Juno News - September 06, 2023


Police officer testifies he was ordered to give "not one inch" to Convoy organizers

Topics
Mentioned
Tamara Lich and Chris Barber are on trial Welcome to Olivia Chow’s Toronto

Episode Stats


Length

48 minutes

Words per minute

172.92

Word count

8,381

Sentence count

319

Harmful content

Misogyny

11

sentences flagged

Toxicity

3

sentences flagged

Hate speech

7

sentences flagged


Summary

Summaries generated with gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ .

On this week's show, we have the latest from the Public Order Emergency Commission (POCE) hearing in the case against police officers Tamara Leach and Chris Barber, as well as a new interview with Eva Chibiuk.

Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Topics generated with Qwen2.5-3B-Instruct.
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 Transcription by CastingWords
00:00:30 Thank you.
00:01:00 welcome to canada's most irreverent talk show this is the andrew lawton show brought to you by true
00:01:20 north hello and welcome to you all canada's most irreverent talk show here the andrew lawton show
00:01:30 on true north on this wednesday september 6th and i will tell you i don't want to give you too too
00:01:38 much but i would encourage you to tune into friday's show not just because i think you should
00:01:43 tune into all the shows but because we're going to have a little bit of an announcement about
00:01:47 the future of this program and no it's not that we're like selling to ginois or that we're like
00:01:52 bringing ourself into full compliance with bill c11 nothing like that but i think you may like it
00:01:57 if you enjoy the show you like it so on friday we'll give you a bit of an announcement on some
00:02:01 changes that are coming up next week on the show and also i would tell you to stay tuned
00:02:06 to our coverage at true north this weekend because a few of us will be on the ground at the
00:02:11 Conservative Party of Canada Convention in Quebec City. We'll be interviewing some of the movers and
00:02:18 shakers of conservative politics and bringing you a lot of what's happening on the ground. And we'll
00:02:22 have a lot of that in the show next week as well. But it is a busy show today. The wonderful
00:02:28 documentarians Trish Wood and Jacqueline Bynon will be on the show in a little bit of a time
00:02:35 here. I think 20 minutes or so they're coming on. And they are producing a documentary called
00:02:39 the Trials of Tamara Leach, and that is something they're still producing right now, and they are on
00:02:45 the ground in Ottawa at the trial, one of the trials anyway, the criminal trial, so we'll talk
00:02:50 to them about what's happening there, and in a few moments time, we'll also discuss that with
00:02:54 Eva Chibiuk, a convoy lawyer, and one who you may recall from this interaction between her and
00:03:01 Justin Trudeau at the Public Order Emergency Commission a few months back. A number of people
00:03:07 have testified in this inquiry referencing your widely published comments and calling the
00:03:13 unvaccinated racists and misogynists. And we have heard testimony in this inquiry about how some of
00:03:20 your officials wanted to label protesters as terrorists. Would you agree with me that one of 1.00
00:03:26 the most important roles of a prime minister is to unite Canadians and not divide them by engaging
00:03:30 a name calling? I did not call people who were unvaccinated names. I highlighted there's a 0.92
00:03:42 difference between people who are hesitant to get vaccinated for any range of reasons
00:03:49 and people who deliberately spread misinformation that puts at risk that life and health of their
00:03:59 fellow Canadians. And my focus, every step of the way, and the primary responsibility of a
00:04:05 Prime Minister is to keep Canadians safe and alive. You have to feel for Eva Chibiuk there.
00:04:13 I can't recall the exact breakdown, but you only have so many minutes to cross-examine
00:04:19 the witness. In that case, the witness was the Prime Minister of Canada, who decides to use his
00:04:24 minutes to explain how he never, ever did the thing that everyone saw him on camera doing,
00:04:30 which was calling the unvaccinated any number of names. But Eva Chibiuk did a bang up job there, 1.00
00:04:35 and we'll talk to her in a few moments time. One of the interesting updates, and again,
00:04:39 just to tell you, the trial of Tamara Leach and Chris Barber is going on for 16 days. Now,
00:04:45 we're on day two right now. I don't think every day is going to bring some like gasp bombshell
00:04:50 like you get in the movies, in the courtroom dramas.
00:04:53 But I do think there are interesting things that are coming out of this.
00:04:56 One of the noteworthy ones today was testimony from Inspector Lucas Russell,
00:05:02 or was it Russell Lucas?
00:05:03 It might have been Russell Lucas.
00:05:04 I apologize.
00:05:05 That's the problem when you have two first names, four names.
00:05:07 But a police inspector with the Ottawa Police Service who is Russell Lucas.
00:05:13 Okay, I can't remember if I landed on the right one earlier,
00:05:15 but it's Russell Lucas anyway.
00:05:17 And he had testified, which was actually quite interesting,
00:05:20 that he was given marching orders by higher ups and he didn't really name who they were
00:05:25 that were to not give one inch those are his words not one inch in concessions to freedom
00:05:32 convoy organizers now why that's so important is because we've heard significant amounts of
00:05:38 testimony in the public order emergency commission and i've done work on this myself interviewing
00:05:43 people uh that actually shows a little bit of a different story there where police and convoy
00:05:48 organizers and then convoy organizers and the city of ottawa were developing a rather good
00:05:53 rapport and had reached that infamous agreement between uh tamara leach and jim watson of the 0.98
00:06:00 city of ottawa the mayor to consolidate the protest to shrink the footprint move all the
00:06:05 trucks onto wellington street and then away from residential areas so that the protest could be
00:06:11 squarely squarely focused where it belonged which is on federal lawmakers and not on ottawa residents
