Juno News - August 09, 2023


Opposing Trudeau's immigration target isn't racist

Topics
Mentioned
Is Justin Trudeau trolling us with Barbie photo op? This is RUINING Canada and nobody is trying to solve it

Episode Stats


Length

47 minutes

Words per minute

165.18

Word count

7,778

Sentence count

352

Harmful content

Misogyny

6

sentences flagged

Toxicity

2

sentences flagged

Hate speech

16

sentences flagged


Summary

Summaries generated with gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ .

In this episode of Canada's Most Irreverent Talk Show, Andrew Lawton talks about the growing problem of immigration in Canada, and why it's become the third rail of Canadian politics. He also talks about why immigration matters, and what it means for the future of Canada.

Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Topics generated with Qwen2.5-3B-Instruct.
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 Transcription by CastingWords
00:00:30 Thank you.
00:01:00 Welcome to Canada's Most Irreverent Talk Show.
00:01:21 This is The Andrew Lawton Show, brought to you by True North.
00:01:25 Hello and welcome to you all.
00:01:30 This is another edition of Canada's Most Irreverent Talk Show here on True North.
00:01:35 I had an email a few moments ago from Dolores asking which home renovation woe I'll be sharing with you today.
00:01:43 I don't actually think she was mocking me.
00:01:45 I think she was actually being quite supportive.
00:01:47 Yesterday I was talking, it wasn't really a home renovation woe.
00:01:50 It was more just a general home ownership woe I was talking about yesterday.
00:01:55 with just having been suckered into spending money on a rented water.
00:01:59 I'm doing it again. I'm talking about the water heater.
00:02:01 No, I've got the water heater. It's installed. It's working.
00:02:04 The water is piping hot, like I hope the ratings of this show are.
00:02:09 They won't be if I talk only about water heaters, so we'll move on from that.
00:02:12 But I do thank you for all of you who have written in and shared your own similar stories.
00:02:19 It was actually a somewhat pertinent topic for a lot of people.
00:02:21 So anyway, one thing I want to talk about on this show, and I'll get to it very shortly, is that True North, it seems like, has finally been blocked by Facebook.
00:02:33 We have been, according to most people, now not all, there are some folks who, for whatever reason, have still been able to navigate to our page.
00:02:40 But for the most part, our content is no longer available to Canadians.
00:02:44 I can't see it on my own account.
00:02:45 we can post it but for the majority of canadians certainly those not using a vpn you can no longer
00:02:53 see true north on facebook and this is easy to blame facebook for but it's actually the fault
00:02:59 of the liberal government and it's internet regulation bill c18 so we'll get to that a
00:03:04 little bit later on in the show and talk about the implications of that but i want to begin
00:03:09 by discussing immigration now this is actually if you go back into the annals of true north history
00:03:15 Immigration is really the reason there is a True North. 0.99
00:03:18 My friend and colleague, Candace Malcolm, saw that there was just this massive issue that was tremendously relevant
00:03:25 and had all sorts of policy failures stemming from it in the federal government's eyes.
00:03:32 And no one was talking about it in the media.
00:03:34 So she actually started this organization, which was originally intended to be a think tank on immigration issues.
00:03:41 And from there, the story of how True North blossomed and bloomed is a long and very positive one.
00:03:48 But ultimately speaking, immigration is an issue that matters a lot,
00:03:51 and it's become the third rail, the third rail of Canadian politics,
00:03:56 where even Conservatives oftentimes get sucked into the very same outlook
00:04:01 and very same approach as the Liberals, or a marginally better one.
00:04:05 Now, Stephen Harper and the Conservatives were very pro-immigration.
00:04:09 There's a reason that they had such a tremendous showing in the 2011 election in the greater Toronto area.
00:04:16 It was because they had done a lot to build inroads within ethnic communities.
00:04:20 And a lot of that was spearheaded by Jason Kenney, who was Harper's longtime immigration minister.
00:04:26 But even Harper's pro-immigration policy and politics was always constrained by economic and cultural realities.
00:04:34 And that was, I think, a very key difference between the conservative approach to immigration, which was pro-immigration, and the liberal approach, which is very much pro-immigration, but in a much more virtue-signaling way.
00:04:49 Now, as it stands, Justin Trudeau has made a very bold and audacious commitment that every year he is going to ratchet up immigration into Canada even more to the point where by 2025 we have 500,000 immigrants coming in every year as PRs, basically economic immigrants and also some family reunification.
00:05:10 Now, that is a low ball if you take into consideration other sources of immigration,
00:05:18 like, for example, asylum seekers, who we know are continuing to increase in number in Canada,
00:05:25 and also some temporary foreign workers, students who are not coming here through the PR stream,
00:05:31 but are nonetheless entrants into Canada.
00:05:33 So there have been some estimates that have said annual entry is closer to a million,
00:05:39 although not all of those are permanent.
00:05:41 Now, all of that aside,
00:05:42 500,000 a year is a number that sounds nice to the Liberals.
00:05:47 It's a number of which they can be proud,
00:05:49 of which all of us as Canadians are supposed to be proud.
00:05:54 And I want to just talk about the way Statistics Canada,
00:05:56 which is supposed to be a neutral arbiter of facts and numbers and stats,
00:06:01 the way Statistics Canada views this.
