Juno News - June 16, 2023


On C2C: Can Canadian law be saved?

Topics
Mentioned
Secret memo exposes plan to mislead public about the vaccine Smith teases Conservative coalition

Episode Stats


Length

37 minutes

Words per minute

177.4

Word count

6,661

Sentence count

179

Harmful content

Misogyny

3

sentences flagged

Toxicity

1

sentences flagged

Hate speech

2

sentences flagged


Summary

Summaries generated with gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ .

In this episode, Andrew Lawton talks about the recent departure of Supreme Court Justice Russell Brown, and what that means for the legal field and justice in Canada. He is joined by Bruce Parris, a law professor at Queen's University and the Executive Director of Rights Probe, and the author of an essay in C2C Journal.

Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Topics generated with Qwen2.5-3B-Instruct.
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 Welcome to Canada's Most Irreverent Talk Show.
00:00:05 This is the Andrew Lawton Show, brought to you by True North.
00:00:12 Welcome along. It is Canada's Most Irreverent Talk Show,
00:00:16 the Andrew Lawton Show, here on True North, Friday, June 16, 2023.
00:00:22 I had the great privilege last night of attending the JCCF,
00:00:26 the Justice Centre for Constitutional Freedom's George Jonas Freedom Awards.
00:00:30 I've been to, I think this was my fourth one.
00:00:33 I was there at the first one a few years back when Mark Stein was given the award.
00:00:37 Last night, it went to none other than Jordan Peterson,
00:00:41 who has done more, I think, to expand the base of people talking about issues of liberty and of free speech
00:00:47 than many other Canadians, though not for lack of trying, I can assure you.
00:00:51 He just captured a few years ago this perfect moment and explained some of these issues so eloquently and so passionately that he has continued on and has had this meteoric rise, but still was willing to stand up there at the JCCF dinner and accept that award and give a tremendous talk.
00:01:09 And I know some of you listening in came up and said that they had a great time and a few of you had very kind things to say about the show.
00:01:16 So I thank you very much for that.
00:01:18 And I also saw Bruce Party, who is no stranger to many of you on this program.
00:01:23 He is a law professor at Queen's University, the executive director of Rights Probe, and
00:01:28 also the author of a fascinating essay in C2C Journal, which has become a very good
00:01:34 friend and supporter of True North.
00:01:37 The piece is called Legal Canons and Social Fables.
00:01:41 The law in Canada has never been perfect, but now it is losing its way.
00:01:45 And it talks about a lot of the key themes of the legal field in Canada that I think we need to tackle as a society.
00:01:52 But before we get into that, I just want to briefly mention, I think I talked about it earlier in the week on the show,
00:01:58 the resignation slash retirement of Supreme Court Justice Russell Brown,
00:02:04 who, if you read Supreme Court decisions, has been a often underappreciated breath of fresh air,
00:02:11 oftentimes one of just a couple of people pushing back against these incursions on civil liberties
00:02:17 that we see from the Supreme Court of Canada, and due to rather bizarre allegations and accusations
00:02:24 that were weak, and even if they were accepted at face value, I don't think would carry the
00:02:29 punishment of being judicial misconduct. He has found himself now no longer on the bench,
00:02:35 another vacancy on the Supreme Court, which Justin Trudeau will get to fill, his sixth judge
00:02:40 of nine on the bench. And what that means for the legal field and justice in Canada,
00:02:46 we can talk about as well. But we'll get to all that. Bruce Party joins me now. It's good to talk
00:02:51 to you again, Bruce. Thanks for coming on today. Andrew, thanks for the invitation.
00:02:55 Let's actually talk about the Russell Brown aspect for a moment here before we get into it,
00:03:00 because he was very much a minority on the Supreme Court, even among justices appointed
00:03:05 by Stephen Harper. Many of them ended up ruling against liberty, against free speech in a couple
00:03:11 of cases. What do you take from his ousting, if I can call it that, which I think is an accurate
00:03:17 way of putting it? Well, I mean, I'm very sorry to see him go. He, I think, was one of the best
00:03:29 minds on the court uh for for for the time that he was there people call him a conservative judge
00:03:35 but that's not to give him enough credit he he was a you know that would that would be to pigeonhole
00:03:41 him in an artificial way he was a just a just a solid judicial thinker a a judge who who took his
00:03:52 restrained rules seriously in the sense that the two traditions, the two competing traditions are,
