Juno News - April 30, 2024


Poilievre hints at using notwithstanding clause to pass tough-on-crime laws

Topics
Hosted by
Mentioned
European conservatives DEMAND to close the border to mass immigration Poilievre kicked out of Parliament for calling Trudeau a “wacko”

Episode Stats


Length

40 minutes

Words per minute

173.69

Word count

7,121

Sentence count

288

Harmful content

Misogyny

2

sentences flagged

Hate speech

6

sentences flagged


Summary

Summaries generated with gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ .

In this episode of The Andrew Lawton Show, host Andrew Lawton talks about the growing problem of crime in Canada. He talks about Uber drivers in Vancouver and Ottawa, the recent high-speed police chase down the 401 in Ontario that left a family of four dead, and the proposed capital gains tax increase that the federal government is pushing.

Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Topics generated with Qwen2.5-3B-Instruct.
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 Transcription by CastingWords
00:00:30 Thank you.
00:01:00 welcome to canada's most irreverent talk show this is the andrew lawton show brought to you by true
00:01:19 north hello and welcome to you all canada's most irreverent talk show here the andrew lawton show
00:01:29 on true north on this tuesday april 30th hope you are all having an absolutely wonderful day a
00:01:36 wonderful week so far we will have some have some real goodies for you we'll be talking about
00:01:40 british columbia's failed drug decriminalization in just a little bit also want to touch on this
00:01:46 capital gains tax increase that the federal government is pushing and a little bit of
00:01:51 interesting news that just came down like I don't know 10 minutes before I went on air
00:01:55 the well we'll talk about it in 15 minutes when we have Jake Fuss on but you won't want to well
00:01:59 maybe you want to miss that but I hope you don't want to miss that but I want to begin talking
00:02:04 about crime now I had the well actually I've been in a couple of cities in the last few days I was
00:02:09 in Vancouver I was in Ottawa and in both cities I you know get to the airport you take an Uber from
00:02:16 the airport to where you're going and both times I landed I was finding it increasingly the case
00:02:24 before then but it happened again in this last few days that uber drivers love to talk about
00:02:31 what's happened to their city and what was interesting is that the uber driver in Vancouver
00:02:37 was telling me that oh Vancouver's worse than ever now and the uber driver in Ottawa said Ottawa is
00:02:42 like Vancouver now and this has happened actually the last time I was in Ottawa something very
00:02:46 similar happened where I was just chatting with the Uber driver and I don't even like I don't
00:02:50 even like those words because it's always so fake sounding when a politician says oh I was talking
00:02:54 to a cab driver the other day and but these are true these are honest bona fide stories that have
00:02:59 happened from my travels as of late and people are noticing what's happening in their communities and
00:03:05 this is no longer just it used to be with drug stuff we'd look at it and say this is a Vancouver
00:03:09 issue. But drugs, crime, homelessness, this is now the norm in pretty much every city and many towns
00:03:16 across the country. And people have had enough. It's not just a left-right issue. This is an issue
00:03:21 that's affecting families, businesses, individuals, and no one is really seeing in federal politics
00:03:27 right now, in the government, a leader or cabinet who are taking things seriously. So it's provided
00:03:33 a massive opening for Pierre Polyev, the leader of the Conservatives, who has come out and said,
00:03:38 we're going to basically keep jails, keep prisoners behind bars. We're going to keep
00:03:43 criminals behind bars. We're going to get rid of this easy bail, this revolving door approach that
00:03:48 has people out of jail on Monday and back in jail by the evening Monday because they were just
00:03:56 committing crimes on with such frequency that the second they're released, they get put back in
00:04:01 bars. That's what he's saying is not working for Canadians. It's not working for communities.
00:04:06 And just yesterday, for example, there was this horrendous case, the news was announced this morning, of a high-speed police chase down the 401 in Ontario, down the wrong lane, as police were chasing a vehicle that had fled a robbery at an LCBO in Bowmanville.
00:04:23 and the police are following this car down the wrong way on the 401 and in the end this car
00:04:29 collides with a vehicle that had two grandparents and an infant. All of them as well as the driver
00:04:35 police were pursuing have died. Now again I don't know the details of the person that police were
00:04:42 pursuing. I don't know if this was a repeat offender or not but the whole point is these stories
00:04:47 are just coming at a time when we are seeing such frequency to them that every day crime is taking
00:04:54 up more of your newspaper if you still have a print edition of your newspaper than it ever has
00:04:59 before in our lifetimes and this is something that a lot of people I don't think are comfortable
00:05:03 just accepting as business as usual now and this brings us to well it was a bit of context that
00:05:10 brings us to this speech that Pierre Polyev gave to the Canadian Police Association yesterday and
00:05:15 And in it, he laid out his plan, his roadmap for crime.
