Juno News - May 16, 2024


Online streaming regulations kicked back to after election

Topics
Mentioned
Trudeau still thinks he's not going anywhere Foreign protesters suffer MELTDOWN after receiving criticism from True North

Episode Stats


Length

44 minutes

Words per minute

176.81

Word count

7,927

Sentence count

307

Harmful content

Misogyny

4

sentences flagged

Toxicity

2

sentences flagged

Hate speech

4

sentences flagged


Summary

Summaries generated with gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ .

In this episode of The Lawton Show on True North, host Andrew Lawton talks about a Canadian politician who did a rap about climate disinformation, and the $1.3 million the Canadian government spent to have him do it.

Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Topics generated with Qwen2.5-3B-Instruct.
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 Transcribed by ESO, translated by —
00:00:30 Thank you.
00:01:00 welcome to canada's most irreverent talk show this is the andrew lawton show brought to you by true
00:01:19 north hello and welcome to you all canada's most irreverent talk show here the andrew lawton show
00:01:29 on true north although i've learned as of this morning i probably could have had another calling
00:01:37 now uh this i wasn't even going to talk about this this we're going to do this on off the record
00:01:41 tomorrow so if you want like the full reaction and the full experience of just talking about how 0.98
00:01:47 crazy and stupid this is, do it. But I also couldn't not talk about it because it landed on 0.86
00:01:52 my desk like, I don't know, 25 minutes ago. I mean, not literally, that would have been very
00:01:56 strange, but figuratively landed on my desk. So you may recall back in, I think it was December
00:02:02 or November, I think it was November, the federal government sent this massive delegation to Dubai
00:02:08 for COP28, which is like the big brand climate summit. And I just got back from Dubai. It's a
00:02:15 lovely, lovely city. It is very beautiful, very global. It's weird in a way. I'm actually writing
00:02:21 a column to this effect because it's this like post-national place where none of the people who
00:02:26 live there are actually from there. But I didn't know that Dubai had played home to what I think
00:02:31 is probably the worst musical performance since Sophie Gregoire Trudeau sang a song that no one
00:02:39 asked for about on martin luther king jr day but i don't know she's got nothing on uh what's
00:02:44 this guy's name his name is baba baba dirkman is it i it's not on my notes here i think his name
00:02:51 his name is baba something or other but uh you won't want to look it up because you're not going
00:02:54 to want to hear anything else from him after this banger do we not have the alleged banger
00:03:06 i guess we don't have the clip okay well we'll play the clip later i just said i set it up so
00:03:14 well okay uh we're gonna play this clip very shortly yeah it's the rap clip sean it's the
00:03:19 rap clip all right here we go all right i don't even know what it says
00:03:30 climate disinformation get that immunization the vaccine for bad meme infiltration climate
00:03:41 misinformation it leads to polarization which leads to radical conspiracy ideation simultaneous
00:03:47 translation between conspiracy theories and violent means of change embracement economic
00:03:54 incentives or ideological basis it doesn't matter because either way it's still disinformation
00:04:00 Climate change is upon us and emissions are like a bomb
00:04:03 As the wave of increasing heat carries on and on
00:04:06 The wave of disinformation keeps on getting shared online
00:04:10 Trapped by the lab of Marie-Yves Carignan
00:04:13 From Université Sherbrooke
00:04:15 According to her book, the anti-government left and right now share a yearbook
00:04:19 And when it comes to floods, droughts, and wildfires
00:04:22 Even today's environmentalists can be climate deniers
00:04:25 Those are the yoga QAnon people up in the mix 1.00
00:04:29 Marie Eve tracks the patterns with the acronym FLIC
00:04:32 False X words, fallacious logic, unrealistic expectations
00:04:36 Cherry picking and conspiracy theory ideation, that's FLIC 0.98
00:04:40 Advertisers can help us find a fix
00:04:42 The climate host is exposed, brought to you by Wix
00:04:45 From the false promotion of bad pollutions and tricks
00:04:48 To the outright denialism saying it doesn't exist
00:04:52 There's a reason for the IPCC
00:04:54 It doesn't make assumptions, make your advertising conscious
00:04:57 take it from jake dubbins yes we need free speech to get the facts in the fight
00:05:02 but like jake said ad revenue is not a human right
00:05:10 that i'm sorry so you paid for that i just like you as a canadian taxpayer paid for that that was
00:05:18 a guy his name i looked it up his name is baba brinkman uh not baba black sheep i believe they're
00:05:25 brothers. Baba Brinkman is a New York-based rap artist, and he does science-themed albums and
00:05:33 off-Broadway theater productions. Probably off-off-off-Broadway, like New Jersey off-Broadway.
00:05:39 Anyway, a little, you know, tiny little relevant tidbit, I think, worth mentioning. His mother is
00:05:45 a Liberal member of Parliament. His mother is Liberal MP Joyce Murray, which may or may not
00:05:51 have influenced the Canadian government's decision to fly him to Dubai to do a rap about climate
00:05:58 disinformation. You can probably make it all your ringtone. Give 99 cents to Al Gore and you can make
00:06:03 that your ringtone or David Suzuki. I can't remember which one. This was at the Canada
00:06:08 Pavilion, which according to our friends at the Canadian Taxpayers Federation, we paid, what was
00:06:14 it $1.3 million to put together. Sorry, $3 million. $3 million to put this together. This is the
00:06:24 $1.3 million. Oh, yeah, sorry. $1.3 million is for the, whatchamacallit, for the pavilion.
00:06:31 $3 million was the overall cost. But basically, we are to feel better about it because we've been
00:06:38 wrapped to by the son of a Liberal member of Parliament. The left loves talking about cultural
