Juno News - January 03, 2024


Plagiarism is okay when the left does it

Mentioned
Justin Trudeau says he's not going anywhere this year Jeffrey Epstein associates EXPOSED in new documents

Episode Stats


Length

44 minutes

Words per minute

171.45

Word count

7,673

Sentence count

273

Harmful content

Misogyny

6

sentences flagged

Toxicity

10

sentences flagged

Hate speech

9

sentences flagged


Summary

Summaries generated with gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ .

In this episode, we talk about the new Canadian citizenship law, Harvard President Claudine Gay stepping down, and the growing problem of plagiarism in the media and in academia. Plus, we take a look at what it means to be a plagiarist.

Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 Transcription by CastingWords
00:00:30 Thank you.
00:01:00 welcome to canada's most irreverent talk show this is the andrew lawton show brought to you by true
00:01:20 north hello and welcome to you all canada's most irreverent talk show here the andrew lotton show
00:01:30 on true north on this wednesday january 3rd 2024 as always i'm probably going to say that wrong for
00:01:38 about a good 11 and a half months and then i'll finally realize it's 2024 by uh basically 2025
00:01:45 That's typically how these things work.
00:01:48 Just moments before I went on air, Twitter is bad for my health.
00:01:52 It's bad for everyone's health or X now.
00:01:54 But I was looking and there's a gentleman by the name of Nasser Hadar who says after 10 years of living in Canada, today he became a Canadian.
00:02:03 And there's a photo of him on, it looks like a Zoom call with a citizenship judge.
00:02:09 and he's like in his own office or home like leaning over and taking a selfie with
00:02:14 the zoom box of the citizen judge holding the Canadian flag and I'm like in 2024 can we not
00:02:21 actually have in-person citizenship ceremonies now like that I mean congratulations and all that but
00:02:26 that is crazy I'm just imagining the way zoom calls are you click the raise hand button and
00:02:31 type out your oath that's presumably all it takes to be a Canadian citizen now my goodness that I
00:02:36 thought we had gotten rid i mean i'm doing this show virtually i can't be in all your homes at
00:02:40 once but i tried once it didn't go well but i didn't know we were still doing stuff like this
00:02:45 with zoom so one of the many ways that covet has killed anything and everything good in the world
00:02:51 or at least most of it but that's a bit of a dark note to start off on all right we'll hopefully
00:02:55 turn things around a little bit great to have you tuned in to the program today if you are a
00:03:01 plagiarist now i don't know if you want to identify or out yourself as such but if you are
00:03:06 a plagiarist who likes taking other words other people's words and passing them off as your own
00:03:10 today is a very good day because we've learned there is an excuse for plagiarism that is a very
00:03:16 compelling one which is to do it well being one of the good guys if you are a lefty you are allowed
00:03:23 to engage in plagiarism because it's only bad if the right does it that's apparently how things
00:03:28 are going here you may have seen the news this week claudine gay who is the very highly paid 0.55
00:03:33 president of harvard or at least was until yesterday has announced she is resigning it 0.99
00:03:39 wasn't the anti-semitism that did iran it wasn't the turning a blind eye to a very rabid jew hatred
00:03:45 on her campus no it was being outed by two independent journalists for in her very few
00:03:52 public works uh engaging in plagiarism now people have looked through and said well you know it's
00:03:57 minor play, you know, you took this sentence here, this sentence here, but plagiarism is plagiarism.
00:04:03 And I'll say as someone who has been to university and someone who has spent my life working in a
00:04:09 creative space, by which I mean just a space where I have to use my words some days better than
00:04:14 others, I assure you, I take plagiarism very seriously to the point where I've even been
00:04:19 nervous when I'm typing something out and I fear I'm accidentally plagiarizing because there are
00:04:25 some sentences that there are really no other ways to word. I remember yesterday, for example,
00:04:31 or two days ago, I was writing something and I had been looking it up on Wikipedia and I typed
00:04:37 it out the way I normally would and realized that there was like a string of five or six words that
00:04:42 were identical to the words that were describing something on Wikipedia. And I was like terrified
00:04:47 because I'm like, these words don't even really have synonyms. Like how else can I describe what
00:04:52 this is. So I end up rearranging things, going out of my way to not plagiarize because I know
00:04:58 it is the unforgivable sin in media and even worse in academia. So for Claudine Gay to go 1.00
00:05:05 through this, she has done what you would be potentially expelled for doing if you were an
00:05:11 undergraduate student, but she's done it and has continued to fall upwards to the point of getting
00:05:15 her PhD and landing a plum gig, making I think 900,000 US a year at Harvard. But the good thing
00:05:22 is, they probably just copied and pasted her salary from someone else's. Do you see what I
00:05:26 did there? Yeah. Anyway, so she is now gone. It was the plagiarism that did her in. But because
00:05:31 of this, because she is the good guy and the right are the bad guys, people have decided in the media
00:05:37 now that plagiarism is not a bad thing at all. You may have seen this headline in the Associated
00:05:43 Press, which CTV in Canada picked up. And if we put this tweet up, you will see this.
