Juno News - October 18, 2022


Phantom honking, microaggression, and government incompetence: Emergencies Act hearings are underway

Guests
Mentioned
Phantom honking and "microaggressions" - Highlights from week 1 of the Emergencies Act inquiry LAWTON: The right to protest no longer exists

Episode Stats


Length

40 minutes

Words per minute

166.47

Word count

6,674

Sentence count

251

Harmful content

Misogyny

1

sentences flagged

Toxicity

2

sentences flagged


Summary

Summaries generated with gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ .

The Public Order Emergency Commission is currently in its fourth day of hearings, and Mayor Jim Watson has testified about the use of the Emergency Order Provisions Act by police in response to a "protester" protest in the streets of downtown Ottawa. Andrew Lawton is joined by Adam Blake Gallupo, a lawyer with the Democracy Fund, to discuss the evidence presented so far, and whether or not the act was justified.

Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 Welcome to Canada's Most Irreverent Talk Show.
00:00:05 This is The Andrew Lawton Show, brought to you by True North.
00:00:12 Hello and welcome to you all.
00:00:15 This is Canada's Most Irreverent Talk Show.
00:00:17 You're tuned in to The Andrew Lawton Show here on True North.
00:00:21 It is Tuesday, October 18th, just after 4 o'clock Eastern Time here.
00:00:27 and I thank you so much for tuning into the program today.
00:00:30 I want to talk for pretty much the entirety of the show
00:00:34 about the Public Order Emergency Commission,
00:00:36 which right now is underway in Ottawa.
00:00:40 And all day we've been hearing from Ottawa Mayor Jim Watson,
00:00:43 who's been testifying about a number of things,
00:00:46 which we'll get to.
00:00:47 We've got lots of clips.
00:00:48 Last week we heard about the horror that is phantom honking
00:00:52 and microaggressions,
00:00:54 which I don't think are spelled out as justification for the Emergencies Act.
00:00:59 I may have to reread the act, but I actually don't think those are part and parcel of it here.
00:01:03 But I want to talk about some of the micro details that have come out here
00:01:07 and also some of the bigger picture discussions and what it is that's really at stake.
00:01:12 And I want to get right into the thick of it here.
00:01:14 I'm joined by Adam Blake-Gallupo, who is a lawyer with the Democracy Fund,
00:01:20 which you will actually be hearing from and have already heard from in the course of these hearings
00:01:25 Adam good to talk to you thank you very much for coming on today
00:01:28 thank you very much for having me Andrew it's great to be here let's just start right out of
00:01:35 the gate with a bit of a housekeeping note here what is the democracy fund's role in these hearings
00:01:41 and before the commission yeah so um yeah good question so we we share standing uh right now
00:01:49 uh with the jccf and another organization um so we we are not uh we are not we don't have full uh
00:01:58 uh party status uh as as many of the other you know ben miller uh is is convoy coalition has
00:02:05 um however we we do have a significant role here and uh as as we were discussing just before this
00:02:11 started um mr alan honor our litigation director was just cross-examining uh mayor watson um so
00:02:19 So it's a privilege to be part of this, but we're here to seek answers with respect to the invocation of the act, just like everybody else is, and I'm certain all of your viewers are as well.
00:02:36 the level of detail that we're coming getting out of this and I should note seven weeks of
00:02:43 hearings we're on day four right now some of the detail has been very granular which you want but
00:02:48 a lot of it I also feel is very extraneous I mean the fundamental question that this commission is
00:02:55 by statute supposed to assess is whether the use of the emergencies act was justified now I know
00:03:01 the liberal government has on top of that heaped through an order in council a number of other
00:03:05 goals for the commission, like to investigate the source of funding and investigate the convoy
00:03:10 itself. But, but really the key question here is, was the emergencies act justified? And a lot of
00:03:16 the testimony, correct me if I'm wrong, doesn't really seem to answer that question or contribute
00:03:21 to an answer. No, you're, yeah, I, I, yeah, I, I, I completely agree with your, your assessment
00:03:28 there, Andrew. The evidence that we've seen so far, I mean, since evidence has been
00:03:35 presented which has just been what as of today two days uh in total uh has has been uh replete
00:03:42 with hearsay and uh and and sort of redundance i mean we haven't you know and and like you said
00:03:50 at the outset we're only on uh what is this day four so there's a lot to come um but as it stands
00:03:58 i mean we we don't have anything uh we can really sink our teeth into at this point i think
00:04:03 the most significant uh sort of telling features that the uh that have transpired to date uh have
00:04:11 been in the opening statements uh to be frank elaborate on that what statements particularly
