Juno News - April 04, 2024


NDP MPs are bailing

Topics
Mentioned
Trudeau admits he's bungled the immigration file Foreigners voting “compliant with Liberal Party’s rules”

Episode Stats


Length

47 minutes

Words per minute

160.02

Word count

7,626

Sentence count

328

Harmful content

Misogyny

1

sentences flagged

Toxicity

1

sentences flagged

Hate speech

7

sentences flagged


Summary

Summaries generated with gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ .

Three more NDP MPs have announced they are stepping down from politics in a day and a half. What does it mean for the future of the party? And what does it say about Jagmeet Singh as the new leader of the main opposition party?

Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Topics generated with Qwen2.5-3B-Instruct.
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 Transcription by CastingWords
00:00:30 Thank you.
00:01:00 Welcome to Canada's Most Irreverent Talk Show.
00:01:16 This is the Andrew Lawton Show, brought to you by True North.
00:01:24 Oh, Charlie, Charlie, Charlie.
00:01:27 Did you hear the big news?
00:01:29 NDP stalwart Charlie Angus is getting out of politics. He was first elected in 2004. That's
00:01:36 the same election in which Pierre Polyev was elected. Things have gone a little bit differently
00:01:41 for the two of them. One is now the leader of His Majesty's Loyal Opposition. The other is
00:01:46 an angry backbencher who generally spends his days shouting at clouds. Charlie Angus has evidently
00:01:52 had enough. He announced this morning he is getting out of politics. Charlie Angus will not
00:01:58 be seeking re-election. He has held the riding of Timmins James Bay in Northern Ontario for quite
00:02:04 some time. Moments later, two more NDP MPs announced they too would be getting out of it.
00:02:11 That is a bit of a cold open for us here. Welcome everyone to the Andrew Lawton Show,
00:02:16 Canada's most irreverent talk show on True North. I'm feeling especially irreverent today
00:02:20 with the NDPers deciding they are going to jump off the ship right now that is certainly
00:02:28 on its way down. Well, it's a green ship. It's powered by solar panels. It really hasn't gone
00:02:32 anywhere. But the NDPers have said they are getting out of it. Now, this is just three MPs.
00:02:37 I think that's like, what, 12% of the NDP's overall caucus that just in one day say they
00:02:44 are getting out of politics. Now, the NDP office, Jagmeet Singh, the leader, has, of course, put out
00:02:49 the statement saying, oh, yes, we thank them for their service on behalf of all new Democrats.
00:02:54 oh we have the statement there I want to thank Rachel Charlie and Carol for their years of
00:02:59 advocacy and dedication to serving working people I mean they weren't working themselves so they
00:03:05 were serving working people apparently they've all accomplished so much for Canadians and worked
00:03:09 tirelessly to make our country a fairer better place they've added so much to our party and well
00:03:14 we'll miss their contributions around the caucus table I want to wish my friends the very best when
00:03:19 each of them begins their next chapter. Now, Charlie Angus is very helpful in politics because
00:03:25 he always, he has no inside voice. Like he'll say exactly what he's thinking, which is a refreshing
00:03:30 quality in politics. It's a shame that what he's thinking is usually utterly bonkers. But when 0.95
00:03:35 Charlie Angus gave his resignation statement, he had said something that I wanted to share. Now,
00:03:41 this was from a Globe and Mail piece by Ian Bailey. Charlie Angus says, one political era
00:03:48 is ending and another begins. As part of this renewal, I have decided not to run for re-election.
00:03:56 There's something embedded in that that I find quite interesting. He's acknowledging that there
00:04:01 is a change in political era, and I don't think he just means Justin Trudeau getting voted out
00:04:05 and possibly, I mean, it seems like almost certainly Pierre Paulyev getting voted in.
00:04:11 I think he means that people like him are not relevant in Canadian politics. Now,
00:04:16 maybe he doesn't understand that. And I realize I'm extrapolating a fair bit from what he said
00:04:20 there. So take it with a grain of salt. But he's realizing that there is coming a point in
00:04:28 Canadian politics. We're basically at the beginning of that point now when things are changing. We're
00:04:34 beyond the point of just tweaking. And people like him actually realize it and are getting out
00:04:39 while they can. Other people involved, Rachel Blaney and Carol Hughes, not as prominent members
00:04:44 of the caucus, but nevertheless, it's a small caucus. So these sorts of things are certainly
00:04:49 notable when people jump down. Now, Jagmeet Singh, I feel bad in a way because I make fun of him and
00:04:56 I don't feel bad about it at all. The joke that someone recently brought up that I had just
00:05:01 mentioned a while back, I was in Ottawa, I think it was in the fall for some reason or another,
00:05:07 and after question period, all the cabinet ministers get in their limos and leave and a
00:05:11 lot of the MPs get out and walk. And I was walking back to my hotel and I looked up and I saw Jagmeet
00:05:15 Singh just like strolling by on his bicycle. And I remarked later how odd I found it that he was
00:05:21 able to bicycle without a functioning spine. And I mean, take whatever visual you want of just like
00:05:26 some limp spaghetti noodle trying to ride a bike down Wellington Street. But Jagmeet Singh has as
00:05:32 NDP leader taken a position that could have made him the most powerful man in Canada. He could have
00:05:39 had that. He is the one that holds the keys to the kingdom. He is the one that holds the balance
