Juno News - November 20, 2023


One-quarter of Justin Trudeau's time in office have been "personal" days

Topics
Mentioned
Trudeau sides with Hamas Human rights commission says Christmas is a "discriminatory" holiday

Episode Stats


Length

48 minutes

Words per minute

183.12

Word count

8,834

Sentence count

413

Harmful content

Misogyny

3

sentences flagged

Toxicity

1

sentences flagged

Hate speech

10

sentences flagged


Summary

Summaries generated with gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ .

Justin Trudeau has been Prime Minister of Canada for the past eight years, and in that time, he s been on duty 76% of the time. Is it possible that he s actually working less than half the time that his predecessor, Stephen Harper, did?

Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Topics generated with Qwen2.5-3B-Instruct.
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 Transcription by CastingWords
00:00:30 Thank you.
00:01:00 welcome to canada's most irreverent talk show this is the andrew lawton show brought to you by true
00:01:20 north hello and welcome to you all welcome back to you all or maybe welcome back to me this is
00:01:31 the andrew lawton show canada's most irreverent talk show here on true north i was away last week
00:01:37 hard at work on a very special product project i hope to be able to tell you about in just a couple
00:01:43 of moments but i'm a little out of practice i i gotta get a sip of water here before we continue
00:01:48 Just one moment. Oh, much better. You can get so much water in when you just use a straw that is
00:01:59 not disintegrating before you. So this was actually illegal. I mean, I always drink like
00:02:05 this, but this was like illegal until Friday when the federal court came down the line and said that
00:02:12 you can absolutely use a non-disintegrating straw. I believe that's technically what they're called
00:02:18 there. But the federal court made a rare good decision about the government's plastic span.
00:02:25 Now, this is the latest rebuke of the government's environmental policies. We'll talk about that in
00:02:30 a little bit of time with Chris Sims from the Canadian Taxpayers Federation. And a bit later
00:02:36 on in the show, we will talk about the perils of corporate welfare and how the government's
00:02:40 bazillion dollar, that's like the technical number, the bazillion dollar electric vehicle
00:02:45 battery corporate welfare plans it has are not even going towards Canadian jobs, believe it or
00:02:52 not. So I'd say with this government, we can probably believe it, but that's where we are
00:02:57 there. This is a bit of an interesting story. So Glenn McGregor in the National Post did a data
00:03:04 analysis of Trudeau's schedule. So he like for the last eight years went through all of the itineraries
00:03:11 that Justin Trudeau posts. It's difficult work. I know that because True North's own
00:03:14 Kosman Georgia did this a couple of years back to look at how many days Justin Trudeau took that
00:03:21 were logged as personal. So on his itinerary, it'll show, oh, you know, we've got a meeting
00:03:26 with the chairman of the World Economic Forum. We've got a check presentation to the president
00:03:32 of Ukraine. We've got all of these things. And then when he's not doing anything, it will say
00:03:37 personal. And sometimes it's personal because he's surfing on the beach in Tofino. Other times
00:03:43 it's because he's surfing on the beach of Tofino. Sometimes his days are personal because he is,
00:03:49 believe it or not, surfing on the beach in Tofino. But I'm sorry, I'm banging my straws now. That's
00:03:55 the problem with prop comedy. But the thing about it is that Justin Trudeau has taken 24% of his
00:04:03 time in office based on 2015 to the present excluding elections as personal. 24%. Now this
00:04:11 amounts to 22 months of personal days in the span of eight years. That is nearly two full years of
00:04:18 time off. Now this is for Canadians quite difficult to grasp because most Canadians will have a very
00:04:27 difficult time getting the time off from work. Most Canadians will also find that they have to
00:04:31 work second jobs on the weekends, say. So Canadians are not getting as much time off as
00:04:36 Justin Trudeau. Now it's easy to criticize him. It is easy for conservatives. And I see a lot of it
00:04:42 jumping up and down saying, oh, he's some dilettante. He's not actually interested in
00:04:47 being prime minister. He just wants to jet off and go on vacation and all of that. And you know
00:04:51 what? Fair enough. But here's the counterpoint to that. And I'm going to do the rare defense
00:04:56 of Justin Trudeau that you don't often get here on The Andrew Lawton Show. Don't tune out just yet.
00:05:01 do we want him working 100% of the time?
00:05:07 Like, look at all that Justin Trudeau has done
00:05:09 in the 76% of time that he's been on duty
00:05:14 for the last eight years.
00:05:15 Do we really want that increase to 100%?
00:05:19 Because I am no mathematician.
00:05:20 I am not great at the numbers.
00:05:22 I'm good with politics.
00:05:23 I'm good with ideas.
00:05:24 I'm wonderful with geography.
00:05:25 If you want to, like, give me a foreign flag
00:05:27 and say, where is this from?
00:05:29 I'll be like, no, no, no, that's Monaco.
00:05:31 that's that stuff's easy but math in a little bit but but by my rudimentary calculations if justin
00:05:38 trudeau were to work full time like maybe not even one let's just say 100 because i can do that i
00:05:44 already did that math in my head if he were to work 100 of the time that would be like 33 wait
00:05:51 sean's checking my math here you say it's a 50 increase no it wouldn't be a 50 increase if he
00:05:57 were to work uh 66 divided okay sean's confusing me with the numbers here no no no because he only
00:06:03 works uh 76 of the time now so if he were to do 100 that would be a 33 increase not a 50 increase
00:06:12 okay my math is apparently better than sean sean like got me but sean's giving me like nine numbers
00:06:18 in our show chat right now and like none of them are the accurate one so anyway yeah so that would
00:06:22 would be a one-third increase so do you want Justin Trudeau to do one-third more than he has
00:06:27 done right now like think of what the national debt would be if we were to add a third to what
00:06:31 the national debt is right now so I'll give Justin Trudeau a bit of credit and saying you know look
00:06:37 if you want to spend more time on Tofino that's better for Canadian taxpayers I'm going to say
