Juno News - March 20, 2024


Poilievre pushes non-confidence motion in Trudeau over carbon tax

Topics
Mentioned
Canada’s open border immigration system is creating CHAOS Former mayor alleges corruption in Chestermere

Episode Stats


Length

48 minutes

Words per minute

167.59

Word count

8,074

Sentence count

251

Harmful content

Misogyny

1

sentences flagged

Toxicity

8

sentences flagged

Hate speech

19

sentences flagged


Summary

Summaries generated with gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ .

The Conservative Party of Canada is pushing a motion of non-confidence in Justin Trudeau's government, and a professor is under fire for stirring up anti-Israel debate among students. Plus, a look at the growing revolt against the carbon tax.

Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Topics generated with Qwen2.5-3B-Instruct.
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 Transcription by CastingWords
00:00:30 Thank you.
00:01:00 welcome to canada's most irreverent talk show this is the andrew lawton show brought to you by true
00:01:19 north hello and welcome to you all welcome back i should say we had a bit of an unannounced
00:01:30 unscheduled unforeseen disruption in the show yesterday but fear not all is well we are going
00:01:38 to hit you back and try to go full strength today to make up for lost time it is wednesday march
00:01:42 20th 2024 hope you're having a wonderful hump day i i think hump i don't think we hump day is
00:01:49 an explicit word. So I think we still get to keep the clean tag on Apple Podcasts here. But
00:01:54 nevertheless, we have a lot of ground to cover today. We'll be talking later on in the show
00:01:59 about that anti-Israel motion that was passed at the NDP's behest with support of almost all
00:02:05 liberals. We'll talk about that later on. And also a professor under fire for daring to stoke
00:02:11 debate among students. I know not something you can get away with in 2024. But let's begin with
00:02:18 the big news coming out of Ottawa today. The Conservative Party of Canada is pushing a motion
00:02:24 of non-confidence in Justin Trudeau's government. Yes, the government could fall tomorrow. It won't
00:02:31 because the NDP is going to continue to prop up the Liberals. But nevertheless, it is a bit of a
00:02:37 bold-sounding move from Conservative leader Pierre Paulyev, who unveiled it this morning
00:02:42 when he was giving a speech before his Conservative caucus. Take a look.
00:02:46 We're not going to put up with it anymore. We as Common Sense Conservatives are saying
00:02:52 no to Trudeau's 23% April Fool's Day increase. We are saying spike the hike until we Common
00:03:00 Sense Conservatives can axe the tax. The good news is Canadians are good and decent people.
00:03:13 They do not have to live like this.
00:03:16 They should not have to give up on the things that we all used to take for granted, like
00:03:21 affordable food and homes, all for the ego and incompetence of one man.
00:03:27 Life was not like this before Justin Trudeau.
00:03:29 It will not be like this after he is gone.
00:03:32 going to replace the hurt he has caused with the hope that Canadians need.
00:03:46 So now, today I am announcing that I am giving Trudeau one last chance to spike his hike.
00:03:52 One last chance, and only one more day.
00:03:56 Today I'm announcing that if Trudeau does not declare today an end to his forthcoming
00:04:01 tax increases on food, gas and heat, that we will introduce a motion of non-confidence
00:04:07 in the Prime Minister.
00:04:09 It will read that the House declare non-confidence in the Prime Minister and his costly government
00:04:15 for increasing the carbon tax by 23% on April 1st as part of his plan to quadruple the tax
00:04:21 while Canadians cannot afford to eat, heat, and house themselves,
00:04:26 and call for the House to be dissolved so Canadians can vote in a carbon tax election.
00:04:43 A carbon tax election.
00:04:51 And in that carbon tax election, there will be a very simple choice.
00:05:02 On the one hand, you will have the carbon tax coalition of the NDP and Justin Trudeau,
00:05:07 who take your money, punish your work, tax your food, double your housing costs, and
00:05:12 unleash crime and chaos in your community.
00:05:15 Or common sense conservatives, who will axe the tax, build the homes, fix the budget,
00:05:20 and stop the crime.
00:05:21 so he is saying there he wants to run on a cam well he wants to run in a carbon tax election
00:05:29 he wants that to be the ballot issue for canadians and increasingly it is looking like that is a very
00:05:34 popular position to take as i discussed on the show monday as we've discussed a lot of the last
00:05:40 few weeks the growing revolt against the carbon tax is a cross party lines now you've got the
00:05:45 liberal premier of newfoundland you've got conservative premiers you've got i mean even
00:05:50 Doug Ford, who's always been one to suck up to the federal liberals, he's come out against the
00:05:56 carbon tax. You also have beyond that, the Ontario Liberal Party, again, a party with a deep history
00:06:02 of spending a lot of money, of taxing a lot of money, saying there will be no carbon tax if
00:06:09 Bonnie Crombie, the new liberal leader in Ontario, has her way. So Justin Trudeau is very quickly
00:06:15 finding himself without a real coalition around this. And even a lot of his caucus colleagues,
00:06:20 You know, we're looking to him being like, come on, I'm already on thin ice with the conservatives doing so well in the polls.
00:06:26 How do you want me to sell this to my constituents?
00:06:29 And Trudeau has effectively said that he doesn't care.
00:06:32 That has largely been the position that the government has taken up on this.
00:06:36 Now, why it's important to talk about in this context here is because Pierre Paulyev knows that this isn't going to pass.
00:06:43 He knows that when push comes to shove, the liberals are going to rely on the support from the NDP.
00:06:47 The NDP is perennially broke. It cannot afford to go into another election.