00:05:44 of power. It is only with his say-so that the liberals can pass legislation, really, because
00:05:50 the bloc have not been reliable dance partners. The conservatives are opposing. So Jagmeet Singh
00:05:55 is the guy that stands between Canadians and an election. And what has he gotten for that?
00:06:01 He got, oh, National Pharmacare. That was the big NDP flagship policy. Oh, wait,
00:06:05 it's birth control and a diabetes drug and it only applies to some people what about dental care
00:06:11 yeah it only applies to a handful of people okay so he has gotten his party nothing and if you're
00:06:19 the NDP you know you're never going to form government you know you're never going to get
00:06:23 elected the only thing you have are your principles the only thing you have are your beliefs and your
00:06:29 convictions if you give up those and get nothing in return what is the point of it all what were
00:06:35 you there for? So he actually had power. He had authority and he chose not to wield it. Or in his
00:06:42 mind, he thinks he has wielded it. I won't do the gag today, but there's kind of a running gag I've
00:06:47 done on the show in the past where I show Jagmeet Singh's stage entrance after the 2019 and 2021
00:06:53 elections when his party has just been trounced. And he comes on and does this like big, exciting
00:06:58 dance as though he was the real winner of it. It's like that meme of the guy who comes in third
00:07:03 place at a tournament, but he's like, you know, dumping champagne on himself and biting his
00:07:07 metal. It's basically that meme. And Charlie Angus also has a book coming out. So he is exiting
00:07:16 politics with a bit of a manifesto. Oh, we have it here. It's called The Great, sorry, Dangerous
00:07:22 Memory Coming of Age in the Decade of Greed. And it's about how the looting of the North American 0.69
00:07:27 working class was planned and carried out so it's basically an anti-capitalist manifesto which
00:07:34 makes me wonder if a part of his reason for leaving is that he believes the NDP is no longer
00:07:39 doing what it's supposed to do which is being that ideological voice for working class people
00:07:45 that would be the pure reason but there's another reason that I suspect may be factoring into this
00:07:51 as well. Charlie Angus is the Member of Parliament for Timmins James Bay. This is a riding that is
00:07:58 as New Democrat as it gets. This is a riding that has large Indigenous communities, it has
00:08:03 coal, not coal miners, but maybe it does have coal miners, I don't know, but it has miners,
00:08:08 unionized workers, it's NDP territory, Northern Ontario. You look at the latest projections in
00:08:13 338 Canada, Conservatives have a 56% likelihood of winning his seat, of winning that election.
00:08:22 Timmons James Bay is most likely, not a guarantee, without Charlie Angus, I think it's almost
00:08:28 certainly going to go Conservative. But Timmons James Bay is going Conservative in the next
00:08:33 election, it looks like. This is a riding, since it was created in 1997, has never gone Conservative.
00:08:40 The Liberals carried it during Chrétien's majority elections, 97 and 2000, but the NDP has had it ever since under Charlie Angus.
00:08:49 If you look at the ridings that were redistricted to become Timmons-James Bay, they were Liberals as well.
00:08:57 So this is not a riding in which the Liberals have ever, or sorry, it's not a riding the Conservatives have ever been a contender in,
00:09:04 but right now they are within spitting distance of actually getting there.
00:09:08 And there are a lot of ridings like this where liberal MPs are saying, I don't want to just spend my last six weeks in office getting pummeled and then losing an election.
00:09:18 Liberals are going to be jumping.
00:09:20 NDPers are in a very similar place.
00:09:23 Yeah.
00:09:23 Oh, OK.
00:09:24 I guess we're doing it.
00:09:24 Sean did.
00:09:25 Sean got the footage.
00:09:26 So this is Jagmeet Singh after winning the 2019 election.
00:09:38 Sorry, I'm told he didn't actually win the election.
00:10:00 No one told him, though, that he didn't win the election.
00:10:03 2021 was a little bit more of an austere victory dance but i he's he still thinks he won
00:10:09 i i just noticed like his wife's basically like okay cool like his wife's just had enough of it 1.00
00:10:23 at that point as well uh so yeah check me sick so he's gonna you you watch he's gonna be like
00:10:29 totally coming in on a trapeze and he's going to be popping champagne corks in, uh, the next
00:10:34 election. And so he'll be so enthusiastic about it. You'll look and be like, wait, did, did he
00:10:39 just, you know, get reduced down to like, you know, a small handful of seats and perhaps lose
00:10:43 his own. Let me look up Burnaby, uh, Burnaby North, because I actually am curious how his
00:10:49 riding is going to, is he Burnaby North or Burnaby South? Let's see. No, he's Burnaby South.
00:10:54 Burnaby North is liberal. So Burnaby South, yeah, that one's okay. That's shaping up to be
00:10:59 pretty much a guaranteed for the NDP. But even so, I mean, the Conservatives are polling at 32%
00:11:05 there on 338, which is only just six points behind the NDPs at 38%. So strange things could happen,
00:11:15 although I'm not expecting them too, too much there. But all of this is to say that the NDP,
00:11:20 it's easy to just pay no attention to them. It's easy to think they're irrelevant. It's easy to
00:11:25 think they, yeah, okay, fair enough. But they could be. They could be relevant. They could
00:11:31 actually wield a tremendous amount of influence if they had someone at the helm who was a legitimate
00:11:35 political operator. Now, Charlie Angus, again, I think most of what he stands for is absolutely
00:11:42 bonkers. But the guy was a legitimate member of that party. He's a much closer figure to the old