00:06:17 who Tamara Leach and other convoy organizers have been the first to say were not the target
00:06:21 of their ire. Now, had this agreement gone through, it would have been very inconvenient
00:06:26 for the federal government. Very inconvenient because what do they have if not the complaints
00:06:32 from Ottawa residents of horn honking and diesel fumes? What do they have? Nothing. They have a
00:06:37 protest on Wellington Street, which yes, blocks traffic on Wellington Street, but I'll tell you
00:06:42 something, blocking traffic on Wellington Street has been what the police and City of Ottawa have
00:06:48 done for the last 17 months. They have never reopened Wellington Street. So no one can say
00:06:54 that there is a national public emergency that comes when cars can't drive down Wellington Street.
00:06:59 So had the protests been concentrated there, which convoy organizers and the City of Ottawa
00:07:05 had agreed to, it would have made the Emergencies Act completely and utterly untenable. It would
00:07:11 have been impossible to sell and the federal government knew that which is why they wanted to
00:07:16 push forward with the emergencies act when they did but doing so stymied the progress that had
00:07:22 been made through back channels through informal unofficial negotiations between convoy leaders
00:07:27 and police and the city of ottawa now if you were to walk around the convoy area in ottawa as i did
00:07:34 at a few points you'd know that there were these liaison officers i think they were wearing red
00:07:39 vest. There were two in particular. And these officers were literally there to be conduits
00:07:44 between Ottawa police and members of the convoy. And obviously they were not there for the convoy.
00:07:50 They were there to represent Ottawa police and Ottawa police's interests. But they also knew
00:07:56 they could get stuff done. And when there was something that came up that perhaps was blocking
00:08:00 an emergency lane, the Ottawa police liaison officer could chat with Tom Marazzo, who's going
00:08:05 to be on the show on Friday, or Tamara Leach, or Keith Wilson, or Eva Chibiuk, and they know they'd
00:08:10 be able to get something like that done. So it was odd to hear testimony from the court. Now,
00:08:15 I didn't hear it firsthand because you aren't allowed to stream, but I've been following the
00:08:19 coverage of reporters that are there, like Trish Wood, and like Rebel News, and so on.
00:08:24 And it's been odd to see that the police, apparently, according to sworn testimony,
00:08:29 didn't actually want any of this progress to take place. Police were saying,
00:08:33 do not give one inch now obviously this is one particular inspector's perception of what he was
00:08:39 told but it raises the question of where such an order would have come from he didn't name names
00:08:44 but he said it would go all the way up to the executive leadership of the ottawa police service
00:08:48 for all we know it could have gone even above that to jim watson's office jim watson being the
00:08:53 former mayor of ottawa now he's been replaced by mark sutcliffe but this is where he gets a little
00:09:00 bit curious here. If this is an accurate reflection of what Ottawa police wanted, what does this mean
00:09:05 about all of these negotiations? Was it all just theater on their part or is this just incompetence
00:09:11 on police where the left hand didn't know what the right hand was doing? We'll talk about this
00:09:15 and other updates from the trial with lawyer Eva Chippia who joins us now. Eva, wonderful to talk
00:09:21 to you. Thanks so much for coming on today. My pleasure. Thanks for having me. So let's talk
00:09:26 first off about that because i know you were literally on the ground yourself as counsel for
00:09:30 the convoy organizers when the convoy was in ottawa and i know you had many discussions as
00:09:36 did your colleague keith wilson with law enforcement you had made progress on those so
00:09:41 how did it feel to you to hear today that there was this directive that no concessions were to
00:09:46 be made not one inch as he says yeah interesting and not incredibly surprising and i think in your
00:09:52 opening, you were saying, what do we have left here? And if you strip away all of this other
00:09:57 stuff is what you have is you have Canadian citizens that went to Ottawa, our national
00:10:03 capital, to air their grievances to their elected officials. And that's really what it was. All this
00:10:09 other stuff is excess, really, if you look at it. And it's not surprising to hear what they're
00:10:17 saying, because it really was chaotic on the ground. I can see that it was obvious the left
00:10:23 hand wasn't talking to the right hand. In fact, in one particular instance, we were talking to a
00:10:28 number of police officers, and they're like, hold on, I'm getting a call. And then they said, okay,
00:10:35 so everything we were just talking about is off the table. And that it wasn't just one incident
00:10:40 like that. Yeah, and I remember actually reporting on this a while ago, there was an audio file that
00:10:46 I received of a phone call between a couple of people in the convoy group and an OPP liaison
00:10:52 apologizing for what Ottawa police had done, because even there, between those two divisions,
00:10:58 there was incredibly poor communication. So you're right that a lot of this is a distraction,
00:11:03 and it's easy to get caught up in, I mean, the big normative question of whether you like the
00:11:08 convoy or dislike and agree with it or disagree with it. When we pivot to the criminal trial
00:11:13 that's underway right now, the questions should be and are supposed to be very narrowly focused
00:11:18 on the law. And I'm wondering if you could explain a little bit. I know you're not representing
00:11:22 anyone in the criminal action, but just as a lawyer, what are the key criminal questions here
00:11:27 that are at stake in the trial? Well, not only am I not representing them in this case, but I'm also
00:11:32 not a criminal lawyer, so I definitely don't want to overstep. But one thing that's really clear
00:11:38 from the evidence that we've heard so far is a lot of the questions and the evidence is coming out