00:06:43 appropriation. I'm more offended by that than I am by anything that someone would wear as a
00:06:49 Halloween costume. But okay, we'll have more on that tomorrow in Off the Record. But like I said,
00:06:54 I could have had that career. I could have been flying around the world to rap about climate
00:06:59 disinformation. Instead, I'm here in my basement. So take from that what you will. It's a cruel,
00:07:03 cruel world. What I actually wanted to talk about today, and I still have left myself a few minutes
00:07:09 to do it was the CRTC's decision to delay implementation of the so-called Online Streaming
00:07:15 Act. Now this is the bill that the government uses to regulate what you see on the internet.
00:07:22 They are saying that there isn't enough Canadian content on YouTube, on Netflix, on Spotify,
00:07:28 so the Canadian government is going to force these platforms to rejig their algorithms
00:07:33 to show you more Canadian content which means government picking and choosing
00:07:38 what you see on the internet now they've also said that these platforms will have an obligation to
00:07:43 produce more to invest in more so we now have the government basically exacting money from
00:07:49 the netflix's and spotify's of the world and doing so because they believe we need more canadian
00:07:55 content more canadian content like that rap i just showed you so the government will make it
00:08:00 so that youtube produces far more of that and less of i don't know some spanish soap opera
00:08:06 you want to watch clips of on YouTube. But all of that notwithstanding, what's interesting here is
00:08:11 that we have a delay. The CRTC is the one that's forced to actually make this work. And according
00:08:18 to the CRTC itself, they are going to be pushing further and further down the pipeline. So they've
00:08:25 actually published a timeline here. They've published a roadmap and they're now saying
00:08:31 full implementation isn't going to be until late 2025. Late 2025. Now what is 2025? What is the
00:08:39 significance of that? Well that also happens to be when we have scheduled a federal election. That
00:08:44 federal election is coincidentally enough later in 2025. It is in October unless there is an
00:08:51 earlier election which is always a possibility although we don't yet know for certain. But let's
00:08:57 just run the timeline here. The CRDC is still building a regulatory framework. They're having
00:09:01 consultations. They're talking to this group and that group. They're going to have a consultation
00:09:06 on closed captioning in the summer of 2024. So that's sure to be a riveting thing that we won't
00:09:13 be live streaming, I promise you. And it's not until when we talk about implementing it, they
00:09:19 say targeting launch late 2025. So they're going to make all these decisions. Then they're going to
00:09:25 focus on implementing them in late 2025. And this is how they describe it. The CRTC will finalize
00:09:32 the contributions online streaming services and traditional broadcasters will have to make to
00:09:38 support Canadian and Indigenous content. We will also start to issue conditions of service that
00:09:42 reflect how each TV station, radio station, and streaming service should support the goals of the
00:09:48 broadcasting system. More details will be included in future updates. So this is predicated on
00:09:54 government even being able to do this all by the end of next year which I think is a big big
00:09:59 question mark as to whether government is capable of doing that but it also coincidentally means
00:10:04 that the government is going to be the liberal government is going to be forced to defend this
00:10:10 throughout the next election campaign and again the beleaguered liberal government I don't think
00:10:15 wants to run on a platform where they've got to defend the carbon tax which is already going to be
00:10:21 a big pressure point for them, and also have to defend why they're focusing, while Canadians are 0.98
00:10:26 struggling with cost of living, on regulating podcasts. If you're to go door to door, as many
00:10:31 political candidates in this country are and will, and ask people, what are your top 10 concerns from
00:10:36 Canada? I don't think anyone, certainly anyone outside of Quebec, is going to list it all in
00:10:41 the top 10. You know, I really don't like my YouTube homepage. So when you get to Ottawa,
00:10:48 I really want to make sure that you tackle what I see when I log on to YouTube. Now,
00:10:53 when I go to YouTube now, I'm not going to read what's there because you'll learn about my taste
00:10:58 in music and you will forever judge me more harshly than you already do. Let's say I've got
00:11:03 a Gordon Ramsay clip there. I've got a couple of clips from Penn and Teller's show. I've got
00:11:08 the Guantanamera song because someone mentioned Guantanamo the other day and it made me think of
00:11:13 the song. I've got my own show. That's good. My own show. I see myself right now talking
00:11:18 back to me. Let's see. I see a clip of Justin Trudeau and I see a comedian I like who I don't
00:11:24 think is Canadian. So right now there is a selection of videos available to me on YouTube,
00:11:30 which has been curated based on things that I like and things that I click on. One of them is
00:11:36 Canadian. Well, two of them, the clip of Justin Trudeau, which I could take or leave and the live
00:11:41 stream that I'm doing right now are the two Canadian things well below the statutory threshold
00:11:47 that we are going to get for Canadian content
00:11:49 and the regulatory threshold from the CRTC.
00:11:53 So already we have by design a policy
00:11:56 that is aimed at manipulating this.
00:11:58 Now, what forms of Canadian content
00:12:01 do you think the government is going to be putting
00:12:03 on people's homepage?
00:12:04 Do you think they're gonna be forcing
00:12:05 the Andrew Lawton show onto Mabel's YouTube homepage?
00:12:09 No, they're gonna be forcing some crappy CBC sitcom. 0.95
00:12:13 They're gonna be forcing some hackish standup comedian. 1.00