00:04:18 did you feel were really noteworthy sure well okay so so i yeah i i you know i'll admit that um
00:04:28 You know, going into this, I assume there's going to be roughly speaking two sides, right?
00:04:34 You're going to have the sort of civil liberties oriented sides with JCCF, obviously ourselves, the protesters, and then the other side, which would include the government entities.
00:04:48 And I'm including the police as part of that group, right?
00:04:53 The competing sides are, you know, lawful invocation of the act versus, no, no, this act was unlawfully invoked in this context.
00:05:03 That's not what we're seeing.
00:05:05 What we're seeing is, and, you know, I'm the first to admit that I was kind of blindsided by this.
00:05:12 We're seeing the police and sort of government branches entering into a more nuanced discussion through their cross-examination and their sort of trajectory and cross-examination has been such that they're seeking to preserve their reputations, right?
00:05:35 Which, of course, hindsight's 20-20, of course, this is something that they would be looking to do, right?
00:05:41 Right. Especially you've got a representative for for chief slowly, you know, in attendance
00:05:48 as well. So so reputation is something that is on the table that, you know, I probably
00:05:54 should have foreseen, but but admittedly didn't. So now and of course, when you've got reputation
00:05:59 on the table and there's arguments with respect to, OK, well, did ops do enough in this particular
00:06:04 context, you've got competing arguments. And if ops didn't do enough, or if they did, let's say,
00:06:13 well, then somebody dropped the ball over here. So the reputational argument turns into,
00:06:20 or sort of rather, is at odds with other interests of other government entities,
00:06:27 if I'm making sense. Yeah, you are. And I would point out, I sort of
00:06:32 saw something similar because it's sometimes more revealing than what the witnesses are saying even
00:06:37 to look at the questions that various lawyers are asking. And when you look at, for example,
00:06:43 Peter Slowly's lawyer coming up to question the Ottawa Police Service, it's almost comical how
00:06:48 transparent his agenda is or questioning Jim Watson, because, you know, the question that
00:06:53 he's asked of like pretty much every witness, it's, would you agree that your interactions with,
00:06:57 you know, Chief Slowly were always professional and that he was always great and he's a nice guy? 0.73
00:07:00 So there is a little bit of arse covering by various divisions of this.
00:07:06 And interestingly enough, though, that may be very revealing for people, but I still 0.66
00:07:11 don't think that gets to that fundamental question of was there a national emergency
00:07:15 at stake here?
00:07:17 And I want to put to you and those listening the text of Section 3 in the Emergencies Act,
00:07:23 that for the purposes of this act, a national emergency is an urgent and critical situation
00:07:27 of a temporary nature that seriously endangers the lives, health, or safety of Canadians
00:07:32 and is of such proportions or nature as to exceed the capacity or authority of a province to deal
00:07:38 with it or seriously threatens the ability of the government of Canada to preserve the sovereignty,
00:07:44 security, and territorial integrity of Canada and that cannot effectively be dealt with under
00:07:51 any other law of Canada. And I think that's one of the critical parts of this year.
00:07:55 If you look at governments that are unable to solve this problem, that police not being able to do it by incompetence, does that satisfy that?
00:08:05 If they had the legal means available, but for political reasons, they weren't able to come up with what they needed?
00:08:12 Well, I mean, if you're asking me, no, no, of course it doesn't satisfy that.
00:08:17 I mean, you've got, you know, Windsor is case in point, right?
00:08:21 Windsor, the protesters were, as stated in opening statements, it's a success story according to
00:08:34 police services. And the last of the protesters, to my knowledge, and I can be corrected here,
00:08:41 the last of the protesters were removed on February 13th, which is a day before the
00:08:45 the Emergencies Act was invoked.
00:08:48 So if they were able to successfully remove the trucks
00:08:52 and protesters, you know, that were allegedly blocking
00:08:57 the Ambassador Bridge, we saw the response,
00:09:01 we saw the police response, there was, you know,
00:09:05 sufficient coverage.
00:09:09 Why was it then necessary to invoke the Emergencies Act
00:09:14 situation like ottawa um and and and this is exactly this is exactly to your point so we've
00:09:20 got we've got competing and again this is this this goes back to what what we were talking about
00:09:26 earlier we've got competing interests here we've got uh police services that are saying well look
00:09:30 at windsor windsor um you know was handled uh beautifully there was no uh this is not me saying
00:09:37 this uh this is an opening statements you know windsor is a is isn't sort of uh an ideal situation