00:06:42 like I believe you've earned more time off you've earned more vacation if you want to just do what
00:06:48 like unionized workers do when they're retiring and they take all their unused vacation and just
00:06:53 take like one nine month paid holiday I think it would be cheaper for Canada even still than what
00:06:59 he would do in that nine months of labor so uh that is my attempt Sean's now like editing the
00:07:04 numbers he did previously to mask the fact that he got them wrong you know you can't edit I've
00:07:08 already read them on air Sean all right this is why we are not a mathematics program here
00:07:12 on the Andrew Lawton show in fact I would actually be qualified to be liberal finance minister with
00:07:17 my mathematics skills sean certainly would be uh qualified to be a liberal finance minister right
00:07:22 now but uh nevertheless it's good to have you tuned in to the program here i i all that math
00:07:28 i've worked up uh the need to have a bit more water here oh you got that lovely slurp into my
00:07:35 high-end microphone just for comedic effect there but uh nevertheless i want to talk about this
00:07:40 little thing that took place this morning so pierre pauliev was doing a scrum with reporters
00:07:44 back in Ottawa. And he mentioned something which I wouldn't have even paid attention to because
00:07:50 I've heard him talk about this in the past. It's not really a new idea. And he said it in French,
00:07:54 so I won't make you listen to it. But that wasn't like an insult to the, well, maybe it was. But
00:07:59 the thing is, Polyev made a comment about the Liberals being socialist. And like this is,
00:08:06 there's that old thing about how when a dog bites a man, that's not news. But when a man bites a dog,
00:08:13 that's news. Trudeau being a socialist is not news. Pierre Polyev calling Trudeau a socialist
00:08:18 is not really news. I wouldn't have really paid much attention to it. But there was a reporter
00:08:23 from the Toronto Star who did chime in and made a comment about this. Alex Ballingall said Pierre
00:08:31 Polyev just said the Trudeau government is socialist. And then he followed it up with a
00:08:37 fair enough comment on this. I've never heard any liberal in this government talk about the appeal
00:08:42 of overthrowing capitalism. Well, I bet they probably have, but here's some reading about
00:08:46 what socialism is. And then he links to a piece that was published by a professor at Stanford
00:08:53 University. Now, I would say that that piece was a little bit more oriented towards communism. I
00:08:58 think we see in a lot of countries that are very markedly socialist, but still have some level
00:09:04 of capitalist enterprise in them. Now, I could go on and on and on, and I'll try not to do too much
00:09:11 of this with discussions about, say, how the liberal government is behaving in a more socialist
00:09:18 way. I could talk about Chrystia Freeland's embrace of stakeholder capitalism, which 0.91
00:09:23 fundamentally undermines what capitalism is and what free markets are. I could talk about
00:09:29 the expansion of the state. I could talk about the expansion of social welfare. I could talk
00:09:34 about the universalization of pharma care and dental care that we get from people on the left,
00:09:40 including Trudeau government, I could make a detailed point by point case for why the Trudeau
00:09:47 government is socialist in nature. Or I could just share this clip with you. Mr. Speaker, so I was
00:09:54 I was sitting. I'm a liberal and a proud socialist, Mr. Speaker. But this reminds me of a certain
00:10:01 quote from Prime Minister Harper, who talked about the fight against climate change as a socialist
00:10:06 plot. That's what the Conservative Party, and here it is, you have it again, Mr. Speaker,
00:10:10 they do not believe that climate change is an issue.
00:10:16 Sorry, I'm a proud socialist. So Pierre Polyev might have been more accurate if he had said a
00:10:26 proud socialist government. That's like the real pride month, socialism pride for the liberals. So
00:10:32 that is Environment Minister Stephen Gilbeau, who I bet has probably talked about overthrowing
00:10:37 capitalism, if I looked hard enough, especially his time before office, getting up in the House
00:10:41 of Commons and saying in response to a complaint by the Conservatives that the Liberals were 0.63
00:10:47 socialists, well, gosh darn it, I am a proud socialist. That is Stephen Gilbeau's approach.
00:10:54 Now, Stephen Gilbeau is having a very, very bad couple of weeks. Stephen Gilbeau has had a
00:11:01 miserable time. The federal government keeps dismissing, sorry, the court system keeps
00:11:06 dismissing his environmental policy, the most recent of which we'll be talking about in a few
00:11:11 moments with Chris Sims, which is the plastics ban. But the whole point is Pierre Polyev makes
00:11:18 what is a factual comment that the liberal government is socialist. We have a Toronto
00:11:22 Star journalist trying to debunk it in some way. Now, I just responded to Alex, who I actually like
00:11:29 And I think it's quite capable with a link to that clip.
00:11:32 And then he retweeted it.
00:11:33 And apparently the conservatives have been circulating that clip in force when asked about this as well.
00:11:39 And then Rachel Gilmore, the TikTok influencer who used to work for my old company, Global News,
00:11:45 had said that Pierre Polyev, so we're just like saying stuff these days, A.
00:11:53 Well, yes.
00:11:54 Who is saying this stuff?
00:11:56 Stephen Gilbeau.
00:11:57 Take a look again, just for posterity.
00:11:59 Mr. Speaker, so I was sitting. I'm a liberal and a proud socialist, Mr. Speaker. But this
00:12:06 reminds me of a certain quote from Prime Minister Harper who talked about the fight against climate
00:12:12 change as a socialist plot. That's what the Conservative Party, and here it is, you have it
00:12:16 again, Mr. Speaker. They do not believe that climate change is an issue. See, socialist plot
00:12:23 to him is like a compliment. If you say, oh, this is a socialist plot, he'll be like, well, yes,
00:12:27 we need to pass it twice as quickly now. So the media is just absolutely deranged about Pierre
00:12:34 Polyev. Like they're, they're like this with every conservative leader. It's not particularly a new 0.99
00:12:39 phenomenon, but we're going to see it ramp up more and more. Now, the one thing is the media has just
00:12:45 been wrong about this. We had, when Pierre Polyev was elected, all of these columns from people in
00:12:50 the Toronto Star and the Globe and Mail saying things like, I won't, I'm just paraphrasing,