00:05:48 harvard's harvard president's resignation highlights new conservative weapon against
00:05:56 colleges plagiarism and i obviously it got community noted there so you see well actually
00:06:02 plagiarism is a breach of the rules plagiarism uh is not a weapon and she was forced to resign
00:06:07 for being a serial plagiarist uh but no conservatives are the ones to blame because
00:06:12 conservatives have weaponized her plagiarism by exposing it. And then there was this gem on
00:06:19 television. I don't make a general point of watching Mara Gay and what she has to say,
00:06:25 but it was interesting, the mental gymnastics that she engaged in to defend Claudine Gay.
00:06:31 I don't, I know Sean's asking if they're related. I don't think they're related. Although to be
00:06:36 honest, Claudine Gay, I think is actually more of an intellectual who wouldn't want to claim
00:06:39 being related to Mara Gay. But this is what Mara had to say. The thing that really disturbs me is
00:06:46 the unrelenting campaign from the right and from some conservative activists to slander, discredit,
00:06:56 and ultimately, I guess, you know, somebody used the phrase, we've claimed a scalp, I said, I think,
00:07:04 on social media, you know, to essentially unseat gay and other presidents as well when
00:07:12 they don't like, you know, not just the handling of the horrific attacks on Israel on October
00:07:21 7th, the way that that was handled on campus, but really anything else that they don't like
00:07:26 about not just these presidents, but actually what they would call wokeism.
00:07:32 And I think that's why these presidents are under attack. That's why Claudine DeGay was under attack.
00:07:38 The fact that she's a black woman and the first person who is a black American to lead Harvard only added to their thirst to dethrone her. 1.00
00:07:51 And, you know, those attacks, you don't have to I don't have to say that they're racist because you can hear and see the racism, the attacks.
00:07:57 when people like Vivek Ramaswamy say, you know, okay, this is a problem about diversity and
00:08:04 hiring. I mean, this is racism as well. So there's a lot of different layers here,
00:08:09 but I don't want to miss the attacks on academic freedom.
00:08:13 I mean, there was a lot going on there. Now, I do not think that Mara Gay is a plagiarist. I think
00:08:20 those are her original thoughts, because I don't think anyone else would have tried to pass those
00:08:24 off as their own. So she probably can lay claim to those words without anyone accusing her of
00:08:29 plagiarism. But now if you expose it, you are anti-diversity, you're anti-black, you're racist. 0.99
00:08:36 And, you know, she could have made any point she wanted. She could have come up with any example 0.92
00:08:41 when she talks about the racism that's self-evident. And she mentioned one name of someone
00:08:47 she thinks is passing off racism. And I don't know who this person is. He sounds very much like
00:08:54 a white supremacist neo-Nazi type. I believe the name was Vivek Ramaswamy. Yeah, the white 0.87
00:09:02 supremacy just drips off that name, Vivek Ramaswamy. We don't have a picture of him,
00:09:07 but I bet he's some blonde haired, blue eyed Aryan skinhead who is just so racist against
00:09:12 that Claudine Gay for saying that he rejects diversity hiring. Now, one of the reasons I've 1.00
00:09:18 always been so fervently against affirmative action and diversity-based hiring is because 1.00
00:09:24 it's unfair to everyone. It's unfair to people who would otherwise deserve a spot but don't get
00:09:30 it because they're the wrong skin color. But it's also unfair to people who are the right skin color 0.97
00:09:35 for these programs who would have earned a spot otherwise because now they have clouding over
00:09:41 their appointment, this concern that, oh, well, maybe they just got there because of their skin
00:09:46 color. And I mean, Claudine Gay, I would have loved to have been able to say this is a woman
00:09:50 who deserved it. Her race had nothing to do with it. But a lot of people have pointed out,
00:09:54 people within academia, that she did not have the depth of her academic record and CV that you would
00:10:00 expect to have from someone in that role. So was she a product of diversity hiring? I have no idea.
00:10:06 But clearly she was not vetted the way
00:10:08 and her work has not been vetted the way it was supposed to.
00:10:12 And there is a reason that people like Elizabeth Warren
00:10:15 used to always check the box off for being Native American
00:10:18 when going through the hiring process and all that
00:10:21 because they thought it was going to get them a better shot,
00:10:24 a better deal in wherever they were going.
00:10:27 And I think this is why it's so dangerous.
00:10:29 But now when someone exposes this,
00:10:31 again, we're talking about the cardinal sin of academia here,
00:10:34 The thing that is drilled into students, if you look in the syllabus of any undergraduate course, graduate course, postdoctoral, anything, you're going to see an academic code of conduct in which in big, bold, all caps, they're telling you about what happens if you plagiarize.
00:10:50 So we cannot say that this is now some hatchet job that is entirely a conservative attack on the left.
00:10:57 So basically what they're doing now, my old friend, dear friend, as she's now passed away, Kathy Shadle once said, you should never try to do the whole exposing hypocrisy.
00:11:08 You should never say, oh, well, the left is a double standard.
00:11:11 She said, because they know they do.
00:11:12 They don't care.
00:11:13 They do.
00:11:13 And kind of the approach that she took to the world was liberals.
00:11:16 It's different when they do it.