00:04:02 you know, judges do policy and they do what they think is right and they interpret the
00:04:06 Constitution as a living tree and so on. And the other philosophy is, no, judges are there to do
00:04:11 a restrained job. They apply the law as it's written. They interpret the text. And sure,
00:04:16 sometimes there's ambiguity in the text, but we're supposed to be doing a judicial rule so that this
00:04:21 idea of separation of powers that deserve and and and brown was was was extremely good at
00:04:27 understanding that philosophy and applying it um and so we we owe him a great debt on the court
00:04:35 uh for his time on the court he he contributed uh far beyond the the time that he had available
00:04:43 on it both both in this in dissent and he dissented uh with with great courage but also he managed to
00:04:49 persuade his colleagues to follow him sometimes in creating a judgment that was the majority
00:04:56 and a good one. So it's a great law. And then you look moving forward at
00:05:02 one more vacancy. There is no convention in Canada where you try to replace someone
00:05:09 with someone who's going to think in a very similar way. And, you know, we look at the
00:05:13 appointments that Justin Trudeau has made or recommended to the bench. And there are people
00:05:18 who, and I know you're in a law society, so you're not allowed to speak ill of other lawyers. I can,
00:05:23 but I'll spare you having to listen to it for now. But they have not been the best picks, I would
00:05:28 say. Well, for my money, for the kind of jurist that I would favor having on the court, someone,
00:05:40 frankly, with Brown's approach and features in terms of his philosophy, I completely agree.
00:05:48 And the likelihood that we will get somebody like that next time, don't put your money on it.
00:05:55 Are you available, by the way? I can start a letter writing campaign. Bruce Party for the
00:05:59 Supreme Court. Sure, sure. Okay, good. Everyone, BrucePartyForTheSupremeCourt.com.
00:06:04 We'll set it up. I'm sure I'm at the top of Trudeau's list. Sure.
00:06:07 If called upon, you will serve. Well, let's segue from there into the bigger picture aspects here. And you and I have often had conversations about a variety of issues on this show and off air. And the problem is, as much as I enjoy talking to you, I always end up very depressed after we've had a conversation because you take a very cynical view of things. And I don't think you can be faulted for that because you look around and there's great reason for cynicism.
00:06:34 I mean, one of the big victories on the Supreme Court in the last couple of years in Canada was
00:06:39 the Mike Ward case, which was the free speech case involving a Quebec comedian. But that was a
00:06:44 victory by one vote. It was one single judge. And that judge was, quite frankly, Russell Brown,
00:06:51 you could say, 5'4", that stood up for something that should have been plain as day, so fundamentally
00:06:56 simple and easy to adjudicate. So what is the problem? Is the problem that we have a set of
00:07:03 judges in this country that are not oriented around liberty and around free speech and around
00:07:08 that strict originalist view of the charter or is the problem the law itself that there's something
00:07:14 fundamentally structurally wrong in the canadian legal system well i i think both
00:07:22 we've so our legal system has worked for a good long time you know it's as it's as good
00:07:34 for periods it's been as good as anything that we've ever seen in the world but it is based upon
00:07:41 a couple of ideas that work as long as you have people inside the system that believe a certain
00:07:48 thing and act in a certain way and one of those things is restraint judicial restraint you know
00:07:53 keeping to your knitting staying in your wheelhouse but we are getting now to the stage where
00:08:00 that that restraint is well not been there for for a good while and if you look at the very basic
00:08:09 premises of the system you have two at least two i mean more than two but here's let's here here
00:08:16 just two basic ideas legislatures are supreme in the sense that they can pass anything they want
00:08:22 like literally anything if you can write it down they can pass it and people think well hold on
00:08:27 wait a minute what about the charter the charter is not the foundation of the legal system the
00:08:32 foundation is legislative supremacy they can do anything they want except those things that the
00:08:39 court says are unconstitutional now we say all right well we got a constitution it's written
00:08:43 down in black and white so that's the restraint well yes except that that document has to be
00:08:48 interpreted by the court and the court can say it means whatever it likes now that's not the theory
00:08:57 not supposed to do that but in fact the court's power to interpret the constitution is essentially
00:09:03 unrestrained so you have two institutions that are essentially unrestrained and that works