00:12:16 they're going to be forcing that rap about climate disinformation. That's the type of
00:12:20 Canadian content they're going to be pushing. So if you don't think this is a significant issue,
00:12:25 you're not paying attention and you should because it's not benign. It's not just about
00:12:30 supporting Canadian content and Canadian artists. It's about manipulating what every single Canadian 0.98
00:12:36 can do and see on the internet. And I'll use myself as an example here. When my Freedom Convoy
00:12:43 book came out a couple of years ago indigo didn't put it on the shelves and we you know criticized
00:12:49 them for it and that's fine but they made the decision to not do it and they said well it's
00:12:53 still available on our website if someone really wants it they can get it but the point is there
00:12:59 is a tremendous value in a book being on the shelves to expose itself to people that otherwise
00:13:05 wouldn't know it was there you walk into a store you see a book oh wow i didn't know there was a
00:13:10 book about the freedom convoy i'm going to buy it that's what home pages for streaming services are
00:13:15 as well spotify serves up music they'll think i like based on music they know i like they're not
00:13:22 going to do that as well if they're focused on serving up a mandatory quota of canadian music
00:13:28 not to say there isn't amazing canadian music but sometimes that's not what i'm after or you're
00:13:33 disproportionately choosing these things and that's the problem with this so to bring it
00:13:38 it back to why it's relevant now. The fact that the CRTC is delaying it, I actually think is a
00:13:43 tremendous source of relief for Canadians. Keep delaying it, keep delaying it, let this be an
00:13:49 election issue so that you could have a conservative government say, if this is what the conservatives
00:13:53 choose to campaign on, that says the first thing we're going to do is dismantle this, go right back
00:13:58 to the old way, and all of a sudden the CRTC, yes, will have wasted the work, but it means that
00:14:03 Canadians will be further in control of their podcast, their streaming, because again, it's
00:14:08 going to limit what podcasts you see. This is a policy that says we need more of, I don't know,
00:14:15 Canada land and less of Joe Rogan, which may or may not be true, but it's a choice that consumers,
00:14:20 that viewers and listeners to podcasts should decide, not bureaucrats and regulators in the
00:14:26 CRTC. We'll move from this issue to a much more real constitutional matter, and that is the
00:14:33 decision that came down yesterday from the Saskatchewan Court of Appeal upholding a ban
00:14:38 that the government had on gatherings outdoors. Now, one of the things that I, this came up the
00:14:45 other day, there was a gentleman who I've interviewed in the past, Kevin Gaudet, who
00:14:48 was fined for not staying in a quarantine hotel. And he had shared about this on a thread on X.
00:14:55 And I had said when I retweeted it or quote tweeted it, that how surreal it seemed that
00:15:00 this was something we went through, that the government was locking people up in quarantine
00:15:03 hotels and giving massive, massive fines. I said, but it's not surreal. It was very real. Government
00:15:08 did it. And they have tried to basically forget this. But the legal process moves slowly at times.
00:15:14 These things are still working their way through the courts. And with the exception of maybe a
00:15:19 small handful of cases, courts have made absolutely abysmal decisions on this. The one in Saskatchewan,
00:15:25 which we'll talk about shortly. And also this week in British Columbia, the BC Supreme Court
00:15:30 has upheld the healthcare workers vaccine mandate, which is pretty much as unscientific at this stage
00:15:37 as a gathering restriction on outdoor gatherings of more than 10 people. Joining me on the line
00:15:44 now is Marty Moore. He leads a team of lawyers across Canada funded by the Justice Centre
00:15:49 for Constitutional Freedoms. And just as a matter of disclosure, I sit on the board for the JCCF,
00:15:55 although that has no bearing on this interview.
00:15:58 Marty, good to talk to you.
00:15:59 Thanks so much for coming on today.
00:16:00 Good to talk to you.
00:16:01 Thank you, Andrew.
00:16:03 Let's start with what the actual decision was in Saskatchewan.
00:16:06 I mean, this was a clear-cut constitutional freedoms case,
00:16:11 your right to assemble, your right to gather outdoors.
00:16:15 And the Court of Appeal has still said the justifications
00:16:18 that the government held were reasonable.
00:16:21 That's right.
00:16:21 and the word reasonable there is obviously doing a lot of work the court has upheld the lower court
00:16:27 decision that found that it was just fine for the government to prohibit people from protesting
00:16:33 outdoors with uh any more than 10 people and if you have a gathering of 10 people outdoors
00:16:38 then you call that a protest you're really stretching already while simultaneously the
00:16:43 government was in fact allowing much greater uh people to gather indoors and the facts in this
00:16:50 case Andrew were not controversial this was not a great battle of the experts if you will
00:16:54 everybody was admitting it's much safer to be outdoors in fact there was no evidence whatsoever
00:17:00 of a single COVID transmission linked to an outdoor protest during the entire period of COVID
00:17:06 in Saskatchewan but yet when it came to restaurants and bars the public health officer there was
00:17:11 estimating 30 cases a day from those restaurants and bars and guess what had the restrictions
00:17:17 outdoor protest did and in a bar you could gather as long as you only have four people at a table
00:17:23 you were fine in Saskatchewan but don't gather with more than 10 people outdoors in a park
00:17:27 regardless of how far you are apart so this is the current decision that's come down the court says
00:17:32 well government is required deference and the precautionary principle needs to be respected
00:17:37 here as well Andrew. And what is that for people that haven't had to spend their lives immersed
