Juno News - April 17, 2024


No end in sight for Trudeau’s spending

Topics
Mentioned
Governor General shills for Liberal "online harms" regulations Poilievre and Trudeau face off on housing crisis

Episode Stats


Length

49 minutes

Words per minute

176.83

Word count

8,749

Sentence count

479

Harmful content

Misogyny

7

sentences flagged

Toxicity

2

sentences flagged

Hate speech

4

sentences flagged


Summary

Summaries generated with gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ .

In this episode of Canada's Most Irreverent Talk Show, host Andrew Lawton takes a behind-the-scenes look at what it's like to be a dog-sitter for his parents' dog and talks about the latest federal budget.

Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Topics generated with Qwen2.5-3B-Instruct.
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 Transcription by CastingWords
00:00:30 Thank you.
00:01:00 Welcome to Canada's Most Irreverent Talk Show.
00:01:16 This is the Andrew Lawton Show, brought to you by True North.
00:01:24 Hello and welcome to you all, Canada's Most Irreverent Talk Show.
00:01:28 hear The Andrew Lawton Show on this Wednesday, April 17th. Now, I have to apologize in advance
00:01:34 a little bit if there's something indiscernible different about the audio, by which I mean if
00:01:40 there's a little bit more of an echo. So I was being the good son. I love dogs. So when I had
00:01:46 an opportunity arise to dog sit my parents' lovely yellow lab, I naturally jumped at the opportunity.
00:01:53 She's a beautiful little thing and is so well-behaved, so mild-mannered, so quiet.
00:01:58 It's so lovely until yesterday, moments before I was about to go on air,
00:02:03 I sat down and I smelled something and realized that she had to relieve herself overnight. 1.00
00:02:09 And attempts to salvage the rug that served both an aesthetic and a soundproofing purpose for this show were unsuccessful.
00:02:18 So we've like just removed the rug altogether.
00:02:19 weather and I noticed that when I was coming in I can like do the Ricola thing because it just has
00:02:25 a bit of an echo in this room now. So this is the behind the scenes look at the Andrew Lawton show
00:02:30 you'd never know you were going to get but it never nevertheless it's good to have you tuned
00:02:34 into the program here. I'm going to be breaking down as promised yesterday the latest from the
00:02:39 federal budget which I kind of could have called I kind of did call actually because I had shared a
00:02:46 meme online a couple of weeks back just about this. It was from this show, It's Always Sunny
00:02:50 in Philadelphia, about these guys talking about a self-sustaining economy. The money moves around
00:02:55 and around. And it's clear they didn't grasp at all how economics or finance or the financial
00:03:01 system worked. And I had remarked that it seemed like it was the Liberal government planning the
00:03:06 budget for this year. And then, of course, I heard the budget from last year. And I'm even more
00:03:10 convinced that that was the case. We have more money being spent. No plan to balance the budget.
00:03:16 projections that are changing above and beyond what last year's projections were which were
00:03:20 different from the year before so the government isn't even sticking to its own projections and
00:03:26 forecasts let alone anything else and in the end what we have here is a system in which the
00:03:32 government is pretending to be speaking up and standing for the middle class they're trying to
00:03:37 do all this big talking tough thing they're saying oh yes we're going to tax the rich they're going
00:03:42 to fiddle with the capital gains tax they're going to make billions more through that and
00:03:47 they're going to use that to dump it into housing and what's been fascinating here is how little
00:03:52 confidence there is in Canada and what Canada is doing from a lot of people if you've been following
00:03:58 a lot of the tech world at the entrepreneurial world online you'll see and we have a story
00:04:03 coming out about this a little bit later on this afternoon a lot of people saying like what on earth
00:04:07 is Canada doing here? Because they are stifling growth. The government is stifling entrepreneurship.
00:04:15 And just to look into some of these numbers in a bit of detail here, I will do that, but I want
00:04:20 to pull out some specifics first and foremost, because the government says, oh yes, you know,
00:04:25 that we have to be very tough with this. They're saying we're going to get rid of 5,000 federal
00:04:30 public service rolls through attrition. And then you hear the government also putting forward this
00:04:36 little nifty graph here that I wanted to share with you. This is a graph showing the cumulative
00:04:41 federal investments to support inclusion and combat hate. So by 2028, the federal government
00:04:50 will have spent $1.1 billion on so-called inclusion and combating hate. Now that is a lot of tampons
00:05:00 in men's washrooms. I don't know what the unit cost of a tampon in a men's washroom is, but
00:05:04 you probably need a lot of them to get to that 1.1 billion dollars. Now perhaps there are some
00:05:08 other line items that come under that, but a billion dollars to combat hate. And when you
00:05:13 look at what the government defines as hate, we know that it's really just an excuse to shovel
00:05:18 money to groups that are supporting a very liberal interpretation of what free speech should be,
00:05:24 which is to say not something that is protected. And the government also found tens of millions
00:05:29 of dollars for CBC oh yes the state broadcaster above and beyond the 1.4 billion dollars a year
00:05:35 it already gets now gets tens of millions of dollars more a somewhat I think 42 million was
00:05:41 the exact number there 42 million that CBC is now going to get when their executives were collecting
00:05:48 millions of dollars in bonuses all the while President Catherine Tate screams about the 1.00
00:05:53 necessity to make layoffs and cut jobs. So CBC is talking about job losses, they're paying fat
00:06:00 executive bonuses, and what do they get for all of this? But a big giant reward from the federal
00:06:05 government into the tune of $40 million plus. So that's where things are going there. Now I find
00:06:14 it interesting just to set the stage here. This is a government that has been incredibly embattled.
00:06:18 The carbon tax fight that Pierre Paulyev and most premiers have been taking up has been effective.
00:06:23 It's been landing blows on the federal government.
00:06:27 Take, for example, this clip from Andrew Fury, who is the premier of Newfoundland.
00:06:31 And before we play it, just a bit of context.