00:11:44 about the Freedom Convoy in general, and not at all specific to Tamara Leach and Chris Barber and
00:11:51 their actions. And I know the lawyers for both Tamara and Chris have said that the Freedom
00:11:57 Convoy is not on trial, nor should it be, because this is criminal actions by Tamara Leach and Chris
00:12:04 Barber that are on trial in a criminal proceeding. And today, one of the, I think it was the second
00:12:11 witness from the Ottawa Police Service. So, you know, you expect that they're coming out with
00:12:16 some good evidence to start off. And he was asked, did you ever speak to Tamara Leach or Chris
00:12:23 Barber? And the answer was no. And it's just very strange because as you mentioned again in your
00:12:29 opening there were a lot of interactions between police and uh the two accused and not to have
00:12:36 those officers come to the stand is strange to say the least well that was i found an interesting
00:12:43 just to bounce around in our timeline here an interesting aspect of the public order emergency
00:12:47 commission where of all of the evidence that was presented and all of the witness after witness
00:12:53 after witness the actual liaison officers were not called to testify and you know the people
00:12:59 that were on the ground that were talking to you and keith and tamara and tom and all of like they
00:13:04 weren't there and it's interesting that we're seeing something very similar take place here
00:13:08 where the uh so far and again it's only the the second day of a 16-day trial but the evidence
00:13:14 that's being presented doesn't really seem to focus on the people and the charges and and i
00:13:20 can say i mean there's no debating that tamara and chris were leaders in the convoy there's no
00:13:24 debating they were there but when i saw some of the video clips that were being entered as evidence
00:13:28 they're like clips that had like Tamara's not even in the clip and Chris isn't even in the
00:13:32 clip it doesn't have anything to do with them yeah and I'm just taking notes because this always
00:13:37 happens I have a thought and then goes in a hundred different directions so you're right
00:13:42 about um at the public order emergency commission not one of the witnesses ever spoke directly to
00:13:50 anyone except for the one person and now his name is escaping me it was the city manager for the
00:13:56 Ottawa City Police. Yes, Steve, Steve Kanellakis, yes, or Steve K, as he was called, yeah. Yes,
00:14:02 because of the last name. And if you recall his evidence, which is the only real first-hand
00:14:08 evidence of, you know, Tamara and Chris, they were very reasonable, and they were agreeable to make
00:14:14 moves and work with the City of Ottawa. That's the evidence they had. Everything else was all
00:14:20 this hearsay, and in the Public Order Emergency Commission, there was a lot more leeway for that
00:14:25 because it wasn't a criminal trial,
00:14:27 but from what I'm hearing as well,
00:14:29 secondhand through posts about the case,
00:14:33 the trial is that there is no room for any hearsay
00:14:36 and that's the way it should be in this type of trial.
00:14:39 So that's good to see and hear.
00:14:41 I trust that you're not a criminal lawyer,
00:14:44 but your knowledge of the law, I think in general,
00:14:46 is very valuable here.
00:14:47 And I was wondering if you could just explain
00:14:49 a little bit about the threshold aspect
00:14:51 because criminal law,
00:14:53 the one thing that even non-lawyers know
00:14:54 is that, you know, proof beyond a reasonable doubt here. So that is a much higher bar that
00:15:00 has to be met by the crown than in most of the other legal cases we've seen about the convoy
00:15:06 that are all governed by the balance of probabilities, as it's called. Yeah. So again,
00:15:12 I won't get too far down the line there because I'm not as familiar. But what I can say for sure
00:15:17 is the crown is the the party that needs to prove the aspects of the charges that they've laid so
00:15:26 it's all on the crown and so they have the obligation not and in a civil case it's very
00:15:33 different so and a lot of criminal charges stemming from the freedom convoy have already
00:15:39 um gone through the courts but you've got a very different case here in in the case of tamara and
00:15:46 And Chris, in that when a lot of those cases had to do with when the police were trying to evacuate people, that's my understanding.
00:15:55 At least, again, I haven't been privy to all of these cases.
00:15:58 Yeah, I believe that's where the obstruction charge is based, that they basically were telling people not to leave when the police were saying leave.
00:16:05 Yes. And ask yourselves now, where was Tamara Leach and Chris Barber when that was happening?
00:16:10 What were their illegal actions? One was already in jail, Tamara, and Chris Barber was in jail and released on bail. So up until that point, they were communicating and cooperating, not only with the police, but the city of Ottawa.
00:16:29 And this is the question I've had since the Freedom Convoy is what was illegal and when did
00:16:35 it become illegal? And those obstruction charges are one thing with the Emergencies Act and police
00:16:42 interactions. Tamara was in jail. What was her crime? And when did it become a crime? And same
00:16:51 with Chris Barber. I like this is where I'm very interested to hear where the Crown is drawing the
00:16:58 line. What was illegal? What actions of there were illegal? And that's, I think, what we're
00:17:05 going to hear throughout this case. But so far, we haven't heard much. That's actually quite a
00:17:10 fascinating point that I think escapes a lot of people, which is when much of the action was
00:17:14 taking place, the two principal characters in this story were already off the streets. And again,
00:17:20 I don't want to get too much into speculation, but I know there was a lot of anger in the crowd
00:17:25 in Ottawa when those two people had been arrested, which probably caused some of the more
00:17:30 tense situations that may have happened between police and protesters. But even then, that was
00:17:35 after these two people were already behind bars. And it's not like the Hollywood movies where
00:17:39 they're smuggling out their messages from the jail cell that are getting emblazoned in the