00:05:19 And one of the things that I'll point out here
00:05:21 is that he was kind of dancing around and hinting here,
00:05:25 but it was very clear what he was saying.
00:05:28 And I think it's very important to note
00:05:30 that what Pierre Polyev has been talking about on this
00:05:32 is resonating with a lot of Canadians.
00:05:36 It is resonating with a lot of Canadians.
00:05:38 And it's something that, well, okay, we have one clip.
00:05:42 I don't know if we have the right clip.
00:05:43 This is, I believe, what he said previously on this, when he's been asked about what he's going to do on crime stuff, when the Supreme Court, if you look back through the Harper years, had always been or often been very resistant to this and had been striking down these things as unconstitutional.
00:05:59 This is what, Polly, I've told a reporter previously.
00:06:01 You've talked about the imposition of mandatory minimums for many of these crimes, but mandatory minimums have consistently been struck down by the Supreme Court as unconstitutional.
00:06:13 How would you reconcile that policy with the court's findings in cases like that?
00:06:19 Many of our mandatory prison sentences have been upheld by the courts.
00:06:26 And all of our proposals are charter-proof.
00:06:29 They respect the Charter of Rights and Freedoms.
00:06:32 And we want laws that respect the rights of all Canadians, including and especially victims of crime.
00:06:41 So it's a violation of your charter rights if you get your head smashed in with a baseball bat.
00:06:48 It's a violation of your charter rights if somebody throws a firebomb into your child's bedroom in the middle of the night.
00:06:55 It's a violation of your charter rights if you open a small business and you pour your life into it
00:07:02 and somebody comes along and says, give me a million dollars or I'll blow up your family.
00:07:06 That's a violation of charter rights.
00:07:08 so the 218 increase in extortions under Justin Trudeau has violated the charter rights of all
00:07:17 of the victims and so we know the courts will uphold our proposals today we'll make sure of it
00:07:23 thank you we won't need to because it's all everything I'm proposing is constitutional
00:07:29 so he was saying there it sounded like at the end and I couldn't quite hear the question that
00:07:35 he was being asked perhaps about the notwithstanding clause which is a part of the
00:07:39 constitution a part of the charter that lets provincial or the federal government pass
00:07:43 legislation notwithstanding the charter implications and it basically shields it
00:07:48 from being stricken down by the supreme court but now he is singing slightly a different tune this
00:07:56 was a clip from a speech he gave to the canadian police association in which he touches on this
00:08:01 and everyone in the room and everyone watching knew exactly what he meant.
00:08:06 All of my proposals are constitutional, and we will make sure we will make them constitutional
00:08:11 using whatever tools the Constitution allows me to use to make them constitutional.
00:08:18 I think you know exactly what I mean.
00:08:21 So they will happen, and they will stay in place,
00:08:24 and I will be the democratically elected prime minister,
00:08:28 democratically accountable to the people,
00:08:30 and they can then make the judgments themselves on whether they think my laws are constitutional.
00:08:37 So one thing that I have learned about Pierre Polyev in the last eight months or so,
00:08:42 actually more than that now, because I started writing a book about him quite a while back,
00:08:46 is that he's very deliberate with his word.
00:08:49 So when he talks about the people who elected him making judgments,
00:08:53 he is saying there, and not that it's all that subtle, I should point out,
00:08:56 that he has more regard for what Canadians think of his agenda than what the Supreme Court of
00:09:02 Canada might think of his agenda. And that's why he's hinting there again, not so subtly at the
00:09:07 use of the notwithstanding clause. And more importantly, he's talking about how it's the
00:09:11 democratically elected government that ultimately has to be accountable to Canadians, not to
00:09:17 unelected judges. That's the point he's making there. Now, the notwithstanding clause, just to
00:09:22 you civics 101 here it was put in the charter basically because there were provinces that
00:09:27 weren't comfortable with everything and it was the federal it was the bargaining chip that said to
00:09:31 provinces okay fine we'll give you this little thing so that we're not superseding your legislative
00:09:37 authority as provinces now for most of the charter's history for basically 40 years
00:09:42 quebec was the only province to have used it and then ontario used it ontario took the hammer broke
00:09:48 the glass case, pressed the button, and now it's been a little bit more normalized in political
00:09:54 discourse. And I think the notwithstanding clause has become more relevant in the political
00:09:58 discussion as the Supreme Court and as the courts in general have gotten more activist and more
00:10:04 antagonistic towards the will of democratically elected governments. And the Supreme Court was
00:10:10 incredibly hostile to much of what Stephen Harper did, especially on the crime file, not the least
00:10:15 of which was striking down mandatory minimums. So Paulieva is saying we want to bring back
00:10:21 mandatory minimums. We want to restrict bail. We don't want that revolving door. And he's saying