00:06:04 Now, they published this piece regarding the previous census information in which they talked about the immigrants making up largest share of the population in over 150 years and continue to shape who we are as Canadians.
00:06:21 Now, that's a very weird analysis, but the premise of this is that we have the largest ever share of the Canadian population that is immigrants now than ever before.
00:06:32 22.3% was the previous 19-21 record, now it is 23%, and that number is expected to increase by 2041 to 34% of the population.
00:06:44 So in about 17, 18 years, more than one-third of the Canadian population will be immigrants.
00:06:53 Now, when you look at population growth, Canadians are not having children.
00:06:58 The Canadian fertility rate is abysmal.
00:07:00 It is not at replacement rate.
00:07:02 So 75% of Canada's population growth is coming from immigrants, not from people having children.
00:07:11 Now, a lot of people would look at this number and say, so what?
00:07:14 What does it matter? And I take a view that is far away from this whole like great replacement fear that some evil sinister forces are trying to reshape the image and make, you know, Canadians, the old stock Canadians, as they are derisively called by Justin Trudeau yesterday's news.
00:07:30 No, I think what's happening here is you have two things. You have people that want to come to Canada because they see in Canada something valuable that they want for themselves and their families.
00:07:40 And then you have people that see in Canada a blank slate on which they can project whatever
00:07:45 they want to bring from their country, from their culture, from their civilization.
00:07:50 And it's that latter category that can cause issues.
00:07:54 It's that latter category that has caused so many problems in places like Germany and
00:07:59 Sweden and the United Kingdom and Ireland.
00:08:02 It's that category of people that do not wish to, the word that you're not supposed to say,
00:08:06 But I will say that people who do not wish to assimilate into a particular society, but wish to bring the best of both worlds in their view, or maybe it's the worst of both worlds, into a home that offers a slightly better economic opportunity than wherever it is from which they've come.
00:08:22 And this is why immigration is an issue that we need to talk about.
00:08:26 And it's why we should be able to have it in a dispassionate way that focuses on the stats.
00:08:32 And to go back to that Statistics Canada piece here, that line that they include as a bit of a boast is actually quite important here, that immigrants continue to shape who we are as Canadians.
00:08:43 So by design, by the government's design, immigration is not meant to be about selling the Canadian experience to people that do not have that experience and do not have that hope and that path forward in their own countries.
00:08:58 It is by design about remaking Canada and reshaping Canada
00:09:04 based on the fabric of the immigrants that we bring into this country.
00:09:09 Now, some people may bring tremendous work ethic.
00:09:12 They may bring a tremendous devotion and dedication to their family.
00:09:16 But we are fooling ourselves if we think there are not other people
00:09:19 that are bringing things that are far less desirable here,
00:09:21 such as a contempt for equal rights, a contempt for women's rights,
00:09:25 a contempt for gay rights.
00:09:27 And as a country, we should be able to talk about that.
00:09:30 We should be able to talk about the social fabric of this nation
00:09:33 when you have such a large and ambitious view of what immigration is supposed to be,
00:09:40 which to the liberals is $500,000 a year as a minimum.
00:09:45 But again, the government brags about the number itself.
00:09:48 And I want to show another government press release here.
00:09:51 Not that I am in the business of just parroting whatever the government wants to tell you,
00:09:55 but I think it's actually worth pointing out.
00:09:57 This is a press release from the Government of Canada
00:10:00 through Immigration, Refugees and Citizenship Canada
00:10:03 that was issued January 3rd, 2023.
00:10:07 Canada welcomes historic number of newcomers in 2022.
00:10:13 The first paragraph here,
00:10:15 Canada has experienced one of the fastest recoveries
00:10:17 from the pandemic,
00:10:19 thanks in large part to our approach to immigration.
00:10:21 Newcomers enrich our communities
00:10:23 and contribute to our economy
00:10:25 by working, creating jobs, and supporting local businesses, recognizing their value.
00:10:31 The government of Canada planned to welcome 431,000 new permanent residents in 2022.
00:10:38 Now, if you look at the numbers a bit further, you see that Canada is, as a general rule,
00:10:45 proud to be the number one acceptor of immigrants as a percentage of population in the G7.
00:10:51 This has been Canada's value added to the world, that we take more immigrants than anybody else 1.00
00:10:57 in the world. This is what Justin Trudeau thinks Canada does better. This is what he believes is
00:11:02 our comparative advantage. Is it working that way? I don't actually think so. And one example,
00:11:08 which is not about culture, it's not about religion, it's not about equal rights, it's not
00:11:12 about any of that. It is purely economic because the government believes that the sales pitch for
00:11:17 immigration is that it enriches and enhances our economy. And there is good reason for that
00:11:21 in some cases, because we do have a labor shortage. We do have immigrants that are happy to come here
00:11:27 and bring a work ethic that makes it so they are all too willing to do a job that perhaps a Canadian
00:11:32 does not want to do. But we also have to house the people that come here. When immigrants come 1.00
00:11:38 to Canada, overwhelmingly, they're flocking to cities that are already very densely populated.
00:11:43 They don't want to go to Moose Jaw, Saskatchewan. And there is an exception here when we're talking
00:11:48 about temporary foreign workers,
