Juno News - March 07, 2024


Poilievre soaring in polls – so the Liberals are campaigning against Trump

Topics
Mentioned
The Canadian Armed Forces is facing a CRISIS | Ret. Lt.-Gen. Michel Maisonneuve Unhinged pro-Hamas protesters are everywhere

Episode Stats


Length

47 minutes

Words per minute

179.61

Word count

8,555

Sentence count

322

Harmful content

Misogyny

10

sentences flagged

Toxicity

14

sentences flagged

Hate speech

12

sentences flagged


Summary

Summaries generated with gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ .

In this episode of The Andrew Lawton Show, we continue our coverage of the Liberal government's online censorship legislation, Bill C-63, with a chat with law professor Bruce Parry, and with the newly elected MP for Durham, Jamil Javani, who joins us for his first post-election interview.

Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Topics generated with Qwen2.5-3B-Instruct.
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 Transcribed by ESO, translated by —
00:00:30 Thank you.
00:01:00 welcome to canada's most irreverent talk show this is the andrew lawton show brought to you by true
00:01:19 north hello and welcome to you all canada's most irreverent talk show here on this thursday
00:01:29 march 7th 2024 just after one o'clock eastern time 11 a.m mountain 10 a.m in the beautiful
00:01:38 albeit somewhat kooky province of british columbia and no i won't leave you maritimers out it is two
00:01:44 o'clock in Atlantic Canada, save for Newfoundland, where you get a jump on the rest of us at 2.30.
00:01:51 That makes, well, Manitoba, no, no, I promise I wouldn't make fun of Manitoba anymore. It is
00:01:57 Manitoba noon hour, a lunchtime in Manitoba province that is the only one I have not yet
00:02:03 visited in the country. So if you can come up with a reason I should go there, please do. My
00:02:08 one colleague who is formerly of Manitoba says that I should just avoid it on principle now and
00:02:14 see how long I can go. But anyway, the polar bears look lovely up in Churchill. So all of that
00:02:19 notwithstanding, it is great to have you tuned into the show. We'll be continuing our coverage
00:02:23 of the Liberal Government's Online Harms Act, Bill C-63, a little bit later on with law professor
00:02:29 Bruce Party, who I suspect, if past interviews are an indication of future comments, will be
00:02:37 very, very much for this. He loves censorship. No, he doesn't. He hates, he's more of a radical
00:02:42 libertarian than I am. So Bruce and I, he's the only one that outflanks me on stuff like that.
00:02:47 So we'll have a great chat later on. And also Jamil Javani, the member of parliament elect
00:02:52 for Durham, he'll be joining us for his first post-election interview on True North. That will
00:02:58 be in, I think just after 1.30. So just about 27 minutes from now, we'll have Jamil on. But
00:03:03 I wanted to begin with a bit of the bigger picture on Canadian politics right now, because
00:03:08 you can always tell when a government or a party is beleaguered or embattled because
00:03:15 they tend to start being really desperate and really unhinged. Now, we have seen in polling
00:03:21 for several months now that the Liberals have their backs up against the wall. They are not
00:03:26 only facing a polling that shows Pierre Polyev and the Conservatives in majority territory,
00:03:31 but they are finding themselves in some cases flirting with the NDP for that coveted third
00:03:37 place spot the spot that the well i mean the liberals went down to fourth place in 2011 but
00:03:42 basically they are behind in some polls or almost behind the ndp uh sean says the block is third
00:03:49 right now so uh that is actually going to be quite fascinating oh in the house yeah so that's going
00:03:55 to be quite interesting about whether the liberals actually get uh down below the ndp and in seat
00:04:01 count they could actually end up as sean says uh right now below the block because of this the
00:04:07 distribution. The Bloc has a much more efficient vote in Quebec. So if the Liberals are polling
00:04:12 third overall, I don't want to get too much into the numbers, but they could still be behind the
00:04:16 Bloc in seats. So we'll keep an eye out for that. But I'm less interested in the poll numbers and 0.99
00:04:23 more interested in how the Liberals have decided to respond to them. Because we see them just
00:04:30 getting really desperate right now. And what are the things the Liberals love to do? They love
00:04:34 importing American battles. When the U.S. Supreme Court overturned Roe v. Wade, a decision that had
00:04:40 zero effect whatsoever on Canada and Canadian abortion access and abortion laws, the Liberals
00:04:47 started campaigning against the Roe v. Wade overturning. They had their crack squad of women's 1.00
00:04:52 rights activists coming out to talk about this unprecedented assault on women's rights as though
00:04:56 it has any effect on Canada whatsoever. The purpose is solely to wedge the Conservatives to try to
00:05:03 debate one of the pro-life conservative MPs into speaking about this. And this is why, I mean,
00:05:08 I've been on the team that the election is not going to be until 2025. That's been the operating
00:05:14 assumption I've had. But the one exception to that is, and it's a theory that's not original,
00:05:20 someone else brought this idea to me, but I can't remember who it was, so I'm going to claim credit
00:05:23 for it. The Liberals may want to run in 2024 because they may wish to do what we're already
00:05:32 seeing them start to do now, which is try to link Pierre Polyev with Donald Trump. This is like the
00:05:37 number one playbook for the Liberals to try to link the relatively moderate Conservative Party 0.99
00:05:43 of Canada with the evil, scary, right-wing, neo-Nazi, white supremacist, Haiti hate-mongery 0.98
00:05:48 Republican Party in the United States. And if they could have a Canadian election overlapping 0.98
00:05:53 with an American election, that will be a lot easier for them to do. We already see them trying
00:05:58 to this. We'll start with this just stellar, stellar graphic. This is the far-right American
00:06:05 one, Sean. There we go. So Pierre Pauly, this is the Liberal Party's official comms page.