00:06:34 There was a by-election loss that Newfoundland saw go incredibly, incredibly dramatically towards the PCs.
00:06:43 And this is what Andrew Fury, or towards the liberals from the PCs.
00:06:47 And this is what Andrew Furey had to say.
00:06:50 Used to be an asset being a friend of the Liberal Party federally.
00:06:53 Now it seems like it's maybe not.
00:06:55 You're talking about fighting them.
00:06:56 No, no, I'm not fighting.
00:06:57 I mean, I think, you know, on the carbon tax in particular, the prime minister has tried to bait me at times with certain ad hominems and name calling almost.
00:07:08 But look, we have a very different opinion on the carbon tax.
00:07:12 It's not right for the people of the province.
00:07:14 right now, given the inflationary pressures, given the indirect costs and induced costs that
00:07:19 trickles down to people's tables. We hear that. We understand that. I wish the Prime Minister
00:07:24 would understand that. He's being very sclerotic in his approach on this ideologic marriage that
00:07:29 he has, this principle. That's not to say that we don't believe in fighting climate change. We
00:07:33 certainly do. But this policy is wrong for the people of the province right now.
00:07:37 the policy is wrong for the people of the province now this is I think very interesting he says
00:07:46 Trudeau's trying to bait him so he's basically taking the comments that Justin Trudeau has made
00:07:52 and pushed them right back at the federal government has what Premier Fury is saying
00:07:56 there is that this is just bad policy it's nothing else it's bad policy it's bad for the people of
00:08:01 the province and that to me is I think a point that Justin Trudeau would for his own benefit
00:08:06 his own political future, do well to take seriously. Now, we couldn't talk about the
00:08:12 federal budget without talking about our old friend Jagmeet Singh, the leader of the NDP,
00:08:17 who has, of course, had no shortage of criticisms about the budget. Let's share a couple of his
00:08:23 tweets on this. Canadians are struggling, he says. This is one point here. There was a video.
00:08:29 Pierre Polyev is fighting to make his rich friends richer. Justin Trudeau had nine years,
00:08:34 but only acts when we force him to.
00:08:37 We're not going to stop.
00:08:39 We're going to take on corporate greed
00:08:41 and we're fighting to lower your bills.
00:08:43 Then he also had this one to say here.
00:08:46 Conservative handouts will continue.
00:08:49 Justin Trudeau will keep Pierre Polyev's
00:08:51 $60 billion in taxpayer handouts to corporation.
00:08:54 Thanks to Pierre and Justin.
00:08:56 It's a good day for greedy Galen Weston
00:08:58 and a bad day for you.
00:09:01 And I think we have one more
00:09:02 from the greatest hits of Jagmeet Singh here.
00:09:06 Budget 2024 tells us two things that we already knew.
00:09:09 One, new Democrats are lowering your bills.
00:09:11 Two, conservatives want to cut services for you
00:09:13 and continue a $60 billion handout
00:09:16 to corporations like Loblaw.
00:09:18 Liberals don't have the courage to go after corporate greed.
00:09:21 New Democrats do.
00:09:22 Ooh, it sounds like Jagmeet Singh
00:09:25 is not happy with the federal budget.
00:09:28 He also had this to say at a press conference.
00:09:30 What is the budget you will support?
00:10:00 What is the plan to ensure that Indigenous communities that for so long have not received adequate funding for infrastructure and housing, what's the plan to close that gap?
00:10:09 What's the plan to address the fact that $500 or $200 a month for people living with disabilities is insufficient?
00:10:16 What is the plan to address those concerns?
00:10:18 So I want to hear that from the Prime Minister before we make a decision.
00:10:23 Oh, well, maybe we'll support it.
00:10:26 I've got some criticisms.
00:10:28 I've got some problems.
00:10:29 Oh, it's terrible.
00:10:30 but uh i don't know maybe maybe if he tells me all this stuff i'll support it this was another
00:10:34 clip from that same press conference yesterday a couple concerns you have with the budget as it
00:10:40 exists what kind of changes must you see in there to get support from the ndp on this one well
00:10:46 there's one contrast that's very clear while i've identified it again and again the reason why your
00:10:51 groceries are high the reason why your cell phone bills are high the reason why you can't afford
00:10:54 housing is corporate greed and the liberals are failing to address that and the conservatives
00:10:59 want to do that either conservatives and the liberals are far too close to wealthy ceos and
00:11:04 big corporations to take on the real reason why your cost of living is so high that's a contrast
00:11:09 it's clear to me that the liberals and nor nor the conservatives are ever going to address that
00:11:13 you'll need new democrats to address that problem but in terms of but in terms of
00:11:18 but in terms of the specific question uh we i need to hear a plan from the from the prime minister
00:11:23 what is his plan to respond to the concerns that i have before we make a decision
00:11:27 But you listed a bunch of concerns there.
00:11:30 Do you need all of those concerns filled?
00:11:32 What is the must-have of those concerns in order to secure your support?
00:11:35 Well, each and every one of those are very important concerns,
00:11:37 so I want to hear what the plan is.
00:11:39 How is the Prime Minister going to guarantee
00:11:41 that there's not massive cuts to services for Canadians
00:11:44 with the cutting of 5,000 employees?
00:11:46 How is he going to justify to people living with disabilities 1.00
00:11:49 that $200 a month is enough to meet their needs?
00:11:52 I need to hear a plan on that before we make a decision.
00:11:55 Last question.
00:11:56 likely blown up now sir with your you know we're not sure you're going to support the budget you're
00:12:01 ready to go in an election is this where we're at where we're at right now is there's things in the
00:12:05 budget that we we fought for that are there there's problems that we have i want to hear
00:12:09 what the plan is from the prime minister to address me so he's basically saying yeah we're
00:12:16 terrible we don't like this it's bad but oh no no oh no no i don't want to go to an election just
00:12:21 yeah no don't take that yeah no it's fine it's fine and then he starts touting all of these
00:12:25 great achievements that he thinks are, well, that he thinks are achievements. I'm not going to do
00:12:30 the dancing video. I did the dancing video last time where he like loses an election and then
00:12:34 just does like a bangra dance on stage as though he has some reason to celebrate. But the thing