00:11:18 And that's basically what they're doing now on plagiarism.
00:11:21 If a conservative professor at some university, I don't know if Alan Dershowitz is still a law
00:11:25 prof, but some conservative professor does something like this, they're going to be out 0.51
00:11:31 on their rear end. It's going to be exposed. They're going to be, oh, well, they only coasted
00:11:34 through because they were a white male. But when Claudine Gay does it, one of the left's chosen 0.85
00:11:39 ones at this particular moment, we decide that plagiarism is no longer a sin. In fact, it might
00:11:45 even be virtuous and who are you to dare call it out now as i said earlier it was not this this is
00:11:52 not what i thought would be her undoing i thought it would probably be her handling of the anti-semitism
00:11:57 issue you may recall uh this little exchange between her and i believe it was congresswoman
00:12:01 elise stephanik before a congressional committee just a few weeks back dr gay at harvard does
00:12:10 Is calling for the genocide of Jews violate Harvard's rules of bullying and harassment, yes or no?
00:12:16 It can be, depending on the context.
00:12:19 What's the context?
00:12:21 Targeted as an individual, targeted at an individual.
00:12:24 It's targeted at Jewish students, Jewish individuals.
00:12:28 Do you understand your testimony is dehumanizing them?
00:12:31 Do you understand that dehumanization is part of antisemitism?
00:12:35 I will ask you one more time.
00:12:40 Does calling for the genocide of Jews violate Harvard's rules of bullying and harassment?
00:12:45 Yes or no?
00:12:48 Anti-Semitic rhetoric.
00:12:49 And is it anti-Semitic rhetoric?
00:12:51 Anti-Semitic rhetoric, when it crosses into conduct that amounts to bullying, harassment, intimidation,
00:12:58 that is actionable conduct, and we do take action.
00:13:03 So the answer is yes, that calling for the genocide of Jews violates Harvard's code of conduct.
00:13:09 correct again it depends on the context it does not depend on the context the answer
00:13:17 is yes and this is why you should resign these are unacceptable answers across the board
00:13:24 in retrospect in retrospect i'm a little bit more forgiving of claudian gay's poor performance 0.97
00:13:30 before that committee you see uh she was waiting for someone else to come up with the answer so
00:13:34 that she could repeat it and no one else came up with the answer so she was there stumbling and
00:13:39 and just had to resort to, it depends, it depends, it depends.
00:13:42 Now, let me point out here that I am a big believer in academic freedom.
00:13:46 I believe in the academic freedom and the freedom of speech to say horrendous things on campus, off campus.
00:13:52 That doesn't mean I agree with those things.
00:13:54 Sean says he loves the plagiarism jokes.
00:13:57 A shame they're not actually mine.
00:13:59 They just keep on coming today.
00:14:02 They keep it.
00:14:02 I'm never going to talk about this sort of stuff.
00:14:04 So anyway, the thing that I'll point out here is that a lot of what we've seen on campuses, I think, is actually protected speech.
00:14:11 That doesn't mean it's comfortable or whatnot, but it's protected.
00:14:15 There are some things that go well beyond that, though.
00:14:17 This was a clip we played when we talked about this pushing a month ago of just what Jewish students at Harvard had to deal with.
00:14:34 So there you had an example of not just speech, it wasn't someone putting up a sign,
00:14:41 shouting a slogan. You had people physically disrupting, making physical barriers, blocking
00:14:47 access to Jewish students. And all of this is part and parcel of what has become a very 0.70
00:14:52 inconsistent defense of academic freedom from a lot of the Ivy League set. And this was the
00:14:57 problem here is that it was the double standard that was an issue. These are not people who would
00:15:02 stand up for your academic freedom to use the wrong pronoun, but they'll stand up for your 0.98
00:15:06 academic freedom to say death to the Jews. And anyone who says that they are big free speech 0.96
00:15:12 defenders at Harvard because of their defense of Claudine Gay is an absolute hypocrite through 0.99
00:15:18 and through. We'll move on from this for now. Yesterday on the show, we had a rather interesting 0.98
00:15:24 discussion, I thought, with our good friend Chris Sims about the move that Saskatchewan has made.
00:15:30 This is like the big, big move, the power move, the boss move from the Scott Moe government to tell the feds we are not going to collect your carbon tax anymore on home heating oil.
00:15:42 Sorry, on home heating and on fuel because the government gave this very narrow exemption to Atlantic Canadians effectively by saying you don't need to pay a carbon tax on home heating oil.
00:15:54 So all of a sudden, Saskatchewan was like, whoa, whoa, whoa, whoa, whoa. You said this was an issue of national concern. You said it was crucial for the climate. And now you are saying that on our natural gas and electrical heating and our fuel that we still have to pay the carbon tax, but all those Newfoundlanders and Nova Scotians with their home heating oil don't.
00:16:13 so Saskatchewan just did the one thing it could do
00:16:17 which is say alright well
00:16:18 the agency responsible for this
00:16:20 SaskEnergy is a provincial agency
00:16:23 maybe we just stop collecting
00:16:25 the carbon tax
00:16:26 that is the move they have put in place
00:16:28 starting as of the beginning of the year
00:16:30 so that would make it starting Monday
00:16:33 I wanted to chat about this
00:16:34 with the Saskatchewan Minister
00:16:36 responsible for Crown Corporations
00:16:38 Dustin Duncan Minister
00:16:40 it is wonderful to have you on the show