00:11:50 but they're not part of the $500,000 figure
00:11:52 that the government is striving towards.
00:11:54 So when people are coming,
00:11:56 they're going to the cities
00:11:57 that already have very high ethnic communities.
00:11:59 They're going to Vancouver,
00:12:00 they're going to Toronto,
00:12:02 in some cases to Montreal.
00:12:04 And the reason those cities
00:12:05 are dealing with such a housing crunch
00:12:07 is because they have more people available
00:12:09 than they have houses available.
00:12:12 And this is just simple supply and demand.
00:12:14 You don't even need to have passed
00:12:15 an economics class to understand that.
00:12:18 We already have a housing crisis in Canada.
00:12:22 Adding 1.5 million new permanent residents in three years
00:12:26 strikes me as a bit of a problem
00:12:28 if you already have millions of Canadians
00:12:30 who would love to buy a home but cannot afford to.
00:12:34 Now, a poll done shows that Canadians are more aware of this problem
00:12:38 than the federal government is.
00:12:40 Canadians actually get this, believe it or not.
00:12:43 A piece that was done by Bloomberg
00:12:45 and polling that was done by Abacus Data
00:12:47 show that 68% of Canadians think that Canada's immigration targets are making things more
00:12:54 unaffordable or less affordable when it comes to housing. That is two-thirds of Canadians.
00:13:00 This is not a racial concern, as is always blamed when people raise an issue with Canada's
00:13:06 immigration numbers. No, this is an economic concern. People who maybe are unable to afford
00:13:11 a house themselves or have children that can't actually buy a home are seeing, okay, you know
00:13:16 what? Maybe 1.5 million. I actually don't care if we bring in this woman from Italy or that guy 0.97
00:13:22 from Sudan or that nice happy couple from Afghanistan. I'm fine with them, but I also
00:13:29 can't afford a house as it is. So maybe we just shouldn't bring in anyone and it has nothing to 0.99
00:13:34 do with country or skin color or religion. And this is an entirely non-racist and legitimate
00:13:40 objection to immigration that the federal government is not interested in and that a lot
00:13:45 of the researchers, the academics, the generally speaking intelligentsia types or self-professed
00:13:52 intelligentsia types refuse to acknowledge.
00:13:55 For example, there was a study that was done by some obnoxious researcher in Canada.
00:14:00 I can't even remember the name of the study, but it doesn't matter.
00:14:03 It was aiming at the so-called far right of Canada.
00:14:06 And they named True North in this along with other outlets.
00:14:09 And they use as an example of being so-called far-right the concerns about uncontrolled migration,
00:14:16 as though it is far-right and perhaps even racist to talk about the issues of uncontrolled migration
00:14:22 when any country, even the most liberal and progressive, has some form of control on migration.
00:14:28 I mean, even the 500,000 figure that the liberals want involves putting a cap in place at that 500,000.
00:14:35 But we know that in Canada, that number is just a fancy virtue signaling number, like, for example, net zero by 2035 is. And the government will get so focused on the quota, they stop looking at the quality and the rigorous vetting that is necessary for a functional and secure immigration system.
00:14:56 And I'm suspicious that they're going to get to, oh, I don't know, the third quarter and find, oh, wow, we haven't actually gotten three quarters of the way to 500,000 yet.
00:15:04 So let's just open the floodgates because we need to hit that number.
00:15:07 We need to put out the press release that talks about how welcoming we are as a country.
00:15:13 But let's just drill down for a moment here on the math on this, on the economics, because the government says that the only way we can fill the labor shortage is through immigration.
00:15:22 Okay, there's some basis for immigrants being necessary to filling up the workforce when there are vacancies.
00:15:29 But the government is claiming that there's not actually going to be a housing issue
00:15:33 because when we have more immigrants, we'll be building more houses.
00:15:37 That's the argument they're putting forward.
00:15:39 And it's one that didn't quite add up to my colleague, Cosman Georgia, host of The Daily Brief,
00:15:44 and a fantastic investigative journalist at True North who joins me now.
00:15:48 Cosman, thanks for coming on the show here.
00:15:51 What do you make of this here?
00:15:52 Where is the government getting this idea from that houses will just be built a dime a dozen once we open the floodgates on immigration? 0.80
00:16:01 I think it's preposterous, and in my piece I call it a myth.
00:16:06 It doesn't really make sense that immigrants are going to come to Canada and suddenly start building houses. 0.77
00:16:12 When you look at the statistics last month, Statistics Canada released the labor survey, and it found that 45,000 construction jobs were lost. The month before that, it was about 16,000. So it really doesn't add up. Where are these immigrants that are building houses?
00:16:31 yeah it's a valid question and i know and you and i spoke about this a little on the the daily brief
00:16:38 yesterday a lot of them go into the service sector and we know there are vacancies in that sector i
00:16:44 mean we've all had issues where you try to get your coffee poured and it takes you know like 25
00:16:49 minutes or something because no one's working at whatever the local cafe is and yeah that's a thing
00:16:54 that happens but these are jobs that are very low paying jobs they're not a job that you're ever
00:16:59 going to be able to build a house with a salary on typically in cities like toronto or vancouver
00:17:03 especially whereas construction jobs pay considerably well and you can actually do
00:17:08 very well with this so why is this not happening has there been any research done into this has