00:12:40 about Singh here is that he could be, if he wanted to, one of the most influential figures in Canada,
00:12:45 yet instead he is a lackey and a lapdog for Justin Trudeau and does, I think, this incredibly,
00:12:53 incredibly harmful thing for the country in which he says on one hand yeah this liberal government 0.74
00:12:58 can you believe the stuff they're doing well conveniently glossing over the fact that he has
00:13:04 been voting for that he has been voting for and endorsing that same liberal government's conduct
00:13:11 and activities and again I'll remind you of the fundamental point here no plan to balance the
00:13:17 budget at all? None whatsoever. Now I had asked, there's a clip I saw just before we went on the
00:13:23 show here from Chrystia Freeland. I don't know if we'll be able to get it in the show today,
00:13:26 but she basically was asked in an interview if you can have, if being balanced matters for the
00:13:32 budget. And her answer was basically, well, I don't know, it's more important to be fiscally
00:13:37 responsible than to have a balanced budget. So the federal government is basically committing
00:13:42 to this idea that a balanced budget doesn't matter.
00:13:45 It's a far cry from this old gem from Justin Trudeau.
00:13:50 So in this economic climate, how committed to a balanced budget would you be right now?
00:13:57 Would it worry you to go into deficit in this current climate to, as you say, put more people
00:14:01 to work?
00:14:02 The commitment needs to be a commitment to grow the economy and the budget will balance
00:14:07 itself.
00:14:07 oh the budget will balance itself that was nine years ago 10 years ago actually almost
00:14:16 and to be honest the budget has not balanced itself i don't know when the budget is going
00:14:21 to balance itself i've been waiting i've been waiting so patiently as a taxpaying canadian
00:14:26 for the budget to balance itself and yet i have seen no such balance take place and even in the
00:14:31 next five years according to the liberal government's latest projections the budget
00:14:35 does not seem keen on balancing itself. Now, perhaps if left to its own devices, the budget
00:14:41 would balance itself, then it would go and take a nice holiday and call it a day. But it strikes me
00:14:48 as inconvenient that the Liberal government is balancing, balancing, balancing. Oh, except not
00:14:54 actually, because that was only when they were convinced it would balance itself. And a decade
00:14:58 later, almost balanced budgets aren't all that important. No, no, no, it doesn't really. You
00:15:02 don't need to balance the budget as long as it's fiscally responsible. Well, I'm not even seeing
00:15:08 the fiscal responsibility baked into this budget that Chrystia Freeland is claiming is there. And
00:15:14 we're going to talk about this in a few moments with someone who has the business perspective on
00:15:19 this. And we'll also chat with our old friend, Franco Terrazzano momentarily. But just to again,
00:15:24 put some context here, we are seeing a government that on one hand is trying to do this weird sort
00:15:30 of like class fighting thing where they say, oh, we're taking aim at the wealthy. We're taking aim
00:15:35 at the rich. We're taking aim at all of that. And as we were talking about yesterday with Ryan
00:15:39 Mallow from the Canadian Federation of Independent Business, they do this while trying to sort of
00:15:45 look at the so-called middle class, which is a group that admittedly can be a bit amorphous in
00:15:49 politics and say, we've got your back. We're supporting you. And this is what Jagmeet Singh
00:15:54 is doing when he takes aim at corporate greed. He is trying to tell all of these people that all of
00:15:59 their problems, all of the issues they have, the reason they can't afford groceries. It's not
00:16:03 inflation. It's not the carbon tax. It's not bad financial policy, bad monetary policy. No,
00:16:09 it's Galen Weston. Galen Weston is the reason that you can't afford groceries. I want to welcome
00:16:14 into the show our good friend, Catherine Swift. I got to see her in person last week at the Canada
00:16:19 Strong and Free Network Conference. She is the president of the Coalition of Concerned
00:16:24 Manufacturers and Businesses of Canada. Catherine, always good to talk to you. Thanks so much for
00:16:29 coming on today. My pleasure. I'd love to talk budgets, Andrew. Just love it. Well, you know,
00:16:35 I've seen over the last, I don't know, 16 hours or whatever, 18 hours, a lot of people that are
00:16:41 with big companies, people that have worked in the tech space, entrepreneurial space that are saying
00:16:46 everything that came out yesterday is just bad news for business. It's bad news for making Canada
00:16:51 competitive and i wanted to to get your perspective on this i mean from an independent business
00:16:55 perspective but just in general for canadian industry yeah it's very bad of course the the
00:17:04 burgeoning deficits and debts are bad for every canadian and including business so uh the fact i
00:17:12 the fact they presented this as somehow a good budget for young people i i couldn't figure that
00:17:17 one out because the young people are going to be paying these massive debts deficits and the fact
00:17:23 that we now have our debt service is 54 billion dollars just to pay interest on the debt uh it
00:17:30 is taking away from any product productive services in our economy so that's one aspect
00:17:35 there's capital gains bumping capital gains i mean to me 50 is pretty rich to start with
00:17:40 bumping that to two-thirds is unconscionable and of course business say everything will only affect
00:17:46 the rich, and so on and so forth. Oh, no, no, no. It'll certainly affect business, investments on the
00:17:52 part of business, assets that they have. They easily can meet that $250,000 threshold. Anybody
00:18:00 who has businesses that have a business premise, perhaps, or a few business premises, and they want
00:18:06 to reorganize that, they're going to be facing charges there. We see anyone that has a second
00:18:13 residents, for that matter, a cottage, say, or whatever, which a lot of free middle-class people
00:18:16 do, and plan to leave it to their kids. Well, now their kids are going to get dinged with a whole
00:18:21 bunch more. And they overall, the funny thing is, Freeland acknowledged our productivity problem a
00:18:28 little while ago. Mind you, it's the 800-pound gorilla in the room. It's pretty hard not to
00:18:32 acknowledge it. But what she has done in this budget is only going to worsen our productivity 0.99
00:18:37 issue. And maybe people think that's some sort of theoretical economic concept. But our
00:18:42 productivity is our standard of living. And we know our standard of living has been stagnant