00:16:41 thanks for coming on today
00:16:43 well thanks for having me and happy new year to you as well now correct me if i'm wrong minister
00:16:47 but i i mean this isn't a surprise move obviously premier scott mo announced this was coming in the
00:16:52 fall and as i understand it you've sent letters i believe plural to the government federally saying
00:16:58 this is what's happening here's the day and you've not received a reply am i understanding
00:17:02 that correctly yeah we haven't received a response yet both sask energy and myself as
00:17:07 the minister have written to the federal minister of national revenue essentially saying that sask
00:17:13 energy will be deregistering as the gas distributor in saskatchewan i essentially on behalf of the
00:17:19 government will be registering as the gas distributor we haven't received a response
00:17:24 from that but that's after a unanimous vote in the house here in in saskatchewan where all
00:17:30 parties agreed that we would essentially move that responsibility from sask energy move it to
00:17:36 the government to me as the minister for both essentially collecting the carbon tax but more
00:17:42 specifically for the remittance of the carbon tax so in the event that we get to a point where we
00:17:47 are no longer remitting a carbon tax that'll be a decision that i will make it won't be a decision
00:17:52 that will be made at the executive level at the officer level or at the board level at sask energy
00:17:59 that's really a government decision to make especially because sask energy is a government
00:18:04 owned entity so we're the shareholder of the government the duly elected government
00:18:08 we're the shareholder we have unanimous support of all members of the legislature to do
00:18:12 to do this and so right now we're awaiting a response from the federal government
00:18:17 is your government confident that this is a legal tactic that you're employing
00:18:23 so we're confident that legally what we did by legislation in saskatchewan that we can do because
00:18:30 sask energy is an entity of the provincial government it's an entity of the provincial
00:18:34 legislature it's created in statute and so what we're essentially saying what we said in that
00:18:39 legislation that did pass in the assembly before our house recessed for the winter for Christmas
00:18:46 is that essentially for all of the parts that are related to that one very narrow specific
00:18:53 part of the greenhouse pollution pricing act that essentially is the carbon tax that for that
00:19:02 section of the federal act that the government not the crown corporation will be responsible
00:19:09 for essentially remitting a carbon tax so because of that sask energy has now um taken the step to
00:19:17 notify the federal government that they wish to deregister as the gas distributor
00:19:22 i in turn have registered the government as the gas distributor going forward after january 1st
00:19:29 that's what we're still waiting on whether or not the government will accept that so
00:19:32 what we did in legislation we can do that we're still waiting whether or not the federal government
00:19:38 will acknowledge the change that we've made i i mean if they don't is this an issue where you've
00:19:44 kind of checkmated them and they don't have a way to do this or are there concerns that you're
00:19:49 having to preempt of how they might respond with this i i know cbc for example ran a story that
00:19:54 there are some concerns about whether the government will claw back uh carbon tax rebates
00:19:58 that it's the canada revenue agency that is responsible for sending out well first of all
00:20:04 it's not the provincial government in saskatchewan or in any other province or sask energy or sask
00:20:09 power that is responsible for determining the rebates that's fully at the discretion of the
00:20:14 federal government they can choose how to distribute the rebates and keep in mind in
00:20:18 atlantic canada where they've been exempt from the carbon tax on home heating fuel
00:20:23 residents still there are getting a rebate and in fact the federal government announced at the
00:20:27 same time that they were topping up the rebate for rural residents which would be you know a
00:20:32 large number of residents not only in atlantic canada but the rest of the country so they made
00:20:37 the decision to not only uh keep in place the rebate for those residents but also top up those
00:20:43 uh the rebates for rural residents regardless of the fact that they uh have not implemented
00:20:49 the carbon tax on home heating fuel for some residents in the country. So the two, I don't
00:20:55 think are linked. The federal government can continue to supply a rebate to people across
00:21:01 the country, regardless of what we do here in Saskatchewan in terms of collection or eventually
00:21:06 remitting or not remitting a carbon tax. I just wanted to, I mean, you mentioned in this interview
00:21:11 and I've seen it elsewhere that you're taking the responsibility for this. You're not making
00:21:15 SaskEnergy do anything. And I think that's a very interesting move here because you're
00:21:20 prepared to own this, whatever happens, are you not? Yeah, absolutely. I'm the minister
00:21:25 responsible for Crown Investments Corporation, which includes SaskEnergy and SaskPower.
00:21:30 What we have wanted to do and signal to first and foremost, the people of Saskatchewan is that we
00:21:36 are continuing to fight for fairness when it comes to the carbon tax. The prime minister has given a
00:21:40 carve out to some Canadians, but not to all Canadians. The other thing to keep in mind is
00:21:44 that Saskatchewan, particularly rural Saskatchewan, used to rely largely on home heating oil like