00:06:53 And of course, Jagmeet Singh has not yet qualified for his pension.
00:06:57 That is not coming until early in 2025.
00:07:01 Now, one of the big challenges that I would bring up here for a lot of people
00:07:06 is that we are going to see this issue and this so-called pressure campaign
00:07:11 that Pierre Paulyev has announced kick up.
00:07:14 And I mean, the Liberals have so much invested in this program.
00:07:18 They have so much invested in this tax.
00:07:20 They don't want to show weakness.
00:07:21 They aren't going to show weakness.
00:07:23 So that means they will have to defend this carbon tax through the increase point on April 1st.
00:07:28 They're going to defend it through the next election.
00:07:30 And Canadians have just had enough of it.
00:07:33 But I wanted to talk about for a moment that carbon tax election question, that idea of a carbon tax election.
00:07:39 Because one may remember that in 2021, when Justin Trudeau was facing accusations that the 2021 election was unnecessary because it did come two years earlier than anticipated, he gave a rather impassioned plea for why Canadians should be comfortable with the election.
00:07:58 And I wanted to go back into memory lane and play a clip of that.
00:08:01 I think Canadians know that we are coming through this pandemic, that it's not over yet and people need to continue to step up and get vaccinated to keep themselves and their loved ones safe.
00:08:14 And that's certainly something I'm going to keep reminding people about every single day over the coming weeks, that people need to continue to do their part, protect their communities, protect each other, protect our kids who can't yet get vaccinated because they're under 12.
00:08:31 I think this is a moment where Canadians can and should be able to weigh in on what we're going through and on how we're going to build a society that is stronger and better and learns from the challenges we've all experienced and the sacrifices we've all made through the worst of this pandemic.
00:08:52 the pandemic is not over and we're going to be taking consequential decisions on
00:08:57 how we finish with this pandemic and I think it's Canadians right to weigh in on that
00:09:03 an election is an opportunity for Canadians to have a right to weigh in on the government's
00:09:11 conduct now I'm not going to compare COVID to the carbon tax one was far more disruptive and
00:09:16 destructive certainly in terms of the government's response to it than the other but the carbon tax
00:09:21 is destructive in its own way the carbon tax is putting businesses into untenable positions
00:09:27 especially businesses that only barely got through if they got through at all the pandemic and justin
00:09:33 trudeau when it came to covid and the polls were more favorable to him said okay well everyone has
00:09:38 a right to weigh in on this but now it's uh well now it's a bit of a different story now it's not
00:09:43 about canadians having a right to weigh in now it's about demagoguery and disruption and political
00:09:48 tricks and partisanship this is what the liberals say now when Pierre Polyev is coming out and
00:09:54 saying actually I believe that Canadians do have a right to weigh in I believe Canadians do have a
00:10:00 right to have a say so what has happened is Polyev has put the liberal government on notice he has
00:10:06 said to Justin Trudeau you've got one day and one day only to scrap the impending increase in the
00:10:13 carbon tax and then that is of course not going to do anything and then tomorrow the conservatives
00:10:18 will put forward their motion of non-confidence now i'll read the motion for you just because
00:10:23 it's probably not going to get a lot of coverage in the legacy media that the house declare
00:10:30 non-confidence in the prime minister and his costly government for increasing the carbon tax 23
00:10:36 on april 1st as part of his plan to quadruple the tax while canadians cannot afford to eat heat and
00:10:42 house themselves and call for the house to be dissolved so canadians can vote in a carbon tax
00:10:47 election. Now, if this motion does somehow pass, if the NDP are, they suddenly find a spine or
00:10:55 perhaps the NDP is homesick tomorrow and the Bloc Québécois votes with the Conservatives, again,
00:11:00 strange things happen. But if for whatever reason this motion passes, yeah, the government will
00:11:05 fall. It will cease to have the confidence in the House. There will be no choice but to have an
00:11:10 election and Canadians will be going to the polls. And the carbon tax probably would be at this point
00:11:16 the ballot issue because it's one of the most demonstrable and clear ways that government can
00:11:22 control the cost of living. And this is the thing. It is easy to point fingers in every direction
00:11:29 when you are dealing with inflation. You can say, oh, grocery store CEOs are greedy. And you can say,
00:11:35 oh, but the government, oh, but the banks, oh, but the central bank, oh, but Tiff Macklem and the
00:11:38 governor of the Bank of Central Canada and all of that. And yeah, everyone has played a role in this
00:11:43 to some extent. There are larger economic trends that aren't in someone's control. But the carbon
00:11:49 tax is the insult to injury. It is the fuel to the fire. I can probably come up with another
00:11:54 a few cliches if you need, but I think you get the point right now. So it is a mechanism by which
00:11:59 government could offer very simple, very tangible relief to Canadians. And even that to the federal
00:12:05 liberals is not something they're interested in doing. Again, provincial liberals get it. Provincial
00:12:10 liberals are far more connected to their constituents right now than the federal liberals
00:12:15 led by Justin Trudeau are, which is why you have Andrew Fury in Newfoundland, Bonnie Crombie
00:12:20 in Ontario, and basically even the liberals in New Brunswick, I forget the name of the
00:12:25 liberal leader there, but the opposition in New Brunswick came out late last week and said