00:12:54 but these were all things that we heard of, oh, he's too radical to win. No Canadian's going to
00:12:59 like him. Conservatives are going to have their worst showing yet. Remember, Jean Charest was the
00:13:03 guy that was going to be able to deliver a conservative victory, not this Pierre Poilier
00:13:09 kind of guy, whoever that is. And this was the point here. We've seen polling consistently
00:13:17 over the last few weeks that not only show more conservative support than liberal support,
00:13:22 but polling that shows massive, massive conservative margins, larger projections for
00:13:29 conservatives in the next election than even Stephen Harper had the year he won his majority,
00:13:35 2011. And then now the media has had to try to find a way to fit this into its narrative.
00:13:42 And it's really interesting. How do you spin really good conservative poll numbers into this
00:13:47 message that, oh, well, the conservatives don't have a shot? This is a great example
00:13:51 in the Montreal Gazette.
00:13:54 Are the Conservatives at risk of winning too many seats?
00:14:00 A row for Pierre Polyev could spell trouble for the Tories
00:14:03 if the result replicates the unmanageable voter blocs
00:14:06 they faced in the past.
00:14:07 You look at how the Liberal polls are weakening.
00:14:11 You read about how, oh yes,
00:14:13 the Conservatives are doing well in the polls.
00:14:14 The Liberals have been trounced in the past,
00:14:17 including in 2011.
00:14:19 And then they're saying, oh, well,
00:14:20 but for the Conservatives,
00:14:21 like if they just win too many it's going to be an unmanageable coalition well it's not an
00:14:27 unmanageable coalition if you win a majority which is what the conservatives did the most stable
00:14:34 conservative government we had in Stephen Harper's three terms was 2011 to 2015 when he had a broad
00:14:41 decisive mandate from Canadian voters now that doesn't mean that everything he did in that time
00:14:47 was perfect but when you win a majority you have a lot of latitude on what it is you can do and you
00:14:53 know i criticize all the time decisions that are made by courts now in the last couple of weeks
00:14:58 there have been some good ones on the liberal environmental policy but nevertheless i will
00:15:04 point out here that for the liberals they are in the midst of right now a decline that is going to
00:15:13 to look a lot like what they went through in 2011 when they're reduced to, I mean, in that case,
00:15:17 it was third party status. Now, I don't know if that's going to happen quite, but it is going to
00:15:23 be really, really bad news. And now all the journalists have to like get rid of the no one's
00:15:27 vote for conservatives narrative and come up with another one. So now the risk is, well, we don't
00:15:32 want them to be too powerful. So this is how things are shifting here. I mentioned earlier in
00:15:39 the program that this is no longer an act of defiance. This was illegal a few days ago. Now
00:15:47 I think it's fine. Now I have to do some more Christmas shopping because I had like ordered
00:15:51 my wife, you know, a thousand plastic straws because I thought that was like the real romantic
00:15:56 Christmas present of the Trudopian era. But now I have to go back to the drawing board. It's not 0.99
00:16:01 as badass now that I don't have to like smuggle them in from some liberated country because in
00:16:06 Canada, you can have your plastic straws now. The federal court has dismissed the government's
00:16:13 plastics ban as unconstitutional. Part of it is because the government had such a broad
00:16:18 and overreaching definition of what plastic is, but we also saw it as being tremendously
00:16:24 unconstitutional, encroaching on provincial jurisdiction, but basically outstretching
00:16:30 its own powers and the bounds of the law and the constitution. Now, what does this mean,
00:16:36 especially when you contextualize it with the Supreme Court's rejection of the Impact Assessment Act,
00:16:44 the No More Pipelines Act, just a couple of weeks ago.
00:16:48 Joining me now is Chris Sims, our regular Monday guest here on The Andrew Lawton Show,
00:16:53 the Alberta Director for the Canadian Taxpayers Federation.
00:16:56 And I actually saw Chris on the weekend in Red Deer at the Canada Strong and Free Network Regional Conference,
00:17:02 which was always a good time, not only because we saw Chris, but that makes any good time better.
00:17:07 Chris, good to talk to you. Thanks for coming back on today.
00:17:10 Likewise, Andrew. Franco and I were talking this morning.
00:17:12 What is Andrew going to get his wife now for Christmas that he doesn't have all these plastic straws to give?
00:17:18 You could give her, like, jerry cans full of gasoline, but that's a little bit too expensive and a little bit too volatile.
00:17:25 Home heating oil. We can import some home heating oil from Atlantic Canada. Tax-free if you get it from there.
00:17:30 Hey, baby, it's tax-free. So this is important from a taxpayer's perspective because it's a wrap on the nose to intrusive, bigger government. And what was interesting in the ruling is some of the language used by the judge was, I'm paraphrasing here, this is problematic for federalism, meaning stay in your lane, Ottawa. You're reaching too far here.
00:17:54 And while a lot of us, when we think of single-use plastics, probably think of exactly your plastic straws there that you're going to have to sell on eBay now, and the single-use plastic shopping bags, which are now almost gone, which causes all of us to walk out of the grocery store carrying all of our jars of food.
00:18:11 It's also certain things like contact lenses, because it tried to declare all plastic manufactured items as being toxic and therefore worthy of regulation by the federal government.
00:18:26 Interestingly, in this case, the judge actually cited things like contact lenses, and she basically said, to paraphrase, your definition of this is too broad, so we're striking it down.
00:18:39 Now, interestingly, of course,
00:18:40 Guibo is saying the fight's not over.
00:18:42 I still want to climb into your house
00:18:44 and regulate what you have in there.
00:18:46 So they're probably going to appeal it.
00:18:48 But you're right.
00:18:49 On the heels of overturning Bill C-69,
00:18:52 at least ruling against it,
00:18:54 and now this plastics ban being called unconstitutional
00:18:57 and a threat to federalism,
00:18:59 this is really good news for people
00:19:01 who want government to be small enough
00:19:04 to drown in the bathtub,
00:19:05 as Governor Norquist famously said.