00:18:47 ever since the Trudeau government's been in power. And what's the most important thing to
00:18:52 enhance productivity is investment. Investment has already fled Canada because our government
00:18:57 can't, we can't get anything built. We can't get anything done. We have building permits that go
00:19:01 on for 10, you know, you don't get something for 10 years. It's utterly ridiculous. But we've 0.83
00:19:06 already killed investment. This capital gains change is going to kill it even more. And that's
00:19:11 our standard of living again. So I just don't get what version of economics, none I've ever seen,
00:19:18 they're basing their thinking on. And boy, I sure hope we have an election sooner rather than later
00:19:24 because I think most Canadians are figuring out that they're getting badly hurt by this government
00:19:29 and it's certainly not helping the broader picture at all. And Chrystia Freeland, I should point out
00:19:35 here, and you noted this in a statement yesterday, had previously said that we were going to keep
00:19:39 deficit under 40 billion dollars as though we're supposed to be grateful for such fiscal prudence
00:19:44 with a deficit that's only 40 billion now it came in just under that we're at 39.8 billion now you
00:19:51 you're suspecting that if you like lift the hood there and take a look around there's going to be
00:19:55 some creative accounting just to get it below that target absolutely no she really the fact
00:20:00 that she focused on it so much prior to the budget i thought oh they're going to pull some fast one
00:20:05 here that won't be apparent right off the bat, but to make that, you know, because she's always
00:20:11 talked about, oh, I have my guardrails and I have my, you know, all these things that she's not
00:20:16 supposed to go past the red line. And yet she's gone over every red line she's set for herself
00:20:23 since. So this one, I wasn't surprised to see it barely. It was by 200 million dollars, I believe
00:20:31 that it was under the $40 billion.
00:20:35 But I would bet serious money today, Andrew,
00:20:39 that that will never be achieved.
00:20:41 When we get the final data,
00:20:42 this isn't the final data for the fiscal year.
00:20:44 We don't get that till usually around September.
00:20:47 And I think once we see those accounts,
00:20:49 we'll see that it's even worse.
00:20:51 And going forward, of course, as you said,
00:20:53 there's clearly no attempt at all to come toward balance.
00:20:57 There's the kind of reduction by a few billion a year.
00:21:00 I don't believe that'll happen either.
00:21:02 We're going to see, again, interest rates are a plague on Canadians right now.
00:21:06 And the higher, the more debt they go into, the more they tax Canadians, the higher they 0.53
00:21:13 keep interest rates for longer.
00:21:14 The Bank of Canada has already said the government's fiscal policy is running absolutely contrary
00:21:20 to the Bank of Canada's monetary policy.
00:21:23 So that prevents, I mean, we all want to see interest rates come down.
00:21:26 A lot of Canadians have yet to renew a mortgage at those higher rates, and they're going to
00:21:30 get hammered when that happens. Some already have been hammered. That won't happen as long as this
00:21:35 government pursues these kinds of policies. They're just making it worse for everyone.
00:21:40 Yeah, and I want to rhyme off some of the numbers here since you bring up the deficit. So we have
00:21:45 the projection for this budget year, $39.8 billion as a deficit. Next year, $38.9 billion.
00:21:54 the year after 30.8 billion, 2027, 2028, 26.8 billion. The end of the projections, 2028 to
00:22:02 2029, the budgetary deficit will be down to $20 billion. So no plan to balance the budget. And if
00:22:09 you go at that rate, it would probably take another decade to get there. And what's interesting
00:22:14 too, is if you look at the debt as a percentage of GDP, that number is relatively stagnant. It
00:22:21 goes from, you know, 42 to 41 and a half to 40.8 to 40 to 39. So we're still going to be at 39%
00:22:27 of our debt as a percentage of GDP within five years if the liberals have their way. And as you
00:22:33 note, that is not taking into account interest rates, which could throw a tremendous wrench.
00:22:37 It just as, you know, individual homeowners are beholden to changes in interest rates, so too
00:22:42 is the government here. So I mean, maybe they're being so reckless because they know they're not
00:22:47 be around beyond a year and a half from now and this will be someone else's problem but like how
00:22:51 do you justify this at all you don't not in any sane manner uh and and i i again i don't believe
00:23:01 any of these targets will be met um and i i have come to believe i don't like to wear my tinfoil
00:23:06 hat too often but i have come to believe that they are making this as as bad as it can possibly be
00:23:12 uh for the next government which looks like it's going to be Pierre Poiliev government
00:23:17 uh so that they just have a horrific time and then of course they'll criticize them right
00:23:21 how could you ever have such a big deficit and let's not forget these are the guys that were
00:23:24 only going to run those modest 10 billion deficits until 2019 when the budget would be balanced uh
00:23:30 also this budget makes assumptions about growth in the economy that look overly optimistic that's
00:23:36 another consideration because they have to assume the economy is going to grow by you know x percent
00:23:40 uh in the in the future years and i think we're heading for some serious trouble here
00:23:45 uh again investors around the world foreign investment's a big deal in canada our dollar
00:23:49 has fallen by the way a falling dollar we weren't a lot into canada too a falling dollar means more
00:23:54 inflation because our dollar doesn't buy as much and and it all every single thing they've done
00:23:59 here is leading toward making all of these critical measures that affect all of our everyday lives
00:24:05 worse and and so it's very depressing of course uh but i i wonder how they can really uh i wonder
00:24:12 how they can justify it in their own minds how they can look in the mirror at themselves with
00:24:16 damage they're doing and but what seems to be interesting is they seem to be thinking maybe
00:24:21 they they almost act as if they haven't been in government for the last eight and a half years and
00:24:25 trudeau saying oh geez we've got an awful lot of immigration what could have happened there and
00:24:30 freeland you know commenting on darn we got all this you know uh debt interest we have to pay
00:24:35 shucks who did that uh and we can we get all this i wonder if it's that new there was supposedly a