00:06:11 Pierre Pauly is bringing far-right American-style politics to Canada. They cite a Toronto Star
00:06:17 article, which as we know is the authority on all truth, the oracle of Canadian political wisdom.
00:06:22 Pierre Pauly wants to look tough, but bows to Donald Trump. Yeah, okay, there you go. And
00:06:28 You even have the scary black and white picture
00:06:30 of Pierre Polyev right beside Donald Trump.
00:06:33 It's terrifying, is it not?
00:06:35 And then let's throw up the other one here. 0.99
00:06:37 This is, again, this is Stellar Liberal Comms.
00:06:39 It is a screenshot from an iPhone note.
00:06:45 And it's Pierre Polyev, oh, no, no, no.
00:06:46 It's far-right American, 0.95
00:06:48 but they've crossed out far-right American
00:06:50 because Pierre Polyev for a moment
00:06:51 thought he was far-right American.
00:06:53 And then he realized he was actually Pierre Polyev.
00:06:56 Very, very witty and incisive here.
00:06:58 uh Pierre Polyev's priorities oh no put that back up deny climate change cut services to cut taxes
00:07:06 for the wealthy gut the middle class we can gun control now the reason I want that up still 1.00
00:07:11 uh they don't even get their metaphor right because you see they they've actually put
00:07:16 x's beside them as if to say he has not done those things so uh Pierre Polyev hasn't denied
00:07:21 climate change he hasn't cut services to cut taxes for the wealthy they should have done check marks
00:07:25 But that would just be relying on and requiring just a little bit too much sense from the liberals.
00:07:31 All right, we can take down the graphic now.
00:07:34 This is going to be the only thing they're capable of doing.
00:07:38 We know it because this goes back to the election that Andrew Scheer contested in 2019,
00:07:44 Aaron O'Toole in 2021, all of Stephen Harper's elections.
00:07:48 You go before that.
00:07:49 It was the attacks against Stockwell Day and the Canadian Alliance,
00:07:52 Preston Manning and the Reform Party. And the reason I'm delving into the history a little
00:07:58 bit here, you may recall on Monday, I shared that I have a forthcoming biography of Pierre
00:08:02 Polyev. It's called Pierre Polyev, A Political Life. It's the so far first and well only to which
00:08:09 I'm aware biography of Pierre Polyev. And you can get the details on that at Amazon or Sutherland
00:08:14 House. But in the course of writing that, I've had to go back through the annals of conservative
00:08:20 of political history in this country. And I focus specifically on 1997 to 2024, because that's the
00:08:28 period in which Pierre Pauliev has been involved politically. But in doing so, I was reminded of
00:08:34 just how the tricks are the same in every single election. The attacks are the same. The chant that
00:08:40 people used to use against Preston Manning in 93 and 97 was racist, sexist, anti-gay, Preston Manning, 0.97
00:08:46 go away. It's got a nice rhythm to it, got a nice cadence. It wasn't true then, and it's not true
00:08:51 now. But it's the same attacks. People are going to say, you know, racist, sexist, anti-gay,
00:08:56 poly-ev, go away. That's going to be the line that they use because the attacks do not change, 0.77
00:09:03 which is why the only way to combat that is by having a politician that's going to flip the
00:09:07 script and not be deferential and conciliatory and take on this appeasement approach to the
00:09:13 media and to the left which is what conservative leaders have tried and failed to do in the last
00:09:18 certainly the last two elections so that's going to be the dynamic and that will be why Pierre
00:09:24 Polyev I think has a very different experience in the election than his predecessors will if he
00:09:29 holds firm because when the attacks were thrown against Sharon O'Toole their instinct was to just
00:09:34 head for the hills they wanted to do the ostrich thing stick their head in the sand hope it would 0.51
00:09:39 go away instead of flipping that script, instead of going on the offense, which you may not like,
00:09:44 maybe you don't think it's prime ministerial, but certainly the approaches to date have not worked
00:09:50 and are unlikely to work again. In fact, I'd say it's impossible for them to work again.
00:09:55 So all that the liberals are left with is this desire to tone police. There was this hilarious
00:10:01 exchange I want to share. This was from a, I forget the name of it. It was from one of the
00:10:05 parliamentary committees yesterday that was looking into the Arrive Can scandal. Arrive Can,
00:10:11 the app that gets millions upon millions upon millions of dollars to do very little work to
00:10:15 basically force Canadians who are coming into the country to subject themselves to this 0.90
00:10:20 scrutinizing of their vaccine status, their testing status. And it's just a couple of guys
00:10:25 in a basement that are getting rich off of this. Well, every other Canadian was forced to go along 0.63
00:10:31 with this absurd thing the conservatives have taken it upon themselves to call this the arrive
00:10:36 scam this is part i mean you may think it's a bit lame but this is what political communications
00:10:41 is about arrive scam well the liberals think that is just a little bit too offensive for their
00:10:48 liking take a look at this exchange from committee yesterday i am very struck by the comments of my
00:10:54 Liberal colleague regarding lack of trust in public institutions, as if public
00:10:59 institutions can be, trust in public institutions can be disconnected from an
00:11:05 evaluation of their conduct. I think public institutions have to earn trust.
00:11:09 Now the Arrive Scam scandal is an earth-shattering scandal.
00:11:13 Point of order, Mr. Chair?
00:11:15 Just one second.
00:11:16 Point of order, Mr. Chair?
00:11:17 Yes, Ms. Khalid, your point of order is?
00:11:21 When Conservative colleagues call it an arrived scam instead of an arrived cam app, then it's impacting the public trust of what I was trying to get at.
00:11:32 Ms. Khalid, that is not a point of order.
00:11:35 That is a term we're hearing both in this committee room but also throughout Parliament Hill.
00:11:40 Mr. Jennings, you have the floor. Four minutes and 40 seconds, please.
00:11:44 Thank you, Mr. Speaker.
00:11:45 So, trigger warning.