00:17:43 in this like you have well the precautionary principle is designed to allow for government to
00:17:49 make uh decisions where there's a lack of evidence uh and there's a high risk of harm if they don't
00:17:56 act well here in this case it's been known for decades and decades that respiratory viruses
00:18:01 don't transmit outdoors with any significant uh or or real risk there um but yet in the case of
00:18:09 covid we threw all of our past knowledge out the window and claimed that the precautionary
00:18:14 principles needed to be used to ban things that the government really you know had problems with
00:18:18 like an outdoor protest which you know obviously is the only way for people to really voice their
00:18:23 objections to the government's current policy though now the precautionary principle was applied
00:18:27 you know in a bizarre way in saskatchewan because as i mentioned when you could gather indoors and
00:18:33 much more risky settings where there's lots of case spread happening on a daily basis
00:18:37 we don't apply the precautionary principle to that that's economic activity but when it comes
00:18:42 to these pesky protesters outdoors well we'll apply rigorously the precautionary principle
00:18:48 because one of them could get sick Andrew even though we have no evidence that anybody got sick
00:18:52 despite mass protests going on during COVID as we know from the Black Lives Matter protest
00:18:58 I haven't read the full decision yet so I didn't see it there but I wanted to ask you about it
00:19:04 because in some of these decisions in other courts and other similar fact patterns, but different
00:19:09 cases, judges will hedge by saying, well, based on the information at the time, and they'll kind
00:19:15 of give government a bit of a weasel way out there by saying, well, it might have been reasonable
00:19:19 for them to think that this was a reasonable policy. Is that something that was engaged here
00:19:23 as well? Well, certainly the decision tries to say we can't, you know, second guess decisions
00:19:28 made during the time. But these were decisions that were months and months in the making. The
00:19:33 The 10-person limit was initially in place during the Black Lives Matter protests.
00:19:37 It was never enforced during that time, of course.
00:19:40 Then it was reimposed in the winter there.
00:19:43 That entire time period, we have statements from the Chief Medical Health Officer in Saskatchewan
00:19:48 saying it's much safer to be outdoors, please gather outdoors, and even statements commenting
00:19:52 on protests that look, you know, it's a restriction, it's guidance not to gather with more than
00:19:58 10 people, but we totally get people's desire to be outdoors protesting for Black Lives
00:20:03 Matter. That was not applied, of course, when it came down to people protesting government
00:20:07 restrictions, in which case the weight of the law was brought down with full force and
00:20:11 a vigor actually unmatched in any other province, more national across the country. I have not
00:20:17 seen a greater prosecution and zeal to punish those who prosecuted or who protested government
00:20:24 restrictions than I've seen in Saskatchewan. And those prosecutions are actually going on
00:20:28 in this state. We had dozens of cases there in Saskatchewan on that basis, but only those
00:20:33 protesters against the government. No one that was protesting other issues, Black Lives Matter,
00:20:37 Palestinian Israel issues, or even LGBTQ matters. All of those things were going on as well. They
00:20:42 were all subject to the same restrictions, but only one group was targeted. So there's a real
00:20:45 rule of a law issue here in Saskatchewan as well. There's a part of this that I find particularly
00:20:50 insidious. Now, I think any restriction on freedom to protest is a very serious thing, but it's
00:20:57 especially concerning when government puts a policy in place that innately and directly
00:21:03 prohibits protest of that policy. Because you're basically saying that you should not be allowed to
00:21:09 express legally your displeasure with the very thing that we're using to prevent you from doing
00:21:13 it. Absolutely. And that's why the courts are there. That is why under the Canadian Charter
00:21:21 rights and freedoms it's a fundamental freedom to peacefully assemble and express publicly in this
00:21:28 very powerful medium your opposition to government action and when we see in this case the courts
00:21:34 repeatedly uh using deference to the government for this kind of direct prohibition uh it is
00:21:43 shocking and it's very much a concern and to be honest andrew the the courts in canada on the
00:21:48 issue of COVID restrictions have really failed to earn Canadians' trust. And when they say, look,
00:21:56 just quoting from the decision itself, it's like, even if the differential treatment between
00:22:00 unstructured outdoor gatherings and retail settings could not be justified on an entirely
00:22:05 public health rationale, which is an understatement, the court says, well, that's not
00:22:09 really determinative of whether it's justified because the government has deference to, quote,
00:22:14 preserve economic activity and other social benefits and so in other words if the government
00:22:19 chooses to violate your rights and allow economic activity which is more risky to go forward
00:22:23 the courts are right now saying we're fine to turn a blind eye to that yeah i wanted to take
00:22:28 a bigger picture look at this i mentioned in the preamble the bc case this week and i i don't think
00:22:33 you were engaged in that case but i i'm sure you followed this in other similar ones and you're
00:22:38 right when you say that there's been this overwhelming attitude of deference and i i'm
00:22:43 really hard-pressed to come up with any wins i mean obviously the the federal court uh did shut
00:22:47 down the emergencies act which was a positive i think decision emanating from that era but that
00:22:53 wasn't actually a coveted restriction or a coveted policy the emergencies act was problematic for