00:12:32 something very similar. So you don't just have unanimity among seven of 10 premiers, but you have
00:12:38 basically crossed the aisle unanimity from government and opposition in a majority of
00:12:44 provinces here, left and right, with just three holdouts. Quebec, which has a very expensive
00:12:49 cap-and-trade system. BC, which is like they had a carbon tax before it was even cool. And I don't
00:12:55 know that it's ever been cool to have one, but you know what I mean. BC had one even before the
00:12:58 federal government required it. And Manitoba, which has been very wishy-washy. I think Wab 0.95
00:13:03 Canoe is like trying to suck up to the federal government so he doesn't want to make his 0.89
00:13:07 criticism known publicly, but he's played very coy about privately whether he has raised any issue 0.69
00:13:13 at all. So we will keep on this, but keep your eyes peeled tomorrow. Again, sometimes weird
00:13:18 things happen in politics, probably not going to pass, but you never know. Well, just as taxes are
00:13:24 inevitable, so too is a clapdown on debate and dissent in the Academy in Canada. You may have
00:13:31 seen this fantastic demonstration that takes place. It's published all over the internet by
00:13:37 Peter Boghossian. It's called Spectrum Street Epistemology. And I have one clip of it just
00:13:44 to get a sense of what this looks like that you can watch here.
00:13:48 Hey, we're going to do some Spectrum Street Epistemology. And my first claim to you is as
00:13:54 follows i am optimistic that peace will be achieved in the israeli-palestinian conflict
00:14:03 five four three two one move
00:14:07 okay why are you not optimistic because i have relatives who my grandfather was originally
00:14:18 from the middle east he's a lebanese um i don't think people in the west or people who have not
00:14:24 lived in that uh particular part of the world understand the depths of hatred that those groups
00:14:30 of people feel for one another particularly the arab slash muslim world towards the israelis 1.00
00:14:36 okay and why are you neutral well i hate to sound like jordan peterson here but it depends what you
00:14:41 mean by peace i mean eventually the fighting will stop you mean though it could stop over millions
00:14:46 of corpses yes so is that peace if that's peace then yeah i mean eventually peace like on a 10
00:14:53 15 20 year time scale the fighting will stop so i strongly agree but i don't know if that's what
00:14:59 you meant by peace sorry to be a no no no it's always good to to ask for clarity in terms all
00:15:04 right i'm gonna say another claim and you walk to the other the line the israeli the current
00:15:09 israeli-palestinian conflict 2023 has a more than 50 chance that it will lead to world war three
00:15:16 watch up mate you both disagree why do you disagree that is just one snippet now uh those
00:15:28 two are francis foster and constantin kishin who are the co-hosts of triggernometry which is a very
00:15:34 great podcast out of the uk uh now constantin he didn't do it right you're supposed to not even
00:15:40 think you're supposed to just go somewhere i actually as it happened uh played that game
00:15:45 with Peter Boghossian in London, England back in November.
00:15:50 I was there for the ARC forum that Jordan Peterson was holding
00:15:53 and Bruce Party played with me as well.
00:15:57 He was on there.
00:15:57 James Lindsay was on there, but I couldn't find the video of it.
00:16:01 They never published it.
00:16:01 So I guess we weren't sufficiently epistemological
00:16:04 to make the final cut
00:16:06 or maybe they're keeping it in the can for something.
00:16:08 But anyway, it's a great game.
00:16:10 It forces you to confront your gut instincts
00:16:12 about a particular issue.
00:16:15 and then it forces you to engage with other people.
00:16:17 One of the questions that Peter will ask participants is,
00:16:20 okay, what would it take to move you
00:16:22 from agree to strongly agree?
00:16:25 Or what would it take to move you away from neutral?
00:16:27 And you end up having very spirited debates and discussions.
00:16:31 And it was a lot of fun,
00:16:32 but in the University of 2024,
00:16:35 this is just not the type of thing you can get away with.
00:16:38 As learned by Professor Lee Revers,
00:16:40 who's an associate professor
00:16:41 at the Institute of Management and Innovation
00:16:44 at the University of Toronto, Mississauga, was reprimanded by his department chair for daring
00:16:50 to do this with students. Lee, it's good to talk to you. Thanks so much for coming on the show today.
00:16:56 Well, thanks for having me. It's great to be here.
00:16:58 So, I mean, what is the value in this? What is the pedagogical value of this that you were going
00:17:05 for in the first place? And then we'll get into what happened.
00:17:08 Yeah, well, because I really think university is a holistic experience. You know, I think students
00:17:13 should go and not just study their subject but also learn how to think so I'm on a committee or
00:17:20 I was I should say on a committee which sorts it prioritizes doing social events for students so
00:17:26 this was one of the events and we were all asked to come up with an activity and I thought what
00:17:31 Peter Boghossian was doing was terrific and I've played this game with colleagues and and students
00:17:36 in the past and it's a lot of fun as you pointed out with that brilliant clip there so we did this
00:17:42 but of course it led to complaints I mean students feel uncomfortable I think you know
00:17:48 there are quite a few young people at the university now especially after the pandemic
00:17:53 and I would describe them as the young identitarians right so these are the people that
00:17:59 you know they enter a room and in this case if they find that there may be people in the room
00:18:05 that don't hold the same opinion that they hold then they make a fuss about it and like to
00:18:12 complain and that's exactly what happened so quite disappointing really what were the the