00:11:46 My comments will use the word arrived scam.
00:11:50 Arrive scam is impacting public trust because it's an earth-shattering scandal.
00:11:56 It's pretty rich for Liberals like Ms. Khalid to talk about the need for public 1.00
00:12:00 trust in institutions when they have presided over a massive decline in the effectiveness
00:12:05 and the trustworthiness of public institutions and done nothing about it.
00:12:09 Mr. Mr. Jenuous, Ms. Khalid, you are, no you're not the next speaker, but go ahead.
00:12:14 You have a point of order. It's a point of order, not a rebuttal.
00:12:17 I'd appreciate if Mr. Genuis did not try to malign me.
00:12:21 I've already been dealing with a lot of hate mail and a lot of threats in my office based on what the conservatives have done.
00:12:28 I would appreciate if he didn't put another target on my back.
00:12:31 Thank you.
00:12:34 I love it.
00:12:36 This is Ikra Khalid, who is, well, I mean, the second part is like calling it arrive
00:12:41 scam subject or no, him calling out her calling out his use of the word arrive scam subjects
00:12:47 her to hate and threats or something like that, which is absurd.
00:12:51 And then the crucial point at the beginning there, that it undermines trust in institutions
00:12:56 when the conservatives call it arrive scam.
00:12:59 That comment is many things.
00:13:00 It's great comedy, but as John Williamson pointed out, it is not by any stretch a point of order.
00:13:07 But this is what the Liberals would love to focus on.
00:13:09 Again, I would say let's perhaps focus on the fact that you're trying to censor what Canadians say and do online.
00:13:14 But instead, they're like, they're already actually policing it.
00:13:18 This is a perfect segue because Ickra Klin is already showing there that she thinks that arrive scam is a word that you shouldn't be able to use. 1.00
00:13:25 And this is the member of parliament from a party, from a government that is trying to police what you say and do online.
00:13:31 So maybe if she gets her way, arrive scam will be an example of hate speech that Bill C-63 will not let you discuss. 0.88
00:13:41 That may be the way that we go from here.
00:13:44 But this is exactly why I've been talking about this and why I should probably do at some point a segment on this show.
00:13:49 Maybe we'll do it next week where I just go through all of the things that the liberals have said are hate.
00:13:54 just to give a sense of the things that they may feel are within the regulatory purview of Bill
00:14:00 C-63. For example, officials from the Department of Justice yesterday said that, this is literally
00:14:09 what they said, they said that comparing people to human excrement may be in fact a violation of
00:14:18 online hate speech. So you could actually make a comparison of someone to human excrement, which 0.94
00:14:22 again, I don't believe is kind. I don't believe you should generally go after people and make
00:14:29 these excremental comparisons. But if you compare people to excrement, that could prompt a hate 0.87
00:14:33 speech probe. And also if you compare them to vermin. So if you think someone is a crappy person 0.99
00:14:39 or as Sean just called me a rat bastard piece of crap, I don't know if we can say rat bastard piece 1.00
00:14:45 of crap on the show and keep the clean tag on iTunes, but I've already said it. So a rat bastard 1.00
00:14:49 piece of crap. This could be hate speech. So Sean, if you want to file a human rights complaint 1.00
00:14:53 against me, actually I could file it against you because you said it to me. Yeah, Sean just called
00:14:58 me a rat bastard piece of crap in our show chat. So I am triggered and traumatized by this. So that 1.00
00:15:04 is, I believe I get $20,000 under C63, but he has to pay $50,000 to the receiver general. So Sean,
00:15:13 you're out $70,000, which means you should think twice about your language. You should have that 1.00
00:15:18 chill that we all hear about in the course of free speech he wants to know if he can expense it now
00:15:23 to to true north well uh as uh no i'm just gonna go out on a limb and say no um so anyway let's
00:15:30 discuss this do we have bruce bruce party we do so bruce party is a law professor and as i said
00:15:35 earlier uh the one who outflanks me on my libertarianism which is already too radical for 0.97
00:15:40 uh some of you so i don't know what you're going to make of him you'll be calling him a rat bastard 1.00
00:15:44 piece of crap before long. But it's always great to get his insights on this. Bruce, thank you for 0.99
00:15:49 coming on the show. This is something you've been warning about for years. And I've quoted a
00:15:55 presentation I heard you give at SAFS in London a few years ago about these sorts of things. And
00:16:00 one of the ones that stands out is your claim that if something is illegal offline, it's illegal
00:16:06 online. So this idea that we need a law to create this special category of online speech is in and
00:16:12 itself flawed is it not yes yes entirely now there might be a jurisdictional reason for the feds to
00:16:20 pursue this because they don't generally have jurisdiction over civil rights and so speech in
00:16:27 general is mostly a provincial matter but they have jurisdiction over telecommunications so they're
00:16:33 using that as a justification to cover for essentially wanting to walk into the role of
00:16:40 censoring our online speech which is becoming a greater proportion of our speech in general all
00:16:46 the time so this is this is one way in which the feds are are elbowing their way into a matter that
00:16:52 the provinces traditionally have have had the major role one of the things that i i find so jarring
00:16:58 about it and i don't know how much you read into this briefing that department of justice officials
00:17:02 gave which was basically because they thought journalists weren't getting it and they just
00:17:06 needed to be you know given some more of the the state propaganda on this but one of the things
00:17:10 that they that i've really taken from this is that the government's leaning very heavily on the just
00:17:15 trust us they're saying no no the canadian human rights commission will make sure that this isn't
00:17:19 abused that's the whole point of this though is that we're empowering these bureaucrats to decide 0.81