00:22:57 other reasons i mean where have been the wins on anything else coveted related well yeah and i mean
00:23:03 actually we were involved there in the vc cases and with the medical health workers and there's
00:23:08 there is a small win there of course uh we do have an order from the court saying dr henry now must
00:23:15 reconsider this prohibition of uh virtual workers they should be hired back uh so there's there's
00:23:23 something there to laugh but that's the way is that maybe maybe just maybe it's not reasonable
00:23:29 to force people who work from home to get a vaccine that that's about that's about as low
00:23:33 a bar as we get in canada right and we've we've now found the courts this is the first time as
00:23:38 i'm aware of a court actually being willing to essentially say that we've seen some arbiters
00:23:42 yeah the canada post uh arbitration said something very similar this week there uh when it comes to
00:23:47 covert restrictions of course we filed a case in bc against the ban on outdoor protests the
00:23:52 government actually conceded that violation and then in alberta we struck down uh the restrictions
00:23:57 on the covert restrictions on the basis not of the charter but on the basis they are illegally
00:24:01 issues by Dr. Dina Hinshaw rather than what they were in fact the cabinet regulations and so
00:24:07 the when the winds come uh they're far and few between on the covert restrictions themselves of
00:24:12 course we've had many victories at trial many dropped charges but on the charter merits themselves
00:24:18 the courts have really let Canadians down to this point the supreme court has yet to weigh in
00:24:23 uh we have seen the Taylor case from Newfoundland recently being granted leave it's hard to say
00:24:29 whether the Supreme Court is going to get to the merits of COVID or whether they're going to get
00:24:32 to this issue of mootness where we've seen courts refuse to even consider COVID restrictions because
00:24:37 oh well that was in the past Andrew. So that's a live issue in the Taylor case and maybe the
00:24:42 court will get past the mootness issue and get to the merits we're not sure but it's a possibility
00:24:47 that here this protest restriction case from Saskatchewan would also be seeking lead from
00:24:52 the Supreme Court. The Supreme Court's been rather not too generous in granting lead to appeal but
00:24:57 But it does, I think, behoove the courts to fight back and actually seek to regain Canadians' trust.
00:25:05 Because the courts are the ones under the Charter through Section 1 that are there to defend Canadians' fundamental rights and freedoms.
00:25:13 And when they fail to do that, they lose Canadians' trust.
00:25:15 And I think we've seen that significantly in Canada and a lot more discussion of, well, maybe if the courts are losing Canadians' trust,
00:25:22 it's going to fall to the legislatures to now be the defenders of people fundamental rights and
00:25:27 freedoms and if the courts agree or not uh politicians are going to have more latitude
00:25:31 to regard or disregard court decisions yes i've got a long-standing frustration with with mootness
00:25:38 which conveniently allows governments to uh skirt accountability and then do the same thing again
00:25:43 elsewhere and i mean i would not being a lawyer but i would point out if the government uses this
00:25:47 that uh the government at every opportunity talks about the need to prepare for the next pandemic so
00:25:52 They clearly are aware of the fact that this could replicate itself in some form.
00:25:58 So absolutely, having on record the actually you can't do this would be would be very important.
00:26:03 Although, as we've been discussing, in fact, the government may end up having on the record a permission slip.
00:26:09 Right. And this is where Canadians really need to.
00:26:12 Obviously, we're going to continue to press these matters through the courts.
00:26:14 But Canadians can also press their politicians.
00:26:17 But the current Saskatchewan government is the government that put these measures in place.
00:26:21 What is that government going to do to promise its citizens to say, look, we're not going to be so unscientific and, quite frankly, just completely ignoring common sense on these issues in the future?
00:26:33 What restrictions is the government going to put on itself to ensure that itself or a subsequent government will not be violating Canadians' rights with such impunity?
00:26:42 Legislatures are, you know, for example, in Alberta are making some changes in that regard.
00:26:46 Public health acts need to be changed.
00:26:48 This idea that the government can, based simply on a potential line of reasoning, however tortured, to restrict your fundamental rights and freedoms, well, why should we allow that?
00:27:01 We can obviously press this through the courts.
00:27:03 I think legislatures have a job to do on this as well.
00:27:07 Marty Moore, always good to get your legal analysis and chat with you in general.
00:27:12 Thank you for coming on, sir.
00:27:13 We'll see you soon.
00:27:15 Thanks for having me, Andrew.
00:27:16 All right. Yeah. The JCCF's Big George Jonas Freedom Award dinners are coming up. So I think
00:27:20 I'll be at the one in, definitely I'll be at the one in Toronto. I think I'll be at the one in
00:27:24 Calgary as well. So we will hopefully catch up with Marty at at least one of those and maybe
00:27:28 some of you as well. I know many of you are supporters of that organization and its work.
00:27:33 One thing that I will say just before moving on here, which I think is crucially important to
00:27:37 point out is that, yes, you need to look at all of the mechanisms available to you. Use the legal
00:27:43 tools and use the political tools. But this is where I get very pessimistic, because let's look
00:27:48 at the post-pandemic electoral record. We have had a handful of elections in the last few years,
00:27:54 and they have revealed that Canadians are willing to give further mandates to the people responsible
00:28:01 for some of these policies. Justin Trudeau re-elected in 2021 with effectively the same