00:10:26 we'll use any constitutional means necessary, hint, hint, wink, wink, nudge, nudge, if you get my
00:10:31 meaning. And then everyone in the room chuckles because they get his meaning. And that's what
00:10:35 he's doing. Now, there's going to be a little bit of pearl clutching here. CBC already has the
00:10:39 constitutional lawyer being quoted saying, oh, well, we know we can't just have this normalized
00:10:45 and this is going to be terrible and it'll be the disintegration of the Charter and all of that.
00:10:49 But as my friend Ginny Roth, who's been on this show before, pointed out on Twitter,
00:10:54 anyone who's shocked by this simply hasn't been paying attention.
00:10:57 This is not new, she said.
00:10:59 Remember, when Polyev tells you what he's going to do, you should really just listen to him.
00:11:05 And she linked there to a statement Polyev put out during his leadership campaign.
00:11:09 So this is back in 2022.
00:11:11 and it was a statement while he was again campaigning for the conservative leadership
00:11:15 in which he talks about the reduced sentence of the man who killed six people in a brutal attack
00:11:22 on a mosque in Quebec City back in January of 2017 and he says I will use the notwithstanding
00:11:30 clause to restore the law so that every life taken counts again in a killer sentence and that the
00:11:35 worst murderers stay behind bars for life and he takes aim at the Supreme Court and says because
00:11:40 of them, multiple murderers will be eligible to have their sentences reduced. So he was very
00:11:46 unequivocal there. Yeah, I will use the notwithstanding clause. So obviously, now that
00:11:50 he is the leader, he equivocates a little bit more on this. I shouldn't say equivocates, but he
00:11:55 dampens the language a little bit. But his agenda has been crystal clear on this. And I don't think
00:12:02 most Canadians care about the constitutional hand-wringing. I don't think most Canadians care
00:12:07 about what the professor of the University of Ivory Tower says about this. I think most Canadians
00:12:12 care about results. And when you've got a guy that's saying, listen, all these criminals that
00:12:16 are on your streets, do you want them off the streets? Yes, great. That's what I'm going to do.
00:12:20 And they probably don't care how it's going to take hold and how he's going to do it.
00:12:25 One thing I'll point out, though, that I found quite interesting is that while he is doing this,
00:12:30 and if you look at the poll numbers, it's clearly resonating with Canadians. The federal government
00:12:35 is just completely in denial on this.
00:12:39 Justin Trudeau, he gave an interview on a fireside chat
00:12:42 at the Canada Building Trade Union,
00:12:45 and he basically said that anyone who doesn't support what he's doing
00:12:49 must be succumbing to misinformation.
00:12:51 Literally, this is what he said.
00:12:54 One of the challenges we have is the level of misinformation,
00:13:00 disinformation, nonsense out there on social media.
00:13:05 means that your members are being convinced not to vote in their own interest but to lash out in
00:13:16 anger. And I will continue to try and have reasonable conversations and not fall into the
00:13:22 misinformation, disinformation game. I'm not going to try and fit the solution to all our problems
00:13:26 on a bumper sticker or in a seven-second TikTok video. I'm going to continue to have real
00:13:33 conversations with people, but you all need to be part of those conversations because your members
00:13:38 trust you more than they trust any given politician. And your role in making sure
00:13:45 Canadians are thoughtful about the kind of future we're building, the kind of country we're building
00:13:49 is more important than it ever has been. So it's actually quite brazen that he is saying to
00:13:59 Canada's Building Trades Union that, well, you know what, if you guys are the victims here,
00:14:05 you're getting all this misinformation. And basically, the argument is that if you have
00:14:10 misinformation, you'll vote conservative. But if you have all the information, you'll vote liberal.
00:14:14 That's the point. Now, what's notable is that I was talking about this on the show last week,
00:14:18 that very same union, that very union was the one who was writing a letter to the federal
00:14:23 government last week saying, hey, by the way, all of those jobs that you promised us for the
00:14:29 Stellantis plant in Windsor. Yeah, why are they going to foreign workers? Why are you bringing 1.00
00:14:33 in foreign workers to do jobs that we want to do ourselves? So that's the union to which he's 0.96
00:14:38 speaking, that he's now saying, oh yes, but you're all victims of misinformation. So a little bit of
00:14:43 hidden context there that you might have missed. And again, I'm sure anyone who criticizes the
00:14:47 federal budget is also most certainly falling victim to misinformation, including perhaps those
00:14:53 who oppose the capital gains tax.
00:14:56 There were hundreds, well over a thousand people
00:14:58 from the business and tech and entrepreneurial space
00:15:01 that signed an open letter to the federal government
00:15:03 calling out this increase to the capital gains tax.
00:15:06 We have a number of experts that are saying
00:15:09 this is going to kill off
00:15:11 or severely curtail innovation in this country.
00:15:14 And now you have a piece that I wanted to highlight
00:15:17 from our friend Jake Fuss of the Fraser Institute.