00:18:18 oh i think we lost you but it appears you're back what statements did you use when you
00:18:30 set set this game up right well i thought you know i'd i'd look at the overton window and see
00:18:36 and that's just the window of like the discussion points that people are reasonably discussing and
00:18:41 started with something fairly simple such as vegetarians are morally superior to omnivores
00:18:50 right so what do you think to that and and a countdown and they moved to the lines and so we
00:18:56 had some spirited discussion because some people you know think yes and others no and we moved on
00:19:02 and of course it gets more interesting as it gets a little bit more political I was actually told
00:19:07 my colleagues don't get too political and by that I thought I'd avoid things like the Trudeau carbon
00:19:12 tax that you were discussing earlier but right but we went on to things like professor Jordan
00:19:20 Peterson requires media training which I thought was topical but according to my department chair
00:19:27 that's outside of the Overton window that's not acceptable students aren't prepared they might
00:19:35 have a manic episode for instance by being challenged and feeling uncomfortable so you
00:19:41 know and those were just warm-up claims so you can see how it might have got out of hand in that
00:19:48 sense I mean what I found to be honest with you were the students were really engaged when I
00:19:52 started with a vegetarian thing I had only a couple of students playing and by the end of this
00:19:58 we had about 15 to 20 people playing it was not enough room on the lines for you know because
00:20:04 people actually enjoy doing this well and they were they were active in it too like one of the
00:20:09 examples you gave here western science is hampered by a political bias you had a student who identified
00:20:14 as muslim and a woman of color who stood in the strongly agree line and explained uh things that
00:20:20 i disagree with and that you disagreed with about science but but she was clearly selling her 0.85
00:20:25 position on this which is the point of it so i'm curious where the complaints came from did students
00:20:30 not like that they were being forced to expose their beliefs or did they not like that certain
00:20:36 questions were being put up as being debatable i think a bit of both uh i think students who
00:20:42 don't want to express an opinion on any particular claim because they haven't seen the claims at the
00:20:47 beginning um so they stay on the neutral line and i think that's reasonable uh you know you don't
00:20:52 have to express an opinion or you can stop playing at any point um but i think some people just don't
00:20:58 like the idea that there are disputes i mean once i got to men can become women uh you know i think
00:21:06 which i think is a very reasonable discussion topic that's now everywhere on the internet and
00:21:12 in the media um i think some folks think that isn't up for discussion at all there is no dispute
00:21:18 um but i find that hard to believe because i keep hearing uh from both sides on that so there are
00:21:25 two sides to that discussion. There are different opinions and differing ideas. And so my job was
00:21:31 simply to be as neutral as possible and not express my own beliefs at all. And that was one
00:21:38 that your chair very clearly said should never have happened. That question never should have
00:21:43 been put out there. Yeah, that's right. I mean, if I wanted to do that, I can do it on the university
00:21:48 property on the campus but i would need to um kind of flag that up first so that people could
00:21:57 be suitably prepared now now my view first of all the game is no fun if you you know what the claims
00:22:03 are going to be part of the fun is yeah but it relies on that gut instinct of just immediately
00:22:08 stand on because and i'll say just for my own part when i played it some of my answers surprised me
00:22:13 which you may think is kind of silly because you're the one that's choosing it but when you
00:22:17 when you don't think about something, when you just are drawn to a mat, it actually is a very
00:22:22 useful self-exploration tool, I think. Absolutely it is. I find the same, which is why I like
00:22:28 hosting, just to see how people respond themselves. And, you know, even people I'm
00:22:33 inclined to agree with, but I don't express that when I ask them, why do you stand there and tell
00:22:38 me why you're standing on that line? They have to think quite hard because of course they weren't
00:22:43 expecting uh the follow-up uh in that sense i mean they have to think and that is the whole point
00:22:49 of doing this right and think about the claims take a position and then try to back up uh your
00:22:57 stance uh preferably with evidence i mean a lot of people say well i just feel um i don't think
00:23:03 that commands a lot of of sway you know from the audience necessarily i think obviously and we want
00:23:09 students to be better at this right because in life uh you know later on there's going to be
00:23:15 the opportunity to debate these things whether it's around a dinner table or maybe it's at work
00:23:19 um and if they haven't really been governed by the skills they haven't acquired the skills
00:23:25 uh university then why are we here um so so for me anyway i mean i teach chemistry normally so
00:23:31 this is not something that i would do in a chemistry class um but we're hearing a lot about
00:23:36 this at the university as you know i mean i've been asked to decolonize my chemistry and i'm
00:23:40 working towards possibly a way of doing that but that could be quite tricky um so my view is we
00:23:47 need to let students make up their own minds and provide an environment where they can actually
00:23:52 have fun doing this and to reassure them that they can take any position they want
00:23:58 one of the the challenges that that i have always wondered about here and and i don't know if you
00:24:02 have any insights on this or not do you believe that your department chair is a true believer in
