00:37:22 to do like the ezra levant thing and set up like a free andrew uh website and go fund me campaign
00:37:27 for when i get you know thrown in the slammer for having a nice and a friendly interview with an oil
00:37:33 CEO, because heaven forbid we promote the positives of what is the lifeblood of the Canadian economy.
00:37:38 Well, that does it for us for today. If you haven't picked it up yet, we have a new show
00:37:43 on Fridays called Off the Record, featuring many weeks anyway, yours truly. So I'll be on tomorrow
00:37:49 alongside Candice Malcolm and Harrison Faulkner. That comes out at sometime on Friday. Just keep
00:37:54 watch all our shows. It's easier that way. You don't miss anything. With that, have a wonderful
00:37:58 weekend and we will see you all on Monday. Thank you. God bless and good day to you all.
00:38:03 Thanks for listening to The Andrew Lawton Show.
00:38:06 Support the program by donating to True North at www.tnc.news.
00:38:33 We'll be right back.
00:39:03 We'll be right back.