00:19:07 yeah and i would also point out that it's incredibly anti-business because you have i
00:19:14 mean not only an entire plastic sector which i think the government is trying to vilify like as
00:19:18 you know the like the big tobacco industry or whatever but you also have i think a really big
00:19:24 problem here in that government companies have all we already had to respond to these regulations
00:19:30 so a lot of the big grocery chains have already done exactly what you've alluded to there
00:19:34 they phase these out. I was in Red Deer. I went to a very freedom loving restaurant
00:19:39 when I was there. This was the day after the decision came and I got like one of those soggy,
00:19:44 dissolving, disintegrating paper straws. And I know they didn't want to give it to me,
00:19:48 but they've probably had to buy, you know, 10,000 of these things already.
00:19:52 And the worst thing is for me that the government may get really what it wanted in the first place
00:19:59 because they forced business to do this and now even though the law has been found to be
00:20:04 unconstitutional a lot of businesses have already embraced these new products so Canadians are still
00:20:09 losing out. They are but the beauty of capitalism of course and free market choice is that if enough
00:20:15 of us complain about having paper straws disintegrating into our drinks that businesses
00:20:20 will respond and then buy the straws or buy the spoons or the cups that we want to use
00:20:26 when we purchase their items. Now, to your point on costs, I was reading some data coming from
00:20:32 the restaurant industry, and you're right. The amount of money that they have had to shell out
00:20:37 now for new clamshells, for example, what they're going to do with stir sticks, all that sort of
00:20:44 stuff, that all costs money up front. And these are all private businesses. And so now you're
00:20:50 right because the government stuck its nose into something so simple as to the containers we use
00:20:55 to eat and drink, they're now going to have to alter their course. Also, this was starting us
00:21:02 down a slippery slope because in my mom's groups on Facebook chats and stuff, a lot of us were
00:21:08 asking, well, what's next? Are my Ziploc bags, you know, my sandwich bags that I put my kid's
00:21:14 sandwich in for school, are they next? And all of the data I kept reading from the government was
00:21:19 Not yet. Yet. But they were definitely establishing the precedent here from Guibo's perspective that, yes, we do have the authority to go in there and regulate what you use out of your pantry.
00:21:31 And so this is a really nice thing to see as a correction to say no federal government, stay in your lane.
00:21:37 This is unconstitutional. Further, this also kind of gave a spirit or a good wind, if you will, to the idea of taxing everything, including banks.
00:21:49 and so in vancouver we saw they went so far as to try to impose a cup ban so a disposable cup ban
00:21:58 so that we would all eventually have to use a communal pool of sippy cups the entire city
00:22:04 i'm not i'm just imagine going into starbucks yeah i'll take my my ice latte right here please
00:22:08 and just like you know really really squeeze the hands together so you don't lose it i forgot i
00:22:12 forgot my reusable cup at home or into into some grody cup that's been sitting in the bottom of a
00:22:18 backpack on some student's mapsack on the SkyTrain for years. It's just gross. But they
00:22:25 repealed that part. They've kept their bag tax though. And now the city of Edmonton has a bag
00:22:30 tax, no matter what it's made out of. So a paper bag in a drive-through at McDonald's, you're
00:22:36 dinged 15 cents every single time. And they're going to jack up that price in the new year.
00:22:41 And that might not sound like a lot, but what it does is it gives the government,
00:22:45 it gives them free reign to intrude into your personal life in this way and tax you even for
00:22:51 that. Even a fully recycled paper bag that's going to disintegrate anyway, they're still going to
00:22:57 tax you for that. So this is nice to see as a correction and a movement hopefully towards more
00:23:04 smaller and responsible government. Well, and wasn't it in Calgary where there was a store
00:23:09 that did the thing that you're all supposed to do? They come up with this reusable bag that they
00:23:14 will charge people for and even that was deemed too plastic by the federal government and you
00:23:20 know that's a good good reminder that's a good freedom of information request to find out just
00:23:25 how many bureaucrats it took to decide whether or not that it was a co-op grocery store if i'm
00:23:30 correct in remembering whether or not so we're not even talking about these like renegade
00:23:34 libertarians there that are like trying to screw the law these are like the do-good lefties that
00:23:38 were trying to do everything right and probably would have even without the regulation exactly
00:23:42 those people that like to sing in like circles and hold hands them they were the ones that were
00:23:47 told no no no your plastic bag is too plastic also when they start looking into alternative
00:23:52 plastics we have to keep in mind that there's pluses and minuses and wins and losses to all
00:23:58 of these subjects and all of these materials so if you're talking about vegetable-based
00:24:03 biodegradable plastics I've read some studies that show hey if you want to amp that up and
00:24:09 move away from petroleum plastic and go to vegetable plastic guess what we need to grow that
00:24:16 where on land you're going to take up arable land in order to create these plastics and you're going
00:24:23 to take away from food production i've heard lots of warnings about that this is all to say that
00:24:28 whenever the sorry i was getting thirsty i'm impressed you look like homer when he was trying
00:24:35 to smoke all the cigarettes at once right so people need to keep this in mind when government
00:24:41 comes up with these big ideas when the bureaucrats are sitting around trying to outdo each other
00:24:46 at environment canada in ottawa or gatineau that they all have consequences they could either cost
00:24:52 families too much money they could nuke businesses that are already on their knees after the covid
00:24:57 lockdowns or they could even have unintended knock-on effect of hey we're taking up arable
00:25:02 land to grow plastic bags instead of food. Yeah, I think you're, well, you're bang on there. And
00:25:09 I think you're right to capture that bigger picture of a plastic span is just a vast expansion