00:09:11 for as long as it works but when it starts to not work because the people involved think well
00:09:17 it's our job to do what we think is right now you're going to start to get into problems and
00:09:23 and in my opinion that's where we're at i i know that there was i think it was uh what 26 years
00:09:30 ago now the the famous charter dialogue uh doctrine that started to emerge that you know
00:09:36 there's this dialogue between the courts and parliament you know parliament puts forward a bill
00:09:40 the court kicks it back and eventually we perhaps make everyone happy but i i think the flaw with
00:09:46 that as we see over time is that someone has to have a veto at a certain point when the court
00:09:50 wants one thing and elected officials want another thing, someone is going to have to
00:09:55 win out. And Beverly McLaughlin infamously said in one decision, I can't remember what
00:10:00 case it was, that, you know, Parliament doesn't get to say, it's not a case of if at first
00:10:04 you don't succeed, try, try again. So she basically thought the Supreme Court should
00:10:08 be the final authority on things. And I'm curious if you think that will hold, that
00:10:13 the court will be the ones that get the final say and not democracy itself, not elected
00:10:18 officials well that's the way it's it's set up to work right now you know given given the
00:10:25 constitution and the charter uh with respect to those matters that come before it on constitutional
00:10:32 grounds instead of legislative supremacy we have judicial supremacy and if i you know when i when
00:10:38 the supreme court makes a final ruling if you know the government doesn't like it there is nothing
00:10:44 they can do nothing they can do about it uh so in that sense we do actually have the last word
00:10:50 sitting with the court now as i say that that system worked for a good while and well when
00:10:57 the court keeps its own purview constrained i guess that's the issue not when they start
00:11:02 extending expending expanding rather well right except that we are we are talking about this
00:11:06 through our own lens and if you talk to somebody with a different view they would say well they are
00:11:10 doing their job you know their the job of the supreme court is to do is to be the final arbiter
00:11:18 of which social values will prevail those are rosa rosalie abella's work um so so this is a
00:11:25 this is a a a dispute about what the proper role of the court actually is i mean and keep in mind
00:11:32 this is not just a view held by the court or its supporters this is also a view held frankly by a
00:11:39 lot of legislators so one time i was giving evidence before a senate committee and there was
00:11:44 some dispute about the content of the bill and one of the senators asked well why don't we just pass
00:11:48 the bill and then send it to the court and have them work it out i said but you're the legislator
00:11:56 you should at least say what it is that you want the bill to mean instead of avoiding the question
00:12:04 and then just fobbing it off onto the court but but that's the mentality that that we that a lot
00:12:10 of people have in this country now that the supreme court ought to be the final arbiter because
00:12:16 you know they're not political they're not elected they're you know nine wise people sitting up there
00:12:23 on the bench so they must know what they're doing well they're just ordinary people they're just
00:12:27 lawyers who've been appointed their political appointments frankly all of them and do you
00:12:32 really want those nine unelected people being the final arbiter of what the law is in the country
00:12:38 that's more or less what we have right now there was an interview years ago that beverly mclaughlin
00:12:44 the former supreme court chief justice gave in which she said that you know her job was to you
00:12:49 know hear the facts hear the evidence then uh you know go back and decide and her exact words were
00:12:55 what is, quote, best for society, unquote. And if you're not keenly astute on these things,
00:13:02 that may sound like a perfectly reasonable thing of, well, absolutely, we want society to be bettered
00:13:08 through the legal system. But in actuality, what she was describing is exactly what you're
00:13:12 discussing there, which is a court that wants to not just choose what is legal, but what is optimal.
00:13:18 And that is not the job. I mean, a court should be, in my view, upholding a very bad,
00:13:24 ineffective policy if that policy complies with the Constitution.
00:13:29 Many, many years ago, I happened to be at some kind of a law school banquet when I was a law
00:13:34 student. And I happened to end up sitting beside Madam Justice Lear de Bay. And I had opportunity
00:13:40 to ask her while we were chatting, you know, what the most important thing, I was just a law student,