00:11:50 Jack Layton NDP in terms of its conviction than to the Jagmeet Singh iteration. And Charlie Angus,
00:11:56 I'd remind you, in 2017 actually sought the leadership of that party. But the party after
00:12:02 the last election held a leadership review. They voted for Jagmeet Singh. They voted to keep him at
00:12:07 the helm. So they ultimately have to be the ones to deal with the consequences of that. But what,
00:12:13 if you're a new Democrat in this country, you have to look at your party right now and say,
00:12:16 what have you delivered for me? It's one thing if you're the NDP and you've got your 35 seats and
00:12:22 it's a liberal majority or a conservative majority, and all you can do is really yell into the void.
00:12:27 The expectations there are going to be pretty low. But when the liberals have a minority and
00:12:33 they need a party that's going to pass legislation for them. And the NDP agrees to be that party.
00:12:38 If you're a new Democrat in this country, you have to look up and say, what on earth have I
00:12:42 gotten out of this? And I'm sorry, but birth control and diabetes drugs are not national
00:12:47 pharma care. A limited extension of dental benefits is not national dental care. Now,
00:12:53 I don't want national pharma care for many, many reasons. I don't trust government to do it well
00:12:57 or do it effectively. I don't want national dental care for the same reason. But here's the reality.
00:13:03 the NDP hasn't even delivered on those things. They could have said to the government,
00:13:07 you want our support, this is the cost, which is what they ostensibly did. But in the end,
00:13:12 we have a supply and confidence agreement that has given the Liberal government a blank check,
00:13:17 given the NDP nothing in return, and no wonder that the principled stalwarts of that party want
00:13:22 nothing to do with it going forward in the future. And I would also say no wonder that NDP voters
00:13:27 are just breaking ranks with the NDP. You're going to see a lot of pickup of traditional
00:13:33 NDP support by the conservatives this time around, because those lines are not as far from each other
00:13:39 as people may think, especially if you look at inroads that the right has made with labor,
00:13:44 with private sector, I mean, public sector unionized workers are a different story,
00:13:48 but with private sector unions, labor is definitely breaking NDP. And in a lot of cases,
00:13:54 it depends on the area going conservative. Look, anyone who's unionized, who's in the construction
00:13:59 sector. They realize that it's only the conservatives that right now are campaigning
00:14:03 on getting houses built, on getting construction. It's the Liberal and NDP base that has really
00:14:09 lost that core reliance on Labour that it's always been able to count on. So this is quite
00:14:16 an interesting development. We will see how many more. There's going to be a point probably this
00:14:20 summer when you're just going to see this deluge, this mass exodus of Liberals and New Democrats
00:14:25 that are just not running again, and we will certainly have the opportunity to talk about that
00:14:31 and cover that as it happens here. I want to shift gears to the inquiry underway. I spent a bit of
00:14:38 time yesterday talking about Aaron O'Toole and his comments on why the Conservatives really lost
00:14:43 the 2021 election, at least in his view. The backdrop for that comment was the public inquiry
00:14:50 into foreign interference in Canadian elections, which is a real issue. It's a serious issue,
00:14:55 and it's one that, you know, whatever you think of Aaron O'Toole, did disproportionately harm
00:14:59 conservative fortunes in the 2021 election. It did not cost most likely the conservatives the
00:15:05 election overall, but there were a number of seats in which you can make a case that foreign
00:15:10 interference may have played a key role in flipping those seats away from the conservatives.
00:15:16 I've seen some numbers that have said as much as nine seats. This is what Aaron O'Toole said in
00:15:22 the inquiry yesterday. And I think it's an interesting discussion to have because
00:15:26 foreign interference, oftentimes the liberals try to view it as something that is just in the
00:15:32 abstract where, oh yes, it happens and we don't like it and it's terrible. And China is trying 0.58
00:15:36 to meddle, maybe India, maybe all these other places, but they don't want to deal with the 0.99
00:15:40 specifics of it, which is that when China is interfering in Canadian democracy, when they're
00:15:46 interfering in a liberal nomination, when they're interfering in a general election, there's a
00:15:51 reason for it. It isn't just as a flex of the muscle because they can. It's because they have
00:15:57 a vested interest in the outcome. They either really don't want one particular person or party
00:16:03 to get in, or they really do want another party or person to get in. And in the case of China,
00:16:10 it was the Liberal Party that was the beneficiary. It was the Chinese Communist Party that said of
00:16:16 all the options we have around the world, of elections in which we think we could have a bit
00:16:20 influence, they wanted the liberals. And more importantly, they did not want the conservatives.
00:16:27 And I'm sympathetic to people like Aaron O'Toole, who, to his credit, has always had a very clear
00:16:33 and convicted position on China and understands the threat that China poses to democracy and to
00:16:39 the Western world. And to people like Kenny Chu, we've had him on the show. He is a former
00:16:44 Conservative Member of Parliament and was himself personally the target of interference. His
00:16:51 advocacy for democracy, for liberty, his criticism of the Chinese regime did not evidently endear him