00:17:45 sky or something. And again, I go back to the beginning of that week when the city of Ottawa
00:17:50 and Freedom Corp, the corporation established by convoy organizers, had literally agreed and they
00:17:56 had arranged these mutual statements from Jim Watson and from Tamara Leach of what was going
00:18:01 to happen. How is that obstructing or working against police and the city when that was literally
00:18:07 an agreement that involved working with police to move trucks? That was, I mean, just what,
00:18:13 four days before the arrests? Dumbfounded, completely dumbfounded with all of this. And
00:18:19 And that's where, again, if you go back to what I started with, is these were Canadian citizens that were escorted through the country into the nationals capital to protest.
00:18:29 And they were every day corresponding, communicating and working with the police and city officials.
00:18:37 And then all of a sudden one's in jail.
00:18:40 They're both in jail even, actually.
00:18:42 So it it still is. And I'm very interested to hear what the Crown thinks and is alleging was illegal.
00:18:51 So just looking at the broader legal landscape here, I know there it's difficult for someone who's observing this only casually to keep up with it because you've had, you know, constitutional challenges against the Emergencies Act and against the emergency orders.
00:19:07 You have people that are taking their own charges and tickets to court.
00:19:10 You've got the criminal trials.
00:19:12 You've got all of these different threads that are connected, not even to just COVID
00:19:15 in general, but specifically the convoy.
00:19:17 And I'm wondering what you think is going to be the, I guess, the culmination of all
00:19:23 this.
00:19:23 I mean, we also have the class action lawsuit, which some people forget is still ongoing.
00:19:27 And even people that weren't charged are finding themselves having to defend against
00:19:31 this class action lawsuit.
00:19:33 I mean, what's the big one of this, if there is a big one?
00:19:35 Well, you know, there is so many things going on, and I'm glad you brought up the lawsuit, because that is something that the Crown is relying on and talking about here.
00:19:46 Well, there was a disruption and harms to Ottawa residents from the Freedom Convoy.
00:19:52 And again, not specific to Tamara Leach and Chris Barber.
00:19:56 Tamara, who didn't even have a truck there, as I have to constantly point out to people. 1.00
00:20:00 Yes, and Chris Barber's was off of a downtown area in any event, but they have an ability to go to court and sue civilly for any harms that were caused.
00:20:12 That is their right, and they have taken that opportunity and venue.
00:20:18 So when the Crown is making those allegations and charges, is that now their responsibility to ensure that there are no harms to people in general, in such a general fashion?
00:20:33 So that's, again, it goes to what is illegal? When did it become illegal? And I think that the Crown itself is playing in this very gray area. And it'll be very interesting to see what the court decides on this one for sure.
00:20:47 eva chipiuk always good to get your analysis and there's a project you're involved with i wanted to
00:20:52 give you a chance just to speak about here for a moment thanks so much and it's because i've been
00:20:56 involved in this for so long and uh like we're talking there it gets complicated but overly so
00:21:02 what i what if you look at the freedom convoy in my opinion looking back at all of this again it
00:21:08 was canadian citizens looking to um get some answers from their elected officials and i think
00:21:15 they're owed that opportunity. And I think from what I've seen is a lot of Canadians just don't
00:21:21 understand the legal system, their civic responsibilities, and the political systems.
00:21:27 And I think that's complicated things in Canada. And it's hard to get into these more, you know,
00:21:34 complicated setups and established systems if we don't know the basics. So I started an
00:21:40 organization called empowered canadians with the goal of doing exactly that empowering canadians
00:21:46 so that they can feel more comfortable when they want to ask questions about what's going on
00:21:51 in our systems so that they feel that they're part of the democracy and especially after what i've
00:21:59 what's happened in this last two years people are telling me all the time we're too scared to get
00:22:04 involved they don't want to be made an example of like tamara leach and chris barber and that is
00:22:08 just terrifying to hear in what is supposed to be a free and democratic society so I think as
00:22:15 Canadians it's on us to get educated to learn and I encourage people to do that with me because a
00:22:22 few people can't stand for the rest of Canada to make sure that we're we're all in and and and we
00:22:28 are all in this together as well so well you say that but it always has to start with a few so
00:22:33 good on those who take the leadership at first but everyone else has to stand behind them
00:22:37 when that happens.
00:22:39 Eva Chiviak, always a pleasure.
00:22:40 Thanks for coming on today.
00:22:41 Thanks for having me.
00:22:43 All right.
00:22:43 Hopefully I was a better interview for her than Trudeau.
00:22:47 In any case, it is good to talk to Eva.
00:22:50 And I want to take a picture for you
00:22:53 outside of the legal aspect
00:22:55 and onto one that is near and dear to my heart,
00:22:57 which is the media aspect.
00:22:58 And I'm going to be talking about this
00:23:00 a little bit on Friday.
00:23:01 It's ended up being a convoy-themed week on the show,
00:23:04 which I haven't had the chance to do
00:23:05 for well over a year now.
00:23:06 so I hope you're enjoying it or tolerating it.
00:23:09 But the one thing I will bring up here
00:23:11 is that it's important to tell these stories
00:23:14 and it's important to have these stories told
00:23:16 in a way that is very respectful of exactly what happened.
00:23:20 And there's a bit of a funny story that I've told.
00:23:23 When my book about the Freedom Convoy came out
00:23:25 in the summer of 2022,
00:23:28 what was quite interesting is that at first