00:13:45 I forget what year I was in but it was very very early on I was just interested what what what is
00:13:51 the most important thing that you consider when you're making a decision and and to my surprise
00:13:57 because I was very green she said uh the the policy you know I my job and I don't want to put
00:14:04 words in her mouth but essentially she said I regard my job as to is to choose the right policy
00:14:10 and I was astounded because that the learning with a little learning that I had done so far in law
00:14:15 school basically said you know you take the law and you find the facts and then you put those two
00:14:19 things together and those two things will tell you what the answer is supposed to be
00:14:23 so that was a a new idea for me but it turns out to be a prevailing one in your c2c piece which
00:14:30 again i think people should definitely read you have a number of these fables that you say the
00:14:35 the suppositions of the uh of the legal system which of course you you then debunk and one of
00:14:40 them that i wanted to ask you about which i think is particularly timely with all of the covet
00:14:45 challenges we've seen over the last few years and we'll continue to see for the next couple fable
00:14:50 court finds courts find facts with evidence explain what you're talking about there yes well
00:14:56 so during covet you know a good number of of suits were brought you know challenging this rule or
00:15:04 that rule or defending tickets or the like uh and the the courts and and not to a court not to a
00:15:12 judge because you know they all have their own minds but um largely the courts embraced the
00:15:19 coveted narrative the government had provided and insisted that everything was fine and and
00:15:26 one of the phenomena that happened in some of those cases was that that judges and this happened
00:15:31 especially in family law cases where there is a dispute between parents about whether a child
00:15:35 was going to be vaccinated or not one of the things that some of these courts did was take 0.99
00:15:39 judicial notice of the safety and efficacy of the vaccine now judicial notice is a is a shortcut to
00:15:47 finding facts without evidence the general rule of course is that any fact you find in the courtroom
00:15:54 has to be proven with evidence you're not allowed to go outside the courtroom read the newspaper
00:15:58 look at the sky and see what's going on and decide what the fact is no no you're strained
00:16:03 to the four walls of the courtroom to what you hear from witnesses but judicial notice is a
00:16:09 shortcut you can take judicial notice and conclude certain facts if they're so notorious that no one
00:16:14 would dispute them or you can or you can you can confirm them with with sources of indisputable
00:16:21 accuracy but in these cases the safety and efficacy of the vaccine was the matter in issue
00:16:26 and judicial notice is not intended to apply to the issue in the case and yet some judges said
00:16:32 well i'm just going to take judicial notice of the fact that for you know for this child or for
00:16:36 children in general the vaccine is safe and effective and the way we go another one of
00:16:42 your fables and and this one i don't think will surprise people necessarily that uh the fable is
00:16:48 that judges are impartial and you point out that they're not uh in many cases well i so i think
00:16:55 they try to be and it's not that they never are it's just that we can see examples where you
00:17:01 really have to wonder about that about that sort of cultural myth that we insist on that they are
00:17:07 so the example that i talk about is is is chief justice wagner talking about the convoy at the
00:17:13 convoy uh the chief justice gave an interview to le devoir where he talked about the convoy basically
00:17:20 condemned them and suggested that it had to be put down by force now that's a perfectly fine 0.99
00:17:25 opinion if you're just a citizen but you're the chief justice of the whole system and there were
00:17:32 challenges of course to be brought to the invocation of the emergencies act and and and those
00:17:37 challenges have now been heard but not decided at the federal court and they could very easily end
00:17:43 up in front of the supreme court and yet the chief justice had already expressed his view
00:17:47 about the nature of the protest whether it was right or wrong what should have been done about
00:17:51 it and so if you were a person involved in that protest you you would be justified in thinking
00:17:58 well am i really going to get a fair shake if this judge is sitting on the case he's already told me
00:18:02 what he thinks and that that that conflicts with the the whole idea of being a a an unbiased
00:18:10 adjudicator with a blank slate who will only base conclusions upon what you hear in the court