00:17:13 there been any effort to get people into that track because that's an area where we desperately
00:17:18 need labor in canada yeah no i don't think there's been much research when i looked at the statistics
00:17:25 from 2019, it shows that the most popular jobs for immigrants are service jobs, healthcare jobs,
00:17:33 bureaucratic jobs. They're not necessarily coming here building the infrastructure
00:17:38 that we need to sustain such high levels of immigration. They're all going to high density 1.00
00:17:44 areas. You mentioned this earlier. And with that comes a host of problems like increases in rent,
00:17:50 increases in the price of housing, increases in the price of goods. Also, high-density areas
00:17:56 generally have higher rates of crime. We see this happening in Toronto and Vancouver and other
00:18:03 major cities. So what solutions are the Liberal government proposing? None, really. What Mark
00:18:11 Miller said last week was that he wants to increase the number of immigrants. He's proposing
00:18:16 to actually make it even higher than the 1 million target every two years we have right now.
00:18:23 Yet we know that there's not enough houses being built. So I'm not sure. I don't think they even
00:18:30 have a solution to the housing crisis. And a part of me thinks that there's a cynical
00:18:35 sort of desire to keep the housing prices high. Yeah. And I'm wondering, I want to drill down
00:18:43 on that point with you in a second, but I would also add here that this is not an issue of saying,
00:18:48 oh, immigrants are making things difficult for native-born Canadians, because immigrants are 1.00
00:18:52 making it difficult for other immigrants. And I don't mean that in a way that is blaming them
00:18:56 individually, but it also means that people that are coming to Canada in two years are dealing with
00:19:02 what I'd say is a bill of goods that's been sold to them that's not really here, that you can have
00:19:07 this economic fortune in Canada when they come here and find that the immigrants that came in 1.00
00:19:12 a year and two years before them are still looking for homes as well and there's nothing left for them
00:19:19 no you're absolutely right and i immigrated here with my family in 2003 and back then in kitchener
00:19:26 where we lived you could rent a three-bedroom apartment for about a thousand dollars a month
00:19:32 and that let my parents get the necessary accreditation and the the training they
00:19:37 needed to to enter the professional workforce while they were doing you know cleaning jobs
00:19:43 and watching the kids so i don't think that that is an opportunity that is present to many uh new
00:19:49 immigrants anymore they have to get full-time jobs uh both parents usually and then they're left
00:19:56 stuck in a position that they didn't see themselves being in in the first place so i think
00:20:02 these uh high levels of um immigration targets we're actually cheapening the immigration
00:20:08 experience we're making it worse for the new immigrants and as a country we should pride
00:20:14 ourselves on on providing a flourishing and positive experience when we come to canada
00:20:20 so making it worse is simply not the solution cosmon georgia host of the daily brief and
00:20:27 investigative journalist here at True North.
00:20:30 Thanks so much, Cosman.
00:20:31 Thank you.
00:20:32 And you can check out his piece at True North
00:20:34 on this very subject.
00:20:35 Canada lost 45,000 construction jobs.
00:20:38 Where are the immigrant home builders? 1.00
00:20:41 And again, I mean, you can make that same criticism
00:20:43 about people born in Canada.
00:20:44 Why are none of them going into construction?
00:20:46 And you can also make the same criticism of Canadians
00:20:49 about why are they, why are we not having children?
00:20:52 These are our legitimate questions
00:20:53 that we should not shy away from as a country and as a society and I will point out here that the
00:21:01 conservatives have often not been particularly strong on this now I last week maybe it was two
00:21:07 weeks ago I think it was two weeks ago yeah I asked Pierre Polyev about this at a press conference
00:21:12 now this was before this polling came out which showed how two-thirds of Canadians think that
00:21:18 housing is being driven even more out of reach because of immigration. It was before that.
00:21:23 But I asked him about the 500,000 target. And this was that exchange. And I'm not going to
00:21:28 give you a preface, a huge preface, because I actually want you to formulate your own thought.
00:21:35 Apparently, we went a bit prematurely there. Let's just roll the clip.
00:21:40 Good afternoon, Mr. Polyev. My question is on immigration. As you know, Canada is on track to
00:21:46 have about 500,000 new immigrants to the country by 2025. And I'm wondering if you think this is
00:21:55 sustainable and if a Conservative government led by you would continue that trend and would
00:22:01 be satisfied with that 500,000 a year number. Justin Trudeau has broken our immigration system.
00:22:08 We see this on the streets of Toronto, where refugees are living on the pavement. 0.98
00:22:16 It wasn't like this eight years ago.
00:22:19 When refugees came to Canada, we had them sponsored by charities, churches, mosques, synagogues, other non-profits,
00:22:25 to give them homes, help them write resumes, and get them fast work permits so they could get jobs and paychecks.
00:22:32 We see it in the new movement online of immigrants who are saying they're going back
00:22:39 because they can't afford to live here in Canada.
00:22:42 After eight years of Trudeau, many immigrants feel like they're better off where they came from
00:22:48 because the costs and the crime that Trudeau's policies have unleashed
00:22:53 make this country unlivable for newcomers and for those who have been here a long time. 1.00
00:23:00 I want to get back to common sense immigration. 0.99
00:23:03 The numbers should be driven by the number of employers who have job vacancies that they cannot fill with Canadians,