00:28:06 size of government that he had going into that election. Doug Ford in 2022 re-elected.
00:28:12 uh danielle smith is the one exception and that was a case of the internal mechanism the leadership
00:28:18 uh process in the united conservative party getting rid of jason kenney apart from that
00:28:23 in manitoba yes the pc government lost and was replaced by the ndp but that really wasn't a
00:28:28 rebuke of the manitoba the former manitoba government's handling of covid so at pretty
00:28:34 much every opportunity when canadians have been able to vote out a government that violated their
00:28:40 civil liberties, they have in fact reelected it, or they've, in the case of Manitoba, voted it out
00:28:45 without really dealing with that issue. So yes, I think Canadians need to wake up. If we talk about
00:28:51 politics as being downstream of culture, it's exactly why we need to keep having these
00:28:55 conversations like we are now. But tell your friends too, I never let anyone tell you that
00:29:00 a Christmas dinner should be banned or something, because when government drives that wedge
00:29:04 between your ability to assemble, they're doing exactly what we were talking about in Saskatchewan
00:29:09 there which is making it so you can't find that you aren't alone and you can't find there are
00:29:12 other people like you that think this is all bonkers and you certainly can't get together in
00:29:16 a group and wave your signs and placards and stand outside a hall of government and say no
00:29:20 so when governments prohibit you from doing that there's a big big problem and you should just
00:29:24 protest on principle because they don't want you to so with that being said let's talk about another
00:29:31 issue where certainly the legal issues have not been solved by the court so we perhaps have to
00:29:37 look for political solutions and health care is a tremendous example of that health care choice
00:29:43 it's not really something we have universally available to Canadians if you are in Quebec you
00:29:48 have that option because the Supreme Court has decided you do but only in Quebec not if you live
00:29:53 in another province certainly not in British Columbia we view health care rightfully so as
00:29:59 a provincial issue but there was a piece from Colin Craig who's the president of secondstreet.org
00:30:05 that says we need to put some of the blame on federal gatekeepers as well. He says we should
00:30:10 demand healthcare choice from federal political leaders. Colin Craig joins me now. Always good
00:30:16 to talk to you, Colin. So yeah, let's just explain the basics here. Why is this an issue that is
00:30:21 federal? Well, it's a reality that the federal government gives provincial governments billions
00:30:28 of dollars every single year for health care. It is a minority position. So when you go to a
00:30:35 hospital and you get care or you visit your family doctor, the bulk of the bill is paid for by the
00:30:42 provincial government using tax dollars. But they still receive a decent portion. I don't know the
00:30:48 exact percentage offhand, but they still receive a decent enough portion that they certainly want
00:30:54 keep ottawa happy because they don't want to lose those dollars and so uh sometimes when provincial
00:30:59 governments go to do things that ottawa doesn't like they threaten or they actually come in with
00:31:03 funding cuts in terms of how much they're giving for health care so that's how ottawa is tied into
00:31:08 this and it's done through the canada health act which is basically a funding mechanism
00:31:13 in terms of how ottawa agrees to give provincial governments money for health care so one of the
00:31:19 the things that I find just so baffling here, and again, we just had Marty Moore on to do the legal
00:31:24 stuff, so you and I don't have to go down the legal road, but the Supreme Court has said, yeah,
00:31:28 access to a wait list is not access to healthcare. They've said that you should have the right if you
00:31:33 have the means available to go and do something else. They've just said this is the case only in
00:31:36 one province alone. You know, it would arguably be more of an easy pill to swallow if they had
00:31:43 said no across the board. But in this case, someone in British Columbia can't go to the
00:31:47 can be clinic but someone in Quebec can go wherever they want to go yeah and just make a
00:31:52 distinction for your listeners because this can get a bit confusing sometimes and what people
00:31:57 don't always pick up on is that it's getting private or non-government care locally this is
00:32:04 the sticking point as a Calgarian if I need a hip operation I cannot pay in Calgary or anywhere else
00:32:11 in Alberta. I can't fly to British Columbia and pay to get one there. I can fly to certainly
00:32:17 Quebec and other provinces. So you actually have the same problem in BC. Someone in Vancouver
00:32:24 cannot pay at a private clinic in Vancouver. They can in Calgary. So you see this happening
00:32:30 where people- And it's the same doctors that could have just served the person in their own
00:32:35 province if legal yeah it's it's crazy no other country on the planet does what canada does in
00:32:42 this regard it makes no sense in terms of cost you're increasing cost for patients you're
00:32:47 inconveniencing them at a time that usually this is the last thing they need if you've got chronic
00:32:52 pain because they're waiting uh for hip operation like last thing you want to do is jump on an 0.78
00:32:56 airplane and go somewhere else to get it done so it makes no sense at all uh you know if if you're
00:33:03 federal government i would point out it's bad for the environment right to force people to have to
00:33:07 travel even further to get the care that you need but i certainly wouldn't criticize any patient for
00:33:12 doing what they can to improve the health of their bodies when you talk about this in level-headed
00:33:19 terms you know i think wow you know this is easy why isn't every canadian getting on board with
00:33:23 this but you bring it into the public realm certainly if a politician were to ever say