00:17:24 what we can and can't say online oh exactly so so you know there have been many lawyers who since
00:17:34 the draft of the bill came out have pointed out all the flaws and and they're absolutely right
00:17:38 but yes so that the trust in the administration to deal with the online platforms the trust in
00:17:46 the human rights uh mechanisms to make the right calls about where the line's supposed to be and
00:17:53 even the trust in the courts in defining what falls on one side and the other side of the idea
00:18:00 of hate speech but so one of my concerns about bill 63 in addition to all of the very valid
00:18:08 criticisms that it's received i mean it's a terrible terrible draft i mean it had it it
00:18:13 cannot be let through but an awful lot of those problems already exist including the one that you
00:18:21 just referred to we already have a major portion of our law in the hands of these kinds of bodies 0.89
00:18:28 whether they're executive bodies or legal bodies per se the lines drawn in our laws
00:18:36 are terribly vague so just take the most basic one we have freedom of speech in section two of
00:18:42 our charter what does that mean who knows it's always up to the courts to decide so when you
00:18:50 think well i have freedom of speech because it says so in the charter you don't actually know
00:18:54 what that means and so we we've got a very basic problem in our law that this is making worse to be
00:19:02 sure but we haven't attacked the actual problem yeah and it's it's so difficult because the whole
00:19:10 point of speech regulations for example in the united kingdom they have a like in canada broadcast
00:19:16 regulator called ofcom and and they have to adjudicate if you use a dirty word on television
00:19:22 whether that word was something you could say on tv before nine o'clock which is their watershed
00:19:27 hour and they publish this annual list of all the words they've said are violated and it's
00:19:33 actually hilarious because you read through this list and you learn of like slurs and swears that
00:19:37 you didn't even know existed that some bureaucrat has just decided but this list gets longer and
00:19:42 longer every year because someone looks at it and makes a judgment call and in the end you have
00:19:47 these absurd boundaries and borders and you know i've been making a point on this show of talking
00:19:51 about this uh what what the government thinks is this uber clear delineation of it can't detest or
00:19:58 vilify but it can disdain offend hurt harm and and they they think that this is clarity but it
00:20:04 actually is no such thing no no and i don't i my guess is that they know there's there's no clear
00:20:11 line there that that is simply to empower the kind of discretion that you're talking about
00:20:16 but remember we we have these kinds of restrictions in our laws already i mean again this is adding to
00:20:26 them making them worse it cannot stand but we have a speech a hate speech provision in the criminal
00:20:32 code already that for my money shouldn't be there we have restrictions on speech and various kinds 0.68
00:20:38 of human rights codes across the country already they shouldn't be there and we've accepted them 1.00
00:20:43 and so this is just a piling on it's a bad piling on it needs to be defeated but it's a piling on
00:20:50 we have accepted the idea that hate speech whatever that happens to me should be restricted
00:20:57 that in my for my money that is incorrect if you live in a free country you're allowed to hate
00:21:07 other people now we don't recommend it it's not a good thing we're not going to encourage it but
00:21:13 if you're free you're allowed to for the reason that you're free and if that's what you think
00:21:19 then again if you're free you're allowed to say so because that's what you think and that I saw
00:21:26 yeah go ahead no I saw you post on Twitter the other day something about that which I found
00:21:32 interesting whereas in the U.S. they've actually specifically protected hate speech whereas in
00:21:37 Canada we've done the opposite so the U.S. doesn't have to deal with this question of where to draw
00:21:42 the line whereas in Canada we do that that's right and as a population we seem to have accepted the
00:21:50 idea that it's appropriate for the government to draw that line somewhere and tell us that we're
00:21:58 not allowed to express our our distaste for other people well now you're being managed and you know
00:22:05 being free includes a lot of uncomfortable ugly things it involves a bit of chaos so there's a
00:22:12 choice here it's been with us for a long time and i think we are failing to choose correctly but
00:22:17 we are choosing to be managed for the sake of of i don't know for the sake of of of you know
00:22:26 civilizational manners in in instead of deciding that actually yeah we are a free country right now
00:22:36 that's very much in doubt. One of the most, I mean, generally speaking, a win is a win and a
00:22:43 loss is a loss, but sometimes a win can be a loss. And by that, I'm referring to the Mike Ward case
00:22:50 before the Supreme Court. This is a Quebec comedian that told a joke about a disabled
00:22:55 teenager. Again, you may think this is incredibly in poor taste. You may think it's unfunny. You
00:22:59 may think it's rude. You may think that people should boycott him, but he did this. His life
00:23:03 was dragged through the ringer. Comedians would rather be performing and doing comedy, although
00:23:08 he was subjected to more of a tragedy and a drama by going before the Quebec Human Rights Commission
00:23:14 and all of that. And in the end, this goes to the Supreme Court of Canada. He wins. But it was a
00:23:19 5-4 decision. Now, the fact that it came down to one judge on whether you have a right to tell
00:23:25 offensive jokes in this country is incredibly dangerous. And that's why I'm not all that
00:23:30 pessimistic or I'm not all that optimistic about C63 because I think since the Ward case there have 0.95
00:23:36 been one if not two more appointments to the Supreme Court by Justin Trudeau so that case
00:23:43 today may end up being you know seven two or something well I totally agree with you on this
00:23:49 and I would go further so yes it was a it was a five four decision but even the basis of the