00:21:50 they do continue to do in Atlantic Canada or large parts of Atlantic Canada. And we went
00:21:55 through a process in the 1980s of moving to rural gasification, where SaskEnergy moved
00:22:01 into rural areas where now the vast majority of residents in Saskatchewan, both farm, small
00:22:06 town and large communities, are on the gas system, natural gas system. That was at a
00:22:11 considerable cost. In today's dollars, that would have been close to half a billion dollars. So we
00:22:16 already made that move. We shouldn't be penalized for having been early adopters to gas, natural gas
00:22:22 here in Saskatchewan. So as minister responsible, if the decision is made to not remit a carbon tax,
00:22:29 and again, that decision has not been made, but if a decision is made to not remit a carbon tax to
00:22:34 the federal government, that will be the government making that decision. That will be me as the
00:22:38 minister, my cabinet colleagues. And so in terms of ministerial responsibility, whatever consequences
00:22:44 are borne by that action or potentially inaction should be borne by us, the elected members and me
00:22:50 as minister responsible. They shouldn't be borne by the board of directors who are Saskatchewan
00:22:56 residents, Saskatchewan citizens. They shouldn't be borne by the officers and senior staff,
00:23:03 uh frankly any employee at sask energy um who are just doing their job uh to provide for
00:23:09 uh heat this winter so people can keep their uh keep their um families warm uh and uh and and so
00:23:18 that that's the decision that we've made so if there are consequences uh to be borne by this
00:23:22 uh they will be uh by me as the minister i mean i mentioned earlier and you were discussing the
00:23:28 federal government's non-response to you and i i guess in a perverse way no news is good news here
00:23:32 Because if the federal government says nothing and does nothing, they're basically endorsing that you have a right implicitly to do this and your citizens, your residents are still getting that break.
00:23:43 Well, I mean, that certainly is a view. We do need, though, some certainty on this because technically as of today, as of January 2nd, we are, well, technically as of January 1st, the beginning of this year, SaskEnergy is still the registered distributor because they have not been notified.
00:24:01 And so potentially any actions against SaskEnergy is still the consequences would be their consequences.
00:24:10 We want to shift that. That was the intent of the bill.
00:24:13 Again, if this decision is going to be made and it hasn't been made, but if there was to be a decision made around the remittance of the carbon tax, that'll be our decision to make.
00:24:23 the shareholder the government of Saskatchewan on behalf of the people of this province
00:24:28 not by anybody at SaskEnergy's head office or around the board table and so
00:24:33 while no news is usually good news we do need that certainty from the federal government whether or
00:24:38 not they will accept the changes that we've made and the change to that registration so that we
00:24:44 can then as a government make further decisions. As of now SaskEnergy has been collecting the
00:24:50 carbon tax until the end of December. And depending on people's billing cycles, they'll see the
00:24:56 carbon tax come off or either in January or potentially February, depending on their billing
00:25:01 cycle. But we've made the decision that any carbon tax on consumption after December 31st would no
00:25:08 longer be billed to the rate payers at SaskEnergy. So we're technically still in compliance.
00:25:17 we'll make a payment that those dollars have been collected on the december bills
00:25:21 we'll make a payment uh here in january we'll then have a decision to make in basically february
00:25:28 depending on what uh what the answer comes back from the federal minister of national revenue
00:25:33 minister dustin duncan thank you very much for your time sir thanks for having me andrew
00:25:40 he is the minister responsible for crown corporations like those in saskatchewan
00:25:45 when they're tasked with doing this.
00:25:46 And I appreciate, I mean, look,
00:25:48 I don't want to get too much into the ins and outs
00:25:50 of the manner in which they're doing this.
00:25:52 But he's saying, no, this is a ministerial decision.
00:25:54 This is a ministerial responsibility.
00:25:56 He is seizing control, basically,
00:25:58 of those government departments,
00:26:01 those crown corporations and saying,
00:26:02 I, as the minister, will make this decision.
00:26:04 So we do have a standoff
00:26:06 between the provincial government in Saskatchewan
00:26:09 and the federal government.
00:26:10 And as I was chatting about yesterday with Chris Sims,
00:26:12 one thing that I find interesting here
00:26:14 is that Alberta has not been going to war for tax reduction as much as Saskatchewan has in a
00:26:22 couple of key ways, notably the fuel tax, which is different. But again, I think to a lot of
00:26:26 Canadians, a tax is a tax is a tax. Whether it's on this thing or that thing, they don't really
00:26:30 know or care as long as they are not the ones that have to keep paying more and more to government
00:26:36 and in government coffers here. So that is where things are in Saskatchewan. Obviously, we'll follow
00:26:41 that. And I actually, we've had trouble in the past. This isn't a complaint. It's more just an
00:26:46 observation because I know we have some viewers and listeners from Saskatchewan. We have had
00:26:51 difficulty in the past getting members of the Saskatchewan government on the show. And part of
00:26:57 it is just, we don't have the contacts there. We've not built the relationships with those people