00:25:14 in the role of the state. Because really, this is central planning, the most minute things. It is
00:25:20 what you put in your pantry cupboard. And incidentally, it's also causing more waste.
00:25:27 I mean, one of the number one complaints that I get from people about these is the one that's so
00:25:31 familiar which is that we all just buy these things every time we go to the grocery store
00:25:37 because we can't hold everything and get out to our cars so we buy them and then we forget them
00:25:42 at home and then we have to buy another one the next time we go there not only is it more expensive
00:25:45 because these are you know like a buck two bucks a piece but also now you're producing more and
00:25:50 more of these things when I think most families and certainly my own have like a giant bag or
00:25:56 cupboard full of plastic bags that we reuse for things like garbage and you know household whatever
00:26:03 walking your dog yeah now what do you do if you want you know a garbage bag to line your uh you
00:26:09 know bathroom garbage can what are you doing you're going to the store and buying plastic garbage
00:26:15 container liners like this is just so absurd exactly there's no there's no proof that this is
00:26:23 fully reducing our use of such things like where are these things being made up so for example
00:26:29 a lot of these so-called plastic or canvas or whatever bags you see i check because i want to
00:26:34 know almost all of them that i've seen are made overseas namely china and i don't know about you
00:26:41 but the last time i checked i don't think china has the same environmental regulations as canada
00:26:46 it does so it also had to get here i mean even if it did it had to be shipped here look it came here
00:26:52 on a barge and again you're right we're all forgetting them at home and so you have to really
00:26:57 look at the knock-on effect and even if you make your own which i do i sewed a whole bunch of these
00:27:03 bags which i also forget in my pantry before i go grocery shopping that also takes up energy and
00:27:09 materials and resources so again this is all you know it reminds me going back to dr thomas soul
00:27:14 who is still with us, thank goodness, 93 years old, and the gentleman just put out a book.
00:27:20 So I wish. So he said, whenever somebody comes up with a brilliant idea, we should ask them
00:27:26 three questions. Compared to what? At what cost? What hard evidence do you have? It looks like
00:27:34 they failed on all three counts. And interestingly, now the court is saying, folks, stay in your lane.
00:27:41 so here's the thing that i i have to ask before we move on from this because obviously the
00:27:47 government doesn't really seem to be accepting that it lost this is true with the impact assessment
00:27:53 act ruling it's true with this the government is still trying to plow ahead so are you kind of
00:27:58 thinking that this is going to end up being a political decision that canadians will make where
00:28:02 they have to elect a government that just says no we don't want this level of intrusion
00:28:06 yeah i think so just from my experience on the hill and my experience as a journalist forever
00:28:12 i see this as one of those nuisance factors so 15 cents is not the same amount as say a photo
00:28:20 radar ticket would have been uh back in in ontario back in the day under pcs and mike harris
00:28:27 but keep in mind the amount of intrusive nuisance factor vote that was so mike harris
00:28:33 won for many reasons when he became Premier of Ontario. But one of the key reasons why he won
00:28:38 is because he said, I'll ban photo radar. I'll get rid of it. And so I think this is one of those
00:28:44 personal, my nose is out of joint. You're in my face. I'm really tapped out because you've caused
00:28:50 inflation. You've jacked up my carbon taxes. You've increased my payroll taxes. I can barely
00:28:56 afford groceries. And now I have to juggle all my jars of jam getting out to my car. So I think
00:29:02 that is eventually going to be one of those issues. It's going to become a political factor.
00:29:07 Yeah, I think jam juggling is going into the next election. All right, Chris,
00:29:10 since you brought it up, I have to ask you, who wore it better?
00:29:15 Oh my gosh. See, I was right. I remembered that one. I like yours. It's more relevant.
00:29:21 Okay. These are more deadly, according to Stephen Gilbeau. So I'll give up plastic straws and take
00:29:28 up smoking that'll be my contribution there uh chris sims from the canadian taxpayers federation
00:29:33 always a pleasure great seeing you on the weekend and we will see you next monday you betcha all
00:29:38 right thanks very much for that uh simpsons references are always the evergreen the always
00:29:44 the evergreen one i don't even get them most of the time but everyone around me does so as someone
00:29:49 on true north's internal discussion understood that reference so uh in any case we are going to
00:29:55 move on from that, but well, let's just do one more victory lap here for the road. There we go.
00:30:02 Apparently I need a refill. Anyway, this is a good day for taxpayers in some ways for the reasons we
00:30:08 were just discussing, but for others, not so much. Now, remember the billions and billions and
00:30:14 billions of dollars that was being spent on the electric vehicle battery plant. This was the big,
00:30:20 giant ambitious plan to set up a Volkswagen EV battery plant in St. Thomas, Ontario.
00:30:27 And then Stellantis, which is the company that now owns Chrysler, said, oh, hang on,
00:30:31 we want a piece of this corporate welfare also, and got into it. Well, now we find out that this
00:30:37 money, which was defended by the government as being for Canadian jobs, is not even going towards
00:30:45 Canadian jobs. It's being largely used to bring in temporary foreign workers that Canadians are now
00:30:53 paying for. So Canadians are on net losing money entirely on this. Here was a clip of
00:31:00 Conservative leader Pierre Polyev condemning this revelation. Now we learn that the $15 billion
00:31:07 dollar grant to the Stellantis plant will fund mostly jobs for non-Canadians not immigrants
00:31:17 we love jobs for immigrants jobs for people who are not Canadian citizens and will not 1.00
00:31:22 be Canadian citizens they will come here get a taxpayer funded paycheck and take it back 1.00
00:31:30 to their country I love South Korea wonderful country but they don't fund jobs for Canadians 0.95
00:31:37 And we shouldn't fund jobs for their workers.
00:31:40 Our money should fund our paychecks.