00:15:20 Ottawa's capital gains tax hike is the final nail in the business investment coffin.
00:15:27 Jake is the Director of Fiscal Studies for the Fraser Institute,
00:15:29 and it's always good to have him back on the show.
00:15:31 Jake, welcome. Thanks for coming on.
00:15:33 Thanks very much for having me back on.
00:15:35 So this can be very abstract for a lot of people.
00:15:38 There are a lot of Canadians, especially as they're doing their personal income tax,
00:15:41 that don't know if they have capital gains, that may never have capital gains,
00:15:46 and they think, okay, well, this doesn't really affect me.
00:15:48 but it does affect everyone if it is stifling business and growth does it not well absolutely
00:15:55 i mean right now we have a business investment crisis in canada from 2014 to 2022 um our per
00:16:01 worker business investment has fallen by almost four thousand dollars even after we account for
00:16:06 inflation that's not the situation in other countries like the united states where they're
00:16:11 actually increasing their per worker business investment right now and this is really critical
00:16:16 to actually equip workers with the tools and technology that we need to improve productivity
00:16:21 and ultimately to actually increase people's wages over time because when businesses become
00:16:25 more profitable and more efficient and more innovative over time this actually benefits
00:16:30 workers and living standards in canada but a measure like increasing capital gains taxes is
00:16:34 only going to make the situation worse for business investment over the long run yeah and i was
00:16:41 pointing or i would point out to this one section in your piece here where you talk about how it is
00:16:48 reducing the return on investment encouraging an exodus of capital and that part is so key because
00:16:53 capital is not restricted by geography at this point i mean you can make whatever claims you
00:16:57 want about globalization but the reality is we do have a globalized economy people can put their
00:17:02 billions of dollars their millions of dollars basically anywhere in the world and countries
00:17:06 do need to be competitive absolutely and we're not competitive already on on many forms of taxation
00:17:12 whether that's business taxes personal income taxes capital gains taxes you know this is only
00:17:17 going to exacerbate the issue now and capital is very mobile and one of the most economically
00:17:23 damaging sources of taxation is taxes on capital so people just take their money elsewhere they're
00:17:28 either just not going to invest in canada at all or they won't invest as much as they would have
00:17:32 in another scenario where taxes were lower on capital and this is the very capital that we need
00:17:38 to actually improve living standards and wages for Canadians so this this is ultimately going
00:17:43 to be a detrimental policy to towards attracting investment and retaining it in Canada as well.
00:17:50 So is there a way to quantify exactly how much damage this will do or does that really depend
00:17:58 on does it depend on things we don't really know right now? I mean I think it's gonna be
00:18:02 tough to quantify exactly, you know, how this is going to affect it. But even when we look at
00:18:07 already the changes on business investment and productivity in Canada, you know, we've either
00:18:12 had stagnant or declining investment and productivity. And that has a big correlation
00:18:17 or causation from government policy. So when we're having increased regulations, high taxes,
00:18:24 and also massive uncertainty for businesses when you're consistently running deficits,
00:18:28 That creates uncertainty for businesses in the future that they could face future tax increases.
00:18:34 I mean, and this is already something that we're seeing now.
00:18:36 Capital gains taxes are essentially being used as a revenue generation tool to pay for a lot of the spending that the federal government is currently taking on.
00:18:45 So this is this is one of the many things that is just going to affect businesses and individuals as well and deter more investment in Canada.
00:18:52 one one point here that i i think is incredibly incredibly important to note is that a lot of the
00:18:59 criticism uh is coming from people that are not in that uber one percent category i think there's
00:19:05 a way to frame this where you think okay a capital gains tax increase this is about the uber wealthy
00:19:09 family doctors one example one group not an uber wealthy group yes they're upper middle class
00:19:14 sometimes beyond that uh but they've structured their businesses in a way where they have corporate
00:19:18 capital gains that they rely on. So there are a lot of middle class people that are pretty directly
00:19:24 affected by this. Yes, and I think it's very misleading to just say that, you know, the rich
00:19:29 are the only ones that are going to be paying the capital gains taxes. I mean, my colleagues did
00:19:33 analysis a few years ago, where they found if you remove kind of these one time capital gains
00:19:39 amounts, and just look at people's normal annual incomes, less than half of the capital gains
00:19:44 taxes that are paid in Canada are paid by people with $150,000 or more of annual income. So it's
00:19:51 very misleading to just say, oh, this is only going to impact the rich. It's going to impact
00:19:55 many Canadians that are not just in that wealthy income group as well. And we're already seeing,
00:20:01 you know, a lot of people coming out against this policy as well.