00:24:08 what was being meted out to you or do you think that there is just that governance of fear and
00:24:14 the governance by the administrators that are forcing people that don't really think all of
00:24:19 what you did was unreasonable to kind of pretend it was unreasonable yeah i think i think amongst
00:24:26 colleagues that they fall into two camps i mean i'm in stem so i think the inherent bias in stem
00:24:33 is this is all rather silly and a bunch of nonsense let's concentrate on doing some science
00:24:39 um i think i think that's very clear but i think people are afraid to express that opinion 0.80
00:24:44 and then there are some uh who seem to be uh the ones that get promoted to positions of
00:24:51 of, you know, power and influence at the university and the administration, who really have drunk
00:24:57 the Kool-Aid, actually. I find it surprising. They're usually not the hard scientists, I would
00:25:04 say. You know, we all believe in the Enlightenment and the idea that you back up all your ideas with
00:25:11 evidence. And I'm a progressive, but I would call myself a rational progressive. But there
00:25:18 are some colleagues here I think they really do believe this, that they hook
00:25:23 line and sinker actually. So I think those are the ones that will be promoted
00:25:27 to chairships, to be deans and ultimately to be presidents and
00:25:32 principals of the University and I think we've seen that. I mean we only have to
00:25:36 look to Claudine Gay and across the border to see that that has in fact
00:25:41 proven true and I don't think Canada is immune at all. So and U of T is the top
00:25:46 university in terms of science right so even here and one of the things i mean obviously it's a
00:25:52 social event and it's light-hearted and i think you fused academia with a game and with something
00:25:58 social pretty well i i was reading your national post op-ed about this which i would encourage
00:26:04 everyone tuned in to do as well and if you take away your contribution to this i i want to read
00:26:09 your paragraph about what was left there were jigsaws arranged on a raid on one table a professor
00:26:15 playing a variant of snap with students at another and on a third no word of a lie were coloring
00:26:20 sheets and crayons aliens arriving from vega would be forgiven for mischaracterizing the event as a
00:26:26 daycare for human 20-something so you can't have any game that is more intellectually provocative
00:26:35 than coloring or a card game with university students in 2024 is basically what i take away
00:26:41 from this well well when i walked into that room i mean i'd made some preparations to have a big tv
00:26:47 screen and you know pa system and all of this set up i couldn't believe my eyes right i mean i saw
00:26:54 a table and i genuinely thought what why are the crayons on that table this must be for this must
00:27:00 be for the the you know something else uh preceding event yeah we're doing the day camp early this
00:27:05 year exactly which we do at the university in the summer um and so i i just couldn't understand this
00:27:13 at all i mean this is not what university is about i mean these people these young people who
00:27:19 i care a great deal about i mean they can vote right so these these are these they're the age
00:27:26 of majority and they'll be making decisions about the future of canada will they not so uh yeah i
00:27:32 find it shocking genuinely shocking quite upsetting really that that was even countenanced as an
00:27:37 alternative activity my feeling is what i did was the only adult activity going on in the room
00:27:44 um and actually i think uh you know people voted with their feet when they came to play i mean i
00:27:50 not my fault that some people don't like the claims um but they can absent themselves you
00:27:55 know but i was i was told the chair told me this was transphobia essentially um the the you know
00:28:02 she didn't say that i i i should clarify um that the complaints indicated that it was transphobic
00:28:09 uh for example to say um safeguarding of children is more important than gender ideology excuse me
00:28:19 you've got you've got a cameo a cameo on the screen now well welcome uh i mean so basically
00:28:25 though i mean your cat actually provides a natural segue here because essentially the only things
00:28:29 you'd be allowed to do uh would be you know cats are better than dogs agree or disagree yeah exactly
00:28:36 cats are better than dogs it would be a perfect claim but it's not terribly exciting is it it
00:28:42 doesn't require great it comes down to personal choice very subjective i like cats other people
00:28:47 like dogs great um there's not a lot of engagement to be had there and i think you know my favorite
00:28:53 of course which is my chair's favorite is why not stick to uh pineapple belongs on pizza uh and i
00:29:00 know that was literally the example they gave of you could do this but only if this is your
00:29:05 this is your question or your claim yeah yeah otherwise get it run past some politically uh
00:29:10 you know sort of sensitive group that you know that would kind of decide you know somebody is
00:29:15 making these decisions uh i thought i had academic freedom in fact according to my uh
00:29:22 union which is university of toronto faculty association according to them i am supposed to
00:29:28 have academic freedom not just in the teaching i do in a classroom but but also in all the
00:29:33 activities that i engage on the campus with students so that would include this and you
00:29:39 know i didn't get to the end of the session because a colleague actually told me to stop
00:29:43 and they just thought it was getting really really too much and that's a shame because i
00:29:48 had some other claims i was quite excited to to present and i didn't get to to show those um but
00:29:55 yeah i i i think this is problematic uh for any serious university uh there is an organization
00:30:03 um at the university now a working group that's all about uh encouraging civil discourse on the