00:16:58 to the Chinese regime. And I think this is where it's an issue that we need to have a big discussion
00:17:04 on. Now, the Liberals have tried to downplay a lot of this. They've tried to put out reports that
00:17:10 all of the media reporting from people such as Sam Cooper and the Globe and Mail are all,
00:17:15 oh, it's not like that. And oh, this intelligence report is, yeah, you got to take it with a grain
00:17:19 of salt. But much of what we've heard in testimony this week has actually vindicated Sam Cooper,
00:17:26 most notably in the case of Han Dong, who was a Liberal member of Parliament until these
00:17:32 allegations came to light. And then he ultimately backed up and is now sitting as an independent,
00:17:37 and he's wanted to rejoin the Liberal Party.
00:17:39 But we've heard evidence that really vindicates
00:17:41 that this guy had a very, very inappropriate relationship
00:17:45 with the Chinese government
00:17:47 while he was supposed to be serving Canada's interests.
00:17:50 I want to discuss this with Kenny Chu,
00:17:52 former Conservative MP,
00:17:54 and he is welcome back on the show at any time.
00:17:57 Kenny, good to see you.
00:17:58 Thanks very much for coming back on today.
00:18:00 Good morning, good afternoon, Andrew.
00:18:02 Can you hear me okay?
00:18:03 Yes, I can.
00:18:04 And thank you for being with us again.
00:18:05 you were talking about this issue when no one else was because you saw this firsthand in your
00:18:11 riding. It's affected your political career and your life. Do you feel a little bit of
00:18:16 vindication this week when we're really hearing a lot of support for what you were talking about
00:18:21 years ago? It's a tough question, Andrew. But yes, there is a deep sense of vindication
00:18:30 that i i had when the uh commissioner council team presented me all the uh declassified
00:18:42 reports and also information and analysis all that has proven that uh you know yes in 2021
00:18:53 i wasn't hallucinating um i wasn't daydreaming or uh like um miss uh jennifer o'connell
00:19:02 the liberal mp said that i'm being donald trump
00:19:08 when you were being subjected to this and i think the term that you used is that you were drowning
00:19:13 in a chinese election misinformation did you think you were a part of a of a story that was
00:19:19 was unfolding nationally or did you think this was just you that was being targeted based on
00:19:23 you know what you've you know the reasons that the Chinese regime obviously wouldn't want 0.98
00:19:27 someone like you in office at the time as a local candidate your eyes is fixated to uh your writing
00:19:35 you don't even have time to to consider you know so-called the air wall uh so you know what what's
00:19:43 being debated nationally let alone internationally uh at that time even though i see telltale
00:19:50 signs that this is far more organized than any uh local constituents can do uh there is this
00:19:57 sense deep down inside me that uh maybe maybe i you know i've been poking depender eyes to
00:20:06 for too long and the panda is now striking back i know you were like the attacks on you were
00:20:12 were very personal. And I'll say foreign interference looks different to different
00:20:17 situations. I mean, in some cases, it could be money that's put into a riding that's connected
00:20:22 to a state. And in your case, it was a lot of it was misinformation that was being circulated
00:20:26 about you. Someone could easily say, listen, I mean, there's misinformation in politics all the
00:20:31 time. Politicians are called all sorts of names. What should have, in your view, been done to stop
00:20:37 this what could have been done to stop this you know that the the canadian reality is that there
00:20:44 are populations that are segregated that are uh base their information their day-in day-out
00:20:51 world view on uh their their selected platform of um social media or even just local radio
00:21:04 stations tv news or you know printed media uh it's all in the language that is not common to
00:21:13 a majority of the canadian and and that created a vacuum of information if imagine somebody could
00:21:21 control uh let's say let's say the uh vladimir putin regime decided to control canada's russian
00:21:29 population and if the russian population does not speak read write english or french it will become
00:21:37 very easy because all they have to do is just buy out the media that the local canadian media that
00:21:42 they have and then pump this information to to these diaspora community that that uses russian
00:21:51 social media. So this is what I observed to be the case in Canada, and it's still ongoing, Andrew.
00:22:01 I'll ask, I mean, I'll mention WeChat specifically. I ran for office provincially in Ontario many years
00:22:06 ago, and I had some volunteers that were from the Chinese community that were
00:22:09 incredible, hardworking people, and they said, oh, you've got to get on WeChat. It's how we talk. So
00:22:13 I did it. And, you know, before long, I was getting added to all of these different groups. And of
00:22:17 course, you know, I was looking at my phone, and it's all in, you know, I can't read any of it. So
00:22:21 So, you know, I don't know if it was helping me or hurting me.
00:22:24 But you raise an important point, which is that these are massive, massive networks.
00:22:28 I mean, WeChat itself is huge and people are communicating.
00:22:33 And it's really there's no way to catch up if you have something that is blatantly false,
00:22:38 something that could have been planted by a foreign actor that's circulating in these communities at a rapid pace in a language that many law enforcement and intelligence experts are not able to read.