00:18:16 Yeah, and I think that's a fair distinction. I mean, everyone has a bias. Journalists have bias. Judges have bias. And anyone who says that bias does not exist in them or in others, I think is delusional. And I think they probably have a view that their position is neutral and everyone else is biased.
00:18:33 But in reality, any position that we expect someone to be unbiased or impartial in is really
00:18:39 a question of how good they are at separating their personal bias from their work. And I would
00:18:44 agree with you. That's what a judge is supposed to do. You cannot separate judges from the context
00:18:50 in which they live as human beings. For example, during COVID, judges were living under the same
00:18:56 laws that we were, the same restrictions that we were. And some of them would have had a variety
00:19:00 of opinions on that. Some of them would have been fine. I mean, you had judges that were very
00:19:04 vigilant about enforcing mask mandates in their courtrooms. And, you know, you then you ask the
00:19:09 question of, well, if you're going in there to fight against mask mandates, how effectively
00:19:13 are you going to be able to do it? Another one, I think it was one of the bail judges that Tamara
00:19:18 Leach had, who was discussing the convoy and referred to Ottawa as my city and my community.
00:19:25 And again, not inaccurate. A judge in Ottawa who lives in Ottawa is not breaking news, but
00:19:30 it's a little thing that just sort of indicates how much are you bringing in your life and your
00:19:37 experience and your values rather than just the law and i think there are very subtle ways in
00:19:42 which this is probably happening yes no i think you put your finger on it though so part of the
00:19:47 part of the bad trend here i think is that the idea of neutrality
00:19:52 is instead of instead of neutrality being equivalent to a blank slate as in i have no
00:20:01 i'm going to do my very best to have no preconceived notions about this yes i'm a human
00:20:07 being i live in a particular context i'm going to have certain biases like everybody does but
00:20:12 my role as a judge is to go in and try and ignore those and and start contracting but more and more
00:20:19 there seems to be a trend i think that new to give neutrality content to give a particular view
00:20:27 the the the the the the credential of being neutral and by that i mean the progressivism
00:20:36 is becoming the neutral view at his first press conference uh the chief justice
00:20:44 as the first press conference as chief justice a reporter asked him whether or not he agreed
00:20:49 the supreme court was the most progressive court in the world and the chief justice agreed
00:20:58 with with some pride now if you are suggesting that it's a good thing that your court is a
00:21:05 progressive court doesn't that mean that right off the bat you are now not neutral
00:21:10 unless you view progressivism as neutral and that's what i'm that's what i mean
00:21:14 yeah and i i think this is the problem and what we've seen here is not just people that are you
00:21:21 know progressive outside the courtroom and then when they sit down it goes to the bare bones of
00:21:26 what the constitution says and what the law says as we've talked about and and i think this brings
00:21:31 us to one of your other fables which was the the constitution means what it says there are
00:21:36 situations in which there is ambiguity in the law and you could have people that in good faith
00:21:41 debate it and discuss it? What did they mean with this? There are other cases where, and you
00:21:46 mentioned the Camo case in particular, which for those who don't recall is the guy who lived in
00:21:52 New Brunswick and wanted to commit the egregious infraction of bringing a case of beer across the
00:21:58 Quebec-New Brunswick border. And the constitution in this case says that there is to be no
00:22:05 restriction on interprovincial trade. And this is, again, of all the things that we cannot
00:22:11 necessarily entirely understand or discern, this one is literally in black and white in ink. And
00:22:17 yet the court finds it's not actually there. Yeah, this is one of the great things about
00:22:22 this case, you know, bad great things, is that, as you say, a lot of parts of the Constitution,
00:22:29 like many statutes, are ambiguous. You know, they're pretty vague, you have to fill in the
00:22:33 and so on. This particular section, as you allude to, is actually pretty clear. It says this in
00:22:40 black and white, and yet still the Supreme Court finds a way to say, well, that's not really what
00:22:45 it means. What it means is this, so as to allow these provincial programs, the monopoly provided
00:22:52 to the alcohol industry in New Brunswick, for example, in the case that we're talking about,
00:22:57 can continue so as to ignore the words of the constitution and allow the regulatory state to
00:23:05 carry on in spite of the statements of the contrary. The thing about this case, I remember