00:23:30 it was a Canadian politics book on Amazon.
00:23:32 Now, I actually have no idea
00:23:33 how any of the selling of it works.
00:23:35 I just sort of wrote it and sent it to my publisher and they did the rest of it.
00:23:39 But Amazon like does its own categorization and it was a Canadian politics book for a
00:23:43 couple of weeks and it was number one in there.
00:23:45 And then they moved it to history.
00:23:47 And I actually quite enjoyed that because it was the first draft of history and it was
00:23:52 this, the first telling of this story in history.
00:23:56 And I actually, an old history professor of mine, I gave him a copy and I don't know if
00:24:00 he agreed with the convoy or not, but he certainly enjoyed the book and conceded that it was a
00:24:05 historical chapter that I think will be taught in the history books. Now, how that's going to be
00:24:09 framed and tempered, perhaps, is a question. The word tempered came to mind. Barbara wrote a
00:24:16 question in the YouTube comments here. Has the regime media tempered their hatred of the convoy?
00:24:22 I don't think they have. I think they've started to be more dismissive of it, though, because they
00:24:26 really can't reconcile what Canadians saw and felt and experienced with how they really blew 0.96
00:24:33 what had happened out of proportion in some ways,
00:24:36 or just in some cases manufactured things.
00:24:39 And I think that has been an example
00:24:41 where they've just sort of avoided it altogether.
00:24:43 But let's talk about the telling of it
00:24:45 because Trish Wood and Jacqueline Bynum,
00:24:48 two incredibly, incredibly accomplished
00:24:50 and capable filmmakers,
00:24:52 are telling the story in a documentary they're producing
00:24:56 called The Trials of Tamara Leach.
00:24:59 Now, I want to share just a little snippet
00:25:01 of the trailer of this.
00:25:03 We made a promise.
00:25:05 Hold the line.
00:25:06 Hold the line.
00:25:07 I think we thought when the trucks left Ottawa,
00:25:10 that was going to be the end of it.
00:25:12 But we didn't realize that was just the beginning.
00:25:15 And I think me going back to Ottawa in a couple days
00:25:20 to this trial is kind of poetic in a way
00:25:23 because I'm going back to fight again
00:25:25 and I'll keep fighting and I'll keep fighting
00:25:28 and I'll keep fighting
00:25:29 because the people that made these decisions
00:25:32 and force parents to die by themselves
00:25:38 and force people to kill themselves need to be held accountable
00:25:45 that was a little bit from the trials of Tamara Leach Trish Wood and Jacqueline Bynon join me now 0.94
00:25:54 it's wonderful to talk to you both thanks so much for coming on
00:25:57 hi Andrew how you doing great to be here well it's good to have you
00:26:01 Let's start with the question of why this and why now, because there are some people, as I mentioned, in the media largely that, you know, they got this wrong.
00:26:12 And because of that, they've never really wanted to talk about it again.
00:26:15 And you get people that sort of say, well, COVID's over, so all discussion of anything related to the convoy is over as well.
00:26:21 Why do you want to tell this now?
00:26:23 Well, from my perspective, as you know, I've been doing a podcast called Trish Wood is Critical, which I started at the beginning of the COVID regime of the COVIDian times because I covered Tony Fauci back in the day and I was really worried about some of the decisions being made not on risk benefit data.
00:26:41 So I got very heavily involved very early on in this.
00:26:45 And I watched, as we all did, as the edicts became more and more kind of authoritarian.
00:26:51 And yet there was no way for us to fight back.
00:26:54 We were losing all the cases in the courts.
00:26:57 The media didn't seem to be on our side.
00:26:59 They weren't asking people in positions of power to, they weren't holding them to account
00:27:03 or asking them accountability questions.
00:27:05 So then you're left with this issue.
00:27:07 And this is where the convoy comes in.
00:27:11 What do you do in a democratic society when you believe to the marrow of your bones as a citizen that what the government and public health in this case is doing is wrong and not just wrong but harmful to people?
00:27:26 What opportunities do you have when the institutions like the courts aren't working?
00:27:32 And I think the convoy answered that question.
00:27:35 And I think it answered it for a lot of Canadians.
00:27:37 Jackie and I are old friends.
00:27:39 We were on the phone a lot during COVID times, very, very frustrated, especially over the media coverage and the inability of them to ask hard questions.
00:27:49 And when the condo happened, we said to each other, wow, maybe that's what has to happen now to get people to start paying attention.
00:27:56 Because remember, they wanted to talk to the prime minister.
00:28:00 They went to Ottawa not to be bad or mean, but because they wanted to open discussion on the mandates.
00:28:09 And he refused to talk to them after he spent a few days smearing them in the news media.
00:28:15 So by the time they got there, the city of Ottawa was terrified about who these big, you know, galoots were going to be. 1.00
00:28:22 So the question for me right now, and I'll let Jackie pick this up because she heard a lot of this.
00:28:27 outside, I was inside the border, she was outside with the people, is what do you do when the 0.99
00:28:33 institutions that you've trusted all your life have stopped working for you and you believe that
00:28:38 in the marrow of your bone? And if we lose the ability to protest en masse the way people did
00:28:43 in Ottawa, then I think we've got a real problem here. Jackie? Yes, and that's, we've talked about
00:28:49 this ad infinitum, locked down and locked up. And I agree with her. And I will say that I think the
00:28:55 the convoy in the protest is probably the single most successful human rights. Some people say
00:29:02 grassroots. I say human rights protest in a generation in this country. Something that
00:29:07 Canadians didn't normally do. It was not something we would see the average Canadian do. They're
00:29:13 compliant. They want government. They just want to have a nice life. And for some reason,