00:23:55 majority decision was not what you want so basically basically they said no this he's oh
00:24:00 he's okay in this instance because you know he didn't intend to target this person on the basis
00:24:06 of the prohibited ground so in other words if he had wanted to make fun of this person on the basis
00:24:14 of a prohibited ground maybe that would not have been okay you know that yeah so you're right it's
00:24:19 not even a it wasn't even a free speech argument that the majority gave it was uh like he he got
00:24:24 off on a tech. It was the Al Capone tax evasion thing. He got off on the technicality. That's
00:24:29 right. That's right. And so we are missing a robust endorsement of the idea that you are free
00:24:36 to say what you think. And the so-called perceived harm on others because of hearing your dreadful
00:24:46 thoughts really should be irrelevant. And we have not gotten there yet. Let me go out to the bigger
00:24:54 picture here because you and i have had many discussions on this show and elsewhere where
00:24:59 we've lamented the state of things in canada and are you and i advocating for something that is
00:25:05 fundamentally not what the law in canada is supposed to be and by that i mean is this an
00:25:10 issue where the law has been designed in a way and it's just diverged so far from that point
00:25:16 or are we in the wrong country has this actually been a case of canada was never meant to have
00:25:21 very robust freedom of expression well this is a question that that that has no clear resolution
00:25:27 right i mean some people would say the former and that our tradition has not been like that in the
00:25:34 u.s and of course you know u.s jurisprudence of freedom of speech has come in peaks and valleys
00:25:40 as well it's not you know black and white it was not one thing from the very beginning but
00:25:45 their first amendment in our section two basically both say people have freedom of
00:25:51 speech and the words are very vague and they in in neither case do they exactly say what that means
00:25:57 and it just so happens that it's played out one way in the U.S. and the other way in Canada so
00:26:02 there's nothing inherent in our provisions that suggest that we ought not to have free speech but
00:26:08 our institutions our legal institutions our courts in particular but also our governments
00:26:12 have insisted that that's actually not not the case in this country. Beverly McLaughlin the
00:26:19 the former Chief Justice did an interview the other day, and I haven't watched the whole thing,
00:26:24 but I read little snippets of it. And it sounds like she's generally supportive of Bill C-63 and
00:26:29 what it tries to do. And the issues that she flags are ones that are more like, well, you know,
00:26:33 I might be concerned if, and it's quite interesting because that aligns with what I expect from
00:26:38 Beverly McLaughlin. But if you look at some past decisions, I mean, she used to be quite strong on
00:26:43 freedom of expression. And it's amazing that there's been this flip where it's only freedom
00:26:48 of expression for certain people now and for certain groups and i i mean she i i think would
00:26:54 be mortified by some of the things she's said in the past about it i mean i she's defended the
00:26:59 right to deny the holocaust but now the right to misgender someone i don't know yes you'd think 0.89
00:27:04 that that that a former version of herself might be appalled with what the present version of
00:27:09 herself is saying maybe maybe but but it is also the case though that even at the supreme court and
00:27:14 even from uh from reverend mclaughlin the justification for free speech has has sometimes
00:27:21 run along the lines of well we need free speech because it it's it's effective it's it's important
00:27:27 to maintain our democracy for the for the you know free marketplace of ideas to get to the truth we
00:27:33 need yada yada and that's that's good that's fine that's true it's a very utilitarian argument
00:27:38 extremely utilitarian. And so the implication is, look, if it doesn't benefit the society
00:27:46 to have this, then you can't have it. And that is not what free means. Free means you can say
00:27:53 what you think because you think it and for no other reason. Wow. Yeah. And there was a quote
00:28:00 I was hoping you would talk for 10 seconds longer so I could pull up the quote. I'll paraphrase it
00:28:05 in the absence of that, because Beverly McLaughlin had said in a speech at some point
00:28:09 that her job as a judge was to take a step back and after hearing a case and decide what's best 0.89
00:28:14 for society, which I mean, it's entirely par for, I think, how the Supreme Court deals with these
00:28:20 things, but very dangerous in kind of on the back end of what you've just said there, which is that
00:28:25 you have judges that all of a sudden start looking at speech as a tool instead of speech as an
00:28:30 inherent good and free speech as an inherent good and that I think is especially concerning when you
00:28:35 go up against these equality rights in the charter and all of a sudden you're going to get a judge
00:28:38 that's saying well yes but your freedom of speech isn't good if it makes someone feel unsafe because
00:28:44 of their gender identity or their race or or whatever this case is yes and we should note how
00:28:51 that changes the idea of the nature of rights right the whole for my money the whole idea was
00:29:00 that these these were things these were lines in the sand where the group could not invade the
00:29:06 ability of the individual to do as he chose but now these rights are being interpreted through
00:29:12 the lens that you're describing which is well the right is okay as long as it serves society
00:29:18 well but that's completely the opposite of the first idea the the the an individual right has
00:29:24 to stand regardless of its effect upon society for the very reason that it is an individual right
00:29:30 and not a societal right all right we'll end on a lighter note bruce who do you think is
00:29:36 getting hauled before the tribunal first you or me oh geez um well you talk uh more frequently
00:29:44 than i do andrew so i'd have to go with you all right well i'll get you as my uh council of record