00:23:11 when it came up and I started following it at some point in the, I don't know, eight or nine
00:23:15 years it was going on. And I recall it being a very wonky thing because interprovincial trade
00:23:21 is not an issue that most people think affects them. If you live in one of these towns or
00:23:27 cities near the border, like Mr. Kamo did, you're obviously more well-versed in this. And I went to
00:23:32 a conference that the CCF put on in Ottawa, and I said, I'm going to report on it. And I, you know,
00:23:37 did all this great coverage. And I think like, I don't know, 42 people, you know, followed it or
00:23:41 anything like that. But I'm of the view that if the Supreme Court can't get the stuff this small
00:23:47 right, of whether you have a right to buy beer in Quebec and drink it in New Brunswick, they're
00:23:53 certainly not going to get the big stuff right that involves our fundamental freedoms well yes
00:23:58 so but this small thing at least through the eyes of the supreme court the beer aspect is small the
00:24:03 underlying concept is large i agree the concept is large i mean one of the things that the supreme
00:24:08 court seems to be concerned have been concerned about is that if we if they say that the constitution
00:24:14 prevents this from happening then you know what are the implications for the administrative state
00:24:19 You know, all these various programs and restrictions and rules about everything under the sun, are those all in jeopardy?
00:24:26 And, you know, do we have to defend and protect the administrative state from this constitutional provision so as not, you know, let the world collapse?
00:24:34 You know, let's just observe this. The administrative state, this nanny state that we have now, is not provided for in the Constitution.
00:24:48 This large mechanism, multilayered bureaucracy that we have is not provided for in the Constitution.
00:24:55 Now, the Constitution doesn't prohibit it exactly, but it doesn't provide for it either.
00:25:00 It's been an evolutionary choice over a long period of time.
00:25:06 And yet it has, if you read this decision in a particular way, it has become, if you like, a constitutional ideal that's higher than the words of the document itself.
00:25:18 in in the in the face of words that suggest actually the state can't and shouldn't do this
00:25:24 the Supreme Court said well we can't we can't have that therefore the words don't mean what
00:25:30 they appear to mean let me ask you though do you believe that the courts should or shouldn't think
00:25:37 of and evaluate the consequences of its decisions I mean should it be looking at things as a moment
00:25:42 in time this is what the law says figuring out the details is not our problem or do you think
00:25:47 courts should, in an ideal world, have to think about the eventualities of what will come from
00:25:52 their decisions? Well, consequences are a legitimate part of judicial reasoning. I mean,
00:25:57 it's part of figuring out what the words are supposed to mean, what the words were intended
00:26:02 to mean. And whenever you have ambiguity in a provision, the courts do have to go through this
00:26:08 process of deciding what the words are supposed to mean and put them into context. But that's not
00:26:15 an a an unlimited license just to make stuff out i mean there's a there's a process a set
00:26:21 of principles that are supposed to apply to this to this this um exercise of of interpretation
00:26:30 and set the there are rules of statutory interpretation now i've got no problem when
00:26:34 a court says you know here here are our principles of interpretation that set out in precedence
00:26:40 and i'm going to apply this principle and that principle here's what we get and so you could
00:26:45 have disagreement i mean there are lots of situations in which you have a provision that's
00:26:48 vague enough so that you could come to different conclusions legitimately by applying these
00:26:55 principles okay so no problem but then there are those situations where well you're just going to
00:27:00 throw the principles out the window and say well because of the consequences of this interpretation
00:27:04 we're not going to do that now now you're now you're legislating from the bench now you're
00:27:10 you know, doing policy instead of interpretation. And of course, all of this is opinion,
00:27:18 but my opinion is that that's the kind of process that they went through in the Como case.
00:27:22 Yeah, and it's interesting to compare the court's own decisions against its own decisions. I mean,
00:27:29 assisted suicide is probably one of the more brazen examples. I mean, not even to weigh in
00:27:33 on the policy itself, where the Supreme Court can basically assess the same question twice
00:27:39 and come up with radically different responses to that.
00:27:43 You know, once in the Rodriguez case