00:22:48 Yeah, this is one point that had come up during the commission hearing yesterday. And, you know, it's actually worse than that, Andrew, unfortunately, because WeChat and Weixing and QQ or even Xiao Hong Su, Little Red Book, these are social media platforms that are popular in Chinese.
00:23:11 But in an authoritarian regime, all these platforms are not only monitored, but also has been tightly controlled.
00:23:24 Messages would be scanned and they will be traced and logged.
00:23:30 And so it's a big challenge.
00:23:33 If I could just interject there for a moment.
00:23:35 so theoretically if you were to try to combat this information and say this is all untrue and
00:23:41 here's why that might not even make it through the platform it may not because it's been it's
00:23:47 been controlled not just by the algorithm so your message could be prioritized much lower than the
00:23:54 other ones i'm sure you familiarize with that uh you know we live in canada now um but also it may
00:24:00 not even go through and even if it's gone through uh you know it may get prioritized against uh in
00:24:08 a lower rank than the the disinformation the thing is andrew uh you can summon the facebook uh
00:24:16 president or ceo or whatever uh that that'll register in canada to come to the house of
00:24:22 commons and ask them to explain hold them to account uh google is similar and we we've seen
00:24:28 that they've done that in in the u.s congress but good luck if you try to get uh you know the tick
00:24:35 tock mother company do in to come to uh parliament of canada to explain why their algorithm biases
00:24:43 one side you know from the other so what would you like to see moving forward because i mean the
00:24:50 liberal government has said that yes it takes this very seriously and they're going to do everything
00:24:55 that can to safeguard the next election i've not seen a concrete plan on what is being done to
00:25:01 stop this from happening so in the 2025 election which is going to be a you know very high stakes
00:25:06 election i could see this being exactly as problematic as it was in 2021. so far the
00:25:14 government seems to be still in denial mode i'm sure you have heard our prime minister justin
00:25:20 trudeau uh in response to uh you know the question about foreign interference uh he is still saying
00:25:28 that it's uh sour grapes these are sore losers and all that uh not recognizing it it's a big
00:25:35 problem because it sends two messages the first one is canadians should not uh be uh over concerned
00:25:43 about this this is nothing it lowers people's um uh alert on the situation and secondly it also
00:25:51 sends a message to russia iran you know people's republic of china all these predatorial uh nations
00:26:00 uh hostile nations that are interested in in influencing canada that you know we're still
00:26:07 burying our heads in the sand uh just like an ostrich and and so come come and explore exploit
00:26:13 our people uh in any way that you can well and i think that's a very important note because you
00:26:20 had said uh as well that canada didn't really protect you like you thought it would so uh look
00:26:26 the life is what it is and you know you may have been able to have won that election had this not
00:26:31 been there there's a very real chance you could have but the election happened the results were
00:26:35 certified what needs to be done if you had to you know write the law basically or could write
00:26:41 the law write the roadmap to the next election what would you do could have should have would
00:26:46 have andrew you're right and and erin o'toole even him said uh in an interview pretty much the same
00:26:53 thing what's important is how do how do we as canadians move forward uh the world it's a dog
00:27:00 dog world. It's very cruel. And we must safeguard our citizens from that. And what I would propose
00:27:09 is let's start with the lowest hanging fruit in establishing a foreign influence transparency
00:27:17 scheme, which is similar to what the Australian and I had proposed. That way, we're not denying
00:27:25 anybody's political activities or rights but we're just moving them from underneath the table
00:27:31 to above to be able and under the sunlight and as we all know it's the best disinfectant
00:27:37 beyond that uh we also need um perhaps fact checkers that are uh in their native language
00:27:44 and these could be um non-government agencies that are certified by by the government to be
00:27:51 uh you know to have the integrity and honesty they could be university they could be ngos proper
00:27:59 and then during the election time these organizations if they could analyze specific
00:28:06 language responsible for fact checking a certain language then the government could direct
00:28:13 you know diaspora communities doesn't matter whether it's iranian persian
00:28:17 or Chinese or Mandarin Cantonese to these certified fact checkers for information to
00:28:25 confirm so there are many things that we can do and you know one of the best country to
00:28:31 for us to ask brainstorming ideas is actually Taiwan they are at the front line of this info
00:28:39 wall with uh with china so they have garnered tremendous amount of experience and ideas and
00:28:47 i'm sure they are more than willing to share with us all right well i appreciate that very
00:28:51 much and your continued advocacy on this i mean in in a roundabout way it's a great compliment
00:28:57 to your integrity that you were targeted because it means that they felt threatened by what you
00:29:01 were doing so i appreciate you speaking up in this way kenny chu thank you andrew for having me
00:29:07 all right my pleasure you're welcome back anytime uh one thing i wanted to revisit was the immigration
00:29:13 about face from justin trudeau i uh shared the clip the last couple days justin trudeau comes