00:31:43 Bring it home.
00:31:45 That's why common sense conservatives are demanding a full inquiry
00:31:49 into how many of these taxpayer-funded jobs are going to temporary foreign workers.
00:31:58 We want a commitment that none of the money should go to temporary foreign workers.
00:32:01 It should only come to Canadians. 1.00
00:32:02 This is a $15 billion grant to one company.
00:32:07 $15 billion works out to $1,000 for every single Canadian family.
00:32:13 You've got 15 million families in Canada.
00:32:16 You've got $15 billion for this one company.
00:32:19 Every family in Canada will give $1,000 to this plant.
00:32:23 And now we know that the majority of the jobs won't even go to Canadians.
00:32:28 That's specifically referring to Stellantis in Windsor.
00:32:33 but I think the general sense here when we talk about Volkswagen, Stellantis, all of this is that
00:32:39 in general corporate welfare is not a winning proposition. Canadian taxpayers, Canadian workers
00:32:45 really don't benefit from this. It becomes a race to the bottom. It's the big multinational
00:32:49 companies that are the ones cashing the checks here but in this case it really is adding insult
00:32:54 to injury when it's not even Canadian jobs that are ostensibly being created here. Aaron Woodrick
00:33:00 is the domestic policy guru over at the mcdonald laurier institute and joins us now aaron always
00:33:06 good to talk to you i mean this is like really a slap in the face but i'm almost glad because it
00:33:11 shows more ostentatiously how bad corporate welfare is yeah look for for those who are 0.96
00:33:17 tuning in who don't know my history on this i mean i've been a long time critic of corporate
00:33:21 welfare in all sectors in all places at all times i'm a big fan of free enterprise and business and
00:33:27 the right to earn a living and make money if you can. But you should not be getting tax dollars if
00:33:32 your business cannot support itself. And that's especially true of these large multinationals.
00:33:36 Andrew, in this case in particular, what I had a bit of a chuckle about is that, you know,
00:33:40 these are the same people, whenever I make my usual objections, they say, well, you know,
00:33:44 that's just the price we have to pay. We have to pay to play. If we want to get this plan,
00:33:49 we just have to outlay these billions of dollars. That's just the way it is. But if you say, oh,
00:33:53 So some of that outlay has to go to, you know, say the South Koreans want to bring in some experts from Seoul because they're the only ones who can do this.
00:34:00 Oh, no, no, we can't have that. That's not a price we're willing to pay.
00:34:02 We're willing to throw billions of dollars at something that makes no economic sense.
00:34:06 But God forbid some of those workers come from outside of Canada.
00:34:09 So I thought that was a little bit rich, but it does expose the absurdity of the whole thing.
00:34:13 And frankly, it's just another reason why governments should not get their fingers into these business, right?
00:34:19 Like if a business brings in foreign workers and they're paying it on their dime, it's kind of none of our business. 1.00
00:34:24 But once our money is engaged, once taxpayer money's invades, you've got the government going in there saying, well, you have to put the plant here and you have to have this many employees and you have to produce.
00:34:33 I mean, the government is basically running the company.
00:34:35 And then you start to wonder, I mean, for people who know, well, government runs itself.
00:34:39 Imagine how good a job they're going to do running a business like Stellantis. 0.92
00:34:43 Yeah.
00:34:43 And I think Pierre Polyev made a point there, which is a valid one.
00:34:46 I mean, South Korea, I don't know much about their domestic politics, but I suspect they're not giving companies large bailouts to bring in Canadian workers, nor should they.
00:34:55 So I don't really see the argument here on how Canada should be doing this.
00:34:59 I mean, TFWs are already a bit contentious.
00:35:02 I mean, the argument is that, well, they only exist because there are jobs that Canadians just can't do or more specifically won't do.
00:35:09 In this particular case, when companies are given money that governments are turning around and defending by saying it's going to create Canadian jobs and it's creating South Korean jobs, it just doesn't really square there.
00:35:20 No, look, and when it comes to importing workers to do work in this country, they generally fall into one of two buckets, right?
00:35:25 You have people who are very rare skills that are highly skilled that we just don't have enough of those people on the high end.
00:35:32 And then also what we call the low skill end.
00:35:34 So you've got work that Canadians don't want to do. 0.92
00:35:36 It doesn't pay very well.
00:35:37 It's very hard.
00:35:37 So those are the two sort of high end and low end. Now on the high end, you know, if you're in a, you know, you're looking for nuclear physicists, right? There's just not that many. There's not that much you can do, but that's not very many jobs. On the low end, the challenge we have is people, employers say, well, we can't find any workers, even if we raise our wages. You know, in some cases, that's true. But my response there is, well, what kind of entitlements is the government offering that will keep people out of these jobs?
00:36:02 I mean, the reality is if people, if we live in a country where the social safety net is so comfortable that you can actually choose to work or not, and I'm not saying all people do this, of course, some people can't work and have legitimate reasons not to work, but especially in certain regions of this country, it's well established that there are people that are prepared to work less or work part of the year because the entitlement system is so generous.
00:36:22 So my argument is if you actually make that entitlement system a little bit less generous, create some better incentives for people to work, you'll have more people going into those jobs, you'll have less need for temporary foreign workers, and this problem largely goes away.
00:36:34 Yeah, and I hate to keep beating people over the head with the obvious point here, but there is a difference between a company that says, look, we have this need, we believe it can be best filled or only filled by foreign workers in this market, and a company that does that well, the government is paying for it.
00:36:51 Well, exactly. We're paying for the privilege. And if a business wants to do that sort of thing, boy, they should be running as far away as they can from any handout because obviously this objection and politicians are right.