00:29:19 a group of people decided this wasn't good enough. What they were hearing on the news,
00:29:25 which is largely controlled by the government, was not what they were feeling or thinking a lot
00:29:30 of people. Now, there were a lot of people who went along with that, but there were a lot. And
00:29:35 Tamara Leach and Chris Barber, when we saw them, we saw those trucks, they became the face of
00:29:42 something we were thinking. And it gave us hope that we didn't feel powerless because we believed
00:29:48 in these institutions, but they weren't speaking to us or listening to us or caring for us.
00:29:52 And that's why we thought this is a very big moment in Canadian history, and we have to document it in what way of being women.
00:30:02 You know, we're so compelling.
00:30:04 Tamara Leach is such a compelling character.
00:30:07 Whether you like her doesn't matter.
00:30:10 As a woman or just as a person who really cares about their country, you have to give her due.
00:30:17 She, as she said, she holds the line.
00:30:19 she has that temerity to say this is my hill and that's what we were inspired by her one thing you
00:30:29 mentioned character and i actually was going to ask about this later on because a lot of your
00:30:33 experience as a producer jacqueline has been in in fictional work as well i know you've done
00:30:38 uh things that have kind of told stories in a more dramatized way and what people fail to realize
00:30:43 about the convoy is that i mean irrespective of the political implications of it which are vast
00:30:49 there's a story here. And there's quite a riveting story of this. And I'm wondering
00:30:54 if you're going to capture that in the story that you're telling.
00:30:59 Oh, we are. We are. This is very interesting you say that because Trish and I talk about this
00:31:03 because we've both done this. I mostly do crime, true crime series that are investigative, but
00:31:09 there is always some impressionistic drama, as they say in it.
00:31:12 Yeah, I guess fiction, I meant more dramatized than fictionalized.
00:31:15 But I wasn't besmirching your work.
00:31:18 It's usually serial killers or people who do horrible things.
00:31:21 Yeah.
00:31:21 But this is apparently that's Tamara. 1.00
00:31:23 If you ask the Ottawa media.
00:31:25 Yeah.
00:31:25 But this is this is still a criminal case we're following here.
00:31:30 And what I saw outside the courtroom, I could do a whole documentary just on what was outside the outside.
00:31:38 As Tricia and I were texting back because there were two groups of people.
00:31:42 There were the people there supporting Tamara, which were, you know, we talk about, Trish and I talk, two solitudes.
00:31:50 These were the working class people.
00:31:52 There was the tinfoil hat man who has the tinfoil hat, and he will be there outside with the Canadian flag as long as the trial goes on.
00:31:59 There were other people who used to work for the government or work for RCMP, and they just were incensed.
00:32:06 And then there was the legacy media who were in a little camp by themselves.
00:32:11 and we were there from about eight o'clock in the morning till the the end of the day and there were
00:32:16 these little skirmishes that would arise and it was a very interesting to see that there were two
00:32:21 different groups and we tried to capture that because I found the legacy media wasn't talking
00:32:27 to any of these people and you know once you get past the the look because they don't look like the
00:32:32 people who wear suits and go and go into work nine to five in Ottawa they don't look like them 0.88
00:32:37 they're just your average person and once you start talking to them they made a lot of sense
00:32:43 and they they have more they were more insightful than a lot of things you heard on the news and
00:32:49 that's what i found interesting because i know when trish was inside she was telling a different
00:32:54 story there was two different groups in there in the courtroom it was a real sense of your background
00:33:00 with investigations has been incredible and and typically the media has always relished wanting
00:33:06 to talk to real people and not wanting to talk to commentators. And it's amazing how that sort
00:33:12 of has reversed. Like I've seen stories that have been published about the Freedom Convoy that
00:33:16 interview a criminologist, often the same one, that interview a criminologist from here and a
00:33:21 professor from there and don't actually speak to anyone involved in this. Yeah, because it's a
00:33:30 grassroots movement, which I think it is. I think to your point, that's exactly what we're talking
00:33:34 about it's a little bit of anthropology when they do that because i would frame this in a sense as
00:33:41 a class struggle um and it's almost as if now the laptop class some of the the legacy media people
00:33:49 i'm not slamming them they have hard jobs but they there is a suggestion that they view
00:33:55 the convoy people the people who attach themselves with the convoy people who protest with the convoy
00:34:00 as this exotic species right in the old days and i was there in the olden days the media used to
00:34:08 love working class people we wrote you know songs about coal miners and we rushed to support them
00:34:13 against the man you know the corporate man and the bad government and now it feels very much
00:34:18 like the media which we all know is you know select leaning now virtually all of them uh is
00:34:25 not allied with the working people which is why the smears from trudeau of them being racist and
00:34:30 sex is homophobic and how can we tolerate them all that stuff really landed because i think there is
00:34:36 a huge divide between the laptop people the legacy media people we saw it in the courtroom 0.84
00:34:44 the the trucker people were lined up behind the defense table everybody else in suits virtually
00:34:50 was behind the crown table in the courtroom and it really felt like there was a massive social
00:34:56 divide and unless i'll say this to you andrew and jackie and i talk this about this almost every day
00:35:02 if we don't sort this out where we stop demonizing each other because we hold different views i sat
00:35:09 in the courthouse and i talked to a woman today she's an ottawa citizen hates convoy thinks the 1.00