00:29:18 out and says what most canadians were thinking of and realizing which was that canada has had a bit
00:29:25 of an overflow of immigration in terms of temporary residence and it's been uh more than the country
00:29:31 could absorb those are justin trudeau's languages or that's justin trudeau's language far beyond i
00:29:35 I should say, far beyond what Canada could absorb. Now, this means it's exacerbated housing,
00:29:41 employment, health care resources. And it's a little bit interesting, as I pointed out yesterday,
00:29:46 that Justin Trudeau has made this claim when it is effectively admitting that over the last nine
00:29:52 years, his government has allowed this problem to take place. Now, this, I said, is basically a
00:29:58 finger pointed directly at Sean Fraser, who up until a minute ago was the immigration minister.
00:30:04 Now he's the housing minister.
00:30:06 And I said, if I'm Sean Frazier, I'd be wondering, well, hang on, why are you throwing me under
00:30:10 this bus?
00:30:11 Well, a journalist did put to Sean Frazier effectively that question, which is kind of
00:30:16 how do you feel with this admission?
00:30:18 And oh boy, was this some, I was going to say twetzel-pristing. 0.98
00:30:23 I believe pretzel-twisting is better.
00:30:25 But to be honest, I actually kind of like twetzel-pristing.
00:30:27 So here were some twetzel-pristing from Sean Frazier.
00:30:31 today you heard the prime minister say that immigration to canada has grown at a rate far
00:30:36 beyond what canada has been able to absorb much of that growth came while you were immigration
00:30:40 minister do you regret not putting restrictions on international students or temporary foreign
00:30:45 workers while you were in your previous role uh first and it's clear jillian you have an
00:30:50 understanding of this but for the benefit of those who may be listening it's important that we
00:30:54 distinguish between permanent residency and temporary residency of course as we increased
00:30:59 the permanent immigration levels that a lot of factors go into those considerations including
00:31:06 the capacity of communities to seek both the benefits of growing population and manage
00:31:12 population growth in a sustained and planned way and i'm very comfortable with the track that we're
00:31:16 on as a federal government when it comes to permanent residency when it comes to temporary
00:31:20 residency there's not a similar annual exercise where the federal government sets a particular
00:31:24 level. Instead, historically, what has happened is employers based on demand and the need to prove
00:31:31 that they cannot find a Canadian to fill a particular role will be able to recruit through
00:31:36 the temporary foreign worker program workers to fill those roles. When it comes to international
00:31:40 students, what we've seen in recent years was significant growth led by institutions who, again,
00:31:48 are using a demand-driven program without regard to the need to house those students. Well, I was
00:31:53 still in that portfolio, and you'll hear answers to interview questions I gave back in the spring
00:31:57 of last year, we were moving towards some of the measures that Minister Miller has put in place,
00:32:02 and I think those measures have largely been the right thing to do, to insist that a demand-driven
00:32:08 program, when it puts too much pressure on communities and doesn't provide the housing
00:32:12 or other services people need, then we did need to step in. Overall, I feel coming out of the
00:32:19 pandemic. It was essential that we listened to businesses that were at risk of closure when we
00:32:23 had over a million job vacancies in the economy, that we listened to institutions who had gone for
00:32:28 a few years without access to international students who may have been studying abroad
00:32:32 and weren't able to come into Canada. But as we come out of this pandemic era and post-pandemic
00:32:37 phase, more to what we feel is a normal and stable course for the next few years ahead,
00:32:43 I think we have to make sure that even on the temporary programs, which are historically driven
00:32:47 by employers and institutions we put measures in place to ensure that communities can accommodate
00:32:52 a growing population oh ever interesting so yeah when it comes to permanent residents oh yes
00:32:59 government can we can control that temporary residents oh no it's it's businesses they decide
00:33:03 what they need and universities they decide what they need he's basically blaming everyone but the
00:33:09 liberal government so justin trudeau says yeah uh this was terrible it wasn't sustainable then his
00:33:14 His immigration minister gets the obvious question and it's everyone else's fault.
00:33:17 Now, my hope would be that all of this means we can finally have that adult conversation on immigration.
00:33:23 Justin Trudeau said yesterday or two days ago what just like five days ago would have been called racist if someone else said it.
00:33:32 Because if you have a discussion about immigration, that's inevitably where it goes.
00:33:36 And this was part of an essay that was published by Macdonald-Laurier Institute, written by Joe Adam George a couple of months back.
00:33:43 Canada, it's not racist or xenophobic to talk about immigration. So my hope would be that all
00:33:49 of this triggers a real grown-up discussion on immigration, that we can shed the name-calling
00:33:55 and put that all aside and have it. Whether we'll get that in politics, I don't know, but we
00:34:00 certainly should. Joe Adam George joins me now from the Macdonald-Laurier Institute. Joe, good
00:34:05 to talk to you. Thanks for coming on today. Absolute pleasure, Andrew. So let's first off
00:34:11 talk about why this has become such an impossible conversation because you trace in your essay back