00:23:11 by the number of charities that want to sponsor refugees,
00:23:17 and by the families that can reunite and support their loved ones here,
00:23:21 not by egotistical targets that are designed to give Justin Trudeau a vanity project.
00:23:30 We need to get back to competent immigration. 1.00
00:23:33 By the way, we need to expand housing construction.
00:23:36 It's all well and good to think that you can increase the population by a million people in a year.
00:23:43 But where are we going to house everybody?
00:23:45 we now have last year we built fewer homes than we built in 1972 think about that in 1972 our
00:23:55 population was 22 million and we built 250,000 homes last year our population was 40 million
00:24:03 and we built 219,000 homes so we have nearly double the population and we're building fewer
00:24:10 homes. Is it any wonder why we have a homelessness crisis, why 9 in 10 young
00:24:16 people believe they'll never be able to afford a home, why we have 70
00:24:20 year old nurses who are living in vans. After eight years of Justin Trudeau's
00:24:25 total incompetence on everything from immigration to housing to health care,
00:24:30 our country is falling to pieces. I will put it back together with common sense
00:24:35 immigration, common-sense health care, common-sense housing policies that get things built. Thank you.
00:24:45 I forget where he was. I think he might have been in Timmins when I asked that question,
00:24:50 although that matters. It was just he was doing a press conference and I zoomed in. And the
00:24:54 answer was a lengthy one, but I wanted you to see it and hear it in full because there was a fair
00:25:01 bit of Rorschach-ing going on on Twitter after that exchange. It wasn't really an exchange because I
00:25:07 didn't get a follow-up. And by Rorschach-ing, I mean, if you're not familiar with it, this idea
00:25:11 where you look at an inkblot and you describe what you see, but there's nothing there. So whatever
00:25:16 you see has been just plucked from your brain. And that people who love the Conservatives saw
00:25:20 that interview and said, wow, that's a sensible, measured, common sense approach to immigration.
00:25:25 And people who don't like Paul Yev, whether they're PPC supporters or just leftists, were
00:25:30 saying, oh, he didn't answer the question, he dodged, he weaseled out. I actually didn't hear
00:25:36 an answer to the direct part of the question the first time I listened, because I had asked
00:25:41 500,000 yes or no was essentially my question. But when I re-listened later, and he says that
00:25:49 part there about how the number should be driven by, he still was sidestepping the very specific
00:25:54 question of, is 500,000 sustainable? But he was giving a hint, I think, a hint that the
00:26:00 Conservatives would have a smaller number. But I would also say, if that's your belief,
00:26:06 come right out and say it. Explain why it's unsustainable. Explain why it's a problem.
00:26:11 But the Conservatives are always, no matter how different a leader might be from his or her
00:26:16 predecessors, the Conservatives are always constrained by the media or the way they think
00:26:21 the media is going to respond and if anyone comes out and gives a thoughtful reason nuanced answer
00:26:27 of well Canadians are not actually convinced that these high immigration numbers are working
00:26:33 and if Canadians are dissatisfied then it will cause them to turn on immigration in general which
00:26:39 is not healthy for a country and we know that housing is out of reach and if we bring in 1.5
00:26:43 million people over three years that's going to further strain housing so I would say perhaps
00:26:48 maybe we should pare back from $500,000.
00:26:50 If you say that, the headline is going to be
00:26:54 Conservatives hate immigrants.
00:26:56 Exaggerating?
00:26:57 Yeah, only a little bit.
00:26:58 That's going to be the takeaway.
00:27:00 That's going to be how any concern raised
00:27:02 about Canada's immigration system,
00:27:04 even if it is purely done in fact-based,
00:27:08 numbers-based ways, is going to be painted.
00:27:12 You may recall a few months ago,
00:27:14 I shared a story and I wrote an op-ed in my sub stack.
00:27:17 Well, I guess I didn't write an op-ed. I just wrote a substack. And I was discussing this really odd and difficult encounter I had with a rather left-wing personality in the Canadian media orbit. And I was really pessimistic about the idea of breaking through our differences.
00:27:34 And one of the things that came up when I was speaking with this person is that I gave two very reasonable conservative positions that are pretty widespread within the right in Canada.
00:27:44 I said, one, that vaccine should not be mandatory.
00:27:48 Two, that Canada should not increase immigration every year automatically.
00:27:53 And I asked this person, what do you think about those two statements?
00:27:56 And this person told me that both were wrong because on the immigration side, this individual said that it would be racist because there is no non-racist reason to oppose immigration.
00:28:11 And you probably think that I'm making this up because it's so absurd, but I'm probably being even more generous than this person deserved based on that interaction.
00:28:23 But this is legitimately how people in the media, certainly those who are of a left-wing orientation, believe conservatives to be on immigration, that if they oppose unqualified increases of immigration, like the kind that you don't see anywhere else in the developed world, in any other G7 country, even Germany, even Germany, which kind of learned its lesson after 2015.
00:28:44 so when canada is going beyond anywhere else these people are still saying well yeah but if
00:28:52 you say no you're a racist and that's why and you know the year of that 2015 increase this was
00:28:58 i believe 1 million into a population of at the time 80 million that was a lower percentage of