00:33:27 what you're saying and as just passionate and mild-mannered away they're going to have the
00:33:31 activists jumping, saying they're privatizing health care, American health care. You're going
00:33:35 to be no longer served. If you don't have money, people are going to go broke. You have all of
00:33:40 these doom and gloom scenarios, which how do you push back against that? I mean, how do you tell
00:33:45 people that actually, no, it increases care for everyone? Yeah. So, I mean, that's really the
00:33:51 debate that dominated 20, 30 years ago. And this is why we didn't see any changes back then. The
00:33:58 public has shifted and in credit to groups that were around before us and certainly we've been
00:34:04 talking about it for several years now but reality is there's not two systems on the planet it's not
00:34:09 just canada or the us there are lots of countries that have universal systems like canada norway
00:34:16 sweden france you know throughout the european union australia new zealand and uh you know many
00:34:24 many reports show that they're doing better than canada and the key difference is that they give
00:34:28 patients the choice between using their public systems or using non-government options whether
00:34:35 it's a non-profit clinic a private clinic whatever patients have that choice we don't typically have
00:34:40 that choice as we've just discussed in canada so i think more and more canadians understand that
00:34:45 they're on board with it the polls show that a large majority of canadians understand that
00:34:51 that throwing money at the system is not the solution.
00:34:54 We spend a lot of money on healthcare in this country.
00:34:57 That's not the problem.
00:34:59 The problem is that we don't get good results
00:35:00 because of the structure of the system.
00:35:03 And giving patients choice,
00:35:05 it helps take pressure off of the public system.
00:35:09 My bet is if we did that across the country,
00:35:11 made it easier,
00:35:12 the vast majority of people would still use the public system
00:35:15 and that's fine.
00:35:16 But you'd probably have maybe around 10, 15%
00:35:19 that would use non-government options.
00:35:22 I mean, that's kind of been the Swedish experience.
00:35:25 And who wouldn't want to take 10 or 15% of pressure
00:35:29 off of our healthcare system right now?
00:35:31 It'd be a significant benefit.
00:35:34 And combined with other reforms,
00:35:35 we could ultimately deliver better care for patients.
00:35:40 But the response you get to that is what happens
00:35:42 if 10% or 15% of the doctors decide to leave the public system
00:35:46 and go to the private system?
00:35:47 you've not really helped anything and what's the answer to that yeah i'm glad you raised that
00:35:51 because a lot of people raise that point and and what i always respond with is well how does sweden
00:35:56 do it how does norway do it how does australia do it i mean all these other countries that perform
00:36:01 better than canada they have found a way to do it and and often the solution is that they will cap
00:36:07 in the united kingdom for example they cap how much time some in the public system can work in
00:36:12 in the private system. The second thing to keep in mind is that when you have more employers,
00:36:18 you end up with more employees. This is something that the Swedes told us when we were in their
00:36:23 country last year talking with people about healthcare. And I thought this is a great way
00:36:27 of explaining it. Because when you have a more vibrant healthcare sector, you have more choices
00:36:33 for people in the healthcare sector in terms of where they want to work. Right now in Canada,
00:36:37 you often have doctors and nurses graduating, and they look around, and often the option is,
00:36:44 well, I work in the government system, or I go somewhere else. Well, if they had more choices
00:36:50 in Canada, then we could retain more doctors, we could retain more nurses, we wouldn't have the 0.99
00:36:54 shortages that we have right now. And I know it's not perfectly analogous, but I would also say that
00:37:00 we could look at the education system. It's another regulated professional designation to be a
00:37:04 teacher. We have private schools. We have not seen this mass exodus of public school teachers to
00:37:10 private schools because we also forget that people are motivated by different things. People that go
00:37:14 into healthcare are motivated by different things. You may really want to be in a hospital, in a
00:37:18 family medicine practice, and you'll stay in the system because it offers you something.
00:37:23 Yeah, I mean, I love that example. We've used it too, Andrew, because it's such a good comparison.
00:37:28 You, across Canada, we have choices for parents. You can put your kids in the government-run system
00:37:34 or you can pay for a private school, independent school, whatever. And the vast majority of
00:37:40 Canadians still choose the public system and that's totally fine. But when those do decide,
00:37:44 some parents decide on private options, again, they're taking pressure off of those public
00:37:49 school systems. The point about choice for workers is important. Here's a crazy number
00:37:56 that we were able to calculate using some data from the state of Michigan is that there's nearly
00:38:02 2,000 nurses who live in Ontario and get up each day for work and they cross the border into
00:38:09 Michigan, primarily working in the Detroit area. Like that is huge. And we talked to them,
00:38:16 we surveyed them, we said, well, why are you doing this? And the number one reason it actually
00:38:20 wasn't compensation. It was the availability of work. They had the types of work, like positions
00:38:27 that they wanted but the second reason was compensation and right behind it was working
00:38:33 conditions and many of them noted that they could get these jobs in uh michigan they were the way
00:38:40 that they wanted them they had uh they were full-time came with benefits they came with um
00:38:47 a predictable schedule i mean you you had a competitive environment in michigan where they