00:24:39 new communications guy uh hired in the pmo back back uh last year and i wonder if this is the
00:24:46 new strategy sort of pretend you know pretend they didn't they didn't do any of this in the
00:24:51 last eight and a half years if so i don't think canadians are going to be fooled yeah very well
00:24:56 said on that they do tend to just be very surprised that uh they've been in the helm for you know the
00:25:01 the last eight years and things just happen. It's so Stephen Harper's fault. I think they're
00:25:05 still blaming Arthur Meehan for the budgetary deficit probably. Catherine Swift, always good
00:25:10 to talk to you. You are doing great work over there standing up for business and industry in
00:25:15 Canada and we appreciate it. Thank you, Andrew. All right, thanks very much. Catherine Swift
00:25:21 of the Coalition of Concerned Manufacturers and Businesses of Canada, formerly of the Canadian
00:25:27 Federation of Independent Business, so she knows this file very well. I wanted to check in on this
00:25:32 from just a taxpayer perspective of, well, we've done the business side, going to do the consumer
00:25:37 taxpayer side, although as we know full well, there is only one taxpayer, and any measures
00:25:43 that penalize business will always end up screwing the little guy as well, as we've noted with carbon 0.98
00:25:48 taxes. I mean, even if you have a policy that's going to be an industrial polluter-based thing
00:25:54 where they try to go after the big industry, it still trickles down to ordinary Canadian
00:26:00 taxpayers. You're always going to be footing the bill, even when, oh, the government is paying.
00:26:04 So it's funny when you hear the rhetoric from Christopher Freeland, we're giving, we're doing
00:26:08 this, we're spending, we're, no, no, we are, we, the people listening to you, we, the taxpayers
00:26:15 are the ones paying for this. You are not paying for anything. The billion dollars you're spending
00:26:19 on combating hate is me. The money you're giving to CBC is me. The deficit spending is me that has
00:26:27 to pay all of you. I mean, I got my little tiny teeny teeny little itsy bitsy share of it. You've
00:26:31 got your own share, but we are the ones that are getting hosed on this. And that's, this is why
00:26:37 there's just such this giant shell game with all of this. And I get so frustrated and I know that
00:26:42 budgets aren't always the most fascinating thing to talk about. I get that, but it matters tremendously
00:26:47 when you have government treating the taxpayers with such disrespect. And Catherine Swift mentioned 0.55
00:26:52 the interest payments. This is actually an important point. I saw an observation yesterday
00:26:58 online and I didn't pull the tweet, but basically the amount that the federal government collects
00:27:03 on GST is like, I think it's $51 billion a year. The amount that the federal government collects
00:27:08 on GST pays for the interest that we pay on our federal debt, the interest. So that means anytime
00:27:16 you pay GST that I mean it's not it's general revenue but I'm saying the amount is the same
00:27:22 so anytime you pay GST know that that money is actually going towards nothing that is going
00:27:27 towards paying the interest payment on the federal government's credit card that does not build you
00:27:33 a road it does not build you a hospital it does not get you another episode of Rosie Barton's show
00:27:39 it provides absolutely well that one's probably good but it provides you nothing that is what
00:27:45 happens when you have such a debt-laden country. One of the only guys in Canada who gets this is
00:27:50 Franco Terrazzano, who is the federal director for the Canadian Taxpayers Federation and joins us
00:27:56 once again. Franco, you didn't get your wish list, it looks like. Oh, I sure didn't, right? And hey,
00:28:03 welcome to Canada where you pay a federal sales tax so Prime Minister Justin Trudeau can cover
00:28:08 the interest on his government's credit card. You know what? I'm so glad you started with the
00:28:13 interest charges because this is what is so bizarre, just how expensive the interest charges
00:28:19 on the debt have become. So now, taxpayers are losing out on more than $1 billion every single
00:28:26 week just to pay interest on the federal government debt. You mentioned that it's now $54 billion,
00:28:32 which is the exact same amount of money that the federal government is bringing in through the GST.
00:28:37 So ponder that the next time you're waiting in the checkout line. But also, what we're
00:28:43 paying on interest charges this year is more money than what the federal government will send
00:28:48 to the provinces in health transfers. Okay. So let all of this sink in and just imagine what we
00:28:54 could do if we didn't have these ballooning debt costs. Okay. You could essentially remove the
00:28:59 entire GST or you could double health transfers, but instead taxpayers are paying more than a
00:29:06 billion dollars every single week on interest charges. That money, it ain't building more
00:29:12 hospitals. It ain't fixing the roads. It ain't staying in your pockets because that money's
00:29:16 going to the bond fund managers on Bay street. And when you look at a budget that has no path
00:29:22 to balance, not even like an aspirational pie in the sky in five years, we're going to balance it
00:29:27 plan. No projection that goes there whatsoever. No. I mean, look guys, we're running a, well,
00:29:33 I'm not, I'm not running a $40 billion deficit. We're just paying for it. They're running,
00:29:38 They're running a $40 billion deficit after they just brought in a massive tax hike.
00:29:44 So even with a massive tax hike, they're still running a $40 billion deficit.
00:29:49 And like, let's just think about it for a second.
00:29:51 This is 2024.
00:29:52 There isn't like a pandemic.
00:29:54 And yet they're still running a deficit that would have been unheard of only a couple years ago.
00:30:01 And you mentioned it.
00:30:02 There is no plan to balance the budget.
00:30:04 the best that this government can muster is, hey, in five years from now, we'll try to run
00:30:09 a $20 billion deficit. But Andrew, just between me and you, don't let anyone know this,
00:30:15 but I don't think this government will ever balance the budget.
00:30:19 No. And I must admit, I'm slightly concerned because I've talked about this with conservative
00:30:24 leader Pierre Polyev. He's obviously the one most poised to be the prime minister
00:30:27 if current polling holds. And I've said, how are you going to get the budget to balance
00:30:32 when this is what you're inheriting and already, and I'm sympathetic to it, he has to start hedging