00:29:05 the population than what canada has proposed and has put into effect so anything that happened in
00:29:11 Germany could very easily happen in Canada. That's the point that I was trying to make then, 0.66
00:29:15 and it's especially acute now because the government has decided to double and triple
00:29:20 down on that, and we should be able to have this conversation, and it's a shame that in this media
00:29:25 climate we cannot. And speaking of the media, I believe it is important to point out here what
00:29:31 has happened to True North. Now, True North, as I discussed earlier, is an outlet that has a six-year
00:29:37 almost, history in this country, and it's grown tremendously. We used to be, I don't want to say
00:29:42 entirely, but virtually entirely on Facebook in terms of where our audience was. Now, that is no
00:29:49 longer the case, and thank goodness, because as of this morning, this was the message that awaited me
00:29:54 when I logged on to the True North Facebook page. No posts available, and I said, okay, well,
00:30:00 have I been fired? Have I been blocked? Have we just decided to go nuclear and hit the kill switch
00:30:06 and delete all our content no we were posting and we continue to post and this show right now
00:30:10 is posting on Facebook and I think like how many people are watching on Facebook right now I think
00:30:14 like 30 people or so because those are the ones that I guess are using VPNs or something oh we
00:30:19 got 60 we got 60 on Facebook so if you're one of the 60 people watching this on Facebook right now
00:30:25 consider yourselves lucky you've evaded the news ban at least for the time being but this happened
00:30:32 And we knew it was coming, so I couldn't act all shocked, but it was still this very upsetting moment because I realized and was reminded of just how surreal it is that we live in a country in which the federal government has decided to extort from tech companies, to extort tech companies to pay off the legacy media.
00:30:51 And I say the legacy media because they were the ones demanding the money.
00:30:55 They were the ones who jumped up and said, stop stealing our content.
00:30:59 Friends of CBC, which is this really bizarre organization that stands to support CBC for
00:31:05 reasons unclear, they ran a poster campaign not long ago. You can see one of their posters here
00:31:10 that Mark Zuckerberg is wanted, that he is wanted for the theft of news content. So this is the
00:31:18 type of unhinged rhetoric you get from these people that Facebook is stealing, Mark Zuckerberg's
00:31:24 a pirate, and that all of their content that they voluntarily and willingly put on social
00:31:28 media has been stolen from them, in fact. And of course, the social media companies turned around
00:31:33 and said when the government extorted them, OK, we'll just make it so that this no longer applies
00:31:37 to us. We'll stop disseminating news. You think we're stealing? Great. We're going to stop
00:31:41 stealing. Problem solved. And Facebook has made good on its threat. And while I have so many
00:31:46 issues, which I've shared relentlessly and continuously with big tech companies, on this,
00:31:52 I am on their side because they are forced to make a decision by government fiat, by government
00:31:58 policy. They did not want to ban this content. They just didn't want to pay for it. And why
00:32:02 should they? Because it's not their content and they never asked for it. They didn't want it.
00:32:07 So the legacy media outlets, places like CBC and Post Media and the Toronto Star and the Globe and
00:32:14 Mail and all of these groups under the auspices of the National News Media Council, they say we
00:32:19 want money. True North never asked for any money from Facebook or the government. We've never
00:32:25 demanded any of this and if I could and I talked about this with my colleague William Macbeth last
00:32:30 week if I had my choice and I could just flip a switch on Facebook and say I hereby cede any claim
00:32:37 for C18 revenue in exchange for being able to post and share our content with Canadians if it
00:32:43 were my choice I would check that box in a heartbeat because this was not our fight but
00:32:48 true north is a casualty of this fight which the legacy media has waged against big tech in which
00:32:55 the government has decided to take up on the side of the legacy media and this is the government
00:33:02 the liberal government extorting big tech to prop up an industry which is in decline which has not
00:33:09 reinvented itself the way that independent media outlets have to have a viable business model
00:33:14 in this climate there's a reason that true north and rebel and canadaland and other independent
00:33:22 outlets not just on the right i mentioned canadaland for a reason the reason that we are
00:33:26 growing well places like bell are shuttering radio stations is because we have come up with
00:33:33 a business model that lets us deliver our content in a stripped down way without a lot of the bells
00:33:38 and whistles but a way that lets us communicate directly with canadians now social media
00:33:43 has played a critical and pivotal role in that.
00:33:48 Will we survive C-18?
00:33:51 Yes, because we have to.
00:33:52 We have no other choice.
00:33:54 But is it going to be easy?
00:33:56 No.
00:33:57 And the reason I had William on last week
00:34:00 is because it was important for me to talk to you,
00:34:03 all of you, about ways you can avoid this.
00:34:05 Up until this morning and last night, I guess,
00:34:08 most people can access True North with relative ease.
00:34:10 there were some isolated examples of people getting blocked and whatnot but we were able
00:34:15 to keep posting now that does not appear to be the case anymore facebook does not appear to be
00:34:20 backing down they have signaled a permanent withdrawal from the market now they haven't
00:34:24 taken us offline no one can do that well i shouldn't say no one justin trudeau probably
00:34:28 wants to but we are still online we still have our website we still have our youtube page we