00:09:43 everybody was cleared out without the invocation of the emergencies act
00:09:48 so then what sort of needs to be revealed i think uh in order to satisfy uh certainly in your your
00:09:55 viewers and certainly individuals watching this but also this should be uh prevalent on the mind
00:10:00 of the commissioner is why was it not necessary uh in windsor but it is necessary in ottawa and
00:10:08 hopefully uh through the course of the next what we have here five and a half weeks we can we can
00:10:14 get some answers with respect to that question i i just want to for context here put a a clip
00:10:20 forward here this is a clip from your colleague uh alan honor litigation director at the democracy
00:10:27 fund and he puts i think in his opening statement a very fine point on why it is that we are all
00:10:34 here and i want to play that clip for you in the audience now good morning commissioner good
00:10:41 morning everyone my name is alan honor and i am the litigation director for the democracy fund
00:10:47 the democracy fund is a registered charity and a civil liberties organization as you've heard
00:10:54 we're sharing standing with the jccf and with citizens for freedom our interest in this inquiry
00:11:01 arises from our legal work. In February of 2022, we sent lawyers to Ottawa and to Windsor to provide
00:11:09 demonstrators with legal information about their rights when protesting, as well as the limitations
00:11:17 of those rights. Around the same time, we were granted intervener status as a friend of the court
00:11:24 at the Superior Court of Justice in Windsor over the Ambassador Bridge injunction proceeding.
00:11:34 Currently, we represent dozens of persons who have been criminally charged
00:11:38 in relation to the protests at Ottawa, Windsor, and Coutts,
00:11:44 and we represent thousands of others who have been charged under the Quarantine Act
00:11:48 or provincial offenses related to the pandemic.
00:11:53 We've also brought applications before Superior Courts and the Federal Court of Canada,
00:11:59 challenging laws related to the pandemic.
00:12:03 Our objective is to participate in the fact-finding process of this inquiry,
00:12:08 particularly as it relates to uncovering the truth about why the federal government invoked a public order emergency
00:12:16 and how they used their powers.
00:12:19 From our perspective, the government did not meet the requisite legal grounds to invoke a public order emergency
00:12:26 for the same reasons you heard from counsel for the Freedom Corps.
00:12:32 It follows that the extraordinary measures the government invoked were therefore inappropriate and indeed outside their jurisdiction.
00:12:41 Our questions and our submissions will focus on these central issues. Thank you.
00:12:48 So the reason I wanted to bring that up is because what your colleague points out there is that there are a number of fronts for the battles right now underway.
00:12:57 We have Quarantine Act charges. There are criminal charges emerging from the convoy protests.
00:13:02 There are constitutional challenges. There's a parliamentary inquiry.
00:13:05 There's there's this thing here. And I think all of them are important in some way.
00:13:09 But but this, to me, is the simplest of them all.
00:13:13 And it's the most important because really it's it's it's not about there's no section one that can save the government here.
00:13:19 There isn't, you know, a body of case law really behind it.
00:13:24 It's a new law that hasn't really been tested in this forum ever.
00:13:27 And it's a fundamentally simple question, is it not?
00:13:31 I mean, OK, so let's let's unpack that, Andrew, you know, as long as we've got the time here.
00:13:36 So first, upon the invocation of the Emergencies Act, and to be specific, in this case, it's a public order emergency under the Act, the government has to establish on reasonable grounds that a public order emergency exists and necessitates the taking of special temporary measures in dealing with the emergency.
00:14:03 So the situation's got to be, you know, to the point where it cannot be effectively dealt with under any other law in Canada.
00:14:15 So so if we're if we're going to the definition, if we're looking at the if we're going to look at the meat and potatoes of this and we're going to look at the definition here,
00:14:25 The definition of a public order emergency is an emergency that arises from, and so one, threats to the security of Canada, right, and which are so serious as to be a two national emergency, right?
00:14:41 So the threats to the security of Canada is defined under the Canadian Security Intelligence Services Act, okay?
00:14:49 There are four sort of sub points to that, subsections to that definition. Espionage or sabotage is one of them. Foreign influenced activities within or relating to Canada activities that are directed towards or in support of the threat or use of acts of serious violence against persons or property for the purpose of achieving political, religious or ideological objectives.