00:27:45 and then more recently in Carter.
00:27:47 And then, but even on a shorter timeframe,
00:27:49 I mean, healthcare is one that came up recently
00:27:51 where in Quebec, the Chayouli case,
00:27:54 the Supreme Court of Canada says basically,
00:27:56 yes, you have a right to private access to healthcare.
00:27:58 And then in British Columbia,
00:28:01 you have courts going a very different direction on this.
00:28:05 I mean, you know, years and years of litigation
00:28:07 and ultimately uh saying yeah shaoli doesn't apply here so two different provinces two different laws
00:28:14 yeah two different laws and two different two different charters in fact so quebec has its
00:28:18 own provincial charter not a part of the constitution but nevertheless was the basis
00:28:22 for the truly a decision but all of this i think reveals a a larger truth if you like which which
00:28:31 is that, you know, one of these cultural fables that we're talking about with respect to the
00:28:39 legal system is that legal decisions are arrived at through a logical reasoning process. And
00:28:47 the counter view, I prefer to use the word skeptical than cynical, but nevertheless,
00:28:54 the skeptical view is that actually we're talking about something else. And that something else is
00:29:00 really could be seen from, if you like, an anthropological point of view, which is the law
00:29:06 and the system is a, if you like, is a social ritual, an institutional ritual. It's political
00:29:14 language to provide legitimacy to political decisions. And as long as we go through the
00:29:20 ritual of the court process and reasoning and we have a statute and everybody does the job that
00:29:26 they're assigned to do, then it doesn't matter what the outcome is because we've given its
00:29:31 ritualistic approval and therefore everything is fine. And that's nothing to do with the content.
00:29:36 So it's an elaborate set of institutional marks to provide cultural legitimacy to a political outcome.
00:29:48 Now, I've plucked out a few of the fables that stood out to me, but I'll let you
00:29:52 pick your favorite here, perhaps the one that you feel is the most misunderstood
00:29:57 that we haven't touched on? Well,
00:30:01 the one, one of the ones, oh, I'm sorry about that. I'm going to have to shut up. 0.80
00:30:10 See, you're getting your Supreme Court appointment.
00:30:13 Sure. So, excuse me.
00:30:17 All right. This is the great thing about live, about live media folks. We'll get
00:30:22 Bruce back on in a couple of moments here, but I just want to kind of reference one aspect here
00:30:27 that he brings up, which I think is quite fascinating in that there tends to be in Canada
00:30:33 this sense that the system is just going to work and that it's going to hold government accountable.
00:30:38 And oftentimes when courts and parliaments are in tension, which let's be honest is the whole point
00:30:43 of courts, that's why we have them there because it needs to be a check on legislative power. 1.00
00:30:48 The problem is that you have courts that wish they were legislators and legislatures, and that is the big difference here.
00:30:56 So, for example, when you have the law itself saying, yes, you can have trade that is interprovincial and you can bring trade from one province into the other, that is supposed to be.
00:31:10 But again, they become policymakers, and that's the issue here.
00:31:13 I think we have Bruce back.
00:31:15 Bruce, was that your appointment call from the prime minister?
00:31:17 Are you on the bench?
00:31:18 i didn't open it i didn't know oh okay we'll find out afterwards but but you asked about about the
00:31:24 these other fables and so let's go to the one that that that i think people have internalized
00:31:32 most deeply without really even thinking about it which is this idea that justice is blind
00:31:37 i mean and you can even see it in the statues if you look at the statues of lady justice
00:31:42 often she has a blindfold on and she has scales and the whole idea is that people are going to
00:31:48 be assessed and the law is going to be applied to them without regard to who they are their
00:31:52 personal circumstances are irrelevant everything is is is again neutral in the sense of identity
00:31:59 your identity doesn't matter and you know that idea as much as any other idea is going by the
00:32:07 wayside. We had a, and this is not the only one, but we had a decision of the Ontario Human Rights
00:32:14 Tribunal last fall that basically came out and said in black and white, no, no, white people
00:32:22 can't claim discrimination. In other words, white people can be discriminated against. In other
00:32:28 words, we have now a regime of the law that says different rules apply depending upon your race
00:32:36 or your gender or your sex or your disability or your religion that's the territory we're now
00:32:44 entering into and you can see this arising in various different contexts under the human rights