00:20:04 I know you alluded to this earlier as well, but we weren't exactly in a great place even before
00:20:09 this budget when it came to business investment. I mean, this was already something where we've
00:20:13 seen a fair bit of decline. I mean, really going back almost a decade, isn't it?
00:20:17 Exactly. I mean, we've been seeing this collapse in business investment really since
00:20:20 the end of 2014. We also have a situation now where our GDP per capita is, it was lower at
00:20:26 the end of 2023 than it was at the end of 2014. And then we had, you know, Carolyn Rogers from
00:20:32 the Bank of Canada raising the alarm about our productivity challenges in Canada. So we have
00:20:38 big problems going into the federal budget and now not only are we not addressing those problems
00:20:43 we're actually making a lot of the problems even worse in terms of innovation productivity
00:20:47 economic growth improving living standards for Canadians job creation all of these things that
00:20:53 we needed more of we're now likely going to get less of those due to some of the government
00:20:57 policies that are being undertaken currently. The piece in business in Vancouver Ottawa's
00:21:02 capital gains tax hike final nail in the business investment coffin thanks so much Jake good to talk
00:21:07 to you. Thanks for having me on. Thank you. And one point I'll raise on this, and this just came
00:21:12 out just shortly before I went on air, is that the federal government is partitioning the capital
00:21:18 gains section of the budget from the budget. So it's not even going to be in, it looks like from
00:21:23 the reports I read, in the main budget that MPs vote on and debate and discuss. It's going to be
00:21:28 its own thing. And I wondered, some people were saying on Twitter, oh, is this the government
00:21:33 backtracking on this? I say, no, no, no, quite the contrary. This is the government trying to make it
00:21:37 a standalone issue to force the conservatives to defend the evil, scary, uber-wealthy 1%, 0.74
00:21:43 to defend, I don't know, Galen Weston and Loblaws or something like that.
00:21:46 And they do that in a way because they simply do not understand or refuse to accept at least
00:21:52 all of the people that are looking at this saying, well, hang on, I want people to invest
00:21:57 in this country.
00:21:57 This isn't just about eating the rich, as the old saying goes.
00:22:01 Now, speaking of the budget, I'm convinced the budget's going to pass.
00:22:05 I'm convinced the NDP will eventually roll.
00:22:07 But I find it funny that even to this day, Jagmeet Singh cannot say whether he's going
00:22:12 to support the Liberal budget.
00:22:14 He's clearly going to, but he's not willing to say it.
00:22:17 This was a clip, I think, from yesterday of him just equivocating on this, despite having
00:22:22 previously told reporters he would unveil his stance on the budget at this media scrum.
00:22:28 Mr. Singh, media were told earlier today that you were going to stand here and tell us your
00:22:33 definitive position on whether or not you were going to support the budget then we were told
00:22:36 you weren't ready to make that decision what happened today why was that switch up so rapid
00:22:42 there are some outstanding elements that we're still waiting on there were some commitments
00:22:46 made and i want to be very clear i'm particularly concerned about the the two elements that i raised
00:22:51 just earlier the the disability benefit as well as jordan's principle on those two there were
00:22:56 some commitments made but i want some more clarity around those commitments again some progress has
00:23:01 been made but i wanted some more clarity before i can make my final before we make our final
00:23:05 decision clear what were those commitments uh without getting into the negotiations
00:23:14 in public i can say that there was some progress made there were some positive steps but there's
00:23:17 additional elements that required clarification and i need to hear that clarification before i
00:23:22 can move forward is it more money like is it are the feds offering more money for this well what's
00:23:28 clear to me, I can answer that directly, what's clear to me is that the federal
00:23:30 government is not signaling an intention to increase the amount so we're going to
00:23:34 keep on fighting on that. Where more progress is being made is around
00:23:38 ensuring that the clawback question is being addressed so we're looking to see
00:23:42 more commitments around that and we're going to continue to fight back though.
00:23:46 We disagree with them strongly on the fact that the amount is so small and
00:23:50 they're not seeming to move on that. We'll continue to fight back because we
00:23:54 know the people in the disability community have raised this concern. I
00:23:57 I know the Liberals have heard those same concerns, so we'll continue to fight for a more fair amount.
00:24:02 We're seeing some progress on the clawback question.
00:24:07 Oh, yes, I don't want to tell you we're really, really negotiating hard behind closed doors.
00:24:12 We're really getting all of this stuff from the, yeah, we keep fighting.
00:24:15 That's why he doesn't want to say his stance on the budget,
00:24:17 because he wants people to think that he's going back there and he's having this big old fight.
00:24:22 I forget, there was a movie where someone did that.
00:24:24 They go into a room and they're alone in the room and they just start like, you know, beating themselves up basically and making noises and grunts to sound like there's a fight.