00:27:01 and other parts of it. When we have tried to reach out, I've tried to have Premier Mo on in several
00:27:05 locations. I've tried to have other ministers on and we've just not managed to get replies. So
00:27:09 I was very pleased yesterday when we reached out to Minister Duncan's office that they replied very
00:27:15 quickly and we had him on and hopefully this can become the beginning of a long-standing relationship
00:27:20 with the good people of Saskatchewan. I've been to Saskatchewan on several occasions. I've been to
00:27:26 Moose Jaw. I've been to Regina a couple times. Haven't been to Saskatoon. When I was in Regina
00:27:31 the first time in a very Saskatchewan way, I recall there was like a controversy and someone
00:27:36 told me this it might not entirely be true this would have been like uh 10 12 years ago or so
00:27:42 and apparently like the city logo had like a silhouette of the skyline of regina which i
00:27:49 didn't know regina had a skyline but there you go and there was like a weird sort of uh regina
00:27:54 controversy where they had built a building and they were wondering if they needed to update the
00:27:59 city logo because the skyline now had a third building in it and i don't know what they ended
00:28:04 up doing on that. But I know that Regina ended up getting into a bit more trouble more recently when 1.00
00:28:07 they decided to play off of the fact that Regina rhymes with vagina as a tourism slogan, or as they
00:28:14 said, Regina, the city that rhymes with fun. And then of course, like anything else, the Killjoys 0.65
00:28:20 took it away from them. So all that notwithstanding, there are plenty of Killjoys, not just
00:28:24 Saskatchewan Tourism Board officials, but also federal court judges. And there was one ruling
00:28:30 over the holidays that we have followed this case for a little while on. And it was on this sign
00:28:37 that you may have seen in an election campaign, the Libranos, Libranos.com by the book. The book
00:28:45 is, well, as it's called there, the Libranos was written by Ezra Levant of Rebel News. And the
00:28:52 elections bureaucrats, the commissioner of Canada elections came down hard and said that sign
00:28:57 wasn't actually a book advertisement, but it was an election campaign sign. It was an election
00:29:03 campaign sign, and you aren't allowed to do it without going through all of these rules
00:29:07 that we have for election advertisers, for third parties and political parties. Now,
00:29:12 Ezra pointed to a section of the law, which specifically says advertising books, like it
00:29:20 literally says advertising books is in a category of its own and are exempt from this. So he
00:29:25 challenged this, brought it to federal court, and a judge ultimately signed on to the narrative put
00:29:31 forward by the Commissioner of Canada Elections and found that those signs were illegal. Ezra
00:29:36 Levant is the author of The Lebranos and the founder of Rebel News and joins us now. Ezra,
00:29:41 I mean, you and I have had a number of conversations over the years about our
00:29:44 dissatisfaction with the judicial status quo, so I don't want to say that I'm totally shocked by
00:29:50 this, but this is like a clear-cut example of when the court is finding that the law doesn't
00:29:55 say what the law says. I have to tell you, I was completely shocked by this for two reasons. First
00:30:01 of all, the plain words in the Kenda Elections Act exempt books and the promotion of books
00:30:09 from their election finances, which makes sense. I mean, it also exempts news and speeches and
00:30:17 letters. Because imagine if every newspaper article that was an endorsement of this party
00:30:24 or a criticism of that party were to be banned or regulated by the government. It would be madness.
00:30:30 So it applies to books or the promotion of books. And as you can see, because you just showed your
00:30:36 viewers there, the promotion of books was very simple. That was the front cover of our book
00:30:42 called The Libranos with three added words, buy the book. But that enraged Elections Canada.
00:30:50 they were obsessed by that book cover and that title they were obsessed by the drawings on it
00:30:57 of trudeau and his friends and so they thought it was so critical that the book and the title of the
00:31:06 book they said were banned and the judge agreed and so i suppose technically the book itself is
00:31:13 not banned but if you've banned the title of the book and you ban the cover of the book
00:31:19 you sort of banned the book and by the way you can buy that book right now on amazon.ca
00:31:27 but if there were an election called tomorrow it would be banned again or at least the cover of it
00:31:34 and the title of it and i couldn't show it and i don't know i was really surprised conceivably you
00:31:40 couldn't run like online ads for it as i mean without being am i do i read that correctly
00:31:45 Yeah, exactly. I mean, they didn't like the lawn sign because they thought it sure felt like a political campaign. And it's true. Lawn signs are something that are used in political campaigns. But we also had online ads. We also had a billboard. We also made videos. We also did emails. Elections Canada only prosecuted this image.
00:32:08 But I want to tell you, Andrew, there were 23 other books published about Justin Trudeau during the exact same time period.
00:32:18 I'm talking about right before the election in 2019.
00:32:21 23 other books.
00:32:23 And they were positive towards Trudeau.
00:32:26 They were boosting him.
00:32:28 It would be like a campaign ad for them.
00:32:31 But, of course, they're exempt because they're books, so they were not prosecuted.
00:32:35 I asked the Elections Canada people, and my lawyer asked the judge, how is it that those 23 pro-Trudeau books are fine, but my one anti-Trudeau, it's anti-Trudeau, book is not?