00:30:10 campus so i think they really want to uh to try to turn the boat around a little bit so i'm very
00:30:15 hopeful but it it's definitely something i think stem we and stem are concerned about all right
00:30:23 well worst case scenario you'll have to team up with uh peter bogosian and start doing it just
00:30:27 outside of the university perimeter and maybe you'll avoid the the sanctions then all right
00:30:32 well fascinating display i'm sorry you went through this but i'm glad you're speaking out
00:30:35 about it the way you are professor lee revers thank you thank you very much all right uh yeah
00:30:41 it was a fun game. I hope, uh, Peter Brugosi inputs mine, uh, in Bruce parties. And, uh,
00:30:45 there was another guy, I think he was from Australia whose name I didn't catch and James
00:30:49 Lindsay. We had lots of fun with it. And I believe what was our, our, cause it starts with
00:30:53 one core claim and then you, you do derivative claims. And I think the core claim, it was
00:30:58 something to do with what the greatest, I wasn't globalism is the greatest threat to freedom.
00:31:04 It was something, something along those lines. Um, and we had, well, anyway, you'll, no one
00:31:08 ever know now so uh but maybe we need to take uh spectrum street epistemology uh canadian and do a
00:31:14 true north version of it sometime harrison harrison faulkner yeah something you can do we can even
00:31:19 splurge for some of those floor mats that people can stand on ahead around toronto and uh take this
00:31:24 take this up all right we have to turn from what is a lighter subject to a far more serious one
00:31:30 uh there was this week a debate in the house of commons over a motion from the ndp
00:31:35 which originally called for recognition of Palestinian statehood
00:31:41 but was watered down somewhat, not hugely
00:31:44 to a number of other claims that have become commonplace
00:31:48 from many activists in the anti-Israel set
00:31:51 but some people were not convinced by these amendments
00:31:54 which the Liberals and New Democrats trumpeted as some great cooperative effort
00:31:58 one of those people that was not convinced was Anthony Howe's father
00:32:02 a Liberal member of Parliament who himself is Jewish
00:32:05 from Montreal, who gave an impassioned speech opposing the motion.
00:32:10 Mr. Speaker, I am a Canadian, I am a Jew, and I am a Zionist. I am proud to have been born in
00:32:17 this country. I am proud that my family came here in the 19th century and helped build this country.
00:32:21 My family members fought in the World War I and World War II. We are part of Canada and lucky to
00:32:27 be so. I've represented Canada in swimming internationally. I've represented Canada as
00:32:31 parliamentarian, and there's no place in the world I want to be other than in
00:32:35 Canada. The Jewish community, of which I am part, is a religious community that has
00:32:40 existed for thousands of years, but we're also a people. And we, since we've been
00:32:45 here in 1760, have helped build this country. We got enormous opportunities,
00:32:50 more than we've received anywhere else in history. But we've also, in academia, in
00:32:55 law, in medicine, in physics, in science, in sports, in journalism, we have helped
00:33:00 build this country. And 95% of Canadian Jews are Zionists. Zionism means we 0.93
00:33:08 believe that we have a right to have one Jewish state in our ancestral homeland.
00:33:13 Jews are indigenous to Israel. And we have had a history where Jews have faced
00:33:20 persecution in every country in the world. We were expelled from England in
00:33:25 1290. We were expelled from Spain and Portugal in the 1490s. We faced the
00:33:30 crusades where people were killed. We were put in ghettos throughout Europe. We faced the Holocaust.
00:33:36 Jews were expelled from Arab lands in the 40s, 50s, 60s, and 70s. And we needed one place where
00:33:44 every Jew in the world knew if things went wrong in their country that they could go. And that is 0.87
00:33:49 Israel and that's what Zionism means. So when I get horrible, horrible threats and emails saying
00:33:56 I'm a dirty Zionist instead of a dirty Jew. 1.00
00:33:59 That's what Zionism means. 1.00
00:34:00 So in all these demonstrations around the country,
00:34:02 outside of synagogues and outside of Jewish schools
00:34:05 and outside of Jewish community centres, 0.95
00:34:07 where people are screaming about how horrible Zionists are, 0.87
00:34:11 well, I am a Zionist. 0.66
00:34:12 And I'm not embarrassed or ashamed of being a Zionist.
00:34:20 And Canadian Jews should not have to live
00:34:23 through what we're living through right now.
00:34:25 my community is terrified that went on for about seven and a half more minutes i would encourage
00:34:34 you if you're interested to watch the whole thing he posted it on his uh social media page he posted
00:34:39 it i think i saw it on x but he posted it elsewhere and uh then he sat down and eventually
00:34:46 when that vote took place there were just two of his liberal colleagues who joined him one was
00:34:52 Marco Mendicino, who was sitting, I think, right beside him. The other was Ben Carr from Winnipeg.
00:34:57 Even Yara Sachs, who is the Minister of Mental Health and Addictions, a Jewish woman from a 1.00
00:35:03 Jewish, well, very heavily Jewish riding in Toronto, was last week holding hands with Mahmoud Abbas
00:35:10 in the West Bank, and this week voted against the Jewish community of Canada by supporting 0.67
00:35:17 that resolution. Now, imagine you saw the emotion, you heard the emotion in Anthony
00:35:23 Howe's father as he gave those remarks. He sat down and then everyone around him pretty much
00:35:29 voted against him. Voted against him. And I mean that. They voted against him as a Jew. They voted 0.98
00:35:34 against him as a member of the Liberal Party with a conscience on the question of Israel and what
00:35:40 the Jewish community in this nation is facing. And I wanted to share another clip of him in the House
00:35:47 of Commons foyer in which he seems to be very well aware of what happened after he sat down