00:30:37 and saying, well, you know, we don't know what we're going to be left with. And the problem is
00:30:40 when the government leaves something this bad, it is going to take an incredibly difficult and
00:30:45 disciplined approach to bring it to balance. I mean, how quickly, realistically could that happen?
00:30:51 Okay, well, let me set the stage because I was pouring through the numbers, as you know, I like
00:30:55 to do. And you know, I was bringing up the budget from 2021, only a couple years ago. And every time
00:31:01 they do a budget, they project spending into the future. That's how they do it. Well, guess what,
00:31:06 folks? If Trudeau just stuck with his big spending pandemic budget from 2021, and he just spent like
00:31:14 how he said he was going to spend, there would be a balanced budget this year. That's all it would
00:31:20 have taken. Just stuck to the big spending budget of 2021 from the Trudeau government, and you would
00:31:25 have a balanced budget this year, right? Because as inflation takes money out of Canadian's pockets,
00:31:32 you know, you hear the NDP talk about greedflation, greedflation. Well, the greedflation is also
00:31:37 coming from the government because their tax revenues, their revenues are also going through
00:31:41 the roof. So, you know, I know the state of the finances are in an awful place, right? The last
00:31:46 budget that we just saw yesterday is an absolute dumpster fire. But the good news for Canadians 1.00
00:31:51 is that it would only take a very modest level of spending restraint to actually balance the
00:31:57 books. All you would have to do is just stick to the spending plan that Trudeau made when he gave
00:32:03 out his big spending budget 2021. I want to get you to react to this clip here. Christopher
00:32:07 Freeland was asked if the federal government cares about a balanced budget. And this is what
00:32:12 she said. Now, I also want to talk about your financial guardrails here, because I appreciate
00:32:17 that your government has kept to your economic guardrails.
00:32:20 But there is no path to balance.
00:32:22 You heard the criticism.
00:32:23 You've heard it before.
00:32:24 There were no cuts made to reduce the $40 billion deficit
00:32:27 that was posted today or predicted past one
00:32:31 and then going forward for the next fiscal year.
00:32:33 Does a balanced budget matter to you or your government at all?
00:32:38 I'll tell you what matters to me.
00:32:40 What matters to me is a fiscally responsible budget.
00:32:44 what matters to me is maintaining canada's triple a credit rating which is the basis for the ratings
00:32:52 of all provinces which is the basis for the ratings of businesses in our banking sector
00:32:57 what matters to me is maintaining a fiscally responsible budget and hitting and you know
00:33:04 sticking within our guardrails because the bank of canada has been clear that those guardrails
00:33:09 are helpful to the Bank of Canada. And so I know by sticking within them, which I have done,
00:33:16 I help to create the conditions that make it possible for the Bank of Canada to lower rates.
00:33:21 And we've seen, we've had some good news on that front just today. Today, we had the March
00:33:27 inflation numbers, 2.9%. February was 2.8. January was 2.9. I would contrast 2.9 in March
00:33:36 with 3.5 in the United States, which, by the way, is running a far more expansive fiscal policy.
00:33:43 For the past three months in a row, inflation has been within the Bank of Canada's target range.
00:33:51 So yeah, it's very important for me to run a fiscally responsible policy. I am doing that.
00:33:57 And the final thing I would say to you, Michael, is, you know, there are some issues on which
00:34:03 reasonable people can have different points of view. It's a matter of opinion of ideology. You
00:34:10 know, you can argue whether gun control is good or bad. You can argue whether a woman's right to 1.00
00:34:15 choose is good or bad. But the simple fact is Canada has the most responsible fiscal approach
00:34:25 of any G7 country. We have the lowest debt to GDP ratio and it's coming down. We have the lowest
00:34:33 deficit to GDP, and that is coming down to, we have a AAA credit rating. It is not, you know,
00:34:39 I'll tell you what, the people who work in ratings agencies, these guys are not liberal partisans,
00:34:44 these guys and gals. If you were, by the way, driving when, and now I've frozen for whatever,
00:34:51 if you were driving when that went on, I apologize. I hope you didn't fall asleep at the wheel. But
00:34:56 so number one, props to Chrystia Freeland for answering a question about, do you care about
00:35:01 balanced budgets with invoking gun control and woman's right to choose. I didn't see that one 0.85
00:35:06 coming. I didn't see that plot twist. But the answer was a long way of saying no. She thinks
00:35:11 it's a fiscally responsible budget that matters, which I suspect, Franco, you also disagree with
00:35:17 the assertion that this budget falls into that category. Of course, it's not physically
00:35:21 responsible. A $40 billion deficit, there's nothing fiscally responsible about that. And look,
00:35:27 I keep hearing this like idea that they have these fiscal guardrails in place as if you just say
00:35:33 fiscal guardrail and that's a good thing. Like, you know, summer's coming up. I got to trim down
00:35:38 a little bit before I go to the beach. So it's like me saying, you know what? I'm going to stick
00:35:42 to my diet. I'm going to do a very good job and stick to my diet. Only one problem. The diet is
00:35:48 10,000 calories a day. Yeah. It's pretty easy for me to stick to a diet when it's that high.
00:35:54 You know what I'm saying? Like, there is nothing fiscally responsible for this government. This government has proved time and again that it doesn't care about balanced budget, that it doesn't care about the fact that it is now doubling the entire national debt since the 2015 election.
00:36:09 And by the way, folks, the whole brand of this budget is fairness for future generations.
00:36:15 Well, doubling the entire debt and making Canadians' kids and grandkids continue to make payments on the federal debt for the rest of their lives, there is nothing fair about that.
00:36:25 And look, there is no plan to find savings in this budget.
00:36:28 There is no plan to balance the budget.
00:36:30 The only plan that this government has is to take as much money from taxpayers as it can.
00:36:36 And in last year's budget, by the way, Freeland said that she would find $15 billion in savings
00:36:42 over a handful of years. Well, let's check in on that progress. This year, the federal government
00:36:47 is increasing spending by $37 billion. So newsflash, when you increase spending by $30