00:15:19 objectives. And then finally, activities directed toward undermining by covered unlawful acts,
00:15:30 the destruction or overthrow by violence of the constitutionality of the established government
00:15:35 of Canada. Okay. So obviously, you know, what, you know, sort of to sort of summarize, it's
00:15:44 very high it's a very high threshold right um so and and then part two of that was the national
00:15:50 emergency so let's look at the definition of that it is an urgent and critical situation of a
00:15:55 temporary nature that either a seriously endangers the lives health or safety of canadians and is of
00:16:03 such proportions or nature as to exceed the capacity or authority of a province to deal with
00:16:07 it or b seriously threatens the ability of the government of canada preserve to preserve the
00:16:13 sovereignty uh security and territorial integrity of canada right so this is the definition and this
00:16:20 is these are the definitions both need to be satisfied uh by this commission in order to
00:16:25 in order for the commission to arrive at a finding of the act being lawfully invoked in this context
00:16:35 um so that's what we need to keep coming back to this is what i think we need to keep in our minds
00:16:40 when we're viewing this to ask these questions and and and think to ourselves are these being
00:16:46 satisfied is this line of questioning answering and supporting these uh necessities by the by
00:16:56 the legislation as it stands i don't want you to give up any legal strategy here that would
00:17:03 disadvantage you in the future but are you able to give a bit of a sense of what it is that you
00:17:08 you think is really the fundamental narrative here that, uh, people need to understand that
00:17:13 really will support the position that you're laying out? I mean, look, so, um, and, and this
00:17:19 is just coming off of, uh, uh, you know, Alan Hunter's, uh, cross-examination and it seems to
00:17:26 be, I mean, look, we're at day four, so it's, it's, it's, it's tough. Um, but, um, it, it seems
00:17:33 to me as of as of today that there are no uh sort of uh there hasn't been any testimony that has
00:17:43 been a direct observations of any violence and as we heard in the definition of a national emergency
00:17:52 violence is something that that is is a requirement i mean unless i'm misreading this
00:17:58 it's, it's something that, that needs to be sort of present in order for this to be engaged
00:18:07 lawfully. You know, and then, but, you know, the issue obviously there is, is what, what is the
00:18:15 definition of, of, of violence? I mean, we've heard a lot of testimony with respect to microaggressions.
00:18:20 Does that amount to to violence? You know, it's it's so so so, yeah, in any event, it's that that's that's where we're at right now.
00:18:31 I'd be interested to see. And as this plays out, what I'd like to see from this commission is and like to hear from it is whether there are any firsthand reports of violence.
00:18:42 we haven't heard any to date i'd like to know more about uh the seizure of bank accounts um
00:18:48 and and who requested because this is another contentious issue is who requested the emergencies
00:18:53 act be invoked in the first place um i'd like to see more testimony uh specifically in relation to
00:18:58 that um so you know it's um so anyway that's that that's where we're at i i don't think i've uh i
00:19:06 hope i've answered your question you did and i don't think you blew your case in the process so
00:19:11 I appreciate it very much. We'll certainly have you and your colleagues back on as we cover this
00:19:15 over the next six weeks now. Adam Blake Gallupo of the Democracy Fund. And I also, in a moment,
00:19:22 have a clip of your colleague cross-examining Jim Watson as well, which I think speaks to that
00:19:26 very point. Adam, thanks so much for your time and great work on this. Thank you so much for
00:19:30 having me, Andrew. All right. Thanks very much. That is Adam Blake Gallupo from the Democracy
00:19:36 he find now this is fun i haven't actually seen this clip because i was like just about to go on
00:19:41 air and this clip came down the pipeline so i get to react in real time which i never get to do
00:19:46 but as i understand it this is exactly what adam was just talking about in jim watson the mayor of
00:19:52 ottawa again resorting to hearsay talking about violence which no one has actually seen so let's
00:20:00 play this clip from just under an hour ago mayor watson let me just ask you um you told us earlier
00:20:07 today um where evidence came out that um these these protesters they were they were nasty um
00:20:16 they were hateful and they were they were vulgar is that right yes and you said that you saw um
00:20:23 where you said that they had ripped masks off of people yes did you actually see that
00:20:31 no i saw it reported in the media okay and i think you also said that certain people were attacked
00:20:39 is that right uh i didn't say that no i i said that i had death threats but i wasn't physically
00:20:45 attacked no i didn't say that you were attacked but you said that these protesters were attacking