00:38:52 They were having employers competing to attract these workers and finding ways to give them
00:38:59 the type of work arrangements that they wanted.
00:39:02 Whereas in Ontario, they were looking at it and they're looking at the government system
00:39:05 and saying, no, I just don't want to work there.
00:39:08 And this has been a problem for a long time.
00:39:10 You can't blame the current government.
00:39:11 You can't blame even, I don't think, the former government, because it's the problem when
00:39:16 you have this monopolistic environment.
00:39:18 to be honest i i wonder why i i should i i understand why but if you really think about it
00:39:27 it's quite surprising provinces haven't seen the opportunity in this because if you're a provincial
00:39:31 government and you can come up with a pitch that you can make to voters which is you will not pay
00:39:37 more in taxes you will not have any reduction in your care but you will have this added option
00:39:42 and at the very least even if you can't afford to use it there will be fewer people on the wait
00:39:47 list ahead of you in the public system to get it because you know two or three of those folks will
00:39:51 go to the system you've actually eased the health care crisis without having to spend a dollar and
00:39:58 i really don't know why provincial governments have not been the ones to take the lead and call
00:40:02 for that they're uh they're concerned about funding cutbacks from ottawa and but to bring
00:40:08 the fight to ottawa let us do it i mean we see provinces on drug decriminalization saying not
00:40:13 not as much anymore, but saying, hey, give us the right to do this. They could do the same
00:40:19 thing provincially if they wanted to expend the political capital doing so. They could. I think
00:40:24 it would be wise for patients for them to do this. And the easiest, I think, argument they can make
00:40:30 going into Ottawa is, look, Ottawa, you're allowing Quebec to do this. Quebecers get more healthcare
00:40:36 rights than anyone else in the country. We need to even the playing field and give all Canadians
00:40:41 the same rights that Quebecers have. I think that's the argument that needs to be made if
00:40:45 you're in BC, Alberta, wherever. I mean, the BC government obviously isn't going to make that
00:40:50 argument, but certainly others could in Ontario. You know, Doug Ford could stand up and make that
00:40:56 argument. We don't really look at this through a partisan lens, but the bottom line is it would
00:41:01 help patients. And it makes sense for elected officials to do it. The public is behind them.
00:41:08 this is like say this isn't the debate from 20 years ago the public has heard they've seen
00:41:12 governments do the same tired old approach of throwing money at the system hoping something's
00:41:17 going to work it hasn't worked it's failed it's time to start looking at what these countries
00:41:23 that perform better than canada what they do and then we can start copying them and bring our
00:41:28 standards up and this is one thing among several changes that could be made to improve results for
00:41:35 patience. Colin, Craig, always good to talk to you from SecondStreet.org. Thanks so much for coming
00:41:40 on today. Thanks for having me, Andrew. All right, thank you. Well, that does it for us for today. I've
00:41:46 been plugging it all week, so just to keep the whole set intact, let me tell you here what we
00:41:51 have coming up in a couple of weeks. I'm going on a book tour. We are launching the release of
00:41:57 my biography. You can see it back there. Well, you can't anymore, but you could see it back there.
00:42:00 Pierre Polyev, A Political Life, a biography that has had a fair bit of media interest.
00:42:05 We'll be doing a launch event in Calgary on Wednesday, May 29th at the Ranchman's Club.
00:42:11 Ooh, fancy.
00:42:12 Going to Toronto at the Albany Club May 30th, and that is going to be at 4 p.m.
00:42:17 That is at the Albany Club, and we're going to do something in Ottawa, I think, June 5th.
00:42:21 We're still finalizing those details, but you can get tickets,
00:42:24 of which there are only a limited number left at modernmiraclenetwork.org
00:42:31 slash Lawton, modernmiraclenetwork.org slash Lawton.
00:42:35 And I hope to see you out there, get your copy.
00:42:37 And I'll sign it if you want.
00:42:38 It reduces the value, though, considerably if I sign it.
00:42:41 But nevertheless, you have that option available to you.
00:42:45 I'm going to be back tomorrow for Off the Record,
00:42:48 which we'll be doing with a couple of cast of characters from True North.
00:42:52 Next week, I am going to be away and I'll be giving you updates.
00:42:56 I'm going to be in Taiwan.
00:42:58 We have been invited by the Taiwanese government and part of the trip will be there for the
00:43:03 presidential inauguration, which should be quite fun.
00:43:06 I'm banned from covering government events in Canada, but I'm getting like nice invitations
00:43:10 to government events in Taiwan.
00:43:12 So take from that what you will.
00:43:13 But as we look at this country being a bulwark for freedom and democracy and a resistance
00:43:20 against China.
00:43:22 It is incredibly important.
00:43:23 I'm glad to be able to go
00:43:24 and I'll have some updates
00:43:26 sent back for you.
00:43:27 But you will be in good hands
00:43:28 because our good friend Chris Sims
00:43:30 is going to be guest hosting
00:43:32 next week from Tuesday to Thursday
00:43:34 because we've got the holiday Monday.
00:43:36 So I trust you will greet her
00:43:38 with the enthusiasm
00:43:39 that I greet her
00:43:40 when she's on every Monday.
00:43:41 But Chris Sims will be filling my shoes,
00:43:44 my novelty size shoes
00:43:45 as a guest host next week.
00:43:47 And then I'll be back
00:43:48 in a couple of weeks time.
00:43:49 But all that being said,
00:43:50 thank you so much for tuning in, everyone. We'll talk to you soon. Thank you. God bless and good
00:43:54 day to you all. Thanks for listening to the Andrew Vaughn Show. Support the program by donating to
00:44:00 True North at www.tnc.news.
00:44:20 We'll be right back.