00:35:14 work all kinds of terrible things none of them provable or litigatable or are true but there's
00:35:19 a lot of folk folk stories out here right now about the convoy from local people just not true
00:35:25 we had a really pleasant conversation but she was saying things that I if I hadn't been kind
00:35:33 of hanging on to my seat the way I was I would have been angry about we cannot we cannot continue
00:35:38 to demonize each other this way and I feel that the the convoy trial and the way the convoy has
00:35:44 been treated by the media and the elites if we can call them that um is a harbinger of this country
00:35:52 blowing apart if we do not sort it out we are canadians canadians we share canadian values we
00:35:57 all love hockey we cried when the humble bush crashed we put the hockey sticks out that's the
00:36:03 stuff that binds us together if we disagree on cultural things that's fine we can disagree
00:36:09 if we disagree on on covert policy we can disagree about that too but we have to stop
00:36:14 with the ad hominem attacks on each other and the and the convoy trial is really really showing that
00:36:20 And that's a bit of what Jackie was talking about outside the building yesterday.
00:36:23 I think whatever happens in this trial, it will go on.
00:36:28 There will be many books, there will be many documentaries of people doing this because we haven't figured it out yet.
00:36:36 This is a historic time in our country.
00:36:40 And this protest and this trial, I think, is sort of where it may change.
00:36:46 And we don't know what's going to happen.
00:36:47 but whatever happens, things will never be the same. And I don't know if it's going to be good
00:36:53 or bad, but I do think the reason why we're fixated on this is because we all know no matter
00:36:59 what side of the coin you're on, that this is a big moment and no one knows how it's going to end.
00:37:05 I hope it ends well. Like Trish said, I hope it's where we can go. Like remember the old days when
00:37:10 you didn't know what your politics were and you just, you would just have a beer or a glass of
00:37:14 I mean, when you make a documentary about a serial killer, for example, I think you can fairly safely say that 99.9% of the audience are going to line up with the serial killer is bad.
00:37:28 At least I hope that maybe even 100 if you're lucky.
00:37:31 When you make something about a topic that people aren't familiar with, and I actually love watching documentaries about things I'm not familiar with, because I can go in kind of with a blank slate and I don't have a preconceived notion.
00:37:42 And then afterwards, you look into it and you have to sometimes separate out the filmmaker's bias, as you should from any product.
00:37:49 But with something like this, I mean, anyone who knows about The Convoy now probably has a pretty strong opinion about it one way or another.
00:37:56 And I'm wondering how you or if you work against that in the story you're telling.
00:38:02 And one example I've shared on my show is that my mother, a lovely woman, very supportive of me and my work, not the Convoy demographic, not a Convoy supporter.
00:38:11 And I kind of knew that public opinion was turning when she had said one day, unprompted, oh, you know, what they're doing to Tamara Leach is terrible.
00:38:19 Because that was for her the hook.
00:38:21 She maybe didn't realize, she didn't agree with the convoy, but she could agree with a mom that doesn't seem like the model criminal or the poster child for criminality. 0.99
00:38:30 But I'm curious what your approach to this is on how you break through those preconceptions, whatever they are.
00:38:35 Well, the reason I like doing crime, true crime, is you don't have to do any politics. There's the bad guy and then they're victims. And I think those stories have to be told. We have to make the bad guys the bad guys.
00:38:50 I think in this story
00:38:52 but all crime boils down to good and evil
00:38:55 and I think this story
00:38:57 boils down to good and evil
00:38:58 and it depends, to use the words of Bill Clinton
00:39:01 depends on your definition
00:39:03 of criminal
00:39:04 of good and evil
00:39:06 and I think that's why we talk about the two solitudes
00:39:09 I think you're either
00:39:10 the convoys good
00:39:13 or the convoys bad
00:39:14 Tamara Leach bad 0.96
00:39:15 that's what I think this boils down to
00:39:17 and it's really hard to find anything in the middle
00:39:20 that's why it's really it's easy in a way to do true crime because you already know who the bad
00:39:25 guy is and you all right let's let's get the tension in here trish go ahead oh no i know she 1.00
00:39:33 agrees with me i would just look circle back differently because there are facts facts are
00:39:39 things right right and and and ray mcginnis has done a brilliant piece on the poec that blows 0.99
00:39:46 apart all virtually every bad smear made against the convoy right arson no uh weapon loaded weapons
00:39:55 no um money from the proud boys no like all of that was wrong supported by russia cbc said that
00:40:04 false false false and so what i think jackie and i are experiencing here in the city of ottawa even
00:40:11 in our hotel one of the people in the restaurant had this wild story it was completely not
00:40:16 true about the convoy is that the facts actually support the convoy's own narrative that they were
00:40:25 here to protest and things went relatively smoothly without a lot of trouble and there
00:40:30 were a lot of bad there were a couple of fringy type people attached as there are to every massive
00:40:35 protest right but the virtually all of the terrible things that made headlines about the
00:40:41 convoy, are demonstrably false. And the POEC found that. That is out of the mouths of the
00:40:49 financial crimes guys at the RCMP, the security folks. They all said, yeah, no, nothing to see
00:40:55 here, people, really. So what we're left with is a massive hearing that made findings of fact
00:41:03 that was not reported in the mainstream media the way it should have been. And why wasn't it? It
00:41:10 wasn't because they were complicit in pushing those fake stories, right? I mean, the arson story