00:24:32 And then they periodically pop their head out and be like, I've almost got him just, you know, I need a couple more minutes.
00:24:37 And then they go back in. And at a certain point, of course, the door opens and it's revealed that they're the only one in the room.
00:24:43 Pretty sure that's Jagmeet Singh doing his negotiations with Justin Trudeau.
00:24:47 He goes into the room, he grunts, he makes some noises, he screams a little bit, he does his best Trudeau impression.
00:24:52 and then he comes out and just dusts himself off
00:24:55 and he's put the double-breasted suit back on
00:24:58 and the button fell off
00:24:59 and everything's all askew on his pants
00:25:02 and he pulls the leg down and all of that
00:25:04 and then he just comes out and says,
00:25:06 all right, we really wore them down
00:25:08 and we've gotten them to agree to
00:25:10 and then he makes up something
00:25:11 that they had already agreed to.
00:25:14 Phil is asking if I'm talking about Ocean's 11.
00:25:16 No, Ocean's 11 did a little similar bit, I guess,
00:25:19 where they did like a fake fight in the room 0.91
00:25:21 but that wasn't the one.
00:25:22 And now just my colleagues are all just talking about movies instead of the show.
00:25:26 So I guess I should.
00:25:27 Oh, it's a common trope, Sean said.
00:25:29 Well, Sean's actually a film guy.
00:25:30 So I trust him on that.
00:25:32 So, all right, next episode, we'll have to find like a clip of that.
00:25:35 And we'll put that out as like a live shot of Jagmeet Singh negotiating with Justin Trudeau
00:25:39 over the budget.
00:25:40 But again, he's not saying that maybe he'll vote for it.
00:25:43 Maybe he won't.
00:25:44 Meanwhile, the liberals, I shared that clip a few moments ago of Justin Trudeau talking
00:25:49 about how misinformation is the only reason that you would basically not vote for him.
00:25:54 The interesting dynamic now is that the Liberals are still committing to this whole Alex Jones
00:26:00 white supremacy radicalism narrative, which is a difficult narrative to sell when you
00:26:06 guys are at 20 something percent and the Conservatives are at over 40 percent.
00:26:09 But nevertheless, the government's House leader, Stephen McKinnon, gave it the old college
00:26:14 try in the House of Commons.
00:26:15 Mr. Speaker, last week we saw the Leader of the Opposition once again visit with supporters of white supremacy, anarchy and misogyny.
00:26:26 This has been a regular occurrence.
00:26:29 He draws the admiration of people who dismiss the slaughter of children in schools.
00:26:34 The Leader of the Opposition now has 30 seconds to speak to this House and to Canadians once I sit down.
00:26:42 I ask him to clearly disavow the views of these dangerous people.
00:26:47 Will he do that?
00:26:55 Order.
00:27:03 The Honourable Leader of the Opposition.
00:27:09 I unequivocally disavow the guy who spent the first half of his adult life as a practicing
00:27:16 racist dressing up in blackface, and since I accepted the support of Hamas, and now he's
00:27:29 brought on the extremist and radical position of allowing legal drug use in playgrounds,
00:27:38 in hospitals, in coffee shops that has led to the mass death of our people.
00:27:44 Will he refuse the demand of Toronto to replicate the decriminalization nightmare in DCEP?
00:27:53 The Honourable Government House Leader.
00:28:04 Mr. Speaker, I'm sad to say the leader of the Conservatives, the opposition, has shown us his true colors.
00:28:11 He speaks without conviction and clarity on a question that should be very, very, very simple for him to address.
00:28:19 His silence speaks volumes.
00:28:21 This is not leadership, Mr. Speaker.
00:28:23 This is political cowardice.
00:28:28 So Paulyev has just gotten so comfortable doing the old blackface throwback. 0.95
00:28:33 anytime he gets these questions from the liberals and they still keep doing it. So I guess they
00:28:38 think it's working for them. But again, look at the polling numbers, read the room, and then we
00:28:42 can go back to that admonition Trudeau gave his caucus members the other day of, no, no, no,
00:28:46 we're not going to go up to the polls this year. Next year, I've got a plan. Next year, it's going
00:28:50 to work. So, and if you believe that, again, you've got that old oceanfront property in Saskatchewan
00:28:55 I've been raving about for quite some time. All right, well, let's talk about British Columbia.
00:29:00 I was in Vancouver for a very brief period of time last week and actually got the chance
00:29:05 to see my next guest speaking.
00:29:07 He's been following this issue in a way that very few in the media are, and I would say
00:29:13 having a little bit of success.
00:29:14 Now, British Columbia did a significant about face last week on this three-year decriminalization
00:29:20 project they have in their province, where for three years you cannot be criminally
00:29:25 charged for using drugs in most public spaces.
00:29:29 We're one year into the three years, and B.C. has had enough and said, no, no, no, please, please, we don't want to do this anymore.
00:29:35 They've now asked the federal government to essentially reverse this project, and the federal government is not yet committing to it.
00:29:43 This is a clip from Yara Sachs, who is the federal addictions and mental health minister, talking about how, well, this isn't even really a criminal issue.
00:29:53 I'd like to know what your reaction is to B.C. pulling back on the criminal.