00:34:33 still have our x account which is not a weird low budget porn site but it is twitter now
00:34:38 and we have ultimately a number of ways
00:34:42 that we are trying to communicate with Canadians
00:34:44 but there is no better way
00:34:45 than if you come to us directly.
00:34:48 Cut out the middleman.
00:34:49 Don't allow our content and the delivery of it
00:34:53 to be beholden to any company,
00:34:55 be it Facebook or otherwise.
00:34:56 Go to our website, tnc.news.
00:34:59 Go to subscribe.
00:35:01 There is a button on there that you'll see
00:35:02 to subscribe to our mailing list
00:35:04 so we can communicate with you directly.
00:35:07 And listen, when I say this, I know we all get so many emails.
00:35:11 I get it, and it bothers me too.
00:35:14 But right now, it is the number one vehicle,
00:35:17 the number one vehicle that we can use and that you can use
00:35:20 so that we are not going to let them win.
00:35:23 Because they are trying to shut us down.
00:35:25 Whether it's intentional or whether we're just casualties of war,
00:35:30 I'll leave for you to decide.
00:35:31 But they are trying to shut independent media down,
00:35:34 and that is what C18 is doing.
00:35:36 and we cannot let them win.
00:35:37 My commitment to you is that we will not let them win,
00:35:40 but it means that we need to engage directly.
00:35:43 And that is what we are going to commit to do.
00:35:44 And I hope you can commit to doing that as well.
00:35:47 And I bring this up and ask about the legacy media
00:35:51 because the question is not entirely about business model.
00:35:54 Sometimes it's just about content
00:35:56 and the type of content they offer.
00:35:58 I mean, without $1.3 billion of taxpayer money a year,
00:36:01 for example, you might never learn
00:36:03 about the troubles of being non-binary in 2023.
00:36:08 Yeah, let's take a look at this piece on CBC today.
00:36:11 This was a first-person piece
00:36:13 that was written by an individual.
00:36:17 I can't even say a person, an individual named Julia.
00:36:22 Now, Julia has a woman's name 1.00
00:36:24 and Julia looks like a woman and dresses like a woman
00:36:28 and is completely and utterly feminine.
00:36:32 But oh, no, no, no.
00:36:33 it is offensive if we view Julia as a woman. As the headline of the piece says there,
00:36:39 I shouldn't have to look non-binary for my identity to be respected. I like my feminine
00:36:45 name and wearing the occasional dress, but that doesn't define me. Julia goes by they, them pronouns.
00:36:51 And if you don't realize that when you encounter they, them in the halls of McGill University, 0.99
00:36:56 you are just a dirty hating bigot. So again, without CBC and the legacy media, how would we 0.94
00:37:02 ever learn about the plight of the non-binary at McGill University. This is exactly what we're
00:37:08 dealing with there. And this story as well, I've said oftentimes that the laziest form of journalism
00:37:14 is the reaction stories where a journalist will just like scroll through Twitter and find three
00:37:19 people who've tweeted something and claim that there's some national broad trend. But sometimes
00:37:24 you can get this really multi-layered exercise where we're going just in all these different
00:37:30 directions and really going to like those little Russian dolls that I forget the names of that have
00:37:36 all the different like ones inside each other to get the reaction story to the reaction story to
00:37:40 the reaction story and that's what we have from Global News. Global News has run this piece so
00:37:46 just for context here you remember Justin Trudeau went to the Barbie movie with his son Xavier and
00:37:50 they were sporting their pink shirts although I think we determined yesterday Justin Trudeau's
00:37:55 was more coral than pink. But nevertheless, they were sporting their pink-ish attire and enjoying
00:38:00 the Barbie movie as a father and son are wont to do. And there were reactions to this, including
00:38:06 from Piers Morgan. So then the Toronto Star and other Canadian outlets ran the reaction to Piers
00:38:12 Morgan reacting to Justin Trudeau. And then we have this story from Global News, which I find to
00:38:19 be absolutely hilarious here that it is a reaction to pierce morgan reacting to justin trudeau and
00:38:28 the reaction comes from the mayor of kitchener ontario now uh no disrespect to kitchener i've
00:38:33 driven through it many times i know my colleague cosman uh is from kitchener originally but i don't
00:38:39 exactly care what the mayor of kitchener thinks about politics on an average daily basis unless
00:38:44 we're talking about kitchener politics but uh barry uh rabinovich uh tweets at pierce morgan
00:38:51 i was raised if i didn't say have something nice to say it's better not to say anything at all
00:38:56 perhaps you can go and repeat that lesson born uh yada yada yada he goes on anyway the reason
00:39:02 i bring that up is because global news writes this that the mayor of kitchener fires back
00:39:07 at pierce morgan for pot shot on justin trudeau social media post so now we have to get someone
00:39:13 to react to the mayor of...
00:39:14 Well, actually, no, I'm doing that.
00:39:15 I'm reacting to the mayor of Kitchener.
00:39:17 So now someone else can write about Andrew Lawton
00:39:20 reacting to the mayor of Kitchener,
00:39:21 reacting to Piers Morgan,
00:39:23 reacting to Justin Trudeau,
00:39:25 reacting to Margot Robbie.
00:39:27 It'll be so great.
00:39:28 We'll just get like 19 reactions in one
00:39:31 and we'll go like around the world.
00:39:32 It's like the old Six Degrees of Kevin Bacon,
00:39:34 the six reactions to Justin Trudeau.
00:39:37 But this is what the legacy media is doing.
00:39:40 My goodness.
00:39:41 Just on the Barbie note here, I mentioned on yesterday's show that I didn't really care
00:39:47 what movies Justin Trudeau sees as Prime Minister.
00:39:50 I thought he was trying to troll people, and I am now convinced that I was right, because 0.93