00:29:50 then uh when it happened uh bruce party the executive director of rights probe law professor
00:29:55 at queen's university always a pleasure bruce thanks for coming on thanks andrew cheers all
00:29:59 All right. I'm glad Bruce is always like the downer when I have him on. He was surprisingly
00:30:03 chipper today, which I quite like. So now that being said, the bill hasn't yet become a law.
00:30:09 So who knows what will happen then. Nevertheless, I mentioned earlier this week, there was a big
00:30:14 win in Durham, not altogether unsurprising, as I said, and I put the caveat there because
00:30:19 it has been a conservative stronghold for 20 years. But the margin of victory by which
00:30:24 the conservative candidate, Jamil Javani won, was actually quite strong. And I think there is a
00:30:30 message in this to Justin Trudeau, either that conservatives are in fact looking beyond or
00:30:36 conservative voters, voters in general are looking beyond all those evil, scary conservative Trump
00:30:40 comparisons. And also that the liberal vote is just not motivated to show up. People that voted
00:30:45 for Justin Trudeau in the last three elections, and especially the last one election, are just
00:30:51 not motivated to show up and do it again so there's a lot to unpack there but i'd rather
00:30:55 focus on the guy himself we've had him on the show in the past on a number of occasions in
00:31:00 a number of different capacities both as a broadcaster as president of the canada strong
00:31:04 and free network and now as the mp elect for durham jamil javani good to talk to you thanks
00:31:10 for coming on and congratulations i thank you andrew it's always good to good to chat with you
00:31:16 and uh yeah being called an mp is still something i gotta get used to so well mp elect i don't want
00:31:22 to jump on too much uh formality do you know when you are going to be uh sworn in i don't know yet
00:31:27 no so elections canada still has to go through their process of ratification and stuff so once
00:31:33 that's done that's when we can schedule the swearing in so we're sort of in their hands
00:31:37 for the moment but it'll be soon it must be very exciting i know you've gone through in the last
00:31:42 few years a lot of change i mean you've had to deal with cancer you obviously got fired from
00:31:47 bell you turned around and tried to and i think successfully stick it to bell with a with a lawsuit
00:31:52 you uh you know taken over the the canada strong and free network for a time like how do you begin
00:31:58 to sort of decide what to do now when you get to ottawa well i mean the the good thing about this
00:32:05 job is that uh we were elected to accomplish the goals that we set out so that's what i think our
00:32:11 focus is you know it's uh it was a 12-word uh promise that we made many many times during the
00:32:18 campaign which is ax the tax build the homes fix the budget stop the crime that is the agenda
00:32:26 and uh certainly at this point where our job is to hold the current government to account
00:32:31 we want to focus as much as we can on pushing for ideas that we think are going to help accomplish
00:32:36 those objectives. And also for me locally, here in Durham, to make sure that I'm a good strong
00:32:42 voice for the issues that people care about. We knocked on over 111,000 doors in the last few
00:32:49 months. And so I've talked to as many of our voters as possible, as many of our community
00:32:55 members as possible. And I think I have a sense of what they want from me as the MP. And that's
00:33:00 what I'm out here to do. One of the questions that always comes up in politics is how much
00:33:06 of a candidate's performance as them and how much as the leader. And you can never quantify it,
00:33:11 but I'm curious if you got a sense when you were out knocking on doors, how Pierre Polyev is
00:33:16 perceived or if he's even perceived by people. Because obviously there's been a bit of a change.
00:33:20 This writing was formerly represented by Aaron O'Toole, who was the previous conservative leader.
00:33:24 We get from the media, no shortage of claims about, you know, Pierre Polyev being the big,
00:33:29 evil, scary conservative meanie. How was that actually on the ground when you were talking to
00:33:33 voters? Well, I think people are very happy with what they've seen from Pierre Polyev up till this
00:33:39 point. Since he became leader of the party, I think a lot of folks unhappy with our current
00:33:45 government and unhappy with our current economy in particular, see Pierre as the change leader,
00:33:51 that if you want something other than Trudeau, if you want an economy that, as we say, works for
00:33:57 those who do the work, that is actually responsive to the needs of middle class and working class
00:34:02 families that pierre is the guy to make that change happen so on the ground a lot of support
00:34:08 for pierre a growing amount of support as people get to know him better and the reality is that
00:34:14 you know the reason we won by the big margin that we did the biggest margin in the 20-year history
00:34:19 of the conservative party of canada in durham was won by us on monday and i think that is because
00:34:25 you know, Pierre Paglia has become a symbol of change for people. So we drew support from
00:34:32 neighborhoods that Conservative Party candidates in the past may not have been able to get as much
00:34:38 support from, because we are now seen as the change party. So that's a very exciting thing
00:34:44 for us, you know, nationally, but also locally. It's very exciting because I think people have
00:34:49 expectations for us that we're going to deliver. And now it's on us to actually hold up our end
00:34:53 the deal you made some waves on monday night when you took aim at liberal elites which i played the
00:35:02 clip on the show and i think the audience was very much on your side on that one but i was curious in
00:35:06 who you included in that because you weren't just talking about the capital l liberal party led by
00:35:11 justin trudeau you talked about uh telecom companies you even talked about i mean what i
00:35:16 read as the ontario pc government did you not well i specifically mentioned the ontario ministry of