00:32:50 codes of the provinces under the equality provision of the charter uh under the support
00:32:55 programs that are promulgated by a government under look at indigenous sentencing guidelines
00:33:00 that your sentencing in cases of criminal conviction
00:33:04 should be laxer because you are indigenous. 1.00
00:33:08 Well, not as a matter of course,
00:33:10 what the Supreme Court has said,
00:33:11 but certainly there is a process
00:33:14 for differentiating the punishment
00:33:17 depending upon the group that you belong to
00:33:20 and the experience that that group identity has provided.
00:33:24 And so, yes, we can no longer proceed
00:33:29 indeed safe in the assumption that we're going to be treated exquisitely equally regardless of
00:33:35 the person that we are. The essay is fantastic and again it I think identifies a number of the
00:33:42 problems but let's try to end on a bit more of a forward-looking note if we can here and the
00:33:48 question that I sort of envisioned coming into this was can it be saved and what would need to
00:33:53 happen for the Canadian legal order to be saved? Well, I think that the, the simple answer would
00:33:59 be to, to return to this very fundamental idea of the separation of powers and that the people
00:34:06 in the system would embrace it as, as well, we, to be fair, that idea has been eroding for a long
00:34:15 time, a long time. This is not just the, you know, past few years, this has been on the road for a
00:34:20 long time but if if we would go to go back to that because after all separation of power the idea
00:34:24 here is this legislatures pass rules the executive uh enforces rules rules carries those those those
00:34:32 rules out and the courts apply the rules to particular cases and that is the rule of law
00:34:38 because it protects us from the concentration of power in any one person or branch of the state
00:34:44 If we have that, then we're all safe.
00:34:46 If we don't have that, then you're liable to be subject to the arbitrary preferences
00:34:52 of one of these persons or agencies, and that's not what we want.
00:34:58 But if the people involved in the system would embrace that idea, again, afresh,
00:35:04 and say, all right, each of these branches have a different role,
00:35:08 and the three shall never mix, never meet, but that's going to be a very difficult
00:35:13 ask because the administrative state is based upon the mixing it's based upon the delegation
00:35:21 of powers to it so that it can make all the rules and the regulations and the directives and the
00:35:26 orders and the policies and so on we've entered into a different era of government the the ideas
00:35:34 like separation of powers is is still talked about it's still praised but it's not applied
00:35:41 aside nearly as seriously as it ought to be. The piece in C2C Journal, Legal Canons and Social
00:35:49 Fables, The Law in Canada, has never been perfect, but now it is losing its way. And I think if we
00:35:55 put that up on the screen there, people will be able to see it for themselves. Do go and read it
00:35:59 at c2cjournal.ca. Bruce Party, the Executive Director of Rights Probe, always good to talk to
00:36:05 you. Hopefully you'll come back on once you're on the Supreme Court there, Bruce. But thank you very
00:36:11 much thanks for having me andrew always good to talk to you all right always good to talk to you
00:36:15 as well thank you for that and thanks again to those of you i had the chance to chat with last
00:36:20 night i also had the chance to speak to jordan peterson who told us uh how big a fan he is of
00:36:26 the work true north is doing so i thank jordan peterson for that we'll have to get him on the
00:36:30 show i interviewed him uh several years ago on my old show that i did before here and admittedly he
00:36:37 has gotten like continued to get more and more and more famous and important since then. I went
00:36:42 up like a little bit since then, but he shot like way up. But it was still nonetheless great to chat
00:36:48 with him and his lovely wife again. So all of you, we will talk to you next week with more of
00:36:52 Canada's most irreverent talk show. And I was hoping to have a promo to play for you now. I
00:36:57 don't have a promo, but we'll post something over the weekend. We have a great interview coming up
00:37:03 next week, a full hour sit down with Tamara Leach, in which she finally breaks her silence 0.92
00:37:09 free of some of the really restrictive bail conditions that were preventing her from speaking
00:37:13 out and have made it difficult to actually have a sit down with her in the past. So we will have
00:37:18 that for you next week. Stay tuned for that. Have a good weekend, everyone. Thank you. God bless
00:37:22 and good day to you all. Thanks for listening to The Andrew Lawton Show. Support the program
00:37:28 by donating to True North at www.tnc.news.