00:20:51 people did you not say that no they were disrupting people's lives that's for sure and they
00:20:58 refused on at least three occasions that i'm aware of that they refused to adhere to the provincial
00:21:04 mandate of wearing a mask when going into a shop or a restaurant so you're not aware of any
00:21:10 incidents of physical violence from the protesters well you'd have to ask the police i know they
00:21:16 arrested a couple hundred people and charged a couple hundred people i don't know what the
00:21:20 charges were so i'm not privy to that information according to your knowledge
00:21:28 you don't know of any so i don't know any of any physical attacks
00:21:34 uh not to my own personal knowledge no all right thank you those are my questions
00:21:42 interesting so it's easy to talk a big game about all the violence on the streets of ottawa about
00:21:48 these protesters going out and just ripping people's masks off and all of that but but
00:21:53 no do you know anything about it yeah no the media got it from the media okay well what about
00:21:57 the physical attacks do you know anything about that well you got to talk to police and i bet
00:22:02 when we have the police witnesses testifying and they're asked the same question they're going to
00:22:05 be like i don't know talk to jim watson it's just like everyone's just pointing at every other
00:22:09 direction for this same as like trying to figure out who invoked the emergencies act is like going
00:22:15 on a fishing expedition because no one actually asked for it no one asked for the emergencies act
00:22:21 it came from the government of Canada and this is something that we saw months ago whenever police
00:22:28 agencies were testifying before parliament before that parliamentary committee that was investigating
00:22:34 we'd find out that the police which Marco Manicino and Justin Trudeau said asked for the emergencies
00:22:40 act couldn't actually find a single police officer that wanted it the rcmp commissioner says no it
00:22:45 wasn't us the opp commissioner says no it wasn't us the ottawa police chiefs all three of them say no
00:22:50 it wasn't us and jim watson i don't know if we have the the clip of jim watson i think we do
00:22:55 jim watson this is from this morning saying that he also did not request the invocation of the
00:23:01 emergencies act now on february 14th we know that the emergencies act was invoked uh were you
00:23:08 consulted on on the invocation of the Emergencies Act before it was invoked?
00:23:13 No, it wasn't. Did the city request that it be invoked? No. Did the city weigh in on
00:23:19 whether it was required, necessary, or needed? Well, when it was released, I think
00:23:24 like most people, very few people knew exactly what the Emergencies Act was, to
00:23:29 be perfectly honest. I remember growing up in Quebec with the War Measures Act
00:23:33 was and the implications that had for the province of Quebec and the rest of
00:23:37 the country but no one had raised the emergencies act with us but when it was invoked and i was
00:23:49 briefed on what its powers were i thought this is a very positive step to getting this situation
00:23:57 resolved once and for all because of the provisions in the act so i very much supported it and i was
00:24:04 As you may recall, the current chair of the police service board, Eli Al Shantir, and I sent a letter to the prime minister thanking him for invoking the act because it actually acted as a catalyst for us to move forward and get that whole situation in the downtown core resolved once and for all and give people their street and their homes back.
00:24:25 so what jim watson said there is that yeah when he learned about it when he found out the government
00:24:31 was already doing it he was supportive of it but he he was like no one's even heard of this thing
00:24:35 before how do we ask for this thing no one had ever heard of which i found quite interesting so
00:24:39 ottawa didn't ask for it yesterday ontario premier doug ford reminded us all which i i don't think
00:24:46 he should be bragging about that he supported the use of it but didn't request it in fact one of the
00:24:52 big sources of or one of the big products of testimony this week is that the Ontario government
00:24:57 was just so disengaged from this process there was this record of a phone call between Justin
00:25:04 Trudeau and Jim Watson during the convoy where they're like they're all just like trashing Doug
00:25:08 Ford for like not wanting to get involved for political reasons so it's actually quite sad
00:25:13 because Doug Ford does this whole buddy buddy routine talking about how great Justin Trudeau
00:25:17 and Chrystia Freeland are and behind his back they're talking about how terrible he is and they
00:25:22 don't like him and don't respect what he's doing. And he's not their ally on this issue, even though
00:25:26 publicly Ford is saying he supports this thing. But we haven't yet found anyone who wanted this
00:25:34 thing and asked for it, who asked the government to do it. So we're left with this idea that the