00:35:22 Education because I mean the facts just bear it out they have upheld a policy agenda that is very
00:35:29 similar to what you might have seen with a liberal government in power they have focused on a lot of
00:35:35 virtue signaling they have focused on race politics meanwhile the average student in Ontario is still
00:35:41 struggling with math with reading with writing they have tried very hard to do in my view
00:35:47 superficial things, while the effects of pandemic school closures are still being felt by middle
00:35:54 class and working class families. You know, my job as an MP is to care about what people in Durham
00:36:00 care about. And I'm knocking on doors, I'm talking to parents every day, I'm talking to students
00:36:05 every day. And they're telling me the school system isn't working for us. So I feel it's
00:36:10 important to tell the truth. And when I say liberal elite, you're absolutely right, Andrew,
00:36:14 i'm not just talking about people who are in one political party a lot of our voters were
00:36:20 former liberal voters and i don't hold them in contempt because i grew up in a community where
00:36:25 i was taught the liberal party is where you belong and it took me a while to figure out that that
00:36:29 wasn't true and it might take others a while to figure out that out too so i don't hold that
00:36:33 against people but when i talk about liberal elites i'm talking about the people who have
00:36:37 abandoned the middle class and the working class and as i said whether they're big bank ceos big
00:36:43 telecom ceos the ministry of education the activists and academics pushing for um you know
00:36:50 anti-law enforcement anti-public safety policies what all of these folks have in common is that
00:36:55 they are serving a privileged few while turning their backs on the majority of people in this
00:37:00 country and i gotta tell the truth about that and if it ruffles feathers and it makes people unhappy
00:37:06 get used to it because my job is to get is to work for the people of durham my job is not to
00:37:10 worry about offending people in the halls of power who are actually making everybody's life harder
00:37:16 one of the things you and i have spoken about this in the past and i know you've spoken about
00:37:19 it in speeches when you were at bell as a radio host you there was kind of an expectation that
00:37:25 was put on you that because you fit a certain demographic mold you would fit an ideological
00:37:30 mold as well and i know that was one of the things you took aim at when you spoke out against them
00:37:35 and i i can't help but notice that the narrative around you and your candidacy would be different
00:37:40 if you had a different political view.
00:37:42 Like I'm convinced, and you may disagree with me, Jamil,
00:37:44 that if you were a liberal,
00:37:45 you would be getting like the New York Times style profile
00:37:48 of this bootstrap guy that got himself into Yale
00:37:52 and is now trying to change the country.
00:37:54 But just to give you one headline from the Globe and Mail,
00:37:57 Jamil Javani will fit right in
00:37:58 with activist populist conservatism of Polly Ev. 0.66
00:38:02 So you just basically get distilled down into this.
00:38:05 And I'm curious what you think of the media's take on you.
00:38:08 I mean, did they really cover you
00:38:09 And did they cover you fairly?
00:38:12 Well, I do not expect fairness from the media.
00:38:16 So Lex and I learned even before I worked in it, but certainly when working in it and
00:38:21 just seeing all the pressure put on employees by these big media corporations to serve a
00:38:26 certain agenda, you know, it's not easy to be fair in the media.
00:38:31 You do have to sometimes put your career on the line because you've got management who
00:38:35 doesn't want you to be fair and doesn't want you to be impartial and objective.
00:38:39 So I don't expect it to be fair. The truth is this. If you want to make a difference in this country right now, you have to fight for the middle class. You have to fight for the working class. You got to fight for the people who are not represented in the media.
00:38:53 They don't work in the media by virtue of the type of training and education and lifestyle that the media rewards.
00:39:02 The voices of the middle class and the working class are often not in these organizations, whether it's a radio station or a TV station.
00:39:09 And there are exceptions to that. But by and large, it's just not the case.
00:39:13 So just look at the polls. You know, in every poll that comes out, Pierre Polyev is at the top of the list because many, many Canadians, a growing number, want change.
00:39:22 but you don't see that reflected in news coverage because they're out of touch.
00:39:26 And our job is not to be beholden to out-of-touch media organizations.
00:39:31 They can call me names when Justin Trudeau was calling me names and a twofer and all that nonsense.
00:39:38 Most of these media organizations didn't cover that either.
00:39:41 They're not interested in providing an objective view of what's happening.
00:39:45 They have their own values. They have their own agenda.
00:39:47 When I say liberal elites, I am talking about the companies that own many of the media outlets that Canadians rely on for information.
00:39:56 So this is why I'm always keen to do independent media like True North to do local media like we have here in Durham.
00:40:03 We've got still a number of newspapers, TV stations, radio stations, because this is where you get a more accurate sense of what's going on in the country.
00:40:11 and I'll tell you now as the MP elect for Durham that is some that is wisdom I take into my new
00:40:17 job I will not be someone who's going to get pushed around by journalists who think if they
00:40:22 give me bad coverage I'm going to change my values I was elected because of my values and
00:40:27 I will continue to stand for them let me just ask you about where you have to direct your attention
00:40:32 now because you know unlike anyone who gets elected in a general election and has you know
00:40:37 two, three, four years of breathing room, you're being elected in a by-election,
00:40:40 which means you could see, I mean, you could theoretically find yourself campaigning in like