00:34:18 more than 50 years when Canada became from an official perspective a multicultural country and
00:34:23 I don't think on its surface there's anything wrong with recognizing that Canada has people
00:34:28 of different cultures and backgrounds. I think the application of this though certainly in modern
00:34:33 political discourse has led to some pretty untenable like you say I mean just allegations
00:34:39 of xenophobia when people want to say what are pretty reasonable things.
00:34:44 Absolutely, Andrew.
00:34:45 And I'd like to begin by saying that I'm glad that Prime Minister Trudeau proved me right
00:34:51 when he said what he said.
00:34:53 But I mean, we have been talking about this for a long time, haven't we?
00:34:58 The conservatives have been talking about this, the economists, people who are specialists
00:35:06 on housing and other policy areas.
00:35:10 I've been talking about the same thing.
00:35:11 So I'm not at all surprised
00:35:13 that he's now doing a flip-flop on the issue.
00:35:16 But then this isn't the first time
00:35:17 that the Liberals are doing it.
00:35:18 And I suspect this is not going to be
00:35:20 the last time as well.
00:35:22 And also specifically...
00:35:27 Oh, I think we've lost Joe there.
00:35:31 We'll get Joe back in a moment.
00:35:32 See, this is what happens
00:35:33 in Justin Trudeau's Canada.
00:35:34 you start making sense in an interview and that uh those internet regulations they they cut you
00:35:39 clean off uh we'll get uh joe adam george back on in a moment there we go carry on sir uh yes
00:35:47 um sorry so i was saying with regard to my piece uh i wanted to also clarify that this is by no way
00:35:54 an anti-immigration piece the old idea of the piece was that i am absolutely supportive of 0.71
00:35:59 immigration and i believe that canada has to have immigration but it needs to be done right
00:36:05 and what really pissed me off as a person of color and as a pro as you know as an immigrant myself
00:36:12 is that we can't seem to have these honest conversations around um around immigration
00:36:19 around uh even allied issues like housing infrastructure uh crime uh foreign policy
00:36:28 uh you know without being branded as racist or xenophobic and that's what really frustrates me
00:36:33 and i find that very disingenuous when it comes from the liberals and the progressive left
00:36:38 uh but i'm really glad that the conversation and the narrative around this issue is now being
00:36:44 you know it's now significantly changing but i know
00:36:47 Oh, we've lost him. There we go.
00:36:54 But yeah, I fear that, you know, in the years to come, if we continue down this path, it's
00:37:02 going to be very bleak for Canada and we're going to lose the consensus on immigration
00:37:07 altogether. And, you know, I think it's time that we as Canadians address that, you know,
00:37:13 not exactly working out the way we desired. It's not just the economic factors in itself, but also,
00:37:20 as I mentioned in my article, the social cohesion part of it as well. There is, as you can see,
00:37:27 since October 7th, we haven't had the kind of social integration that we have desired.
00:37:34 You've seen the protests play out on the street, the anti-Semitism on the rise. All this
00:37:41 you know, is symptomatic of the failure of the policies of Trudeau, of Justin Trudeau. And I'd
00:37:48 like to see, hopefully, if the next Conservative government comes to power, to try and rectify it.
00:37:54 I mean, though I would imagine it's going to be a Gargantuan challenge for them.
00:37:59 One thing that you touch on in your piece, which I think is quite important, and it's what's missing
00:38:04 from the immigration discussion in Canada, is the idea of integration. And even the Conservatives
00:38:09 are guilty of this. Well, they talk about it only in economic terms. They say, okay, well,
00:38:13 do we have enough jobs, enough homes, and enough healthcare resources, which is a fair question
00:38:18 for a society if you're talking about population growth. But integration has been, I mean,
00:38:23 going back to 2015, when the Conservatives were talking about Canadian values, and that was deemed
00:38:28 as just horrendous and offensive and racist. But you've argued here, and you talked to Eric
00:38:33 Kaufman, a professor who's been on this show a couple of times, that's just completely missing,
00:38:38 but it's a very important part of the discussion. Absolutely. And I think Professor Kaufman has
00:38:44 made some very interesting points. One thing I wanted to even highlight as well, as a matter of
00:38:49 fact, like I alluded to before, that any kind of discussion around immigration is just branded as
00:38:58 racist xenophobic. Something even as simple as people choosing where to live in Canada.
00:39:03 You know, it isn't uncommon for people to choose which part of Toronto or Calgary or Vancouver they want to live in because, I mean, this is not just specific to whites alone.
00:39:18 It's also very commonplace for ethnic minority groups to live in cities or communities where, you know, they have their fellow community members so that they like to feel comfortable.
00:39:32 We have seen that in Brampton or Mississauga, for example.
00:39:37 But often it seems like when you talk about this, you know, white people tend to be branded as racist and so on.
00:39:46 But it's and I find that very disingenuous, again, because because you have ethnic minority groups doing it for the same reasons as well. 1.00
00:39:55 And, you know, and you can't, I think it's very unfair to punish people for choosing
00:40:00 where they want to live any more than you can punish people for choosing who they want
00:40:05 to marry or date.
00:40:07 One point that's interesting, and you raised this in your piece, is other countries that