00:35:53 and MPs voted. Is this the first time you're actually kind of reflecting on your role within
00:35:59 this party? I mean, this has been going on for a number of months now. There's been tensions in
00:36:03 Canada rising in 1970s and you've seen your government struggle to sometimes or, you know,
00:36:08 come up with a position that satisfies everybody. And you've kind of been at the forefront of this,
00:36:12 but is this the first time you're actually kind of reflecting on your future here?
00:36:17 I think it's the first time in my parliamentary career that I've had a reflection like this where I truly felt last night that a line had been crossed.
00:36:29 When my party members got up and cheered and gave a standing ovation to Heather McPherson and the NDP, I started reflecting as to whether or not I belonged.
00:36:41 And I will let you know further how I feel over the coming days. For the moment, I'm still there.
00:36:47 that was a very strong language from someone who's typically been a team player with his party
00:36:54 joining me on the line now is robert walker who's the assistant director for honest reporting canada
00:37:00 robert good to have you on the show here i mean we heard that speech from anthony house father in
00:37:05 which he takes aim at what is one of the most i'd say dishonest portrayals we see that that you
00:37:14 could separate zionism from judaism and this is what we see in a lot of the media coverage what
00:37:19 we see in a lot of the protests i wanted to get your thoughts on this well um thank you andrew
00:37:24 for the uh for the question and for covering this because i think this is an angle that
00:37:27 this term this concept has been completely abused and and and bastardized uh by uh by the far left
00:37:35 and those who seek to demonize uh israel and the jewish people writ large which is we talk about
00:37:40 this indigenous movement is that Zionism is the indigenous movement of the Jewish people,
00:37:45 that the, you know, this return to their ancestral homeland where they have lived for three
00:37:49 millennia, practicing the same faith, speaking the same language, walking in the same steps.
00:37:55 But if you listen, of course, to, you know, ideological extremists today in Canada and
00:38:00 indeed around the world, you know, they are this colonialist people who have invaded and 0.93
00:38:06 kicked out the locals um and it's it's not just an inversion of reality uh it is a moral outrage
00:38:12 and i mean one of the things that i i think is so difficult here is that you have this language
00:38:19 of colonial resistance that's being appropriated and applied to what's happened in the middle east
00:38:26 and parties like the ndp will wear their kafias in the house of commons as they are are voting
00:38:31 on this and they pretend this is benign. Well, it certainly isn't because I think what we've seen
00:38:38 is not just the legitimization, if you will, of Hamas terrorism. And then that was pointed out
00:38:46 by a number of parliamentarians who said that although the initial extreme motion as proposed
00:38:54 by the NDP was a unilateral calling for the government to unilaterally recognize the Palestinian
00:38:59 a state, which of course, anybody with a pair of eyes can look and say, listen, if October 7th
00:39:03 hadn't happened, if Hamas's October 7th attacks hadn't happened, then very clearly that wouldn't
00:39:07 have happened. So it's very clearly a reward for terrorism. And if you're sitting there
00:39:11 and you're a Hamas leader, whether sitting on top of billions of dollars in Qatar,
00:39:17 whether you're sitting underneath the tunnels of Gaza, you're sitting there thinking,
00:39:21 my goodness, you know, the more terrorism that we perpetrate, the more legitimacy we get,
00:39:26 the more legitimacy we get and the more credibility we get from certain individuals in Canada,
00:39:32 and perhaps worst yet, was that this wasn't just, you know, voted on by the NDP, but of course by
00:39:38 the governing party of this country, the Liberal Party. And I think that sends a very, very powerful
00:39:44 message, not just to Hamas, but indeed to Jewish Canadians and indeed to the majority of moral
00:39:49 Canadians who look and say, you know, you're allowed to have, this is a free country and we
00:39:53 have a diversity of opinion and you're allowed to believe one thing or another, but this legitimizes
00:39:59 not just Hamas terrorism, but indeed the scourge and rise of anti-Jewish hate here, which is of
00:40:05 course not just a threat to Jewish Canadians, but to any Canadians who values the peace and security
00:40:11 and order that we've come to value in this country. And when we have a government, when we
00:40:17 have parliamentarians who vote in favor of a motion which glorifies and which excuses Hamas
00:40:23 terrorism uh that's that's an extraordinarily dangerous precedent well and then for people that
00:40:29 are not as people that don't spend their lives immersed in in this issue and pour over all the
00:40:35 coverage like certainly you do with your work and me to to some extent although i'd probably say not
00:40:39 as much as you do they they are easily duped by no fault of their own by certain language and
00:40:45 ceasefire i think is a great example of this because a ceasefire if you're just someone that
00:40:49 doesn't like that war is taking place this sounds like a very uh virtuous thing why is that not the
00:40:55 case well everybody wants in theory a ceasefire at one point the question is under what conditions
00:41:00 hamas wants a ceasefire once the jews are dead uh israel wants a ceasefire of courts once hamas 0.74
00:41:06 is defeated and the hostages are returned so everybody's talking about a ceasefire but the
00:41:09 major issue that we see among those the extremists who talk about a ceasefire is very rarely uh that
00:41:16 really there's a lot of context here, which is of course we want a ceasefire, but a ceasefire that
00:41:21 keeps Hamas in power is ultimately nothing less than a capitulation. I really, I shudder to think 0.57