00:40:44 a month's time. It looks like it's probably going to be about a year, a year and a half until the
00:40:48 next election. But what pressure does that put on you to, you know, perform as an MP to navigate
00:40:55 this new life, this new world, like, you know, figuring out everything from where the bathrooms
00:40:58 are on Parliament Hill to, you know, how you can get a bill passed and then have to turn around
00:41:03 and do it again? Yeah. Well, it's one thing that a lot of people might not know is that
00:41:07 getting elected to parliament, there are things you have to do just like with any other job.
00:41:13 There's orientation and there's the tech guy who has to explain how you use your phone and log into
00:41:18 your new email address. So there's a lot of those steps that I'm just figuring out now and trying
00:41:23 to learn how it all works as quickly as I can. But the truth is that the fact an election or
00:41:30 general election could be coming so quickly is, you know, this is exactly why we have to stay
00:41:36 close to our people, close to our voters, close to the community, because I want, I'm not going
00:41:41 to be surprised. I want to know what people want from their MP every step of the way. I'm not going
00:41:47 to be one of those politicians just comes and knocks on your door every few years. I want to
00:41:51 be someone who the public feels this guy has our back. He's there to do a job. He works just as
00:41:56 hard as we do, and we can trust him to speak for us. So that's the mentality I come into the job
00:42:02 with. And that's why I have the confidence I have that we can take positions that the media might
00:42:07 not like. We can stand for things that the liberals are going to attack us on. They can throw all
00:42:12 their darts and all their stones all they want. And I'm fine to take it because I really believe
00:42:17 I have a sense of what people want, what the majority of people in our community here want.
00:42:22 And that's what I'm trying to be accountable to.
00:42:25 Is there like a bucket list thing that you'd love to achieve in your first, I don't even
00:42:30 want to call it a first term because it's like a partial term, but is there, there's
00:42:33 something that you want to be able to get to the end of the next, you know, 12, 18 months
00:42:37 and be able to say, I've done this when you go to campaign for reelection?
00:42:41 Yeah, well, I guess there's two things I have in mind.
00:42:44 One is, you know, I think nuclear energy is a really, really important part of the future
00:42:49 of Canada.
00:42:50 you know we've been sort of sold this idea that you know free market economics and the climate
00:42:56 have to be at odds with each other that has opened the gates to a lot of bad policies like the carbon
00:43:02 tax I don't support any of that I mean obviously we campaign on axing the carbon tax all the time
00:43:08 but we do have you know lower emission options that will grow the economy especially for us here
00:43:14 in Ontario. And in my area in particular, there are over 3,000 people who are employed by our
00:43:20 local nuclear plant. So I think nuclear energy is a really big part of the future. And I want to do
00:43:25 my part as an MP to push for that and get us away from this sort of anti-free market, anti-economic
00:43:33 growth approach that the Liberals have taken. And the other issue is I want to draw attention to
00:43:38 some of the challenges facing boys and young men in our society. You know, Andrew, I commend you
00:43:44 a great deal because you've been open with some of the challenges you faced as a man. Mental health
00:43:48 is one of the biggest things that are going on that are happening with boys and young men. We
00:43:53 often don't talk about it. Often there aren't services available to a lot of us. And I think
00:43:58 we need to make sure that the funding that goes out to programming in our communities is accounting
00:44:04 for the fact that the vast majority of people who are committing suicide, the vast majority of
00:44:10 people who are dying from overdoses, these are men. And I think that their stories need to be
00:44:15 told and heard. And I know a lot of moms and grandmas who are expecting me to stand up for
00:44:20 their sons and their grandsons. So that's a big part of what I'd like to accomplish early on
00:44:25 in this part of my journey as well. Well, and I'm glad you did tremendous work as an author on that
00:44:30 file. And I hope you pick that up as a member of parliament. And obviously, I'm available if you
00:44:35 need anything, but you've got that in, you seem to have that well handled. And I look forward to
00:44:39 hearing what you do with that. So MP elect for Durham, Jamil Javani, it's great to talk to you
00:44:44 and congratulations again. Thank you very much, Andrew. And I'm very happy for your continued
00:44:49 success. And I'm a big fan of the show. So always happy to be here. Oh, it's a good thing you didn't
00:44:53 say that before the election. You never would have won with an endorsement like that. Thanks a lot,
00:44:57 Jamil. Take care. You can always tell if someone is true to themselves if they will talk to
00:45:05 independent media. That's what I always say. Well, I've said it once, but and that was right now. So
00:45:09 Anyway, thanks again to Jamil Javani for coming on the show.
00:45:13 And I seem to have a lot of fans in the comments there as well.
00:45:15 So hopefully we'll get him back once he's in Ottawa
00:45:17 and tackling all of the things he wants to tackle.
00:45:21 But with that, I will say farewell for today.
00:45:24 We are going to be back with Off the Record tomorrow,
00:45:26 which you won't want to miss.
00:45:27 I don't even know who's on Off the Record tomorrow.
00:45:28 It's me and Candice Malcolm.
00:45:31 And I don't know.
00:45:32 I think Rachel Emanuel is doing it.
00:45:34 But you'll have to tune in to figure that out.
00:45:37 And we'll see you then.
00:45:37 And of course, The Andrew Lawton Show returns on Monday.
00:45:40 So have a great weekend, everyone.
00:45:42 Thank you.
00:45:42 God bless and good day to you all.
00:45:44 Thanks for listening to The Andrew Lawton Show.
00:45:47 Support the program by donating to True North at www.tnc.news.
00:46:07 We'll be right back.
00:46:37 We'll be right back.
00:47:07 We'll be right back.