00:41:15 was absurd on its face, only an idiot. Oh, and literally repeated on the floor of the House of 1.00
00:41:21 Commons by people that have never apologized, that have never admitted that it was not just
00:41:27 muddy or fuzzy or kind of two sides, but demonstrably fictional. That's important too,
00:41:34 because that part of the story that Trish is talking about didn't get covered as enthusiastically
00:41:40 as the actual protest with the truckers.
00:41:42 For example, when I was outside yesterday,
00:41:44 there was one guy there who obviously was a retired public service worker.
00:41:49 Like, I would have bet my condo on it.
00:41:53 He asked me why I was there, and he said,
00:41:57 well, they ruined Ottawa.
00:42:00 They were terrible. 0.98
00:42:02 They were horrible, and it was illegal.
00:42:03 I said, well, it's my understanding that the judge ruled it was a legal protest.
00:42:08 He goes, no, it wasn't illegal.
00:42:09 and I don't care what the judge said it was illegal well how do you argue with someone like
00:42:14 that there's that you just that and he didn't care what what the facts that we had all that
00:42:20 Trish is talking about that all this stuff had been largely debunked didn't matter he had it in
00:42:25 his set this is the way it is I hope she goes to jail for 10 years oh and then he said he asked me
00:42:31 a whole bunch of stuff well you seem like a logical person do you like Tucker Carlson I said
00:42:34 yeah i love him he goes that's it we were running away that's a good way to end the conversation
00:42:39 with a retired bureaucrat in ottawa yeah you can use that anyone can use that if you want to get
00:42:43 out of it just say you like tucker and it goes all right can i add one thing to that and that's
00:42:48 what she said is really important because she's describing what i call the invasion of the body
00:42:54 snatchers moment and we have them when we confront certain people with irrefutable facts that
00:43:01 completely debunk their thought process, right? It happens on COVID when you say the vaccines
00:43:07 don't prevent transmission. You know, these are the people writing, I got COVID. Thank God I've
00:43:12 got two shots and four boosters. I got COVID. I'm so grateful I've had the shot. And you're saying,
00:43:17 well, so it doesn't prevent transmission. Well, no, that's safe and effective, right? That's how
00:43:21 and so this world has been created because people in this country now have bilateral
00:43:29 siloed information systems they curate their social media feeds to feed their own biases
00:43:35 they're either watching legacy media or doing totally the indie thing and so we live in two
00:43:43 separate worlds and we hold on to those in the context of a moral framework so somebody
00:43:49 challenging with facts this happens in my own family my oldest kid was a little bit like this
00:43:54 few years ago he's softening but he's like mom you've always got facts stop you know stop attacking
00:43:59 me with facts and and and i always thought as an investigator that's a good thing right but
00:44:04 but we this is a dangerous world if if the truckers legacy is constructed out of these
00:44:13 falsehoods that have landed so heavily on this very city that i'm in right now and used to live
00:44:19 in and used to love, but has contaminated much of the thinking here. We've got a problem. It's
00:44:24 no different than the witch trials. It's no different than any of the other kind of moral
00:44:29 panic situations in history, where facts, McCarthyism, facts became irrelevant, and belief
00:44:37 systems feeding tyranny took over, right? That's, I hate to say it, but that's kind of where we are
00:44:44 right now here can i can i just add i want to go back to why we're doing the doc okay let's go we're
00:44:50 gonna wrap it up after this so let's hear it why she's talking about that is tamara leach or tamara 1.00
00:44:56 leach i keep calling her by the it's tamara leach and chris barber they are not your typical canadian
00:45:02 they are willing to despite everything despite the slings and arrows of outrageous fortune
00:45:08 they're willing to take arms against that sea of fortune and sit there and take it and they are
00:45:13 going to hold that line and as a canadian you have got to admire their fortitude and i think that is
00:45:19 one of the things that i find so so hopeful and exciting about tamara and that's one of the
00:45:26 reasons why we we wanted to to dig deeper and do this documentary well i'm so certainly glad you
00:45:34 are it is called the trials of tamara leach we can put the graphic up on the screen there i know you
00:45:39 are uh having the trailer available we played a little bit of it and you're also doing a crowd
00:45:44 funding campaign which people can chip into uh not on gofundme thankfully because then they'd
00:45:49 freeze your bank accounts and seize the money so you've used uh give send go which has proven to be
00:45:54 more reliable uh trish wood and jacqueline vine and wonderful to talk to you both thank you so
00:45:59 much for coming on can i make one small comment before we say goodbye yes of course you two are
00:46:04 dangerous the take up arms was metaphorical because i know how mainstream media watches these shows
00:46:11 right we all know that but all right you know it's terrible that we've lost metaphor now in
00:46:19 this day and age with the way the media works so all right well now we have the context to add if
00:46:24 they uh if they take you out of context but good for the ratings anyway uh wonderful to talk to
00:46:28 you trish and jacqueline thank you and uh looking forward to your continued coverage in ottawa thank
00:46:33 All right. That does it for us. That was an absolute riot. We've got to have them back on
00:46:38 and certainly we'll share when news of their documentary becomes a bit more clearer in focus
00:46:43 as far as timeline and all of that, but they're still getting material out of it. So can't release
00:46:48 it just yet. We'll talk to you all on Friday with more of Canada's most irreverent talk show here
00:46:53 on True North. Thank you. God bless and good day to you all. Thanks for listening to the Andrew
00:46:58 Lawn Show. Support the program by donating to True North at www.tnc.news.
00:47:28 We'll be right back.
00:47:58 We'll be right back.