00:32:52 And both the Elections Canada staff and the judge agreed, well, if I didn't like those 23 other books, I should have complained about them.
00:33:01 But I don't want to complain about those 23 other books.
00:33:04 i mean i could complain about them but i don't want to prosecute them and you know what the
00:33:09 judge said and i if you don't mind i wouldn't mind reading very quickly from the actual ruling
00:33:14 please the judge said it yeah the judge says it was no big deal all i had to do was act like a
00:33:21 political party register with the government disclose my finances to the government and comply
00:33:27 with the government and i could have the lawn sign in my book all i like basically become one
00:33:33 those registered third party political activist groups like lead now or you know whatever here
00:33:39 let me i'm just going to read uh very quickly here's one sentence from the judge even if the
00:33:45 promotion of a particular book is election advertising such promotion is not prohibited
00:33:53 she's saying my book wasn't banned quote the third party that would be me must simply comply
00:34:00 with the requirements of the act that apply to all third-party election advertisers authors or
00:34:06 publishers comply with the spending registration and disclosure requirements so oh it's no big
00:34:13 deal all i have to do is register my book with the government but just let me say that again
00:34:19 all i have to do is an author duh just register with the government let me read one more sentence
00:34:25 from the judge when we argued, well, that would be a kind of chilling effect to require authors
00:34:31 to say, hello, government, we'd like to register our book with you. The judge said, quote,
00:34:38 it should not be overly onerous for an author or a publisher to demonstrate what their intention was
00:34:46 as to the timing of the promotion. As in, I had to justify publishing the book during an election
00:34:54 And because I did so, that's what made it an illegal book.
00:34:59 But every political book is published during election.
00:35:03 You don't publish a book after the election about the election.
00:35:06 That's a totally different book.
00:35:07 And like I say, 24 publishers, 24 authors all had the same idea.
00:35:13 Let's talk about Justin Trudeau in the 2019 election.
00:35:17 The judge says, I had to, I just read it to you.
00:35:20 The judge said, I should have justified to the government why I did it during the election.
00:35:27 I don't know.
00:35:28 I'm really surprised by this.
00:35:29 My fine is $3,000 plus $10,000 for the court case.
00:35:35 So I have to pay the government $13,000.
00:35:39 That's not the end of the world, although that's a very stiff fine for publishing a book.
00:35:44 But both the judge and Elections Canada had a warning for me.
00:35:47 They both said that they could have come after me criminally. And theoretically, I could have been jailed. And they both hinted to me that if I do this again, I will be prosecuted criminally. No one in Canadian history has ever been prosecuted for publishing a book critical of a politician.
00:36:09 and i say again it was the fact that i was critical of him that bothered them they said so again and
00:36:16 again and and if you read the ruling it's 85 pages long we put up we put up a website for those who
00:36:21 want to see it and see my side of the story the website is save rebel news.com because i think
00:36:28 that this is really goes to our freedom if let me just jump in there ezra was your uh legal case i
00:36:36 know you weren't the you weren't fighting it yourself you had a lawyer but was your case
00:36:39 a constitutional free speech uh you know freedom of expression case or was it just listen your own
00:36:45 law says that the promotion of books is fine uh therefore your application of the law against us
00:36:51 is uh completely made up it was both and the judge dismissed the that second one very quickly
00:36:58 too quickly i mean and then and again how did the judge rationalize that because literally you can
00:37:03 see the words right there. Yeah. Well, there's three parts. Your book has to be published at
00:37:10 a commercial price. My book was $14, which is commercially fair. And it has to be published
00:37:17 whether or not there was an election. Well, we would have published my book,
00:37:22 whether or not there was an election. Of course, we were going to publish it. And I don't even know
00:37:26 what it means that there wouldn't be an election. Well, and in Canada also, I mean, the 2019 election
00:37:32 was fixed in 2015 but in our system there can be an election i mean there could be an election in
00:37:36 40 days that you have no idea is coming right and listen i was honest with the with the judge and i
00:37:42 was honest with the cops who interrogated me i said we did what every other author did is we
00:37:47 coincided with the election but we would have published it whether or not i mean i've published
00:37:52 more than 10 books um and we publish them during an election we do publish them when it's not an
00:37:57 election i have another book coming out about justin trudeau ideally i would publish it
00:38:02 right before the election it would be terrible if i was late until after the election but the
00:38:08 judge sorry the law does not stop me from timing it it doesn't it just says i have to publish it
00:38:14 whether or not there's an election she thought that was a silly uh difference that there was no
00:38:19 difference and then oh we have uh elections canada has to oh there we go i thought elections canada
00:38:28 was coming after you but we appear to have gotten you back now ezra sorry about that i'm i'm on the