00:37:03 I mean, at least in this instance, you have governments now saying, well, we want to make sure the taxpayer money is well spent on a subsidy in a different way.
00:37:10 But nonetheless, I mean, you can see how any politician worth their salt is going to see the alarm ringing here saying this is not going to go over well with anybody if this money is actually leaving the country.
00:37:21 Outside of this, I wanted to get you on the show anyway today.
00:37:24 You had a great piece in the Globe and Mail.
00:37:26 The key to saving Canada's economy is tax reform.
00:37:30 Now, I think it's safe to say in the last eight years,
00:37:32 no one in government has come up with a key to saving Canada's economy.
00:37:35 So I think as a Canadian, I say thank you for putting this up there.
00:37:39 But when you say tax reform, I mean, we often hear governments
00:37:42 and political parties talk about, oh, we can, you know,
00:37:45 add this little tax credit here, this reduction.
00:37:48 In some cases, even more radical reforms, like what Stephen Harper did in reducing the GST.
00:37:54 But when you talk about tax reform, you're talking about something a bit more radical here.
00:37:58 Explain.
00:37:59 Yeah, I say, too, the title's a little bit generous.
00:38:03 I argue that tax reform's a key plank in, you know, boosting our economy.
00:38:06 It's not the only one.
00:38:07 That alone's not going to do it.
00:38:08 I would say, Andrew, generally the, you know, the debate over taxes is about higher or lower.
00:38:12 And I think that's an important debate.
00:38:14 I come down firmly on the lower side of that.
00:38:16 But that's a separate debate than a complex system.
00:38:19 We have an absurdly complicated tax system.
00:38:22 Most people who have to do their taxes know this.
00:38:24 Don't even try doing it without a professional help or without one of those softwares that
00:38:29 you purchase.
00:38:29 It's just it's way too complicated.
00:38:31 There's a cost to that.
00:38:33 It distorts the system.
00:38:34 It's confusing.
00:38:35 It makes it hard for businesses to comply.
00:38:38 I think it's fair to say we should have a debate about how much money does the government
00:38:41 need?
00:38:42 And then we got to look at the fairest, simplest, most neutral way to raise that money.
00:38:46 And that's part of the thing that often gets left out when we're debating higher or lower
00:38:50 taxes is which taxes are the ones that are the best to get this money, which ones are
00:38:54 going to create the least distortions and do the least damage to our economy.
00:38:59 One of the biggest problems with taxes, in my view, well, paying them, but one of the
00:39:03 other biggest problems, and this is true in Canada, it's especially true in the United
00:39:07 States, is that we have such a path dependency in our approach to taxes.
00:39:11 if you were to say we're going to gather around a group of people and we're going to create a new
00:39:16 tax system from scratch that you know starting from zero no assumptions previously i don't think
00:39:22 anyone would land on what we have i don't think anyone would come up with a tax code that is just
00:39:27 this long in the us even longer because it doesn't make sense and because it's so complex and
00:39:32 convoluted yet this is what we have and and as a result changes seem to be very limited to tweaks
00:39:39 and like you say, higher or lower. So would you, in the ideal world, if you were at that table,
00:39:45 would you be changing something fundamental in how much you rely on consumption, how much you
00:39:50 rely on corporate, how much you rely on sales and income? What would your approach be if you
00:39:55 were to really blow this up and start from scratch? Yeah, that's a great question. And
00:39:59 you're right. It's a bit like barnacles on the hull of a ship, right? They just keep clinging
00:40:02 on and eventually you sort of, you drag the ship down with you. There's an inertia element to that,
00:40:07 right? Politicians have limited political capital. They don't want to waste all their time sort of
00:40:11 undoing or fixing the things their predecessors done. They want to get on with their own. So they
00:40:14 just end up layering it on top of things. Look, I think there's a good debate to be had about
00:40:19 the role of consumption taxes. You know, people don't like them because they can see them. So
00:40:24 they're kind of economically efficient, but they are very, very politically damaging. We saw that
00:40:28 with the GST in this country. We've seen it with things like carbon taxes. The other problem with
00:40:33 consumption taxes is rarely are they applied consistently see like you'll
00:40:36 you'll you'll bring in something like a GST or a carbon tax and then you'll get
00:40:39 all these little carve-outs right well we won't tax poor people we won't tax
00:40:42 pregnant mothers and we won't tax this product and so you kind of undermine the 1.00
00:40:46 purpose of the consumption tax and just interject there for a moment and then
00:40:50 you get these really convoluted debates about what a food product is you know
00:40:53 things like well this is a grocery product but this is a snack product so
00:40:57 it's not even consistent within a category yeah so I would say generally
00:41:02 speaking, whether, you know, if you're going to do consumption taxes, just do it blanket. Don't
00:41:07 have all these carve outs because otherwise you're just undermining the additional value of that.
00:41:11 I mean, the other debate is over the, you know, taxing things like land and housing. You know,
00:41:14 some people are pushing for things like a home equity tax. You can imagine how that's probably
00:41:18 about as, you know, popular as a snowfall in July. But I think another thing we need to really
00:41:24 wrap our heads around, and this is another political challenge, is this idea of when we
00:41:28 talk about taxing businesses. People love taxing big corporations, right? People forget that
00:41:33 corporations are illegal fiction. There is no thing called a corporation paying tax. In reality,
00:41:38 someone else is paying that tax. It's the employees of the company. It's the shareholders
00:41:42 of the company. It's the customers of the company. So somebody else somewhere is paying that tax. So
00:41:47 it's very popular politically to say we should tax, corporate tax, raise it. That doesn't hurt
00:41:53 anybody. Well, it actually does. Somebody else is paying that tax. And in a lot of cases, it's