00:36:55 billion in one year, you're saving money wrong. Yeah, I think you're bang on there. And we would
00:37:05 perhaps be better suited having you as finance minister, although you've previously poo-pooed
00:37:09 such nominations on your part. Franco Terrizano, Federal Director for the Canadian Taxpayers
00:37:14 Federation. Always a pleasure, sir. Hey, thanks for having me on, Andrew. All right. Thank you,
00:37:19 Franco. And again, good to catch up with him last week in Ottawa as well. It was like a big old
00:37:22 Andrew Lawton Show family reunion. All our favorite guests under one roof. We should have had a
00:37:27 designated survivor in place in case calamity hit. We could have just carried on the show. So,
00:37:32 So, all right, well, that does it for the budget stuff.
00:37:35 I wanted to do a bit of a counterbalance,
00:37:37 give you that red meat culture war content you crave
00:37:40 and throw to this interview I did last week
00:37:43 at the big old conference with Christine Van Gein.
00:37:46 Take a look.
00:37:49 Well, civil liberties have been under attack in Canada
00:37:52 for certainly four years.
00:37:54 And we've seen this war being waged in provinces,
00:37:58 municipalities, and certainly the federal government.
00:38:01 And when people ask me how I remain so chipper and cheery about it, the only answer I have is that there are a great many people, probably not as many as there should be, that take on the fight and push back against this.
00:38:12 And there has been one organization that stands out above many others that has been at the forefront of that.
00:38:17 The Canadian Constitution Foundation, whose litigation director, Christine Van Gein, is a mainstay on The Andrew Lawton Show and joins me in person today.
00:38:25 Christine, great to see you.
00:38:26 Thanks so much for having me on, Andrew.
00:38:28 And I should say congratulations first and foremost.
00:38:30 I've had you on to talk about it.
00:38:31 Hold it up there to talk about the book Pandemic Panic,
00:38:34 which has now been nominated for the Donner Prize,
00:38:37 which is quite a prestigious, shortlisted for it,
00:38:39 quite a prestigious award.
00:38:41 It was not one bestowed upon my book on the Freedom Convoy.
00:38:44 It should have been.
00:38:44 Well, thank you.
00:38:45 But the Freedom Convoy book was cited in here.
00:38:47 Many times.
00:38:48 So I get like one, you know, 157th of the glory.
00:38:51 Your several footnotes of glory.
00:38:53 All right.
00:38:54 Well, my several footnotes of glory is actually the name of my memoir,
00:38:56 I believe, that I'm penning right now.
00:38:58 But well done.
00:38:59 What do you take from that?
00:39:01 I actually don't know what the nomination criteria are.
00:39:03 So what is it that you're really being recognized for?
00:39:05 So it's the top prize for public policy writing in Canada.
00:39:09 It's a $60,000 prize.
00:39:11 There's five books that get shortlisted.
00:39:13 There's a jury that reviews nearly 100 books
00:39:17 that get submitted for consideration.
00:39:19 They narrow that down to five books for the shortlist.
00:39:23 And the idea is that it is not just a history, it's a public policy book.
00:39:29 So the book needs to include recommendations for things for the future.
00:39:32 And that's a big part of what's in Pandemic Panic.
00:39:35 In fact, the last part of the book is a series of recommendations
00:39:38 for what individuals can do to improve civil liberties in Canada
00:39:42 and help better hold governments to account.
00:39:44 Because the things that happened during the pandemic, a lot of them were illegal,
00:39:48 a lot of them were completely inexcusable.
00:39:50 But if we don't remember the lessons and if we don't learn to hold our governments to account, we are absolutely bound to repeat them in whatever the next crisis or imagined crisis is.
00:40:01 Yeah, you're right about that.
00:40:02 And you and I have talked on the show about this mootness fallacy that government likes to advance where, well, this was just a really hyper-specific circumstance.
00:40:10 And they do that to really deflect against people looking back to prevent abuse in the future.
00:40:15 And, you know, it's a ridiculous example, but it's an incredibly useful one.
00:40:19 Niagara region declaring an eclipse emergency we talked about this on the show they basically said
00:40:24 oh yes this eclipse is coming up and there are going to be a lot of tourists we're going to
00:40:27 declare this as an emergency and CCF criticized this and in the end we didn't see you know like
00:40:32 police horses coming in and trampling people that were looking up at the sun but it was still
00:40:36 government at a municipal level or a regional level using powers that are not meant for that
00:40:42 and using them without any real worry of the implications of that and I think that really
00:40:48 proves your thesis here which is why these issues are so important to have so that that category of
00:40:53 what an emergency is doesn't perpetually broaden yeah and i think one of the concerns look the
00:40:59 emergency management civil protection act in ontario it's provincial legislation very different
00:41:04 in nature from the federal emergencies act the powers in the federal emergencies act are a lot
00:41:09 broader it allows the federal government to create new criminal law especially by executive order
00:41:15 And they did pretty extreme things with those powers when they invoked the state of emergency federally.
00:41:22 I mean, they froze bank accounts, they prohibited gatherings.
00:41:25 In Niagara region, the powers under emergency declaration are more limited,
00:41:30 but they still give the government the power to do things like perhaps ration goods or impose a curfew.
00:41:36 Those would be permitted under the Emergency Management Civil Protection Act.
00:41:40 And if we broaden what is considered an emergency to include an entirely foreseeable event, like an eclipse.
00:41:48 It's been scheduled for like 40 years.
00:41:50 We literally know when the next one is happening 90 years from now or 120 years from now or whatever it is.
00:41:56 It's a very predictable event.
00:41:58 If we call that an emergency, then I already know what's going to happen.
00:42:02 Social activists across the province, across the country are going to argue that all kinds of social issues, serious ones, but still social issues of a systemic nature that are addressed through public policy, they're going to say those are emergencies.
00:42:18 Homelessness is an emergency.
00:42:20 Climate change is an emergency.
00:42:22 The opioid crisis, that's an emergency.
00:42:24 We need emergency powers like a curfew or a rationing of goods to deal with these social issues.