00:38:33 road i've had the judge the judge said the timing of the publication is what one of the things that
00:38:39 made it illegal but like i say 23 other authors time their books the exact same time i'm worried
00:38:45 about this and well you mentioned you have another book coming out i mean what are you
00:38:49 not that i would ever say that you are a generally compliant person with government edicts but uh
00:38:54 what is your plan going to be if you've gotten that far on on what to do about that book well
00:38:59 i'm going to publish it and i don't want to be charged and i don't want to be convicted and i
00:39:04 certainly don't want to be fined and i absolutely don't want to register with the government right
00:39:08 I'm absolutely not going to. And, you know, I remember during the COVID times, the lockdowns,
00:39:16 I made some personal decisions that I was not going to comply. Now, they never came down hard
00:39:21 on me like a ton of bricks, but I was on their no-fly list because I was unjabbed. I didn't get
00:39:27 a vaccine passport, and I just decided I was not going to comply. And I am not going to register
00:39:32 my next book with the government. I'm just not going to. In terms of the exact timing of the
00:39:37 book obviously it's going to be before the next election um we don't know when that next election
00:39:42 will be but if it comes if we are at the point andrew in canada when a critic of the government
00:39:49 when an author is prosecuted and god forbid convicted of a crime and jailed for writing a
00:39:55 book about him then that person should be mean because i i i say i believe in freedom and i say
00:40:03 I believe in fighting back. And just like I felt an obligation to walk the walk during the lockdowns,
00:40:09 I feel an obligation here. And if it's not me, who would it be? I mean, God, I don't want you
00:40:15 to be prosecuted for your book. I don't want anyone else, but I know that I've got the fighting spirit
00:40:19 and our viewers generally like to crowdfund these battles. So I am going to publish another book
00:40:27 before the next election, critical of Justin Trudeau. It's going to be a real book. It's
00:40:31 be sold at a real price it's going to be published whether or not there's an election but we're going
00:40:35 to time it before the election i'm just going to do that and if that sends me to jail and god
00:40:42 forbid it i hope it doesn't um canadians ought to know that's the country we live in now will i just
00:40:49 on the note of this one are you going to bring this to the federal court of appeal yes we've hired
00:40:54 a great lawyer sarah miller is she's been on the show a number of times yeah i think she's really
00:41:01 smart. I chose her because she's had good luck in the court of appeals. She was the one who took
00:41:06 Arthur Pavlovsky's case, the Christian pastor who was jailed in Alberta for keeping his church
00:41:13 open. She won that on appeal. And I thought, boy, I need a smart lawyer who'll do well in the court 0.94
00:41:19 of appeals. So she's already, at least she's shown me the notice of appeal. I think she's filed it
00:41:24 already. It's an uphill battle. I got to tell you, most appeals in court fail. It's just a
00:41:31 statistical thing i think two out of three lose and this was a well crafted ruling by the judge
00:41:39 she wasn't i mean 85 pages she took to make her case so i'm not optimistic it's not about the
00:41:46 fine i mean the fine does bother me it's about the law itself it's crazy we would and what it
00:41:52 says to people that don't have your spirit and frankly your finances to fight this stuff i mean
00:41:57 you're just some you know self-published author that wants to make a point and maybe you want to
00:42:02 you know spend a couple thousand dollars promoting your book this does have a chilling effect
00:42:06 absolutely and i just can't get over the fact that the judge said that oh it's no big deal
00:42:11 it's not onerous i mean i was i was called to the headquarters of elections canada and two 30-year
00:42:18 rcmp veterans interrogated me for an hour now you know me i don't mind that i like the sparring of
00:42:25 You enjoy it. You're bored when you're not being interrogated by some bureaucrat or police officer.
00:42:30 But unless you're a lawyer or a real tough cookie who's used to fighting, I mean, I wasn't terrified, but I think 99% of people would have been really scared by that.
00:42:44 And the fine, the $13,000 fine, I think that that would dissuade a lot of people.
00:42:50 not everyone has $13,000 to pay the fund. Now, we're going to crowdfund this appeal,
00:42:56 and hopefully we won't have to pay it in the end. But for the judge to pretend there was no chilling
00:43:01 effect here, that really is one of the worst parts of this ruling. I'm just going to read that again
00:43:06 for 30 seconds. Quote, it should not be overly onerous for an author or publisher to demonstrate
00:43:13 what their intention was. As in, you've got to go to the government and say, no, no, no,
00:43:19 this is we're not trying to criticize you uh saint trudeau please this is just a book you know to
00:43:27 you know what that the judge was wrong there i'm just i don't want this to become a legal precedent
00:43:33 i fear it will be but we've got to fight it very well said ezra levant the rebel commander himself
00:43:39 thank you so much and best of luck thanks bye-bye all right that does it for us for today we'll be
00:43:45 be back in just 23 hours and 15 minutes with more of canada's most irreverent talk show here on true
00:43:50 north thank you god bless and good day to you all thanks for listening to the andrew lawton show
00:43:56 support the program by donating to true north at www.tnc.news
00:44:15 We'll be right back.