00:25:40 government was the one that wanted it on its own. The government wanted to do it. And we've been
00:25:46 hearing all sorts of testimony for the last two days. Yesterday was particularly insightful
00:25:51 because we heard from Steve Kanellakis, who's the Ottawa city manager, and also Serge Arpin,
00:25:57 who's the chief of staff to Jim Watson. And they were talking about their negotiations with the
00:26:03 convoy leaders, with the convoy organizers. Negotiations that, by the way, resulted in a
00:26:10 successful agreement to relocate trucks onto Wellington Street away from residential
00:26:16 neighborhoods an agreement we talked about on the show back in february when it came out
00:26:21 and they all said yeah and what we heard this morning and what we heard yesterday most notably
00:26:26 was that it wasn't the convoy protesters that pulled the plug on that agreement what it was
00:26:32 was the parliamentary protective service that didn't like it and then the ottawa police which
00:26:37 moved to an enforcement posture once the emergencies act came into play so they were the
00:26:43 ones that pulled the plug on this deal, not the members of the convoy. And these things are so
00:26:49 critical because right now I have seen no evidence, no evidence of an actual emergency,
00:26:57 no evidence of a bona fide emergency, certainly not one that would justify these unprecedented
00:27:02 powers by the federal government. And we've just been hearing about the effect on the ground in
00:27:07 Ottawa. We haven't even been hearing testimony yet on the bank account freezes. We heard a little
00:27:12 bit from the government in Ottawa about how they really were having trouble getting tow truck
00:27:16 drivers because tow truck drivers were not wanting to tow trucks because they were sympathetic to the
00:27:24 convoy. And I did an interview that you'll see tonight with Ezra Levant at Rebel News, and Ezra
00:27:30 pointed out that the ability to just commandeer a tow truck, which the federal government claimed
00:27:35 it needed the Emergencies Act for, actually exists in the criminal code as it is. So it wasn't even
00:27:41 like needing to just conscript tow truck drivers against their will to get involved was something
00:27:47 that needed the Emergencies Act. It was the bank account freezes. And that's the part we haven't
00:27:52 actually gotten to yet. And the government can try to muddle this as much as they want.
00:27:56 The government can try to make this an inquiry into the convoy. They can try to string up Tamara
00:28:01 Leach. They can try to make this all about the protesters that were fed up with vaccine mandates, 0.98
00:28:06 but they cannot hide from their own role in this. And what they did is decide that the right to
00:28:13 protest no longer exists. The right to peacefully assemble no longer exists. That the government's
00:28:20 refusal to engage with people is supposedly the way you respond to a problem and then you go to
00:28:27 the last resort despite not even having given the courtesy of a conversation along the way.
00:28:32 and I don't know if there's going to be a smoking gun of some kind that shows some wrongdoing by
00:28:39 government that summary I talked to earlier I talked about earlier of the phone call between
00:28:44 Justin Trudeau and Jim Watson it was like a page and a half and there were several lines redacted
00:28:49 including some like mid-sentence where they just start redacting something and you look at that
00:28:54 and you say what is it that they're hiding and maybe it's nothing maybe Jim Watson said something
00:28:58 about its kids in there that is not supposedly for public consumption. But already, you're starting
00:29:05 to see areas where the government is just concealing little bits and pieces. The government
00:29:09 doesn't want there to actually be the accountability that we know is required. Now, I'll tell people,
00:29:14 as much as I don't think the government has a leg to stand on, on this invocation of the
00:29:19 Emergencies Act, I also would be remiss to not point out that this is just one of a number of
00:29:24 battles that is right now underway. Constitutional challenges, criminal cases, numerous, numerous
00:29:31 constitutional challenges, by the way, and not just by people who were charged, but by civil liberties
00:29:36 groups like the Canadian Civil Liberties Association, the Canadian Constitution Foundation,
00:29:42 the Justice Centre for Constitutional Freedoms. The government of Alberta is engaged in that battle
00:29:48 as well. Jason Kenney joined and now Danielle Smith, the Premier, has decided to continue that.
00:29:53 So these are all very important distinctions and discussions here. This is just one particular
00:29:59 battle, but I maintain it's the simplest one and has the clearest question. Was this a national
00:30:06 emergency? Was this a national emergency? Was this something that had espionage and sabotage,
00:30:13 or did it just have phantom honking and microaggressions, which sound comical? It does.
00:30:19 And I mean, laugh at it. It's going to be a long seven weeks. You got to have some fun with it.