00:40:12 have gone through their own about face on this.
00:40:15 And countries have typically been very progressive, very pro-immigration.
00:40:18 I don't even like calling it pro-immigration because you and I are both pro-immigration,
00:40:22 but we're pro-sensible immigration.
00:40:24 So other countries, like Germany is one of the biggest examples of, I think, a failure on the immigration front. They went through this horrendous asylum year in, I think it was like 2014 or 2015. They brought in a million people in the span of a year and had a lot of issues over the next few years that still continue to this day.
00:40:44 Germany has had legislation to allow for easier deportation of asylum seekers.
00:40:50 Australia has reduced immigration.
00:40:52 The UK, again, a country that's gone through its own reversal on this.
00:40:56 So other countries are starting to come around on this, even when they've been averse.
00:41:00 Does that give you hope for there to be, in Canada, a more sensible or common sense approach to this issue?
00:41:08 Well, certainly not under the Liberal government.
00:41:11 I'm not confident of that.
00:41:13 I would imagine the conservatives would be more proactive on the file, though I would suspect that the liberals and the NDP would then go about, as you know, they've done in the past, would just label conservatives as racist.
00:41:28 So I'm not, but I would imagine they would go about doing the right thing to address the issue.
00:41:33 But the problem, like I said, you know, in the article as well, is because, you know, the issue of political correctness is so strong in Canada as compared to other, most of our Western peers.
00:41:46 You know, it's very hard to have a discussion around this.
00:41:51 So, but if you see countries like you mentioned, Andrew, in Europe, you see the countries that have clamped down on immigration.
00:41:59 These are not governments that are right-wing governments.
00:42:04 For example, if you've seen Denmark or France or Germany, these are left or left-of-center governments.
00:42:14 So, in fact, Denmark, the Denmark government is run by the equivalent of our NDP, the Social Democrats.
00:42:23 And they have our zero refugee policy, which, I mean, if you were trying to implement that in Canada, you would most certainly be branded as racist.
00:42:35 So, you know, which is why you can see that the consensus on immigration in Europe is certainly dwindling.
00:42:43 And also, as you can see, down south in our neighbors in the U.S. as well, immigration has become the most, you know,
00:42:50 it's a major hot button issue for the upcoming elections. So I suspect that it's going to be
00:42:56 no different here in Canada when our next elections come. Joe, Adam, George, good to talk
00:43:03 to you, sir. Great piece at the Macdonald-Laurier Institute, a bit of an evergreen one, but
00:43:07 a renewed relevance this week with the admissions from the Liberals. So I appreciate you coming on,
00:43:11 sir. Thank you so much, Andrew. All right. Thank you. We are just been out of time for today and
00:43:17 for the week. I will tell you now, next week, well, the beginning of the week will be a bit
00:43:22 of a normal week, but later on, I'm going to be broadcasting live from the Canada Strong and Free
00:43:28 Network Conference in Ottawa. We've got a great set of shows planned out. Actually, I say that
00:43:33 we haven't planned any of it, but it will, well, we got one. No, we have one interview lined up,
00:43:36 but it's a really good interview. It's a former prime minister, but not of Canada. So it'll be
00:43:40 good though. And we'll have some other stuff planned. I am going to be interviewing Blaine
00:43:44 Higgs and Danielle Smith on stage so that will be fun and hopefully we'll have some footage of that
00:43:49 to share with you but do stay tuned and if you're in Ottawa might be worth coming out and seeing us
00:43:55 and Sean's trying to tell me other things that are I'm not I'm not teasing the whole week next
00:43:58 week Sean I'm just talking about what's happening at Canada Strong and Free no uh they I'm not going
00:44:03 to tell them who the surprise Monday guest is until Monday so uh that'll we do have a surprise
00:44:07 Monday guest on Monday's show which will be a lot of fun but uh anyway that does it for uh that but
00:44:13 we did, I try to kind of give the people what they want. We had a super chat on YouTube, which
00:44:19 is, we're very grateful for. Marco Peruzza writes when Pierre, because we were talking about the
00:44:24 walk-on music that Jagmeet Singh has, where he dances even though he lost. So Marco says,
00:44:29 when Pierre enters the 2025 debate, I want the Stone Cold entrance music. I believe Stone Cold
00:44:35 Steve Austin is what that's a reference to, the pro wrestler. And one of my colleagues was
00:44:42 incredibly bored, so created this for you.
00:45:12 thank you very much who's ready to axe the tax
00:45:17 who's ready to build the homes who's ready to fix the budget and who's ready to stop the crime
00:45:27 i i know okay so i won't name the person i think i might have just named the person who did that
00:45:35 you couldn't have found a video where his face didn't have a sign in front of it for the first
00:45:39 half of it anyway uh it was okay so you got the song marco i hope it was worth your uh five dollar
00:45:45 super chat we appreciate very much your support all right well i'm back tomorrow for off the
00:45:49 record next week from ottawa and i hope you have a fantastic weekend here from the andrew lawton
00:45:54 show team thank you god bless and good day to you all thanks for listening to the andrew lawton
00:46:00 support the program by donating to true north at www.tnc.news
00:46:09 We'll be right back.
00:46:39 We'll be right back.
00:47:09 We'll be right back.