00:41:57 better to just tax people um on their personal income tax than it is through you know if you're
00:42:02 if you're very wealthy you want to get a very wealthy person to pay more tax don't tax the
00:42:06 business they own more just tax tax above a certain threshold their income higher that's
00:42:11 the better way to go about that coming back to that whole um figure out how much you want to
00:42:14 raise and then figure out the least sort of distorting way to raise it well and to put that
00:42:18 into the context of our corporate welfare discussion i mean i imagine if a government
00:42:23 could say to a company we're going to give you zero dollars in corporate welfare but we're going
00:42:28 to charge you zero percent corporate tax because we know that you're going to employ all these
00:42:33 people who are going to pay corporate tax and your executives are going to pay income tax or income
00:42:37 tax rather uh and and you know that there's i don't know how much money that works out too
00:42:41 because it depends on the company but there's a very real chance that that would give them more
00:42:46 than corporate welfare does and it's an incentive that doesn't cost taxpayers money
00:42:52 right well look and incentives matter right i've often gone to these debates about people say well
00:42:56 you support tax cuts isn't that the same as corporate welfare right i mean you're giving
00:42:59 the company money and my response is pretty straightforward right there's a big difference
00:43:03 between if you run a business and you earn money that's your money and you get to keep more of it
00:43:08 right that's or that's money you had to go out and earn in the marketplace that's different than the
00:43:12 government coming along and saying we're just going to sprinkle this money on you you just
00:43:15 get this money whether you sell stuff or not and only just some companies well exactly is across
00:43:20 the board that's where the fairness thing comes in but i mean just um you know conceptually they're
00:43:24 very different for you to believe that a tax cut is the same as corporate welfare requires you to
00:43:29 believe it's actually the government's money in the first place right and they're just letting
00:43:32 you keep some of it so i find that um you know we can debate i'm not a big fan of boutique tax cuts
00:43:37 either i think you should treat all businesses equally you shouldn't sort of single different
00:43:41 ones out but letting people keep more of their own money is a very different thing than giving
00:43:45 them a bunch of money that was never theirs in the first place well and this is where we get to i i
00:43:49 I think the biggest issue here,
00:43:50 and I realize that you're in a very good position on this
00:43:53 because you work in policy,
00:43:54 but the politics and the policy of taxes and economics,
00:43:58 I think are oftentimes in direct conflict.
00:44:01 And this is, I mean, we can talk about
00:44:02 the liberal government's financial mismanagement,
00:44:04 but I think the conservatives are particularly bad historically
00:44:07 at wanting to embrace these boutique tax cuts,
00:44:10 because it's very good politics.
00:44:11 If you can say to a single mom,
00:44:13 you know, we're gonna do this for you.
00:44:15 Or if you can say to a family with kids in sports,
00:44:17 we're gonna give you this money
00:44:18 for your kids to do sports. But then what you've done is you've added more and more complexity,
00:44:23 more carve outs, and less universality to the tax system. Absolutely. And you saw this argument
00:44:29 during the conservative years under Stephen Harper, they added a lot of boutiques credits.
00:44:32 And who's going to argue with that? Who's going to argue with the idea that, you know, giving
00:44:35 families a tax credit to put their kids in sports is a bad thing. The problem is, what I found
00:44:41 ironic was that people at the time argued that, well, you know, if we just cut, if we just cut
00:44:45 income taxes the liberals would come along and reverse that whereas if we put these little
00:44:49 things in the tax code for the reasons we talked about earlier they'll stay there what ended up
00:44:52 happening ironically as Justin Trudeau comes into office one of the first and best things he did in
00:44:56 my view is he actually he got rid of those credits and he actually just cut taxes so it's been a long
00:45:01 time since uh since early 2016 when he did those great tax measures Andrew but I do remember back
00:45:06 in the distant history that there was actually a couple of good tax policies under Justin Trudeau
00:45:11 But then your fiscal honeymoon ended
00:45:13 when he still continued to ramp up spending
00:45:15 for the next eight years.
00:45:16 Yeah, it ended pretty fast.
00:45:17 That nominal tax cut.
00:45:18 Yeah.
00:45:19 Well, I hope that the Aaron Woodrick vision
00:45:21 finds a home in someone who's in a position
00:45:24 to put it there where it needs to be on the books.
00:45:26 Aaron Woodrick from the Macdonald-Laurier Institute.
00:45:28 Great piece in the Globe and Mail.
00:45:30 And thanks as always for coming on today.
00:45:32 Thanks a lot, Andrew.
00:45:33 All right.
00:45:34 That does it for us for today.
00:45:36 I will say it's going to be a regular week for the show
00:45:38 and I'm very excited about something we have
00:45:40 for you on Thursday, which touches on the idea of economic rights for Canadians. We'll have a bit
00:45:46 more information about that as the week progresses. But I am going to be in Burnaby, British Columbia
00:45:51 on Wednesday for an event hosted by the Justice Centre for Constitutional Freedoms. I'll be
00:45:57 speaking alongside Rav Aurora and Amy Hamm and the great folks at the JCCF. Now, I do sit on the
00:46:04 board, but I don't think that I didn't make them invite me as a speaker. They did that on their own.
00:46:09 So that wasn't like my, you know, big defiant act as a board member.
00:46:12 So that'll be good.
00:46:13 And I know a lot of you are in British Columbia.
00:46:16 So if you want to come out, they have tickets available at jccf.ca.
00:46:20 Hope to see you there.
00:46:21 And as always do, come and say hello.
00:46:23 Every time I say that, I mean it because I had people in Red Deer come and say hello
00:46:26 and I appreciated it.
00:46:27 So that does it for me for today.
00:46:29 We will be back in just 23 hours and 15 minutes here on Canada's Most Irreverent Talk Show,
00:46:36 The Andrew Lawton Show on True North.
00:46:37 Thank you, God bless, and good day to you all.
00:47:07 We'll be right back.
00:47:37 We'll be right back.
00:48:07 We'll be right back.