00:30:24 But the fact that that was being entertained is an example to me of the attempt by a lot of the
00:30:30 people that applied to appear as witnesses to really muddy the waters here and try to inject
00:30:35 a bunch of extraneous detail that may help paint a picture, but doesn't really help the commissioner
00:30:42 reach that fundamental finding of whether the government's use of the Emergencies Act was
00:30:47 appropriate or whether it was inappropriate? And that's a very simple question. I want to play a
00:30:54 clip from Brendan Miller here. He is the lawyer representing the convoy protesters appearing. He
00:31:00 talks about what the Emergencies Act is actually meant to be used for, and it's not protests with
00:31:06 bouncy castles. Good morning. My name is Brendan Miller of Foster LLP, and I am counsel to Freedom
00:31:14 Corp, which is an organization that represents the protesters of which attended Ottawa in January and
00:31:22 February of 2022. My colleague, Ms. Beth Sheba Vandenberg of Foster LLP is my co-counsel on this
00:31:29 matter, as well as the solicitors of record, both Mr. Keith Wilson, King's counsel, as well as Ms.
00:31:36 Eva Chipiuk, who is counsel to the convoy. With respect to sort of everyone's given an overview
00:31:44 of the theory of their case, it is our view that there was no justification whatsoever to invoke
00:31:52 the Emergencies Act. The Emergencies Act requires several things. One, it could be invoked due to
00:32:00 espionage, and sabotage.
00:32:02 Are you going to hear any evidence
00:32:04 about espionage and sabotage?
00:32:07 The answer to that is no.
00:32:09 Two, it could be invoked on the basis of clandestine
00:32:12 or deceptive foreign influence,
00:32:15 or foreign influence that involves a threat to a person.
00:32:18 Are you going to hear evidence about that?
00:32:19 The answer to that is no.
00:32:22 It also could be invoked on the basis of threats
00:32:24 or use of acts of serious violence
00:32:27 against persons or property.
00:32:29 Are you going to hear evidence of violence against persons or property?
00:32:33 The answer is no.
00:32:36 Lastly, it can also be invoked if there is a group or persons trying to destroy or overthrow by violence the system of government of Canada.
00:32:48 Are you going to hear evidence about individuals trying to do that?
00:32:53 The answer is no.
00:32:54 And the answer is, is that there was no reasonable and probable grounds to invoke the Emergencies Act, and that the government exceeded their jurisdiction, both constitutionally and legislatively, in doing so. Thank you.
00:33:11 I actually have to correct Brendan Miller. Now, I am not a lawyer, but if I were a lawyer, I would call him my learned friend.
00:33:20 My learned friend, I believe, got it wrong.
00:33:22 It's espionage, sabotage, inflatable hot tubs.
00:33:27 Yeah, again, you have to look really, really closely,
00:33:30 but there is a section of the Emergencies Act
00:33:32 that inflatable hot tubs or espionage or sabotage
00:33:37 or threats to the sovereignty and security of Canada.
00:33:39 So I guess when you look really, really closely,
00:33:41 you realize that the convoy doesn't have a leg to stand on.
00:33:44 I am kidding, of course.
00:33:46 You have to say that before you get like the fake news label
00:33:48 appended to anything you do now. Bouncy Castles, not in there. Saunas, not in there. Inflatable
00:33:55 hot tubs, not in there. So right now we're looking at a heavy-handed approach, so heavy-handed,
00:34:01 in fact, that even Paul Champ, who's the lawyer representing the Freedom Convoy
00:34:08 protesters, sorry, not the Freedom Convoy protesters, the residents of Ottawa that say
00:34:13 were put out by this. Even Paul Champ is an opponent of the use of the Emergencies Act.
00:34:21 And I think that's actually quite an important little divide here. And he said that's not his
00:34:26 client's position. Lawyers sometimes take on positions that aren't their own personal views,
00:34:31 not suggesting there's anything wrong about that. But I'm saying that the idea that the
00:34:35 Emergencies Act was wrong is a pretty widespread belief that expands far beyond simple support
00:34:42 for or membership in the Freedom Convoy. And it's an early, early stage here. And I want to stress
00:34:49 this. And when I talked to Keith Wilson last week on the show, he said, sometimes it's going to be
00:34:53 very annoying when you're hearing testimony that is going basically unchallenged because this is
00:35:00 not adversarial. It's meant to be a fact-finding operation. So that is, I think, very critical
00:35:05 here. We're not seeing objections. We're not trying to make people cry on the stand. We're
00:35:09 not doing any of that what they're doing is trying to get a sense of what the truth is
00:35:14 and it's going to be interesting for some people like Tamara Leach and Chris Barber that have not
00:35:19 to this point been able to tell their stories to be able to tell their stories for the first time
00:35:25 and address some of these things but right now we have a protest that by the standards of the