00:42:34 Some politicians locally are already attempting this, declaring homelessness or opioid emergencies.
00:42:41 This is not what that legislation was designed to do.
00:42:45 There's a statutory definition of emergency, and it's a situation of a temporary nature that is a serious danger to persons or property.
00:42:57 And an eclipse just doesn't meet that threshold.
00:43:00 Yeah, and to go back, when you mentioned climate emergency, it wasn't that long ago that any politician or commentator who mentioned that there could be such a thing as that was told to be a conspiracy theorist.
00:43:10 And I think that's really short-sighted to make that claim.
00:43:13 And one example, if I go back to the Ontario Supreme or the Ontario Court of Appeal hearing some years back on the carbon tax, which I was sitting through and you were arguing, I believe you were representing the Canadian Taxpayers Federation in that one.
00:43:26 Oh, yeah, I was.
00:43:26 Yeah. But, you know, there you had the David Suzuki Foundation arguing that the carbon tax was justifiable under federal government's emergency powers.
00:43:34 Now, this is not the Emergencies Act.
00:43:36 This is the emergency powers in the Constitution.
00:43:39 But that's not new, that idea of activists really co-opting emergency language
00:43:43 to make policy prescriptions just because they think that's their way to do it.
00:43:48 So I am very concerned about that mission creep and redefinition of emergency.
00:43:52 Yeah, I think that, and this all kind of ties back to the book.
00:43:55 It's a kind of mentality that some people have called safetyism,
00:43:58 where safety is the governing sacred value of society
00:44:04 and our whole lives should be organized
00:44:06 as that is the most important thing in our life.
00:44:09 And I just fundamentally disagree with that worldview.
00:44:13 I think that the organizing value of liberal democracies
00:44:15 is freedom and liberty, not safety.
00:44:19 And these two things are not necessarily incompatible
00:44:21 with one another, but if you put safety ahead of freedom,
00:44:25 we're going to see a terrible erosion
00:44:27 of our fundamental freedoms
00:44:29 that have served Western liberal democracies well
00:44:32 for hundreds of years.
00:44:33 To pivot to an issue that,
00:44:35 I don't want to say more pressing,
00:44:37 but certainly one that's more timely politically,
00:44:39 Bill C-63.
00:44:40 This is the Federal Government's Online Harms Act.
00:44:43 And you and I have spoken about this on the show in the past.
00:44:45 So I don't want to rehash those conversations
00:44:47 except to say that with all of the criticisms
00:44:49 that have been brought by people,
00:44:50 like I'm a bad faith actor to the government.
00:44:52 I don't expect them to listen to me.
00:44:54 I think they should probably listen to people like you,
00:44:56 But even people that are far more mainstream in their views than a lot of the critics on C63 have been raising some of the very similar criticisms.
00:45:05 And the government showed no willingness to really give an inch on this.
00:45:08 They're not really saying, yeah, maybe we're overplaying our hand on the hate speech stuff.
00:45:12 Or maybe we could separate out the online hate speech from the child sexual exploitation and revenge porn.
00:45:17 And I think it's politically different or politically understandable why they're doing that.
00:45:23 Legally, I understand that they're going to face challenges on this stuff immediately.
00:45:27 Are you optimistic that free speech challenges against C-63, when it becomes law eventually,
00:45:33 will go the right way in court with how courts have viewed freedom of expression issues?
00:45:38 I actually am optimistic that certain provisions of this legislation will be challenged almost immediately.
00:45:45 I think the biggest ones relate to the criminal law amendments.
00:45:49 I think that the peace bond provisions and the standalone hate offense, which has the potential to, if someone commits an offense that is then motivated by hatred, that can be a standalone offense and can come with a maximum penalty of life imprisonment.
00:46:10 No, no, the PMO says that's not true.
00:46:12 Supriya Devetti did her column.
00:46:14 She said that's not about that at all.
00:46:15 I literally don't know what she is talking about.
00:46:18 She seems to think that because there are principles of sentencing that overcharging won't happen and that there's zero risk associated with this.
00:46:29 But she does not operate on the ground in the criminal law sphere.
00:46:35 And I'm telling you that this is a piece of the, that is probably the most constitutionally vulnerable piece of Bill 63.
00:46:42 The peace bond provisions, there's nothing like these peace bonds in any legislation because it's a prohibition on future speech, not future action.
00:46:53 It's very, very different in nature and inherently a lot more speculative.
00:46:58 And it's tied to the squishy definition, the statutory definition that derives from human rights law about what hatred is.
00:47:05 So putting all of this into the criminal law context and tying it to the possibility of life imprisonment, very constitutionally vulnerable.
00:47:13 I am optimistic that a constitutional challenge of that part of the legislation will be successful.
00:47:19 And look, if it passes in its current form, we at the Canadian Constitution Foundation may be the ones to bring that challenge.
00:47:26 Well, I hope you will. And I wish you well with it. Congratulations again on the shortlist.
00:47:29 Thank you. I mean, I hope I hope it's not us because I hope they don't pass this legislation.
00:47:33 You need to find another alliteration when you write your speech version of Pandemic Panic about all the online hate stuff.
00:47:39 I don't know what you're going to call that book, but you've got to write another one.
00:47:41 Oh, alliteration is great.
00:47:42 Okay. All right. Thank you very much, Christine Van Gein, Litigation Director for the Canadian Constitution Foundation.
00:47:49 That's it.
00:47:53 As I was talking, the wheels were turning as I tried to come up with that alliteration, but I fell short.
00:47:57 But in any event, always great to talk to Christine.
00:48:00 Tomorrow, we will share my lengthy fireside chat with New Brunswick Premier Blaine Higgs.
00:48:05 That is tomorrow on The Andrew Lawton Show.
00:48:08 Plus, we'll have some other goodies for you as well.
00:48:09 I don't know what they are yet, but we'll come up with some.
00:48:12 In the meantime, thank you, God bless, and good day to you all.
00:48:15 Thanks for listening to The Andrew Lawton Show.
00:48:18 Support the program by donating to True North at www.tnc.news.
00:48:27 We'll be right back.
00:48:57 We'll be right back.
00:49:27 Thank you.