00:39:55 this is the tweet that Justin Trudeau put up yesterday with him and his daughter taking
00:40:01 in a movie.
00:40:02 That is his daughter, Ella, and the movie that they are seeing is not Barbie, but it
00:40:07 is Oppenheimer.
00:40:08 Now, Jen Gerson, as I shared with you yesterday, had that rather astute tweet that all she wants is a world leader who's going to see Oppenheimer.
00:40:15 She got her wish there.
00:40:16 Some people might wonder why this grand cinephile has all this time for seeing movies when he's supposed to be running the country.
00:40:24 It is kind of interesting here because he is doing the opposite of what you'd expect.
00:40:30 Because the expectation people would have is that, oh, his daughter would rather see the Barbie movie and the son would rather see the Oppenheimer movie.
00:40:36 and it's almost as though they're trying to just make this very brand oriented decision
00:40:41 as part of their quest for privacy to like put the child with the movie that is going to make the
00:40:49 stereotype shattering point that the liberals want to make i don't know what movie he's going
00:40:54 to see with his other son like maybe that kid gets screwed out of seeing a movie at all because
00:40:58 they've covered off barbie and oppenheimer already is there anything else in theaters that's worth
00:41:02 seeing actually i don't think there has been for like 20 years so mission impossible sean
00:41:06 writes, no, he can't bring his son to see Mission Impossible, Sean, because that would just be too
00:41:11 on the nose that a young boy might like Mission Impossible. He has to bring his son to see
00:41:16 something else entirely. So whatever the next sort of traditionally girly-ish movie might be,
00:41:22 because that's how we have to do it. I mean, I hope the daughter liked Oppenheimer and I hope
00:41:26 she wasn't just dragged there to make the point that girls can like Oppenheimer and guys can like
00:41:31 Barbie. But you know what? In the inauthenticity of politics, it wouldn't surprise me in the least.
00:41:36 That does it for us today with one exception here.
00:41:39 I want to show you this little video here because you may recall that being in a movie theater for much of the last three years was illegal because the theaters were shut down under COVID protocols.
00:41:50 Now, when the world reopened, it meant that life could go back to normal.
00:41:54 Well, some people just aren't all that comfortable with normal.
00:41:59 But I'm pleased to tell you, if you happen to be in the Portland, Oregon area, there is a way that you can see Barbie in a completely safe, sterile environment.
00:42:09 COVID free. Take a look.
00:42:13 I don't remember the last time I went to see a movie because I don't love going to the movie theater.
00:42:18 But I'll tell you what, it pisses me off that I can't go see Barbie.
00:42:22 I want to go see it, even if it is white feminism. 1.00
00:42:25 I want to be able to go.
00:42:26 So I'm doing a thing.
00:42:27 and if you live in the pacific northwest you can do a thing with me here's what it is next week
00:42:33 which is july 31st august 1st someday next week on a weekday i am renting out a theater in
00:42:40 northwest portland the entire theater the whole theater um the theater seats 46 people i think
00:42:48 we're only going to do 20 tickets so me and 19 other people that's it um in addition to that
00:42:55 there will be one employee so the entire building the entire cinema is going to be one employee
00:43:00 plus 20 attendees that's it um we are the only people in the building and every single person
00:43:06 including that employee is going to be wearing an n95 the entire time the employee is going to put
00:43:12 it on before they enter the building they've been chosen specifically for this purpose they seem to
00:43:17 get it um if you show up because you bought a ticket i need to see a kn94 well fitted or a 95
00:43:24 well-fitted or a P100 and if I see a baggy mask I'm going to tell you to take it off and put on
00:43:30 one that I hand you. I'm holding onto a bunch of masks. Choose the one you like best. There are no
00:43:36 concessions during the movie. They're not even going to open it up. Do not bother bringing food
00:43:40 or drinks. You may not take your mask off in the movie. If you need to scratch your nose or you
00:43:45 need to take a sip of water you need to get up, exit the theater, do that, and then come back.
00:43:54 It is a risk. I don't know how else to put that. It is definitely a risk to be in a building for
00:44:00 two hours. Makes me anxious. But I feel like it's a measured risk and one I'm willing to take. And
00:44:07 if there are more cautions that we could take, definitely let me know.
00:44:11 i'm just give me a second on this one i've seen this like five times now and i still
00:44:24 cannot get through it with a straight face okay so
00:44:28 we're going to see barbie she's not like left the house in four years or something 0.99
00:44:36 she really really really wants to see barbie because a movie which is supposed to be about 0.96
00:44:41 entertainment offers the opportunity for fun. And what's more fun than renting out a theater
00:44:47 in the morning before it opens, capping it to 20 people, banning concessions, making everyone wear
00:44:56 an N95 mask, and like chastising anyone if they dare want a sip of water or to scratch their nose.
00:45:04 And after all that, we still get the warning of I'm anxious about the risk. So here's my question
00:45:10 for you who would you rather see barbie with that woman or justin trudeau let me leave you with that 0.99
00:45:17 as we head out here my thanks to you all this is canada's most irreverent talk show we'll be back
00:45:21 on friday here on true north thank you god bless and good day to you all thanks for listening to
00:45:28 the andrew lawton show support the program by donating to true north at www.tnc.news
00:45:35 We'll be right back.
00:46:05 We'll be right back.
00:46:35 Thank you.