00:35:30 Ottawa police and the city of Ottawa from their early communications was peaceful was always
00:35:36 promised to be peaceful. A little bit disjointed at times, but not actually anything that anyone
00:35:44 in any of these early conversations linked to violence. So the issue that's being raised
00:35:50 is the idea that it turned into what they call an occupation. Now that word is a very tricky one
00:35:58 because even then it does not appear in the Emergencies Act. No one has been able to answer
00:36:04 the question to this point now to be honest no one has even asked the question of when this protest
00:36:09 became illegal jim watson for his part said in his testimony this morning that yeah you know he
00:36:16 thinks this would have been unacceptable even if it lasted a day but he concedes there is a right
00:36:20 to protest well how magnanimous of you mayor watson but even beyond that okay if it would
00:36:26 have been justifiable maybe for a day maybe for two days maybe if it just went through the weekend
00:36:31 at what point would it have become illegal? Two days? Three days? Five days? A week? At what
00:36:40 point is it illegal? And that is such a critical question, so I'm going to ask it again. If the
00:36:46 Freedom Convoy was a legitimate protest for a time and then morphed into something illegal,
00:36:52 at what point did that happen and more importantly, why? Or was it always illegal but our tolerance
00:36:59 is a little bit more flexible for those first couple of days? These are very critical questions
00:37:04 because fundamentally the situation didn't change. The convoy was the same on day 22 as it was on day
00:37:11 one. There were still music. There was still a dance party. There were still trucks. There were
00:37:15 still thousands of people. The makeup of the protest didn't change. It didn't become more
00:37:20 violent. It didn't become more unruly. It didn't become more riotous. It didn't become more
00:37:25 threatening. So if you want to say that this was a peaceful protest at the outset and then became
00:37:31 a national emergency, you actually have to make very clear that you explain to Canadians why
00:37:37 that is the case. And so far, no one has done that. No one in policing has done that. No one
00:37:43 at the federal government, the provincial government, or the municipal government has
00:37:47 done that. At what point did this thing become illegal? I don't think you can answer that because
00:37:53 i'm not sure it ever was we will have another show tomorrow we'll give you the latest of the
00:38:00 public order emergency commission let me know what you think because this is going to be going on
00:38:03 for seven weeks so i don't know if you want every single show to be about this if you want me to do
00:38:09 what i did today would you share some clips share some analysis and share an interview or two with
00:38:14 some of the people involved or if you want me to like just confine this to a 15 20 minute segment
00:38:19 at the end of every show and talk about all these other things.
00:38:22 This is a bit of a test balloon in that sense.
00:38:24 So do let me know in the comments what you think.
00:38:27 And if you are watching on YouTube, we are so, so, so close
00:38:31 to getting to 100,000 subscribers.
00:38:34 So please, please, if you're on YouTube, hit that subscribe button.
00:38:37 If you are on Facebook, at the end of the show, go to YouTube,
00:38:40 go to True North, and then hit the subscribe button there.
00:38:43 This is something that is very, very important
00:38:45 because only a few independent media outlets get that privilege
00:38:48 of crossing that 100,000 subscriber threshold.
00:38:51 And we want to be among them.
00:38:52 We think we're kind of cool.
00:38:54 Also, if you are enjoying the work we're putting out,
00:38:56 please do head on over to donate.tnc.news.
00:39:00 And lots of great things happening.
00:39:01 I have to put in a plug.
00:39:03 He's going to be on the show soon enough.
00:39:05 But Anthony Fury, the legend of Canadian media,
00:39:08 has just joined True North as our VP of content and editorial,
00:39:14 which I am so thrilled by.
00:39:15 I've known Anthony for many, many years.
00:39:17 I used to have him on my old radio show.
00:39:20 I have written for him when he was the editor at the Toronto Sun.
00:39:23 And now he is like jumping whole hog into new media.
00:39:26 And he's going to be our VP of editorial and content.
00:39:29 I think I got it backwards.
00:39:30 So I hope he doesn't fire me.
00:39:31 But Anthony is going to do some great things at True North.
00:39:34 He's always been a valued member of the team.
00:39:36 And I hope you will all give him a huge welcome to the True North team in his new and improved and expanded role.
00:39:43 So Anthony, welcome.
00:39:44 Looking forward to working with you.
00:39:46 and all of you tuning in looking forward to talking to you tomorrow this is canada's most
00:39:51 irreverent talk show here on true north thank you god bless and good day to you all thanks for
00:39:58 listening to the andrew lawton show support the program by donating to true north at www.tnc.news