00:29:56 Well, at this point in time, I met with Minister Whiteside in BC on Friday and we are reviewing the request to the exemption that they put forward to us.
00:30:06 We're sitting with Health Canada officials at this time, but we are wholeheartedly committed to continue to work with BC.
00:30:12 They requested this exemption from the federal government with a full plan for a suite of tools to address the illicit toxic drug supply and the overdose crisis.
00:30:21 our commitment is to keep this firmly in the frame that this is a health care
00:30:25 crisis and it is not a criminalization issue so sir BC has asked you to take
00:30:32 these actions and as you said you met with the minister how quickly can you
00:30:35 respond and give them what they're looking well considering I only received
00:30:39 the letter on Friday and today is Monday we are it is under review with officials
00:30:43 are you committed to decriminalization if another jurisdiction I know Toronto
00:30:47 for example has an application to allow for decriminalization but the
00:30:51 federal government be in the position given bc's experience to be granting more exemptions for
00:30:56 decriminalization so i think we need to go back to first principles of policy here in addressing the
00:31:01 illicit toxic drug supply and the overdose crisis we know as a federal government that we work with
00:31:05 jurisdictions on a case-by-case basis making sure we have a full suite of tools available
00:31:11 to help vulnerable populations that includes prevention that includes harm reduction that
00:31:15 includes treatment and that includes a full set of health considerations at this time
00:31:21 toronto's request is under review we look at this case by case it's not an apples to
00:31:25 apple situation and we continue to partner and work with restrictions to be clear you
00:31:28 would still decriminalization is still something you would be prepared to go forward with and
00:31:33 grant in a jurisdiction the overdose crisis as i've said before and i say again is a health
00:31:37 crisis issue it is not a criminal one not a criminal issue well british columbia is saying
00:31:44 well we kind of think it should be a criminal issue again and BC this is not some like ravaging
00:31:50 right-wing conservative government here this is the NDP government which has been one of the most
00:31:55 effectively drug permissive governments in the western world on this certainly in Canada and
00:32:02 Minister Yarra Sachs is now fine with just slow walking BC's request to get out of this and still
00:32:08 actively considering the request from Toronto this was another clip from that same scrum that
00:32:13 I found interesting when well let's just hear it from her words. What does this tell us about the
00:32:19 decriminalization tool though? I take your point it's a suite of tools but this is one of the tools
00:32:23 what's the lesson here about that? We are one year into a three-year pilot and we continue to work
00:32:28 with the BC government to evaluate. What went wrong in your mind because one year in BC is already
00:32:32 saying we got to pull back and it's too much so what went wrong here? One year in we're still
00:32:36 evaluating the data and working with BC. Thank you. Oh, it's just one year in. We don't have
00:32:44 the data yet. Okay. Well, do you want to do two more years of this, Minister Sachs? Is that
00:32:48 really what you think people need? Joining me is Adam Zeevo, founder and director of the Center
00:32:53 for Responsible Drug Policy. Adam, I know that there are people whose lives and livelihoods
00:32:59 are at stake here, but you must have a bit of I told you so with your work on this and now even
00:33:05 bc really seeing the error of its ways to some extent well so i mean the the failure of this
00:33:11 experiment in bc was completely predictable i actually wrote an article for the washington
00:33:15 examiner uh predicting everything that we saw and there's a clear reason for this there are a variety
00:33:21 of ways that you can decriminalize drugs and and some models of decriminalization are actually
00:33:26 fairly sensible and have had positive results in the past for example portugal but what bc did
00:33:32 is decriminalize drugs in the least responsible and laziest way possible.
00:33:38 So I'm going to go back to Portugal and explain what they did 0.95
00:33:40 and how that contrasts starkly with what we saw in Canada.
00:33:44 So Portugal, in the lead-up to decriminalization in the early 2000s,
00:33:49 they spent years investing into their treatment capacity
00:33:53 to ensure that anyone who wanted to get better could easily get into rehab.
00:33:57 Then, when they decriminalized drugs,
00:33:59 they didn't just let people do whatever they wanted,
00:34:01 like we saw in bc uh what they did is they created a parallel justice system where if you were caught
00:34:08 openly using drugs or possessing the small amounts you were sent to a non-criminal dissuasion
00:34:14 commission composed of a social worker a lawyer and a psychologist and that commission could use
00:34:20 punitive measures including fines to coerce you into treatment so what this does is it ensures
00:34:25 that there is some level of accountability for people's actions and that there is a mechanism
00:34:30 in place to push you into rehab which is very available bc did none of that uh didn't invest
00:34:36 in treatments they had no mechanism in place to divert people into into recovery they basically
00:34:41 said well if you know you destigmatize drugs that'll increase treatment uptake and there's