00:41:27 of what this dialogue would look like 80 years ago during World War II. You know, people were
00:41:33 talking about facing this scourge of, you know, the Nazi Germany and saying, well, ceasefire, 0.78
00:41:38 ceasefire. Ultimately, I think of anybody who looks at, you know, the Hamas casualty numbers,
00:41:43 And this was pointed out last week by a statistician of the Wharton School who said that Hamas's numbers are essentially statistically impossible, that Hamas's numbers are fake, that Israel takes steps unprecedented in modern history to minimize civilian casualties.
00:41:59 And ultimately, most importantly, this war could be over in five minutes if Hamas surrenders the hostages and surrenders its leaders. 0.59
00:42:07 And until we have parliamentarians and protesters who refuse to call for that, I think it's very clear that anything short of that is ultimately a capitulation, not just of Israel, but every value that we as Canadians hold dear. 0.64
00:42:21 And I think that what we've seen from the demonstrations, whether they're blocking hospitals, attacking synagogues, blocking roads, preventing G7 leaders from speaking, is that we can have a small minority of people.
00:42:34 And as long as they're loud, they can have a bigger impact than 10 million people who are quiet.
00:42:39 And I think this is perhaps the most chilling thing is that 100 loud people can have a greater voice than 10 million quiet people.
00:42:46 And this should be really the the message for all of us is to say, you know, we I read on Twitter and acts and the comments and people are angry and they're upset.
00:42:54 And they're saying, listen, even if we don't all have the same view here, how dare you try to, you know, you see the polls showing the liberals 15, 20 points ahead.
00:43:02 People are upset. People are angry. But rather than identifying and addressing the issues that are of concern to Canadians, we have this kind of politics of division and people can be upset.
00:43:14 But ultimately, unless we speak out and we demand better from elected officials, from the news media, who then give unflattering, pardon me, flattering coverage to this kind of content, ultimately, we're going to see more of the same.
00:43:26 The silent majority at some point needs to become the vocal majority.
00:43:29 Otherwise, it really doesn't matter what the majority think.
00:43:33 I'd be remiss to not ask you as well, Robert, about this La Presse cartoon this morning that was published.
00:43:40 I don't even want to put the image up, but it depicted, you know, look, editorial cartoons are never flattering.
00:43:46 We know that. But this depicted Netanyahu as a bloodsucking vampire, which is itself an old anti-Semitic trope here.
00:43:55 And I believe they've pulled the cartoon, but only sort of in the face of backlash here.
00:44:01 But my goodness, I mean, you'd never see this level of stereotype in a cartoon on any other group in Canadian media.
00:44:08 No, and nor should you. I mean, this cartoon, of course, borrowed from the 1922 silent German film, which extremely anti-Semitic, certainly in commentators today, depicted Jews as, first of all, as a stereotypical, you know, hook-nosed Jew, depicted Jews as being carriers of disease, as bloodsuckers of virtuous young Christian children. 0.52
00:44:33 And, of course, this is imagery that was gladly and enthusiastically then mimicked and taken by the Nazis. 0.64
00:44:39 So it's not only that we had this columnist decide to use this imagery, A,
00:44:45 then he uses it to depict perhaps the most famous or the most prominent Jew in the world,
00:44:51 the prime minister of the world's only Jewish state.
00:44:53 That's crazy enough.
00:44:54 But then at what point did the leadership of La Presse, a prominent French-language newspaper,
00:45:01 see no problem with this whatsoever?
00:45:02 So at best case scenario, we have here profound ignorance, which honestly beggars belief is how these people were in journalism at all.
00:45:10 That's one. And that's best case scenario. Worst case scenario was the embrace of vocal Nazi like right caricature of Jews. 0.52
00:45:19 I mean, it's just it's obscene here and it's akin to sort of describing, you know, any other group with the kind of cartoons that we would expect, you know, would remain in the dustbin of history.
00:45:31 And so it's great that they've removed it. But honestly, it's like whack-a-mole here. And I think the more that we see the legitimization of anti-Semitism or really the excusal of it, when politicians stay quiet, news media organizations stay quiet, it becomes normalized, it becomes excused.
00:45:47 And it becomes really normalized because those who seek to propagate this kind of stuff become emboldened, whether it's putting out anti-Semitic cartoons, whether it's blocking roads, synagogues, highway overpasses, or whether it's passing legislation or motions in the House of Commons, which are a one-sided defamation of a democratic country, all while downplaying really a genocidal Islamic terrorist organization. 0.55
00:46:12 So I think that we as a society, you know, we hear from our prime minister that this isn't who Canadians are, but ultimately we're seeing that that's exactly what Canadians are and what Canada is.
00:46:21 And I think that it's high time. Five months ago was high time.
00:46:24 But now that the silent majority speak out and really say absolutely no more.
00:46:28 This absolutely cannot continue a day longer.
00:46:31 Very well said. Robert Walker, Associate Director of Honest Reporting Canada.
00:46:35 Thank you for coming on.
00:46:37 Thanks, Andrew.
00:46:38 Thank you. That does it for us for today.
00:46:40 We'll be back tomorrow with more of Canada's Most Irreverent Talk Show to close out the week.
00:46:44 This is True North.
00:46:45 Thank you.
00:46:46 God bless and good day to you all.
00:46:49 Thanks for listening to The Andrew Vaughn Show.
00:46:51 Support the program by donating to True North at www.tnc.news.
00:47:10 We'll be right back.
00:47:40 We'll be right back.