00:34:46 no real evidence behind that hypothesis which turned out to be spectacularly incorrect
00:34:50 yeah and i mean the fact that they're seeing this so early on i think is noteworthy because this was
00:34:57 a three-year trajectory. So they, I guess, assumed that it was going to take them three years to be
00:35:01 able to see if this was working or not. And now a year in, they're basically tapping out. Now,
00:35:06 maybe there is a genuine conversion here, or maybe they're realizing, hey, we've got an election
00:35:11 coming up in October, and this isn't working, or maybe a little bit of both. But do you think the
00:35:17 election is more of a driver to a recognition of wrong? Because they haven't been showing any real
00:35:22 contrition on their approach, even as recently as a couple of weeks ago.
00:35:25 I would say so, because when you look at the BC NDP, they've basically done the bare minimum to roll back decriminalization, safe supply.
00:35:35 You kind of have to force them to do a kicking and screaming.
00:35:37 For example, decriminalization was immediately disastrous.
00:35:41 And last year, throughout the summer of 2023, people expressed a lot of concerns about public disorder.
00:35:46 Only when those concerns became impossible to ignore did the provincial government try to amend decriminalization, recriminalize open drug use in public places through provincial law.
00:35:58 Then, of course, the Harm Reduction Nurses Association launched a lawsuit against the provincial government and managed to get an injunction, which prevented Bill 34, which was the law that recriminalized drugs at the provincial level, from being enforced.
00:36:12 And that injunction was granted in January.
00:36:14 uh so at that point at that point david eby could have asked the federal government to step in he
00:36:21 could have been proactive but instead he's like well you know what like it's in front of the
00:36:25 courts now what can we do and i think it's notable that he only went to the federal government now
00:36:31 when there is polling showing that support is consolidating behind the bc conservatives who
00:36:37 have a serious shot of displacing the BC NDP in the October election. Yeah, and I was wondering
00:36:45 if you could then go to the federal perspective on this and why the federal government is not
00:36:49 really being responsive, it seems like, to the same polling. I mean, we heard from
00:36:53 Minister Sachs in that clip I played a couple of moments ago, and they're basically not even
00:36:57 committing to granting BC's request, and they still have this active request from Toronto to
00:37:02 do the same thing. Well, I'm going to be really blunt here. Oh, sorry about the noise. I'm at
00:37:07 an airport. No, I appreciate you squeezing us in. Yeah. So so Yara Sachs, the Minister of
00:37:14 Addiction Mental Health is incompetent and an ideologue. And this is something, you know,
00:37:18 I know a lot of people who know her as well. She doesn't have a strong grasp of the evidence base.
00:37:24 She's unwilling to listen. She has a certain idea of what we should do in Canada. And she wants to
00:37:32 pursue that goal regardless of what we see on the ground. So I don't think we're going to see any
00:37:36 real change as long as she's the federal minister of addiction and mental health, given her background
00:37:41 and given her lack of knowledge on this issue. I mean, for God's sakes, she used to be a yoga 1.00
00:37:46 teacher. And her only qualifications here is that she had a nonprofit based on addiction and mental
00:37:52 health. That's how they try to sell it. And when you go to the website, you see that she was
00:37:56 advocating for mindfulness meditation. I'm sorry, we need someone who actually has experience on the
00:38:01 job running this file. Yeah, I think that's an incredibly valuable point here and or the very
00:38:06 least someone who's listening to the evidence and listening to the experts on this and is not so
00:38:11 driven by ideology. Well, it's a bit of a victory hopefully for the people of BC who I know have
00:38:16 been pushing for this and we'll see if the federal government ultimately goes along with it. Adam
00:38:20 Zeevo, National Post and more crucially on this file, the Center for Responsible Drug Policy. Good
00:38:26 to talk to you, Adam, and safe travels wherever you're going. Thanks for having me back on the
00:38:30 All right. Thanks, Adam. And that does it for us. That is dedication right there. Calling in from
00:38:36 the airport. And I'm actually amazed the Wi-Fi cooperated because, well, it rarely does. But
00:38:40 actually, to be honest, unrelated to anything, I was at the airport and I was trying to use Air
00:38:45 Canada's Wi-Fi. And there's this little board game. Well, it's not little. It's a big board
00:38:49 game I like called Diplomacy. And you can play it online. And when I tried to log on to the
00:38:54 Diplomacy website where I was playing, Air Canada said it was inappropriate content. So I couldn't
00:38:59 get my moves in in time. But anyway, that's my grievance. Of all the grievances with Air Canada,
00:39:05 probably one of the more minor ones. But nevertheless, we will talk to you tomorrow,
00:39:09 Canada's most irreverent talk show here on True North. This is The Andrew Lawton Show.
00:39:13 Thank you, God bless, and good day to you all. Thanks for listening to The Andrew Lawton Show.
00:39:18 Support the program by donating to True North at www.tnc.news.
00:39:29 We'll be right back.
00:39:59 We'll be right back.
00:40:29 Thank you.